Donald Trump’s Arctic ambitions are sending a chill through the Treasury market. Among President Trump’s most recent altercations with the free world, the diplomatic spat over the fate of Greenland stands out as particularly surreal. Yet, while the President’s offer to purchase the world’s largest island to “appease tensions” was largely dismissed by the public as geopolitical theater, the behavior is beginning to register as a genuine risk factor for the world’s most significant allocators of capital: defined benefit pension funds.

In a quiet but notable shift, some of the largest Nordic pension funds – stalwarts of global asset allocation known for their prudent, long-term horizons – have begun to divest from U.S. Treasuries (USTs). They describe this not merely as a portfolio rebalancing, but as a financial “defense” strategy. While this selling pressure currently represents a fraction of the colossal USD 700 billion to USD 1 trillion daily trading volume in the Treasury market, it serves as a canary in the coal mine: traditional funding sources of U.S. government debt are becoming increasingly wary of financing the hegemon’s ambitions when those ambitions seem divorced from good governance.

The Erosion of Stewardship

To understand why an unpopular real estate deal in the Arctic matters to the bond market, one must look beyond the headlines to the underlying metrics of institutional health. Trump’s geopolitical gyrations are simply the accelerant for a fire that has been smoldering for years.

A cursory glance at the Chandler Good Government Index confirms what many asset managers have quietly feared: the U.S.’ governance indicators have deteriorated substantially. Most damning is the metric of “Financial Stewardship”, which includes fiscal stewardship, where the U.S. arguably fails to meet the standards of a developed reserve currency nation. In fact, the U.S. rank for financial stewardship has plummeted to 63rd in the world within the index’s database over the past 5 years – the worst performance among all G7 nations.

For decades, the global bond market operated on the assumption of American exceptionalism – that the U.S. political system, however messy, would ultimately safeguard the creditworthiness of the dollar. That assumption is now being stress-tested. The combination of chronic fiscal deficits, recurring brinkmanship over the debt ceiling, and now, executive capriciousness on the global stage, has led to a derating by credit agencies. These agencies, which will surely feel the President’s wrath soon enough, are merely acknowledging the mathematical reality: the U.S. fiscal and debt outlook is on an unsustainable trajectory.

 

The Search for Safer Harbors

As a result of this erosion in trust, international investors are engaging in a rigorous search for alternatives. In a twist that would have seemed improbable a decade ago, German and increasingly, Canadian sovereign debt – are being reassessed not just as diversification tools, but as superior risk-adjusted assets.

While U.S. yields remain higher than their G7 peers, the risk premium required to hold American debt is rising, as evidenced by the table below. Investors are asking whether the extra yield is worth the volatility injection coming from the White House.

In this context, Canadian debt, in particular, is looking increasingly attractive. With a banking sector renowned for its stability, a resource-rich economy, and a comparative adherence to fiscal sanity, Canada offers a “boring” reliability that is suddenly in high demand; the table below shows that the bond spread of various countries with U.S. Treasurys is narrowing, which offers one indication of comparatively more demand for non-U.S. bonds. Considering the growing borrowing needs of Germany, Japan, and Canada in the coming years to fund energy transitions and demographic shifts, bond investors will find an ample supply of high-quality debt securities in which to park their capital outside the blast radius of Washington D.C.

The De-Dollarization Trend

This migration away from U.S. assets was well underway before the Greenland affair. It is being driven by the fundamental mechanics of macroeconomics: falling real U.S. dollar rates amid persistent inflation. This toxic combination is the classic trigger for debasement fears, prompting sophisticated investors to dump dollars in favor of hard assets like gold – a trend that reached a fever pitch this past week.

As an example of recent changes in the global market for USTs, China, the second largest holder of U.S. debt, has been a net seller of USTs over the past year. Beijing is keenly aware of the precedent set in the Spring of 2018, when Russia liquidated approximately USD 80 billion worth of Treasuries within a single month to insulate itself from pending financial sanctions. While the Russian liquidation was barely a blip in the deep ocean of the global UST market, a sustained withdrawal by China (even if unlikely), combined with the “quiet quitting” of European pension funds, would be  different beast entirely.

The Pension Fund Dilemma

This brings us to the acute dilemma facing domestic asset managers, particularly in countries like Canada. Conversely to the global trend, many Canadian investors have actually increased their positions in USTs recently as per the chart above, driven by a desire to hedge against domestic equity risk and speculate on lower U.S. rates. However, this strategy is becoming politically and financially fraught.

As Mark Carney alluded to in his speech at Davos earlier this month, the logic of the past thirty years is fracturing. One must wonder how a country’s public sector pension funds can justify financing the deficit of a foreign power that explicitly threatens to hurt its neighbors with tariffs and/or absorb their territories; we expect there is significant justification and momentum for Canadian and other “aligned countries” asset owners to increasingly repatriate capital.

The Rise of Economic Nationalism

We are most likely witnessing the dawn of a new era of economic nationalism, and defined benefit pension schemes are on the front lines. Until the late 1990s, Canadian pension funds were constrained by the “Foreign Property Rule,” which capped international investments at 20%. When this rule was abolished in the early 2000s, Canadian funds rushed to internationalize, becoming some of the world’s most sophisticated global investors. They became “Maples” – massive, distinct entities investing in everything from Chilean toll roads to Manhattan skyscrapers.

Now, the pendulum is swinging back. Pressure groups and corporate interests are increasingly demanding that pension capital be repatriated to support the domestic economy. Beyond the political pressure, it is also becoming a risk management necessity. Allocators are finding that as correlation between global asset classes rises during geopolitical crises, the safety of “foreign” risk-free assets is illusory.

Managers are being cornered into a riskier world where they must divest from what was once perceived as the bedrock of safety (USTs) – and move into more complex, illiquid, domestically focused assets. Given the limited supply of palatable non-U.S. government deb securities (compared to the huge size of the UST market), this means that those investors will be forced to look at debt attached to riskier infrastructure projects in countries which plan to either rebuild their economies, either/or re-arm themselves.

In 2025, many ESG monikers like “greenwashing” and “net zero” fell by the wayside. However, a fancy term to describe accelerating inequalities has made its way into public discourse: the “K-shaped” economy refers to bifurcated labor, wealth and spending patterns, with the upper arm of the “K” representing wealthy asset owners and high-skilled professionals who are thriving, while the lower arm represents low-to-middle-income earners who are facing stagnant wages and rising costs.

As a result, differentiated spending patterns emerge and creates a stark contrast in prosperity across different groups within the economy.

The bland sobriquet – K-shaped economy – may lull some readers to sleep…but it shouldn’t. It’s just a polite way of saying that U.S. income and wealth inequality is accelerating.

Usually, in a “normal” recovery (V or U-shaped), all boats rise, even if the yachts rise faster than the rowboats. The harsh reality is that U.S. income and wealth inequality is accelerating and bringing it with alarming consequences.

What’s To Blame?

 There are three main factors that we highlight that are driving the divergence in income, wealth and spending:

 
1.
To Own or Not to Own?

The single largest driver of the K is the gap between those who own assets and those who rely solely on labor for income.

 

This is what the hard data tells us, but one can also see it the performance of stock prices.

For example, the media has already made much of the fact that Delta airlines stock have diverged markedly from their peers. This is in large part because the company has focused on higher-tier travel: the majority of their profits are now generated from business and first class tickets. Last year, sales of economy tickets contracted by 7% while premium ticket sales rose by 9%.  

Another example is the banking industry, where there have been clear winners from the “K” – those that cater to high-net worth individuals have seen their stock prices blast off in the past year, while lower tiered banks – those catering to a more diversified clientele – have lagged.

2. The AI Divide

Both the anecdotal and data evidence is making clear that the rapid adoption of Artificial Intelligence is creating a skills gap that serves to reinforces the K-shape.

For example, an analysis of how Anthropic’s chatbot Claude is used by businesses and consumers around the world suggests that richer countries are much more likely to adopt AI. Claude usage per capita remains highly uneven and strongly correlated with GDP, with currently no evidence that low-use countries are catching up.

Equally significant is who is using AI within countries. Research from Anthropic suggests that more educated users are reaping greater productivity benefits from AI because they can give AI chatbots more sophisticated prompts and therefore get better responses. According to Anthropic, “While Claude is able to respond in a highly sophisticated manner, it tends to do so only when users input sophisticated prompts.”

In other words, the rewards from AI are going to higher educated workers who tend to be at the higher end of the income scale (there are exceptions: tech jobs, once considered high-paying and high-demand, are leading the layoffs precisely due to the AI pivot).


3. Asymmetric Impact of Inflation

 U.S. inflation has been running hotter than the Fed’s 2% target for almost half a decade now, but the extra increases in prices don’t hit everyone equally. Essentials like food and housing take up a much larger percentage of low-income budgets and the prices of these items have been rising faster than other consumer prices.

Indeed, households in the bottom 20% of wage earners allocate approximately 63% of their total expenditures to just three categories: housing, food, and transportation. These categories are considered inelastic spending so any price increase in these areas acts as a direct reduction in a family’s standard of living.

 

In contrast, the highest 20% of earners spend roughly 30-35% of their income on these same essentials. When the price of these essential items goes up, wealthier households simply reduce non-essential spending, while for the lower arm of the “K”, that money often comes out of an emergency fund or basic nutrition.

 

How Can Sustainability Investors Navigate the K?

For investors focused on sustainability strategies and outcomes, a K-shaped economy, i.e. the speeding up of income and wealth inequalities, can feel like losing the battle. Indeed, many of the potential winners of inequality are not names one would naturally find on the long side of sustainability themed portfolios (premium banks, private jets, yacht builders, etc.)

Nonetheless, there are many themes that are either orthogonal or even aligned to the realities of a split economy. We highlight three below:

Circular Economy: From an environmental perspective, transforming from a linear to circular economy is widely viewed as necessary because it is considered the only legitimate solution to limiting environmental degradation – the ultimate goal is to decouple resources consumption from economic growth.

From an economic perspective, a decline in purchasing-power for the majority of the population implies more interest and demand for recycling, refurbishing, and “product-as-a-service” (i.e. renting or leasing) models.

Business models based on using less raw inputs, extending the economic life of a product and aiming for substantial improvement in resource performance along the way should be seen as increasingly attractive and a major differentiator. We plan to update our previous work on this subject (Circular Economy: When Going Around in Circles is the Right Thing to Do, April 13, 2022) in the weeks ahead.

Social And Sustainability Bonds: While the interest for green bonds has most likely passed the hype phase of the early 2020s, there appears to be steady interest in other fixed income products tied to sustainability. Social bonds offer a steady yield while directly addressing the “downward” trajectory of the lower-K population.

Earlier this month, the International Finance Corporation (IFC) issued a $2 billion Social Bond The proceeds are specifically earmarked for low-income communities in emerging markets, focusing on healthcare, sanitation, and education. The bond was oversubscribed by an impressive 2.7 times. For investors wanting to make real social impact, financing that is tied to specific project outcomes is a direct way to achieve it.

Sustainable Regenerative Agriculture: With climate-related disasters costing well over 100 billion USD again in 2025, we have argued that climate adaptation (i.e. resilience) will become a necessary investment priority. As we noted above and in previous notes, food prices will continue to outpace generalized inflation due in large part to climate change.

Investing in sustainable farmland and timberland are one of the main ways to combat the impacts of climate change while mitigating risks in our food supply chain (please see, Environmental Assets in Short Supply, October 9, 2025). These assets also provide a hedge against inflation (the lower-K struggle).

One of the most unexpected developments this year is that despite Trump’s anti-ESG outlook, clean energy sector stocks have done very well thanks to a favorable interest rate backdrop and an AI-fuelled increase in demand for energy. AS a result, the ICLN ETF significantly outperformed the S&P 500 throughout the year, similar to how the sector performed during the latter part of Trump’s first administration in 2019-20.

Our research process remained unaffected by this year’s changing ESG narrative: sustainability concepts like climate adaptation continue to present significant investment opportunities, as the chart below highlights.

The Good, The Bad & The Ugly

Despite setbacks in environmental policies affecting EV adoption, energy transition, and regulation in North America and Europe, this performance stands out as notable. Beyond energy transition, several other notable calls from 2025 finished in the green. Here’s a review by quarter follows below:

Q1 2025 The quarter was defined by the return of “Trumpian” policies, creating volatility through tariffs, immigration crackdowns, and inflation risks, alongside specific themes like the GLP-1 weight-loss revolution and legal risks in ESG. Our research concentrated on sectors that benefit from U.S. reshoring, grid electrification, and “Make America Healthy Again” (MAHA) policies. Investment recommendations included going long on U.S. waste management (Waste Management, Republic Services), grid infrastructure (Nexans, Eaton), and GLP-1 leaders (Novo Nordisk, Eli Lilly), while shorting oil majors, unhealthy food producers (PepsiCo, Mondelez), and consumer discretionary stocks like Victoria’s Secret.

Greener Than Expected

NotebookLM’s synthesis of our research agenda and investment calls from 2025 clearly challenges the notion that Trump is harming sustainable investing. Strong gains came from grid plays, mining, recyclers, and Korean transition stocks. A timely short on consumer discretionary, notably Victoria’s Secret, paid off. Underperformers included water utilities, climate adaptation, Long EV/Short legacy automakers, and health care positions. Here’s a compendium of our trades, rationale and 3-month performance.

SMS Note Titles: Gifts that Keep On Giving

An additional quirky benefit of our AI assistant is that it reminded us of some of our best weekly note titles. Your editors believe a good title is half the battle of writing. Based on the 2025 research notes provided, our AI friend suggested the title that stands out as the most original and creative—utilizing a clever pun to describe geopolitical alliances—is:

“Seoul Mates: The Case for Korean Sustainability Plays” (May 1, 2025) This title plays on the term “soulmates” to highlight South Korea as a strategic “friend-shoring” partner and winner in the U.S.-China trade war.

Other titles from 2025 that were given credit for their good use of pop culture references, idioms, or wordplay:

“The future is already here — it’s just not evenly distributed.”

William Gibson’s line, coined in the early days of the internet, feels oddly apt for the energy transition in 2025. The future, as it turns out, isn’t being built in the places that talk about it the most.

If you judged progress by headlines, you’d assume the transition is stalling. In Washington, “ESG” has become a three-letter insult. In parts of Europe, net-zero policies are being watered down under the pressure of populism, high energy bills, and the pivot to defense. Although it may look like the green dream is fading, the data quietly says otherwise — and it’s pointing in a surprising direction.

According to the IEA’s World Energy Investment 2025 report, total global energy investment will hit a record US$3.3 trillion this year. Of that, US$2.2 trillion will flow to clean energy technologies — twice the US$1.1 trillion still going to fossil fuels. In other words: the energy transition isn’t slowing down; it’s just changing lanes.

The new fast lane isn’t in Berlin, London, or Washington. It’s in Shenzhen, São Paulo, Mumbai, Nairobi, and Jakarta.

While developed markets are bogged down in ideological trench warfare — arguing over what counts as “green,” “just,” or “sustainable” — emerging markets are quietly building the physical infrastructure of the next energy system. They’re not doing it to virtue-signal; they’re doing it because it makes economic sense. Solar panels, batteries, and electric vehicles have simply become the cheapest and most practical options available in the Global South.

The transition that was supposed to start in the West and trickle down to the rest of the world has flipped upside down. It’s a delicious historical irony. The Industrial Revolution, the automobile age, and the internet boom all began in the West and radiated outward, leaving developing countries scrambling to catch up. Now, in the clean energy revolution, it’s the emerging economies setting the pace while the incumbents debate the rules.


The Emerging Market Acceleration

According to BloombergNEF, emerging economies now attract two-thirds of global renewable investment, and their clean-energy capacity additions have outpaced developed markets every year since 2021. The IEA estimates that in 2025, over 80% of new solar and wind capacity will be built outside North America and Europe.

The scale is staggering. Pakistan imported 17 GW of solar modules in 2024 — nearly half its grid-connected capacity. Across Africa, solar imports jumped 60% year-on-year, lighting up villages long ignored by traditional utilities.

As this momentum builds, new solar superpowers are emerging. In 2022, India overtook Japan to become the world’s third-largest solar generator. In 2024, Brazil overtook Germany, climbing to fifth place. Alongside China, this means that BRICS nations now account for three of the world’s top five solar producers.

 
The Great Pivot – From Policy to Pragmatism

The original script for the energy transition was that Europe and the United States would lead — because they had the wealth, the policy frameworks, and the moral resolve to do so. Emerging markets would follow adopting cleaner technologies once costs came down. Net zero by 2050 for the West, 2060 for China, 2070 for India — a moral hierarchy neatly aligned with GDP per capita.

This mirrors the rhythm of UN climate negotiations, where developed countries are expected to lead while developing ones shoulder few formal obligations.

But 2025 has torn up that playbook.

In the United States, politics beat pragmatism. A number of solid renewable energy projects were canceled for no better reason than being “too green.” In Europe, climate ambition collided with voter fatigue: the Netherlands suspended farm-emission targets, Germany scaled back its heat pump subsidies, and France quietly scaled back its EV subsidies. The result is what the IEA now calls “a policy slowdown phase” — lots of speeches, little concrete action.

Politics alone doesn’t explain the stall; two deeper forces are at play. First, the West erroneously bet big on technologies that were either uneconomic or premature (green hydrogen, solar thermal, carbon capture). That gave skeptics all the ammunition they needed to kill ALL green projects. By trying to be too clever, the West tripped over its own ambition.

Second, the explosive rise in energy demand from data centers, industrial reshoring, and AI has scrambled energy planning. Even the greenest server farms need power 24/7 — and that reliability still comes from peaker plants, which, for the most part, run on natural gas.

Meanwhile, emerging markets appear to have taken a far more pragmatic approach to ensuring energy supply. China, India, Brazil, and others did the math. When solar modules, lithium batteries, and wind turbines became cheaper than coal or gas, they bought them.

The contrast couldn’t be clearer. Renewable power growth in developed markets has plateaued, adding only modest capacity through the rest of the decade despite lofty policy targets. Meanwhile, emerging markets are projected to install nearly four times as much renewable capacity as the developed world by 2030, led by solar and wind.

 

The old centers of global leadership are bogged down in taxonomy debates, while emerging markets are scaling factories, grids, and EV fleets. Capital, as usual, is doing what politics couldn’t: move forward.

Once clean technology stopped being a policy project and became an economic one, the world’s fastest-growing economies were destined to lead. They had no legacy infrastructure to defend, no sunk political capital in oil and gas. They just had growing energy demand and cheap solutions.

Implications for Global Sustainability-Minded Investors

For investors, the map of opportunity has quietly flipped. Most “sustainable” and “energy transition” portfolios remain overweight developed markets — the same markets now mired in politics, planning delays, and policy fatigue. Meanwhile, the real build-out is happening elsewhere, driven by balance sheets that care less about ideology and more about kilowatts.

The numbers are blunt. Emerging markets already account for nearly 60 % of global clean-energy revenues. Yet in most global equity benchmarks, they still represent barely 12 % of portfolio exposure.

That disconnect creates both risk and alpha. Portfolios anchored to Western policy cycles remain exposed to subsidy rollbacks, voter mood swings, and bureaucratic inertia — while emerging-market clean-tech firms are growing revenues at roughly twice the global sector average. Their surge in clean-energy revenues has gone hand in hand with stronger equity performance.

The turning point came in early 2024, when emerging-market clean-energy equities began to pull ahead decisively. This aligns with IEA data showing that emerging economies started deploying significantly more renewable capacity than developed markets, led by solar, wind, and grid infrastructure.

Yet, as the valuation chart shows, these same companies continue to trade at historically lower price-to-earnings multiples, with the gap now widening again after briefly narrowing in 2023. In short, investors are still paying a premium for slower-growing, policy-dependent clean-tech names in the West — while faster-scaling, economically driven leaders in emerging markets deliver better performance at a discount.

Nine months into Trump’s presidency, its contours are taking shape. Beyond campaign promises—tax cuts, manufacturing revival, and drilling expansion – the U.S. government has taken a strong tack toward interventionism. From interference at the Fed to taking stakes in American companies, Trump’s republicanism is vastly different from preceding Presidents of the same party.

Indeed, Trump’s growing intervention, especially in corporate affairs, is fueling concerns that the U.S. is shifting away from the so-called laissez-faire economy. That said, with equity markets at new highs and both government and corporate bond yields trading in a relatively tight range, one might be hard pressed to find evidence that it matters, yet!

In 2021, we published a note ( “Macro Goes ESG” July 8, 2021) that outlined our high conviction view that fiscal and industrial policy would become dominant policy levers in the coming decade. Although we were far too optimistic that interventionist governments would address voter preferences such as climate change and socioeconomic inequalities, our forecast of government interventionist policies is proving true.  

Important for investors is that unlike monetary policy which “lifts (sinks) all boats”, fiscal and industrial policy creates winners and losers. This is true for sustainability themes and financial markets at large.

In today’s Macro Meets Sustainability quarterly update, we discuss the three main U.S. government interventions that have evolved since Trump took office.

  1. Mar-A-Lago and USD: Beware the Kindleberger Trap

The Kindleberger Trap – named for economic historian Charles Kindleberger – posits that global stability depends on a leading power that is willing and able to supply public goods that benefit the international community. When the dominant power fails to fulfill this role, the international system becomes prone to conflict and economic crisis.

For investors, the essential public good that keeps the global economy out of the Kindleberger trap is the U.S. dollar acting as the world’s reserve currency. Reserve currencies are necessary in global trading systems to facilitate international transactions and act as a store of value, and they tend to impose two characteristics on the reserve status country:

The so-called Mar-a-Lago Accord is an attempt in our view to have one’s cake (low interest rates, access to capital) and eat it too (revive the domestic industrial and manufacturing sector) but does not consider the consequences of falling into a “Kindleberger trap”.   If the U.S. is unable or unwilling to maintain policy that ensures the greenback as the world’s reserve currency, it is unlikely that foreign nations and investors will risk asset value erosion by currency devaluation or inflation (see the section below).

To this end, there is more evidence that investors are becoming nervous about the impacts of U.S. policy on the greenback: equity investors are aggressively increasing currency hedges. According to a recent FT article and Deutsche Bank data, over 80% of the 7 billion USD that has flowed into foreign domiciled U.S. ETFs in the past three months has been on a hedged basis, compared to 20% at the beginning of the year. In other words, investors still want to own U.S. equities but are wary of the currency.

The bottom line is the current U.S. administration’s desire to decrease the trade deficit risks obliterating a key public good – a stable reserve currency – and sending the global economy into a Kindleberger trap, with the concomitant increase in volatility in financial markets. We believe that currency hedging is fully justified for non-U.S. investors exposed to U.S. markets and/or the currency risk should create a significant home bias in sustainable investments.

2. Monetary Interference: Stoking Inflation

Recent events and nominations at the Fed underscore President Trump’s intention to politicize the central bank and the outcome of last week’s FOMC meeting gave a good indication of how investors should think about policy stimulus in the current regime. Recall that last week, the FOMC voted to lower interest rates while simultaneously upgrading the economic outlook and increasing its expectation for inflation over the next year (to a level well above 2%). Thus, we believe that investors should position for both lower central bank rates and higher inflation, as it marks an important deviation from the conventional central bank’s playbook. Since 1982 (when Volcker broke the back of runaway inflation), monetary policy generally fell into four quadrants:  

  1. Interest rates are becoming stimulative (rates are below the neutral rate and falling while the economy is weakening and lower inflation is anticipated)
  2. Interest rates are becoming less stimulative (rates are below the neutral rate and rising while economic growth is bottoming and higher inflation is anticipated).
  3. Interest rates are becoming increasingly restrictive (rates are above the neutral rate and rising because the economy is running hot and higher inflation is anticipated).
  4. Interest rates are becoming less restrictive (rates are above the neutral rate and falling as economic growth is peaking and lower inflation is anticipated).

By signaling that rates can go lower while economic and inflation accelerates, it is becoming more probable that the Fed will de-emphasize its objective on inflation stability and focus on maximum employment and low interest rates.  

Historically, low rate and higher inflation environments have favored real estate plays and other real assets. For ideas that fit squarely within a sustainability framework, please see our recent notes on this subject: It’s About to Get Real, August 21, 2025 and The Age of Opportunity: Investments in Eldercare April 23, 2025.

  1. Corporate Interventionism: From Invisible Hand to Tightening Grip

In 2024, the IMF published a new data set that documents emergent patterns of policy intervention associated with the return of industrial policy. In one year, they recorded over 2,500 new industrial policies worldwide, of which 71% are considered trade distorting. This is perhaps not surprising to anyone watching the news flow. In the past quarter alone, the following U.S. developments have occurred:

These are perhaps the most jaw-dropping developments, not least of all because they occurred at the firm-specific level, which represents almost half of all the interventions documented by the IMF (see table below).

The IMF’s database also categorizes policy interventions by their motivating factor. Interestingly, supply chains and climate change – considerations that both fit squarely within sustainability investing – feature prominently (see the chart below). The one caveat is that the data was collected from 2009 to 2023 and researchers noted that in the most recent year, measures focused increasingly on national security, and less on competitiveness.

The rise of industrial policy and interventionist governments is far from a uniquely U.S. phenomenon (see the table below). A case in point is this month’s announcement from Canada’s Prime Minister Mark Carney, which unveiled the first phase of the country’s “nation building” projects, all five of which could be classified by the IMF as being motivated by climate change or supply chains and include energy production (nuclear), energy transport (LNG), mineral production (copper, gold) and supply chains (port expansion).

An investment backdrop that is dominated by political catalysts implies an environment where active portfolio management is necessary because sectoral, thematic, and geographic winners and losers will be produced. Critically, this applies equally to sustainability themes. While ESG has become a touchy subject and there is no longer a wholesale buying of related equity products, companies that derive revenue from specific sustainability themes (e.g. waste management, green infrastructure, carbon) have had excellent performance so far during Trump’s reign.  

Sustainability winners and losers are likely to run along thematic lines that are heavily influenced by both perceived threats and actual policy pivots; carbon is an excellent example, as discussed in last week’s note (Contrarians in the Green,  September 18, 2025).

There’s a famous line in Bruce Springsteen’s Atlantic City: “Down here it’s just winners and losers, and don’t get caught on the wrong side of that line.” Today, it seems that line is drawn between those whose productivity will be augmented by AI and those who will be displaced by it.

This note examines how the AI revolution will reshape the labor market. We explore how once-enviable service-sector jobs will be affected and how Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) — if ever achieved — will likely amplify income and wealth inequalities over the coming decades. We begin with the macro view — who benefits from AI-driven productivity gains — and then drill down to industry-level effects.

Will AI Benefit Workers or Profits?

Historically, disruptive technologies have had unequal impacts depending on skill levels, income brackets, gender, and sector. Many consider AI the most significant General-Purpose Technology (GPT) since the internet in the late 1990s.

From a macro perspective, if AI can “lift all boats” by driving higher productivity, it is crucial to understand whether those gains will flow to corporate profits (and shareholders) or to workers. To answer this, we must examine how past technological breakthroughs affected worker productivity and the subsequent growth in real wages as technology integrated into daily workflows.

If productivity growth tends to translate into higher real wages over the long run, then AI’s impact on worker productivity — particularly in the services sector, which accounts for roughly 80% of GDP in many advanced economies — should, in theory, benefit those whose work is augmented by AI.

However, while labor productivity and real wage growth tracked closely until the mid-1970s, the relationship began breaking down in the 1980s as globalization expanded the labor pool and wage pressure increased. In recent decades, faster technological change — and its positive effects on productivity — has been less profitable for workers, with gains flowing largely to corporate profits.

Corporate profits as a share of national income are now at record highs, while wage share has continued to decline. Unless taxation or redistribution mechanisms change, most AI-driven gains will likely keep flowing to shareholders rather than workers.

Displaced, Augmented, or Dropped?

Every technological shift forces workers to adapt — but not all can or will. Encouragingly, a recent McKinsey & Co. survey found that many employers expect AI to create a net increase in jobs in most functions, except for service operations, supply chain management, HR, and manufacturing. While this is positive news overall, it underscores the need for workers in certain functions to adapt quickly.

Similarly, PwC’s Fearless Future: 2025 AI Jobs Barometer shows that jobs with “some exposure” to AI are still growing, but at a slower rate than jobs in occupations where AI is less relevant or not applicable.

Unlike past disruptions — such as the offshoring-driven manufacturing job losses of the early 2000s — the workers most at risk today are in coveted service-sector roles, many requiring advanced education. One striking example: the author recently saw a man in downtown Toronto wearing a sandwich board reading “Junior programmer looking for work” — a scenario almost unimaginable just two years ago. Such rapid shifts could spark political and social unrest, as displaced, highly educated workers may influence policy debates much as displaced “Rust Belt” manufacturing workers did during the 2016 U.S. election. A recent article even suggests that Silicon Valley may have mishandled the junior IT job market

A recent OECD study suggests that jobs most affected by AI are disproportionately held by highly educated white men in their prime working years — a politically influential demographic in many developed economies. Some researchers argue that this “overproduction” of educated elites could fuel additional instability.

The takeaway: not all well-educated workers will be augmented by AI to the same degree, and many will drop out of the labor market entirely, unable to integrate AI into their workflows. This is especially pronounced in services, where senior roles may benefit most from productivity gains while junior roles face displacement. As a result, workers in the top income quartiles are likely to see faster wage growth than those in lower quartiles.

Research by Apollo suggests that the two highest income quintiles — already accounting for roughly 60% of total spending — will further increase their share of consumption in the coming years.

This trend is already visible. Since 2018, earners in the top income quartiles have increased real consumption by 15%, five percentage points more than the lower quartile.

As Spring turns to Summer in the Northern Hemisphere, along with the canopies coming back to our communities, this year once again brings smoke from forest wildfires in Western Canada. In a world where ESG investing continues to face an uphill battle, it seems that themes like natural capital and biodiversity are more relevant than ever and to many a surprise, are still showing some momentum as a way of trying to find value while protecting the invaluable.

What’s the Difference Between Biodiversity and Natural Capital?

According to the UN, the term “natural capital” includes the stock of renewable and non-renewable resources (e.g. plants, animals, air, water, soils, minerals) that combine to yield a flow of benefits to people. In this definition, the concept of natural capital extends beyond nature as a source of raw materials for production (e.g. timber) to include the role of the environment and ecosystems in supporting human well-being through the supply of important goods and services such as clean water, fertile soils and valuable genetic resources. For its part, biodiversity has a narrower focus and refers to the variety and variability of life forms. Therefore, whereas biodiversity focuses specifically on the variety and variability of life forms, natural capital includes biodiversity and covers all natural resources and ecosystem services that contribute to human well-being and economic value.

In 2024, over 30 global equity funds with a biodiversity focus were launched. Furthermore, a recent survey by MSCI shows that AUM in biodiversity funds grew by around 50% in the year to September 2024 to USD 1.6 billion. Most of these funds apply exclusion screens and are characterized by a predominant exposure to the GICS Industrials sector.

However, the prominence of greenwashing has gotten us used to looking beyond the label – i.e. it is not because “biodiversity” is in the name that it is necessarily investing in the service of biodiversity and natural capital. After all, the financial sector has been quick to jump on the opportunity to sell to investors the idea that companies like Microsoft, Google and Apple are a good biodiversity play because their level of emissions per dollar of revenue is low. While the ultimate goal of these funds should be to improve biodiversity, applicable investment opportunities in public markets are hard to come by.

In our view, investors looking for real impact on biodiversity should look for funds (or holdings) which aim to restore/protect – if not provide solutions in service to the environment – or at the very least aim to “Do No Significant Harm” (DNSH). Indeed, of the hundred or so biodiversity funds that exist, we identified only a handful whereby the major holdings appear to have strong alignment with biodiversity. The following table highlights some of these “better aligned” funds.

Our observation is that currently, the strongest funds have adopted a DNSH approach to natural capital and biodiversity – i.e. they invest in companies that – while not necessarily providing products and services in service to natural capital – at least contribute to slowing the pace of destruction of the natural world. In this context, investment themes such as circularity, water, packaging, waste management are consistent with this approach.

 

Some (Financial) Resilience in Nature

Investing in highly aligned biodiversity funds offer both real-world resilience to climate change, and portfolio protection in times of high financial volatility. In fact, the biodiversity and natural capital themes have outperformed the MSCI World Index these past few months as the financial world gyrates in attempting to price-in Trump’s policies.

Biodiversity Data: Hardly Investment Grade

Several data providers and data tools developed by non-profit organizations now offer to benchmark public equity portfolios against difference biodiversity frameworks. As an example, the Finance for Biodiversity Foundation has published an extensive study looking at the impact of companies included in the MSCI ACWI index on biodiversity. Notable conclusions are: 1) the importance of including the full value chain in biodiversity analysis and 2) the food industry has the largest impact on biodiversity. For private assets, platforms such as the UNEP-funded Encore initiative offers resources assessing biodiversity “damage” according to the materiality of the impact of private projects in different economic sectors.

However, there remain several limitations regarding the methodologies used to build these datasets. As an example, the association of revenue segments/industry sectors to specific biomes or ecosystem services – and the scope of the damage inflicted on biodiversity – remains patchy at best and still involves an important number of assumptions. By comparison, obtaining scope three GHG emissions for a company, or even evaluating avoided emissions, appears straightforward compared to evaluating the butterfly effect of the damage on biodiversity by a given company. 

 

The Hardest Part – How to Invest?

If one were to translate natural capital and biodiversity concepts into financial asset classes lingo, then timberland as well as companies building products and services which are in service to natural capital and the protection of biodiversity could be investable. These would include asset classes such as timber, water, food and industries which focus on anything that reduces waste and/or supports a more efficient use of resources. Conversely, those looking to invest in pure-play “biodiversity” assets ought to look at asset classes such as private assets (PE or credit) where the impact of the investment on biodiversity could be answered in hefty pre-investment questionnaires as part of loan covenants. Another emerging sector are biodiversity credits in the voluntary sector.

To this end, the Biodiversity Credit Alliance (BCA) is emerging as a standard bearer in developing the biodiversity credit “industry”. Some estimates suggest that while nascent, the biodiversity credit market could be worth some USD 40 billion by 2040. According to BCA, a biodiversity credit is a certificate that represents a measured and evidence-based unit of positive biodiversity outcome that is durable and additional to what would have otherwise occurred. Emerging schemes stipulate that a biodiversity credit is a financial instrument that supports the conservation of nature and typically includes some aspect of a conservation activity or outcome, over a certain area, during a certain time period. For those hoping to see a significant rise in the price of biodiversity credits this past couple of years, we were unable to find any proper pricing data for the most traded biodiversity credits. For this reason, and despite the efforts made so far in structuring the industry, the murkiness of the concept of biodiversity credits suggests that this industry is hardly investable.

For all the promise of a transition to low-carbon energy (and the fear of trillions in stranded fossil fuel assets), it may not be obvious in the aggregate data that much has happened. Against a backdrop of unrelenting increases in total energy demand, the share that has been supplied from renewable sources has hardly been transformative. The chart below shows the world’s energy mix in 2010 vs 2023: oil and coal accounted for 61% of total energy in 2010. Thirteen years later, 57% of the world’s energy supply remain oil and coal.  

But since transitions are never linear, it is not a useful exercise to extrapolate the current pace of transition to suggest a date in the future whereby our reliance on fossil fuels is negligible. Indeed, almost all successful technological transformations have followed an S-curve, which begin with a period of exponential growth, followed by linear growth, then exponentially declining growth before settling at a fixed level. A well-known example of the S-curve is mobile phone adoption (see chart below). Typically, a technological transformation may take several years (decades) to reach between 5 – 10% market share and is often supported by subsidies or other incentives to get them off the ground. Once this threshold is reached, new transformative technologies will then rapidly gain a high market share (i.e. greater than 50%) even in absence of government support, before levelling off.

The S-Curve for Energy Technology

In terms of the energy transition, one example of the S-curve at work is EV sales in Norway. Despite being introduced to Norwegian consumers in the 2000s, electric vehicles only accounted for about 5% of car sales by 2012. Sales penetration really sped up in 2015 and by 2021 over 85% of car sales were electric. The pace of penetration has now clearly slowed, increasing by only 1% between 2022 and 2023.

 

Dying technologies also follow an (inverted) S-curve. For example, coal consumption in the U.S. peaked in 2008 and is charting a textbook trajectory toward collapse. Interestingly, forecasts from respected organizations like the U.S. EIA erroneously made linear projections for the recovery/stabilization of coal power. The 2025 annual report, that projects out to 2050, is the first year that the EIA estimates an S-curve for coal consumption, essentially flat-lining at less than 1% of levels experienced in the 1990s and 2000s. Once the economics of substitutes (e.g. solar) became attractive, the collapse began happening at a faster rate than expected.  

Note that in the case of coal, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the ensuing energy shortage caused a temporary increase in coal demand. Today, despite the ongoing war, coal is experiencing a multi-year supply glut, with prices now at a four-year low. This is despite the U.S. government accusations that coal companies are conspiring with their major shareholders (BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street) to reduce their coal production!

 

U.S. COAL CONSUMPTION IS FOLLOWING AN INVERTED S-CURVE

The S-curve has major implications for coal-related stock prices. There used to be several ways for equity investors to participate in the coal market. However, by 2020 most popular products for gaining exposure to coal were discontinued: the Dow Jones U.S. Coal Index (DJUSCL) and ETFs like KOL (Van Eck), TONS (Wisdom Tree) were all among the dead. Note that a new ETF was launched in early 2024 (ticker COAL) and, not surprisingly for those that predicted an S-curve in coal, has lost 30% of its value since inception and has stagnated at $15M in AUM.

When To Invest…

As the above example shows, understanding where renewable technologies are on the S-curve – rather than making linear extrapolations about adoption – is key to investment timing for long-term investors, both in entering long positions in new technology and also exiting from losing energy assets.

Solar, wind and battery storage are all candidates for hitting the steep positive slope of the S-curve for electricity production. For example, the chart below shows the share of electricity production from solar; at 7% of total electricity production, it is in the range whereby rapid market share gains will be imminent if it is to be a transformative technology.  

But how to we do know if solar will follow the S-curve? To be sure, public policy can speed up (or slow down) the adoption of new technology. In the example regarding EV adoption in Norway, that government put in place an aggressive program of fiscal incentives and practical advantages beginning in the 2000s to kickstart the transition away from ICE vehicles.

A second consideration is connection. In last week’s note, we argued that the major bottleneck for renewable energy deployment is the urgent need to expand and modernize electricity grids. Renewable energy will not realize its potential if it is hampered by unstable, unreliable grids (or if solutions to mitigate intermittency are not deployed). This is, in our view, the largest remaining challenge to rapid, mass deployment of renewable energy strategies.  

In other words, we have already surmounted the most significant hurdle, which is cost. Indeed, a necessary condition of scaling the S-curve is that, in absence of government support, the cost of the new technology must be less than the incumbent. We have written about the relative cost of renewables versus fossil fuels in the past, and it is fast becoming common knowledge that both wind and solar systems for electricity production are now cheaper than fossil fuels. In many ways, a virtuous cycle is already in effect, whereby many renewable technologies are getting cheaper the more they are deployed and will see greater deployment the cheaper they get. Solar panels, wind turbines, and lithium-ion batteries have all declined in cost by over 90% in the past two decades. 

We note that renewable energy stocks hardly reflect this upbeat view relative to fossil fuel companies. First Solar (FSLR), the closest company to a U.S. solar national champion, has declined 20% ytd, and is highly sensitive to tariff and federal policy news. Perhaps too sensitive - after all, the economics of solar suggest that although IRA subsidies provided a nice tailwind, they aren’t crucial to choosing solar over dirty alternatives. Nonetheless, as we wrote in recent research, companies involved in the buildout of the electricity grid, and not the energy producers, offer the most upside in the current environment (please see From Solar Panels to Control Panels: Why It’s Time to Focus on the Grid, May 22, 2025).

…And When To Divest

Many sustainability minded investors will have already divested from fossil fuel stocks years ago, not wanting to be investing in products that are known to be harming the planet. When it comes to coal, this clearly was the right investment decision, since most coal stocks have had a disastrous performance over the past fifteen years as the switch to natural gas and some early renewables were easy “wins” over coal. But the same has not been true for conventional oil and gas: over the past five years, investors in this part of the energy sector have been rewarded with equity gains of over 100%.

However, if we are correct that renewables are ripe to gouge fossil fuel market share, then the risk of stranded assets is no longer tomorrow’s problem.

The most recent wave of significant write-downs in the energy sector occurred in 2020, after a prolonged period of weak oil prices (and a wave of high-profile asset manager commitments to net zero). This makes sense since the underlying commodity price is a key input to oil and gas companies’ asset valuations. At that time, write-downs were on average less than 5% of major oil companies’ assets and were, in most cases, due to a downward revision in long-term expected oil prices (see the table below). Note that in 2020, renewable energy alternatives were far less competitive than they are today, while the breakeven price of oil (i.e. the cost to bring oil out of the ground and bring it to market) has increased over the past five years.  

Indeed, knowing the oil price forecast that a company uses is a key way for investors to estimate how susceptible its assets are to write-downs. This information is not always readily available/disclosed, especially in the U.S. However, among the U.K. and European companies that do disclose this information (Shell, TotalEnergies, BP, Equinor, Repsol), the vast majority have forecasts for oil prices over the next decade to stay above 60 USD/barrel.

Coincidentally, oil prices have been trading at around 60 USD/barrel over the past month and market participants and observers have been systematically revising down oil price forecasts for 2025 and 2026. To be sure, it will take a more prolonged period of weak oil prices before the oil majors make major asset price revisions. However, if we use the 2020 write down cycle as a roadmap, it is most likely that stock prices will take a significant hit before write-downs (stranded assets) are announced.

The seismic shift in the White House has already provoked another one: in the corporate world, many firms are letting go of their climate and Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) objectives. Blackrock is the latest of several U.S. financial institutions to drop out of net zero commitment groups. This contrasts starkly with their stance in 2020 when Larry Fink gained notoriety for his statement that “climate risk is financial risk” in his annual letter to CEOs.

Net zero and other climate commitments were already putting some firms under the spotlights of the anti-ESG movement this past year. That said, the current corporate back off from “all things ESG” is now triggering sustainability-minded investors and other activists in asking for greater accountability over greenwashing claims and past corporate statements about sustainability.

Time to hit the courts?

As the environment for corporate shareholder engagement becomes more challenging, we think that increased focus on litigation could offer another way to hold corporations accountable for their misrepresentation of practices about sustainability and/or their insufficient action on social and environmental issues. With the growing impact of climate change, pollution, and other harmful practices, impacted communities are increasingly likely to seek legal recourse for damages, driving an uptick in lawsuits. This should be good news for the legal crowd – for whom a Trumpian White House is already proving a boon. As such, we think that litigation cases on ESG issues are set to grow substantially over the next few years.

In our view, there are two main areas where we think litigation is set to grow: Consumer and Environmental law. Greenwashing – i.e. the use of misleading environmental claims – is one prominent example which could fall under consumer laws. Conversely, environmental impact, such as pollution, would fall under environmental laws. Here’s how corporate malpractice could fall under one of those categories:

Litigators Unite!

One thing we can be certain of is that litigation has a promising future—especially in the U.S., with climate change cases leading the charge. To this end, a database from Columbia University’s Sabin Center for Climate Change Law contained 2,796 climate litigation case (as of September 2024): 1,850 (66%) were filed in the US and 946 (34%) in the rest of the world. According to the Center, one of the most rapidly growing forms of climate litigation is “climate-washing,” the practice of using misleading or false claims to cover a company’s true climate impact – and mislead consumers into believing its products and services are sustainable. More than 140 such cases have already been filed to date, with 47 filed in 2023 alone.

While it is challenging to determine a precise success rate for climate change litigation due to the variety of cases and jurisdictions involved, the Sabin Center’s studies suggest that over 50% of climate cases have resulted in judicial outcomes favorable to climate action. These favorable outcomes include court rulings that have led to changes in government policy, corporate behavior, and public awareness.

Interestingly, cases challenging “climate-washing” have been particularly successful, with over 70% of finalized cases decided in favor of the claimants. This high success rate highlights the growing scrutiny of corporate environmental claims, and the increasing legal risks associated with greenwashing. The good news is that it seems that the increasing success of climate-washing litigation suggests a growing trend of corporate accountability for environmental claims.

Furthermore, jurisdictions across the U.S. are taking legal action against climate offenders, seeking compensation for environmental damages. A comprehensive map of these cases, created by the Climate Integrity Project, highlights the growing efforts to hold the oil industry accountable for the harm it causes to communities. This trend indicates that sustainability-focused litigators now have a wider range of jurisdictions to consider when pursuing justice in court.

Finally, some research suggests that the global litigation funding investment market was valued at USD 18.2 Billion in 2022 and is anticipated to generate robust growth through 2028, with a CAGR of 13.2%. For those looking to capitalize on the expanding litigation market, it’s worth noting that while a few publicly listed companies specialize in litigation finance, firms exclusively focused on environmental or greenwashing cases remain rare. Consequently, the opportunity in sustainability litigation is more readily accessible through private equity investments.

As it has become a tradition at SMS, December is the time when we take a step back and look at our investment calls of the past year – mostly to help us identify our own cognitive biases. This year’s review happens at a time when 2024 will be the very first year when the world will have breached the 1.5 degree Celsius of warming above 1900 levels – despite countries’ commitments (including those of the investment community) made at the Paris 2015 Climate Agreement.

With this in mind, today’s note looks at our past performance – the good, the bad and the ugly. We first look at the performance of our 2024 new year’s investment calls and then look at the performance of our various investment themes and universe. Finally, we look at trades that we still have in play which we’ve researched in the past few months and which could still have some legs in 2025. Today’s note sets the table for our next publication on January 9th which will outline our investment views for 2025. We wish our reader a very happy holiday season.

  1. A Look at Our 2024 Early Calls

We had five main views at the outset of 2024 (see our note “Investment Trends in 2024: Bounce Back for Sustainability”, December 14, 2023): 1) Long Industrials over Consumer Discretionary, Long Uranium and Nuclear (stocks like Cameco; 2) Toe-dip into sustainable infrastructure and renewable energy/energy efficiency (e.g., MSCI Alternative Energy) when rates start to abate, 4) Long North American carbon markets and 5) Short “Buy Now, Pay Later” stocks (such as Affirm).

In retrospect, these calls have performed quite well – at least until the election of November 5th. Except for Energy Efficiency, the sustainability complex reacted positively to a lower yield environment in the first three quarters of 2024 – only to be clobbered in Q4 in the lead up to and the outcome of the election – and its accompanying 60 bps upswing in yields. Trump was clearly a ‘known unknown” type of event for the sustainability complex, which was compounded by the expectations that the new Administration will bring significant changes to the Inflation Reduction Act and its suite of pro-climate policies.

One of our favorites – yet unprofitable – calls of 2024 was to be long North American regulated carbon allowances. This proved a money-losing proposal – where we bet too early on a recovery in California carbon prices coming from trends such as 1) increased demand for energy, 2) re-industrialization and 3) the reshoring of the U.S. Economy. We are still waiting for a bounce in North American carbon prices.

2) SMS Thematic Performance

Turning to our aggregate thematic performance, the first consideration is that our average long and short call of 2024 (calculated since the note was published on an equal-weighted basis) made a YTD return just shy of +4%, which compares palely to the S&P return of +27% (in USD) and +33% for the NASDAQ YTD. Our Tech calls proved the most performing, closely followed by those in sustainable infrastructure, while sustainable transportation and transition materials where our worst themes.

This performance underlines the subpar performance of most sustainability funds throughout 2024. This happens amid a context where most ESG/sustainability/impact funds have continued to underperform “normcore” benchmarks by a margin. To this point, it’s hard to make a buck when your long investment universe tanks and when your short investment universe is on a tear. This was the problem of many sustainable investors the past year.

This also justifies the current conversation about what would be the appropriate benchmark for sustainability-focused investors – especially those who are serious about moving capital towards a more sustainable world – without losing face with their stakeholders. That said, readers should be (conveniently) reminded that past performance is not indicative of future results.

Looking at the performance of our long (based on the date at which our note was written), one sees that none of our themes matched the stellar performance of the all-powerful US market.

Looking at our shorts – which were incredibly hard to do when markets are up by so much – our average call yielded a -6.4% performance (our shorts actually went up in price), mostly driven by Food Sustainability and Transition Materials. Considering the impressive performance of markets so far, one could say that the fact that our short calls went down by just -6.4% is a testament to our ability to pick companies in our short themes.

3) SMS Universe – Mostly Red, Not Much Green

Finally, looking at SMS’ investment Long/Short universe of approximately 700 companies out of the MSCI All Country World Index, one also sees how hard 2024 was. Overall, our long universe went up by 13% (that’s half the performance of the S&P 500 YTD), while our short universe went up by 20%. In this context, it’s been hard to build outperforming portfolios.

4) Selection of calls that worked in 2024 and still have some legs for 2025

a) Short Temp Staffing

We first published on temp staffing agencies on January 18, 2024 (Temp Staffing Agencies: Minimum Pay & Minimal Returns). As labor markets started to show some slack on both sides of the Atlantic, we saw an opportunity to take short positions on stocks such as Adecco, Robert Half and Manpower. Temp staffing firms are notorious for underpaying their staff and offering less-than-market working conditions to their employees – which are often the first to be let go when sales sour. This play was very timely.

b) Long Engineering Services – especially those active in sustainability fields

Engineers can be boring (SMS has some on its team) – but they can sure deliver – as per SMS equal-weighted Engineering index this past year which beat the NASDAQ index. In fact, SMS wrote on engineering firms last August, whose business lines can be closely related to sustainability and climate adaptation – and which should continue to benefit from Trump’s America first policies (see our August 19, 2024 note, “US Election Color Wheel: Spotting the Green in the Blue vs. Red Landscape”).

c) Less Alcohol, More Money and Health

In our October 17, 2024 note “Last Call for Alcohol Companies”, we highlighted a long-term trend suggesting that people are drinking less. In fact, it seems that millennials actually drink less than their X or boomer counterparts, a megatrend which doesn’t bode well for alcoholic beverage makers – but probably better on your wallet and longer-term health prospects.

As a conclusion, the past two years of underperformance of sustainability-themed investment strategies raises a few critical questions for investors who want to change the world with their portfolios – while assuring an acceptable level of performance for their stakeholders.

  1. Sustainable investing is like playing the long game: Are you really ready for it?
  2. Your interest in saving the world from itself through an investor lens may look crazy at times (like now), how much risk are you ready to take in veering away from established benchmarks?
  3. If you agree with our view that climate change and inequalities will be critical economic and increasingly financially material factors over the next 5 years, then financial markets are offering a very attractive opportunity as they are currently anticipating an acceleration of the recent unsustainable past.