“My Precious”: Why Recycling Beats Mining

November 6, 2025
You must provide your professional email address to view this content.
  • Precious metals are scarce, durable and of growing industrial use for clean energy, electronics and medicine.
  • Their durability allows for recycling which is becoming increasingly profitable due to the rise in precious metals’ prices.
  • Companies with significant precious metals recycling activity are trading at valuation multiples below the market with an improving profitability outlook, making them worthy additions to a portfolio.

Precious metals’ combination of scarcity, durability, and conductivity makes them indispensable to advanced industry—from clean energy and electronics to medicine. With prices up roughly fourfold over the past decade and new supply increasingly constrained, recycling has emerged as a more profitable and sustainable way to gain exposure than mining.

Key points:

  • Industrial demand drives new growth: Gold, silver, and platinum-group metals have moved beyond their traditional role as stores of value to become critical inputs for renewable energy, hydrogen, semiconductors, and medical devices. Industrial demand now rivals investment flows as the sector’s key growth engine.

  • Recycling as the new mining: Precious metals can be recycled indefinitely without loss of quality. Recyclers benefit from rising metal prices and tightening primary supply while avoiding the high energy use, toxic waste, and land impacts of extraction.

  • Policy and critical minerals support: Developed markets are prioritizing domestic critical minerals; Canada recently allocated C$214 million over five years to accelerate such projects.

  • Publicly traded exposure: Investors can access this circular-economy theme through companies leading in recycling and refining:

    • Umicore SA (UMI-BE) – Global leader in advanced metals and recycling with one of the world’s largest complex-material refineries.

    • Johnson Matthey Plc (JMAT-GB) – Runs world-class platinum-group metals recycling and catalyst facilities.

    • Dowa Holdings Co. (5714-JP) – Integrated recycler of gold, silver, and base metals from industrial and electronic waste.

    • Mitsubishi Materials Corp. (5711-JP) – Major Japanese recycler operating precious-metal recovery for automotive and electronics.

    • Sims Ltd. (SGM-AU) – Global recycling leader in ferrous and non-ferrous metals, expanding into circuit-board recovery.

    • Aurubis AG (NDA-DE) – Europe’s largest copper recycler, also processing gold, silver, and PGMs.

    • ARE Holdings Inc. (5857-JP) – Specializes in recovering gold, silver, and platinum from e-waste and industrial by-products.

    • Materion Corp. (MTRN-US) – Refines high-tech manufacturing scrap into specialty and precious metals for electronics and aerospace.

  • Valuation opportunity: Precious-metal recyclers still trade well below market—P/E ratios of 8–20× and price-to-book below 2× vs. 27× and 4.6× for the S&P 500. With rising metal prices and expanding margins, the group offers compelling re-rating potential.

  • Investment case: Recycling aligns resource efficiency with profit growth, offering cleaner exposure to the energy transition and digital-economy demand than mining.

Which recyclers are best positioned to benefit from tightening metal supply, policy support, and rising sustainability premiums?
Contact [email protected] to access the full note, including valuation charts and in-depth company analysis.

Disclaimer / Securities Disclosure

The author(s) of this research note do (does) not personally hold a any position in any of the above-mentioned securities.
Nordis Capital (SMS’ sister company) does not hold any position in any of the above-mentioned securities in its funds.

DISCLAIMER
© Sustainable Market Strategies, a division of SMS Financial Technologies inc. Redistribution prohibited without prior consent. This report has been prepared by Sustainable Market Strategies mainly for distribution to market professionals and institutional investors. It should not be considered as investment advice or a recommendation to purchase any particular security, strategy, or investment product. References to specific securities and issuers are not intended to be, and should not be interpreted as, recommendations to purchase or sell such securities. Information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but not guaranteed.