TITLE: ‘Tis The Time to Feel AI-Augmented
SUMMARY (3 bullet points)
- Despite a turbulent ESG narrative and global policy setbacks, the energy transition theme, along with other SMS sustainability investment calls outperformed in 2025 amid weakened environmental policies.
- Lower interest rates acted as the main tailwind to our themes – reminiscent of the early 2020 fiscal/monetary nexus under Trump 1.0
- Themes over labels: While ESG as a label struggled, core sustainability themes—grid electrification, climate adaptation, resource scarcity, recycling, and emerging market transition—proved resilient and profitable, reinforcing SMS’ agnostic, theme-driven investment approach.
One of the most unexpected developments this year is that despite Trump’s anti-ESG outlook, clean energy sector stocks have done very well thanks to a favorable interest rate backdrop and an AI-fuelled increase in demand for energy. AS a result, the ICLN ETF significantly outperformed the S&P 500 throughout the year, similar to how the sector performed during the latter part of Trump’s first administration in 2019-20.
Our research process remained unaffected by this year’s changing ESG narrative: sustainability concepts like climate adaptation continue to present significant investment opportunities, as the chart below highlights.
The Good, The Bad & The Ugly
Despite setbacks in environmental policies affecting EV adoption, energy transition, and regulation in North America and Europe, this performance stands out as notable. Beyond energy transition, several other notable calls from 2025 finished in the green. Here’s a review by quarter follows below:
Q1 2025 The quarter was defined by the return of “Trumpian” policies, creating volatility through tariffs, immigration crackdowns, and inflation risks, alongside specific themes like the GLP-1 weight-loss revolution and legal risks in ESG. Our research concentrated on sectors that benefit from U.S. reshoring, grid electrification, and “Make America Healthy Again” (MAHA) policies. Investment recommendations included going long on U.S. waste management (Waste Management, Republic Services), grid infrastructure (Nexans, Eaton), and GLP-1 leaders (Novo Nordisk, Eli Lilly), while shorting oil majors, unhealthy food producers (PepsiCo, Mondelez), and consumer discretionary stocks like Victoria’s Secret.
- Q2 2025 Our research emphasized “strategic decoupling” from China, focusing on supply chain sovereignty, grid modernization following blackouts, and the “re-arming” of Europe. We warned against investing in Chinese green tech due to ESG risks, preferring “friend-shoring” partners like South Korea and companies addressing critical mineral shortages. Investment recommendations targeted European defense specialists (Thales, Leonardo, Saab), non-Chinese rare earth miners (MP Materials, Lynas), and grid stability providers (Siemens Energy, Quanta Services), while advising to avoid legacy U.S. automakers in favor of EV leaders like BYD and Tesla.
- Q3 2025 Climate adaptation and “real assets” as a hedge against persistent inflation and extreme heat were major themes at the end of the summer. Along with water scarcity, rail revival, and cooling technologies. We highlighted that pricing signals for water are weak and consumption is increasing, especially due to data centre demand. That same data centre demand, along with general heat stress are also driving demand for cooling solutions. . Investment recommendations favor desalination and water efficiency leaders (Energy Recovery, American Water Works), rail equipment suppliers (Wabtec, Knorr-Bremse), and HVAC companies (Comfort Systems, Trane), alongside a broader rotation into real assets for inflation protection.
- Q4 2025 We concluded the year with a focus on “scarcity” in finite resources (sand, fertilie soil, copper) and the shift of the energy transition’s momentum toward Emerging Markets where the economics of renewable energy trump ideology. In addition, given the budding structural rise in metals prices recycling as a superior alternative to mining for precious metals and emphasizes logistics optimization to handle trade friction. Investment recommendations include precious metal recyclers (Umicore, Sims Ltd), logistics software and real estate (Zebra Technologies, Segro), and Emerging Market clean-tech leaders that are undervalued relative to their developed market peers.
Greener Than Expected
NotebookLM’s synthesis of our research agenda and investment calls from 2025 clearly challenges the notion that Trump is harming sustainable investing. Strong gains came from grid plays, mining, recyclers, and Korean transition stocks. A timely short on consumer discretionary, notably Victoria’s Secret, paid off. Underperformers included water utilities, climate adaptation, Long EV/Short legacy automakers, and health care positions. Here’s a compendium of our trades, rationale and 3-month performance.
SMS Note Titles: Gifts that Keep On Giving
An additional quirky benefit of our AI assistant is that it reminded us of some of our best weekly note titles. Your editors believe a good title is half the battle of writing. Based on the 2025 research notes provided, our AI friend suggested the title that stands out as the most original and creative—utilizing a clever pun to describe geopolitical alliances—is:
“Seoul Mates: The Case for Korean Sustainability Plays” (May 1, 2025) This title plays on the term “soulmates” to highlight South Korea as a strategic “friend-shoring” partner and winner in the U.S.-China trade war.
Other titles from 2025 that were given credit for their good use of pop culture references, idioms, or wordplay:
- “Chill, Baby, Chill: Why Natural Gas is Not a Lay Up” (January 30, 2025)
- A play on the political slogan “Drill, baby, drill,” this note argued that natural gas is a sub-optimal solution compared to renewables and that investors should ignore the hype.
- ““My Precious”: Why Recycling Beats Mining” (November 6, 2025)
- A reference to The Lord of the Rings, this title introduced a note on the scarcity and value of recycling precious metals like gold and silver.
- “Winners Make it Here, Losers Source it There” (May 15, 2025)
- A riff on the lyrics to “New York, New York” (“If I can make it there, I’ll make it anywhere”), this title described the winners and losers of supply chain decoupling and re-shoring efforts.
- “MAHA: All Hat and No Cattle” (August 28, 2025) (This is the personal favorite of today’s note writher, which is not an AI BTW)
- Using a classic idiom meaning “all talk, no action,” this title described the underwhelming draft strategy of the “Make America Healthy Again” commission regarding pesticide use and processed foods.
- “Peak Elderly Circus” (February 20, 2025)
- A play on the London location “Piccadilly Circus,” this title introduced the demographic reality that the world is currently experiencing peak growth in the elderly population.
BOTTOM LINE
2025 proved to be a difficult year for the ESG investment complex amid an adverse global political environment. However, for those expressing their views by investing into sustainability related themes, the year was reminiscent of the hype of the early 2020s as most of our themes outperformed the market.