The North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) released their latest Long-Term Reliability Assessment in December 2023 which showed an increased risk of shortfalls in electricity under both extreme and normal conditions. Within a single year, the projected five-year annual growth rate for electricity consumption nearly doubled from 0.5% to 0.9%! This projection could be even higher as some utilities have revised their numbers upward since the release of the NERC forecast. There are several drivers behind this surge in demand – the reshoring of manufacturing, adoption of EVs and fossil fuel free heating systems – but perhaps the most noteworthy is AI.
The process of training new AI models is very energy intensive. AI dedicated servers can use 4 to 14 times the electricity of a normal rack of servers and AI queries (like ChatGPT) use 3-30 times more energy than a typical google search. Furthermore, generative AI not only needs to be trained on large datasets, but also creates loads of new data, thereby increasing the need for data centers. One study estimates the share of U.S. electricity demand for data centers will triple from 2.5% in 2022 to 7.5% by 2030. Clearly, a broader adoption of AI will be a substantial source of electricity demand.
This increased demand creates a challenging scenario for electricity grids. Already, the integration of renewables into the system has proved challenging. While it may seem faster to develop more traditional power plants to increase electricity production, this counters decarbonization goals. A better idea would be to improve the efficiency of existing grids instead. Ironically there is a role for AI in grid optimization, meaning AI can be leveraged to address the very problem it is helping to create.
The Ultimate Power Move: Efficiency
We see two areas where AI can serve to improve efficiency challenges. Firstly, continuous optimization of electricity consumption in industry and buildings. AI can help to unlock efficiency improvements in the design of individual electronic devices, reducing their electricity consumption. AI can also be applied to assess the energy management of larger industrial processes or commercial buildings. These make up 64.4% of U.S. electricity demand; with the rest of demand mostly coming from residential heating and cooling needs (see chart). Use of advanced data analytics in these areas can identify opportunities for energy savings, regulate power consumption and dynamically adjust needs in accordance with changes in electricity demand. This contributes to reduced energy waste and lower operational costs.
The second more direct approach is integration of AI into the electricity grid. This can be achieved using smart grid technologies that allow for real-time monitoring and control of grid operations. An example of grid optimization would be to use AI algorithms to dynamically adjust the distribution of electricity. So in times of low demand, surplus energy is directed to power-hungry processes or energy storage, and when demand peaks, the grid adapts in real-time to reduce strain and prioritize energy efficient consumption. Virtual power plants (VPPs) will be an important element to this. These systems aggregate small scale energy sources such as solar panels, wind turbines and energy storage enabling coordinated management of those resources to optimize energy supply. The U.S. Department of Energy has estimated that tripling the scale of virtual power plants (VPPs) could lower America’s grid costs by $10 billion a year.
Deploying smart meters and IoT devices embedded with AI into grid infrastructure is paramount to deploying these technologies. It facilitates the collection of real-time data which can then be processed by AI algorithms to optimize grid performance. This will be especially important as the share of intermittent energy sources like wind and solar increases.
Investment in digital grid infrastructure has grown significantly in recent years (see chart below). Countries are taking advantage of technological advances to modernize their systems. However, this level of investment will need to accelerate to keep pace with the newly anticipated surge in electricity demand.
Making Gains in Power Savings
In our note Finding Real Returns in Artificial Intelligence (April 27, 2023), we explored how AI is helping to improve industrial resource efficiency across impactful sectors, including energy. We expect continued sales growth for established players in industrial automation and IoT connectivity such as ABB, Honeywell and Siemens as their solutions support enhanced energy efficiency in several key areas: building energy management, industrial processes, and grid infrastructure.
Similarly, information technology companies like Oracle, Fujitsu and IBM are poised to benefit from the expansion of AI. Any innovations by these companies that improve the energy efficiency of IT infrastructure will help reduce strain on the grid and lower electricity costs for customers as prices are likely to rise given greater demand. In addition to higher sales associated with more data centers and servers, these technology companies will see increased revenues from products with direct applications in electricity grid optimization.
- Fujitsu is already leveraging AI to improve energy efficiency for communications networks.
- IBM’s expanding consulting services aim to support clients with digital transformation and AI deployment and include services specific to energy utilities.
- Oracle was identified as a leader for advanced electricity distribution management systems and has a variety of data collection and analytics tools for both energy and water utilities.
Companies with energy management as their main business segment offer the greatest impact with regards to sustainability. They are key in helping to lower emissions and integrate renewables in our electricity infrastructure. Investors should pay close attention to how these energy management companies are trying to leverage AI to optimize the grid.
There are two small cap names of interest: Itron and Landis+Gyr Group, with market caps of $4 billion USD and $2 billion USD respectively. Landis+Gyr is exclusively dedicated to smart grid. Itron earns 67% of revenues from smart grid products but also sells smart metering devices for water management, another growing sector. General Electric is also a leader in smart grid technology, earning nearly $3.5 billion in revenues from that segment. The former conglomerate completed the spin-off of its energy segment into GE Vernova earlier this week, this is a great opportunity for sustainability investors looking for exposure to innovative energy solutions.
Eaton and Schneider Electric are two other large companies with a strong focus on energy efficiency. These more specialized companies cover all bases, improving industrial companies’ consumption and the efficiency of data centers while also supporting utilities with the integration of digital technologies aimed at optimizing the grid. Both of these companies have slightly higher valuations (Fwd PE of 25.1 for Schneider and 30.5 for Eaton) than the information technology and industrial automation companies mentioned above (average fwd PE of 21.9 for ABB, Honeywell and Siemens and 19.7 for Fujitsu, IBM and Oracle), but this may be justified given the outlook for electricity demand.
R&D spend will be a critical factor in these companies’ ability to keep pace with AI developments. There is a notable increase in recent years relative to historical levels. One can also pay attention to the mentions of AI in earnings calls and business strategies. Though we recognize that some companies may be mentioning AI to take advantage of the current hype, it can serve as an indicator of how much they are leveraging AI capabilities. Investors just need to be diligent in their research to filter out any fluff. In Eaton’s documents, “AI” jumped from 6 mentions in 2022 to 182 in 2023 and is already at 48 for 2024. For Schneider, this year’s mentions of AI are already 5% higher than last year’s total; it is afterall one of the five key focus areas in their latest strategy.
Similar to other technology stocks, many of these companies are currently trading at elevated levels. Investors can watch for potential pullbacks to add exposure. Unlike some other AI-hyped names, we expect digitization of the grid to have staying power as society comes to terms with the significant increase in electricity demand.
Our hypothesis at the end of 2023 that the artificial intelligence hype had become extreme with respect to related stock valuations has not panned out so far in 2024. Not only did Nvidia’s stock price soar on last week’s earnings announcement, but the company’s CEO Jensen Huang has further fuelled excitement related to generative AI with his optimistic guidance, “[AI] Demand is surging worldwide across companies and nations… Auto, health, robotics, financial services… multibillion-dollar industries are embracing our generative AI”.
Although the valuations of many “AI companies” make our eyes water (NVIDIA is trading at 66 times earnings), there is certainly much to be excited about from a productivity perspective. After all, as we highlighted in our April 2023 note, “Finding Real Returns in Artificial Intelligence” ChatGPT displays an IQ of above 120, placing it among the top 10% of humans. This is quite the progress, given that less than a decade ago, researchers ranked Google’s AI IQ at 47, just shy of the average IQ (55) of a human 6-year-old. That said, for AI to make its way into all spheres of the economy like Internet did in the late 1990s, a massive economy-wide CAPEX effort will be needed – and as of now, that has yet to happen.
And what about from a sustainability perspective? There has been healthy debate (although perhaps not enough action) surrounding ethical aspects of AI. Questions have been raised about the energy intensity of AI tools, about data biases that are leading to discriminatory outcomes, about potential job losses, etc. On the flip side, AI promises to address challenges across industries, including resource optimization and medical breakthroughs. In short, artificial intelligence’s influence on our future is complex and heterogeneous. For investors looking to put capital to work beyond the semiconductor companies that have supplied AI with the chips to flourish, we note the key Sustainable Market Strategies’ themes where leveraging AI should produce superior real-world outcomes alongside superior returns.
Productivity with Purpose
With labor shortages persisting in many developed countries and an ever-increasing need to make better use of physical resources, the first major allure of artificial intelligence is its potential to increase productivity, either by replacing less efficient technologies (and/or labor) or via optimisation of resources.
Software companies were one of the “early movers” with respect to excitement in the application of AI tools. Indeed, four software companies with strong ESG credentials that have been widely lauded for their AI integration – Salesforce, ServiceNow, Adobe and Workday – have seen their stock prices jump between 70- 80% in the past year: a less stellar performance than Nvidia perhaps, but nonetheless extraordinary relative to the S&P500.
That said, investors would be justified if concerned that last year’s hype will not be repeated in 2024: ServiceNow and Workday both reported quarterly earnings in February and the stock market reaction was negative. Both companies disappointed on revenue growth. Investors seemed particularly underwhelmed by Workday’s announcement of the acquisition of an “AI talent solution company”. What is more, Workday has recently come under pressure for facilitating discriminatory biases with its existing AI tools. At valuations still sky high (the lowest P/E of these companies is Adobe at 47 times earnings!), it makes sense to look elsewhere for productive and sustainable applications of AI.
Beyond software, one area that we find exciting as an AI sustainability opportunity is in industrial automation and digital design. In our note last year, we screened for companies that were best positioned to leverage AI advances for purposeful applications, i.e. supporting decarbonization, optimizing physical resource use and improving safety in industries like energy and food production.
The companies we identified at the time were already making good use of artificial intelligence tools and this has continued, with several companies like Schneider Electric and Rockwell Automation announcing new partnerships with Microsoft to leverage their OpenAI tools.
- Rockwell Automation (ROK) provides automation and software solutions to the manufacturing sector, primarily in the U.S. Like many parts of the U.S. manufacturing sector, the company struggled over the past year with an inventory bulge and supply chain constraints, which have been reflected in the company’s muted stock price performance. With the U.S. manufacturing sector showing signs of revival (e.g. the ISM manufacturing survey has bottomed), companies like Rockwell offer an interesting entry point.
- Schneider Electric SE is an automation and energy management company, with about three-quarters of revenue generated from energy management and one-quarter from industrial automation. This makes the company particularly well-positioned to leverage AI advances for purposeful applications as well as to capitalize on the structural buildout of electricity grids (see last section below).
Leave No Person Behind
At Sustainable Market Strategies, investing to reduce social inequalities centers around three key ideas: improving health outcomes through greater access to care and medical breakthroughs, improving education and increasing labor fairness. Of these three sub-themes, we believe education is the area where artificial intelligence is already playing out in stock prices and where sustainability investors can leverage near-term trends.
Artificial intelligence apps, such as ChatGPT, are increasingly part of an educational toolbox just like calculators, and simple web searches. Artificial intelligence employs adaptive learning, intelligent content curation, and smart monitoring and reporting to teach skills: dozens of learning apps powered by AI have sprung up in recent months. One stand-out is Duolingo. The company’s main focus is on language learning, which is in high demand due to ever-increasing international worker flows and remote work. In a note last June “Education Stocks: Will ChatGPT Decide Who Passes or Fails”, we contended that Duolingo would be an AI winner. Since then, the company has added personalized language lessons fuelled by AI-powered feedback and has reached all-time high engagement rates, as measured by the activity of daily and monthly users. The stock price is up over 40% since our June note and Q4 earnings that were reported earlier this week confirm that the company is able attract paid subscribers to their products.
As for health care, this is the sector that holds the most promise for positive disruption from AI. Already, there are several research studies showing that AI can perform as well as or better than humans at some health care tasks. Studies show, for example, that patients often prefer responses to medical questions from chatbots over physicians, giving the chatbot higher ratings on both quality and empathy!
But the best medical use cases of AI involve settings where large data sets (especially images) that can be applied to well-defined problems are available. Diagnosing diseases, by reviewing X-rays for example, is a very effective use of AI. Companies like Quest Diagnostics, which offers access to diagnostic testing services for cancer, cardiovascular disease, neurological disorders, already leverage AI in their diagnostic tools, most notably for dementia.
A major risk, however, is that current medical AI tools tend to amplify existing discriminative biases in health care outcomes: since AI-based health care technology depends on the data that it is fed, a lack of representative data risks leading to biased models that ultimately produce incorrect health assessments especially according to race. Moreover, although the health care sector is heavily regulated, no regulations directly target the use of AI in medical devices. This is likely to change and will significantly alter the risk/reward profile of health care companies actively investing in AI tools.
Finally, in terms of labor fairness, there remain many challenges to ensure that AI tools do not accentuate existing cognitive biases. In addition, at a macro level, there are good odds that artificial intelligence will impact income inequality in ways similar to previous technology booms: if AI is levered mainly to increase automation, then a widening in the gap between capital and labor and between the professional class and other workers is likely.
A recent Pew survey in the U.S. is illustrative: the survey showed that workers with a university education are twice as likely as those without to be exposed to AI in their jobs. These same workers were far more likely to say that AI will help them more than hurt them in their jobs. On the flipside, retail trade, construction and accommodation and food services are all industries where workers are unlikely to see much benefit from AI tools and are also at risk of being replaced by technology. These are industries that tend to be lower wage jobs with low levels of unionization or other worker protections. In other words, there is some evidence to suggest that gains from artificial intelligence will accrue in already high-paying sectors and largely bypass and/or harm employment in lower paying industries. It is challenging to find AI focused investment ideas related to alleviating income/labor fairness, particularly since, as described above, some of the best company software tools (Salesforce, Workday) allegedly create increased discriminatory biases.
Achieving The Energy Transition
Artificial intelligence is a voracious consumer of energy. An oft-quoted study published in late 2023 projects that based on current and future sales of Nvidia microchips specifically for AI, the amount of electricity required to power the world’s data centers could jump by 50% by 2027, thanks to AI alone. According to the study, that’s about the power consumption of the Netherlands, and would require the entire output of about 15 average-size nuclear power plants.
Many companies are working on smaller, less power-hungry AI models that, but even if AI-related energy is half of the current estimate, it will require substantial increases in power production. Most problematic is that the energy “needs” of AI are arriving at a time when renewable energy supply is still falling short of overall energy demand: without the complicating factor of AI, the energy transition is already a massive challenge.
To be sure, artificial intelligence can be used to make the grid smarter and optimize energy usage. But it’s likely that over the next five years, demand from the production of data across industries will far outpace energy savings from optimization within the energy sector.
Crucially, it is the demands on distribution and transmission of electricity (i.e. the grid) that is particularly challenged by artificial intelligence demands. Transporting electricity from where it is produced to where data centres are desired requires a buildout of the electricity grid.
This problem is particularly acute in North America, where grid planners have recently nearly doubled their 5-year load growth forecast; in the U.S. electricity demand is now expected to increase by 4.7% over the next five years. By way of comparison, over the past decade, grid planners have been forecasting a mere 0.5% annual growth rate.
We see this as a major bottleneck for artificial intelligence usage and a major opportunity for companies involved in the buildout of energy transmission. Schneider Electric, Eaton Corporation, ABB, Nexans, Prysmian should become household names for investors that want exposure to the energy transition.
Internet access has become an indispensable element of modern life. Having the basic proficiency to use the internet is a crucial skill: beyond simply obtaining information, essential services like recruitment, education, healthcare, banking, and commerce are increasingly offered through online platforms. The COVID-19 pandemic helped accelerate online service use, but also magnified the consequences of access disparity. Individuals with limited or no internet do not experience the same accessibility to these essential services, which creates a form of social inequality. This is referred to as the digital divide. Disparities in internet use not only exist between urban and rural residents, but also gender and even race.
We see telecom companies as providers of an essential service given the important role the internet plays in daily life. On this basis, telecom companies are potential candidates for sustainability portfolios. Of course, not all telecom organizations are created equal; there are certain characteristics investors can look out for to identify internet providers that are contributing to positive social and environmental outcomes. For example, telecom providers that offer services in EM have more potential to reach underserved communities – especially in countries where access to finance mostly happens through efficient telecom networks. Product impact, business ethics and companies’ engagement with local communities are also relevant. This is especially important as the large telecom providers benefit from owning the infrastructure resulting in a market with limited competition.
When to Invest in Telecoms
Telecom may have become an “essential service”, but the industry is hardly viewed as essential in investment portfolios. Telecom companies have been known for paying stable dividends (more on this below), but despite this advantage, the telecom industry has been unloved by investors for years. The unpopularity of telecoms is perhaps with good reason: high debt levels, complex corporate structures, heavy-handed regulation and costly capex are just some of the reasons that made telecom unattractive over the past decade, with only intermittent bouts of outperformance (see the chart below).
This may seem surprising, given that the demand for their services continue to rise. As the chart below shows, global data consumption is expected to keep on its exponential rise higher, driven especially by video content. Unfortunately, however, telecom companies have very little pricing power; in the U.S. for example, internet services inflation, as measured by the consumer price index, did not keep pace with overall service price inflation during the past ten years. In other words, the demand for connectivity continues to rise but telecom companies’ ability to get paid to provide it has not: connectivity and data services have largely been commoditized.
Meanwhile, telecom companies are constantly under pressure to make significant investments in the costly infrastructure that enables them to serve customers. In the current context, just as the transition to 5G networks is becoming well-advanced, newer technologies are on the horizon that will once again require large investments and potentially higher debt levels. Telecoms have had a difficult time generating return on expensive, large-scale investments due to the constant “need” to upgrade infrastructure.
So, what do telecoms have going for them for an investment perspective?
As we highlighted above, telecoms tend to provide stable dividends which boost their appeal during phases of equity market (and economic) growth slowdowns. Demand for telecom services suffer little fluctuation during economic booms and busts and this revenue stability tends to be sought out by equity investors during recessions. With most global equity markets at or near all-time highs, forward-looking investors that are getting nervous about the timing of the end of the global bull market can look to sustainable telecom plays to add a more defensive stance to portfolios.

How to identify potential winners?
We consider both telecom infrastructure companies and service providers. For the infrastructure companies with at least 10 billion USD in market cap, we identify three that take top ranks in terms of sustainability: Cellnex Telecom, Infrastrutture Wireless Italiane and American Tower Corp. Both American Tower Corp and Cellnex serve emerging and frontier markets 31.5% and 14.7% of revenues respectively.
Identifying the most impactful wireless service providers is challenging. Among a group of 15 of the largest companies (market cap greater than 10 billion USD) with a significant portion of revenues from wireless services, each has a CSRHub overall sustainability rank falling between the 87th and 98th percentile. By contrast, the range for the six wireless infrastructure companies with a similar market cap was spread 38 points and only two companies had overall ranks above the 85th percentile.
To pinpoint the standout wireless providers, we eliminate companies with revenues from media ownership. Large companies that own media outlets (Verizon, Comcast and Bell Canada respectively own CNN, NBC and CTV) can be viewed as a conflict of interest. The concentration of power can result in unfair competition where companies prioritize their affiliated businesses and potentially limit consumer choice. Furthermore, these legacy media companies face growing competition from new entrants and streaming services. From a more impactful product perspective, European companies Orange (France, OR FP), Telefonica (Spain, TEF SM), and UK play Vodafone Group (VOD LN) earn at least 15% of their revenues from servicing emerging markets. Telus Corp in Canada stands out for its health service offerings, accounting for close to 10% of year-to-date revenues as of Q3 2023 and has the largest exposure to EMs among North American companies. Additionally, Telus consistently ranks at the top for material sustainability topics.
From a financial perspective, telecom companies in general are known for their high dividends. Drilling down, infrastructure telecom plays (shown in blue) tend to have lower dividends, albeit stronger sales growth (consistent with their higher valuations) compared to wireless service providers. Of the wireless service providers, Telus has shown the strongest sales but despite this, it has underperformed the S&P TSX over the last two years. The reverse is true for Telefonica which is also more leveraged than its peers.
In the chart below, we highlight the European telecom companies that we believe have attractive sustainability and financial characteristics. These stocks have outperformed the Stoxx 600 during the past year as the European economy has slowed, underscoring the defensive characteristics of the telecom industry. We expect the outperformance bout to continue until clear signs of an economic upturn prevail.
Investors can also look to subsidiaries of the larger companies that have their own independent listing on the stock exchange. Telefonica Brazil (parent: Telefonica), Vodafone Idea (parent: Vodacom), TIM SA (sister to INW-IT, spun out from parent company TIT-IT) earn all of their revenues in emerging and frontier markets. This can provide investors with stronger exposure to the growth in these markets (1-year sales growth of at least 9%). These subsidiaries have similar equity performance and rankings on material topics as their developed country parent companies.
As the sustainable investing industry continues to mature, participants seek investment opportunities in themes beyond climate change and renewable energy. One of the increasingly popular themes in the social investing space is financial inclusion.
Far be it from us to pretend that this topic is new – we have written several notes on this subject, including “Banking on Impact” on August 31, 2023, and “Three (Sexy) Banking Plays to Change the World” on September 8, 2022.
It’s time to re-visit this subject given inclusion of some of these companies in supposed “impact” funds that has us raising our collective eyebrows.
The increase in popularity of the financial participation theme also entices some companies to try to brand themselves with the “financial inclusion” label, knowing it could attract investors. This is another form of greenwashing – this time the green is for the color of the money!
Take the recent story involving a Nasdaq-listed company called Tingo Group and Agri-Fintech Securities (TIO US). For years, it defrauded investors on the basis that it was providing financial products and services to millions of Nigerian farmers. Tingo was even included in a handful of Article 8 and 9 funds on that basis. Following a report by the US-based short seller Hindenburg Research last year, the SEC recently concluded that Tingo inflated its accounts with ‘billions of dollars of fictitious transactions’ and was in fact an empty shell with no products and even fewer clients.
However, when done right, financial inclusion can be a significantly impactful sector. After all, there is a growing recognition of the importance of financial inclusion as a catalyst for sustainable development. Governments, financial institutions, and international organizations are increasingly focusing on strategies to expand access to financial services as it is positioned prominently as an SDG enabler; it is featured as a target in eight of the seventeen Sustainable Development Goals, with notable positive impact on gender equality, poverty, health and education.
The latest iteration of the World Bank's Global Findex, a comprehensive survey conducted every three years to assess the state of financial inclusion worldwide, reveals a startling reality: nearly a quarter of the global population is without a formal bank account. This basic financial service is a cornerstone of financial inclusion, yet access to it is uneven across different demographics, influenced by factors such as nationality, gender, income levels, and educational background. Thankfully, mobile money accounts are rapidly becoming an alternative to traditional banking in the developing world.
The goal of achieving universal financial inclusion is not only about providing financial services but also about creating a financial system that will improve the socio-economic conditions of the underserved and undervalued populations.
Yet, it seems that some portfolio managers are quick to put in the “financial inclusion” bucket pretty much any company that operates in the financial or fintech sectors and that serves populations in developing countries.
Let’s use three company examples active in South America that are often found in various forms of impact funds: dLocal (DLO US), Nu Holdings (NU US) and MercadoLibre (MELI US).
On the surface, dLocal could be attractive for investors who care about financial inclusion. They are a pure play fintech company operating out of Uruguay and Brazil and derive more than 90% of their revenues almost exclusively from emerging and frontier markets. But behind the financial inclusion buzzwords, they operate a payment platform that, in a nutshell, facilitates transactions between the largest tech firms (Amazon, Google, Uber, etc.) and customers that are underserved by mainstream payment providers such as Visa or MasterCard. Moreover, they charge above-market fees (up to 7%) for that service. The social impact is minimal and dLocal would be a questionable name to include in an impact fund.
Nu Holdings, or Nubank as it is commercially known, has a slightly better financial inclusion story, but we are still not completely convinced the company is making a substantial impact. True, Nubank brought six million Brazilians into the financial system for the first time by allowing them to open a digital bank account in just a few steps. This is undoubtedly good. But beyond that financial inclusion story – which is what they want you to know about them – they derive the vast majority of their revenues from the remaining 70 million clients they serve. Much like other consumer finance companies, the main way they generate revenues is via fees and interests paid on loans. For Nubank though, 80% of the interest paid to them come from their credit card segment, which charges up to 20% a month in interest fees, or up to 200% a year! While this is in line with other Brazilian financial institutions, generating this much revenue from credit card loans as opposed to more socially productive personal or business loans hurts their financial inclusion credibility. Though not entirely convinced, we understand why some managers include this name in the financial inclusion theme.
The case for impact investing is easier when it comes to MercadoLibre, which is Latin America’s largest ecommerce platform and emerging as a leader in the region’s financial technology (fintech) industry. In 2021, the firm served 51.5 million individual fintech customers. Additionally, 900,000 households identified MercadoLibre’s platform as their primary income source. On average, the platform was responsible for the creation of 6 jobs every hour. Throughout the year, more than half a million small-to-medium enterprises (SMEs) utilized the platform for sales. The company has a net positive impact through its democratisation of commerce and financial services. It aims to level the playing field between large and small vendors, and to make payments and commerce processes simpler, safer and more efficient for all.
Apple’s Mother Nature video (watch below) has been viewed a stunning 4.2 million times since its release in early September. The video attempts to showcase Apple’s progress on several environmental targets and ultimately gains approval from “Mother Nature”. The video has been applauded for being creative and bold but also slammed by critics with disapprovals ranging from cringe, woke, virtue signaling, and greenwashing.
The video release was timed to the launch of another round of Apple products, including the iPhone 15 and updated watch. But it also corresponded with a relatively intense legislative period that will affect how smartphone makers build their products; from right-to-repair bills in California, to new battery replacement rules in the EU, there is growing pressure for smartphone makers to make more durable products.
Apple dominates over half of the U.S. smartphone market and is responsible for about 20% of global market share. In addition, it is the only smartphone company in the Magnificent 7, that magic group of high-profile technology-centric mega-caps (Apple, Alphabet, Amazon, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia, and Tesla) responsible for the lion’s share of equity gains this year. Apple, along with Amazon, is one of the few tech companies that tends to be highly scrutinized from an environmental perspective.
In today’s Note, we assess Apple’s record relative to its competitors on a number of sustainability topics and evaluate whether sustainability will factor into the success or failure of Apple stock over the longer term.
Sustainability Topic #1: Carbon Neutrality - So What?
Carbon neutrality features prominently in Apple’s Mother Nature video. The company’s sustainability team lists off a number of ways they are supporting this initiative. However, neither energy management nor greenhouse gas emissions is among the materiality topics identified as relevant by the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB). Since Apple does not own the factories where its products are manufactured, the bulk of emissions come from the company’s value chain. As a result, it is relatively easy to achieve carbon neutrality in its offices, stores, and data centers. The greater (and more impactful) challenge would be lowering scope 3 emissions.
Sustainability Topic #2: Materials Sourcing
The video starts by discussing materials, which is a relevant topic under SASB. Apple employees state the commitment to eliminate all plastics in packaging by 2025 and the company’s use of recycled aluminum. This is a good start, but as the SASB metric highlights, cell phones are dependent on a supply of critical materials. Though not addressed in the video, Apple covers the topic at length in their latest environmental progress report.
The company has an ambitious goal of using only recycled and renewable materials in their products. In 2022, the share of shipped materials meeting these criteria was 20%. The video mentions the use of 100% recycled aluminium for enclosures on most products and the report includes a target to achieving this for other materials (cobalt, tin, gold and rare earth elements) in even more components by 2025. Apple has also identified 14 materials where they are prioritizing their efforts. These account for 87% (by mass) of the products shipped to customers in 2022. In addition to addressing environmental and social concerns associated with extraction, prioritization of these materials is a strategic endeavor to secure a reliable supply of these resources.
Sustainability Topic #3: Managing the Supply Chain
Materials sourcing goes hand in hand with supply chain management. As a major producer of hardware, Apple can leverage its influence for change and improvements. Apple ticks all the boxes when it comes to best practices for supply chain management. It adheres to top frameworks, relies and discloses on third-party audits, has an inventory of chemicals used in manufacturing and even publishes a 25-page supplier list! Despite these efforts, the company has encountered several controversies, mainly concerning labor issues. For the most part, these issues have had little effect on operations and pose more of a reputational risk. Still, there is room to do better. While competitors have faced controversies, they have not been embroiled in human rights issues.
Comparing the operational aspects of supply chain management and materials sourcing with other major phone makers shows that Apple is leading the way in its efforts to sustainably source materials and is aligned with its peers when it comes to supply chain management.
Sustainability Topic #4: Product Lifecycle
Perhaps the greatest sin in Apple’s Mother Nature video is the error of omission. In fact, there is no environmental claim regarding product lifecycle, which is a key material disclosure topic for hardware companies, especially given the potential for rapid obsolescence.
Apple has been criticized for its strategy of mediatizing their annual fall product launches in an attempt to create perceived scarcity and incentivize customers to upgrade their devices before the end of the useful life of their products. The strategy appears to be working; the average lifespan of smartphones – both Apple and their competitors - is declining (see data for the U.S. in the chart below).
If Apple and other smartphone manufacturers were truly sustainable companies, they would be embracing a more circular business model. In contrast to a linear economic model, a circular economy refers to an economic system whereby the value of products, materials and other resources in the economy is maintained for as long as possible and whereby resources no longer used in one system become inputs in another.
As we wrote in our note, Circular Economy: When Going Around In Circles is the Right Thing To Do (April 13, 2022), the “R” hierarchy refers to an order of preference for action to reduce and manage waste (see table below).
Concretely, in the case of smartphone makers, actions that are high on the “R” hierarchy - notably rethink, reuse and repair –would increase the life of smartphones and thus slow the rate of production and associated environmental damage.
Re-use: One way to extend the life of products is to ensure that a healthy re-use market exists. Unfortunately, this doesn’t seem to be the case for smartphones; analysts estimate that about 282 million second-hand smartphones shipped in 2022. This is paltry in comparison to the 1.2 billion new smartphones that were shipped in the same year. That said, the vast majority of resold phones are Apple products; the resale value of Apple phones as a share of initial purchase price is higher than any other phone brand. The implication is that, despite an overall shallow second-hand market, Apple is nonetheless ahead of its peers in terms of re-use.
Repair: Smartphone makers are highly criticized (Apple in particular) for the inability to repair products: forbidding design elements such as nonstandard screws and glued-on parts make it tough to access basic components such as the battery. Moreover, the industry is routinely accused of programmable obsolescence, which involves “serialization,” wherein spare parts (e.g. microchips, speakers) are linked with specific phone models/generations through serial numbers. This hinders third-party repairers from using generic parts. Here too, Apple seems to do better among a poor lot. According to rankings by iFixit, an American e-commerce and how-to website that aids consumers in repairing electronics, Apple phones are easier to repair than Samsung, Huawei and most other competitors.
The whole industry will nonetheless get a makeover. Recent legislation in both Europe and the U.S. is likely to impel manufacturers to make parts, repair guides, and diagnostic tools available for consumers and third-party repair shops. Apple in particular appears to be getting out in front of this; after years of stalling, the company has finally endorsed U.S. federal right to repair legislation.
Rethink: Another way to ensure a longer lifespan for smartphones is to guarantee software and security updates for longer periods; the longer that phones are supported by software updates, the more likely a phone will remain in service. Here again, Apple performs somewhat better than its competitors.
A second “rethink” factor to account for in the design of products is compatibility. Apple is routinely criticized for making its products and accessories incompatible with non-Apple products, which forces consumers to purchase more Apple products. A high-profile example is the iPhone charger; last year EU legislation was passed that contained new rules introducing a single charging port for most electronic devices. Apple was the most affected by this change given that most Androids already use a standard USB-C charger.
The bottom line is that the smartphone industry in general appears to be firmly rooted in a linear economic model. Regulation is increasingly forcing companies to undertake activities and/or redesign some aspects to increase the lifespan of electronic products, but the speed of change remains slow.
Apple Investment Outlook
Apple and its magnificent seven peers have experienced impressive stock market returns in 2023, driven by several elements including the excitement about artificial intelligence, a factor bias in favor of quality companies, and a desire by investors to hold mega-cap names. Unfortunately, sustainability has not been a consideration that is driving this basket of stocks higher, particularly in a year when a gust of anti-ESG sentiment has blown in.
Nonetheless, Apple sustainability practices – in spite of the contentious advertising – are on par or exceed the standards of other smartphone makers. This position implies that if/when consumers, regulators, and other stakeholders become more serious about reducing the environmental footprint of electronic devices, Apple’s sustainability track record will allow them to maintain, if not increase, market share.
The past decade has witnessed remarkable progress in access to financial services around the world. Technological developments led to a growing number of FinTech platforms that enabled a greater number of poorly-served people to access financial services. New service providers increased competition for several different platforms – bank transfers, electronic payments, cell phones, etc. – in countries where such choices are available. These developments were useful to 1) empower consumers; 2) extend the reach of financial services to a greater share of the population; and 3) lower transaction costs. Today, the most underserved individuals with regard to access to financial services are found in Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa.

Despite this progress, it is still challenging to qualify the extent to which companies in the financial sector can have an “impact”. At Sustainable Market Strategies, we designed a matrix that shows the many ways a financial company can have impact according to the services they provide in developed, developing and frontier markets.
From our perspective, financial companies who “push the envelope” and look to increase their reach by growing their exposure to the underserved are considered impactful. For example, the penetration rate of mobile money services in regions such as Sub-Saharan Africa is a testament to the impact of such services on those populations. Airtel Africa is an example of a Telecom company which provides a fair amount of financial services to its client base.

In developed markets, financial companies can typically be considered impactful if they provide services to lower-income “unbanked” and/or “underbanked” populations. For their part, insurance companies who establish methods to limit price increases of their premiums and ensure coverage in higher-risk areas (i.e. areas with higher crime rates, lower incomes, and greater climate risks) would be considered impactful. This is especially relevant in the U.S. where a growing number of people are going uninsured.
In emerging and frontier markets, banks with specific outreach programs such as microfinance business streams and/or payment/transfer/mobile phone companies that facilitate the availability of services via digital platforms are considered impactful because of their contribution in elevating people out of poverty. Additionally, financial companies that facilitate and/or lower the costs of P2P transfers between DMs and EMs/FMs are also considered impactful as the provision of low-cost international transfer services could enable greater financial flows from DMs towards EMs and FMs.
In today’s note, we look at three investment ideas whereby investors looking to have an impact can invest in the financial sector: Community Banks, EM/FM banks and transfer payment providers. This note builds on our previous analysis of the financial sector (see our note “Three (Sexy) Banking Plays to Change the World” September 8, 2022).
Idea #1: DMs/US Community Banks
Community banks typically cater to regional communities across the United States. With their loan portfolio and deposit base “close to home”, these institutions are often very familiar with the people they serve and their regional markets. That said, recent wobbles in the U.S. banking system and the more stringent funding requirements have hit this sector hard. Furthermore, many communities and regional banks have a relatively high exposure to commercial real estate – which remains itself under stress as the asset class continues to re-price. Thus, it is not surprising that U.S. community banks have underperformed the overall sector in the U.S. – and globally – over the past year.
It is difficult to see a good entry point into U.S. community banks at this juncture. After all, persistently high interest rates should continue to create problems in their loan portfolios as well as challenge their asset and liability matching over the next few months.
Idea #2: EMs/FMs Banks
To have in impact, one could also consider investing in EMs/FMs banks that are leading the pack with regard to financial inclusion. While country-level data on financial inclusion is made available by organisations such as the WorldBank or the IMF, bank-level data on financial inclusion remains scarce. That said, sustainably-minded investors looking to invest in financial institutions with a view to promote financial inclusiveness could look into some data published by the World Bank, as highlighted in the table below.
With this in mind, EMs/FMs banks really ought to disclose more data on financial inclusion as a means to grow their investors’ base. Looking at recent pricing trends in global banking stocks, one can see that banks have underperformed the global equity market these past few months – especially EM banks. While interest rates have not “normalized” as much in EMs as they have may have done in DMs, one can think that (in absence of issues around financial stability and excluding Chinese banks) higher-for-longer interest rates could help EM banks boost their net interest margins in the coming months. This should contribute positively to their profit margins going forward.
Finally, we look at financial inclusiveness mentions in Financials’ sector filings included in the MSCI FM and EM indices. Interestingly, mentions of financial inclusion are about absent in U.S. banks filings. Aside from financial institutions such as VISA, it is hard to believe that U.S. financial institutions – such as Goldman Sachs or BlackRock – are really putting financial inclusion high up on their agenda.
Conversely, mentions of financial inclusiveness are much more prevalent in EM and FM financial insitutions’ filings.
This seems especially true for institutions such as the Commercial International Bank (Egypt) and Creditcorp (Peru), two frontier markets’ banks. Interestingly, both have outperformed the MSCI Frontier index this past year and for investors ready to look for financial inclusiveness plays on the margins – these institutions could prove a smart way to address financial inclusiveness through publicly-listed banks in the frontier space.
Idea #3: Transfer payment companies
Recent developments in FinTech and the strong growth of the global market for remittances gave a boost to transfer payments companies – especially those looking to shave off costs on international money transfers. A recent compilation of newcomers in the transfer payment market suggests that these firms’ markup on international transfers varies from 0 to 1.5%. This compares to about 1-6% using the mid-market FX rate for a traditional transfer company such as Western Union. As a result, the market for global remittances has gotten much more competitive – and this comes to the benefit of users of such platforms.
From an impact perspective, one could favor transfer payment companies that offer the possibility to do P2P transfers from DMs to EMs at a lower cost. While companies like Western Union provide the biggest outreach in the remotest part of the planet – they are also the most expensive service in the sector. Conversely, upcomers such as Wise payments, which enables transfers to a wide range of geographies and currencies – offer discount transfer and FX rates and are quickly gaining market share as their service is offered in an increasing number of currencies. For its part, Remitly offers the possibility to send and receive money transfers – but just for users in the U.S. at this point – which makes it less interesting from an impact perspective. Despite the sector’s tailwinds coming from the growing global remittance markets and low-cost international financial transfers, these companies have underperformed the NASDAQ over the past year – aside for Remitly and Wise. Interestingly, some money transfer companies display hefty profit margins, hovering around 20%, which could make an interesting investment opportunity.
Looking at valuation, newcomers appear expensive against more established players. No doubt that market participants are pricing an outcome whereby lower-cost alternatives such as Wise, Remitly and others rapidly displace “old school” companies such as Western Union.
Up until February 2022, the defense and military sector’s stock performance had pretty much stagnated for half a decade as budgets were being cut and the world was enjoying a quasi-conflict-free phase. This period also coincided with the rise of ESG investing which came with its suite of sectoral exclusions. Defense stocks were rapidly labelled as “sin stocks” along with tobacco, coal, gambling, and alcohol. In fact, controversial weapons are, to this day, the most excluded activity with over 70% of European funds excluding them, while about 50% exclude civilian firearms and 35% exclude conventional military equipment and services. Prior to February 2022, the reasoning was flawless: Defense companies make products that kill people, and are often sold to bad actors – for instance to Saudi Arabia, even despite Jamal Khashoggi’s murder in 2018.
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine on February 24, 2022 changed a lot of things – including how some ESG-minded investors are looking at the defense sector.
The consensus before the invasion was that it was just flexing and positioning on Putin’s part. We were all wrong. Then we were certain that Ukraine would surrender in a matter of days. Wrong again. These days, we like to think that China would never do the unthinkable and make a move for Taiwan. However, we may have to face the fact that we live in an increasingly uncertain world with a greater likelihood of major geopolitical moves making lasting impacts on our lives and our investments. One of these impacts for investors is the subject of this week’s note: Can defense stocks be considered in an ESG portfolio?
For the first time since the creation of the Munich Security Index (a global risk perception survey conducted by the Munich Security Conference) in 2014, security has replaced climate change as the top concern among the 12,000 respondents.
Governments too are concerned about security, and defense budgets are shooting up to historically high levels.
In and of itself, an increased interest from investors and bigger budgets should not influence whether defense stocks belong in and ESG portfolio or not. The change in mindset came from the Ukraine invasion and the West’s response of sending military equipment to support the Ukrainian resistance. After all, security is a human right enshrined in human rights treaties and most would agree that the right to defend oneself and preserve sovereignty does not go against any ESG principles. This is one element that separates defense-related activities from tobacco or gambling for instance, where it is legitimately difficult to see any wider social good from those activities.
Defense hawks might even argue that there is a social benefit to consider too: well-equipped military can act as “armed deterrence”, preventing conflict and maintaining stability in the international system. By having a powerful military, they argue, potential adversaries will be deterred from aggressive actions, thereby reducing the likelihood of conflict and promoting a safer world. As the saying goes: “weapons are harmful – but they are even more harmful if those who threaten you have them and you do not”.
The conundrum is, however, that defensive weapons are indistinguishable from offensive weapons – it’s a matter of perspective – and the pendulum between global good and evil can rapidly swing.
Nonetheless, this is a bet that some asset managers are willing to take in light of the Russian invasion. For instance, Swedish financial group SEB announced in March 2022 that it would start permitting some of its funds to buy shares of weapons makers and defense companies, reversing a position it adopted a year prior as part of its ESG commitments. SEB justified the change of tack by claiming the war in Ukraine had softened some of its clients’ view on the defense sector.
Defense No-Go Zones: Controversial Weapons and Weak Governance
Relaxing ESG exclusions for the defense sector should not be unbridled, however. There are good ‘S’ and ‘G’ reasons to continue to exclude large swaths of the sector. For instance, “controversial weapons” are unjustifiable in an ESG portfolio because these weapons – which include biological, chemical and incendiary weapons, white phosphorus, landmines, cluster bombs, depleted uranium and nuclear weapons outside of the international non-proliferation treaty – are often used in ways that violate human rights. For example, landmines and cluster munitions have been used over and over to kill civilians, whether intentionally or not. Although there is some debate over what should be considered a controversial weapon or not, a good starting point is to stick to the definitions in international treaties (Convention on Cluster Munitions, Ottawa Convention on the Prohibition of Anti-Personal Mines, Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, Chemicals Weapon Convention, and the Biological Weapons Convention).
Another exclusionary filter that should be applied relates to Governance. The defense sector is notorious for operating behind closed doors and entertaining an incestuous relationship with the government. It was recently revealed that as of 2021, 672 former Pentagon, Congress and other Government Agencies’ officials were working for the top 20 defense contractors, with the vast majority – 91 percent – effectively lobbying the very government they formerly worked for. This revolving door between the military-industrial complex and government agencies is perfectly correlated with the government contracts these companies receive. In 2021 and 2022, Lockheed Martin, Boeing, Raytheon, General Dynamics, and Northrop Grumman – also known as the “Defense Primes” – were the top 5 federal defense contractors in the U.S. and they also had some of the highest numbers of “revolving door hires” out of the top 20 contractors. Between the five of them, they provided 60% of the total lobbying money spent by more than 200 companies in the defense industry in 2022.
This defense oligopoly is a problem for ESG investors. Half a century ago, the U.S. relied on 50 major arms contractors, but a massive consolidation has brought that number down to five – the Defense Primes. This concentration of defense technology expertise only gives the Pentagon few choices of where to go for the production of major weapons systems, raising the risk of price hikes and irresponsible behavior when it comes to delivering weapons that can perform as advertised (e.g. Lockheed Martin’s F-35 saga).
Now that we have determined that ESG-minded investors should probably avoid the Defense Primes altogether, what criteria should be considered to gain exposure to the sector while respecting basic responsible investment principles?
First, controversial weapons should be avoided at all costs. Second, companies working with both civilian and government clients are better protected in case of massive government policy changes following an election or even a severe austerity plan. Finally, according to SASB, the material ESG elements for the Aerospace & Defense Industry are: Energy Management, Hazardous Waste Management, Data Security, Product Safety, Fuel Economy & Emissions in Use-phase, Materials Sourcing, and Business Ethics. Companies which score well in these categories could therefore be interesting candidates for inclusion in ESG portfolios.
These five companies – the SMS Secondary Defense Contractors – all happen to be Europeans. Due to the level of ESG maturity in Europe, this should not come as a surprise. American companies in the defense industry are more likely to be involved in controversial weapons and suffering from a low score with regard to business ethics and transparency.
From a stock performance perspective, the SMS Secondary Defense Contractors basket underperformed the S&P 500 and the Defense Primes for most of the last 5 years but outperformed massively since the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Although some macro factors partially explain why the European names contained in the Secondary Defense Contractors basket did so well since October 2022 (e.g. optimistic easing calendar, consistently strong earnings, etc.) these companies are also more directly involved in the global efforts to supply Ukraine with state-of-the-art military equipment.
With Price to earnings ratios in-line with the general market – the S&P 500 P/E is about 19 – but a growth perspective more attractive than the rest of the market thanks in part to the defense spending having been increased. Timing could therefore still be on the side of an ESG investors wanting to add some defense-exposed companies to her portfolio. Leonardo S.p.a. and Rheinmetall AG could be particularly interesting due to their valuation and contract pipelines.
Since its launch in November, ChatGPT has become hugely popular and has already been integrated in a myriad of software by companies like Duolingo, Snapchat, Salesforce and others. It’s no wonder companies and individuals have been quick to adopt ChatGPT – for most humans, it is more than just another tool that improves productivity. In terms of raw intelligence, ChatGPT can do things that many humans can’t: AI experts estimate that ChatGPT displays an IQ of above 120, placing it among the top 10% of humans. OpenAI researchers estimate that around 80% of the U.S. workforce could have at least 10% of their work tasks affected by the introduction of large language models (like ChatGPT), while approximately 19% of workers may see at least 50% of their tasks impacted. This is quite the progress, given that less than a decade ago, researchers ranked Google’s AI IQ at 47, just shy of the average IQ (55) of a human 6-year-old.
This massive rise of machine intelligence has given way to an important debate about the ethical nature of AI and possible paths for humans once computers surpass us in both verbal and social intelligence. This is a topic that will increasingly concern investors of all stripes and one that we will tackle within a sustainability framework in a future note.
In the meantime, with labor shortages persisting in most developed countries and an ever-increasing need to make better use of physical resources, today’s note explores seventeen companies that are well positioned to leverage the progress in AI in order to address these challenges (and accelerate what is sometimes referred to as the fourth industrial revolution). The companies we’ve identified provide technological solutions that support decarbonization, optimized resource use and improved safety and they tend to serve high impact industries like energy, food and health care.
A. Defining a Frontier Technology Sustainability Enabler
The companies best positioned to leverage AI advances for purposeful application are those with products and services already integrating machine learning. Computer-assisted manufacturing (CAM) and computer-assisted design (CAD) are two such areas.
CAM relies on the combination of software and hardware; this includes automation, robotics and Internet of Things (IoT) devices. Each of these technologies can improve resource efficiency and worker safety. Enhanced with stronger AI, this hardware will be better able to communicate and interpret data in real time and rapidly adapt to the situation at hand having implications for reducing safety risks and the waste of resources.
CAD, on the other hand, supports effective decision-making at the design phase of a new process or new factory. Things like digital twinning software replace physical mock-ups and facilitate testing of various scenarios. As AI evolves, the capabilities of CAD will improve at assessing inputs and constraints to make relevant recommendations for optimized design.
To identify companies that we believe are frontier technology sustainability enablers, we follow three steps:
- We screen for companies with at least 20% of revenue from factory automation, control sensors or computer-assisted design software. To do this, we use Factset’s RBICS Industry classification and we include companies within the following RBICS sub-industry groups: Industrial Robots and Robotic Assembly Line Makers, General Factory Automation Makers, Other Automation Support Product Manufacturing, Monitoring and Control Sensor/Instrument Products, and Computer Assisted Design software.
- We then identify those companies that are serving high impact areas: health care, energy and food.
- Finally, we assess whether the companies are operational leaders in terms of ESG by observing their CSRHub ESG rankings.
The table below highlights companies with a market cap of $10 billion or greater that satisfy all three of the above criteria for “frontier technology sustainability enablers”.
B. Macro Considerations
Many of the companies in the above table have seen the performance of their stock prices appreciate meaningfully in the past few months. The leaders are ANSYS and Yaskawa which have returned 49.5% and 35.0% respectively over the last six months. Automation companies have faired the strongest with all but one outperforming the SP500 (6 out of 8 outperforming the Nasdaq YTD). To be sure, these companies have benefitted from positive media mentions about the recent leap forward in artificial intelligence, as described above.
Going forward, there are a number of crosscurrents for investors to consider.
The bearish news:
- Automation and digital design companies, especially those with the sustainability and ESG characteristics that we favor, continue to have very lofty valuations. In our basket of companies, the trailing p/e ranges from 13.5 to 57.0, with the median company trailing p/e of 27.1. On a twelve-month forward basis, the range in p/e is 15.9 to 41.5, with a median company forward p/e of 23.4. The Digital Design category exhibits the highest valuation, likely attributable to the ease of adoption of new AI technologies in this segment. For both automation and IoT applications, upgrading software with the latest AI may also necessitate changes to hardware. The implication is that it is currently challenging to find bargains in this sector.
- The stock prices of the companies highlighted above typically behave as growth stocks: they tend to outperform broad equity benchmarks at early and mid stages of economic cycles (i.e. when interest rates are accommodative and economic growth is accelerating) and underperform during late business cycle stages (when interest rates become restrictive and economic growth is slowing and/or contracting). Although interest rate expectations have peeled back in recent weeks, SMS’ view is that we remain in an economic slowdown phase, with recession risks greater than 50%. In this context, we would expect automation and digital design companies’ stock prices to be held back in this environment.

The bullish news:
- We anticipate that the recent U.S. fiscal stimulus will be an important tailwind for these companies for the next several years. There are over 40 new semiconductor ecosystem projects that have been announced across the U.S. since May 2020 valued at nearly US $200B in private investment. Some projects have already broken ground and virtually all require industrial automation, digital transformation and workforce enablement solutions.
- With unemployment rates hovering at historic lows in many developed economies, the cost of labor is increasing and the ability to find skilled labor is challenging. In this context, companies will continue to be incentivized to invest in automation and robotization solutions rather than labor, especially as countries are looking to re-shore critical industries.
If our 2022 investment outlook note could be reduced to one investment adage – “power of diversification” – then SMS’ outlook theme for 2023 takes a page from Warren Buffett and focuses on “knowing the difference between price and value”. We believe that the bear market in stocks that got underway in 2022 is not yet over, but that 2023 will nonetheless offer opportunity for bargains in high-quality sustainable companies that are positioned for a low-carbon, high-care economy.
From a macro perspective, we expect there will be less surprises about inflation in 2023 (trending lower, but still above 2%) but ongoing uncertainty about the timing of recession. The chart below shows the evolution of our expectations about different macro investment scenarios; we expect recessionary conditions to linger for most of the year leading broad equity indices to trend lower until there is early evidence of a positive inflection point in the economic cycle. Equity markets have priced in the higher interest rate environment but not the fall in profitability. For now, a soft landing with no recession seems to be priced in markets.
Against this backdrop, and with our approach to investing that is focused on finding tradeable sustainability themes and the best companies that embody them, it is no surprise that we enter the year with a defensive tilt that offers downside protection. As the second half of the bear market unfolds, we will intensify our focus to find beaten-down names that offer superior value. A catalyst for the latter will be once forward earnings expectations turn firmly negative, which should serve as a sign that investor sentiment reflects economic reality.
We therefore kick off 2023 with a list of our high conviction investment ideas, with an eye on value: In the very short term, we look to protect capital in defensive areas of the stock market until a recession is well advanced. Looking further out into 2023, we expect conditions to be in place to be able to shift capital to select higher beta companies once the Fed reaches the end of its tightening campaign.
Idea #1: Long Energy Efficiency
Within the energy sector, we expect energy efficiency plays to outperform in 2023. Oil prices will be volatile, while companies involved in renewable energy production are often growth-oriented and highly sensitive to the interest rate backdrop, which we expect will continue to be a headwind for now. In contrast, many energy efficiency companies, e.g. companies that manufacture and/or provide solutions such as heat pumps, HVACs, and smart metering, tend to have low P/Es and trade as value stocks.
Energy efficiency is one of only a few areas that are well-supported by fiscal policy in 2023. According to the IEA, over half of OECD countries have generous subsidies for heat pumps and other energy-conserving products, with the RePower EU plan among the most ambitious; the EU must double the current roll-out rate in the next five years if its heat pump targets are to be achieved. In the U.S., the Inflation Reduction Act also provides significant support for heat pumps, offering subsidies up to $14, 000 per household.
The following companies have strong sustainability characteristics on an operational basis (i.e. ESG), provide excellent energy efficiency solutions, and are in good financial health: Carrier, Johnson Controls, Nibe, and Trane Technologies.
Idea #2 An ESG Comeback: Short Greenwashers
Events in 2022 sparked a necessary shakeout for “ESG” and responsible investment. Although recent focus has been on the asset management industry, these debates have been helpful at shining a spotlight on all false claims whether they be at the investment or corporate level.
Companies that embellish their sustainability credentials risk being punished in this environment, since reputational risk affects stock price performance.
We suggest two trades for 2023, based on the concept of “go long sustainability” and “short greenwashing”. Incidentally, in both cases, our short candidates are not only viewed as potential sustainability fraudsters, but their dubious use of financial engineering is also a major investment risk:
- Short Enviva/Long Svenska Cellulosa: The world’s largest producer of wood pellets, which are considered a renewable energy source, is Enviva. But Enviva is also the producer most shrouded in controversy. As early as 2013, a report was delivered to the SEC regarding omissions and misrepresentations by Enviva; the company has been regularly cited since for giving false information about greenhouse gas emissions in this industry. There is currently a class action lawsuit against Enviva for making materially false and misleading statements regarding the company's business, operations, and compliance policies. According to the suit, Enviva has misrepresented the environmental sustainability of its wood pellet production and procurement and has also overstated the true measure of cash flow generated (the company has not had a positive net income over the past 3 years and has been issuing more debt and selling shares to support increases in their dividend payment).
On the opposite end of the spectrum, Svenska Cellulosa merits its reputation as one of the most sustainably managed forest companies in Europe. As an integrated industrial business, they aim to maximize the possible value in the forest and from the forest; wood pellets are a by-product from production of other wood products, helping the company achieve a recycled waste-total waste ratio of 96% (!) and underscoring the company’s effectiveness at maximizing the value of the entire forest.
- Short Credit Acceptance Corp: a self-described socially responsible company, Credit Acceptance Corp claims to help indebted individuals purchase automobiles by offering loans to consumers with “Bad & No Credit”. SMS and the U.S Financial Protection Bureau see things differently. The latter (along with the New York Attorney General) recently announced a lawsuit against Credit Acceptance Corp for predatory lending practices- practices that ultimately yielded profits for the company. We first mentioned Credit Acceptance Corp in our “The Greed Without the Green” Note (October 6, 2022) questioning the conduct of consumer finance companies and spotting an opportunity to short in the context of rising interest rates. As we anticipate this economic context to carry over to 2023, more defaults should be expected; the January lawsuit announcement may be just the beginning of bad news for CACC. In addition, the company has used virtually all cashflow from the past three years for the repurchase of shares at inflated prices (2-year average weighted price 30% higher than current market prices). This is destroying shareholder value, rather than adding to it.
Idea #3: Switch from Illiquid Alternatives to Liquid Alternatives
Money poured into the illiquid alternative space over the past decade. However, investors should never forget that liquidity has a price and you pay for it with a premium over publicly traded investments.
While the rise in interest rates last year created havoc in bonds and public equities, many illiquid alternative funds (PE, real estate, infrastructure, etc.) actually reported gains for the year, despite many of the underlying assets being highly interest rate sensitive. The best example is private real estate funds compared to publicly traded real estate investment trusts: both essentially hold the same assets, yet private real estate funds were up 5-10% while real estate investment trusts were down 20-25%. Unless bonds and stocks recover quickly, this is an unsustainable practice: smoothing out returns and locking in clients by limiting redemptions is a recipe for disaster.
We look at private assets under one of our investable sustainability themes: Building Better Markets. The opacity of private asset investment vehicles and, in many cases, the way they have been sold to investors is a dangerous practice.
We believe poor returns are in store for private investments since these products will need to be marked down over the next three years to progressively absorb the new valuation reality. If it is possible to redeem, investors would be better served by 3-year certificate of deposits yielding close to 5% or liquid alternatives like hedge funds that are marked to market, have attractive investment opportunities in a changing investment landscape and can benefit from a higher volatility regime that is likely to persist for the next 3 years.
Idea #4: Build Back Better With Industrial Automation
In the latter half of 2023, if recession risks wain and signs of a new bull market appear, we will advocate for beginning to reallocate to growth opportunities, starting with the industrial sector. Especially in the U.S., bipartisan support for recapturing manufacturing prowess will provide a favorable backdrop for upgrades to existing factories and the construction of new ones. Given the combination of reshoring and a structural labor shortage, we anticipate a boon in industrial automation. The benefits of automation include improved resource efficiency (optimized water, waste and energy management) and better safety. Two names on our radar are: Rockwell Automation and Emerson Electric.
Rockwell is the largest pure play in industrial automation and is also recognized as a leader in sustainability (CSRHub overall rank of 94 and listed on Barron’s 100 Most Sustainable Companies). In 2021, Rockwell’s energy efficiency related products were responsible for over one quarter of revenues. Emerson Electric also counts energy efficiency among its solutions. The company serves industries (such as energy, life sciences and food and beverage) that are key to a low-carbon, high-care economy and is diversified across both automation and commercial HVAC solutions. We find this especially beneficial from an investment perspective, given that the company is the intersection between two highly investable 2023 themes: energy efficiency (see idea #1) and automation. Though currently expensive, investors should look for buying opportunities later in the year.
Idea #5: Opportunities in EM
Similar to Idea #4, we expect that later in 2023, there will be scope for a change in leadership between EM and DM. Historically, the U.S. business cycle leads the rest of the world by about six months, since U.S. consumption is a major source of demand for much of the world's export.
It is therefore premature to expect emerging markets stock outperformance in the near term. We have articulated in prior research why we are hesitant investors in China (for example, please see Chinese Capitalism’s Long March, September 29, 2021; we continue to believe that the country is extremely challenging for international investors that focus on sustainability, given an unpredictable regulatory backdrop and overall opacity in the country. That said, many emerging markets – as well as the companies that make up their stock markets – have historically healthy debt profiles and excellent growth prospects, yet are still trading at crisis-level valuations. Some tailwinds that may develop in 2023 include manufacturing revivals in some markets from “China plus one” strategies related to supply chains, exposure to the commodity cycle, as well as favorable political cycles in some pockets. Opportunities in EM for sustainability-minded investors are a key topic that we intend to explore further in 2023, stay tuned.
Idea #6: Structural Long in Transition Metals
Long-time readers of our work will note that we have been recommending positions in transition metals for quite some time and believe that an overweight allocation to these metals will be profitable on a structural basis. To be sure, higher metal prices are incongruent with our forecast for recession and we would not be surprised to see prices soften in the short-to-intermediate term. However, the long-term outlook for transition materials and metals is extremely bullish. Our preferred investments focus on sustainable miners and high-tech recyclers such as Umicore and Boliden. We believe that resource scarcity, the regulatory backdrop, as well as national energy and security policies of various nations will largely benefit these companies.
Undervalued Ecosystem
Soil is a complex ecosystem made up of organic matter, minerals, air and water. It is the home of many organisms like insects, worms and nature’s nutrients: bacteria and fungi. The soil ecosystem is critical for life on Earth. Healthy soil can be a productivity booster, improving drainage and air exchange. It also serves as a carbon sink. Unfortunately, rather than working with the soil, current farming practices are contributing to its degradation. The table below depicts the positive contributions of healthy soil and the negative contributions of compacting and tilling.
Soil, like forests and water, is undervalued because it is abundant. Currently, the value of soil is mainly reflected by its ability to generate revenues from growing food. The other contributions of the soil do not directly generate cash flows, even if they are crucially beneficial. As awareness of those benefits increases, the value of soil should also rise. This should result in actions by land owners to protect and nurture their soil. Unfortunately, economic pressures are putting land owners in survival mode, distracting them from the longer term viability of their land.
Food Armageddon
Fast population growth since the Industrial Revolution owes a lot to our collective ability to produce food. This ability is facing new challenges. Climate change is making the weather unpredictable, more aggressive, warmer and drier in places where food is produced. The map below shows the agricultural potential of the soil in different parts of the world. Bare areas with large populations and low incomes are clearly dependent on imports for food. The outlook for agriculture is poor in some important agricultural hubs: the U.S., Australia and Brazil.

Additionally, the major conflict in Ukraine will affect a very productive agricultural area and the consequent sanctions on Russia could curb Russian food exports. As a result, the poorest people in each country will see higher food prices and some of the poorest regions of the world will struggle to access food from to their usual exporters. To continue to feed the globe, we need seeds, water, fertilizers, soil and labor. So far in 2022, we foresee major issues for at least three of the five elements (water, fertilizers, and labor) in the form of shortages and rising costs. The issues of climate change, supply chain challenges, and rising input costs are increasing the probability of a large global humanitarian crisis. The chart below shows the food price index before the Russian invasion.
While these issues are alarming, there is potential for them to serve as a catalyst in returning to farming practices that put soil health at the forefront and are therefore more sustainable over the long term.
Effective Water Management
Regarding water issues, climate change is wreaking havoc from floods to extreme heat and drought. The map below superposes long-term drought conditions with the drought outlook for the next 3 months for the United States as of March 17th, 2022. It does not look promising again this year.

The increasing frequency of drought will have farmers very attentive to their water usage, securing supply and maximizing its efficiency. Soil is one way to optimize water usage. Healthy soil is productive, it interacts more efficiently with water. Ironically, drought-ridden areas are also prone to flooding as dry ground does not have the capacity to absorb water when rain does fall. Farms that prioritize their soil will be more resilient to both droughts and flooding in the long term and continue to yield crops. A company like Plasson (PLSN IT) is well positioned to help farmers with water management and optimization. The use of fertilizer can also impact water efficiency, as it can contribute to runoff where crops absorb only a small portion of the water poured onto it.
Fertilizer Optimization
Access to fertilizers is becoming a challenge. The war in Ukraine, the accompanying sanctions and export bans are creating the potential for significant fertilizer shortages. The chart below shows the portion of fertilizer exports that Russia typically represents. If Russia does not export fertilizers in 2022, it would mean that approximately 20% needs to be produced elsewhere. Considering Belarus is under similar sanctions as Russia, it is even worse. Belarus represents another 20% of global potash export volume. Moreover, unbearable natural gas prices have already been curtailing nitrogen fertilizer production, especially in Europe where natural gas prices are relatively higher.
Farmers are already being challenged by input price squeezes. The rising cost of fertilizer due to the conflict in Ukraine is not making it any easier. This could provide some momentum to begin reducing the use of fertilizers. One alternative is cover crops. Planting these crops improves soil health and reduces the need for herbicides as it covers the land, limiting the growth of weeds. Seed companies such as Sakata Seeds (1377 – JP) and Corteva (CTVA – US) could benefit. Corteva also offers products beyond seeds, including fertilizer and some digital tools. The transition won’t happen overnight – farms are more likely to slowly wean themselves off fertilizers. Precision agriculture can facilitate this transition, using a targeted focus to apply less. There are many actors in this growing space that stand to gain (e.g. Deere & Co., CNH Industries, Raven Industries, Yara, Bayer, IBM, Trimble, etc.)
Please, Grow Food
With higher food prices, a simple conclusion would be that farmers are making a lot of money from their operations, but the reality is very different. They are suffering from weather shocks, labor shortages, energy cost increases and fertilizer cost increases. The USDA forecasted a 12% rise in fertilizer for 2022 after a 17% increase in 2021. This was before the war Ukraine. As the conflict exacerbates food prices, governments will face increasing pressure to help farmers. In addition, those that are hedging their production in the futures’ market need to put more collateral with price rises, worsening their cash flow situation further.
Fortunately, some government initiatives to help long-term farming were already underway and we expect them to accelerate commensurate to the potential impact of a food crisis. The COP26 held in October included an event to encourage investment in digital agriculture. The Biden administration is proposing a shift from USDA commodity credits to carbon credits, incentivizing farmers to prioritize healthy soil for its carbon holding properties. Corporations are also seeing the value in dirt. Companies in both the food and fashion industries have pledged to source crops produced from regenerative practices. From that standpoint, we believe that companies addressing water efficiency, precision agriculture and soil management will benefit from a tailwind.