The ESG “industry” suffered a double blow recently when the former CIO of BlackRock’s Sustainable Investing arm published a 30-page essay on why he thinks ESG investing is – and will remain – mostly a smokescreen for asset owners looking to change the world with their assets. At the same time, the ex-head of Sustainability at DWS, a large European asset manager, also blew the whistle on the firm’s ESG foundations – or the lack thereof – which sent the company’s stock plummeting.
While one should remain critical of any ex-employee allegations of their previous employer, today’s note examines the arguments put forth from highly visible “ESG whistleblowers” and provides our view on whether the skepticism is warranted. We also conjecture on the future of ESG investing and its potential impact on the real world.
ESG teams don’t talk to investment people: Kind of true.
Given the nature of SMS’ business, we interact with several of the world’s largest ESG and investment teams within some of the largest investment groups. In some cases, these teams remain quite separate, with, on one hand the Head of ESG and, on the other hand, the Head of Investments. We have observed that sometimes these two silos don’t communicate much, save for marketing and client servicing purposes. We believe that full ESG integration will come once there is attribution of some P&L to the ESG function – or the “ESG overlay of a portfolio” perhaps akin to the macro function in asset management. This trend is beginning but has much further to go.
ESG is useful for the industry to talk about itself: True.
The financial world is quite good to put up pay-to-play type conferences to talk about itself. In this context, ESG remains a great “narrative” for the industry to justify its social mission and mitigate its reputation after the massive tarnishing following the 2008 financial crisis. As such, ESG conferences, have become the hallmark of financial and asset management communication strategies. One potential indicator of the asset management industry’s commitment to ESG objectives would be the changing nature of industry perks. For example, do conference hosts dare serve meatless meals? Do executives continue to fly business class, given the extra GHG emissions related to this type of travel? Unfortunately, our observations are that these “soft” indicators do not yet show much change in behavior. Interestingly, it also seems that ESG/Sustainability heads are now becoming even more present than Chief Economists when talking up their firms’ investment strategies and how they can align "doing good" with financial performance.
The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase its Profits. An irrelevant discussion
Investing in ESG inevitably brings about a discussion about what the mission of business is since ESG skeptics assume that it is impossible to construct a portfolio that delivers positive externalities (higher wages, cleaner water, lower carbon footprint, etc.) while delivering performance on par with portfolios without positive externalities. To us, this argument is extremely dangerous, not because this narrow definition of responsibility risks favoring the greedy and the ruthless, but rather because it shows a failure to understand the wider investment landscape. At SMS, one of our central investment beliefs is that successful investing requires anticipating what society will care about in the future; we have repeatedly shown evidence that a myriad of social and environmental causes are increasingly mobilizing societies. Investing in companies that embrace these societal goals will deliver superior returns, not despite their ‘loftier goals’ but precisely because they will be more highly valued from the goods, services and business models they offer. This value creation might be direct (e.g., providing a technological solution to an environmental or social problem) or indirect (e.g., decreasing reputational risk via exemplary social and governance practices).
The Rules of the Game Are Broken. True, but it is dishonest to shift the blame on another part of the system.
Investors who shun ESG as an investment strategy often argue that their profession is powerless: it is government that needs to ‘fix’ important issues like climate change and income inequality. This is true: a myriad of rules (e.g., imposing caps on CEO pay, instituting a highly punitive carbon tax) could be administered to severely mitigate risks in the ESG universe. Bold policy initiatives take courage and willful leaders; it also takes engaged citizens to elect them. But the necessity for stronger regulation does not excuse financial participants and investment professionals from using the tools at their disposal to influence outcomes.
Sustainable investing is becoming a deadly distraction that is doing more harm than good.False, but the propensity and facility of greenwashing is way too high.
Marketing investment products that proclaim to be making a difference, but actually do very little, allows for the general public to ‘feel good’ about ESG while absolving them from taking decisive action. There is no doubt that this form of greenwashing is alive and well in the investment industry (‘ESG-aware’ ETFs should not be fooling anyone). But dishonest marketing is as old as snake oil and is perhaps inevitable in the nascent phases of ESG adoption. Recall that FASB accounting rules were established in the 1970s but took over twenty-five years before becoming the international golden standard (remember Enron in 2000). Regulatory instruments related to ESG are only in their infancy (SFDR) and it is certainly not the first time that financial markets and their participants are ahead of the regulatory backdrop.
ESG lacks a “theory of change”: False, remember that people respond to incentives
A common argument among ESG skeptics is that ESG lacks a theory of change. Therefore, for those asking what ESG can achieve besides fees for the financial industry, one has to look at how ESG investors have been reshaping markets these past few years. Here’s how we see ESG impacting the real world beyond the financial space.
For one, with ESG flows towards sustainable strategies (at least in name) forecasted to be in the hundreds of trillions over the next decade, one can easily say that the ESG tsunami of money is already reshaping markets – and individual stock and sectoral valuations with it. As such, the flow-of-funds into ESG themes and companies which are developing solutions to real-world problems (as opposed to developing problems such as tobacco or gaming) is giving a powerful price signal to investors. By doing so, investors are pushing up prices of companies that they think are actually changing the world for good.
The corollary effect of the tsunami of “sustainability-themed” money now going into the equity market acts as a powerful incentive for company executives to deliver the real-world impact that ESG investors are looking for. With more than 7% of a typical S&P 500 company’s float in possession of executives (according to Bloomberg data), feeding ESG investors the meal they’ve been craving can have a powerful impact not only on the real world – but also on their total pay package – which is probably the strongest ESG incentive of all. To this end, the emergence of a greater number of models of sustainability-linked pay packages should be a key engagement focus area ahead.
Secondly, one can see that firms that achieve superior ESG scores (taking the aggregate of all ESG scoring agencies) are rewarded with access to cheaper financing for debt and equity – suggesting that ESG can actually have a very material impact on a company’s cost of capital, capital structure and profitability. While many executives are now “gaming the ESG report” of their own companies (such as the likes of Philip Morris), one could think that companies which are actually producing something useful to solve our world’s problems – the true definition of impact investing – are also benefitting from ESG-minded investors’ appetite of for future-positive investment assets.
For the past three decades, equity investors could reliably count on central bankers around the world to ensure investment opportunities. Regulating the business cycle via interest rates meant that a certain rhythm and predictability to economic expansions and contractions could be capitalized upon to make investment decisions. However, although monetary policy was the right tool for its time, it is becoming increasingly clear that current challenges require something more.
The structural transition to fiscal as the dominant policy force is already in full swing. The investment implications of this shift will be major. In this report, we detail how this phenomenon will take ESG from a niche investing theme to a central force that will drive returns across asset classes.
Monetary Policy Dominance: The End of an Era
Business cycles and macroeconomic conditions are the foundation of investment decisions. Although each business cycle is different, the various stages – if properly identified – have reliably offered periodic entry and exit points to different assets and asset classes.
For investors, over the past thirty years, identifying and capitalizing on the various stages of the business cycle has overwhelmingly centred on one thing: positioning for the monetary policy backdrop.
Of course, it wasn’t always this way: prior to the 1980s, both fiscal and monetary policy levers worked – sometimes together and sometimes in opposition – to steer the economic path of various nations.
However, the watershed moment for U.S. monetary history – with global repercussion – is undeniably when Fed Chairman Paul Volcker, in the fall of 1979, took dramatic steps to rein in runaway inflation. After elected officials – headed by Presidents Nixon and Carter – failed to solve skyrocketing prices with wage and price controls and currency debasement, it was Volcker who ultimately proved that rampant prices could be corrected by curbing the money supply.
Not only did Volcker set the table for long, prosperous economic expansions for subsequent decades, but he shifted – and cemented – the place of monetary policymakers at the head of that table.
The Fed, using interest rates as its primary tool, was wildly successful at fulfilling its dual mandate: the below chart shows that from 1985 to 2009, the Fed was largely able to adjust monetary policy in order to deliver the level of interest rates required to generate economic growth and price stability. However, as the chart shows, that all changed at the time of the Great Recession. At the zero bound on interest rates, central banks have had to resort to unconventional policy tools (quantitative easing). There has been much debate about the efficacy of QE programs, and a detailed analysis is outside the scope of this report. We simply note that while QE is broadly effective at ensuring market liquidity and therefore reducing financial market and banking system stress, its ability to manage economic growth is far less impactful.
Even the most fervent monetarists would concede that most of today’s economic challenges are ill suited to the prescription; rising inequality, the hollowing out of middle class, jobs outsourced to robots and overseas workers… these are not things that can be fixed by adjusting the level of interest rates and the money supply.
The bottom line is that monetary policy has been wildly successful at managing business cycles and inflation over the past 30 years; this monetary dominance has made for a methodical, iterative framework for investors. However, since the Great Recession of 2007-2008, it has become increasingly clear that new tools – outside of the monetary sphere – are necessary to tackle the most pressing economic issues.
Fiscal Policy: Into the Overton Window
As it happens, it was a central banker that most powerfully and presciently called the peak in monetary policy dominance. Writing in the Washington Post while at the helm of the U.S. Federal Reserve in November 2010, Ben Bernanke declared, “The Federal Reserve cannot solve all the economy's problems on its own.” He subsequently called on Congress, the administration, and regulators to do more.
To be sure, Trump’s four-year Presidential interlude paused the advancement of fiscal policy as a tool to manage the economy. However, it has been abundantly clear since Joe Biden’s first day in office that taxation and spending are no longer dirty words in Washington. Indeed, by most accounts, fiscal policy has now transited from the Reagan-era ‘big government is bad’ to something that is socially acceptable. The Overton Window refers to the notion that policymakers must choose from the range of policies that are politically acceptable at the time. We posit that since 2010, fiscal policy has moved within the window of acceptable policy. Indeed, the American electorate is increasingly comfortable with the role of government (i.e. fiscal policy) and would like it to play a larger role (see Chart).
The key takeaway is that there is a fundamental shift in the importance between the two branches of macroeconomic policy. The multi-decade era of monetary policy dominance has ceded to one where fiscal levers – taxation, spending and regulation – will be far more important. This has significant implications for the business cycle and by extension, investors.
Monetary is to Fiscal as Hammer is to Scalpel
As is now well known, monetary policy – controlling the money supply – is a blunt and rather undiscriminating instrument for producing economic outcomes. Indeed, in the Fed’s own words in 2003, “monetary policy …is a ‘blunt instrument’ that can not be selectively used to stimulate the economies of particular regions or industries.” It follows that the same blunt instrument cannot be selectively used to stimulate the growth of particular socioeconomic groups, demographic tranches, etc. Some would say, in fact, that recent monetary policy has contributed to income equality.
Fiscal policy, on the other hand, almost by definition is rather like a scalpel; there are almost infinite ways to slice, dissect and attempt to reconstruct the economy through legislation (spending and taxation) and regulation.
There are several implications for financial markets, but we focus on those that we view as most critical for investors:
- When central banking dominates, progress can be easily measured against the two stated policy goals: inflation and employment. In contrast, when fiscal policy dominates, measuring progress is more complex, since stated policy goals can be multiple, competing and can change over time. Thus, the era of iterative, business cycle investing based on transparent, rules-based monetary policy will give way to more irregular market outcomes.
- When compared to monetary policy, economic management through fiscal policy will create specific winners and losers, which leads to more dispersion in prices across companies and industries.
- These winners and losers will be an approximation of voters’ desires, since dominant policymakers (elected officials) decisions are strongly tied to their re-election prospects. Thus, the prevalent concerns of voters - through their ability to trigger policy outcomes - will become a critical factor in investor success in the decade ahead.
Macro Goes ESG
As detailed above, when fiscal policy begins to shape the macro landscape, understanding voter preferences becomes key to investing. Historically, voters have almost always prioritized economic growth and although this remains the top concern, its relative importance to voters has declined (the abrupt halt to economic activity due to the pandemic caused a major flare-up in economic worries in 2020, but we do not expect this to reverse the trend that has been in place since 2012).
A raft of environmental and social issues are fast becoming the prevalent concerns. Inadequate health and education, racial injustice, stagnant wages, climate change are just a few of the growing priorities among voters.
The link to ESG investing thus becomes clear: the preferred macroeconomic policy (fiscal) will increasingly reflect voter preferences that are governed by environmental, social and governance issues. These ESG themes - previously viewed as a niche investment class – will become major drivers of investment strategies.
Indeed, this phenomenon is already being borne out in the data. It is widely known that investment flows to ESG funds has skyrocketed in recent years. Moreover, general interest in ‘ESG’ has seen a secular rise, while the peak in ‘macro’ has already occurred.
Fiscal Policy As A Driver of (ESG) Productivity
Governments around the world are increasingly aware of this shift of voter preferences. But perhaps nowhere is it more clear than in the United States, where the Biden-Harris government’s stated policy priorities mirror the social and environmental concerns of our time. Even more important, there appears enough political support for these projects that government spending will follow; Biden’s infrastructure plan has good chances of passing and will release over 1$ trillion in new spending over the next five years.
Crucially, the importance of infrastructure spending goes well beyond the direct impact of boosting GDP in the short term and providing an immediate improvement to services for citizens. While the empirical magnitude of the effect is often debated, there is academic consensus that government infrastructure has been a determinant to aggregate productivity growth.
The implication is that the much-needed boost to U.S. infrastructure will pay dividends long after the initial spending boost is over. In this way, expansive fiscal policy has the potential to boost sectoral productivity by unleashing the next innovation wave, producing winners (and losers) along the way. By earmarking spending to particular sectors (e.g. ‘green’ infrastructure, health and long-term care), there are good odds that superior productivity and investment returns will be generated in corresponding industries.
“The biggest danger is not inaction. The real danger is when politicians and CEOs are making it look like real action is happening when in fact almost nothing is being done, apart from clever accounting and creative PR.” Greta Thunberg, COP25 2019.
As we all now know, 2020 was a blowout year for attracting capital to ESG investing and 2021 is also off to a great start: according to Morningstar, sustainable fund assets climbed by almost 20% again in Q1 2021, meaning that “ESG” assets under management stand at just under USD $2 trillion. This represents a doubling since 2019!
The rising trend toward ESG investing means that management at publicly traded companies understand the allure of appearing “green”: as more investors choose ESG over traditional stock picks, companies will be overlooked and/or left out of more popular ESG-inspired indices. The latter risks damaging their stock price performance. Moreover, according to a recent MSCI study, companies with high ESG scores experience lower costs of capital compared to companies with poor ESG scores. This is true across developed countries and across sectors.
The implication is that there is a rising incentive for companies to pursue implementing ESG business strategies. Or at the very least, there is a rising incentive to pursue an image of implementing ESG strategies.
The latter - paying lip-service to causes with little impact - affect all of ESG; blue washing refers to pretending to be socially conscious, pink washing refers to falsely promoting fair gender, and of course, greenwashing refers to environmental cover up. All three are important (and could be committed by the same offenders!) but in this week’s note we shine a light specifically on greenwashing.
Corporate greenwashing has implications for multiple economic actors and the planet. In terms of investing, greenwashing misdirects capital away from the goals and preferences of underlying investors.
The principal tool for companies to communicate to investors about their environmental credibility is via sustainability reporting. Therefore, for investors that are looking to marry superior returns and positive ESG outcomes, it is crucial to be able to determine which companies are truly making improvements in environmental performance (either through efficiencies, new technology or innovative business models) and those companies that are merely improving their ability to communicate on ESG factors via glossy reporting.
The matrix below highlights the possible outcomes between being green and reporting green (note that environmental “duds” should be entirely ignored among modern investors).

Although there is a plethora of reporting metrics, indices, standards and practices, all with varying degrees of reliability, we have developed a simple filter to help decipher which companies are likely to fall into each quadrant. Starting with the S&P Global 1200 (covering roughly 70% of total equity market capitalization) as the investment universe, we follow these steps to decode where companies fall in the matrix:
- First, we use SASB’s materiality map’s environmental dimension to evaluate which industries are most affected by environmental issues. We do this to ensure that we only include industries whereby greenwashing is a material investment risk. We then translate the SASB industries to MSCI sectors. This limits our investment universe to MSCI companies within the energy, materials, industrials, and consumer staples sectors.
- Next, we rank these companies using both Eikon Refinitiv and CSR Hub data. Since we are focused only on greenwashing, we use only the Environment Scores (i.e. we ignore the overall ESG, as well as the Social and Government scores). We then compare the overall environment score with two critical sub-components of the environmental dimension: environmental innovation and product. We consider these two sub-categories as an indicator for “potential positive environmental impact” because high scores in these categories suggest that the company is more likely to be focused on environmental technology and/or innovative environmental business models that should lead to productivity in the future. In other words, the overall E score is likely to most closely represent a company’s E communication score, while the E innovation/product score should represent the company’s ability to deliver on green performance in the future.
- We then compare the gap in ranking between a company’s overall E score and its E innovation/product score. Companies that have high overall E, but low E innovation are flagged as having a higher potential for greenwashing (bottom right quadrant of the matrix), while companies with high innovation but low overall scores are more likely to be potential environmental underdogs (top left quadrant of the matrix). Importantly, we only include companies whose scores are consistent in both the Refinitiv and CSR Hub data bases; given the ongoing wide discrepancies in reporting standards and methodologies, this criterion helps increase the accuracy of our filter.
The results of our “greenwash” filter are shown in the tables below by sector.
There are a few key observations and caveats from this exercise:
- Although we applied our filter across the four sectors whereby environmental factors are most material according to SASB, a qualitative check on the individual names that were flagged by the filter suggest that this methodology is less effective for the energy space. We agree that Baker Hughes should be on investors’ watchlist for greenwashing, however we are unconvinced about the names that were flagged as “green underdogs” or “truly green”. These companies were in part flagged by our filter because many do indeed develop innovative technology, but they continue to operate in dirtier aspects of fossil fuel businesses. A case in point is Cenovus, which continues to extract heavy oil from the Canadian tar sands, albeit with technology that improves its water efficiency.
- Within the consumer staples sector, our filter “caught” almost exclusively companies in the tobacco, food products and food retailing industries. This is largely because scores in these industries were more extreme relative to the other industries within this sector (beverages, personal and household products).
According to our filter, the potential for greenwashing is greater among companies with larger market capitalization: the average market cap of companies in our potential greenwasher bucket is 13% greater than those companies in the green underdog category. The correlation between ESG reporting and company size has been widely reported in recent years; the results from the filter suggest that not only are larger companies more likely to report on ESG issues, they are also more likely to exaggerate their green performance.
Finally, we caution readers that this filter is not intended to act as a standalone screen for investors to track down greenwashers. The companies highlighted in the tables should not be viewed conclusively as partaking in greenwashing; even when using several sources of ESG reporting, errors and omissions occur. Rather, our Greenwashing Screen can be used as one tool among many and alongside thorough qualitative company analysis.
The news that another activist hedge fund has effected change in the ESG space elicited strong reactions not only in the press but also among SMS’ strategists. Engine No. 1’s success at seating at least two new board members (a third board seat could be confirmed imminently) – along with increasing shareholder pressure at Chevron and court intervention at Royal Dutch Shell – was viewed by some of us an important nail in the coffin for fossil fuel companies that have failed to wake up to the energy transition. Others among us had a far more sober reaction. Thus, when a savvy client asked us for our view, we struggled to present a united front. In today’s note, we present both sides of our internal debate, sparked by last week’s shareholder events among some of the oil majors.
Round 1: Does replacing a couple of board members at Exxon really matter?
Yes:
The election of new directors at Exxon is a tremendous achievement, but perhaps not something equity investors should have been all that surprised about. After all, many of Exxon’s largest shareholders have made public commitments against fossil fuel companies; failing to support Engine No. 1’s mission by voting against the board changes would have created significant reputational risk for many institutional investors.
The Exxon shake-up is nevertheless exciting because it gives much-needed validation that investors are providing more than lip-service to decarbonization. Indeed, although the trend is still in its infancy, investors are beginning to discriminate between big oil companies that are participating in the energy transition and those that are not. On one extreme is Total (recently rebranded TotalEnergies to reflect this point) while Exxon is on the other. Since 2018, a gap in the companies’ equity price has opened up; this is at least in part due to a “dirty discount” for Exxon and a “green premium” for TotalEnergies.
No:
Directors have a relatively minimal impact on company outcomes and this is especially the case for Exxon. The board is composed mainly of former CEOs of large corporations that are not particularly active in the ESG space. To be sure, the new board members may start to tilt the balance, but there is a long way to go.
Moreover, it has taken decades of engagement at Exxon in order to achieve even this board result; buying and holding companies with the goal of changing them requires patience that very few investors have.
Perhaps most importantly, a key problem for Exxon (and Chevron) is that management continues to fight shareholders and governments on climate change. The energy sector is clearly in the midst of a massive transition. There is a very strong consensus in change management literature that when pressure on companies to change is being exerted by external forces (e.g. boards, social movements, technology, etc), a company’s capacity to respond appropriately is highly dependent on the strength of the organization’s mission and its management. Notably, for complex organizations like Exxon, these factors rank higher than culture, organisational structure, or any other factor).
Nonetheless, the above comparison with TotalEnergies is apt and we are agreed that the equity price action of these two companies does reflect some dirty discount/green premium. But a crucial point is that for TotalEnergies, the transition to a more renewable focus has been broadly successful because it was lead from within. In other words, for the Exxon case, investors should only turn more optimistic once there is significant change in management. At the time of writing, Darren Woods has been retained as CEO, suggesting that there is still a long way to go.
Round #2: Can Exxon Hope to Catch Up On Sustainability?
Yes:
Depending on Exxon’s next steps, this initial push could trigger a positive chain reaction. Suppose the new board members now manage to force a cut to unproductive capital spending (in dirty fossil fuels). This could lead to investors pricing in a higher equity multiple in the short term, thus incentivizing management to continue with further steps down this path. In this way, one decision – to reduce capital spending in an increasingly less productive business model – could spark a chain reaction toward better sustainability goals.
No:
As per the comments above about the capacity to change in the face of external pressures, the reticence at Exxon that has existed for decades vis-à-vis the relationship between climate change and fossil fuels is a good indication that the company does not currently have the right ingredients to participate in the energy transition.
Furthermore, for Exxon, a capital spending-chain reaction is unlikely. One should not forget that the remaining appeal for Exxon stock is its hefty dividend. While it’s true that Exxon’s dividend payout ratio looks to be on an untenable path, management would likely be highly enticed to use any “savings” from reduced capital savings to shore up the company’s reputation as a dividend payer. Indeed, Exxon is consistently one of 65 stocks in the S&P 500 dividend aristocrat index, long considered a badge of growth and consistency. Failing to increase the dividend for even one quarter in 2021 risks ejecting the company from this index.
Clearly, opting to increase dividends would do nothing to advance the company in terms of sustainability. Unfortunately for Exxon, the sustainability ship has sailed and this company seems to have missed the boat.
Round 3: So are activist hedge funds like Engine No. 1 a force of good or evil?
Evil:
The literature is pretty clear: activist hedge funds’ main objectives are to boost or depress a company’s stock price for short term gains without regard for longer term value. In a recent note regarding shareholder activism at Danone (see “The Empire strikes back”, April 22, 2021), we showed that value is actually eroded in only three years after activist fund involvement with a company. Admittedly, there are exceptions to this rule and perhaps Engine No. 1 is one of them.
Good:
Activist hedge funds are no doubt focused mainly on the short term but that does not mean that they can’t also deliver longer term results if their actions are aligned with broader market themes. Perhaps a more important lesson from the Engine No. 1/Exxon story is that contrary to popular opinion, activist shareholders can affect change with very small ownership stakes. Engine No. 1 owns less than 1% of Exxon, but their goals were highly aligned with equity holders with much larger stakes.
Final Round: Is Exxon a Buy or Sell?
Something we agree on! A shared core belief is that to be a successful investor, one needs to anticipate what society will care about in the future and support companies that are properly aligned. Exxon failed to foresee the staying power and necessity of the transition, which now leaves them in a lagging position and forced to play catch-up. Indeed, last year we highlighted data from Energy Strategy Reviews that assesses and ranks the readiness of Big Oil companies to shift toward renewables. Although the data are over a year old, it is extremely likely that the general conclusions still hold: Exxon is a laggard when it comes to the energy transition.
To be sure, Exxon’s stock could experience a price bounce in the near-term but there is scant evidence that longer term investors will be rewarded.
The events at Exxon/Chevron/Shell add credence to our view that the energy transition theme is 1) still in its early days and 2) has staying power. We will continue to search for the most appropriate ways to capitalize on this theme.
While science is crucial in adapting to climate change, one could argue that innovation in applied sciences is paramount. Sustainability is rapidly becoming a growing business line for many engineering companies worldwide.
While engineering services companies will continue to benefit from the global fiscal stimulus in the years to come and from “build-back-better” initiatives, those with dedicated practices in the fields of environmental remediation, public transportation, water management and renewable power are set to outperform the pack.
The good news is that many engineering companies have taken a serious turn towards sustainability, such as SNC-Lavalin, a Canadian engineering household name who recently joined the UN Global Compact and issued its plan to become Net Zero by 2030. For ESG investors, such a firm, which was engulfed in several corruption scandals in the early 2010’s in Libya and barred from World Bank contracts for a decade, poses an interesting case study on the importance of governance in the engineering sector. After a long period of adjustment and internal cleansing of its practices, the firm has straighten up its act and is now building up its future using sustainability as an edge to win contracts.
More than 300 engineering firms have now joined the UN Global Compact and the list continues to grow as more and more clients – public and private – are now asking their suppliers to adhere to some level of sustainability standards in engineering (such as ISO 140011 and others). Moreover, NGOs such as Corporate Knights’ Global 100 rankings have included engineering firms such as Stantec, one of the world’s largest engineering firms (also based in Canada), in its top 10 most sustainable companies (among all sectors) for 2020.
Given the complex nature of the way business is done for engineering firms – and the various countries they work in – the quality of governance of such firms becomes paramount to the long-term value and to the sustainability outcomes of their activities. To this end, it seems that the quality of governance in the sector has improved substantially these past few years, with SNC-Lavalin displaying some of the greatest improvements of its percentile rank in CSRHub with Arcadis, another firm that is strongly committed to sustainability and Stantec, which remains at the top of the pack.
Overall, engineering and construction services companies have had a good ride during COVID and benefitted greatly from governments’ promises to “build-back-better” in many countries.
Interestingly, the sector remains cheaper than the overall market as the S&P 1200 Construction and Engineering Index trades at a 20% discount to the market on a P/E basis. Should the equity market correct in the coming months, engineering services and construction companies could even become an interesting haven – at least those companies with a lower market Beta – for investors looking to de-risk their portfolios and anchor themselves more closely to developments and the direction of fiscal levers in the real economy.
Sustainable Market Strategies looked at large-cap engineering companies with dedicated practices in line with environmental, renewable power, water, and public transportation themes. We view that these companies will benefit the most from the soon-to-come government spending in these sectors. While most of these companies are based in North America, their activities remain global in nature – which also makes them exposed to growth in EMs and lower income countries.
Interestingly, SMS’s index of Green Engineering companies outperformed both the S&P 500 and the S&P 1200 Engineering and Construction indices on equal-weighted basis since August 2020. We think that the outperformance of our index should continue in the coming months.
That said, looking at the P/E of our index, some of the hype around green engineering seems to be already priced-in by markets at this point.
While that valuation of SMS’ Green engineering index appears expensive against the rest of the sector, one should look for cheaper names within our index. As such, companies such as SNC-Lavalin, Stantec and WSP – all of them global engineering powerhouses – and up-and-coming contenders such as Montrose Environmental – could be interesting plays for those looking to find value and exposure to the build-back-better theme.
Detractors of ESG investing like to point out that the growth in ESG assets is mainly due to investors willing to overpay for stocks at a given level of profitability. Sceptics might say that the premium is not really warranted and that it is all hype. However, there are also fundamental reasons, such as lower non-financial risks, that would justify fundamentally higher valuations for ESG branded companies. Nonetheless, we wanted to find out if ESG portfolios were outperforming mostly due to P/E ratio expansion, rather than hard-earned EPS growth. We decided to go and find out for ourselves, by looking at the drivers of global equity returns in recent years based on their ESG ratings. To do that we simply decompose the total return of S&P 1200 stocks into changes in trailing P/Es, trailing EPS (which includes the effect of buybacks), and dividends. We group these stocks into three categories by industry-adjusted consensus ESG scores, which aggregate the ratings of different ESG data providers. Securities are aggregated in each group using free float adjusted market cap. Despite some missing data, our resulting stock universe covers about 90% of the S&P 1200 market cap, which itself represents 70% of the global market cap.
We look at the 2 years before COVID-19 began, (2018 and 2019), when ESG equity flows started accelerating and global P/E ratios were falling from their early-2018 highs. It turns out that stocks with higher ESG scores (top 33% of stocks by ESG score) did outperform thanks to rising valuations. However, the P/E return boost was only relative: the higher the ESG score the lower the fall in trailing P/E ratios was, but P/Es fell nonetheless.
Since COVID-19 started hitting the global economy in early 2020, stocks with good ESG ratings (top 33%) have actually had less P/E expansion (19%) than the overall universe (21%), while their EPS and dividend return contributions were in line with the broader universe. It is hard to notice any sign of a global ESG bubble in equities since 2020, contrary to popular belief.
At the other end of the spectrum, low-rated ESG stocks have been the worst performing group since 2020: they are the only group with negative EPS contribution (-10%) and the worst performer out of our 3 stocks groups. The best-performing group, in terms of both EPS and total returns, was the middle-ground group of stocks with average ESG scores, which was overweight Communication Services (Facebook, Alphabet, Tencent, Walt Disney), and underweight Health Care and IT. Regionally, it was also overweight the U.S. and Japan.
We can also use total return decomposition to identify pockets of potential ESG bargains: stocks with good ESG scores, which have trailed their industry due to slower P/E expansion rather than lower EPS growth. One of these pockets of ESG opportunities lies in US industrial stocks, where well-ESG rated firms have trailing their sector in total return terms since the beginning of 2020, while having more resilient earnings. A portfolio of the top 33% US industrials by ESG scores includes no airlines and is overweight road & rail companies. We would focus particularly on rail companies in light of the recent Biden administration’s infrastructure plan, which is calling to “invest $80 billion to address Amtrak’s repair backlog; modernize the high traffic Northeast Corridor; improve existing corridors and connect new city pairs; and enhance grant and loan programs that support passenger and freight rail safety, efficiency, and electrification.”
In Japan, a DM industrial powerhouse, industrial stock returns have been largely proportional to their ESG ratings, with top rated firms beating the overall Industrials sector by almost 10pp since the end of 2019, while ESG laggards trailed by just as much. This recent ESG outperformance in Japanese industrial stocks has mostly been driven by P/E expansion, which makes US industrials more attractive in comparison. Japanese machinery exporters also benefited from a strong Chinese industrial rebound over the past year, while in 2021 the US will be the main global growth engine.
Finally, another cyclical ESG play can be found in European consumer discretionary stocks. With a slower vaccine rollout than in US and Europe-wide rescue funds that have not yet fully been allocated, the pent-up demand and cyclical outperformance story has further to run in European stocks. Interestingly, European consumer discretionary names with higher ESG scores have had their trailing earnings even more affected by the pandemic than the sector average: their combined net income fell by 78% (!) since the end of 2019 vs. 71% for the sector average. Investors were clearly unhappy with this and respective P/E ratios were also more penalized than European Industrials as a whole. We believe that this development only makes the case even stronger for a European Consumer Discretionary rebound led by well-rated ESG stocks. This top 33% European industrial stocks by ESG scores is underweight autos and hotels, overweight retail, and neutral on apparel.
«Never tell me the odds». In a March 2009 case study by Simon David Handelsmon called “Realities and Perceptions of Human Rights in the Mining Industry – A Case Study”, Rio Tinto was under analysis. The main conclusion was that since 2000, although there has been a vast improvement in the general sensitivity of the mining industry to human rights issues, the reality on the ground has not kept pace with the aspirational rhetoric of the companies. When the study came out, the mere thought that, merely 10 years later, a Rio Tinto chief executive officer would resign under pressure from shareholders over an inadequate response to the destruction of ancient Aboriginal heritage sites in Australia, would not have crossed somebody’s mind. Social issues can no longer be ignored.
Activist hedge funds typically invest in a company to initiate change, move the stock price higher, sell at a profit and get on to the next target. In a February 5, 2020 research article by Mark R. Desjardine and Rodolphe Durand called “Disentangling the effects of hedge fund activism on firm financial and social performance“, they analyzed data from 2000 to 2016 on activist hedge funds. They also conducted interviews with activist managers as well as leaders of companies that were targets of activists. They confirmed through their interviews that the motivation of activist hedge funds is to increase the value of their investments quickly by cutting costs, scaling back investments, restructuring assets, redistributing cash, and replacing board members. The approach is typically to accuse management of subpar corporate governance and demand changes. Their investment horizon being very short, their demands heavily discount future returns.
«This deal’s getting worse all the time». The table above compares the results of companies that were targets of activist hedge funds to those that were not. For the first two years following the appearance of an activist, the market value and profitability is better for targets than non-targets while cash flows and ESG performance deteriorates. Over a 5-year period, market value, profitability, cash flows and ESG measures are all significantly worse for targets. By that time, the activist hedge fund is long gone since their investment horizon rarely breaches 3 years.
«We would be honored if you joined us». In November 2020, the activist hedge fund Bluebell Capital sent a letter to Michel Landel, the lead independent director at Danone recommending that the role of CEO and Chairman of the Board be separated. They also asked to initiate a search for a new CEO because of his poor operational track record and questionable capital allocation choices. In December, Gilles Schnepp was appointed to the board as lead director.
The above graph shows the stock performance of Danone compared to its peers. Danone was a clear target for activists.
Moreover, its margins, cash flows and valuation were below its competitors.
«I am altering the deal. Pray I don’t alter it any further». In February, Bluebell had four requests: The first was to separate the functions of chairman and chief executive officer. The second was to appoint an independent chair. The third request was that the board of directors to strengthen, by integrating people with experience in mass consumption and the fourth, request was that Mr. Faber must be let go for a new general manager.
«Apology accepted». the Danone CEO was fired in March. Following the firing, Gilles Schnepp wrote in a shareholder letter that Danone will pursue some of the organisational changes set in motion by former boss Emmanuel Faber and said «We want to make clear this is an organisational framework only, leaving the incoming CEO all the latitude to design and execute his or her strategy”.
Danone is one of only ten companies in the world with a AAA rating from CDP, a leading environmental reporting framework. Mark Carney, the current UN special envoy for climate and former governor of the Bank of England and the Bank of Canada, mentions Danone in his new book as a model for the way it changed its corporate signature to “One planet, One health” and its governance structure to require stakeholders’ consideration.
The Danone story is still unfolding and our opinion on it is not completely formed. Were the long-term benefits to stakeholders maximized by the actions of the company or was it wasteful publicity? The activist shareholders got what they wanted. Since Bluebell wrang, the stock price has underperformed the French index, has done worst than Nestle but better than Unilever. It will be a very interesting case study for years to come. The activist tactics are clearly an attack on sustainability and long-termism.
The table above shows public companies that obtained a CDP AAA rating. As we can see, those companies believe sustainability is a competitive advantage. They also have high margins and strong cash flows that allow them to implement sustainability programs dear to ESG-minded investors and ESG rating agencies. To obtain that rating, you need to be extremely good on operations and spend quite a lot on glossy documents detailing those programs. If their stock performance falters, those companies may become targets for activist investors – just like Danone.
«Do or do not, there is no try». Natura is a company based in Brazil that is eco-friendly, sustainable and uses ordinary people as models to promote products. It changed its corporate structure to a B-Corp. Unusually, it does not have a very good CDP rating but its commitments to climate change, to protect the Amazon, to human rights, and to a circular economy make it very interesting. Philip Morris is AAA from CDP because its environmental practices and reporting are very good but considering its products kill people, it is tough to stomach. As a long term ESG investor, a BFF like Natura that aims for long-term improvements in life looks like a better investment partner than AAA-rated Philip Morris that destroys your health.
«Impressive, most impressive». The stock performance of Natura has been volatile but good compared to its CDP-AAA competitors L’Oréal and KAO. It will not be a target for activist hedge funds for now. If KAO continues to have poor performance, it could become a target.
«The son of Skywalker must not become a Jedi». The more demanding nature of younger participants in the economy is leading or coinciding with the evolution of institutional investors towards a greater emphasis on long term prospects. «Luminous beings are we. Not this crude matter». This presents a new hope for markets to play their ultimate role as optimal allocators of capital for the greater good of society. The road will be treacherous.
Perhaps the most surprising element of the U.S. administration’s call for a global minimum corporate tax is that it took so long to happen. Despite its bad reputation with the general public, tax avoidance has long been tolerated – if not even encouraged – by some OECD countries (e.g., Ireland). Others, such as France and the U.K. – who benefit from the proximity of complacent tax jurisdictions (Monaco and the Channel Islands, respectively) still support their high-earning companies (and individuals) in the fiercely competitive global economic game through such tax avoidance schemes.
It also seems that the IMF and other organizations are now all out about tax collection to finance monster COVID-related deficits – and they are now championing global cooperation on the issue. The good news is that similar to the fiscal and monetary response given to the COVID crisis, we see a high chance that governments will cooperate more seriously on the issue of tax evasion and tax avoidance to fund ever-growing government deficits.
In a note last year (see “ESG investors vs. the taxman”, January 9, 2020), we foresaw such an increase in America’s corporate tax rates following Trump’s fiscally unsustainable cuts of December 2017. The increase in corporate taxes is also on the radar as corporate America expects a solid earnings’ year from the COVID boost to several industries (Construction, Materials, Tech, etc.).
While many welcomed the previous White House’s reduction of the U.S.’ corporate tax rate to 21% – in-line with other developed countries – it seems that the new world in which we are living is asking for much stronger action, i.e. a substantial increase in corporate “tax effort”. In our note of last week (see “Working-class hero”, April 8, 2021), we underlined the decreasing tax effort of American corporations since 1950 as a share of GDP. It seems that governments are giving in to the “populist” impression that Big Business is not paying its fair share – and they are right.
In our note of January 2019, we had also suggested ESG-minded investors to engage with their investee companies on the issue – albeit a very delicate one for the asset management industry. Indeed, financials are often pointed as serial tax avoiders and important users of tax heavens to preserve profit margins. We also underlined that sectors most exposed to a change-of-tack in U.S. corporate tax policy were chemicals, hospitality, casinos, and tech sectors.
That said, investors – which are typically much more avid of tax cuts than they are about tax hikes – benefitted largely from Trump’s tax policies. In fact, the S&P 500 increased by about 7% in late 2017 following the enactment of Trump’s corporate tax plan.
Interestingly, the P/E ratio of the S&P 500 decreased following the tax cut announcement in a context of strong growth and a tight labor market.
While Biden’s tax plan will first target a 15% minimum tax rate on profits for companies in “high tax avoidance” industries with a minimum of USD 100 million of revenue, some sectors and industries will suffer more than others. In our view, sectors with high earnings’ yield and low effective tax rates could suffer some level of reputational risk as the Biden administration looks to re-tax corporate America.
One other way to look at where the IRS will find its “fiscal nuggets” is to look at corporate America’s “fiscal space” – i.e. its tax “effort” as a percentage of EBIT. Here, and perhaps surprisingly, one sees that cash paid in taxes as a percent of EBIT can represent a substantial portion of EBIT in industries such as apparel, hospitality, and systems software.
Conversely, the IRS could look for some corporate fiscal space in industries such as semiconductors, steel and passthrough structures such as REITs which display a much higher potential of being re-taxed.
Finally, Biden’s re-tax plan also sheds light on the current level of corporate welfare – which will likely come under greater scrutiny in the coming months. Here, the rather interventionist Biden administration will likely give back some of the money it will take through taxes to corporations that are in harmony with the agenda of the government.
According to the GoodJobsFirst NGO, subsidies to America’s 20 biggest “corporate welfare queens” amounted to more than USD 80 billion last year. This is something that certainly will be looked at by policymakers as they re-tax corporations in the months to come and unwind the unprecedented level of public support provided to corporates this past year.
One of the high-growth areas of sustainable finance and ESG these days are financial instruments – in this case bonds and loans – with embedded triggers tied to issuers’ sustainability outcomes – many of which compatible with ESG performance frameworks such as the GRI, SASB, SBTi, etc. As a result, many see sustainability-linked instruments as one of the future drivers of sustainability in the corporate world.
According to Bloomberg data, more than USD 30 billion of sustainability-linked loans and bonds have been issued globally by corporates and governments since 2019, and we expect this number to grow at an even faster pace in the coming years. While European corporate and government issuers continue to lead the pack, the U.S. has caught up substantially and is poised to see an increase in its issuance given the recent change of tack in DC and the growing appetite from lenders, corporates and investors for all-things sustainable.
The issuance of sustainability-linked instruments is also becoming more widespread across U.S. and European BICS sectors, with Utilities and Materials leading the group in terms of total amount issued since 2019. Here, three sectors are of interest: Utilities, Financials and Energy.
One can understand some of the reasons pushing Utilities to embark on the sustainability path – with renewables (notably wind and solar) now cheaper than thermal sources (natural gas and coal), companies in this sector can easily attach sustainability strings to their loans knowing that their future most likely will be one with less carbon intensity. In that, we expect Utilities – especially those embracing the transition to a lower carbon future at a faster pace – to benefit from lower financing costs that will likely come with sustainability-linked financing instruments.
Conversely, Financials find themselves in a position where they will have to commit to a change in their books and source of profits (think of Canadian banks’ exposure to oil sands financing) which will take longer than other sectors to achieve – hence the relatively smaller amount of outstanding sustainability-linked instruments in the financial sector.
Surprisingly, sustainability-linked instruments remain a marginal source of finance in the Energy sector – perhaps the area where they could have the greatest impact.
That being said, assessing the effectiveness of sustainability-linked instruments in addressing real-world problems forces us to measure the relative contribution of financial incentives vs. those aiming at other business vectors such as 1) management (i.e. pay) and 2) the contribution of technological change to the improvement of corporate-level sustainability outcomes.
While many are calling for regulatory standards regarding ESG in markets (the latest being Mark Carney in his new book), there remains a fair amount of noise as to the standards to which issuers should adhere when tying their financing costs to sustainability outcomes. One of the leading standards comes from ICMA’s Sustainability-linked bond principles.
While most frequently used metrics include internal KPIs such as energy efficiency performance and improvement of ESG scores (the latter doesn’t make much sense in our view considering the discrepancies in ESG scores across third-party ESG data providers), we much prefer issuers’ adherence to “’hard” objectives such as the Science-Based Targets initiative, commitments to increase gender equality at all levels of the organization, executive pay incentives (one of the most effective ESG incentive when done right), and any other measurable “absolute” sustainability-related targets.
While several studies suggested a disappearing greenium (lower yields for green instruments vs. plain vanilla comparables) in the green bond space, we note that sustainability-linked instruments still offer a lower financing cost compared to the average yield asked for by market participants in several sectors (we don’t know the extent to which sustainability clauses were triggered in Bloomberg, in fact very few details on the covenants themselves).
Looking at about 100 such instruments in the U.S. and Europe issued since 2019, one sees that sustainability-linked instruments yields (BICS sector average) remain lower than the sectoral averages of their plain vanilla equivalents. Like for the early days of green bonds, we are seeing some yield compression happening given the high demand for such products at this point.
Moreover, looking at the G-spread average per sector, we also see that sustainability-linked loans display lower spreads vs. their plain-vanilla equivalents.
Furthermore, we think that sustainability-linked instruments will prove to have their greatest impact in highly leveraged sectors such as Real Estate and Utilities. It also happens that along with Energy, these sectors probably have the biggest “transition” potential of all.
The assault of the Reddit r/WallStreetBets crowd on excessively shorted companies like GameStop and AMC Entertainment shows a disenchantment with the current financial structure, an ingenious understanding of the weak links in the system and a strong desire to protest. Some of the participants in this assault are saying that financial markets are rigged, and that the establishment always has a significant advantage over the “main street” crowd. Sticking it to them is worth the risk of losing. In financial theory, we typically talk about risk aversion where losses have a greater emotional impact than gains. In this case, gains have a much greater emotional impact than losses. GameStop’s branding uses “Power to the Players”. Game players have to be resilient and generally face unfavorable odds – this describes the situation well. The lesson we should learn is that this is a call to improve fairness in markets. It could have more staying potential than the “Occupy Wall Street” movement.
In our view, the growth in popularity of Special Purpose Acquisition Corporations (SPACs) is yet another example of an unfair financial system.
Let’s look at how they are structured with a typical example. A SPAC issues stocks at 10$ and put the proceeds in a trust with the sponsor generally supporting the initial underwriting cost and other fees in case no transaction takes place during the investment period. In essentially all cases, a transaction takes place and the balance sheet before the transaction typically has an underlying value of the shares at 80-90% of the original price.
Since a De-SPAC transaction must typically represent 80% of the sum raised and investors can decide to accept or reject the transaction, the sponsor will typically find additional financing to make sure there is enough capital for the transaction to go through. The most common approach is to use a private investment in public equity or PIPE where a group of investors which like the transaction contemplated agree to provide additional financing at the original 10$ issue price.
At the time of the transaction, the underwriter gets the postponed underwriting fee and an investment banker or consultant gets the review fees for the transaction. Ultimately, if every equity holder approves the deal and the PIPE is fully utilized, we get to the maximum value that can be paid for the target acquisition. From that analysis, we see that in order for the SPAC transaction to be worth the original 10$ invested, the acquisition has to be done at a discount of at least 20% since the money available divided by the shares is sued amount to 80% of the issue price.
Moreover, the sponsors and the original SPAC investors get awarded warrants which further reduces the upside with potential dilution.
The following table describes the required undervaluation of the target in order for the investment to be a success under purchase price scenarios of (12$, 15$ and 20$).
The last 10 years of success and the feeling of invincibility with markets is propelling the demand for opportunities of large gains. Stars have joined the fray with aggressive marketing campaign to promote SPACs.
As can be seen in the table below, the financial industry has most of the incentives. The underwriter, banker, target company, sponsor and even the original investor which is typically an institutional investor all have incentives for hype and higher prices. Ironically, SPACs are a growing point of interest of the retail crowd.