Corporate scandals, like those which emerged following the Global Financial Crisis have shed light on the need for improving the economic system. We recognize that reforms are necessary to ensure a more inclusive and sustainable economic environment, and this is captured in our Building Better Markets theme. Shareholder rights should evolve to align the financial system with broader stakeholder objectives. By balancing profitability with social and environmental considerations, businesses can help to address the shortcomings of the current system in favor of a more desirable outcome. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for investors to identify opportunities.

The significant decrease in the average equity holding period on the NYSE as shown below is an example of the impact of changing market dynamics towards gambling in the stock market instead of investing. A short-term focus over long-term performance and sustainable advancements presents a notable hurdle to effectively integrate responsible considerations. The emphasis on the short-term can divert attention and impede progress towards lasting positive transformations within companies.

In this note, we examine the current issues of capitalism and the calls to rethink the contemporary economy. We analyze the implications of this growing awareness and the anticipated developments for the financial system to support the goals of stakeholder capitalism. Our analytical framework considers four critical economic drivers: demography, international relations, regulations, and technology. The call for companies to embed sustainability and social progress aligns with the focus on broader stakeholder objectives in Sustainability DNA, while the pressure for inclusivity and fair access to financial services relates to Economic Participation.

From Trends to Transformation: Current Demographic Forces

Increased awareness of environmental and social issues is driving a shift towards ethical and sustainable consumption practices. As shown in the chart below, 71% of consumers surveyed have shifted their purchasing behavior in favor of the planet.

Demographic factors play a significant role in the need for better markets, as baby boomers are retiring and younger generations will take over as consumers and leaders, therefore changing consumption patterns landscape. The younger consumer is more concerned about the sustainability of the products they purchase.

Gen Zs and Millenials are recognized for their environmental consciousness, but their love for fast fashion poses a conflict between their stated values and their purchasing habits. Still, they share a strong commitment to aligning their spending with their environmental values, as indicated by a willingness to pay a premium for sustainable products, prioritize philanthropic giving to environmental causes, and invest in portfolios that emphasize environmental impact over purely financial metrics, as we highlighted last summer in the note “Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous and the Future of Global Warming”, July 7th, 2022.

As consumers increasingly seek products aligned with their values, businesses are compelled to demonstrate their social and environmental responsibility. Societal pressure is mounting to include a wider range of stakeholders in company decision-making processes. This inclusive approach acknowledges the significance of employees, communities, and the environment. As companies opt for greater disclosures, the laggards (or those who greenwash) are at risk while truly good corporate citizens could gain market share, as reflected in our theme.


Beyond Borders: The Chess of Geopolitical Relations

In recent years, political activism advocating for fairness, nationalism, and populism has gained traction. Elections increasingly highlight wealth inequalities as a central issue. Political campaigns often focus on policies that prioritize economic fairness and wealth redistribution. The outcomes of these elections can shape economic policies, regulations, and initiatives aimed at making markets more fair for all.

 

Global Disparity Atlas: Wealth Inequity Unveiled

World map highlighting in which countries the top 1% owns more wealth than the bottom 80%.

Source: World Inequality Database, 2021

 

Dynamics in France offer an interesting case. Following social unrest from a police shooting of a 17 year-old, multiple French executives asserted in an article in Le Monde that current economic divides are having repercussions not only on the economy itself but also on democracy and the social contract. In the context of successive crises, including the “yellow vest” movement, the COVID-19 pandemic, the war in Ukraine, and the impending climate crisis, it is imperative for the country, just like others, to stop neglecting the most vulnerable.

Geopolitical tensions and power struggles also have far-reaching implications for the pursuit of inclusive and sustainable markets. They can disrupt global trade, create trade barriers, and shape government policies and regulations. Trade conflicts can hinder the import and export of goods, including those related to sustainable technologies and practices. These have a direct impact on companies’ abilities to produce their products, source materials and sell their goods globally. Increasingly, governments and large multinationals are seeking security and resilience over global value chains. This is apparent in the push for deglobalization, reshoring and nearshoring and will inevitably impact supply chains, hopefully for the good. These elements underscore the need for companies to prioritize supply chain resilience, sustainable sourcing and production, regulatory adaptation, market diversification and strategic partnerships. These are the types of companies found in our Building Better Markets theme.

International collaboration and cooperation are essential in addressing wealth inequalities and navigating geopolitical challenges. In an effort to counter potentially stronger ties between Russia and China, Western countries have come together to impose sanctions and export bans. Frameworks like the EU 10-Point plan have also had success in coming together to meet the energy needs of their population Multilateral frameworks and agreements can foster shared objectives, facilitate knowledge exchange, and promote sustainable practices across borders. Countries with stronger environmental and labor practices will be well positioned for friendshoring and more favourable to foreign investment opportunities.

 

Redefining the Rules: Regulation’s Role

Regulation plays a pivotal role in driving the movement towards better markets. Government policies and mandates are instrumental in setting the stage for companies to prioritize sustainability and responsible practices. Regulations related to ESG reporting, corporate governance, environmental protection, social welfare, and responsible investing set the standards for corporate sustainability.

There are an increasing number of laws pushing companies to adopt better operational practices. One example is the EU law, passed in 2022, that mandates mobile phones, tablets and cameras sold in the EU to have a USB Type-C charging port by the end of 2024. Other laws in the lineup are "the right to repair" as mentioned in the table below. Companies that already embody these practices will be ahead of the game.

 

For a list of recent social regulations, see our note “Fast and Furious: A Distressing Tale of the Fashion Industry”, February 24, 2022.

Investor expectations and activism also play a significant role in shaping the regulatory landscape. Investors are increasingly incorporating ESG factors into their decision-making processes and demanding transparency and accountability from companies. This has led regulatory bodies and financial institutions to adopt rules and frameworks that require companies to disclose relevant ESG information and adhere to sustainable practices, like the GHG emissions disclosure rules from the SEC. Governments and regulatory bodies are pushing for greater disclosure of environmental, social, and governance data through initiatives like the EU taxonomy, which provides guidelines for classifying sustainable economic activities.

This evolving regulatory environment emphasizes the importance of data disclosure and transparency. Financial market regulations are becoming more proactive in addressing income inequality and favoring wealth redistribution through corporate and income tax policies. Again, early adopters of these frameworks, considered as sustainability leaders, will be ready and rewarded. This type of companies make up our Sustainability DNA subtheme.

Wired for Change: Technology as a Catalyst

Technology is a driving force in enabling transformative changes and reshaping the financial landscape. Technological advancements, such as digital platforms, data analytics, artificial intelligence, and blockchain, are enabling the integration of ESG factors into core business processes. These advancements allow companies to gather, analyze and report relevant data, improve supply chain transparency, develop sustainable products and services, and enhance stakeholder engagement.

Technological innovation plays a crucial role in developing sustainable solutions across industries. Advancements in clean energy technologies, circular economy models, smart cities, and sustainable transportation are all examples of how technology can drive economic growth while minimizing environmental impact.

In some cases, technology is helping to bridge unequal access to important services. One example of this is the expansion of financial services through apps and digital platforms has increased access to investment and wealth management, reaching a broader population. The worldwide market size of neobanks is expected to be multiplied by over 40 within 10 years, in 2030, with innovations empowering individuals who may have previously been underserved by traditional institutions, and emerging markets are its best example. As shown in the chart below, the penetration of digital banking in Latin America is high, with Brazil leading the way.

Furthermore, nearly nine in ten consumers across the emerging and developed markets of the Asia–Pacific region use digital banking actively, and most of these are open to purchasing more banking services through digital channels. Companies enabling this are reflected in the economic participation subtheme of Building Better Markets.

Since our last quarterly macro meets sustainability update – published March 15, 2023 – financial risks have significantly diminished. Less than three months ago, the fall of SVB bank triggered a mini-banking crisis, but since then, U.S. and global bank CDS spreads have collapsed, the VIX is below 15, and the NASDAQ index has rallied significantly. Crisis averted – at least for now.

Although the likelihood of a banking crisis is now severely diminished, the outlook for risky assets remains gloomy in our view.

To be sure, the AI fuelled rally in tech stocks may have some juice left, but the threat of further central bank hawkishness means that the risk/reward trade-off of betting on further gains is deteriorating. After all, the policy hikes last week and accompanying hawkish tone were enough to send a negative jolt to global interest rate sensitive stocks.

In the U.S. and elsewhere, we expect upcoming inflation prints to be relatively benign, given year-over-year comparisons with last year’s May and June surging inflation rates. However, this will not be enough to end the Fed hiking campaign; inflation is still outside of acceptable range for policymakers with core CPI still above the overnight rate.

Meanwhile, although consumers in most advanced economies are still spending, thanks both to lingering savings built up during the pandemic as well as ongoing tightness in the job market, industrial activity is less buoyant. Manufacturing surveys in the U.S. and elsewhere show that current levels of pessimism typically coincided with economy-wide recession. We expect that consumers will also become increasingly downbeat as higher interest rates and tighter lending conditions begin to bite more substantially. With this backdrop, we continue to advise investors to overweight high impact, defensive sectors like health care and grocery stores. Despite a manufacturing slowdown, there remain select opportunities in industrial stocks that are best positioned for the energy transition and ongoing fiscal stimulus. Indeed, the chart below highlights that constructors of manufacturing facilities are already enjoying a massive boom thanks to the Inflation Reduction Act.

Finally, we reiterate our bullish conviction toward sustainability plays in Japan.

Macro Is Supporting Innately Sustainable Japan

Japanese stocks have been among the best performing risk assets year to date, a trend that we believe can continue in the months ahead. Weakness in the Japanese yen (which is typically bullish for Japanese equities) is unlikely to reverse anytime soon, given that the Bank of Japan appears in no rush to join its peers and tighten monetary policy. Furthermore, an important tailwind is coming from foreign investors who have recently increased allocations to this country, attracted by relatively cheap equity valuations.

As we highlighted in a recent note (“Sustainability Is Big in Japan”, December 1, 2022), Japanese companies are often highly aligned with sustainability principles, given cultural and geographic characteristics of the country. Indeed, within the Sustainable Market Strategies investment universe, Japanese companies have, on average, higher sustainability rankings than the rest of our universe. Among the companies that we believe will perform well based on the macro and sustainability backdrop are: Asahi Holdings, Denso, Kubota, Kurita, Marubeni and Oji Holdings.

H1 Climate Disasters Bring Adaptation Into Focus

Beyond the monetary and growth conditions highlighted above, a second major sustainability trend that should not catch any investor off-guard is the proliferation of climate disasters this year. The number of costly and frequent climate disasters has been rising for the past decade, and 2023 will not be an exception to this trend.

Some climate disasters are direct forces of nature, while others are clear, direct acts by humans.

War is never good for environmental health and the ongoing Russian invasion of Ukraine is no exception. Last week’s Nova Kakhovka dam burst is being considered “ecocide” by environmentalists and politicians alike. At least 150 tons of oil has been taken by the current to the Black Sea so far and unpredictable amounts of chemicals, fertilizers and oil products that were stored in the flooded areas will end up in the rivers and sea.

Meanwhile, Quebec wildfires made headlines last week, not in small part because winds blew smoke and particles to the south, briefly New York City one of the worst air quality scores in the world. The delocalization of the inhabitants of several towns has (finally) sparked a larger conversation about the necessity to fund climate adaptation. Our expectation is that as more and more climate disasters occur, there will be increasing realization of the need to invest in our ability to adapt to be resilient to climate change. Of course, adaptation will not be uniform and will range from building flood defences, setting up early warning systems for cyclones, switching to drought-resistant crops, and so on.

There is room for the private sector to provide adaptation solutions (this will be the subject of an upcoming research note) but much of the funding and programs associated with climate adaptation will need to come from the public sector. This is because the benefits of climate adaptation infrastructure are often difficult to quantify and monetize in a way that creates the cash flows required for the private sector to invest.

So far, most experts agree that adaptation is massively underfunded. For example, in a recent report from the UN, Adaptation Gap Report 2022, it was estimated that worldwide annual adaptation needs will be between $160 billion to $340 billion by the end of the decade, and up to $565 billion by 2050.

As SMS readers know, one of our major structural investment theses is that fiscal policy will become an ever-greater force in financial markets and the economy at large. This is because monetary policy is a less effective tool in solving the major environmental and social challenges of our time. Financing climate adaptation will, on the margin, put extra pressure on government budgets.

Up until February 2022, the defense and military sector’s stock performance had pretty much stagnated for half a decade as budgets were being cut and the world was enjoying a quasi-conflict-free phase. This period also coincided with the rise of ESG investing which came with its suite of sectoral exclusions. Defense stocks were rapidly labelled as “sin stocks” along with tobacco, coal, gambling, and alcohol. In fact, controversial weapons are, to this day, the most excluded activity with over 70% of European funds excluding them, while about 50% exclude civilian firearms and 35% exclude conventional military equipment and services. Prior to February 2022, the reasoning was flawless: Defense companies make products that kill people, and are often sold to bad actors – for instance to Saudi Arabia, even despite Jamal Khashoggi’s murder in 2018.

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine on February 24, 2022 changed a lot of things – including how some ESG-minded investors are looking at the defense sector.

The consensus before the invasion was that it was just flexing and positioning on Putin’s part. We were all wrong. Then we were certain that Ukraine would surrender in a matter of days. Wrong again. These days, we like to think that China would never do the unthinkable and make a move for Taiwan. However, we may have to face the fact that we live in an increasingly uncertain world with a greater likelihood of major geopolitical moves making lasting impacts on our lives and our investments. One of these impacts for investors is the subject of this week’s note: Can defense stocks be considered in an ESG portfolio?

For the first time since the creation of the Munich Security Index (a global risk perception survey conducted by the Munich Security Conference) in 2014, security has replaced climate change as the top concern among the 12,000 respondents.

Governments too are concerned about security, and defense budgets are shooting up to historically high levels.

In and of itself, an increased interest from investors and bigger budgets should not influence whether defense stocks belong in and ESG portfolio or not. The change in mindset came from the Ukraine invasion and the West’s response of sending military equipment to support the Ukrainian resistance. After all, security is a human right enshrined in human rights treaties and most would agree that the right to defend oneself and preserve sovereignty does not go against any ESG principles. This is one element that separates defense-related activities from tobacco or gambling for instance, where it is legitimately difficult to see any wider social good from those activities.

Defense hawks might even argue that there is a social benefit to consider too: well-equipped military can act as “armed deterrence”, preventing conflict and maintaining stability in the international system. By having a powerful military, they argue, potential adversaries will be deterred from aggressive actions, thereby reducing the likelihood of conflict and promoting a safer world. As the saying goes: “weapons are harmful – but they are even more harmful if those who threaten you have them and you do not”.

The conundrum is, however, that defensive weapons are indistinguishable from offensive weapons – it’s a matter of perspective – and the pendulum between global good and evil can rapidly swing.

Nonetheless, this is a bet that some asset managers are willing to take in light of the Russian invasion. For instance, Swedish financial group SEB announced in March 2022 that it would start permitting some of its funds to buy shares of weapons makers and defense companies, reversing a position it adopted a year prior as part of its ESG commitments. SEB justified the change of tack by claiming the war in Ukraine had softened some of its clients’ view on the defense sector.

Defense No-Go Zones: Controversial Weapons and Weak Governance

Relaxing ESG exclusions for the defense sector should not be unbridled, however. There are good ‘S’ and ‘G’ reasons to continue to exclude large swaths of the sector. For instance, “controversial weapons” are unjustifiable in an ESG portfolio because these weapons – which include biological, chemical and incendiary weapons, white phosphorus, landmines, cluster bombs, depleted uranium and nuclear weapons outside of the international non-proliferation treaty – are often used in ways that violate human rights. For example, landmines and cluster munitions have been used over and over to kill civilians, whether intentionally or not. Although there is some debate over what should be considered a controversial weapon or not, a good starting point is to stick to the definitions in international treaties (Convention on Cluster Munitions, Ottawa Convention on the Prohibition of Anti-Personal Mines, Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, Chemicals Weapon Convention, and the Biological Weapons Convention).

Another exclusionary filter that should be applied relates to Governance. The defense sector is notorious for operating behind closed doors and entertaining an incestuous relationship with the government. It was recently revealed that as of 2021, 672 former Pentagon, Congress and other Government Agencies’ officials were working for the top 20 defense contractors, with the vast majority – 91 percent – effectively lobbying the very government they formerly worked for. This revolving door between the military-industrial complex and government agencies is perfectly correlated with the government contracts these companies receive. In 2021 and 2022, Lockheed Martin, Boeing, Raytheon, General Dynamics, and Northrop Grumman – also known as the “Defense Primes” – were the top 5 federal defense contractors in the U.S. and they also had some of the highest numbers of “revolving door hires” out of the top 20 contractors. Between the five of them, they provided 60% of the total lobbying money spent by more than 200 companies in the defense industry in 2022.

This defense oligopoly is a problem for ESG investors. Half a century ago, the U.S. relied on 50 major arms contractors, but a massive consolidation has brought that number down to five – the Defense Primes. This concentration of defense technology expertise only gives the Pentagon few choices of where to go for the production of major weapons systems, raising the risk of price hikes and irresponsible behavior when it comes to delivering weapons that can perform as advertised (e.g. Lockheed Martin’s F-35 saga).

Now that we have determined that ESG-minded investors should probably avoid the Defense Primes altogether, what criteria should be considered to gain exposure to the sector while respecting basic responsible investment principles?

First, controversial weapons should be avoided at all costs. Second, companies working with both civilian and government clients are better protected in case of massive government policy changes following an election or even a severe austerity plan. Finally, according to SASB, the material ESG elements for the Aerospace & Defense Industry are: Energy Management, Hazardous Waste Management, Data Security, Product Safety, Fuel Economy & Emissions in Use-phase, Materials Sourcing, and Business Ethics. Companies which score well in these categories could therefore be interesting candidates for inclusion in ESG portfolios.

 

These five companies – the SMS Secondary Defense Contractors – all happen to be Europeans. Due to the level of ESG maturity in Europe, this should not come as a surprise. American companies in the defense industry are more likely to be involved in controversial weapons and suffering from a low score with regard to business ethics and transparency.

From a stock performance perspective, the SMS Secondary Defense Contractors basket underperformed the S&P 500 and the Defense Primes for most of the last 5 years but outperformed massively since the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Although some macro factors partially explain why the European names contained in the Secondary Defense Contractors basket did so well since October 2022 (e.g. optimistic easing calendar, consistently strong earnings, etc.) these companies are also more directly involved in the global efforts to supply Ukraine with state-of-the-art military equipment.

With Price to earnings ratios in-line with the general market – the S&P 500 P/E is about 19 – but a growth perspective more attractive than the rest of the market thanks in part to the defense spending having been increased. Timing could therefore still be on the side of an ESG investors wanting to add some defense-exposed companies to her portfolio. Leonardo S.p.a. and Rheinmetall AG could be particularly interesting due to their valuation and contract pipelines.

The rise of private assets in institutional portfolios is one of the great investment stories of the last decade. Indeed, the GFC prompted many investors to reduce their exposure to publicly listed assets to shelter their portfolios against market volatility and diversify sources of returns. Furthermore, private asset investors were also blessed with a 15-year-long monetary détente which acted as a major tailwind to the PE industry. With inflation roaring back last year and Central Banks “normalizing” monetary policy, PE allocations became especially relevant and convenient in preserving returns amid the market rout. Many institutional pension funds reported positive returns in their PE portfolios despite negative returns for other asset classes. While PE investments are normally marked-to-market, their “resilient” paper returns continue to amaze many market participants – including this research service.

In the buoyant investment context of the past decade, listed private equity firms such as KKR, Blackstone, TPG, The Carlyle Group and EQT have made their PE investment models available to retail investors by listing publicly. These investors were not immune to the changing tide of the past few months – PE firms have underperformed the MSCI World Financials index by about 15 percentage points on an equal-weighted basis. To this end, the demise of SVB as well as the response from the U.S. Treasury to offer yet another bail out to the financial sector – which suggests a significant financial stress – puts further pressure on the even riskier PE sector. With the perfect storm of tighter financial conditions, the repricing of growth/PE/VC type investments, lesser amounts of carried interest and slower prospects for fund-raising, it is not surprising that listed-PE firms have underperformed the overall financial sector over the past year.

 

Looking at sector exposure of listed private equity firms, one sees that some firms are now forced to navigate a perfect storm in Real estate, Tech and Financial Services. Unsurprisingly, listed-PE firms with a higher exposure to tech and growth companies underperformed those with a relatively higher exposure to energy sectors (Carlyle Group and TPG are in the latter group).

While EQT has re-repriced considerably in the past 18 months, firms such as KKR and Blackstone have yet to fully price-in current monetary conditions. From a valuation perspective, Blackstone appears especially vulnerable to the “gravity pull” of a serious repricing of its real estate, financial and tech portfolios in the coming months. Moreover, for PE fund managers to preserve their own financial stability, we expect an increasing number of investors with little exposure to PE to enter the asset class at very favorable terms - akin to the recent deal between the Regents of the University of California and Blackstone which granted advantageous terms for the U of C. In that, we view that the current liquidity crunch and its impact on listed-PE firms’ revenue and profit outlook puts further pressure on listed-PE firms’ stock prices.

Furthermore, publicly listed-PE fund managers are often criticized for their opaque structure – which typically gets even more opaque when valuations start sinking as they have done since last year. In fact, it is hard to truly assess the value of listed-PE fund managers as they are mostly a “pass through” of the underlying companies they hold. In short, the number of subsidiaries and varying valuation methodologies make it hard to put a price on listed-PE firms, especially in a context of receding financial liquidity and rising interest rates.  

We see several reasons why investing in listed private equity asset managers could be problematic for investors with a concern for governance:

Hidden Fees: investors in listed public equity firms don’t really know the true level of fees they are paying on the deals that make it into the holding firm’s portfolio.

Upper Hands: investors don’t really know the extent to which each deal also encompasses “side deals” whereby partners or other entities gravitating around deals can access better terms than listed-PE firm investors. Furthermore, it’s hard to understand who between 1) listed-PE company shareholders, 2) listed-PE company partners or 3) PE investee company founders - or for that matter any other party - really gets the better deal when transactions are brought to the table. After all, whatever happens in terms of side deals may remain forever secret to many listed-PE stakeholders and shareholders.

Successor Funds and Illiquidity: when liquidity becomes scarce, successor funds often buy out earlier vintages in a way that gives a false sense of price and liquidity to the market.

Taxes Paid: the number of entities controlled by listed-PE firms suggests a great use of tax havens and tax avoidance practices which makes it likely that listed-PE firms true tax effort remains below average. In fact, one can see that 1) US-based listed-PE firms pay less taxes than their European peers and 2) listed-PE firms also pay less effective taxes than the overall financial sector.

As a result, investors looking for a maximum level of transparency in investments they make in publicly listed companies must learn to “look through” governance practices of listed-PE firms. Indeed, most ESG rating agencies rate listed private equity firms with poor governance score, with the bigger ones just above the passing grade with a less than stellar “D-”.

Finally, less than optimal transparency and governance structures of many listed-PE firms’ investee companies does not necessarily mean that they do not invest in innovative solutions in sustainability-themed sectors such as housing, energy efficiency and climate tech. While sustainability-inclined investors are typically also interested in governance aspects of their investments, the relatively low level of transparency of listed-PE firms could make them think twice about such an idea. It’s just that the level of murkiness of these firms - especially in times of financial stress - could become increasingly problematic for investors looking for transparency.

The recent spotlight on the Adani Group, an EM darling for several sustainability-driven investors and its involvement in many renewable power projects, underscores the perils of investing in EMs. Subsidiaries within the wider Adani Group are trading at a 30-45 percentage point discount to their January levels following a report from Hindenburg Research suggesting that the Group’s leaders have been fudging numbers while artificially inflating the stock price.  

This scandal emerged as low interest rates of the past decade made EMs relatively attractive – which may have encouraged investors to look away from the region’s generally weaker governance structures. After all, many investors look hard to find investments with acceptable level of ESG risk and impact potential in EMs despite their relatively low level of ESG disclosures. Interestingly, in the case of Adani Enterprises, the company faired well in global ESG scoring databases, as evidenced by its “top tier” rank in governance percentile scores not only among its Indian peers – but also globally – in CSRHub.

While such “governance fails” are somewhat expected in less stringent regulatory environments such as those found in many EMs, it is worth reminding that these cases can still happen in very large groups such as Adani, despite the amount of investor scrutiny these conglomerates are under. For instance, the case of Azure Power, another Indian renewable power company facing issues with its internal controls and accounting, has ballooned into the media and is rapidly becoming an issue for its investors, which include large Canadian pension funds such as CDPQ and OMERS.  

Despite these alarming headlines, corporate scandals – at least those that have been made public – are actually less frequent in EMs than in DMs, perhaps due to the over-representation of DM-listed companies over EM-listed companies in global markets. To this end, a recently published study suggests that as much as 10% of publicly-listed firms could commit securities fraud every year. In this context, when data is weak and goes missing like it is the case in many EM-based companies, looking at an alternative set of data points becomes a necessity for investors to add additional safeguards. Today’s note looks at 1) EM attractiveness in a context of growing scrutiny and 2) relevant metrics to assess corporate governance risks in EMs.

Are EMs a missed opportunity?

Despite their promises – and even since China’s incredible economic ascension since the 1990’s – EM companies have considerably underperformed their DM peers over the last decade. Looking at price indices only, a DM investor would have doubled her money if she had chosen to invest in DMs over EMs over the past ten years. In that, one could say EM investors lost another decade in markets since 2013.

More recently, although EMs’ relative performance to DM improved in the second half of 2022, it seems that like their DMs peers, EM companies are also suffering from their elevated corporate debt ratios – especially in hard currency– and slowing global trade flows. According to the IMF’s 2022 Global Debt Monitor, both DMs and EMs corporates now have above-100 percent debt-to-GDP ratios.

Given the global slowdown and mounting pressures in EMs, the Citi Economic Surprise index of EMs had already started underperforming that of G10 economies in late 2022. While China’s re-opening post-COVID restriction somewhat boosted economic activity in EMs, and with it the CESI EM index, it’s hard to see how the momentum will be maintained through 2023. Moreover, growing interest rate differentials between DMs over EMs will also create additional liquidity shortages in EMs which could further hamper their ability to deliver interesting returns to investors going forward. That said, there are still some positive stories developing in some EM countries such as Mexico (and other Latam countries) as well as in Asia (such as Korea) which could benefit from and near-shoring strategies out of China over the medium term.

EM Companies’ governance performance – the good, the bad and the ugly

One way to look at EM management teams’ relative governance performance over their DM peers is to look at metrics around leadership, ethics and transparency. In this case, CSRHub defines “leadership & ethics” as “the effectiveness in treating all shareholders equitably” while “transparency” is defined as “the management of the company being transparent to its stakeholders”.

Looking at leadership and ethics data from CSRHub, the good news is that between 2017 and 2022, leadership and ethics in EM companies’ management teams has improved in many—if not all industry groups in the top 100 companies (by market cap) included in the MSCI EM Index. The level of leadership and ethics demonstrated in the largest EM companies is now in the top tier on a global basis.

Conversely, the top 100 EM companies’ (by market cap) transparency and reporting efforts have lost some ground compared to their global peers among between 2017 and 2022. In this context, EM companies—and indeed stock exchanges and regulators—ought to review their disclosure requirements for EM companies to remain attractive to the growing number of sustainability-minded investors always looking for more transparency.

Furthermore, there remain industries where management teams’ EM leadership and ethics skills are surpassing that of DM counterparts; this is especially the case for Travel, Sports & Leisure and Education & Government. However, overall, where EM companies closely track DM companies on leadership and ethics grounds, transparency still falls short of what can be expected in DM companies in all industry groups.

A secondary check that can help investors decrease the risk of being sidelined by EM governance issues is to look at what management – especially insiders – are doing with their equity. Indeed, as far as governance standards go, legal frameworks and ESG disclosures of many EM companies are often lower than those of their DM counterparts, and investors must thus use an additional amount of “street sense” when looking to invest in EM companies. One way to see how broader investors’ interests may “align” with that of the management team of EM-listed companies is to look at insider interest as a percentage of total share ownership, and its link to profitability and performance metrics such as ROE and/or ROA.

For this exercise, we looked at the relationship between insider holdings and ROE of companies included in the MSCI iShares MSCI Developed Core ETF; one sees that the relationship appears flat.

Conversely, if one looks at companies included in the iShares MSCI EM ETF, the amount of insider interest appears positively correlated with ROE – albeit with a weak statistical link. One way to think about this is that in the absence of clear data and low access to management, investors might as well “line up” with management teams to boost their chances of making positive returns.

For all investors, staying on top of the regulatory framework, best practices and political landscape is necessary to generate positive returns. But for investors focused on sustainability, the challenge is even greater; definitions and approaches to sustainability investing in many jurisdictions remain nebulous.   

In Today’s note, we address our readers’ top questions regarding the regulatory and political landscape, to clarify and anticipate how the sustainability rules of the game may affect participants.

Question 1: Let’s start in Europe. What is going on with SFDRs? Why are so many funds being downgraded from Article 9 to Article 8?

There has been a lot of media attention about recent downgrades of European funds from “Article 9 to Article 8”. Recall that under European financial regulation, all investment funds must now be classified as either Article 6, 8 or 9; the higher the number, the more sustainable: for example, an Article 8 fund is defined as promoting environmental or social characteristics (light green funds) while an Article 9 must have a sustainable investment objective (dark green funds).

Asset managers have been required to classify their funds since March 2021, but earlier this month, tighter compliance around the classification has been applied. In anticipation of this, many asset managers downgraded their funds from Article 9 to Article 8 late last year; under the realization that their funds would not qualify for Article 9.

To be sure, this is causing frustration among investors who believed they were purchasing an investment product with a particular goal in mind. It could also shake the credibility of Europe’s approach to sustainability via the SFDR.

However, recent data suggests the opposite. Despite these high-profile downgrades, there is heightened demand for the greenest of investment products: according to Morningstar data, while non-sustainable (Article 6) funds saw marked outflows in the latter part of 2022, there were net inflows into Article 9 funds as well as far less outflows from Article 8 funds. This underscores that there is a strong and growing market for high-grade sustainable investment products.

In our view, the downgrading of certain funds suggests that EU taxonomy is “working”; asset managers believe the consequences from mislabelling their products are high enough that they are taking corrective action.

Question 2: What does all this mean for the next leg of EU disclosure rules, is “social” still on the table?

At the outset, the European commission had set a goal of sustainability taxonomy and disclosures for both environmental and social issues. The goal of the social taxonomy is to classify economic activities that contribute to the EU’s social goals and provide guidelines for investors, businesses and regulators. In early 2002, a social taxonomy proposal was published by the EU, but since then, work has stalled. Unlike for the environmental taxonomy, there is no formal timeline set out for social taxonomy and according to some sources, there is little likelihood of progress until 2024 or beyond.  

Question 3: What about in the U.S.? It seems like there are forever delays in improving financial disclosure around climate.

There are two positive developments in the U.S. that we view of interest for investors concerned with climate change risks and opportunities.

First, the U.S. SEC is getting closer to instituting a new rule will require audited emissions data to be included in corporate financial reports. After a notable rise in greenwashing lawsuits (see chart below), the SEC plans to enact the new regulation before May 2023. Companies will need to describe in their annual 10-Ks (i.e. detailed financial report) their strategy toward climate risk, data on Scope 1 and 2 greenhouse gas emissions and obtain independent attestation of the data.

Second, the three main U.S. banking regulators (Federal Reserve, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp) released draft guidance on how they want large U.S. banks to manage exposure to climate change; final guidance is expected later this year. In addition, beginning in 2023, the Federal Reserve, now requires the country’s six largest banks to undergo “pilot” climate scenario analysis, aimed at providing clarity on how lenders are thinking about climate risks.

Together, the SEC proposal and the monitoring of systemically important banks regarding climate change will help investors have a clearer view of the risks and opportunities in their portfolio.

Question 4: What about other countries? Is there anything we need to know?

Investors in the U.K. have also started grappling with new regulation in regard to sustainability. The U.K.’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has issued its proposal for sustainability disclosure requirements (SDRs), which is largely the U.K. equivalent of Europe’s SFDRs. The consultation period ends this week and according to the preliminary timeline, the final rules will be published this June and enforced starting in June 2024.

The main difference between the EU’s SFDR and the U.K.’s SDR proposal is that the latter is a labelling regime, not a disclosure regime. If products do not meet the qualifying criteria under the FCA's proposals, they will not be able to use any of the regulator's sustainable investment labels, which are: “sustainable focus”, “sustainable transitioning” and “sustainable impact”. The flow chart below highlights how the UK labels correspond to the EU’s Articles 6, 8 and 9.

Ultimately, we continue to believe that disclosure and regulation around labelling will help investors and market participants avoid greenwashing. The main challenge is for investors and industry participants that sell products in multiple markets: complying to multiple national frameworks is complex and burdensome. There are various initiatives at work to harmonize various standards, such as the Global Reporting Initiative and International Sustainability Standards Board collaboration, but it is unlikely that concrete steps will be taken in 2023.  

Question 5: What about voluntary carbon offsets? Isn’t it high time these are standardized and regulated?

Voluntary carbon offset programs have been around for close to twenty years but have recently grown exponentially, given the number of institutions that will need to use offsets to reach their net zero goals.

The voluntary offset market includes a wide range of programs, entities, standards, and protocols. However, the lack of standardized quality criteria, has generated plenty of concern that voluntary offsets are, at best, unproductive and at worst, fraudulent. A case in points: a recent article in The Guardian uncovered that Verra, one of the most commonly used carbon offset providers in the world uses projects whereby more than 90% of their rainforest offset credits are likely to be “phantom credits” and do not represent genuine carbon reductions. 

Clearly, efforts to regulate the voluntary offset market have been wholly insufficient so far, but there are two international groups trying to address the issue by establishing new guardrails for offsets. The Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market (ICVCM) and the Voluntary Carbon Markets Integrity Initiative (VCMI) — were created in 2021, and include representatives from governments, businesses, non-profits, etc. ICVCM focuses on the characteristics that would render a particular carbon offset project legitimate, while VCMI is attempting to establish how companies should be permitted to use offsets. The supposition is that once international guidelines are in place, offsets that adhere to the guidelines will be more credible and therefore help institutions make better quality offset choices. ICVCM’s current plan is to release a first set of requirements in March.  

Question 6: What else is on your radar?

We expect that the top two issues that could change the investment landscape specific to sustainability are the political sentiment surrounding ESG in the U.S. and the “climate incentive war” between the U.S. and Europe. We view both as positive developments for sustainability.

As is now well known, in 2022, “ESG” backlash resulted in some U.S. states enacting legislation preventing them from contracting with banks and asset managers with ESG policies, removed state funding from these firms, or reinvested state pension policies. But as Larry Fink (CEO, Blackrock) adroitly pointed out, the $4B withdrawn by Republican states was more than offset by $230B in US inflows last year. This underscores the notion that the global demand for sustainability investment products is growing much faster than the support for Republican “anti-ESG” ideas.

Nonetheless, Republicans are continuing their work from last year, and Republican state-attorneys general have begun 2023 by accusing ISS and Glass Lewis – the two companies that control about 97% of the market share for voting advice – of running afoul of laws and contractual obligations for state investments by prioritizing environmental and social concerns. Our base case is that these actions coming from Republican states will have little consequence over the next two years, i.e. while Joe Biden remains U.S. president, but this could change thereafter. We view all of this media attention as positive and contributing toward the legitimization of sustainability as a conventional and worthy investment approach.

A second issue is the current green stimulus battle between the U.S. and Europe, which could end up as the most beneficial “trade war” of our lifetime! 

The U.S. Inflation Reduction Act, which includes significant tax breaks and subsidies amounting to a boost for US production of electric vehicles, solar panels, batteries, etc. has been widely lauded as a significant win for slowing climate change. However, the EU regards these subsidies as contrary to fair competition.

European policymakers, it appears, will be forced to initiate their own subsidy packages for climate investment to level the playing field. Europe’s response could take shape as early as next month at the extraordinary summit of the leaders of the EU (where the main topics will be migration and the EU’s global competitiveness). 

All in all, the major likely developments in 2023 are pointing in the same direction: increasing legitimacy and clarity around sustainability investing.

The approximately 400 private planes landing in Davos for the World Economic Forum this week led us to reflect on how the richest have the potential to change from being the greatest climate change offenders to being leaders (as previously mentioned in a note from summer 2022: Lifestyles of the Rich and the Famous and the future of Global Warming, July 7, 2022). Moreover with the luxury hype surrounding China’s reopening, we thought it would be appropriate to cover the luxury goods sector this week. Companies in this space produce high-end products sold at a premium price and generally claim to be sustainable. Do not be fooled, these companies have great marketing machines, as the following chart of Louis Vuitton’s marketing expenses since 2010, shows.

The main factor that makes luxury goods unsustainable is the focus on consumerism. Luxury companies create obsolescence for profits by releasing new products and collections. This contributes to a culture of excess and waste, as people feel pressure to keep up and purchase new products to maintain their status. Depletion of natural resources from the rising demand of materials leads to negative environmental and social impacts. For example, many luxury goods are made from materials such as leather and exotic skins that are resource-intensive to produce and contribute to environmental degradation. Additionally, the manufacturing process for luxury goods generates significant waste and carbon emissions. Overall, while luxury goods companies may produce high-quality products and support the creative craftsmanship of artisans, they are not sustainable due to their resource-intensive production processes, consumerism, excess packaging, and high price point.

Luxury companies charge premium prices due to the perception of exclusivity and prestige associated with their brands. These companies rely on strong marketing and advertising strategies to create brand loyalty resulting in a loyal customer base that is willing to pay higher prices for the luxury goods and services that they offer. It is important to stay ahead of trends and understand customer preferences to remain competitive in the luxury market. To protect luxury company profits, high-quality products and services must be offered along with strong brand image to ensure repeat customers. Companies recently realized that sustainability is taking precedence in the customer’s mind as an attractive feature. To that end, we can see that ESG scores for most luxury companies are very high, as the table below shows. Similar to tobacco companies, luxury companies with huge profit margins and large marketing budgets are putting all the right policies in place to appeal to sustainable consumers. For example, there are only twelve firms that have received AAA from CDP for climate, water and forests. Philip Morris is one ; Firmenich, a private fragrance and taste company Beiersdorf, a closely held skin care company and Louis Vuitton, which we analyze in this note are three others in the luxury space.

 It is great that these companies have policies and practices in place to optimize their operations from a sustainability standpoint. The problem is their product and the overconsumption and excess packaging it comes with.

To illustrate, according to Eikon, the 17 companies listed in the table above have a policy on resource reduction in production (including reduction in the use of water and energy, and raw materials) but less than half have any associated reduction targets. Reporting from luxury companies can sometimes be misleading. For example, Kering states in its latest sustainability report that it “sourced in the most responsible and sustainable manner”. This leaves a lot of room for interpretation!

Luxury companies have done so well since the Global Financial Crisis (2007-2008) that many investors believe that they are immune to risk because the rich are not affected by inflation as much as others. The two charts below highlight the historical performance of luxury compared to the market. The first chart starts with the launch of the S&P Global Luxury Index in 2005 and compares it to a global index. The second chart illustrates the behavior of a subset of French luxury brands compared to the French index during the dot-com era which was prior to the existence of the luxury index. As we can see in both charts, when the overall market falls, luxury tends to fall more. One fundamental justification for this behavior is that when wealth suffers from falling asset prices, even the rich are worried and become thrifty and those that pretended to be rich, prefer to eat.

In the current market environment of higher interest rates, we expect excess spending to be further curtailed from the negative wealth effect - investors have not only lost on their equity portfolio, but their fixed-income portfolio has also suffered in 2022 and private assets are likely to follow suit in 2023. Moreover, we anticipate labor shortages to be part of the economic equation for the next decade as baby boomers retire and are replaced with a smaller generation Z. After a very long period where capital has been handsomely rewarded compared to labor, we believe that inequalities will decline naturally as workers get a bigger slice of the pie. This should lead to less demand for luxury as profits (which is the major source of wealth for the well-to-do) decline as a percentage of the economy.

When we examine the specific financial characteristics of our luxury company subset, as shown in the tables below, we see that these companies are highly sensitive to market movements, have good margins and decent growth but trade at very high valuation.

In this first table we see that most luxury companies have a Beta greater than 1.

This second table shows their high profitability (over 10% net margin, for most) and decent growth which was very strong last year compared to previous years that were affected by the pandemic.

The final table highlights the high valuation of luxury companies (many have a forward P/E over 20), especially when one accounts for the rise in interest rates. There are a few companies with leverage issues (like Nordstrom), but it is not a major problem for the segment as a whole.

If our 2022 investment outlook note could be reduced to one investment adage – “power of diversification” – then SMS’ outlook theme for 2023 takes a page from Warren Buffett and focuses on “knowing the difference between price and value”. We believe that the bear market in stocks that got underway in 2022 is not yet over, but that 2023 will nonetheless offer opportunity for bargains in high-quality sustainable companies that are positioned for a low-carbon, high-care economy.

From a macro perspective, we expect there will be less surprises about inflation in 2023 (trending lower, but still above 2%) but ongoing uncertainty about the timing of recession. The chart below shows the evolution of our expectations about different macro investment scenarios; we expect recessionary conditions to linger for most of the year leading broad equity indices to trend lower until there is early evidence of a positive inflection point in the economic cycle. Equity markets have priced in the higher interest rate environment but not the fall in profitability. For now, a soft landing with no recession seems to be priced in markets.

Against this backdrop, and with our approach to investing that is focused on finding tradeable sustainability themes and the best companies that embody them, it is no surprise that we enter the year with a defensive tilt that offers downside protection. As the second half of the bear market unfolds, we will intensify our focus to find beaten-down names that offer superior value. A catalyst for the latter will be once forward earnings expectations turn firmly negative, which should serve as a sign that investor sentiment reflects economic reality.

We therefore kick off 2023 with a list of our high conviction investment ideas, with an eye on value: In the very short term, we look to protect capital in defensive areas of the stock market until a recession is well advanced. Looking further out into 2023, we expect conditions to be in place to be able to shift capital to select higher beta companies once the Fed reaches the end of its tightening campaign.

Idea #1: Long Energy Efficiency

Within the energy sector, we expect energy efficiency plays to outperform in 2023. Oil prices will be volatile, while companies involved in renewable energy production are often growth-oriented and highly sensitive to the interest rate backdrop, which we expect will continue to be a headwind for now. In contrast, many energy efficiency companies, e.g. companies that manufacture and/or provide solutions such as heat pumps, HVACs, and smart metering, tend to have low P/Es and trade as value stocks.  

Energy efficiency is one of only a few areas that are well-supported by fiscal policy in 2023. According to the IEA, over half of OECD countries have generous subsidies for heat pumps and other energy-conserving products, with the RePower EU plan among the most ambitious; the EU must double the current roll-out rate in the next five years if its heat pump targets are to be achieved. In the U.S., the Inflation Reduction Act also provides significant support for heat pumps, offering subsidies up to $14, 000 per household.

The following companies have strong sustainability characteristics on an operational basis (i.e. ESG), provide excellent energy efficiency solutions, and are in good financial health: Carrier, Johnson Controls, Nibe, and Trane Technologies.

Idea #2 An ESG Comeback: Short Greenwashers

Events in 2022 sparked a necessary shakeout for “ESG” and responsible investment. Although recent focus has been on the asset management industry, these debates have been helpful at shining a spotlight on all false claims whether they be at the investment or corporate level.

Companies that embellish their sustainability credentials risk being punished in this environment, since reputational risk affects stock price performance.

We suggest two trades for 2023, based on the concept of “go long sustainability” and “short greenwashing”. Incidentally, in both cases, our short candidates are not only viewed as potential sustainability fraudsters, but their dubious use of financial engineering is also a major investment risk:

On the opposite end of the spectrum, Svenska Cellulosa merits its reputation as one of the most sustainably managed forest companies in Europe. As an integrated industrial business, they aim to maximize the possible value in the forest and from the forest; wood pellets are a by-product from production of other wood products, helping the company achieve a recycled waste-total waste ratio of 96% (!) and underscoring the company’s effectiveness at maximizing the value of the entire forest.

Idea #3: Switch from Illiquid Alternatives to Liquid Alternatives

Money poured into the illiquid alternative space over the past decade. However, investors should never forget that liquidity has a price and you pay for it with a premium over publicly traded investments.

While the rise in interest rates last year created havoc in bonds and public equities, many illiquid alternative funds (PE, real estate, infrastructure, etc.) actually reported gains for the year, despite many of the underlying assets being highly interest rate sensitive. The best example is private real estate funds compared to publicly traded real estate investment trusts: both essentially hold the same assets, yet private real estate funds were up 5-10% while real estate investment trusts were down 20-25%. Unless bonds and stocks recover quickly, this is an unsustainable practice: smoothing out returns and locking in clients by limiting redemptions is a recipe for disaster.

We look at private assets under one of our investable sustainability themes: Building Better Markets. The opacity of private asset investment vehicles and, in many cases, the way they have been sold to investors is a dangerous practice.

We believe poor returns are in store for private investments since these products will need to be marked down over the next three years to progressively absorb the new valuation reality. If it is possible to redeem, investors would be better served by 3-year certificate of deposits yielding close to 5% or liquid alternatives like hedge funds that are marked to market, have attractive investment opportunities in a changing investment landscape and can benefit from a higher volatility regime that is likely to persist for the next 3 years.

Idea #4: Build Back Better With Industrial Automation

In the latter half of 2023, if recession risks wain and signs of a new bull market appear, we will advocate for beginning to reallocate to growth opportunities, starting with the industrial sector. Especially in the U.S., bipartisan support for recapturing manufacturing prowess will provide a favorable backdrop for upgrades to existing factories and the construction of new ones. Given the combination of reshoring and a structural labor shortage, we anticipate a boon in industrial automation. The benefits of automation include improved resource efficiency (optimized water, waste and energy management) and better safety. Two names on our radar are: Rockwell Automation and Emerson Electric.

Rockwell is the largest pure play in industrial automation and is also recognized as a leader in sustainability (CSRHub overall rank of 94 and listed on Barron’s 100 Most Sustainable Companies). In 2021, Rockwell’s energy efficiency related products were responsible for over one quarter of revenues. Emerson Electric also counts energy efficiency among its solutions. The company serves industries (such as energy, life sciences and food and beverage) that are key to a low-carbon, high-care economy and is diversified across both automation and commercial HVAC solutions. We find this especially beneficial from an investment perspective, given that the company is the intersection between two highly investable 2023 themes: energy efficiency (see idea #1) and automation. Though currently expensive, investors should look for buying opportunities later in the year.

Idea #5: Opportunities in EM

Similar to Idea #4, we expect that later in 2023, there will be scope for a change in leadership between EM and DM. Historically, the U.S. business cycle leads the rest of the world by about six months, since U.S. consumption is a major source of demand for much of the world's export. 

It is therefore premature to expect emerging markets stock outperformance in the near term. We have articulated in prior research why we are hesitant investors in China (for example, please see Chinese Capitalism’s Long March, September 29, 2021; we continue to believe that the country is extremely challenging for international investors that focus on sustainability, given an unpredictable regulatory backdrop and overall opacity in the country. That said, many emerging markets – as well as the companies that make up their stock markets – have historically healthy debt profiles and excellent growth prospects, yet are still trading at crisis-level valuations. Some tailwinds that may develop in 2023 include manufacturing revivals in some markets from “China plus one” strategies related to supply chains, exposure to the commodity cycle, as well as favorable political cycles in some pockets. Opportunities in EM for sustainability-minded investors are a key topic that we intend to explore further in 2023, stay tuned.

Idea #6: Structural Long in Transition Metals

Long-time readers of our work will note that we have been recommending positions in transition metals for quite some time and believe that an overweight allocation to these metals will be profitable on a structural basis. To be sure, higher metal prices are incongruent with our forecast for recession and we would not be surprised to see prices soften in the short-to-intermediate term. However, the long-term outlook for transition materials and metals is extremely bullish. Our preferred investments focus on sustainable miners and high-tech recyclers such as Umicore and Boliden. We believe that resource scarcity, the regulatory backdrop, as well as national energy and security policies of various nations will largely benefit these companies.

Following up on our quest for defensive companies in anticipation of an economic recession, this week’s note expands on previous notes on defensive sectors. Over the past few months, we have written on healthcare (“High Impact: Surviving a Recession with Care”, June 02, 2022), and utilities (“Improving Utility with Water and Power”, October 20, 2022). This time, we focus on grocery stores. Demand for consumer staples generally remains stable during recessions, as people continue to buy food, household goods and hygiene products. Consumer staples have outperformed the reference index in all recessions since 2000. This story holds so far this year, as the performance of consumer staples remained positive while the rest of the market fell.

In an environment of rising inflation, grocery stores, as a subset of consumer staples, benefit from a simple thesis: people tend to stay home and cook instead of going to restaurants when prices increase (backed by the fact that inflation for food away from home has been higher than inflation for food at home in the U.S. over the past twelve months). As a non-discretionary budget item, food spending is far more stable than other parts of consumer budgets. Budget constraints can be due either to a surge in inflation or from a weakening economy (i.e. recessions). After 40 years of declining inflation, on average, and particularly, the past two decades of inflation mostly under 2% in developed economies, the recent eruption in inflation has been an adjustment for consumers in most income brackets. Although prices have risen across most categories, grocery prices have skyrocketed, and consumers are trying to find ways to eat without jeopardizing their finances. Supply chain issues, tough weather conditions and the higher cost of fertilizers from the war in Ukraine have all contributed to food price increases. In many countries, like Canada, controversies are developing around egregious profits from grocery stores.

The chart below shows the price evolution of important grocery items over the past year in Canada. These increases are similar in many countries.

 “Greedflation” is a new word to reflect taking advantage of inflation to raise prices. Grocery stores are facing increased scrutiny with regards to this. For example, a recent survey showed that more than half of Canadians say they can't keep up with the rising cost of living, and 78% blame grocers for soaring food prices. At the same time, large corporations are reporting record earnings, Loblaw's first-quarter profits this year were up nearly 40% from last year, which adds fuel to the fire: Are grocery stores greedy? To answer the question, we looked at the 2022 quarterly profit margins of 20 of the largest grocery chains worldwide to see if companies increased their margins to generate those higher profits.

We looked at the profit margins of the following companies:

The charts below show that margins have decreased over the past decade and remained steady throughout 2022, refuting the price gouging theory.

 

 

Given the above analysis on profit margins, it seems clear that the rise in profits is due to the volume of groceries sold, i.e. greater demand for groceries both during COVID when consumers were constrained from eating elsewhere and more recently, by generalized inflation that is curbing discretionary spending budgets.

We expect that high inflation will persist for several more months. In this context, the outlook for defensive companies with pricing power will stay positive. To untangle the best sustainable companies to invest in the sector, we looked at their relevant sustainability practices and financial outlook of prospect companies.  

We used the SASB materiality index for food retailers & distributors to find the most material sustainability topics for the sector, which include energy management, food waste management, product health & nutrition and labor practices. We examined several indicators to assess the sustainable performance of the companies and highlighted those with best practices in the table below:

Next, we analyzed the financial characteristics of grocers:

The eight grocery stores listed above pass our sustainability test as well as offers investors positive financial features, in particular attractive valuations.

For impact-minded investors, finding plays in the financial sector that are truly aligned with environmental or social objectives is not an easy task. A first consideration is to look at the extent to which financial companies bring additionality to the impact/sustainability debate – i.e. do they intermediate capital in a way that benefits larger societal goals like environmental sustainability and financial market transparency? In this context, today’s note looks at – and probably debunks many sustainable finance concepts – or at least what is claimed to be sustainable – and explains why we find it hard to add financial companies to sustainable and impact portfolios.

We do this by taking a prescriptive approach and by looking at some of the key functions of financial companies for them to become more impactful. First, we look at “green” investment banking, then at asset management greenwashing, and finally at the consumer finance segment of the industry. To close, we examine the overall reputation of financial companies.
  

1. Seeing Through the Green Smoke in Investment Banking

Stop kidding the market with “green” bonds: While many banks are themselves issuing green paper and/or helping corporates issue green paper of their own, we are still having a hard time understanding the real-world impact of the growing “float” of green loans and bonds. Indeed, because the “use of proceeds” of these issues remains fungible once they make their way into corporate treasuries, it makes it hard for us to rely on only the “color” of a financial product without looking at the issuing company’s overall operations. Nevertheless, investment banks have not hesitated to jump on the green bond underwriting opportunity – and we expect this trend to continue despite scarce evidence that the growing green bond market delivers on its promises.

Ramp up the clauses embedded in sustainability-linked loans and bonds: With regard to the growing sustainability-linked loan and bond markets, we view that the tightness at which such instruments trade makes it unlikely that the incentives built-in these financial instruments can trigger real-world change (see our note “Sovereign Green Bonds: Carrots with no Strings Attached”, April 7th, 2022). Sustainability-linked instruments with a coupon step-up structure with weak sustainability triggers are neither interesting from the financial nor the sustainability point of view. For now, the main beneficiaries of these instruments are the underwriters and investment banks – not investors or the planet.   

Make sustainability flow through the “Chinese” wall: One way of looking at the structuring role of banks regarding sustainability is to look at the extent to which their lending practices are aligned with internationally accepted frameworks such as the EU taxonomy for sustainable activities and/or the Science-based targets initiative (SBTi). For the latter, of the 30 financial institutions claiming to have science-based targets, none are among top 30 issuers worldwide. Meanwhile, most large financial groups still fund fossil fuel projects while their asset managers are pledging to become “net zero” – which seems incompatible.

Steer away from SPACs: With many financial groups generating an increasing chunk of their revenues from their investment banking activities (20% of total revenue for Goldman Sachs), SPAC structuring is a rapidly emerging trend in structured finance – one which raises some significant issues for investors who value governance and market transparency as a source of long-term value (see our note: “2021 A SPAC Odyssey”, March 3rd, 2021). With hindsight, SPACs have proven to be destructive of value since their emergence in 2021, while also curtailing shareholders rights to the profit of SPACs managers and to their fee-earning structurers.

Large U.S. investment banks in particular – while receiving a small amount of their total revenue from SPACs – have profited from the hype while showing little to no consideration for values such as market transparency. By engaging in such poor market practices, several investment banks continue to disqualify themselves from portfolios and investment strategies that look to build better markets.

Align banking practices to hard frameworks: As EU financial institutions align their reporting to what is required by the EU taxonomy for sustainable activities, one can already witness the extent to which green lending is being implemented in banks. Interestingly, the banks with the greatest exposure to sustainable activities are already reporting that about 40 percent of current lending is already “aligned”. This leaves us doubting the extent to which 1) those numbers are valid, and 2) if an increase in these numbers (a key policy objective for the EU) can have a real-world impact. Even here, self-disclosed bank data on how their lending aligns with eligible activities under the EU taxonomy sectors looks fishy.

2. Asset Management: Stop the Greenwashing

Asset managers increasingly claim that their actions are contributing to improve the impact of financial markets on the real world. Interestingly, recent debates around the usefulness – and true impact of ESG policies in the asset management industry - suggest taking a strong look at asset managers’ true performance over sustainability.

To this end, Share Action, a UK not-for-profit, recently surveyed 75 asset managers’ sustainability/ESG policies and only gave the top 1/3 a “BBB” or better rating, with only 5 receiving a “AAA” rating. For this, asset managers are not a terribly exciting sustainable, let alone impact investment idea. Moreover, the fact that many asset managers are often looped into larger financial conglomerates can render the most sustainable asset manager un-investable because of the activities of its sister companies (think of BNP Paribas, among the top 10 financiers of fossil fuels). 

3. Consumer Finance: Stop Preying on Consumers

With interest rates on the rise and the scars of the GFC of 2008 still visible, consumer finance companies – be them auto loans, point-of-sale financing (“Buy now, pay later” schemes) or other credit-focused financial institutions, could rapidly become problematic in the current environment. That said, investors looking to make a positive impact with their investments should steer clear of such companies – especially those which target subprime borrowers (i.e., those with lower credit scores) in the delivery of their business models.

Auto loans: In auto loans, Credit Acceptance Credit Corporation (CACC) targets subprime borrowers looking to finance the purchase of a new car. Interestingly, this company will likely get stuck with a bunch of repossessed cars should interest rates pursue their rise once borrowers become unable to reimburse their loans. Moreover, one could also expect that the asset value of the underlying car fleet will also decay more rapidly than that of prime borrowers who would want to purchase more expensive, and better value-holding vehicles such as EVs for instance.

Buy now pay later: with consumers increasingly relying on BNPL services to avoid even higher credit card interest rates, one can expect that such companies will also go belly up as interest rates are set to remain elevated for some time. Reports suggest that some BNPL companies such as Affirm Holdings (AFRM) are already involved in some form of predatory lending practices by doling out as much as 20% more loans than competitor products. This yet another sign indicative that the consumer credit cycle is about to bust.

Credit cards: reports are starting to be floated on the bubbling subprime credit card issuance in the U.S. This includes that of Goldman Sachs (GS)’ “Apple” credit card – which is showing higher than average repayment delinquency rates compared to other lenders for its credit products. It seems that targeting subprime borrowers can be part of a deliberate business strategy – even if not in the best interest of the client.

4. Financial Companies: Time to Game Up Your Reputation

Finally, financial companies still have a long way to go before cleansing their poor reputation. The industry still places poorly in global reputational rankings, such as in AI-based Refinitiv’s ESG controversies ranking. With companies such as Goldman Sachs already under investigation in their asset management businesses for greenwashing by the SEC, its no surprise to see it being rated with the worse possible controversies score from Refinitiv. Other companies such as Wells Fargo and Morgan Stanley also fare poorly in this ranking.