The opening months of 2024 have brought four macro developments worth monitoring that will impact investment outcomes for sustainability portfolios for the remainder of the year. In this installment of our quarterly update on Macro Meets Sustainability, we address the following:

 

A Neutralized, Neutral Fed

Whenever big gaps form between the Fed’s expectations and market participants’ expectations of interest rate policy, there is opportunity (and risk) for investors. That is NOT the current environment. Recall that as recently as January, the bond market was predicting a less than 5% chance that the Fed policy rate would still be at 525 basis points at this point in the year, fully expecting that the Fed would cut interest rates up to six times in 2024. Expectations have now fallen to a rather benign three rate cuts, beginning in June or later, which is incidentally, what the FOMC also expects of themselves (as per their March summary of projections). Although we wouldn’t be surprised to see even fewer rate hikes this year (due to sticky inflation), a Fed on hold with market participants that agree makes for a reasonably docile rate backdrop.

This should be viewed as especially good news for the “pain trade” in the renewable energy sector. In this sector especially, monetary policy had become incredibly restrictive. As we wrote in a note last week (“A Second Wind: What Peak Interest Rates Mean for Renewables”), simply removing the rate headwind improves the prospects of many renewable energy projects, since most of the operational costs associated with running utility-scale wind and solar projects are derived from financing costs (rates). To be sure, without interest rates coming down, the operating costs of running renewable projects do not improve. But with credit spreads in this sector suggestive of a low risk of default, we believe that “bottom fishing” in renewable energy production – though not equipment manufacturers due to the risks related to China as described below – is timely given the incredible long-term prospects.

A Trump World?

Although there are still seven months before the next U.S. president will be decided, the enormous gap between the two parties’ platforms suggests that investors of all stripes should consider how their portfolio will stand up to a change of guard.

President Biden recently released his proposed 2025 budget: the trajectory is one of very tepid deficit reduction, albeit a hefty increase in corporate tax rates is included. In contrast, Trump has indicated that if elected he would push to extend for another decade all the individual tax cuts that are set to expire at the end of this year. On the face of it, a Trump government appears likely be more “inflationary” than a Biden government.

More notably, the “flavor” of fiscal policy in the U.S. will certainly change under Trump. In 2022, President Biden’s government signed into law the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) as well as the Chips and Science Act. Both acts represent an Industrial Policy approach to fiscal expansion: they target specific industries that are in the national interest. We expect that industrial policy will increasingly become the norm across the globe (please see our note from July 21, 2021, “Macro Goes ESG”). But the problem is that Trump does not share the Biden administration’s view of which issues are in the national interest – ignorance about climate change being the most glaring one.

That said, Biden and Trump do agree that re-shoring manufacturing and protecting American jobs are priorities. In this sense, many “green industries” may not suffer much under a Trump government. After all, many climate-focused companies truly are helping to make America great again.

Our preliminary work suggests that from a sector perspective, outside of the fossil fuel industry and a possible knee-jerk election-day reaction, a changing of the guard may not be overly deleterious for sustainability portfolios; we intend to delve further into this topic in an upcoming research note.

 

Dr. Copper

Copper - the "metal of electrification" — is vital to all energy transition plans. Demand for the metal is expected to double between now and 2035, but the supply side is constrained on several fronts (underinvestment over the past decade, environmental backlash and bans, cost overruns, lower ore grades, etc).

The logical outcome of this demand/supply imbalance is a rise in copper prices. The breakout in copper above 4$/lb in March is just a small sign of things to come. However, before investors pile into the long-term copper trade, it’s worthwhile reviewing recent dynamics (after all, copper as part of the industrial metal complex, is subject to significant boom/bust cycles):

The bottom line is that we remain structural bulls on copper due to the enormous demands from electrification, however a more sustained rally and/or “copper mania” may only take place once some of China’s power glut is re-absorbed. Note that copper is a highly recyclable commodity; sustainability investors should first consider companies with strong potential in the recycling space. However, given the enormous amounts of copper required, high-quality miners with superior ESG standards can also be considered. Since most of the rest of the industrial metal complex does not share copper’s bullish dynamics, we suggest investors focus on miners that are producing exclusively (or nearly exclusively) on copper. Freeport-McMoRan (FCX US) and Ero Copper (ERO TSE) are two companies that fit this bill.

 

China Dumping: No Lift Off For Europe

As mentioned above, China currently appears stuck with overcapacity in solar panel production, but also a whole host of other industries from steel to electric vehicles. Indeed, China has (re)begun flooding its export markets with deeply price discounted goods to help support its domestic manufacturing sector.

But China’s goods dumping is perhaps nowhere more contentious than in the “green goods trade”. After all, cheap accessible green products should be a godsend to global decarbonisation. Unfortunately, both U.S. and EU efforts to address climate change have been wrapped around another goal: to reshore manufacturing capacity and create jobs. Thus, while China solar panel production (as well as wind power equipment, batteries and EVs) may be good for the global energy transition, they are problematic for competing nations’ goals.

For now, it appears that the EU is unlikely to impose new anti-dumping tariffs on Chinese solar panels or other renewable energy equipment, opting instead to find more ways to subsidize local production. We reiterate our view that the odds of other regions catching up to China are very low (see our note March 8, 2023 “China’s Solar Power and Deglobalization”). Investors keen to gain exposure to renewables should avoid solar equipment manufacturers and focus on renewable energy operators.

In previous notes, we wrote about the comparative advantage of Mexico and India relative to China from a global manufacturing standpoint: “Made in Mexico” on July 6, 2023, and “Slumdog Millionaire Could Eat Wolf Warrior’s Lunch” on August 3, 2023. This week, we examine how and where the opportunities should materialize within Mexico and India on their own merits, rather than simply as replacements to China.

Our analytical framework consistently examines four drivers that shape the global economy: demography, international relations, technology and the regulatory backdrop. For the foreseeable future, climate change and social inequalities are also important factors that should not be ignored. Our analysis indicates that the next ten years will be chaotic globally because the large Baby Boomer generation is retiring, being replaced by the much smaller Gen Z, while populism and zero-sum calculus is steering international relations. Meanwhile, artificial intelligence and robotics have reached the implementation phase which could bring great productivity improvement at a time when regulatory oversight is lagging. Meanwhile, the earth is getting warmer and social inequalities are reaching levels that have historically resulted in a popular sense of resentment.

Considering this global context, we find that India and Mexico are better positioned than most countries. On demographics, they have a young and growing population without the baby boomer retirement issue. Contrary to most other countries, they have more residents in the 10-20 year-old cohort than in the 50-60 year-old age group. The chart below highlights the difference between Mexico and India’s similar profiles versus China. We use China, but Europe and Japan also have a lot more upcoming retirees than new workers.

On geopolitics, Mexico is located next to the largest consuming country in the world, with which it has a free trade agreement. India, by not being strategically aligned to a specific group of countries, is courted by both the United States and China. Geographical factors can influence economic opportunities and trade dynamics. Both India and Mexico have strategic geographical locations that facilitate trade as the map below highlights. Mexico's proximity to the United States makes it a key player in North American supply chains, while India's location provides access to emerging markets in Asia, Africa, and the Middle East.

On the negative, the map also spotlights the risk resulting from social inequalities in Mexico and India with GINI coefficients of 46.1 and 35, respectively, in 2019. These inequality levels are not as dire as those in Brazil and South Africa – as measured by the GINI coefficient - but they are still relatively high. Also, since both countries are close to the Equator, it puts them at greater risk from climate change.

For the last two drivers: technology and regulation, both represent opportunities and risks. India is producing a large number of engineers that can harness technology, but artificial intelligence and robotization will reduce the demand for workers. For regulations, we cannot affirm that Mexico and India are regulatory leaders with political interference and lots of red tape, but they have shown some progress over the years.

 

Structural Trends

Considering our perspective on the six drivers examined above, we are optimistic on the structural paths of India and Mexico. The picture below highlights the areas where investors should focus for sustainability impact: infrastructure and essential services. More consumers and greater household formation levels lead to more purchases of food, cell phones, housing-related items, technology and financial services. To support this larger and younger population, infrastructure needs will increase for education, water, telecom, electricity, hospitals and waste management, among others.

Both India and Mexico are vulnerable to various climate change impacts, and these effects can manifest across different sectors. Some potential risks for India and Mexico are highlighted below.

 

These climate risks compound the need for improved infrastructure and essential services like water, electricity, food and medical supplies.

 

Infrastructure

On infrastructure, we looked for sustainability leaders that will participate in the infrastructure expansion and respond to climate change issues. Larsen & Toubro, in India, is a diversified company involved in infrastructure and heavy industries. It builds roads, bridges, airports, energy transmission and production. Orbia, in Mexico, is similar as it is involved in a similar sector with a greater emphasis on agriculture. In the materials industry, Cemex in Mexico, is a leader in low-carbon cement and has a Science-Based Target Initiative (SBTi) objective consistent with 1.5 degrees of warming. For telecom and the electric grid, Bharti Airtel and Power Grid of India are strong candidates.

 

Essential Services

With that in mind, we searched for locally focused sustainability leaders well positioned to respond to increased internal demand. Consumer staple companies that fit the bill include Hindustan Unilever in India and Walmex in Mexico, while in the financial services industry: HDFC in India and Banorte in Mexico tend to be leaders. Infosys is a promising technology play.

The chart below displays their overall sustainability performance using their sustainability percentile score from CSRHub.

Have these drivers led to strong equity performance since the beginning of the decade? The chart below shows the performance for the companies we discussed regrouped according to their sector of activity. We are using a short history and small sample of companies but a wide dispersion of results is evident: Infrastructure in India has done amazingly well but the same cannot be said for Mexico. Essentials have behaved decently in both countries. The stronger performance of infrastructure in India coincides with a strong push by the government with the “Make in India” program. In Mexico, political interventions have contributed to the poor performance of the infrastructure sector.

2023 will surely be remembered as a year of market divergences: while global equity indexes delivered returns in the mid-teens, this masks the explosive performance of the Magnificent 7, the catastrophic year for many renewable energy plays, and much “muck” in between.

To be sure, economic and financial market performance can be chalked up to the extreme optimism surrounding artificial intelligence as well as a resilient U.S. consumer. Neither of these factors are likely to be in such force in 2024.

After all, there are signs that generative AI (i.e. models like ChatGPT) has already hit the peak in the hype cycle and is set to enter the “trough of disillusionment” (see chart below).

As for the U.S. consumer, the thick buffers in household budgets thanks to emergency COVID policy measures are wearing thin. The lag has been longer than is typical, but tight monetary policy is showing up in the form of higher consumer loan delinquency rates and less appetite for interest rate-sensitive purchases.

Our 2024 economic expectations are captured in the chart below. We expect a mild-to-average consumer-focused recession and see the balance of risks tilted toward stickier-than-expected inflation but about equal in regard to growth. Ergo, relative to current market expectations, we anticipate that policy rates will be higher for longer (we disagree with market participants that currently price a greater than  70% chance of March rate cuts). Central banks can no longer opt for aggressive accommodation at first sight of a growth slowdown due to structurally higher inflation trends.

 

If we are correct, this means that stocks are less appealing overall but the typical investment playbook for recessionary periods does need to be revised. There are sectoral implications and nuances that sustainability investors should consider:   

 

Against this backdrop, we propose five sustainability centric investment ideas for 2024.

Idea #1: Stay long green industrials, go short wasteful consumer discretionary (but mind the Presidential polls)

As noted above, the global manufacturing sector contracted all through 2023 and a major inventory destocking cycle is well advanced. On the flipside, consumers are finally showing signs of fading. Higher for longer interest rates won’t favor either sector, but fiscal firepower sits squarely in favor of the industrial sector thanks to the IRA and to a lesser degree, pro-climate policies in other countries as well. Thus, on a cyclical horizon, industrial plays, especially those that benefit from the great building green retrofit are well placed to outperform consumer discretionary sectors. On a longer-term basis, the desire to re-shore as well as greenify key infrastructure means that for the first time in decades, the industrial sector is likely to grow as a sustainable share of underlying GDP. 2024 provides a good entry point into this long-term theme. Investors looking to build positions could start with companies tied to essential goods and services.

For example, water efficiency names like Watts Water (WTS US) and Xylem (XYL US) have been moving higher but have further to go if our economic outlook is correct. On the short side, luxury “greenwashers” tend to underperform the market during recession (LVMH is a favored short candidate). Additionally, news that Shein, an ultra fast-fashion retailer is looking to go public is also exciting from the short side: we can’t wait for the shine to come off this stock after the IPO pumping hype. 

Idea #2: Selectively toe dip in Sustainable Infrastructure, Renewable Energy and Utilities

Given their high correlation to bond yields and defensive characteristics, sustainable infrastructure, renewable energy and utilities typically require policymakers to embark on a rate-cutting cycle to outperform. But some stocks in these sectors became extremely oversold in 2023. We highlight two stocks that we believe currently offer excellent value within sustainability themes benefitting from long-term tailwinds:  

Alstom: This railcar manufacturing company, while relatively unaffected by the interest rate backdrop (debt/equity ratio of 31%), has nonetheless been crushed in 2023 due to supply chain issues and project delays. This led to the company going from a healthy positive cashflow projection to negative in a span of months. In 2023, Alstom had to deal with a USD 5 Billion legacy backlog that delivered negative margins, and it also mistimed a costly inventory buildup while customers delayed desired delivery times.

We believe Alstom’s problems are largely over. Fortunately, customers are not cancelling orders, they have just been delayed: Alstom currently has USD 87 billion order backlogs, which equates to around five years worth of contracts. The company has a forward P/E of 9 and is trading at half of book value. Importantly (and unlike some U.S. wind projects that have recently been derailed), Alstom has long-term service contracts in place that are indexed to inflation.

Ameresco:  A designer of energy efficiency projects in buildings – with a high exposure to U.S. government contracts –  Ameresco should be relatively well insulated from slower economic growth. This company was mistakenly caught up in the “anything renewable” sell-off in 2023, but higher interest rates have not hindered the company’s access to financing, having secured over half a billion dollars in Q3 alone.

Ameresco has an impressive project backlog and has doubled the number of projects it was awarded over the past year. To be sure, one headline risk is a potential repeal of climate-friendly policies should Trump be elected, but even here, Ameresco is well positioned: many current and future projects focus on energy efficiency that ultimately save money.  

Idea #3: Catch the Uranium Wave

Nuclear power provides 10 per cent of the world’s electricity. Construction of nuclear reactors takes a long time (5-10 years) but offers a substantial service life advantage: twice as long as alternatives like solar panels and wind turbines. Around 60 power reactors are currently under construction (primarily in China and India), with an additional 110 reactors in the planning and 300 in proposal stages. Current capacity is 391,699 MWe while reactors under construction should add 69,599 MWe to the grid by 2030, and planned and proposed reactors could provide a combined 461,029 MWe, more than double the existing capacity. Extending the lifetime of existing nuclear power plants will also play an important role: the original design lifetime of nuclear power plants is usually 40 years but can be extended by 20-year increments. In the US, 90 percent of US plants have already been renewed to 60 years. The subsequent wave of renewals from 60 to 80 years will therefore be critical in supplying enough electricity to meet growing demand.

Even accounting for better efficiency of newer reactors, the trend of increasing global nuclear energy capacity means higher demand for uranium. To be sure, uranium demand does fluctuate with economic cycles and 2024 global recessionary conditions are a concern, but uranium supply is currently tight, even considering a potential cyclical slowdown. Alleviating supply-side constraints is not easy since mines take a long time to build and investments have been lacking after the long bear market of the 2010’s. Note that our enthusiasm for nuclear precedes the recent uranium spike; our series on this topic was launched in January 2021 (“A Radioactive Topic for ESG-Minded Investors”). Since then, uranium prices have increased significantly, but we expect we are still in the early innings. The recent commitment made at COP 28 by a group of 22 countries to triple nuclear capacity by 2050 underscores an increasing global desire for nuclear energy and the bullish sentiment around this investment.

A company like Cameco (CCO CA), which focuses on extraction of uranium ore and the production of uranium concentrate, is well positioned to capitalize on rising uranium demand. In order to be used as a fuel, however, uranium needs to be enriched. The U.S. currently imports a quarter of its enriched uranium from Russia. Enter Centrus Energy (LEU US). This company is a U.S. provider of high-assay low-enriched uranium used in most of the advanced reactor designs now under development. Being a U.S. company,  it is in an enviable position, especially since the American government has proposed legislation that would bar the importation of enriched Russian uranium.

 

Idea #4: Carbon Copies? Not Quite: The Unique Traits of NA and EU Markets

Despite being a global molecule affecting climate globally, carbon dioxide (CO2) exhibits fundamental regional differences when it comes to the tradable commodity. Depending on which version of the carbon commodity you look at, the year 2023 tells a very different story. While the EU allowances (EUAs) have lost 17% of their value, the WCI allowances (CCAs) have gained more than 32%.

What explains this? The short answer is the correlation between industrial GHG emissions and economic activity. The Eurozone economy has fared worse than the North American economy in 2023 and as a result, Europe’s industrial GHG emissions were lower than last year (about 7% according to LSEG). This is positive for the environment but translates to lower demand for EUAs. The chart below also shows the performance of the voluntary carbon market credits, aka carbon offsets. Avid SMS readers know that we are not fans of that market. The past year was filled with integrity scandals and voluntary markets should continue to be avoided.

For 2024, we remain generally bullish for most liquid regulated carbon markets (Europe’s market is about $850B per year while California-Québec is roughly $70B per year). In Europe, industrial activity is likely to remain tame, but there are other positive factors at work:

As for the California-Québec market, even though prices had a good run in recent months, there is still ample upside potential to the unit price. Currently, carbon allowances trade just above CA$52 which is already trailing its European equivalent and in addition, the Canadian Carbon Tax scheme will increase to CA$80 in 2024, leaving a comfortable gap to fill on the upside. Moreover, the State of Washington intends to join California and Québec which should be a bullish event for the CCAs.

KRBN dominates the carbon ETF market. However, this ETF is heavily skewed toward Europe (65%). For investors that prefer to build their own regional weighting, Kraneshare California Carbon Allowance (ticker KCCA) ETF provides exposure to only North American carbon, while Kraneshare European Carbon Allowance (ticker KEUA) is the European equivalent. In the current context, we suggest two-thirds allocation to North America.

 

Idea #5: Short? Affirmative!

Affirm is one of the major players in the Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) space. At SMS we have a negative view towards BNPL as it facilitates excess spending, while targeting consumers that can ill afford to do so. Affirm also ranks low on ESG scores, such as CSRHub rankings for community, employees and environment. Affirm’s share price has had a wild ride the past two years: after losing 85% of its value in 2022, the stock spent the first ten months of 2023 carving out a base. It has since shot up 100% since end-October. This recent rise was fuelled by Affirm’s better than expected Q3 earnings – i.e. less negative earnings - the headline-grabbing surge in BNPL for holiday shopping and the general risk-on rally in the stocks.

However, the BNPL model is struggling to cope with the end of ZIRP and macro headwinds on consumer discretionary spending. Affirm is projected to be unprofitable for the next five years(!) and there are other big players in the payment space that can easily take their market share (there is little brand loyalty in this industry). Affirm stock is now coming into overhead resistance above $40 and we agree with the broker consensus that the share price should be lower (we target $20). Even though short interest on the stock is high (currently 21%) that should not be a deterrent for nimble-footed sustainable investors from shorting this stock.

 

The Tech Titans

In last week’s note (“The Apple Case Study: Magnificent and Sustainable?”, November 2, 2023) we delved into the sustainability efforts of Apple. This week, we turn our attention to the other giants in the “Magnificent 7”. We examine their robust performance and discuss implications for investors focused on sustainability.

The evolution from “FAANG” (Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, Google) to the Magnificent 7 (encompassing Microsoft, Nvidia, and Tesla in addition to FAANG but excluding Netflix) highlights the relentless expansion and market hegemony of these tech giants. In the current year, the Mag 7 has not just led the market but have significantly outpaced the S&P 500.

Indeed, not owning this group of companies in 2023 has been detrimental to many investors: these seven stocks are outperforming the benchmark by a wide margin. Year-to-date, virtually all the gains in the S&P 500 Index can be attributed to the Mag 7, and their weight in the index has reached all-time highs. This has been a big headache for active managers.  

The Hype

The impressive growth trajectory of the Mag 7 has been fueled by exposure to artificial intelligence (AI) and cloud computing, areas experiencing explosive growth. Despite pressure from rising bond yields on tech stocks’ long duration and their steep valuations compared to the equity benchmarks, money continues to chase their share price higher. The Mag 7 has also been boosted by financial market participants’ pricing of a soft landing and benefit from passive flows that buy the benchmark. Their outsized impact on the market indices and investment portfolios presents a complex scenario: the Mag 7 serves as both a propeller of growth and a potential amplifier of systemic risk because of their sheer market weight. Furthermore, there is an extra layer of complexity as the sheer size of these companies brings greater scrutiny and greater regulatory risks.

Navigating Legal Waters

As pioneers in innovation, the Mag 7 tech stocks are increasingly encountering legal challenges. The volume and nature of litigation these companies face is reflective of their operational scale, and their aggressive pursuit of market share through anti-competitive behavior. Patent disputes are common, often stemming from the high-stakes race to secure intellectual property rights. President Biden's administration is intensifying scrutiny on monopolistic practices, resulting in a proliferation of antitrust and competition-related legal actions. This is mirrored in the uptrend of legal cases for some companies since 2021 (see chart below).

The prevalence of patent and antitrust lawsuits of the Mag 7 bear significant implications. The risks include potential financial liabilities and also risks to reputation, regulatory compliance, and business models.

Meta, Amazon, and Alphabet have seen the greatest increase in the number of litigations in the past few years. Specific examples for each company are described below:

Meta: Meta is facing lawsuits from 41 states, claiming the company's social media platforms, particularly Instagram and Facebook, are addictive and harm children's mental health. Consequences for Meta may include the implementation of stringent age verification systems, modified content algorithms to reduce addictive tendencies, and clear labeling of digital health risks. Such reforms could diminish user engagement and advertising revenue, directly affecting stock valuation.

Amazon: Amazon is accused of using a secret pricing algorithm ("Project Nessie") to inflate prices, with the FTC lawsuit suggesting the company earned over $1 billion from this practice. A ruling against the company could result in orders to dismantle or significantly alter its pricing algorithms, increased regulatory oversight, and compensation for affected customers. For Amazon, this could lead to lower profit margins, a loss of competitive advantage, and a decrease in market share.

Alphabet: Alphabet is under scrutiny for antitrust issues, with the DOJ filing a lawsuit over its advertising and search engine practices. If Alphabet is found to have violated antitrust laws with its advertising and search practices, the company could be required to separate parts of its advertising business and alter its search algorithm to ensure fairer competition – akin to what happened to Microsoft in 2000. The implications for Alphabet may involve a reconfiguration of its core business model and a decrease in ad revenue growth. For shareholders, the risks are tied to potential drops in share price and future earnings, coupled with the uncertainty of Alphabet’s strategic direction in a more regulated environment.

Investors must consider the potential for substantial regulatory shifts and financial penalties that could impact the operations and valuations of these tech giants. Furthermore, these issues bring into question the place of these companies in sustainability funds.

Sustainability: Seeing Through the Haze

The technology giants have a noteworthy presence in sustainable investment funds. The Mag 7 stocks are prominently featured in funds adhering to the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) Articles 8 and 9 as depicted in the following table:

However, using a double materiality approach, i.e. one that considers both the operational performance and the impact the companies’ products and services have on the planet and its people, we uncover a different conclusion. The broad inclusion of these stocks in sustainability-focused funds may be somewhat dubious.

According to our double materiality analysis, Microsoft and Nvidia emerge as leaders compared to their Magnificent 7 peers. They show positive alignment with sustainability both operationally and through their products and services. Conversely, Amazon and Meta display significant challenges, warranting caution for investors seeking to prioritize sustainability. Apple, Alphabet, and Tesla present a mixed landscape, with commendable initiatives overshadowed by areas of concern (see the Apple case study note from November 02, 2023, for a detailed breakdown of Apple).

What Should a Sustainable Investor Do?

Based on the above analysis, a sustainable investor’s choices in the Mag 7 are somewhat slim, even before considering what the extremely lofty valuations of these companies (see table below). Amazon and Meta are not appropriate as long positions in a sustainable strategy. For investors that hold companies that we view as neutral regarding sustainability (Tesla, Apple and Alphabet), only Alphabet looks interesting based on its growth expectations relative to forward P/E. Telsa’s high P/E isn’t justified by its growth expectations, while Apple is not growing at all, failing to justify its premium valuation over the market. As for the only two companies of the Mag 7 that we do view as sustainable: Microsoft looks like the safer bet as it still has many avenues to continue growing. Nvidia is trading on a lot of AI hype, and we don’t believe that its growth expectations will be able to be met. For investors that can short sell, an interesting pair trade would be to buy Microsoft and short Amazon: both have been growing in cloud computing, but Microsoft has the added AI potential, while Amazon has the negative of slower consumer spending and regulation overhang.

Apple’s Mother Nature video (watch below) has been viewed a stunning 4.2 million times since its release in early September. The video attempts to showcase Apple’s progress on several environmental targets and ultimately gains approval from “Mother Nature”.  The video has been applauded for being creative and bold but also slammed by critics with disapprovals ranging from cringe, woke, virtue signaling, and greenwashing.

The video release was timed to the launch of another round of Apple products, including the iPhone 15 and updated watch. But it also corresponded with a relatively intense legislative period that will affect how smartphone makers build their products; from right-to-repair bills in California, to new battery replacement rules in the EU, there is growing pressure for smartphone makers to make more durable products.

Apple dominates over half of the U.S. smartphone market and is responsible for about 20% of global market share. In addition, it is the only smartphone company in the Magnificent 7, that magic group of high-profile technology-centric mega-caps (Apple, Alphabet, Amazon, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia, and Tesla) responsible for the lion’s share of equity gains this year. Apple, along with Amazon, is one of the few tech companies that tends to be highly scrutinized from an environmental perspective.

In today’s Note, we assess Apple’s record relative to its competitors on a number of sustainability topics and evaluate whether sustainability will factor into the success or failure of Apple stock over the longer term.

Sustainability Topic #1: Carbon Neutrality - So What?  

Carbon neutrality features prominently in Apple’s Mother Nature video. The company’s sustainability team lists off a number of ways they are supporting this initiative. However, neither energy management nor greenhouse gas emissions is among the materiality topics identified as relevant by the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB). Since Apple does not own the factories where its products are manufactured, the bulk of emissions come from the company’s value chain. As a result, it is relatively easy to achieve carbon neutrality in its offices, stores, and data centers. The greater (and more impactful) challenge would be lowering scope 3 emissions.

Sustainability Topic #2: Materials Sourcing

The video starts by discussing materials, which is a relevant topic under SASB. Apple employees state the commitment to eliminate all plastics in packaging by 2025 and the company’s use of recycled aluminum. This is a good start, but as the SASB metric highlights, cell phones are dependent on a supply of critical materials. Though not addressed in the video, Apple covers the topic at length in their latest environmental progress report.

The company has an ambitious goal of using only recycled and renewable materials in their products. In 2022, the share of shipped materials meeting these criteria was 20%. The video mentions the use of 100% recycled aluminium for enclosures on most products and the report includes a target to achieving this for other materials (cobalt, tin, gold and rare earth elements) in even more components by 2025. Apple has also identified 14 materials where they are prioritizing their efforts. These account for 87% (by mass) of the products shipped to customers in 2022. In addition to addressing environmental and social concerns associated with extraction, prioritization of these materials is a strategic endeavor to secure a reliable supply of these resources.

Sustainability Topic #3: Managing the Supply Chain

Materials sourcing goes hand in hand with supply chain management. As a major producer of hardware, Apple can leverage its influence for change and improvements. Apple ticks all the boxes when it comes to best practices for supply chain management. It adheres to top frameworks, relies and discloses on third-party audits, has an inventory of chemicals used in manufacturing and even publishes a 25-page supplier list! Despite these efforts, the company has encountered several controversies, mainly concerning labor issues. For the most part, these issues have had little effect on operations and pose more of a reputational risk. Still, there is room to do better. While competitors have faced controversies, they have not been embroiled in human rights issues.

Comparing the operational aspects of supply chain management and materials sourcing with other major phone makers shows that Apple is leading the way in its efforts to sustainably source materials and is aligned with its peers when it comes to supply chain management.

Sustainability Topic #4: Product Lifecycle

Perhaps the greatest sin in Apple’s Mother Nature video is the error of omission. In fact, there is no environmental claim regarding product lifecycle, which is a key material disclosure topic for hardware companies, especially given the potential for rapid obsolescence.

Apple has been criticized for its strategy of mediatizing their annual fall product launches in an attempt to create perceived scarcity and incentivize customers to upgrade their devices before the end of the useful life of their products. The strategy appears to be working; the average lifespan of smartphones – both Apple and their competitors - is declining (see data for the U.S. in the chart below).  

If Apple and other smartphone manufacturers were truly sustainable companies, they would be embracing a more circular business model. In contrast to a linear economic model, a circular economy refers to an economic system whereby the value of products, materials and other resources in the economy is maintained for as long as possible and whereby resources no longer used in one system become inputs in another.

As we wrote in our note, Circular Economy: When Going Around In Circles is the Right Thing To Do (April 13, 2022), the “R” hierarchy refers to an order of preference for action to reduce and manage waste (see table below).

Concretely, in the case of smartphone makers, actions that are high on the “R” hierarchy - notably rethink, reuse and repair –would increase the life of smartphones and thus slow the rate of production and associated environmental damage.

Re-use: One way to extend the life of products is to ensure that a healthy re-use market exists. Unfortunately, this doesn’t seem to be the case for smartphones; analysts estimate that about 282 million second-hand smartphones shipped in 2022. This is paltry in comparison to the 1.2 billion new smartphones that were shipped in the same year. That said, the vast majority of resold phones are Apple products; the resale value of Apple phones as a share of initial purchase price is higher than any other phone brand. The implication is that, despite an overall shallow second-hand market, Apple is nonetheless ahead of its peers in terms of re-use.

Repair: Smartphone makers are highly criticized (Apple in particular) for the inability to repair products: forbidding design elements such as nonstandard screws and glued-on parts make it tough to access basic components such as the battery. Moreover, the industry is routinely accused of programmable obsolescence, which involves “serialization,” wherein spare parts (e.g. microchips, speakers) are linked with specific phone models/generations through serial numbers. This hinders third-party repairers from using generic parts. Here too, Apple seems to do better among a poor lot. According to rankings by iFixit, an American e-commerce and how-to website that aids consumers in repairing electronics, Apple phones are easier to repair than Samsung, Huawei and most other competitors.

The whole industry will nonetheless get a makeover. Recent legislation in both Europe and the U.S. is likely to impel manufacturers to make parts, repair guides, and diagnostic tools available for consumers and third-party repair shops. Apple in particular appears to be getting out in front of this; after years of stalling, the company has finally endorsed U.S. federal right to repair legislation.  

Rethink: Another way to ensure a longer lifespan for smartphones is to guarantee software and security updates for longer periods; the longer that phones are supported by software updates, the more likely a phone will remain in service. Here again, Apple performs somewhat better than its competitors.

A second “rethink” factor to account for in the design of products is compatibility. Apple is routinely criticized for making its products and accessories incompatible with non-Apple products, which forces consumers to purchase more Apple products. A high-profile example is the iPhone charger; last year EU legislation was passed that contained new rules introducing a single charging port for most electronic devices. Apple was the most affected by this change given that most Androids already use a standard USB-C charger.

The bottom line is that the smartphone industry in general appears to be firmly rooted in a linear economic model. Regulation is increasingly forcing companies to undertake activities and/or redesign some aspects to increase the lifespan of electronic products, but the speed of change remains slow.

Apple Investment Outlook

Apple and its magnificent seven peers have experienced impressive stock market returns in 2023, driven by several elements including the excitement about artificial intelligence, a factor bias in favor of quality companies, and a desire by investors to hold mega-cap names. Unfortunately, sustainability has not been a consideration that is driving this basket of stocks higher, particularly in a year when a gust of anti-ESG sentiment has blown in.

Nonetheless, Apple sustainability practices – in spite of the contentious advertising – are on par or exceed the standards of other smartphone makers. This position implies that if/when consumers, regulators, and other stakeholders become more serious about reducing the environmental footprint of electronic devices, Apple’s sustainability track record will allow them to maintain, if not increase, market share.

The term greenwashing has gained attention over the past few years, but the world of corporate “washing” spans a far more vibrant spectrum of colors.

In May 2023, as part of their preparations for Pride Month, retail giant Target introduced a range of LGBTQ-themed merchandise, ostensibly to show their support for the cause. However, their actions took a different turn when they faced substantial customer backlash. In response, Target then removed these items from shelves. But this just further amplified the controversy: by not standing their ground, the company then faced additional criticism from LGBTQ supporters.

This one example underscores the complexity of corporations engaging in marketing related to social causes. Is support genuine or merely a marketing tactic? In the case of Target, there were no meaningful incentives for LGBTQ+ employees, but merely rainbow-colored products and marketing campaigns: a potential candidate of “rainbow washing”.

Washing- whatever the colour – should not be construed merely as an unsuccessful marketing campaign. Washing is a deliberate and deceptive strategy where companies falsely tout their environmental or social responsibility to attract conscious consumers, all while seeking to bolster sales and reputation without making substantial improvements. In contrast, an unsuccessful marketing campaign typically stems from poor planning or execution, failing to resonate with the intended audience due to messaging flaws or product-marketing mismatches. An unsuccessful marketing campaign might lead to missed business objectives but typically lacks the deceptive nature of washing.

Washing comes in many colours, as the table below highlights.

The Allure of Washing

Although 2022 was marked by greater criticism of “ESG”, there is nonetheless an ongoing incentive for companies to pursue sustainability strategies. There is a consistent perception that companies that pursue lower carbon footprints merit a “greenium” and tend to have higher valuations than those that do not. Consequently, if management believes their stock price will be rewarded, there is a clear incentive for companies to pursue implementation of ESG business strategies - or at the very least, pursue an image of implementing ESG strategies.

Washing occurs when there is information asymmetry. When a seller has greater knowledge than the buyer, the seller can charge a premium for products or services. In an environment where specific, sometimes difficult to verify, product or service traits are desired, there can be a high incentive for a company to make its products more attractive to increase sales volumes, charge higher prices, and/or retain workers inspired by strong sustainability credibility.

Ultimately, if washing is successful at doing the above, then it will have a positive impact on a company’s stock price – so long as the firm does not get caught. A 2022 study of SP1500 companies showed just that: the authors  divided companies between those that greenwash without repercussion and those that don’t, it was found that the financial market reaction was positive in the medium term (i.e., six months) for the companies that greenwash.

The Deterrent to Washing

What about those that do get caught?

There are two main ways that greenwashing gets punished. The first is through a company’s social license to operate, i.e. their reputation. Quantifying the value of reputation and reputational risks is a daunting task, but one straightforward way is to consider changes in the goodwill value of a company. Goodwill refers to the value a company derives from its brand, customer base and reputation associated with its intellectual property. Third-party sources also estimate the value of brands and have shown that “greenwashing” affects this metric. For example, in the wake of Volkwswagen’s Dieselgate, Brand Finance estimated that in 2015, VW’s brand value dropped from $31 billion to $21 billion. While this is impressive, keep in mind that in the same year, VW’s non-current assets were over 230 million euros:  the overall balance sheet effect of their brand loss shouldn’t be overstated.

The second way that greenwashing gets punished is through litigation. One example is the Keurig class action suit that settled in 2022. Keurig Doctor Pepper (KDP US) deceptively advertised its K-Cups coffee pods’ recyclability by misleadingly labeling and marketing them as “recyclable” when the pods were not actually accepted for recycling in most municipalities. The complaint was filed in December, 2018 and was settled in February, 2022; the company agreed to pay USD 10 million. Coffee product sales represent about one-third of the company’s revenues (total company sales were about USD 14 billion in 2022).

The chart below shows the stock performance of KDP at the time of the announced lawsuit, during the proceedings and after the case; the company’s results are hardly distinguishable from its peers in the rest of the beverage industry!  

A second example of washing litigation is the case of Credit Acceptance Corporation (CACC), which, over the past three years, faced no less than four significant litigations, each related to its business practices within the automotive lending sector. These controversies have raised questions about compliance, consumer relations, and predatory lending. Note that contrary to Keurig, where the lawsuit did not question the legitimacy of the company’s product (coffee), the CACC cases were all aimed directly at the service provided. The effect of legal proceedings on CACC's stock price have been pronounced, with declines exceeding 10% in three out of four cases, as shown in the chart below.

The Net Present Value Of Greenwashing: Currently Positive, But….

The above examples show that the penalty for washing, as measured by stock market return, can range from paltry (Keurig) to material (CACC).  We expect, however, that the deterrence to washing is about to become more substantial.

Investors can think about washing in financial terminology. The net present value (NPV) of washing, for most companies, has been net positive: the projected earnings generated by washing activities - misleading marketing campaigns, making donations to improve a company’s corporate image, other investments made to appear more sustainable - exceed the anticipated costs.

But the costs of getting caught are beginning to rise, making the NPV less favorable. For one thing, the number of greenwashing cases that end up in litigation is surging. Climate litigation in general is skyrocketing higher, and greenwashing cases are a rising portion within that trend. The chart below shows the number of greenwashing cases that are in litigation.

Moreover, greenwashing cases are increasingly being reported on by media, implying that the public is far more aware of the practice.

Importantly, although the  Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has yet to finalize proposed new rules for company disclosures regarding environmental, social, and governance (ESG) policies, last November, the SEC gained broader authority under the Marketing Rule to examine all of firms’ compliance processes for advertising and marketing material, including ESG claims. In addition, the SEC has also created a 22-member Climate and ESG Task Force in its Division of Enforcement to better monitor firms’ and issuers’ ESG practices. On their website, they cite six examples of enforcement actions that occurred in 2022 alone. These range from an Adviser charged for failing to follow its policies and procedures involving ESG investments to a health insurance distributor and former CEO charged with making false statements to investors as well as a sham environmentally-friendly bottling company.

In Europe, rooting out washing is further advanced. In the financial sector, the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) has been in effect since 2021 and gives transparency to investors on how providers and products affect the environment and society. In addition, the European Commission published a proposal for a Green Claims Directive in the spring 2023, with the goal to ensuring that environmental labels and claims are credible and trustworthy.

The past decade has witnessed remarkable progress in access to financial services around the world. Technological developments led to a growing number of FinTech platforms that enabled a greater number of poorly-served people to access financial services. New service providers increased competition for several different platforms – bank transfers, electronic payments, cell phones, etc. – in countries where such choices are available. These developments were useful to 1) empower consumers; 2) extend the reach of financial services to a greater share of the population; and 3) lower transaction costs. Today, the most underserved individuals with regard to access to financial services are found in Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa.

Despite this progress, it is still challenging to qualify the extent to which companies in the financial sector can have an “impact”. At Sustainable Market Strategies, we designed a matrix that shows the many ways a financial company can have impact according to the services they provide in developed, developing and frontier markets.

From our perspective, financial companies who “push the envelope” and look to increase their reach by growing their exposure to the underserved are considered impactful. For example, the penetration rate of mobile money services in regions such as Sub-Saharan Africa is a testament to the impact of such services on those populations. Airtel Africa is an example of a Telecom company which provides a fair amount of financial services to its client base.

In developed markets, financial companies can typically be considered impactful if they provide services to lower-income “unbanked” and/or “underbanked” populations. For their part, insurance companies who establish methods to limit price increases of their premiums and ensure coverage in higher-risk areas (i.e. areas with higher crime rates, lower incomes, and greater climate risks) would be considered impactful. This is especially relevant in the U.S. where a growing number of people are going uninsured.

 

In emerging and frontier markets, banks with specific outreach programs such as microfinance business streams and/or payment/transfer/mobile phone companies that facilitate the availability of services via digital platforms are considered impactful because of their contribution in elevating people out of poverty. Additionally, financial companies that facilitate and/or lower the costs of P2P transfers between DMs and EMs/FMs are also considered impactful as the provision of low-cost international transfer services could enable greater financial flows from DMs towards EMs and FMs.

 

In today’s note, we look at three investment ideas whereby investors looking to have an impact can invest in the financial sector: Community Banks, EM/FM banks and transfer payment providers. This note builds on our previous analysis of the financial sector (see our note “Three (Sexy) Banking Plays to Change the World” September 8, 2022).

Idea #1: DMs/US Community Banks

Community banks typically cater to regional communities across the United States. With their loan portfolio and deposit base “close to home”, these institutions are often very familiar with the people they serve and their regional markets. That said, recent wobbles in the U.S. banking system and the more stringent funding requirements have hit this sector hard. Furthermore, many communities and regional banks have a relatively high exposure to commercial real estate – which remains itself under stress as the asset class continues to re-price. Thus, it is not surprising that U.S. community banks have underperformed the overall sector in the U.S. – and globally – over the past year. 

It is difficult to see a good entry point into U.S. community banks at this juncture. After all, persistently high interest rates should continue to create problems in their loan portfolios as well as challenge their asset and liability matching over the next few months.

Idea #2: EMs/FMs Banks

To have in impact, one could also consider investing in EMs/FMs banks that are leading the pack with regard to financial inclusion. While country-level data on financial inclusion is made available by organisations such as the WorldBank or the IMF, bank-level data on financial inclusion remains scarce. That said, sustainably-minded investors looking to invest in financial institutions with a view to promote financial inclusiveness could look into some data published by the World Bank, as highlighted in the table below.

With this in mind, EMs/FMs banks really ought to disclose more data on financial inclusion as a means to grow their investors’ base. Looking at recent pricing trends in global banking stocks, one can see that banks have underperformed the global equity market these past few months – especially EM banks. While interest rates have not “normalized” as much in EMs as they have may have done in DMs, one can think that (in absence of issues around financial stability and excluding Chinese banks) higher-for-longer interest rates could help EM banks boost their net interest margins in the coming months. This should contribute positively to their profit margins going forward.

Finally, we look at financial inclusiveness mentions in Financials’ sector filings included in the MSCI FM and EM indices. Interestingly, mentions of financial inclusion are about absent in U.S. banks filings. Aside from financial institutions such as VISA, it is hard to believe that U.S. financial institutions – such as Goldman Sachs or BlackRock – are really putting financial inclusion high up on their agenda.

Conversely, mentions of financial inclusiveness are much more prevalent in EM and FM financial insitutions’ filings.

This seems especially true for institutions such as the Commercial International Bank (Egypt) and Creditcorp (Peru), two frontier markets’ banks. Interestingly, both have outperformed the MSCI Frontier index this past year and for investors ready to look for financial inclusiveness plays on the margins – these institutions could prove a smart way to address financial inclusiveness through publicly-listed banks in the frontier space.

Idea #3: Transfer payment companies

Recent developments in FinTech and the strong growth of the global market for remittances gave a boost to transfer payments companies – especially those looking to shave off costs on international money transfers. A recent compilation of newcomers in the transfer payment market suggests that these firms’ markup on international transfers varies from 0 to 1.5%. This compares to about 1-6% using the mid-market FX rate for a traditional transfer company such as Western Union. As a result, the market for global remittances has gotten much more competitive – and this comes to the benefit of users of such platforms.

From an impact perspective, one could favor transfer payment companies that offer the possibility to do P2P transfers from DMs to EMs at a lower cost. While companies like Western Union provide the biggest outreach in the remotest part of the planet – they are also the most expensive service in the sector. Conversely, upcomers such as Wise payments, which enables transfers to a wide range of geographies and currencies – offer discount transfer and FX rates and are quickly gaining market share as their service is offered in an increasing number of currencies. For its part, Remitly offers the possibility to send and receive money transfers – but just for users in the U.S. at this point – which makes it less interesting from an impact perspective. Despite the sector’s tailwinds coming from the growing global remittance markets and low-cost international financial transfers, these companies have underperformed the NASDAQ over the past year – aside for Remitly and Wise. Interestingly, some money transfer companies display hefty profit margins, hovering around 20%, which could make an interesting investment opportunity.

Looking at valuation, newcomers appear expensive against more established players. No doubt that market participants are pricing an outcome whereby lower-cost alternatives such as Wise, Remitly and others rapidly displace “old school” companies such as Western Union.

 

For long-term asset owners like pension and sovereign wealth funds, the most important investment decision is strategic asset allocation, i.e. determining the target weight of each asset class to deliver sufficient returns to match or exceed liabilities. After all, empirical research shows that over a longer time horizon (10+ years) more than 80% of returns and risks are the result of Strategic Asset Allocation (SAA).

Meanwhile, climate change is being recognized as a critical factor in potential long-term returns; the largest capital expenditure program we will witness in our lifetimes is the worldwide shift towards emission reduction. Every asset will be impacted in some way by climate change and the low carbon transition, either directly, via supply chains, or by changing consumer preferences.

Given this shift, how should climate change alter strategic asset allocation decisions among institutional asset owners?

In part one of today’s report, we analyze the impact of climate change on the various drivers of asset class returns. In part two, we apply these adjusted return expectations to asset classes to uncover how climate change are likely to impact strategic asset allocation.  

 

Part One: Climate Change as a Driver of Long-term Returns

Long-term capital market assumptions (LTCMAs) are the traditional backbone of decision-making for strategic asset allocation. To establish LTCMAs, each asset class is decomposed into the main drivers of return to build a reliable estimate of forward-looking risk and return. The long-term risk/reward profile of each asset class then determines the strategic asset allocation.

Generating LTCMAs traditionally uses historical data (for example, expected default rates on corporate bonds are modeled from historical averages). But the emergence of new and difficult-to-measure environmental – and social – phenomenon mean that related risks are less likely to be reflected in any historical data. That said, there is an increasingly large body of academic work that supports an emerging consensus about how climate change, arguably the most pressing environmental and social risk, will affect various fundamental drivers of returns.

We leverage this research to provide estimates of the main return drivers:

 

The key takeaways from this exercise so far are:

 

Part Two: How to Incorporate Climate Change in SAA

Perhaps the most straightforward approach to accounting for climate change in strategic asset allocation is to embed climate change impacts directly in long-term capital market assumptions.

By using assumptions of how climate change will affect fundamental drivers of returns, we can compute new forecasts of asset class returns expectations. The table below displays how we expect climate change to impact each asset class driver relative to a base case scenario where climate change is not considered. Note that for the base case capital market assumptions (i.e. those not affected by climate change), we use a consensus average estimate of long-term capital market assumptions, using various sources such as Oxford Economics, J.P. Morgan, AQR, etc.. Our goal is to demonstrate the direction and magnitude that we expect climate change to affect asset returns, not to precisely predict long-term capital market assumptions (the latter is outside the scope of our research).

 

There are several significant takeaways that should stand out:

Putting it all together, we can apply the revised long-term capital market assumptions to a benchmark portfolio to get a sense of how a “climate change embedded” portfolio might differ relative to a return outcome whereby climate change is ignored.

Suppose an investor has a mandate to deliver 5% annual real returns plus inflation, “without undue risk of loss”. She repeats the assumption about inflation that she has been making for years: 2% per annum. Therefore, she constructs the portfolio that we call, “Living in the Past”. Living in the Past portfolio attempts to achieve 7% annual returns while ignoring the impact of climate change. With this portfolio, our investor believes she is generating 5% real and 7% nominal by allocating 70% to equity (evenly split between private and public), 20% in government bonds and 10% in infrastructure.

However, if we update the asset class return forecasts by using the climate change-embedded expectations, we see that the investor, when using this portfolio, significantly underperforms her return objectives (lines in red in the below table).

Conversely, using climate change-embedded capital market assumptions, we construct a new portfolio, “Climate Change Embedded Portfolio” in the table below. In order to achieve her mandate of 5% + inflation (she now knows that inflation will be higher with climate change and therefore strives for a nominal portfolio closer to 8%), the investor needs to have a significant allocation to assets that offer greater inflation protection and are mostly likely to have a positive valuation change to offset the decline in real growth that is expected from climate change. An effective portfolio is highlighted below: it is invested significantly in natural resources and infrastructure.

So what have we learned? First, there is a building consensus that climate change will, on a net basis, detract from economic growth while adding to inflation. The impact on inflation is expected to be larger (about 1% for headline, but considerably higher in the food sector) than the headwind to growth (-0.2% per year globally).

Our illustrative portfolios suggest that higher allocations to asset classes like natural resources and infrastructure are the best way to account for the changes in return expectations related to climate change. The drawback is, of course, liquidity. In future research, we will explore options for investors that are keen to gain exposure to infrastructure and renewable resources plays through public/liquid markets.  

Second, it is becoming obvious that the consequences of climate change are extremely uneven from one year to the next as well as from a geographic perspective. This makes overall uncertainty increase as well as introduces more heterogeneity in returns within asset classes.

Our illustrative portfolios also suggest that the overall increase in return heterogeneity creates a powerful argument for active management. In other words, if the role of beta becomes increasingly challenged, the role of alpha in portfolio construction is more important than ever. Generating alpha through greater active management can take many forms, such as a dynamic asset allocation that overlays SAA, or by taking thematic positions within asset classes (e.g. focusing exclusively on exposure to “green” infra, implementing a strategic underweight to specific GICs sectors within public equity portfolios, or allocating to specific alternative public equity strategies in climate themes). 

When it comes to grocery shopping, it’s more likely than not that you will purchase products from large conglomerates owning some of the most well-known brands. Products like Activia yoghurt, Ben & Jerry’s ice cream, Oral-B toothbrushes, Palmolive soap and Nespresso machines all originate from influential conglomerates such as Danone, Unilever, Procter & Gamble, Colgate-Palmolive, Nestlé, General Mills, and Reckitt Benckiser. Data reveals that Unilever, Colgate, P&G, L’Oreal, and Kimberly-Clark collectively command a substantial 35% of the worldwide revenue share in personal care and cleaning products. In the food and beverage market, Danone, Nestlé, PepsiCo. JBS, AB InBev, and Tyson amass a significant worldwide 17% market share.

These conglomerates not only have significant market presence, but some enjoy recognition as ESG darlings. To provide valuable insights, we conducted an analysis that focuses on the top performers among GICS Consumer Staples companies in personal care, household and food products industries with a market capitalization exceeding 30 billion USD. Our nine “darlings of ESG” are identified through their high ranking (above 85th percentile) among an aggregate of ESG score providers as well as their significant presence in SDFR Article 9 funds. Within these nine companies, an unsettling irony emerges; five of them hold positions among the world’s top ten plastic polluters, according to the Break Free from Plastic movement.

 

In a previous note, titled "A Reality Check About Plastic Fantasies" on April 20, 2023, we shed light on the environmental issues stemming from the production and disposal of plastics and the difficulty in finding alternatives to plastic. It seems counterintuitive that the five giants – Danone, Nestlé, Unilever, Procter & Gamble and Colgate-Palmolive - are receiving accolades for their sustainability practices given their massive involvement in plastic production. In the table below, we summarize the main reasons why the consensus accepts these companies as sustainability leaders within their industry.

While these initiatives and commitments appear commendable, it’s difficult to assess which of these companies are truly leading. We therefore apply SASB standards to analyze operational performance. The latter are designed to facilitate the disclosure of financially material sustainability information to investors. Our analysis uncovers disparities in the level of disclosure among the companies, as shown in the table below.

 

The table demonstrates that each of these companies possess operational strengths as well as areas for improvement. That said, Nestlé and Unilever have demonstrated superior performance in their respective industries. Their comprehensive disclosures and proactive approaches to water management, energy efficiency, product safety, and sustainability initiatives set them apart from competitors. On the other hand, despite their image as “ESG darlings,” we believe that Danone, Procter & Gamble and Colgate-Palmolive have more room to improve.

The table below compares companies across the primary SASB materiality metrics, with multiple companies from the same industry.

It is evident that Nestlé, Danone and Unilever stand out among their industry peers, Procter & Gamble, and Colgate-Palmolive, in terms of their lower environmental intensities, higher representation of women on boards, and stronger percentile ranks across various sustainability metrics, even though it varies between metrics. They have demonstrated a commitment to reducing their greenhouse gas emissions, water consumption, and waste generation, while also promoting gender diversity in leadership positions.

However, it is important to acknowledge that each company has its own weaknesses in certain areas. Colgate, despite not facing significant controversies in the past, lags behind its competitors in terms of its environmental performance. Nestlé, although seen as a leader in sustainability practices, continues to face accusations of child labor, which raises concerns.

Critically, the information cited above is primarily sourced from the companies themselves and may not provide a complete picture, particularly when it comes to addressing the controversies they face. The proceeding table lists the major controversies that have occurred at these firms over the past 2 years.

Of particular note is that despite strong commitments made by these companies to affordability and product access, there have been several instances of backlash regarding pricing practices. This misalignment raises questions about their ability to uphold the values they promise to deliver.

A final point is that some of the products offered by companies such as Unilever, Colgate-Palmolive, and Procter & Gamble, Danone and Nestlé seem extremely counterintuitive from a sustainability perspective. For example, Danone, a company that is predominantly focused on food and dairy products derives 16% of its revenues from (plastic!) bottled water manufacturing. Moreover, Nestlé took the decision mid-2023 to abandon its net-zero commitments for certain brands.

Even after a thorough analysis, it remains challenging to determine which consumer conglomerates - if any - truly stand out, given their mixed performance on various sustainability indicators. This poses a question of whether investing in these “ESG darlings” is the right choice. While they bear a great responsibility as some of the most influential companies in the world, it is noteworthy that their large sales volumes also contribute to higher pollution levels.

Demographics

Population growth often drives consumption growth. With more people, the overall demand for goods and services increases through household formation. Increasing demand allows the government to increase spending on public services and infrastructure. It also supports investment and technological innovation because there are more potential clients for new products. Increase in the working-age population has another advantage: a competitive labor force, as we have seen with the tremendous economic growth experienced in China over the last 50 years.

The following chart highlights the working age population growth rate of India and China relative to their economic growth rates over the last 50 years. Throughout this period, China had much higher economic growth compared to its population as it became a global manufacturing hub. India’s economy also grew strongly throughout the period, but at approximately half of the speed of China.

Over the last 50 years, China built tremendous infrastructure and subsidized exports through low wages. Since 2008, China has continued its model of using debt to finance infrastructure spending and keep strong growth as its working-age population starts to drop. They have built phantom cities and uneconomical infrastructure. Those excesses combined with a falling overall population are a recipe for stagnation. On the other hand, India grew slower and underinvested in infrastructure while they still have a growing population. At this point, it is better positioned for the future.

The relationship between population growth and economic growth is not one-dimensional. Income distribution, economic policies, cultural norms, and access to resources also impact economic growth.

The table below provides more explanatory factors for the divergence in economic growth rates between India and China over the past 50 years.

As we look ahead, India could be a major growth beneficiary from demographic trends as China’s labor force continues to shrink. The chart below shows the mismatch between future retirees (50-59 year-old) and future workers (10-19 year-old) in China compared to India. China has a worker replacement problem (11.7% of the population joining the workforce compared to 16% retiring). Meanwhile, India has excess replacement labor: 18% of the population is between 10 and 19 compared to less than 10% between 50 and 59. China can no longer rely on a cheap labor advantage while India still can.

Moreover, geopolitics are pushing some countries to look for alternative manufacturing spots outside of China. Countries like Vietnam, Malaysia and Indonesia have cheap labor but export shipments from those countries need to cross the Malacca Strait which could be problematic during a conflict. Mexico stands to benefit as a viable manufacturing option, as we wrote in a previous note: “Made in China Mexico” on July 5th, 2023, but its population is too small to completely replace China’s workforce. Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and India are poised to absorb some of China’s de-shoring because they have cheaper labor than Mexico and transport access.

 

Geography

Geography plays a crucial role in shaping the economy of India. India is a diverse country with varying geographical features. India has a direct access to the Indian Ocean with deep ports and maritime infrastructure that can accommodate large vessels. This access places it at the crossroads of major global shipping lanes from the Middle East to East Asia, providing a great strategic advantage.

Agriculture remains very important in India. According to the World Bank, more than 50% of its population is considered farmers and landholding is highly fragmented. As a result, India is considered self-sufficient and is a net exporter of food compared to China that has less than 25% of its population in farming and is a net importer of food.

However, India's farm economy heavily depends on the monsoon and irregular monsoons could create havoc on agricultural output. Glacier melting is a secondary factor for agriculture but it is very important for river flow with 3 of the 5 most important rivers in India directly dependent: the Indus, Ganges and Brahmaputra. This means that climate change could have a large impact on the regularity of the monsoon and the navigability of rivers. Moreover, excessive heat, especially in Northern India, could impact productivity and lead to migration. Studies have shown that the body does not function well over 40 degrees of heat.

The table below highlights the potential regional issues that India faces from a warming climate.

In sum, India’s geography is a positive from its strategic location, its diversity and its food self-sufficiency but climate change could block its way on the road to economic success because the country is already very warm and crucially depends on water availability.

 

Policy

Throughout its history, India's industrial policies have evolved to strike a balance between protectionism, self-reliance, and opening up to international trade and investment. The country continues to implement measures to support domestic industries, foster innovation, and integrate into the global economy. However, there is an ongoing debate on the appropriate level of protectionism, considering the need to remain competitive and address the challenges of a rapidly changing global economic landscape.

The table below shows the general policy evolution of India since its independence. Even as policies remain relatively protective, India is cautiously opening up to the world to take advantage of its potential.

Historically, India has tried to remain independent in global affairs. It is currently being courted by the West to act as a counterweight to China; its strategic autonomy is an asset.

 

Risks

One of the main risks for India is that recent improvements could be temporary:

Other risks that could destabilize the country include the conflict with Pakistan that could explode at any moment, the border/water dispute with China and the effects of climate change.

 

How to invest?

We expect India to be a strong source of opportunities for investors looking for sustainable companies. Strong demographics, diversified geography with a strategic position on the Indian Ocean and supportive policies are to the country’s advantage. The table below highlights large, sustainable Indian companies across sectors that are poised to participate in the build-out of the Indian economy.

As the chart below shows, we have selected companies that have a high percentile ESG performance compared to peers.

The following chart highlights the quantitative financial characteristics of our India sustainability picks. Growth is strong but bargains do not abound. From a quantitative standpoint, they look expensive.