The Sustainable Side of Property Insurance
Hurricanes Helene and Milton reminded us that the enjoyment of physical property should not be taken for granted: insurance seems like a useless expense until you really need it.
The table below highlights how insurance contributes to the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals (SDG).
How Insurance Keeps You Covered
Property insurers are the first line of defense that provide coverage for property damage. To make sure they have enough money when large-scale events occur, their actuaries conservatively calculate the required funds necessary in case of an event and regulators put rules in place for them to hold sufficient capital to support the policies they have issued. They use risk transfer techniques like reinsurance, which takes on a portion of financial risk of policies, generally the worst part, for a fee. They use it to protect against the worst events thereby reducing their capital requirements. This allows them to issue more policies with the same capital and grow their business from their direct contact with clients.
For their part, reinsurers take on the financial effects of the worst events and reinsurers also need to be well-capitalized. Reinsurers’ primary risk management tool is to diversify across insurers. But like insurers, they need to transfer risk to grow. Their tools to further spread their downside risk are catastrophe bonds and retrocession, also known as ‘the reinsurance for reinsurers” which generally comes from other reinsurers looking to diversify their exposure. Catastrophe bonds are standardized contracts issued by reinsurers in financial markets; investors get their capital plus interest at the end of the term if no catastrophic event occurs, as defined in the bond document. But, if something bad happens, they get an amount that is inversely proportional to the extent of the damage which can eliminate all of the expected interest payment and also eat in the capital they invested. In essence, the reinsurers get money up front and the investor takes on the risk of a bad event like a hurricane. All of those lines of defense are critical for the property insurance industry to continue to provide their service to property owners.
The picture below simplistically depicts how property insurance operates starting from the coverage of the property to who ultimately bears the risk to the property. At the property level, the property is insured but there is a deductible and some exceptions that are not insured, so the owner bears some of the risk and the client-facing insurer takes the rest. The client-facing insurer unloads the downside portion of its exposure to reinsurance which unloads the downside portion of its exposure to retrocession or insurance-linked securities.

When Insurers Can No Longer Provide Affordable Coverage
Population size and property values in risk-prone areas have exploded from a combination of older people looking for clement weather and easy access to credit. Insurers can no longer provide coverage at affordable prices in certain regions and governments have stepped in to complement or replace the private sector. The table below highlights places where government has had to step in. It may seem weird that taxpayer money goes to insure new multi-million dollar beach front properties in a high risk-zone such as Florida, but it is a reality. Like most insurance coverage, government-backed schemes use reinsurance as a risk mitigation tool.
Reinsurance to the Rescue
Property reinsurance requires sophisticated modeling and risk management, but it is a relatively simple business from a profitability standpoint: premiums plus investment income fewer claims and expenses determine profitability. The chart below shows the stock performance of a reinsurer index compared to an index of insurance-linked securities; there is a very high correlation between the two. From 2010 to 2017, both were going up, then they based for 5 years during a period of weak pricing power while claims increased. Since the pandemic, both insurers and reinsurers have had solid price performance.
To illustrate further the cyclical nature of the industry, the chart below highlights the insurance-linked securities index, which is a proxy for the profitability of the industry on a year-on-year basis and the property renewal rate index which shows the pricing power of the industry. Pricing power weakens when the industry is most profitable: past performance attracts more capital and this new capital tries to gain new business with lower prices which puts pressure on prices across the industry. As we can see on the chart, renewal rates were at their weakest in 2018 after seven years of strong profitability. A few years of poor profitability from 2018 to 2021, exacerbated by high inflation, resulted in extremely strong pricing power and much better profitability in the past few years.
Compare insurance, reinsurance and the S&P 500 Index, reinsurance has been one of the few subsectors that have nearly matched the strong performance of the S&P 500. We can also see a significant fall in price at the start of the pandemic for reinsurers because they also cover extreme mortality events on top of property insurance. The risk for reinsurers at the onset of the pandemic was excess mortality from COVID which turned out to be less than originally feared. During the pandemic, reinsurers’ stock price fell much more than insurers when confronted with a potentially large event because they take on the extreme downside risk.
Insurance in a Changing Climate
The growing frequency and severity of climate-related events, such as floods, wildfires, hurricanes, and other natural disasters, has forced insurers to reevaluate their business models and adapt to manage rising risks and ensure long-term sustainability. Some of the techniques involved in doing this include:
- Enhancing risk models with advanced technologies and data analytics that take the impact of climate change into account.
- Adopting location-based pricing where the price or coverage is tied to the geographic risk of climate change.
- Promoting climate-resilient practices with discounts for flood-resistant materials and storm-resistant infrastructure.
- Transferring of a greater proportion of their climate-related risk to reinsurers.
On the regulatory side, many jurisdictions are imposing stricter environmental and climate-related disclosures that insurers have to deal with.
An Overview of Key Reinsurance Companies
For the purpose of this note, we look at reinsurers with significant portions of their business in the Property and Casualty (P&C) segment. We concentrate our efforts on six public companies with more than 30% of their revenues originating from P&C reinsurance. Renaissance Re is the purest play while Scor has the lowest exposure.
Reinsurance Leaders
In general, reinsurers have improved their financial performance: strong pricing power and decent claim experiences have been the drivers. Nonetheless, as the price chart below highlights, there are discrepancies amongst the companies. Arch Capital has rewarded its shareholders the best and Scor, has performed the worst.
There are a few important reasons behind the diverging performance of these companies, including growth, risk management, claims experience, expense control and balance sheet management. The table below highlights how each company has performed along these vectors.
To further illustrate the gap in financial performance between companies, the chart below highlights the return on tangible equity for each company. There is a strong link between this measure and stock performance. SCOR is at the bottom just like its stock performance.
Earlier this year, we published a note on the Testing, Inspection and Certification (TIC) market (Testing the TIC Market, June 6, 2024) whose growth is supported by increased awareness of environmental and social issues and accompanied by stricter regulations. Today, we expand on that research, focusing specifically on companies providing services and tools used in the testing segment.
Testing Extends Beyond Certification of ESG Credentials
Similar to the inspection and certification segments, firms complying with sustainability standards and looking to showcase it will also support increased spend on testing. Testing is needed to be able to label a product as free of certain harmful substances or tout a cleaner production process. Additionally, regulatory requirements that mandate certain types of testing also provide a steady stream of revenue separate from verifying green credentials.
While certification and elective inspections may be more tied to voluntary ESG disclosures, even companies with little interest in sustainability must comply with mandated testing. This provides a broad customer base and stable revenues, somewhat insulated from evolving attitudes toward ESG reporting (though we expect voluntary disclosures on these topics to continue, see previous TIC note).
Consider the recent regulatory change for American water utilities. In April, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) passed a new law that made water utility companies responsible for the monitoring and treatment of PFAs (also known as forever chemicals) in drinking water. Introduction of more routine monitoring and reporting of PFA levels will increase spending on testing. Although PFAs have long been recognized as harmful, new research showing that even low levels of exposure have negative consequences was the driver for the regulation change. We expect regulatory trends to continue to evolve in this direction as more is understood about the effects of chemicals present in our environment.
Historically, pharmaceuticals, food and consumer products (toys, apparel, cosmetics) have been the most relevant industries for the testing market. But if the information on PFAs is any indication, harmful substances are everywhere.
Growing Scrutiny on Chemicals
In 2016, under the Obama administration but with broad bipartisan support, the Toxic Substances Control Act underwent significant changes to strengthen the authority of the EPA in assessing chemicals. While the implementation of new bans by the EPA has faced some challenges, the bipartisan reform laid the groundwork for expanded regulatory action. The work on PFAs being one positive example.
The EPA maintains a list of chemicals identified for their association to acute health and/or environmental effects in the Toxic Release Inventory (TRI) program. Since 2015, 30 new chemicals and over 172 PFAs (tracked separately since 2020) have been added to the list. The program helps monitor industrial management of these chemicals.
America’s efforts are widely considered to lag behind the EU. The U.S. is criticized for failing to reassess previously approved substances and there are significant differences in the way the two regions address the food and cosmetics industries. There is plenty of room for improvement.
Indeed, stricter regulation is not without some hurdles. In the U.S. for example, Project 2025 suggests Trump plans to overhaul the EPA if elected and new regulations can be subject to legal challenges. However, public opinion strongly favors greater protection from harmful chemicals. A national survey of registered voters in the U.S. found that 54% think chemical regulations are not strong enough and 89% agree (56% strongly) with the Toxic Substances Control Act’s goal to make it easier to limit or ban harmful chemicals. The results of OECD project: Surveys on Willingness-to-Pay to Avoid Negative Chemicals-Related Health Impacts (SWACHE) show that globally 82% support stricter government action on chemicals (see chart below).
Perhaps this is not so surprising. After scandals such as tobacco, PFAs and opioids (see The Pain Trade: New Frontier of Non-Opioid Investments, August 8, 2024) consumers are justifiably skeptical of industrials’ claims of product safety. Greater awareness supports public demand for stricter oversight by third parties. This spells growth for the testing market; driven by both regulators and brands that are eager to demonstrate their product’s safety. Furthermore, in addition to checking for harmful chemicals, testing is also done to ensure overall quality assurance.
The Testing Ground: Healthcare Companies Rule the Testing Industry
It is not hard to see why testing companies fit into a sustainability investment strategy. Much like the TIC companies, the testing work being done is in direct connection with environmental protection by verifying that standards are upheld. A reliable reputation is the nature of the business and so these companies typically exhibit top ESG scores and tend to be free from controversy.
From our previous TIC industry research, we reaffirm our recommendations for Bureau Veritas, Intertek and SGS. These companies have made noteworthy acquisitions in the testing space. SGS acquired AQM and Cromanal, and Intertek is set to acquire Controle Analitico (environmental analysis), and Base Met Labs (metallurgical testing services).
Expanding beyond these TIC companies, we searched for identified competitors with a specialization in the laboratory or testing market that had a market cap above $1 billion USD. Most of these companies are classified in the healthcare sector though their testing capabilities have applications beyond this.
The healthcare sector is among the most strictly regulated industries where safety and accuracy are top priorities. It is therefore not surprising that the largest testing companies would have originated in this field, as their expertise in working with chemicals and complex testing can be effectively applied across other industries. Testing companies with exposure to healthcare tend to exhibit greater revenue stability compared to those relying on more cyclical sectors like consumer goods, for which testing revenues can be sensitive to product volumes. For example, Mettler Toledo, Bruker, and Horiba have betas greater than one, likely reflecting their lower healthcare exposure. Horiba, in particular, derives a substantial portion of its revenue from more volatile sectors such as automotive (28%) and semiconductors (39%).
These large testing companies also operate on a global scale with revenues well diversified across the Americas, Europe and Asia. Horiba being the exception with greater concentration in Asia (24% of revenues from Japan and 22% from China).
Under the current macroeconomic context (see last week’s note Macro Meets Sustainability: Outlook for Q4 and Beyond) where defensive sectors are looking increasingly attractive, we prioritize testing companies that lean more to the defensive side. Financial data for these companies is presented in the table below.
These firms are characterized by quality financial standing in terms of sound leverage and cash flows. Nearly all of the leading testing companies, with the exception of Eurofins, look expensive with valuations exceeding the S&P 500 forward P/E of 21.
Waters stands out with the highest profitability, evidenced by its leading EBITDA and Net Margin. Waters is primarily an equipment provider to laboratories rather than running the testing itself.
The sales growth of these companies has been skewed by the COVID-19 pandemic which significantly increased demand for testing services. This effect is reflected in the three-year sales growth numbers, with more recent sales growth indicating decline. Waters, Agilent and Thermo Fisher are however showing signs of return to a pre-pandemic normal in 2024.
In contrast, Danaher appears to still be facing some struggles, relatively weaker sales combined with its higher valuation (Forward P/E 36.5) make it a less attractive option. Though the spinoff of its Environmental and Applied Sciences segment at the end of last year (Veralto Corp.) is an opportunity in the water testing market. Eurofins was also significantly impacted by the Covid effects. The company does not release quarterly data, though its H1 2024 results saw some improvement which helped raise the stock price. Eurofins also has the lowest margins of the group.
Agilent, Waters and Thermo Fisher have just slightly underperformed the SP500 in the last year. Their exposure to stable revenue sources and a return to pre-pandemic sales levels suggest it could be time for a breakout.
In our last macro update (March 27, 2024), we had argued that the rate backdrop had become relatively benign for equity markets and that investors should begin to reflect on sector implications of a potential Trump presidency. The interest rate environment was indeed calm over the past six months: the Fed is on the cusp of its first interest rate reduction in over four years and has managed to stay very aligned with financial market participants’ expectations. However, whether the Fed can continue to deliver the rate cuts that are expected after September still depends on inflation. While there is more and more indication of lagging economic activity (in particular, we highlight below the impact of worsening credit conditions for consumers), the Fed can only provide stimulus if progress toward lowering inflation to 2% is sufficient. The most recent data was not encouraging in this regard; August data shows that progress at bringing down core CPI has stalled and prices continued to rise over the summer at over 3% annually.
On this basis, it’s hard to see how the Fed moves to a more accommodative stance barring a severe weakening (contraction) in economic growth. The bottom line is that contrary to the past six months when the Fed and market expectations of interest rate policy have been well aligned, odds are rising that policymakers will be unable to deliver on market expectations for rate cuts of 75 – 150 bps by year end.
Meanwhile, judging by the election betting markets after Tuesday’s Presidential debate, the likelihood is increasing for a Democratic win, reducing the allure of the “Trump trade” (i.e. overweight positions in USD, prisons, banks and oil companies).
From a sustainability perspective, the debate bolstered our suspicion that Harris is unlikely to make bold moves regarding major issues like climate change, climate adaptation and health care. Climate change was nary discussed, except to underscore that Harris would not ban fracking. On healthcare, she promised to “strengthen” Obamacare and to keep in place the Biden’s administration $2,000 cap on out-of-pocket prescription drug costs, which is slated to take effect for Medicare enrollees in 2025.
In terms of overall government spending, the debate confirmed our view that irrespective of the election result, U.S. fiscal spending will be neither headwind nor tailwind for financial markets in Q4 2024 and 2025.
The chart below shows that in the U.S., the fiscal policy contribution to real GDP growth will become roughly neutral in the fourth quarter of 2024, and be mildly negative throughout 2025. The Brookings Institute’s projection shown in the chart assumes an extension of the provisions of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act that are set to expire at the end of 2025, an assumption that we find most plausible. Trump has stated that if he wins, the tax cuts will of course be extended, while Harris pledges to re-distribute the fiscal burden among tax brackets. In both cases, overall tax revenues will not look very different.
Overall, the conclusions from our recent note covering the U.S. election “US Election Color Wheel: Spotting the Green in the Blue vs. Red Landscape” still hold: Harris’ approach of an “all of the above” domestic energy policy (including fracking) is unlikely to tarnish the allure of investing in regulated carbon markets. Meanwhile, sectors like engineering services will prove resilient regardless of who makes it to the White House since it’s now common lore that the U.S. needs improved infrastructure as well as more (cheap and clean) energy.
What else should thematic sustainability investors keep an eye on in the months ahead? Consumer health and a potential defensive rotation top our list.
Consumer Check- Up
Financial market pundits are ratcheting up expectations for a recession, which typically means bear market. But for the U.S. to slide into recession, it will take a much bigger crack in consumer spending.
With excess savings now largely been worked off, credit cards and other forms of consumer financing have also become more heavily tapped. So much so that lending institutions are beginning to ring a warning bell. Comments from consumer finance company Ally Financial earlier this week – and the company’s stock price reaction (-19%) – particularly struck us. The CFO articulated a view whereby borrowers have been struggling with the cost of living, and now are also faced with a deteriorating employment backdrop; late-stage loan delinquencies are rising and there is a necessity to shore up reserves.
To be sure, the Fed’s highly anticipated September interest rate cut is designed to alleviate building stressors in the consumer sector and interest rates at the long end have already declined somewhat. Nonetheless, consumers are less sanguine about their economic prospects and it is rational that this translates into a pullback in discretionary spending.
So far, 2024 has already seen a modest outperformance of consumer staples stocks relative to consumer discretionary names when looking at the overall S&P sectors. This is true even when omitting index heavyweights Tesla and Amazon from the discretionary universe. Given the discussion above, we expect that staples will continue to outperform discretionary stocks as consumers pull back spending.
Admittedly, however, sustainability concerns have not been a factor in driving the outperformance of staples: since January, SMS’ universe of consumer staples sustainability winners (primarily food companies) has only performed on par with our universe of consumer discretionary sustainability losers. Much of the disappointing result is coming from strong price appreciation of single names in our consumer discretionary short universe: despite sub-par ESG and sustainability records, cost-conscious consumers have not shied away from fast-fashion (Abercrombie & Fitch is up 67% YTD) and fast food (Wingstop and Brinker International are up 61% and 48%, respectively). Although this underscores the need for strong stock selection, as we wrote in a recent note “Consumers Bite Off More Than They Can Chew: An Outlook for the Restaurant Industry”, the current economic environment nonetheless implies less restaurants (discretionary) and more food at home (staples). We expect that the outperformance of staples will continue and stronger sustainability candidates offering good value will be propelled higher.
Defensive Rotation?
The decent performance of consumer staples recently is of course also thanks to an important rotation out of tech stocks that began this summer. We continue to believe that risks favor more air coming out of still sky-high valuations in AI-hyped stocks and it’s not just staples that will benefit. The health care sector helps form the backbone of diversified sustainability portfolios and current macro conditions are helpful for this sector.
Overall, the health care sector displays defensive characteristics much like staples; it’s hard to cut back on medications and health care procedures even when times get tougher. It is worth noting that Harris acknowledged the ravages of the fentanyl crisis in the Presidential debate and that the NOPAIN Act (Non-Opioids Prevent Addiction in the Nation Act) is a popular, bipartisan legislative effort, aiming to reduce opioid dependence by expanding access to non-opioid pain management treatments. Starting in 2025 separate Medicare reimbursement for FDA-approved non-opioid therapies will be provided, particularly in outpatient surgical settings. Pharmaceutical companies such as Pacira BioSciences (PCRX US), Indivior (INDV LN), and Vertex Pharmaceuticals (VRTX US) are developing non-opioid alternatives, positioning themselves as promising investments.
More Money Going Out than Coming In
Budget deficits have been growing since the beginning of the century. An older population with large entitlements has driven to the deterioration of government finances. The chart below shows deficits as a % of GDP for G20 countries plus Singapore and Ireland (the latter two are especially relevant to the topic of corporate taxes). Out of the 22 countries, 16 experienced a deterioration (higher deficit as a % of GDP) since 2003, four have improved and two have stayed the same.
We Want More but Are Starved for Cash
Governments have spent more and taxed less - and yet opinion surveys show that respondents are not happy with the leadership of their countries. The chart below shows that on average, respondents think that their society is broken and their country is in decline, and that elites act for their own good more than for the public good. They want to increase spending on infrastructure, health care and education – all this without increasing taxes. Even Sweden, a Nordic country and often the poster child of an egalitarian approach - fares very poorly. A surprising fact is that the Sweden surveys have significantly deteriorated since the onset in 2016 whereas the average of countries has remained at about the same disgruntled level. On the other hand, Singaporeans do not believe their country is in decline or that their society is broken. They also have a more favorable view of elites.
What Are Potential Solutions for Smaller Deficits?
Considering the high likelihood that government expenses keep on growing with a greying population, more revenues will be needed to keep the current level of services. In this context, the solution probably lies on the revenue side of the equation. The table below highlights many of the options available for government to increase their revenues. In a world of high-income inequality, we have highlighted the first row because those options seem more likely to be chosen because they disproportionately affect the rich.
Profits Rise, Workers Left Behind
The current economic landscape is marked by corporate profits reaching historical highs as a percentage of GDP. This phenomenon reflects a significant shift in the distribution of economic gains, where corporations have managed to increase efficiency, reduce costs, and leverage technology to boost profitability. However, this trend raises concerns about the broader economic implications, particularly in terms of income inequality and wage stagnation. As profits surge, workers' share of economic output has not kept pace, leading to growing disparities. This situation underscores the need for policy discussions around tax reform, corporate responsibility, and labor rights to ensure a more equitable distribution of economic prosperity.
The charts below show the effective tax rate for the largest public companies in the world from 2008 to 2023; most of the lines are downward sloping, indicating that the largest companies are paying less as a % of their profits. Reverting to the 2008 effective tax rate would bring in substantial revenue for governments and we believe they have their eye on it. Only Exxon Mobile and Costco have an effective tax rate significantly over 20%.
Maximum Profits, Minimum Taxes
To reduce their tax burden, companies are willing to use complex structures to hide their true economic reality from the taxmen. The table below highlights some of the tricks of the trade and their weird names.
Strait Success-Luck of the Irish
The economies of Ireland and Singapore have performed exceptionally well since the beginning of the century, in large part, because of their low tax regime. The chart below shows the importance of corporate taxes in Singapore and Ireland compared with the United States and a middle of the road country like Sweden. Even with a very low effective tax rate, Ireland and Singapore have a much larger contribution of corporate taxes compared to their overall taxes. It is obvious that multinational companies are moving profits to be taxed at a lower rate.
Stocks Soar, Will Taxes Roar?
The charts below highlight the stock performance of the largest corporations in the world. These companies have enjoyed amazing growth in profitability. The median performer is Eli Lilly: if you had invested 1,000$ in 2008 in its stock, it would be worth close to 20,000$ excluding the dividends you have received.
Most of these companies have been arbitraging corporate taxes on a global basis. Spanning our list of the largest companies with effective tax rates much below 15%, Apple and Alphabet have used the Double Irish with a Dutch Sandwich strategy to shift profits to Ireland, while Nvidia, Broadcom and Johnson & Johnson have also shifted some of their profits to lower tax jurisdictions. but Tesla has been less active on the tax front, benefitting from EV subsidies, instead. For companies with an effective rate closer to 20%, Microsoft, Amazon, Eli Lilly and Meta have large Irish operations.
What Comes Next?
In the first year of the Biden administration, Democrats recognized the big revenue opportunity regarding corporate taxes and the problem of tax optimization; Janet Yellen led an effort to apply a 15% global minimum tax. However, implementation has been slow: members of the European Union are in the process of incorporating the minimum tax in their national laws, the United States are committed to the minimum tax but face ongoing legislative challenges and other countries like Australia, Canada and Japan are working on its implementation. These initiatives are moving slowly against the will of big corporate lobbies, but they are moving. Moreover, a similar initiative for billionaires is being considered.
We believe that current beneficiaries of tax management (large multinational corporations, billionaires and tax havens) will be under more scrutiny and will bear the brunt of upcoming adjustments. The timing and the specific groups targeted are somewhat unclear but the driving factors for higher corporate tax rates are all in place: income inequality is persisting or increasing, public sentiment toward the elites and governments is very poor and some politicians have espoused economic fairness and redistribution as their calling card.
With U.S. interest rates now on a downward trajectory – approximately 200 basis points of cuts are anticipated over the next 24 months – and electoral polls indicating a tight race between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris, today’s note revisits the performance of our sustainability themes during electoral periods. We also assess the economic and policy differences between the 2020 context and today and explore opportunities for re-entry into some of our favorite investment themes.
First, we examine the performance of seventeen of SMS’ sustainable investment themes three months before, and three months after the 2020 election. Recall that interest rates were near zero during this period due to COVID-19. Some themes, such as Human Capital (which includes edtech, up 68%), Tech Infrastructure, and Transition Materials (up 45%), performed exceptionally well, while others, like Alternative Energy, somewhat underperformed (up 5%) post-election – especially we consider that the S&P 500 was up by some 10 percentage points in the three months following the election. In our view, the performance of many of our themes was driven more by market momentum and close-to-zero interest rates than by any government policies discussed during the 2020 election.
As such, there was a clear rotation in and out of several sustainable investment themes following the 2020 election. This time around, investors should also be prepared for another election-based market shift – especially if we consider that market participants already penciled in a Trump victory - and discounted several sustainability plays. Now that a Harris victory is the cards, investors could re-ignite the kind of hype in themes such as renewables and energy transition we last witnessed in 2019-20.
A second consideration is to explore how the election could alter the fundamental trajectory of U.S. policymaking, which could also impact several of our investment themes. The table below outlines our expectations for what could stay the same versus what could change following the election - and identifies potential areas for surprise.
Given the table above, we suggest four sustainable investment ideas that take into account the current U.S. political and monetary backdrop: Shorting prisons, going long on carbon, engineering firms, and renewable energy.
Short Prisons
Private prisons remain a contentious theme in the U.S., with equity prices in the sector closely tracking electoral polls. While Kamala Harris would likely aim to shut down private prisons and prolong Biden’s policy on the matter, Donald Trump would probably expand their role in the U.S. carceral system. As Harris is currently leading Trump in the polls, prison stock prices have already receded. Companies such as GEO Group (GEO US) have already profited from stricter immigration control policies, including electronic surveillance through apps, which have boosted revenues for companies in the sector. One could expect such controls to be less infringing on immigrant rights should Harris win, likely capping prison stock prices.
From a valuation perspective, prison stock prices also seem stretched when considering their 12-month trailing P/E ratios – they are trading at a 50 percent premium compared to their 2020 levels. That said, as immigration remains an important electoral theme – and in a context where private prisons increasingly rely on immigration flows as a source of revenue - we recommend taking a smaller short position on this theme while continuing to monitor polls closely.
Long Carbon
One of the starkest wedge issues between Kamala Harris and Donald Trump is their stance on the environment and carbon. Kamala Harris, known for her prosecutorial background, did not hesitate to take on Big Oil and win a settlement for the people of California over environmental damage from climate-warming fossil fuel emissions. In contrast, Donald Trump advocates for minimal, if any, environmental regulations.
This divergence in views is evident in North American regulated carbon markets. December 2024 carbon futures have recently plummeted due to 1) the prospect of Trump winning the election (especially when he was leading in polls), 2) the politicization of carbon markets (the State of Washington has put the termination of its newly created carbon market on the November 5th ballot), and 3) retail investors feeling the pressure and cashing out of their positions.
That being said, current North American carbon auction pricing dynamics are approaching the government-set floor price of $24.04, which is 25% lower than the most recent auction price of $30.24. As a reminder, the floor price is set by WCI member governments to increase by 5% plus inflation every year. For an investor with a six-year time horizon, the floor price will be equivalent to the current price in 2030, even if inflation is 0% between now and then. Investors now have the chance to buy the equivalent of a convertible bond that will pay inflation between now and 2030 with a conversion price equivalent to the current price. If the price of carbon credits rises to last spring’s peak of $44, a return of almost 50% could be achieved. For public market access to this play, investors can purchase the KCCA ETF, which has dropped by about 25 percentage points since its February 2024 peak.
Furthermore, the foundations of the North American carbon market remain strong. New York State is contemplating the creation of its own market, which could potentially merge with the Western Climate Initiative, which include the main players in the market such as California and Québec. Additionally, current electricity demand trends in North America, particularly in California, suggest that the scarcity of emission rights could return soon amid a growth in production – including from non-renewable sources. This is currently our strongest conviction for a “Kamala trade.”
Long Renewable Energy
In a recent note, we recommended re-entering the renewables sector when and if interest rates began to decline (see our note “A Second Wind: What Peak Interest Rates Mean for Renewables” March 21, 2024). Now that approximately 200 basis points of rate cuts are priced in over the next 24 months, we are somewhat surprised that the sector hasn’t yet rebounded, especially in light of recent trends in energy demand in the U.S. In that, we think that the time to re-enter the renewables space is now.
While we don’t anticipate additional government funding à la Biden IRA for the sector just yet, overweighting the sector could makes sense if you think that Kamala will make it to the White House. Companies - developers and operators - that have demonstrated strong revenue growth these past years amid higher interest rates – such as Acciona and Hannon Armstrong – could strongly reprice positively in the coming months, even if they are already trading at high P/E ratios.
Long Engineering & Construction
Given that infrastructure spending is likely to persist regardless of who wins the White House, the Engineering Services sector looks promising, especially for companies with a strong presence in the United States. We place particular emphasis on those that have developed leading sustainability practices. Many of the companies listed below have integrated sustainability as a key feature of their practice, making them a natural fit for sustainability-focused portfolios as they are the builders of infrastructure of the future.
The sector has substantially outperformed the rest of the stock market since November 2020 and, to much surprise, has even proved resilient to the current higher interest rate environment. To this end, SMS’s Green Engineering Leaders Equal-Weighted Index has outperformed both the S&P and Nasdaq by nearly 100 percentage points since Biden was elected to the White House in 2020. Given both parties’ interest in improving infrastructure, we believe this trend will continue for the foreseeable future. Companies like Stantec and Arcadis stand out in this group for their sustainability features and relatively attractive valuations.
Macro: “A Tall Order for Restaurants”
At the start of the month, U.S. Employment data sent a shock wave through financial markets. There were fewer jobs created than was expected and the unemployment rate increased to its highest level since October 2021. And just yesterday, a significant downward revision of the number of jobs created in the 12 months leading up to March 2024 was announced. This trend does not bode well for discretionary spending like restaurants, especially when interest rates remain elevated.
Although subsequent data struck a more “goldilocks” tone, we still see reasons to believe that households will curtail spending at restaurants:
- Although overall inflation fell below the 3% mark for the first time in over three years, for food prices, the cost of dining out is significantly outpacing the cost of eating at home. To be sure, restaurant food inflation can be taken as a sign that restaurants have been able to pass on higher input costs to consumer. However, as the relative cost of dining out vs dining in become stretched, we expect that more consumers will turn budget-conscious and opt for eating at home.
- The latest retail sales may have surprised to the upside, but a closer look at spend on bar and restaurants shows that spending on food away from home is starting to plateau since its post-pandemic boom (see chart below). On a monthly basis, food services and bar sales increased 0.3% while grocery store sales rose by 1% reflecting the swap to dining in as mentioned above. These observations are especially noteworthy given that retail sales data does not adjust for inflation which remains elevated for dining out. Furthermore, sales data for other discretionary areas, like leisure and apparel, were weaker compared to the previous month.
At Sustainable Market Strategies, we are more inclined to short the restaurant industry concerns over nutritional content and quality of employment. This is fitting for the current economic backdrop. However, we also remain vigilant for potential buying opportunities if value has been created. The remainder of today’s note focuses on American publicly traded restaurant companies, as there are virtually no comparable European listed options, and companies listed in Asia are further removed from U.S. economic and consumer data.
Corporate Responsibility in Restaurants: The Long and Short of It
The biggest issue with the restaurant industry is the poor nutritional value offered to customers. In our list of publicly traded American restaurant companies with over 1 billion USD in market cap, most fall into the fast-food category, also known as limited-service restaurants. Sure, everyone loves a treat and the convenience of take out, but the widespread availability of cheap, high calorie meals is problematic: the expansion of fast-food chains has long been associated with rising obesity.
Unfortunately, full-services restaurants, offering sit down meals served by wait staff, don’t fare much better on the nutrition front. Two studies from 2018 showed that meals at full-service restaurants often contain even more calories than the meals at fast-food chains. None of the companies in these two segments (limited and full service) stand out as having a more health-focused brand, we therefore do not consider them for long positions.
The last two decades saw the emergence of a third restaurant category: Fast casual. These restaurants offer the same quick convenience, often in a more upscale dining experience. Fast casual restaurants tend to have more limited menus with basic ingredients, benefitting from simplified supply chains. This category is where we see the greatest potential for long candidates. Not all fast casuals are created equal: some, but by no means all, emphasize healthier menus. We consider what they serve, average calorie content and branding (self-proclaimed mission or menu description). Our analysis identifies Sweetgreen, Chipotle and Cava as candidates for long positions given their lower in calorie and higher in vegetables menus.
According to the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), another material consideration for the restaurant industry is their role as employers. Restaurants are major employers in the U.S., but these jobs tend to offer low pay, few benefits and poor working conditions. None of the companies we reviewed had a CSRHub Employment Score rank within the top 20%. Though none qualify as high-quality employers, we deem companies with scores below the 40th percentile as particularly underperforming. The companies are ordered by their Employment score rank in the table below.
Finally, we assess energy, waste and water metrics (also key topics identified by SASB). The extensive number of restaurant locations makes for a significant environmental footprint. Food safety and Supply Chain Management are also flagged as key issues by SASB. Food safety is difficult to assess beyond health records and past controversies. For supply chain management, we give a leg up to the fast casual restaurants given their simplified menus. The table below presents our findings on the three categories of restaurants.
For the fast casual segment, we retain only Chipotle on the long side. Despite better nutrition in their menus, Cava Group and Sweetgreen (whose labor score is notable) do not have sufficient disclosures to retain as long opportunities. Wingstop is kept as a short candidate given its weaker labor score and lack of reporting on environmental factors. Recall that limited and full-service restaurants are only considered from the short angle given their poor nutritional value. Three shorts are identified in the full-service segment: Darden Restaurants, Texas Roadhouse and Bloomin Brands; and two in the limited-service segment: Domino’s Pizza and Krispy Kreme. These companies are identified as short candidates due to their poor labor scores and weak disclosures.
Various Business Models Drive Diverging Stock Results
Since the pandemic reopening, fast casual restaurants stock prices are the only segment that have outperformed the SP500. The performance or full-service restaurants is relatively flat and limited-service restaurants have seen price declines.
This can be attributed to the different business model characteristics of each of the restaurant segments. Fast casual and full-service restaurants have higher price points and therefore tend to have higher-income patrons that are better able to weather the rising inflation over this period. Up until 2024, the performance of these two segments was mostly aligned. But fast casual has two advantages over full service: health (higher quality menus) and convenience. Customers of these restaurants are seeking the convenience of a fast-food place but willing to pay more for a better quality or more specialized menu.
Most of the short candidates we identified have seen sales growth decline in the first half of 2024 compared to last year. Full-service restaurants have seen sales growth reduce the most (see chart below). Wingstop, in the fast casual segment, has also had waning sales growth, but still remains well above restaurants in the other categories (though this cannot be attributed to customers seeking healthier options and is likelier more the result of expansion). Domino’s is the exception, and may be explained by consumers trading down from fast casual or other more expensive pizza chains. Within the fast-food category, the last two quarters saw sales growth decline for both Starbucks (-0.6%) and Papa John’s (-1.3%) while it remained positive - around 7% - for Krispy Kreme and Domino’s.
In the limited-service (fast food) category, restaurants that are able to offer the best deals will be favored by consumers. With their higher margins, fast food giants like McDonald’s (33% net margin) and Yum! (owner of Taco Bell, KFC and Pizza Hut, net margin of 23%) will have the greatest capacity to offer discounts, cutting prices on some items while maintaining positive margins.
Still, if rates remain elevated and unemployment continues to rise, we expect a further decline across the board for restaurants. It is noteworthy that Krispy Kreme, Domino’s and Wingstop have the highest betas. Chipotle, a long candidate (though too richly valued today), also has a relatively higher beta.
With market breadth at historical lows and only a handful of tech stocks moving entire indices, monopolistic behavior is in the spotlight. Antitrust issues are in the forefront, as seen in legal cases involving real estate services, Live Nation in the entertainment industry, Big Tech like Alphabet, Amazon and META and even in the groceries sector with players like Loblaws and George Weston.
We previously remarked that the current frenzy over AI deserves a closer look over concerns of concentration of economic power in this nascent industry (see our note “History Lessons for an AI Future”, June 20, 2024). Interestingly, it seems that the U.S. FTC might have read our note as it just released a statement whereby the antitrust enforcers of the U.S. (DOJ+FTC), the UK and the EU pledged to “remain vigilant for potential competition issues and expressed their determination to use available powers to safeguard against tactics that would undermine fair competition or lead to unfair or deceptive practices in the AI ecosystem”.
In addition to the technology sector, today’s note looks at pricing power in key industries such as real estate services, entertainment and groceries, and suggests that investors beware of companies that exert too much control and influence.
Case 1: The People vs. Realtors
Every year in the U.S., USD 100 billion worth of commissions go to some 2 million realtors in exchange for their brokerage services. According to a recent report from the Brookings Institute, the lack of price transparency and the opaque commission plans of realtors come at a serious cost to homebuyers and the overall U.S. economy. Recent lawsuits and settlements suggest that real estate brokers, particularly through the workings of the Multiple Listing System (MLS), are coordinating their actions to control the market, limit competition, and keep prices high. This behavior undermines consumer rights and fair market practices and is indicative of broader issues of anti-competitive behavior within the real estate sector. While the stock price of listed real estate brokerage firms did not move much since the latest USD 418 million antitrust settlement in April 2024, the sector has underperformed the S&P 500 substantially since the COVID-era real estate frenzy.
Case 2: The People vs. Canadian Grocers
Canada, like many smaller developed economies, is prone to antitrust behaviors due to its large geographical size and small population, which can justify limited competition in sectors like banking, telecoms, transport, and grocers. The most recent ruling against antitrust-like behavior was addressed last week following a settlement that was reached after Canada’s competition bureau inquired into a potential bread price-fixing scheme among players in Canada’s tightly knit groceries sector. The grocer Loblaw agreed to pay CAD 500 million to settle the lawsuit. While the profit margin of Canada’s main grocers has remained stable since 2019, that of Loblaws has increased.
Interestingly, the stock prices of companies in this sector barely budged following the news, likely reflecting that investors had anticipated the fine and priced it in before the announcement, as the case had been ongoing for years.
Case 3: The People vs. Live Nation
The merger of Live Nation and Ticketmaster in 2010 has resulted in a near-monopoly in the live event ticketing industry. This consolidation has led to increased ticket prices and numerous operational issues, drawing public and legal scrutiny. In a previous note in 2022 (“Miss Materiality’s Night Out: A Lesson in Consumer Choice” December 8, 2022), we highlighted Live Nation’s monopolistic practices, the debate over its market dominance, and its poor operational performance.
This year, among multiple litigation cases regarding the company’s poor practices, the U.S. government and dozens of States sued Live Nation in May, alleging that for years the parent company of Ticketmaster abused its industry dominance at the detriment of fans nationwide. The long-expected suit is seeking a jury trial and a breakup of the company. Live Nation is monopolizing the ticketing and live events industry by cutting exclusive deals with major venues, which has led to higher fees and limited competition. As illustrated in the chart below, Live Nation's venue operations expanded significantly from 2016 to 2023:
If the company were broken up, it could lead to a more competitive market, potentially lowering ticket prices as venues and promoters have more options for ticketing services. However, the complexity of unravelling Live Nation's operations means that immediate changes might not be drastic. Ticketmaster's well-capitalized structure enables it to offer significant financial incentives to major venues and event promoters, that other companies might struggle to match. The impact on fees and prices could be limited unless other competitors can scale their operations quickly.
For investors, the regulatory risks associated with Live Nation are substantial. A breakup could lead to market volatility in the entertainment industry, with potential short-term declines in Live Nation's stock prices. However, if managed properly, a more competitive landscape could benefit the industry in the long run by improving customer satisfaction and operational efficiency.
Case 4: The People vs. Big Tech
Since the beginning of Biden's mandate, there has been a clear focus on addressing the monopolistic behaviors of major tech companies such as Meta, Alphabet, and Amazon. The administration's intent was to curb tech giants' overwhelming market dominance. The following chart illustrates the number of new litigation cases per year against these companies, highlighting increasing legal scrutiny in recent years.
Despite the growing number of litigation cases, Big Tech companies remain dominant in digital services and market share. During Trump’s presidency, there was a notable push against Big Tech, which included actions against Alphabet for monopolistic practices. His current running mate, J.D. Vance, is also an advocate for strong antitrust measures against Tech monopolies. If Kamala Harris continues on the trajectory of the current administration, we can expect ongoing antitrust enforcement.
The future administration could also heavily influence the development and regulation of AI. While Harris supports Biden’s executive order to advocate for greater public oversight and regulation of AI, Trump has vowed to reverse these measures, potentially loosening the constraints on Tech companies. As it stands, companies like OpenAI, Alphabet, and Meta face significant hurdles in sourcing sufficient high-quality data to train their AI models. This has led them to adopt questionable practices, such as transcribing YouTube videos against the platform's rules and using copyrighted data without proper licenses, highlighting their monopolistic tendencies in circumventing regulations to maintain their dominance.
Meanwhile in Europe, the EU has attempted to regulate the growing influence of AI with the newly enacted EU AI Act. That said, the Act has already faced criticism for not adequately addressing the monopolistic power of dominant tech firms, which continue to control vast amounts of data and market share.
While waiting for more decisive actions against these Big Tech companies, investors can proactively engage with these firms to ensure transparency in practices, avoid regulatory risks, and prevent greenwashing.
Shareholders Vs. Anti-competitive behavior
Following our analysis of anti-competitive practices in various industries, we dive into how investors can drive change within these companies through active engagement and shareholder. We have compiled the following table of shareholder proposals from this year's AGMs for the mentioned companies, focusing on topics related to their oligopolistic practices. These shareholder proposals come from the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility (ICCR), a coalition of organizations that advocate for corporate social responsibility through shareholder engagement and activism.
As an investor, supporting and/or filing proposals can play a crucial role in changing corporate practices. Another form of engagement, dialogue, allows investors to engage directly with companies to discuss concerns and advocate for changes in policies and practices. This method can be particularly effective in addressing monopolistic behaviors by encouraging transparency and accountability. Though finding public data on investor-led dialogues and collaborations can be challenging, when combined with proxy voting, it has a complementary role in influencing corporate behavior. While anticompetitive behaviors and the regulatory risk of being fined or caught do not always affect stock performance, investors should care about their non-financial repercussions, such as investor reputation. Furthermore, it is important to note that while regulatory risks from monopolistic practices do not always impact stock prices immediately, they pose long-term threats to company valuations and investor returns.
Investors can bolster their reputation by engaging on relevant topics that create healthier market structures, thereby avoiding the reputational risk of greenwashing. By leveraging their influence through active engagement and shareholder proposals, investors can play a pivotal role in promoting transparency, and mitigating regulatory risks in companies with monopolistic tendencies.
Shareholder engagement, defined as various strategies investors can use to influence the operational practices of the companies they hold, plays a critical role in driving corporate accountability and sustainable practices. While research suggests no direct link between governance practices and financial returns (see our last note on the topic, “Governance, Are the Efforts All in Vain?”, July 21, 2022), these practices improve the corporate environment by reducing ineffective boards, fostering better decision-making, and curbing overly dominant CEOs. Institutional investors have an outsized influence on corporate governance action. According to Broadridge, in 2022, U.S. retail investors voted only 29% of the shares they owned whereas institutional investors voted 82% of theirs.
In this week’s note, we provide a preliminary analysis of the 2024 proxy voting season results, on compensation, directors’ elections and main trends in shareholder proposals, with a focus on North America.
Paychecks Under the Microscope
Top executive compensation is assessed by shareholders in a say-on-pay vote, a process where shareholders have a non-binding vote on the compensation of top executives, typically occurring annually during a company’s annual general meeting.
Proxy advisors provide research and recommendations on how shareholders should vote on various corporate governance issues, including executive compensation and director elections. Their objective is to guide institutional investors in making informed voting decisions that align with best practices and shareholder interests. The biggest proxy advisors in the world, Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) and Glass Lewis, significantly influence voting outcomes with negative recommendations leading to substantial declines in support on say-on-pay. For instance, a negative recommendation from ISS can lead to a 33% decrease in support for Say-on-Pay proposals, while Glass Lewis’s negative recommendations result in a 12% decline. This year, both advisors focused their decisions on issues such as non-rigorous performance goals, lack of transparency, and the use of discretion in bonus plans. These advisors’ compensation analyses scrutinize performance targets linked to remuneration rather than just looking at the total compensation figures, emphasizing the importance of aligning executive pay with company performance and long-term shareholder value.
A preliminary analysis of the 2024 proxy season on Say-on-Pay voting among S&P 500 and Russell 3000 companies shows higher rates of approval (over 50% votes for) and increased support compared to previous years. No company with a compensation proposition that failed in 2023 failed again in 2024, indicating satisfactory changes to last year’s failed proposals.
The table below highlights the increased support for executive compensation proposals among S&P 500 and Russell 3000 companies from FY 2023 to May 2024.
In corporate governance standards, a Say-on-pay support under the 70% threshold is often seen as a clear signal to the board that the current compensation plan may need reassessment. Low support levels can lead to increased scrutiny from investors and proxy advisors. Recent voting results show that these phenomena remain low, below 5%.
One compensation package that caused quite a stir this season was that of Tesla CEO Elon Musk. Back in January of this year, the Delaware Court struck down the $55 billion pay package for Tesla CEO Elon Musk proposed back in 2018. Even though the package was approved by 73% of unaffiliated Tesla shareholders at that time, the court found that Musk, as a controlling shareholder, had too much influence over the Board and that conflicts of interest were not fully disclosed. As a result, the court decided the package was unfair and rescinded it. Tesla decided to once again submit this package for shareholder approval at the 2024 AGM in June. Despite a campaign from the New York City Comptroller’s Office and other investors urging shareholders to reject Musk’s pay (one which significantly impacted discussions and was noted in reports by ISS and Glass Lewis), the proposal was approved by shareholders. And it came in addition to approval to change Tesla’s state of incorporation from Delaware to Texas.
The season highlights that transparent and performance-aligned executive compensation remains crucial for shareholder approval, underscoring the influential role of proxy advisors in guiding voting decisions.
Boardroom Battles
Support for director nominations remained high in the U.S. in 2024, with average support rising from 95.9% to 96.4%. The season saw significant impacts from the Universal Proxy Card (UPC) rule, which mandates the inclusion of all director nominees on a single ballot when there is a proxy fight and a shareholder want to elect other directors than proposed by the company. This change makes it easier for shareholders to vote across slates, referring to the lists of candidates nominated by different parties. Previously, shareholders had to choose between separate ballots for the company's and the dissident's candidates, but the new rule allows for a mix-and-match approach, simplifying the process and enhancing shareholder choice in proxy contests.
Notable proxy contests were seen this year at Crown Castle Inc. and The Walt Disney Company, where management achieved clean sweeps despite proxy advisor recommendations for some dissident nominees. Meanwhile, at Norfolk Southern Corporation three dissident nominees were elected.
Gildan’s case was the major event of the Canadian proxy season: in May 2024, Browning West, a California-based hedge fund manager, led a historic and successful proxy campaign at Gildan Activewear, resulting in the complete replacement of Gildan’s board and the reinstatement of co-founder Glenn Chamandy as CEO. This campaign was supported by unanimous recommendations from major proxy advisory firms and led to the resignation of Gildan’s entire board and CEO just days before the annual meeting. The full timeline can be found in the table below:
This year's proxy season demonstrates the importance of shareholder choice and robust governance practices, with the Universal Proxy Card rule enhancing the ability of shareholders to influence board composition effectively.
Shareholders’ Frontline
United States
In the 2024 proxy voting season, significant trends emerged regarding shareholder proposals. According to Ceres, a nonprofit organization advocating for sustainability leadership, there was a noticeable support for climate transition plans, particularly within the banking sector. This indicates growing investor demand for more detailed disclosures on how companies plan to mitigate and adapt to climate change. However, overall support for environmental proposals, which include a range of issues from biodiversity protection to sustainable resource use, declined, highlighting varying levels of investor interest in different aspects of environmental sustainability.
Diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) proposals faced increased scrutiny and declining support, reflecting a more critical view from investors. This underscores the importance of carefully framing and justifying ESG initiatives to garner investor backing. According to the Groupe Investissement Responsable Inc. (GIR), a Canadian leading proxy advisor, among Fortune 250 companies, five shareholder proposals received majority votes. These proposals were predominantly governance-focused, including measures to adopt simple majority voting, the right to call a special meeting, and the repeal of rules enacted without shareholder approval. The GIR also mentions that shareholder proposals (excluding anti-ESG proposals) garnered an average support of 19.94%. The ten most frequently filed environmental and social (E&S) proposal categories are presented below:
Tech companies were heavily targeted, with fifteen shareholder proposals for Amazon, twelve for Alphabet, and eleven for Meta Platforms. The E&S proposals that received the highest support are presented in the next table, as highlighted by the GIR:
Canada
In Canada, the GIR highlighted notable shareholder proposals that received majority approval at BMO, CIBC, Air Transat, and Metro. These proposals advocate for in-person shareholder meetings supplemented by online options, reversing the trend of virtual meetings necessitated by the COVID-19 pandemic. The Movement for the Education and Defense of Shareholders (MEDAC), known for its advocacy efforts, particularly with major banks, saw relative success in support on its environmental proposals, reflecting a certain level of influence for its shareholder initiatives.
Key proposals that garnered substantial support in Canada are included in the table below:
Anti-ESG Shareholder Proposals
In the first five months of 2024, the number of anti-ESG proposals saw a significant increase. Despite this surge, they remain unpopular among investors, with average support declining slightly to 1.6%. The increased number of these proposals is partly driven by recent regulatory initiatives in some red states. However, their arguments have not gained traction with larger institutional investors. Overall, while anti-ESG factions are more vocal, their efforts have yet to translate into substantial support. According to GIR, anti-ESG proposals in Canada showed similar levels of support.
This season's proxy voting outcomes on shareholder proposals underscore the ongoing tension between pro- and anti-ESG perspectives within the investment community. While anti-ESG proposals continue to receive minimal support, the substantial backing for governance reforms suggests that investors prioritize strong governance structures, which they view as foundational to effectively addressing environmental and social issues. This indicates a nuanced stance where investors may support ESG initiatives, but with a particular emphasis on robust governance as a critical component of overall corporate responsibility.
Heightened awareness of the environmental and social issues associated with global economic activities is driving demand for greater transparency and prompting governments to take regulatory action. Greater consumer scrutiny and a more stringent regulatory backdrop add to reputational risks that investors must consider, but also create opportunities: companies that provide the testing and certifications needed to comply with these evolving standards will benefit from increased demand. In this note, we explore investment opportunities in the testing, inspection and certification (TIC) market.
The Growing Testing, Inspection and Certification Market
Despite recent backlash on ESG, companies appear to recognize its merits. The need to comply with government regulations and meet expectations of various stakeholders (customers, board, senior management, and shareholders) were identified among the top (“very significant”) reasons for having a sustainability strategy in a recent Morgan Stanley survey where 85% of respondents see sustainability as a value creation opportunity. Both factors translate to greater demand for testing and certification. The market is expected to achieve a cumulative annual growth rate of 4.5% over the next decade.
1) Government Regulations
Over the past two decades, there has been a notable tightening of environmental policies globally (see chart below). Though data for the Environmental Policy Stringency index is only available up to 2020, the trend continues as protection of the environment protection remains a key public issue.
For example, in the U.S., the Biden Administration has sought to pass a slew of environmental policies. The EPA has published new standards addressing vehicle tail-pipe emissions, acceptable air, water and waste levels from fossil-fuel power plants, mandatory independent audits for chemical plants and utilities’ responsibility in monitoring and treating PFAs in the water supply. Efforts have been made to try and safeguard these laws from a change in administration. Though a Trump presidency creates a more challenging context for passing environmental policy, reversing pollution controls (like tracking PFAs in water) could be unpopular with the public. This suggests that more stringent standards are likely to continue as public awareness of environmental health risks grows.
Europe is recognized as the leader when it comes to environmental policy, and the EU continues to introduce new policies, most recently the ecodesign regulation that sets sustainability requirements for a broad array of goods sold in the EU.
While new, more stringent environmental regulations are found mostly in richer countries, the environmental standards in developing nations are likely to tighten as these countries attain greater economic wealth. We can see this in the progress of both China and India’s Environmental Policy Stringency numbers in the past ten years, shown in the chart. As developing countries continue to improve environmental policy, the demand for testing and certification will also increase in these regions.
2) Green Credibility
In addition to adhering to new laws and regulations, companies are also striving to live up to consumers’ higher standards. Environmental criteria are growing in importance in purchasing decisions. Although this trend has given rise to the issue of greenwashing - where companies make misleading claims about environmental benefits of their products with the hopes of capitalizing on demand - growing awareness is driving a push for standardized metrics and disclosures. Companies can gain credibility by providing specific environmental data points and disclosures and obtaining third-party verifications. Moreover, the pressure for companies to disclose on a growing number of data points including water usage, biodiversity impacts, worker and product safety and supply chain traceability will broaden the testing, measuring and certification needed to meet higher standards.
The Testing, Inspection and Certification Companies
The TIC market is involved in a wide variety of industries ranging from health care and food to mining and automotive. There are a few exceptions like Eurofins Scientific, that focus almost exclusively on bio-analytical testing. In today’s note, we focus on the companies that are most highly levered to the trends described above, i.e. increasing regulation and sustainability adherence, and that are exposed to a wide array of industries.
The TIC market is considered to be highly fragmented, with only a few large global players competing against many highly specialized local entities. To this end, it is an industry that is ripe for M&A activity. The large, publicly traded TIC companies tend to be long-standing, established companies with entrenched relationships. It should not be a surprise that companies operating in the quality assurance and certification space have impeccable ESG records; after all, they are paid to ensure the quality of others! All five of the names that we have identified rank above the 90th percentile for ESG practices, according to CSRHub scores. They are also all headquartered in Europe, except for ALS in Australia.
The stock prices of the five companies we analysed – Intertek, Bureau Veritas, Applus, ALS, and SGS – tend to be highly correlated and have a beta to the global equity market of well under one. This is no doubt because many of the companies derive significant revenue from the public sector and because it is difficult to reduce expenditure on testing and assurance, even during economic downturns. All of the companies’ annual reports cite the importance of the two megatrends we described above – sustainability and regulation. Note that we include Applus in our analysis in order to have a larger company sample size, despite the fact that the company will (finally) be taken private: last month Spanish regulators approved the takeover by two private equity firms, making it no longer investable for public equity participants.
- Bureau Veritas serves a very diverse customer base including marine, Oil & Gas, electricity, transportation, manufacturing, agri-food and commodities, buildings & infrastructure, and consumer products. By revenue, it is the second largest TIC company, founded over a century ago. In an industry where relationships and trust are crucial, Bureau Veritas has a high moat.
- SGS SA operates a highly diverse TIC business, with operations across industries including electrical and electronic goods testing, food, crop and health science, cosmetics & hygiene, ag commodities, metallurgy, etc. One third of their business is generated in Europe, one-third in Asia, with the remainder derived from North America, Africa and the Middle East. Similar to Bureau Veritas, SGS is one of the longest standing global TIC companies that also benefit from a high moat related to reputation and relationships.
- Intertek is a UK-listed company, though only 6% of revenues are generated in that country. About a third of revenue is derived from the U.S. and almost 20% from China. Indeed, of the five major TIC companies, Intertek is the one most exposed to both the U.S. and China. We see this as an advantage, though there may be some turbulence should Trump be elected (and reverse some of Biden’s environmental regulatory progress). Intertek serves an extremely diverse customer base, including health & safety (food and health care industries), consumer products, building & construction and the energy industry.
- ALS’s most substantive revenue stream (42%) is related to the commodities industry, ranging from mine site analysis to metallurgical testing. Another one-third of revenues is generated from environmental testing including water analysis. Food and pharmaceutical testing accounts for the final 25% of sales. Of the five TIC companies, this Australian-based company has more cyclical stock returns, owing to its higher exposure to the mining industry (the stock has outperformed its peers over the past year thanks to the bull market in commodities).
The past month has seen a flurry of activity in the U.S., China and the euro area regarding competition in key “green” industries. The European commission has launched several new probes into Chinese companies for anti-competitive behaviour in wind, electric vehicles and batteries. Meanwhile, U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen visited China aiming to address U.S. concerns that China is dumping their overproduction of renewable energy equipment onto other nations. There is talk of imposing more tariffs on China as Chinese exports of solar panels have helped push prices down over 40% in the last year, making it difficult for solar panel producers in other countries to compete.
From a climate change perspective, a glut of solar panels and wind turbines is hardly a bad thing. After all, according to the IEA, the decline in solar panel prices is related to a three-fold increase in manufacturing capacity since 2021. The result: an estimated 96% of newly installed, utility-scale solar PV capacity now has lower generation costs than new coal and natural gas plants. This is excellent news –the economics of renewable energy support an ongoing shift away from dirty energy sources.
Unfortunately, however, what is good for the planet does not always align with national interests: attempts by governments to turn green growth into a competition for green jobs has translated into a wave of disputes. Below, we explore the past and current state of global green trade and outline a possible path forward.
Origins of a Trade War
China joined the WTO in 2001 and in the beginning, there was a highly symbiotic relationship between China and the U.S. (and many other developed economies). China, thanks in large part to comparatively cheap labor, supplied U.S. consumers with low-cost goods in exchange for much-needed U.S. dollars to fuel a move up the development curve.
For a long time, this relationship worked, since the two economies did not compete – China largely produced items at a cost efficiency too difficult for American firms to achieve on domestic soil, lowering the price of many consumer goods, while China did not have the skilled workforce or capital savings needed to produce in critical sectors where America excelled.
However, for the past decade or so, the relationship has become less mutually beneficial, in no small part because China and America no longer operate in different spheres: the Chinese economy has advanced so much that China is now equipped to compete across a plethora of high-skill industries. Indeed, the chart below shows the economic complexity indexes (ECI) of China and the U.S. The ECI is a measure of knowledge intensity of an economy. While China still lags the U.S. somewhat, the convergence underscores that China is competent in many of the areas that used to be the domain of the U.S. and a handful of other developed economies.
Green Goods Dumping
In retrospect, it shouldn’t have been a surprise to anyone that China became a leader in green goods industries. After all, the Chinese government’s economic plan “Made For 2025” which was laid out in 2015 made clear the ten industries for which China aimed to reduce the country’s reliance on foreign technology imports and to create domestic companies relying on domestic innovation. Of the ten industries targeted, “energy saving” and “power equipment” are among the loftiest goals.
By all accounts, China was wildly successful at creating flourishing domestic industries in ‘new energy vehicles’ and ‘renewable energy equipment’.
In fact, China has been so successful that export markets have taken a keen interest in their products. BYD, the main Chinese electric car manufacturer currently already sells about 8% of its cars outside of China.
Meanwhile, China’s ‘renewable energy equipment’ industry is a true global phenomenon. Returning to solar panels, while China represents less than 40% of total solar panel demand, the country accounts for virtually all global production.
State of Play
Anti-dumping and anti-subsidy tariffs on the Chinese solar panel industry began in 2012 and 2013 by the U.S. and euro area, respectively. As a result of these moves, many Chinese companies spent the rest of the decade moving their manufacturing facilities to other countries to avoid the duties. In other words, actions against China were not successful at curbing Chinese solar power capacities.
Although the euro area dropped their tariffs in 2018, the U.S. added a new 30% tariff on solar imports which is still in place today. The U.S. is contemplating further tariffs, while the euro area recently launched new probes into Chinese manufacturers of solar panels suspected of benefitting from "distortive" state subsidies and gaining an "unfair advantage." The EU has also launched subsidy investigations into Chinese wind turbine companies and Chinese EV manufacturers.
All of these moves by Western countries are happening under the guise of protecting national industries. But what’s left to protect? Of the top producers of solar panels (listed companies by market cap), only four are U.S. or European companies. By most accounts, it is extremely unlikely that other nations can catch up to China on production. As for other green industries, although China has a formidable wind turbine manufacturing base, Chinese manufacturers have not yet been able to penetrate markets abroad (where roughly 95% of demand in 2023 was covered by European and American companies).
What Comes Next?
Despite China’s total dominance in solar panel manufacturing, it is highly unlikely that policy and trade friction between China and other nations will disappear. It is well known that China is suffering from an economic growth slowdown and will continue to support its local industries in order to maintain jobs and stability. Meanwhile, in Western countries, it is politically popular to “target” China irrespective of the efficacy of policies. In other words, we do not expect any major policy change that will disrupt the current status quo of a strong, steady stream of Chinese-sourced renewable energy equipment. We do not wish to bet against U.S. and European manufacturers, though we do not expect current headwinds to diminish for the foreseeable future.
A key point is that Chinese solar panel manufacturers are producing goods that are inexpensive, but not “cheap”. One of the main reasons that Chinese panels have fallen in the past decade is due to improvements in design. A notable metric for solar panel quality is bankability, i.e. the likelihood that investors are willing to invest because data indicates the quality and long-term durability of the solar module, as well as the trustworthiness of the manufacturer.
Chinese companies such as Longi and Jinko Solar receive the same bankability ratings as U.S. companies like First Solar. On this basis, it seems unlikely that a major shift in the industry is likely to occur.
Investment Implications
As China attempts to stabilize its domestic economy and reach its Made for 2025 objectives, it is highly likely that renewable energy equipment manufacturers will remain in high gear, maintaining the global supply glut, particularly in solar panels but also for other equipment.
This trend is developing at a time when it is becoming increasingly well known that grid investment has not kept pace with renewable energy development. This is evidenced by longer and longer grid connection queues (the IEA estimates that over 3 000 GW of renewable energy projects are in connection queues globally, with nearly 1 500 GW of wind and solar PV projects in advanced stages of development). This is enough to nearly double current installed global capacity for these technologies, all of which is just sitting in queues!
We have written in past notes about our preferred investment picks to invest in the coming buildout in grid capacity (for example, please see “From Gridlock To Gridsmart”, April 4, 2024). In the simplest terms, given the oversupply in manufacturers vs the building demand for transmission, investors should be looking to go “long renewable energy operators and grid producers” and avoid “renewable energy equipment manufacturers”.