For those looking to achieve impact and earn extra return, allocating a greater share of their fixed income (FI) portfolio to supranational paper could make sense. As it happens, the fallout of the global COVID crisis will likely generate massive lending from supranational institutions such as the IBRD (World Bank), EBRD (European Bank for Reconstruction and Development), IDB (InterAmerican Development Bank), and other International Financial Institutions (IFIs) – which also happen to specialize in impact lending for developing countries.
As a reminder, these institutions typically attach strings to the loans they make to governments enticing their sovereign clients to make progress in areas such as health care, education, and climate change. As a result, supranational bonds offer an interesting way of leveraging IFI impact frameworks towards measurable results while improving and diversifying your overall bond portfolio. More importantly, as the COVID crisis will likely linger in several of the world’s poorest nations, financial lifelines from IFIs will become even more important to sustain the fight against the virus and its economic repercussions.
One interesting class of bonds we have identified back in 2018 (see our note “World Bank bonds: A “macro” impact Opportunity”, October 10th, 2018) were IBRD (World Bank) bonds. Overall, the Bloomberg Barclays World Bank Global Aggregate Index has outperformed USTs since 2012, with 300+ bps of outperformance on an aggregate, total return basis. With 10-year USTs trading below 1% amid aggressive QE operations from the Fed, such an outperformance could continue to benefit even the most conservative bond portfolios.
Looking at duration, World Bank bonds started to display a lower duration than their USTs equivalents before the COVID crisis. When the Fed starts to normalize its policy, one can expect WB bonds to become interesting once again from a duration perspective.
Interestingly, the spread between both indices compressed substantially until March 2020, time at which the Fed reignited its QE purchases. While the spread increased significantly these past few months, we would expect it to resume its path towards zero as an increasing amount of impact and search-for-yield investors increase their allocation to IBRD paper in the coming months and years and the Fed starts to reduce its monthly purchases of USTs.
Impact investors’ effect on the IBRD yield curve and spreads against USTs is especially visible if one considers the change in IBRD/UST spreads at every maturity. One could also expect that the IBRD yield curve spread will continue to compress given the relative health of the IBRD’s credit outlook versus that of the U.S. Treasury – which has not yet finished to pick up the US fiscal AND COVID policy messes. To this end, IBRD paper is rated at lesser credit risk (AAA) than the USTs (AA+) while the institution’s balance sheet is solidly diversified and backstopped by the Banks’s contributing members.
Many market participants have entered the IBRD Green bond market. The institution increased its green bond issuance program these past few years and we expect those trends to continue in 2021. While many Green bonds displayed even more spread compression against their comparable non-green issues given strong demand and limited offer, the “greenium” mostly disappeared in FI markets these past few months.
Looking ahead, we expect the liquidity on IBRD benchmark bonds to increase as the World Bank increases its own lending to its developing country clients post-COVID. Moreover, an increasing number of search-for-yield and impact investors will continue to enter the supranational market, which should help reduce bid-ask spreads of IBRD paper and make IBRD bonds a staple holding within diversified portfolios. Finally, the recent reflation trade and growing inflation expectations in the U.S. should also signal that U.S. bond yield have perhaps touched the bottom these past few weeks.