“He who opens a school door, closes a prison.” – Victor Hugo
Investing in education is an obvious goal for impact and sustainability-focused investors. Afterall, education is an important pillar of the U.N. Sustainable Development Goals; SDG 4 is about providing quality education for all. In addition, education is directly correlated with higher wages, better health and general life satisfaction.
At Sustainable Market Strategies, education is one of our key social themes, along with health care. Our views are highly influenced by the economists Anne Case and Angus Deaton who have convincingly laid out the inextricable link between education levels and access to quality health care; in the U.S. and elsewhere: adult life expectancy is rising for the college educated and falling for the rest.
In most nations, basic education is provided as a public good and is financed through government taxation. Indeed, there are two key finance benchmarks for governments that have been set out to help fulfill SDG 4 under the Unesco Education 2030 Framework for Action :
- allocate at least 4% to 6% of GDP to education, and/or
- allocate at least 15% to 20% of public expenditure to education.
Globally, governments are not far from these norms, albeit poorer countries struggle to meet these goals.
The challenge is that even when these targets are met, there remains a glaring discrepancy in outcomes for individuals depending on their education levels, as the chart above highlights. This underscores the need for both ongoing investment in accessing education as well as improving the quality of accessible education.
In this sense, and despite acknowledging that education should be a public good, the private sector can nonetheless play a crucial role in developing tertiary education, pedagogical tools, skill enhancement, and supplementary educational services.
For public equity investors, the landscape is nonetheless challenging. The main hurdle is simply a lack of listings, which makes it difficult to create a robust portfolio: there are only a handful of large cap companies (greater than 1 Bil USD) specializing in higher education or supplying services to education providers. The vast majority of these are heavily biased toward the U.S. market.
This is particularly problematic given that the global increase in enrolment rates in the past decade - and forecasts for the next decade - are due exclusively to rising student numbers in the global south, especially in China and India. In the U.S., enrolment rates have steadily declined over the past decade. In our analysis, we exclude Chinese education stocks given our view, expressed in a note in our September 30, 2021 note, « Chinese Capitalism’s Long March », that this sector is uninvestable due to the regulatory risks in the Chinese education market.
Moreover, artificial intelligence and other technological tools are expected to be a massive disruptor to the education industry. Already, AI has devastated the market value of firms like Chegg as free sources like ChatGPT challenge the business case for paid study aids.
On the flipside, companies like Duolingo have seen their stock price rise on the news that the company is increasingly integrating AI in its services.
Given the challenging backdrop and limitations, but also the high potential rewards both in terms of profit and positive impact, today’s note focuses on three key education areas that are available to public market investors: higher education providers and assistance, alternative learning mediums and specialized training.
Note that we have opted to omit using “edtech” to characterize education companies, as our approach is to instead consider how technology is permeating the afore mentioned categories.
- Higher Education Providers and Assistance
Across all OECD countries, the majority of education spending by governments is allocated to primary and secondary education (generally defined as kindergarten through grade 12), with tertiary education receiving on average only 25% of total education funding. Thus, there is a clear opportunity for the private sector to provide an “undersupplied” good. We define higher education providers and assistance as companies that either provide on-line or in-class graduate degree programs or are providing services to these institutions (such as placement and assessment tools, pedagogical materials, etc). An example of a higher education provider is Adtalem Global Education (ATGE US). The company offers degree and non-degree programs in physical and on-line formats at four universities in the U.S. and Caribbean.
An example of higher education assistance companies is Grand Canyon Education (LOPE US). Grand Canyon offers technological solutions, infrastructure and operational processes to provide services to university institutions on a large scale. Another example is 2U (2U US) which provides the technology and services to non-profit colleges and universities to enable the online delivery of degree programs and also provides premium online open courses, executive education programs, technical, skills-based boot camps and micro-credential programs through relationships with non-profit colleges and universities.
As the table below highlights, few of these companies are able to grow their market cap to USD 1 billion or more.
For companies in this sector, artificial intelligence can play an increasingly important role that will amount to higher productivity and lower overhead costs. Indeed, in the wake of ChatGPT, when the stock prices of companies like Chegg have come under pressure, higher education providers and higher education assistance companies have for the most part seen their stock prices keep up with, and in some cases, outperform the 2023 rally in tech stocks (see below charts).
Alternative Learning Mediums
As is well known, traditional tertiary education programs are not for everyone. The high price – both in terms of financial and time commitment – is a major barrier for prospective students. Add on schedule stiffness, program pre-requisites and lack of customization and there is no wonder that technological solutions have been developed to provide alternative learning options. Alternatives to traditional college and university can improve access to higher education by removing significant barriers to entry.
One such alternative solution is MOOCs (massive open on-line courses), which have proliferated over the past decade and offer the advantage of being inexpensive and with few pre-requisites to register. Coursera (COURS US) and Udemy (UDMY) are two of the largest providers and while their business models differ, both are considered low-cost disruptors to the education industry.
All three of these companies have trailed the rally in technology stocks that began in 2023, with total returns roughly flat since January and with high volatility. This may reflect that these companies have the potential to both win and lose from artificial intelligence. Low-cost, self-lead learning from home options will naturally be threatened by the allure of free ChatGPT. On the flipside, artificial intelligence can improve the experience that Udemy, Coursera and others provide: Udemy is using AI to personalize the learning experience for each user and to improve the quality of its courses while Coursera is using it to enhance its assessment and evaluation processes.
Specialized Training
Alongside alternative learning mediums like MOOCs, advanced economies require professionals with increasingly specialized skill sets. Specialized training companies often fill voids in public sector education because training in specific fields is prohibitively expensive and/or only a small number of people need to be trained. As a result, companies providing these services tend to be smaller in nature as the potential market size for their products is limited.
Examples of listed companies that offer specialized training in specific industries are Afya Ltd, which provides specialized training to medical practitioners in Brazil and CAE (provider of simulation technology to the aviation industry). The stock prices of these types of companies tend to be less correlated with tech stocks (i.e. the Nasdaq index); it is reasonable to expect that specialized training companies integrate artificial intelligence into their processes with less risk that demand will be threatened by AI. In other words, we expect these companies to be relatively well insulated from AI-related product redundancies.
Duolingo: An Alluring Exception
So far, we have noted that education stocks make for challenging investments for several reasons: there are few large cap names available to investors; several AI disruptions cross-currents are on the horizon; advanced economy enrolment rates are on the decline, creating a sizeable revenue headwind, and; many companies are overly specialized.
There is one company that stands out from this picture, however. Duolingo (DUOL US) is the leading mobile learning platform globally. Its flagship app has organically become the world's most popular way to learn languages and the top-grossing app in the Education category on both Google Play and the Apple App Store.
The link between multiple language proficiency and economic development is well documented; economies that actively nurture different languages reap a range of rewards, from more successful exports to a more innovative workforce.
Duolingy IPO’d on the Nasdaq in July 2021 and has a current market cap of over USD 6 Bil. Duolingo has powered its newest product using GPT-4 (the latest technology from OpenAI), implying that strides in artificial intelligence are an advantage to this company and they are quickly capitalizing on it. The learning app has broad appeal, with over 300 million registered users studying 95 languages and there is potential to broaden its content even further by offering other subjects beyond languages.
Despite not yet being profitable, DUOL's Q1 2023 results showed another growth acceleration in monthly average users (MAU). Conversion rates to paid subscribers are steadily improving: subscription revenue grew 49% y/y this last quarter. That said, its current valuation (15.9x Price/Sales) clearly imposes a premium on investors, which can be explained by the company's continued efforts to innovate and its position as a leader in a competitive but large addressable market.
Investors continue to witness the political, economic, and social impacts of the demographic transitions playing out around the world – a recent example is the pension reform protests in France. More than other countries, however, China has the potential, as its population profile changes, to impact the global economy. In 1978, when Deng Xiaoping opened the country’s doors to direct foreign investment China had a working-age population of some 546 million people – a proportion of the total population which had been flat for 20 years at roughly 55%. A demographic dividend occurred as the working-age population surged to more than 70% of the total population by 2015, adding over 450 million potential workers. China became the manufacturing center of the world, riding a wave of globalization.
China’s demographic dividend is now moving in reverse and persistent declines in the working-age population may have implications for sustainable economic growth, domestic fiscal balances, and social policies.
Japan - Demographic Roadmap for China
Following World War II, Japan experienced significant direct foreign investment flows from the US and other countries and also benefited from a major demographic dividend as its working-age population increased from 50 million people in 1950 to 87 million people by 1994. Like China two decades later, Japan experienced an extended period of growth as the growing population of working-age Japanese benefitted from foreign investment, new jobs, training, education, increasing urbanization, and improved healthcare. In both Japan and China, expansion of the working-age population corresponded with sustained increases in per-capita GDP. Over the 35 years until the working age population peaked (1960-1994 in Japan and 1982-2016 in China), per-capita GDP grew at compounded annual growth rates of 14% and 12% respectively.
The Reverse of the Medal
By 1994, the last year when Japan’s working-age population increased, per-capita GDP in Japan had reached approximately US$40,000 putting Japan in the same league as Luxembourg and Switzerland. Only Monaco and Liechtenstein were meaningfully higher. The significant household wealth that was created in Japan is now an important source of ongoing fiscal revenue through Japan’s non-trivial inheritance tax. In China, when the working-age population peaked in 2015, per-capita GDP had reached only $8,000. Whether China’s GDP per-capita can continue to grow as it has in the past has important implications for the country’s fiscal balances and social spending.
If the relationship between growth in the working-age population and per-capita GDP continues to follow that observed in Japan, future per-capita GDP increases in China may be limited. While there have been years since 1994 (the year the working-age population peaked) in which Japan’s per-capita GDP increased, and even spans of years (2007 to 2012), the country’s average annual increase in GDP per-capita since 1994 has been zero. Growing dependency ratios tend to hold back growth.
Dependency Ratios and Sustainable Economic Growth
The reasons for Japan’s per-capita GDP stagnation are largely the reverse of what happens when the working age population expands. When the proportion of working age people (“net producers”) declines, the proportion of non-working people (those aged 0-14 and those 65 and older who are “net consumers”) increases. The proportion of net consumers to net producers is called the “dependency ratio”. Very generally, dependents do not engage in household formation or the widespread purchase of big-ticket items, they do not borrow money to buy homes, go to university, or start businesses, they do not pay high levels of income tax to the government but instead draw government benefits. A rising dependency ratio is often associated with falling consumer spending, declining income tax revenues, a rising medical-care and elder-care burden, and increased government reliance on borrowing. Japan’s dependency ratio started to rise in 1994, the year its working-age population peaked. China’s dependency ratio followed the same trend, beginning to rise just before the working age population peaked in 2015.
While there may be no particular tipping point beyond which dependency ratios trigger fiscal strain, Japan provides a study of what happens to the national accounts as the burden of a growing number of net consumers is shouldered by a falling number of net producers. Since the early 1990s when the working-age population peaked and began to decline, not only did per-capita GDP stagnate in Japan, tax revenue from income tax and corporate tax began to fall. At the same time, social security-related expenses increased, nearly doubling from 17.5% of expenditure in 1990 to 34% in 2021. The widening gap between tax revenue and expenditure has been filled by a consumption tax (which itself is inimical to growth), other taxes (the most important of which is Japan’s inheritance tax), and the increasing issuance of government bonds. With China’s lower level of per-capita GDP, raising consumption taxes and instituting an inheritance tax may not be sustainable long-term policy options.
Must Rising Dependency Ratios Lead to Slower Growth?
Three things affect the dependency ratio: the death rate (mortality), the birth rate (fertility) and immigration. In countries where both the death rate and the birth rate are high, dependency ratios can be very high yet portend growth rather than stagnation. Niger has one of the world’s highest dependency ratios (much higher than Japan’s) but the dependents, instead of being 30% retirees, are almost exclusively in the 0 to 14-year-old age cohort - an enormous potential pool of future workers (human capital).
Countries that can boost the working age population through pro-growth immigration policies can reduce their dependency ratios, in some cases to very low levels. For an extreme example, see (above) the United Arab Emirates (UAE) where immigrant workers make up a large part of the population. Dependency ratios in countries like Japan and China, with little or no immigration, are subject purely to the interaction of birth rates and death rates. Between 2016 and 2021, China’s working-age population fell by nearly 12 million people. Between 2016 and 2050, it is estimated that China’s working-age population is expected to decline by over 230 million people. Over the same period, the population aged 65 and older is forecast to increase by 243 million. By 2050, China’s dependency ratio is expected to be the same as Japan’s is today, with the same proportion of the dependent population in the 65 and older age cohort (30%).
Dependency Ratios Increasing Across the G20
China is not alone in following Japan. All but two G20 countries (Indonesia and South Africa) are headed toward dependency ratios like Japan’s this century.
Investment Implications
The Chinese demographic transition that is underway may have significant implications for global sustainability investors. Whereas the ramifications of Japan’s contracting workforce after 1994 have so far been mostly domestic (because the global labor pool continued to grow while Japan’s relatively small labor pool contracted) declines in China’s working-age population could have domestic and global repercussions. These go beyond manufacturing and trade and include global capital flows.
- As China becomes less able to supply the global labor market with workers, there may be a “higher floor” on the cost of global labor. The wildcard here is Africa where the population of working-age people is expected to increase by some 750 million people by 2050 but across diverse countries with widely varying infrastructure and degrees of integration into the global economy. All else equal, the decline in China’s working-age population may act as an inflationary force in the global economy and spur further capital deepening in order to maintain productivity growth.
Beyond the geopolitics of deglobalization, a narrowing difference between wages in China and in other manufacturing centres may further reduce the incentive to offshore to China. In some industries, i.e., those in which China enjoys technology leadership, foreign companies already operating in China may stay. In industries in which a young, low-cost labor force is the main competitive advantage, however, reshoring could occur quickly. Vulnerable industries could include garments, furniture, and bedding.
- There are powerful links between demographic imbalances and fiscal imbalances. Japan’s demographic dependency ratio is mirrored by a bond dependency ratio that has grown since the early 1990s as the rising benefits paid to elders in the form of social security coverage have outstripped the burdens of tax and social security payments collected from the working-age population.
Over the period that Japan’s bond dependency ratio has increased, the credit rating of Japanese government bonds has decreased. While most Japanese government bonds have been held domestically and at low interest rates maintained by financial repression, foreign investor participation in the market is increasing. While foreign investors help diversify the funding base, they may demand higher yields for lower-rated sovereign bonds. Rising yields and stagnant or declining GDP growth could result in yet further deterioration in Japan’s debt to GDP ratios and increased risk of global contagion. While foreign investors still make up a small part of China’s bond market, foreign participation is increasing. As in Japan, domestic demographic and fiscal imbalances in China will have a greater ability to impact the world economy as China’s capital market integration deepens.
With billions of tons of cargo transported around the world each year by trucks, planes, ships, and trains, freight transportation is a critical component of the global economy. While freight transportation supports economic growth and helps to improve the standard of living, it is also a big contributor to GHG emissions. The International Transport Forum (ITF) estimates that international trade-related freight transport currently accounts for around 30% of all transport-related CO2 emissions from fuel combustion, and more than 7% of global emissions. Moreover, emissions from global freight transport are expected to increase fourfold from 2010 levels, and are, at this pace, incompatible with a net-zero scenario.
Although ships transport the majority of the world's cargo (75%), trucks and vans are responsible for emitting 65% of the freight's total emissions. This is because ships are more efficient, meaning they can carry a large amount of cargo while emitting a relatively low level of emissions. On the other hand, trucks emit more pollutants than ships when transporting the same amount of freight over the same distance. A look at the U.S. alone shows the predominance of trucks within freight transportation:
Freight movement is expected to increase by nearly 50% by 2050 in volume (compared to 2019 levels), and trucks are following the same trend line due to their cheap costs. With logistics trends such as digitization, faster innovation cycles and local production, there is an increased pressure on prices, which made trucking boom over the past years (see our note Keep on Trucking: How Driver Retention Can Reinforce Supply Chains, April 28, 2022). However, in order to reach net-zero goals, trains seem to be the best alternative option to trucks, as they emit 4 times less on average than trucks and can help avoid traffic congestion and health problems linked to pollution.
Putting Trains Back on the Right Track
Trains have the possibility to carry freight for long distances while greatly reducing CO2 emissions. In addition, clean electric rail’s energy efficiency and proven safety systems can translate into six-times lower external costs (noise, climate change, pollution, accidents) of freight rail versus road freight. However, in many developed countries, the majority of trains are still powered by diesel: as of 2019, 64% of locomotives in the U.S. freight rail fleet were powered by diesel, and this number is even at 91% in Canada. Europe is more electrified with 52% of electric freight trains. Japan is the most advanced, with 82% of electric trains in its freight rail transport.
Massive investments are therefore necessary to electrify the sector with clean energy. However, in rail, asset replacement cycles are up to 10 times longer than for roads, which naturally limits the rate of innovation uptake of companies. Government investments are critical for countries wanting their trains to compete with trucks if they want to achieve their climate goals. The table below presents the most recent programs in key countries regarding investment in rails:
These plans mostly concern passenger transportation, and the ambitious 30 by 2030 program envisioned by the European Freight Rail Association is facing a number of limitations. The growth of goods with rail affinity (like coal, metal, ores or wood) is expected to decline, compared to a strong growth of goods with low rail affinity (such as food, textile and machinery, which require shorter transport times, smaller shipment size and demand higher reliability), putting a brake on the development of freight railroads. In an effort to stay competitive, rail companies have cut costs, mostly on maintenance, safety and labour. This led to negative outcomes like the Norfolk Southern’s Train Derailment in Ohio in February 2023, shining a spotlight on the deficiencies of an often overlooked industry.
Derailing Expectations
Numerous articles point out that the train derailment and chemical spill in Ohio was the culmination of a long trend of cost-cutting in the rail industry. Rail workers, government officials, and industry analysts have long warned that such disasters are an expected consequence.
While the number of train derailments in the U.S. has decreased over time, with over 1,000 still occurring each year as shown in the chart below, a closer examination reveals an increase in the derailment rate. This is likely due to the trend of longer and heavier trains, which have enabled railroads to reduce the number of miles travelled. As a result, even though there are fewer accidents overall, the rate of derailments has increased in five out of the last seven years when compared to the miles travelled.
Most derailments are caused by a lack of investment in tracks and human error:
The primary cause of derailment is often attributed to track issues, such as broken sections of the track that have been repeatedly pounded by passing trains due to lack of maintenance. Maintenance and inspections are critical to safe operations. The Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) regulations do require railroads to maintain track inspection records and make them available to FRA or state inspectors on request, but freight rail carriers are not required to report publicly on freight track conditions. Universal track condition reports are therefore unavailable.
Operational cost cutting also has social implications. As shown in the chart below, the rail industry has seen declining levels of employee compensation and benefits for rail workers (Norfolk Southern ranking the worst among the five), leaving employees discontented, but not without reaction.
In December 2022, President Biden signed legislation to impose a labour agreement between rail companies and workers who had been locked in a bitter dispute over paid sick leave, averting a strike that could have upended the economy just before the holiday season. In February 2023, the Union Pacific CEO announced its departure after an activist shareholder accused the company of providing the worst service among the major railroads and blaming the CEO.
Freight Rail Investing: Proceed With Caution
This is a challenging context for sustainability minded investors. In the absence of government support, there seem to be few tailwinds for increased transport by rail. In North America, where nearly all freight rail relies on diesel locomotives, the top five publicly traded railway companies (Union Pacific, Canadian Pacific, Canadian National, CSX and Norfolk Southern) have been working to improve their environmental standing; moving from around the 50th percentile closer to the 90th percentile over the past ten years. Though electrification in this region seems unlikely, there are other ways trains can reduce their emissions and environmental impact (such as the use of cleaner fuels, efficiency and energy-saving measures). We expect rail operators to invest in these environmental solutions as well as safety improvements as these elements take on increasing importance when it comes to being selected as a supply chain partner. We consider three rail equipment companies that are providers of these solutions: Alstom, Wabtec and Knorr-Bremse.
Alstom and Wabtec have similar product offerings but serve different regions; Alstom’s revenues are more concentrated in Europe (62%) and Wabtec in North America (50%). In addition to producing new locomotives, both companies contribute to the circular economy through the sale of remanufactured trains. Trains can be retrofitted to operate more efficiently, helping to lower emissions. Both companies are also looking into researching alternatives to diesel trains including battery locomotives, hydrogen and other alternative fuels (Alstom is hoping to expand in the U.S. market with these solutions). Smart digital solutions that help to optimize processes and improve safety are also on offer. In 2021, 22% of Wabtec’s revenues were from products that support environmental efficiency, an important consideration given the market it serves most. A distinguishing factor for Alstom is that it does have more passenger rail clients than Wabtec and produces more electric locomotives which is also related to the region it serves. This could be to its advantage as passenger rail appears to be a higher governmental priority.
Knorr-Bremse is a provider of smart solutions for the rail industry. These services aim to enhance safety, limit air pollutants and optimize HVAC systems among other efficiency gains. The company’s Digital Freight Train product offering supports objectives of standardizing processes across the European rail network. This is more of a supply chain optimization than emissions reducing but it will be advantageous in encouraging more freight transport by rail.
Compared to the five large publicly traded freight rail companies (Union Pacific, Canadian Pacific, Canadian National, CSX and Norfolk Southern), these three equipment companies have more attractive valuations, less debt and better growth prospects.
According to the International Energy Agency, if the world is going to reach its renewable energy goals in 2030, the decade will bring a gargantuan buildup of solar energy power. Currently, solar accounts for about 13% of total renewable energy, but is expected to account for one-third in 2030. Overall, to stay on a path to reach 2050 target emissions of net zero, solar power capacity will need to multiply by seven in the next seven years!
This is an extremely ambitious global goal that will require significant global cooperation. Unfortunately, this is not currently the case, as the industry appears to be confronted with a version of the irresistible force paradox.
An irresistible force paradox is commonly summed up in the phrase “unstoppable force meets immovable object”. When analyzing the solar power industry, China appears to be the unstoppable force that is about to meet its immovable object: deglobalization.
Solar Manufacturing Domination
China is a leader in solar power, both in domestic production of electricity, but also in the manufacture of solar panels; the Chinese solar panel industry is what allows other nations to claim solar as a renewable power source. Indeed, the country is both the largest producer and consumer at all stages of the solar power supply chain, including polysilicon, wafers, cells and completed modules.
Based on manufacturing capacity under construction, China’s share of global polysilicon and wafer production will soon reach almost 95% of total production. But even more alarming is that according to the IEA, one single province in China - Xinjiang - accounts for 40% of global polysilicon manufacturing; one out of every seven panels produced worldwide is manufactured by a single facility in China.
Note that Xinjiang province, referred to by China as the Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region (XUAR), has drawn worldwide attention for human rights abuses; the United Nations Human Rights Commissioner determined in 2022 that “allegations of patterns of torture, or ill-treatment, including forced medical treatment and adverse conditions of detention, are credible”. Investors with interests in the region -need to understand the risks involved, even with passive portfolios.
U.S. Policy to the Rescue?
Of course, this almost total domination of the solar power industry has not gone unnoticed. In 2021, U.S. President Biden emitted an executive order to review America’s supply chains. The “energy sector industrial base” was one of six key industries identified for further assessment. In the subsequent 2022 study by the U.S. Energy Department, a section is dedicated to “Building a Solar Power Chain Not Dependent on China”.
Since then, the U.S. government has taken several actions that have impacted the solar manufacturing industry. The Inflation Reduction Act’s (IRA) aggressive tax credits: The Advanced Manufacturing Production Tax Credit provides tax credits for each clean energy component domestically produced across the solar PV supply chain, while the Advanced Energy Project Credit provides a tax credit for building and commissioning a facility for clean-energy component manufacturing.
In addition, in February 2022, the U.S. extended tariffs on solar products containing crystalline silicon coming from China. Finally, the federal government enacted the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act in June 2022, which bans products including solar components from China’s Xinjiang region. Granted, it is unclear as how successful the ban has been, since there are myriad ways to circumvent this law.
China has not stood still in the face of U.S. promotion of a domestic solar industry. The Chinese government is reportedly looking to add raw materials used in solar panels to a list of items that could be restricted for export in order to ‘help safeguard national security’. These materials would require special permission for export and if enacted aggressively, could effectively strangle the global solar power industry.
How to Invest
From an investor perspective, the complex geopolitics of the solar power industry mean that what should be a relatively straightforward bull case for solar power stocks is in reality, highly muddled and potentially quite risky. Of course, there is the ethical question of investing in an energy transition built on the back of human rights abuses. At a very minimum, the potential for reputational and regulatory challenges associated with solar companies requires that investors embed a significant risk premium on equity in the solar industry.
As we have articulated in previous notes (for example, see Chinese Capitalism’s Long March, September 30, 2021), we believe that China is not investable at the current juncture. For investors desiring to gain exposure to the solar industry, this means that there are few options. After all, Chinese solar manufacturing companies have incredibly strong economic moats and it is far from clear that the U.S. (and other countries) will be able to (re-)establish a solar power manufacturing industry. As the IEA notes, “China is the most cost-competitive location to manufacture all components of the solar PV supply chain. Costs in China are 10% lower than in India, 20% lower than in the United States, and 35% lower than in Europe. Large variations in energy, labour, investment and overhead costs explain these differences. Still, in the absence of financial incentives and manufacturing support, the bankability of manufacturing projects outside of panel assembly remains limited outside of China and few countries in Southeast Asia.”
Currently, the vast majority of public solar power manufacturing companies – irrespective of where they are listed - have strong ties to China and the Xinjiang province and many have already been caught in scandal. The table below highlights features of publicly listed solar power players.
For investors that want to steer clear of trade regulation risks and human rights violations, gaining exposure to the solar manufacturing industry is tricky. Only six companies pass the above preliminary screening: Meyer Burger, Sun Power, First Solar, Maxeon, Wacker Chemie and Tokuyama. The two names that are considered pure plays and have severed any ties with Chinese solar suppliers are Meyer Burger and First Solar.
Note that these companies have already benefitted from being relatively unattached to the Chinese solar panel supply chain, as is reflected in their stock valuations and price performance. Meyer Burger is trading at a P/E of 56, while Sun Power and First Solar are valued at 28 times earnings. Only Wacker Chemi and Tokuyama have closer to fair valuations (14 and 8 respectively), although both of these companies are diversified chemical companies and are thus not pure plays on the solar industry.
We believe that a company like Maxeon Solar provides a good example of the risk associated with investing in solar power manufacturers within the current geopolitical context. Maxeon Solar Technologies was originally the manufacturing arm of SunPower and is now a separate company. Maxeon continues to supply SunPower with solar panels along with other international customers. Maxeon has a joint venture with a module manufacturer in China to produce panels; although the Chinese manufacturer is not in Xinjiang province, it is expected that this company could soon be a target for U.S. trade regulators and by extension, create business risks for Maxeon. Both Maxeon and SunPower stock prices have struggled since China’s human rights violations have come into investors’ focus.
Regardless of socioeconomic status, housing is a basic need. In recent years, the cost – whether homeownership or rent – has become increasingly burdensome.
In the U.S., home ownership is seen as a national purpose and a hallmark of the American dream. Since World War II, it has been encouraged by policymakers. Most notably in 1997, when Democratic President Clinton passed an act to force mortgage lenders to relax the conditions on loans for low-income households, followed by tax breaks on housing capital gains in 1998. Despite these aggressive policies promoting home ownership, 34% of households were renters in 2022, the mid-range of historical homeownership rates. Moreover, housing affordability is becoming a growing concern in many regions as the cost of housing continues to outpace the growth in household incomes and both renters and homeowners are facing a housing affordability crisis that threatens to deepen economic inequality and exacerbate social problems.
In today’s note, we focus on the state of the U.S. housing market, and the role for investors in broadening access to affordable housing.
Access to Affordable Shelter: The Current State
Shelter expenses have risen dramatically. According to the CPI index, the median rent has risen nearly 20% in the past five years. Meanwhile, housing affordability (both rent and ownership) has also deteriorated (see the chart below). The cost of shelter has increased due to multiple factors. There is a chronic undersupply (limited inventory) of affordable housing. Many who would like to build are pushed out/unable due to higher labor and material costs and the effects of the pandemic are pushing housing prices higher in areas that were previously more affordable. For decades, housing supply has fallen short of what is needed to keep housing affordable. After the Great Recession, new home construction cratered; fewer new homes were built in the decade following 2008 than in any decade since the 1960s. This is only partly explained by slowing population growth, meaning that U.S. housing supply is historically extremely tight; by some estimates, the shortage of housing units for sale or rent is around 3.8 million.
In addition, the rise in interest rates has negatively affected homeownership affordability.
These factors have made it challenging for many people to afford suitable housing. Nearly 50% of U.S. renters are dedicating over 30% of their gross income to housing costs and are considered rent-burdened.
“Rent burden” is a challenge that particularly affects low-income individuals and families. As seen in the graph below, 80% of households with an income under US$ 15,000 were rent-burdened, and households with income under US$30,000 are approaching that ratio as well.
Families in the lowest income bracket have a monthly income that is barely sufficient to cover shelter costs leaving them with less than $500 to spend on basic necessities like food, clothing, healthcare, and transportation. Any unexpected reduction in income could easily result in eviction, further exacerbating their financial struggles.
Even with the recent slowdown of home price growth and the reduction in demand caused by higher interest rates, the run-up in rents and home prices since 2019 has been catastrophic for working families. And with wage growth failing to keep up with the pace of inflation over the past year, many households feel increasingly burdened paying for necessities such as gas, food, medical bills, and housing payments.
Levers to Improve Affordability
Fortunately, several strategies, at both a regional and national level, exist to tackle the challenge of housing affordability:
A. Build More and Build Efficiently
The path to build efficient housing was laid out during the last major affordable housing shortage, which occurred directly after World War II. At that time, innovative builders such as William Levitt, alleviated the national housing crisis by focusing on four principles: building smaller homes, improvements in manufacturing processes, mass production and government-backed mortgage funding. In the final section of today’s note, we show how Levitt’s principles can be applied to the private sector today.
B. Greater Government Support
In order to improve access to affordable housing, some jurisdictions have relied on progressive taxation on residential housing. For example, in California, taxes are collected from richer neighbourhoods to fund construction of parks/schools in poorer areas. At the national level, the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC – enacted in 1986), encourages private investment in the creation of affordable housing. Under the program, developers receive tax credits for a portion of the costs of constructing or rehabilitating affordable rental housing. These credits can then be sold to investors to help raise capital for the project. Since its creation, the LIHTC program has helped finance the construction or rehabilitation of over 3 million units of affordable housing across the United States.
More recently, the Biden administration has proposed a first-time homebuyer credit focused on accessibility to help new homeowners with down payment. The administration also announced the Housing Supply Action Plan in May 2022 with the objective of building and/or rehabilitating 100,000 homes over the next three years.
According to a recent study of Fannie Mae, addressing housing supply shortages will require different, highly localized strategies. The socioeconomic problems underpinning shortages of affordable housing are complex and difficult to entangle. For this reason, unique solutions are often required for each neighborhood. Municipal governments are typically best positioned to design programs aimed at social and affordable housing.
What Can Investors Do?
The background provided above underscores that improving access to affordable housing has several challenges and solutions require both the private and public sectors. From an investment standpoint, since affordable housing projects tend to have lower profit margins, they are often less attractive from a purely financial perspective. However, the potential for impact is significant and offers an opportunity for impact investors. Some ideas/opportunities for investors looking to make a difference in affordable housing are:
A. Social Purpose REITS: Social purpose REITs are similar to traditional REITs in that they own and manage a portfolio of real estate properties, and generate income from rents, leasing, and property appreciation, but with a focus on investing in properties that have a positive social impact, such as affordable housing, healthcare facilities, and education properties.
The social purpose REIT market is still relatively small, but there are some funds that have been very successful. One of the most well known is Housing Partnership Equity Trust (HPET), which was created by non-profit housing providers who recognized it as a gamechanger to tap into private capital to alleviate the housing crisis. HPET acquires properties with for-profit and non-profit partners, the latter of which can take advantage of state and local tax abatements to help reduce operating costs.
B. Manufactured homes: manufactured homes, also known as mobile homes or prefabricated homes, can be part of the solution to creating more affordable housing.
Unfortunately, this type of housing has long been stigmatized and associated with negative stereotypes. Some of the reasons for this stigma include historically poor-quality build, poor aesthetics and perception of value (i.e. mobile homes are viewed as a depreciating asset rather than a long-term investment like a traditional site-built home).
However, as William Levitt recognized in the 1950s, manufactured homes are probably the best value proposition for affordable housing. The lower barrier to entry - average new home sale prices are often well under $150,000—along with lower taxes makes housing attainable. In addition, the environmental footprint of manufactured homes, particularly recent builds, is far smaller than traditional homes. This is by virtue of being built in a factory setting, which results in less waste and more efficient use of materials.
Like with all investing, manufactured housing companies are not all created equally from an ESG perspective. One company that shows good potential is Sun Communities (NYSE: SUI). SUI provides real estate management services, with about half its revenue generated from owning, operating, and developing manufactured housing communities to provide housing solutions. The company has implemented a number of energy efficiency measures in its communities, including upgrading lighting systems, installing energy-efficient HVAC systems, and conducting energy audits. The company has received recognition for its sustainability efforts, including being named a 2020 Green Lease Leader by the Institute for Market Transformation and is included in the Dow Jones Sustainability North America Index.
C. Traditional Homebuilders With a Social Conscience
With housing shortages existing for years, big firms have taken advantage of a real estate market that had become very profitable, but not without controversy. BlackRock (NYSE: BLK) was accused in 2021 with contributing to the U.S. housing crisis by engaging in large-scale buying of single-family homes. The controversy arose because BlackRock and other institutional investors had been buying single-family homes in large numbers, which was driving up home prices. BlackRock is not an exception; the biggest real estate residential companies have faced criticism in recent years over their practices. Among them, Equity Residential (NYSE: EQR), Mid-America Apartment Communities (NYSE: MAA), and AvalonBay Communities (NYSE: AVB), have all been accused of gentrification, rent increases and eviction of long-term tenants.
The complexity of the real estate sector makes it difficult to find socially conscious investment plays. Nonetheless, one name to consider is Bridge Investment Group (NYSE: BRDG - listed since 2021). The US-based real estate investment trust focuses on affordable and senior housing. The company notably owns 11,500 seniors’ units, and 18,100 “Workforce & Affordable Home” units where at least 51% of units are occupied by families earning less than 80% of the area’s median income.
Around the world, there has been a documented rise in polarization that has been political, social, and economic in nature. The reasons why this is occurring are numerous and often disputed. However, what is not disputed is the notion that rising polarization is bad for democratic societies: polarization coincides with less democratic governments and lower levels of economic wealth.
At Sustainable Market Strategies, one of our sub-themes is Social Cohesion with the investment thesis that in an increasingly polarized world, the desire to conciliate rather than aggravate social tensions can serve to reduce inequalities and promote inclusive social progress. Therefore, companies that offer products and services that act to improve (detract from) social cohesion should be considered as potential long (short) candidates in a sustainable investment universe. Media outlets, some forms of leisure, penitentiary systems, and gambling are all examples of activities that often impact how societies function.
Football (soccer) is one form of leisure currently in the spotlight, as the World Cup is taking place this month. The World Cup is the biggest sporting event in the world with a record 3.5 billion viewers in 2018. Its 2022 edition, currently happening in Qatar, is expected to break this record. However, the organization of the competition has sparked controversy from the moment it was awarded to Qatar in 2010. Accusations of corruption within FIFA (Netflix released a documentary on the subject) have been accompanied by both environmental and social controversies. Detractors called for boycotts, while proponents denounced double standards from the Western world. The reasons justifying the two views are presented in the table below:
The table above highlights that what is often one person’s virtue, is another person’s vice. In the realm of responsible investing, there are often shades of gray. Nonetheless, there is a growing belief among consumers that companies need to do more to positively impact society and consumers can substantiate this belief that companies must create value for multiple stakeholders through their spending choices. Consumer sovereignty is the concept that citizens can exercise their power through their purchases. The implication is that companies who are not aligned with consumers’ values will simply not be profitable and it will be reflected in their equity price. In the following short story, we feature companies that consumers are confronted with when engaging in social activities. Each of them has the potential to be a positive contributor to society. Some are seizing their potential, while others are squandering it.
A Night on the (Post-Covid) Town
Chapter 1: Choosing an Activity
It was a long day at the (Platinum Leed certified) office and Miss Materiality was tired. Finally back home, she stood at the kitchen counter, waiting for her (avocado &) toast to grill, half-heartedly scrolling Instagram, with one earbud tuned in to Spotify. All of a sudden, something caught her attention: one of her favourite bands just posted the end of its hiatus with a world tour announcement, and a ticket pre-sale starting the following week.
- Meta (NASDAQ: META): The parent company of Instagram (WhatsApp is also a subsidiary), otherwise known as Facebook has suffered various reputational scandals over the past year. In a Note on October 7, 2021 (“Thumbs Down: A Socially-toxic Reputation for Facebook”), we enumerated the problems with this company in relation to its practices that help or hinder society. Notably, as many as 6% of American users of Instagram traced the urge to kill themselves to using that app. Other issues include weak data privacy policies, and their role in propagating misinformation. For all these reasons, we believe that Meta – in its current configuration – does more harm than good for social cohesion and is a candidate for our short universe.
- Spotify (NYSE: SPOT): Spotify provides music streaming services and offers both commercial free music and ad-supported services to subscribers. The content available on Spotify grows constantly and as a global platform with more than 406 million monthly active users, the company has an important role to play in educating listeners and encouraging positive actions. The company is not free from controversy - Spotify faces scrutiny over artist compensation, but on the whole, we believe the streaming service offers positive content to a wide audience. The company has a hate content and hateful conduct policy which at times, has been criticized for being overly punitive. We believe that Spotify has been right to err on the side of too stringent a policy rather than too lax. Spotify is a candidate in our long universe.
Chapter 2: Securing a Ticket
Miss Materiality sets a reminder on her phone to be the first to purchase tickets. However, even before the reminder goes off, she gets notification of an early presale access from Spotify. When she clicks on the link, she is directed to the Ticketmaster queue page for the concert, among a thousand other fans. After furiously clicking, she gets access to the sale where the only tickets left cost $500, in part due to the dynamic pricing Ticketmaster instituted in 2022, and are the worst located seats at the venue. Discouraged, she decides it is not worth going. She then looks for a more reasonable option. She decides to spend her money on tickets to go watch Manchester United football game with friends when she will be in Europe.
- Live Nation Entertainment Inc. (NYSE: LYV) is the parent company of Ticketmaster and engages in the production, marketing, and sale of live concerts for artists. Back in 2010, North American competition authorities approved the merger of Ticketmaster and Live Nation. Fans have since seen a price increase in concert tickets, and the recent Taylor Swift tour sale debacle revived the debate on the company’s monopoly: the U.S. Justice Department has opened an antitrust investigation into the owner of Ticketmaster and New York Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez called for the breakup of Live Nation and Ticketmaster. This is not the only controversy the company is facing. The giant has been fined and sued over the past decade for issues ranging from unruly crowds to equipment failures at various venues, endangering customers and worker safety. The company’s greed and poor operational performance are reflected in its CSRHub scores which have dropped since the merger, as seen in the chart below. Therefore, from its monopoly to its deficient operations, alongside legal risks associated, Live Nation is a candidate for our short universe.
Chapter 3: The Night Out – The Red Devils’ Groupie
A few months later, it is finally the day, and Miss Materiality sets foot in Old Trafford, the football stadium home of the Red Devils, for a Premier League Championship game.
- Manchester United PLC (NYSE: MANU), is the club with the most titles in England football history (20 Premier League titles). It is also known as one of the most environmentally conscious clubs, with initiatives to improve waste management on-site and education of fans on recycling and reducing waste. Manchester United is a strong brand: the club has a passionate and loyal community of 1.1 billion fans, and makes revenues from sponsorship, sale of merchandise, distribution/broadcasting of live football events, and the organization of domestic games in their stadium.
Since 2005, the Glazers, an American family, have owned the majority of the club, however, approximately one-third of shares are traded publicly on the NYSE. The right time to invest in the club may be coming soon, as the Glazers announced at the end of November 2022 the possible sale of their shares in the club. The announcement delighted investors, the club’s stock surged by almost 19% on the news. It also pleased supporters, who have not been a fan of the Glazers since they took ownership. Indeed, the Glazer’s controversial leveraged buyout in 2005 put the club in significant debt. According to fans, the Glazer family has not acted in the best interests of the club, as profits have not been reinvested in needed infrastructure. The wind of change blowing through Manchester United makes it a candidate in our long universe.
Chapter 4: The Night Out - Snacks & Beer
Miss Materiality doesn’t wait for the referee to blow the start whistle to quench her thirst. She knows the queue will be long later, so she quickly buys her go-to combo, two “United Sausage Rolls” and her favourite brew. She then finds her seat and settles in for the match.
- Heineken (HEIA NA) manufactures and distributes both alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages under various brands including Heineken, Amstel, Desperados, Sol, Tiger, Birra Moretti, Affligem, Lagunitas, Mort Subite, Strongbow Apple Ciders. Headquartered in Amsterdam and in operation since 1864, the company sells its products worldwide. From an ESG perspective, the company has a strong handle on how the world is changing and has so far been able to adapt with it. The move away from alcoholic beverages and toward craft breweries is increasingly captured in their product lines (e.g. Heineken 0.0% has been the official beer sponsor of the UEFA Europa League since 2020). Though not without controversy (working conditions in Africa were recently revealed to be worse than the company purports), the company is regarded as a sustainability leader on most fronts, with a CSRHub rank score of 93/100. Heineken’s trailing P/E – at 20X – makes the stock historically cheap; the stock historically has performed comparatively well during recessions.
Despite the loss of Manchester United to West Ham, Miss Materiality thoroughly enjoys her night out, which ends up at a local bar.
The pickup in global inflation that began in 2021 has coincided with a period of structural labor shortages in most developed economies. This backdrop has the potential to unleash a significant surge in wage inflation. Whether that occurs is a crucial question for investors since, for the past several decades, the muted cost of labor has been a key factor in the structural trend higher in corporate profit margins.
Indeed, this long-term decline in labor’s share of profits, along with rising income inequality, are significant driving forces behind one of our six top-down sustainability themes: “Leave No Person Behind”.
Today’s note provides a graphical snapshot of the U.S. labor market to ascertain whether labor is beginning to gain the upper hand. It tells the story of an employment market that is behaving remarkably similar to previous economic cycles: there is no evidence from the macro data that the situation for U.S. workers is improving on a structural basis, i.e. that rising real wages are leading to improved purchasing power or reduced inequality.
The U.S. Labor Market in Pictures
- The Labor Market Is Cyclically & Structurally Tight
- The U.S. unemployment rate, currently at 3.5%, is well below the non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment (NAIRU). Typically, when this condition occurs, it is a strong signal that labor is in short supply and wage growth tends to accelerate – see shaded regions on the chart.
- Note that this is an excellent cyclical indicator of underlying wage conditions and suggests that employment costs are likely to continue to accelerate.
- Nominal Wage Growth Is Uniformly Strong
- Wage growth has surged across industries and sectors, from retail trade to professional service industries.
- Despite little disparity in wage growth, some industries are suffering more acutely from labor shortages (i.e. the supply/demand imbalance is greater). Notably, the job vacancy rate in leisure, hospitality, health care and social assistance jobs is almost twice as high as in finance and education fields.
- Real Wages Are Not Keeping Up to Inflation
- Despite the acceleration in wages, it is critical to note that wage inflation has not kept pace with generalized inflation (CPI). This means that in real terms, workers are actually worse off, since their wages can buy less goods and services than previously.
- It is noteworthy that wage inflation typically lags CPI in the early phases of business cycles and outpaces CPI in latter stages. This is because wages tend to be less volatile than other prices; when the economy cools, inflation tends to moderate more than underlying wages.
- The Share of Workers with Negative Real Wage Growth Is Rising Sharply
- Over the past 25 years, on average, 45% percent of U.S. workers experienced negative real wage growth over the prior 12 months. This number vaulted higher in 2021.
- Despite stronger wage growth due to the tightness of the labor market, a majority of workers are finding their wages falling even further behind inflation. For workers who experienced a decline in their real wage in the second quarter of 2022, the median decline was close to 9%.
- High Paying Jobs Have Faster Rising Wages Than Low Ones
- Workers who are in the top quartile of wage earners are getting the biggest percent wage increases. The gap between low-wage earners and high ones is getting bigger.
- Income inequality appears to be getting worse in the current business cycle.
- Beyond the Cycle, Long-term Bargaining Power Is Not Improving
- The charts above capture business cycle trends; if and when the economy cools, the demand for labor will diminish and pressure on wages to increase will fall.
- On a structural basis, the bargaining power of labor to negotiate sustained higher wages has not changed. In fact, despite a few highly mediatized cases (e.g., Amazon, Starbucks, etc.), the rate of unionization remains at multi-decade lows.
- The Regulatory Backdrop for Labor Has Not Meaningfully Changed
- The stated claim of the current U.S. government is to improve working conditions for the middle class. But the current federal minimum wage is $7.25 the lowest level in real terms since the 1950s (note that wage laws vary at the state level – some states having no minimum wage and some, like California and Washington set to over $14/hour). By way of comparison, researchers at MIT calculate that the “living wage” (i.e. the approximate income needed to meet basic needs) at the end of 2021 was over $21/ hour.
- Some regulatory progress is being made, however. Earlier this week, the Department of Labor proposed a new rule on how to classify employees and independent contractors. The aim is to push back against the “gig economy” and restore workers’ rights and protection. If the rule is enforced, companies like DoorDash, Uber, Lyft, etc. would face important headwinds.
According to a recent World Health Organization report, about 9 million people with genetic Type 1 diabetes are alive today thanks to insulin. Type 1 diabetes requires multiple insulin injections per day whereas Type 2 diabetes can generally be treated with a combination of pills and much less frequent injections.
The Origin of Insulin
The discovery of insulin, a century ago, was an amazing breakthrough for type 1 diabetes patients who were previously condemned to die. Its discovery was also accompanied by internal rivalries. Today’s insulin market is controversial, led by its long history of price gouging.

More Obesity – Less Insulin
Contrary to popular belief, Type 1 diabetes is not purely genetic and Type 2 is not purely lifestyle-related. In both cases, individuals are genetically predisposed and there is a trigger in their environment.
For Type 1, risk factors are generally inherited from both parents. Type 2 has been shown to have a stronger link to family history. For example, a study of identical twins showed that less than 50% of the time, both twins have Type 1 whereas around 75% of the time, both twins have Type 2 diabetes.
Recognizing that genetics are more important than lifestyle, there is still a link between obesity and Type 2 diabetes. Obesity rates have been rising over the past two decades in the U.S., half of U.S. adults are expected to be obese by 2030. Obesity is increasing around the world, but the focus of our analysis is the United States because the consequent insulin price gouging problem is an American situation. As the chart below shows, the trend is going in the wrong direction.
This increase is mainly due to a change in diets, mostly from added sugar (as discussed in a previous note, “Heath Is the New Wealth”, November 12, 2020). Rates of lifestyle-related type 2 diabetes have increased in parallel with obesity. In 1958, 1.6 million Americans were diagnosed with diabetes, compared to 28.7 million in 2019 (with 9 million more undiagnosed). While more and more American need insulin supplies, its accessibility is increasingly out of reach.
As of 2021, 7.4 million Americans relied on insulin to manage their condition, but fewer patients are picking up their prescriptions. The U.S. insulin market is an oligopoly that has seen its three manufacturers (Eli Lilly, Novo Nordisk and Sanofi), dramatically increase their prices over the past two decades, making it difficult for people without insurance to afford as few alternatives exist. Even worse, in some emerging countries, insulin is not even available: three in four people affected by type 2 diabetes live outside of North America and Europe, yet they account for less than 40% of the revenue from insulin sales.
Insulin Prices to the Moon
Since the start of the century, the price of insulin has exploded compared to the official United States consumer price basket (see below). In the United States, oligopolistic price behavior by the three global manufacturers of insulin is surprising considering access to health care and medication is considered a primary need.
Novo Nordisk, Eli Lilly and Sanofi – the triumvirate who control the insulin market – generate incredible profitability. Novo Nordisk is more of a pure play, as diabetes represents more than 70% of its revenue, whereas it is less than 20% for Sanofi. Notwithstanding the fact that mastering insulin production requires significant investments, such high profitability should attract competition or at least scrutiny from the regulators.
A Weak U.S. Position
As the chart below shows, extreme insulin prices is a U.S. phenomenon. When looking at insulin prices in other countries, the difference is striking.
Why is it so expensive in the U.S.? Most nations empower their governments to actively negotiate prescription drug prices in order to hold costs in check. We use the German system as an example. In Germany, when a new drug enters the market, an independent panel sets a maximum price that insurers will pay ― a practice known as “reference pricing”. Most German residents have public health plans that are tightly regulated as German law requires public plans to cap out-of-pocket health care costs, and to cover all medically necessary treatment, including insulin.
The American Health Care system is comparatively far less interventionist. Federal health insurance programs are only provided to low-income earners, disabled people, and people over 65 years old. For other tranches of the population, private insurance can (sometimes) cover them, but there can be high deductibles. Free market principles are less effective when prices are totally inelastic: no matter how much the price of insulin rises, if you are a diabetic, you will pay or you will die. Prices are totally inelastic because there is no substitution effect for insulin: people will sell their house, their car or anything else they own.
Owners Beware
Insulin certainly has a positive impact on the life of diabetics. We looked at Article 9 funds in Europe as a good proxy for public market impact investments. The most popular companies in EU SFDR-regulated Article 9 funds are Schneider Electric and Microsoft. Novo Nordisk is number three. Sanofi and Eli Lilly are also well represented. After analyzing their pricing behavior in the United States, it seems unusual that so many impact funds have not shied away from these companies given their egregious pricing behavior on essential medicines.
Hands in the Cookie Jar
The basic instinct of greed in the American health care system is not reserved to drug manufacturers, it applies to other participants involved in drug delivery. The picture below details the money flow between the different parties involved for insulin and diabetes patients specifically.

Insurers, pharmacy benefit management companies (PBM), pharmacies and drug manufacturers are all part of this symbiotic machine to generate profit. In the United States, health care costs have tripled as a percentage of GDP since the 1970s as can be seen in the chart below.
Moreover, the health care costs as a percentage of GDP is much higher than other rich countries.
Government Action
Access to lifesaving medication should not be a privilege. The U.S. health care system is unlikely to be regulated like it is in Western Europe. The ballooning health care costs as a percentage of GDP put pressure on politicians to act. Pharmaceutical companies with extremely high profit margins should be wary of the regulatory landscape which could explain their growing lobbying efforts.
As discussed in last week’s note (“Outlook for Q4 and Beyond”, September 15, 2022), the Inflation Reduction Act touches on insulin: it caps its cost at $35 per month for Medicare recipients (around 3.3 million insulin users), starting in 2023. It covers only half of those who need insulin, but this is still significant. The proposed bill formerly included a cap on insulin for patients on private insurance, but Republicans opposed it, stating that it is not the role of the government to fix prices for private companies and that this capping would increase insurance premiums. On the other hand, California Governor Newson announced the State would make its own low-cost insulin, in an effort to improve accessibility. This move was made possible through an allocation of $100 million in the state budget to manufacture at a cheaper price. Its partner could be Civica Rx, a non-profit generic drug maker, who announced a plan in March to make and sell insulin for no more than $30 a vial. It is expected to be available as soon as early 2024, pending federal approval. Hopefully, these initiatives will introduce competition, reducing vulture-like behavior by member companies of the oligopoly.
Importantly, Eli Lilly, Sanofi and Novo Nordisk are no strangers to insulin pricing lawsuits. The most recent happened in the State of Arkansas, which sued insulin giants and PBMs in May 2022 for allegedly driving up the cost of insulin.
When a 2018 Supreme Court ruling reversed the decision to outlaw sports gambling in the U.S., state governments and sports leagues saw dollar signs. State governments saw an easy path to higher tax revenues. Sports leagues backtracked on a long-held stance that sports betting was bad for the integrity of the game and made sponsorship deals with gambling companies in hopes of reaching new levels of engagement in their respective sports. As of the beginning of 2022, thirty states have legalized betting and numerous sports teams have inked advertising deals. This has led to strong growth in the betting industry, but at what cost?
Why Gambling is Currently a Growing Industry
The history of gambling in the United States goes back to the first settlers in the colonies. Periods of greater acceptance are generally followed by retrenchment under moral grounds. We are currently in a phase of acceptance. Right now, the winners (casino operators and taxing authorities) promote their effect on local job creation with success while the losers (gamblers with impulse issues and their families) are not visible.
The graph below shows the growth in revenues for the U.S. sports gambling industry and tax authorities since the Supreme Court ruling. As more states allow sports gambling, revenues are growing fast and collected taxes are following.
California is set to vote on legalization of sports betting in November 2022. Following that, Texas is the next big target. Those two states are among the last growth opportunities. The road may be narrower with more competition for entertainment dollars following the end of lockdowns.
The graph below highlights the evolution of the monthly wagers in the United States as a whole since 2018. With more new states legalizing sports gambling, the amounts placed have definitely been on an uptrend.
Socio-economic Problems of Gambling
As the U.S. ramps up its gambling activities, the UK is cracking down. Sports gambling was already legal in the UK when betting opportunities began to be available on smart phone apps. Through this head start, Britain has already started to see the consequences of easier access to sports betting. Online casinos make most of their money with a small percentage of their gamblers. Over the last 20 years in the UK, problem gambling has been measured to affect 1 out of 200 gamblers and 7% of adults are negatively impacted by their own gambling or those of a family member. One UK study shows that online gambling losses are very skewed towards deprived areas. The industry typically praises upon the poor, many with mental health and self-esteem issues. After all, gambling is a zero-sum game, it does not improve productivity. For the gamblers, it is a negative-sum game because of operational fees, taxes and profits of the service provider (gambling app/casino).
It is one thing to allow gambling, but relentlessly promoting it is another. The same complacency does not apply to other addictions prone industries like alcohol and tobacco, which have heavily regulated advertising. The UK has started to address this issue with restrictions on the timing and amount of gambling ads. In 2018, fearing a stronger crackdown, gambling companies voluntarily agreed to a ‘whistle-to-whistle’ ban on advertising. In April of this year, new rules were approved to limit marketing tactics appealing to younger demographics. Additionally, a white paper to be presented at British Parliament could see the removal of betting sponsorship of Premier League teams. While it is early days in the U.S.’s relationship with sports betting and sponsorship, one should anticipate that regulation is coming.
Evolution of Gambling Culture
While legal changes triggered the sports betting boom, it was further amplified by the mood during pandemic lockdowns. There are some surprising examples highlighting the desire to bet for the sake of betting: a pause on major sports leagues resulted in a boon for Russian table tennis; and just this year, Russian gamblers were duped out of their money by wagering on fake cricket matches staged by inhabitants of an Indian village. These behaviors are consistent with the big bump in risk taking or gambling culture across society, over the last couple of years. People have become mesmerized by the possibility of short-term, one-off gains. Gamification of the world went feverish in 2021 when people were looking for anything after the novelty of lockdowns waned: crypto-trading platforms proliferated and Robinhood created a gaming-like experience for small investors. The problem is exacerbated as “players” are pushed by relentless promotion, easy access, the cashless effect and algorithms that know exactly when to prompt to keep someone engaged.
Instant access to everything gets us to only tune in for immediate outcomes. But, in order to reach long-term goals such as improving health care, education and incomes; short-term thinking will fail. Our proximity to planetary boundaries leading to global warming and the current timid response by society is a clear example of this short-termism. The rise of online gambling is an example of an unproductive use of capital.
As the graph below shows, sports betting in the traditional markets of Nevada and New Jersey (where it has been legal since 2018) have not seen a dip in the amount of gambling activity, even with the explosion of betting in new legalized states. This new activity is not coming from gamblers switching from betting in the previous legal states or switching from illegal betting with bookies; it is coming from new gamblers. Timing suggests stymie cheques and lockdowns have also contributed to the rise.
When interest rates were at zero, and stimulus cheques from governments were the norm, this type of zealous behavior was to be expected. However, with recent inflation, the easy money times are coming to an end, as governments and central banks look to tighten their purse. The invisible hand will likely redress the excesses and the gambling culture should erode with time.
Why Most Will Fail?
If we look globally, Asia is a tough market because China is closed off. Europe is a mature market where the excitement has peaked and regulations are being introduced. For now, North America is the wild west as sports betting is becoming legal in most states. The immediate tax revenues and the lack of regulation gives some temporary leeway in this market.
Gambling companies are playing the market capture game with profits far away. As the hype for new entrants peaked in 2021, along with other craziness like SPACS and Crypto fever, the business strategy of PENN and DKNG has not changed much: they are looking to acquire new clients with incentives. We expect consolidations in the industry once high client acquisition costs are recognized and enough pain has been endured. The chart below highlights the share price of the top 4 public online gambling companies in the United States over the last 30 months. Euphoria has been followed by pain, we expect to see some more pain in the future.
The 1% has the potential to change from being the greatest climate change offenders to the leaders; these wealthy individuals have disproportionate climate influence via their roles as consumers, investors and by leveraging their social networks. It is promising that younger members of the 1% are beginning to act in favor of improved environmental outcomes.
Much of the attention about inequality is focused on income and wealth. However, inextricably tied to wealth and income disparity is carbon emissions, both in terms of those who emit (the wealthy) and those who suffer (the poor). The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the UN group responsible for evaluating climate change related matters, has issued a series of science-based reports documenting the impact of climate change on the planet and its inhabitants. Its analysis of how GHG emissions have and will disproportionately hurt the poor is a reminder of inequality in the world, and the responsibility that the richest have for the living conditions of the poorest.
In this note, we provide an overview of the current situation, what systemic approaches can be utilized to improve outcomes and perhaps, most importantly, what investment tools are at the disposal of wealthy individuals to rectify their current carbon footprint.
State of the World Today: In the Eye of the Storm
Just as the top 1% captured 38% of all additional wealth accumulated since the mid-1990s, the production of GHG emissions is also extremely concentrated among a small share of the population: the charts below show that the top 10 per cent of income earners is responsible for close to half of all emissions, whereas the lowest 50 per cent of income earners account for around 7–15 per cent of all emissions. In terms of volume, each member of the 1% on average is responsible for 110 tonnes of CO2 equivalent emissions, compared to only 6.6 tonnes for the median wage earner.
Perhaps even more dramatic, in many rich countries, per capita emissions among the bottom half of emitters have declined since 1990: their current emission levels are close to the 2030 per capita climate targets set by the US, the UK, Germany and France. In contrast, highest emitters continue to do so at ever increasing rates.

Looking forward, if the world is to comply with the Paris agreement to limit warming to 1. 5°C, the wealthiest 1% will need to reduce their current emissions by 97% by 2030. In other words, all emission reductions efforts “should” be made by citizens in the top half of wealth distribution. The climate crisis shows how rich people blow through their “fair share” of carbon emissions.
These statistics underscore that it is overwhelmingly a wealthy minority that is fuelling the climate crisis. But what is it precisely about wealthy individuals that makes their carbon footprint so drastically different? The main culprit is their choices regarding transportation and leisure, and to a lesser extent, their choice of residence(s). The chart below shows the environmental footprint of several high-profile billionaires: although transportation in private jets, helicopters and luxury cars are a well known high-emitting pleasure of the super-rich, yachts are actually the biggest contribution to their mammoth carbon footprint.
Toward a more equal outcome: Policy, People, and Portfolio Impacts
Policy makers are traditionally focused on reducing income inequality, yet for the future of the Earth to be secured, they must shift the focus to addressing carbon inequality.
Carbon inequality differs from income and wealth inequality in that in the case of the latter, the aim of policymakers is generally to increase the income and wealth outcomes of those in the bottom half, without negatively impacting the level of income and wealth of those that are better off. In other words, the goal is to “increase the pie,” and improve the quality of life – as measured in financial terms – for everyone.
Unfortunately, unless consumer preferences change naturally, or unless policymakers devise an improved set of policy tools to impact consumer preferences, increasing the pie for everyone would tragically mean increasing GHG emissions per capita.
Since the bottom half of the population is responsible for only a very small share of carbon emissions, it follows then that in order to be successful, policies must focus on the largest emitters, i.e., wealthier nations and wealthier individuals. Possible solutions include:
Carbon wealth tax: A carbon wealth tax involves applying a supplemental tax to high earners and spending the proceeds on green energy investments and/or other tools that redistribute in favor of lower carbon emitters.
Policy and Consumer Preferences: COVID-19 has shown how rapid lifestyle changes can be brought about by governments, through lockdown periods establishing new routines. While lockdowns are draconian, they highlight that spending patterns can shift meaningfully in the near term when there is a strong government action, or exogenous shock (COVID). Consumer preferences can be shifted by government policies, and this shift is a critical part of addressing the climate crisis. One approach, called Choice Editing, refers to the active process of controlling or limiting the choices available to consumers end goal, specifically by banning or imposing punitive taxation on certain products and services. In the case of forcing habit changes of the super-rich, authorities can restrict carbon-intensive products (like private jets or mega yachts) from coming to the market in the first place, or by taxing specific products so that lower-carbon options are favored. Tax incentives for modifying consumer behavior are a long established part of the policy took kit. For example, in the U.S., there are significant tax incentives for individuals to purchase municipals bonds to help finance local and state governments - these incentives largely help the wealthy and encourage them to direct their wealth to public infrastructure projects and financing the activities of municipalities. It would be reasonable to provide both taxes and tax incentives to shift the consumer preferences of the richest to save the planet.
In theory, both of the above approaches are straightforward. But in practice, both can be difficult to implement and in the case of taxation, difficult to assess the impact. Wealthy individuals not only have outsized financial resources but they also tend to have substantial social resources, meaning that their ability to lobby and influence regulatory incomes is high relative to other socioeconomic groups. Therefore, the likelihood that choice editing would occur in a way that would crimp the lifestyles of the rich and famous is lowered. In any case, there are currently few such restrictive measures in place. A lone exception is the UK labour party’s proposal to ban private jets from airports beginning in 2025. Meanwhile, carbon taxes have, historically, had little impact on the consumption of high-income households since demand inelasticity is greatest among this group.
A third approach in curbing carbon emissions by wealthier households is by targeting non-financial factors of decision-making. Much of consumer behaviour is influenced not only by rational choice regarding prices, but also by other factors including routines, normative influences, and heuristics and biases. Nudge theory is a concept in behavioral economics that proposes positive reinforcement and indirect suggestions as ways to influence the behavior and decision-making of groups or individuals. In other words, it attempts to alter people’s behavior in a predictable way without forbidding any options or significantly changing their economic incentives.
Nudging has been recognised as an effective policy tool to align intention and action in facilitating behavioural change with regard to environmental outcomes, especially in the areas of waste management, energy conservation and sustainable travel. Since high-income individuals are often viewed as role models (influencers) and set the tone to which others aspire, they could play an important positive role in changing consumer behavior at large in favor of “greener lifestyles”.
Generational Shifts: All Hands on Deck
An expected $68 trillion will change hands over the next two decades as part of the “Great Wealth Transfer” from the baby boomer generation (born 1946 - 1964) to millennials (born 1981 - 1996) and Gen Z (born 1997-2012). As the survey data in the Chart below highlights, the latter generations place a stronger importance on environmental issues, suggesting that as this wealth transfer occurs, the likelihood that behavior is more aligned with sustainable consumption will increase.
Moreover, a Deloitte survey shows that millennials and Gen Zs are willing to align their spending with their values: 90% of millennials and Gen Zs are taking action to limit environmental impact and are willing to pay a premium for more sustainable products.
This finding is especially true for the wealthiest of these generations. A 2020 report by Wealth-X exploring global luxury highlights that younger members of the ultra wealthy (defined as those having wealth over $30 M) do not have the same affinity for luxury items as those over 50 years old. They are less likely to own a yacht, private jet, art collection or other asset collection (real estate, cars, watches and jewelry, sports team, etc.) of significant value.
Further impact can be achieved through philanthropic activity. There is approximately US$1.5 trillion dedicated to all philanthropic assets and endowments around the world, but less than 1% was spent on curbing climate change in 2020. Philanthropic spending tends to be centred on health, public safety, community development and education, but since millennials tend to prioritize environmental projects, one can expect that giving to environmental causes will skew favourably in the future.
Finally, millennials are likely to invest in portfolios that are different than their parents and grandparents, by placing greater emphasis on environmental impact relative to financial metrics. This is good news since investments in stocks, bonds, businesses and real estate are disproportionately made by those in the top 1% of income and wealth. Through shifting investments to low-emissions companies and mutual funds, the 1% can push companies to lower GHG emissions and thereby drive structural change. By contrast, investments that favour continuing fossil fuel use will delay emissions reductions.