Headlines abound about bottlenecks, backorders, stoppages, empty shelves and exorbitant shipping costs. Indeed, global supply chains that were previously built for a world with peaceful borders, regular weather patterns and steady demand – have faced multiple challenges over the past two years and have forced some companies to rethink their operational strategies.
Of course, not all the supply chain hiccups encountered of late are strictly due to ESG issues. However, many of the consistently cited global supply risks are of an environmental, social, or political nature and in all circumstances, the investment implication is always the same: there is a trade-off between operational efficiency and resilience. For the past several decades, investors have rewarded operational efficiency, but the future will increasingly favor those companies that bet on the side of resiliency.
Over the past several months, the covid-19 pandemic has altered both demand and supply patterns across multiple goods and services. Eventually, demand patterns will normalize (albeit they may be different than before for some goods and services). However, supply-side challenges are rooted in several factors that go well beyond the pandemic and will be longer lasting. For example, while factory shutdowns in Vietnam are directly due to virus breakouts, the lack of McDonald’s milkshakes in the U.K. is due to a truck driver shortage. And while storms in Texas meant that it was impossible to buy paint in North America for most of the first half of 2021, leather furniture prices in Canada have skyrocketed since anti-dumping tariffs imposed on Vietnam and China have occurred at a time of no domestic production…the list goes on and on.
There are almost no industries that escape supply chain challenges. However, today’s note considers goods and services where the consumer is the end-user, because we believe that given current macroeconomic trends, resilient supply chains may be a particularly decisive success (fail) factor for companies selling to consumers.
The Consumer Spending Spree Has Much Further To Run
There are several important tailwinds that suggest U.S. consumers, who continue to be the largest single driver of global growth, will continue to spend at an above-trend pace. The charts below highlight the excellent financial position of consumers: the savings rate is higher than it has been in decades and with interest rates at multi-decade lows, the ability to service outstanding debt is extremely good. Moreover, the labor market has tightened substantially, indicating that job security has improved; strong government support from the Biden administration has no doubt also improved consumer confidence.
These superior consumer conditions have been in place for some time and spending in some sectors has already rebounded sharply. Housebound consumers have already upgraded their furniture, appliances and electronics and now that vaccination rates are rising, consumers with the wherewithal to spend, will do so outside of the house: spending sectors like restaurants, recreation services and clothing are most likely to play catch up to the consumer durable goods sector.
Given this backdrop, our investment thesis is that companies that provide nondurable consumer goods and services that are best prepared to handle ongoing supply chain hiccups will be particularly well-positioned to reap gains from the ongoing consumer spending revival.
Restaurants: A Case Study
We, by no means, expect that consumer activity will return to pre-covid norms in the very near future. However, adequate Covid vaccinations mean that the worst-case outcome is likely behind us and there is a budding consensus that we will begin to “live with the virus”. This means that domestic hibernation has likely peaked as activities like eating outside of the home resume. In this context, the restaurant industry is an interesting case study for our supply chain resilience thesis.
In the case of restaurants, there are three stand-out supply chain hiccups: shortage of labor, constraints in shipping and transport and the unavailability of certain items.
We discussed the backdrop for wages in a note on August 26 (Pay Up And They Will Come) and made the case that companies that manage to retain workers by paying above current market rates would be rewarded with higher stock prices. This is also a primary tactic in confronting the problem in supply chains, from front-line restaurant staff to truck drivers transporting raw materials to farm workers growing necessary ingredients.
As for shipping bottlenecks, a full exploration of this subject is beyond the scope of this report but suffice to say that companies that can minimize the distance travelled between products sourced and their customers can avoid unexpected/volatile costs associated with the transportation of goods.
Finally, in terms of availability of items, in the food industry, shortages tend to be of a short-term nature, measured only in hours or at most, days. The impact on profitability is mostly through reputation and client satisfaction.
In the supply chain literature, three of the main determinants of supply chain resilience are as follows:
(1) The degree to which product sourcing is diversified: the ability to source inputs from various suppliers and from various locations limits the likelihood that an isolated problem will shutdown production.
(2) The number of products and SKUs (bar codes) that are carried by a brand/company: fewer components to produce the end product, as well as fewer options/variations offered limits the likelihood that customers will be disappointed when items are out of stock.
(3) Product pricing: companies that have higher profit margins to begin with - which are often companies offering higher end products - will tend to have more room to absorb the costs associated with tighter supply of input products.
In the following table, we apply these principles to the restaurant industry and within the current context of restaurant supply chain challenges.
Using the above table of risk mitigating factors, we analyse the current strategies of the companies in the S&P 500 restaurant index (Chipotle, McDonald’s, Darden, Domino’s Pizza and Starbucks). The following stand out:
Offer superior wages: as highlighted in our previous note, both McDonald’s and Chipotle have offered pay hikes above the minimum wage in order to retain workers. While this is certainly positive, and sets them apart from their peers, it does not mitigate risks emanating further upstream. Nonetheless, both companies have reported that the “acute labor shortage” has diminished, which helps build resilience at the end of the supply chain.
Improve technology: Obviously, digitising menus and orders is only one example of how technology can reduce the number of tasks assigned to employees, but this has proven to be an effective strategy. McDonald’s had been a leader in this area prior to the pandemic, but QR code menus is increasingly becoming the norm; there appears to be little competitive advantage among the restaurant chains analysed.
Locally-sourced ingredients: Out of the five restaurant companies in the index, Chipotle is far and away the company that relies most on fresh ingredients and therefore, by design, has some of the shortest distances travelled between suppliers and restaurants.
Limit number of menu items and ingredients: All of the five restaurants have made efforts in order to reduce the number of menu items and SKUs in their locations over the past two years. For example, both Starbucks and McDonald’s have simplified their menus. Meanwhile at Chipotle, the necessity to reduce items was already low because keeping a simple ingredient list has been a fundamental business strategy since the company was created.
Diversify suppliers of equivalent products: Our analysis of the level of diversification for suppliers among the five restaurants in the index is incomplete to date. Using the supply chain function in Bloomberg, investors can track the supply chains of each company, and we did indeed find a large variation in the number and geographic locations of suppliers. McDonald’s and Starbucks have by far the most diversified supply chains (161 suppliers in 46 countries at Starbucks and 185 suppliers in 57 countries for McDonald’s) but this is most likely more a result of the globalized nature of their businesses rather than a concentrated effort to diversify suppliers.
Taking all of these elements together, our qualitative analysis suggests that features in both Chipotle and McDonald’s supply chain put them in a better position than their peers. Chipotle in particular - by focusing on a limited number of fresh and widely available ingredients - has reduced the risk of encountering unforeseen transportation costs and/or supply shortages (not to mention offering a healthier menu to customers!) As highlighted in a previous note, this company has also gone further than its peers in tackling the challenge of labor shortages by offering higher wages. On the flipside, Domino’s and Darden appear to be lagging on many fronts that help determine the resiliency of supply chains. Interestingly, this positioning is also reflected in overall ESG scores, with Domino’s in particular consistently in the bottom ranking among its peers.