The Water Digital Revolution refers to new digital tools that will improve our water utility systems.

Water systems – in the developed world – are a piece of underground infrastructure that were built around 100 years ago, and that were meant to bring water and sanitation to every citizen’s home. The primary goal was to fight rampant diseases in society. Underground water systems were a revolutionary design that entailed opening all the streets across an entire city to settle a set of pipes, valves and pumps below ground in order to extend the water cycle from nature to everyone’s home. This herculean work concluded with the refilling of streets with concrete and running the system from a central utility. Our “modern” societies have hence enjoyed water services at their doorstep ever since.

These water systems have seen little change since then, mostly undergoing local renovations here and there following a pipe failure. This means that our most basic need – water – is serviced by an infrastructure that is more than a century old and the entire piece of infrastructure is buried under the ground: out of sight and out of mind.

This means these assets have deteriorated – and keep on deteriorating – and it is difficult to know how and where exactly. Most repairs are reactive; after a leaking pipe becomes a broken one, neighbourhoods flood and the situation inflicts costly repairs on the utility and the municipality.

Adding pain to injury, climate change is bringing new challenges to water infrastructure with floods and storms, which adds extreme flow volatility to the system. This increases the risk of quality and quantity failures in various points of the system (e.g. flooded sewage or chemicals spills at treatment plants). Water scarcity – or drought – also brings its own kind of trouble when every drop of water will start to count. A utility will no longer be able to afford water loss across its systems (water loss can amount to 25 to 30% in developed countries like France and Italy).

In a somewhat perverse way, climate change is the best thing that could have happened to water systems, because it is challenging the very notion on which most thrive, or at least claim to: the safety of water delivery. Most utilities have been very conservative, shunning innovation for the fear that is not robust enough to sustain basic security of delivery and could imply costly system failures (both from financial and reputational terms). These kinds of failures are nonetheless happening with cases like Flint, PFAS Global Contamination and Texan Water System Collapse from the last deep freeze. This means climate change and pollution are challenging the status quo and will push for survival behavior. This makes for a timely opportunity for investors to participate in this change.

While many investors would look to investing into water utilities to access the water theme, we prefer water technology stocks. A such, this is a smart way to avoid investing directly into pipes and sewers, which are the typical legacy assets of utilities and which are in deep need of being renovated (high capex) in the coming years.

Indeed, accessing the water theme while avoiding water utilities can be done by investing in the companies that will deliver digital solutions that address the technical and environmental challenges of the 21st century. To be sure, the Digital Water Transition will take time to be implemented because it implies a change of mindset in older generations of engineers that are accustomed to the status quo. But this change of mindset is a small hurdle when compared to the huge economic benefits that these technologies can deliver – it is far more cost effective to digitally monitor and micro repair problems underground rather than ripping up and replacing miles of underground pipes. Once the digital revolution will have reached water infrastructures, strong tailwinds are to be expected for the companies in this space. We have identified three companies that are the most likely to play a dominant role in this thematic:

Xylem (XYL US) is the leader in water industrials with digital integration. Their portfolio is quite large and purely dedicated to water, making it a safe bet to access the theme. An example of their work is a scanning and monitoring project the company deployed on a pipeline from Lake Huron to the city of London in Southwestern Ontario (Canada). The pipeline had suffered several critical failures and used Xylem’s technologies to prevent new ones. Smart Ball and Snake-like Probing devices were introduced in the pipeline without service interruption to monitor deteriorations along the entire line. Monitoring devices were later installed along the line to gauge the health of the asset after initial probing. This allowed the pipeline owner to have an initial assessment of its asset deterioration and evolution over time, allowing for proactive rather than reactive maintenance. This meant a 5:1 ROI on every pipe failure, as the former costs $300k CAD and the latter $1.5M CAD.

Badger Meter (BMI US), as its name implies, is the leader in smart metering. They meter all kinds of parameters: flow, pressure and quality, for various industries. Flow and pressure efficiency are important to maintain the smooth delivery of water across the entire system, as well as keeping it sanitized. Accurate metering in chemicals reaction for water treatment plans are similarly important to keep water safe and meet regulatory standards. Measuring tools such as those developed by Badger Meter will be in high demand as data become an increasingly important factor in monitoring water assets.

Autodesk (ADSK US) is developing Digital Twinning at full scale. Digital Twinning is a new technology that creates a real-time holographic replica of an infrastructural asset. This is an AR/VR Tech (Augmented/Virtuality Reality) that shows how water systems are functioning live. The value proposition is boundless as it allows water engineers to actually “see” water system in real time, therefore having a complete picture of water infrastructures right in front of their eyes. This helps better understand the assets, monitor them, and allow simulations of potential disasters and improve preparedness. This is also a very valuable tool to train new engineers.

All these companies have great financials making them solid investments in their own right. The above chart highlights that these three stocks returned an annualized performance of between 22% and 38% per year in the last five years.

And while the companies are getting more expensive, it is to be expected in the current environment where multiples are inflated but as long as other fundamentals such as profitability, solvency and liquidity are attractive (see table below), these companies should be on an ESG-minded investor’s mind.

6% NIM is a healthy margin for XYL US, an industrial stock that is exiting the global lockdown which had tempered its sales. It has low debt (D/E at 0.51x) and good cash on hands (CR 1.8x) to restart projects amid the Covid-Recovery. BMI US is almost debt-free, while ADSK US enjoys a comfortable net-margin of almost 32%. On top of good financial health, the true value potential of these companies is delivering water solutions. As more and more water infrastructure challenges materialize, we expect these companies to provide critical solutions and become even better performing assets.

The main risk in the space is competition replacement: there is always the potential that a new technology is developed and outdates the previous versions. But even then, business in the water space is pretty sticky and that makes the sales pipeline pretty robust. Nonetheless this is a long-trade game, and the benefits will be harvested throughout the transition. Investors need to keep an eye on these companies and make sure they remain on the top of their game.

“The biggest danger is not inaction. The real danger is when politicians and CEOs are making it look like real action is happening when in fact almost nothing is being done, apart from clever accounting and creative PR.” Greta Thunberg, COP25 2019.

As we all now know, 2020 was a blowout year for attracting capital to ESG investing and 2021 is also off to a great start: according to Morningstar, sustainable fund assets climbed by almost 20% again in Q1 2021, meaning that “ESG” assets under management stand at just under USD $2 trillion. This represents a doubling since 2019!  

The rising trend toward ESG investing means that management at publicly traded companies understand the allure of appearing “green”: as more investors choose ESG over traditional stock picks, companies will be overlooked and/or left out of more popular ESG-inspired indices. The latter risks damaging their stock price performance. Moreover, according to a recent MSCI study, companies with high ESG scores experience lower costs of capital compared to companies with poor ESG scores. This is true across developed countries and across sectors.

The implication is that there is a rising incentive for companies to pursue implementing ESG business strategies. Or at the very least, there is a rising incentive to pursue an image of implementing ESG strategies.

The latter - paying lip-service to causes with little impact - affect all of ESG; blue washing refers to pretending to be socially conscious, pink washing refers to falsely promoting fair gender, and of course, greenwashing refers to environmental cover up. All three are important (and could be committed by the same offenders!) but in this week’s note we shine a light specifically on greenwashing.

Corporate greenwashing has implications for multiple economic actors and the planet. In terms of investing, greenwashing misdirects capital away from the goals and preferences of underlying investors.  

The principal tool for companies to communicate to investors about their environmental credibility is via sustainability reporting. Therefore, for investors that are looking to marry superior returns and positive ESG outcomes, it is crucial to be able to determine which companies are truly making improvements in environmental performance (either through efficiencies, new technology or innovative business models) and those companies that are merely improving their ability to communicate on ESG factors via glossy reporting.  

The matrix below highlights the possible outcomes between being green and reporting green (note that environmental “duds” should be entirely ignored among modern investors).

Although there is a plethora of reporting metrics, indices, standards and practices, all with varying degrees of reliability, we have developed a simple filter to help decipher which companies are likely to fall into each quadrant. Starting with the S&P Global 1200 (covering roughly 70% of total equity market capitalization) as the investment universe, we follow these steps to decode where companies fall in the matrix:  

- First, we use SASB’s materiality map’s environmental dimension to evaluate which industries are most affected by environmental issues. We do this to ensure that we only include industries whereby greenwashing is a material investment risk. We then translate the SASB industries to MSCI sectors. This limits our investment universe to MSCI companies within the energy, materials, industrials, and consumer staples sectors.

- Next, we rank these companies using both Eikon Refinitiv and CSR Hub data. Since we are focused only on greenwashing, we use only the Environment Scores (i.e. we ignore the overall ESG, as well as the Social and Government scores). We then compare the overall environment score with two critical sub-components of the environmental dimension: environmental innovation and product. We consider these two sub-categories as an indicator for “potential positive environmental impact” because high scores in these categories suggest that the company is more likely to be focused on environmental technology and/or innovative environmental business models that should lead to productivity in the future. In other words, the overall E score is likely to most closely represent a company’s E communication score, while the E innovation/product score should represent the company’s ability to deliver on green performance in the future.  

- We then compare the gap in ranking between a company’s overall E score and its E innovation/product score. Companies that have high overall E, but low E innovation are flagged as having a higher potential for greenwashing (bottom right quadrant of the matrix), while companies with high innovation but low overall scores are more likely to be potential environmental underdogs (top left quadrant of the matrix). Importantly, we only include companies whose scores are consistent in both the Refinitiv and CSR Hub data bases; given the ongoing wide discrepancies in reporting standards and methodologies, this criterion helps increase the accuracy of our filter.

The results of our “greenwash” filter are shown in the tables below by sector.

 

 

 

 

There are a few key observations and caveats from this exercise:

- Although we applied our filter across the four sectors whereby environmental factors are most material according to SASB, a qualitative check on the individual names that were flagged by the filter suggest that this methodology is less effective for the energy space. We agree that Baker Hughes should be on investors’ watchlist for greenwashing, however we are unconvinced about the names that were flagged as “green underdogs” or “truly green”. These companies were in part flagged by our filter because many do indeed develop innovative technology, but they continue to operate in dirtier aspects of fossil fuel businesses. A case in point is Cenovus, which continues to extract heavy oil from the Canadian tar sands, albeit with technology that improves its water efficiency.

- Within the consumer staples sector, our filter “caught” almost exclusively companies in the tobacco, food products and food retailing industries. This is largely because scores in these industries were more extreme relative to the other industries within this sector (beverages, personal and household products).

According to our filter, the potential for greenwashing is greater among companies with larger market capitalization: the average market cap of companies in our potential greenwasher bucket is 13% greater than those companies in the green underdog category. The correlation between ESG reporting and company size has been widely reported in recent years; the results from the filter suggest that not only are larger companies more likely to report on ESG issues, they are also more likely to exaggerate their green performance.

Finally, we caution readers that this filter is not intended to act as a standalone screen for investors to track down greenwashers. The companies highlighted in the tables should not be viewed conclusively as partaking in greenwashing; even when using several sources of ESG reporting, errors and omissions occur. Rather, our Greenwashing Screen can be used as one tool among many and alongside thorough qualitative company analysis.

While science is crucial in adapting to climate change, one could argue that innovation in applied sciences is paramount. Sustainability is rapidly becoming a growing business line for many engineering companies worldwide.  

While engineering services companies will continue to benefit from the global fiscal stimulus in the years to come and from “build-back-better” initiatives, those with dedicated practices in the fields of environmental remediation, public transportation, water management and renewable power are set to outperform the pack.

The good news is that many engineering companies have taken a serious turn towards sustainability, such as SNC-Lavalin, a Canadian engineering household name who recently joined the UN Global Compact and issued its plan to become Net Zero by 2030. For ESG investors, such a firm, which was engulfed in several corruption scandals in the early 2010’s in Libya and barred from World Bank contracts for a decade, poses an interesting case study on the importance of governance in the engineering sector. After a long period of adjustment and internal cleansing of its practices, the firm has straighten up its act and is now building up its future using sustainability as an edge to win contracts.

More than 300 engineering firms have now joined the UN Global Compact and the list continues to grow as more and more clients – public and private – are now asking their suppliers to adhere to some level of sustainability standards in engineering (such as ISO 140011 and others). Moreover, NGOs such as Corporate Knights’ Global 100 rankings have included engineering firms such as Stantec, one of the world’s largest engineering firms (also based in Canada), in its top 10 most sustainable companies (among all sectors) for 2020.

Given the complex nature of the way business is done for engineering firms – and the various countries they work in – the quality of governance of such firms becomes paramount to the long-term value and to the sustainability outcomes of their activities. To this end, it seems that the quality of governance in the sector has improved substantially these past few years, with SNC-Lavalin displaying some of the greatest improvements of its percentile rank in CSRHub with Arcadis, another firm that is strongly committed to sustainability and Stantec, which remains at the top of the pack.

Overall, engineering and construction services companies have had a good ride during COVID and benefitted greatly from governments’ promises to “build-back-better” in many countries.

Interestingly, the sector remains cheaper than the overall market as the S&P 1200 Construction and Engineering Index trades at a 20% discount to the market on a P/E basis. Should the equity market correct in the coming months, engineering services and construction companies could even become an interesting haven – at least those companies with a lower market Beta – for investors looking to de-risk their portfolios and anchor themselves more closely to developments and the direction of fiscal levers in the real economy.

Sustainable Market Strategies looked at large-cap engineering companies with dedicated practices in line with environmental, renewable power, water, and public transportation themes. We view that these companies will benefit the most from the soon-to-come government spending in these sectors. While most of these companies are based in North America, their activities remain global in nature – which also makes them exposed to growth in EMs and lower income countries.

Interestingly, SMS’s index of Green Engineering companies outperformed both the S&P 500 and the S&P 1200 Engineering and Construction indices on equal-weighted basis since August 2020. We think that the outperformance of our index should continue in the coming months.

 

That said, looking at the P/E of our index, some of the hype around green engineering seems to be already priced-in by markets at this point.

While that valuation of SMS’ Green engineering index appears expensive against the rest of the sector, one should look for cheaper names within our index. As such, companies such as SNC-Lavalin, Stantec and WSP – all of them global engineering powerhouses – and up-and-coming contenders such as Montrose Environmental – could be interesting plays for those looking to find value and exposure to the build-back-better theme.

One of the high-growth areas of sustainable finance and ESG these days are financial instruments – in this case bonds and loans – with embedded triggers tied to issuers’ sustainability outcomes – many of which compatible with ESG performance frameworks such as the GRI, SASB, SBTi, etc. As a result, many see sustainability-linked instruments as one of the future drivers of sustainability in the corporate world.

According to Bloomberg data, more than USD 30 billion of sustainability-linked loans and bonds have been issued globally by corporates and governments since 2019, and we expect this number to grow at an even faster pace in the coming years. While European corporate and government issuers continue to lead the pack, the U.S. has caught up substantially and is poised to see an increase in its issuance given the recent change of tack in DC and the growing appetite from lenders, corporates and investors for all-things sustainable.

The issuance of sustainability-linked instruments is also becoming more widespread across U.S. and European BICS sectors, with Utilities and Materials leading the group in terms of total amount issued since 2019. Here, three sectors are of interest: Utilities, Financials and Energy.

One can understand some of the reasons pushing Utilities to embark on the sustainability path – with renewables (notably wind and solar) now cheaper than thermal sources (natural gas and coal), companies in this sector can easily attach sustainability strings to their loans knowing that their future most likely will be one with less carbon intensity. In that, we expect Utilities – especially those embracing the transition to a lower carbon future at a faster pace – to benefit from lower financing costs that will likely come with sustainability-linked financing instruments.

Conversely, Financials find themselves in a position where they will have to commit to a change in their books and source of profits (think of Canadian banks’ exposure to oil sands financing) which will take longer than other sectors to achieve – hence the relatively smaller amount of outstanding sustainability-linked instruments in the financial sector.

Surprisingly, sustainability-linked instruments remain a marginal source of finance in the Energy sector – perhaps the area where they could have the greatest impact.

That being said, assessing the effectiveness of sustainability-linked instruments in addressing real-world problems forces us to measure the relative contribution of financial incentives vs. those aiming at other business vectors such as 1) management (i.e. pay) and 2) the contribution of technological change to the improvement of corporate-level sustainability outcomes.

While many are calling for regulatory standards regarding ESG in markets (the latest being Mark Carney in his new book), there remains a fair amount of noise as to the standards to which issuers should adhere when tying their financing costs to sustainability outcomes. One of the leading standards comes from ICMA’s Sustainability-linked bond principles.

While most frequently used metrics include internal KPIs such as energy efficiency performance and improvement of ESG scores (the latter doesn’t make much sense in our view considering the discrepancies in ESG scores across third-party ESG data providers), we much prefer issuers’ adherence to “’hard” objectives such as the Science-Based Targets initiative, commitments to increase gender equality at all levels of the organization, executive pay incentives (one of the most effective ESG incentive when done right), and any other measurable “absolute” sustainability-related targets.

While several studies suggested a disappearing greenium (lower yields for green instruments vs. plain vanilla comparables) in the green bond space, we note that sustainability-linked instruments still offer a lower financing cost compared to the average yield asked for by market participants in several sectors (we don’t know the extent to which sustainability clauses were triggered in Bloomberg, in fact very few details on the covenants themselves).

Looking at about 100 such instruments in the U.S. and Europe issued since 2019, one sees that sustainability-linked instruments yields (BICS sector average) remain lower than the sectoral averages of their plain vanilla equivalents. Like for the early days of green bonds, we are seeing some yield compression happening given the high demand for such products at this point.

Moreover, looking at the G-spread average per sector, we also see that sustainability-linked loans display lower spreads vs. their plain-vanilla equivalents.

Furthermore, we think that sustainability-linked instruments will prove to have their greatest impact in highly leveraged sectors such as Real Estate and Utilities. It also happens that along with Energy, these sectors probably have the biggest “transition” potential of all.

 

Morgan Stanley released a report last week to help investors properly value environmentally themed stocks. It revealed that the most common question it has received over the past month is whether a ‘green bubble’ has formed.

This past year was all about the color green. From renewable energy to EVs, all 50 shades of green saw a massive hike in valuations. In fact, according to Morgan Stanley’s report, a basket of green stocks saw their price-to-earnings ratios increase by an average of 24 points over 2020, compared with two points for sector peers.

In our note “ESG discounts in emerging markets” (October 29, 2020), we suggested to investors who thought that green investments in DMs were too “bubbly” to look down south for green opportunities in EMs. This week, we suggest an alternative approach: changing your color palette from green to blue.

From the graph above, one can see that the decoupling between the performance of green, blue and the general market indicators happened since the rebound following the COVID flash crash. The very nascent correction observed in the green sectors these past couple of weeks has also not been observed in the Blue Economy sectors. In our opinion, this is the perfect time to for ESG-minded investors to reallocate some of the profits from green investments towards blue ones.

But first, let us define what we mean by Blue Economy, as its definition can be as wide and deep as the oceans themselves. The Asian Development Bank’s taxonomy for the sector is probably one of the most complete out there.

The segments represent different investable industries related to the oceans and the services they provide.

According to the OECD, the ocean economy is projected to double and reach USD 3 trillion by 2030. Moreover, the required investments to make the Blue Economy more sustainable are even greater than the land-based ones, as of the 17 UN Sustainable Development Goals, SDG14 on the conservation and sustainable use of the ocean and its resources attracts the lowest share of investment (3.5%). With the increased realization that more needs to be done to ensure the sustainability of the water resource in particular and the oceans in general, the growth opportunities for ESG-minded investors are extremely attractive.

A few segments are particularly attractive right now. Aquaculture, and its corollary Seafood Processing, is definitely the hottest theme of the space as it drives on demographic drivers to feed a growing population. The WWF estimates that more than USD 3 billion people depend on seafood as their main source of protein. As the state of global fisheries is very dire, all hopes are focused on aquaculture to feed this large part of the human population. Listed companies like Mowi (MOWI NO), the leader in the space with 25 to 30% of the trout and salmon markets, is often touted to be a sustainable leader in this space. Aquaculture is, however, not without its challenges as it suffers from the same issues as industrial farming, namely overcapacity, animal welfare, and over-reliance on chemicals to combat diseases – in this case sea lice. Moreover, environmentalists often criticized aquaculture to be detrimental to local ecosystems with fish excrement concentration as well as inducing genetic degeneration in wild populations when farmed fish escape. Another Norwegian company, Atlantic Sapphire (ASA NO) is one of the few listed companies working on recirculating aquaculture systems (RAS), which offers a way to do land-based fish farming – a more sustainable method as fish are farmed closer to centers of demand, reducing the incidence of sea lice and contamination with wild populations. Aquaculture is definitely an attractive opportunity for investors as the market is expected to grow to USD 245 billion by 2027, but they should proceed with care as this space is not free from potentially large environmental risks.

Algaculture, or seaweed farming, is the next big thing in the Blue Economy, if not destined to be the top. The global Seaweed market has been estimated at USD 13 billion in 2019 and expected to grow to USD 23 billion by 2027. Final use is the most important aspect as seaweed has the potential to be a strong sustainable substitute to many existing industrial processes in consumer staples to create more eco-friendly products. This is especially relevant for direct substitute in Agriculture Fertilizers, Animals Feeds, and Bioplastics, whilst Cosmetics and Pharmaceuticals have their own direct needs for seaweed properties. Furthermore, seaweed farms are carbon negative as seaweed acts as a carbon sink. The space is mostly now in a Private Equity / Start-up stage although DuPont (DD US) has a seaweed businessv that can be a listed equity play. The space should, however, stay on any ESG investor’s radar because of its strong economic and environmental potential.

Offshore Wind is one of the big investment opportunities as it has its part to play in the energy transition, expecting to deliver 61 GW of energy by 2025. Moreover, it also has a lot of geopolitical strategical importance as it can help coastal countries strive towards energy independence. Germany, China and the UK are some of the leading country in the matter whilst South Korea just announced the Biggest Offshore Wind Infrastructure plans estimated at USD 43 bn. Ørsted (ORSTED DC) is the poster child in the theme and for the energy transition, having almost completely shifted its oil business to renewables. Vestas Wind (VWS DC) is a second play whilst BP (BP/ LN) just got in the game with a 3 GW project in the Irish Sea.

From an investment universe perspective, and beyond the deep value potential we just covered, Ocean Equities are an investment universe already composed of profitable and rewarding companies.

On a portfolio construction perspective, these different segments and stocks can make a diversified stand-alone allocation with its own risk-return characteristics. The SMS Basket of 29 Ocean Equity Stocks achieved an annualized over-performance of 3.7% to the MSCI World over 5 years, a reduction in annualized volatility of 1.8% and a negative correlation of -2.89%. The space has therefore the potential to deliver performance and diversification to any kind of portfolio when considered together.