Biodiversity is increasingly becoming a hot topic for investors as COP 15, dedicated to biodiversity (COP 27 is on climate change), gathers in Montréal next month (Montréal being our hometown, please come and meet with our team either in situ at the COP 15 convention center or at our neighboring office!). As with other environmental issues, financial market participants have been quick to jump on the bandwagon and associate themselves to the preservation of biodiversity – often in doubtful ways, alas –  and many asset managers now promise “protection of biodiversity” as a key objective of some of their impact/ESG portfolios.

Given the complexity in measuring what biodiversity means and what indicators should be used by those who wish to preserve it, we felt it important to circle out what investors can expect to achieve by trading companies who have a positive/negative impact on our natural world. Today’s note builds on our last notes covering biodiversity (“Valuing the Invaluable”, March 31, 2022) and nature-based solutions (“Nature Always Wins”, June 16, 2022).

Three Issues with Investing in Biodiversity

There are three main issues in grappling with the concept of biodiversity as investors. First, the capitalistic nature of investing – itself predicated on the use of natural and human resources to produce goods and services – makes it hard to claim that investors can protect biodiversity through their portfolios. After all, the notion that investors invest in anticipation of future growth appears in contradiction with the preservation of biodiversity and natural capital.

This is probably why many investors look at biodiversity from the private assets side – some of them even use blended finance vehicles to compensate for the insufficient financial return associated with many investments under the “biodiversity” theme. Indeed, it remains unclear how an investor who would want to protect a tract of land and/or reforest it could one day recoup her investment, let alone make a profit out of it. That said, investors can perhaps have a greater impact by investing in nature-related markets that create incentives to protect nature, such as the still nascent – and messy – voluntary and/or regulated carbon market.

Second, in the absence of a “market” for biodiversity, the current economic framework can hardly reward investors seeking commercial returns by investing in the protection of natural capital. In our view, those who look to preserve biodiversity could find some inspiration by looking at the regulatory framework which was put in place in global carbon markets. These regulations have enabled some significant investments in climate finance related projects and explain why the global market for climate finance has been expanding rapidly while the market for biodiversity still remains in its infancy.

The third issue is that biodiversity-related disclosures from companies remain extremely difficult to assess (and audit) to see if the former are actually delivering on their promise to protect the ambient world. Like with many other ESG data points, these policies are mostly unaudited and hardly comparable between listed companies. It remains even more difficult harder to assess which KPIs have been met against the set of biodiversity KPIs that are disclosed to investors - when applicable at all. However, while we all strive for perfect data disclosed in a timely manner - and that most importantly could move markets in a way that protects nature - we don’t see the upcoming TFND (Taskforce on Nature-related Disclosures) disclosures starting to move markets before the end of this decade, at the very least. In the meantime, investors promising to save biodiversity with their portfolios could rely on (and even fund) third-party NGOs to follow the sectors and companies in which they are invested from a biodiversity protection perspective.

Engagement Ideas: You Can’t Value What You Can’t Price

In the absence of clear and perfect data on biodiversity, investors and/or stock exchanges could survey listed companies and proactively ask if they put an internal price on ecosystem services such as water, air, carbon, solar, biomass, etc. After all, as with many social issues, economists view that putting a price on free resources is the first step in addressing the management of them: you can’t manage what you can’t measure, and you can’t value what you don’t price.

We reviewed a selection of databases which list and attempt to put an economic value on ecosystem services (such as this one). That said, to see where companies could “put a price” on nature, one could look at the various categories of ecosystem services and ask their investee company how they value each of them. Many firms already do this by putting an internal price on carbon, water and other services they currently receive for free as to optimize their management processes and future capex patterns. For our part, we looked at the Ecosystem Services Partnership, an NGO mostly backed by universities, and how they categorized Ecosystem Services. 

Some Good News on Biodiversity for Investors: Growing Adoption & Carbon Markets

The good news is that about half of the companies listed on global stock exchanges already have a biodiversity policy. Unsurprisingly, companies listed on the Eurostoxx 50 are leading the way in the adoption of such policies; while companies listed on the S&P 500 lag their peers. Exchanges should lead the charge in asking for more biodiversity disclosures as regulators will likely take a decade before reaching a consensus on how biodiversity disclosures should be reported.

The second piece of good news is that carbon pricing works. The growing interest for carbon markets makes it increasingly interesting for investors. Indeed, as challenges around pricing the concepts of natural capital and biodiversity are likely to remain for the foreseeable future, the best bet for investors is to rely on these voluntary markets. The voluntary carbon market is growing in a profitable way while at the same putting the right incentives in place to preserve natural capital. To this end, a recent study by Ecosystem Marketplace, which is part of the Forest Trends initiative NGO, looked at the trading volume in global voluntary carbon markets and found that, with the exception of agriculture, all subsectors have seen both their volume of transaction and price increase between 2020 and 2021. Some attempts have been made to value ecosystem services by the global economic sector, but their methodologies remain choppy and can hardly be used to inform any investment decision at this point.

The Value of Nature – the Case of NYC's Catskills/Delaware Watershed

Finally, one of the first - and finest - examples of the “value” of ecosystem services comes from New York city’s decision to preserve the Catskill watershed in the early 20th century. A system of naturally filtered reservoirs about 100 miles north of the city, the Catskill watershed supplies 9 million New Yorkers with some of the best water in the United States. Studies have estimated that this “free” water system saves about USD 10 billion (about 0.3% of GDP of NYC) a year for taxpayers and encourages NYC officials to invest in ecosystem preservation. Here again, NYC taxpayers are protecting their watershed because there is a market for the ecosystem services they receive – in this case clean water.

2022 has been marked with enormous volatility and uncertainty around energy prices of all kinds. The wood pellet industry has been no exception, with the price of pellets increasing in Europe three-fold in the past year.

From an opportunity perspective, it is not hard to see why investing in wood pellet companies is compelling. The desire for Europe to eliminate its dependence on Russian oil and gas means that energy consumers of all kinds are scrambling to find substitutes. Wood pellets fit this bill, since in many cases the cost of swapping out natural gas or coal for wood pellets is nil and/or very low.

But the outlook for the wood pellet industry, also known as , faces even greater uncertainty than other fuel sources due to its ambiguous status as a renewable energy. Indeed, energy sources tend to fall into one of two categories: dirty (discouraged from being part of the future) or clean (encouraged to be part of the future). Coal and petroleum fall into the first, whereas solar, wind, hydrogen, fall into the latter. The role of forestry biomass, however, remains disputed for the reasons discussed below.

In the Eyes of the Law

There is a long-held notion that wood is renewable because trees can be regrown. Ergo using forest products can be considered a renewable energy source. Under the 1992 Kyoto Protocol, harvesting forests to make wood pellets, which are then burned in converted coal-fired power plants, was classified as a renewable energy activity. In addition, under Kyoto rules, which were then grandfathered into the Paris Agreement, using wood pellets for electric power is considered a carbon-neutral energy source — as long as companies replant trees. The European Union – which is the largest consumer of wood products as energy – has taken the same stance: forestry biomass is included as a renewable energy. Importantly, it is widely acknowledged that the EU will NOT achieve its aggressive target of cutting emissions by 55% by 2030 without embracing biomass as a zero-carbon energy source.  

The problem is that the scientific literature contains contrasting findings about the climate effects of forestry biomass:

The key takeaway from the above points is that under strict conditions, forestry biomass may result in an approximately carbon neutral activity. However, the danger is that as market forces (i.e. surging demand relative to supply for renewable energy sources) take hold, there will be ever greater incentive to supply wood pellets and other products faster than forests can sustainably deliver. For this reason, investors that are looking to diversify among renewable energy investments must be very diligent when it comes to the wood pellet industry.

We see two main risks for the wood pellet industry.

Last month, the EU revised its Renewable Energy Directive (RED). The European Parliament voted this week not to declassify woody biomass as renewable energy, acknowledging that the region will not achieve its target of cutting EU carbon emissions by 55% by 2030, without forestry biomass. Forest advocates nonetheless view the ruling as a minor win, since the requirements for the sustainability of biomass were significantly increased. This is raising awareness; the topic will be up for vote again in three years, giving investors in this space a short runway before the regulatory backdrop risk will once again re-surface.

Forestry Biomass the Wrong Way

The world’s largest producer of wood pellets, Enviva, is also the producer that is most shrouded in controversy. Enviva is a U.S. publicly traded corporation that sells most of its wood pellets to customers in the United Kingdom, the European Union, and Japan. The company believes it is helping to “accelerate the energy transition and to decarbonize hard-to-abate sectors like steel, cement, lime, chemicals, and aviation fuels.”  However, sustainability investors have long had this company on their “naughty list”. Most recently, activist investor Blue Orca Capital has publicly stated that Enviva is “engaged in textbook greenwashing” and that, “Satellite imagery indicates that contrary to the company's claims, in many instances Enviva is procuring wood from the widely condemned practice of clear-cutting.”

The SEC was solicited multiple times by various stakeholders including investors to issue guidance on how companies should disclose information about activities in the forest biomass industry. As early as 2013, a report was delivered to the SEC regarding omissions and misrepresentations by Enviva and the company has been regularly cited since for giving false information about greenhouse gas emissions in this industry.

Forestry Biomass the Right Way

One major difference between Enviva and the companies that are considered sustainable leaders in the wood pellet industry is their place in the supply chain. It is important to note that Enviva does not own forests, rather it sources raw materials through suppliers who purchase wood from working forests, sawmills and manufacturers. In other words, the company does not have direct oversight of the forests involved in its wood supply; it does not control its supply chain. On the other end of the spectrum, a company like Svenska Cellulosa Aktiebolaget (SCA), which is the largest forest owner in Europe, sources its wood fibres from its own land. As an integrated industrial business, they aim to maximize the possible value in the forest and from the forest.

As a result, wood pellets are only a small fraction of SCA’s business. In 2021, SCA produced 11.7 TWh of bioenergy, with the vast majority (9.2 TWh) used in its own plants. Of the 2.5 TWh delivered to external customers, less than half consisted of wood pellets, while the rest was unprocessed biofuels (i.e. bark, sawdust and by-products from harvesting). SCA’s production capacity at fully or partially owned plants is 300,000 tonnes of pellets per year and represents only a small fraction of SCA’s total revenues.

Recent economic turmoil makes it harder to find assets with positive near-term growth prospects. Earlier this year, we looked at health care to find impactful defensive companies (see our note “High Impact: Surviving a Recession With Care”, June 02, 2022). Such defensive names are interesting for investors looking to protect their portfolio. Today, we expand that work to look for defensive companies that should do relatively well once the interest rate shock has passed. Water and electricity utilities have high interest-rate sensitivity and while they generally perform poorly in the most acute period of interest rate increases, we believe this acute phase of interest rates increases is nearing its end, which presents a buying opportunity for these utility companies. Below is a graphical display of the Utilities sector when the Federal Reserve is increasing rates (grey zone).

The utilities sector has existed for centuries and provides essential services. It is also often monopolistic, can be affected by weather and geopolitical events, and its prices are capped by regulatory agencies in many countries. This note addresses these issues, searching for the best plays amongst these challenges.

Water

Water utilities are a good starting point. These companies ensure a reliable supply of clean water to communities and ecosystems and contribute to general resilience of agriculture, energy, and manufacturing. In other words, the water sector is critical to public health and the economy.

The sector, however, faces increasing risks from climate change, including more droughts as shown across the world over the summer of 2022, as well as ageing infrastructure. California is one example: as seen in the graph below, the state has been in a complete state of drought from October 2021 to October 2022, and over half of the past 10 years have seen an average drought of 98% or more. California is an extreme case but more regions are following in its footsteps. Higher global temperatures are forecasted to bring more rain but the distribution in time and space is increasingly uneven. This will create further pressure on water utilities that will have to deal with not enough water, and then suddenly, too much rain.

Droughts can result in significant operational issues for water utilities, including supply loss and poor water quality. Consequently, building drought resilience is critical for water utilities.

To assess water investment plays, we developed a methodology that takes into account the ability of a utility to respond to water threats, withstand impacts from droughts, and quickly recover when they occur, as well as financial and sustainability criteria:

  1. The water utility universe consists of developed-market companies with a market capitalization of over US$1 billion selected from the pool of companies from Refinitiv Eikon tagged as “Utilities” and tagged “Water Utilities” in the SASB Materiality Index.   
  2. To account for resiliency, we looked at water efficiency policies and targets for water efficiency.
  3. We then screened for ESG practices (through controversies and CSRHub scores) and financial stability (through pertinent financial ratios).

We find that Aguas Andinas, Veolia and American Water Works all have superior characteristics due to their drought monitoring and forecasting systems, underscoring their preparedness to potential climate threats.

Electricity

The electricity market can be even more complex. In the EU energy system, the wholesale electricity price is set by the last power plant needed to meet overall demand. Wind farms, nuclear, coal and gas plants and all other generators bid into the power market, with the cheapest sources coming in first, followed by pricier sources like gas. This has led to a surge in prices since the beginning of the war in Ukraine, and high gas prices for this coming winter raise the potential for protests and social unrest (Czech Republic is already seeing them).

European governments are trying to head off that risk with caps on the electricity rates for residents. Those price caps will leave governments on the hook for making up the difference likely leading to huge spending deficits (as these actions could cost billions) and/or force them to nationalize utilities as a way to bail them out (such as the case of EDF In France). Leaders hope to minimize deficits by heavily taxing energy companies, while demanding more production from them. Electric utilities in regulated markets could also be negatively impacted as the government shares in the pain of its subsidies. Indeed, many electric utilities had to be bailed out by their governments due to the recent increases in natural gas prices. Electric utilities with significant state ownership were already the ones mainly dependent on fossil fuels and natural gas, while utilities without government ownership generate much more of their electricity from renewables, as shown in the graph below. This gap will accentuate with bailouts. European governments now face a conundrum where they want to reduce carbon emissions but directly own large percentages of those same heavy emitters.

Electric utilities that have gone through this period of heightened volatility without government support fall into three categories: the naturally more resilient, the better risk manager and the fortunate enough (i.e. those that did not sell too much electricity forward at lower prices).

In order to find the best investment plays in electrical utilities (meaning the most resilient and best risk managers), we used a similar approach to water, but this time looked for “Electric Utilities” in the SASB Materiality Index and assessed resiliency through the percentage of energy supply coming from renewables.

The characteristics of the selected companies are presented in the table below:

We expect these companies, which are independent from conventional energy and also have strong financial ratios, to outperform.  

Current conventional farming practices have farmers stuck in a loop, hooked on products from the major agri-science companies. Once a boon to crop yields, overuse of chemical products like fertilizers, herbicides and pesticides, have led to degradation of the growing environments. To break free from this problem is no easy task. Switching to more environmentally friendly methods will not happen overnight and it can take years for crop yields to return to previous levels as the soil readjusts. At the same time, as pressure from climate change continues, the failure to break old habits will also hurt production. Given this conundrum, we investigate companies offering products that can help farmers optimize their crop yields while transitioning to more sustainable practices. These options include genetically modified (GM) seeds (though controversial, and not for the reasons one might think); the use of biologicals (products derived from naturally occurring matter), and ag-tech that help farmers use less input by being selective and precise about application.

Designer Drugs: Genetically Modified Seeds

Genetically modified (GM) crops are crops whose genetic material has been altered to achieve certain characteristics. This is also known as genetic engineering. Genetically modified crops have existed since the 1990s and are now prevalent in the food chain. Their progression has been controversial; concerns include impacts on health and the environment and the appropriateness of intellectual property rights on plants. However, there is little scientific support for health issues attributed to eating GM foods. Afterall, the process of genetic modification stands on thousands of years of cultivators selectively breeding plants to achieve specific traits like flavor and color. The bigger issue is how a handful of large companies have come to dominate the seed industry at the expense of farmers and the environment. This seed cartel, consisting of Corteva, Bayer, ChemChina and BASF, owns over 60% of the world’s seeds.

Evolution of seed industry 1990s to 2018

Each dot was its own seed company in the 1990s, now acquired by Bayer, Corteva, ChemChina or BASF.

Source: NY Times

These companies could develop seeds that are genetically engineered to be resistant to drought or other impacts from climate change and certainly have the R&D budgets to do so. Syngenta (now owned by ChemChina) and Bioceres have shown some progress. Unfortunately, much of the focus has been on making crops better able to withstand heavy use of herbicides and pesticides, products which these companies also sell. This business model encourages the sale of more chemicals which can be sprayed indiscriminately on resistant crops and makes farmers dependent on these companies for both seeds and crop protection. This is where environmental concerns come into play; heavy use of herbicides and pesticides is linked to water pollution, soil degradation and biodiversity loss. The use of patents also gives companies strict control over the use of their seeds and reinforces the dependency on these suppliers, removing power from smaller farmers. When looking for companies in the seed space, investors should assess the potential for conflict of interest between revenue sources; whether the seeds are engineered for climate resilience or recommended in conjunction with traditional pest and weed controls. We find that seed-producer KWS meets the mark for these criteria. The company operates in the seed segment and has clear ambitions to breed varieties aimed at lowering agricultural inputs; they also have an admirable stance on patents, favoring protection for innovative breeding but drawing the line at monopolistic inclinations.

Intervention

Engineering seeds to be more tolerant to a changing climate, as discussed above, can prop up yields temporarily, but this solution lacks staying power for the following reasons. First, ignoring the drawbacks from current farming methods will lead to further degradation of the environment. Second, it will potentially leave farmers reliant on several iterations of genetic modifications. Third, it is not clear that it will always be scientifically feasible. Rather than forcing plants to adapt to unhealthy environments, a more sure-fire tactic is to rebuild healthy fields to achieve long-term sustainability. As we discussed in our note Dirt Cheap (March 24, 2022), prioritizing soil supports both healthy plants and carbon sequestration (the latter is at the root of climate change). Healthier soil is also more resilient to both a lack and excess of water. Swapping out chemical fertilizers, pest and weed control for biological products can help achieve these benefits.

For public equity investors, it is challenging to find pure-plays in the biological space. Most of the big producers of herbicides and insecticides offer both synthetic and natural products but failure to offer more sustainable products will leave agriscience companies at risk of failing behind. A report released at Climate Week finds agricultural input companies could lose 26% of their value by 2030 as the agricultural system is transformed. To account for these risks, investors should focus on companies with strong commitments to expanding biologicals as demonstrated through clear targets on the share of new products or share of revenues. FMC Corp launched 10 products in 2022 and are applying to test more than 30 additional products. Importantly, there is increasing demand for biologicals: from 2010 to 2020 the global land area dedicated to organic farming has doubled, and consumer global demand for organic products shows 8% annualized growth over the last 5 years. Additionally, the European commission’s Farm to Fork strategy (announced in May 2020) should provide a tailwind for safer products. Objectives of this initiative include reducing the use of chemical pesticides by 50% and achieving 25% of total farmland dedicated to organic agriculture by 2030. To be sure, a switch to organic farming cannot happen overnight (a repeat of Sri Lanka’s dilemma is to be avoided), but a shift to soil prioritization is imminent.

 

 

Weaning off the System

Every farm is its own different ecosystem, which makes it difficult to put in place a “one size fits all” approach to crop management. Introducing data analytics technology into farming enables agriculturalists to better understand and care for each component of their ecosystem. Equipped with detailed information, farmers can be selective with their resources: watering what is thirsty, fertilizing where there is a lack of nutrients and managing weeds and pests as needed. This facilitates the transition to more sustainable methods as farmers can do more with less.

Tools that support this are becoming more accessible. Deere (DE US) is a clear leader in this space. The company has made it easier for farmers to adopt digital management tools by offering technologies that can be retrofitted to existing machinery, meaning cash strapped farmers do not need to make daunting investments to replace their entire fleet. Connected devices leverage data analytics to very specifically inform farmers on what their crops need. This supports resource optimization and is a complementary with precision agriculture tools. The John Deere Operations Centre (a digital farm management platform with data collection and analytics) tracks more than 315 million acres globally with a goal of reaching 500 million acres (equivalent to more than half of all U.S. acreage) by 2026, and to have 75% of these acres engaged in sustainable practices by 2030. The company is ahead of its competitors, although some smaller agriculture-oriented companies are making great strides: AGCO currently has 80% of retailed products offering connectivity, with an objective to reach 100% by 2025. CNH Industrial lags slightly behind; they have focused innovation on automation and some precision agriculture but intend to improve connectivity solutions which appear fragmented.

Much like the first three quarters of 2022, we expect that energy markets and central bank policy rate expectations will be the main factors affecting macro sustainability portfolios until year end. These factors are especially relevant for SMS’s Energy Transition, Protecting Natural Capital and Leave No Person Behind themes. In terms of policy developments, now that the Inflation Reduction Act and the CHIPs and Science Act have been signed into law (both of which will have significant long-term global implications for climate change and supply chains) we believe that the COP15 on biodiversity in December may be the next important development in policy/global accords for sustainable investment portfolios.

Below, we detail how these three factors – central bank policy, COP15, and energy supply – are likely to play out in relation to key sustainability investment themes in the months ahead.

 

1  Central banks’ reaction to inflation will continue to drive equity style and sector biases.

Our base case is that there is considerable cyclical and structural inflationary pressure in the global economy and inflation prints will continue to dictate the direction of financial market price movements until at least the end of the year. To combat inflation, bond yields will need to continue to rise until substantial economic pain is triggered. Indeed, researchers at the IMF estimate that the unemployment rate may need to reach as high as 7.5% (double today’s rate) to end the inflation outbreak in the U.S.  

In this environment, broad equity indexes will struggle to deliver gains because interest rate sensitive sectors like tech will stagnate. Looking further out, the next phase of equity market developments will entail both falling bond yields and lower stock prices, i.e. the phase in which market participants price in recession.

Although few indicators are heralding imminent recession (the inverted yield curve is the exception), we continue to position for this eventuality, given the likely steady march upwards in interest rates to combat inflation.

We are maintaining our tilt toward sustainable companies within defensive sectors and value-oriented stocks. Our “social” theme – Leave No Person Beyond – is chock full of health care companies that we believe can leverage productivity growth to provide diagnostics, medication, products for wellbeing and patient care services that will contribute to improving healthcare access.

Other defensive areas of the stock market that have proven to stand up well to inflation pressures are grocery stores, albeit investors need to discriminate between ESG leaders and laggards in this space: several grocery chains have been accused of price gouging during the current ballooning of food prices. We focus on grocers that can sustain profit margins while providing products at reasonable prices – Carrefour (CA.PAR) recently announced a price freeze on 100 essential products – and whose customers are likely to be stickier given their product offering - Sprouts Farmers’ Market (SFM) is one such name.

2  From IRA to Chips To…Biodiversity?

From a policy and regulatory perspective, by far the most significant developments in the past quarter were the passing into law of two key pieces of U.S. legislation: the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) and the U.S. CHIPS and Science Act. There has already been much dissection about the environmental and social impact of IRA. Less covered by the press, the passing for the CHIPs act emboldens our view that re-shoring of key industries will occur. The strategic U.S. goal is to ensure that critical resources are available; supply chains will be shorter, simpler and to the extent possible, domestically controlled. But an important corollary is that re-shoring can also be a major win for the environment: when “dirty” industries move to jurisdictions with tighter environmental regulations, the overall global output of pollution/emissions drops. The table below summarizes the impact of the two laws with respect to SMS’ themes. Note that government funds allocated to these two acts will be deployed over the next several years, thus we view them as critical long-term support to our themes.

In the shorter term, one possible catalyst for our “protecting natural capital” theme is the 15th Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity (COP15) to be held in Montreal in December. The summit will finalize a global biodiversity conservation framework for 2020-2050 and the meeting is to biodiversity what the Paris Agreement is to climate change. The expected outcome is articulated global targets to preserve and protect 30% of land and sea by 2030, however, just like for climate change, any resultant accords will not be legally binding. Nonetheless, we view this as an important opportunity to educate and sensitize investors - and the public at large - to the fact that environmental challenges are far broader than simply GHG emissions.

If this opportunity is seized, one investment idea that will receive a supplementary tailwind is nature-based solutions and, especially given the inflationary context, sustainable forest companies. Moreover, forests are important natural carbon sinks, and in the rush for companies to put forward net zero carbon plans, trees are a basic, existing technology that can help companies reach net zero. Holmen (HOLM-B) and Svenska Cellulosa (SCA-B) are two Swedish forest companies that featured in our top 2022 sustainable stock picks report last January: both companies have had a flat performance so far this year (i.e. have outperformed relative to broad equity indices). Renewed investor interest in natural capital plays amid the strong inflationary backdrop will provide an ongoing tailwind.

3.  Energy shortages and uncertainty remain.

 Uncertainty around the supply of energy – and the fiscal response to this – will continue to dictate the direction of oil prices, renewable and non-renewable energy stocks, and related investments that are sensitive to oil price movements, such as industrial stocks.

In recent days, Ukraine has managed to push back Russian forces. However, it is premature to forecast an end to the war and it is even more premature to forecast an end to high and volatile energy prices. Our high conviction view is that national energy security issues have sped up the transition to renewable energy production and we are long-term bulls on all alternative energy, including nuclear.

In the more immediate term, however, energy efficiency plays have the most potential to outperform. In an era where all types of energy are in short supply, solutions to conserve energy are increasingly popular and will lend themselves better to a more challenging economic growth backdrop: certainly in the building sector where construction activity is already beginning to slow, projects that upgrade existing infrastructure for energy - and financial - savings are most likely. Retrofitting includes improving heating and cooling systems (the market for heat pumps is set to explode higher, see chart below), replacing windows and doors, improving insulation, as well as water systems. Companies with superior ESG credentials and also comparatively low equity multiples include Owens Corning, Carrier and Kingspan.

 

 

Water risks are increasingly discussed among the investment community amidst warming weather patterns and the growing frequency of droughts and water shortages. Most of these risks are directly material to almost any investment’s bottom line.

These risks are the usual suspects of climate change: increased severity of droughts, floods, wildfires, storms, sea-level rise and loss of freshwater reserves. They all imply either an excess or lack of water in any given place, affecting the water supply in local economies. Moreover, while carbon emissions are only material through regulatory and reputational mechanisms, water risks are physically material to the bottom line of almost all industries. The following materiality matrix from the World Resources Institute shows precisely how the 13 water risks it measures are relevant to all sectors of the economy in one way or another (on scale of 0 to 4, see the table below).

This is not difficult to grasp once one realises that all industries are using water as one of their main factors of production; most of them not even knowing it. Indeed, one needs water to grow food, produce cement, clothes, medicine, mining metals and to produce any kind of energy. All of these industries have developed business models that implicitly rely on a steady, secure and free supply of water.

The abundant supply of water is now being challenged by climate change and is creating various financial risks for businesses and their supply chains that investors need to understand:

Operational Risks: The most straightforward type of climate/water risk is simply if a business no longer has the necessary water to generate its own production. This is for example the case for a hydropower plant in California serving 750,000 homes that had to be shut down because there was no longer enough water in the river to run its turbines, following the aridification of the Californian landscape. The same applies this year to the Hoover Dam and Lake Mead with its historically low water levels.

Profitability Risks: Another straightforward risk businesses face from climate change are the increasing costs for adapting to abrupt changes in local water supply. This was, for example, the case for Taiwan Semi-Conductor Manufacturers whose water allowance was reduced by 15% by the government following an historic drought in the island. The company had to resort to shipping water by trucks every day from the other side of the island, a very costly solution. The change in the water supply and its costs inevitably affect business models and their economics through their margins and profitability.

Competitive or Transition Risks: Indirect but consequent types of risk due to climate change are Competitive or Transition Risks. These are the risks derived from failing to make the investments necessary to adapt. For example, businesses that have invested in resilient infrastructure to face increasing natural risks will be better prepared than those that did not. The same logic goes for companies that have invested in circular water management solutions for their factories and will therefore be less sensitive to change in the local water supply; as well as having reduced operational costs and improved margins. These companies will have a strong competitive edge, which will also be reinforced by market mechanisms and increasing green regulations. Financial markets participants will create the same discriminatory effect by screening between the companies that are fit enough to survive climate change.

Systemic Risks: A good example to illustrate systemic risk is the collapse of the energy and water systems in Texas during the last deep freeze in February 2021. Because of an ailing jet stream that could no longer contain arctic weather in the arctic, the state of Texas faced some polar weather for a month which froze most of its gas and water infrastructure. This left some parts of the state without running water and electricity for weeks and cost the Texan economy between $80-130 billion in direct and indirect economic losses. This included damage to homes and businesses, cleaning costs for contaminated water and foregone economic activity. This example shows how modern economies are dependent on a secured supply of water, and when threatened, creates systemic risks across the economy.

Inflation Risks: Little discussed is the inflation risk water scarcity is likely to bring. Water scarcity in many regions of the world will inevitably lead to an increase in its price. This has the potential to spread throughout supply chains and to consumers, and lead to sustained inflation throughout the economy. This is also valid for the other side of the water quantity spectrum, where too much water in the forms of floods, storms and intense rainfalls will increase asset erosion and repair costs. These are likely to be new structural pricing effects in the economy that will become new long-term risks for investors.

As the examples above show, many of these risks have already started to materialise in the economy and the probability is rising that water problems become greater over time. That said, hedging portfolios against the growing water risks remains a difficult task. While several ETFs and water “indices” have been created, we feel that they still poorly capture the true “water risk” embedded in the corporate world. To this end, we see three ways to measure water risks for investors.

The first way to evaluate this risk is to look at water usage per million dollars of revenue for companies in each sector, which points us to some of the companies with the highest “water hazard” embedded in their business models.

Second, the WWF Water Risk Filter gives a comprehensive water risks assessment of any global asset that is entered into its database. This tool can then be used as part of an engagement strategy whereby investors can request water-vulnerable companies to take a water-risk assessment, monitor their water vulnerability and eventually incentivize companies to invest in new water innovations to hedge against these risks.

Third, CDP is also emerging as one of the leading data providers for water metrics. It has designed an extensive questionnaire for 10 years on water awareness, exposure, management and stewardship of companies. This effectively evaluates the level of water responsibility for all companies globally and their readiness to face new climate risks. CDP Water ratings (A-F) can therefore be used to screen water risks across portfolios, for example, by only retaining water leaders that have scored an “A”. This water screen can be added to a carbon screening methodology to add adaptation risks to an existing sustainable investment strategy or risk management strategy.

As the consequences of climate change become more evident – drought, flooding, fires, hurricanes, etc. – the rallying call is growing louder to not only protect nature and natural ecosystems, but also to collaborate with nature. From an investment perspective, there is still plenty of room on this bandwagon; according to some calculations, the financing gap for nature is estimated at USD 700 billion.

In today’s Note, we provide a brief overview of the nomenclature of solutions stemming from nature, we pinpoint the most promising, and characterize the state of investment in these opportunities.

Nature and Its Solutions: The Landscape

Nature-based solutions (NbS) – the notion of working with nature to address societal challenges – has recently gained momentum as an integrated approach that could address the twin crises of climate change and biodiversity loss. Even with this definition in hand though, it is often unclear what the potential investment opportunities are. To start, we provide definitions of key terms in the table below to help guide investors. 

Nature derived solutions are already well understood by investors; renewable energy has existed for decades and is already an important share of the total global energy mix. Meanwhile, nature inspired solutions, such as artificially synthesized spider silk as a textile, or harvesting wave energy with kelp motion, do not necessarily tackle climate change and biodiversity loss. Therefore, this report focuses on Nature-based Solutions and the opportunities for investors.

Nature-based Solutions

A defining feature of NbS is that this approach to addressing climate change and biodiversity loss relies on functioning ecosystems. Thus, the goal is to protect and restore natural capital so that nature can function properly and provide the ecosystem services that people and businesses depend on.

Investing in Nature-based Solutions is only in its infancy and the chart below shows just how underfunded nature is: although $44 trillion (over half of the world’s GDP) of value is generated in industries that depend highly (US$13 trillion) or moderately (US$31 trillion) on nature and its services, there is a major financing gap for conservation activities.

Moreover, investors have largely ignored NbS as an investment opportunity. As the chart below highlights, of the total financial flows that go toward biodiversity conservation, only 1% are considered NbS.

The private sector has been particularly slow to acknowledge nature’s solutions: as the chart illustrates, not only do NbS attract a far smaller dollar amount of funding relative to climate finance, but the private sector hardly participates. Indeed, the majority of funding for climate change originates with the private sector, whereas funding for Nature-based Solutions is almost exclusively done by the public sector. The scaling up of private capital for nature-based solutions is widely viewed as a central challenge to being on a path to sustainable economic growth.

For investors seeking direct opportunities in NbS, we see two broad categories where impact is highest: forestry and sustainable cities.

Forestry:

Protecting, managing and restoring forests offers roughly two-thirds of the total mitigation potential of all nature-based solutions. Not only are trees, plants and healthy soil an abundant and cost-effective means of removing and storing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, they are also home to insects, birds, animals and a world of microscopic organisms that help to underpin human life. We have previously articulated our top picks for publicly traded forestry companies (please see, Knock on Wood, May 20, 2021 and Investment Trends in 2022: Don’t Put Your ESG In One Basket, January 5, 2022). Beyond investing directly in forestry companies that have superior biodiversity records and goals, one of the other (few) options for investors looking to gain access to NbS in forestry is via carbon credits.

Recall that carbon credit markets function when sellers in the carbon market create carbon credits by reducing their emissions (e.g.  a farmer who adopts sustainable land-use practices). Buyers, often corporations or governments, buy the credit and thus “gain” the right to emit a set amount of carbon dioxide.  For more information, please see our Note, Heros and Zeros: What Investors Need to Know About Carbon Pledging, December 2, 2021.

Although carbon offsets are created and traded based on their climate benefits, many offset projects have positive collateral effects, or “co-benefits,” that may include the protection of forests and biodiversity. The co-benefits associated with forest carbon projects can include protecting watershed areas that supply clean water, safeguarding critical habitat for biodiversity, and providing important social benefits.

For now, most carbon offsets are largely focused on the accounting for greenhouse gas reductions or carbon sequestration and do not consider measures for protecting biodiversity. However, last month the NYSE launched the first Nature-Based Solutions carbon credit futures contract. This follows the launch of a similar product by the CME last year. We view this as solid evidence that there is at least tentative buy-in by financial actors of the role of nature-based solutions; tracking this market for liquidity and volume will provide an important bellwether regarding investor interest in nature-based solutions.

Sustainable Cities:

Urban resilience challenges are going to multiply as climate change will increase the frequency and intensity of natural hazards. In the past, structural interventions to reduce disaster risk and build climate resilience in urban settings have largely focused on gray infrastructure. Gray infrastructure refers to built structures and mechanical equipment, such as reservoirs, embankments, pipes, pumps, water treatment plants, canals, etc. The problem with these engineered solutions is that they are often less suitable to withstand more frequent and intense weather events, i.e. are less effective and resilient against extreme weather.

The figure below gives examples of Nature-based Solutions in an urban context.

Diversity of Nature-based Solutions for Urban Application

Source: Global Program on Nature-based Solutions for Climate Resilience

Equity investors can gain access to some of these solutions by being on the lookout for building and/or engineering companies that specialize in nature-based solutions. For example, we have highlighted in past research Arcadis (ARCAD NA), which is a Dutch firm that designs “sponge cities”, which are cities that are designed with sustainable features such as permeable pavements, small water storage facilities, public green spaces that absorb storm water, etc.

Another urban solution is green & cool roofs, whereby soil and vegetation function as living insulation, which moderates building temperatures year-round and reduces the need for energy used in heating and air-conditioning. The global green roof market size was valued at USD 1.1 billion in 2019 and is expected to grow at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 17% from 2020 to 2027. No wonder there is an increasing number of companies specializing in the design and installation of green roofs. ZinCo GmbH, Bauder Ltd., Green Roof Blocks, SOPREMA Group, XeroFlor, Bender GmbH & Co. KG, Green Roof Technology, Sempergreen, Axter Limited, and Optigreen International AG are among the larger players, although none have yet to go public.

Finally, companies that specialize in coastal remediation and protection stabilize shorelines by reducing wave intensity and to protect coasts from erosion. In contrast to concrete-based solutions, NbS can grow with sea-level rise or, if necessary, can be more easily adapted. Great Lakes Dredge & Dock (GLDD US) is an American-based company that undertakes projects all over the world, with 100% of revenue derived from dredging, coastal remediation, and marine construction.

There are several long- and medium-term factors that imply that capital expenditures will be stepped up significantly in the years ahead. Climate change has led to net zero commitments from both the private and public sectors; in many cases, fulfilling these commitments will require new or retrofitted physical structures. Meanwhile, geopolitics are driving re-shoring or friend-shoring of supply chains which will necessitate investment in new facilities to run these operations closer to home. Also, an ageing population with low fertility rates is creating labor shortages which entice capital investments to substitute workers by machines. On top, public infrastructure programs in developed countries are determined to replace old infrastructure. Those are all factors pointing toward further construction spending.

Indeed, it is estimated that by 2060, the global total floor area of buildings will double. This massive construction boom will have significant environmental implications. As it stands, the construction industry is responsible for about 10% of global energy-related greenhouse-gas emissions, and this is primarily due to the materials used, namely minerals (dominated by cement), metals (steel), and a range of petrochemical-based and rubber materials. Therefore, the construction and building sector will need to undergo important changes if we are to avoid the worst of climate change.

Fortunately, there are numerous solutions that can contribute to reducing emissions related to building and construction. Researchers at the University of Leeds have analysed the potential emissions reduction of various solutions under different scenarios. The table below describes the potential solutions to reduce emissions.

The following table details how building emissions can be reduced by nearly one half. The progressive scenario presents expected emissions reductions based on the application of currently available technology coupled with progressive changes in consumer choice. The ambitious scenario presents additional reductions based on widespread application of technology that is currently in development and extensive changes in consumer choice.

Of these five (partial) solutions, the two with strong opportunities for investors include material switching and low-carbon cement, since these two solutions are likely to create capital allocations toward the materials in higher demand and in companies that can effectively produce low carbon cement. Sustainable Market Strategies addressed the opportunities for low-carbon cement in a note last year, “Cement and steel: the last mile of decarbonization”, March 25, 2021. Thus, in today’s note, we explore the trade-offs between steel and timber and analyze opportunities and risks in both markets.

Strong as Steel:

The Good:

Steel as a building material has several advantages including strength, safety, reliability, design adaptability, quality and speed of construction. Moreover, from an environmental perspective – and contrary to other building materials - steel is 100% recyclable. The table below shows the end-of-life scenarios for concrete, timber and steel. Only 1% of steel ends up in landfill, while 99% is either recycled or re-used. These rates beat other building materials by a significant margin.

In addition, as we face an increasing number of extreme weather events, steel is well adapted to withstand the ravages of climate change: steel structures perform well during earthquakes and other extreme weather events and are a non-combustible material that does not contribute to the spread of fire.

The Bad:

The primary disadvantage is that the steel industry is responsible for 7% of energy-related global greenhouse gas emissions, which is mainly because steel production is an energy intensive process: it requires high temperatures to transform iron ore into steel and the energy currently being used is primarily coal and/or other fossil fuels.

It is difficult to envision a future without material amounts of steel being used in construction. Indeed, steel will also be an important material for the energy transition, since solar panels and wind turbines depend on steel as an input. The IEA predicts that global demand for steel will increase by more than a third through to 2050.

Knock on Wood:

The Good:

Wood is fast and simple to build with and it is biodegradable and regenerative. It captures carbon, is a good insulator, absorbs sound, has good electrical resistance and tensile strength. It also uses less energy, creates less wastewater and has less toxic emissions than steel. Moreover, buildings made of wood are known to foster more comfortable and healthier environments.

The Bad:

Wood is not perfect. It burns, rots and lacks the engineering strength of steel. In regions where the energy required to produce steel and cement comes from relatively clean sources, it is unclear whether wood is less polluting: when the analysis considers a life-cycle assessment that accounts for soil disturbance caused by logging and incomplete recovery of the forest through time.

The Future Must Be Green (Wood and Steel)

Advances in science have created new processes to reduce the negative effects of steel such as CO2 emissions. In the same fashion, scientific progress is reducing the negative attributes of wood like flammability and engineering strength. As a result, we expect low emission steel production to ramp up and engineered wood to be a growing industry.

The solution to dirty steel in the construction industry will include not only material switching away from steel, but also energy switching within the steel industry.

According to the IEA, to meet global energy and climate goals, emissions from the steel industry must fall by at least 50% by 2050. About 40% of this reduction can come from material efficiency (i.e. using less steel), but the rest will need to occur by reducing the average direct CO2 emission intensity of steel production. In other words, new steelmaking processes are critical, and there is not one technology that will be the right answer. The chart below shows which strategies are likely to account for emission reductions until 2050: together, hydrogen, carbon capture, use and storage (CCUS), bioenergy and direct electrification are all potential avenues that can achieve 60% of the necessary emission reductions. Investors should focus on companies that are developing these innovation solutions. Steel production with renewable electricity and green hydrogen has already started, and zero-emission steel plants are scheduled to begin operations in less than 5 years.

Meanwhile, the potential for forestry to reduce emissions by replacing some steel usage is significant. Innovation on biofuels as renewable energy sources and advanced biomaterials used for long-lived constructions such as cross-laminated timber, laminated veneer lumber and Glulam beams are promising. This could reduce emissions for wood as a construction material and expand its construction spectrum to bigger projects previously reserved for steel because of the decreased flammability and greater strength of engineered wood.

Companies That Are Leading the Way  

The analysis above highlights that the construction industry will need to draw upon various strategies to tackle its GHG emission challenge. Material switching toward timber is a partial solution but steel will remain a critical building material. For these reasons, we recommend that investors focus on a basket of “green material companies” that are proving to be environmental innovators.

In the steel sector, we note that the Swedish firm SSAB owns an important stake of Hybrit, which produces steel with renewable electricity and green hydrogen. Voestalpine is an Austrian publicly traded company transitioning to steel using hydrogen, while ArcelorMittal has invested heavily in its Setao plant that will be the world’s first full-scale zero carbon-emissions steel plant, beginning production in 2025.

Meanwhile, for wood-based biomaterials, Stora Enso and Mayr Melnhof Holz are leaders in Cross-laminated timber (CLT); a lighter-weight material now used as a replacement for cement or steel in large construction projects because it resists to strong racking and compressive force. Boise Cascade is a leader in Glulam Beams that are replacing steel beams.

We constructed an equal-weighted index of these six companies; the chart below shows that the “SMS Green Building Materials” index is near its one-year low.

Interestingly, valuations in these companies are relatively attractive, especially when you consider the growth potential of low-emission steel and engineered wood.

Global warming is progressing unevenly with the Northern hemisphere experiencing more rapid changes. The heat waves in the Pacific Northwest in 2021 and in Siberia in 2020 are just two recent examples.

Pakistan and India have broken numerous heat records for March and April of this year. Indian crop estimates are being reduced; extreme heat is affecting workers and the harvest.

The map below shows that agricultural potential will deteriorate in most places, but it will improve in the North.

A 2020 study published the map below that shows the suitability of different areas in the world to grow new crops in the next 40-60 years. The warming of the North will create harvest opportunities.

Climate Change and Agriculture

The latest IPCC report underscores the many adverse impacts of climate change including the likely effects on agriculture. Greater variability in weather means greater variability in output for farmers.

Below are two maps: the latest Drought Monitor of the United States and the one at the same time last year. We can see that the western portion of the United States is in drought again. Water is becoming a critical issue and states are fighting for it. California is often called the breadbasket of the world; the California Department of Food and Agriculture says it is the world’s fifth-largest supplier of food and agricultural products. This is a problem because the state is in a worsening drought.

Unstable Climate

Ecology is often governed by nonlinear dynamics: systems which respond disproportionately to initial conditions. Nonlinear relationships often include thresholds; incremental changes in drivers that provoke exceptionally large responses. Using historical analysis instead of climate models, researchers found that the threshold for dangerous climate change will be reached between 2027 and 2042 instead of the IPCC’s forecast of 2052. This means the scary window starts in 5 years. There are many events that should occur once every millennium that now happen every year.

Russian Invasion of Ukraine

Russia is likely to see the greatest increase in arable land from climate change over the long term. However, the invasion of Ukraine is bringing greater food uncertainty around the world for the next couple of years. Russia and Ukraine are among the largest exporters of food and fertilizers in the world. But Russia is now a pariah. Disruptions are currently happening for fertilizer exports and are likely to emerge over the summer for the export of their harvests; bulk carriers cannot get insurance on Russian exports, Ukrainian farmers are interrupted and the ports they use to export from are now in a combat zone.

Carbon Sink

To ensure that the world has enough food, we need to examine more places to grow it. On the other hand, we have seen the effects of unscrupulous deforestation on the Amazon. Land use and land cover changes have led to less carbon dioxide uptake in the tropics compared to untapped boreal forests. Thoughtless agriculture in the North could have a similar effect, if we are not careful. An editorial by researchers Adrian Unc, Bartosz Adamczyk and Nils Borchard provides more background on the topic of expanding northward.

Investment Opportunities

Russia and Ukraine are currently not investable. Canada is a very good place to benefit from the long-term trend of improved agriculture in the North. There are interesting investments in public markets like Nutrien, which is a global producer and distributor of fertilizers based in Saskatchewan and Ag Growth, which is a global leader in food infrastructure based in Manitoba. In private markets, there are funds that invest in Canadian farmland; AGinvest, Area One Farms and Bonnefield.

Investors of all stripes are now familiar with climate change as a material risk to their portfolios. Biodiversity is an equally large, but a less understood environmental challenge. It is underappreciated by investors from both the risk and opportunity perspectives. Below, is a series of questions and answers on the most pressing biodiversity concerns for investors.

What are biodiversity and ecosystem services? Why should investors care?

Biodiversity is the variety of natural capital’s living components (for example, species and habitats). Biodiversity ensures the resilience of natural capital assets and secures them for the future. In other words, biodiversity is for nature what portfolio diversification is to investors: just as asset managers reduce the risk of negative tail outcomes by holding assets with a variety of financial characteristics, natural capital requires diverse species and habitats to thrive.

Ecosystem services is a term used to describe the outputs, conditions, or processes of natural systems that benefit humans. Carbon sequestration by forests is one example of an ecosystem service, but hundreds exist. Importantly, biodiversity loss and ecosystem services go well beyond the agricultural sector and include land, fresh water, oceans and air. Ecosystem services can be recorded in monetary terms, which facilitates understanding of the value that these services represent.

These ecosystem services, which are vital to human survival, exist because there is variety in natural capital, i.e., because Earth is biologically diverse. As biodiversity declines, the ecosystem services that humans rely on also decline.

For investors, biodiversity is important because significant economic rents in the past several decades have been achieved by using the ecosystem’s services without having to pay for them.

Why should investors care now?

Although losses in biodiversity have been recorded for several decades, healthy natural capital (biodiversity) was so sufficiently abundant that economic actors of all types (governments, consumers, corporates) could take the services that ecosystems provide for granted. The situation has changed drastically: according to the WWF and the Living Planet index, there has been a 68% average loss in animal population since 1970!

Animal population loss is highly correlated to the natural world that they live in, and biodiversity loss means loss of the ecosystem services that go along with it. In this sense, traditional business models that take ecosystem services for granted risk not being able to operate for lack of services and/or will have to secure these services at a much higher cost.

Concretely, which businesses are most at risk of losing undervalued ecosystem services and/or which businesses are most dependent on nature?

Biodiversity loss is happening to land, sea, freshwater and air and estimates are that $44 trillion of economic value generation—over half the world’s total GDP—is moderately or highly dependent on nature and its services, and therefore at risk. The industries that are most dependent on biodiversity are construction, agriculture and food and beverages. These industries rely on either the direct extraction of resources from forests and oceans or the provision of ecosystem services such as healthy soils, clean water, pollination, etc. That said, many other industries have significant “hidden dependencies” on nature in their supply chain and are at risk of disruption. Chemicals and materials, tourism, real estate, mining and metals; transportation are all industries whereby over half of their supply chains’ gross value added is highly or moderately nature-dependent.

How can investors know which portfolio companies are aware of their risks and are doing something about it?  

Similar to investor risks associated to climate change, several initiatives have gathered momentum for investors to better understand portfolio management through a biodiversity lens.

A well-known reporting framework, the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), defines material topics for companies based on their industry and presents accounting metrics for each category. While “biodiversity” is not its own category, many of the key elements and ecosystem services are accounted for within the SASB framework. Investors that consult the CSR reports of their portfolio companies will have a first inkling of the degree of nature dependency.

Why can’t investors focus on just one biodiversity indicator like GHG emissions and the cost of CO2 for climate?

Biodiversity is extremely difficult to distill into one indicator since it has multiple dimensions and not all dimensions will be relevant for all types of businesses. Exposure to biodiversity loss depends on a complex array of factors: geography, operational arrangements, value chain position (upstream vs. downstream), extent of dependency on one or more aspects of diversity (e.g. water AND soil health AND air quality), impact on biodiversity, ability to substitute materials, etc.

It is for this reason that for investors, a financial metric that expresses the monetized value of ecosystem services—the services that nature provides to benefit humans—is useful. This method would help to reveal the economic contribution of nature and its services to an underlying investment.

Are there regulatory headwinds/tailwinds associated with biodiversity?

The 15th Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity (COP15) to be held in Kunming, China, in the third Quarter of 2022 (dates to be confirmed), will finalize a global biodiversity conservation framework for 2020-2050. This meeting is to biodiversity what the Paris Agreement is to climate change i.e., a once in a generation opportunity for the global community to commit to significant necessary actions to protect the planet. The expected outcome is to articulate global targets to preserve and protect 30% of land and sea by 2030.

However, just like for climate change, any resultant accords will not be legally binding. In other words, there are no international laws designed to enforce the preservation of biodiversity.

For investors, perhaps the biggest regulatory risk will come from the reversal of economic subsidies in certain industries. Take agriculture: according to the United Nations, nearly 90% of the $540bn in global subsidies given to farmers every year is considered harmful to the environment. These subsidies include price incentives for specific livestock and crops, subsidies for fertilizers and pesticides, and export subsidies and import tariffs. Equally frustrating is that often these subsidies and their concomitant environmental degradation, serve only to prop up certain parts of the agricultural market that would not otherwise be profitable. This tactic is no different than keeping zombie banks in operation after a banking crisis!

We expect that harmful subsidies will eventually be repealed (COP15 is likely to be influential in this regard). And there is already supportive evidence in the UK regarding the agricultural industry. Investors that are exposed to industries that rely on subsidies known to have deleterious environmental impacts will be on the wrong side of the trade.

How can I understand the environmental depletion—and therefore the biodiversity risk—of my investment?

The first step for investors is to have access to appropriate disclosure about biodiversity risks.

Regional and national disclosure endeavours already exist: France has already implemented a decree requiring all financial institutions to disclose biodiversity and climate-related risks as well as disclosing their strategy to reduce impacts. Meanwhile, the EU taxonomy does include significant drivers for preventing biodiversity loss, and the EU government is also expected to adopt a Directive on Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence in 2022, requiring companies with significant turnover in the EU to understand whether value chain activities have an adverse impact on biodiversity.

A non-exhaustive list of frameworks is provided in the table below, but the most significant development in nature-related financial disclosures is the Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures (TNFD), which is a framework that builds on the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD). A beta version was released earlier this month, with the aim to provide a framework for corporates and financial institutions to assess, manage and report on their dependencies and impacts on nature. A key feature of the framework is that it proposes location-specific disclosure given that dependencies and impacts on nature are inherently local. Indeed, the TNFD framework encourages transparent data to be reported about both impact and dependency (i.e., double materiality) on biodiversity.

We expect that over time, the TNFD will become a necessary, widely used disclosure framework that ultimately will influence how capital is allocated. It is significant that the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) last week issued a proposed rule change that would require companies to make specific climate-related disclosures. The new requirements are based on the TCFD disclosure framework. While legislation takes time, the TNFD will be the roadmap for enforced disclosure of a broader array of environmental factors.

Disclosure means that investors will be in a better position to make decisions. That said, forward-looking investors do not need to wait for disclosure regulation to act. The majority of public enterprises now publish some environmental data related to their operations, most often in a CSR report. With regards to biodiversity, companies that report according to SASB materiality risks already divulge significant information (see the table above).