Investors who associate climate change with a singular play—renewable energy stocks—have had an extremely challenging year. Vehicles like the iShares Global Clean Energy Fund (ICLN US) have had a disastrous first ten months of 2023 and only found some relief in November, once the Fed signalled a potential end to their rate raising campaign.

This performance should not be overly surprising, since renewables are highly sensitive to real interest rates; any portfolio levered to the climate change theme that relies only on clean energy stocks will largely move with the interest rate cycle. Debt comprises over 80% of capital expenditures for most wind and solar projects (since the energy source is free) and until recently, most U.S. utility-scale solar and onshore wind projects had not faced rising interest rates. Going forward, the economics of new projects are vulnerable to higher borrowing costs.

The outlook for this sector is certainly brighter in 2024, given the consensus view (of which the SMS team agrees) that the bulk of monetary policy tightening is behind us.

 

Investing for Environmental Diversification

2023 was a year when diversification within green portfolios was key to performance. While renewable energy stocks lost value, energy efficiency plays and nuclear energy stocks had a banger year. Other environmental sub-sectors like water and forestry were decent and are likely to end the year in the green. By and large, investors who understand that environmental investment themes go beyond the transition from fossil fuels to renewables have been rewarded with positive portfolio returns in 2023.

The table below lists some of the green sub-themes that we consider investable through public markets and some of the key macro drivers of each sub-theme. The key takeaway is that different environmental challenges are affected by varying macro conditions—this makes it possible to construct an active environmental equity strategy that takes account of the cyclical economic backdrop.

U.S. High Impact Outperformance Candidates

To illustrate the fact that environmental impact goes beyond renewable energy, here are three high impact U.S. candidates that should continue to do well in three different environmental sub-sectors: water, energy efficiency, and forestry.

Water

A couple months ago, Danaher Corp (DHR US) spun off its Environmental & Applied Solutions segment to create a new listed company, Veralto Corp (VLTO US). Approximately 60% of the company's sales come from water quality services, encompassing various brands and businesses such as Hach, ChemTreat, Trojan Technologies, Aquatic Informatics, and others. These entities are extensively involved in water analytics and treatment addressing specific applications such as managing water scarcity, ensuring water quality, complying with contamination regulations, and promoting sustainability. The impact of the company is even more significant as more than 30% of its revenues come from Emerging and Developing Economies (EDEs), where providing water solutions can literally be a life-or-death issue.

As the newly listed company is a direct extraction from another company’s segment, we have the luxury of knowing some key financial metrics instead of having to wait for the first earnings report. In 2022, the $4.9 billion business not only achieved 8% core sales growth but also demonstrated impressive margins, with gross margins reaching 57%, and EBITDA margins accounting for 24% of sales. Despite a slowdown in core sales growth to 4% in the first half of 2023—prior to the spin-off—the operating profit margins stood at 23%. Valuation-wise, the company started trading at a forward P/E ratio of 26x (now 24x) which is well in-line with its peers in the water and sanitation sector (the average P/E ratio of companies included in the Invesco Water Resources ETF (PHO US) is 26x).

Energy Efficiency

The energy efficiency company we expect to do well is Owens Corning (OC US). Owens Corning is a leading producer of insulation products for buildings, including fiberglass insulation, foam insulation, and blown-in insulation. These products help to reduce heat loss in winter and heat gain in summer, resulting in important energy savings for their clients. The company has had a banger year, resulting in its stock price being up 60% year-to-date. This can be partly explained by the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA). The IRA is the most substantial federal investment in home energy efficiency to date, allocating $8.8 billion to weatherize homes and assist households in saving billions of dollars in energy costs while reducing carbon emissions. Nearly a year after the enactment of the law, the U.S. Department of Energy just recently released the requirements and instructions for accessing $4.3 billion from the Home Efficiency Rebates Program, providing grants for comprehensive home efficiency improvements. This should continue to provide a significant tailwind for Owens Corning. In addition, in an unexpected turn of events, Owens Corning finds itself in a position to capitalize on the rising frequency and intensity of hurricanes, given the company's products in constructing buildings that can withstand storms.

Sustainable Forestry

Finally, the third company we wish to highlight is Weyerhaeuser (WY US). Weyerhaeuser is an American timberland company that owns or manages nearly 14 million acres of timberlands in the United States and Canada, which makes them America’s largest private landowner. The company has two main segments: Wood Products and Timberlands (logging). As per our September 7th note “Don’t Miss the Forest for the Trees”, not all forestry-related products have the same environmental impact.

Weyerhaeuser falls in the highest impact category for the sector as instead of producing short-lived products that would return the carbon to the atmosphere shortly after having been produced, the company manufactures structural lumber and other construction materials which have a very long and useful life. As for their logging business, the company follows strict sustainable forestry practices and plants more trees than it cuts. Finally, Weyerhaeuser is able to collect advanced geological data on its leased lands which led to strategic partnerships with energy companies (notably Occidental and Denbury) looking to sequestrate some carbon.

According to some estimates, the company’s new Natural Climate Solutions unit could become a profit center before long, which makes them an attractive high-impact firm to follow. Due to the slowdown in residential construction related to the high-interest-rate situation, the company’s revenues stalled somewhat in 2023 (which explains a modest +1% gain for its stock price year-to-date). However, other underlying tailwinds like limited inventory of existing homes and growing demographics should offset the higher interest rate environment that could last for a while.

Increasing Demand & Volatile Supply of Food

The global population is projected to increase by 10% this decade while the lower and upper-middle-class increase by 30%. As more people reach the middle class with a more calorific diet, the demand for food will continue to increase.

On the supply side, it is unlikely that more of the earth’s land surface can be dedicated to food production and the situation has complexified with climate change.

A warmer earth -as shown in the chart below- is causing more droughts, excessive rain and wind that are creating havoc for food production.

In theory, warming accelerates crop development and brings longer growing seasons to the North. On the other hand, excessive heat (over 32 degrees Celsius) stresses crops and weather uncertainty harms production. The changing nature of climate brings a problem similar to the supply chain issues that we experienced during the pandemic: you cannot get what you need on time from the usual sources. In such cases, the solution is resiliency instead of efficiency. This adaptation will take time, but it will create new investment opportunities.

The irony is that climate change is driving food prices higher, but our current food system has also been a big GHG emitter pushing global warming.

Moreover, a social mood veering away from globalization is another source of volatility: surging food inflation have triggered some countries to adopt restrictions. When food inflation hits local populations, food exporting nations have been pressured to curb exports to in an attempt to retain local food supplies and thereby lowering local prices. Protectionist policies like export restrictions of fertilizers in China and rice, sugar and onions from India are recent examples of these policies. The map below highlights the different export bans that are currently in place around the world.

As the chart below illustrates, sustained increases in food prices are a new phenomenon for many consumers: the share of food within the typical consumption basket, has until recently been in structural decline. In fact, spending on food as a share of total budgets has more than halved over the last 70 years in the U.S. Higher prices of food relative to other items means that households are likely to spend more of their budgets on food.

Meeting global food demand while tackling the associated environmental issues will be no easy feat; but there are areas along the food chain ripe for improvement and opportunities to better manage the world’s food supply - much of which goes to waste (around 30%). As supply pressures increase, these inefficiencies will likely be the first targets for action.

Future of Farming

Agricultural production is the basis of our food system. The green revolution was crucial for agricultural production to keep pace with population growth over the last century. It enabled significant increases in crop production through the introduction of techniques that are mainstays of agriculture today: fertilizers, pesticides and new seed varieties. Unfortunately, these methods are also key contributors to climate change and current environmental issues. The next phase of agriculture needs a different solution set.

As discussed in our note, Agriculture’s Addiction Problem (September 9, 2022), precision farming techniques and biological products that are less damaging to the environment are providing a pathway for farmers to limit harmful practices without sacrificing yields. We expect companies providing these solutions to have continued success.

Another option for increasing food supply is to better cultivate arable land. This too, must be done differently than in the past. As seen in the chart above, agricultural land use is a significant source of greenhouse gas emissions. But as temperatures rise, farming will become more productive at higher latitudes (Finding the True North to Feed the World, May 5, 2022). Rethinking what and how we cultivate northern farmland offers the chance to do things better this time around. The latest survey of farmers under 40 years of age by National Young Farmers Coalition (NYFC) showed 86% of respondents use regenerative practices and 83% identified conservation and regeneration as their reasons for farming. Furthermore, farms are increasingly seen for their potential as a carbon sink, creating incentives for farmers to adopt better methods.

From a portfolio perspective, investing in farmland has attractive characteristics. Because its value tends to move with food prices and production yield, historical returns have exhibited low correlation with traditional markets and served as inflation hedge. REITs like Gladstone Land (LAND US) and Farmers Partners (FPI US), though both small caps at under $1 billion USD, are a way for public equities investors to add exposure to farmland in their portfolios. Environmental impact of these holdings is challenging to verify as they lease their land to a multitude of farmers using a variety of techniques. However, ESG disclosures, while currently lacking, appear to be moving in the right direction. Moreover, because they lease farmland, these companies can provide a stepping-stone for the next generation of farmers. Affordability and availability of land for purchase was identified as the biggest challenge for respondents of the NYFC survey.

Reducing/Eliminating Food Waste

While food production is a significant contributor to greenhouse gas emissions, wasted food exacerbates climate change even further. Food waste is a major problem that extends across the entire food supply chain. Broadly defined, it encompasses any discarded or unused food substance, from production and processing to consumption. If we compare emissions from food waste to countries, it would be third, just below the United States and China. Additionally, food waste contributes to land degradation and water pollution when it ends up in landfills. Given these statistics, it isn’t surprising that both the U.S. and European governments have implemented food waste management plans.

The refrigeration of food from harvest to delivery is one way to lower emissions from food waste (see also Some Like it Cold, August 4, 2022). By some estimates, refrigeration could prevent nearly 30% of global food waste. Leading companies in this area of the food chain include Americold, Carrier and Daikin. Notably, refrigeration services in developing countries have the greatest impact on reducing food waste. In 2022, Daikin industries had 27% of revenues from emerging markets.

Grocery stores bear a substantial cost from food waste, losing a staggering $28 billion annually due to unsold or expired products. Addressing this issue requires a multifaceted approach.

Innovations like dynamic pricing in grocery stores could hold great promise for combating food waste. At its core, dynamic pricing is a tool employed by retailers to optimize prices based of various factors, including cost and market competition. For instance, Revionics, a price optimization software company, is collaborating with major grocers like Ahold Delhaize, Carrefour and Loblaws to implement their pricing strategy. Other dynamic pricing companies like Afresh, Shelf Engine and Wasteless are actively developing solutions aimed at highly perishable products, integrating critical factors such as product freshness and nearing expiration dates. A data-driven approach that encourages consumers to purchase items at risk of going to waste can yield dual benefits: consumers enjoy lower prices and grocers gain additional revenue.

In addition to pricing strategies, improvements in operations are essential for reducing food waste by reducing overstocking and ensuring that food is delivered to consumers efficiently. The growth of e-commerce in the grocery industry has made it even more important to efficiently manage stock levels. One notable example in this field is Ocado Group, which has developed automated solutions for customer fulfillment centers, using a variety of robotic technologies to pick, pack, and ship orders. These innovations not only streamline the order fulfillment process but also significantly enhance inventory control.

The voluntary carbon market (VCM) has had a rough year. It started in January with a devastating investigation published in The Guardian which suggested that 90% of rainforest carbon offsets accredited by Verra, one of the biggest certifiers, were worthless. As it is often the case, the article was slightly exaggerated – some would say borderline click bait – but it did shine a spotlight on an industry that clearly needs to be kept in check. In response to the criticisms, Mark Carney’s ICVCM (Integrity Council for Voluntary Carbon Markets) released the Core Carbon Principles (CCPs), a set of 10 principles that define high-quality carbon credits by strengthening controversial offset credit characteristics such as additionality, permanence, transparency, and monitoring and verification. However, it seems to be too little too late when it comes to reputational damages. Last week, Shell, which has historically been an important player in carbon offsets, ended the world’s biggest corporate plan to develop carbon offsets. And the damages can also be felt when looking at the voluntary carbon offset futures contracts which have collapsed more than 70% year-to-date (90% from the highs of January 2022).

Nevertheless, the VCM’s existential troubles should not necessarily be transposed to the forestry sector as a whole. The science is clear on the importance of the world’s forests. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) concluded that forests play an important role in both mitigating and adapting to climate change, including by absorbing about 2.6 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide per year from the atmosphere.

It is this feature of forests, namely their carbon absorption capacity, that attracts investors’ interest. Financial institutions with a combined US$130 trillion in assets under management are now committed to reaching a state of net-zero before 2050. Most have no clue how to do that, but the attraction to the forestry sector is palpable. Case in point: the Sydney-based investment manager New Forests, specialized in, you guessed it, sustainable forest investments, was acquired by Japanese powerhouses Nomura and Mitsui, with the clear intention of benefiting from all the carbon captured in these forests. It is the same story with Climate Asset Management, which was created by HSBC using the natural capital expertise of Pollination Group.

The signatories of all the net-zero alliances (asset managers, asset owners, banks, insurances, etc.) do not yet know for sure what will be acceptable to meet their targets. Officially, the Science-Based Targets initiative’s (SBTi) framework allows financial institutions to set emissions reduction targets using the following tactics: portfolio-wide abatement, engagement, divestment, avoided emissions, and climate solutions financing. It is this last tactic that makes the forestry sector appealing to financial institutions struggling with their objectives. Could they claim the carbon held in the forests they own through their investments against the emissions from their other holdings?

The debate continues, but investors interested in moving early should at least follow the following principles:

  1. No double counting: If the investor claims the credit against its financed emissions, neither the forestry company nor the jurisdiction (country) can claim it at the same time.
  2. Not every forestry company is created equal: Depending on the company’s product portfolio, the lifecycle emissions are very different. See table below.
  3. Co-benefits: sustainably managed forests can provide much more than just carbon sequestration – they provide clean water, critical habitat, foods and medicines, support rural livelihoods, and provide valuable recreational and cultural experiences.
  4. Indirect reductions: In addition to the carbon stored in the products themselves – be they construction wood, paper, cardboard, etc. – additional reductions can come from the fact that these products are replacing more carbon-intensive materials. For instance, one square metre of a wood-based outer wall leads to the emission of 7.8 kg of CO2e, while producing one square metre of a concrete-based wall emits 117 kg of CO2e (15 times more).
  5. From timber to biorefinery: Biorefining is the process of converting biomass into a variety of products, including fuels, chemicals, and materials. Companies that are investing in biorefining technologies to create new products and markets for their biomass are adding additional revenue sources and these products also replace more emission intensive alternatives.

Based on these criteria, we have selected a basket of forestry names that could appeal to investors looking to maximize their odds of possibly using an investment in these companies to neutralize other portfolio emissions.

For the first category of companies, Construction Wood and Forest Management, only Weyerhaeuser (WY US) is interesting both from a sustainability perspective and a reasonable price-to-earnings ratio. The fact that they are exclusively in the harvested wood products (HWP) and the forest management sectors boosts their sustainability profile as the carbon captured by their forests has a much higher chance of staying in solid pieces of wood for a longer period of time. In the Paper and Cardboard category, UPM-Kymmene (UPM FH), Klabin (KLBN11 BZ) and Oji Holdings (3861 JT) all offer a great balance between their sustainability credentials and reasonable valuations. All three also realize that they become more attractive to sustainability-minded investors when they increase the recyclability of their products.

As a bonus, it also happens the companies that scored the best in our methodology are also the highest promoters of biorefining technologies, which could prove to be a smart technology to invest in today to reap benefits in the future. All four top-scoring companies are developing biorefineries that produce cellulosic ethanol, lignin-based products, bio-based chemicals, and renewable packaging materials.

Looking at the price performance over the last five years, one may doubt the strategy of investing in these companies considering the choppiness. However, it can be explained by the fact that (1) the forestry industry is cyclical by nature and we are currently in an uncertain economic environment and (2), it is a very capital intensive industry which is especially a headwind for the industry over the past year given the high rate environment.

In the last couple of months, insurance behemoths Allstate, State Farm and AIG all announced they would no longer write new homeowners’ insurance policies in California. All three cited the rising risk of wildfires as the main reason for their decision. These announcements followed other statements from private insurers that have almost completely withdrawn from parts of Florida – where storm coverage is becoming increasingly difficult to find – and other environmental-disaster-prone areas such as Louisiana and Kentucky where flood insurance has also recently been removed. As an industry that doesn’t like surprises, the insurance sector looks to be rapidly approaching a pivotal realization that climate risks are financial risks.

Though increased news coverage sometimes gives the false impression that something is happening more often than it is in reality (a phenomenon called the illusory truth effect, exemplified in the perception that crime levels are on the rise when they actually are not), in this instance, you would be right to believe that climate-related natural catastrophes are truly happening more frequently. Unfortunately, they are not only growing in frequency, but also in intensity. According to the World Meteorological Organization (WMO), the number of 1 in 100 years occurrences has increased five-fold over the past 50 years, which aligns with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)’s data specific to the USA.

As mentioned in our June 15, 2023, note “Macro Meets Sustainability: Outlook for Q3 and Beyond”, climate adaptation is climate mitigation’s poor little brother, as 93% of total climate funding going towards reducing greenhouse gas emissions instead of building resilient infrastructure.

But this unbalance is unsustainable. A study by McKinsey found that even if the global temperature warms only by 1.5°C by 2030 – which is an increasingly elusive target as we drag our feet when it comes to concrete actions – almost half of the world's population will still be exposed to climate hazards, such as heat stress, drought and floods. Most reasonable observers would then conclude that we should probably accelerate the pace of adaptation investments instead of praying to the hydrogen God to save us, or even crazier, to seriously consider geoengineering techniques such as stratospheric aerosol injection to reflect the sun rays (currently proposed for discussion by the European Commission!)

Historically, it has been very hard to find relevant publicly listed companies in the adaptation space as most of the capital was flowing between government departments, multilateral development banks, municipal governments, academics, and NGOs.

As projects became more sophisticated and larger in scale, some businesses developed an expertise in adaptation-related fields. So, while mainstream investors are still stuck in the carbon mitigation tunnel, sustainability-minded investors should be looking for opportunities beyond mitigation as the inevitable tailwinds that should benefit climate adaptation solutions are not yet priced in our opinion.

Although climate adaptation opportunities cut across industries such as resilient agriculture, irrigation, and water management –covered by other investment themes in our proprietary SMS sustainable thematic mapping – we will focus on three subsectors for the purpose of this note: insurance, advanced data, and resilient infrastructure.

In a 2019 note (“Some Unreassuring Thoughts”, June 20, 2019), we discussed the fact that at some point, insurance companies that fail to account for increased climate physical risks in their policies would eventually pay the price. This situation is unfolding now. According to a January 2023 report by the Swiss Re Institute, the global cost of climate-related insurance claims has increased by more than 50% in the last five years. The report also found that the number of climate-related insurance claims has increased by 30% in the same period. The three major companies who pulled out from the California market were clearly ill-prepared for this situation and have paid the price of increased claims. Other insurance companies have seen these climate risks coming and have built-in new risk models in the insurance policies. For instance, Markel Group (MKL US) acquired Nephila Holdings in 2018. Over the years, Nephila developed a strong expertise in natural disaster risk and has launched a number of innovative products to help manage their exposure to these risks (catastrophe bonds, insurance-linked securities, weather derivatives, etc.). These cutting-edge products have generated a new revenue stream for Markel, which helped them outperforming their peers.

One way insurance companies, as well as other industries, can better prepare for the physical climate risks coming their way is by modeling these impacts. An entire industry of data providers and data analytics companies is starting to emerge, and their future looks bright as the insurance and risk management industry will (eventually) embrace AI and other advanced data analysis techniques. For instance, Verisk Analytics (VRSK US) offers data, statistical and actuarial services to the insurance industry, with an increased focused on natural disasters. They have an entire unit (Verisk Climate Division) focused on providing their clients tools such as wildfire or flood risk analyses. Same with Willis Tower Watson (WTW US) which also serves the insurance industry with risk management consulting services, including through their Climate and Resilience Hub which grew to more than 130 climate risk professionals. Other data companies such as Fugro NV, Hexagon AB and Vaisala Oyj are also well positioned to benefit from the climate adaptation tailwinds as they provide data and technology that can help insurers assess and manage climate-related risks.

These companies have generally performed well over the past couple of years, with valuations (price to earnings ratio) hovering from a relatively cheap 10.8x for Fugro NV and 14.9x for Willis Tower Watson, to a more expensive 37.4x for Verisk Analytics.

Adapting to climate change also means building more resilient infrastructure. A few companies have shown leadership in this domain and are worth looking into for a sustainability-minded investor. First is Arcadis NV (ARCAD NA). Being based in the Netherlands with its low-lying geography and extensive coastlines, Arcadis has developed an expertise in water management infrastructure, and has now become a leader in the field of climate adaptation engineering. Most of what they do falls in the adaptation category: designing and constructing flood defenses, developing water management plans, assessing the vulnerability of infrastructure to climate change, and providing training and education on climate adaptation. NV5 Global (NVEE US) is another engineering firm with a growing portfolio of climate adaptation solutions for their clients. Software company Bentley Systems (BSY US) provides products and services that help engineers, architects, and other professionals design, build, and operate infrastructure that is more resilient to the impacts of climate change. Some of their most recent projects include working with the US Army Corps of Engineers to design and construct a new levee system to protect the city of New Orleans from flooding, and working with the State of Florida to manage and operate the state's stormwater management system. Finally, Great Lakes Dredge & Dock Corp (GLDD US) provides dredging services, which are used to maintain and improve waterways. As climate change causes sea levels to rise and storms to become more severe, the demand for dredging services is likely to increase.

While these company examples show how broad climate change adaptation as a theme is, what they all have in common is the potential to greatly benefit from the wall of money that is about to flood – pun intended – the adaptation-related industries.

Pollution and : Unveiling the Dynamic Duo’s Destructive Alliance

In recent years, the global community has rightfully placed immense focus on mitigating the impacts of climate change, recognizing the urgent need for collective action. However, amidst this vital effort, another pressing environmental challenge has often been relegated to the background: air pollution. While climate change is undeniably crucial, it is essential to acknowledge that it is just one component of a broader set of planetary boundaries, which include other key environmental challenges such as the biosphere integrity, freshwater use, and atmospheric aerosol pollution. In fact, we were reminded just this week that scientists now estimate that seven out of the eight quantifiable planetary boundaries have already been surpassed by humans, according to an update published in Nature (only stratospheric ozone depletion is under control).

Air pollution is a multifaceted problem that poses severe risks to human health, ecosystems, and the global economy. The adverse impacts of polluted air on respiratory and cardiovascular health are well-documented, contributing to increased mortality rates and a significant burden on healthcare systems. Additionally, air pollution’s destructive influence on ecosystems, including crop yields and biodiversity, further jeopardizes our planet’s delicate balance.

To make matters worse, global warming can exacerbate certain forms of pollution through feedback loops. For example, as temperatures rise, air pollution can intensify due to the increased formation of ground-level ozone, a harmful pollutant. Industrial processes, deforestation, agricultural practices, and the burning of fossil fuels release significant amounts of methane and nitrous oxide into the atmosphere, trapping heat and leading to a rise in global temperatures.

In order to foster a sustainable future, investors and policymakers must broaden their scope to include air pollution as a priority. By doing so, we not only fulfill our moral duty to safeguard the planet but also capitalize on the compelling business case presented by the increasing demand for air pollution solutions worldwide.

In this week’s note, we will focus our analysis on pollution from methane, nitrous oxide, sulfur dioxide, and volatile organic compounds, all of which are affecting the ability of the planet to rehabilitate naturally. Building upon our previous discussions regarding the planetary boundaries, most recently explored in “Hold Your Nose – A Sustainable Investor’s Guide to Fertilizers” on March 2, 2023, we now delve deeper into the pollution control for these specific compounds.

 

The Pollution Puzzle: Identifying the Sources

The table below neatly condenses the main sources of pollution and highlights the need for transversal regulation.

 

 

Pollution Patrol: Unveiling the Rules for a Cleaner Future

Taking an optimistic view on the power of regulation and innovation; we believe in the Porter Hypothesis where strict environmental regulations can trigger/instigate efficiency gains and encourage innovations that improve competitiveness. Our optimism is fueled by two major historical successes: elimination of acid rain and the halt of ozone depletion. In the 1980’s, acid rain in North America was a major issue and the environment movement won the acid rain fight. In 2000, the ozone hole reached its peak but the Earth’s ozone layer is on track to recover following the Montreal Protocol. Those two success stories give us hope that smart regulation brings focus, investments and innovation.

In the past decade, the world has witnessed a remarkable surge in the implementation of air pollution regulations, reflecting the growing recognition of the urgent need to address this critical issue. The table presented herein encapsulates the culmination of these endeavors, illustrating a comprehensive overview of air pollution policies worldwide.

The increase in regulatory measures targeting air pollution signifies a profound shift in public perception and understanding of the detrimental consequences associated with poor air quality. Recognizing the far-reaching implications on human health, ecosystems, and climate change, policymakers have taken proactive steps to prioritize this challenge.

As policies set the stage for environmental change, it is through innovative solutions offered by companies that the tangible implementation and transformation of these policies into practical measures happens.

 

From Problem to Solution: Companies Leading Against Pollution

Fortunately, there are several companies spearheading the battle against pollution; we explore their innovative solutions for effective air pollution control.

 

In 1997, while sailing home to Southern California after finishing the Transpacific Yacht Race, oceanographer Charles Moore sailed into a massive swirling mass of plastic debris in the middle of the North Pacific Ocean. The discovery of the “Great Pacific Garbage Patch”, as it became known, acted as a wake-up call to the global community that our addiction to plastics and our inability to manage its disposal had to stop. Or has it?

Since the discovery of what has been called the “seventh continent”, the global production of plastics worldwide has more than doubled.

How is it possible that our collective outrage hasn’t yielded more concrete results? The problem is that we are addicted to plastics for the same reasons we must get rid of them: plastics are ultra durable (a great material characteristic, but not so great when it ends up in nature) and inexpensive to produce (which makes managing the end of its useful life more expensive than using new plastics). Moreover, plastics are super lightweight, making transportation of goods easier and less emission-intensive, and can dramatically improve food preservation, elongating shelf lives of certain foods by as much as 4.5 times. And of course, the hygienic characteristics of plastic can come in handy during a global pandemic. No wonder its use is ubiquitous and our addiction is so hard to break.

Another thing we are addicted to is making commitments without proper follow-through. Earlier this week, G7 members committed to ending plastic pollution by 2040. This commitment sets the stage for a new round of intergovernmental negotiations on the future international treaty against plastic pollution, which is scheduled for the end of May in Paris. Talk is like plastic – cheap! For those who prefer practical solutions, this note shows how investors can position themselves to tackle the plastics problem.

In short, the environmental issues linked to plastics come from three different parts of the supply chain which are also the three elements of the linear economy: Take (feedstocks) – Make (production) – Waste (disposal). An obvious part of the plastic solution is the reduction of plastic use altogether, but this is hardly investible and we know it won’t be enough to entirely eliminate the problem.

Upstream: The Feedstock Conundrum

Let’s start upstream and discuss the feedstocks necessary for making all this plastic. For approximately 70 years, plastic has been made from a range of petrochemical products that are derived from crude oil. It was an economical way to produce plastic as there was an excess of oil by-products that were well adapted for its production. Now, however, about a tenth of global oil production is attributed to the petrochemical industry, and it is projected to represent a fifth of oil production by 2050; we can hardly talk about plastics as an oil by-product anymore. Considering that the current feedstock is almost exclusively fossil fuel-based, the main issue at the upstream level is the carbon emissions released, which represent globally about 4% of all emissions.

Solving this issue requires changing the feedstock to something less emission intensive than petrochemicals. Luckily for us, plastics can be made from a variety of renewable sources, including plants, algae, and even bacteria, to create bioplastics. It can also be produced using recycled plastic as feedstock.

Bioplastics are made from organic materials rather than petrochemicals and it is the feedstock source that saw the largest relative growth since 2018 (+69%). Bioplastics CAN BE biodegradable and compostable, but this is not always the case. Currently, only about half of bioplastics are biodegradable. The rest needs to be responsibly disposed, just like all other fossil-based plastics. Also, because bioplastics predominantly use food commodities as feedstock (i.e. corn and potatoes), there is a concern that they could compete with food production and potentially drive up food prices. Fortunately, some companies are developing advanced bioplastics technologies made from algae or bacteria, which is a more sustainable avenue. For instance, Origin Materials (ORGN US), Green Earth Institute (9212 JT), Corbion (CRBN NA), and Danimer (DNMR US) are all companies that are working to develop sustainable alternatives to traditional plastics. They are all using different methods to achieve this goal, but they share the same goal of reducing the environmental impact of plastic pollution. While Origin Materials is developing a process to convert plant-based materials into high-performance plastics, Green Earth Institute is developing a process to convert agricultural waste into plastics. For their part, Corbion is developing a process to convert sugar into plastics and Danimer is developing a similar process using algae.

All of these companies are still in the early stages of development, but they have the potential to make a significant impact on the fight against plastic pollution. If they are successful, they could help reduce the amount of plastic that ends up in our oceans and landfills.

Using recycled materials to make new plastics also sounds like a good idea, but as shown in the previous table, it represents less than 10% of the plastic production feedstock and has been at that level for many years. This is in part due to the premium that producers need to pay for the recycled PET pellets. It is usually more economical for plastic manufacturers to use Virgin PET (and pay the Plastic Tax, which in the UK for instance is at £200 per tonne), rather than to pay the €700 premium for recycled pellets!

Midstream: Being the Best at Making Plastics

Having dealt with the feedstock issue, other production considerations can make a plastic manufacturer more attractive for sustainability-minded investors. Below is a table with 12 listed companies producing the most single-use plastics (SUP) along with their SBTi status and their CSRHub Environmental Scores. Only three companies have developed a credible, SBTi-aligned target: Indorama Ventures (IVL TB), LyondellBasell (LYB US), and Alpek SA de CV (ALPEKA MM). Of them, only Alpek SA de CV ‘s targets have been set and approved by the SBTi – a more rigorous process than the initial commitment that Indorama and LyondellBasell have made.

As producers of SUP, these companies can play a pivotal role in helping solve the environmental problems of plastics. Some are clearly not interested in participating in the transition, while others take the necessary step to work on a SBTi target and getting it approved, which demonstrates a certain level of commitment.

Downstream: Managing Plastic Disposal Responsibly

Recycling comes at the very end of the “R” hierarchy but it would be irresponsible to think that it is not an important part of waste management, especially for plastics. With current plastic recycling rates in the low double digits, there is a lot of room for improvement. Traditional mechanical recycling techniques are not very well adapted for the plastic industry as the contamination levels are sky high, especially in the food packaging sector.

A number of companies are developing advanced recycling techniques, such as Eastman Chemicals (EMN US), PureCycle Technologies (PCT US), and Agilyx (AGLX NO) who are all working on recycling specific types of plastic using mostly chemical recycling techniques, while Carbios (ALCRB FP) and Pyrum Innovations (PYROM NO) are working on recycling mixed plastic waste using enzymes.

Of these companies, only Eastman Chemicals has produced positive earnings and its P/E ratio hovers around 10, making it an attractive investment idea. From a technological standpoint, Agilyx offers an interesting proposition with its Advanced Recycling Technology.

Water stress or scarcity occurs when demand for safe, usable water in a given area exceeds the supply. Historically, most water shortages were considered broadly as an economic scarcity: inadequate water infrastructure to meet the needs of communities.

More and more however, water scarcity is due to physical scarcity: we are consuming more water than the natural world can supply. It is predicted that by 2030, the demand for fresh water will outstrip supply. That is in less than seven years!

It is therefore appropriate that, for the first time since 1977, the UN Water Conference was held in New York last week. The aim is to raise awareness about water scarcity. The event is way overdue since it has been long known that many industrialized economies, like the U.S., under the status quo, would run low on water.

To be clear, water risks are broader than “just” water scarcity. Other threats include water contamination, plastic pollution, diversion and transfer of water, and eutrophication. All of these risks have financial implications that include reduced company revenue, increased operating costs, and an impairment to business viability.

As the table below shows, eutrophication and groundwater depletion (water scarcity) threats are deemed the most severe from an industrial/economic perspective. We have written in past notes on fertilizers’ detrimental impacts on the environment, including eutrophication. Therefore, today’s note focuses on the other most critical water risk - groundwater depletion - and on opportunities inherent in companies that are mitigating this risk.

Risky Business - Industries most at risk from water scarcity

Water, like many resources, is often taken for granted. This is in large part because in most regions, the cost of water is severely underpriced (in most countries, only the cost of service is paid, not the commodity price of water). Despite growing media attention, World Water Days are critical to raise awareness about water scarcity because most economic actors continue to underprice both water as an asset as well as the risks associated with water scarcity. The problem is perhaps even worse among investors: a 2022 report by CDP showed that water reporting is increasing (although severely lags climate change reporting) but there are still one third of listed financial institutions that are not yet assessing exposure of financial activities to water risks.

For investors, water scarcity risks run right through any diversified portfolio: virtually all S&P 500 GICS sectors have some exposure to risks associated with groundwater depletion. That said, some sectors are far more exposed to water scarcity risks than others. According to The Global Institute For Water Security, the industry that is both the biggest threat and most at risk from water scarcity is the Consumer Staples sector, including food, beverage, and livestock production. Specific industries within the Consumer Discretionary sector – apparel, textiles and luxury goods – are also major contributors and are at major risk, mostly due to thirsty cotton production, in India, Brazil, Central Asia, and parts of the U.S. The Metals and Mining industry and Oil and Gas industry, especially from hydraulic fracturing and oil sands extraction, are also causing severe groundwater depletion and pollution.

Only a handful of companies like Diageo and Nestlé, have made efforts to quantify the impact of water scarcity on their businesses.

 

 

 

Keep it Flowing - Companies providing water reuse and recycling solutions

In the face of these risks, it is imperative that companies reuse, or at the very least, recycle their water. Recycling consists of treating wastewater so it can be safely discharged back into the environment, relieving some of the strain on regional water supply. Companies can optimize their own water supply by reusing water in as many processes as possible before recycling it. Even better is water management within a closed loop system (Zero Liquid Discharge) where water is treated and reused without being discharged from the facility. Factories able to implement this will have the best chance at mitigating water scarcity issues.

The key to water recycling and reuse is water treatment. Veolia, Ecolab and Kurita Water Industries are three companies that offer water treatment solutions to industrial clients (including tools dedicated to closed-loop systems).

Veolia Water Technologies has solutions in place for major clients in several water-intensive industries: food production (Nestle), mining, automobile (General Motors) and pharmaceuticals (Pfizer). Ecolab is recognized as a sustainability leader and has a 2030 objective to contribute to the conservation of 300 billion gallons of water annually, equivalent to the drinking water needs of 1 billion people.

Both Veolia and Ecolab operate in business segments other than water. Veolia also offers waste management solutions and energy management services and Ecolab is a chemicals company with products supporting healthier food and quality hygiene. These other segments support environmental and social objectives, and we expect them to benefit from the growing focus on sustainability.

Finally, Kurita operates exclusively in the water treatment business, providing purifying chemicals and filters. Included in its offerings is a five-phase approach to Zero Liquid Discharge systems.

Xylem is another pure play in water. The company earns the majority of its revenues from water infrastructure and only about 8% from water treatment products. However, this is about to change as Xylem is in the process of acquiring Evoqua (100% of revenue from water treatment). Expansion in this segment will be complementary to the company's existing products which also support water conservation. Following announcement of the acquisition in January, Xylem’s stock price has come in, creating a potential buying opportunity.  

In the past year, Veolia, Kurita and Xylem stock prices have outperformed global equities; Ecolab’s performance was aligned. While the valuations of these companies look expensive (see chart below), we believe the growing recognition of water scarcity and the ensuing water conservation goals will provide tailwinds that outweigh expensive valuations.

Use of synthetic fertilizers is yet another wicked problem facing society (see also “Transition Metals: Wicked Problem, Smart Solutions”, October 14, 2021). Renowned for facilitating higher yields on less land, the use of synthetic fertilizer also has devastating effects on the environment and the Earth’s natural nitrogen cycle. This is a challenging landscape for sustainable investors looking to support solutions to food security. To help investors navigate this industry, this note discusses the role of fertilizers in food production and its associated challenges followed by a review of the best opportunities for a positive impact.

Apply More Fertilizer to Feed the World

As the global population marches toward its expected 10.4 billion peak in the 2080’s, food production will need to be scaled accordingly. Fertilizer’s role in crop production is to provide the nutrients necessary for plant health. These nutrients (nitrogen, potassium and phosphorous) are naturally occurring and can be found in healthy soil or from sources like manure, but they are absorbed more efficiently from the application of synthetic fertilizers. This efficiency also serves to limit the land area used for cultivating crops. In the face of growing demand for fertilizer, the early 1900s saw the creation of the Haber-Bosch process which enabled mass production of synthetic nitrogen fertilizers; an agriculture productivity boom that supported the rapid global population growth of the last century. It is estimated that up to 50% of crop yields come from the use of synthetic nitrogen fertilizers. Accordingly, synthetic fertilizer is fundamental to sustaining the global population and access to it has important implications for food security. Also of note, is that there appears to be little productivity improvement in fertilizers; since 1990, the amount of fertilizers consumed per person (see chart below) has remained stable. The implication is that as the global population continues to grow, it will require a proportionate increase in kilos of fertilizer. This has important consequences for planet Earth.

Apply Less Fertilizer to Save the Planet

Though this abundance of fertilizer improved quality of life for many historically, it has resulted in negative environmental outcomes. For one, it is a GHG intensive process; fertilizer production accounts for about 2% of GHG emissions and much like the use of other agri-chemicals (see note “Agriculture’s Addiction Problem”, September 29, 2022), over-application of fertilizer is having harmful effects on biodiversity. This overuse is especially harmful to waterways. As excess nutrients leach off fields into the water supply, they cause disproportionate algae growth creating dead zones. Furthermore, fertilizer is the subject of one of the breached planetary boundaries: biogeochemical cycles; this breach indicates that human activity has become the dominant force affecting the Earth’s nitrogen and phosphorous cycles. This poses a crucial conundrum: feed the people, or preserve the planet? Given the need for food production to keep pace with population growth, a transition to more sustainable solutions is urgently needed.

Adopt a Fertilizer Transition Plan

In addition to environmental issues, recent geopolitical events have countries reassessing their relationships with synthetic fertilizers. Natural gas is a key input in the production of nitrogen fertilizers, and the resultant price volatility of fertilizer over the past two years has been challenging for farmers. Prices first rose in 2021 with the economic recovery from COVID. The subsequent 2022 price hike following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine even led some fertilizer companies to halt production during 2022 as it was no longer cost-effective.

Restricted supply was not only due to higher energy prices. Chinese policymakers implemented an export ban on fertilizers in 2021, prioritizing access for its farmers. Sanctions on Belarus have limited access to Potash fertilizer and although Russian fertilizer was exempt from sanctions in the name of food security, many are reluctant to purchase from the country. These geopolitical events have added to price volatility as fertilizers are sourced from a limited set of countries that includes China, Belarus and Russia among top suppliers.

In the face of rising prices in 2021, Sri Lanka placed a ban on imports of synthetic fertilizers and pesticides. Unfortunately, rather than serve as a model for success, this decision showed just how much our food systems depend on these inputs and the necessity of a transition period. The sudden halt in the use of synthetic fertilizers led to a 20% decline in rice yields and 18% in tea yields, two important crops for Sri Lanka’s economy. Though the ban was reversed within a year, it was enough to contribute to runaway inflation rates and an economic crisis that culminated with the President’s resignation.

Strategies undertaken by the U.S. and Europe, take a slow but firm approach. The U.S. has made $500 million in grants available through its Fertilizer Production Expansion Program. The program seeks to expand domestic fertilizer production to reduce reliance on foreign suppliers, prioritizing alternatives that are more sustainable. The European commission is also tackling fertilizer challenges by encouraging green fertilizers (produced from clean energy), and sustainable agriculture methods (including precision farming) on top of an existing goal of organic farming on 25% of agricultural land under organic farming by 2030 - part of its Farm to Fork strategy.

Invest in the Future of Fertilizer

We see investing in fertilizer companies as a transition solution. For the time being, synthetic fertilizer will remain a considerable input to the global food system as it is a key input in maintaining sufficient food supply. Over the longer term, as countries focus on limiting environmental impacts and seek to reduce their dependence on volatile agricultural inputs, the role of synthetic fertilizers will become less significant. This has two implications for investors: 1) choosing companies with best-in-class environmental standards will help to limit effects of this otherwise regrettable necessity. Additionally, the companies operating in countries subject to higher environmental standards will also see their market share increase as they fill export gaps left by sanctioned countries and China’s export ban. North American producers also benefit from greater stability in natural gas prices. 2) Companies with diversified revenues will be best positioned to weather the transition away from synthetic fertilizers.

We find four suitable companies for these criteria: CF Industries, Nutrien, Sociedad Quimica Y Minera de Chile (SQM) and Yara. Each of these has an overall ESG rank above the 80th percentile in CSRHub, but of these four, Yara and Nutrien are the environmental leaders. Both have initiatives aligned with best environmental practices, strong disclosure on material topics and each has limited water withdrawal (~2%) from high stress areas. Nutrien is a significant supplier of the world’s Potash fertilizer and the company’s nitrogen production capacities are concentrated in North and South America, areas which have greater independence for natural gas supplies. The same goes for CF Industries with over 90% of their nitrogen production capacity in North America.

Looking for diversified revenues, SQM is a company with transition experience. Aside from fertilizers, SQM draws 32% of its revenues from lithium manufacturing, a metal used for batteries which are key to the energy transition. Yara is expanding its organic fertilizer offerings with a goal of $1.5 billion in revenue from this segment in 2022 (~10% of 2021 revenue values) and the company also sells precision agriculture tools, two products that are key in the next phase of agriculture production. Yara is also a leader in clean ammonia for use as a fuel selling 4.1 million tons in 2021; Nutrien (1 million ton capacity) and CF Industries also have ambitions in this space.

In 2022, each of these companies’ stock price outperformed the MSCI global equity benchmark, and we anticipate similar performance this year as farmers will once again rely more on the West for their supply of fertilizer.

If our 2022 investment outlook note could be reduced to one investment adage – “power of diversification” – then SMS’ outlook theme for 2023 takes a page from Warren Buffett and focuses on “knowing the difference between price and value”. We believe that the bear market in stocks that got underway in 2022 is not yet over, but that 2023 will nonetheless offer opportunity for bargains in high-quality sustainable companies that are positioned for a low-carbon, high-care economy.

From a macro perspective, we expect there will be less surprises about inflation in 2023 (trending lower, but still above 2%) but ongoing uncertainty about the timing of recession. The chart below shows the evolution of our expectations about different macro investment scenarios; we expect recessionary conditions to linger for most of the year leading broad equity indices to trend lower until there is early evidence of a positive inflection point in the economic cycle. Equity markets have priced in the higher interest rate environment but not the fall in profitability. For now, a soft landing with no recession seems to be priced in markets.

Against this backdrop, and with our approach to investing that is focused on finding tradeable sustainability themes and the best companies that embody them, it is no surprise that we enter the year with a defensive tilt that offers downside protection. As the second half of the bear market unfolds, we will intensify our focus to find beaten-down names that offer superior value. A catalyst for the latter will be once forward earnings expectations turn firmly negative, which should serve as a sign that investor sentiment reflects economic reality.

We therefore kick off 2023 with a list of our high conviction investment ideas, with an eye on value: In the very short term, we look to protect capital in defensive areas of the stock market until a recession is well advanced. Looking further out into 2023, we expect conditions to be in place to be able to shift capital to select higher beta companies once the Fed reaches the end of its tightening campaign.

Idea #1: Long Energy Efficiency

Within the energy sector, we expect energy efficiency plays to outperform in 2023. Oil prices will be volatile, while companies involved in renewable energy production are often growth-oriented and highly sensitive to the interest rate backdrop, which we expect will continue to be a headwind for now. In contrast, many energy efficiency companies, e.g. companies that manufacture and/or provide solutions such as heat pumps, HVACs, and smart metering, tend to have low P/Es and trade as value stocks.  

Energy efficiency is one of only a few areas that are well-supported by fiscal policy in 2023. According to the IEA, over half of OECD countries have generous subsidies for heat pumps and other energy-conserving products, with the RePower EU plan among the most ambitious; the EU must double the current roll-out rate in the next five years if its heat pump targets are to be achieved. In the U.S., the Inflation Reduction Act also provides significant support for heat pumps, offering subsidies up to $14, 000 per household.

The following companies have strong sustainability characteristics on an operational basis (i.e. ESG), provide excellent energy efficiency solutions, and are in good financial health: Carrier, Johnson Controls, Nibe, and Trane Technologies.

Idea #2 An ESG Comeback: Short Greenwashers

Events in 2022 sparked a necessary shakeout for “ESG” and responsible investment. Although recent focus has been on the asset management industry, these debates have been helpful at shining a spotlight on all false claims whether they be at the investment or corporate level.

Companies that embellish their sustainability credentials risk being punished in this environment, since reputational risk affects stock price performance.

We suggest two trades for 2023, based on the concept of “go long sustainability” and “short greenwashing”. Incidentally, in both cases, our short candidates are not only viewed as potential sustainability fraudsters, but their dubious use of financial engineering is also a major investment risk:

On the opposite end of the spectrum, Svenska Cellulosa merits its reputation as one of the most sustainably managed forest companies in Europe. As an integrated industrial business, they aim to maximize the possible value in the forest and from the forest; wood pellets are a by-product from production of other wood products, helping the company achieve a recycled waste-total waste ratio of 96% (!) and underscoring the company’s effectiveness at maximizing the value of the entire forest.

Idea #3: Switch from Illiquid Alternatives to Liquid Alternatives

Money poured into the illiquid alternative space over the past decade. However, investors should never forget that liquidity has a price and you pay for it with a premium over publicly traded investments.

While the rise in interest rates last year created havoc in bonds and public equities, many illiquid alternative funds (PE, real estate, infrastructure, etc.) actually reported gains for the year, despite many of the underlying assets being highly interest rate sensitive. The best example is private real estate funds compared to publicly traded real estate investment trusts: both essentially hold the same assets, yet private real estate funds were up 5-10% while real estate investment trusts were down 20-25%. Unless bonds and stocks recover quickly, this is an unsustainable practice: smoothing out returns and locking in clients by limiting redemptions is a recipe for disaster.

We look at private assets under one of our investable sustainability themes: Building Better Markets. The opacity of private asset investment vehicles and, in many cases, the way they have been sold to investors is a dangerous practice.

We believe poor returns are in store for private investments since these products will need to be marked down over the next three years to progressively absorb the new valuation reality. If it is possible to redeem, investors would be better served by 3-year certificate of deposits yielding close to 5% or liquid alternatives like hedge funds that are marked to market, have attractive investment opportunities in a changing investment landscape and can benefit from a higher volatility regime that is likely to persist for the next 3 years.

Idea #4: Build Back Better With Industrial Automation

In the latter half of 2023, if recession risks wain and signs of a new bull market appear, we will advocate for beginning to reallocate to growth opportunities, starting with the industrial sector. Especially in the U.S., bipartisan support for recapturing manufacturing prowess will provide a favorable backdrop for upgrades to existing factories and the construction of new ones. Given the combination of reshoring and a structural labor shortage, we anticipate a boon in industrial automation. The benefits of automation include improved resource efficiency (optimized water, waste and energy management) and better safety. Two names on our radar are: Rockwell Automation and Emerson Electric.

Rockwell is the largest pure play in industrial automation and is also recognized as a leader in sustainability (CSRHub overall rank of 94 and listed on Barron’s 100 Most Sustainable Companies). In 2021, Rockwell’s energy efficiency related products were responsible for over one quarter of revenues. Emerson Electric also counts energy efficiency among its solutions. The company serves industries (such as energy, life sciences and food and beverage) that are key to a low-carbon, high-care economy and is diversified across both automation and commercial HVAC solutions. We find this especially beneficial from an investment perspective, given that the company is the intersection between two highly investable 2023 themes: energy efficiency (see idea #1) and automation. Though currently expensive, investors should look for buying opportunities later in the year.

Idea #5: Opportunities in EM

Similar to Idea #4, we expect that later in 2023, there will be scope for a change in leadership between EM and DM. Historically, the U.S. business cycle leads the rest of the world by about six months, since U.S. consumption is a major source of demand for much of the world's export. 

It is therefore premature to expect emerging markets stock outperformance in the near term. We have articulated in prior research why we are hesitant investors in China (for example, please see Chinese Capitalism’s Long March, September 29, 2021; we continue to believe that the country is extremely challenging for international investors that focus on sustainability, given an unpredictable regulatory backdrop and overall opacity in the country. That said, many emerging markets – as well as the companies that make up their stock markets – have historically healthy debt profiles and excellent growth prospects, yet are still trading at crisis-level valuations. Some tailwinds that may develop in 2023 include manufacturing revivals in some markets from “China plus one” strategies related to supply chains, exposure to the commodity cycle, as well as favorable political cycles in some pockets. Opportunities in EM for sustainability-minded investors are a key topic that we intend to explore further in 2023, stay tuned.

Idea #6: Structural Long in Transition Metals

Long-time readers of our work will note that we have been recommending positions in transition metals for quite some time and believe that an overweight allocation to these metals will be profitable on a structural basis. To be sure, higher metal prices are incongruent with our forecast for recession and we would not be surprised to see prices soften in the short-to-intermediate term. However, the long-term outlook for transition materials and metals is extremely bullish. Our preferred investments focus on sustainable miners and high-tech recyclers such as Umicore and Boliden. We believe that resource scarcity, the regulatory backdrop, as well as national energy and security policies of various nations will largely benefit these companies.

Sustainable Japan

Japanese culture thrives on common goals that naturally result in sustainable behavior. Their geographic location and difficult access to natural resources help explain the attention put on waste minimization and efficient water use and makes it one of the most resource-efficient nations in the world.

In our previous note of April 14, 2022 titled: “Circular Economy: when going around in circles is the right thing to do”, we referred to the 9R framework that applies within the general behavior of Japanese society. The table below describes the 9R.

We expect that many Japanese companies are well-positioned to benefit from a global shift towards sustainability, as well as a re-ordering in supply chains and a relative improvement in demographics.

To analyze the relative sustainability of Japanese companies, we took the SMS Investment Universe (Long-Only) and compared the percentile rank of Japanese companies to the rest of our investment universe. On average, their sustainability rank for Japanese companies is better than the rest of the universe.

With a Little Help From My Friends

The trend towards trading with allies and the need for environmental improvements will favor certain sectors of the economy. For those, like us, who believe that companies providing solutions to protect the environment will emerge as winners; with greater revenue potential and fiscal policy support, there are many under-the-radar, investment opportunities in Japan. We expect friend-shoring in this space should favor certain companies that we have identified in the table below.

Thematic Winners

Of SMS’ six investable themes (achieving the energy transition, protecting natural capital, making supply chains more resilient, leaving no person behind, building better markets and productivity with purpose), Achieving the Energy Transition and Protecting Natural Capital are the most closely associated with environmental improvement. In the following table, we list financially attractive Japanese companies according to their SMS thematic exposure. We will explore each name in greater financial detail in the second half of the note.

Better Labor Force Ratios Than Germany

Declining population in Japan is a well-chronicled phenomenon. As seen in the chart below, the ratio of incoming workers (15-19) compared to future retirees (60-64) has been dropping since 1950. The number of new entrants in the workforce peaked in 1966 with an echo in 1989 coinciding with the top of the Nikkei index. In 1997, the ratio of incoming workers to future retirees dropped below the replacement level of 1. It bottomed at 0.58 in 2011 and has been rising since, reaching a peak of 0.78 in 2020 but is forecasted to decline for the rest of this decade. More retirees than new entrants in the workforce is an issue in many developed markets as well as China.

Culminating in the 1980’s, Japan was a big export machine: more entrants in the workforce compared with retirees meant that a large workforce supported greater production. But in recent decades, to adapt to its smaller workforce, Japanese companies have moved production sites closer to the global demand for products. The best example of this is car manufacturers such as Toyota that design their cars in Japan but produce them elsewhere. Japan is also a leader in robotics that can counter/supplement a lack of labor. Contrary to many other countries, Japan developed ways to cope with a declining labor force without generating inflation.

The theory used to be that ageing demographics are deflationary due to falling demand. This proved true for Japan since 2000 when globalization was a strong force lowering prices. Globalization brought abundant, cheap labor from China, and the country became the manufacturer of choice for the world. Moreover, globalization reduced friction and kept commodity prices low because you could locate them anywhere in the world and get them shipped easily. The forces of cheap labor, cheap commodities and low friction have probably peaked and could reverse. Recent labor shortages are causing a new theory to emerge whereby when the replacement ratio of new entrants to new retirees is below 1, it is considered an inflationary tailwind due to potential wage increases instead of deflationary from a drop in demand.

The picture below highlights the relative situation of Germany, Japan and the United States in terms of employee replacement ratios since 1950. A few interesting observations from the data: natality rates in Germany were low during and after WWII, whereas in Japan, low natality rates were relatively short-lived. In America, the decline in birthrates was not observed at all. Since 2010, both Germany and Japan have a ratio below 1 and it is likely to remain that way at least until 2030. The United States is in an advantageous position with a ratio around 1. Currently, Japan is in a better relative position than Germany, so wage inflation could be less of an issue in Japan because they have experience with the problem.

No Refunding Hit From Higher Rates

The long period of deflation and the ability to deal with more retirees than entrants in the workforce is allowing the Japanese central bank to remain very accommodative and maintain its yield curve control program. From a refunding cost perspective (i.e. when companies that have issued debt retire outstanding callable bonds and replaces them with lower-rate new bonds) this is a big advantage for Japanese companies. The table below shows different points on the yield curve for the G7 countries. Japan is clearly the outlier with much lower rates. We expect Japan to give up its yield curve control program in the next couple of years but, if a global recession materializes and global inflation temporarily slows, they may be able to keep the program in place until at least Q2 2023.

Competitive and Cheap With Low Debt

In the graph below, we use various financial metrics to compare the seven companies that align with our environment themes to the median company in the MSCI World Index. From a profitability and growth standpoint, they look favorable.

From a competitive standpoint, the fall in real effective exchange rate should help. The graph below highlights its improved competitiveness.

Below, we examine valuation and leverage. The conclusion is the same: our seven Japanese companies trade at compelling valuation with less demanding debt servicing relative to the MSCI world median company and cheaper valuation with less competition from bonds in Japan compared to other countries, which should help Japanese companies rerate.