You probably remember Miss Materiality from our December 2022 note: Miss Materiality’s Night Out: A Lesson in Consumer Choice and our August 2023 note: Miss Materiality’s Summer Vacation. She is back for a third year, this time, at the grocery store. In 2022, right after the pandemic, she just wanted to go out. Last year, she wanted to get away. This year, she is concerned about meeting her basic needs because the reality of higher and more volatile food prices is becoming a greater preoccupation for her.

Miss Materiality has become more cost-conscious this year and this is translating to how she spends on food she cooks at home.

On her list, she has the basics that are difficult to replace, things like olive oil, milk and sugar. She needs protein: salmon, eggs, tofu and some meat and she cannot live without coffee, orange juice, bananas and chocolate. Recent sticker shock for some of these items leaves her curious about the evolution of prices over the past five years.

As can be seen from the graph below, the overall cost of her basic foodstuffs has increased, with olive oil leading the way higher, albeit milk has reverted to pre-pandemic price levels.

 

Researching the salient points for each food item (see table below), Miss Materiality notices a common theme: the impact of the weather. Olive oil and sugar price inflation is the result of supply disruptions from droughts.

For proteins, the trend toward higher prices has been volatile and she was happy to see recent price drops after massive run-ups in basic ingredients like eggs.

Traditional supply and demand factors have been at play in proteins; except for eggs where the H5N1 disease created a shortage in 2023 that is still not completely resolved.

 

Miss Materiality noticed large price moves for the things she loves most. The cost of cocoa is a relatively small portion of the price of chocolate bars but with cocoa price shooting up in recent years, chocolate bars have followed suit with, higher prices per gram.

From a nutrients and calorie perspective, her other favorite snack, bananas, are cheaper than other fruits and have remained so for many years. Miss Materiality was wondering why and she found that bananas are produced in many countries. India, China and Indonesia are the top 3 producers but they have large populations to feed. The top exporters are in Latin America: Ecuador, Costa Rica, Colombia and Guatemala. Other reasons for the low prices of bananas are the fact they are picked green and ripen during their transportation, the trees are perennials and there is a strong global system for bananas. In other words, diverse geographic crop location and ease of transport makes bananas one crop that is relatively insulated from many of the major threats of global food supply disruption. That’s a good thing for Miss Materiality!

Just like for the basics, Miss Materiality realized that the weather played a significant role in the prices of indulgence items. For some of her other favorites like coffee and orange juice, weather and diseases – both directly linked to climate change – are creating episodic shortages that drive prices higher.

 

These price surges underscore that concentration of production is a major consideration in food supply chains. Theoretically, food items that are produced in only a few countries are at greater risk of supply disruption from the weather, local diseases or internal politics leading to export bans. In the chart below, Miss Materiality shows the share of global production of her grocery items by the top 5 and top 10 producing countries. She posits that those with the lowest concentration have a reduced risk of supply shortages. This is consistent with preceding charts, where the price of bananas and milk are the only prices that fell during the period (both have among the lowest concentration of production). Eggs are the exception to the assertion that low concentration reduces the risk of shortages which is explained by the effects of H5N1, a global disease.

 

Since Miss Materiality is doing as much as she can to adapt to higher food prices, she wonders if her investments could compensate for those higher costs. The map below shows the publicly-listed companies with strong sustainability practices that she could potentially invest in. For salmon, Mowi has strong sustainability practices and is a relatively low-cost producer. For soybeans which get transformed into tofu, House Group Food fits the bill. Adecoagro scores highly for a sugar producer, while JDE Peets is a positive standout for coffee and tea that is on pace to have 100% of its tea and coffee certified as responsible this year. For orange juice and olive oil, she did not find interesting candidates. For cocoa and meat, she cannot find attractive long candidates; she has a negative view on Mondelez, Tyson Foods and JBS. For eggs and bananas, she found four companies: Vital Farms, Cal Maine, Dole and Fresh Del Monte.

 

From an investment perspective, we agree with Miss Materiality that it is better to own low-cost producers in a concentrated industry where one can benefit from shortages. From that standpoint, MOWI, House Food Group, JDE Peets and Adecoagro are companies that are likely to benefit should a shortage occur in a related foodstuff. The chart below shows financial ratios for the companies mentioned above, with Cal-Maine and Adecoagro having the most attractive historical financial ratios. Miss Materiality is not surprised to see a company from an emerging market country, Adecoagro, in a concentrated industry with attractive financial ratios. Emerging markets have lagged developed markets over the last 15 years.

In terms of helping farmers and finding solutions that mitigate climate change risks with the view to stabilize prices, Miss Materiality found four leading irrigation companies with the greatest irrigation revenues as shown on the map below. Irrigation is key because droughts and excess heat can ravage crops. Miss Materiality could not believe that both, Valmont Industries and Lindsay Corporation are based in the home of Warren Buffett, Omaha, Nebraska.

Companies heavily involved in irrigation have comparable financial ratios, with the exception of Orbia Advance Corporation from Mexico, another company that operates in an emerging market. Note also that Orbia has a smaller exposure to irrigation compared to other companies in the chart. Beyond irrigation, Orbia is involved in other aspects of the chemical product industries.

 

The chemical industry is low on the list of what comes to mind for sustainable investors. It is generally considered to be among the largest sources of industrial greenhouse gas emissions, with steel and cement being the other major contributors. The chemical industry is complex, covering a wide variety of processes and applications that are present in nearly 95% of manufactured products. As an industry with a tight regulatory framework and large emissions, it is devoting significant efforts to reduce its carbon footprint.

The industry is divided into four major categories: commodity chemicals, fertilizers, industrial gases, and specialty chemicals. In this note, we start at the base and focus on commodity chemicals which encompass petrochemicals and inorganic commodities.

 

Chemicals Outlook

The overall outlook for the chemical industry is one that is intimately tied to the state of global manufacturing. The chart below shows that global manufacturing is starting to recover after more than a year of slow manufacturing activity.

To identify investment ideas, we focused more on the operational performance of companies than their products. The list of end-products produced from chemicals is vast, making it difficult to narrow down a company to a single product. The purpose of this note is to guide sustainability-minded investors through this sector to make more informed investment decisions mainly based on operational performance.

 

Commodity Chemicals

 Commodity chemicals remain at the bottom of the chemical product value chain. Compared to more complex sectors of the chemical industry like industrial gases and specialty gases, technical barriers to entry are low and differentiating factors are smaller.

There are two types of commodity chemicals: petrochemicals and inorganic chemicals. Polyvinyl chloride (PVC) is a combination of the two. In our search for companies, we included PVC in the petrochemical segment.

Petrochemicals are obtained through the process of refining oil, they are fossil fuel-based products.  Their most common use is as plastic in packaging and containers. Though plastic packaging can draw the ire from environmentalists, a lack of good alternatives means they do have a role to play in preserving food, among other uses (see notes A Reality Check about Plastic Fantasies, April 21, 2023 and Good Things Come in Minimal Packaging, May 16, 2024).

Inorganic commodities are co-products from the chlor-alkali process. This process is very energy-intensive, accounting for about 40 to 50% of manufacturing costs. There are two main products: chlorine and sodium hydroxide. Chlorine is a disinfectant, a solvent and is used in solar panels and PVC. Sodium hydroxide, also known as caustic soda, is a cleaning agent commonly found in soaps and detergents, used as a water treatment product and in aluminum production to break down bauxite. These products have very useful applications where alternatives are limited.

 

Commodity Chemicals Outlook

 The short-term outlook for ethylene depends on the resolution path of the current oversupply; improved demand and/or shutdown of capacity. Improved demand prospects for the Chinese economy and recent capacity reduction have resulted in a recent increase in prices.

The short-term outlook for PVC is slightly better than ethylene because oversupply is not as pronounced. Just like ethylene, the recent price increases reflect improved prospects from China.

The caustic soda market is in better balance between supply and demand. This market is not as economically sensitive as ethylene which explains the less dramatic price increases observed recently.

Just like the United States, which used to be the biggest importer of energy and is now a net exporter, China was the world's largest importer of chemicals but has now become a net exporter. The significant growth in supply from China across the chemical industry is transforming the landscape.

The price and proximity of energy determines where commodity chemicals are produced. The shale revolution and the war in Ukraine have put significant pressure on European plants. The shale revolution improved access to petroleum in the United States with very cheap prices relative to other jurisdiction for natural gas. The war in Ukraine deteriorated access to cheap Russian energy for European chemicals company. As a result, many chemical producers are curtailing their operations in Europe. Higher cost of production and lower prospects for increasing demand from Europe are the driving force behind those shutdowns.

 

Petrochemical Companies

To find the most attractive companies within ethylene and PVC from a long and short perspective, we constrained our analysis to a minimum market capitalization of 1B$ and at least 30% of revenues from plastic resins and materials manufacturing industry. We use the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) materiality framework to identify key issues such as GHG emissions, hazardous waste management, and safety & environmental stewardship of chemicals. To rank the companies within the industry we referred to their CSRhub scores for energy and climate change, and resources management and evaluated the number and importance of recent safety controversies to assess safety aspects.

The following table provides a ranking of petrochemical producers based on their percentile score in energy and climate change, resource management, and safety controversies.

Despite its top ranking, we decided to exclude Daicel Corp from long opportunities as it is also the leading Japanese producer of materials used in cigarette filters, as we try to avoid exposure to the tobacco industry.

We also excluded Alfa SAB de CV from short opportunities despite its bottom ranking because of conflicting signals: Alfa operates in the petrochemical and synthetic fibers industry (polyester, plastics, and chemicals), its petrochemical segment – Alpek - was spun off and is now a public company. Alpek has high CSRHub rankings and still represents 40% of the market capitalization of Alfa.

The two long opportunities derived from our analysis are Shin-Etsu Chemical and Covestro given their strong operational scores in high materiality elements of the business. Westlake and EMS-Chemie are short opportunities, especially given their poor operational scores, but also because of the concerns raised about Westlake's safety practices following the plant explosion at their Louisiana facility.

Inorganic Companies

To select companies in the inorganic chemical industry, we used the same methodology as for petrochemicals.

Based on our analysis, we identified 2 long opportunities, Tata Chemicals and Tokai Carbon, and 2 short opportunities, Genesis Energy and Olin Corp.

Finally, we looked at financial ratios to determine the most attractive long and short for each of petrochemicals and inorganics. From the graph below, we see that Shin-Etsu has good margins, strong growth, decent valuation and no debt whereas EMS-Chemie has similar margins with no debt but much lower growth and much higher valuation. For inorganics, Tokai Carbon has high margins, strong growth, decent valuation and no debt whereas Genesis has low margins, low growth, high valuation and a high debt load.

It is not hyperbole to say that there is a packaging waste crisis underway. Plastic packaging pollution is by far and away the biggest problem, but virtually all packaging materials have some associated environmental challenges.

For investors, packaging is considered a defensive sector, given the industry’s link to the stability of the consumer staples and healthcare sectors. The bulk of packaging companies have a beta of 1 or less. However, this “boring” backdrop masks key risks and opportunities in the industry, virtually all driven by environmental concerns. This makes the packaging industry a more exciting investment opportunity than what first meets the eye.

Overview of the Packaging Industry

Packaging is used to wrap and protect all sorts of goods, virtually everything that is sold to consumers has some sort of packaging or labelling, meaning that container and packaging companies are a key cog in all consumer discretionary and staples companies. Their presence is most ubiquitous in the food, beverage and healthcare industries. Indeed, according to SASB, packaging is a material topic primarily for consumer staples but also consumer discretionary-related companies; the table below describes packaging’s relevance for all industries whereby SASB deems it to be a material topic. 

In recent years, the shift toward e-commerce has provided a major increase in demand for packaging materials related to shipping (cardboard boxes and envelopes), while the COVID pandemic saw a surge in protective plastic packaging that has been slow to fade. However, the largest driver of change for the next several years is the desire by both consumers and regulators to reduce the environmental degradation caused by packaging. The 2023 Buying Green Report from Trivium Packaging released in conjunction with Earth Day, showed that of the over 9,000 consumers surveyed across different continents, 82% were willing to pay more for sustainable packaging, and 59% were looking at information on recyclability or sustainability when buying a product. Moreover, the Plastic Pollution Coalition, tracks over 1200 (!) plastic laws worldwide, many of which have come into force in the past five years. Not surprisingly, most of the packaging companies we track acknowledge escalating regulatory risks with regard to reducing packaging pollution.

From a sustainability perspective, there is no doubt that plastic packaging gets the worst (w)rap by far. After all, packaging accounts for about 36% of all plastic produced, according to the United Nations, and 85% of it ends up in landfills. Even in industries like fresh food packaging, where there is some justification for the use of plastic packaging to prolong shelf life and avoid bacterial contamination, overuse is preponderant.

Plastic and paper account for almost 80% of all packaging. Metal and glass are often touted as superior eco-friendly packaging options because they are infinitely recyclable. However, glass is heavy, meaning that transportation costs and related emissions are significantly higher than for plastic. Metal has similar constraints. Paper and cardboard are recyclable, albeit not infinitely (fibres become too short to adhere to each other after the fifth or sixth use) and their uses are not as universal as plastic (it is not waterproof or airtight). The reality is that there are no miracle substitutes to plastic packaging without introducing major changes to consumer behaviour (and costs).

It is also significant that despite some packaging being more recyclable, it does not mean that it is actually recycled to its potential. Recycling rates vary by material, about 5% for plastic, 30% to 40% for glass and metal, and about 60% for paper. And for all the talk about moving away from plastic, nothing has changed in terms of the composition of packaging waste; according to EU data, the relative share of plastic, metal and paper in packaging waste of has remained unchanged in the past decade.

Each of the prevalent packaging materials have their flaws, but they remain essential in meeting the demands of the market as there are no other scalable alternatives. Understanding the pros and cons for their use is crucial to assess their sustainability, as highlighted in the table below.

Investment Opportunities

Given the less than stellar reputation of packaging, it’s tempting to want to divest or short the entire industry! However, we desperately need solutions. After all, packaging is necessary to protect goods, preserve food, and deliver medicines.

Since packaging materials have different properties, and none are a perfect substitute for another, finding best-in-class investment opportunities from a sustainability perspective is a superior investment approach than simply excluding or divesting from packaging.

For this reason, we find it compelling to create long/short strategies with industry leaders and laggards, promoting packaging companies with innovative solutions while punishing those that continue to contribute to the packaging crisis. In addition, not all clients are considered equal: packaging companies that address essential needs like food and pharma should be more appealing to investors concerned with sustainability than companies addressing more discretionary goods such as alcoholic beverages.

 

To find packaging pair trades, we do the following:

The following summary table highlights key data from our approach described above:

Results

Based solely on controversies and poor CSRHub scores, the following companies are “short” candidates in our packaging universe: Silgan Holdings, Nine Dragons Paper and Winpak. Of the remaining companies that are free of controversies and rank in the top quartile operational scores, we add Berry Global to our short candidate list: this plastic packaging producer is a supplier across consumer discretionary and staples that shows little interest in adapting its business model to the environmental reality of plastic. With less than 1% of revenues invested in research and development, we expect this company will find it difficult to pivot away from problematic plastics.

Second, our analysis uncovers a list of packaging companies that are difficult to get excited about; we take these companies as “neutral”. In many instances, these are companies that operate in highly recyclable markets — either glass or metal packaging — but their main clients are either beverage companies or consumer discretionary industries. Take Verallia as an example: this 100% recyclable glass company is free from controversy and delivers respectable CSRHub scores, but almost three quarters of its product is used for…alcoholic beverages.

Finally, our third list contains packaging companies that are free from controversy, display good operational performance and tend to serve important end markets like food and pharmaceuticals. We do not exclude plastic companies, though we note that Amcor, Avery Dennison and Aptar are the only packaging companies that derive significant revenues from plastic that make our list. In recent years, Amcor has been consistently recognized by its peers for sustainable packaging innovation in both plastic and paper. Avery Dennison primarily makes product labels, an essential component of all packaging, regardless of material. Other companies that sustainability investors can be excited about are primarily in the paper industry, such as Graphic Packaging and Sonoco Products. We note that WestRock – a maker of corrugated paper and fibre packaging initially fulfilled our criteria as a potentially sustainable packaging company, but the announced takeover by Smurfit Kappa calls for caution. Smurfit Kappa is an integrated paper packaging company that is rife with environmental controversies, especially related to their Latin American forestry holdings.

Interestingly, we note that the companies we are most inclined to support tend to be more frequently included in Article 9 funds, i.e. funds that, according to the EU taxonomy, have sustainable investment as their objective. Very few packaging companies that use plastics are included in Article 9 funds, but we note that metal, glass and paper packaging companies appear frequently, irrespective of what the packaging is used for.

Recent news about carbon sequestration projects is yet another demonstration of the gyratory nature of carbon markets – at least in the voluntary sector. The first one is encouraging as it highlights recent developments in Brazil where some farmers are accepting to replant trees in lieu of grazing land for cattle. On the flipside, in Alberta, Shell is in the middle of a major mishap along with the provincial government regarding its carbon credit scheme, where millions of “phantom” carbon credits were sold to other oil sands polluters thanks to the generous “capture 1 tonne, get 2 credits” program. And how could we not mention the ongoing debate within the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) regarding their recent policy shift to allow companies to use carbon credits for offsetting Scope 3 emissions has certainly stirred considerable discussion within the sustainable finance community.

Today’s note reviews recent developments in compliance – or regulated carbon markets – which still offers the best play for carbon-savvy investors in our opinion. Second, we look at Voluntary Carbon Markets (VCM) and various Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) techniques, which in some cases can offer high-risk high-reward VC-like investment opportunities.

 

Regulated Carbon: Looking for its Next Leg of Growth

A first look at EU and North America carbon futures’ prices shows that some sort of continental rift has appeared between the two regions these past few months.

In Europe, the market has been affected by lower-than-average electricity consumption due to softer industrial production, which typically puts a ceiling on carbon prices. Conversely, the resiliency of the U.S. economy and its current “industrial resurgence” supports carbon prices in regulated markets such as Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) and Quebec-California cap-and-trade scheme.

Furthermore, taking a longer-term view on the European economy, the possible demise of Germany’s industrial sector will surely negatively impact carbon prices. A decline in this industrial powerhouse would mean even less demand for commensurate carbon credits within the EU. Meanwhile, in North America, it is the political backdrop that remains the biggest risk for regulated carbon markets – although key players like Québec and California show no sign of walking away from the cap-and-trade scheme. Moreover, the State of New York is looking to launch its own cap-and-trade program which could one day join the Western Climate Initiative (WCI). That said, we continue to favor the North American market over the EU as we view that U.S./Canadian federal-level political risk as less of a concern than muted industrial activity in Europe.

 

A Voluntary Mess?

The voluntary carbon market (VCM) occupies a curious position of both promise and caution. On one hand, the VCM's potential is underscored by the substantial demand from global corporations eager to mitigate their environmental impact through carbon offsets. However, the market's expansion has not been as rapid or robust as some proponents of the VCM might suggest. It's both surprising and expected; surprising because of the undeniable corporate demand, and expected due to persistent concerns that cast long shadows over the market.

The 2023 State of the Voluntary Carbon Markets report by Ecosystem Marketplace highlights a telling stagnation: the price of carbon offset credits in 2022/2023 mirrors those of 2008, accompanied by only a modest increase in trading volume over the same period. These figures suggest that while the VCM could be a pivotal tool in our climate response toolkit, it still struggles to escape the perception that it is more of a future promise than a present solution. We can almost say that VCM is the carbon solution of tomorrow, and might always be!

 

Other Solutions Exist (for Those with Deep Pockets)

For those who want to avoid the credibility, transparency and permanence issues that comes with lower quality forest projects, there are options. The carbon dioxide removal (CDR) space is rich in options, for those ready to pay the rich price! Compared with the average forestry carbon credit price for 2022/2023 according to Ecosystem Marketplace, the other CDR options are 5 to 140 times more expensive!

Interestingly, the demand for high-quality CDR credits such as Direct Air Capture (DAC) currently outpaces the offer of such credits, which is creating a rapidly growing market and VC-like investment opportunities.

Investing in DAC is not for the faint of heart, however. With DAC credit prices over $700 per tonne, we are still far from commercial viability, and it is difficult to see a time when it will be. In our opinion, it is likely to remain a niche market for the carbon removal purists.

Among the other CDR technologies, biochar is gaining global recognition as a potentially more effective carbon solution compared to direct air capture (DAC) for several reasons. Firstly, the production of biochar through pyrolysis not only captures carbon but also returns nutrients to the soil, improving soil health and agricultural productivity. This dual benefit enhances the sustainability and economic viability of biochar as a carbon solution.

Moreover, biochar can be produced using organic waste materials, making it a form of waste-to-value technology that contributes to circular economy principles. This use of readily available biomass can significantly reduce the operational costs associated with capturing and storing carbon when compared to DAC technologies, which require large amounts of energy and sophisticated infrastructure.

Despite their environmental benefits, biochar start-ups often lag behind direct air capture (DAC) in terms of early-stage financing. This discrepancy may stem from the perceived “unsexyness” and complexity of biochar solutions by non-technical investors. Unlike DAC's more straightforward, large-scale mechanical processes – often likened to giant vacuums – biochar and biocarbon involve nuanced biochemical processes, soil enrichment, and pyrolysis and plasma technologies which can be more challenging to quantify and explain in investment pitches. In our opinion, this could be a better CDR solution for investors to get behind considering that the space is not as crowded, the economic case is better, and the environmental benefits are greater.

Record temperatures for sea and air surface are continuing in 2024 after a record 2023. Due to above normal sea surface temperatures and expected La Niña conditions, a busy hurricane season is expected this summer; warm water adds more energy to the tropics and La Niña1 usually reduces vertical wind shear that lets hurricanes come to shore. These factors are supporting forecasts for more than twenty named storms in the Atlantic Basin to occur in 2024. The presence of warm water earlier in the year has the potential to advance and extend the period of intense hurricanes that causes the most damage.

Longer term, warmer temperatures should increase the frequency of consequential weather events from high winds. Higher sea surface temperature also has the potential to increase flooding.

These consequential weather events have implications all across our built environments. Instead of measuring physical risks, we identified four equity investment plays that are leveraged to climate adaptation: residential rebuild, electric connections, electricity grid buildout and engineering services.

From the household sector, residential repairs and more construction activity will increase demand for all sorts of building supplies such as lumber, plywood, shingles, roofing panels, windows, doors, etc.

From corporations and governments, infrastructure repairs and resiliency improvements are necessary. In a note on April 4: “From Gridlock to Grid Smart: AI’s Role in Electricity Efficiency”, we argued that greater electricity demand will bring further strains on the grid. Indeed, there are already supply chain issues for switchgear and other electrical components, but destructive weather is likely to supercharge this demand.

In this note, we focus on building materials, grid connections, grid buildout and design. The table below lists companies and their respective products. Among the companies listed, only a few, mention climate change as a potential source of activity: Owens Corning highlights that 16% of its roofing business comes from climate events, Stella Jones highlights fire-resistant wrap utility poles as a strong growth driver and all of the engineering firms discuss climate change as a source of growth in revenues. The other companies on the list focus on residential construction. We believe that all the firms on the list could benefit from a busy hurricane season.

The chart below highlights a few public companies likely to benefit from increased demand from hurricanes this year and a more volatile climate in the future. These companies have been identified due to the likelihood of higher revenue streams associated with building reconstruction. These companies are characterized by decent margins, strong sales growth and reasonable valuations.

The next chart shows a few companies with products and solutions such as switchgear, structural connectors, cable and wire baskets that will be needed for infrastructure. Strong demand for their products, good margins with commensurate valuation metrics make them interesting investment opportunities. Simpson Manufacturing just reported its Q1, 2024 results and its price fell by 10% because construction activity was weaker than expectations. This could just be a temporary drop if demand for their products recover as we anticipate. In contrast, Owens Corning just reported better earnings, in part because of weather-related replacements.

Similarly, companies involved in the expansion and repair of the grid – including wooden poles to towers - will also benefit from extreme weather-related demand. The chart below displays the financial characteristics of Valmont Industries (a company that specializes in grid infrastructure among other things) and Stella Jones, a supplier of utility poles and other wood products. These two companies have low margins, strong sales growth and relatively fair valuations.

Finally, the engineering companies that design and manage construction and reconstruction should remain very busy. The following chart shows various financial ratios for select engineering firms. From a pure financial ratio perspective, investors seem to have anticipated better times than for the other groups highlighted above since margins and sales growth are relatively low but price to earnings and price to cash flows are relatively high.

Note that relative to a U.S. equity broad benchmark, each of the groups identified has outperformed over the past two years, suggesting that investors are already excited about these plays and their prospects. If our analysis of bigger climate events is correct, further strong results will follow.

 

Note

1: La Niña is a climate pattern that describes the cooling of surface-ocean waters along the tropical west coast of South America. It is considered to be the counterpart to El Niño, which is characterized by unusually warm ocean temperatures in the equatorial region of the Pacific Ocean. In this pattern, strong winds blow warm water at the ocean’s surface from South America to Indonesia. As the warm water moves west, cold water from the deep rises to the surface near the coast of South America. La Niña has significant effects on weather and climate. It can lead to severe weather conditions, affecting sectors such as agriculture, health, water resources, and disaster management. For example, during La Niña events, southern states in the U.S. tend to experience drought, while the Pacific Northwest and Canada see heavy rainfall and flash flooding.

As discussed in our recent note on the implications and investment opportunities of AI for the energy sector (see From Gridlock to Grid Smart: AI’s Role in Electricity Efficiency, April 4, 2024), AI has the potential to severely disrupt most of the themes that are dear to sustainability-minded investors. This week, we continue on the AI theme by focusing on other environmental subsectors – waste and water management – to identify the winners of the AI revolution in these two subsectors.

In order to find potential winners of the AI revolution, we looked for firms that have been discussing AI-related concepts in transcripts and disclosures as well as firms that have been aggressively investing through AI-related acquisitions, R&D budget, and Capex spending.

The most AI-vocal sector in transcripts and company disclosures is, to no one’s surprise, Technology. However, as the internet revolution in the early 2000s showed us, the next wave of AI-related return on investment might come from the application in other sectors of the economy, not the hardware itself. From that perspective, the industrials sector is punching above its class when it comes to the share of AI mentions relative to its weight in the global equity indices.

More specifically, AI mentions in transcripts and disclosures of companies that are part of our proprietary SMS Environmental Solutions universe (400 global companies) have been rapidly increasing over the past five years, demonstrating an interest in AI solutions for the environmental sector. Let’s dive a little deeper in a few of these sub-sectors.

How AI Is Sorting Out Waste Management

In a previous note (see Trash Talk: Turning Waste into Money Makers, February 15, 2024), we discussed how the waste management sector, both municipal and industrial, has been struggling to increase its recycling rate for technical and economic reasons. The reality is that traditional sorting methods rely heavily on manual labor, leading to challenges such as human error and higher processing costs. There are a few different ways AI and machine learning can support waste management companies.

For instance, AI can help waste management companies analyze data about the place and time of waste generation to optimize pick-up schedules. But the most promising and impactful application is likely to be in optimizing waste flow monitoring, where autonomous robots use visual sensors and advanced operational skills to sort and classify waste. Optimization can easily increase material recovery rates by up to 40%, therefore lowering labor and disposal costs by 40-60%.

All major waste management companies have started to mention their interest in AI-powered sorting robots, but two companies also have the investments and partnerships to back it up.

Republic Services (RSG US) has quietly started to integrate an AI-enabled operating system for material recycling facilities (MRFs) in some of its new plants. The RecycleOS technology is provided by EverestLabs, a privately owned start-up. It allowed them to reopen their “Next-Gen” recycling facility in Plano, Texas (after a fire destroyed the original one) with half the labor thanks to automation and optical sorters such as those from EverestLabs.

The second waste management company making serious investments in the AI space is Tomra Systems (TOM NO). The Norwegian reverse vending machine maker recently officialized an important investment in PolyPerception, a start-up offering AI-based waste flow monitoring, to help build more efficient collection and waste sortation infrastructure. This news was welcomed by market participants, bumping Tomra’s stock price by 30% on the day of the announcement (this coincided with earnings, but the acquisition was mentioned as a positive by many analysts).

AI's Dive into Water Management

Water management, from both quality and quantity angles, is already impacting businesses’ operations and citizens’ lives every day. As per a recently released report by the WWF, the looming water crisis endangers water resources and freshwater ecosystems valued at approximately $58trn annually (a whopping 60% of global GDP!). Even if this number is grossly exaggerated, the reality is that since 1970, the world has lost one third of its remaining wetlands, while freshwater wildlife populations have, on average, dropped by 83%.

Without being the silver bullet, AI applications have significant potential to revolutionize water purification and treatment systems. For instance, AI-powered sensors can continuously monitor water quality parameters like pH, turbidity, and contaminants in real time, enabling early detection of pollution events. AI can also optimize water treatment processes by analyzing complex data to determine the most efficient and cost-effective methods, reducing chemical and energy usage. Another important application is for leak detection, where AI can analyze distribution network data to detect and address leaks promptly, thereby conserving water resources.

Once again, two companies stand out as early leaders in the water management sector. Both have invested heavily and early in AI-related IP and, ceteris paribus, should greatly benefit from these investments in the future.

First, we have Veolia Environnement SA (VIE FP), active in water management (65% of their revenue) but also in waste management (35% of their revenue), which makes it even more relevant in the context of this note. Veolia claims to be the first company to actively use AI across all its divisions via its digital solutions “Hubgrade” which enables smart monitoring of the production and consumption of their clients’ water, energy, and waste. From an operational perspective, efficiency gains increased to €350m annually thanks to AI. With over 10,000 connected sites worldwide and 500 data scientists dedicated to its digital solutions, Veolia is definitely putting its money where its mouth is when it comes to AI.

The second candidate in the water management subsector is Ecolab Inc (ECL US). The water and sanitation firm was also an early mover with regards to digitalisation of assets. Their platform, called “ECOLAB3D”, gathers over 90 billion data points annually from over 100,000 globally connected assets like cooling towers, wastewater plants, and data centers. Their Digital Technology department has over 1,000 employees and is clearly one of their growing verticals. Another related area of growth for Ecolab is their water-based cooling solution for data centers, which has been growing at over 30% year over year. Ecolab therefore has two rather than one potential growth opportunity from the AI revolution.

On September 10, 2020, around the first time when an ounce of gold traded at 2,000, we wrote a note: “Finding a place for gold in an ESG portfolio” whereby we identified sustainable companies involved in gold recycling and mining equipment. While the price of gold has traded sideways for the last three years, with the recent gold breakout to new all-time highs, we are revisiting the topic.

Gold is a scarce commodity. A cube of gold  with an edge measuring only 22 m would contain all the gold that has ever been mined! Other than its distinctive color, gold has attractive chemical properties: it is inert (does not corrode or tarnish), highly malleable and ductile (it can be stretched very thin), has high conductivity (electricity and heat) and is nontoxic (compatible with humans in medical devices or dental work).

What Is Gold Used For?

Due to the above properties, gold has been used as a medium of exchange and store of value (currency), in art (jewelry, decoration, craftmanship) and in technology (telecom, electronics, aerospace, medical devices, dentistry).

Despite having other useful applications, the main sources of demand for gold are jewelry and finance.

The image below, from the World Gold Council, shows the interaction between annual supply and demand for gold over the last 10 years. Gold supply has come mainly from new mining (75%) with the remainder sourced from recycling (25%). It is worth noting that the average annual amount devoted to functional use in technology (8%: 329 tonnes) is lower than the supply from recycling (25%: 1,172 tonnes). In other words, the quantity of gold needed for functional applications could be entirely derived from recycling.

What Are the Factors Determining the Price of Gold?

Let’s look at the supply and demand picture:

Supply: there is not a lot of gold left to mine, according to the World Gold Council, approximately 80% of identified gold reserves have already been mined leaving just 20% of tougher to access reserves, where the concentration of gold is lower. Meanwhile, recycling could bring a lot of existing gold back towards more useful endeavours. The chart below shows the main cost differences between mining and recycling. In mining, costs are associated with exploration, geology, and mining methods. Recycling involves expenses related to collection, sorting, and processing. There are other economic factors that determine the marginal cost of gold like interest rates, currency and inflation. Even with the price of gold at its historical high, gold supply is expected to experience only modest growth over the next decade given declining ore grade, higher extraction costs and stricter environmental regulations.

Demand: Gold experiences demand from various sectors, with jewelry, industry, financial products, and central banks are the primary sources.

While new supply of gold is expected to be limited, demand could increase at a faster pace from greater jewelry demand and increased industrial use. Financial product demand is a wild card; the advent of Bitcoin ETFs has taken financial flows that would normally have gone to gold (even though the gold price increased in 2023, physical gold ETF saw outflows). The most promising source of demand lies in central bank reserves that are reacting to the confiscation of Russian assets. The chart below highlights that for central banks surveyed, they expect the portion of gold in their reserves to increase (63% expect it will increase compared to 9% that believe it will decrease from the current 15%).

How to Gain Exposure to Gold?

Since the price of gold broke out to all-time highs, should a sustainable investor gain exposure through gold miners, gold royalties, gold recyclers or some form of gold bullion ownership?

Gold Miners:

The practices of gold miners have improved significantly over the years, especially for the larger firms, but many issues still exist. From an environmental standpoint, deforestation, water and air pollution, soil degradation and energy needs are all major concerns. From a social standpoint, human rights violations, health and safety, and other issues such as worker displacement, labor exploitation, and cultural disruption are worrisome. Finally, in terms of governance, challenges include corruption, lack of transparency, weak regulations, and the abuse of land and indigenous rights.

For all of these reasons, it is difficult to find long investment candidates in the mining sector from a sustainability perspective. We find it much easier to find companies to potentially short sell. Gold miners are levered to the price of gold because they have fixed costs and benefit disproportionately from higher prices. Moreover, the value of their reserves increases with the price of gold. As a result, their beta to the underlying global gold price is generally much higher than one.

Gold Royalties:

The role of royalty companies is to provide upfront financing to support initial mining costs in exchange for a percentage of the revenue generated from the sale of gold. They are exposed to the same issues as miners: instead of being the operator, they finance gold mining activities. Royalties have a lower gold beta than miners because they have lower fixed costs.

Gold Recyclers:

Considering the environmental and social damage from gold extraction, recycling offers a more sustainable option. Gold can be recycled without losing its purity, it is much less energy intensive to recycle and recycling avoids the bulk of the environmental and social risks highlighted above. Recyclers have an even lower beta to gold than royalties (less than 1).

Gold Bullion:

The sustainability argument for gold bullion is that it has already been mined. This is a weak argument in our opinion because gold mining is hard on the environment and society but some investment products, like Royal Mint’s Responsibly Sourced Physical Gold ETC, try to improve the sustainability of gold bullion by having a high percentage of recycled gold. Holding gold bullion or investment products linked to gold is not as damaging as miners or royalties, but to us, recyclers are still the most sustainable.

Which Companies Caught Our Attention?

The table below highlights gold miners with weak ESG scores versus recyclers with strong ESG scores, using CSRHub data. Barrick, B2B, Anglo and Kirkland Lake stand out as strong potential gold miner short candidates, while Sims, Umicore, Are Holdings and Johnson Matthey are potential long recyclers.

Next, from a financial perspective, the table below highlights a similarity in revenue growth over the past five years for both miners and recyclers. Valuation remains attractive for both groups, though it is worth noting that miners currently exhibit more favorable profit margins than recyclers. However, as highlighted above, 80% of identified reserves have already been mined. Given that the remaining 20% will be harder to access and yield lower concentrations of gold, miners will need to inject significant capital to explore and increase production. This will inevitably be reflected in higher capital expenditures and interest costs, thereby impacting the overall profitability of mining companies.

How Has the Gold Complex Behaved Recently?

The chart below shows an index of the four miners compared to an index of the four recyclers and the price of gold. Even if the price of gold has increased steadily since the beginning of the decade, gold miners and recyclers have struggled.

How to Position?

The resilience of the price of gold to much higher interest rates, falling inflation and reduced financial market volatility has been surprising. As we discussed earlier, physical gold ETFs saw outflows in 2023 but the main reason for gold’s resilience lies in increased central bank demand. As we have shown, most central banks expect to continue to accumulate gold in the next 5 years. Recyclers that have not yet followed the price of bullion higher should be the investment of choice for sustainable investors looking for gold exposure.

The share of consumers’ budgets dedicated to spending on food has made new multi-decade highs; in the U.S., households have not spent this much of their income on food since the 1980s. Is the long era of cheap and plentiful food behind us? We think so.

Although cyclical forces such as a tight labor market are also contributing to higher food prices, much of the increase in food costs are due to the headwinds to agricultural productivity from climate change, biodiversity loss and other environmental and social factors at a time when the global population is still growing. Indeed, these headwinds are affecting a multitude of food supply chains. Work at Ceres reveals that within each of the eight major food commodity supply chains, there exists at least one environmental or social factor considered a ‘high’ risk. This includes factors that pose threats to food production itself, as well as instances where food production contributes to environmental and social harm.

These risks are not simply theoretical and/or something to consider in the future. Take cocoa for example; West Africa produces most of the world’s cocoa, but two years of hot and dry weather have severely impacted crops; both current yields and the viability of farming in the future are at risk. U.S. cocoa futures reached a nearly fifty-year high in February!

From an environmental perspective, no food industry is more problematic than beef. Risks are rated as “high” or “medium” across all major environmental and social factors according to Ceres.

If the status quo prevails, it is likely to lead to levels of price inflation that can not be fully borne by the consumer. Put simply, industry profit margins are at risk from the environmental and social factors in the table above. In today’s note, we analyze the food supply chain of beef and cocoa. We explore how investors can both protect their capital and improve environmental and social outcomes.

What’s The Beef About Beef

The U.S. and Brazil are the largest producers of beef, accounting for one-third of global production. The main difference is that beef raised in the U.S. is primarily nourished on grains (corn, soybeans, and alfalfa), while beef produced in Brazil is mostly grassfed. In the U.S., the beef value chain has five major links:

For each stage of the beef value chain, we use public company reports and government data to estimate profit margins. The table below summarizes each stage of production and relevant characteristics.

There are two key takeaways from the table above:

Cracking the Cocoa Conundrum

Cocoa production is heavily concentrated in Ivory Coast and Ghana, which collectively account for nearly 60% of the world's production. The cocoa supply chain involves four distinct stages:

As with beef, in the table below, we use public company reports and government data to estimate profit margins and we summarize each stage of production of cocoa and provide relevant characteristics.

Again, there are two key takeaways from the table above:

Investment Implications

So far, our analysis has shown that in the two foodstuffs we analyzed, there is at least one stage in the value chain that is completely dominated by a limited number of companies. In the cocoa chain, Mondelez, Olam, Cargill, Barry Callebaut and Nestle dominate. For beef, JBS, Tyson, and Cargill dominate meat processing, while ADM, Cargill and Bunge have the stronghold on animal feed production.

The table below revisits the initial eight foodstuffs analyzed by CERES and shows that there are a handful of companies involved in ALMOST EVERY food value chain.

In other words, there are select public companies that are likely to participate in virtually every meal of the typical western diet!

At the early stages in the value chain, ADM, Cargill, and Bunge are involved in all eight foodstuffs. At the transformation stage, Nestle, Mondelez and Kellogg are each involved in at least 50% of the foodstuffs.

From a consumers’ perspective, the realization that a mere handful of companies have such dominance in what we eat can be unsettling. However, from an investor’s perspective, particularly one that is concerned with sustainability, it is clear that influencing the operations of just a handful of companies can potentially have enormous impacts throughout our food system. In other words, food is an industry whereby aggressive investor engagement, when done at key links in the value chain, can be effective by concentrating efforts on just a short list of companies.

Engagement at the Agricultural Production Stage: ADM, Bunge and Cargill

ADM, Bunge and Cargill together are the main agribusiness companies that buy, trade, process and ship agricultural commodities such as corn, soybean, palm, wheat, etc. ADM and Bunge are both listed companies while Cargill is private. Another major difference is that ADM and Bunge have similar, elevated ESG scores across all material SASB categories (energy management, water management, product quality, employee safety, supply management, materials sourcing) while Cargill is severely lagging (in 2019, it was named the worst company in the world by Mighty Earth!)

That said, all three companies have a multitude of controversies; ADM scores a D- according to Refinitiv Eikon and Bunge is not much better with a C-. Controversies range from animal testing, workplace conditions, child labor, deforestation, shareholder rights, anticompetition and more.

Engagement at the Processing & Transformation Stage: Nestlé, Olam, Mondelez and JBS

Nestlé: Nestlé demonstrates comprehensive disclosures and proactive approaches to water management, energy efficiency, and product safety, and is considered better than its peers on these topics. However, they lack disclosures on corrective audits in supply chains, GMO products, and ingredient sourcing in regions with high water stress. Furthermore, Nestlé has faced a series of recent controversies (scoring a D according to Refinitiv Eikon), including lawsuits over anti-competition practices (infant formula), allegations of illegal water bottling (California), labor disputes and working condition controversies. They have long been accused of child labor in their cocoa supply chain and following stakeholders’ pressure, they announced a US$1.4 billion investment plan in 2022 to address the issue, even though there are limitations in their ability to effectively tackle this pervasive issue.

Olam Group Ltd: Olam provides operational disclosures that are slightly behind their peers, although the good news is this company is relatively free of controversies. However, they acknowledge that child labor remains a persistent issue in cocoa production. Olam relies on a vast network of suppliers spanning over 60 countries, with a direct and indirect supply base predominantly farmed by small-scale farmers in emerging markets. While the company is aware of child labor, their efforts remain paltry: they provide training on the topic to 240,000 farmers which represents a mere 5% of all farmers they work with.

Mondelez International: Mondelez stands out not only for its operational performance but also for its product portfolio, which primarily consists of highly-processed and sugary snacks. Unlike other companies mentioned, Mondelez specializes in indulgent treats that often contain high levels of sugar, unhealthy fats, and artificial additives. This focus contributes to potential health risks such as weight gain, obesity, diabetes, and heart disease associated with excessive consumption of these products. In addition to these concerns, Mondelez, like its peers, faces regular controversies, scoring a C- according to Refinitiv Eikon, regarding product recalls, data breaches, advertisement norms violations, and child labor in its supply chain.

JBS: JBS has been long-considered a major laggard on most ESG-related issues, with particularly low scores related to working conditions, human rights and its supply chain. But the company’s controversies go even beyond these issues and include environmental scandals, child labor issues and anti-competitive behaviour (Refinitiv Eikon ratings is a D). All of these areas are ripe for investor engagement.

There is a significant perception gap between the actual operations of municipal waste management companies and the public’s perception of their environmental impact. It’s understandable that the public might view these companies as environmental saviors, given their green-themed logos and websites.

Currently, municipal waste management companies generally derive less than 10-15% of their revenue from recycling activities, with the majority (80-90%) coming from the collection and disposal of trash at landfill sites. Industrial waste management companies, however, tend to have a higher share of revenue from recycling activities, particularly in the metals and batteries sectors.

In this week’s note, we will focus on the municipal waste management companies and see if sustainability-minded investors should consider them in their portfolios.

From an investment outlook perspective, the municipal waste management sector is quite attractive. Annually, our planet generates about 2.01 billion tons of municipal solid waste (MSW), a figure expected to reach 3.40 billion in about 30 years (a 70% increase). According  to the World Bank, daily per capita waste in developed markets is expected to increase by 19%, while in emerging and frontier markets, it could rise by 40% or more.

The good news from a sustainability perspective is that the MSW business model is evolving in the right direction. A few years ago, these companies were even less involved in recycling activities, as the norm was to ship most recycling to China and other Asian countries.

As discussed in our note Somebody's Trash is Someone Else's Treasure, July 11, 2019, this situation started to change in 2018 after China stopped accepting plastic waste and other recycling materials from the rest of the world due to environmental concerns. The sudden ban – called Operation National Sword – drastically changed how plastic recycling had been handled in developing countries. Up until then, China was the final destination for half of the world’s plastics destined to be recycled. To avoid becoming large plastic dumpsites, Indonesia, the Philippines, Thailand, Malaysia and Vietnam introduced regulations to limit, if not outright ban, the import of contaminated recycled materials – a definition that de facto excludes most of what was being shipped at the time. To avoid a race to the bottom, the EU even banned the export of waste plastic to non-OECD countries. MSW companies in North America, Europe and Japan had to step up and fill the gap, which they are still in the process of doing.

Another positive change in the MSW industry is the revenue potential from renewable natural gas (RNG) and landfill gas-to-electricity (LFGTE) projects due to methane capture at landfills. Thanks to incentive programs like the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) and the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS), MSW companies can generate more revenue from environmentally-friendly activities.

The main incentive in the US is the opportunity for landfill operators to generate Renewable Identification Number (RIN) credits that can be sold to regulated entities under the RFS scheme, such as refiners. The different types of RINs (D3, D4, D5, D6) correspond to different categories of renewable fuels.

The different RIN credits have vastly different environmental credentials, and this can be reflected in their value.

Fortunately for municipal waste management companies involved in RNG production at landfills, they qualify for the highest integrity credits (D3), which carry a very lucrative price these days.

Some MSW companies have started to notice. Waste Management (WM US), for instance, will invest up to $2.9B in its recycling and renewable energy platforms through 2026. In particular, WM expects to commission five new renewable natural gas facilities by the end of the year, with 15 more in the coming years. These renewable energy investments are expected to generate over $510M in incremental operating EBITDA per year by 2026, which should surpass the company's recycling revenues.

Waste Connections (WCN CN) is also investing significantly in RNG and expects about $200M in incremental operating EBITDA per year by 2026 to come from their landfill methane capture projects, which is proportional to WM's numbers.

Republic Services (RSG US), on the other hand, seems to have chosen to focus on its advanced polymers recycling facilities, which should rapidly become a profit center as they will charge other MSW companies to process their plastics. The first Polymer Centre opened in Las Vegas in 2023, with a handful more planned in the next 5 years across the US. Contrary to WM and Waste Connections, Republic does not seem to believe in the RNG market, as they have given the operationalization of these projects to BP, only retaining a minority stake in the business.

Finally, while being slightly behind in terms of RNG projects, GFL Environmental (GFL CN) still expects about $175M in incremental operating EBITDA by 2026. In addition, another $50M to $75M is expected to come from recycling facilities in Canada as a result of the Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) regulations coming into effect in various provinces. As GFL derives almost 40% of its revenues from Canada (versus 13% for Waste Connections and 3% for WM), they are probably better protected than the others in the event of a change of tack at the White House this November – an event that would more than likely affect the subsidies currently available through the IRA and RFS programs.

 

Despite the differences in strategies and markets of these four companies, the stock performance and valuation charts show a certain homogeneity in the MSW sector. For us, picking winners will be a question of total sustainability efforts and future-proofing of the business model in case of a change in direction in Washington come this November.

In terms of total sustainability efforts, WM stands out as the company with the highest share of revenues directly linked to recycling and renewable energy projects (approximately 20% by 2026). Also, GFL Environmental, with its larger presence in Canada, could be an interesting political hedge in case some of the juicy subsidies don't survive past the next White House Administration.

2023 will surely be remembered as a year of market divergences: while global equity indexes delivered returns in the mid-teens, this masks the explosive performance of the Magnificent 7, the catastrophic year for many renewable energy plays, and much “muck” in between.

To be sure, economic and financial market performance can be chalked up to the extreme optimism surrounding artificial intelligence as well as a resilient U.S. consumer. Neither of these factors are likely to be in such force in 2024.

After all, there are signs that generative AI (i.e. models like ChatGPT) has already hit the peak in the hype cycle and is set to enter the “trough of disillusionment” (see chart below).

As for the U.S. consumer, the thick buffers in household budgets thanks to emergency COVID policy measures are wearing thin. The lag has been longer than is typical, but tight monetary policy is showing up in the form of higher consumer loan delinquency rates and less appetite for interest rate-sensitive purchases.

Our 2024 economic expectations are captured in the chart below. We expect a mild-to-average consumer-focused recession and see the balance of risks tilted toward stickier-than-expected inflation but about equal in regard to growth. Ergo, relative to current market expectations, we anticipate that policy rates will be higher for longer (we disagree with market participants that currently price a greater than  70% chance of March rate cuts). Central banks can no longer opt for aggressive accommodation at first sight of a growth slowdown due to structurally higher inflation trends.

 

If we are correct, this means that stocks are less appealing overall but the typical investment playbook for recessionary periods does need to be revised. There are sectoral implications and nuances that sustainability investors should consider:   

 

Against this backdrop, we propose five sustainability centric investment ideas for 2024.

Idea #1: Stay long green industrials, go short wasteful consumer discretionary (but mind the Presidential polls)

As noted above, the global manufacturing sector contracted all through 2023 and a major inventory destocking cycle is well advanced. On the flipside, consumers are finally showing signs of fading. Higher for longer interest rates won’t favor either sector, but fiscal firepower sits squarely in favor of the industrial sector thanks to the IRA and to a lesser degree, pro-climate policies in other countries as well. Thus, on a cyclical horizon, industrial plays, especially those that benefit from the great building green retrofit are well placed to outperform consumer discretionary sectors. On a longer-term basis, the desire to re-shore as well as greenify key infrastructure means that for the first time in decades, the industrial sector is likely to grow as a sustainable share of underlying GDP. 2024 provides a good entry point into this long-term theme. Investors looking to build positions could start with companies tied to essential goods and services.

For example, water efficiency names like Watts Water (WTS US) and Xylem (XYL US) have been moving higher but have further to go if our economic outlook is correct. On the short side, luxury “greenwashers” tend to underperform the market during recession (LVMH is a favored short candidate). Additionally, news that Shein, an ultra fast-fashion retailer is looking to go public is also exciting from the short side: we can’t wait for the shine to come off this stock after the IPO pumping hype. 

Idea #2: Selectively toe dip in Sustainable Infrastructure, Renewable Energy and Utilities

Given their high correlation to bond yields and defensive characteristics, sustainable infrastructure, renewable energy and utilities typically require policymakers to embark on a rate-cutting cycle to outperform. But some stocks in these sectors became extremely oversold in 2023. We highlight two stocks that we believe currently offer excellent value within sustainability themes benefitting from long-term tailwinds:  

Alstom: This railcar manufacturing company, while relatively unaffected by the interest rate backdrop (debt/equity ratio of 31%), has nonetheless been crushed in 2023 due to supply chain issues and project delays. This led to the company going from a healthy positive cashflow projection to negative in a span of months. In 2023, Alstom had to deal with a USD 5 Billion legacy backlog that delivered negative margins, and it also mistimed a costly inventory buildup while customers delayed desired delivery times.

We believe Alstom’s problems are largely over. Fortunately, customers are not cancelling orders, they have just been delayed: Alstom currently has USD 87 billion order backlogs, which equates to around five years worth of contracts. The company has a forward P/E of 9 and is trading at half of book value. Importantly (and unlike some U.S. wind projects that have recently been derailed), Alstom has long-term service contracts in place that are indexed to inflation.

Ameresco:  A designer of energy efficiency projects in buildings – with a high exposure to U.S. government contracts –  Ameresco should be relatively well insulated from slower economic growth. This company was mistakenly caught up in the “anything renewable” sell-off in 2023, but higher interest rates have not hindered the company’s access to financing, having secured over half a billion dollars in Q3 alone.

Ameresco has an impressive project backlog and has doubled the number of projects it was awarded over the past year. To be sure, one headline risk is a potential repeal of climate-friendly policies should Trump be elected, but even here, Ameresco is well positioned: many current and future projects focus on energy efficiency that ultimately save money.  

Idea #3: Catch the Uranium Wave

Nuclear power provides 10 per cent of the world’s electricity. Construction of nuclear reactors takes a long time (5-10 years) but offers a substantial service life advantage: twice as long as alternatives like solar panels and wind turbines. Around 60 power reactors are currently under construction (primarily in China and India), with an additional 110 reactors in the planning and 300 in proposal stages. Current capacity is 391,699 MWe while reactors under construction should add 69,599 MWe to the grid by 2030, and planned and proposed reactors could provide a combined 461,029 MWe, more than double the existing capacity. Extending the lifetime of existing nuclear power plants will also play an important role: the original design lifetime of nuclear power plants is usually 40 years but can be extended by 20-year increments. In the US, 90 percent of US plants have already been renewed to 60 years. The subsequent wave of renewals from 60 to 80 years will therefore be critical in supplying enough electricity to meet growing demand.

Even accounting for better efficiency of newer reactors, the trend of increasing global nuclear energy capacity means higher demand for uranium. To be sure, uranium demand does fluctuate with economic cycles and 2024 global recessionary conditions are a concern, but uranium supply is currently tight, even considering a potential cyclical slowdown. Alleviating supply-side constraints is not easy since mines take a long time to build and investments have been lacking after the long bear market of the 2010’s. Note that our enthusiasm for nuclear precedes the recent uranium spike; our series on this topic was launched in January 2021 (“A Radioactive Topic for ESG-Minded Investors”). Since then, uranium prices have increased significantly, but we expect we are still in the early innings. The recent commitment made at COP 28 by a group of 22 countries to triple nuclear capacity by 2050 underscores an increasing global desire for nuclear energy and the bullish sentiment around this investment.

A company like Cameco (CCO CA), which focuses on extraction of uranium ore and the production of uranium concentrate, is well positioned to capitalize on rising uranium demand. In order to be used as a fuel, however, uranium needs to be enriched. The U.S. currently imports a quarter of its enriched uranium from Russia. Enter Centrus Energy (LEU US). This company is a U.S. provider of high-assay low-enriched uranium used in most of the advanced reactor designs now under development. Being a U.S. company,  it is in an enviable position, especially since the American government has proposed legislation that would bar the importation of enriched Russian uranium.

 

Idea #4: Carbon Copies? Not Quite: The Unique Traits of NA and EU Markets

Despite being a global molecule affecting climate globally, carbon dioxide (CO2) exhibits fundamental regional differences when it comes to the tradable commodity. Depending on which version of the carbon commodity you look at, the year 2023 tells a very different story. While the EU allowances (EUAs) have lost 17% of their value, the WCI allowances (CCAs) have gained more than 32%.

What explains this? The short answer is the correlation between industrial GHG emissions and economic activity. The Eurozone economy has fared worse than the North American economy in 2023 and as a result, Europe’s industrial GHG emissions were lower than last year (about 7% according to LSEG). This is positive for the environment but translates to lower demand for EUAs. The chart below also shows the performance of the voluntary carbon market credits, aka carbon offsets. Avid SMS readers know that we are not fans of that market. The past year was filled with integrity scandals and voluntary markets should continue to be avoided.

For 2024, we remain generally bullish for most liquid regulated carbon markets (Europe’s market is about $850B per year while California-Québec is roughly $70B per year). In Europe, industrial activity is likely to remain tame, but there are other positive factors at work:

As for the California-Québec market, even though prices had a good run in recent months, there is still ample upside potential to the unit price. Currently, carbon allowances trade just above CA$52 which is already trailing its European equivalent and in addition, the Canadian Carbon Tax scheme will increase to CA$80 in 2024, leaving a comfortable gap to fill on the upside. Moreover, the State of Washington intends to join California and Québec which should be a bullish event for the CCAs.

KRBN dominates the carbon ETF market. However, this ETF is heavily skewed toward Europe (65%). For investors that prefer to build their own regional weighting, Kraneshare California Carbon Allowance (ticker KCCA) ETF provides exposure to only North American carbon, while Kraneshare European Carbon Allowance (ticker KEUA) is the European equivalent. In the current context, we suggest two-thirds allocation to North America.

 

Idea #5: Short? Affirmative!

Affirm is one of the major players in the Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) space. At SMS we have a negative view towards BNPL as it facilitates excess spending, while targeting consumers that can ill afford to do so. Affirm also ranks low on ESG scores, such as CSRHub rankings for community, employees and environment. Affirm’s share price has had a wild ride the past two years: after losing 85% of its value in 2022, the stock spent the first ten months of 2023 carving out a base. It has since shot up 100% since end-October. This recent rise was fuelled by Affirm’s better than expected Q3 earnings – i.e. less negative earnings - the headline-grabbing surge in BNPL for holiday shopping and the general risk-on rally in the stocks.

However, the BNPL model is struggling to cope with the end of ZIRP and macro headwinds on consumer discretionary spending. Affirm is projected to be unprofitable for the next five years(!) and there are other big players in the payment space that can easily take their market share (there is little brand loyalty in this industry). Affirm stock is now coming into overhead resistance above $40 and we agree with the broker consensus that the share price should be lower (we target $20). Even though short interest on the stock is high (currently 21%) that should not be a deterrent for nimble-footed sustainable investors from shorting this stock.