The anticipated surge in demand for batteries is garnering a lot of attention. China has managed to carve out a dominant position all along the battery supply chain (see also A Matter of National Security, November 3, 2022). With ambitious targets for EV adoption and as home to some of the world’s largest automakers, the U.S. and Europe are in a scramble to secure their battery supply chain. This geopolitically charged backdrop is difficult to navigate for investors as it is hard to know whether supportive policy will one day materialize into fruitful domestic production. In this note, we assess investment opportunities in three segments relating to the battery industry: materials mining, recycling, and production.
The Miners
Lithium-ion is the dominant battery type, accounting for 85% of battery capacity sold in 2021. These batteries are characterized by a cathode composed of slightly varying quantities of cobalt, nickel, manganese and lithium. Investing in the mining of these materials remains challenging from a sustainability perspective (see Transition Metals: Wicked Problem, Smart Solutions, October 14, 2021).
Cobalt is shrouded in human rights controversies; 70% of the cobalt produced comes from the Democratic Republic of Congo which holds a significant majority of the world’s reserves. Moreover, 41% of global cobalt mines are controlled by China. Neither of these countries has a strong track record on the environment or human rights.
Nickel and manganese are more abundantly available but, as a result, are predominantly sourced by large mining companies that also extract other resources, making them a controversial choice for sustainability-minded investors.
This leaves lithium. It should come as no surprise that China controls a significant portion of lithium mining as well (28%). However, it is Chile that holds the most lithium reserves globally and two non-Chinese miners with a focus on the energy transition mineral are already established there: Sociedad Quimica y Minera (SQM) and Albemarle (though it should be noted that China’s Tianqi Lithium Corp owns a 20% stake in SQM). As two of the biggest lithium miners, the future looked promising for Albemarle and SQM given the West’s objective of lowering reliance on China; but an announcement in April by Chilean president Gabriel Boric to nationalize lithium operations has brought the prospects for mining in Chile into question. Both Albemarle and SQM stocks slumped on the news but have rebounded since.
This could be seen as a win from an ESG perspective (part of the reasoning behind nationalization is to protect the environment and local communities), but how it will affect Chile’s competitiveness remains to be seen. If countries with good environmental and social standards, such as Australia, the U.S. and Canada, areincrease mining production in time to meet soaring battery demand, Chile will face intense competition. Investors should watch closely how nationalization proceeds in Chile and the pace of production at new geographic sites.
Lastly, miners also face the risk of disruption from alternative battery types. In 2022, rising material costs favoured lithium iron phosphate (LFP) battery chemistries, despite their weaker energy density (which translates to lower range for an EV). Moreover, with lithium being the most expensive mineral, China has recently made significant progress on lithium free chemistries such as sodium-ion. These two alternative battery types (LFP and na-ion) offer lower costs but are less efficient in terms of energy density; meaning there are still gains to be made in optimizing EV range. A breakthrough could cause a sudden drop in demand for certain battery materials.
The Recyclers
In contrast to mining, battery recycling is something sustainability-minded investors can certainly get behind. However, the risks facing this segment of the battery industry overlap with those in the mining segment, though stock prices of recycling companies like Umicore (UMI BB) and Li-cycle (LICY US) did not rally along with the 2022 boom in prices for battery materials (see chart below).
A shortage in supply would offer a huge tailwind for recycling, but there is contention on this subject. U.S. geological survey results (see table below) show the estimated amount of lithium reserves has doubled in the last decade. While the IEA projects a shortage of lithium, others like McKinsey see things differently. Cobalt is also looking more abundant than once thought. This has implications for both miners and recyclers who may have to cope with a ceiling on prices resulting from wider availability.
One thing favouring recycling in this context is the European Critical Raw Materials Act. While pressure to appropriately dispose of batteries at the end of their lifecycle will likely come from an increasingly environmentally conscious public, the Critical Raw Materials Act (which applies to battery minerals) has set a target that by 2030, a minimum of 15% of EU critical raw materials must come from domestic recycling sources. Action items include financial support and faster permit processing, but these may do little to help with the supply issue facing battery recyclers: a lack of batteries.
Even though EV sales are growing each year, it takes about seven years (and closer to ten years for more recent models) before the batteries are available for recycling. Hence, the recycling facilities in existence today are competing over battery scrap from the number of electric cars sold in 2016! With Europe speeding up permit processing and offering financial support, the result is a fragmented market where consolidation is likely. The few publicly traded companies that exist are small and face competition from conglomerates like BASF looking to enter the market. One company to watch is Umicore; an established metals recycler that is already known in the automotive industry, it is well suited for EV battery recycling. Umicore inaugurated Europe’s first battery factory last year and signed a contract with Canada to do the same, the company also entered a partnership with Volkswagen to support its battery needs.
The Producers
On the road to success, established battery makers appear to have the path of least resistance. The demand for ready-made batteries is not a question of “if”, but “when”. The threat of alternative batteries is somewhat mitigated since it is the composite materials rather than the battery structure (anode, cathode, electrolyte, and separator) that are most vulnerable to innovation, and this can be further offset by sufficient R&D. South Korean companies LG Energy Solutions, SK Innovation and Samsung SDI as well as Japan’s Panasonic could grab some of China’s market share (ruled by CATL and BYD) by benefitting from anti-China policies. South Korean companies could be further bolstered by their own government’s plans to support domestic battery makers.
Though a strong contender with 7% of global battery market share, SK Innovation still earns the majority of its revenues from fossil fuels. The more pure-play battery makers are found in LG (100% of revenues from batteries) and Samsung (87%) and come at higher valuations, FWD PE of 54 and 21 respectively. For staying on top of innovations, Samsung’s R&D investment of 5.3% of revenues is comparable to its Chinese counterparts CATL and BYD. LG lags with R&D at 0.1% of sales though it is a recent subsidiary of the larger LG Chem, carved out in December 2020.
The world is undergoing a major transformation as the transition to a low-carbon economy gains momentum. This shift is being driven by a range of factors, from climate change and growing public awareness of its impacts, to technological advancements and shifting economic and regulatory landscapes. As the transition progresses, it is becoming increasingly clear that the energy sector will play a critical role in shaping the future of the global economy. In this note, we review the main structural growth drivers and their anticipated effects on the energy transition as an investment theme.
Demographic Shifts Are Reshaping the Energy Landscape
The UN projects the world population to reach 9.7 billion people by 2050. This rise in population will mostly come from the middle class, which is expected to grow by 1.7 billion to reach 5.3 billion by 2030 from 2020 levels and especially in Asia – which will represent almost 9 in 10 of the next billion middle-class consumers – (spread out between China, India, and South and Southeast Asia). As the global population continues to grow, the demand for energy is expected to surge significantly, especially since the rate of increase in energy intensity is outpacing the rate of population growth. As the chart below shows, there is a critical need for an increase in energy supply to meet rising demand.
Note that the increase in demand for energy services is largely driven by middle-income countries that are experiencing both population growth and a rise in the middle-class, which is being fueled by a fast rate of wage increase. This growing middle class tends to adopt more energy-intensive behaviors, as reflected in the graph below.
Space cooling accounts for a large share of the increase in energy demand, as it requires a significant amount of electricity. There is some irony here that need for more air conditioning will make it hotter if we fail to transition from GHG energy sources. It is projected that an additional 2,800 terawatt-hours of electricity will be needed globally by 2050 to meet this demand. If we don’t transition rapidly to clean energy production, this will create a negative feedback loop, wherein the more we rely on fossil fuels to generate energy for cooling, the more we contribute to the vicious circle we find ourselves in. Furthermore, the transport sector is also expected to more than double by 2050, propelled by the rising mobility needs in developing countries, where the transition to electric vehicles is far from guaranteed (see “A Two-Speed Transition: Why it's Time to Park the EV Frenzy in EMs”, February 16, 2023). Additionally, the trend towards urbanization, improvements in health and living conditions, and increasing life expectancy are among the many factors that have significant implications for the patterns of energy use.
The Rise of the Green Regulators
The scale of action required to achieve a successful energy transition should not be underestimated. It entails a comprehensive overhaul of all sectors, including energy, manufacturing, transport, infrastructure, agriculture, forestry, and land use. Governments need to increase their efforts and scale up interventions to meet the requirements for transitioning to green energy. With more than 70 countries, including major polluters such as China, the United States, and the European Union, committing to a net-zero target, there is expected to be a surge in clean energy demand. In this context, electrification and a shift away from fossil fuels are essential for achieving a net-zero emissions system. The table below illustrates how governments are taking action to promote this transition.
As previously stated ("Macro goes ESG", July 8, 2021), the realm of sustainability issues is increasingly intertwined with politics, leading governments to prioritize climate considerations in their industrial and economic policies. The key takeaway is that the regulatory backdrop around the world is now pushing in one direction: to limit higher intensity GHG emissions products. This means that, relative to previous decades, the ability to ramp up energy production to meet increased demand will be constrained.
Technological Solutions Exist but Costs Need to Come Down
Should population growth and energy intensity forecasts to 2050, as mentioned above, be accurate, we will require much more energy than we currently have. If we are to achieve climate goals, the need to lower the emission intensity of energy is obvious.
Solar panels and wind turbines have advanced significantly in recent years, becoming more efficient and cost-effective. The table below shows the relative cost of producing electricity from different sources as of 2021. These costs can vary depending on several factors, such as the location of the power plant, the availability of resources, and the efficiency of the technology used. The low level of GHG emissions emanating from renewable energy relative to traditional fuel sources highlights the need to produce more energy from wind, hydro, nuclear, geothermal, and solar and less energy from coal, oil, and natural gas in order to reach net zero goals.
An ongoing challenge for the energy transition is storage, especially considering the intermittent nature of wind and solar. Energy storage technologies, such as batteries and pumped hydro storage, allow excess energy to be stored and used when demand is high, ensuring a reliable and stable energy supply. The cost is still high but the prize for success in improving the efficiency and cost is also high.
Electrification is another necessary ingredient of the energy transition and one where technology will play an important role. Electricity is a highly efficient form of energy, and electrifying various systems and processes can lead to significant improvements in energy efficiency. For example, electric motors are typically more efficient than internal combustion engines, and electric heating systems can be more efficient than gas heating systems.
Smart grid technologies will be needed to optimize the distribution and management of electricity across the grid. These technologies enable better monitoring, control, and coordination of energy resources, and can help to increase the efficiency and reliability of the grid. Grid modernization technologies include sensors, communication networks, and advanced analytics that enable the grid to operate more efficiently and effectively.
While electrification offers many benefits, there are also several challenges that must be addressed to increase its adoption. Some of the main challenges include cost, resilience and grid integration.
The upfront cost of new electric vehicles, appliances, and infrastructure. The performance and cost of battery technology is a key factor in the adoption of electric vehicles and other electrified systems. While battery technology has improved significantly in recent years, further advancements will be necessary to improve the range, charging time, and durability of batteries. Electric vehicles and appliances may be more efficient and cost-effective over the long-term, but the initial investment can be a significant obstacle for many consumers and businesses.
Meanwhile, the integration of renewable energy sources like wind and solar can also present challenges for electricity grids, as these sources are intermittent and can be difficult to predict. Energy storage technologies like batteries and pumped hydro storage will be critical to balancing supply and demand on the grid.
The graph below highlights the mid-point of global investments required to achieve the energy transition. The size of the needed investments is so large that we can expect tremendous activity for the energy transition for years to come.
Tougher Relationships
Deglobalization refers to the process of reducing the interconnectedness and interdependence of economies across the world. The effects of deglobalization on the energy transition can be both positive and negative, depending on the extent of deglobalization, the policies and regulations implemented, and the availability of alternative energy sources.
On the positive side, deglobalization may lead to a reduction in global energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions, as trade and transportation activities decrease through the promotion of local production and consumption of goods and services, reduction in long-distance commuting, and energy efficiency in buildings and transportation. Additionally, deglobalization may increase the resilience of local energy systems, as countries focus on developing their own energy sources and reducing their dependence on imported fossil fuels.
However, there are also potential negative effects of deglobalization on the energy transition. Some countries may choose to prioritize their own economic interests over environmental concerns. While, global collaboration and knowledge-sharing are crucial for accelerating the development and deployment of renewable energy technologies, deglobalization may slow down the pace of innovation and limit the availability of renewable energy technologies, as countries become more isolated and less willing to share knowledge and resources.
Overall, the effect of deglobalization on the energy transition is complex and multifaceted. While it may provide some benefits in terms of reducing emissions and increasing energy resilience, it also poses significant risks to the pace and scale of the transition to a low-carbon economy.
As the graph below shows, the growth in global trade has been slowing since the Great Financial Crisis.
The Russian invasion of Ukraine and the deteriorating relationship between the United States and China are recent indications of greater geopolitical tensions that can have significant impacts on the energy transition, affecting the production, distribution, and consumption of energy resources in various ways. Geopolitical tensions can disrupt global supply chains, leading to shortages and price spikes in critical components needed for renewable energy technologies. For example, conflict or sanctions on countries that produce key minerals such as lithium and cobalt, which are essential for manufacturing batteries, can impact the availability and cost of these materials.
Geopolitical tensions can lead to an increase in fossil fuel prices due to supply disruptions and production cuts. This may incentivize a shift to renewable energy sources that are less affected by geopolitical tensions but may also slow down the transition if renewable energy prices remain higher than fossil fuel prices. Geopolitical tensions can also lead to changes in government policies and regulations, affecting the development and adoption of renewable energy technologies. For example, sanctions or trade barriers can limit the export and import of renewable energy products, while subsidies and incentives for fossil fuels can slow down the transition to renewable energy. Barriers create uncertainty and risks for investors, leading to a reduction in investment in the renewable energy sector which can slow down the pace of innovation and deployment of renewable energy technologies, critical for achieving the energy transition.
With billions of tons of cargo transported around the world each year by trucks, planes, ships, and trains, freight transportation is a critical component of the global economy. While freight transportation supports economic growth and helps to improve the standard of living, it is also a big contributor to GHG emissions. The International Transport Forum (ITF) estimates that international trade-related freight transport currently accounts for around 30% of all transport-related CO2 emissions from fuel combustion, and more than 7% of global emissions. Moreover, emissions from global freight transport are expected to increase fourfold from 2010 levels, and are, at this pace, incompatible with a net-zero scenario.
Although ships transport the majority of the world's cargo (75%), trucks and vans are responsible for emitting 65% of the freight's total emissions. This is because ships are more efficient, meaning they can carry a large amount of cargo while emitting a relatively low level of emissions. On the other hand, trucks emit more pollutants than ships when transporting the same amount of freight over the same distance. A look at the U.S. alone shows the predominance of trucks within freight transportation:
Freight movement is expected to increase by nearly 50% by 2050 in volume (compared to 2019 levels), and trucks are following the same trend line due to their cheap costs. With logistics trends such as digitization, faster innovation cycles and local production, there is an increased pressure on prices, which made trucking boom over the past years (see our note Keep on Trucking: How Driver Retention Can Reinforce Supply Chains, April 28, 2022). However, in order to reach net-zero goals, trains seem to be the best alternative option to trucks, as they emit 4 times less on average than trucks and can help avoid traffic congestion and health problems linked to pollution.
Putting Trains Back on the Right Track
Trains have the possibility to carry freight for long distances while greatly reducing CO2 emissions. In addition, clean electric rail’s energy efficiency and proven safety systems can translate into six-times lower external costs (noise, climate change, pollution, accidents) of freight rail versus road freight. However, in many developed countries, the majority of trains are still powered by diesel: as of 2019, 64% of locomotives in the U.S. freight rail fleet were powered by diesel, and this number is even at 91% in Canada. Europe is more electrified with 52% of electric freight trains. Japan is the most advanced, with 82% of electric trains in its freight rail transport.
Massive investments are therefore necessary to electrify the sector with clean energy. However, in rail, asset replacement cycles are up to 10 times longer than for roads, which naturally limits the rate of innovation uptake of companies. Government investments are critical for countries wanting their trains to compete with trucks if they want to achieve their climate goals. The table below presents the most recent programs in key countries regarding investment in rails:
These plans mostly concern passenger transportation, and the ambitious 30 by 2030 program envisioned by the European Freight Rail Association is facing a number of limitations. The growth of goods with rail affinity (like coal, metal, ores or wood) is expected to decline, compared to a strong growth of goods with low rail affinity (such as food, textile and machinery, which require shorter transport times, smaller shipment size and demand higher reliability), putting a brake on the development of freight railroads. In an effort to stay competitive, rail companies have cut costs, mostly on maintenance, safety and labour. This led to negative outcomes like the Norfolk Southern’s Train Derailment in Ohio in February 2023, shining a spotlight on the deficiencies of an often overlooked industry.
Derailing Expectations
Numerous articles point out that the train derailment and chemical spill in Ohio was the culmination of a long trend of cost-cutting in the rail industry. Rail workers, government officials, and industry analysts have long warned that such disasters are an expected consequence.
While the number of train derailments in the U.S. has decreased over time, with over 1,000 still occurring each year as shown in the chart below, a closer examination reveals an increase in the derailment rate. This is likely due to the trend of longer and heavier trains, which have enabled railroads to reduce the number of miles travelled. As a result, even though there are fewer accidents overall, the rate of derailments has increased in five out of the last seven years when compared to the miles travelled.
Most derailments are caused by a lack of investment in tracks and human error:
The primary cause of derailment is often attributed to track issues, such as broken sections of the track that have been repeatedly pounded by passing trains due to lack of maintenance. Maintenance and inspections are critical to safe operations. The Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) regulations do require railroads to maintain track inspection records and make them available to FRA or state inspectors on request, but freight rail carriers are not required to report publicly on freight track conditions. Universal track condition reports are therefore unavailable.
Operational cost cutting also has social implications. As shown in the chart below, the rail industry has seen declining levels of employee compensation and benefits for rail workers (Norfolk Southern ranking the worst among the five), leaving employees discontented, but not without reaction.
In December 2022, President Biden signed legislation to impose a labour agreement between rail companies and workers who had been locked in a bitter dispute over paid sick leave, averting a strike that could have upended the economy just before the holiday season. In February 2023, the Union Pacific CEO announced its departure after an activist shareholder accused the company of providing the worst service among the major railroads and blaming the CEO.
Freight Rail Investing: Proceed With Caution
This is a challenging context for sustainability minded investors. In the absence of government support, there seem to be few tailwinds for increased transport by rail. In North America, where nearly all freight rail relies on diesel locomotives, the top five publicly traded railway companies (Union Pacific, Canadian Pacific, Canadian National, CSX and Norfolk Southern) have been working to improve their environmental standing; moving from around the 50th percentile closer to the 90th percentile over the past ten years. Though electrification in this region seems unlikely, there are other ways trains can reduce their emissions and environmental impact (such as the use of cleaner fuels, efficiency and energy-saving measures). We expect rail operators to invest in these environmental solutions as well as safety improvements as these elements take on increasing importance when it comes to being selected as a supply chain partner. We consider three rail equipment companies that are providers of these solutions: Alstom, Wabtec and Knorr-Bremse.
Alstom and Wabtec have similar product offerings but serve different regions; Alstom’s revenues are more concentrated in Europe (62%) and Wabtec in North America (50%). In addition to producing new locomotives, both companies contribute to the circular economy through the sale of remanufactured trains. Trains can be retrofitted to operate more efficiently, helping to lower emissions. Both companies are also looking into researching alternatives to diesel trains including battery locomotives, hydrogen and other alternative fuels (Alstom is hoping to expand in the U.S. market with these solutions). Smart digital solutions that help to optimize processes and improve safety are also on offer. In 2021, 22% of Wabtec’s revenues were from products that support environmental efficiency, an important consideration given the market it serves most. A distinguishing factor for Alstom is that it does have more passenger rail clients than Wabtec and produces more electric locomotives which is also related to the region it serves. This could be to its advantage as passenger rail appears to be a higher governmental priority.
Knorr-Bremse is a provider of smart solutions for the rail industry. These services aim to enhance safety, limit air pollutants and optimize HVAC systems among other efficiency gains. The company’s Digital Freight Train product offering supports objectives of standardizing processes across the European rail network. This is more of a supply chain optimization than emissions reducing but it will be advantageous in encouraging more freight transport by rail.
Compared to the five large publicly traded freight rail companies (Union Pacific, Canadian Pacific, Canadian National, CSX and Norfolk Southern), these three equipment companies have more attractive valuations, less debt and better growth prospects.
According to the International Energy Agency, if the world is going to reach its renewable energy goals in 2030, the decade will bring a gargantuan buildup of solar energy power. Currently, solar accounts for about 13% of total renewable energy, but is expected to account for one-third in 2030. Overall, to stay on a path to reach 2050 target emissions of net zero, solar power capacity will need to multiply by seven in the next seven years!
This is an extremely ambitious global goal that will require significant global cooperation. Unfortunately, this is not currently the case, as the industry appears to be confronted with a version of the irresistible force paradox.
An irresistible force paradox is commonly summed up in the phrase “unstoppable force meets immovable object”. When analyzing the solar power industry, China appears to be the unstoppable force that is about to meet its immovable object: deglobalization.
Solar Manufacturing Domination
China is a leader in solar power, both in domestic production of electricity, but also in the manufacture of solar panels; the Chinese solar panel industry is what allows other nations to claim solar as a renewable power source. Indeed, the country is both the largest producer and consumer at all stages of the solar power supply chain, including polysilicon, wafers, cells and completed modules.
Based on manufacturing capacity under construction, China’s share of global polysilicon and wafer production will soon reach almost 95% of total production. But even more alarming is that according to the IEA, one single province in China - Xinjiang - accounts for 40% of global polysilicon manufacturing; one out of every seven panels produced worldwide is manufactured by a single facility in China.
Note that Xinjiang province, referred to by China as the Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region (XUAR), has drawn worldwide attention for human rights abuses; the United Nations Human Rights Commissioner determined in 2022 that “allegations of patterns of torture, or ill-treatment, including forced medical treatment and adverse conditions of detention, are credible”. Investors with interests in the region -need to understand the risks involved, even with passive portfolios.
U.S. Policy to the Rescue?
Of course, this almost total domination of the solar power industry has not gone unnoticed. In 2021, U.S. President Biden emitted an executive order to review America’s supply chains. The “energy sector industrial base” was one of six key industries identified for further assessment. In the subsequent 2022 study by the U.S. Energy Department, a section is dedicated to “Building a Solar Power Chain Not Dependent on China”.
Since then, the U.S. government has taken several actions that have impacted the solar manufacturing industry. The Inflation Reduction Act’s (IRA) aggressive tax credits: The Advanced Manufacturing Production Tax Credit provides tax credits for each clean energy component domestically produced across the solar PV supply chain, while the Advanced Energy Project Credit provides a tax credit for building and commissioning a facility for clean-energy component manufacturing.
In addition, in February 2022, the U.S. extended tariffs on solar products containing crystalline silicon coming from China. Finally, the federal government enacted the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act in June 2022, which bans products including solar components from China’s Xinjiang region. Granted, it is unclear as how successful the ban has been, since there are myriad ways to circumvent this law.
China has not stood still in the face of U.S. promotion of a domestic solar industry. The Chinese government is reportedly looking to add raw materials used in solar panels to a list of items that could be restricted for export in order to ‘help safeguard national security’. These materials would require special permission for export and if enacted aggressively, could effectively strangle the global solar power industry.
How to Invest
From an investor perspective, the complex geopolitics of the solar power industry mean that what should be a relatively straightforward bull case for solar power stocks is in reality, highly muddled and potentially quite risky. Of course, there is the ethical question of investing in an energy transition built on the back of human rights abuses. At a very minimum, the potential for reputational and regulatory challenges associated with solar companies requires that investors embed a significant risk premium on equity in the solar industry.
As we have articulated in previous notes (for example, see Chinese Capitalism’s Long March, September 30, 2021), we believe that China is not investable at the current juncture. For investors desiring to gain exposure to the solar industry, this means that there are few options. After all, Chinese solar manufacturing companies have incredibly strong economic moats and it is far from clear that the U.S. (and other countries) will be able to (re-)establish a solar power manufacturing industry. As the IEA notes, “China is the most cost-competitive location to manufacture all components of the solar PV supply chain. Costs in China are 10% lower than in India, 20% lower than in the United States, and 35% lower than in Europe. Large variations in energy, labour, investment and overhead costs explain these differences. Still, in the absence of financial incentives and manufacturing support, the bankability of manufacturing projects outside of panel assembly remains limited outside of China and few countries in Southeast Asia.”
Currently, the vast majority of public solar power manufacturing companies – irrespective of where they are listed - have strong ties to China and the Xinjiang province and many have already been caught in scandal. The table below highlights features of publicly listed solar power players.
For investors that want to steer clear of trade regulation risks and human rights violations, gaining exposure to the solar manufacturing industry is tricky. Only six companies pass the above preliminary screening: Meyer Burger, Sun Power, First Solar, Maxeon, Wacker Chemie and Tokuyama. The two names that are considered pure plays and have severed any ties with Chinese solar suppliers are Meyer Burger and First Solar.
Note that these companies have already benefitted from being relatively unattached to the Chinese solar panel supply chain, as is reflected in their stock valuations and price performance. Meyer Burger is trading at a P/E of 56, while Sun Power and First Solar are valued at 28 times earnings. Only Wacker Chemi and Tokuyama have closer to fair valuations (14 and 8 respectively), although both of these companies are diversified chemical companies and are thus not pure plays on the solar industry.
We believe that a company like Maxeon Solar provides a good example of the risk associated with investing in solar power manufacturers within the current geopolitical context. Maxeon Solar Technologies was originally the manufacturing arm of SunPower and is now a separate company. Maxeon continues to supply SunPower with solar panels along with other international customers. Maxeon has a joint venture with a module manufacturer in China to produce panels; although the Chinese manufacturer is not in Xinjiang province, it is expected that this company could soon be a target for U.S. trade regulators and by extension, create business risks for Maxeon. Both Maxeon and SunPower stock prices have struggled since China’s human rights violations have come into investors’ focus.
The Mineral Demand Story
We highlight three main structural forces that will keep demand for minerals very buoyant for years to come:
1. Industrial Transformation to Fight Climate Change
Almost all developed countries have fairly aggressive emissions targets. To achieve those targets, a more carbon-efficient industrial complex is required. The table below highlights some of the solutions for the energy transition.
These solutions will require more industrial commodities like copper which is used in electric vehicles and renewable energy technologies, lithium, nickel, cobalt and manganese for batteries, graphite for energy storage, rare earth elements for renewable energy technologies, aluminum for electric vehicles and renewable energy technologies, iron for energy storage technologies and electric vehicles and tungsten for renewable energy technologies.
The chart below shows where each of those critical minerals was sourced from in 2021. China is a leading producer of many critical minerals. This makes sense since China enjoyed rapid growth after their accession to the World Trade Organization and developed local mineral companies to do so.
2. Invasion Leads to Depletion and More Defense
The defense industry is very demanding on critical minerals accounting for close to 10% of global annual output, as can be seen from the chart below. Over the next 5 years, it is reasonable to assume a 30-50% increase in defense spending (countries going from 1-1.5% of GDP to 1.5-2% of GDP on defense). This could translate into 2-5% more demand for minerals.
The US Department of Defense estimated that Tomahawk cruise missiles and Javelin missiles contain approximately 45% of critical materials, including steel, aluminum, copper. Those are the same minerals required for the industrial transformation.
3) India Replaces China
India is the likely replacement for China and its previous insatiable and growing demand for industrial commodities. India’s population is still growing, and its birth rate is at replacement level with around 2 children per woman. The estimated average age of the Indian population in 2022 is 28.5 years old (compared to, 39.3 in China and 39.4 in the United States). The Indian economy is expected to experience 7% real growth over the next five years and infrastructure investments are expected to grow by more than 8% over the same period.
One dampening factor for strong mineral demand in the future is China. The government has heavily subsidized infrastructure investments since the beginning of the century as China’s substantial industrial output outpaced all other countries. More recently, the country’s debt has grown much faster than the size of the overall economy with infrastructure investment representing a much larger part than anywhere else in the world. Debt growing faster than GDP is a clear sign that China has overinvested, and growth will slow on a structural horizon. Moreover, its population is aging and its size will fall rapidly with a birth rate far below the replacement rate, at close to 1 per woman. It has already built empty cities, but infrastructure investments are a quick way to get an economy going (a trick used aggressively during the 2008 and 2016 downturns); expect the long-term trend in commodity demand from China to slow with boom and bust episodes.
The Mineral Supply Story
On the supply side, we are looking at the geography of mining and the complexity to build new mines with a specific focus on copper.
1) Reserve Locations Lead to New Geopolitical Considerations
Chile, Peru and the Democratic Republic of Congo could replace Saudi Arabia as the most courted countries in the world, due to their vast reserve of “in-demand” transition minerals. The list of countries with abundant critical mineral reserves is very different from fossil fuel reserve maps. Vast countries like Russia, Canada, the United States and Brazil have both critical minerals and fossil fuels but smaller countries in South America and Africa are the place to be for minerals as can be seen from the chart below.
2) Copper in the Middle
Since copper is irreplaceable and critical to electrification, its availability will determine the pace of the energy transition. We will concentrate on copper for the remainder of the note.
The demand for copper is likely to increase rapidly from 20-25 million tonnes currently to 30-35 million tonnes in 10 years. There should be a persistent imbalance between supply and demand. We should witness a temporary reprieve over the next two years with a cluster of projects coming into production but the longer-term picture remains favorable to higher copper prices according to BHP’s 2023 Economic and Commodity Report.
Following the difficulties they suffered after overinvesting during the previous commodity cycle that started in 2000, commodity producers remain wary of new mine development even if they believe the strong consensus that there will not be enough copper after 2024. Building a new copper mine is difficult due to increasing costs and environmental regulations. Copper is becoming increasingly scarce. Also, the cost of mining operations have been increasing due to rising labor, energy, and transportation costs. The complexity of the mining process and the environmental impact of mining operations also presents a challenge for mining companies.
3) The Production Challenge
Africa has become more attractive for miners with the recent Lumwana Mine in Zambia, owned by Freeport McMorran, that is estimated to produce approximately 500,000 metric tonnes of copper annually and the Tenke Fungurume Mine in the Democratic Republic of Congo which is estimated to produce approximately 200,000 metric tonnes annually and is owned by Barrick Gold.
The graph below highlights that recent production has mainly come from Latin America where the political landscape is getting more difficult for existing mine operators and those looking to start new mines.
Looking at the companies with the biggest copper production and recognizing their positive optionality on higher copper prices and volume, the graphic below displays the sustainability scores from CSRHub to ascertain which companies have reduced downside risks. If a company is a good citizen from a community, employee and environmental standpoint, the risks to its operations should be reduced allowing it to benefit fully from higher prices and volume.
4) Recycling to the Rescue
Recycling accounts for approximately 25% of annual copper demand (5-7 million tonnes of recycling compared to 20-25 million tonnes of demand). The biggest copper recyclers in the world are China, the United States, and Japan. Together, these three countries account for approximately 60% of global copper recycling. China is the largest copper recycler, accounting for around 37% of global copper recycling. The United States is the second-largest, accounting for around 14% of global copper recycling, while Japan is the third-largest, accounting for around 9% of globally recycled copper.
Considering the difficulties in operating and building new mines that we addressed in the previous section, copper recyclers benefit from the same optionality in price and potentially less operational risks.
Looking at the biggest recyclers, the graph below highlights the sustainability scores from CSRHub to ascertain which companies have the best operations.
Almost all developed countries have fairly aggressive zero-emission vehicles targets for 2030 -2040. Shockingly, some of these targets could actually be met (government targets have a tendency to be missed)! Recent data has shown that the adoption of electric vehicles has been much faster than the projections made a few years ago and the trend seems to be accelerating. According to the International Energy Agency, the number of new electric cars sold worldwide has risen from just 200 000 in 2013 to 10.5 million in 2022. In terms of market share, 13% of new cars sold worldwide are EVs (in Norway it is 79%, China 27%, Europe 21% and USA 7%).
Looking at these numbers, we could conclude that we are well on our way to meeting the 2030 target of 60% of new cars sold being electric and that we should move on to a more difficult challenge. Hold your horses! As Stanley Druckenmiller once said, “trends work until they don’t”. We will soon be running out of rich Norwegians willing to go electric. When we get to the middle-class Indian farmer, living hundreds of kilometers from a reliably-functioning EV charging station, we might have a harder time to convince him of buying an EV over a conventional ICE car.
In this week’s note, we tackle the automotive transition dichotomy between developed and emerging markets and propose an investment thesis that is currently overshadowed by the EV hype: being bullish on catalytic converters!
As mentioned above and shown in the table below, most developed countries have aggressive zero-emission vehicle targets, but targets are weaker in some of the biggest emerging countries.
Another important factor to consider when looking at the rate of penetration of electric vehicles is the accessibility to EV charging stations and access to reliable electricity to power them. According to the Indian government, there are only 934 charging stations in the entire country – about the same numbers you can find in Oslo! Also, according to the Energy for Growth Hub, about 3.5 billion people, or about 45% of the world’s population, live without reliable power.
The utopia whereby in 2030 everyone drives an EV while drinking their oat milk latte is a very Western-centric vision. In reality, millions of new cars with internal combustion engines (ICE) will continue to be sold in countries with an increasingly large middle-class population that dreams to buy what is often viewed as a symbol of freedom and economic success: a car.
The demographic and economic cleavages between EMs and DMs are such that the vast majority of the growth in new car sales will be coming from EMs for the foreseeable future. Considering that, as discussed above, EMs will be neither here nor there in terms of EV sales by 2030, we can expect close to 100 million new conventional Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) cars to be built and sold worldwide by the end of the decade.
The good news is that while EV sales in EMs will likely remain low (except in China), most EMs are getting better at regulating the tailpipe emissions that are causing so much pollution and health problems around the world. Take India for instance. The Bharat Stage (BS) emission standards have been in place since 2000. The country has since moved from the initial BS-I standard to the current BS-VI standard adopted in 2020, which is equivalent to the Euro 6 standard used in Europe. The BS-VI standard mandates a reduction in sulfur content in fuels from 50 parts per million (ppm) to 10 ppm, and a reduction in nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions from diesel cars by 70% and from petrol cars by 25%. India is also in the process of implementing the Bharat Stage-VII (BS-VII) standards, which will come into effect in April 2025 and will be even stricter than the current standards. A similar regulatory process is happening in Brazil, with the PROCONVE (Programa de Controle de Poluição do Ar por Veículos Automotores).
These stricter emission controls for the automotive sector in EMs will act as a massive tailwind for catalytic converters (and their components). Catalytic converters are devices that are installed in the exhaust system of cars to reduce emissions of harmful gases. The converter contains a honeycomb-like structure coated with a catalyst such as platinum, palladium or rhodium. As exhaust gases pass through the converter, they come into contact with the catalyst, which triggers a chemical reaction that breaks down the toxic pollutants. The stricter the tailpipe pollution controls are, the more platinum, palladium and rhodium a catalytic converter needs.
There are two main strategies to benefit from the tailwind in tailpipe emission controls. First is to look at the main catalytic converter manufacturers. There are no real pure plays in the publicly traded markets but three companies are perceived as the leaders in this space (Umicore [UMI BB], BASF SE [BAS GY] and Johnson Matthey Plc [JMAT LN]), each of them deriving about 30% of their revenues from manufacturing catalytic converters.
As manufacturers, their costs exploded when commodity prices went up beginning at the end of 2021, so these companies have not been an attractive investment in the last few years. They are also exposed to a number of other markets beyond catalytic converters so it’s difficult to determine how that segment fared relative to the other sources of revenues of these companies. Of the three companies mentioned, Umicore and Johnson Matthey have the best sustainability-adjusted upside in our view due to their contribution to the transition to a circular economy (they are both heavily involved in the recycling of transition metals – see “Transition Metals: Wicked Problem, Smart Solutions”, October 14, 2021). Investors should avoid BASF due to their role in the genetically modified seed cartel alongside Corteva, Bayer, and ChemChina (see our note “Agriculture’s Addiction Problem: Pursuing a High(er Crop Yield)”, September 22, 2022).
The other way to ride the catalytic converter wave is to go straight at the source: by investing in companies involved in mining the platinum, palladium and rhodium necessary to build these magical devices (Impala Platinum [IMP SJ], Royal Bafokeng Platinum [RBP SJ], Anglo American Platinum [AMS SJ] and Sibanye Stillwater [SSW SJ]).
These companies, all listed on the Johannesburg stock exchange, derive the majority of their revenues from the mining and processing of the three metals of interest. They have had quite a ride, and are all getting close, or even have surpassed, their historical peak. The latter occurred days after the invasion of Ukraine when Russian company Norilsk Nickel, one of the major miners of these metals worldwide, was barred from trading internationally. Despite the phenomenal performance of these stocks, their valuation remains very palatable.
From a sustainability perspective, mining companies are known to have all kinds of ESG problems but almost surprisingly, these companies all fared very well in our analysis, opening the door for sustainability-minded investors to consider them as impactful investment opportunities.
If our 2022 investment outlook note could be reduced to one investment adage – “power of diversification” – then SMS’ outlook theme for 2023 takes a page from Warren Buffett and focuses on “knowing the difference between price and value”. We believe that the bear market in stocks that got underway in 2022 is not yet over, but that 2023 will nonetheless offer opportunity for bargains in high-quality sustainable companies that are positioned for a low-carbon, high-care economy.
From a macro perspective, we expect there will be less surprises about inflation in 2023 (trending lower, but still above 2%) but ongoing uncertainty about the timing of recession. The chart below shows the evolution of our expectations about different macro investment scenarios; we expect recessionary conditions to linger for most of the year leading broad equity indices to trend lower until there is early evidence of a positive inflection point in the economic cycle. Equity markets have priced in the higher interest rate environment but not the fall in profitability. For now, a soft landing with no recession seems to be priced in markets.
Against this backdrop, and with our approach to investing that is focused on finding tradeable sustainability themes and the best companies that embody them, it is no surprise that we enter the year with a defensive tilt that offers downside protection. As the second half of the bear market unfolds, we will intensify our focus to find beaten-down names that offer superior value. A catalyst for the latter will be once forward earnings expectations turn firmly negative, which should serve as a sign that investor sentiment reflects economic reality.
We therefore kick off 2023 with a list of our high conviction investment ideas, with an eye on value: In the very short term, we look to protect capital in defensive areas of the stock market until a recession is well advanced. Looking further out into 2023, we expect conditions to be in place to be able to shift capital to select higher beta companies once the Fed reaches the end of its tightening campaign.
Idea #1: Long Energy Efficiency
Within the energy sector, we expect energy efficiency plays to outperform in 2023. Oil prices will be volatile, while companies involved in renewable energy production are often growth-oriented and highly sensitive to the interest rate backdrop, which we expect will continue to be a headwind for now. In contrast, many energy efficiency companies, e.g. companies that manufacture and/or provide solutions such as heat pumps, HVACs, and smart metering, tend to have low P/Es and trade as value stocks.
Energy efficiency is one of only a few areas that are well-supported by fiscal policy in 2023. According to the IEA, over half of OECD countries have generous subsidies for heat pumps and other energy-conserving products, with the RePower EU plan among the most ambitious; the EU must double the current roll-out rate in the next five years if its heat pump targets are to be achieved. In the U.S., the Inflation Reduction Act also provides significant support for heat pumps, offering subsidies up to $14, 000 per household.
The following companies have strong sustainability characteristics on an operational basis (i.e. ESG), provide excellent energy efficiency solutions, and are in good financial health: Carrier, Johnson Controls, Nibe, and Trane Technologies.
Idea #2 An ESG Comeback: Short Greenwashers
Events in 2022 sparked a necessary shakeout for “ESG” and responsible investment. Although recent focus has been on the asset management industry, these debates have been helpful at shining a spotlight on all false claims whether they be at the investment or corporate level.
Companies that embellish their sustainability credentials risk being punished in this environment, since reputational risk affects stock price performance.
We suggest two trades for 2023, based on the concept of “go long sustainability” and “short greenwashing”. Incidentally, in both cases, our short candidates are not only viewed as potential sustainability fraudsters, but their dubious use of financial engineering is also a major investment risk:
- Short Enviva/Long Svenska Cellulosa: The world’s largest producer of wood pellets, which are considered a renewable energy source, is Enviva. But Enviva is also the producer most shrouded in controversy. As early as 2013, a report was delivered to the SEC regarding omissions and misrepresentations by Enviva; the company has been regularly cited since for giving false information about greenhouse gas emissions in this industry. There is currently a class action lawsuit against Enviva for making materially false and misleading statements regarding the company's business, operations, and compliance policies. According to the suit, Enviva has misrepresented the environmental sustainability of its wood pellet production and procurement and has also overstated the true measure of cash flow generated (the company has not had a positive net income over the past 3 years and has been issuing more debt and selling shares to support increases in their dividend payment).
On the opposite end of the spectrum, Svenska Cellulosa merits its reputation as one of the most sustainably managed forest companies in Europe. As an integrated industrial business, they aim to maximize the possible value in the forest and from the forest; wood pellets are a by-product from production of other wood products, helping the company achieve a recycled waste-total waste ratio of 96% (!) and underscoring the company’s effectiveness at maximizing the value of the entire forest.
- Short Credit Acceptance Corp: a self-described socially responsible company, Credit Acceptance Corp claims to help indebted individuals purchase automobiles by offering loans to consumers with “Bad & No Credit”. SMS and the U.S Financial Protection Bureau see things differently. The latter (along with the New York Attorney General) recently announced a lawsuit against Credit Acceptance Corp for predatory lending practices- practices that ultimately yielded profits for the company. We first mentioned Credit Acceptance Corp in our “The Greed Without the Green” Note (October 6, 2022) questioning the conduct of consumer finance companies and spotting an opportunity to short in the context of rising interest rates. As we anticipate this economic context to carry over to 2023, more defaults should be expected; the January lawsuit announcement may be just the beginning of bad news for CACC. In addition, the company has used virtually all cashflow from the past three years for the repurchase of shares at inflated prices (2-year average weighted price 30% higher than current market prices). This is destroying shareholder value, rather than adding to it.
Idea #3: Switch from Illiquid Alternatives to Liquid Alternatives
Money poured into the illiquid alternative space over the past decade. However, investors should never forget that liquidity has a price and you pay for it with a premium over publicly traded investments.
While the rise in interest rates last year created havoc in bonds and public equities, many illiquid alternative funds (PE, real estate, infrastructure, etc.) actually reported gains for the year, despite many of the underlying assets being highly interest rate sensitive. The best example is private real estate funds compared to publicly traded real estate investment trusts: both essentially hold the same assets, yet private real estate funds were up 5-10% while real estate investment trusts were down 20-25%. Unless bonds and stocks recover quickly, this is an unsustainable practice: smoothing out returns and locking in clients by limiting redemptions is a recipe for disaster.
We look at private assets under one of our investable sustainability themes: Building Better Markets. The opacity of private asset investment vehicles and, in many cases, the way they have been sold to investors is a dangerous practice.
We believe poor returns are in store for private investments since these products will need to be marked down over the next three years to progressively absorb the new valuation reality. If it is possible to redeem, investors would be better served by 3-year certificate of deposits yielding close to 5% or liquid alternatives like hedge funds that are marked to market, have attractive investment opportunities in a changing investment landscape and can benefit from a higher volatility regime that is likely to persist for the next 3 years.
Idea #4: Build Back Better With Industrial Automation
In the latter half of 2023, if recession risks wain and signs of a new bull market appear, we will advocate for beginning to reallocate to growth opportunities, starting with the industrial sector. Especially in the U.S., bipartisan support for recapturing manufacturing prowess will provide a favorable backdrop for upgrades to existing factories and the construction of new ones. Given the combination of reshoring and a structural labor shortage, we anticipate a boon in industrial automation. The benefits of automation include improved resource efficiency (optimized water, waste and energy management) and better safety. Two names on our radar are: Rockwell Automation and Emerson Electric.
Rockwell is the largest pure play in industrial automation and is also recognized as a leader in sustainability (CSRHub overall rank of 94 and listed on Barron’s 100 Most Sustainable Companies). In 2021, Rockwell’s energy efficiency related products were responsible for over one quarter of revenues. Emerson Electric also counts energy efficiency among its solutions. The company serves industries (such as energy, life sciences and food and beverage) that are key to a low-carbon, high-care economy and is diversified across both automation and commercial HVAC solutions. We find this especially beneficial from an investment perspective, given that the company is the intersection between two highly investable 2023 themes: energy efficiency (see idea #1) and automation. Though currently expensive, investors should look for buying opportunities later in the year.
Idea #5: Opportunities in EM
Similar to Idea #4, we expect that later in 2023, there will be scope for a change in leadership between EM and DM. Historically, the U.S. business cycle leads the rest of the world by about six months, since U.S. consumption is a major source of demand for much of the world's export.
It is therefore premature to expect emerging markets stock outperformance in the near term. We have articulated in prior research why we are hesitant investors in China (for example, please see Chinese Capitalism’s Long March, September 29, 2021; we continue to believe that the country is extremely challenging for international investors that focus on sustainability, given an unpredictable regulatory backdrop and overall opacity in the country. That said, many emerging markets – as well as the companies that make up their stock markets – have historically healthy debt profiles and excellent growth prospects, yet are still trading at crisis-level valuations. Some tailwinds that may develop in 2023 include manufacturing revivals in some markets from “China plus one” strategies related to supply chains, exposure to the commodity cycle, as well as favorable political cycles in some pockets. Opportunities in EM for sustainability-minded investors are a key topic that we intend to explore further in 2023, stay tuned.
Idea #6: Structural Long in Transition Metals
Long-time readers of our work will note that we have been recommending positions in transition metals for quite some time and believe that an overweight allocation to these metals will be profitable on a structural basis. To be sure, higher metal prices are incongruent with our forecast for recession and we would not be surprised to see prices soften in the short-to-intermediate term. However, the long-term outlook for transition materials and metals is extremely bullish. Our preferred investments focus on sustainable miners and high-tech recyclers such as Umicore and Boliden. We believe that resource scarcity, the regulatory backdrop, as well as national energy and security policies of various nations will largely benefit these companies.
Sustainable Japan
Japanese culture thrives on common goals that naturally result in sustainable behavior. Their geographic location and difficult access to natural resources help explain the attention put on waste minimization and efficient water use and makes it one of the most resource-efficient nations in the world.
In our previous note of April 14, 2022 titled: “Circular Economy: when going around in circles is the right thing to do”, we referred to the 9R framework that applies within the general behavior of Japanese society. The table below describes the 9R.
We expect that many Japanese companies are well-positioned to benefit from a global shift towards sustainability, as well as a re-ordering in supply chains and a relative improvement in demographics.
To analyze the relative sustainability of Japanese companies, we took the SMS Investment Universe (Long-Only) and compared the percentile rank of Japanese companies to the rest of our investment universe. On average, their sustainability rank for Japanese companies is better than the rest of the universe.
With a Little Help From My Friends
The trend towards trading with allies and the need for environmental improvements will favor certain sectors of the economy. For those, like us, who believe that companies providing solutions to protect the environment will emerge as winners; with greater revenue potential and fiscal policy support, there are many under-the-radar, investment opportunities in Japan. We expect friend-shoring in this space should favor certain companies that we have identified in the table below.
Thematic Winners
Of SMS’ six investable themes (achieving the energy transition, protecting natural capital, making supply chains more resilient, leaving no person behind, building better markets and productivity with purpose), Achieving the Energy Transition and Protecting Natural Capital are the most closely associated with environmental improvement. In the following table, we list financially attractive Japanese companies according to their SMS thematic exposure. We will explore each name in greater financial detail in the second half of the note.
Better Labor Force Ratios Than Germany
Declining population in Japan is a well-chronicled phenomenon. As seen in the chart below, the ratio of incoming workers (15-19) compared to future retirees (60-64) has been dropping since 1950. The number of new entrants in the workforce peaked in 1966 with an echo in 1989 coinciding with the top of the Nikkei index. In 1997, the ratio of incoming workers to future retirees dropped below the replacement level of 1. It bottomed at 0.58 in 2011 and has been rising since, reaching a peak of 0.78 in 2020 but is forecasted to decline for the rest of this decade. More retirees than new entrants in the workforce is an issue in many developed markets as well as China.
Culminating in the 1980’s, Japan was a big export machine: more entrants in the workforce compared with retirees meant that a large workforce supported greater production. But in recent decades, to adapt to its smaller workforce, Japanese companies have moved production sites closer to the global demand for products. The best example of this is car manufacturers such as Toyota that design their cars in Japan but produce them elsewhere. Japan is also a leader in robotics that can counter/supplement a lack of labor. Contrary to many other countries, Japan developed ways to cope with a declining labor force without generating inflation.
The theory used to be that ageing demographics are deflationary due to falling demand. This proved true for Japan since 2000 when globalization was a strong force lowering prices. Globalization brought abundant, cheap labor from China, and the country became the manufacturer of choice for the world. Moreover, globalization reduced friction and kept commodity prices low because you could locate them anywhere in the world and get them shipped easily. The forces of cheap labor, cheap commodities and low friction have probably peaked and could reverse. Recent labor shortages are causing a new theory to emerge whereby when the replacement ratio of new entrants to new retirees is below 1, it is considered an inflationary tailwind due to potential wage increases instead of deflationary from a drop in demand.
The picture below highlights the relative situation of Germany, Japan and the United States in terms of employee replacement ratios since 1950. A few interesting observations from the data: natality rates in Germany were low during and after WWII, whereas in Japan, low natality rates were relatively short-lived. In America, the decline in birthrates was not observed at all. Since 2010, both Germany and Japan have a ratio below 1 and it is likely to remain that way at least until 2030. The United States is in an advantageous position with a ratio around 1. Currently, Japan is in a better relative position than Germany, so wage inflation could be less of an issue in Japan because they have experience with the problem.
No Refunding Hit From Higher Rates
The long period of deflation and the ability to deal with more retirees than entrants in the workforce is allowing the Japanese central bank to remain very accommodative and maintain its yield curve control program. From a refunding cost perspective (i.e. when companies that have issued debt retire outstanding callable bonds and replaces them with lower-rate new bonds) this is a big advantage for Japanese companies. The table below shows different points on the yield curve for the G7 countries. Japan is clearly the outlier with much lower rates. We expect Japan to give up its yield curve control program in the next couple of years but, if a global recession materializes and global inflation temporarily slows, they may be able to keep the program in place until at least Q2 2023.
Competitive and Cheap With Low Debt
In the graph below, we use various financial metrics to compare the seven companies that align with our environment themes to the median company in the MSCI World Index. From a profitability and growth standpoint, they look favorable.
From a competitive standpoint, the fall in real effective exchange rate should help. The graph below highlights its improved competitiveness.
Below, we examine valuation and leverage. The conclusion is the same: our seven Japanese companies trade at compelling valuation with less demanding debt servicing relative to the MSCI world median company and cheaper valuation with less competition from bonds in Japan compared to other countries, which should help Japanese companies rerate.
2022 has been marked with enormous volatility and uncertainty around energy prices of all kinds. The wood pellet industry has been no exception, with the price of pellets increasing in Europe three-fold in the past year.
From an opportunity perspective, it is not hard to see why investing in wood pellet companies is compelling. The desire for Europe to eliminate its dependence on Russian oil and gas means that energy consumers of all kinds are scrambling to find substitutes. Wood pellets fit this bill, since in many cases the cost of swapping out natural gas or coal for wood pellets is nil and/or very low.
But the outlook for the wood pellet industry, also known as , faces even greater uncertainty than other fuel sources due to its ambiguous status as a renewable energy. Indeed, energy sources tend to fall into one of two categories: dirty (discouraged from being part of the future) or clean (encouraged to be part of the future). Coal and petroleum fall into the first, whereas solar, wind, hydrogen, fall into the latter. The role of forestry biomass, however, remains disputed for the reasons discussed below.
In the Eyes of the Law
There is a long-held notion that wood is renewable because trees can be regrown. Ergo using forest products can be considered a renewable energy source. Under the 1992 Kyoto Protocol, harvesting forests to make wood pellets, which are then burned in converted coal-fired power plants, was classified as a renewable energy activity. In addition, under Kyoto rules, which were then grandfathered into the Paris Agreement, using wood pellets for electric power is considered a carbon-neutral energy source — as long as companies replant trees. The European Union – which is the largest consumer of wood products as energy – has taken the same stance: forestry biomass is included as a renewable energy. Importantly, it is widely acknowledged that the EU will NOT achieve its aggressive target of cutting emissions by 55% by 2030 without embracing biomass as a zero-carbon energy source.
The problem is that the scientific literature contains contrasting findings about the climate effects of forestry biomass:
- Burning biomass emits carbon dioxide at similar rates to coal. Although this is true, the difference between forestry biomass and coal is that burning fossil fuels releases carbon that has been locked in the ground for millions of years, whereas burning biomass releases carbon simply returns the carbon to the atmosphere that was previously absorbed as the trees grew.
- Carbon reductions only come many decades after tree harvesting and only in certain conditions. Since trees mostly absorb carbon dioxide while they are growing, the only way that forestry biomass can be “carbon neutral” is under conditions whereby the annual tree cut is equal to the annual growth, of the whole forest.
- Existing standing forests support biodiversity, whereas clearcut and re-planted monoculture forests do not.
The key takeaway from the above points is that under strict conditions, forestry biomass may result in an approximately carbon neutral activity. However, the danger is that as market forces (i.e. surging demand relative to supply for renewable energy sources) take hold, there will be ever greater incentive to supply wood pellets and other products faster than forests can sustainably deliver. For this reason, investors that are looking to diversify among renewable energy investments must be very diligent when it comes to the wood pellet industry.
We see two main risks for the wood pellet industry.
- Regulatory: As discussed above, there is some evidence that forestry biomass should not be considered a renewable energy source and there is increasing pressure in Europe to remove it from the list of renewable energies. If this were to occur, it would mark a massive reversal in the outlook for the industry: Europe is the largest global market for wood pellets.
Last month, the EU revised its Renewable Energy Directive (RED). The European Parliament voted this week not to declassify woody biomass as renewable energy, acknowledging that the region will not achieve its target of cutting EU carbon emissions by 55% by 2030, without forestry biomass. Forest advocates nonetheless view the ruling as a minor win, since the requirements for the sustainability of biomass were significantly increased. This is raising awareness; the topic will be up for vote again in three years, giving investors in this space a short runway before the regulatory backdrop risk will once again re-surface.
- Reputational: Long-time readers of Sustainable Market Strategies will know that we are in love with forests! Not only are trees, plants and healthy soil an abundant and cost-effective means of removing and storing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, they are also home to insects, birds, animals and a world of microscopic organisms that help to underpin human life. Thus, companies that manage forests sustainably should be a core holding for investors that expect capital will increasingly be allocated to carbon reduction strategies. Reputational risks enter the forestry industry (including wood pellets) in large part via the interpretation of “sustainable”. For wood pellet producers, sustainable means that pellets are made from forest waste products including sawmill residual (sawdust), discarded materials from other wood-based industries (e.g. tree tops, underbrush, and smaller branches that are a waste product of lumber and paper production) and diseased trees. Companies that produce wood pellets through other means, i.e., using whole, healthy trees that may or may not involve clear-cutting, are at major risk of confrontation from forest advocates and activists.
Forestry Biomass the Wrong Way
The world’s largest producer of wood pellets, Enviva, is also the producer that is most shrouded in controversy. Enviva is a U.S. publicly traded corporation that sells most of its wood pellets to customers in the United Kingdom, the European Union, and Japan. The company believes it is helping to “accelerate the energy transition and to decarbonize hard-to-abate sectors like steel, cement, lime, chemicals, and aviation fuels.” However, sustainability investors have long had this company on their “naughty list”. Most recently, activist investor Blue Orca Capital has publicly stated that Enviva is “engaged in textbook greenwashing” and that, “Satellite imagery indicates that contrary to the company's claims, in many instances Enviva is procuring wood from the widely condemned practice of clear-cutting.”
The SEC was solicited multiple times by various stakeholders including investors to issue guidance on how companies should disclose information about activities in the forest biomass industry. As early as 2013, a report was delivered to the SEC regarding omissions and misrepresentations by Enviva and the company has been regularly cited since for giving false information about greenhouse gas emissions in this industry.
Forestry Biomass the Right Way
One major difference between Enviva and the companies that are considered sustainable leaders in the wood pellet industry is their place in the supply chain. It is important to note that Enviva does not own forests, rather it sources raw materials through suppliers who purchase wood from working forests, sawmills and manufacturers. In other words, the company does not have direct oversight of the forests involved in its wood supply; it does not control its supply chain. On the other end of the spectrum, a company like Svenska Cellulosa Aktiebolaget (SCA), which is the largest forest owner in Europe, sources its wood fibres from its own land. As an integrated industrial business, they aim to maximize the possible value in the forest and from the forest.
As a result, wood pellets are only a small fraction of SCA’s business. In 2021, SCA produced 11.7 TWh of bioenergy, with the vast majority (9.2 TWh) used in its own plants. Of the 2.5 TWh delivered to external customers, less than half consisted of wood pellets, while the rest was unprocessed biofuels (i.e. bark, sawdust and by-products from harvesting). SCA’s production capacity at fully or partially owned plants is 300,000 tonnes of pellets per year and represents only a small fraction of SCA’s total revenues.
Recent economic turmoil makes it harder to find assets with positive near-term growth prospects. Earlier this year, we looked at health care to find impactful defensive companies (see our note “High Impact: Surviving a Recession With Care”, June 02, 2022). Such defensive names are interesting for investors looking to protect their portfolio. Today, we expand that work to look for defensive companies that should do relatively well once the interest rate shock has passed. Water and electricity utilities have high interest-rate sensitivity and while they generally perform poorly in the most acute period of interest rate increases, we believe this acute phase of interest rates increases is nearing its end, which presents a buying opportunity for these utility companies. Below is a graphical display of the Utilities sector when the Federal Reserve is increasing rates (grey zone).
The utilities sector has existed for centuries and provides essential services. It is also often monopolistic, can be affected by weather and geopolitical events, and its prices are capped by regulatory agencies in many countries. This note addresses these issues, searching for the best plays amongst these challenges.
Water
Water utilities are a good starting point. These companies ensure a reliable supply of clean water to communities and ecosystems and contribute to general resilience of agriculture, energy, and manufacturing. In other words, the water sector is critical to public health and the economy.
The sector, however, faces increasing risks from climate change, including more droughts as shown across the world over the summer of 2022, as well as ageing infrastructure. California is one example: as seen in the graph below, the state has been in a complete state of drought from October 2021 to October 2022, and over half of the past 10 years have seen an average drought of 98% or more. California is an extreme case but more regions are following in its footsteps. Higher global temperatures are forecasted to bring more rain but the distribution in time and space is increasingly uneven. This will create further pressure on water utilities that will have to deal with not enough water, and then suddenly, too much rain.
Droughts can result in significant operational issues for water utilities, including supply loss and poor water quality. Consequently, building drought resilience is critical for water utilities.
To assess water investment plays, we developed a methodology that takes into account the ability of a utility to respond to water threats, withstand impacts from droughts, and quickly recover when they occur, as well as financial and sustainability criteria:
- The water utility universe consists of developed-market companies with a market capitalization of over US$1 billion selected from the pool of companies from Refinitiv Eikon tagged as “Utilities” and tagged “Water Utilities” in the SASB Materiality Index.
- To account for resiliency, we looked at water efficiency policies and targets for water efficiency.
- We then screened for ESG practices (through controversies and CSRHub scores) and financial stability (through pertinent financial ratios).
We find that Aguas Andinas, Veolia and American Water Works all have superior characteristics due to their drought monitoring and forecasting systems, underscoring their preparedness to potential climate threats.
Electricity
The electricity market can be even more complex. In the EU energy system, the wholesale electricity price is set by the last power plant needed to meet overall demand. Wind farms, nuclear, coal and gas plants and all other generators bid into the power market, with the cheapest sources coming in first, followed by pricier sources like gas. This has led to a surge in prices since the beginning of the war in Ukraine, and high gas prices for this coming winter raise the potential for protests and social unrest (Czech Republic is already seeing them).
European governments are trying to head off that risk with caps on the electricity rates for residents. Those price caps will leave governments on the hook for making up the difference likely leading to huge spending deficits (as these actions could cost billions) and/or force them to nationalize utilities as a way to bail them out (such as the case of EDF In France). Leaders hope to minimize deficits by heavily taxing energy companies, while demanding more production from them. Electric utilities in regulated markets could also be negatively impacted as the government shares in the pain of its subsidies. Indeed, many electric utilities had to be bailed out by their governments due to the recent increases in natural gas prices. Electric utilities with significant state ownership were already the ones mainly dependent on fossil fuels and natural gas, while utilities without government ownership generate much more of their electricity from renewables, as shown in the graph below. This gap will accentuate with bailouts. European governments now face a conundrum where they want to reduce carbon emissions but directly own large percentages of those same heavy emitters.
Electric utilities that have gone through this period of heightened volatility without government support fall into three categories: the naturally more resilient, the better risk manager and the fortunate enough (i.e. those that did not sell too much electricity forward at lower prices).
In order to find the best investment plays in electrical utilities (meaning the most resilient and best risk managers), we used a similar approach to water, but this time looked for “Electric Utilities” in the SASB Materiality Index and assessed resiliency through the percentage of energy supply coming from renewables.
The characteristics of the selected companies are presented in the table below:
We expect these companies, which are independent from conventional energy and also have strong financial ratios, to outperform.