Today’s note looks at pricing discrepancies in equity vs. credit markets within our Energy Transition theme. While both ESG and sustainable investing had a hard time since 2022, within the Energy Transition theme, our renewable energy subtheme has suffered the most. Indeed, the combination of higher interest rates, ESG cultural wars and backlash against renewables in some jurisdictions (Texas, Alberta) have all contributed to the derating of transition-focused strategies. As a result, many companies in the space are now trading close to their 2017 values – while both the NASDAQ and the S&P 500 have doubled and continue to make new records.
On the face of it, many highly levered stocks in the energy transition space are facing costs associated with higher interest rates. This has affected profit margins and free-cash flow yields – which have deteriorated in the past three years as total debt to EBITDA ratios have doubled.
Conversely, the credit market points towards a different story. First, credit spreads over U.S. Treasuries for the global alternative energy sector – renewables and energy efficiency – have come back to their pre-COVID levels, a time when energy transition was one of the hottest investment themes.
Energy Transition: The Tide Will Turn Soon
In addition to the disconnect between equity and credit markets, we think that it is time for equity investors to move back into the renewable energy theme, essentially for two economic reasons:
- Global Demand for (clean) Energy: Can’t Stop Won’t Stop
Electricity demand is set to boom globally over the next few years. Increased demand coming from AI computing capacity, the growth in the number of data centers (see our note “Catching The Next Wave: Positioning For 2nd Derivative AI Plays in Sustainable Themes”, February 29), increasing demand for heat pumps, additional electrification of the grid, electrification of the automotive fleet, the reshoring and re-industrialisation western economies are indicative trends of a stronger demand for electric power – both in Europe and in the U.S.Furthermore, some studies suggest that in the U.S. alone, the additional electrical production capacity that needs to be built is equivalent to bringing all of California’s current production online within the next five years. In this context, electricity prices will remain elevated and so will demand for renewable energy suppliers to build the required. This should support utilities and equipment makers in the renewable space.
Source: World Bank via IEA
- The Pipeline for Green Projects is Full
Furthermore, the sheer amount of renewable energy projects set to come online globally will support renewable equipment makers. While several renewable projects were cancelled in the U.S. in recent months due to growing costs and soaring interest rates (see our note: “Finding a Floor in Renewables”, October 26, 2023), it still makes sense for these projects to come off the shelf now that interest rates have stabilized and will potentially decline later this year.
After all, the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) forecasts that renewable energy production will soon match the capacity of natural gas – yet another indication that companies operating in renewable energy production, distribution and equipment making are set to benefit from a renewed second tailwind.

Finding Nuggets Among the Wreckage
To find gems within the renewable energy space, one should first look at companies that have lost their downside momentum. Interestingly, companies like Innergex and NextEra (producers and developers) have recently bounced off their recent 3-month low.
What’s more, the credit market is also suggesting that the default risk of these companies is relatively low. That said, one also sees that most credit spreads against their benchmarks remain substantially higher than the MSCI Global Green Bond Alternative Energy Index (which itself was of 72 bps as of March 20) – suggesting that the companies in our sample have also somewhat derated with credit investors compared to the overall sector.
Our hypothesis at the end of 2023 that the artificial intelligence hype had become extreme with respect to related stock valuations has not panned out so far in 2024. Not only did Nvidia’s stock price soar on last week’s earnings announcement, but the company’s CEO Jensen Huang has further fuelled excitement related to generative AI with his optimistic guidance, “[AI] Demand is surging worldwide across companies and nations… Auto, health, robotics, financial services… multibillion-dollar industries are embracing our generative AI”.
Although the valuations of many “AI companies” make our eyes water (NVIDIA is trading at 66 times earnings), there is certainly much to be excited about from a productivity perspective. After all, as we highlighted in our April 2023 note, “Finding Real Returns in Artificial Intelligence” ChatGPT displays an IQ of above 120, placing it among the top 10% of humans. This is quite the progress, given that less than a decade ago, researchers ranked Google’s AI IQ at 47, just shy of the average IQ (55) of a human 6-year-old. That said, for AI to make its way into all spheres of the economy like Internet did in the late 1990s, a massive economy-wide CAPEX effort will be needed – and as of now, that has yet to happen.
And what about from a sustainability perspective? There has been healthy debate (although perhaps not enough action) surrounding ethical aspects of AI. Questions have been raised about the energy intensity of AI tools, about data biases that are leading to discriminatory outcomes, about potential job losses, etc. On the flip side, AI promises to address challenges across industries, including resource optimization and medical breakthroughs. In short, artificial intelligence’s influence on our future is complex and heterogeneous. For investors looking to put capital to work beyond the semiconductor companies that have supplied AI with the chips to flourish, we note the key Sustainable Market Strategies’ themes where leveraging AI should produce superior real-world outcomes alongside superior returns.
Productivity with Purpose
With labor shortages persisting in many developed countries and an ever-increasing need to make better use of physical resources, the first major allure of artificial intelligence is its potential to increase productivity, either by replacing less efficient technologies (and/or labor) or via optimisation of resources.
Software companies were one of the “early movers” with respect to excitement in the application of AI tools. Indeed, four software companies with strong ESG credentials that have been widely lauded for their AI integration – Salesforce, ServiceNow, Adobe and Workday – have seen their stock prices jump between 70- 80% in the past year: a less stellar performance than Nvidia perhaps, but nonetheless extraordinary relative to the S&P500.
That said, investors would be justified if concerned that last year’s hype will not be repeated in 2024: ServiceNow and Workday both reported quarterly earnings in February and the stock market reaction was negative. Both companies disappointed on revenue growth. Investors seemed particularly underwhelmed by Workday’s announcement of the acquisition of an “AI talent solution company”. What is more, Workday has recently come under pressure for facilitating discriminatory biases with its existing AI tools. At valuations still sky high (the lowest P/E of these companies is Adobe at 47 times earnings!), it makes sense to look elsewhere for productive and sustainable applications of AI.
Beyond software, one area that we find exciting as an AI sustainability opportunity is in industrial automation and digital design. In our note last year, we screened for companies that were best positioned to leverage AI advances for purposeful applications, i.e. supporting decarbonization, optimizing physical resource use and improving safety in industries like energy and food production.
The companies we identified at the time were already making good use of artificial intelligence tools and this has continued, with several companies like Schneider Electric and Rockwell Automation announcing new partnerships with Microsoft to leverage their OpenAI tools.
- Rockwell Automation (ROK) provides automation and software solutions to the manufacturing sector, primarily in the U.S. Like many parts of the U.S. manufacturing sector, the company struggled over the past year with an inventory bulge and supply chain constraints, which have been reflected in the company’s muted stock price performance. With the U.S. manufacturing sector showing signs of revival (e.g. the ISM manufacturing survey has bottomed), companies like Rockwell offer an interesting entry point.
- Schneider Electric SE is an automation and energy management company, with about three-quarters of revenue generated from energy management and one-quarter from industrial automation. This makes the company particularly well-positioned to leverage AI advances for purposeful applications as well as to capitalize on the structural buildout of electricity grids (see last section below).
Leave No Person Behind
At Sustainable Market Strategies, investing to reduce social inequalities centers around three key ideas: improving health outcomes through greater access to care and medical breakthroughs, improving education and increasing labor fairness. Of these three sub-themes, we believe education is the area where artificial intelligence is already playing out in stock prices and where sustainability investors can leverage near-term trends.
Artificial intelligence apps, such as ChatGPT, are increasingly part of an educational toolbox just like calculators, and simple web searches. Artificial intelligence employs adaptive learning, intelligent content curation, and smart monitoring and reporting to teach skills: dozens of learning apps powered by AI have sprung up in recent months. One stand-out is Duolingo. The company’s main focus is on language learning, which is in high demand due to ever-increasing international worker flows and remote work. In a note last June “Education Stocks: Will ChatGPT Decide Who Passes or Fails”, we contended that Duolingo would be an AI winner. Since then, the company has added personalized language lessons fuelled by AI-powered feedback and has reached all-time high engagement rates, as measured by the activity of daily and monthly users. The stock price is up over 40% since our June note and Q4 earnings that were reported earlier this week confirm that the company is able attract paid subscribers to their products.
As for health care, this is the sector that holds the most promise for positive disruption from AI. Already, there are several research studies showing that AI can perform as well as or better than humans at some health care tasks. Studies show, for example, that patients often prefer responses to medical questions from chatbots over physicians, giving the chatbot higher ratings on both quality and empathy!
But the best medical use cases of AI involve settings where large data sets (especially images) that can be applied to well-defined problems are available. Diagnosing diseases, by reviewing X-rays for example, is a very effective use of AI. Companies like Quest Diagnostics, which offers access to diagnostic testing services for cancer, cardiovascular disease, neurological disorders, already leverage AI in their diagnostic tools, most notably for dementia.
A major risk, however, is that current medical AI tools tend to amplify existing discriminative biases in health care outcomes: since AI-based health care technology depends on the data that it is fed, a lack of representative data risks leading to biased models that ultimately produce incorrect health assessments especially according to race. Moreover, although the health care sector is heavily regulated, no regulations directly target the use of AI in medical devices. This is likely to change and will significantly alter the risk/reward profile of health care companies actively investing in AI tools.
Finally, in terms of labor fairness, there remain many challenges to ensure that AI tools do not accentuate existing cognitive biases. In addition, at a macro level, there are good odds that artificial intelligence will impact income inequality in ways similar to previous technology booms: if AI is levered mainly to increase automation, then a widening in the gap between capital and labor and between the professional class and other workers is likely.
A recent Pew survey in the U.S. is illustrative: the survey showed that workers with a university education are twice as likely as those without to be exposed to AI in their jobs. These same workers were far more likely to say that AI will help them more than hurt them in their jobs. On the flipside, retail trade, construction and accommodation and food services are all industries where workers are unlikely to see much benefit from AI tools and are also at risk of being replaced by technology. These are industries that tend to be lower wage jobs with low levels of unionization or other worker protections. In other words, there is some evidence to suggest that gains from artificial intelligence will accrue in already high-paying sectors and largely bypass and/or harm employment in lower paying industries. It is challenging to find AI focused investment ideas related to alleviating income/labor fairness, particularly since, as described above, some of the best company software tools (Salesforce, Workday) allegedly create increased discriminatory biases.
Achieving The Energy Transition
Artificial intelligence is a voracious consumer of energy. An oft-quoted study published in late 2023 projects that based on current and future sales of Nvidia microchips specifically for AI, the amount of electricity required to power the world’s data centers could jump by 50% by 2027, thanks to AI alone. According to the study, that’s about the power consumption of the Netherlands, and would require the entire output of about 15 average-size nuclear power plants.
Many companies are working on smaller, less power-hungry AI models that, but even if AI-related energy is half of the current estimate, it will require substantial increases in power production. Most problematic is that the energy “needs” of AI are arriving at a time when renewable energy supply is still falling short of overall energy demand: without the complicating factor of AI, the energy transition is already a massive challenge.
To be sure, artificial intelligence can be used to make the grid smarter and optimize energy usage. But it’s likely that over the next five years, demand from the production of data across industries will far outpace energy savings from optimization within the energy sector.
Crucially, it is the demands on distribution and transmission of electricity (i.e. the grid) that is particularly challenged by artificial intelligence demands. Transporting electricity from where it is produced to where data centres are desired requires a buildout of the electricity grid.
This problem is particularly acute in North America, where grid planners have recently nearly doubled their 5-year load growth forecast; in the U.S. electricity demand is now expected to increase by 4.7% over the next five years. By way of comparison, over the past decade, grid planners have been forecasting a mere 0.5% annual growth rate.
We see this as a major bottleneck for artificial intelligence usage and a major opportunity for companies involved in the buildout of energy transmission. Schneider Electric, Eaton Corporation, ABB, Nexans, Prysmian should become household names for investors that want exposure to the energy transition.
News last week that the U.S. was now putting restraints on new liquified natural gas shipments to countries with whom it does not have a free trade agreement may mark the “peak gas” moment in the world economy. This comes at a time when environmental concerns are growing regarding the role of natural gas as a “clean” source of energy. After all, total global CO2 emissions from natural gas are approaching those of oil and to a lesser extent, coal.

Furthermore, numerous studies suggest that methane leaks coming from LNG operations and other natural gas facilities are at least as potent as coal with regards to global warming. Recently published research suggests that assuming a 0.2% loss of methane across natural gas and LNG facilities, this would put the LNG/natural gas industry on par with coal and its effects on climate change. What’s more, other researchers found that methane leaks are often largely underreported by the Oil & Gas sector in countries such as Canada, adding to the overall climate warming estimates of the industry. Finally, a recently published article in Nature suggests that the extraction and use of fossil fuels account for about 15–22% of total methane emissions and those same methane emissions have been underestimated in the range of 20–60%. Given that natural gas is mostly made up of methane, these numbers are especially alarming considering that global natural gas production has boomed since 2000, in fact doubling in volume, and growing much faster pace than oil.
Despite the greenhouse gas potency coming of gas-related emissions, some countries are still accelerating their dependence on the fuel. For example, Germany has decided not to restart some of their decommissioned nuclear facilities despite the energy crisis resulting from Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. As a surprise to many - and despite the critique from several experts and environmental groups - the country recently announced that it would launch the construction of several new LNG terminals instead.
In this context – with coal almost universally banned from sustainability-minded investor portfolios and several investors now divested out of oil – what are investors to do with assets in gas? After all, for many years gas-related companies and utilities have claimed that they were “cleaner than coal”. This was a convenient way to keep consumers and governments happy, permitting a business-as-usual approach in supplying the economy with a stable source of base power – all this despite its relatively high carbon footprint. But that narrative is changing rapidly – at least in regions where energy security seems a lesser concern than in Germany.
An increasing number of cities around the world have taken steps to ban new natural gas hookups to combat climate change. In the U.S., Berkeley (California) became the first American city to ban natural gas hookups in new buildings in 2019. Other cities such as San Jose, Mountain View, Santa Rosa and Brisbane have also banned natural gas equipment in new buildings. Chicago is also considering a ban on natural gas hookups in new construction. In Canada, Montreal just announced it will no longer allow gas hookups in new buildings of up to three storeys high as of October 2024, and ban the fossil fuel as of April 2025 in larger new builds.
If the trend stays the same, gas-related assets could realistically become stranded within the next decade or so. Aside from issues pertaining to global warming, this is especially true if one considers the fact that the levelized cost of electricity production from gas is increasingly expensive compared to that of renewable sources – and even nuclear.
The Last Mile Is the Hardest One
For some investors, the path towards “getting out” of gas will prove a hard feat. We see two main issues around weaning portfolios off gas. First, if will be hard for investors in the Canadian stock market, with a 17 percent weight in Energy in the S&P TSX equity index, to find diversified investment strategies if we start excluding gas and pipelines from the universe. Looking at the fixed income market, as much as 20 percent of all fixed income securities in Canada were in the gas and pipeline sector as of 2023. In this context, decarbonizing the “last mile” of Canada-focused fixed-income portfolios could also mean considerably shrinking the investment universe and increasing active risk.
The second issue comes from the desire of many investors to gain exposure to infrastructure assets through infrastructure funds. These multi-sector infrastructure funds often include pipelines, LNG terminals, and local gas distribution networks. In fact, while the Oil & Gas sector represents only 3.8% of the S&P 500’s market capitalization, it represents about 15% (on average) in infrastructure funds. Looking at 98 funds on Bloomberg with exposure to Oil & Gas assets included in the infrastructure theme, we see that Oil & Gas assets represented about USD 9.9 billion of a total AUM of USD 48.6 billion as of late 2023. The table below underlines the funds with the heaviest exposure to the Oil & Gas sector, with some funds displaying a 20-40 percent exposure to Oil and Gas.
Interestingly, the equal-weighted index of the 98 infrastructure funds underperformed by some 30 percentage points against the MSCI ACWI index since 2019 (on a total return basis). While the infra sector should benefit from lower interest rates towards the latter part of this year, it is hard to see a long-term case for holding infrastructure assets with a high exposure to Oil & Gas in your portfolio for the long run.
2023 will surely be remembered as a year of market divergences: while global equity indexes delivered returns in the mid-teens, this masks the explosive performance of the Magnificent 7, the catastrophic year for many renewable energy plays, and much “muck” in between.
To be sure, economic and financial market performance can be chalked up to the extreme optimism surrounding artificial intelligence as well as a resilient U.S. consumer. Neither of these factors are likely to be in such force in 2024.
After all, there are signs that generative AI (i.e. models like ChatGPT) has already hit the peak in the hype cycle and is set to enter the “trough of disillusionment” (see chart below).
As for the U.S. consumer, the thick buffers in household budgets thanks to emergency COVID policy measures are wearing thin. The lag has been longer than is typical, but tight monetary policy is showing up in the form of higher consumer loan delinquency rates and less appetite for interest rate-sensitive purchases.
Our 2024 economic expectations are captured in the chart below. We expect a mild-to-average consumer-focused recession and see the balance of risks tilted toward stickier-than-expected inflation but about equal in regard to growth. Ergo, relative to current market expectations, we anticipate that policy rates will be higher for longer (we disagree with market participants that currently price a greater than 70% chance of March rate cuts). Central banks can no longer opt for aggressive accommodation at first sight of a growth slowdown due to structurally higher inflation trends.
If we are correct, this means that stocks are less appealing overall but the typical investment playbook for recessionary periods does need to be revised. There are sectoral implications and nuances that sustainability investors should consider:
- The impacts of the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) will be present for at least the first half of 2024. Re-shoring and building back better continue to be relevant sustainability themes and these effects are particularly strong in the U.S. It is our principal support for advocating for an overweight bias to the U.S. relative to Europe. In fact, the persistent positive impact of the Inflation Reduction Act is one of very few sources of global stimulus.
- That said, a reversal in Biden-era policies should Donald Trump win the 2024 American presidential election risks having a significant, detrimental impact on several sustainability themes - including renewable energy, energy efficiency and possibly healthcare plays. This is a key development worth watching beyond Q2.
- The global manufacturing recession is well advanced while the U.S. consumer recession is just getting started. This pattern is not unique (manufacturing tends to lead economies into and out of recessions), but in light of the ongoing IRA stimulus, there is a strong case that the manufacturing cycle has already bottomed and is stabilizing while momentum in the consumer sector is accelerating to the downside.
Against this backdrop, we propose five sustainability centric investment ideas for 2024.
Idea #1: Stay long green industrials, go short wasteful consumer discretionary (but mind the Presidential polls)
As noted above, the global manufacturing sector contracted all through 2023 and a major inventory destocking cycle is well advanced. On the flipside, consumers are finally showing signs of fading. Higher for longer interest rates won’t favor either sector, but fiscal firepower sits squarely in favor of the industrial sector thanks to the IRA and to a lesser degree, pro-climate policies in other countries as well. Thus, on a cyclical horizon, industrial plays, especially those that benefit from the great building green retrofit are well placed to outperform consumer discretionary sectors. On a longer-term basis, the desire to re-shore as well as greenify key infrastructure means that for the first time in decades, the industrial sector is likely to grow as a sustainable share of underlying GDP. 2024 provides a good entry point into this long-term theme. Investors looking to build positions could start with companies tied to essential goods and services.
For example, water efficiency names like Watts Water (WTS US) and Xylem (XYL US) have been moving higher but have further to go if our economic outlook is correct. On the short side, luxury “greenwashers” tend to underperform the market during recession (LVMH is a favored short candidate). Additionally, news that Shein, an ultra fast-fashion retailer is looking to go public is also exciting from the short side: we can’t wait for the shine to come off this stock after the IPO pumping hype.
Idea #2: Selectively toe dip in Sustainable Infrastructure, Renewable Energy and Utilities
Given their high correlation to bond yields and defensive characteristics, sustainable infrastructure, renewable energy and utilities typically require policymakers to embark on a rate-cutting cycle to outperform. But some stocks in these sectors became extremely oversold in 2023. We highlight two stocks that we believe currently offer excellent value within sustainability themes benefitting from long-term tailwinds:
Alstom: This railcar manufacturing company, while relatively unaffected by the interest rate backdrop (debt/equity ratio of 31%), has nonetheless been crushed in 2023 due to supply chain issues and project delays. This led to the company going from a healthy positive cashflow projection to negative in a span of months. In 2023, Alstom had to deal with a USD 5 Billion legacy backlog that delivered negative margins, and it also mistimed a costly inventory buildup while customers delayed desired delivery times.
We believe Alstom’s problems are largely over. Fortunately, customers are not cancelling orders, they have just been delayed: Alstom currently has USD 87 billion order backlogs, which equates to around five years worth of contracts. The company has a forward P/E of 9 and is trading at half of book value. Importantly (and unlike some U.S. wind projects that have recently been derailed), Alstom has long-term service contracts in place that are indexed to inflation.
Ameresco: A designer of energy efficiency projects in buildings – with a high exposure to U.S. government contracts – Ameresco should be relatively well insulated from slower economic growth. This company was mistakenly caught up in the “anything renewable” sell-off in 2023, but higher interest rates have not hindered the company’s access to financing, having secured over half a billion dollars in Q3 alone.
Ameresco has an impressive project backlog and has doubled the number of projects it was awarded over the past year. To be sure, one headline risk is a potential repeal of climate-friendly policies should Trump be elected, but even here, Ameresco is well positioned: many current and future projects focus on energy efficiency that ultimately save money.
Idea #3: Catch the Uranium Wave
Nuclear power provides 10 per cent of the world’s electricity. Construction of nuclear reactors takes a long time (5-10 years) but offers a substantial service life advantage: twice as long as alternatives like solar panels and wind turbines. Around 60 power reactors are currently under construction (primarily in China and India), with an additional 110 reactors in the planning and 300 in proposal stages. Current capacity is 391,699 MWe while reactors under construction should add 69,599 MWe to the grid by 2030, and planned and proposed reactors could provide a combined 461,029 MWe, more than double the existing capacity. Extending the lifetime of existing nuclear power plants will also play an important role: the original design lifetime of nuclear power plants is usually 40 years but can be extended by 20-year increments. In the US, 90 percent of US plants have already been renewed to 60 years. The subsequent wave of renewals from 60 to 80 years will therefore be critical in supplying enough electricity to meet growing demand.
Even accounting for better efficiency of newer reactors, the trend of increasing global nuclear energy capacity means higher demand for uranium. To be sure, uranium demand does fluctuate with economic cycles and 2024 global recessionary conditions are a concern, but uranium supply is currently tight, even considering a potential cyclical slowdown. Alleviating supply-side constraints is not easy since mines take a long time to build and investments have been lacking after the long bear market of the 2010’s. Note that our enthusiasm for nuclear precedes the recent uranium spike; our series on this topic was launched in January 2021 (“A Radioactive Topic for ESG-Minded Investors”). Since then, uranium prices have increased significantly, but we expect we are still in the early innings. The recent commitment made at COP 28 by a group of 22 countries to triple nuclear capacity by 2050 underscores an increasing global desire for nuclear energy and the bullish sentiment around this investment.
A company like Cameco (CCO CA), which focuses on extraction of uranium ore and the production of uranium concentrate, is well positioned to capitalize on rising uranium demand. In order to be used as a fuel, however, uranium needs to be enriched. The U.S. currently imports a quarter of its enriched uranium from Russia. Enter Centrus Energy (LEU US). This company is a U.S. provider of high-assay low-enriched uranium used in most of the advanced reactor designs now under development. Being a U.S. company, it is in an enviable position, especially since the American government has proposed legislation that would bar the importation of enriched Russian uranium.
Idea #4: Carbon Copies? Not Quite: The Unique Traits of NA and EU Markets
Despite being a global molecule affecting climate globally, carbon dioxide (CO2) exhibits fundamental regional differences when it comes to the tradable commodity. Depending on which version of the carbon commodity you look at, the year 2023 tells a very different story. While the EU allowances (EUAs) have lost 17% of their value, the WCI allowances (CCAs) have gained more than 32%.
What explains this? The short answer is the correlation between industrial GHG emissions and economic activity. The Eurozone economy has fared worse than the North American economy in 2023 and as a result, Europe’s industrial GHG emissions were lower than last year (about 7% according to LSEG). This is positive for the environment but translates to lower demand for EUAs. The chart below also shows the performance of the voluntary carbon market credits, aka carbon offsets. Avid SMS readers know that we are not fans of that market. The past year was filled with integrity scandals and voluntary markets should continue to be avoided.
For 2024, we remain generally bullish for most liquid regulated carbon markets (Europe’s market is about $850B per year while California-Québec is roughly $70B per year). In Europe, industrial activity is likely to remain tame, but there are other positive factors at work:
- The allowance’s price is back to its pre-Ukraine invasion price (<70€), after having flirted with 100€ at the end of 2022.
- France and Germany just recently reached key power price deals that should set the stage for increased power consumption by industry from 2024 onwards.
- Favorable regulatory adjustments and post COP28 international momentum should provide necessary tailwinds to push up the price.
As for the California-Québec market, even though prices had a good run in recent months, there is still ample upside potential to the unit price. Currently, carbon allowances trade just above CA$52 which is already trailing its European equivalent and in addition, the Canadian Carbon Tax scheme will increase to CA$80 in 2024, leaving a comfortable gap to fill on the upside. Moreover, the State of Washington intends to join California and Québec which should be a bullish event for the CCAs.
KRBN dominates the carbon ETF market. However, this ETF is heavily skewed toward Europe (65%). For investors that prefer to build their own regional weighting, Kraneshare California Carbon Allowance (ticker KCCA) ETF provides exposure to only North American carbon, while Kraneshare European Carbon Allowance (ticker KEUA) is the European equivalent. In the current context, we suggest two-thirds allocation to North America.
Idea #5: Short? Affirmative!
Affirm is one of the major players in the Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) space. At SMS we have a negative view towards BNPL as it facilitates excess spending, while targeting consumers that can ill afford to do so. Affirm also ranks low on ESG scores, such as CSRHub rankings for community, employees and environment. Affirm’s share price has had a wild ride the past two years: after losing 85% of its value in 2022, the stock spent the first ten months of 2023 carving out a base. It has since shot up 100% since end-October. This recent rise was fuelled by Affirm’s better than expected Q3 earnings – i.e. less negative earnings - the headline-grabbing surge in BNPL for holiday shopping and the general risk-on rally in the stocks.
However, the BNPL model is struggling to cope with the end of ZIRP and macro headwinds on consumer discretionary spending. Affirm is projected to be unprofitable for the next five years(!) and there are other big players in the payment space that can easily take their market share (there is little brand loyalty in this industry). Affirm stock is now coming into overhead resistance above $40 and we agree with the broker consensus that the share price should be lower (we target $20). Even though short interest on the stock is high (currently 21%) that should not be a deterrent for nimble-footed sustainable investors from shorting this stock.
Investors who associate climate change with a singular play—renewable energy stocks—have had an extremely challenging year. Vehicles like the iShares Global Clean Energy Fund (ICLN US) have had a disastrous first ten months of 2023 and only found some relief in November, once the Fed signalled a potential end to their rate raising campaign.
This performance should not be overly surprising, since renewables are highly sensitive to real interest rates; any portfolio levered to the climate change theme that relies only on clean energy stocks will largely move with the interest rate cycle. Debt comprises over 80% of capital expenditures for most wind and solar projects (since the energy source is free) and until recently, most U.S. utility-scale solar and onshore wind projects had not faced rising interest rates. Going forward, the economics of new projects are vulnerable to higher borrowing costs.
The outlook for this sector is certainly brighter in 2024, given the consensus view (of which the SMS team agrees) that the bulk of monetary policy tightening is behind us.
Investing for Environmental Diversification
2023 was a year when diversification within green portfolios was key to performance. While renewable energy stocks lost value, energy efficiency plays and nuclear energy stocks had a banger year. Other environmental sub-sectors like water and forestry were decent and are likely to end the year in the green. By and large, investors who understand that environmental investment themes go beyond the transition from fossil fuels to renewables have been rewarded with positive portfolio returns in 2023.
The table below lists some of the green sub-themes that we consider investable through public markets and some of the key macro drivers of each sub-theme. The key takeaway is that different environmental challenges are affected by varying macro conditions—this makes it possible to construct an active environmental equity strategy that takes account of the cyclical economic backdrop.
U.S. High Impact Outperformance Candidates
To illustrate the fact that environmental impact goes beyond renewable energy, here are three high impact U.S. candidates that should continue to do well in three different environmental sub-sectors: water, energy efficiency, and forestry.
Water
A couple months ago, Danaher Corp (DHR US) spun off its Environmental & Applied Solutions segment to create a new listed company, Veralto Corp (VLTO US). Approximately 60% of the company's sales come from water quality services, encompassing various brands and businesses such as Hach, ChemTreat, Trojan Technologies, Aquatic Informatics, and others. These entities are extensively involved in water analytics and treatment addressing specific applications such as managing water scarcity, ensuring water quality, complying with contamination regulations, and promoting sustainability. The impact of the company is even more significant as more than 30% of its revenues come from Emerging and Developing Economies (EDEs), where providing water solutions can literally be a life-or-death issue.
As the newly listed company is a direct extraction from another company’s segment, we have the luxury of knowing some key financial metrics instead of having to wait for the first earnings report. In 2022, the $4.9 billion business not only achieved 8% core sales growth but also demonstrated impressive margins, with gross margins reaching 57%, and EBITDA margins accounting for 24% of sales. Despite a slowdown in core sales growth to 4% in the first half of 2023—prior to the spin-off—the operating profit margins stood at 23%. Valuation-wise, the company started trading at a forward P/E ratio of 26x (now 24x) which is well in-line with its peers in the water and sanitation sector (the average P/E ratio of companies included in the Invesco Water Resources ETF (PHO US) is 26x).
Energy Efficiency
The energy efficiency company we expect to do well is Owens Corning (OC US). Owens Corning is a leading producer of insulation products for buildings, including fiberglass insulation, foam insulation, and blown-in insulation. These products help to reduce heat loss in winter and heat gain in summer, resulting in important energy savings for their clients. The company has had a banger year, resulting in its stock price being up 60% year-to-date. This can be partly explained by the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA). The IRA is the most substantial federal investment in home energy efficiency to date, allocating $8.8 billion to weatherize homes and assist households in saving billions of dollars in energy costs while reducing carbon emissions. Nearly a year after the enactment of the law, the U.S. Department of Energy just recently released the requirements and instructions for accessing $4.3 billion from the Home Efficiency Rebates Program, providing grants for comprehensive home efficiency improvements. This should continue to provide a significant tailwind for Owens Corning. In addition, in an unexpected turn of events, Owens Corning finds itself in a position to capitalize on the rising frequency and intensity of hurricanes, given the company's products in constructing buildings that can withstand storms.
Sustainable Forestry
Finally, the third company we wish to highlight is Weyerhaeuser (WY US). Weyerhaeuser is an American timberland company that owns or manages nearly 14 million acres of timberlands in the United States and Canada, which makes them America’s largest private landowner. The company has two main segments: Wood Products and Timberlands (logging). As per our September 7th note “Don’t Miss the Forest for the Trees”, not all forestry-related products have the same environmental impact.
Weyerhaeuser falls in the highest impact category for the sector as instead of producing short-lived products that would return the carbon to the atmosphere shortly after having been produced, the company manufactures structural lumber and other construction materials which have a very long and useful life. As for their logging business, the company follows strict sustainable forestry practices and plants more trees than it cuts. Finally, Weyerhaeuser is able to collect advanced geological data on its leased lands which led to strategic partnerships with energy companies (notably Occidental and Denbury) looking to sequestrate some carbon.
According to some estimates, the company’s new Natural Climate Solutions unit could become a profit center before long, which makes them an attractive high-impact firm to follow. Due to the slowdown in residential construction related to the high-interest-rate situation, the company’s revenues stalled somewhat in 2023 (which explains a modest +1% gain for its stock price year-to-date). However, other underlying tailwinds like limited inventory of existing homes and growing demographics should offset the higher interest rate environment that could last for a while.
News last week that energy project developers in the State of New York canceled some offshore wind energy projects served another blow to the already-bruised renewable energy sector. Indeed, the combination of higher interest rates, increased maintenance costs and power purchase agreements (PPA) that did not price-in these new macro conditions has diminished developers’ and investors’ appetite for renewable energy projects.
Our in-house equal-weighted indices of Renewable Developers, Renewable Utilities, and Renewable Equipment Manufacturers have substantially underperformed the MSCI World index by a margin of 30 to 50 percentage points YTD.
This underperformance of the renewable energy sector explains a large part of the underperformance of sustainability-focused investment strategies since February. Furthermore, the combination of decade-high interest rates and yields, added to anti-ESG backlash of the past few months, means that scouting investment ideas in the sector has become much harder.
Assuming that we are close to an interest rate ceiling – as currently suggested in the OIS market in the U.S. – where should one look to find investment opportunities across the renewable space? To find the answer, consider that one of the latent problems of a longer-for-higher interest rate environment is that it materializes itself in higher interest costs in balance sheets and income statements – especially for firms which have highly levered business models. While macro headwinds are strong, renewables remain a significant part of our energy future, so it is worth searching for the names likely to survive/persist through the tempest. Today’s note looks at three sub-sectors in SMS’ investment universe: renewable equipment manufacturers, renewable project developers, and renewable utilities and suggests a few ideas to survive the storm.
Renewable Equipment Manufacturers: Hope for a Recession and its Stimulus Companion!
It is challenging to see the light at the end of the tunnel for renewable equipment manufacturers. The sector still faces several headwinds: 1) exposure to China across the supply chain in wind and solar manufacturers makes them a no go for many investors and project developers (see our note “China’s Solar Power and Deglobalization: An Irresistible Force Paradox”, March 9, 2023); 2) higher costs associated to projects and PPP models vis-à-vis risk-free rate makes them a relatively less attractive investment in the current context; and 3) already high public and private debt levels which could push back the much-needed infrastructure investments – especially in the Energy sector. Interestingly, some studies suggest that about 65% of windmill maintenance costs are currently unplanned for by operators. Considering turbines built in 2023, the study estimates that after 20 years more than 40% of gearboxes will need to be replaced, 20% of main bearings and more than 5% of wind blades. This should be kept in mind for equipment manufacturers and project developers/operators given the potential impact of lower-than-expected reliability on the overall costs and profitability.
In the shorter term, one way to examine companies' vulnerability to a higher interest rate environment is to look at their interest coverage ratios. Firms such as Alfen N.V. display short-term relative strength from a credit perspective (EBITDA/Interest ratio) vis-à-vis its peers, which could prove an interesting play if rates remain elevated over the next 12 months. Conversely, investors should remain underweight companies with low EBITDA/Interest ratios at least until some recessionary fiscal stimulus from governments if a recession materializes and/or lower rates start to be priced in by markets.
Project Developers: On the Dentist’s chair Longer than Thought?
Developers likely will suffer the most in the current environment as they remain highly levered compared to the other renewable energy sub-sectors. Here again, one should prioritize firms with lower debt ratios. A play like Acciona appears interesting. One could also look at Ameresco, a firm which focused on the development of energy projects. The company derives about 50% of revenues from U.S. government contracts which are likely to bounce in the context of ongoing green stimulus.
Renewable Utilities: Useful in Times of Crisis
Looking at utilities in the renewable space, one should focus on players with relatively low exposure to debt and with high interest coverage ratios such as Verbund AG, which has a solid footing in the renewable space in Austria. Another company is NextEra Energy Partners, displaying a strong business model and better than average credit fundamentals. The stock plunged late last month when management revised the dividend outlook from 8% to 5% per share – but the company remains on strong footing for the long-term.
In our view, some renewable energy stocks have now become sufficiently depressed that they present an interesting entry point. The list below provides a summary of what should remain on investors’ shopping list, with a view to buy when interest rates look to peak. for the coming months.
Transport represents around 20% of global emissions, with passenger vehicles accounting for nearly 50% of those emissions in 2022. As an act requiring little change to current behaviors, the EV swap is a quick win to lower transport emissions. The transition is already well underway: electric cars on the road have increased five-fold since 2018, reaching 26 million vehicles globally in 2022. Many countries have targets to phase out gas and diesel-powered cars within the next twenty years and in its latest report, the IEA estimates that there will be 240 million electric vehicles in circulation by 2030.
Far from the nascent days of this technology, most automakers today are producing electric vehicles. The market is competitive with everyone looking for their slice of the (growing) pie. Since 2018, the number of EV models available for purchase has doubled to 500! In light of this, our note examines the relevant factors for analysing auto stocks amidst the EV transition, and also broadens the EV opportunity set by exploring other links in the automotive value chain.
EV Winners – Anybody’s Guess?
When it comes to car manufacturers, Tesla and BYD are leading the battery electric vehicles (BEV) and plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEV) sales by a big margin, followed (not so) closely by VW Group and Stellantis. To determine a winner in this sector, multiple factors need to be taken into consideration: brand recognition, car lineup, pricing, and production capacity. These factors are not fundamentally different from those used 20 years ago to pick winners among ICE vehicles. In addition to these traditional elements, we also expect EV specific aspects of car offering, government subsidies and supply chain to have an impact:
- EV offering: Companies that have a broad EV offering (BEV, Hybrid and/or PHEV) can attract a larger share of customers. An example of this is Toyota. Despite focusing on hybrids, Toyota managed to be first in terms of total cars sold even though it is nowhere among the top for strictly BEV sales. By focusing not only on BEV but also on hybrids and/or PHEVs, companies will benefit from bridging the gap for consumers who have range anxiety and are concerned about availability of charging stations.
- Government’s EV subsidies: Companies that are located in certain geographic regions can also benefit from the underlying demand growth driven by government support. Both Europe and America have subsidies in place for EV automakers. America may have a slight advantage in that its consumers are more inclined to “buy American”. Ford F-series, Chevrolet Silverado and Ram pickup trucks were the top 3 selling vehicles in the US in 2022 and GM and Ford draw a large majority of their revenues from the Americas.
- Battery Supply chain robustness. Finally, although most automakers are by now well established in terms of securing their battery supply, partnerships can be a decisive factor to assure that the supply chain is robust enough to keep up with demand.
Building Your EV
The biggest difference between EVs and ICE is obviously the battery. Given its stronghold on battery materials, China has an advantage in battery production. Looking to de-risk the supply chain, America and Europe are offering various subsidies to support domestic battery production (please see our Note on this topic, The Range of the EV Battery Trade, May 23, 2023).
Though electric vehicles have no emissions from fuel combustion, non-exhaust emissions are still culprits for air pollution. As EV adoption accelerates, emissions from brake, tire and road wear will become the dominant source of traffic-related pollution. Tire-wear is exacerbated by the fact that EVs tend to be heavier than their gasoline counterparts due to the battery. As major cities crack down on air pollution (London’s ULEZ plan, France’s ZFEs and the EPA’s ambitious proposal), non-exhaust emissions could be the next target for regulation.
Europe already has standardized tire labelling with the goal to inform consumers and incentivize tire manufacturers to improve tire efficiency (rolling resistance). Since the demand for tires is unaffected by the transition to EVs, pure-play tire companies like Bridgestone and Goodyear that are already on the forefront of tire technology face limited risks to their business model. Innovation aimed at reducing the pollution from tire wear could be to their advantage.
Another important difference between EV and ICE vehicles is the use of semiconductors: EVs require twice as many as ICE vehicles. Despite a recent alleviation in the global shortage of semiconductors, strong demand is expected to persist on a structural basis. Regardless of the pace of EV adoption, the number of chips in new cars will grow to support smart safety features, driver assist technology and in-car entertainment. Chips will also be integral to the next evolutionary step for the family car: autonomous driving. In response to supply chain disruptions, automakers have sought to move away from a “just in time” approach by establishing contracts with semiconductor providers.
Leaders in the automotive semiconductor market include Renesas Electronics, STMicroelectronics, ON Semiconductor, Infineon and NXP. Each of these companies earns a significant amount of revenue (over 40% for 2022) from the automotive sector and have experienced consistent double-digit sales growth over the last two years (both Infineon and STMicroelectronics have done so consistently every quarter since 2021). Compared to some other semiconductor companies, those serving the automotive market are trading at a much lower valuation (average FWD PE for these five companies is 12.7) than advanced chip companies like Nvidia (FWD PE of 30.2) and investors are expecting rapid success of complex AI.
Servicing Your EV
The vehicle servicing industry is undergoing transformation. While some jobs will be lost, new ones will be created. Boston Consulting Group estimates that about 930,000 jobs in the European auto industry will disappear by 2030, while another 895,000 will be added.
Most of the job losses will be due to the reduction in labor required by OEMs and ICE-focused suppliers but should be offset by an increase in opportunities related to the rising demand for batteries, charging infrastructure, and other related components and services.
The automotive assembly line is already experiencing the impact of EVs. Both Ford and Volkswagen estimate that electric cars require 30% less labor compared to conventional vehicles. This is because EV powertrains have a simpler design, with fewer than 20 moving parts compared to hundreds for ICE vehicles. Moreover, automation on assembly lines is reducing the need for human labor. Fanuc is one example of a company that provides robotic solutions for automotive manufacturing applications such as welding, painting, material handling and assembly. This company has an 87% CSRHub rank in the machinery manufacturing industry because of the positive impact of its products, helping manufacturers improve productivity and safety, and optimize the use of resources. As a result of both increased automation and less need for labor in EV production, some automakers have laid off workers. An example is Ford that announced in 2022 the company would lay off 3,000 workers from its assembly plants, citing various factors including the shift to EVs.
The maintenance and repair industry will also see significant changes. Since EVs have fewer moving parts and don't require oil changes, they generally need less maintenance and repair compared to conventional vehicles. In fact, the U.S. Department of Energy’s Argonne National Laboratory suggest that the estimated scheduled maintenance cost of BEV totals 6.1 cents per mile compared to 10.1 cents per mile for ICE vehicles, meaning that the traditional repair shops should experience a direct decline in revenue of up to 35%.
Repairing EVs has also become more complex as workers need to develop new skills. Electric safety has become a crucial aspect of the job, requiring changes in certification standards set by organizations like the National Institute for Automotive Service Excellence in the US. The complexity of repairs is also observed through insurance premiums, which have soared due to factors such as longer repair times caused by part shortages, battery damage susceptibility and advanced features like driver-assistance systems which require additional time and advanced expertise for calibration and repair.
A more centralized approach whereby dealerships take greater control of maintenance and repairs is likely; dealerships have advantages like access to original equipment manufacturer parts and training. Traditional repair companies involved in oil change and brake servicing such as Driven Brands Holdings (DRVN US) and Monro (MNRO US) may be less likely to adapt to the adoption of EVs. Auto parts companies such as Genuine Parts (GPC US) and O'Reilly (ORLY US) may also be at risk due to the drastically reduced number of mechanical parts required in EVs. The characteristics of these companies are presented in the table below:
Monro and Driven Brands have already seen their stock price drop by half in the past year. However, with their valuations still in double digits, it is unlikely that investors are adequately discounting reduced demand for parts and services.
The voluntary carbon market (VCM) has had a rough year. It started in January with a devastating investigation published in The Guardian which suggested that 90% of rainforest carbon offsets accredited by Verra, one of the biggest certifiers, were worthless. As it is often the case, the article was slightly exaggerated – some would say borderline click bait – but it did shine a spotlight on an industry that clearly needs to be kept in check. In response to the criticisms, Mark Carney’s ICVCM (Integrity Council for Voluntary Carbon Markets) released the Core Carbon Principles (CCPs), a set of 10 principles that define high-quality carbon credits by strengthening controversial offset credit characteristics such as additionality, permanence, transparency, and monitoring and verification. However, it seems to be too little too late when it comes to reputational damages. Last week, Shell, which has historically been an important player in carbon offsets, ended the world’s biggest corporate plan to develop carbon offsets. And the damages can also be felt when looking at the voluntary carbon offset futures contracts which have collapsed more than 70% year-to-date (90% from the highs of January 2022).
Nevertheless, the VCM’s existential troubles should not necessarily be transposed to the forestry sector as a whole. The science is clear on the importance of the world’s forests. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) concluded that forests play an important role in both mitigating and adapting to climate change, including by absorbing about 2.6 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide per year from the atmosphere.
It is this feature of forests, namely their carbon absorption capacity, that attracts investors’ interest. Financial institutions with a combined US$130 trillion in assets under management are now committed to reaching a state of net-zero before 2050. Most have no clue how to do that, but the attraction to the forestry sector is palpable. Case in point: the Sydney-based investment manager New Forests, specialized in, you guessed it, sustainable forest investments, was acquired by Japanese powerhouses Nomura and Mitsui, with the clear intention of benefiting from all the carbon captured in these forests. It is the same story with Climate Asset Management, which was created by HSBC using the natural capital expertise of Pollination Group.
The signatories of all the net-zero alliances (asset managers, asset owners, banks, insurances, etc.) do not yet know for sure what will be acceptable to meet their targets. Officially, the Science-Based Targets initiative’s (SBTi) framework allows financial institutions to set emissions reduction targets using the following tactics: portfolio-wide abatement, engagement, divestment, avoided emissions, and climate solutions financing. It is this last tactic that makes the forestry sector appealing to financial institutions struggling with their objectives. Could they claim the carbon held in the forests they own through their investments against the emissions from their other holdings?
The debate continues, but investors interested in moving early should at least follow the following principles:
- No double counting: If the investor claims the credit against its financed emissions, neither the forestry company nor the jurisdiction (country) can claim it at the same time.
- Not every forestry company is created equal: Depending on the company’s product portfolio, the lifecycle emissions are very different. See table below.
- Co-benefits: sustainably managed forests can provide much more than just carbon sequestration – they provide clean water, critical habitat, foods and medicines, support rural livelihoods, and provide valuable recreational and cultural experiences.
- Indirect reductions: In addition to the carbon stored in the products themselves – be they construction wood, paper, cardboard, etc. – additional reductions can come from the fact that these products are replacing more carbon-intensive materials. For instance, one square metre of a wood-based outer wall leads to the emission of 7.8 kg of CO2e, while producing one square metre of a concrete-based wall emits 117 kg of CO2e (15 times more).
- From timber to biorefinery: Biorefining is the process of converting biomass into a variety of products, including fuels, chemicals, and materials. Companies that are investing in biorefining technologies to create new products and markets for their biomass are adding additional revenue sources and these products also replace more emission intensive alternatives.
Based on these criteria, we have selected a basket of forestry names that could appeal to investors looking to maximize their odds of possibly using an investment in these companies to neutralize other portfolio emissions.
For the first category of companies, Construction Wood and Forest Management, only Weyerhaeuser (WY US) is interesting both from a sustainability perspective and a reasonable price-to-earnings ratio. The fact that they are exclusively in the harvested wood products (HWP) and the forest management sectors boosts their sustainability profile as the carbon captured by their forests has a much higher chance of staying in solid pieces of wood for a longer period of time. In the Paper and Cardboard category, UPM-Kymmene (UPM FH), Klabin (KLBN11 BZ) and Oji Holdings (3861 JT) all offer a great balance between their sustainability credentials and reasonable valuations. All three also realize that they become more attractive to sustainability-minded investors when they increase the recyclability of their products.
As a bonus, it also happens the companies that scored the best in our methodology are also the highest promoters of biorefining technologies, which could prove to be a smart technology to invest in today to reap benefits in the future. All four top-scoring companies are developing biorefineries that produce cellulosic ethanol, lignin-based products, bio-based chemicals, and renewable packaging materials.
Looking at the price performance over the last five years, one may doubt the strategy of investing in these companies considering the choppiness. However, it can be explained by the fact that (1) the forestry industry is cyclical by nature and we are currently in an uncertain economic environment and (2), it is a very capital intensive industry which is especially a headwind for the industry over the past year given the high rate environment.
You may remember Miss Materiality from our December note: Miss Materiality’s Night Out: A Lesson in Consumer Choice. She is back again this week, and in search of summer vacation plans that meet her budget and reflect her values.
Consumers don’t seem to be holding back on lavish spending despite the economic backdrop of higher interest rates and high inflation. Economists have even attributed Beyonce and Taylor Swift concert goers with boosting economic activity in some regions. When Miss Materiality looks at the price for those concerts, hotels and airline tickets, she wonders, “how can they afford this ?!”.
Inflation data for June showed that prices for hotels and restaurants remain well above pre-pandemic levels, though airfares have cooled recently, experiencing an 8% drop from May to June. The latter could be a sign of consumers’ last hurrah with pandemic revenge travel as a more dire economic reality is setting in.
Miss Materiality is also concerned by recent climate news. Just as the pandemic had disruptive effects on tourism-dependent industries, she wonders how the realities of rising global temperatures will shape the future of travel. This reflection has made her more cognizant of how her travel choices impact her carbon footprint and the climate.
Still, Miss Materiality wants to do something during her time off. To settle on her vacation plans, she will need to choose her destination, accommodation, and transportation with consideration for both her budget and the environmental and social impacts from her spending choices.
Destination
Miss Materiality is relieved she didn’t travel to Europe during July where record temperatures and historic wildfires left some destinations looking more apocalyptic than dream vacations. The continent’s record hot summer last year was already enough for travellers to seek cooler places for their 2023 vacations: Travel operator Black Tomato reported a 37% increase in bookings for Scandinavia compared to 2022 and Spanish travel booking site EDreams Odigeo saw a significant increase in searches for destinations further north, notably Ireland for which searches were up 1000%. Miss Materiality will do the same, opting for a location where she can avoid the worst of the heat. As climate records continue to be broken, she can’t help but wonder whether mother nature will get the last word and if some of the most popular tourist spots have hit peak travel forever.
Miss Materiality considers visiting New Zealand where it is currently winter. The country is known for its beautiful landscapes and is hosting the 2023 Women’s World Cup during August. However, the long flight equates to a lot of emissions, and despite her passion for the sport, Miss Materiality has her qualms with FIFA.
She looks a little closer to home; beautiful British Columbia (literally the province’s tagline) where the Rocky Mountain range offers plenty of hiking opportunities. Though cooler than southern Europe, she learns the province is also experiencing intense wildfires. She doesn’t want to chance it. She’ll have to keep searching.
Accommodation
Perhaps finding the right hotel will help narrow her search. She looks for hotel chains with locations in more temperate regions. If the statistics above are any indication, such locations will benefit from rising demand over the next few years, and she can say she was there first!
The hospitality industry is a labor intensive one. In the U.S., the Leisure and Hospitality industry currently accounts for 11% of the workforce.
With a substantial number of people relying on the industry for their employment, metrics like employee compensation, benefits and working conditions are part of Miss Materiality’s criteria when evaluating hotels that align with her values. Companies that treat their employees right will benefit from lower turnover rates and cost savings from training new personnel. This is especially true when there is a labor shortage, as evidenced by wage data from the past three years (see chart below). To attract and retain talent following the pandemic, compensation in leisure and hospitality has outpaced overall wage growth, and the other consumer discretionary industry of retail. The dynamic has been similar in Europe. After all, a hotel is unlikely to get return customers if the service is not up to snuff.
Miss Materiality knows that effective energy and water management is relevant for addressing hotels’ environmental impact. She also looks for sustainability certifications like LEED and the Green Key Eco Rating. The table below shows five hotel companies that align with Miss Materiality’s environment and labor criteria as well as locations in cooler regions.
Even if she doesn’t end up staying at one of these hotels, she can consider adding them to her investment portfolio (also sustainability focused) when the economic context is more conducive.
Transport
Often the greatest contributor to an individual’s carbon footprint, transport is the most difficult consideration for Miss Materiality’s travel plans.
Growing awareness of the emissions and pollution from travel is beginning to drive some policy changes.
France’s ban on short-haul flights and the Netherlands’ restrictions on flights to Amsterdam and closure of cruise ship terminals show shifting attitudes. New measures proposed by the European Emissions Trading System and the International Maritime Organization (IMO) to charge shipping companies for their CO2 emissions could have substantial implications for cruise ship operators’ bottom lines.
Miss Materiality welcomes these actions; particularly when it comes to cruise ships. For indecisive travel planners, cruise ships may seem like an easy choice with multiple destinations, accommodation and transport bundled into a single package. However, the reality behind this convenience is that cruise lines are notorious polluters. Per kilometre emissions are estimated to be worse than taking the plane. Within marine transportation, cruise ships are the biggest emitters of black carbon (aka soot) and one European study in 2022 showed cruise ships emitted 4.4 times more sulphur oxides (SOx) than all the cars on the continent.
The regulatory risk faced by cruise operators is not reflected in their stock prices which have been inflated by robust bookings from Covid’s revenge travel. Between this and their unsustainable debt levels (Royal Caribbean, Carnival Corporation and Norwegian Cruise Line have debt to equity ratios of 624, 598 and 86198 respectively), Miss Materiality sees a short opportunity rather than a viable travel option.
As climate issues intensify, Miss Materiality anticipates tougher regulation on pollution and emissions stemming from travel. She believes this will support increased investment into more environmentally friendly modes of transportation like rail. For instance, America’s passenger rail system, Amtrak, is undergoing a $66 billion investment as part of the Infrastructure bill passed in 2021. Though North American passenger rail systems still mostly rely on diesel locomotives, taking the train instead of a flight is often the more ecological choice, especially for shorter inter city trips. Just earlier this week, France’s Transport Minister discussed plans to tax airlines in order to support investment in the country’s rail transit. Policies such as these should result in tailwinds for companies in passenger rail equipment, such as Westinghouse Air Brake Technologies, Siemens, and Alstom.
Among all the potential solutions to fix the climate problem, two stand out as favorites of politicians and Big Oil CEOs, and for perpetually being on the brink of scaling up. We are of course talking about Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage (CCUS) and Green Hydrogen.
Here is a case in point: Earlier this month, Exxon acquired Denbury inc., a small oil and gas firm, for $4.9B. It was touted as a significant move from Exxon to prove how serious their decarbonization efforts are. While it is true that Denbury has a CCUS business, the captured CO2 is mainly used to extract more oil, a process called Enhanced Oil Recovery or EOR, which is not universally accepted as a sustainable activity. The company’s revenues essentially come from oil production, and not their carbon business. In fact, according to their own reported numbers, only 3.6% of their 2022 revenues, or $61M, are from their “Carbon Dioxide & Transportation” segment. Based on the spin Exxon gave to this deal, one might be given the impression that it was much, much more. To put these numbers in perspective, Exxon netted about $150M in profits, per day, in 2022! The fact that Denbury is deemed a leader in CCUS despite the discrepancy in the numbers is a clear example that the CCUS industry has a long way to go to deliver on its promises.
On the green hydrogen front, the hype is still running strong despite some recent news that challenged the Green Hydrogen Economy utopia. A growing list of green hydrogen projects that were once enthusiastically announced by politicians are now being delayed or cancelled due to unrealistic assumptions or costs. Projects in France, Germany, Australia, the US and many more have been scrapped after the realization that it was not viable to convert everything under the sun to green hydrogen. Big Surprise!
To be clear, we are not saying that all CCUS and all hydrogen projects are unrealistic, and we are certainly not throwing the baby out with the bath water. There are opportunities in these segments; however, savvy sustainability-minded investors should exercise judgement before jumping in the hydrogen-powered CCUS bandwagon. In this week’s note, we will make the distinction between the fairy tales told by politicians and Big Oil CEOs and the real investment opportunities in the CCUS and hydrogen sectors.
Carbon Capture and Storage: A real solution but hard to scale
We could say that carbon capture is to decarbonization what gastric bypass is to dieting – the ones promoting it want us to believe we don’t have to change our behaviour in order to achieve our goals. This is the main reason the environmental movement is usually not a fan of CCS.
Alternatively, the IEA (International Energy Agency) sees carbon capture and storage (CCS) as a key technology for decarbonizing the global energy system. In its Net Zero by 2050 Scenario, the IEA projects that CCS will be needed to capture and store up to 1.2 Gt CO2 per year by 2030 and up to 4 Gt by 2050. But the IEA has also identified a number of challenges that need to be overcome in order to scale up CCS deployment. These challenges include the cost of CCS, the availability of CO2 storage sites, and the political will to support CCS.
There are currently 40 commercial carbon capture facilities in operation globally, with a total annual capture capacity of about 45 Mt of CO2. Although CCS deployment has been slow in the past, there has been a recent surge in activity. Since January 2022, seven new large-scale capture facilities have come online, with a capture capacity of over 100,000 tonnes of CO2 per year. These facilities include the Red Trail Energy Project in the United States, the Arcelor LanzaTech Carbalyst (Steelanol) project in Belgium, the Global thermostat DAC pilot in the US, and four projects in China. In addition, over 500 projects are in various stages of development, and 50 new capture facilities are expected to be in operation by 2030. However, even this level of deployment would only capture a fraction of the CO2 required by 2030 to even hope to achieve net zero emissions by 2050 (see chart below).
Recent news of Norwegian specialized CCS firm Aker Carbon Capture ASA (ACC NO) partnering with Aramco of Saudi Arabia is a welcomed development in this space and demonstrates that even if the end goal is most certainly out of reach when it comes to CCS for net zero ambitions, there are nonetheless some effective applications that provide opportunities for investors. In fact, in contrast to Denbury, Aker Carbon ASA is one of the only pure plays available to investors, drawing all of its revenues from its carbon capture technologies. The other investment opportunities in the CCS space would be riskier from a sustainability point-of-view as investors would have to venture into the traditional oil businesses that are slowly but surely taking the CCS turn. These include companies like Occidental Petroleum (OXY US), Schlumberger NV (SLB US) and even Advantage Energy Ltd (AAV CN) through their investment in Entropy.
Green Hydrogen – A real solution for limited applications, a false solution for everything else
There are few technologies more hyped by politicians than green hydrogen (maybe AI is in the running nowadays). What’s not to like from their perspective? Green jobs in the hydrogen economy, potential massive CO2 emissions reduction, and the perfect excuse to delay any type of decarbonization projects now because all problems will be solved by hydrogen.
The reality is far different. Green hydrogen will play a role in decarbonization, there is no doubt about that. However, it is not the be-all and end-all solution that some people claim. The reasons are straight-forward: physics, chemistry and thermodynamics. First, hydrogen does not occur naturally, so it must be extracted from other sources, such as water or fossil fuels. This process requires energy, which can offset some of the benefits of using hydrogen. Second, hydrogen is difficult to store and transport. It can be compressed to 700 times atmospheric pressure, but this requires a lot of energy. It can also be liquefied, but this requires even more energy. Alternatively, hydrogen can be combined with an organic chemical or metal hydride, but this can be expensive. Third, hydrogen has a low energy density per unit volume. This means that it takes up a lot more space to store the same amount of energy as other fuels, such as gasoline or natural gas. Fourth, hydrogen is a highly flammable gas. This means that it can be dangerous if it is not handled properly.
In the graph below, the orange boxes (“No Real Alternative” in the key) illustrate the potential to introduce hydrogen into gas grids to achieve activities for which there are no real alternatives other than hydrogen, except obviously producing it in a cleaner fashion. The takeaway is that taking on the cost and risk of making clean hydrogen and using it for things done more easily with clean electricity or biofuels makes no sense. The uses for hydrogen should instead be focused on those tasks for which clean hydrogen is the only choice.

What does it mean for investors interested in clean hydrogen plays? Our advice is to focus on the hydrogen infrastructure sector and to avoid specific applications that have a high probability of not being economically viable.
Companies in the industrial gases sector like Air Liquide (AI FP), Air Products and Chemicals (APD US), and Linde PLC (LIN US) are all moving aggressively to produce clean hydrogen that can be agnostically used for whatever applications make economic sense. Moreover, by investing in these industrial gas firms, an investor would kill two birds with one stone as these firms are also involved with CCUS as providers of membrane separation and direct air capture technologies.