If you were just following the headlines, you might get the impression that electric vehicle (EV) sales are in free fall. The reality is different. The EV market remains robust. In the U.S., for example, EV sales grew by 11.3% year-over-year in the second quarter, reaching a record-breaking 330,463 units. This was 23% higher than the sales figures from Q1.

In Europe, the narrative is more intricate. Comparing August 2024 to August 2023 shows a 7.5% decline, but that’s largely due to an artificial boost in August 2023 when Germany saw a rush of purchases before a government subsidy expired. Looking at the bigger picture, year-to-date sales in the EU+EFTA+UK region are up by 4.2% compared to 2023.

Meanwhile, in China, which holds the title for the world’s largest EV market, the numbers are even more impressive. Sales of new energy vehicles have soared by 37%, with EVs now making up more than 50% of new car purchases.

Given these positive figures, why are some automakers scaling back or delaying their EV plans? This can be attributed to the pendulum swinging back after the extreme hype of 2020-2021. The market is also rebalancing with more hybrids, especially plug-in hybrids (PHEVs), competing with battery electric vehicles (BEVs). However, the overall EV market remains healthy, and these hurdles should be seen as a natural correction.

At the same time, the EV industry is entering a critical phase. The keenest buyers have already made their purchases, but the next wave of consumers will need assurance in two key areas: (1) that the total cost of ownership (TCO) of EVs outcompetes traditional internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles, and (2) that the electric vehicle charging infrastructure (EVCI) can ease concerns over range anxiety.

The first issue—TCO—has largely been addressed, with BEVs generally offering lower operating costs than comparable ICE vehicles. But the second challenge still lingers: Is EVCI a sustainable business model that infrastructure investors should consider?

To answer this, it's important to distinguish between the various players in the EV charging ecosystem. First, there are carmakers like Tesla and Volkswagen (Electrify America), who are investing heavily in charging infrastructure but for whom charging station revenues remain a small part of their business. There are also the companies that manufacture and operate charging stations. Finally, there are specialty suppliers that produce the parts needed for these stations.

As our readers know, we tend to favor the "picks and shovels" strategy when investing in emerging technologies. However, in the case of EV charging, the most compelling business model seems to lie with the charging station networks rather than the hardware manufacturers. Hardware manufacturers like Kempower Oyj (KEMPOWR FH), Alfen NV (ALFEN NA), and Wallbox NV (WBX US) focus primarily on selling EV chargers to residential and commercial customers, but they don’t operate the charging networks themselves. These businesses face two major challenges. First, the rise of PHEVs is reducing the demand for fast chargers at homes and workplaces. Second, competition from Chinese manufacturers like TGOOD Electric and EVB, who produce chargers at a lower cost, threatens their market share. This mirrors the solar panel industry, where European and American manufacturers struggle to compete on price despite temporary support from tariffs and subsidies.

Our focus, therefore, is on the EVCI network owner-operators—those companies that not only install charging stations but also manage the networks and generate revenue from charging services. These companies are responsible for building and maintaining the infrastructure, from hardware to the network, and are more aligned with the traditional infrastructure asset class.

Given that the EVCI sector is still in its infancy, it presents significantly higher risks compared to more established infrastructure sub-sectors. The EVCI industry is currently akin to where the renewable energy market was around two decades ago—unprofitable and volatile in the short-term but with a promising long-term outlook.

Key companies that align with this business model include EVgo Inc. (EVGO US), ChargePoint Holdings (CHPT US), and Blink Charging (BLNK US) in the U.S., along with Allego NV (JS9 GR) and Fastned BV (FAST NA) in Europe.

Unfortunately for equity investors, it's worth noting that Allego NV is currently being taken private by Meridiam, a French investment firm specializing in sustainable infrastructure. This does however underscore confidence in the owner-operator business model for EVCI.

Among the remaining publicly traded companies, EVgo stands out as a pure-play network owner-operator. While ChargePoint has the largest number of installed chargers, only 25% of its revenue comes from its network subscriptions. The remainder comes from commercial deals to install chargers at locations like restaurants and shopping malls, a non-recurring revenue that is very sensitive to global macro conditions. Blink Charging has carved out a niche in the Level 2 charging market but is lagging behind in the fast-charging (Level 3) segment, which may hurt its long-term competitiveness. Lastly, Fastned BV operates an innovative model where 100% of the energy is generated on-site via solar panels, however this limits the speed and density of its charging stations, making it more of a niche player with limited growth potential.

In contrast, EVgo, benefits from fully owning and operating its charging stations. Over time, this may give the company an edge, as additional revenue streams could emerge from convenience shopping—similar to gas stations, where margins on fuel are thin, but profits are made on other products and services. EVgo’s dedication to customer service is another strong point, helping to build a loyal customer base. Additionally, their leadership in DC fast chargers was recently recognized by the U.S. Department of Energy, which awarded the company a $1B loan commitment to accelerate its network expansion, boosting its stock price by more than 60%.

Carbon markets – both voluntary and regulated – were once again front and center during discussions at Climate Week, which concluded a few days ago. All participants reiterated that well-functioning carbon markets are widely considered essential to reaching the globally agreed-upon target of limiting the Earth’s temperature rise to 1.5°C. It has been well over a decade since the inception of the first carbon markets, and the concept of buying and selling emission credits is no longer novel: the traded value of the major programmes exceeds $900 billion.

Carbon has proven itself as a liquid and investable asset class (over $1 billion per day is traded across physical carbon, futures and options), although returns over the past year have not been lucrative. The two main regulated carbon markets – EU ETS and WCI (Western Climate Initiative) – have both seen carbon prices trade with small premiums over their mandated floors during 2024. Although there are a few lingering risks, we view current prices as an excellent entry point, especially for North American carbon credits.

Regulated Carbon: What Is It  

Two kinds of tradeable carbon markets exist. The first is carbon allowances, which are credits issued by governments in cap-and-trade systems, i.e. regulated carbon. The second is the voluntary carbon market, on which carbon offsets are bought directly from project developers or brokers/intermediaries and are intended to balance an entity’s carbon footprint by investing in projects that reduce or remove emissions.

As is becoming well-known, the quality of carbon offsets, i.e. the voluntary market, is extremely heterogeneous and is fraught with risk, due to their unregulated nature. The value of the voluntary carbon market has dropped significantly, due to reputational and credibility problems and for all the talk, the voluntary market size is paltry compared to regulated markets.

Conversely, existing regulated carbon markets are already well-functioning, liquid and of a high standard. For these reasons, we believe that investors should focus here.

Long-term Factors of Regulated Carbon Price Moves

Regulated carbon markets are cap-and-trade systems that set emissions limits for specific industries, including oil and gas production, transportation, electricity distribution utilities, and large industrial facilities. Funds raised through auctions are then used to finance the development of low carbon economic activities.

The main feature of regulated carbon markets is that they are intended to create scarcity for the right to emit carbon and this scarcity intensifies over time via a decreasing cap. For example, in the California system, the distribution of allowances is set to be reduced by one-third in 2030 from its 2021 level.

In addition, in most cap-and-trade systems, the floor price, i.e. the minimum price at which a carbon allowance may trade hands, increases each year by law. These two factors – scarcity by design and minimum pricing - means that there is a strong likelihood that carbon prices within the system will increase over time.

 

Short-term Factors of Regulated Carbon Price Moves

If only it were so easy!  Like all traded financial instruments, the price of carbon in various cap and trade systems has not moved up in a straight line. Traded carbon allowances are subject to the basic laws of supply and demand and the following factors tend to affect the underlying price on a cyclical basis:

1. Industrial demand: Cap and trade systems cover the largest emitting sectors, including the utilities and industrial sectors that are highly correlated with swings in economic activity. When economic output is strong, more carbon emissions are produced and hence more allowances need to be purchased, i.e positively impacting demand and putting upward pressure on prices.  

2. Weather patterns: in some jurisdictions like California, weather patterns can also influence the demand side. In California, periods of drought force utilities to switch from hydroelectricity production to production of electricity from natural gas. The latter requires utility companies to purchase additional carbon allowances, once again putting upward pressure on carbon prices.

3. Regulation: As with any market that is dependent on government intervention, a change in the regulatory backdrop can create price volatility. As discussed above, a scheduled removal of carbon allowances aims to create scarcity in the market. However, political pressure can force lawmakers to alter the pace of carbon allowance removal, and therefore change market participants’ expectations about the price of credits. Knock-on effect from other markets. As described above, the voluntary market has come under quite a bit of scrutiny during the past eighteen months. However, just as “risk on” trades tend to be tightly correlated despite often having different underlying drivers, there can be contagion between the sentiment regarding voluntary carbon offsets and regulated carbon.

 

The Current Investment Opportunity

Over the past year, all of the four factors described above worked as headwinds in the California-Quebec cap-and-trade (i.e. the main North American) system:

Looking ahead, we have a high conviction view that the bulk of the bad news for North American regulated carbon is behind us. To be sure, there is always the lingering fear that regulators will pull back and the major near-term risk in this regard relates to Washington: earlier this year, Washington, Quebec and California agreed to explore linkages between the two carbon markets, with an expectation to finalize an agreement by late 2025. Any setback to this stated plan could have negative ramifications on the level of confidence in cap-and-trade systems.  

However, other developments are more positive. There is an increasing effort to standardize voluntary offsets with the objective of making them safer for investors; in the U.S., the Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) recently approved new guidelines regarding the listing for trading of voluntary carbon credit derivative contracts. The implication for regulated markets is that any negative sentiment contagion emanating from the voluntary market is likely to be stemmed.

Similarly, although we do not forecast the weather, simply assuming a return to the mean, i.e. that the 2024-2025 season does not yet again deliver record rainfall, would mean that weather conditions would be less of a drag on carbon prices over the next several quarterly auctions.

Finally, with the Fed now embarking on an easing path and continued momentum in reshoring, there are good odds that the U.S. manufacturing cycle will turn more positive in the months ahead.

Pulling it all together, of the four major factors that are affecting North American carbon prices in the near term, the majority are turning from headwind to tailwind, creating enticing conditions for higher carbon prices in 2025.

 

Why and How to Invest in Carbon

Investing in regulated carbon markets offer investors two important financial properties: a potential to protect against inflation and low correlation to other investments.

    1. Inflation protection: in the California-Quebec cap-and-trade system, the minimum price (or floor price) increases each year by a set amount plus the annual rate of inflation.
    2. Uncorrelated to other markets: As discussed above, carbon prices are somewhat positively correlated to the business cycle given that the demand for carbon credits increases when economic activity is accelerating. However, given all the other factors involved, carbon prices tend to have a beta less than one and importantly, display low correlation to other financial assets (see the table below).

As such, we believe regulated carbon markets should occupy a growing place in investors’ asset allocation.

For financial actors, there are two main ways to express a bullish mid-term view on carbon prices. First, one can register to participate directly in the quarterly auctions. Second, the most popular retail investment vehicles are ETFs such as the Kraneshare California Carbon Allowance Strategy (ticker KCCA) that track the underlying futures contracts.

For those looking for attractive financial characteristics as well as real-world impact, participating in regulated carbon markets is the way forward.

In our last macro update (March 27, 2024), we had argued that the rate backdrop had become relatively benign for equity markets and that investors should begin to reflect on sector implications of a potential Trump presidency. The interest rate environment was indeed calm over the past six months: the Fed is on the cusp of its first interest rate reduction in over four years and has managed to stay very aligned with financial market participants’ expectations. However, whether the Fed can continue to deliver the rate cuts that are expected after September still depends on inflation.   While there is more and more indication of lagging economic activity (in particular, we highlight below the impact of worsening credit conditions for consumers), the Fed can only provide stimulus if progress toward lowering inflation to 2% is sufficient. The most recent data was not encouraging in this regard; August data shows that progress at bringing down core CPI has stalled and prices continued to rise over the summer at over 3% annually.

On this basis, it’s hard to see how the Fed moves to a more accommodative stance barring a severe weakening (contraction) in economic growth. The bottom line is that contrary to the past six months when the Fed and market expectations of interest rate policy have been well aligned, odds are rising that policymakers will be unable to deliver on market expectations for rate cuts of 75 – 150 bps by year end.

Meanwhile, judging by the election betting markets  after Tuesday’s Presidential debate, the likelihood is increasing for a Democratic win, reducing the allure of the “Trump trade”  (i.e. overweight positions in USD, prisons, banks and oil companies).

From a sustainability perspective, the debate bolstered our suspicion that Harris is unlikely to make bold moves regarding major issues like climate change, climate adaptation and health care. Climate change was nary discussed, except to underscore that Harris would not ban fracking. On healthcare, she promised to “strengthen” Obamacare and to keep in place the Biden’s administration $2,000 cap on out-of-pocket prescription drug costs, which is slated to take effect for Medicare enrollees in 2025.

In terms of overall government spending, the debate confirmed our view that irrespective of the election result, U.S. fiscal spending will be neither headwind nor tailwind for financial markets in Q4 2024 and 2025.

The chart below shows that in the U.S., the fiscal policy contribution to real GDP growth will become roughly neutral in the fourth quarter of 2024, and be mildly negative throughout 2025. The Brookings Institute’s projection shown in the chart assumes an extension of the provisions of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act that are set to expire at the end of 2025, an assumption that we find most plausible. Trump has stated that if he wins, the tax cuts will of course be extended, while Harris pledges to re-distribute the fiscal burden among tax brackets. In both cases, overall tax revenues will not look very different.

Overall, the conclusions from our recent note covering the U.S. election “US Election Color Wheel: Spotting the Green in the Blue vs. Red Landscape” still hold:  Harris’ approach of an “all of the above” domestic energy policy (including fracking) is unlikely to tarnish the allure of investing in regulated carbon markets. Meanwhile, sectors like engineering services will prove resilient regardless of who makes it to the White House since it’s now common lore that the U.S. needs improved infrastructure as well as more (cheap and clean) energy.

What else should thematic sustainability investors keep an eye on in the months ahead? Consumer health and a potential defensive rotation top our list.

Consumer Check- Up

Financial market pundits are ratcheting up expectations for a recession, which typically means bear market. But for the U.S. to slide into recession, it will take a much bigger crack in consumer spending.

With excess savings now largely been worked off, credit cards and other forms of consumer financing have also become more heavily tapped. So much so that lending institutions are beginning to ring a warning bell. Comments from consumer finance company Ally Financial earlier this week – and the company’s stock price reaction (-19%) – particularly struck us. The CFO articulated a view whereby borrowers have been struggling with the cost of living, and now are also faced with a deteriorating employment backdrop; late-stage loan delinquencies are rising and there is a necessity to shore up reserves.

To be sure, the Fed’s highly anticipated September interest rate cut is designed to alleviate building stressors in the consumer sector and interest rates at the long end have already declined somewhat. Nonetheless, consumers are less sanguine about their economic prospects and it is rational that this translates into a pullback in discretionary spending.

So far, 2024 has already seen a modest outperformance of consumer staples stocks relative to consumer discretionary names when looking at the overall S&P sectors. This is true even when omitting index heavyweights Tesla and Amazon from the discretionary universe.  Given the discussion above, we expect that staples will continue to outperform discretionary stocks as consumers pull back spending.

Admittedly, however, sustainability concerns have not been a factor in driving the outperformance of staples: since January, SMS’ universe of consumer staples sustainability winners (primarily food companies) has only performed on par with our universe of consumer discretionary sustainability losers. Much of the disappointing result is coming from strong price appreciation of single names in our consumer discretionary short universe: despite sub-par ESG and sustainability records, cost-conscious consumers have not shied away from fast-fashion (Abercrombie & Fitch is up 67% YTD) and fast food (Wingstop and Brinker International are up 61% and 48%, respectively). Although this underscores the need for strong stock selection, as we wrote in a recent note “Consumers Bite Off More Than They Can Chew: An Outlook for the Restaurant Industry”, the current economic environment nonetheless implies less restaurants (discretionary) and more food at home (staples). We expect that the outperformance of staples will continue and stronger sustainability candidates offering good value will be propelled higher.

Defensive Rotation?

The decent performance of consumer staples recently is of course also thanks to an important rotation out of tech stocks that began this summer. We continue to believe that risks favor more air coming out of still sky-high valuations in AI-hyped stocks and it’s not just staples that will benefit. The health care sector helps form the backbone of diversified sustainability portfolios and current macro conditions are helpful for this sector.  

Overall, the health care sector displays defensive characteristics much like staples; it’s hard to cut back on medications and health care procedures even when times get tougher. It is worth noting that Harris acknowledged the ravages of the fentanyl crisis in the Presidential debate and that the NOPAIN Act (Non-Opioids Prevent Addiction in the Nation Act) is a popular, bipartisan legislative effort, aiming to reduce opioid dependence by expanding access to non-opioid pain management treatments. Starting in 2025 separate Medicare reimbursement for FDA-approved non-opioid therapies will be provided, particularly in outpatient surgical settings. Pharmaceutical companies such as Pacira BioSciences (PCRX US), Indivior (INDV LN), and Vertex Pharmaceuticals (VRTX US) are developing non-opioid alternatives, positioning themselves as promising investments.

With U.S. interest rates now on a downward trajectory – approximately 200 basis points of cuts are anticipated over the next 24 months – and electoral polls indicating a tight race between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris, today’s note revisits the performance of our sustainability themes during electoral periods. We also assess the economic and policy differences between the 2020 context and today and explore opportunities for re-entry into some of our favorite investment themes.

First, we examine the performance of seventeen of SMS’ sustainable investment themes three months before, and three months after the 2020 election. Recall that interest rates were near zero during this period due to COVID-19. Some themes, such as Human Capital (which includes edtech, up 68%), Tech Infrastructure, and Transition Materials (up 45%), performed exceptionally well, while others, like Alternative Energy, somewhat underperformed (up 5%) post-election – especially we consider that the S&P 500 was up by some 10 percentage points in the three months following the election. In our view, the performance of many of our themes was driven more by market momentum and close-to-zero interest rates than by any government policies discussed during the 2020 election.

As such, there was a clear rotation in and out of several sustainable investment themes following the 2020 election. This time around, investors should also be prepared for another election-based market shift – especially if we consider that market participants already penciled in a Trump victory - and discounted several sustainability plays. Now that a Harris victory is the cards, investors could re-ignite the kind of hype in themes such as renewables and energy transition we last witnessed in 2019-20.

A second consideration is to explore how the election could alter the fundamental trajectory of U.S. policymaking, which could also impact several of our investment themes. The table below outlines our expectations for what could stay the same versus what could change following the election - and identifies potential areas for surprise.

Given the table above, we suggest four sustainable investment ideas that take into account the current U.S. political and monetary backdrop: Shorting prisons, going long on carbon, engineering firms, and renewable energy.

Short Prisons

Private prisons remain a contentious theme in the U.S., with equity prices in the sector closely tracking electoral polls. While Kamala Harris would likely aim to shut down private prisons and prolong Biden’s policy on the matter, Donald Trump would probably expand their role in the U.S. carceral system. As Harris is currently leading Trump in the polls, prison stock prices have already receded. Companies such as GEO Group (GEO US) have already profited from stricter immigration control policies, including electronic surveillance through apps, which have boosted revenues for companies in the sector. One could expect such controls to be less infringing on immigrant rights should Harris win, likely capping prison stock prices.

From a valuation perspective, prison stock prices also seem stretched when considering their 12-month trailing P/E ratios – they are trading at a 50 percent premium compared to their 2020 levels. That said, as immigration remains an important electoral theme – and in a context where private prisons increasingly rely on immigration flows as a source of revenue - we recommend taking a smaller short position on this theme while continuing to monitor polls closely.

Long Carbon

One of the starkest wedge issues between Kamala Harris and Donald Trump is their stance on the environment and carbon. Kamala Harris, known for her prosecutorial background, did not hesitate to take on Big Oil and win a settlement for the people of California over environmental damage from climate-warming fossil fuel emissions. In contrast, Donald Trump advocates for minimal, if any, environmental regulations.

This divergence in views is evident in North American regulated carbon markets. December 2024 carbon futures have recently plummeted due to 1) the prospect of Trump winning the election (especially when he was leading in polls), 2) the politicization of carbon markets (the State of Washington has put the termination of its newly created carbon market on the November 5th ballot), and 3) retail investors feeling the pressure and cashing out of their positions.

That being said, current North American carbon auction pricing dynamics are approaching the government-set floor price of $24.04, which is 25% lower than the most recent auction price of $30.24. As a reminder, the floor price is set by WCI member governments to increase by 5% plus inflation every year. For an investor with a six-year time horizon, the floor price will be equivalent to the current price in 2030, even if inflation is 0% between now and then. Investors now have the chance to buy the equivalent of a convertible bond that will pay inflation between now and 2030 with a conversion price equivalent to the current price. If the price of carbon credits rises to last spring’s peak of $44, a return of almost 50% could be achieved. For public market access to this play, investors can purchase the KCCA ETF, which has dropped by about 25 percentage points since its February 2024 peak.

Furthermore, the foundations of the North American carbon market remain strong. New York State is contemplating the creation of its own market, which could potentially merge with the Western Climate Initiative, which include the main players in the market such as California and Québec. Additionally, current electricity demand trends in North America, particularly in California, suggest that the scarcity of emission rights could return soon amid a growth in production – including from non-renewable sources. This is currently our strongest conviction for a “Kamala trade.”


Long Renewable Energy

In a recent note, we recommended re-entering the renewables sector when and if interest rates began to decline (see our note “A Second Wind: What Peak Interest Rates Mean for Renewables” March 21, 2024). Now that approximately 200 basis points of rate cuts are priced in over the next 24 months, we are somewhat surprised that the sector hasn’t yet rebounded, especially in light of recent trends in energy demand in the U.S. In that, we think that the time to re-enter the renewables space is now.

While we don’t anticipate additional government funding à la Biden IRA for the sector just yet, overweighting the sector could makes sense if you think that Kamala will make it to the White House. Companies - developers and operators - that have demonstrated strong revenue growth these past years amid higher interest rates – such as Acciona and Hannon Armstrong – could strongly reprice positively in the coming months, even if they are already trading at high P/E ratios.

Long Engineering & Construction

Given that infrastructure spending is likely to persist regardless of who wins the White House, the Engineering Services sector looks promising, especially for companies with a strong presence in the United States. We place particular emphasis on those that have developed leading sustainability practices. Many of the companies listed below have integrated sustainability as a key feature of their practice, making them a natural fit for sustainability-focused portfolios as they are the builders of infrastructure of the future.

The sector has substantially outperformed the rest of the stock market since November 2020 and, to much surprise, has even proved resilient to the current higher interest rate environment. To this end, SMS’s Green Engineering Leaders Equal-Weighted Index has outperformed both the S&P and Nasdaq by nearly 100 percentage points since Biden was elected to the White House in 2020. Given both parties’ interest in improving infrastructure, we believe this trend will continue for the foreseeable future. Companies like Stantec and Arcadis stand out in this group for their sustainability features and relatively attractive valuations.

 

The Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) is a policy tool in the European Union designed to address carbon leakage – when companies relocate their production to countries with less stringent climate regulations to avoid carbon costs – and to promote carbon neutrality by imposing a carbon price on imports of certain goods from countries with less stringent climate policies.

By putting a carbon price (tax) on imports to the EU, CBAM aims to ensure a more level playing field between domestic products and imports. In addition, while not the stated goal, a carbon border adjustment tax is a sign of the times in terms of deglobalization; countries that are currently exporting emission-intensive products view CBAM as thinly veiled trade barrier and have threatened taking complaints to the WTO.

CBAM has been in a “transitional phase” since end-2023 when importers of steel & iron, aluminum, fertilizers, cement, electricity and hydrogen became required to report carbon emissions. Beginning in 2026, importers of these goods will also need to buy CBAM certificates that correspond to the number of embedded emissions in their goods at a certificate price determined by the European carbon price (i.e. the weekly auction emission trading price).

In a nutshell, the CBAM will erode any competitive advantage for companies that are not currently subject to paying a carbon price on par or above the cost of carbon in the EU.

Notably, much of the sell-side investment research published about the implications of CBAM focuses on country-level trade implications. But it is the companies that produce these goods that are directly subject to the policy, creating the potential for equity winners and losers.

In today’s note, we highlight the companies that stand to gain or lose in four of the six industries targeted by CBAM – fertilizers, cement, aluminum, and steel & iron. We exclude electricity and hydrogen because these markets are currently supplied primarily within the European market. To identify companies, we follow a simple procedure:

We discuss our findings for each of the industries below.

Cement: Largely Irrelevant for Equity Investors  

It is unlikely that CBAM will have a significant impact on competitivity of the global cement industry. Europe barely imports any cement and indeed, all over the world cement and concrete are typically manufactured locally because raw materials are available, and transportation is relatively expensive due to the low density value of cement. According to the European Cement Bureau, the value of imports of cement in 2023 was USD 443 million for the euro area, or roughly 9 million tonnes of cement. This accounts for a puny 3% of the annual cement needs in the region.

The chart below shows European imported cement by country of origin. Together, Turkey, Tunisia, Algeria, and Ukraine make up 75% of all imported cement. Investment opportunities in these countries are scarce since, in Algeria and Tunisia the major cement manufacturers are not publicly listed. In Ukraine, the major cement exporter is a subsidiary of CRH, an Irish company listed in the U.S.

Of the approximately 40 publicly traded cement companies we found, only eight report generating more than 10% of revenues in Europe. Moreover, with the exception of two, all of these companies are headquartered within the euro area or in a country that is exempt from CBAM (EEA countries and Switzerland).

Cemex (Mexico) and Nuh Cimento Sanayi AS (Turkey) are the only companies with any real exposure to the CBAM risk. Nuh Cimento Sanayi AS ranks among the very worst carbon emitters per revenue dollar, while Cemex is among the companies with the lowest emissions. The implication is that only Nuh Cimento Sanayi AS is a potential short based on the likelihood of a margin squeeze induced by CBAM.

 

Fertilizers

Contrary to cement, the EU is largely dependent on imports for most fertilizers and has traditionally sourced its mineral fertilizers from a select group of suppliers, primarily Russia, Egypt, Algeria, Morocco, and Belarus.

Looking at the ten largest publicly traded fertilizer companies, only three are located in the euro area or in countries that are excluded from CBAM. This implies that the majority of fertilizer will be newly subjected to integrating the cost of its carbon emissions into the price of production.

The table below highlights total emissions/ million USD in revenue for each company. CF Industries and SABIC are among the most carbon intensive fertilizer manufacturers and are most likely to see the greatest margin compression once CBAM is enforced.

 

 

Iron & Steel

In the iron & steel market, an examination of emissions intensity uncovers that the CBAM may create opportunities for some low-intensity steel producers outside of the euro area. In the steel industry, a major factor in emissions is the type of energy used in furnaces to make steel. Electric arc furnaces (EAFs) generate a mere fraction of the carbon emissions by traditional blast furnace steelmaking. In the U.S., the vast majority of steelmaking plants use EAFs, which explains why U.S. steelmaking companies generally have low emissions intensity versus companies elsewhere in the world. In India for example, less than 10% of plants use EAFs. Given that neither of these countries currently have nationwide carbon schemes in place, there is a significant cost advantage to U.S. producers should they desire to compete in the European market.

As it stands, many high-emitting steel companies are currently exporting to the euro area, while many lower emitting companies (using primarily electric arc furnaces) mostly serve their domestic markets and have not competed in the euro area. The steel industry is highly political and the ability to export goes far beyond the cost of carbon. That said, of all of the industries addressed by CBAM, our analysis suggests that it is the steel industry that has the greatest potential for change. Companies with low carbon intensity that have already had some success at entering the European market, such as Sims Metals, are non-EU candidates that stand to benefit from a levelling of the carbon playing field.



Aluminum

In the aluminum industry, for now CBAM only covers direct-process related emissions. However, it is the indirect emissions that account for most (80%) of total emissions in the primary aluminum process – which is mostly related to the production of electricity that is subsequently consumed in the smelting process.

In the sixth column of the table below, we show Scope 1 emissions per revenue for the major publicly traded aluminum companies.

Of the companies that have a significant share of exports to the euro area, Hindalco Industries, Alcoa and Aluminum Bahrain are the three with the higher scope 1 emissions intensity; they are at the highest risk of observing a margin squeeze when the euro area price of carbon is applied.

 

 

 

This week saw yet more bad news for proponents of the famous Hydrogen Economy. One of the Biden administration’s flagship projects to derive energy from hydrogen, the $6bn Appalachian Regional Clean Hydrogen Hub (ARCH2), is in jeopardy due to unrealistic project economics and strong community opposition, as well as another minor obstacle: fundamental physics.

The demise of a variety of hydrogen projects is becoming increasingly common. There are example in the transportation, industrial, energy, and heating sectors.

In this week’s note, let’s bust some myths around the hydrogen economy.

 

How Did We Get Here?

The Climate Crisis is often described as a wicked problem which involves numerous interconnected factors, including economic, environmental, political, and social elements, with no straightforward solutions, and each intervention often leads to unforeseen consequences and trade-offs. So when a visibly simple solution is presented, like 'transitioning to the hydrogen economy,' people want to believe it and jump on the bandwagon.

These promises are then being amplified by powerful people with large audiences: politicians and Big Oil. For both groups, the idyllic image of a hydrogen economy allows them to delay any real and difficult transition decisions. By dangling this shiny catch-all technological solution that will solve (almost) all our climate problems, they can continue their business as usual: producing fossil fuels. And they are putting their money where their mouth is: fossil fuel companies rank among the top lobbying firms for hydrogen and outnumber companies from every other industry, including the renewable energy sector!

In fact, hydrogen lobbying efforts by all industries seriously took off with the inauguration of Joe Biden in 2021, in anticipation of a massive environmental Bill which the industry hoped would include generous subsidies for several technological solutions, including hydrogen. In August 2022, that Bill took form as the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) and indeed included the largest and most generous hydrogen subsidies in the world, known as the 45V credit for hydrogen. The lobbying efforts seems to have paid off as blue hydrogen, the kind that is produced by fossil fuels assisted by some CO2 capture technology, does qualify for the tax credit.

The situation in Europe is very similar. A 2023 study by LobbyFacts showed that more than €75 million a year is spent on lobbying efforts by the EU hydrogen promoters, among which the top players are Shell, ExxonMobil, Dow, BASF, TotalEnergies, Equinor, BP and Siemens Energy.

 

“It’s physics, stupid”

The fact that Oil & Gas majors are aggressively promoting a technology does not automatically disqualify it, although it should raise flags and call for more scrutiny. The main disqualification for hydrogen is much more clear-cut: thermodynamics.

Without going into the details of hydrogen’s physical properties, there are a few killer facts that demonstrate that betting the climate farm on the hydrogen economy is a dead end.

First things first: hydrogen is not an energy source. It’s an energy vector. Since hydrogen can’t be found – in sufficient quantities – in its natural form, it needs to be extracted from compounds like water (H2O) or hydrocarbons (e.g., methane, CH4). Producing hydrogen requires energy, typically through processes like electrolysis (the green-ish way, by splitting water using electricity which itself may or may not be green) or via steam methane reforming (SMR), the gray or black way, which involves reacting methane with steam (which emits a lot of CO2 as a by-product). In this sense, hydrogen serves as a medium to store, transport, and utilize the energy that originated from those primary sources.

How efficient is this whole process? Not very, unfortunately. When considering the entire hydrogen value chain – from production to end-use – the overall efficiency, expressed as the resulting energy as a share of initial energy input, is quite low. For example, starting with electricity from a renewable source to produce hydrogen via electrolysis (70% efficiency), then compress it for storage (90% efficiency), transport it (95% efficiency), and finally use it in a fuel cell (60% efficiency), the overall efficiency would be:

0.70 (electrolysis) * 0.90 (compression) * 0.95 (transport) * 0.60 (fuel cell) = 0.36 or 36%

This means that only 36% of the original energy input is converted into usable energy at the endpoint, with 64% lost along the way! Of course, the industry would like us to believe that they can improve these efficiencies with a few additional billions in subsidies, but if there is one thing that money can’t change, it is the Second Law of Thermodynamics (i.e. energy transformations are inherently irreversible and always generate some amount of waste heat, leading to inefficiencies).

 

“Ok, so the hydrogen space is uninvestible?”-  Not so fast…

There’s physics, and then there’s politics. The reality is that there is so much public money being poured on this issue that not every project will be kiboshed. It won’t be the first time, nor the last, that governments go ahead with the most expensive option possible to accomplish something. However, our expectation is that the vast majority of the hydrogen applications that are being discussed right now will not go ahead. For example, hydrogen as a transportation solution is a hard sell, even for trucks, trains and planes (biofuels make more sense for economics and logistical reasons). What about hydrogen as a heating source? Why would we use electricity to inefficiently convert it to hydrogen to inefficiently transport it to ultimately inefficiently re-convert it to an energy source? By cutting out the molecular middleman, one saves energy and capital. Other applications like energy storage face the same inefficiencies. Furthermore, competition with other energy storage technologies is strong (batteries, pumped hydro, and compressed air energy storage (CAES) are more efficient for large-scale energy storage and have established infrastructure).

From an investment perspective, this suggests that investors should stay away from unprofitable, unproven-at-commercial-scale, single-technology-dependent, narrow-focused hydrogen companies like Plug Power (PLUG US), FuelCell (FCEL US), Ballard Power Systems (BLDP CN), NEL ASA (NEL NO), Bloom Energy (BE US), and ITM Power Systems (ITM LN). For reference, these companies lost between 55% and 92% of their market capitalisation since Joe Biden took office, promising to make the hydrogen economy a reality.

The remaining opportunity for a sustainability-minded investor to play the hydrogen theme lies in the transition from dirty to clean hydrogen production. Global hydrogen production currently stands at around 100-125 million tonnes per year, with approximately 60% used in oil refining (hydrocracking and desulfurization), 30% in ammonia production (a key ingredient in fertilizers), and about 10% in methanol production (used as a feedstock for chemicals). Presently, almost all (99%) of this hydrogen is produced from fossil fuel sources—50% from natural gas, 20% from coal, 22% from oil, and only about 1% from electrolysis powered by clean electricity.

Only a handful of companies produce the vast majority of this hydrogen. First Principles Thinking suggests that market incumbents have competitive, technological, economic, and reputational advantages over the numerous narrow-focus start-ups that must fight an uphill battle to gain any market share. This advantage is due to the incumbents' established infrastructure, experience, and resources, which position them better to transition to cleaner hydrogen production methods.

The four major incumbents are Air Liquide SA (AI FP), Air Products and Chemicals Inc (APD US), and Linde PLC (LIN US) for the industrial segment, and Yara International ASA (YAR NO) for the fertilizer segment. Any of these companies would make a justifiable investment in the greening of hydrogen production, as they all have major projects underway. Moreover, despite being at the center of the green hydrogen theme, their valuations are very reasonable, with price-to-earnings ratios between 20 and 27 for the industrial names and 12 for Yara. These investment options make more economic and scientific sense compared to the small-cap, unprofitable names mentioned above.

The past month has seen a flurry of activity in the U.S., China and the euro area regarding competition in key “green” industries. The European commission has launched several new probes into Chinese companies for anti-competitive behaviour in wind, electric vehicles and batteries. Meanwhile, U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen visited China aiming to address U.S. concerns that China is dumping their overproduction of renewable energy equipment onto other nations. There is talk of imposing more tariffs on China as Chinese exports of solar panels have helped push prices down over 40% in the last year, making it difficult for solar panel producers in other countries to compete.  

From a climate change perspective, a glut of solar panels and wind turbines is hardly a bad thing. After all, according to the IEA, the decline in solar panel prices is related to a three-fold increase in manufacturing capacity since 2021. The result: an estimated 96% of newly installed, utility-scale solar PV capacity now has lower generation costs than new coal and natural gas plants. This is excellent news –the economics of renewable energy support an ongoing shift away from dirty energy sources.

Unfortunately, however, what is good for the planet does not always align with national interests: attempts by governments to turn green growth into a competition for green jobs has translated into a wave of disputes. Below, we explore the past and current state of global green trade and outline a possible path forward.

 

Origins of a Trade War

China joined the WTO in 2001 and in the beginning, there was a highly symbiotic relationship between China and the U.S. (and many other developed economies). China, thanks in large part to comparatively cheap labor, supplied U.S. consumers with low-cost goods in exchange for much-needed U.S. dollars to fuel a move up the development curve.

For a long time, this relationship worked, since the two economies did not compete – China largely produced items at a cost efficiency too difficult for American firms to achieve on domestic soil, lowering the price of many consumer goods, while China did not have the skilled workforce or capital savings needed to produce in critical sectors where America excelled.

However, for the past decade or so, the relationship has become less mutually beneficial, in no small part because China and America no longer operate in different spheres: the Chinese economy has advanced so much that China is now equipped to compete across a plethora of high-skill industries. Indeed, the chart below shows the economic complexity indexes (ECI) of China and the U.S. The ECI is a measure of knowledge intensity of an economy. While China still lags the U.S. somewhat, the convergence underscores that China is competent in many of the areas that used to be the domain of the U.S. and a handful of other developed economies.

Green Goods Dumping

In retrospect, it shouldn’t have been a surprise to anyone that China became a leader in green goods industries. After all, the Chinese government’s economic plan “Made For 2025” which was laid out in 2015 made clear the ten industries for which China aimed to reduce the country’s reliance on foreign technology imports and to create domestic companies relying on domestic innovation. Of the ten industries targeted, “energy saving” and “power equipment” are among the loftiest goals.  

By all accounts, China was wildly successful at creating flourishing domestic industries in ‘new energy vehicles’ and ‘renewable energy equipment’.

In fact, China has been so successful that export markets have taken a keen interest in their products. BYD, the main Chinese electric car manufacturer currently already sells about 8% of its cars outside of China.

Meanwhile, China’s ‘renewable energy equipment’ industry is a true global phenomenon. Returning to solar panels, while China represents less than 40% of total solar panel demand, the country accounts for virtually all global production.

State of Play

Anti-dumping and anti-subsidy tariffs on the Chinese solar panel industry began in 2012 and 2013 by the U.S. and euro area, respectively. As a result of these moves, many Chinese companies spent the rest of the decade moving their manufacturing facilities to other countries to avoid the duties. In other words, actions against China were not successful at curbing Chinese solar power capacities.

Although the euro area dropped their tariffs in 2018, the U.S. added a new 30% tariff on solar imports which is still in place today. The U.S. is contemplating further tariffs, while the euro area recently launched new probes into Chinese manufacturers of solar panels suspected of benefitting from "distortive" state subsidies and gaining an "unfair advantage." The EU has also launched subsidy investigations into Chinese wind turbine companies and Chinese EV manufacturers.

All of these moves by Western countries are happening under the guise of protecting national industries. But what’s left to protect? Of the top producers of solar panels (listed companies by market cap), only four are U.S. or European companies. By most accounts, it is extremely unlikely that other nations can catch up to China on production. As for other green industries, although China has a formidable wind turbine manufacturing base, Chinese manufacturers have not yet been able to penetrate markets abroad (where roughly 95% of demand in 2023 was covered by European and American companies).

What Comes Next?

Despite China’s total dominance in solar panel manufacturing, it is highly unlikely that policy and trade friction between China and other nations will disappear. It is well known that China is suffering from an economic growth slowdown and will continue to support its local industries in order to maintain jobs and stability. Meanwhile, in Western countries, it is politically popular to “target” China irrespective of the efficacy of policies. In other words, we do not expect any major policy change that will disrupt the current status quo of a strong, steady stream of Chinese-sourced renewable energy equipment. We do not wish to bet against U.S. and European manufacturers, though we do not expect current headwinds to diminish for the foreseeable future.

A key point is that Chinese solar panel manufacturers are producing goods that are inexpensive, but not “cheap”.  One of the main reasons that Chinese panels have fallen in the past decade is due to improvements in design. A notable metric for solar panel quality is bankability, i.e. the likelihood that investors are willing to invest because data indicates the quality and long-term durability of the solar module, as well as the trustworthiness of the manufacturer. 

Chinese companies such as Longi and Jinko Solar receive the same bankability ratings as U.S. companies like First Solar. On this basis, it seems unlikely that a major shift in the industry is likely to occur.

 Investment Implications

As China attempts to stabilize its domestic economy and reach its Made for 2025 objectives, it is highly likely that renewable energy equipment manufacturers will remain in high gear, maintaining the global supply glut, particularly in solar panels but also for other equipment.

This trend is developing at a time when it is becoming increasingly well known that grid investment has not kept pace with renewable energy development. This is evidenced by longer and longer grid connection queues (the IEA estimates that over 3 000 GW of renewable energy projects are in connection queues globally, with nearly 1 500 GW of wind and solar PV projects in advanced stages of development). This is enough to nearly double current installed global capacity for these technologies, all of which is just sitting in queues!

We have written in past notes about our preferred investment picks to invest in the coming buildout in grid capacity (for example, please see “From Gridlock To Gridsmart”, April 4, 2024). In the simplest terms, given the oversupply in manufacturers vs the building demand for transmission, investors should be looking to go “long renewable energy operators and grid producers” and avoid “renewable energy equipment manufacturers”.

Record temperatures for sea and air surface are continuing in 2024 after a record 2023. Due to above normal sea surface temperatures and expected La Niña conditions, a busy hurricane season is expected this summer; warm water adds more energy to the tropics and La Niña1 usually reduces vertical wind shear that lets hurricanes come to shore. These factors are supporting forecasts for more than twenty named storms in the Atlantic Basin to occur in 2024. The presence of warm water earlier in the year has the potential to advance and extend the period of intense hurricanes that causes the most damage.

Longer term, warmer temperatures should increase the frequency of consequential weather events from high winds. Higher sea surface temperature also has the potential to increase flooding.

These consequential weather events have implications all across our built environments. Instead of measuring physical risks, we identified four equity investment plays that are leveraged to climate adaptation: residential rebuild, electric connections, electricity grid buildout and engineering services.

From the household sector, residential repairs and more construction activity will increase demand for all sorts of building supplies such as lumber, plywood, shingles, roofing panels, windows, doors, etc.

From corporations and governments, infrastructure repairs and resiliency improvements are necessary. In a note on April 4: “From Gridlock to Grid Smart: AI’s Role in Electricity Efficiency”, we argued that greater electricity demand will bring further strains on the grid. Indeed, there are already supply chain issues for switchgear and other electrical components, but destructive weather is likely to supercharge this demand.

In this note, we focus on building materials, grid connections, grid buildout and design. The table below lists companies and their respective products. Among the companies listed, only a few, mention climate change as a potential source of activity: Owens Corning highlights that 16% of its roofing business comes from climate events, Stella Jones highlights fire-resistant wrap utility poles as a strong growth driver and all of the engineering firms discuss climate change as a source of growth in revenues. The other companies on the list focus on residential construction. We believe that all the firms on the list could benefit from a busy hurricane season.

The chart below highlights a few public companies likely to benefit from increased demand from hurricanes this year and a more volatile climate in the future. These companies have been identified due to the likelihood of higher revenue streams associated with building reconstruction. These companies are characterized by decent margins, strong sales growth and reasonable valuations.

The next chart shows a few companies with products and solutions such as switchgear, structural connectors, cable and wire baskets that will be needed for infrastructure. Strong demand for their products, good margins with commensurate valuation metrics make them interesting investment opportunities. Simpson Manufacturing just reported its Q1, 2024 results and its price fell by 10% because construction activity was weaker than expectations. This could just be a temporary drop if demand for their products recover as we anticipate. In contrast, Owens Corning just reported better earnings, in part because of weather-related replacements.

Similarly, companies involved in the expansion and repair of the grid – including wooden poles to towers - will also benefit from extreme weather-related demand. The chart below displays the financial characteristics of Valmont Industries (a company that specializes in grid infrastructure among other things) and Stella Jones, a supplier of utility poles and other wood products. These two companies have low margins, strong sales growth and relatively fair valuations.

Finally, the engineering companies that design and manage construction and reconstruction should remain very busy. The following chart shows various financial ratios for select engineering firms. From a pure financial ratio perspective, investors seem to have anticipated better times than for the other groups highlighted above since margins and sales growth are relatively low but price to earnings and price to cash flows are relatively high.

Note that relative to a U.S. equity broad benchmark, each of the groups identified has outperformed over the past two years, suggesting that investors are already excited about these plays and their prospects. If our analysis of bigger climate events is correct, further strong results will follow.

 

Note

1: La Niña is a climate pattern that describes the cooling of surface-ocean waters along the tropical west coast of South America. It is considered to be the counterpart to El Niño, which is characterized by unusually warm ocean temperatures in the equatorial region of the Pacific Ocean. In this pattern, strong winds blow warm water at the ocean’s surface from South America to Indonesia. As the warm water moves west, cold water from the deep rises to the surface near the coast of South America. La Niña has significant effects on weather and climate. It can lead to severe weather conditions, affecting sectors such as agriculture, health, water resources, and disaster management. For example, during La Niña events, southern states in the U.S. tend to experience drought, while the Pacific Northwest and Canada see heavy rainfall and flash flooding.

The North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) released their latest Long-Term Reliability Assessment in December 2023 which showed an increased risk of shortfalls in electricity under both extreme and normal conditions. Within a single year, the projected five-year annual growth rate for electricity consumption nearly doubled from 0.5% to 0.9%! This projection could be even higher as some utilities have revised their numbers upward since the release of the NERC forecast. There are several drivers behind this surge in demand – the reshoring of manufacturing, adoption of EVs and fossil fuel free heating systems – but perhaps the most noteworthy is AI.

The process of training new AI models is very energy intensive. AI dedicated servers can use 4 to 14 times the electricity of a normal rack of servers and AI queries (like ChatGPT) use 3-30 times more energy than a typical google search. Furthermore, generative AI not only needs to be trained on large datasets, but also creates loads of new data, thereby increasing the need for data centers. One study estimates the share of U.S. electricity demand for data centers will triple from 2.5% in 2022 to 7.5% by 2030. Clearly, a broader adoption of AI will be a substantial source of electricity demand.

This increased demand creates a challenging scenario for electricity grids. Already, the integration of renewables into the system has proved challenging. While it may seem faster to develop more traditional power plants to increase electricity production, this counters decarbonization goals. A better idea would be to improve the efficiency of existing grids instead. Ironically there is a role for AI in grid optimization, meaning AI can be leveraged to address the very problem it is helping to create.

The Ultimate Power Move: Efficiency

We see two areas where AI can serve to improve efficiency challenges. Firstly, continuous optimization of electricity consumption in industry and buildings. AI can help to unlock efficiency improvements in the design of individual electronic devices, reducing their electricity consumption. AI can also be applied to assess the energy management of larger industrial processes or commercial buildings. These make up 64.4% of U.S. electricity demand; with the rest of demand mostly coming from residential heating and cooling needs (see chart). Use of advanced data analytics in these areas can identify opportunities for energy savings, regulate power consumption and dynamically adjust needs in accordance with changes in electricity demand. This contributes to reduced energy waste and lower operational costs.

The second more direct approach is integration of AI into the electricity grid. This can be achieved using smart grid technologies that allow for real-time monitoring and control of grid operations. An example of grid optimization would be to use AI algorithms to dynamically adjust the distribution of electricity. So in times of low demand, surplus energy is directed to power-hungry processes or energy storage, and when demand peaks, the grid adapts in real-time to reduce strain and prioritize energy efficient consumption. Virtual power plants (VPPs) will be an important element to this. These systems aggregate small scale energy sources such as solar panels, wind turbines and energy storage enabling coordinated management of those resources to optimize energy supply. The U.S. Department of Energy has estimated that tripling the scale of virtual power plants (VPPs) could lower America’s grid costs by $10 billion a year.

Deploying smart meters and IoT devices embedded with AI into grid infrastructure is paramount to deploying these technologies. It facilitates the collection of real-time data which can then be processed by AI algorithms to optimize grid performance. This will be especially important as the share of intermittent energy sources like wind and solar increases.

Investment in digital grid infrastructure has grown significantly in recent years (see chart below). Countries are taking advantage of technological advances to modernize their systems. However, this level of investment will need to accelerate to keep pace with the newly anticipated surge in electricity demand.

Making Gains in Power Savings

In our note Finding Real Returns in Artificial Intelligence (April 27, 2023), we explored how AI is helping to improve industrial resource efficiency across impactful sectors, including energy. We expect continued sales growth for established players in industrial automation and IoT connectivity such as ABB, Honeywell and Siemens as their solutions support enhanced energy efficiency in several key areas: building energy management, industrial processes, and grid infrastructure.

Similarly, information technology companies like Oracle, Fujitsu and IBM are poised to benefit from the expansion of AI. Any innovations by these companies that improve the energy efficiency of IT infrastructure will help reduce strain on the grid and lower electricity costs for customers as prices are likely to rise given greater demand. In addition to higher sales associated with more data centers and servers, these technology companies will see increased revenues from products with direct applications in electricity grid optimization.

Companies with energy management as their main business segment offer the greatest impact with regards to sustainability. They are key in helping to lower emissions and integrate renewables in our electricity infrastructure. Investors should pay close attention to how these energy management companies are trying to leverage AI to optimize the grid.

There are two small cap names of interest: Itron and Landis+Gyr Group, with market caps of $4 billion USD and $2 billion USD respectively. Landis+Gyr is exclusively dedicated to smart grid. Itron earns 67% of revenues from smart grid products but also sells smart metering devices for water management, another growing sector. General Electric is also a leader in smart grid technology, earning nearly $3.5 billion in revenues from that segment. The former conglomerate completed the spin-off of its energy segment into GE Vernova earlier this week, this is a great opportunity for sustainability investors looking for exposure to innovative energy solutions.

Eaton and Schneider Electric are two other large companies with a strong focus on energy efficiency. These more specialized companies cover all bases, improving industrial companies’ consumption and the efficiency of data centers while also supporting utilities with the integration of digital technologies aimed at optimizing the grid. Both of these companies have slightly higher valuations (Fwd PE of 25.1 for Schneider and 30.5 for Eaton) than the information technology and industrial automation companies mentioned above (average fwd PE of 21.9 for ABB, Honeywell and Siemens and 19.7 for Fujitsu, IBM and Oracle), but this may be justified given the outlook for electricity demand.

R&D spend will be a critical factor in these companies’ ability to keep pace with AI developments. There is a notable increase in recent years relative to historical levels. One can also pay attention to the mentions of AI in earnings calls and business strategies. Though we recognize that some companies may be mentioning AI to take advantage of the current hype, it can serve as an indicator of how much they are leveraging AI capabilities. Investors just need to be diligent in their research to filter out any fluff. In Eaton’s documents, “AI” jumped from 6 mentions in 2022 to 182 in 2023 and is already at 48 for 2024. For Schneider, this year’s mentions of AI are already 5% higher than last year’s total; it is afterall one of the five key focus areas in their latest strategy.

Similar to other technology stocks, many of these companies are currently trading at elevated levels. Investors can watch for potential pullbacks to add exposure. Unlike some other AI-hyped names, we expect digitization of the grid to have staying power as society comes to terms with the significant increase in electricity demand.

The opening months of 2024 have brought four macro developments worth monitoring that will impact investment outcomes for sustainability portfolios for the remainder of the year. In this installment of our quarterly update on Macro Meets Sustainability, we address the following:

 

A Neutralized, Neutral Fed

Whenever big gaps form between the Fed’s expectations and market participants’ expectations of interest rate policy, there is opportunity (and risk) for investors. That is NOT the current environment. Recall that as recently as January, the bond market was predicting a less than 5% chance that the Fed policy rate would still be at 525 basis points at this point in the year, fully expecting that the Fed would cut interest rates up to six times in 2024. Expectations have now fallen to a rather benign three rate cuts, beginning in June or later, which is incidentally, what the FOMC also expects of themselves (as per their March summary of projections). Although we wouldn’t be surprised to see even fewer rate hikes this year (due to sticky inflation), a Fed on hold with market participants that agree makes for a reasonably docile rate backdrop.

This should be viewed as especially good news for the “pain trade” in the renewable energy sector. In this sector especially, monetary policy had become incredibly restrictive. As we wrote in a note last week (“A Second Wind: What Peak Interest Rates Mean for Renewables”), simply removing the rate headwind improves the prospects of many renewable energy projects, since most of the operational costs associated with running utility-scale wind and solar projects are derived from financing costs (rates). To be sure, without interest rates coming down, the operating costs of running renewable projects do not improve. But with credit spreads in this sector suggestive of a low risk of default, we believe that “bottom fishing” in renewable energy production – though not equipment manufacturers due to the risks related to China as described below – is timely given the incredible long-term prospects.

A Trump World?

Although there are still seven months before the next U.S. president will be decided, the enormous gap between the two parties’ platforms suggests that investors of all stripes should consider how their portfolio will stand up to a change of guard.

President Biden recently released his proposed 2025 budget: the trajectory is one of very tepid deficit reduction, albeit a hefty increase in corporate tax rates is included. In contrast, Trump has indicated that if elected he would push to extend for another decade all the individual tax cuts that are set to expire at the end of this year. On the face of it, a Trump government appears likely be more “inflationary” than a Biden government.

More notably, the “flavor” of fiscal policy in the U.S. will certainly change under Trump. In 2022, President Biden’s government signed into law the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) as well as the Chips and Science Act. Both acts represent an Industrial Policy approach to fiscal expansion: they target specific industries that are in the national interest. We expect that industrial policy will increasingly become the norm across the globe (please see our note from July 21, 2021, “Macro Goes ESG”). But the problem is that Trump does not share the Biden administration’s view of which issues are in the national interest – ignorance about climate change being the most glaring one.

That said, Biden and Trump do agree that re-shoring manufacturing and protecting American jobs are priorities. In this sense, many “green industries” may not suffer much under a Trump government. After all, many climate-focused companies truly are helping to make America great again.

Our preliminary work suggests that from a sector perspective, outside of the fossil fuel industry and a possible knee-jerk election-day reaction, a changing of the guard may not be overly deleterious for sustainability portfolios; we intend to delve further into this topic in an upcoming research note.

 

Dr. Copper

Copper - the "metal of electrification" — is vital to all energy transition plans. Demand for the metal is expected to double between now and 2035, but the supply side is constrained on several fronts (underinvestment over the past decade, environmental backlash and bans, cost overruns, lower ore grades, etc).

The logical outcome of this demand/supply imbalance is a rise in copper prices. The breakout in copper above 4$/lb in March is just a small sign of things to come. However, before investors pile into the long-term copper trade, it’s worthwhile reviewing recent dynamics (after all, copper as part of the industrial metal complex, is subject to significant boom/bust cycles):

The bottom line is that we remain structural bulls on copper due to the enormous demands from electrification, however a more sustained rally and/or “copper mania” may only take place once some of China’s power glut is re-absorbed. Note that copper is a highly recyclable commodity; sustainability investors should first consider companies with strong potential in the recycling space. However, given the enormous amounts of copper required, high-quality miners with superior ESG standards can also be considered. Since most of the rest of the industrial metal complex does not share copper’s bullish dynamics, we suggest investors focus on miners that are producing exclusively (or nearly exclusively) on copper. Freeport-McMoRan (FCX US) and Ero Copper (ERO TSE) are two companies that fit this bill.

 

China Dumping: No Lift Off For Europe

As mentioned above, China currently appears stuck with overcapacity in solar panel production, but also a whole host of other industries from steel to electric vehicles. Indeed, China has (re)begun flooding its export markets with deeply price discounted goods to help support its domestic manufacturing sector.

But China’s goods dumping is perhaps nowhere more contentious than in the “green goods trade”. After all, cheap accessible green products should be a godsend to global decarbonisation. Unfortunately, both U.S. and EU efforts to address climate change have been wrapped around another goal: to reshore manufacturing capacity and create jobs. Thus, while China solar panel production (as well as wind power equipment, batteries and EVs) may be good for the global energy transition, they are problematic for competing nations’ goals.

For now, it appears that the EU is unlikely to impose new anti-dumping tariffs on Chinese solar panels or other renewable energy equipment, opting instead to find more ways to subsidize local production. We reiterate our view that the odds of other regions catching up to China are very low (see our note March 8, 2023 “China’s Solar Power and Deglobalization”). Investors keen to gain exposure to renewables should avoid solar equipment manufacturers and focus on renewable energy operators.