The election of Donald Trump and the resurgence of European populist parties does not augur well for global policy regarding environmental challenges. Trump already pulled the U.S. out of the Paris 2015 Climate Accord (again) and started rolling back most of Biden’s environmental regulations of the past four years. In Europe, the European Commission watered down its ambition as it looks to impose the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM, see our note “Carbon Protectionism: Winners and Losers under EU’s Carbon Border Plan”, July 25, 2024). In this context, some investors and carbon market participants are already asking whether regulated carbon markets – both in Europe and in North America – are poised to end.

Many speculators – mostly financial market participants, as opposed to regulated entities – have indeed left the market these past few months looking for better return opportunities elsewhere. Looking at recent carbon market auction data from the California Air Resource Board (CARB), one sees that the share of “voluntarily associated bidding entities” (i.e. speculators) was lower at the end of 2024 if compared to 2022-2023 averages. This has pressured carbon prices lower.

Why is the WCI Carbon Markets so Attractive?

While market sentiment and recent price-action of global regulated carbon markets have been negative lately, carbon market fundamentals remain strong – which is mostly true in North America. Interestingly, EU ETS market has been less affected by the current political environment in the U.S. and Canada than its WCI counterpart, which could explain the relative resilience in the price of EU emission allowances vis-à-vis those traded in the WCI market. That being said, current woes of the German industrial sector – a key player in EU emissions – could also mean that there will be less upwards price pressure on EUAs in in the coming years vis-à-vis WCI allowances.

 

This is why we think that the most interesting investment opportunities can be currently found in the Québec-California market. First, North American carbon markets are trading close to their regulated floor price. To this end, the most recent WCI auction (on February 19th) shows that the current price of $29.27 (a $2.64 decrease from the previous auction in November 2024) is just $3.40 above the 2025 Reserve Price.

Second, Québec and California issued fairly ambitious and restrictive emission reduction targets in the Fall of 2024 (good for carbon prices) for the period going up to 2030. While market rules for the post-2030 period have been delayed because of wildfires and a tough political environment (tariffs on Québec industrial exports), both Québec and California should publish them later this year, which should provide support for higher prices going forward.

Third, states like Washington – who are toying with the idea of linking their market with the WCI – are not afraid to buck the current political trend and press ahead with their climate ambitions.

Fourth, while the price of carbon – and its “social acceptability” – has been negatively affected by the current political context, many of the U.S. and Europe’s “Big Businesses” – most of them being regulated entities – are re-iterating their preference for keeping a price on carbon.

Finally, one could think that energy demand coming from AI data usage added to the reshoring of industrial activities in North America in many sectors required to comply with emission reductions should also put a floor on carbon prices going forward.

Could Populism Kill Carbon Markets?

In theory, both California and Quebec could eliminate their carbon market; in practice they won’t. That’s because those jurisdictions would probably have to repay emission rights holders – or else face a series of costly lawsuits, such as the one initiated under NAFTA’s Chapter 11 by Koch Industries against Government of Ontario in 2020. In that, the idea of repaying emission rights holders for the value of their carbon credits in the current fiscal context seems unfeasible.

After all, carbon markets, both in Europe and North America, have been in operation for more than a decade. For businesses, this means that some regulated industry participants have built a significant vested interest in these markets over time. Companies such as Tesla, which has reaped a USD 10 billion windfall from the sales of its carbon credits since 2017, are still seeing their revenues being bankrolled by the value of their carbon credits.

Turning to governments, many jurisdictions are seeing carbon markets as a precious source of revenue in times of fiscal consolidation. According to the World Bank, the EU and governments of California and Québec have respectively collected USD 160, 21 and 6 billion worth of cumulated fiscal revenue since 2018 through their carbon pricing schemes.

In all, the most likely course of action is that carbon markets are here to stay – even if we could expect them to be somewhat less buoyant than what was expected in 2024 due to current political headwinds. Other risk factors could come from the prevalence of natural disasters such as the recent wildfires in California – which have delayed rule making with regard to carbon market for the post 2030 period - and the fact that elevated carbon prices could be perceived as contributing to higher cost of living for consumers - notably through higher food and energy prices. In Europe more specifically, difficulties in in the industrial sector amid the need to produce more energy domestically (e.g. natural gas, coal) could also reduce policymakers’ appetite to make carbon markets more stringent than what was planned.

The Inevitable Clash

China is the world’s manufacturer, and the United States is its consumer. In the 2000’s, the commercial trade deficit of the United States was larger as a percentage of GDP (6%), it was balanced across many countries and built on the hope that the rise of China would bring new consumers. Obama realized late in his second term that China would not become a consumer, and he timidly pivoted to Asia. In his first term, Trump tried to make a deal with China using sticks (tariffs). Biden maintained those tariffs but used carrots (industrial subsidies for United States production). Trump will now use bigger sticks to reverse China’s manufacturing domination. The chart below highlights the biggest global economic issue of our time between the two largest economies in the world; China produces 5% more than it consumes, and the U.S. consumes 3% more than they produce.

At the top of the following graph, we can see the countries on the target list of the Trump administration’s goal to rebalance production towards the United States. Unsurprisingly, Mexico, Canada and China have been targeted for tariffs for national security reasons even before the required analysis to implement tariffs for economic reasons is completed (the latter should be completed by April 1st). We can expect global tariffs following the economic analysis with special negotiation tariffs for specific countries when opportunities arise.

The chart below describes the items for which the United States has the largest deficits and the largest surplus. The commercial balance is negative for manufactured items and positive for energy and food commodities, as well as high-tech circuits and semi-conductor machinery. The United States will fight hard to keep exporting high-tech circuits and semi-conductors.

On the opposite side, the picture below highlights sectors where China dominates global production. Those sectors have not been kind for global companies because profit margins have essentially disappeared. Chinese companies are choosing volume over profits, supported by Chinese banks that continue to lend to non-profitable companies at the directive of the government.

The table below shows the sectors where China will concentrate its efforts in the future. These are high-value-add sectors and the commercial clash between China and the United States will shape the global economy for the next decade.

The First Chinese Curveball to the New Trump Administration

Just as Donald Trump announced the Stargate project dedicated to huge investments in AI/data centres in the United States, performance results for DeepSeek models were released: they were truly impressive, especially considering the high-performance chips embargo that China is under and the relatively small size of the DeepSeek team. Moreover, their models are available as open source and use specialization techniques that reduce chip performance demand.

The implication is that the huge moat that supposedly encircled large current Western language models no longer looks so large. If a small firm can build highly performing models at a fraction of the cost, one can expect a race to low profitability similar to other sectors where China is competing aggressively.

American Exceptionalism

The U.S.’ brightest spot relative to China was Silicon Valley’s tech dominance. However, since ChatGPT came out in 2023, the big question has been how large language models (LLM’s) will be monetized. Just like the prospects from the Internet in the late 1990’s or those of the Chinese consumer in the early 2000’s, investors are really excited by the opportunity of LLMs and assume that Apple, Amazon, Microsoft and Google will be able to extend their existing large moats to artificial intelligence. It’s an open question whether LLMs will follow the profitability path of the Internet that eventually delivered or to the Chinese consumers that have proven disappointing.

Investor enthusiasm has led Open AI, Anthropic, Google, Meta and Microsoft to spend enormous amounts to be AI leaders. So far, their investments seem based on the motto “If you build it, they will come.” Open AI and Anthropic are dedicated to LLMs whereas Google, Meta and Microsoft aim to control the artificial intelligence ecosystem. So far, the large language model builders have adopted a brute force approach that resulted in huge demand for the best hardware. This created scarcity for Nvidia’s H100 chips (made for about $3,000 with a lifespan of 2-3 years and sold for 10 to 50 times that price). As a result, Nvidia became the most valuable company in the world.

Winners and Losers

The table below highlights our view of future market behavior in artificial intelligence. Software developers should benefit from more cost-friendly development leading to greater adoption (Jevons Paradox). Profitability winners from lower cost could be users that have not participated in the LLM arms’ race, most small businesses and everyday users. The big losers are risking being pure LLM developers like Open AI, which happens to be in fund-raising mode, and Anthropic; they could quickly become obsolete due to their high operating cost if a race to the bottom starts. Google, Microsoft and Meta have made large investments in LLM development, they are also likely losers because they have overspent but they could still benefit from greater adoption.

In terms of the infrastructure build-out, all else equal, Nvidia is a likely loser because the scarcity value of its chips will diminish, and their margins risk falling from their current stratospheric levels. Meanwhile, we expect data center enablers like energy producers and energy efficiency providers, to fare somewhat better; they will benefit from greater use of artificial intelligence but be negatively impacted by lower energy needs. Data centers will likely charge less for computing but pay less for chips. The economics behind the build-out of independent data centers (not the ones built by Google, Microsoft and Meta) generally assume a 20-year payoff. These will some under scrutiny from uncertainty in compute pricing even if the lower cost of chips could compensate for lower revenues.

The Likely Reaction

No one can “unsee” DeepSeek’s cost-to-performance results. Nonetheless, we expect a witch hunt to target the origin of their chips and intellectual property theft, leading to an eventual ban of DeepSeek in the United States.

Significance for Sustainability Investors

One of our investment themes is Productivity with Purpose, whereby technological innovations enable new solutions to improve quality of life. DeepSeek’s lower cost and energy demands could make LLMs more readily available and produce economy-wide gains as described in our note, “History Lessons for an AI Future”, June 20, 2024.

A core SMS megatrend is the age of electricity. From a pure energy efficiency standpoint, DeepSeek is an improvement over previous LLMs and could reduce the strain on projected energy demand emanating from the AI sector. However, given that AI is only a one piece of the electrification trend, we believe that the punishing market reaction to energy efficiency and nuclear power companies since Deepseek entered the scene is overdone.

DeepSeek Market Implications

The mega-cap names based in the United States have been clear beneficiaries of globalization. Their domination has grown since 2023 from the expected moats of artificial intelligence and investors assumed that the largest companies would be the ultimate beneficiaries, but a small company like DeepSeek should create doubts about their continued domination. Just like with the Internet around Year 2000, the ultimate winners have not been the ones people expected. From this standpoint, we expect subpar performance from the large companies that have optimistic implied expectations and outperformance from smaller companies that have reasonable implied expectations that will benefit from low-cost AI solutions.

Immediate Investment Opportunities in Electrification

The table below shows five companies that have fallen between 10-20% since the DeepSeek moment. Considering the long-term electrification trend should continue (even if data centers construction slows down), the activities in which they are involved will see sustained demand.

Emergence of AI Applications

As discussed above, the emergence of DeepSeek marks a shift in AI’s evolution; suddenly the technology is significantly cheaper and more efficient - if the data holds true. Moreover, as an open-source AI model, broad accessibility will facilitate further development. Based on these factors, we believe investors should shift their focus on software rather than hardware. Lower costs and improved accessibility create tailwinds for companies leveraging AI in their products.

From a sustainability perspective, we focus on AI applications that drive meaningful productivity gains (SMS theme Productivity with Purpose). Two areas with the most impactful opportunities are industrial and healthcare applications.

In industrial settings, AI enhances resource efficiency, reducing waste through optimized processes or improved design in the case of engineering tools. We have explored this topic in past research: “Finding Real Returns in Artificial Intelligence”, April 27, 2023. These companies stand to benefit not only from effective use of AI, but also from the ongoing deglobalization trend leading to new factory construction. Autodesk, PTC Inc. and Parker Hannifin are well positioned in this space and experienced strong stock performance in the past year. Dassault Systemes and Rockwell have lagged their respective peers.

In healthcare, AI is being used to improve diagnostics and accelerate drug discovery. In contrast to some of the industrial plays, healthcare names have underperformed the market in recent months offering a more attractive entry point. Both GE Healthcare and Quest Diagnostics are leveraging AI in their diagnostic tools and processes; Quest Diagnostics is also notable for its acquisition of PathAI. On the drug discovery side, Eli Lilly had partnered with OpenAI to find treatments for drug-resistant bacteria and GSK is touting the benefits of its AI use. Investors should also watch life science companies like Danaher, Agilent and Thermo Fisher, which provide tools that support drug development and research. These too can benefit from cheaper, more readily available AI.

Beyond industrial and healthcare applications, greater AI accessibility will be disruptive across other sectors, though the societal benefit varies. AI enhancements to tools like Workday, Shopify and Duolingo are beneficial, but less transformational. A step further, companies like Verisk (insurance), Wisetech Global (logistics) and Wolters Kluwer (finance, ESG) can leverage AI for specialized applications in more critical industries. However, the most significant beneficiaries of expanding AI adoption are enablers like Accenture, CGI Inc and Capgemini which help businesses across a broad range of sectors integrate AI to enhance operational efficiency and better decision-making. As this technology becomes more accessible and cost-effective, demand for their services will surely rise.

President Trump has been very clear about his ambitions to flood the world with cheap, U.S. fossil fuels. The new administration pins these goals on a desire to bring down consumer price inflation and to avoid an electricity shortage in the years ahead. Meanwhile, the natural gas industry has seized the moment, with a flurry of new deals and activity, and with little regard to climate change mitigation.  

Despite the plethora of renewable energy solutions available, the new U.S. Administration has opted for drilling.  In today’s Note, we explore the natural gas market in a series of questions and answers that are top of mind for sustainability investors.

 

1. What is behind Trump’s “drill, baby, drill” mantra?

The move to declare a national “energy” emergency appears to have three motives: to reduce consumer energy prices, improve national security and to decrease the trade deficit. Indeed, in his January 20 speech, Trump declared “…We will bring prices down, fill our strategic reserves up again right to the top, and export American energy all over the world“.  

The ability to reach any of these objectives is shaky:

Survey data of U.S. gas producers show that a price of $3.69 /Million Btu is needed for producers to be profitable, but they also expect average prices to be below that level for the next two years. No wonder producers report having little intention to increase activity over the next few quarters! Since the U.S. gas market is already oversupplied, drilling is unlikely to accelerate and there is no reason to suggest natural gas prices will fall (or rise for that matter) significantly from here. Only once new sources of demand, i.e. new gas power plants come on-line, will there be a need for further drilling. That development is still years away.

 

2. Does the U.S. “need” more energy?

Total energy consumption in the U.S. has been stagnant over the past decade and the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) expects this to be the case over the next decade, with increased industrial consumption to be largely offset by a decline in transportation usage.

However, this masks an important trend in what kind of energy will be in demand. By far, the most important development in energy markets is the inflection point in electricity demand. To be sure, AI and data centers have triggered new interest in electricity grids, but it is not the primary driver behind the surge in electricity demand. As the chart below shows, electricity consumption has been rising since the beginning of the decade, well before ChatGPT became a household name.

 

Therefore, though the U.S. may not need more total energy, it will most definitely require more electricity (and transmission). We have written about this theme in several recent notes.

What may change in 2025 is the fuel mix to generate this electricity. In a Trump world, will more electricity be generated from non-renewable sources than was forecast to be the case with the Inflation Reduction Act in place? Possibly, but it is economics that will ultimately be the deciding factor (see question four below).

 

3. Why such a big push for LNG and can it succeed?

One of the main reasons why the previous administration halted LNG permits is because liquefied natural gas is thought to generate even more greenhouse gases than coal (because the methane in natural gas is twenty times more potent than carbon).

However, since the current administration does not factor environmental harm into policy decisions, there is a clear line leading to exporting more LNG. As highlighted above, one of the current administration’s primary goals is to reduce the U.S. trade deficit. This requires either importing less (perhaps to be helped along by punitive import tariffs) or to export more. The U.S. energy sector is one area that has the capacity to send more overseas, particularly natural gas, by liquifying it and then transporting by sea. 

Now that the building of LNG ports can be fast-tracked, there will be the capacity for LNG exports to double by 2028, should there be sufficient demand. And therein lies the rub: currently, the majority of U.S. LNG is shipped to Europe, but these countries are forecast to consume less natural gas over the next decade. To be sure, the U.S. can replace some Russian LNG, but investors should stay cognizant of the longer term trend to lower gas consumption in Europe. The U.S. may find clients in Asia, where switching from coal to gas plants remains in full swing. That said, energy security and autonomy is also a policy goal in China, making U.S. LNG less tempting in the current environment.

The bottom line is that discarding “red tape” only removes one hurdle for LNG exporters; aggressive environmental objectives in Europe as well as the geopolitics of energy security are two others that might be harder to overcome.   

 

4. Is there any positive environmental merit to natural gas?

Natural gas is often thought of as a “bridge” fuel within the energy transition to renewables. On the surface, it’s not hard to see why, since natural gas does not share the “shortcomings” of most renewables – intermittency and lack of storability. Meanwhile, although CO2 emissions are astronomical relative to renewables, they’re nonetheless lower for dry natural gas than coal and oil.

In fact, if the U.S. electricity sector has had any success at all at reducing carbon emissions, it has been primarily through the switch from coal to natural gas (and solar and wind). But with coal now less than 20% of total fuel source for U.S. electricity, much of the “easy” reduction in emissions has already occurred.

Moreover, the “bridge fuel” argument that favors natural gas is becoming weaker over time.

 As noted in the chart below, the economics of renewable energy + battery storage (excluding subsidies) are more favorable than natural gas. In other words, by combining clean technologies, one can deliver equally reliable, cheaper, and cleaner energy to the grid than through natural gas. In our note published last November, “What’s in Store for Energy Storage?” we provided an update on the advanced state of battery storage, with a focus on utility-scale solutions and the companies that are winning in this field.

In addition, it currently takes less time to build renewable plants than it does coal-fired!


5. What is a sustainable investor to do?

Natural gas has become a hot topic thanks to Trump’s energy mantra and the hype around AI’s insatiable energy needs (Deepseek notwithstanding).  Indeed, there have been a flurry of high-profile announcements of both acquisitions and new gas plant construction in recent days, most of which from companies that we typically look to short sell (for example, Chevron has partnered to build new gas plants, but carbon capture installations are absent). This has not gone unnoticed by investors; even interest in the futures market has increased since Trump was elected.  

With North American gas prices expected to remain depressed and at the low end of where producers are profitable, we expect tactical opportunities to short-sell U.S. gas producers.  

On the long side, long-time readers will note that our preferred investment strategy to play the electrification trend is to favor companies involved in the grid buildout. We see significant opportunities across several sub-sectors critical to electrification and grid modernization: cables, substation equipment, and transmission infrastructure.

In cables, we favor Nexans (NEX FP) and Prysmian (PRY IM), both of which are global leaders in providing the essential wiring and connectivity solutions required for grid expansion. In the substation equipment segment, there are no surprises that ABB Ltd (ABBN SW) and Schneider Electric (SU FP) are favored winners, since both firms have a strong track record of innovation and are delivering equipment necessary to support smarter, more efficient energy distribution. Finally, in transmission infrastructure, we’re bullish on Valmont Industries (VMI US) and Stella-Jones Inc (SJ CN), both of which provide essential transmission and utility poles and towers.

Note that many of these companies received a severe knock earlier this week with the news that Deepseek, China’s opensource large language models, consume far less energy to deliver the same results. However, as mentioned above, the electrification trend goes well beyond artificial intelligence needs; today’s lower entry points make many of our preferred names even more attractive.

For investors that had high hopes that COP29 would deliver some sort of direction about where to allocate capital in a world desperately needing climate solutions, they would be right to be disappointed. Nations failed to agree on binding commitments to phase out fossil fuel subsidies, but perhaps most disappointing relative to expectations is the paltry commitment to emerging economies. The “New Collective Quantified Goal on Climate Finance (NCQG)” was officially drafted and agreed upon during COP29 and earmarks an underwhelming USD 300 billion annually. This sum falls far short of the estimated needs reported by developing countries. Given this modest commitment, it becomes obvious that the role of private finance is critical for a green transition in EM.

In today’s note, we argue why the energy transition in EM will be different than what has occurred so far in developed economies and we outline where we see the most practical opportunities for investors.

 

It’s Different in EM

For developed economies like European countries and the U.S., energy transition means primarily decarbonizing established energy systems by replacing fossil fuel energy sources with renewable ones. In other words, there is a singular objective of energy substitution.

In emerging markets, the energy transition must satisfy multiple goals, sometimes referred to as the energy trilemma: energy security, energy equity (both access and affordability), and energy sustainability. To achieve this, many factors need to be taken into account:

A key point in the energy transition in EMs is that achieving one goal cannot risk sacrificing another. Take the current electricity situation in South Africa. ESKOM is the public utility in South Africa and generates about 95% of electricity for the country and it is also the largest emitter of sulphur dioxide in the power industry in the world. ESKOM has periodically implemented rolling blackouts (a.k.a. load shedding) since 2008, unable to maintain enough power production to consistently meet demand. Ever since, ESKOM has been caught in a death spiral, i.e. a financial and operational catastrophe whereby declining revenues lead to higher costs, which in turn drive more customers away, perpetuating the cycle). Add to this, major governance scandals that make it difficult for ESKOM to attract new capital.

Frustrated by blackouts and rising bills, South Africans that can afford to have invested in private electricity generation (mainly via rooftop solar panels) and therefore have migrated away from Eskom’s grid. This leaves a smaller (and less well-off) base of customers to shoulder ever-rising costs. Faced with fewer (and poorer) consumers and therefore less revenues, ESKOM’s services – reliable electricity output – worsens. In this way, some South Africans that can afford it manage to have access to clean, renewable energy, but those that are left behind see the quality of their (dirty) electricity deteriorate sharply. South Africa may achieve one goal of having a cleaner energy mix through greater use of solar panels, but at the expense of improving energy access to all.

The bottom line is that investors interested in the energy transition in emerging markets are faced with a far more challenging set of variables than in DM. However, the potential for impact is also much higher.

 

Where to Start: An Investors Guide to EM Energy Transition

Investors can have the most impact in countries where access to reliable electricity is weakest. In these regions, clean energy initiatives will offer more than just decarbonization, they will also support improved living standards and economic participation.

Developing nations’ frustrations at the recent COP negotiations is understandable considering the substantial need for investor capital in fund green initiatives. In 2023, only 15% of the $1.8 trillion invested in clean energy infrastructure went to emerging and developing economies according to the World Economic Forum. Moreover, it is estimated that emerging markets will require $2.6 trillion annually for energy investment if 2050 net zero goals are to be achieved. Needless to say, there is a significant funding gap to fill.

Part of the reluctance to fund green energy projects in emerging markets can be explained by the much higher cost of capital. Higher risk premiums are demanded due to a slew of risks (higher volatility in exchange rates, political risks, etc). The chart below highlights the massive range in cost of capital for solar projects in various countries; other renewable energy projects face similar cost of capital ranges.

A Just Transition Means Significantly Higher Cost of Capital

Source: IRENA 

According to the International Agency for Renewable Energy (IRENA), for purposes of energy-transition investments, emerging economies fall into three broad contexts:

Category 1: Countries that already have well-established power markets (e.g.  China, and Brazil). Renewable projects are generally bankable and thus capital costs are lower.

Category 2: Jurisdictions that successfully mobilised large amounts of private capital for certain renewable technologies but are now hitting a ceiling due to technical challenges (e.g. risk of curtailment) or bankability risks (e.g. off-taker risk). Vietnam and South Africa are in this category.

Category 3: Countries that have not been able to attract investments owing to constrained macroeconomic conditions or political conflicts. Projects may not become bankable in the near term, but investments are urgently needed. Even if some projects have already been completed, system integration, transmission constraints, utility creditworthiness are all headwinds. Here, the role of concessional loans and grants and partnering with international organization and/or local government is almost always necessary since investment decisions must be based on factors that go beyond realising financial profits for private investors. Many African countries fit here.

Category 1 economies like China and India experienced a massive growth in energy consumption since 2000, reflecting both demographics and overall economic development over the past 20 years. Electricity consumption per capita increased a whopping 516% in China and 182% in India, far outpacing Africa’s 17% growth. The chart below shows the increased level of energy consumption for industry during this timeframe.

Given that big energy gains have already been achieved, investing in the energy transition in China and to some extent in India, is in many ways like investing in advanced economies: there will be an increasing focus on energy substitution, i.e. decarbonization of current energy systems, rather than building new ones.

Brazil’s slower growth in energy demand reflects its relatively smaller manufacturing sector. The country certainly has an important role to play in lowering emissions; along with China and India, Brazil is among the largest emitters globally. However, its large emissions are far more related to agriculture (nearly 50% of Brazil’s greenhouse gas emissions stem from this sector). Brazil’s heavy reliance on hydroelectricity (see chart further below “Breakdown of Energy Supply by Region”) makes its energy consumption less carbon-intensive compared to other developing nations.  

To be sure, decarbonisation of these countries (category 1) is necessary as the chart above shows that China, India and other BRICs countries (Brazil is an exception) still rely heavily on fossil fuels. However, investors seeking to make greater impact should look to other emerging markets, i.e. countries that are striving to improve access to (renewable) energy, like those in “category three” described above. In frontier markets, particularly Africa, energy needs remain largely unmet. Data from the World Bank shows almost 50% of the population of Sub-Saharan Africa did not have access to electricity in 2022 and still has significantly lower electricity consumption per capita (0.632 MWh) compared to other parts of the world (global electricity per capita is 3.4 MWh). We mentioned earlier the electricity woes of South Africa, yet South Africa has the highest rate of electricity production of African countries.

The following table shows the breakdown of total energy supply by source for various countries and regions. There is plenty of room to expand clean energy in Africa. Notice the high share of biofuel use; this could seem positive, but it is actually a clear example of inequalities in energy access.

The high share of biofuel use comes from the traditional cookstoves that rely on firewood, charcoal and biomass (even animal dung) or high polluting fuels like kerosene. Widespread reliance on cookstoves is a clear consequence of energy poverty and is not only more common in lower-income populations, but also disproportionately affects women and children who have the responsibility of collecting these fuel sources and are also more exposed to the associated pollutants. Cookstoves are used in parts of South Asia and South America but are most common in Africa. Improving accessibility to electricity can facilitate the transition to cleaner cooking technologies.

It is perhaps surprising that nuclear energy is represented in the table above, even at modest shares, in developing economies, given the large capital costs and long pay-off times. Several EMs successfully built nuclear power plants in the 1970s and the 1980s through support from the Soviet Union within the Council for Mutual Economic Cooperation (COMECON) framework or by the United States. Today, however, lack of international cooperation implies that most EMs don’t have the capacity to build reactors. According to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), only a handful EM countries have any plans at all to invest in nuclear.  

The recent Northvolt saga should serve as a stark reminder that even with cutting edge technology, key strategic partnerships (in this case Volkswagen) and billions in public funding, scaling a battery manufacturing business is not for the faint of heart.

For sustainability-focused investors navigating an increasingly complex geopolitical and economic environment, this underscores the importance of conducting thorough competitive landscape analyses before committing to a company or specific technology.

This week’s note delves into the rapidly expanding world of battery energy storage systems (BESS) within the current economic and political context.

The ABC of BESS

Energy storage is far from a novel concept. In Ancient Rome, thermal mass in buildings was employed to store heat and stabilize temperatures. Modern energy storage technologies emerged in the late 19th century, with innovations such as pumped hydroelectric energy storage (PHES) and lead-acid batteries. Today, PHES remains the dominant energy storage solution. However, according to the International Energy Agency (IEA), battery energy storage systems are poised to overtake PHES as the leading energy storage technology within the next 5 to 10 years.

This is largely due to the limited growth potential of hydroelectric power compared to other renewable energy sources. In many regions, the economically viable hydroelectric capacity has already been tapped, and geographic and social acceptability constraints significantly limit further expansion. As a result, nearly all additional electricity generation over the next 25 years is expected to come from wind and solar energy.

As critics of renewables like to remind us all, wind and solar energy are inherently intermittent, relying on fluctuating weather conditions that vary throughout the day and across seasons. Their capacity factors (ratio of actual electrical energy output over a given period of time to the theoretical maximum) typically range from 25% for solar to around 40% for offshore wind. What critics tend to forget is that these intermittent technologies also produce surplus electricity beyond immediate demand on a regular basis (e.g. during a windy night or a sunny temperate day). This excess, low-cost electricity from grid-connected solar and wind can be stored and later discharged to the grid to balance supply and stabilize the energy system when renewable generation falls below demand.

 

Average Daily Profile of Renewables+BESS Systems

Source: David Osmond, Renew Economy, Aug 23, 2024

 

The benefits of pairing BESS with renewable energy extend well beyond the concept of “peak shaving”. Compared to natural gas “peaker plants” —the most common configuration today—BESS offers a far cleaner alternative, with zero emissions of CO₂, NOₓ, or SOₓ. It also brings significant operational advantages, such as faster response times for grid stabilization and demand spikes, while providing ancillary services like frequency regulation and voltage support, which collectively enhances grid reliability.

What Investors Need to Know

These benefits are not constrained by political boundaries. Supporting BESS projects aligns with broader infrastructure goals, including Trump’s focus on modernizing America’s aging and fragile electricity grid.

Investors should also note Tesla’s strong performance in this sector. In its most recent Q3 earnings, Tesla reported flat revenue growth in its Automotive segment, while its Energy Storage business grew over 50% year-on-year, reaching nearly 10% of total revenue. Projections indicate this segment could account for 20% of Tesla’s earnings by 2025, driven by a robust demand pipeline and increased production capacity at the Shanghai Megapack plant. Given the current bromance between Musk and Trump, it is reasonable to expect that they will find a way to achieve their political objectives without hurting such an important segment of Musk’s business.

The BESS market is divided into three key segments: front-of-the-meter (FTM) utility-scale installations, typically larger than 10 megawatt-hours (MWh); behind-the-meter (BTM) commercial and industrial installations, ranging from 30 kilowatt-hours (kWh) to 10 MWh; and BTM residential installations, usually below 30 kWh. Each of these segments presents distinct opportunities and challenges for investors and policymakers alike.

Given the distinct differences in market size, profitability, and risk profile across the three BESS segments, we focus on one or two companies from each segment for our analysis. It's worth noting that major EV and battery manufacturers such as Tesla, BYD, CATL, Samsung SDI, and Panasonic are all involved in BESS projects to varying extents. However, for the purpose of this research, we are concentrating on companies with significant exposure to the theme, defined as deriving more than 50% of their revenue from energy storage-related activities.

In the FTM (Front-of-the-Meter) segment, we first turn to Wärtsilä Oyj (WRT1V FH), the Finnish marine and energy giant. In their most recent earnings, the energy segment surpassed 50% of total revenue for the first time in years, solidifying their growing influence in the BESS market. Their GridSolv Quantum, a fully integrated, modular, and scalable BESS solution powered by their proprietary GEMS Energy Management Software, positions them as a key player in the sector. Notable achievements include a utility-scale BESS project in Texas, USA—a 200 MW facility that is the largest fully merchant and market-facing energy storage installation globally. Wärtsilä expects to grow this already profitable segment significantly in the coming years and is open to strategic acquisitions to further bolster their position.

The second company to highlight is Fluence Energy (FLNC US), a well-recognized name in most clean energy and smart grid funds. However, we argue that Wärtsilä presents a more compelling BESS investment opportunity, even though it is not yet synonymous with the energy transition. Fluence, formed in 2018 as a joint venture between Siemens and AES Corporation, benefits from a strong technological foundation and a robust network of partnerships, and participates in cutting-edge energy storage projects worldwide. Despite these advantages, Fluence faces challenges convincing investors of its ability to deliver strong financial results. Its stock price, currently half of its IPO level from three years ago, reflects these concerns.

Shifting focus to residential and C&I (Commercial and Industrial) BESS segments, Enphase Energy (ENPH US) emerges as a noteworthy contender. Initially known for its residential solar microinverter business, Enphase underwent a meteoric rise during the COVID era, gaining over 1,000% in market value between March 2020 and December 2022. While some of this growth was justified—driven by rising renewable demand and government incentives—the valuation became unsustainable, with a P/E ratio in the hundreds. Following a correction that wiped out more than 80% of its peak valuation, the company now presents a more rational investment case. Enphase has been expanding its energy storage offerings, such as the launch of the IQ PowerPack 1500 in the U.S. and Canada. The company’s strategic pivot to BESS includes plans to introduce next-generation batteries in 2025, targeting both residential and commercial markets. Notably, Enphase reinvested 10% of its revenue into R&D last year—three times the industry average—signaling its commitment to innovation and market expansion.

Lastly, EnerSys (ENS US) offers a compelling case as a legacy player transitioning into the BESS market. With over a century of expertise in stored energy solutions, EnerSys caters to diverse industries, including telecommunications, utilities, agriculture, aerospace, and defense. While historically seen as a traditional, "unsexy" battery supplier, EnerSys has embraced the BESS revolution with its OptiGrid Stored Energy Solutions—a turnkey, utility-scale capacity optimization system designed for both front-of-the-meter and behind-the-meter applications such as curtailment, demand response, and peak shaving. Interestingly, despite operating in a rapidly evolving industry, EnerSys exhibits value-oriented financial metrics, such as a P/E of 11x and a dividend yield, making it an attractive investment for those seeking exposure to energy storage with a value-driven edge.

 

 

The election of Donald Trump has cast a pall over many investors that adhere to the idea that purchasing stocks using both financial and non-financial criteria deliver superior long-term returns.

To be sure, the turn away from “ESG” investing has been underway for quite some time – the chart below shows that fund outflows from U.S. ESG ETFs occurred throughout 2023 and 2024.

President-elect Donald Trump will most likely move to dismantle ESG-related regulations in the U.S. when he takes office in January, including blocking Securities and Exchange Commission rules for corporate and fund disclosures and putting limits on ESG-related shareholder proposals filed during proxy season. U.S. companies have already taken the hint that ESG is no longer a sales or marketing advantage and have been working fast to erase the phrase “ESG” from corporate speak: the chart below shows the precipitous drop-off of the number of mentions during quarterly earnings calls.

The turn away from ESG is not, however, a death knell for investors that focus on sustainability. Investors should recall that Trump’s first term was an excellent time for many thematic sustainability funds and many equity sectors moved in a contrary fashion to consensus expectations:

The key takeaway is that despite the anti-ESG trend, successful investing remains about understanding the macroeconomic backdrop and anticipating the needs and desires of the future. As climate change and related environmental challenges continue to mount at a time when social inequalities are ever-present, sustainability themes will not fade from focus.

That said, President-elect Trump’s policy aims will nonetheless shift the macroeconomic backdrop in ways that impact key sustainability themes. In today’s note, we outline how inflation, industrial policy and climate change will affect the outlook for these themes.

  1. Inflation: Yes. But Where and How Much?

It has become a consensus view that a Trump presidency will exacerbate inflation. We find it difficult to disagree. After all, economic theory, borne out in practice time and again, shows us that large fiscal deficits (which are expected thanks to the extension of tax cuts under Trump) stoke inflation. Tariffs are also inflationary – historically, about half of the cost of tariffs is assumed by producers (via smaller profit margins) and the other half by consumers (rising prices).

Pile on a restrictive immigration policy that will further constrain an already cyclically and structurally tight labor market and labor costs will face upward pressure, all else equal.

Nowhere will the labor squeeze be felt more acutely than in agriculture and our forecast is that food prices are the most likely source of consumer price inflation in the intermediate term. A recent article in the Atlantic estimated that if the Trump administration were to enact “the largest deportation operation in American history, somewhere between 40 and 50 percent of the people who plant U.S. crops would leave the domestic workforce.”

Already, food inflation has been running hotter than overall CPI due to structural reasons: the global population is projected to increase by 10% this decade while the lower and upper-middle-class increase by 30%. As more people reach the middle class and adopt a more calorific diet as is characteristic of that class, the demand for food will continue to increase. Meanwhile, on the supply side, it is unlikely that more of the earth’s land surface can be dedicated to food production and climate change is also complexifying food production as we know it.

Though the nomination of Robert F. Kennedy Junior as Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) is not yet a done deal (RFK Jr’s aberrant views on vaccines, fluoride, cell phone radiation and other topics mean that many groups are already lobbying against his nomination); when it comes to food, RFK’s desired policy path would unequivocally result in higher food price inflation. The current U.S. food system is designed to maximize yields at the lowest cost. An overhaul that includes solving for multiple variables, i.e. improving human health and environmental outcomes, will not come without financial cost for consumers.  

At Sustainable Market Strategies, we have high conviction that sustainable food production will be an important investment theme over the next decade (for example, please see our note “Food for Thought”, September 21, 2023). Readers can expect updated research from us, especially should RFK be nominated. Investors should closely watch the policy backdrop for opportunities on both the long and short side within the food and health sectors.

  1. Industrial Economy 2.0: Bring the Companies Home

We have written extensively over the past several years about the rising dominance of fiscal policy that has occurred since 2010. Notably, in 2021, we quoted ex-Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke, who, after dropping the Federal interest rate to zero and undertaking the largest quantitative easing program in history, declared, “The Federal Reserve cannot solve all the economy's problems on its own.” He subsequently called on Congress, the administration, and regulators to do more to prop up the U.S. economy. Washington policymakers jumped to the call and have never looked back. Since that time, both Republican and Democrat governments have announced major fiscal packages that have totaled over 9 trillion USD. In the table below, we list, describe and colour-code (features in red denote fiscal measures targeting specific industries) the main features of the various spending bills. A pattern emerges: spending packages are increasingly being used to deploy industrial policy.

Investors may recall that soon after Biden was elected, the White House published a list of key priorities for the government (see the table below). These priorities were reflected in the spending bills of the past four years, and to a great extent (the proliferation of AI notwithstanding) were apparent in the growth prospects and stock performance of U.S. companies.

There is a strong consensus that at the top of Trump’s priority list is the reshoring of U.S. manufacturing as well as other key industries critical to national security and autonomy (e.g. energy and semiconductors).

To be sure, manufacturing re-shoring and rebuilding should be viewed as a continuation of a trend that got underway with the Inflation Reduction Act, since the bill inherently favored onshoring jobs and production in key sectors. In this sense, many of the excelling companies that have benefited from the process of “deglobalization,” i.e. the building out of domestic supply chains, will continue to thrive in the years ahead. Sustainability focused investors should look for industrial companies with most of their revenues in the U.S. and that support resource efficiency, climate adaptation, automation as these will be in high demand, some of which are highlighted in the table below.

 

  1. Investors Must Make Room for Climate Change Adaptation

Should the U.S. withdraw from the Paris Agreement - as is most likely under Trump – there are lower odds that the planet will warm at less than two degrees in the coming decades.

A study by McKinsey found that even if the global temperature warms only by 1.5°C by 2030 –an increasingly elusive target as we drag our feet on concrete actions – almost half of the world's population will still be exposed to climate hazards, such as heat stress, drought and floods. On this basis, it makes sense for investors to make greater space in their portfolios for companies focused on climate change adaptation.

As it stands, climate adaptation is mitigation’s poor little brother when it comes to financing, with 93% of total climate funding going towards reducing greenhouse gas emissions instead of building resilient infrastructure.

President-elect Trump’s distaste for global cooperation on climate change implies that investors should now be looking for opportunities beyond mitigation. The climate adaptation trade can take many forms, from betting on the long-term success of the most prepared insurance companies to banking on the increased demand for data from firms that feed insurance models, to positioning for increased spending on resilient infrastructure.

The reinstatement of Donald Trump into the White House deals a significant blow to sustainability-focused investors; many sustainability-themed equity prices declined sharply last week as the consensus among financial market participants is now that the tailwinds behind the global sustainability agenda – or at least in the U.S. – are likely to disappear soon. There is even the potential for headwinds to come at the federal government level from the new President’s strong anti-ESG agenda.

Against this backdrop, we share how Sustainable Market Strategies sees the medium-term investment landscape for renewable energy, a key theme within many sustainability related portfolios.

Things that will change

The death of the Inflation Reduction Act has not been exaggerated: President-elect Trump will gut the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) but will likely pass something like the “President Trump Act to Fix the Country” – which likely will include a list of measures targeted at meeting the country’s growing grid capacity needs. In this context, we still believe that several clauses of the soon-to-be-defunct IRA will prevail, especially subsidies for new energy projects – green or dirty. On the green side, we still expect some fiscal tailwinds – especially for solar project given their prevalence in Red States to remain under Trump.

Interest rates and yields are popping back up: Promises of fiscal spending, lower taxes and higher tariffs will put pressure on interest rates and bond yields in 2025. Spiking yields are already suggestive of a less stable fiscal outlook while reflecting the perspective of a weak fiscal outlook and higher inflation. For us, continued higher interest rates remain the main headwind for the development of renewable projects as these require substantial debt financing.

Things that won’t change

Power demand is set to accelerate: A recent study from the EIA suggests that the U.S. power grid will have to double in capacity from 2022 to 2050 to meet increasing demand for electric power, and that most newly-built capacity will come from renewables. As a consequence, the U.S. will have to add the equivalent of California’s capacity alone to its grid by 2030. That’s a lot of power!

Green Energy remains the cheapest source of electricity: The levelized cost of energy for electricity (LCOE) production coming from renewables will continue to come down and become even cheaper than fossil sources. According to Lazard, this is even true in a context of higher interest rates.

It takes less time to build green: While the U.S. still has a strong pipeline of fossil-based energy plants, building green remains a cheaper and faster way to add capacity.

 

 

 

 

Wind and Solar in a Trump’s Brave New World

According to the Global Energy Monitor, of the current pipeline of projects approved and in the preconstruction stage, wind and solar could respectively account for about 25 and 5 percent of U.S. 2030 capacity needs.

There are currently 233 wind power projects and 4,233 solar projects announced and in the pre-construction phase in the U.S., with the majority located in Red States—many of which are power-hungry and need to improve grid reliability and resilience. Onshore wind projects are expected to have the most development potential due to their lower costs and social acceptability, while solar projects present a resilient investment within the renewables sector given their relatively lower costs compared to wind. Analyzing the Global Energy Monitor’s list of these projects, we examined company-level exposure to wind and solar, noting that companies like Orsted, NextEra, and EDPR could face significant capacity risks if Trump were to cancel projects on ideological grounds, as hinted by the recent derating of some clean energy stocks, though we view this scenario as unlikely.

 

Conversely, looking at solar projects, we see that EDPR, Next Era and AES also have some significant capacity at risk of being cancelled should Trump decide to favor fossil fuel projects over renewable ones. Again, this would make no sense in a context of power scarcity and the fact that solar is currently the cheapest and fastest way to produce electricity.

 

Those companies with projects at risk of being cancelled have derated even more than the S&P Clean Energy Index these past few days; meanwhile the S&P 500 increased by about 500 basis points.

The Wildcard: Donald and Elon’s Bromance

While sustainability plays took a punch to the gut since the U.S. election, there could be a path where renewables could emerge as a winner under the new Administration: enter Elon Musk. Musk’s estimated USD 130+ million dollar donation to the Trump campaign is surprising given the two’s 2017 fallout over climate policies in the first Trump administration. However, it still compares advantageously with the USD 23 million received (officially see Open Secrets) from the fossil fuel lobby. In this context, one could think that Musk’s influence over the incoming President could jolt his interest over climate change issues (at best) and make him more lenient towards renewable energy (at the very least). 

Searching for Fallen Angels

Given the above considerations, one can assess the extent to which the recent de-rating of clean energy stocks has been exaggerated.  The chart below shows the top 10 losers in price (percent) since the election. With many investors indiscriminately dumping the iShares S&P Clean Energy ETF, this means that there could be an opportunity to find some diamonds in the rough.

 

This is especially true for large cap companies such as Orsted and Vestas which have limited revenue exposure to the U.S. That said, we do not advise catching a falling knife; investors should take their tim and wait until a sufficient troughing phase has occurred before bargain hunting. If and when the new President becomes more lenient toward the need to build up the grid using clean energy, then that should be clear re-entry signal for investors.

The first commercial flight, connecting two Floridian cities, celebrated its 110th anniversary this year. Since that milestone, the aviation industry has grown at a wicked pace and has become an integral part of our global economy. However, despite its expansion and economic significance, the industry has historically struggled with profitability, often facing high operational costs and tight margins and comes with significant environmental consequences.

Although global aviation is often cited as responsible for “only” 2.5% of worldwide emissions, it is the world’s wealthiest that account for 90% of emissions from air travel. And most of the air travel occurs between high and upper-middle-income countries, where alternative, lower-emission travel infrastructure is widely available (e.g. train, bus, etc.).  

The map below illustrates the concentration of per capita CO₂ emissions from domestic flights, pinpointing the countries where domestic air travel is (too) common: the U.S., Australia, Norway, New Zealand and Canada, all high-income countries. Though some of these countries are large, the travellers do have alternative options to hopping on a plane.

Indeed, air travel is sometimes necessary, but short distance flights as shown in the table below are by far the most CO₂ intensive option.

Despite this emission burden, air travel remains extremely popular. The number of flights performed annually has nearly doubled over the past twenty years, contracting only during the COVID years.  The International Air Transport Association (IATA) forecasts that air travel will double again by 2040. It goes without saying that the concurrent carbon emissions would be disastrous for efforts to mitigate climate change.

As awareness about the air travel’s emissions grows, it is perhaps not surprising that forty of the largest airlines have committed to some form of emission reduction, with 29 pledging to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050. Unfortunately, progress has been minimal. Eight airlines had pledged to submit a net-zero target for validation by the Science-Based Target initiative (SBTi), but only Delta Air Lines remains committed, likely because its target is yet to be validated while all others have missed their deadlines, essentially invalidating the process.

Boarding the Eco-Friendly Class: No One’s At the Gate

In 2021, The International Air Transport Association (IATA), representing over 330 airlines and 80% of global air traffic, approved a resolution for the global air transport industry to achieve net-zero carbon emissions by 2050. Its strategy towards net-zero emissions is based on a combination of technologies, highlighted in the chart below.  

 

We are extremely suspicious of the plan: Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF), hydrogen, and electric planes face extreme technological, cost, and scaling obstacles. Even if SAF really can reduce up to 80% of emissions compared to traditional jet fuel, in 2023, it only amounted to 0.2% of all aviation fuel available. Additional strategies, such as upgrading air traffic management and carbon capture, are costly and slow to implement, while offsets remain controversial as they don’t reduce direct aviation emissions. Many airlines have faced accusations of 'greenwashing,' because none have been able to substantiate their claims of being a truly sustainable mode of transportation.

In sum, none of the global airline carriers have been able to set themselves apart from the competition as leaders in low-emission air travel. This highlights the need for regulatory action.

The table below summarizes the key regulation that is in play in critical jurisdictions, aimed at curbing short haul flights in regions where other forms of travel are possible and/or desirable (i.e. mostly in Europe). In this sense, regulation has some potential to penalize short-haul, low-cost carriers, albeit so far, the evidence that this is working is weak.

 

Flying Through Operational Storms

While we found little to distinguish leaders from laggards based on airlines’ carbon reduction plans, there are nonetheless wide gaps when taking account of broader sustainability issues for airline companies. According to SASB, there are four material topics for the airlines industry: GHG emissions, labor practices, competitive behavior, and critical incident risk management. Indeed, controversies have often arisen in these areas, impacting public perception and operational stability (see the table below).

No clear leaders emerge, as these issues are widespread within the industry, underscoring the sector’s difficulty in upholding consistent standards.
 

Landing Lights: Charting Sustainability Leaders and Laggards

Focusing on material issues and being careful to consider controversies in these areas does prove instructive for deciphering airline leaders vs. laggards. The table below is the output of our analysis of the forty largest publicly listed airline companies. We use our proprietary materiality ranking, that relies on CSRHub scores for relevant topics only, i.e. those related to emissions, labor, ethics and risk management.

 We then retain those companies with CSR hub adjusted scores in the 70th percentile as potential long candidates and those with adjusted scores below the 60th percentile as potential shorts. We also remove any companies from our potential winner list with material controversies.

Except for Alaska Air and EasyJet, all of the long candidates are full-service airline companies, while the bulk of the short candidates are short haul, discount carriers or private jet companies.

A Long/Short Approach

The passenger airline industry is notoriously difficult for equity investors to navigate. Despite being very sensitive to economic cycles, airline stocks routinely underperform in pro-cyclical environments. The industry is capital intensive, labor intensive and largely a commodity-type business whereby passengers are very price conscious. The chart below shows the historical performance of select U.S. airlines (the top ten holdings of U.S. Global Jets ETF are U.S. holdings) over the past nine years; even ignoring the disastrous COVID period, U.S. airlines have only rare bouts of market outperformance and have failed to keep pace with benchmark returns since COVID.

We find no compelling argument to overweight airline stocks from neither a sustainability nor a performance perspective. Therefore, investors should look to opportunistically short sustainability laggards, or at best, explore pair trades between leaders and laggards.

One of the most important metrics for the airline industry is the load factor (i.e. the capacity utilization).  This is measured as Revenue Passenger Miles (RPM) divided by Available Seat Miles (ASM). This ratio represents the number of paying passengers flown one mile divided by the total number of seats (whether occupied or empty) flown one mile. This metric shows how efficiently an airline fills its seats. When load factors are high (i.e. above 80%), the demand for seats is high enough to favour pricing and profitability. Conversely, when load factors are low (below 80%), airplanes fly with more empty seats than is optimal.

In general, low-cost airlines – which tend to provide only short and medium haul flights - need a higher load factor to stay profitable, since, by offering lower prices, they need to sell more seats. Full-service airlines, which tend to offer a mix of short, medium and long-haul flights can be profitable at a lower load factor since each seat generates more revenue (there are very low marginal costs associated with each additional passenger).

In the chart below, we show that since 2019, full-service U.S. airlines have had a higher load factor than low-cost carriers. In other words, they have higher utilization rates at higher ticket prices.  Indeed, in the post-pandemic period, full-service U.S. carriers have eked out higher operating profits than their discount peers.

Some pundits expect this to change, arguing overcapacity issues that have plagued the industry since 2020 may now be behind us. We remain skeptical, since any slowdown in economic activity would once again curb demand forcing carriers to lower prices at the expense of margins.

The 2024 U.S. election has been heavy on drama including failed assassination attempts on Donald Trump and Joe Biden dramatically exiting the presidential race in favor of Kamala Harris. The counterweight of this drama has been the light policy content on the campaign trail. Nonetheless, the table below highlights the main policy differences between Republicans and Democrats, but most importantly, their areas of agreement.

 

Trade Barriers

A big area of contention between the two candidates is trade, with Trump purporting that tariffs are a great source of revenue for the government while Harris wants to focus on good relations with allies. Both prefer to be tough on China. The chart below shows that the United States is still a country with relatively low trade barriers compared to China (a low number indicates more free trade). Starting from such a position, the United States could continue to reduce access to its market.

 

No Fiscal Restraint

Trump and Harris disagree on taxes but neither candidate display much worry about bloated deficits; Trump wants to cut taxes while Harris wants to increase benefits. The chart below highlights the evolution of the budget deficit in the United States since the early 1970’s. As we can see, we are hovering at levels close to the Great Financial Crisis of 2008, but this time, there is no recession in sight. With the ratio of U.S. government debt to GDP over 100%, fiscal proclivity could lead to upward pressure on long-term interest rates.

Environment, Regulation and Infrastructure

There is a wide gulf in environmental policies between the two candidates: Harris wants to continue with Biden’s policies to attack climate change by financially supporting industrial solutions with legislation like the Inflation Reduction Act. Trump wants to “Drill, Baby Drill” and exit the Paris Climate Agreement (again). Regarding regulation, Trump wants to deregulate everything, especially roll back environmental regulations - while Harris looks to maintain the status quo. One area of agreement is that both want to build more in the United States. The chart below shows the extent to which manufacturing facilities’ construction has grown since 2002. Considering the political desire to bring industrial activity (and jobs) back to the United States, and that much of the Inflation Reduction Act dollars still need to be spent, there is a high likelihood that construction in this sector will continue.  

Immigration and Labor

On immigration, Trump wants to build a wall and deport illegal immigrants while Harris also wants to be tougher on immigration. The chart below shows demographic projections from the United Nations under two scenarios: one with average immigration levels and the other with no immigration. The number of people aged 20-65 should continue to grow under the normal scenario but it would fall under the scenario where immigration stops. The implication is that without immigrants, a major productivity impulse is necessary or else wages for labor could skyrocket.

Specifically on labor, Harris favors higher minimum wages, and Trump wants to cut income taxes, but the more pressing question will be to find enough workers to build more in the United States.

Likely Winners

Concentrating our analysis on areas where there is agreement between Trump and Harris - tough on China, favoring domestic production, no fiscal restraint and lower immigration- we found ten companies in three segments that are well-positioned to face this political combination: building, automation and moving things. Importantly, these companies are considered sustainability leaders and should continue to benefit from the U.S. political landscape no matter which party wins the election. The table below shows the ten companies with a brief description of their operations.

Build

Companies involved in building America have outperformed the S&P 500 during the first Trump administration and continued to deliver during the Biden presidency (see the chart below). These companies have all multiplied by a factor of three over the past eight years. They are cyclical and have been more volatile than the index but they have performed exceptionally well, especially right after the 2016 election and after the initial shock of the pandemic. Given that their activities are concentrated in areas of where there is high political agreement between Harris and Trump, their revenues should continue to grow.

 

To gauge their future potential from a political standpoint, we looked at 1) their sales exposure to China, 2) their U.S. sales exposure, and 3) their effective tax rate compared to the Magnificent Seven companies and to the 20 largest companies in global indices. As we can see in the picture below, they are similar in exposure to the U.S. economy: they all have much lower exposure to China sales (their supply chain could be impacted though), much greater exposure to the United States and are currently paying a much higher effective tax rate than the more fiscally mobile large corporations. From this perspective, the outlook seems relatively attractive for those with low exposure to China, high exposure to the United States and a relatively high tax rate that could be reduced.

 

Automate

Next, we looked at automation companies. On average, they have performed very well and outperformed the index, with Eaton Corporation being the big winner with more than a five-fold increase. Similar to building companies, they are strongly exposed to the economic cycle and the Trump election of 2016 was a positive tailwind.

We looked at the same measures as building companies (exposure to China, write out the rest). Automation companies have more diverse exposures than the building companies: Eaton pays low taxes already and Emerson Electric has 11% sales exposure to China. In general, they are better positioned than the Mag 7 and other large cap companies, but it is not as clear cut as the other groups.

Move

For companies involved in moving, we looked at Arcbest which is a trucking company and Prologis which is an industrial warehouse company. We also added Deere because they are involved in moving food and dirt. The performance of the three companies was very strong and very volatile, especially Deere, over the last eight years.

 

 

The data we looked at for the movers, as seen in the chart below, shows very little exposure to China, high exposure to the U.S. and relatively higher effective tax rates, except for Prologis which is a real estate investment trust that benefits from special tax treatment. Again, this group is well-positioned to benefit from areas of consensus between Harris and Trump.

Financial Ratios

To complete the analysis, we used four financial ratios to examine aspects of the health of each company: profitability, capital efficiency, valuation and leverage. The chart shows that there is a lot of variability among the different companies. On average, the net margin of 13.4% is slightly higher than the index, the return on assets at 7.5% is slightly lower, the forward price-to-earnings ratio of 22.7 slightly lower and a debt-to-equity ratio of 85% that is lower than the index.

The Sustainable Side of Property Insurance

Hurricanes Helene and Milton reminded us that the enjoyment of physical property should not be taken for granted: insurance seems like a useless expense until you really need it.

The table below highlights how insurance contributes to the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals (SDG).

How Insurance Keeps You Covered

Property insurers are the first line of defense that provide coverage for property damage. To make sure they have enough money when large-scale events occur, their actuaries conservatively calculate the required funds necessary in case of an event and regulators put rules in place for them to hold sufficient capital to support the policies they have issued. They use risk transfer techniques like reinsurance, which takes on a portion of financial risk of policies, generally the worst part, for a fee. They use it to protect against the worst events thereby reducing their capital requirements. This allows them to issue more policies with the same capital and grow their business from their direct contact with clients.

For their part, reinsurers take on the financial effects of the worst events and reinsurers also need to be well-capitalized. Reinsurers’ primary risk management tool is to diversify across insurers. But like insurers, they need to transfer risk to grow. Their tools to further spread their downside risk are catastrophe bonds and retrocession, also known as ‘the reinsurance for reinsurers” which generally comes from other reinsurers looking to diversify their exposure. Catastrophe bonds are standardized contracts issued by reinsurers in financial markets; investors get their capital plus interest at the end of the term if no catastrophic event occurs, as defined in the bond document. But, if something bad happens, they get an amount that is inversely proportional to the extent of the damage which can eliminate all of the expected interest payment and also eat in the capital they invested. In essence, the reinsurers get money up front and the investor takes on the risk of a bad event like a hurricane. All of those lines of defense are critical for the property insurance industry to continue to provide their service to property owners.

The picture below simplistically depicts how property insurance operates starting from the coverage of the property to who ultimately bears the risk to the property. At the property level, the property is insured but there is a deductible and some exceptions that are not insured, so the owner bears some of the risk and the client-facing insurer takes the rest. The client-facing insurer unloads the downside portion of its exposure to reinsurance which unloads the downside portion of its exposure to retrocession or insurance-linked securities.

When Insurers Can No Longer Provide Affordable Coverage

Population size and property values in risk-prone areas have exploded from a combination of older people looking for clement weather and easy access to credit. Insurers can no longer provide coverage at affordable prices in certain regions and governments have stepped in to complement or replace the private sector. The table below highlights places where government has had to step in. It may seem weird that taxpayer money goes to insure new multi-million dollar beach front properties in a high risk-zone such as Florida, but it is a reality. Like most insurance coverage, government-backed schemes use reinsurance as a risk mitigation tool.

Reinsurance to the Rescue

Property reinsurance requires sophisticated modeling and risk management, but it is a relatively simple business from a profitability standpoint: premiums plus investment income fewer claims and expenses determine profitability. The chart below shows the stock performance of a reinsurer index compared to an index of insurance-linked securities; there is a very high correlation between the two. From 2010 to 2017, both were going up, then they based for 5 years during a period of weak pricing power while claims increased. Since the pandemic, both insurers and reinsurers have had solid price performance.

To illustrate further the cyclical nature of the industry, the chart below highlights the insurance-linked securities index, which is a proxy for the profitability of the industry on a year-on-year basis and the property renewal rate index which shows the pricing power of the industry. Pricing power weakens when the industry is most profitable: past performance attracts more capital and this new capital tries to gain new business with lower prices which puts pressure on prices across the industry. As we can see on the chart, renewal rates were at their weakest in 2018 after seven years of strong profitability. A few years of poor profitability from 2018 to 2021, exacerbated by high inflation, resulted in extremely strong pricing power and much better profitability in the past few years.  

Compare insurance, reinsurance and the S&P 500 Index, reinsurance has been one of the few subsectors that have nearly matched the strong performance of the S&P 500. We can also see a significant fall in price at the start of the pandemic for reinsurers because they also cover extreme mortality events on top of property insurance. The risk for reinsurers at the onset of the pandemic was excess mortality from COVID which turned out to be less than originally feared. During the pandemic, reinsurers’ stock price fell much more than insurers when confronted with a potentially large event because they take on the extreme downside risk.

Insurance in a Changing Climate

The growing frequency and severity of climate-related events, such as floods, wildfires, hurricanes, and other natural disasters, has forced insurers to reevaluate their business models and adapt to manage rising risks and ensure long-term sustainability. Some of the techniques involved in doing this include:  

On the regulatory side, many jurisdictions are imposing stricter environmental and climate-related disclosures that insurers have to deal with.

An Overview of Key Reinsurance Companies

For the purpose of this note, we look at reinsurers with significant portions of their business in the Property and Casualty (P&C) segment. We concentrate our efforts on six public companies with more than 30% of their revenues originating from P&C reinsurance. Renaissance Re is the purest play while Scor has the lowest exposure.

Reinsurance Leaders

In general, reinsurers have improved their financial performance: strong pricing power and decent claim experiences have been the drivers. Nonetheless, as the price chart below highlights, there are discrepancies amongst the companies. Arch Capital has rewarded its shareholders the best and Scor, has performed the worst.

There are a few important reasons behind the diverging performance of these companies, including growth, risk management, claims experience, expense control and balance sheet management. The table below highlights how each company has performed along these vectors.

To further illustrate the gap in financial performance between companies, the chart below highlights the return on tangible equity for each company. There is a strong link between this measure and stock performance. SCOR is at the bottom just like its stock performance.