Globalization has been challenged by a series of systemic shocks: the COVID-19 pandemic exposed supply chain fragility, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine reignited geopolitical risk in Europe, and rising tensions between the West and China have turned strategic dependencies into security liabilities. In response, governments across advanced and emerging economies are reorienting their industrial strategies by prioritizing defense preparedness, energy resilience, and industrial sovereignty. This includes reshoring critical manufacturing, securing supplies of key technologies and materials, investing in clean energy capacity, and generally improving domestic capabilities in a variety of economic sectors. “Just-in-case economics” that favors resiliency, redundancy, and sovereignty have become the consensus; Donald Trump may be isolated in style on the global stage, but the mood has shifted towards his kind of self-centered policies.

 

Defense, Energy Resilience and Industrial Sovereignty

Three areas are especially ripe for change over the next decade: defense, energy and industrial production. Starting with defense, the chart below shows projections on spending as a percentage of GDP in 2035 compared to 2025 for the fifteen largest defense spenders in the world. Countries that spend a lot already (Ukraine, Russia, Israel, Saudi Arabia) are scheduled to maintain big defense budgets, while those that have historically spent little, i.e., were strong believers that globalization would eliminate conflicts (most NATO members), have committed to increase their defense budget to 3.5% of GDP by 2035. That increase is also accompanied by an extra 1.5% towards defense-adjacent sectors like infrastructure. In other words, the largest marginal investments are likely to originate from NATO countries.

In terms of energy resilience, many governments are demonstrating an urgent commitment to energy resilience, driven by the strategic need to safeguard national interests. For example, the war in Ukraine exposed Europe’s deep reliance on foreign energy, prompting an aggressive shift towards securing alternative supply routes, expanding domestic production, and reinforcing storage infrastructure. The U.S. has also taken major steps to strengthen its energy independence by supporting domestic oil and gas production and modernizing the electric grid. China is investing heavily in long-term energy security through solar, wind and coal capacity, nuclear power, and strategic stockpiling, while also controlling key upstream inputs like critical minerals and refining capacity. India is working to stabilize its energy mix by expanding domestic coal output, developing infrastructure for energy transport, and reducing exposure to global fuel price swings. Canada is also adapting its strategy by emphasizing reliability and capacity building across its oil, gas, and electricity networks. There is a clear trend towards reasserting control over national energy systems as energy resilience becomes a pillar of national security.

The chart below shows the major economies in terms of energy dependency. Countries where energy resilience is most critical are in red and include the EU, South Korea and Japan.

Finally, in terms of manufacturing, countries with persistent account deficits, deindustrialized regions, and hollowed-out middle classes are those that are most likely to prioritize reshoring. Concretely, many governments are now pursuing industrial and trade policies that aim to rebuild domestic manufacturing capacity, reduce reliance on foreign suppliers, and anchor critical supply chains. In the U.S., Joe Biden attempted to use “carrots” by introducing supply side legislation) such as the CHIPS and Science Act and the Inflation Reduction Act. Trump has the same objective but is using sticks (i.e., tariffs). In the EU, the Green Deal Industrial Plan and the EU Chips Act are designed to lessen dependencies on foreign entities.

The chart below shows the countries that import more than they export (in red) and thus have the greatest incentives to reindustrialize.

Now, that we have made the case for defense, energy and the industrial sector to be favored by government policies, let’s look at investment thematics that will benefit from it.

 

From Defense Preparedness to Space-Defense and Shipbuilding Investments

Countries with renewed focus on defense are investing in a range of strategies. For example, the U.S. hopes to expand capabilities in space and cyber domains, India is accelerating in military modernization, Saudi Arabia and the UAE are choosing to heavily invest in drones, missile defense, and naval platforms. While each country may have a particular focus, the common thread is clear: a multi-domain buildup across land, sea, air, cyber, and space is underpinning defense spending.

In recent months, we have written about defense-related stocks that are poised to continue to benefit from increased military spending. However, one related and perhaps overlooked sector is shipbuilding.

Maritime power in armed conflict is critical and as the chart below shows, China is the dominant power in building ships, with South Korea and Japan, the only other significant builders. It is perhaps no surprise that the U.S. is now attempting to revitalize its shipbuilding industry through legislative measures like the SHIPS for America Act and financial incentives such as the Maritime Security Trust Fund. These efforts will take time but the aim to enhance national security and reduce reliance on foreign vessels should support companies involved in building ships on U.S. soil.

In the table below, we list our favored companies that will benefit from a growing defense sector and present superior sustainability characteristics.

We also highlight below the relevant financial ratios for these companies. As we can see, some future growth has already been factored into their valuation metrics. That said, we expect the strong tailwinds detailed above to remain in place, creating further room for appreciation.

From Energy Resilience to Grid, Nuclear, Geothermal, Energy Storage Investments

Achieving domestic energy resilience and independence often favors renewable and nuclear energy strategies since these energy sources are less dependent on the geological endowments of a particular nation. That said, grid reliability becomes an increasing priority in countries that prioritize electrification. Along with investments in the grid, advancing energy storage technologies is crucial for managing energy variability.

In the table below, we list companies that are best placed to benefit from dual supports of growing energy resilience and sustainability.

Relevant financial ratios are presented below. Growth has been relatively strong recently and we should expect it to get stronger in the next decade.

From Industrial Sovereignty to Critical Minerals, Water, Waste, AI, Quantum and Automation

Industrial sovereignty is driving investments in critical sectors such as minerals, water, waste management, AI, quantum computing, and automation. We have written in detail about the various companies that are best positioned to benefit from a reshoring revival in past research (see notes highlighted at the top of this document) and a summary is provided in the table below.

Many of these companies have already seen a significant increase in valuations as this theme picks up steam, though we remain convinced that conditions will remain in place for further gains.

China is a dominant player in several technologies that are key to the energy transition. This should make it an appealing opportunity for sustainability-minded investors, but that appeal is offset by persistent human rights and environmental issues, not to mention a heavy-handed government. Despite its critical role in the production of solar panels, EVs and battery materials, many investors have deemed China uninvestable. In this note, we explore whether Chinese green tech companies present a viable sustainable investment opportunity.

China is a Green Giant…

Our past notes on the Energy Transition theme have acknowledged China’s role in critical green technologies (The Range of the EV Battery Trade, May 25, 2023; China’s Solar Power and Deglobalization: An Irresistible Force Paradox, March 9, 2023 and China will Single-handedly Pick the Next EV Winner, March 4, 2021). The nation is difficult to ignore when it comes to investing in green tech, providing a significant majority of the manufacturing capacity for Solar PV, batteries, technology and EVs as well as mining and processing of rare earths. In 2024, clean energy-related sectors accounted for 10% of China’s GDP and 25% of its growth.

Supportive industrial policy has fueled the growth of Chinese companies in these industries. And while similar “carrot” approaches for green tech industries have existed in Europe and the U.S. matching China’s cost competitiveness is a huge challenge; the nation’s ability to manufacture products cheaply often relies on compromises in labor and environmental standards. In other words, China’s low costs carry hidden costs.

… With Lots of Red Flags

For one, Chinese manufacturing relies on a lot of coal. China leads global coal consumption. The amount of coal used continues to rise year after year, with industry accounting for a large share of demand, around 75%. Unsurprisingly, China is the world’s largest carbon emitter in absolute terms. While per capita emissions are lower than those of developed countries, its carbon intensity measured per unit of GDP remains significantly higher (see chart below). Water pollution and air quality concerns also persist, though government efforts to improve in these areas have delivered some progress.

In addition, China has a poor record on human rights, especially in its manufacturing sector. Despite efforts by the U.S. and the EU to ban imports of goods that relied on forced Uyghur labor from Xinjiang, recent evidence suggests such practices are still occurring. These methods seem hard to shake; even in Brazil, EV powerhouse BYD has been accused of “slave-like” labor conditions in the construction of its first EV factory outside of Asia. Cheap labor is a major factor in China’s cost competitiveness in manufactured goods.

Finally, on governance, many Chinese companies face challenges including significant state ownership, which further contributes to an already elevated level of regulatory unpredictability/influence (see note: Chinese Capitalism’s Long March, September 30, 2021). Companies show limited transparency and corporate social responsibility reporting is less robust than global peers, though efforts are  being made to improve. Enforcement of shareholder rights is also considered weak.

In sum, the environmental, social and governance practices in China mean that the environment in which Chinese companies operate make it difficult for them to meet the SMS requirements for responsible investment using a Double Materiality framework: positive impact of green tech products is offset by poor governance, labor concerns and environmental practices. For these reasons, China remains a conundrum for sustainability-focused investors.

A Best-in-Class Approach to China

For instances when a product or service’s positive impact might be undermined by poor operational practices (mining is another example of this), a sustainability best-in-class approach is often the most appropriate way to assess opportunities. This consists of screening the companies within a given industry to find those with the highest operational performance and no recent controversies.

In the case of Chinese green tech companies, we focus on those having significant revenue (>30%) in industries that support the energy transition: renewable energy products (wind and solar), EVs and battery technology. While China also dominates in the processing of materials critical to the transition, the complexity of assessing a controversial industry within a controversial region merits a separate analysis. Alternatives to Chinese Rare Earth Elements companies were discussed in two recent notes: Critical Minerals, Critical Moves: The Scramble for Rare Earth Metals, May 8, 2025 and Macro Meets Sustainability: The Outlook for Q3 and Beyond, June 19, 2025.

Our screening process excludes companies with a market cap below $5 billion USD; as larger companies are more likely to be traded on international exchanges (Hong Kong or U.S.) and therefore to have greater transparency. To identify best-in-class, we look for low level of controversies, strong ESG-materiality scores and in the case of China, add a particular focus on transparency scores. The tables below present the results for renewable energy equipment manufacturers and EV and battery-makers.

1- Renewable Equipment Manufacturers

Chinese wind equipment manufacturers leave much to be desired: two have high controversy levels, and the third ranks below the 50th percentile on key sustainability metrics. Both CRRC and Goldwind are also over 50% state owned.  

Among solar companies, the two largest stand out for their scores: LONGI Green Energy Technology and Sungrow Power Supply. Jiangsu also has good scores and a low controversy level, and although only 15% of its revenues are from solar, the remainder are tied to grid efficiency, another key transition enabler.

2- EV and Battery-Makers

Among the EV and battery-makers, there are more large cap companies with over $10 billion USD in market cap. Still, only Li Auto and XPeng have sufficient materiality scores and low controversy levels. EVE offers a similar ESG profile among the battery producers. While CATL and Gangfeng have strong scores, they have higher controversy levels.

Overall, few companies meet the mark for best-in-class. Only 3 of the 23 Chinese companies identified across the four segments exhibit both low controversy levels and Materiality scores above the 65th percentile (Jiangsu is included if we lower the threshold to 60th percentile). Transparency scores are especially weak. Moreover, passing the sustainability screen is only one part of the story – macroeconomic pressures and geopolitical tensions further complicate the investment case for China.

Beyond the Green Screen

With its lofty decarbonization goals, China is a key market for green tech; actually, the world’s largest for EVs, solar and batteries. Domestic companies can benefit from national policy support, but they also face significant challenges if this support were to cease. And despite the global urgency for green tech deployment, most of the companies we examined exhibit a very high concentration of sales in China, making them vulnerable to a Chinese economic slowdown.

China’s economy has struggled following strict pandemic lockdowns and lingering effects of the property crisis. Long-term, there are significant demographic headwinds given the nation’s aging population. Despite stimulus efforts, there are concerns about the Chinese consumer. This is particularly problematic for EV makers, most of whom generate the bulk of their sales in China. And with an ongoing trade war, it is unlikely that an increase in exports will materialize to offset weaker consumption at home.

There appear to be few bright spots for Chinese green tech segments. With the exception of EVs, each Energy Transition segment has underperformed Chinese equities in the past two years. A significant negative divergence from the broader Chinese market has occurred especially in the past month for EVs, Solar and batteries.

Despite their scale, both the EV and solar industries are suffering from supply gluts characterised by a race to the bottom pricing. This leaves batteries and wind as potential alternatives for investors seeking green tech opportunities; however, Chinese firms face stiffer international competition in these areas. The wind industry has its own set of challenges, but alternatives to Chinese wind turbine suppliers do exist. For battery-makers, South Korean companies are competitive and well-positioned to benefit from more favorable trade terms with Western governments (see Seoul Mates: The Case for Korean Sustainability Plays, May 1, 2025). Even when extending the focus to grid efficiency plays – an increasingly important area of the energy transition (see From Solar Panels to Control Panels: Why It’s Time to Focus on the Grid, May 22, 2025), a number of quality companies exist in Europe and the U.S.

In short, given China’s woes (both sustainable and economic), we reiterate our conviction that investors will be better served looking at Energy Transition plays in other countries that have built friendlier trade relations.   

Since our last Macro Meets Sustainability update (March 20th), the equity market has been climbing a wall of worry. The S&P 500 has recovered all the losses of “Liberation Day” and has increased 6 %, despite several economically threatening events in the past three months: the Big Beautiful Bill passed the House (summarily wiping out fiscal support to green initiatives in Biden’s Inflation Reduction Act); Middle East conflicts have once again escalated (though oil prices have stayed somewhat muted); major crackdowns in U.S. immigration have shocked international observers (and created a never-seen-before shortage in agricultural workers), tariffs have been threatened, imposed, lifted…and in some cases re-imposed (earning Donald Trump the nickname TACO).

In today’s Note, we evaluate the potential for equity markets to continue climbing a wall of worry and articulate where we expect the biggest risks and opportunities lie within sustainable themes.

Global Growth Divergences: More Europe, Less U.S.

According to the OECD’s most recent projections, the global economy will grow at 2.9% in 2025, just a smidgen slower than last year. If the OECD is correct, this level of growth would mark an incredible feat given all the events listed above that have the potential to throw growth off-course. But what makes the forecast even more interesting is that these projections mask important regional divergences, and ones that are at odds with recent equity performance.

To the extent that equity market performance is a reflection of expected regional growth prospects, euro area large cap stock returns have outpaced those of the U.S. in 2025, albeit the U.S. has out-delivered relative to the euro area so far in Q2.  

 

However, the OECD is forecasting weakening in economic prospects in the U.S. (and Canada) and China: U.S. growth was revised down to 1.6% in 2025. In the euro area, growth is forecast to accelerate over the next two years according to the OECD.

These forecasts are bearing out in the “surprises” data. The economic surprise index measures whether economic data points are better or worse than expected (a positive index number indicates the data is stronger than expected). The chart below shows that European economic news has been performing better than pundits had expected, while the opposite is true in the U.S. data.

From a policy perspective, we expect the euro area has more tailwinds than the U.S. Note that the U.S.’ Big Beautiful Bill (which was passed in the House) is expected to add a mere 0.2% to GDP in 2025 and 2026, and is expected to be a drag on growth in the long term due to significantly higher Treasury borrowing costs. Meanwhile in Europe, a major green light was given to member States earlier this month; the National Escape Clause (NEC) allows member States to temporarily deviate from their endorsed net expenditure paths to boost defence financing. No less than sixteen countries asked the Commission to implement this mechanism. Increased (defense) spending will be a tailwind to European growth in coming years.

The implication is that if these projections for regional growth materialize, then the recent outperformance of U.S. equities is likely to be short-lived. Note that our base case – as outlined in our previous macro update – is that the effective U.S. tariff rate climbs to 10% (from about 2% in 2024). As highlighted below, recent negotiations between China and the U.S. reinforce our position.

 

Tariff Strategy: China Found the U.S.’ Achilles Heel

U.S.-instigated tariffs continue to offer a cloud of uncertainty for equity investors and have earned Trump the TACO moniker (Trump Always Chickens Out). While the name may be cute, we expect that the situation is less about “chickening out” and more about finding out the true pain points of trade in the U.S. economy.

One particularly sore spot is rare earth metals. In retaliation to Trump’s tariffs, China imposed an export ban on rare earth metals in early April. It took only six weeks before the U.S. cried “uncle” and removed the 115% sweeping tariffs on China in exchange for removing the export ban.

 

 

 

 

Although the export ban has been temporarily lifted for 90 days, we stand by the conclusions in our May 7th note on the subject; countries around the world will prioritize establishing non-Chinese rare earth metals sources. Currently, there are only a handful of companies that have processing capacity outside of China. All of these stand to benefit from the wake-up call that the rest of the world’s dependency on China is extreme. Recent corporate announcements buoy this view:

Along with rare earth metals, copper is also on our radar due to similar, albeit less extreme, supply dynamics. It is no secret that China has been trying to build a dominant global position in copper processing. To do this, China currently offers negative smelter fees in order to obtain enough copper concentrate to run its copper processing operations. In a market where copper concentrate supply is tight, the overall impact is that rival smelters outside of China struggle to compete. A case in point: in March, Glencore halted smelter operations in Philippines, citing increasingly challenging market conditions. The implication is that while copper mining remains geographically diversified, the processing of copper is becoming increasingly a Chinese affair.

 

We are both short-term and long-term bulls on copper. The long-term story for copper is well understood; electrification is driving a once-in-a-generation surge in copper demand at a time when the mining industry has underinvested. In the short-term, tariffs have put upward pressure on copper prices (alongside China’s negative smelter fees) as “hoarding” behavior has occurred. Although U.S. recession risks are a headwind for copper prices, we nonetheless expect that supply/demand dynamics will be such that 4.50 USD/lb will hold as the new floor.

Our preferred copper strategy is a mix of owning best-in-class for sustainability and recyclers. Since mining is inherently a dirty business, it is imperative to own companies with the highest ‘all-in sustaining cost’ (AISC). The AISC includes not only direct mining and processing costs (labor, energy, etc.) and royalties but also other expenses like site rehabilitation at the end of the mine life. Mines with a lower AISC are generally the most profitable; those with high all-in sustaining costs are properties that are most likely to adhere to only the lowest acceptable environmental and social standards.

Oil & Geopolitics: A Break-down in Relationships

At the time of writing, Israel was on its fifth day of offense in Iran; Trump was singing the praises of Putin at the G7 summit in Canada, and; European countries are scrambling to increase military capacity. Most of the geopolitical risk indicators traditionally monitored by investors reflect this uncertain world, with one major exception: oil prices. Below, we review the recent behavior of risk bellwethers:

Gold prices and : gold is making new all-time highs, suggesting some flight-to-safety is at work. Note that the Swiss Franc/USD is also at decade highs and is among the strongest currencies this year.

VIX volatility index: a common measure of equity risk, it has scaled back from its April tariff highs, but is nonetheless in what appears to be a cyclical uptrend since Trump took office.

Economic policy uncertainty index: has blown past all levels reached in previous uncertain times (COVID, the Great Recession, etc.)

Oil prices: sitting in the middle of their 52-week trading range, showing no signs of panic.

Of all of these indicators, we are inclined to heed the message from gold, VIX and the uncertainty index. Historically, oil prices rise in times of war, especially when oil-rich and/or logistically important regions are involved. Thus, it may seem surprising that oil prices have not surged given the current backdrop. However, as we have written in recent notes (“Chill Baby Chill, A Transition Tipping Point” May 28th), the dynamics of fossil fuel energy supply and demand are changing. A supply glut in both natural gas and oil means that fossil fuel prices are comparatively less sensitive to supply disruptions.

For all the promise of a transition to low-carbon energy (and the fear of trillions in stranded fossil fuel assets), it may not be obvious in the aggregate data that much has happened. Against a backdrop of unrelenting increases in total energy demand, the share that has been supplied from renewable sources has hardly been transformative. The chart below shows the world’s energy mix in 2010 vs 2023: oil and coal accounted for 61% of total energy in 2010. Thirteen years later, 57% of the world’s energy supply remain oil and coal.  

But since transitions are never linear, it is not a useful exercise to extrapolate the current pace of transition to suggest a date in the future whereby our reliance on fossil fuels is negligible. Indeed, almost all successful technological transformations have followed an S-curve, which begin with a period of exponential growth, followed by linear growth, then exponentially declining growth before settling at a fixed level. A well-known example of the S-curve is mobile phone adoption (see chart below). Typically, a technological transformation may take several years (decades) to reach between 5 – 10% market share and is often supported by subsidies or other incentives to get them off the ground. Once this threshold is reached, new transformative technologies will then rapidly gain a high market share (i.e. greater than 50%) even in absence of government support, before levelling off.

The S-Curve for Energy Technology

In terms of the energy transition, one example of the S-curve at work is EV sales in Norway. Despite being introduced to Norwegian consumers in the 2000s, electric vehicles only accounted for about 5% of car sales by 2012. Sales penetration really sped up in 2015 and by 2021 over 85% of car sales were electric. The pace of penetration has now clearly slowed, increasing by only 1% between 2022 and 2023.

 

Dying technologies also follow an (inverted) S-curve. For example, coal consumption in the U.S. peaked in 2008 and is charting a textbook trajectory toward collapse. Interestingly, forecasts from respected organizations like the U.S. EIA erroneously made linear projections for the recovery/stabilization of coal power. The 2025 annual report, that projects out to 2050, is the first year that the EIA estimates an S-curve for coal consumption, essentially flat-lining at less than 1% of levels experienced in the 1990s and 2000s. Once the economics of substitutes (e.g. solar) became attractive, the collapse began happening at a faster rate than expected.  

Note that in the case of coal, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the ensuing energy shortage caused a temporary increase in coal demand. Today, despite the ongoing war, coal is experiencing a multi-year supply glut, with prices now at a four-year low. This is despite the U.S. government accusations that coal companies are conspiring with their major shareholders (BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street) to reduce their coal production!

 

U.S. COAL CONSUMPTION IS FOLLOWING AN INVERTED S-CURVE

The S-curve has major implications for coal-related stock prices. There used to be several ways for equity investors to participate in the coal market. However, by 2020 most popular products for gaining exposure to coal were discontinued: the Dow Jones U.S. Coal Index (DJUSCL) and ETFs like KOL (Van Eck), TONS (Wisdom Tree) were all among the dead. Note that a new ETF was launched in early 2024 (ticker COAL) and, not surprisingly for those that predicted an S-curve in coal, has lost 30% of its value since inception and has stagnated at $15M in AUM.

When To Invest…

As the above example shows, understanding where renewable technologies are on the S-curve – rather than making linear extrapolations about adoption – is key to investment timing for long-term investors, both in entering long positions in new technology and also exiting from losing energy assets.

Solar, wind and battery storage are all candidates for hitting the steep positive slope of the S-curve for electricity production. For example, the chart below shows the share of electricity production from solar; at 7% of total electricity production, it is in the range whereby rapid market share gains will be imminent if it is to be a transformative technology.  

But how to we do know if solar will follow the S-curve? To be sure, public policy can speed up (or slow down) the adoption of new technology. In the example regarding EV adoption in Norway, that government put in place an aggressive program of fiscal incentives and practical advantages beginning in the 2000s to kickstart the transition away from ICE vehicles.

A second consideration is connection. In last week’s note, we argued that the major bottleneck for renewable energy deployment is the urgent need to expand and modernize electricity grids. Renewable energy will not realize its potential if it is hampered by unstable, unreliable grids (or if solutions to mitigate intermittency are not deployed). This is, in our view, the largest remaining challenge to rapid, mass deployment of renewable energy strategies.  

In other words, we have already surmounted the most significant hurdle, which is cost. Indeed, a necessary condition of scaling the S-curve is that, in absence of government support, the cost of the new technology must be less than the incumbent. We have written about the relative cost of renewables versus fossil fuels in the past, and it is fast becoming common knowledge that both wind and solar systems for electricity production are now cheaper than fossil fuels. In many ways, a virtuous cycle is already in effect, whereby many renewable technologies are getting cheaper the more they are deployed and will see greater deployment the cheaper they get. Solar panels, wind turbines, and lithium-ion batteries have all declined in cost by over 90% in the past two decades. 

We note that renewable energy stocks hardly reflect this upbeat view relative to fossil fuel companies. First Solar (FSLR), the closest company to a U.S. solar national champion, has declined 20% ytd, and is highly sensitive to tariff and federal policy news. Perhaps too sensitive - after all, the economics of solar suggest that although IRA subsidies provided a nice tailwind, they aren’t crucial to choosing solar over dirty alternatives. Nonetheless, as we wrote in recent research, companies involved in the buildout of the electricity grid, and not the energy producers, offer the most upside in the current environment (please see From Solar Panels to Control Panels: Why It’s Time to Focus on the Grid, May 22, 2025).

…And When To Divest

Many sustainability minded investors will have already divested from fossil fuel stocks years ago, not wanting to be investing in products that are known to be harming the planet. When it comes to coal, this clearly was the right investment decision, since most coal stocks have had a disastrous performance over the past fifteen years as the switch to natural gas and some early renewables were easy “wins” over coal. But the same has not been true for conventional oil and gas: over the past five years, investors in this part of the energy sector have been rewarded with equity gains of over 100%.

However, if we are correct that renewables are ripe to gouge fossil fuel market share, then the risk of stranded assets is no longer tomorrow’s problem.

The most recent wave of significant write-downs in the energy sector occurred in 2020, after a prolonged period of weak oil prices (and a wave of high-profile asset manager commitments to net zero). This makes sense since the underlying commodity price is a key input to oil and gas companies’ asset valuations. At that time, write-downs were on average less than 5% of major oil companies’ assets and were, in most cases, due to a downward revision in long-term expected oil prices (see the table below). Note that in 2020, renewable energy alternatives were far less competitive than they are today, while the breakeven price of oil (i.e. the cost to bring oil out of the ground and bring it to market) has increased over the past five years.  

Indeed, knowing the oil price forecast that a company uses is a key way for investors to estimate how susceptible its assets are to write-downs. This information is not always readily available/disclosed, especially in the U.S. However, among the U.K. and European companies that do disclose this information (Shell, TotalEnergies, BP, Equinor, Repsol), the vast majority have forecasts for oil prices over the next decade to stay above 60 USD/barrel.

Coincidentally, oil prices have been trading at around 60 USD/barrel over the past month and market participants and observers have been systematically revising down oil price forecasts for 2025 and 2026. To be sure, it will take a more prolonged period of weak oil prices before the oil majors make major asset price revisions. However, if we use the 2020 write down cycle as a roadmap, it is most likely that stock prices will take a significant hit before write-downs (stranded assets) are announced.

Three weeks ago, at 12:33 p.m. CEST on April 28, 2025, the entire Iberian Peninsula was plunged into darkness. Europe’s largest blackout in two decades affected tens of millions of people across Spain and Portugal. Trains screeched to a halt. Planes were grounded. Traffic lights blinked out. Hospitals ran on backup generators. Power wasn’t fully restored for 23 hours, and the economic fallout is estimated at €2.3–4.5 billion.

While a full forensic analysis will take months, we already know the basics: a sudden loss of ~15 GW of generation in southwestern Spain – roughly 60% of the system’s online capacity – triggered a rapid frequency drop to 48.0 Hz. Under-frequency load shedding (UFLS) was automatically deployed in Spain and Portugal, but it wasn’t enough. Within 21 seconds, the overhead lines linking France and Spain were tripped by protection systems. The Iberian grid was isolated – and collapsed.

Anti-renewable pundits were quick to blame the blackout on the intermittent and non-synchronous nature of renewable energy. But as with most complex systems, the reality is more nuanced. As we will explore in this note, renewables should not be singlehandedly blamed for the failure. That said, the pace at which Spain integrated variable renewable energy production relative to the pace of investment in modernizing its grid warrants some scrutiny.

What the Iberian blackout underscores is that grid stability in the modern era is a multifaceted challenge. The event’s implications go far beyond a lack of power; it risks eroding public and investor confidence in the grid’s ability to support the energy transition. The rush by “armchair experts” to blame renewables reveals something deeper: a pressing need for clear, fact-based communication about how grids actually function.

Grids are among the most intricate human systems ever built. Their complexity comes not just from scale, but from their very nature: a network of networks. This makes them difficult to control and predict, especially under stress. In older regions like Europe and North America, grids have evolved into a patchwork of mid-century infrastructure layered with newer technologies – sometimes described anecdotally as a “Frankenstein of 3,000 utility companies held together by duct tape, Windows 98, and prayers”. The system is so fragile that even a small rodent can wreak havoc. In fact, the American Public Power Association maintains a Squirrel Index (TSqI) to track power outages caused by squirrels – the second leading cause of power outages in the U.S. (after weather events).

These fragile systems now face a rising tide of stress. Climate change is triggering more frequent and severe weather events: heatwaves that sag transmission lines, floods and hurricanes that knock out substations, and wildfires that torch entire grid corridors. For example, the U.S. saw major grid disruptions jump from fewer than 20 in 2000 to over 180 in 2020. At the same time, electricity demand is shifting dramatically. The electrification of transportation and heating, along with the explosion of energy-hungry data centers, is creating load shapes and peak demands that legacy infrastructure was never designed to handle. On top of it all, grid digitalization – while offering valuable control and efficiency – has opened up new vulnerabilities to cyber threats, that often target systems with outdated or underdeveloped security protocols.

In the global push to decarbonize, the lion’s share of attention and capital has gone toward replacing fossil fuel generation with wind and solar. That’s a worthy goal. And to be sure, a gleaming offshore wind farm is a far sexier photo op than a synchronous condenser buried in a substation; politicians and investors have gravitated toward the optics of generation, not the plumbing of grid transmission. As a result, investment has skewed heavily toward supply, while the grid itself remains chronically underfunded.

Figuratively speaking, we are replacing coal-powered steam locomotives with shinny high-speed bullet trains – while still running them on 19th-century tracks. The result is a sleek, modern fleet of renewable generation that risks derailing on fragile infrastructure. It’s time to reframe the energy transition: before renewables can finish the race, grids need to be brought up to speed.

According to BloombergNEF, annual investments in renewable energy generation are expected to plateau around 2028, while spending on power grid expansion and modernization will continue to grow until 2040. By that point, grid investment will have tripled compared to 2020 levels.

As Winston Churchill famously said, “Never let a good crisis go to waste.” In that spirit, this note outlines solutions to two of the main structural weaknesses revealed by the Iberian blackout: the loss of natural grid inertia due to the replacement of conventional power plants with renewables, and the insufficient interconnectivity of national grids.

We also recognize the critical role of energy storage in enhancing grid stability and flexibility. However, as we’ve covered that sector in detail in our November 28, 2024 note, What’s In Store for Energy Storage?, we refer readers to that publication for a deeper dive.

 

Grid Inertia: Some Moving Technologies

Traditional power plants – coal, gas, nuclear, and hydro – contribute rotating mass that provides mechanical inertia, helping to stabilize grid frequency and absorb shocks from sudden imbalances. At the time of the Iberian outage, solar generation was dominating supply: 59% of electricity came from solar, or a total of 71% from renewables if wind is included. In contrast, nuclear and gas provided just 11% and 5%, respectively. With such low conventional output, the grid’s natural inertia was limited.

When inertia is low, even routine disturbances can result in sharp frequency swings. These rapid changes can trip protection systems across generation fleets, cascading into larger failures – as likely happened here.

Some countries, like Germany, are planning to build gas-fired plants as a backup to renewables, in part to provide mechanical inertia. But technology already offers cleaner alternatives. Solutions like grid-forming inverters and synchronous condensers can deliver synthetic inertia – fast, controllable responses that mimic the stabilizing role of spinning turbines.

Leading manufacturers of these technologies include Siemens Energy (ENR-DE), GE Vernova (GEV-US), and Eaton (ETN-US). All are well-positioned to benefit from the surge in demand for grid stability solutions as renewables take center stage.

Grid Interconnectivity: Stronger Together

Another top priority is reinforcing transmission links – both within countries and across borders. Stronger interconnections allow power to flow more flexibly, enabling regions to support each other during imbalances and preventing isolated grid collapses. This means building new high-voltage transmission lines, especially HVDC (high-voltage direct current) systems, which are more efficient for long-distance electricity transport and better suited for integrating large-scale renewable projects.

Europe is now actively evaluating new cross-border projects to boost Spain–France transfer capacity, which currently sits at a meager 3% of Spain’s peak demand – far below the EU’s recommended minimum of 15%. This bottleneck played a key role in the Iberian blackout.

Once again, HVDC system manufacturers like Siemens Energy and GE Vernova are at the center of the solution. But equally important are the companies that actually build the infrastructure.

Two standouts on either side of the Atlantic are Quanta Services (PWR-US) and SPIE Group (SPIE-FR). While not equipment manufacturers, they are critical EPC (engineering, procurement, and construction) partners for large HVDC transmission lines and converter station infrastructure. Quanta, for example, is involved in the TransWest Express and Champlain Hudson Power Express – two high-profile HVDC projects in North America. Meanwhile, SPIE has made a series of strategic acquisitions that position it as a continental leader in Europe’s push for HVDC interconnectivity.

For sustainability-minded investors who agree that grid modernization will rapidly climb up the priority list in the wake of the Iberian Peninsula blackout, we recommend a closer look at the companies mentioned above – with one potential exception: GE Vernova (GEV-US). Our hesitation with GE Vernova is threefold:

  1. It trades at a notably higher valuation than its peers;
  2. It remains newly independent, with only one full calendar year under its belt post-spin-off; and
  3. Roughly 70% of its revenue still comes from renewable generation equipment, a segment that could underperform if investor focus shifts decisively toward grid infrastructure.

From a performance standpoint, it has been an electrifying two years for this group of stocks – all have handily outpaced the MSCI World Index. And with a massive wave of grid investment now on the horizon, we believe the ceiling could be even higher.

The United States is deeply unsettled by the prospect of losing its global hegemonic status to China, a shift that challenges its national identity. Since the Second World War, America has been positioned as the world’s economic, technological and military leader, a role intertwined with its sense of exceptionalism. China’s rapid ascent, backed by state-led industrial strategy, expanding global influence, and technological ambition, poses a direct threat to U.S. supremacy.

Countries with current account deficits should find it easier to strike deals with the Trump administration because they have more flexibility in reaching a balanced trade position with the USA, i.e. they can buy stuff from the United States to appease politicians. Trump has repeatedly framed global trade as a zero-sum game, where US deficits equate to losses, and surpluses indicate exploitation. This is how Liberation Day was framed where countries with bilateral deficits with the USA had the minimum 10% tariffs and trade surplus countries had much higher tariffs. In this context, countries that run deficits are less threatening and more likely to be dependable trading partners. Moreover, deficit countries often share concerns about global imbalances and may be more amenable to bilateral arrangements that emphasize domestic industry protection, supply chain re-shoring, and nationalist economic policies. The initial information we have on the trade deal between the United Kingdom and the United States is an example where the UK has essentially given a veto to the US to reject Chinese company purchases. The table below highlights some of the countries that run current account deficits. The first deal announced is with the UK. Discussions with India seem to be advancing. The case of Japan is slightly more complicated because its current deficit account status is highly dependent on the price of commodities since they import most of them. With lower commodity prices, a current account deficit will rapidly swing to a surplus. Initial indications are that Japan will be among the early deals. We added Canada to the list, even if it currently runs a surplus, since Canada, Mexico and the USA will probably modify their current trade deal (USMCA). Canada is the opposite of Japan where low commodity prices can swiftly shift it to a current account deficit country.

Countries with large current account surpluses—such as those in the graph below, are likely to face tougher trade negotiations with the United States because they are seen as benefitting disproportionately from global trade. A surplus implies these countries export significantly more than they import, often into large consumer markets like the U.S. The White House argues that imbalances reflect unfair advantages such as undervalued currencies, protectionist policies, or state support for export-driven sectors. The U.S. will demand concessions like greater market access, reduced subsidies, or currency adjustments and tariff rates greater than the minimum 10% are likely to stay for the countries that run current account surpluses. China and re-routing countries such as Indonesia, Vietnam and Malaysia are the main targets. The European Union may also encounter more difficult negotiations than currently expected, even if it is a historical ally.

 It is clear that pursuing maximum cost efficiency is no longer the main goal of our evolving economic system; the prospects for globalization are dimming. GDP for consumption sake will get replaced by industrial policy where resiliency is more important and how money is spent counts. For example, investments in the US shipbuilding industry are more important than purchases of dolls even if each dollar spent results in the same when measuring economic output.

Biden used carrots to re-industrialize with the Inflation Reduction Act, the Chips Act and the Infrastructure Bill. Trump is using sticks with tariffs and other coercive measures. Earlier this week, China and the United States announced a 90-day truce period to negotiate a comprehensive trade agreement. During the press conference, Scott Bessent, the US Treasury Secretary, confirmed that the United States is seeking strategic decoupling from China. This helped to reduce the temperature of the trade war, but the direction of travel is clear to both sides. Companies have been warned: do not invest in China, bring your supply chain closer to the consumer and create jobs.

When production is closer to major markets, companies can iterate products faster, ensure better quality control, and maintain greater control over labor and environmental standards. While shorter supply chains may raise production costs, it can reduce exposure to supply risks in a transforming World Order. This change signals a broader move away from a purely globalized efficiency model toward one rooted in strategic autonomy and resilience.

In the context of strategic decoupling, we identified 20 sustainable companies from our investment universe, across sectors and investment themes, that are best positioned to thrive in a deglobalizing world, specifically related to the eventual strategic decoupling of the United States from China. 

The table below highlights the 20 companies, their sector, what they do and why they are not affected by the trade conflict.

Next, we examined historical performance over the last 10 years to align with the long perspective of this note. The chart below shows a list of strong performers over the last 10 years in health care (Intuitive Surgical, Vertex and Quest), utilities (Constellation) and energy (Cameco). As we can see, our selection of health care companies have done very well and they remain well-positioned for the upcoming mayhem. Cameco and Constellation Energy are both beneficiaries of the nuclear renaissance.

The following chart shows companies in the same sectors that have some catch up to do. Ormat is a geothermal utility which has not yet benefitted from the same excitement as nuclear but it could come soon since the Trump administration supports geothermal. LKQ is an auto parts recycler and Americold is a cold storage real investment trust which have not been top of mind. Vital Farms is a pasture-raised egg producer that has not yet completely recovered from the pandemic.

The next chart looks at strong performers in technology, industrials and materials. Fortinet and ServiceNow, and even Parker Hannifin benefitted from the strong performance of technology-related companies. Republic Services and Waste Management rode the wave of increased demand and consolidation in waste and recycling.

And finally in the chart below, we look at companies that have lagged in industrials and materials over the last decade. Most of the companies on the chart below were performing very well until recently when the risk of recession increased and engulfed Commercial Metals, First Solar, Freeport, ArcBest and even Packaging Corporation. We believe those companies will benefit from strategic decoupling that will favor local producers and shorter supply chains. Their recent drops in price reflects the risk of a recession emanating from less global commerce. In our view, these companies could reverse higher once/if a recession gets fully reflected in their price.

Lanthanides, or more commonly referred to as rare earth elements (REEs), are a set of 17 silvery-white soft, heavy metals. The interest and insatiable demand for REEs is due to their widespread use in LED monitors, catalytic converters, electric vehicles, X-ray machines, superconductors, military equipment and so much more. In other words, REEs have become integral and unavoidable constituents in today’s economy.

Rare earth metals (REE) are actually very abundant in the Earth’s crust, but the “rare” moniker stuck because minable concentrations are far less common than for most other mineral commodities. They are rarely found in large, concentrated deposits on their own, but rather among other elements. This makes them difficult to mine – and also difficult to process and purify –current production methods require a lot of ore and generate a great deal of harmful waste. Along with the usual environmental degradation associated with mining activities (toxic wastewater, tailings, air pollution, biodiversity loss, etc), processing REEs often also creates radioactive waste. Until very recently, any countries that had allowed mining of REEs on their territory shipped their ore to China for processing and purifying to reduce the negative environmental impacts on domestic soil.

Indeed, it’s becoming well known that China dominates the rare earths market. The country has vast reserves, but most importantly, processes 90% of the world’s REEs.

China’s production dominance of REEs is not arbitrary. Rather, it is a result of calculated efforts beginning in 1990, when the Chinese government declared rare earths as protected and strategic minerals. Other countries became aware of the need for REEs and their reliance on China in 2010;  the Senkaku boat collision incident sparked a diplomatic standoff whereby China drastically reduced critical mineral exports and triggered an unanticipated rise in REE prices. Furthermore, supply chain havoc during the COVID pandemic turbocharged various governments’ plans to diversify REE sources away from China.

It is within this context that President Trump’s government has threatened to purchase Greenland, taunted Canada about becoming a U.S. state, and signed a minerals deal with Ukraine. What all of these countries have in common is their relative abundance of critical resources, especially REEs (resources of rare earths were estimated to include 2.7 million tons in the U.S. versus more than 15 million tons in Canada).

It’s true that one day, the U.S./Ukraine mineral deal could change the global supply dynamics of REEs. However, that day will be far in the future:

Given this backdrop, it is clear that any incremental demand for REEs will be supplied by current producers. Since China has now restricted exports around the world in retaliation for Trump’s tariffs, it stands to reason that any company that can replace Chinese REEs will reap rewards.

Price Outlook

The price of REE mining stocks, like most mining stocks, is positively correlated with the underlying price of the mineral or metal in question: REE mining stocks observe price appreciation when the selling price of REEs rise. Major upswings in REE prices and related company stock prices have previously coincided with Chinese policy (see the Chart below). In 2016, the Chinese government undertook a massive stockpiling of rare earths, purchasing over 10 000 tons of oxides that year. Another significant upswing occurred in 2021, when China further consolidated the industry by forming the China Rare Earth Group, effectively merging several of the biggest state-owned firms and allowing the government to have greater control of output.

Over the past two years, however, REE prices have been weak. This is because demand for REEs slowed primarily due to softer global EV sales and slower Chinese consumption. Existing inventory is slowly being worked off, just as China has announced export restrictions.

Indeed, prices of some rare-earth metals have rebounded sharply since April 4th, when China announced it was clamping down on exports to all nations, a move widely seen as retaliation against Trump’s tariffs on China.

It is impossible to predict how long the export restrictions will stay in place. Nonetheless, given that the  inventory overhang had already been reduced, even if China re-starts exporting, there is a good chance that REE will stay in a cyclical uptrend. However, as demonstrated below, there are only a handful on non-Chinese companies that can capitalize on this dynamic.

Who Can Displace China In REEs?

There are few viable substitutes for REE for the vast majority of current uses and replacing Chinese supply is a tall order, especially if environmental risks are taken into account. Mining is a classic, environmental Wicked Problem, i.e. one whereby the end-use of many products that contain metals offer major improvements in quality of life and are strong enablers of social progress but the mining activity that produces these goods is environmentally destructive and tends to be rife with negative social impacts (i.e. human rights abuses). We wrote about this in detail in a note on October 14, 2021 (Transition Metals: Wicked Problem, Smart Solutions) and the investment approach we outlined then is valid to REE production as well. Indeed, there are two viable strategies for investors that wish to ensure that a vital economic activity affected by wicked problems is carried out in an optimal way: the first is choosing best-in-class companies and the second is supporting companies with recycling activities.

Rare Earth Best-in-Class Is a Challenge

Searching for non-Chinese producers of REEs produces slim pickings, let alone those that have strong environmental, social and governance records. We find only three companies to consider:

MP has a far from stellar sustainability record. The company is in the bottom quartile relative to mining peers when it comes to resource management (according to CSR Hub), and in 2022 there was a class action lawsuit against MP for violating securities laws, alleging an abusive transfer pricing manipulation scheme.

Of these three companies, Neo Performance Materials has been the biggest winner in terms of stock price appreciation since April’s Chinese export restrictions were put in place (see the chart below). This is no doubt because both MP Materials and Lynas Rare Earths are not completely detached from China for processing their ore.

REE Recyling: E-Waste Trash To Treasure

Recovering REEs from electronic waste (i.e. recycling) is appealing from a geopolitical perspective because it gets around the problem of geographical concentration of key resources: recycling companies have no geographic constraints and they also relieve pressure on primary supply (i.e. helps to leave more metals in the ground).

Humans create over 60 million metric tons of e-waste each year, much of it containing rare earth metals that are never recovered (recycling rates of REEs are estimated at under 1%). This makes electronic trash a rich and relatively abundant supply of REEs.

Much like the miners however, there are only a handful of companies that have e-waste REE recovery solutions:

Other REE recycling ventures include Ionic (Ireland), REEcycleinc (US), REETec (Norway), LKAB (Sweden) and Heraeus Remloy (Germany), which are all seeking to extract rare earths from magnets, batteries, mining and other products, but these groups are relatively young and not yet commercially viable.

The global economy stands at an inflection point. Following the sharp escalation of U.S. tariffs in early April, most countries — including allies like South Korea, Japan, and the EU — now find themselves in a strange 90-day negotiation window. This isn’t business as usual; it’s a fork in the road between the good old days of globalization and more fractured, politically-driven, self-centered economies. Shifts like this create potential winners and losers, determined by who is best (and worst) positioned to seize the opportunity to reset their role in a changing world.

While the outcome of the 90-day negotiations with many countries might still fizzle into a nothingburger — much like the USMCA reset with Canada and Mexico in 2018 — the U.S.-China relationship is heading for a hard break. Trump has been blunt: the goal isn’t tweaks around the edges; it’s a take-no-prisoners approach for a full reset of their economic relationship.

That reset is already underway. For the past 25 years, China was the beating heart of global supply chains. Now, companies and capital are being pushed — or pulled — to look elsewhere. Even if tariffs are reduced for allies, the supply chain fracture with China will not simply reverse. In this emerging reality, countries like South Korea, with trusted political ties, advanced manufacturing, and leadership in critical green sectors, could take a much larger role in the global economy. In short, thanks to Korea’s strong industrial base and US-aligned trade relations, the country makes a perfect “friend-shoring” partner.

To be sure, no investment is a slam dunk in the current geopolitical climate. Although Korea could be a relative winner from deglobalization, the country faces structural headwinds that investors must weigh carefully. Demographically, Korea holds the world’s lowest fertility rate — at just 0.72 births per woman in 2024 — putting long-term pressure on domestic consumption and labor supply. Politically, governance risks persist: four of the last six former Korean presidents and one Prime Minister have either been jailed, impeached, or convicted of criminal charges, underlining a volatile political backdrop that periodically spills into corporate affairs.

On the other hand, South Korea’s reaction to the tariff announcement has been cool, calm and collected. They are most likely to have a new deal in place with the US before the tariffs kick in on July 9, 2025.

In addition, while Korea is often viewed as a supply chain alternative to China, the reality is more complicated. Korean industries remain highly dependent on China for critical primary materials — from rare earths to battery metals — leaving them exposed to upstream supply shocks or geopolitical tensions beyond their control. But Korea has seen a lot of foreign investment coming in the last couple decades which put them on a path to becoming a powerhouse in their own right.

Given these realities, selectivity is essential. In this note, we focus on Korean companies that (1) generate a majority of their revenues outside Korea and China, (2) are investing heavily in R&D and supply chain diversification to mitigate input risks, and (3) operate in green sectors that should remain resilient, even amid the growing politicization of sustainability themes. These companies offer the best combination of exposure to global growth, alignment with energy transition trends, and insulation from Korea’s domestic vulnerabilities.

And while Korea’s green leaders have outperformed the KOSPI in recent years, we now need to go a step further: to identify those with real upside left — not because of current macro conditions, but in spite of them.

Seoul Mate #1: Batteries

Korean companies dominate the global battery supply chain outside of China. LG Energy Solution (LGES), Samsung SDI, and the SK Group (SK On and SK ie Technology) – collectively referred to as the “K-battery trio” – together account for roughly a quarter of the world’s EV battery output, supplying automakers across Asia, Europe, and North America. With Chinese battery giants like CATL facing restricted access to the U.S. market, global automakers have increasingly turned to Korean cell suppliers. Several multi-year supply agreements have recently been announced with Ford (SK On), General Motors (LGES via their Ultium JV), Stellantis (Samsung SDI in a JV), and others. In Europe, LGES and Samsung SDI operate large plants in Poland and Hungary, respectively, giving European automakers a non-Chinese source for batteries as well.

However, recent earnings reports from Korea’s major battery manufacturers indicate a cautious short-term outlook, influenced by global trade uncertainties and a temporary deceleration in electric vehicle (EV) demand. LG Energy Solution (LGES) reported a 138% increase in Q1 operating profit, attributed to favorable exchange rates and U.S. tax credits. However, the company anticipates a revenue decline in Q2, citing automakers’ hesitancy due to U.S. tariff policies. In response, LGES plans to reduce its 2025 investments by approximately 30% and has paused construction of its Arizona battery plant, opting instead to accelerate lithium iron phosphate battery production at its Michigan facility to meet growing battery energy storage systems (BESS) demand.

Samsung SDI experienced a significant downturn, with a net loss of 216 billion won in Q1, primarily due to decreased sales in EV batteries, along with lower utilization rates and higher fixed costs. The company also highlighted that upcoming U.S. tariffs are expected to increase production costs for its U.S.-made batteries, as many components are imported.

SK Innovation, the parent company of SK On, reported an unexpected operating loss of 45 billion won in Q1, with losses deepening in its battery segment amid a global economic slowdown. Despite these challenges, SK Innovation expressed cautious optimism for gradual improvement in Q2.

Collectively, these developments signify a strategic pivot among Korean battery manufacturers, with a heightened focus on battery energy storage systems (BESS) to counterbalance the volatility of the EV market. This shift underscores the industry’s adaptability in navigating geopolitical and market challenges.

While competition remains— (Japan’s Panasonic, and emergent players in Europe or U.S.), Korea’s multi-year head start, and massive ongoing investments make it likely the country’s battery champions will retain global leadership. Barring a sudden U.S.-China trade truce that removes all barriers, the structural trend of supply-chain de-Sinicization should keep Korean battery giants on a high-growth trajectory for years to come. True, this positive view is not reflected in the stock performance of Korean battery makers. That said, the repricing of battery stocks is a global phenomenon, as captured by dismal performance of the global battery ETF BATT-US.

 

Seoul Mate #2: Nuclear Energy

South Korea is an often-underappreciated nuclear powerhouse that is now leveraging trade realignments to its advantage. Korea’s state-backed players, led by Korea Electric Power Corp. (KEPCO) and its subsidiaries (KEPCO E&C and KEPCO KPS) plus Doosan Enerbility have decades of nuclear experience. They designed and built the APR-1400 reactors, which have a proven track record domestically and overseas (the UAE’s Barakah plant was delivered by a Korean consortium, marking the first full export of Korean reactor technology).

With global demand for nuclear new-builds on the rise (driven by energy security and decarbonization), there is a lot of room for these Korean firms to export their expertise to other markets.

The Korean government set a formal goal of exporting ten nuclear reactors by 2030, and a dedicated task force now coordinates nuclear export efforts (spanning financing, diplomacy, and technical support).

The large-cap companies positioned here include: KEPCO, which would typically take on operator roles or equity stakes in overseas projects, is the parent of reactor designer KHNP; Doosan Enerbility, the main equipment manufacturer for reactors (pressure vessels, steam generators) and a contractor for construction; and Hyundai Engineering & Construction and Samsung C&T, which bring project management and engineering expertise (the nuclear revenue for these firms is low so we kept them out of the final list).

Beyond traditional reactors, Korea is also investing in advanced nuclear technologies such as small modular reactors (SMRs). Doosan has partnered with U.S.-based NuScale to supply components for SMRs, and several Korean startups/consortia are developing their own SMR designs. The government’s inclusion of nuclear in its green taxonomy and export financing means Korean banks and funds can more easily invest in these projects, which should lower the cost of capital for nuclear projects relative to peers.

Seoul Mate #3: Air and Water Pollution Control Technologies

While high-profile sectors like batteries and nuclear power grab headlines, Korea also hosts leading companies in other environmental technologies. These firms address industrial emissions, waste management, and air/water quality. Trade tensions indirectly benefit this segment too: as China historically exported low-cost environmental equipment (e.g. basic filters, cheap sensors), its reduced global presence creates opportunities for Korean providers, especially in emerging economies looking for reliable partners to improve environmental standards.

One notable player is Samsung E&A, a large-cap engineering firm (part of Samsung Group) that has diversified into environmental projects. It designs and builds flue-gas desulfurization units (to reduce sulfur emissions at power plants), wastewater treatment facilities, and chemical recycling plants worldwide. Samsung Engineering has won contracts in the Middle East and Southeast Asia that might have otherwise gone to Chinese firms. Its revenue from environmental projects has been growing, contributing to improved profitability.

With regards to water, Korean companies have quietly become world leaders in desalination and water purification technologies. Doosan Enerbility (mentioned above) ranks among the top global desalination plant builders. Over the past decades, Doosan delivered dozens of large-scale desalination facilities in the Middle East (Saudi Arabia, UAE, Oman), leveraging its thermal desalination technology. It is now also a leader in reverse osmosis (RO) desal, often partnering with international firms.

Another major player is GS Engineering & Construction, which acquired Spain’s Inima (a water treatment specialist) a decade ago. GS E&C has since expanded in wastewater recycling and seawater desalination, operating plants in Brazil, the Middle East, and North Africa. It positions itself as a global water project developer, not just an EPC contractor, which means recurring revenue from operating concessions. This strategic shift was driven partly by the recognition that Korean firms could move up the value chain in water; historically, Western companies like Veolia won operating concessions, while Korean firms were subcontractors. Now, with more competitive financing and support, GS E&C and others can take on full project roles.

Top Picks

From a market standpoint, many of these Korean stocks have rerated upward in 2025 as investors recognize the dual themes of deglobalization beneficiary and sustainability play. Yet valuations in Korea often remain below global peers, partly due to the historical “Korea discount.”

There is room for further upside if companies continue to execute and if corporate governance reforms attract a broader investor base. For sustainability-minded investors, Korea offers a unique sweet spot: exposure to critical green technologies without the geopolitical baggage of China at reasonable valuations relative to U.S. or European pure-plays in these areas.

Based on their strong market positions and superior alignment with our selection criteria, our top three picks are: Samsung E&A (air and water treatment), Doosan Enerbility (nuclear and water infrastructure), and LG Energy Solution (batteries and energy storage).

Events of the past week have left market pundits, economists and geopolitical strategists in both shock and awe in the face of U.S. trade policy and more generally, about the country’s overall policymaking process (or lack of thereof). Although the main target of the U.S.’ trade war is China (please see last week’s note), the collateral damage is far and wide.

Indeed, the endgame for the U.S. is to repatriate manufacturing to domestic soil and diffuse the threat that China could replace the U.S. as the world’s hegemon. However, success is not guaranteed, and the unwinding of the current trade regime will come at a significant cost to corporate profitability. The chart below shows U.S. profits as a share of GDP over the long-term. In 2001, China’s entry into the World Trade Organization meant that American businesses could take advantage of cheap labor and lax environmental standards: as a result, profits as a share of GDP went from a structural low of 7% in 2000 to a multi-decade high of 18% just before the global pandemic. The aggressive tariffs in place since March are meant to be sufficiently punitive to drive production back on American soil, which also means that the U.S. economy is about to stop profiting from lower production costs elsewhere. While profits as a percentage of GDP in the U.S. are now close to their World War II highs, it seems implicit that corporate profitability will decline given Trump’s tariffs policy and the uncertainty that it has created.

In this context, investors ought to pick tariff-winning companies, i.e., those companies that already produce locally or those that are offered carve-outs and/or can effectively onshore their activities to avoid the profit margin squeeze.

Interestingly, the current environment holds several parallels to what we experienced during the pandemic. In most industries, COVID-19 sparked a major turning point in operational strategy. After decades of hyper-focus on efficiency, businesses learned the value of building resilience into supply chains and operations.

From a sustainability perspective, this turning point is generally positive as shorter supply chains (i.e. more local supply chains) and the utilization of local labor pools have both environmental and social advantages. As we wrote in a note in September, 2021, “not all the supply chain hiccups encountered of late are strictly due to sustainability issues. However, many of the consistently cited global supply risks are of an environmental, social, or political nature and in all circumstances, the investment implication is always the same: there is a trade-off between operational efficiency and resilience. For the past several decades, investors have rewarded operational efficiency, but the future will increasingly favor those companies that bet on the side of resiliency”. We stand by that conclusion and although the driving forces are different, we expect that resiliency will be increasingly valued by investors and/or forced by rule.

In today’s note, we look for pockets of opportunity in our sustainability themes that will benefit from the U.S.’ efforts to repatriate manufacturing.

Sustainability Under Pressure

At SMS we have a “Long” investment universe of about 500 companies that meet sustainability criteria based on our proprietary double materiality framework. The year-to-date performance of an equal-weighted index of our universe is broadly in-line with conventional global stock indices. In other words, sustainability themes have fared no worse than the broad market despite Trump’s anti-climate measures. It is worth noting that the SMS universe has relatively less exposure to U.S. tech firms, while being highly exposed to EU and Japanese industrials – both of which were crushed during the recent selloff.

It is understandable that in the face of Trump’s cataclysmic trade policy, climate change and broader sustainability themes are not currently top of mind for investors: tariffs and the economy remain their number one priority. Nonetheless, as tectonic shifts in the global trade backdrop occur, opportunities that fit squarely within sustainability themes are being created.

Our approach to finding the “green diamonds in the rout” is to favor: 1) stocks with a limited exposure to the U.S. market that are relatively immune to the ongoing tariff war; 2) explore defensive themes less affected by the anticipated recession; and 3) look for names focused on services’ in countries outside the U.S. Here again, one should note that our starting sustainability investment universe is slightly more exposed to the U.S. market than global benchmarks.

1. Look for stocks with a limited exposure to the U.S. market that are relatively immune to the ongoing tariff war

Japan is one market that fits the bill – the Japanese stock market has a relatively low exposure to the U.S. (and the U.S. consumer in particular). Moreover, at the time of writing, President Trump has issued a 90-day reprieve on all countries that have not retaliated, basically leaving China. According to Trump, Japan is first in line to negotiate a more lasting reprieve, putting the country’s companies in a relatively better position than non-Japanese competitors. One could also expect South Korea to follow suit as a close ally to the U.S. Australia, which does not have a trade deficit with the United States, could also prove an interesting market to look for sustainability plays in the current context.

2. Explore defensive themes less affected by the anticipated recession

Exhorbitant tariff on Chinese goods means, along with a major erosion in consumer and business confidence, that there is a high chance that a global recession occurs before the end of 2025. In the face of recession risks, stocks in the renewable energy and utilities sectors look appealing: both were hit hard by the elevated yields since 2022. Moreover, one could think that the current set of policy choices in the White House, coupled with higher volatility in markets also supports companies with stable cash flows.

One idea is NextEra, which is a stable company operating in the renewable space with long-term PPAs.  Another idea is First Solar. To be sure, this company is hardly considered defensive with a beta around 1.5. However, it is one of the very few solar manufacturers that do not rely on China. To the extent that solar remains even a partial solution for the U.S.’ surging energy needs, this company is well-positioned. 

3. Look for names mostly focused on services’ that are less exposed to the U.S. consumer

One area of interest is engineering services. Stock prices of these companies reacted sharply to the recession risks these past few months. Nonetheless, many of these companies have business segments that are relatively recession-proof – such as infrastructure projects – since minimum maintenance and replacement of infrastructure must take place. In addition, global engineering service companies are well positioned to benefit from countries that announcing fiscal measures to ease the tariff shock (e.g., Germany, Canada and potentially others). Favored engineering service companies include AtkinsRealis, Stantec and WSP.

The Macro Picture

For the last 20 years, the global investment landscape went like this: China manufactures, the United States consume, and corporate margins increase. When financial issues come up, Central Banks save the day. We occasionally hear that inequalities are unsustainable like in “Deaths of Despair”, the 2020 book by Anne Case and Angus Deaton that details the impact of the loss of manufacturing in Middle America. While nothing happened in the past, the election of Donald Trump, who ran as a populist rule breaker, is pushing us into a transformational period, for better or worse. The chart below shows the fall in wages as a % of GDP in the United States.

Donald Trump’s support came from those that have been most negatively affected by the drop in wages. The next chart highlights that hourly workers did not reap the rewards of improved productivity.

The current US administration has identified the unsustainability of the commercial trade deficit as a key economic target to bring jobs back to the United States. This administration has an unusual style of moving fast and breaking things akin to how Sillicon Valley operates. Einstein said: “Nothing happens until something moves”. Investors underestimate the likelihood of drastic changes in the way economic relationships operate; statecraft could dominate economics. Recent tantrums like the one over the Panama Canal could be a sneak peek. The picture below highlights historical tariffs dating back to the 19th Century.

In this context, the natural inertia of the economic and political environment should not be the base case because things are now moving. The table below highlights the likely transformation of the global investment landscape.

 

To expand more on statecraft: Trump clearly has his eyes set on critical minerals in Greenland, Canada, and Ukraine. Given the strategic importance of these materials, we’re not surprised they’ve caught his attention. In this changing world, metals and mining are likely to attract interest from investors, as well.

On the one hand, the U.S. wants to reshore manufacturing, build locally and maintain its technological lead with more electrical power. On the other hand, Europe recognizes the urgent need for defense and infrastructure spending. For its part, China wants to continue its manufacturing build-out. Finally, the Global South wants to build better infrastructure and move up the economic ladder. As the chart below shows, electricity consumption increases with income. Increased electricity consumption is directly linked to an increase in metals demand.

Build, build, build will imply more demand for metals -and probably some excess manufacturing capacity in the long run considering slowing demographics. The effects of climate change on the frequency and intensity of destructive climate events that require rebuild, using metals, will add to demand. Moreover, the desirability of a greener industrial base that needs modified processes requiring new infrastructure will also use more metals.

Inflation Hedge

For more than ten years after the Great Financial Crisis of 2008, policymakers grappled with how to raise inflation closer to their target (generally around 2%). As a result, central banks performed aggressive quantitative easing, but the only prices that rose were those of financial assets.

When the 2020 pandemic hit the world and budget deficits increased significantly, the inflation genie was out of the bottle and main street prices finally rose – but this time, a bit too much. Since then, inflation has remained above target in most countries and politicians are much looser with public purses. When we examine the table above that lists the changing world drivers (reshoring, defense, infrastructure, inward focus, increasing electricity demand), we anticipate the next 5-10 years to be inflationary.

At the same time, while most large investors are trend followers (even if they will not admit to it), most have very little exposure to inflation hedges. Some argue that equities are a strong inflation hedge even if popular equity indices are heavily weighted in technology and communication which have both have very long duration – probably not very good inflation hedges. However, they have close to no exposure to commodities or mining, which are strong inflation hedges. The chart below highlights the evolution of metals prices compared to U.S. inflation since the 1970’s. As we can see, there are long periods of divergence, but in the long run, metals have been good inflation hedges.

Sustainable Mining

Mining has long been associated with environmental degradation; However, regulatory pressure, investor scrutiny, and growing consumer demand for ethically sourced materials are pushing companies to adopt cleaner technologies and more responsible mining practices. The Towards Sustainable Mining (TSM) Protocol, developed by the Mining Association of Canada (MAC), is one of the most recognized frameworks for improving mining sustainability. Adopted by countries, including Argentina, Australia, Brazil, Finland and Mexico, it provides a structured approach for companies to measure, report, and improve their environmental and social performance. It focuses on key sustainability areas such as: climate change mitigation through carbon reduction, indigenous and community engagement, water stewardship, tailing management and biodiversity conservation.

Another major shift is how the electrification of mining operations has enabled digitization and greater automation, which through improved efficiency help to reduce waste and energy consumption. Technologies like artificial intelligence and real time monitoring also help optimize resource extraction, minimizing environmental impact.

Supply and Demand for Critical Minerals

The last period of investor excitement for mining was during the 2000s, when China industrialized. But now, governments have a renewed interest in mining. Worried about China’s dominance in metals processing, governments in the US, Canada, the EU, India, the UK and Australia have created lists and strategies for critical minerals. The table below shows the supply and demand outlook for the main minerals that appear on most critical minerals lists.

Considering the supply and demand outlook and the uses of the different minerals, we have created a an attractiveness ranking that shows our subjective view of the most desirable metals. Copper, uranium, silver figure at the top of our list. We assume that import constraints will be put on metals dominated by China, like rare earths, lithium, manganese and graphite. This will make these more attractive.

Which Companies Stand Out

Considering our positive outlook on metals, we identified global sustainable companies involved in the mining the critical minerals listed in the previous chart. The table below highlights these companies alongside the metals they produce.

Looking at the financials of those companies, our next step is to assess profitability, leverage and sustainability for each company as can be seen from the picture below. The starting point for all of those companies is decent: They have positive margins with reasonable debt levels except for Eramet and Impala. Investment in mining remains tricky and cannot rely only on financial ratios because the quality of the assets is paramount for future profitability.

Canada remains the most active market for mining companies looking to raise funds. Even so, the lack of interest in mining has resulted in companies moving their listings out of Canada to attract Chinese capital, which has been the only game in town for the past 10 years. Considering our view that Canada will remain a very strong player in the mining space, we did a similar analysis for Canadian companies and the metals they cover.

Most of those companies are profitable (Hudbay and First Quantum, not so much) and have decent leverage.

Our view is that higher commodity prices will lift all boats and rekindle interest in mining. If prices do not increase as much as we expect, finding the right companies is critical because they will create value even if commodity prices remain stable.