“The biggest danger is not inaction. The real danger is when politicians and CEOs are making it look like real action is happening when in fact almost nothing is being done, apart from clever accounting and creative PR.” Greta Thunberg, COP25 2019.

As we all now know, 2020 was a blowout year for attracting capital to ESG investing and 2021 is also off to a great start: according to Morningstar, sustainable fund assets climbed by almost 20% again in Q1 2021, meaning that “ESG” assets under management stand at just under USD $2 trillion. This represents a doubling since 2019!  

The rising trend toward ESG investing means that management at publicly traded companies understand the allure of appearing “green”: as more investors choose ESG over traditional stock picks, companies will be overlooked and/or left out of more popular ESG-inspired indices. The latter risks damaging their stock price performance. Moreover, according to a recent MSCI study, companies with high ESG scores experience lower costs of capital compared to companies with poor ESG scores. This is true across developed countries and across sectors.

The implication is that there is a rising incentive for companies to pursue implementing ESG business strategies. Or at the very least, there is a rising incentive to pursue an image of implementing ESG strategies.

The latter - paying lip-service to causes with little impact - affect all of ESG; blue washing refers to pretending to be socially conscious, pink washing refers to falsely promoting fair gender, and of course, greenwashing refers to environmental cover up. All three are important (and could be committed by the same offenders!) but in this week’s note we shine a light specifically on greenwashing.

Corporate greenwashing has implications for multiple economic actors and the planet. In terms of investing, greenwashing misdirects capital away from the goals and preferences of underlying investors.  

The principal tool for companies to communicate to investors about their environmental credibility is via sustainability reporting. Therefore, for investors that are looking to marry superior returns and positive ESG outcomes, it is crucial to be able to determine which companies are truly making improvements in environmental performance (either through efficiencies, new technology or innovative business models) and those companies that are merely improving their ability to communicate on ESG factors via glossy reporting.  

The matrix below highlights the possible outcomes between being green and reporting green (note that environmental “duds” should be entirely ignored among modern investors).

Although there is a plethora of reporting metrics, indices, standards and practices, all with varying degrees of reliability, we have developed a simple filter to help decipher which companies are likely to fall into each quadrant. Starting with the S&P Global 1200 (covering roughly 70% of total equity market capitalization) as the investment universe, we follow these steps to decode where companies fall in the matrix:  

- First, we use SASB’s materiality map’s environmental dimension to evaluate which industries are most affected by environmental issues. We do this to ensure that we only include industries whereby greenwashing is a material investment risk. We then translate the SASB industries to MSCI sectors. This limits our investment universe to MSCI companies within the energy, materials, industrials, and consumer staples sectors.

- Next, we rank these companies using both Eikon Refinitiv and CSR Hub data. Since we are focused only on greenwashing, we use only the Environment Scores (i.e. we ignore the overall ESG, as well as the Social and Government scores). We then compare the overall environment score with two critical sub-components of the environmental dimension: environmental innovation and product. We consider these two sub-categories as an indicator for “potential positive environmental impact” because high scores in these categories suggest that the company is more likely to be focused on environmental technology and/or innovative environmental business models that should lead to productivity in the future. In other words, the overall E score is likely to most closely represent a company’s E communication score, while the E innovation/product score should represent the company’s ability to deliver on green performance in the future.  

- We then compare the gap in ranking between a company’s overall E score and its E innovation/product score. Companies that have high overall E, but low E innovation are flagged as having a higher potential for greenwashing (bottom right quadrant of the matrix), while companies with high innovation but low overall scores are more likely to be potential environmental underdogs (top left quadrant of the matrix). Importantly, we only include companies whose scores are consistent in both the Refinitiv and CSR Hub data bases; given the ongoing wide discrepancies in reporting standards and methodologies, this criterion helps increase the accuracy of our filter.

The results of our “greenwash” filter are shown in the tables below by sector.

 

 

 

 

There are a few key observations and caveats from this exercise:

- Although we applied our filter across the four sectors whereby environmental factors are most material according to SASB, a qualitative check on the individual names that were flagged by the filter suggest that this methodology is less effective for the energy space. We agree that Baker Hughes should be on investors’ watchlist for greenwashing, however we are unconvinced about the names that were flagged as “green underdogs” or “truly green”. These companies were in part flagged by our filter because many do indeed develop innovative technology, but they continue to operate in dirtier aspects of fossil fuel businesses. A case in point is Cenovus, which continues to extract heavy oil from the Canadian tar sands, albeit with technology that improves its water efficiency.

- Within the consumer staples sector, our filter “caught” almost exclusively companies in the tobacco, food products and food retailing industries. This is largely because scores in these industries were more extreme relative to the other industries within this sector (beverages, personal and household products).

According to our filter, the potential for greenwashing is greater among companies with larger market capitalization: the average market cap of companies in our potential greenwasher bucket is 13% greater than those companies in the green underdog category. The correlation between ESG reporting and company size has been widely reported in recent years; the results from the filter suggest that not only are larger companies more likely to report on ESG issues, they are also more likely to exaggerate their green performance.

Finally, we caution readers that this filter is not intended to act as a standalone screen for investors to track down greenwashers. The companies highlighted in the tables should not be viewed conclusively as partaking in greenwashing; even when using several sources of ESG reporting, errors and omissions occur. Rather, our Greenwashing Screen can be used as one tool among many and alongside thorough qualitative company analysis.

While science is crucial in adapting to climate change, one could argue that innovation in applied sciences is paramount. Sustainability is rapidly becoming a growing business line for many engineering companies worldwide.  

While engineering services companies will continue to benefit from the global fiscal stimulus in the years to come and from “build-back-better” initiatives, those with dedicated practices in the fields of environmental remediation, public transportation, water management and renewable power are set to outperform the pack.

The good news is that many engineering companies have taken a serious turn towards sustainability, such as SNC-Lavalin, a Canadian engineering household name who recently joined the UN Global Compact and issued its plan to become Net Zero by 2030. For ESG investors, such a firm, which was engulfed in several corruption scandals in the early 2010’s in Libya and barred from World Bank contracts for a decade, poses an interesting case study on the importance of governance in the engineering sector. After a long period of adjustment and internal cleansing of its practices, the firm has straighten up its act and is now building up its future using sustainability as an edge to win contracts.

More than 300 engineering firms have now joined the UN Global Compact and the list continues to grow as more and more clients – public and private – are now asking their suppliers to adhere to some level of sustainability standards in engineering (such as ISO 140011 and others). Moreover, NGOs such as Corporate Knights’ Global 100 rankings have included engineering firms such as Stantec, one of the world’s largest engineering firms (also based in Canada), in its top 10 most sustainable companies (among all sectors) for 2020.

Given the complex nature of the way business is done for engineering firms – and the various countries they work in – the quality of governance of such firms becomes paramount to the long-term value and to the sustainability outcomes of their activities. To this end, it seems that the quality of governance in the sector has improved substantially these past few years, with SNC-Lavalin displaying some of the greatest improvements of its percentile rank in CSRHub with Arcadis, another firm that is strongly committed to sustainability and Stantec, which remains at the top of the pack.

Overall, engineering and construction services companies have had a good ride during COVID and benefitted greatly from governments’ promises to “build-back-better” in many countries.

Interestingly, the sector remains cheaper than the overall market as the S&P 1200 Construction and Engineering Index trades at a 20% discount to the market on a P/E basis. Should the equity market correct in the coming months, engineering services and construction companies could even become an interesting haven – at least those companies with a lower market Beta – for investors looking to de-risk their portfolios and anchor themselves more closely to developments and the direction of fiscal levers in the real economy.

Sustainable Market Strategies looked at large-cap engineering companies with dedicated practices in line with environmental, renewable power, water, and public transportation themes. We view that these companies will benefit the most from the soon-to-come government spending in these sectors. While most of these companies are based in North America, their activities remain global in nature – which also makes them exposed to growth in EMs and lower income countries.

Interestingly, SMS’s index of Green Engineering companies outperformed both the S&P 500 and the S&P 1200 Engineering and Construction indices on equal-weighted basis since August 2020. We think that the outperformance of our index should continue in the coming months.

 

That said, looking at the P/E of our index, some of the hype around green engineering seems to be already priced-in by markets at this point.

While that valuation of SMS’ Green engineering index appears expensive against the rest of the sector, one should look for cheaper names within our index. As such, companies such as SNC-Lavalin, Stantec and WSP – all of them global engineering powerhouses – and up-and-coming contenders such as Montrose Environmental – could be interesting plays for those looking to find value and exposure to the build-back-better theme.

One of the high-growth areas of sustainable finance and ESG these days are financial instruments – in this case bonds and loans – with embedded triggers tied to issuers’ sustainability outcomes – many of which compatible with ESG performance frameworks such as the GRI, SASB, SBTi, etc. As a result, many see sustainability-linked instruments as one of the future drivers of sustainability in the corporate world.

According to Bloomberg data, more than USD 30 billion of sustainability-linked loans and bonds have been issued globally by corporates and governments since 2019, and we expect this number to grow at an even faster pace in the coming years. While European corporate and government issuers continue to lead the pack, the U.S. has caught up substantially and is poised to see an increase in its issuance given the recent change of tack in DC and the growing appetite from lenders, corporates and investors for all-things sustainable.

The issuance of sustainability-linked instruments is also becoming more widespread across U.S. and European BICS sectors, with Utilities and Materials leading the group in terms of total amount issued since 2019. Here, three sectors are of interest: Utilities, Financials and Energy.

One can understand some of the reasons pushing Utilities to embark on the sustainability path – with renewables (notably wind and solar) now cheaper than thermal sources (natural gas and coal), companies in this sector can easily attach sustainability strings to their loans knowing that their future most likely will be one with less carbon intensity. In that, we expect Utilities – especially those embracing the transition to a lower carbon future at a faster pace – to benefit from lower financing costs that will likely come with sustainability-linked financing instruments.

Conversely, Financials find themselves in a position where they will have to commit to a change in their books and source of profits (think of Canadian banks’ exposure to oil sands financing) which will take longer than other sectors to achieve – hence the relatively smaller amount of outstanding sustainability-linked instruments in the financial sector.

Surprisingly, sustainability-linked instruments remain a marginal source of finance in the Energy sector – perhaps the area where they could have the greatest impact.

That being said, assessing the effectiveness of sustainability-linked instruments in addressing real-world problems forces us to measure the relative contribution of financial incentives vs. those aiming at other business vectors such as 1) management (i.e. pay) and 2) the contribution of technological change to the improvement of corporate-level sustainability outcomes.

While many are calling for regulatory standards regarding ESG in markets (the latest being Mark Carney in his new book), there remains a fair amount of noise as to the standards to which issuers should adhere when tying their financing costs to sustainability outcomes. One of the leading standards comes from ICMA’s Sustainability-linked bond principles.

While most frequently used metrics include internal KPIs such as energy efficiency performance and improvement of ESG scores (the latter doesn’t make much sense in our view considering the discrepancies in ESG scores across third-party ESG data providers), we much prefer issuers’ adherence to “’hard” objectives such as the Science-Based Targets initiative, commitments to increase gender equality at all levels of the organization, executive pay incentives (one of the most effective ESG incentive when done right), and any other measurable “absolute” sustainability-related targets.

While several studies suggested a disappearing greenium (lower yields for green instruments vs. plain vanilla comparables) in the green bond space, we note that sustainability-linked instruments still offer a lower financing cost compared to the average yield asked for by market participants in several sectors (we don’t know the extent to which sustainability clauses were triggered in Bloomberg, in fact very few details on the covenants themselves).

Looking at about 100 such instruments in the U.S. and Europe issued since 2019, one sees that sustainability-linked instruments yields (BICS sector average) remain lower than the sectoral averages of their plain vanilla equivalents. Like for the early days of green bonds, we are seeing some yield compression happening given the high demand for such products at this point.

Moreover, looking at the G-spread average per sector, we also see that sustainability-linked loans display lower spreads vs. their plain-vanilla equivalents.

Furthermore, we think that sustainability-linked instruments will prove to have their greatest impact in highly leveraged sectors such as Real Estate and Utilities. It also happens that along with Energy, these sectors probably have the biggest “transition” potential of all.

 

The path to decarbonizing our economies seems clearer than ever. Clean energy sources are now cheaper than dirty ones even without subsidies, electric vehicle market penetration is growing faster than we ever predicted, and more and more people are changing the way they consume – from the food they eat to the clothes they wear – due to the environmental impacts of the stuff they buy.

However, there is one building block of the economy for which we are way behind in addressing its environmental impacts and finding low-carbon alternatives: building materials – and especially cement and steel. This week’s note will address the challenges and opportunities for an ESG-minded investor looking for strategies in the cement and steel sectors.

Earlier this week, the Biden Administration announced a USD $3 trillion infrastructure plan that will inevitably involve the pouring of a lot of concrete and the welding of a lot of steel beams. The same can be said about stimulus programs in Europe and around the world that aim to kickstart the global economy following the COVID crisis by making much needed infrastructure investments.

How can we reconcile our thirst for cement and steel and the need to transition to a low-carbon economy – to eventually reach carbon neutrality? Let’s start with some facts.

Global greenhouse gas emissions from cement and steel production combined already represents about 15% of the world’s emissions – the equivalent of all emissions from the United States.

These are jarring numbers and the worst part is that contrary to other large emitting sectors such as transport or power, there are no readily, commercially available and affordable alternatives to reducing emissions from the cement and steel sectors. Even if all the energy needed in the production of cement and steel was non-emitting, we would still be stuck with about half of the emissions – reason being that in both cases, the chemical processes involved release pure CO2 in the atmosphere.

We also know that demand for these materials has been and will continue to come mainly from emerging markets – with Africa leading the pack as they catch up infrastructure-wise for the next few decades. The demand will therefore continue to be for the cheapest sources, for the most part.

It is for that reason – namely the demand for the cheapest possible cement and steel – that the production technologies have barely evolved in 100+ years. Cement still requires a lot of energy to heat up limestone in a kiln (invented circa 1890) and most of the steel in the world is produced in coal-powered blast furnaces (invented circa 1828). Some incremental efficiencies have, of course, taken place, but to hope to bring these emissions to zero in the next few decades, we will need transformative and disruptive innovations – fast.

One way we have seen innovation happening was by forcing companies to internalize the externalities through carbon pricing. Because of their high emission intensity and their trade exposure, the cement and steel sectors have historically been spared from paying the full carbon price, notably in Europe (they receive free allocations for the vast majority of their emissions). However, this should change in the coming years and cement and steel manufacturers will have to pay for emitting CO2 in the atmosphere. Current carbon prices in Europe are at an all-time high (€40+ a tonne) and need to surpass €100 a tonne in the next decade if we want to achieve our collective Paris Agreement targets. The issue for the cement and steel sectors are that the emissions costs will by then represent a substantial portion of the cost of the product (at least 40% for steel and 100% for cement).

So one of two things (or a combination of both) need to happen in the next 10-15 years: (1) disruptive innovations such as carbon capture, utilisation and sequestration (CCUS) and green hydrogen as an energy source for steelmaking need to become economically viable and applied globally; and (2) governments need to create a level playing field so that carbon costs are internalized at the firm level and encourage them to adopt the lowest emission intensive technologies possible.

Investors have very little control over the latter so we will focus on the former. Because we want to assess which companies are ahead in the development and adoption of potentially disruptive technologies, looking at the backward-looking ESG performance is not useful. Instead, we looked at how companies in both sectors compared to their peers in terms of low-carbon process innovations, R&D spending, and governance around climate pledges.

In the cement sector, HeidelbergCement (HEI GY) distinguishes itself with the most advanced CCUS technology in Brevik, Norway. Moreover, HeidelbergCement was the first cement company to have an approved science-based target (SBT) in-line with the Paris Agreement. Dalmia Cement (DBEL IN) is also well positioned to supply low-carbon cement in the future as they have succeeded in reducing the clinker-to-cement ratio by using alternative materials, making them one of the most efficient cement manufacturing companies globally with one of the lowest carbon footprints. Dalmia Cement was the first heavy-industry sector company globally to announce a 2040 carbon negative commitment in 2018.

At the other end of the spectrum, Asia Cement Corporation (1102 TT) is trailing far behind and should face much heavier headwinds than its peers. Asia Cement has neither done nor said what they intended to do to transition to a low-carbon economy.

In the steel sector, the Swedish steelmaker SSAB (SSABA SS) and ArcelorMittal (MT NA) are ahead of their peers when it comes to using hydrogen for iron and steelmaking and CCUS projects. SSAB is one of the only steelmakers with an emission reduction target aligned with a 2-degree C pathway which includes becoming carbon neutral by 2045. They have also started to heavily invest to switch from the emission-intensive blast furnace technology to the more efficient electric arc furnace – a move that few have committed to do yet.

In terms of laggers in the steel sector, the Chinese-based company Inner Mongolia Baotou Steel (600010 CH) and US Steel (X US) seem in denial about the upcoming transition and should be avoided, or even shorted, by ESG-minded investors.

Ammonia is composed of one atom of nitrogen, the fifth most abundant element in the universe that makes up about 78% of the earth’s atmosphere, and three atoms of hydrogen, the most abundant element in the universe that is available in great quantities on earth but always as a compound that needs to be extracted. Hydrogen is a very light gas and it escapes the gravitational force of the Earth. Ammonia is a key component for multiple uses; as a fertilizer, a pesticide, a herbicide for water treatment, for building materials and many other.

The most recent interest for ammonia lies as a fossil fuel replacement in the Green Revolution for the fight against climate change. Two approaches are feasible, the first one as a direct source of energy from ammonia combustion that emits water and nitrogen as by-products and the second as a way to transport and store energy before hydrogen is cracked from ammonia into a gas.  Arguments for ammonia as a fossil fuel replacement are the fact that there exists a transportation infrastructure necessary to deliver fertilizers.  It also packs more energy density and can be stored at higher temperature than liquid hydrogen.

Ammonia production is primarily performed through steam methane reforming that requires considerable energy and currently represents between 1% and 2% of global emissions. For ammonia to be part of the Green Revolution, it needs to emit less carbon.

Currently most ammonia is produced through processes that are labeled as brown or grey – and those are big emitters. To play a positive role in the fight against climate change, there needs to be an acceleration towards carbon capture. Second, the production of blue ammonia, followed by green ammonia under the traditional Haber-Bosch approach will both require enormous clean energy and away from Haber-Bosch processes towards less energy intensive clean production processes of ammonia. We are witnessing an accelerated pace of research on carbon capture, ammonia generated from clean sources and new production processes based on synthesis that do not require huge production sites and as much energy.

Producing brown or grey ammonia is the prevalent approach today because it is financially cheaper. With countries declaring their desire to reach net zero over the next 30 to 40 years, we can expect the cost of carbon emissions to increase either explicitly or through stricter regulations – as well as incentives for ammonia and hydrogen. Moreover, companies across the industrial space are pursuing net zero objectives which could create demand for green ammonia at a premium.

Considering the projected increase in energy needs from now until 2050 and the desire to fight climate change, demand for energy sources that improve on emissions will increase significantly. The fact that ammonia can be utilized for transport, storage and directly as a source of energy makes it highly likely that production will need to increase substantially. Since 1978, ammonia production has increased by 3% per year on average. With its energy potential, the most likely scenario is an annual growth greater than 4% over the next 30 years and the gradual elimination of grey and brown ammonia production in favor of green ammonia.

Fertilizer currently represents more than 80% of total production with a very small percentage for energy. With a gradual replacement of fossil fuels, it is expected that energy could represent more than 50% of ammonia utilization by 2050.

In terms of investment implications, the transition away from fossil fuels towards less climate impactful energy sources like wind, solar, hydro, thermal, nuclear, hydrogen and ammonia will be even more impactful than the transition away from combustion vehicles. Specifically for ammonia, opportunities abound for companies like Yara (YARA NO), CF (CF US), Nutrien (NTR US) and OCI (OCI NA) since they already lead the space for fertilizers. On the technical side, private companies like Haldor Topsoe and public companies like Air Products and Chemicals (APD US), Air Liquide (AI FP), Siemens (SIE GY) and many others are already discovering and implementing solutions which will propel the market to higher levels.

Looking at fundamentals of fertilizer companies, these appear relatively attractive from a risk-reward perspective. We can see that there is no ammonia excitement yet even though the prospects for growth and innovation are significant. For example, Plug Power that focuses on hydrogen fuel cells has a larger market cap than Yara even though it only generates 1% of Yara’s revenues. As an ESG-minded investor, concentrating on the companies that are moving more aggressively on green ammonia like Yara seems like the best proposition.

As the reflation trade continues, ESG-minded investors – and indeed other fossil fuel sector bears – remain skeptical about the recent oil price hike to USD 70+/bbl. Oil prices are up about 40% in the last 12-month amid recent Middle East tensions, attacks against Saudi assets and OPEC+ limitation on supply.

As we view these elements being transitory in a context where stimulus money will continue to flow into the global economy (and in the U.S. in particular), one can wonder for how long the global oil market can remain at levels worthy of its glorious days. Like a growing number of Big Oil executives, we are of the view that global demand for oil will probably have topped with the COVID crisis and that going forward, the commodity’s future looks down more than up.

Interestingly, despite the recent rise in oil prices, it seems that drilling activity remains subdued, which suggests that drillers have taken a cautious approach to the recent rebound in prices.

That said, rising oil prices have provided a breather for the suffocating North American oil industry these past few months. While we are seeing some resurgence in High Yield Energy bond prices, we think that the market has somewhat been getting ahead of itself given the sector’s underlying weaknesses.

This is perhaps due to the fact that unconventional Oil & Gas debt levels have increased substantially since the COVID crisis (six percentage points in fact) and, in a context of rising interest rates, the increased debt load (and its associated debt service) could prove detrimental to free cash flow levels of the industry. In this context, drillers should consider taking advantage of the current hike in prices to transition towards more financially sustainable business models.

Moreover, it seems the sector also has been shedding assets following depressed oil prices of the past few years (and 2020 in particular) which are now at their 5-year low point. In that, we expect that the crisis will have accelerated the amount of stranded assets in sector.

Pre-COVID, some were already worrying about the financing difficulties of North American oil producers given their deteriorating financial structure. Interestingly, this does not seem to worry HY Energy investors as bond prices in the sector have also increased by about 25 percentage points over the last 12 months – almost as much as the commodity itself.

Looking at how the market perceives risks in HY Energy assets these days, one sees that the Markit CDX HY Index is back to normal. Knowing that this index is comprised of CDS of several junk-graded debt securities from unconventional energy producers in North America, one could think that CDS spreads in HY will only go up over the coming months, especially those in HY Energy unless the price of oil stays elevated.

The sector’s resurgence is also visible in equities – especially those of shale oil in the U.S. and oil sands in Canada. Here again, the unconventional sector, represented by the FRAK ETF in the chart, rebounded as much as the commodity itself these past few months. Given the operational leverage in the Oil & Gas industry, we would have expected an even stronger rebound in the FRAK if things would be as rosy as the market currently prices for the industry – especially in HY. It is as if equity investors into Unconventional Oil & Gas are becoming more doubtful about the sector’s overall financial sustainability – which is now affecting equities’ valuation in the sector. We expect this trend to continue and accelerate going forward.

Furthermore, a look at the most important components of the MVIS Unconventional Oil & Gas Index shows us that the industry’s fundamentals are still far from appealing. More specifically, financial ratios of the largest holdings of the FRAK ETF show that despite bond spreads coming back to their pre-covid levels, most key financial ratios have continued to deteriorate this past quarter. A case in point is Cenovus Energy, a Canadian oil sands company, which saw an increase in its financing cost (WACC) this past quarter amid difficulties and growing reputational risks associated to the financing of Alberta’s Oil & Gas activities.

Finally, some companies in the sector are trying to burnish their reputations by launching experimental GHG-reducing initiatives such as Occidental Petroleum – but these are still mostly window-dressing for companies whose operations remain firmly anchored in oil drilling. We don’t’ think that drillers will derive a significant part of their revenues from carbon capture anytime soon.

Electric vehicles companies have had a rough start of 2021. The sector is in “bear market” territory, having corrected more than 20% since its peak mid-January. After the incredible year EV stocks had in 2020, it was bound to happen. To put the correction in context, an investor who would have bought NIO (NIO US) in January 2020 would still be up more than 1,000% as of today.

Not all EV stocks are nosediving, though. Volkswagen (VOW GR) was upgraded this week by some analysts who saw the full potential of VW’s new EV lines, ID.3 and ID.4, resulting in the stock being up 24% on the year. Long-time readers of ours know how bullish we are on VW precisely for its EV growth potential. If Tesla is the Apple of EVs, Volkswagen is its Samsung – cheaper, bigger total addressable market, and still a very high-quality product.

But what will determine who wins or loses the race to become the next Tesla will entirely depend on who comes on top in the Chinese market. By far, China is and will be the most important market for electric vehicles due to a few reasons. First of all, China already accounts for more than 40% of global EV sales (1.3M EVs sold in China in 2020 out of 3.2M globally) and the sheer size of the automotive market in China means that a company with any significant market share of the Chinese market is automatically a global leader.

 

Secondly, China imports two thirds of the oil they consume, and they hate it. There is only one path to energy independence for China and it heavily relies on the fast dissemination of EVs. Thirdly, the air pollution is still a problem that they need to address as it has important health and economic consequences. To promote EVs, the Chinese government offers license plates for free in a country where it can take months, if not years, to obtain the right for a license plate for a regular car. Finally, Beijing set aggressive targets for itself regarding EVs (one in every five new cars hitting the country’s roads to be either purely electric, hybrid or fuel-cell powered by 2025) and carbon neutrality (net-zero commitment by 2060) – and so far they seem serious about achieving them.

Objectively speaking, Tesla (TSLA US) has everything going in its favor to remain market leader in China. After all, they are currently selling the most EVs (premium segment), its gigafactory in Shanghai is operating at full capacity, and the company’s finances are solid and able to withstand greater market swings than local competitors. However, Tesla is the only foreign-owned manufacturing company in China without a local joint venture partner. Historically, China favored the JV model, especially when it comes to foreign companies in the tech sector – which is arguably the case for Tesla. Notably, Tesla generates loads of data that feeds its AI algorithm and China is known to be protective of any data on its citizen. If past behavior is indicative of future behavior, Tesla could be slowed down in their growth in China either through regulations, or even consumer preferences once the local competition is up to par. In fact, signs of interference may have already started to appear. Last month, five Chinese regulators summoned Tesla over quality and safety issues at its plant – a measure that seemed excessive to industry observers.

Volkswagen took the more traditional way to enter the Chinese EV market by investing €2 billion in two separate deals – one with JAC Motors and the other with Guoxuan High-tech Co Ltd, a maker of electric vehicle batteries. The VW approach might be the less risky strategy in the circumstances.

In terms of domestic Chinese pure play companies, four companies stand out for their unique strategies.

In the past year, the Chinese EV market has already seen a significant consolidation, with hundreds of start-ups having either been acquired or disappeared. Li Auto and Xpeng are the most vulnerable of the remaining “Big Four” having a more fragile cash position but the anticipated growth and strong financial backers should help during the transition to profitability.

The fact that Xpeng is more advanced when it comes to autonomous driving is a considerable advantage considering the anticipated growth in that market. Xpeng will release a model in 2021 that will be equipped with LiDAR, which is a technology that significantly improves the vehicle’s high-precision object recognition performance. Li Auto and NIO’s strategy to overcome the lack of charging infrastructure by either providing a battery swap service (NIO) or a gas engine that can generate additional power (Li Auto) seems overkill for what is likely to be a temporary problem, considering the infrastructure investments the Chinese government is currently doing in the electrification space (82% of all publicly accessible fast chargers in the world are already in China).