Around the world, there has been a documented rise in polarization that has been political, social, and economic in nature. The reasons why this is occurring are numerous and often disputed. However, what is not disputed is the notion that rising polarization is bad for democratic societies: polarization coincides with less democratic governments and lower levels of economic wealth.

At Sustainable Market Strategies, one of our sub-themes is Social Cohesion with the investment thesis that in an increasingly polarized world, the desire to conciliate rather than aggravate social tensions can serve to reduce inequalities and promote inclusive social progress. Therefore, companies that offer products and services that act to improve (detract from) social cohesion should be considered as potential long (short) candidates in a sustainable investment universe. Media outlets, some forms of leisure, penitentiary systems, and gambling are all examples of activities that often impact how societies function.

Football (soccer) is one form of leisure currently in the spotlight, as the World Cup is taking place this month. The World Cup is the biggest sporting event in the world with a record 3.5 billion viewers in 2018. Its 2022 edition, currently happening in Qatar, is expected to break this record. However, the organization of the competition has sparked controversy from the moment it was awarded to Qatar in 2010. Accusations of corruption within FIFA (Netflix released a documentary on the subject) have been accompanied by both environmental and social controversies. Detractors called for boycotts, while proponents denounced double standards from the Western world. The reasons justifying the two views are presented in the table below:

 The table above highlights that what is often one person’s virtue, is another person’s vice. In the realm of responsible investing, there are often shades of gray. Nonetheless, there is a growing belief among consumers that companies need to do more to positively impact society and consumers can substantiate this belief that companies must create value for multiple stakeholders through their spending choices. Consumer sovereignty is the concept that citizens can exercise their power through their purchases. The implication is that companies who are not aligned with consumers’ values will simply not be profitable and it will be reflected in their equity price.  In the following short story, we feature companies that consumers are confronted with when engaging in social activities. Each of them has the potential to be a positive contributor to society. Some are seizing their potential, while others are squandering it.

 

A Night on the (Post-Covid) Town

Chapter 1: Choosing an Activity

It was a long day at the (Platinum Leed certified) office and Miss Materiality was tired. Finally back home, she stood at the kitchen counter, waiting for her (avocado &) toast to grill, half-heartedly scrolling Instagram, with one earbud tuned in to Spotify. All of a sudden, something caught her attention: one of her favourite bands just posted the end of its hiatus with a world tour announcement, and a ticket pre-sale starting the following week.   

Chapter 2: Securing a Ticket

Miss Materiality sets a reminder on her phone to be the first to purchase tickets. However, even before the reminder goes off, she gets notification of an early presale access from Spotify. When she clicks on the link, she is directed to the Ticketmaster queue page for the concert, among a thousand other fans. After furiously clicking, she gets access to the sale where the only tickets left cost $500, in part due to the dynamic pricing Ticketmaster instituted in 2022, and are the worst located seats at the venue. Discouraged, she decides it is not worth going. She then looks for a more reasonable option. She decides to spend her money on tickets to go watch Manchester United football game with friends when she will be in Europe.

Chapter 3: The Night Out – The Red Devils’ Groupie

A few months later, it is finally the day, and Miss Materiality sets foot in Old Trafford, the football stadium home of the Red Devils, for a Premier League Championship game.

Since 2005, the Glazers, an American family, have owned the majority of the club, however, approximately one-third of shares are traded publicly on the NYSE. The right time to invest in the club may be coming soon, as the Glazers announced at the end of November 2022 the possible sale of their shares in the club. The announcement delighted investors, the club’s stock surged by almost 19% on the news. It also pleased supporters, who have not been a fan of the Glazers since they took ownership. Indeed, the Glazer’s controversial leveraged buyout in 2005 put the club in significant debt. According to fans, the Glazer family has not acted in the best interests of the club, as profits have not been reinvested in needed infrastructure. The wind of change blowing through Manchester United makes it a candidate in our long universe.  

Chapter 4: The Night Out - Snacks & Beer

Miss Materiality doesn’t wait for the referee to blow the start whistle to quench her thirst. She knows the queue will be long later, so she quickly buys her go-to combo, two “United Sausage Rolls” and her favourite brew. She then finds her seat and settles in for the match.   

Despite the loss of Manchester United to West Ham, Miss Materiality thoroughly enjoys her night out, which ends up at a local bar.

It has become a widely held view that global supply chains are set to become more regionalized. We are firmly part of this consensus, although the speed, magnitude and breadth of “re-shoring” is still unclear.

In a recent Insight Note (“A Matter of National Security”, November 3, 2022), we analysed the potential of four sectors to be re-shored. Regardless of the national prospects in each of these industries to dominate and/or gain global market share, one thing is clear: significant investments in new physical structures will occur. For example, in our November 10th Note (“Taking a Bite Out of Asia’s Chip Dominance”), we highlighted several chip companies that have announced construction of new factories on American soil. Whether or not Intel and others “win the race”, the companies that build their facilities will gain revenues.

Indeed, from a macro perspective, the re-build of supply chains offers interesting investment opportunities within an otherwise increasingly challenging economic backdrop. Monetary policy is already tight (and continues to tighten) in most regions and pandemic-related fiscal stimulus is now well behind us. Specific to the U.S., while overall fiscal conditions will remain a drag for the next two years, the Inflation Reduction Act and the CHIPS Act, will nonetheless help increase spending on targeted infrastructure. In other words, a non-residential capex acceleration is likely to be a healthy source of growth relative to other areas in a decelerating economy.

Why U.S. Small Cap Value Will Outperform

We continue to have a cyclical bias in favor of equities with both high U.S. sales and U.S. operational exposure. U.S. companies are benefitting from relatively lower energy costs (especially compared to European rivals) and the outlook for demand, while deteriorating, remains relatively healthier than other developed economies. That said, we are looking for ways to gain exposure to value-oriented segments of the U.S. market, given our expectations that inflation will remain higher and stickier compared to past cycles (and relative to consensus forecasters).

Historically, U.S. small cap stocks have outperformed their large cap counterparts during inflationary periods. For all of the above reasons, we believe that U.S. small cap value stocks are one area of the equity market with significant relative outperformance potential.

Given our ongoing interest in companies that will help re-build resilient and sustainable supply chains, we focus our attention on three small-cap value names that are representative of the types of businesses we expect to do well in this environment. 

 

AtKore (ATKR)

Atkore manufactures electrical raceway products, which are the enclosed channels that isolate and protect wires and cables in buildings, thus shielding them from heat, humidity, corrosion, and other physical threats. Atkore is the leading manufacturer of electrical products primarily of the non-residential construction and renovation markets; their products are a necessity in all buildings, plants, and facilities.

90% of the company’s revenues are based in the U.S. and their manufacturing footprint matches this: almost all manufacturing is done in the U.S., with additional facilities in Australia, Belgium, Canada, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom.

Importantly, the company is considered a “sustainability leader” having won multiple prestigious awards across various subjects:

Atkore trades with a P/E multiple of 8 and is likely to benefit from the buildout of future U.S. domestic supply chains across industries.

ABM Industries (ABM)

 

ABM Industries, Inc. provides facility services for commercial, industrial, and institutional buildings. The majority of their revenues are generated from building maintenance and engineering services, and janitorial & industrial cleaning services. Importantly, as part of their engineering services, the company has completed over 26,000 commercial EV installs and is considered the national leader in eMobility design, installation and maintenance solutions.

Over 90% of their services are delivered in the U.S. and among their top customers are various states as well as the U.S. federal government, making for a stable revenue environment. The company is trading at a P/E of 12.

ABM Industries generally receives good grades on ESG-related issues. According to CSR Hub, the company ranks in the 90th percentile of overall ESG issues and scores particularly well for its environmental record. As an employer of over 100,000 Americans, working conditions are particularly material to this business; the company is not considered an outstanding employer (receiving an average rank for this category in CSRHub and middling reviews on Glassdoor). However, information in ABM’s annual sustainability report, which has been verified by an outside source, shows that the company has made considerable improvement; for example, the employee turnover rate had a noticeable drop in 2021. ABM is one of the largest sector unionized employers in the U.S.; approximately 34% of employees are represented by 250 active collective bargaining agreements.

SPX Technologies (SPXC)

SPX Technologies operates in two segments: heating, ventilation and cooling (HVAC) and detection and measurement used for the maintenance of critical infrastructure.

The company’s HVAC solutions include energy efficient cooling towers, residential and commercial boilers and heating products that help to reduce energy use in buildings. SPX’ s detection and measurement products encompass underground locators (used to help remediate leakage of underground water and wastewater pipes), fare collection technologies and specialty lighting.

The company’s main market is the U.S., but they also sell detection and measurement tools across Europe for underground utility protection as well as cooling systems in Asia.

In terms of operational performance, SPX has a clean record. The company discloses information using both the GRI and SASB frameworks; the company reported a decrease in Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions in each of the past three years and has appropriate policies in place for all other material topics.

Present in virtually every electronic device, chips are integral to our modern lives and the most advanced ones have a critical role to play in the next technological frontiers, like quantum computing and AI. Last week’s note (A Matter of National Security, November 3, 2022) explored how nations are competing to secure critical sectors, including semiconductors. This week, we take a deeper dive into the semiconductor industry to look at which companies are poised to benefit from changing national defense and industrial policy. Re-shoring of semiconductor manufacturing can have beneficial environmental consequences if these processes expand in regions with stronger regulation and standards, it can also support the creation of quality jobs.

Different Flavors of Chips Policies

The COVID-19 pandemic brought the vulnerabilities of the global supply chain for semiconductors to the forefront. The Russian invasion of Ukraine drove the point home (literally). As governments watched Europe learn first-hand the consequences of dependence on other nations for critical resources, they launched a flurry of initiatives to support the re-shoring of chips manufacturing. Japan got a head start, making an announcement at the end of 2021 for a ¥774 billion allocation for the Japanese semiconductor industry as part of its FY22 budget (equivalent to ~$5.3 billion USD at current exchange rates). This pales in comparison to the amounts offered in Europe and America. The EU Chips Act was announced in February of this year and earmarked $43 billion for the cause. The U.S.’ CHIPs and Science Act provides a total of $280 billion in incentives, with $52 billion dedicated specifically to the semiconductor industry.

A look at historical capex numbers sheds some light on why these governments are eager to spend. Since the 1990s, capital expenditure in the Asia Pacific region has exploded. The proportion of spending in Europe and America has remained relatively stable, though America deploys significantly more capital than Europe. Expenditure by Japanese companies has been on the decline. Little surprise that these nations are afraid of falling behind.

We see some reasons why America’s efforts could pay off. For one, the government support for the U.S. chips industry is a larger than that of Europe and dwarfs Japan’s. Moreover, the country recently took policy one step further by imposing export restrictions to China. The U.S. has also managed to hold onto its key role as a chips designer (Nvidia and AMD) and relevancy in the provision of manufacturing equipment (KLA, LAM Research and Applied Materials – though the Netherlands’ ASML leads in advanced chips equipment). This bodes well for supply of talent and expertise that could have some transferability to the manufacturing of chips. It is also an edge over Japan where chipmakers have voiced concerns about a lack of engineers. America is a significant contributor in the academic research on semiconductors. The country accounts for around 40% of the publications at the top 3 global conferences and has consistently maintained this presence over the years. This level of knowledge will be advantageous when it comes to the innovation required for the equipment and manufacturing of more advanced chips. America has some of the key components for building a resilient chips supply chain, which can support the success of chipmakers headquartered there.

A Bite of the Chips (Value Chain)?

As America’s top manufacturer in advanced chips, Intel has the greatest potential to benefit from favourable government policy. The company operates in two legs of the semiconductor supply chain: design and manufacturing. Within the manufacturing segment, Intel Foundry Services was launched in 2021, expanding into fabrication of chips designed by companies other than Intel. This foundry approach is the business model underlying the very profitable TSMC. Intel is increasing its manufacturing capacities by building new factories in the U.S. and Germany, while also fostering an R&D presence in Europe via a new hub in France. The company’s strategy includes an objective to help increase the market share of chips production from 12% to 30% in the U.S. and from 9% to 20% in Europe. Though Intel has struggled as of late, we believe the company’s push to expand its manufacturing capabilities will pay off in the long term.

As for semiconductor manufacturing equipment, American companies are strong contenders. The country accounts for 42% of equipment sales in the global value chain and has three big players: Lam Research, Applied Materials and KLA Corp. Applied Materials enables production of advanced chips and will need to keep pace with chips innovation if it wants to hold onto market share. Supplementary R&D funding thanks to the CHIPs and Science Act will support these efforts and product demand will grow alongside chips production.

The Right Ingredients

Given that China, Europe and the U.S. are the largest consumers of semiconductors, moving links in the chips value chain closer to home for these nations will yield a lower carbon footprint. In our note from just over a year ago (Let’s Make Chips at Home, October 21, 2022), we explored the wicked problem of chips manufacturing (essential product, but environmentally intensive production process) and how a reshoring of chips manufacturing in the West could be beneficial. As governments mobilize their support for the industry, examples of this are coming into view. Intel is building a new manufacturing facility (fab) in Ohio and Micron is investing in two new fabs in Idaho and New York. These states have lower water stress than Arizona, the location selected by TSMC.

The table below presents CSRHub employee and environment scores for companies in the semiconductor industry (according to SASB Industry Classification) that have a market cap greater than $10 billion. The companies with the lowest ranks are nearly all Chinese. Unsurprisingly, Europe is the gold standard; the five semiconductor companies in this jurisdiction all rank above the 80th percentile for both scores. Broadcom is a weak point for the U.S. on these metrics. However, there are plenty of other American enterprises with stronger scores (while complete for the other regions, the American companies in this table are limited to the five largest - plus Applied Materials - by market cap. There are a total of 18 American companies exceeding a $10 billion market cap). Both Intel and Applied Materials rank in the 90th percentiles. With the rising pressure for all products, including electronics, to demonstrate sustainability in their supply chains, semiconductor producers with strong environmental qualities will be more likely to win contracts.

In our last Insight Note on supply chains on March 3rd (Global Supply and Its Chains: From Efficient Bounty to Complex Scarcity?), we laid out our view as to why we forecast that industries, companies and countries will attempt to build less complex, more diverse and regionalized supply chains. Since we wrote that Note, there has been accumulating evidence that our forecast is playing out, both in terms of government initiatives and corporate actions. Most recently, in mid-September, U.S. President Joe Biden signed an executive order that targets foreign investments in US biotech, artificial intelligence (AI), semiconductors and other sensitive technologies. Not long after, in China, Xi Jinping consolidated his power, underscoring the country’s “Made in China” policy.   

Today we identify the four industries that we expect to be most disrupted based on U.S. and Chinese national security concerns (we exclude energy from our analysis since we have discussed this topic frequently in prior notes). What these sectors have in common, beyond being stated priority sectors for one more of these governments, is that they are also industries with major environmental challenges. There are significant and varied investment implications of “re-shoring” and “friend-shoring”, but one important opportunity (or risk) is the potential for improving (or deteriorating) environmental outcomes at a global level, as polluting and/or environmentally intensive industries shift from regions with lax standards to stricter ones (or vice versa). We address these issues below.

Batteries: The China Advantage

China dominates almost every aspect of battery manufacturing, starting with the materials sourcing all the way through battery production and EV manufacturing (see chart below).

At the extraction stage, it is noteworthy that current mining production compared to mineral reserves shows that diversification of extraction is possible in the longer term. But whether or not this occurs highly depends on environmental regulation; in many instances, strict environmental regulation makes it uncompetitive to extract resources in particular jurisdictions.

As for the rest of the battery supply chain, the IEA forecasts that most of the supply chain is likely to remain in China until 2030. After all, 70% of battery production capacity announced to date for the period to 2030 is in China.

Nonetheless, the U.S. has bold public sector initiatives to develop domestic battery supply chains.

In March 2022, the United States invoked the Defence Production Act to rapidly boost US production of critical minerals for EV and storage batteries. In addition, in February 2022, the US departments of Energy, Defense and State signed a Memorandum of Agreement to support stockpiling of critical minerals that would facilitate the transition to clean energy, in particular for batteries and wind turbines, and to meet national security needs. Note that China has been stockpiling industrial metals for years; quantities are unknown, but various reports confirm that copper, nickel, zinc and molybdenum are held in substantial volumes.

Takeaway: in the race for battery and EV production, China has a substantial lead. Significant investments at every step of the American supply chain need to be made. Environmental regulation is a major determinant of country dominance at the extraction link of the supply chain.

Semiconductors: U.S. Needs to Produce, China Needs to Design

Experts believe China still remains about a decade behind the United States and its allies in key aspects of semiconductor design (the latter requires talent but significantly less initial capital outlays compared to manufacturing). Manufacturing of chips is another story however: recently it has generally been far cheaper to produce chips in Asia, mainly because tax incentives in those countries have been dramatically more generous and environmental regulations are far looser (semi-conductor manufacturing requires huge amounts of water and anywhere between 10 to 80 percent of the fluorinated greenhouse gases (GHG) pass through semiconductor manufacturing unreacted and are released in the air). Thus, in China the challenge is access to design, while in the U.S., the challenge is manufacturing at a competitive price.

Since September, China’s challenge just got a lot harder: Biden’s executive order prohibits certain entities from investing in US organizations and prohibits U.S. companies from selling certain products to Chinese organizations; this will strongly impede China’s ability to catch up from a design basis.

Meanwhile, the U.S. has rectified the tax incentive situation for semiconductor manufacturing and various states are in a rush to attract new production sites. This leaves environmental challenges. With much of the west coast in a multi-year drought and many aquifers throughout the country going dry, it is an open question whether there is a long-term future for chip manufacturing to re-shore to the U.S. or perhaps more likely, friend-shore to water-rich allies.

Takeaway: both China and the U.S. face important constraints regarding de-linking their semiconductor supply chain.

Seeds: The ‘Computer Chips’ of Agriculture

China is now the world’s largest agricultural importer and grain security remains a top government priority. Unlike in the U.S., food security has been listed as equally important as national energy security in China.

Paralleling the semiconductor industry, China has used both illegal and legal channels to set the foundations for food security. The most well-known case of agricultural property theft occurred last decade and involves Chinese nationals sending Iowa corn seeds to China in suitcases among popcorn bags and Subway napkins. Another important data point is that in 2017, China – through China Chem - also acquired Syngenta (a provider of agricultural science and technology) in what remains the largest takeover of a foreign company. Note that five years later, China Chem is preparing for the re-sale of Syngenta (through an IPO) and plans to use the proceeds to acquire more of the US$100 billion worldwide market for seeds and agrichemicals.

Satisfying China’s food demand without harming the environment is a massive sustainability challenge for the coming decades. China’s agricultural sector is a huge producer of GHG emissions, and the expansion of imports in recent years is also contributing to environmental pressure in exporting countries (for example, almost half of deforestation emissions due to soybean cultivation in Brazil can be attributed to China’s soybean imports).   

Therefore, China’s next steps on food security will, whether it be through ongoing agricultural trade or a stepping up of domestic production, have global reaching implications for environmental trends.  

Takeaway: China has set targets to reduce dependency on foreign food, but whether it is achievable – and whether it brings positive or negative environmental change – remains an open question.

Pharmaceuticals: China Wants to Design, U.S. Wants to Manufacture

Until the mid-1990s, the U.S., Europe and Japan produced 90% of the world’s active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs). Today, China has over 40% of worldwide API market share, and the U.S. relies on China and India for 75%–80% of its supply of APIs. Factory shutdowns in China under that government’s zero-covid policy have meant that in recent months there have been scarce supplies of acetaminophen, antibiotics and chemotherapy drugs; although the manufacturers of these medicines may not be located in China, the active ingredients are sourced there.  

Why did the offshoring occur in the first place? Much like other manufacturing businesses, pharma production plants moved to Asia because labor, regulatory and environmental and tax costs are lower. The remedy to entice pharma production back to America is clear; increase incentives to operate in the U.S.

Although it is early days, but there are signs that companies are beginning to invest in domestic and “neighbourly” production sites.  

Takeaway: Early evidence suggests that the U.S. will achieve greater independence from China with regards to the pharmaceutical supply chain. The barriers to bring back pharma manufacturing to the U.S. is lower than other critical supply sectors. We do not have sufficient information to decipher the extent to which China can develop new medicines independently from U.S. expertise.

The pickup in global inflation that began in 2021 has coincided with a period of structural labor shortages in most developed economies. This backdrop has the potential to unleash a significant surge in wage inflation. Whether that occurs is a crucial question for investors since, for the past several decades, the muted cost of labor has been a key factor in the structural trend higher in corporate profit margins.

Indeed, this long-term decline in labor’s share of profits, along with rising income inequality, are significant driving forces behind one of our six top-down sustainability themes: “Leave No Person Behind”.

Today’s note provides a graphical snapshot of the U.S. labor market to ascertain whether labor is beginning to gain the upper hand. It tells the story of an employment market that is behaving remarkably similar to previous economic cycles: there is no evidence from the macro data that the situation for U.S. workers is improving on a structural basis, i.e. that rising real wages are leading to improved purchasing power or reduced inequality.

 

The U.S. Labor Market in Pictures

  1. The Labor Market Is Cyclically & Structurally Tight

  1. Nominal Wage Growth Is Uniformly Strong

  1. Real Wages Are Not Keeping Up to Inflation

  1. The Share of Workers with Negative Real Wage Growth Is Rising Sharply

  1. High Paying Jobs Have Faster Rising Wages Than Low Ones

  1. Beyond the Cycle, Long-term Bargaining Power Is Not Improving

  1. The Regulatory Backdrop for Labor Has Not Meaningfully Changed

For impact-minded investors, finding plays in the financial sector that are truly aligned with environmental or social objectives is not an easy task. A first consideration is to look at the extent to which financial companies bring additionality to the impact/sustainability debate – i.e. do they intermediate capital in a way that benefits larger societal goals like environmental sustainability and financial market transparency? In this context, today’s note looks at – and probably debunks many sustainable finance concepts – or at least what is claimed to be sustainable – and explains why we find it hard to add financial companies to sustainable and impact portfolios.

We do this by taking a prescriptive approach and by looking at some of the key functions of financial companies for them to become more impactful. First, we look at “green” investment banking, then at asset management greenwashing, and finally at the consumer finance segment of the industry. To close, we examine the overall reputation of financial companies.
  

1. Seeing Through the Green Smoke in Investment Banking

Stop kidding the market with “green” bonds: While many banks are themselves issuing green paper and/or helping corporates issue green paper of their own, we are still having a hard time understanding the real-world impact of the growing “float” of green loans and bonds. Indeed, because the “use of proceeds” of these issues remains fungible once they make their way into corporate treasuries, it makes it hard for us to rely on only the “color” of a financial product without looking at the issuing company’s overall operations. Nevertheless, investment banks have not hesitated to jump on the green bond underwriting opportunity – and we expect this trend to continue despite scarce evidence that the growing green bond market delivers on its promises.

Ramp up the clauses embedded in sustainability-linked loans and bonds: With regard to the growing sustainability-linked loan and bond markets, we view that the tightness at which such instruments trade makes it unlikely that the incentives built-in these financial instruments can trigger real-world change (see our note “Sovereign Green Bonds: Carrots with no Strings Attached”, April 7th, 2022). Sustainability-linked instruments with a coupon step-up structure with weak sustainability triggers are neither interesting from the financial nor the sustainability point of view. For now, the main beneficiaries of these instruments are the underwriters and investment banks – not investors or the planet.   

Make sustainability flow through the “Chinese” wall: One way of looking at the structuring role of banks regarding sustainability is to look at the extent to which their lending practices are aligned with internationally accepted frameworks such as the EU taxonomy for sustainable activities and/or the Science-based targets initiative (SBTi). For the latter, of the 30 financial institutions claiming to have science-based targets, none are among top 30 issuers worldwide. Meanwhile, most large financial groups still fund fossil fuel projects while their asset managers are pledging to become “net zero” – which seems incompatible.

Steer away from SPACs: With many financial groups generating an increasing chunk of their revenues from their investment banking activities (20% of total revenue for Goldman Sachs), SPAC structuring is a rapidly emerging trend in structured finance – one which raises some significant issues for investors who value governance and market transparency as a source of long-term value (see our note: “2021 A SPAC Odyssey”, March 3rd, 2021). With hindsight, SPACs have proven to be destructive of value since their emergence in 2021, while also curtailing shareholders rights to the profit of SPACs managers and to their fee-earning structurers.

Large U.S. investment banks in particular – while receiving a small amount of their total revenue from SPACs – have profited from the hype while showing little to no consideration for values such as market transparency. By engaging in such poor market practices, several investment banks continue to disqualify themselves from portfolios and investment strategies that look to build better markets.

Align banking practices to hard frameworks: As EU financial institutions align their reporting to what is required by the EU taxonomy for sustainable activities, one can already witness the extent to which green lending is being implemented in banks. Interestingly, the banks with the greatest exposure to sustainable activities are already reporting that about 40 percent of current lending is already “aligned”. This leaves us doubting the extent to which 1) those numbers are valid, and 2) if an increase in these numbers (a key policy objective for the EU) can have a real-world impact. Even here, self-disclosed bank data on how their lending aligns with eligible activities under the EU taxonomy sectors looks fishy.

2. Asset Management: Stop the Greenwashing

Asset managers increasingly claim that their actions are contributing to improve the impact of financial markets on the real world. Interestingly, recent debates around the usefulness – and true impact of ESG policies in the asset management industry - suggest taking a strong look at asset managers’ true performance over sustainability.

To this end, Share Action, a UK not-for-profit, recently surveyed 75 asset managers’ sustainability/ESG policies and only gave the top 1/3 a “BBB” or better rating, with only 5 receiving a “AAA” rating. For this, asset managers are not a terribly exciting sustainable, let alone impact investment idea. Moreover, the fact that many asset managers are often looped into larger financial conglomerates can render the most sustainable asset manager un-investable because of the activities of its sister companies (think of BNP Paribas, among the top 10 financiers of fossil fuels). 

3. Consumer Finance: Stop Preying on Consumers

With interest rates on the rise and the scars of the GFC of 2008 still visible, consumer finance companies – be them auto loans, point-of-sale financing (“Buy now, pay later” schemes) or other credit-focused financial institutions, could rapidly become problematic in the current environment. That said, investors looking to make a positive impact with their investments should steer clear of such companies – especially those which target subprime borrowers (i.e., those with lower credit scores) in the delivery of their business models.

Auto loans: In auto loans, Credit Acceptance Credit Corporation (CACC) targets subprime borrowers looking to finance the purchase of a new car. Interestingly, this company will likely get stuck with a bunch of repossessed cars should interest rates pursue their rise once borrowers become unable to reimburse their loans. Moreover, one could also expect that the asset value of the underlying car fleet will also decay more rapidly than that of prime borrowers who would want to purchase more expensive, and better value-holding vehicles such as EVs for instance.

Buy now pay later: with consumers increasingly relying on BNPL services to avoid even higher credit card interest rates, one can expect that such companies will also go belly up as interest rates are set to remain elevated for some time. Reports suggest that some BNPL companies such as Affirm Holdings (AFRM) are already involved in some form of predatory lending practices by doling out as much as 20% more loans than competitor products. This yet another sign indicative that the consumer credit cycle is about to bust.

Credit cards: reports are starting to be floated on the bubbling subprime credit card issuance in the U.S. This includes that of Goldman Sachs (GS)’ “Apple” credit card – which is showing higher than average repayment delinquency rates compared to other lenders for its credit products. It seems that targeting subprime borrowers can be part of a deliberate business strategy – even if not in the best interest of the client.

4. Financial Companies: Time to Game Up Your Reputation

Finally, financial companies still have a long way to go before cleansing their poor reputation. The industry still places poorly in global reputational rankings, such as in AI-based Refinitiv’s ESG controversies ranking. With companies such as Goldman Sachs already under investigation in their asset management businesses for greenwashing by the SEC, its no surprise to see it being rated with the worse possible controversies score from Refinitiv. Other companies such as Wells Fargo and Morgan Stanley also fare poorly in this ranking.

According to a recent World Health Organization report, about 9 million people with genetic Type 1 diabetes are alive today thanks to insulin. Type 1 diabetes requires multiple insulin injections per day whereas Type 2 diabetes can generally be treated with a combination of pills and much less frequent injections.

The Origin of Insulin

The discovery of insulin, a century ago, was an amazing breakthrough for type 1 diabetes patients who were previously condemned to die. Its discovery was also accompanied by internal rivalries. Today’s insulin market is controversial, led by its long history of price gouging.

More Obesity – Less Insulin

Contrary to popular belief, Type 1 diabetes is not purely genetic and Type 2 is not purely lifestyle-related. In both cases, individuals are genetically predisposed and there is a trigger in their environment.

For Type 1, risk factors are generally inherited from both parents. Type 2 has been shown to have a stronger link to family history. For example, a study of identical twins showed that less than 50% of the time, both twins have Type 1 whereas around 75% of the time, both twins have Type 2 diabetes.

Recognizing that genetics are more important than lifestyle, there is still a link between obesity and Type 2 diabetes. Obesity rates have been rising over the past two decades in the U.S., half of U.S. adults are expected to be obese by 2030. Obesity is increasing around the world, but the focus of our analysis is the United States because the consequent insulin price gouging problem is an American situation. As the chart below shows, the trend is going in the wrong direction.

This increase is mainly due to a change in diets, mostly from added sugar (as discussed in a previous note, “Heath Is the New Wealth”, November 12, 2020). Rates of lifestyle-related type 2 diabetes have increased in parallel with obesity. In 1958, 1.6 million Americans were diagnosed with diabetes, compared to 28.7 million in 2019 (with 9 million more undiagnosed). While more and more American need insulin supplies, its accessibility is increasingly out of reach.

As of 2021, 7.4 million Americans relied on insulin to manage their condition, but fewer patients are picking up their prescriptions. The U.S. insulin market is an oligopoly that has seen its three manufacturers (Eli Lilly, Novo Nordisk and Sanofi), dramatically increase their prices over the past two decades, making it difficult for people without insurance to afford as few alternatives exist. Even worse, in some emerging countries, insulin is not even available: three in four people affected by type 2 diabetes live outside of North America and Europe, yet they account for less than 40% of the revenue from insulin sales.

Insulin Prices to the Moon

Since the start of the century, the price of insulin has exploded compared to the official United States consumer price basket (see below). In the United States, oligopolistic price behavior by the three global manufacturers of insulin is surprising considering access to health care and medication is considered a primary need.  

Novo Nordisk, Eli Lilly and Sanofi – the triumvirate who control the insulin market – generate incredible profitability. Novo Nordisk is more of a pure play, as diabetes represents more than 70% of its revenue, whereas it is less than 20% for Sanofi. Notwithstanding the fact that mastering insulin production requires significant investments, such high profitability should attract competition or at least scrutiny from the regulators.

A Weak U.S. Position

As the chart below shows, extreme insulin prices is a U.S. phenomenon. When looking at insulin prices in other countries, the difference is striking.

Why is it so expensive in the U.S.? Most nations empower their governments to actively negotiate prescription drug prices in order to hold costs in check. We use the German system as an example. In Germany, when a new drug enters the market, an independent panel sets a maximum price that insurers will pay ― a practice known as “reference pricing”. Most German residents have public health plans that are tightly regulated as German law requires public plans to cap out-of-pocket health care costs, and to cover all medically necessary treatment, including insulin.

The American Health Care system is comparatively far less interventionist. Federal health insurance programs are only provided to low-income earners, disabled people, and people over 65 years old. For other tranches of the population, private insurance can (sometimes) cover them, but there can be high deductibles. Free market principles are less effective when prices are totally inelastic: no matter how much the price of insulin rises, if you are a diabetic, you will pay or you will die. Prices are totally inelastic because there is no substitution effect for insulin: people will sell their house, their car or anything else they own.

Owners Beware

Insulin certainly has a positive impact on the life of diabetics. We looked at Article 9 funds in Europe as a good proxy for public market impact investments. The most popular companies in EU SFDR-regulated Article 9 funds are Schneider Electric and Microsoft. Novo Nordisk is number three. Sanofi and Eli Lilly are also well represented. After analyzing their pricing behavior in the United States, it seems unusual that so many impact funds have not shied away from these companies given their egregious pricing behavior on essential medicines.

Hands in the Cookie Jar

The basic instinct of greed in the American health care system is not reserved to drug manufacturers, it applies to other participants involved in drug delivery. The picture below details the money flow between the different parties involved for insulin and diabetes patients specifically.

Insurers, pharmacy benefit management companies (PBM), pharmacies and drug manufacturers are all part of this symbiotic machine to generate profit. In the United States, health care costs have tripled as a percentage of GDP since the 1970s as can be seen in the chart below.

Moreover, the health care costs as a percentage of GDP is much higher than other rich countries.

Government Action

Access to lifesaving medication should not be a privilege. The U.S. health care system is unlikely to be regulated like it is in Western Europe. The ballooning health care costs as a percentage of GDP put pressure on politicians to act. Pharmaceutical companies with extremely high profit margins should be wary of the regulatory landscape which could explain their growing lobbying efforts.

As discussed in last week’s note (“Outlook for Q4 and Beyond”, September 15, 2022), the Inflation Reduction Act touches on insulin: it caps its cost at $35 per month for Medicare recipients (around 3.3 million insulin users), starting in 2023. It covers only half of those who need insulin, but this is still significant. The proposed bill formerly included a cap on insulin for patients on private insurance, but Republicans opposed it, stating that it is not the role of the government to fix prices for private companies and that this capping would increase insurance premiums. On the other hand, California Governor Newson announced the State would make its own low-cost insulin, in an effort to improve accessibility. This move was made possible through an allocation of $100 million in the state budget to manufacture at a cheaper price. Its partner could be Civica Rx, a non-profit generic drug maker, who announced a plan in March to make and sell insulin for no more than $30 a vial. It is expected to be available as soon as early 2024, pending federal approval. Hopefully, these initiatives will introduce competition, reducing vulture-like behavior by member companies of the oligopoly.

Importantly, Eli Lilly, Sanofi and Novo Nordisk are no strangers to insulin pricing lawsuits.  The most recent happened in the State of Arkansas, which sued insulin giants and PBMs in May 2022 for allegedly driving up the cost of insulin.

Much like the first three quarters of 2022, we expect that energy markets and central bank policy rate expectations will be the main factors affecting macro sustainability portfolios until year end. These factors are especially relevant for SMS’s Energy Transition, Protecting Natural Capital and Leave No Person Behind themes. In terms of policy developments, now that the Inflation Reduction Act and the CHIPs and Science Act have been signed into law (both of which will have significant long-term global implications for climate change and supply chains) we believe that the COP15 on biodiversity in December may be the next important development in policy/global accords for sustainable investment portfolios.

Below, we detail how these three factors – central bank policy, COP15, and energy supply – are likely to play out in relation to key sustainability investment themes in the months ahead.

 

1  Central banks’ reaction to inflation will continue to drive equity style and sector biases.

Our base case is that there is considerable cyclical and structural inflationary pressure in the global economy and inflation prints will continue to dictate the direction of financial market price movements until at least the end of the year. To combat inflation, bond yields will need to continue to rise until substantial economic pain is triggered. Indeed, researchers at the IMF estimate that the unemployment rate may need to reach as high as 7.5% (double today’s rate) to end the inflation outbreak in the U.S.  

In this environment, broad equity indexes will struggle to deliver gains because interest rate sensitive sectors like tech will stagnate. Looking further out, the next phase of equity market developments will entail both falling bond yields and lower stock prices, i.e. the phase in which market participants price in recession.

Although few indicators are heralding imminent recession (the inverted yield curve is the exception), we continue to position for this eventuality, given the likely steady march upwards in interest rates to combat inflation.

We are maintaining our tilt toward sustainable companies within defensive sectors and value-oriented stocks. Our “social” theme – Leave No Person Beyond – is chock full of health care companies that we believe can leverage productivity growth to provide diagnostics, medication, products for wellbeing and patient care services that will contribute to improving healthcare access.

Other defensive areas of the stock market that have proven to stand up well to inflation pressures are grocery stores, albeit investors need to discriminate between ESG leaders and laggards in this space: several grocery chains have been accused of price gouging during the current ballooning of food prices. We focus on grocers that can sustain profit margins while providing products at reasonable prices – Carrefour (CA.PAR) recently announced a price freeze on 100 essential products – and whose customers are likely to be stickier given their product offering - Sprouts Farmers’ Market (SFM) is one such name.

2  From IRA to Chips To…Biodiversity?

From a policy and regulatory perspective, by far the most significant developments in the past quarter were the passing into law of two key pieces of U.S. legislation: the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) and the U.S. CHIPS and Science Act. There has already been much dissection about the environmental and social impact of IRA. Less covered by the press, the passing for the CHIPs act emboldens our view that re-shoring of key industries will occur. The strategic U.S. goal is to ensure that critical resources are available; supply chains will be shorter, simpler and to the extent possible, domestically controlled. But an important corollary is that re-shoring can also be a major win for the environment: when “dirty” industries move to jurisdictions with tighter environmental regulations, the overall global output of pollution/emissions drops. The table below summarizes the impact of the two laws with respect to SMS’ themes. Note that government funds allocated to these two acts will be deployed over the next several years, thus we view them as critical long-term support to our themes.

In the shorter term, one possible catalyst for our “protecting natural capital” theme is the 15th Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity (COP15) to be held in Montreal in December. The summit will finalize a global biodiversity conservation framework for 2020-2050 and the meeting is to biodiversity what the Paris Agreement is to climate change. The expected outcome is articulated global targets to preserve and protect 30% of land and sea by 2030, however, just like for climate change, any resultant accords will not be legally binding. Nonetheless, we view this as an important opportunity to educate and sensitize investors - and the public at large - to the fact that environmental challenges are far broader than simply GHG emissions.

If this opportunity is seized, one investment idea that will receive a supplementary tailwind is nature-based solutions and, especially given the inflationary context, sustainable forest companies. Moreover, forests are important natural carbon sinks, and in the rush for companies to put forward net zero carbon plans, trees are a basic, existing technology that can help companies reach net zero. Holmen (HOLM-B) and Svenska Cellulosa (SCA-B) are two Swedish forest companies that featured in our top 2022 sustainable stock picks report last January: both companies have had a flat performance so far this year (i.e. have outperformed relative to broad equity indices). Renewed investor interest in natural capital plays amid the strong inflationary backdrop will provide an ongoing tailwind.

3.  Energy shortages and uncertainty remain.

 Uncertainty around the supply of energy – and the fiscal response to this – will continue to dictate the direction of oil prices, renewable and non-renewable energy stocks, and related investments that are sensitive to oil price movements, such as industrial stocks.

In recent days, Ukraine has managed to push back Russian forces. However, it is premature to forecast an end to the war and it is even more premature to forecast an end to high and volatile energy prices. Our high conviction view is that national energy security issues have sped up the transition to renewable energy production and we are long-term bulls on all alternative energy, including nuclear.

In the more immediate term, however, energy efficiency plays have the most potential to outperform. In an era where all types of energy are in short supply, solutions to conserve energy are increasingly popular and will lend themselves better to a more challenging economic growth backdrop: certainly in the building sector where construction activity is already beginning to slow, projects that upgrade existing infrastructure for energy - and financial - savings are most likely. Retrofitting includes improving heating and cooling systems (the market for heat pumps is set to explode higher, see chart below), replacing windows and doors, improving insulation, as well as water systems. Companies with superior ESG credentials and also comparatively low equity multiples include Owens Corning, Carrier and Kingspan.

 

 

First World Banking Problems: Get Local to Stay Strong

When financial institutions look to solve issues around financial inclusion in developed markets, there’s nothing like having local lenders lend to local borrowers. Given their knowledge of local social capital, community banks typically cover a greater spectrum of the population while managing their risk more carefully than large-scale banking institutions. After all, locals typically get a better sense about the risks affecting their communities: be they at the personal borrower level or in the business sector.

Moreover, because local banks are typically more prudent and run less sophisticated loan books than their larger counterparts, their level of leverage remains about one third as that of larger banking groups. This becomes especially relevant when interest rates and bond yields across the curve are on the rise and is suggestive of more careful management of risk from local banks.

Moreover, it seems that local banks have a knack of finding where the money is and reap a higher return on their assets than larger banks.

This relative carefulness in managing risk and in generating return has become apparent in pricing too. As rates continue to rise, we see a wedge appearing between the large banks index (S&P 500 Banks) and that of the community bank ABQI index; which reflects the growing “cost” of leverage for large banks amid higher interest rates.

Conversely, ABQI Index trades at a premium to book vis-à-vis the S&P 500 Banks index, a trend which has accelerated with the most recent spike in interest rates. That said, for asset managers looking to invest in more impactful financial institutions in the developed country space, looking at community banks - as opposed to “bigger” banks - could make sense.

Frontier Banks – Or Is It Telecoms?

News earlier this summer that some additional frontier-market telecom companies had received their banking licenses should be seen positively for underbanked populations. While many developed countries banking institutions are looking for ways to increase their reach in mature markets, it seems that banks - or quasi-banks in EM and in Frontier markets in particular – are making strides in growing their market share and by reaching into the global financial system. That said, there remains swathes of people in Southeast Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa who have yet to obtain access to financial services: an issue which should be helped by financial and payment services offered through telecom operators.

To this end, if one looks at a country like Nigeria and its rapidly-rising status as Africa’s economic giant, the recent delivery of banking licenses to some of its largest telecom operators paves the way for the acceleration of access to finance for the poorest: an objective closely tied to SDG 1.4, which covers access to financial services and microfinance. That said, the crucial importance of efficient banking for economic growth and empowerment for all layers of society should be seen as a major technological development of our time in those regions. Interestingly, recent survey by the World Bank points towards a significant acceleration in the number of people who now hold mobile money accounts through their mobile phone operators.

Furthermore, telecom-now-turned-banking companies in frontier markets have fared relatively well – at least in LCL currency - these past two years despite COVID. In fact, companies such as Airtel Africa and MTN have both outperformed the MSCI Frontier Index in local currency by about 150 percentage points. As telecoms will increasingly continue to officiate as banks in several frontier markets, we think that telecoms with an active financial program will continue to outperform in the coming years.

For investors looking to promote financial inclusion by investing in public markets, looking at banking groups – or quasi-banks like Telecom providers – in South Asia and Africa is a smart, impact-adjusted investment.

Going global to local, all for the wrong reasons

Our third, late-summer banking “dive” looks at recent developments at HSBC, one of the most globalized banks in the world - at least for now. As the bank looks to abide to Chinese party-minded regulations at their Hong Kong Asian headquarters, it looks like the bank is increasingly complacent vis-à-vis the regime’s exactions over human rights to remain in good terms with the government.

To this end, the recent critiques against HSBC’s ESG credentials, coming from either the firm’s status as one of the most important backers of fossil fuels in the world or their lack of action against human rights amid reported abuse in Xinjiang puts their reputation increasingly between a rock and a hard place. The company’s value of intangibles, expressed as a percent of total assets - a useful tool to measure the brand’s reputation and value in the market - has halved these past 20 years.

Interestingly, while the firm was founded as a trade finance house linking Asia to Europe (regions which today account for 90% of its revenue), it seems that it is increasingly choosing Eastern values as opposed to those from the West. Furthermore, the company continues to carry a collection of controversies which yielded them a D rating by ESG rating agencies Refinitiv. We don’t see any sign of improvement in the company’s ESG narrative just yet.

Finally, HSBC’s stock price has been trailing its global peers these past few years, but it staged a comeback lately. As global growth and international trade flows start to fade, it is hard for us to see a positive catalyst for a company such as HSBC given their fading reputation, increasing alignment with Chinese authorities and deteriorating financial and economic fundamentals.

“ESG” has gotten a bad rap especially over the last year as many media outlets have focused on everything that isn’t working in the ESG industry. At SMS, we pride ourselves on taking a pragmatic approach to investment and research: in today’s note, we uphold the view that ESG has been an excellent tool for risk management; how the ESG and investor movement has effected real change on concrete, measurable corporate operations; and why ESG is ripe to become a popular (and potentially successful) “active” investment strategy. “ESG” is not a cure-all, but when done properly, it can influence and amplify social and environmental trends that are important to the broader world, as well as generate superior returns.

ESG: A Proven, Successful Investment Risk Management Tool

Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) – the term used to identify matters associated with corporate responsibility beyond generating financial profit (extra-financial items) – has been an excellent tool for businesses (and investors who take ownership stakes in them) to safeguard themselves from future risks. The clearest demonstration of this is through the lower cost of financing that is accorded to businesses with strong ESG records. Study after study concludes that the cost of financing is cheaper for firms with strong ESG records (see chart below). To be sure, a size bias sometimes overstates this impact (large companies tend to access cheaper funding and also tend to have strong ESG records) but it is not hard to understand why lenders view ESG leaders in a better light: businesses that demonstrate they are at lower risk from controversies, whether it be environmental accidents, or fraudulent financial activity are viewed as more creditworthy by lenders than those that don’t. For investors, the corollary is simple: businesses that have access to cheaper capital, all else equal, offer better risk/reward than investments with higher funding costs.

The overwhelming number of publicly-traded companies that publish sustainability reports is testament to this fact; it is no doubt cheaper to dedicate financial resources to showing transparency about ESG topics than to pay higher borrowing costs.  

ESG naysayers will rightly point out: there is a monumental difference between reporting on sustainability and being sustainable and that ESG data can be of poor quality and is fallible. These critiques are true. Few ratings of any kind are ever perfect - one only needs to look back to the rating agencies’ view of U.S. residential mortgage debt in 2008 for a reminder – but imperfect scores have nonetheless yielded results. As the section below demonstrates, the act of reporting on sustainability - and the imperfect ESG ranking of companies has led to corporate change.

ESG: Real World Results 

Plenty of corporate behaviours and practices have shifted in recent years. It is impossible to prove causality, but the link between increased, quality sustainability reporting and several changes in corporate behavior is nonetheless present. Although it has been over a decade now that the majority of large and mega-cap (i.e. the world’s 250 largest companies by revenue) produce sustainability reports, it is only very recent that the quality of reporting has improved. What is quality reporting? It is materiality reporting. Materiality refers to an organization's significant economic, environmental and social impacts and risks.

SASB is the gold standard on materiality reporting and as the chart below shows, despite a flourishing ESG reporting trade for the past decade, SASB reporting has only accelerated in the past three years.

This has corresponded to change in several issues that are widely considered to be urgent (i.e. material) environmental and societal issues.

A first example is the role of women in decision-making roles. The increased attention attributed to issues like #Metoo, working conditions in “pink collar” jobs during the pandemic, and the repeal of U.S. abortion laws mean that companies and investors are increasingly exposed to reputational risk if they cannot show improvement on gender issues. Although women continue to make up a paltry minority of senior corporate roles, the rate of change has accelerated markedly in the past three years, which has coincided with the number of businesses reporting gender diversity – or the lack of thereof - as a “material” risk.

A second example is the use of voluntary carbon offsets. As the chart below shows, the voluntary carbon offset market has exploded higher in the past two years, at exactly the same time that businesses are feeling pressure to react to the very material risk that climate change has on their operations. While the voluntary market is extremely imperfect and there is most certainly some greenwashing at play, the development of voluntary carbon offsets is an important step toward internalizing the costs of greenhouse gas emissions, especially for industries where emission regulation is weak or absent. 

Similarly, net zero pledges have existed for quite some time and by some estimates, now cover 80% of world GDP. However, it has been far too easy to commit to a vague plan about something far in the future, such as what was done by several countries and oil companies in the past years. Fortunately, along with the materiality of climate change on corporations, the number of independently verified, science-backed targets, has had unprecedented growth in the past two years (see chart below). 

The bottom line is that investors who may have initially been keen to see companies publish ESG reports to better analyze, gauge and quantify risks, have no doubt participated in spurring companies to take steps on materially important ESG issues!

From ESG to ESG Investing: A “Passive” Fail but a Massive “Active” Opportunity

In as much as the track record for ESG as a risk management tool and as a force for corporate behavior change has been a success, the same case cannot be made for ESG investing (yet). There is burgeoning evidence that although overall ESG scoring does not correlate consistently with stock performance, firms with good ratings on material sustainability issues do significantly outperform companies with poor ratings on material issues. And in contrast, firms with good ratings on immaterial sustainability issues do not significantly outperform firms with poor ratings on the same issues.

Still, we stand by our conclusions from our February report (“Authentic ESG Funds: Looking for the (Tracking) Error”, February 10, 2022): the bulk of ESG funds are passively managed, and more often reflect growth funds masquerading as low-carbon.

Indeed, the chart below shows the performance of ESG-aware passive investments. In rising oil price environments, ESG-aware ETFs underperform their benchmarks and in declining oil price environments, they outperform. Over long periods of time, net of management fees, ESG ETFs have generally underperformed, or in the best of cases, tied the broader benchmarks.

To us, this makes sense and we agree with others that point out that ESG investors that pursue a strategy of divestment (or passive investment with exclusions) should not be surprised by potentially lower financial returns because they’re constraining their universe. In other words, if diversification is good for portfolios over the long run, then by excluding certain types of stocks with particular properties, a passive ESG investor is reducing the ability to diversify, and therefore, should expect lower returns.

But let us be clear, it is not because passive investing in ESG has under-delivered that ESG investing can not be successful. We believe that active investing in select ESG themes will be successful for precisely the same reason that materiality reporting has affected corporate change: financial markets are a reflection of (and sometimes influence on) societal themes that unfold.

Share prices assist in the efficient allocation of capital, helping to steer savings toward the most promising investments; when investors allocate to a particular theme, they are taking an active stance on an anticipated change in the world.

One of the major critiques of ESG investing is that it lacks precise goals and it is difficult to measure since the number of objectives is almost infinite and varies from one company to the next. But active ESG investors, i.e. those that do not simply subtract the companies they don’t like, are in fact actively pursuing particular themes that align with - or reside within - broad ESG goals.

A Tale of Three Sustainability-Minded Investors

Take three different investors. The first - The Divestor - purchases an ESG-aware fund that reports low carbon emissions. The second - Passive Clean Investor - has more conviction in the energy transition theme and therefore invests in a (passive) clean energy ETF. The third - Active Transition Investor - recognizing the importance of the energy transition thematic, but also cognitive of the broader macro landscape, devises an active energy transition strategy.

The Divestor does particularly well when energy prices are in a bear market but underperforms when oil prices rise. This is because there are not enough “green” energy transition companies in the broad index to compensate for outsized positive contribution of dirty fossil fuel producers when oil prices rise. The Divestor may post returns in some macroeconomic environments but is unlikely to do well over an entire business/financial cycle.

Similarly, Passive Clean Investor has an even more constrained universe to choose from (companies with low carbon footprints and that produce energy) and is even more beholden to the economic and financial cycle: non-fossil fuel energy companies typically have similar characteristics in that they tend to be technology-centric and therefore extremely long duration assets with high P/Es. Under the right conditions, such as low interest rates and strong economic growth, the Passive Clean Investor’s high conviction views of the energy transition will be rewarded, but under other macro backdrops the strategy will struggle to outperform. 

Finally, the Active Transition Investor understands that the energy transition will occur, albeit its trajectory will be highly dependent on the macroeconomic and geopolitical backdrop. The Active Transition Investor overweights her portfolio to cleantech companies when rates are low, but dials back this exposure in favor of “boring”, lower P/E names that are early in the energy supply chain (like cable providers to the electricity grid industry) when recession fears strike. The Active Transition Investor may also dabble in renewable natural gas stocks or nuclear solutions when necessary, knowing that intermediate solutions are urgently needed to fill the gap left from coal and tar sands before renewable solutions can entirely take over. Active Transition Investor, in fact, may sometimes look indistinguishable from a macro hedge fund investor in that she seeks to deliver returns based on market developments caused by political or economic events.