You may remember Miss Materiality from our December note: Miss Materiality’s Night Out: A Lesson in Consumer Choice. She is back again this week, and in search of summer vacation plans that meet her budget and reflect her values.
Consumers don’t seem to be holding back on lavish spending despite the economic backdrop of higher interest rates and high inflation. Economists have even attributed Beyonce and Taylor Swift concert goers with boosting economic activity in some regions. When Miss Materiality looks at the price for those concerts, hotels and airline tickets, she wonders, “how can they afford this ?!”.
Inflation data for June showed that prices for hotels and restaurants remain well above pre-pandemic levels, though airfares have cooled recently, experiencing an 8% drop from May to June. The latter could be a sign of consumers’ last hurrah with pandemic revenge travel as a more dire economic reality is setting in.
Miss Materiality is also concerned by recent climate news. Just as the pandemic had disruptive effects on tourism-dependent industries, she wonders how the realities of rising global temperatures will shape the future of travel. This reflection has made her more cognizant of how her travel choices impact her carbon footprint and the climate.
Still, Miss Materiality wants to do something during her time off. To settle on her vacation plans, she will need to choose her destination, accommodation, and transportation with consideration for both her budget and the environmental and social impacts from her spending choices.
Destination
Miss Materiality is relieved she didn’t travel to Europe during July where record temperatures and historic wildfires left some destinations looking more apocalyptic than dream vacations. The continent’s record hot summer last year was already enough for travellers to seek cooler places for their 2023 vacations: Travel operator Black Tomato reported a 37% increase in bookings for Scandinavia compared to 2022 and Spanish travel booking site EDreams Odigeo saw a significant increase in searches for destinations further north, notably Ireland for which searches were up 1000%. Miss Materiality will do the same, opting for a location where she can avoid the worst of the heat. As climate records continue to be broken, she can’t help but wonder whether mother nature will get the last word and if some of the most popular tourist spots have hit peak travel forever.
Miss Materiality considers visiting New Zealand where it is currently winter. The country is known for its beautiful landscapes and is hosting the 2023 Women’s World Cup during August. However, the long flight equates to a lot of emissions, and despite her passion for the sport, Miss Materiality has her qualms with FIFA.
She looks a little closer to home; beautiful British Columbia (literally the province’s tagline) where the Rocky Mountain range offers plenty of hiking opportunities. Though cooler than southern Europe, she learns the province is also experiencing intense wildfires. She doesn’t want to chance it. She’ll have to keep searching.
Accommodation
Perhaps finding the right hotel will help narrow her search. She looks for hotel chains with locations in more temperate regions. If the statistics above are any indication, such locations will benefit from rising demand over the next few years, and she can say she was there first!
The hospitality industry is a labor intensive one. In the U.S., the Leisure and Hospitality industry currently accounts for 11% of the workforce.
With a substantial number of people relying on the industry for their employment, metrics like employee compensation, benefits and working conditions are part of Miss Materiality’s criteria when evaluating hotels that align with her values. Companies that treat their employees right will benefit from lower turnover rates and cost savings from training new personnel. This is especially true when there is a labor shortage, as evidenced by wage data from the past three years (see chart below). To attract and retain talent following the pandemic, compensation in leisure and hospitality has outpaced overall wage growth, and the other consumer discretionary industry of retail. The dynamic has been similar in Europe. After all, a hotel is unlikely to get return customers if the service is not up to snuff.
Miss Materiality knows that effective energy and water management is relevant for addressing hotels’ environmental impact. She also looks for sustainability certifications like LEED and the Green Key Eco Rating. The table below shows five hotel companies that align with Miss Materiality’s environment and labor criteria as well as locations in cooler regions.
Even if she doesn’t end up staying at one of these hotels, she can consider adding them to her investment portfolio (also sustainability focused) when the economic context is more conducive.
Transport
Often the greatest contributor to an individual’s carbon footprint, transport is the most difficult consideration for Miss Materiality’s travel plans.
Growing awareness of the emissions and pollution from travel is beginning to drive some policy changes.
France’s ban on short-haul flights and the Netherlands’ restrictions on flights to Amsterdam and closure of cruise ship terminals show shifting attitudes. New measures proposed by the European Emissions Trading System and the International Maritime Organization (IMO) to charge shipping companies for their CO2 emissions could have substantial implications for cruise ship operators’ bottom lines.
Miss Materiality welcomes these actions; particularly when it comes to cruise ships. For indecisive travel planners, cruise ships may seem like an easy choice with multiple destinations, accommodation and transport bundled into a single package. However, the reality behind this convenience is that cruise lines are notorious polluters. Per kilometre emissions are estimated to be worse than taking the plane. Within marine transportation, cruise ships are the biggest emitters of black carbon (aka soot) and one European study in 2022 showed cruise ships emitted 4.4 times more sulphur oxides (SOx) than all the cars on the continent.
The regulatory risk faced by cruise operators is not reflected in their stock prices which have been inflated by robust bookings from Covid’s revenge travel. Between this and their unsustainable debt levels (Royal Caribbean, Carnival Corporation and Norwegian Cruise Line have debt to equity ratios of 624, 598 and 86198 respectively), Miss Materiality sees a short opportunity rather than a viable travel option.
As climate issues intensify, Miss Materiality anticipates tougher regulation on pollution and emissions stemming from travel. She believes this will support increased investment into more environmentally friendly modes of transportation like rail. For instance, America’s passenger rail system, Amtrak, is undergoing a $66 billion investment as part of the Infrastructure bill passed in 2021. Though North American passenger rail systems still mostly rely on diesel locomotives, taking the train instead of a flight is often the more ecological choice, especially for shorter inter city trips. Just earlier this week, France’s Transport Minister discussed plans to tax airlines in order to support investment in the country’s rail transit. Policies such as these should result in tailwinds for companies in passenger rail equipment, such as Westinghouse Air Brake Technologies, Siemens, and Alstom.
Demographics
Population growth often drives consumption growth. With more people, the overall demand for goods and services increases through household formation. Increasing demand allows the government to increase spending on public services and infrastructure. It also supports investment and technological innovation because there are more potential clients for new products. Increase in the working-age population has another advantage: a competitive labor force, as we have seen with the tremendous economic growth experienced in China over the last 50 years.
The following chart highlights the working age population growth rate of India and China relative to their economic growth rates over the last 50 years. Throughout this period, China had much higher economic growth compared to its population as it became a global manufacturing hub. India’s economy also grew strongly throughout the period, but at approximately half of the speed of China.
Over the last 50 years, China built tremendous infrastructure and subsidized exports through low wages. Since 2008, China has continued its model of using debt to finance infrastructure spending and keep strong growth as its working-age population starts to drop. They have built phantom cities and uneconomical infrastructure. Those excesses combined with a falling overall population are a recipe for stagnation. On the other hand, India grew slower and underinvested in infrastructure while they still have a growing population. At this point, it is better positioned for the future.
The relationship between population growth and economic growth is not one-dimensional. Income distribution, economic policies, cultural norms, and access to resources also impact economic growth.
The table below provides more explanatory factors for the divergence in economic growth rates between India and China over the past 50 years.
As we look ahead, India could be a major growth beneficiary from demographic trends as China’s labor force continues to shrink. The chart below shows the mismatch between future retirees (50-59 year-old) and future workers (10-19 year-old) in China compared to India. China has a worker replacement problem (11.7% of the population joining the workforce compared to 16% retiring). Meanwhile, India has excess replacement labor: 18% of the population is between 10 and 19 compared to less than 10% between 50 and 59. China can no longer rely on a cheap labor advantage while India still can.
Moreover, geopolitics are pushing some countries to look for alternative manufacturing spots outside of China. Countries like Vietnam, Malaysia and Indonesia have cheap labor but export shipments from those countries need to cross the Malacca Strait which could be problematic during a conflict. Mexico stands to benefit as a viable manufacturing option, as we wrote in a previous note: “Made in China Mexico” on July 5th, 2023, but its population is too small to completely replace China’s workforce. Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and India are poised to absorb some of China’s de-shoring because they have cheaper labor than Mexico and transport access.
Geography
Geography plays a crucial role in shaping the economy of India. India is a diverse country with varying geographical features. India has a direct access to the Indian Ocean with deep ports and maritime infrastructure that can accommodate large vessels. This access places it at the crossroads of major global shipping lanes from the Middle East to East Asia, providing a great strategic advantage.
Agriculture remains very important in India. According to the World Bank, more than 50% of its population is considered farmers and landholding is highly fragmented. As a result, India is considered self-sufficient and is a net exporter of food compared to China that has less than 25% of its population in farming and is a net importer of food.
However, India's farm economy heavily depends on the monsoon and irregular monsoons could create havoc on agricultural output. Glacier melting is a secondary factor for agriculture but it is very important for river flow with 3 of the 5 most important rivers in India directly dependent: the Indus, Ganges and Brahmaputra. This means that climate change could have a large impact on the regularity of the monsoon and the navigability of rivers. Moreover, excessive heat, especially in Northern India, could impact productivity and lead to migration. Studies have shown that the body does not function well over 40 degrees of heat.
The table below highlights the potential regional issues that India faces from a warming climate.
In sum, India’s geography is a positive from its strategic location, its diversity and its food self-sufficiency but climate change could block its way on the road to economic success because the country is already very warm and crucially depends on water availability.
Policy
Throughout its history, India's industrial policies have evolved to strike a balance between protectionism, self-reliance, and opening up to international trade and investment. The country continues to implement measures to support domestic industries, foster innovation, and integrate into the global economy. However, there is an ongoing debate on the appropriate level of protectionism, considering the need to remain competitive and address the challenges of a rapidly changing global economic landscape.
The table below shows the general policy evolution of India since its independence. Even as policies remain relatively protective, India is cautiously opening up to the world to take advantage of its potential.
Historically, India has tried to remain independent in global affairs. It is currently being courted by the West to act as a counterweight to China; its strategic autonomy is an asset.
Risks
One of the main risks for India is that recent improvements could be temporary:
- Indian infrastructure has improved significantly but it is still relatively poor. Many still refer to life in India as “organized chaos”.
- There has been political stability in India with the Modi majority government for the last 8 years but India is a complex country with a diffuse power structure.
- Inflation in India has been relatively low compared to the past where very high inflation often occurred.
Other risks that could destabilize the country include the conflict with Pakistan that could explode at any moment, the border/water dispute with China and the effects of climate change.
How to invest?
We expect India to be a strong source of opportunities for investors looking for sustainable companies. Strong demographics, diversified geography with a strategic position on the Indian Ocean and supportive policies are to the country’s advantage. The table below highlights large, sustainable Indian companies across sectors that are poised to participate in the build-out of the Indian economy.
As the chart below shows, we have selected companies that have a high percentile ESG performance compared to peers.
The following chart highlights the quantitative financial characteristics of our India sustainability picks. Growth is strong but bargains do not abound. From a quantitative standpoint, they look expensive.
Corporate scandals, like those which emerged following the Global Financial Crisis have shed light on the need for improving the economic system. We recognize that reforms are necessary to ensure a more inclusive and sustainable economic environment, and this is captured in our Building Better Markets theme. Shareholder rights should evolve to align the financial system with broader stakeholder objectives. By balancing profitability with social and environmental considerations, businesses can help to address the shortcomings of the current system in favor of a more desirable outcome. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for investors to identify opportunities.
The significant decrease in the average equity holding period on the NYSE as shown below is an example of the impact of changing market dynamics towards gambling in the stock market instead of investing. A short-term focus over long-term performance and sustainable advancements presents a notable hurdle to effectively integrate responsible considerations. The emphasis on the short-term can divert attention and impede progress towards lasting positive transformations within companies.
In this note, we examine the current issues of capitalism and the calls to rethink the contemporary economy. We analyze the implications of this growing awareness and the anticipated developments for the financial system to support the goals of stakeholder capitalism. Our analytical framework considers four critical economic drivers: demography, international relations, regulations, and technology. The call for companies to embed sustainability and social progress aligns with the focus on broader stakeholder objectives in Sustainability DNA, while the pressure for inclusivity and fair access to financial services relates to Economic Participation.
From Trends to Transformation: Current Demographic Forces
Increased awareness of environmental and social issues is driving a shift towards ethical and sustainable consumption practices. As shown in the chart below, 71% of consumers surveyed have shifted their purchasing behavior in favor of the planet.
Demographic factors play a significant role in the need for better markets, as baby boomers are retiring and younger generations will take over as consumers and leaders, therefore changing consumption patterns landscape. The younger consumer is more concerned about the sustainability of the products they purchase.
Gen Zs and Millenials are recognized for their environmental consciousness, but their love for fast fashion poses a conflict between their stated values and their purchasing habits. Still, they share a strong commitment to aligning their spending with their environmental values, as indicated by a willingness to pay a premium for sustainable products, prioritize philanthropic giving to environmental causes, and invest in portfolios that emphasize environmental impact over purely financial metrics, as we highlighted last summer in the note “Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous and the Future of Global Warming”, July 7th, 2022.
As consumers increasingly seek products aligned with their values, businesses are compelled to demonstrate their social and environmental responsibility. Societal pressure is mounting to include a wider range of stakeholders in company decision-making processes. This inclusive approach acknowledges the significance of employees, communities, and the environment. As companies opt for greater disclosures, the laggards (or those who greenwash) are at risk while truly good corporate citizens could gain market share, as reflected in our theme.
Beyond Borders: The Chess of Geopolitical Relations
In recent years, political activism advocating for fairness, nationalism, and populism has gained traction. Elections increasingly highlight wealth inequalities as a central issue. Political campaigns often focus on policies that prioritize economic fairness and wealth redistribution. The outcomes of these elections can shape economic policies, regulations, and initiatives aimed at making markets more fair for all.
Global Disparity Atlas: Wealth Inequity Unveiled
World map highlighting in which countries the top 1% owns more wealth than the bottom 80%.
Source: World Inequality Database, 2021
Dynamics in France offer an interesting case. Following social unrest from a police shooting of a 17 year-old, multiple French executives asserted in an article in Le Monde that current economic divides are having repercussions not only on the economy itself but also on democracy and the social contract. In the context of successive crises, including the “yellow vest” movement, the COVID-19 pandemic, the war in Ukraine, and the impending climate crisis, it is imperative for the country, just like others, to stop neglecting the most vulnerable.
Geopolitical tensions and power struggles also have far-reaching implications for the pursuit of inclusive and sustainable markets. They can disrupt global trade, create trade barriers, and shape government policies and regulations. Trade conflicts can hinder the import and export of goods, including those related to sustainable technologies and practices. These have a direct impact on companies’ abilities to produce their products, source materials and sell their goods globally. Increasingly, governments and large multinationals are seeking security and resilience over global value chains. This is apparent in the push for deglobalization, reshoring and nearshoring and will inevitably impact supply chains, hopefully for the good. These elements underscore the need for companies to prioritize supply chain resilience, sustainable sourcing and production, regulatory adaptation, market diversification and strategic partnerships. These are the types of companies found in our Building Better Markets theme.
International collaboration and cooperation are essential in addressing wealth inequalities and navigating geopolitical challenges. In an effort to counter potentially stronger ties between Russia and China, Western countries have come together to impose sanctions and export bans. Frameworks like the EU 10-Point plan have also had success in coming together to meet the energy needs of their population Multilateral frameworks and agreements can foster shared objectives, facilitate knowledge exchange, and promote sustainable practices across borders. Countries with stronger environmental and labor practices will be well positioned for friendshoring and more favourable to foreign investment opportunities.
Redefining the Rules: Regulation’s Role
Regulation plays a pivotal role in driving the movement towards better markets. Government policies and mandates are instrumental in setting the stage for companies to prioritize sustainability and responsible practices. Regulations related to ESG reporting, corporate governance, environmental protection, social welfare, and responsible investing set the standards for corporate sustainability.
There are an increasing number of laws pushing companies to adopt better operational practices. One example is the EU law, passed in 2022, that mandates mobile phones, tablets and cameras sold in the EU to have a USB Type-C charging port by the end of 2024. Other laws in the lineup are "the right to repair" as mentioned in the table below. Companies that already embody these practices will be ahead of the game.
For a list of recent social regulations, see our note “Fast and Furious: A Distressing Tale of the Fashion Industry”, February 24, 2022.
Investor expectations and activism also play a significant role in shaping the regulatory landscape. Investors are increasingly incorporating ESG factors into their decision-making processes and demanding transparency and accountability from companies. This has led regulatory bodies and financial institutions to adopt rules and frameworks that require companies to disclose relevant ESG information and adhere to sustainable practices, like the GHG emissions disclosure rules from the SEC. Governments and regulatory bodies are pushing for greater disclosure of environmental, social, and governance data through initiatives like the EU taxonomy, which provides guidelines for classifying sustainable economic activities.
This evolving regulatory environment emphasizes the importance of data disclosure and transparency. Financial market regulations are becoming more proactive in addressing income inequality and favoring wealth redistribution through corporate and income tax policies. Again, early adopters of these frameworks, considered as sustainability leaders, will be ready and rewarded. This type of companies make up our Sustainability DNA subtheme.
Wired for Change: Technology as a Catalyst
Technology is a driving force in enabling transformative changes and reshaping the financial landscape. Technological advancements, such as digital platforms, data analytics, artificial intelligence, and blockchain, are enabling the integration of ESG factors into core business processes. These advancements allow companies to gather, analyze and report relevant data, improve supply chain transparency, develop sustainable products and services, and enhance stakeholder engagement.
Technological innovation plays a crucial role in developing sustainable solutions across industries. Advancements in clean energy technologies, circular economy models, smart cities, and sustainable transportation are all examples of how technology can drive economic growth while minimizing environmental impact.
In some cases, technology is helping to bridge unequal access to important services. One example of this is the expansion of financial services through apps and digital platforms has increased access to investment and wealth management, reaching a broader population. The worldwide market size of neobanks is expected to be multiplied by over 40 within 10 years, in 2030, with innovations empowering individuals who may have previously been underserved by traditional institutions, and emerging markets are its best example. As shown in the chart below, the penetration of digital banking in Latin America is high, with Brazil leading the way.
Furthermore, nearly nine in ten consumers across the emerging and developed markets of the Asia–Pacific region use digital banking actively, and most of these are open to purchasing more banking services through digital channels. Companies enabling this are reflected in the economic participation subtheme of Building Better Markets.
News earlier this summer about DoorDash now offering its delivery workers an hourly wage option caught our attention as the appeal to zoom through cities delivering via e-bike likely rises as summer sets in. This rather positive development occurred as many are arguing that the business model of app-based delivery companies remains dependent on shortchanging workers. A recent article about the life of gig-delivery workers in Toronto underlines the perils and low pay in the industry. After all, delivery workers – especially those who work for app-based companies – remain among a low pay group – with the highest quintile earning only about USD 23 per hour.
Perhaps more important than pay, data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics on work-related injuries shows that delivery workers have the 12th highest rate of injury in the whole economy – not that different from that or prison or iron workers (as a reminder, the incidence rate of injuries and illnesses is computed from the following formula: number of injuries and illnesses X 200,000) / Employee hours worked = Incidence rate).
The proliferation of delivery app workers and the fact that their pay can hardly be considered a ‘living wage” prompted some cities such as NYC to legislate a minimum wage in the industry – paid hourly – to the workers of these companies. Despite this, several accounts from workers suggest that their take-home pay – especially once one accounts for bike/car expenses – remains below that of legislated minimum wages and still offers little-to-no protection against work-related injuries. Some workers also report that more than 50% of their wages come from customer tips (which compares to about 25% in the restaurant industry); this makes total pay highly unstable.
Furthermore, many workers have also reported some level of wage compression in the industry these past few years, which coincides with the falling ratio of personnel expenses as a percentage of sales for app-based delivery companies since 2017. Conversely, UPS, a parcel company well known for its above-average pay packages, displayed a flat ratio during the same period. This suggests that some app-based companies are increasingly squeezing their deliverers – notably through the use of AI-based algorithms that favor the employer over the employee when allocating delivery routes.
Many workers in the delivery sector are recent immigrants. The contractual nature of their employment with app-based companies limits their integration and progress in the formal job market – while putting them at risk of injuries and/or legal pursuits when accidents occur. In this context, it is not surprising to see that poor compensation and benefits are recurring complaints against app-based companies on platforms such as Glassdoor, a website which reviews employee satisfaction with their employers.
Despite a business model highly dependent on unfair labor practices, app-based delivery companies displayed strong revenue growth in the past few years – while remaining unprofitable. Some companies such as Delivery Hero also display high debt-to-equity ratios, negative 3Y EPS growth and negative profit margins, suggestive of a fragile financial structure being built atop an increasingly fragile cheap labor model.
Many-pure-play delivery companies’ market capitalization is less than half what it was in 2019. One exception is UBER, which is more a play on mobility (and not without its own set of labor and regulatory issues) than a play on food delivery through its “Eats” delivery platform continues to display the strongest fundamentals in the sector and performed on par with the MSCI World since 2019.
Looking at historical profit margins, one sees that a company such as DoorDash has failed to deliver a positive profit since it IPO’d in 2020.
A final consideration is that the price markup associated to getting your food delivered to your door does not make any sense in a context of already high inflation. A recent comparison (2022) of markup margins for Canadian delivery app users suggests that prices can be marked up by as much as 50 percent by such platforms.
Early evidence suggests that predictions of Mexico being a “U.S. nearshore winner” have been spot on. In May of 2023, total Mexican exports rose 5.8% from a year earlier, with manufactured goods making up the vast majority (89%) of total exports in 2023. Meanwhile, foreign direct investment in the country rose 48% in Q1 from a year earlier. Demography, geography and policy are the three key reasons why we believe Mexico in general – and select companies specifically – will benefit from the U.S.’s ongoing desire to weaken its trade ties with China and to nearshore.
Demographics
One of Mexico’s greatest strengths lies in its youthful population. With an average age of 29.6 years compared to 38.8 for China, Mexico possesses a demographic advantage. Combined with its population size of more than 125 million people, it provides a substantial labor force, ready to drive the country’s manufacturing sector. Obviously, the size of the Mexican population is not big enough to completely replace China but its demographic profile is attractive.
The graphic below shows the percentage of the Mexican population by age group compared to the Chinese population. In Mexico, 50% of the population is under 30 compared to 35% in China. The typical retirement age in China is 55 years old for women and 60 years old for men. Just looking at the population pyramid, China has a worker problem because the 50-60 year-old cohort that is nearing retirement, represents 16% of its population whereas the 10-20 years old cohort, which will replace them, represent only 12%. Mexico has 10% in the 50-60 cohorts and 17% of 10-20 years old. Contrary to China, there will be net new workers in Mexico.
Geography
Mexico's geographic proximity to the United States is a critical factor in its potential as a manufacturing stronghold. The United States is the world's largest consumer market, and Mexico's proximity provides logistical advantages, reducing transportation costs and facilitating just-in-time manufacturing processes. Manufacturers can benefit from shorter supply chains, faster response times, and improved coordination between production facilities in both countries.
This proximity has already fostered a strong foundation in manufacturing, particularly in industries such as automotive, aerospace, electronics, and medical devices. Beginning in the 1960s, maquiladoras - manufacturing plants in Mexico with the parent company's administration facility in the United States - have helped transfer skills between the two nations.
Despite this long history, Mexico's labor costs remain relatively low. , equivalent to approximately 8,000$ per year. Similar information from the National Bureau of Statistics in China indicates that the average annual wage for a Chinese manufacturing worker was 68,506 Chinese yuan at the end of 2021. If we use the prevailing exchange rates at the end of 2021, it amounts to around 11,000$ per year. The difference is surprising. corporate executives were choosing China over Mexico because Chinese labor costs were much lower even if the quality of products was uncertain and it was further away for Americans.
Policy
While the U.S. has been increasing trade barriers with China, trade in North America is as open as ever. The United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), includes provisions for reduced tariffs and increased regional integration. Moreover, under the Inflation Reduction Act, electric cars and batteries made in Mexico are eligible for federal incentives not available to vehicles made in Asia or Europe. This just adds to the already enviable position of Mexico within the global automotive industry: under NAFTA and USMCA, vehicles made in Mexico have long been shipped to the United States and Canada duty-free.
Importantly, the USMCA has much stronger sustainability protection than its predecessor, the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA). USMCA includes a dedicated environment chapter where the parties committed to adopt better practices to address marine pollution, to promote sustainably sourced forest products and to enhance biodiversity and combat illegal trade in wildlife. It also establishes a framework for environmental cooperation which presents a development opportunity for Mexico.
This is especially important given that the current Mexican government, led by President Andrés Manuel López Obrador (AMLO) has failed to prioritize the environment and climate change mitigation. Mexico’s latest 2030 target to cut carbon emissions is weaker than the goal set in 2016. It is notable that AMLO’s term will expire in 2024 and he will surely be replaced by a leader that prioritizes environmental protection.
Overall, we believe that USMCA and the likelihood of a more “pro-environment” government in 2024 means that manufacturing in Mexico has better safeguards than most other low-cost jurisdictions.
Risks
Granted, reshoring to Mexico is not without risks. Mexico has faced persistent issues related to crime and security that can lead to concerns about the safety of investments in manufacturing facilities. Additionally, the government's focus on austerity measures and cuts in infrastructure and education, may impact the long-term development of the manufacturing sector.
Indeed, a significant challenge is the state of infrastructure. Mexico ranks 54th in the infrastructure pillar of the 2019 Global Competitive Index, below countries like Chile (42), Turkey (49), or Morocco (53) (WEF, 2019). Granted, there are significant disparities in infrastructure investment among states, with those near the U.S. border doing significantly better than others. Nonetheless, it is well documented that Mexico will need more infrastructure to meet nearshoring demand.
We believe there are numerous Mexican investment opportunities across sectors that are directly related to both the buildout of this infrastructure and the growth of the Mexican manufacturing sector as to China. Indeed, it is estimated that with over 400 companies looking to relocate to Mexico, the country needs to build 25 industrial parks to respond to the increased demand for industrial buildings driven by (industrial occupancy is reported at a record 97%).
In the table below, we have highlighted publicly listed Mexican companies across various sectors such as materials, construction, manufacturing and telecom that are well- positioned to benefit from this buildout.
The chart below highlights the percentile rank of ESG performance of the Mexican companies on our list. Most are ESG score leaders while Grupo Mexico and Alfa are more middle of the pack. Grupo Mexico produces copper and zinc which are critical for the energy transition.
The chart below shows financial metrics for profitability, growth, leverage and valuation of these same companies. If we are correct that there will be continued strong growth in Mexico, there are interesting to invest in companies with strong growth prospects at reasonable valuation.
So far this year, our “Mexican Nearshore Winners” have performed in line with the overall Mexican stock market (see chart below). However, we expect that as the evidence of U.S. nearshoring stacks up and these companies increasingly report a demand for their products and services, a period of outperformance will occur.
The global population is aging, with the situation being particularly acute for high-income nations (as defined by the World Bank) where the share of the population over 65 years of age is expected to be around 26% by 2041 according to latest UN population estimates (comparably, the projected global share is 14.7%). With this demographic shift, specialized devices and equipment that cater to the needs of older adults will experience a surge in demand.
A year ago, we explored the broad sector of healthcare in our note “High Impact: Surviving a Recession with Care“, (June 2, 2022). In this week’s note, we focus on medical equipment designed to enhance longevity of older individuals. We consider two distinct categories of devices: those enhancing wellbeing and quality of life, and those that directly prolong life through the treatment of non-communicable diseases. The first category encompasses devices used to restore mobility, hearing and sight, such as hip replacements, hearing aids and intraocular lenses. The second category includes devices and equipment used in the management of chronic conditions associated with common non-communicable diseases such as cardiovascular disease, cancer, neurological disorders, and respiratory illness.
Enhanced Wellbeing and Quality of Life
Although joint replacements, cataract surgeries and hearing aids are known as elective procedures since patients can technically live without them, they nonetheless contribute to patient longevity by significantly improving overall quality of life. Consequently, these procedures are often covered under public health plans or deemed worthwhile investments for those opting for private health services.
With seniors being more prone to the issues of mobility, vision and hearing loss, demand for associated devices is expected to increase as seniors’ share of the population grows. We can see this trend in the chart below. In the decade leading up to the pandemic, the number of knee and hip replacements in reporting G7 countries was steadily increasing. The combined total of hip and knee replacement surgeries increased 24.1% while the proportion of citizens between the ages of 60 and 70 for the corresponding countries increased 15.9% over the same time horizon.
Unsurprisingly, 2020 (the latest year for which this data is available) saw a significant decline in joint replacement surgeries, but comments made last week by executives at insurance companies UnitedHealth and Humana suggest a rebound in joint replacement procedures is underway. This could result in a boost to earnings at the next reporting date for companies that produce orthopedic implants. The top companies by revenue that are specialized in orthopedic devices include Zimmer Biomet (67% of revenues in joint replacement devices), Stryker Corp (28%) and Smith & Nephew (68%). Stryker has been the top performer, though all three have outperformed the SP Health Care Sector in the past year.
Relative to other categories in this note, companies providing equipment for the visually impaired have high valuations collectively. Similarly, providers of hearing aid solutions have recently rallied, so it may be wise for investors to wait for a better entry point when it comes to vision and hearing devices. Companies like Alcon, Hoya and Carl Zeiss offer lenses for the treatment of cataracts, among other things, but have P/E ratios over 30. Hoya, a Japanese company, has diversified revenues through exposure to the semiconductor industry as a provider of manufacturing equipment (28% of revenues). This makes for an interesting opportunity given the current tailwinds in both Japan and AI. The main providers of hearing solutions include Sonova, Cochlear and Demant.
Diagnoses and Treatment of Non-communicable Diseases
Globally, non-communicable diseases (NCDs), such as cancer and heart disease, are responsible for 74% of all deaths. Even within G7 countries where treatment is more accessible, 89.5% of deaths of individuals over the age of 70 were attributed to NCDs in 2019. The NCDs most frequently resulting in death for seniors aged 70 and up are cardiovascular diseases, cancers, chronic respiratory diseases and neurological conditions such as Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s. For these health issues, access to adequate treatment is directly linked to longevity.
Investment in innovative companies dedicated to finding cures to NCDs offers the potential for significant impact. However, predicting the winners and timing for such discoveries is a challenge. Alternatively, recent advances in the medical equipment used for diagnosing or treating these diseases are providing positive outcomes helping to extend patients’ lives. Therefore, opportunities in treatment and diagnostics still make for an impactful investment, one with more stable revenues and defensive characteristics. As the population ages, demand for both diagnostic testing and treatment will rise as a growing number of individuals begin to exhibit symptoms. Additionally, the prevalence of these diseases suggests an increase in preventive screenings which are often recommended based on age and family history.
Looking at the top 5 companies by revenue for diagnostic devices: all but one achieved strong sales growth over the past three years. Indeed, diagnostics from COVID testing may have provided a nice bump over this timeframe. However, with the exception of Roche holdings, each of Siemens Healthineers, Abbott Laboratories, Thermo Fisher and Danaher maintained positive sales growth for 2022 as COVID worries subsided.
Despite its weaker sales growth, Roche is an attractive opportunity. Roche has a lower valuation than its diagnostic device peers and earns the majority of its revenues from biopharmaceuticals (73%) with sizeable exposure to oncology treatments (30% of total revenues). As this segment should also experience long-term growth, Roche is well positioned in both diagnostics and treatment of NCDs.
GE Healthcare Technologies and Hologic are two other large healthcare equipment names that are relatively cheap for healthcare equipment providers, with P/E ratios at 13.8 and 12.3 respectively. GE provides radiology equipment used for various diagnoses and is executing its strategy for digital solutions. Hologic is differentiated by its focus on women’s health which furthers its impact appeal: it is well documented that women are underrepresented in healthcare research.
For impact investors focused more on treatment of the four major NCDs, it is challenging to find investment opportunities in medical equipment treating cancer and neurological conditions. Roche, mentioned previously, does offer biopharmaceutical products for the treatment of cancers. Treatments for neurological disorders such as Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s remain at early stages though companies like Biogen are making progress. Thus, it is currently cardiology devices that have the greatest potential for life-saving treatment of NCDs. In addition to its diagnostic segment, Abbott Laboratories is also a major player in devices for the treatment of cardiology issues. For more of a pure play in tackling heart disease, investors can look to Edward Life Sciences or Boston Scientific.
Since our last quarterly macro meets sustainability update – published March 15, 2023 – financial risks have significantly diminished. Less than three months ago, the fall of SVB bank triggered a mini-banking crisis, but since then, U.S. and global bank CDS spreads have collapsed, the VIX is below 15, and the NASDAQ index has rallied significantly. Crisis averted – at least for now.
Although the likelihood of a banking crisis is now severely diminished, the outlook for risky assets remains gloomy in our view.
To be sure, the AI fuelled rally in tech stocks may have some juice left, but the threat of further central bank hawkishness means that the risk/reward trade-off of betting on further gains is deteriorating. After all, the policy hikes last week and accompanying hawkish tone were enough to send a negative jolt to global interest rate sensitive stocks.
In the U.S. and elsewhere, we expect upcoming inflation prints to be relatively benign, given year-over-year comparisons with last year’s May and June surging inflation rates. However, this will not be enough to end the Fed hiking campaign; inflation is still outside of acceptable range for policymakers with core CPI still above the overnight rate.
Meanwhile, although consumers in most advanced economies are still spending, thanks both to lingering savings built up during the pandemic as well as ongoing tightness in the job market, industrial activity is less buoyant. Manufacturing surveys in the U.S. and elsewhere show that current levels of pessimism typically coincided with economy-wide recession. We expect that consumers will also become increasingly downbeat as higher interest rates and tighter lending conditions begin to bite more substantially. With this backdrop, we continue to advise investors to overweight high impact, defensive sectors like health care and grocery stores. Despite a manufacturing slowdown, there remain select opportunities in industrial stocks that are best positioned for the energy transition and ongoing fiscal stimulus. Indeed, the chart below highlights that constructors of manufacturing facilities are already enjoying a massive boom thanks to the Inflation Reduction Act.
Finally, we reiterate our bullish conviction toward sustainability plays in Japan.
Macro Is Supporting Innately Sustainable Japan
Japanese stocks have been among the best performing risk assets year to date, a trend that we believe can continue in the months ahead. Weakness in the Japanese yen (which is typically bullish for Japanese equities) is unlikely to reverse anytime soon, given that the Bank of Japan appears in no rush to join its peers and tighten monetary policy. Furthermore, an important tailwind is coming from foreign investors who have recently increased allocations to this country, attracted by relatively cheap equity valuations.
As we highlighted in a recent note (“Sustainability Is Big in Japan”, December 1, 2022), Japanese companies are often highly aligned with sustainability principles, given cultural and geographic characteristics of the country. Indeed, within the Sustainable Market Strategies investment universe, Japanese companies have, on average, higher sustainability rankings than the rest of our universe. Among the companies that we believe will perform well based on the macro and sustainability backdrop are: Asahi Holdings, Denso, Kubota, Kurita, Marubeni and Oji Holdings.
H1 Climate Disasters Bring Adaptation Into Focus
Beyond the monetary and growth conditions highlighted above, a second major sustainability trend that should not catch any investor off-guard is the proliferation of climate disasters this year. The number of costly and frequent climate disasters has been rising for the past decade, and 2023 will not be an exception to this trend.
Some climate disasters are direct forces of nature, while others are clear, direct acts by humans.
War is never good for environmental health and the ongoing Russian invasion of Ukraine is no exception. Last week’s Nova Kakhovka dam burst is being considered “ecocide” by environmentalists and politicians alike. At least 150 tons of oil has been taken by the current to the Black Sea so far and unpredictable amounts of chemicals, fertilizers and oil products that were stored in the flooded areas will end up in the rivers and sea.
Meanwhile, Quebec wildfires made headlines last week, not in small part because winds blew smoke and particles to the south, briefly New York City one of the worst air quality scores in the world. The delocalization of the inhabitants of several towns has (finally) sparked a larger conversation about the necessity to fund climate adaptation. Our expectation is that as more and more climate disasters occur, there will be increasing realization of the need to invest in our ability to adapt to be resilient to climate change. Of course, adaptation will not be uniform and will range from building flood defences, setting up early warning systems for cyclones, switching to drought-resistant crops, and so on.
There is room for the private sector to provide adaptation solutions (this will be the subject of an upcoming research note) but much of the funding and programs associated with climate adaptation will need to come from the public sector. This is because the benefits of climate adaptation infrastructure are often difficult to quantify and monetize in a way that creates the cash flows required for the private sector to invest.
So far, most experts agree that adaptation is massively underfunded. For example, in a recent report from the UN, Adaptation Gap Report 2022, it was estimated that worldwide annual adaptation needs will be between $160 billion to $340 billion by the end of the decade, and up to $565 billion by 2050.
As SMS readers know, one of our major structural investment theses is that fiscal policy will become an ever-greater force in financial markets and the economy at large. This is because monetary policy is a less effective tool in solving the major environmental and social challenges of our time. Financing climate adaptation will, on the margin, put extra pressure on government budgets.
“He who opens a school door, closes a prison.” – Victor Hugo
Investing in education is an obvious goal for impact and sustainability-focused investors. Afterall, education is an important pillar of the U.N. Sustainable Development Goals; SDG 4 is about providing quality education for all. In addition, education is directly correlated with higher wages, better health and general life satisfaction.
At Sustainable Market Strategies, education is one of our key social themes, along with health care. Our views are highly influenced by the economists Anne Case and Angus Deaton who have convincingly laid out the inextricable link between education levels and access to quality health care; in the U.S. and elsewhere: adult life expectancy is rising for the college educated and falling for the rest.
In most nations, basic education is provided as a public good and is financed through government taxation. Indeed, there are two key finance benchmarks for governments that have been set out to help fulfill SDG 4 under the Unesco Education 2030 Framework for Action :
- allocate at least 4% to 6% of GDP to education, and/or
- allocate at least 15% to 20% of public expenditure to education.
Globally, governments are not far from these norms, albeit poorer countries struggle to meet these goals.
The challenge is that even when these targets are met, there remains a glaring discrepancy in outcomes for individuals depending on their education levels, as the chart above highlights. This underscores the need for both ongoing investment in accessing education as well as improving the quality of accessible education.
In this sense, and despite acknowledging that education should be a public good, the private sector can nonetheless play a crucial role in developing tertiary education, pedagogical tools, skill enhancement, and supplementary educational services.
For public equity investors, the landscape is nonetheless challenging. The main hurdle is simply a lack of listings, which makes it difficult to create a robust portfolio: there are only a handful of large cap companies (greater than 1 Bil USD) specializing in higher education or supplying services to education providers. The vast majority of these are heavily biased toward the U.S. market.
This is particularly problematic given that the global increase in enrolment rates in the past decade - and forecasts for the next decade - are due exclusively to rising student numbers in the global south, especially in China and India. In the U.S., enrolment rates have steadily declined over the past decade. In our analysis, we exclude Chinese education stocks given our view, expressed in a note in our September 30, 2021 note, « Chinese Capitalism’s Long March », that this sector is uninvestable due to the regulatory risks in the Chinese education market.
Moreover, artificial intelligence and other technological tools are expected to be a massive disruptor to the education industry. Already, AI has devastated the market value of firms like Chegg as free sources like ChatGPT challenge the business case for paid study aids.
On the flipside, companies like Duolingo have seen their stock price rise on the news that the company is increasingly integrating AI in its services.
Given the challenging backdrop and limitations, but also the high potential rewards both in terms of profit and positive impact, today’s note focuses on three key education areas that are available to public market investors: higher education providers and assistance, alternative learning mediums and specialized training.
Note that we have opted to omit using “edtech” to characterize education companies, as our approach is to instead consider how technology is permeating the afore mentioned categories.
- Higher Education Providers and Assistance
Across all OECD countries, the majority of education spending by governments is allocated to primary and secondary education (generally defined as kindergarten through grade 12), with tertiary education receiving on average only 25% of total education funding. Thus, there is a clear opportunity for the private sector to provide an “undersupplied” good. We define higher education providers and assistance as companies that either provide on-line or in-class graduate degree programs or are providing services to these institutions (such as placement and assessment tools, pedagogical materials, etc). An example of a higher education provider is Adtalem Global Education (ATGE US). The company offers degree and non-degree programs in physical and on-line formats at four universities in the U.S. and Caribbean.
An example of higher education assistance companies is Grand Canyon Education (LOPE US). Grand Canyon offers technological solutions, infrastructure and operational processes to provide services to university institutions on a large scale. Another example is 2U (2U US) which provides the technology and services to non-profit colleges and universities to enable the online delivery of degree programs and also provides premium online open courses, executive education programs, technical, skills-based boot camps and micro-credential programs through relationships with non-profit colleges and universities.
As the table below highlights, few of these companies are able to grow their market cap to USD 1 billion or more.
For companies in this sector, artificial intelligence can play an increasingly important role that will amount to higher productivity and lower overhead costs. Indeed, in the wake of ChatGPT, when the stock prices of companies like Chegg have come under pressure, higher education providers and higher education assistance companies have for the most part seen their stock prices keep up with, and in some cases, outperform the 2023 rally in tech stocks (see below charts).
Alternative Learning Mediums
As is well known, traditional tertiary education programs are not for everyone. The high price – both in terms of financial and time commitment – is a major barrier for prospective students. Add on schedule stiffness, program pre-requisites and lack of customization and there is no wonder that technological solutions have been developed to provide alternative learning options. Alternatives to traditional college and university can improve access to higher education by removing significant barriers to entry.
One such alternative solution is MOOCs (massive open on-line courses), which have proliferated over the past decade and offer the advantage of being inexpensive and with few pre-requisites to register. Coursera (COURS US) and Udemy (UDMY) are two of the largest providers and while their business models differ, both are considered low-cost disruptors to the education industry.
All three of these companies have trailed the rally in technology stocks that began in 2023, with total returns roughly flat since January and with high volatility. This may reflect that these companies have the potential to both win and lose from artificial intelligence. Low-cost, self-lead learning from home options will naturally be threatened by the allure of free ChatGPT. On the flipside, artificial intelligence can improve the experience that Udemy, Coursera and others provide: Udemy is using AI to personalize the learning experience for each user and to improve the quality of its courses while Coursera is using it to enhance its assessment and evaluation processes.
Specialized Training
Alongside alternative learning mediums like MOOCs, advanced economies require professionals with increasingly specialized skill sets. Specialized training companies often fill voids in public sector education because training in specific fields is prohibitively expensive and/or only a small number of people need to be trained. As a result, companies providing these services tend to be smaller in nature as the potential market size for their products is limited.
Examples of listed companies that offer specialized training in specific industries are Afya Ltd, which provides specialized training to medical practitioners in Brazil and CAE (provider of simulation technology to the aviation industry). The stock prices of these types of companies tend to be less correlated with tech stocks (i.e. the Nasdaq index); it is reasonable to expect that specialized training companies integrate artificial intelligence into their processes with less risk that demand will be threatened by AI. In other words, we expect these companies to be relatively well insulated from AI-related product redundancies.
Duolingo: An Alluring Exception
So far, we have noted that education stocks make for challenging investments for several reasons: there are few large cap names available to investors; several AI disruptions cross-currents are on the horizon; advanced economy enrolment rates are on the decline, creating a sizeable revenue headwind, and; many companies are overly specialized.
There is one company that stands out from this picture, however. Duolingo (DUOL US) is the leading mobile learning platform globally. Its flagship app has organically become the world's most popular way to learn languages and the top-grossing app in the Education category on both Google Play and the Apple App Store.
The link between multiple language proficiency and economic development is well documented; economies that actively nurture different languages reap a range of rewards, from more successful exports to a more innovative workforce.
Duolingy IPO’d on the Nasdaq in July 2021 and has a current market cap of over USD 6 Bil. Duolingo has powered its newest product using GPT-4 (the latest technology from OpenAI), implying that strides in artificial intelligence are an advantage to this company and they are quickly capitalizing on it. The learning app has broad appeal, with over 300 million registered users studying 95 languages and there is potential to broaden its content even further by offering other subjects beyond languages.
Despite not yet being profitable, DUOL's Q1 2023 results showed another growth acceleration in monthly average users (MAU). Conversion rates to paid subscribers are steadily improving: subscription revenue grew 49% y/y this last quarter. That said, its current valuation (15.9x Price/Sales) clearly imposes a premium on investors, which can be explained by the company's continued efforts to innovate and its position as a leader in a competitive but large addressable market.
With economic activity slowing down in many advanced economies amid still-rising interest rates, some EMs are showing signs of strength. This is not yet reflected in relative company-level stock performance, providing a potential opportunity for investors. In today’s note, we explore sustainable plays within EM markets.
Macro Perspective
A first consideration is that the EM economic surprises index (growth, inflation, economic activity, etc) has diverged in the past two months from that of G10 economies despite China’s underwhelming growth.
Second, with the value of USD likely reaching a peak on a trade-weighted basis, the impact of rising rates in the U.S. may now be priced into a number of EM stocks already. Risk of a U.S. recession later in the year could reverse this course but for now, we see that the path of less resistance for EM currencies is to start appreciating against the USD over the medium term.
A case in point is Airtel Africa, a mobile phone service provider and payments facilitator that operates in several African countries, which suffered a blow to its earnings FX hedging issues when they reported their 2023Q1 earnings last month. With many such companies adjusting to a weaker exchange rate against the USD, foreign investors can go bargain hunting in EMs and, potentially, frontier markets (FMs) at this juncture. Afterall, the J.P Morgan EM currency index is currently at a 4-year low, suggesting that many EM currencies could actually start rebounding in the coming months as the interest rate differential between DMs and EMs/FMs starts to decrease. In that, sustainable plays in EMs and FMs represent an interesting tactical play before EM currency appreciation against the USD starts to impact companies bottom line negatively.
Furthermore, EM companies remain about 30% cheaper on a forward P/E basis compared to their MSCI and FM companies are even cheaper than their historical discount would suggest.
Sustainable Opportunities In EM
Although the macro context is brightening for EMs and FMs, investing for sustainability remains a difficult task in those regions given 1) the scarcity of listings in general and those related to sustainability themes in particular, 2) questionable sustainability features of some FM and EM companies, especially in regard to governance and 3) underwhelming country-level regulatory frameworks.
Despite these difficulties, “Long” opportunities in SMS’ EM investment universe include companies such as Bajaj Auto and Hero Motorcorp, two transportation companies with good electrification potential with a strong exposure to India’s secular growth story which score well on SMS’ proprietary financial investment attractiveness score based on value, momentum and technical analysis (ranging from -100 to 100). Furthermore, with lumber, pulp and paper prices close to a cyclical bottom, Brazilian companies such as Suzano and Klabin – two pulp and paper companies using Brazilian eucalyptus forests in a renewable fashion - offer attractive valuation. Finally, for those willing to see through South Africa’s current macro and energy wobbles, opportunities to gain exposure to palladium producers (see our note “A Two-Speed Transition: Why it’s Time to Park the EV Frenzy in EMs”, February 16, 2023) abound in a context where demand for palladium should continue to grow at a double-digit rate in the coming decade.
Conversely, looking at SMS’ EM short side, Gaotu – an Edtech firm – fares poorly against our proprietary investment attractiveness score (ranging from -100 to 100). After all, China’s government crackdown against private education, its firm grip over curriculum and its relatively unattractive investment environment could sink firms such as Gaotu even further over the next few months. Another potential short idea includes Petrobras, for which the combination of 1) the outlook of Brazilian politics, 2) enduring poor internal governance standards and 3) oil prices increasingly vulnerable to an economic slowdown also makes it an interesting candidate on the short side.
While our names in India (Bajaj Auto and Hero Motorcorp) appear to have rebounded lately, Suzano and Klabin in Brazil look particularly attractive from a momentum perspective.
Finally, from a valuation perspective, Klabin remains attractive, and scores above its industry peers with regard to sustainability according to CSRHub’s overall percentile rankings – including on environmental grounds.
Up until February 2022, the defense and military sector’s stock performance had pretty much stagnated for half a decade as budgets were being cut and the world was enjoying a quasi-conflict-free phase. This period also coincided with the rise of ESG investing which came with its suite of sectoral exclusions. Defense stocks were rapidly labelled as “sin stocks” along with tobacco, coal, gambling, and alcohol. In fact, controversial weapons are, to this day, the most excluded activity with over 70% of European funds excluding them, while about 50% exclude civilian firearms and 35% exclude conventional military equipment and services. Prior to February 2022, the reasoning was flawless: Defense companies make products that kill people, and are often sold to bad actors – for instance to Saudi Arabia, even despite Jamal Khashoggi’s murder in 2018.
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine on February 24, 2022 changed a lot of things – including how some ESG-minded investors are looking at the defense sector.
The consensus before the invasion was that it was just flexing and positioning on Putin’s part. We were all wrong. Then we were certain that Ukraine would surrender in a matter of days. Wrong again. These days, we like to think that China would never do the unthinkable and make a move for Taiwan. However, we may have to face the fact that we live in an increasingly uncertain world with a greater likelihood of major geopolitical moves making lasting impacts on our lives and our investments. One of these impacts for investors is the subject of this week’s note: Can defense stocks be considered in an ESG portfolio?
For the first time since the creation of the Munich Security Index (a global risk perception survey conducted by the Munich Security Conference) in 2014, security has replaced climate change as the top concern among the 12,000 respondents.
Governments too are concerned about security, and defense budgets are shooting up to historically high levels.
In and of itself, an increased interest from investors and bigger budgets should not influence whether defense stocks belong in and ESG portfolio or not. The change in mindset came from the Ukraine invasion and the West’s response of sending military equipment to support the Ukrainian resistance. After all, security is a human right enshrined in human rights treaties and most would agree that the right to defend oneself and preserve sovereignty does not go against any ESG principles. This is one element that separates defense-related activities from tobacco or gambling for instance, where it is legitimately difficult to see any wider social good from those activities.
Defense hawks might even argue that there is a social benefit to consider too: well-equipped military can act as “armed deterrence”, preventing conflict and maintaining stability in the international system. By having a powerful military, they argue, potential adversaries will be deterred from aggressive actions, thereby reducing the likelihood of conflict and promoting a safer world. As the saying goes: “weapons are harmful – but they are even more harmful if those who threaten you have them and you do not”.
The conundrum is, however, that defensive weapons are indistinguishable from offensive weapons – it’s a matter of perspective – and the pendulum between global good and evil can rapidly swing.
Nonetheless, this is a bet that some asset managers are willing to take in light of the Russian invasion. For instance, Swedish financial group SEB announced in March 2022 that it would start permitting some of its funds to buy shares of weapons makers and defense companies, reversing a position it adopted a year prior as part of its ESG commitments. SEB justified the change of tack by claiming the war in Ukraine had softened some of its clients’ view on the defense sector.
Defense No-Go Zones: Controversial Weapons and Weak Governance
Relaxing ESG exclusions for the defense sector should not be unbridled, however. There are good ‘S’ and ‘G’ reasons to continue to exclude large swaths of the sector. For instance, “controversial weapons” are unjustifiable in an ESG portfolio because these weapons – which include biological, chemical and incendiary weapons, white phosphorus, landmines, cluster bombs, depleted uranium and nuclear weapons outside of the international non-proliferation treaty – are often used in ways that violate human rights. For example, landmines and cluster munitions have been used over and over to kill civilians, whether intentionally or not. Although there is some debate over what should be considered a controversial weapon or not, a good starting point is to stick to the definitions in international treaties (Convention on Cluster Munitions, Ottawa Convention on the Prohibition of Anti-Personal Mines, Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, Chemicals Weapon Convention, and the Biological Weapons Convention).
Another exclusionary filter that should be applied relates to Governance. The defense sector is notorious for operating behind closed doors and entertaining an incestuous relationship with the government. It was recently revealed that as of 2021, 672 former Pentagon, Congress and other Government Agencies’ officials were working for the top 20 defense contractors, with the vast majority – 91 percent – effectively lobbying the very government they formerly worked for. This revolving door between the military-industrial complex and government agencies is perfectly correlated with the government contracts these companies receive. In 2021 and 2022, Lockheed Martin, Boeing, Raytheon, General Dynamics, and Northrop Grumman – also known as the “Defense Primes” – were the top 5 federal defense contractors in the U.S. and they also had some of the highest numbers of “revolving door hires” out of the top 20 contractors. Between the five of them, they provided 60% of the total lobbying money spent by more than 200 companies in the defense industry in 2022.
This defense oligopoly is a problem for ESG investors. Half a century ago, the U.S. relied on 50 major arms contractors, but a massive consolidation has brought that number down to five – the Defense Primes. This concentration of defense technology expertise only gives the Pentagon few choices of where to go for the production of major weapons systems, raising the risk of price hikes and irresponsible behavior when it comes to delivering weapons that can perform as advertised (e.g. Lockheed Martin’s F-35 saga).
Now that we have determined that ESG-minded investors should probably avoid the Defense Primes altogether, what criteria should be considered to gain exposure to the sector while respecting basic responsible investment principles?
First, controversial weapons should be avoided at all costs. Second, companies working with both civilian and government clients are better protected in case of massive government policy changes following an election or even a severe austerity plan. Finally, according to SASB, the material ESG elements for the Aerospace & Defense Industry are: Energy Management, Hazardous Waste Management, Data Security, Product Safety, Fuel Economy & Emissions in Use-phase, Materials Sourcing, and Business Ethics. Companies which score well in these categories could therefore be interesting candidates for inclusion in ESG portfolios.
These five companies – the SMS Secondary Defense Contractors – all happen to be Europeans. Due to the level of ESG maturity in Europe, this should not come as a surprise. American companies in the defense industry are more likely to be involved in controversial weapons and suffering from a low score with regard to business ethics and transparency.
From a stock performance perspective, the SMS Secondary Defense Contractors basket underperformed the S&P 500 and the Defense Primes for most of the last 5 years but outperformed massively since the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Although some macro factors partially explain why the European names contained in the Secondary Defense Contractors basket did so well since October 2022 (e.g. optimistic easing calendar, consistently strong earnings, etc.) these companies are also more directly involved in the global efforts to supply Ukraine with state-of-the-art military equipment.
With Price to earnings ratios in-line with the general market – the S&P 500 P/E is about 19 – but a growth perspective more attractive than the rest of the market thanks in part to the defense spending having been increased. Timing could therefore still be on the side of an ESG investors wanting to add some defense-exposed companies to her portfolio. Leonardo S.p.a. and Rheinmetall AG could be particularly interesting due to their valuation and contract pipelines.