While we are all sinners, some of us sin (or have sinned) much more than your average citizen, which typically empowers sectors such as pornography, weapons, alcohol, gambling, tobacco, etc. In this context, many ESG-minded investors who invest with their values typically look to avoid sin sectors. The problem with sins is that 1) the list grows by the day and 2) emerging sectors such as private prisons and internet gaming are also rapidly becoming part of an ESG-minded investor “no-no” list.
Today’s note looks back at some of our sins and at our “sin basket” themes. We evaluate the current opportunities to short some of them – in life but also in portfolios.
A first consideration is that over the past year, the pandemic has created a variety of societal pressures that have led to an increase in undesirous behavior. For instance, there has been a significant uptick in crime involving shootings as well as substance abuse rates. It seems that markets have also caught up with these trends: most traditional sin stocks having outperformed the S&P 500 since the beginning of the year.
On guns, a slew of shootings have occurred (up 30% over 2020 so far this year) and gun sales have also flared up at almost the same pace as shootings. To this end, profits of pure-play listed gunmakers have soared. As a result, we expect gun sales to continue to increase in the near-term. This should support stocks such as VSTO US (Vista Outdoors), SWBI US (Smith and Wesson) and RGR US (Sturm Ruger & Co), making it difficult to implement a short position at this point.

The fact that gun violence is treated as a U.S. public health issue – an epidemic in fact – and that the current administration is committed to rein it in has also encouraged Americans to exert their second amendment right. We think this trend will continue for some time as legislative action in Congress remains blockaded by Republican legislators. For these reasons, our naturally inclined short position on gun makers would hardly produce a result at this point. Nonetheless, we will monitor developments closely and wait for a more appropriate entry point. A trigger to our short position could occur when and if Republicans take back control of the Senate following the 2022 Mid-Term elections.
A second, perhaps more contextually appropriate short idea, could be to look at the private prisons theme in the United States. Here again, the current administration takes a radically different approach than the previous one in the way the Federal Administration and U.S. States should handle those who have truly sinned. The Biden administration is looking to terminate private prison contracts over the next few months. That said, a recent deferral court ruling over California’s private prison ban currently is supporting stock prices of private prison companies such as CXW US (CoreCivic) and GEO US (GEO Group). We do not think this is sustainable given the overarching political context and the need to reform the criminal justice system in the United States.
While the sector remains cheap and some of these companies still present strong fundamentals from a ‘value’ perspective (long-term PPP contracts, low P/E, etc.), we feel that the recent surge in equity prices in this sector are unwarranted given the political sensitivity of the private prison issue.
The equity market remains strongly short of CoreCivic and GEO Group, and this trend is unlikely trend to change anytime soon. A key risk would be that either of these two companies could be taken private at a higher multiple by a private equity group that is not too fussy about the social issues associated with the private prison theme.
What is the Crypto Space? Blockchain, cryptocurrencies, stable coins backed by traditional assets, a disintermediation tool, an anonymous medium of exchange for criminals, a tool of amusement for Elon Musk or maybe something else.
The two trends the financial media is getting excited about are ESG (as are we), and Crypto, more specifically Bitcoin. For Crypto, the hype often reduces the discussion to superficial analysis and binary beliefs. Notwithstanding the hyperbole, there is a massive potential for finance, health care, law and product tracing to improve exactness, speed and costs from blockchain. While the hype remains elevated these days for all things Crypto – it seems that its interest as a “world-ending” monetary debasement trade could fade.
That said, the brainpower attracted to the space due to its potential applications holds significant hope for developments to rival the impact of the Internet. Since our last note on the topic (“An ESG Building Block(chain) for your Portfolio?”, October 18, 2018), there has been tremendous activity in the Crypto space but very little visibility on significant developments with life-changing effects. Reminiscent of the Dot-com craze, get-rich quick schemes are a natural consequence. The winners of the space are not known in advance. Few people thought that an online bookstore like Amazon would dominate retail commerce 20 years later. Our view is that the number of survivors will be few, the big winners even fewer, but they could change our world.
Michael Saylor, the president of MicroStrategy and a big proponent of Crypto, has some of the most savoury quotes about Bitcoin: “Bitcoin is a bank in cyberspace, run by incorruptible software, offering a global, affordable, simple and secure savings account to billions of people that don’t have the option or desire to run their own hedge fund.” One of the reasons why the Crypto world is concentrating on finance is because the industry has a lot of monopolistic rents in areas such as trade settlement for public markets or private transactions such as real estate. T+2 or T+3 trade settlement for public securities does not align with instantaneous trading. But just like Kodak Eastman developed digital pictures but fought it to its grave to protect its existing business, financial innovation faces barriers emanating from within the financial system itself.
The chart above shows the extent of Cryptos issuance. More widespread adoption has led to general price increases, but also, many dodgy coins are already dead. This may remind history buffs of wildcat banking in the United States during the Free Banking Era when the country did not have a central bank. Back then, many shady banks operated scams by issuing their own currency back then, dispossessing unsuspecting individuals just like now for Coins.
Two other interesting quotes from Michael Saylor: “The signal is monetary expansion everywhere. The problem is people are going to lose half their wealth in a few years. The solution is Bitcoin. The rest is noise.”, and “The destiny of money is to be encrypted.” Bitcoin was launched on January 3, 2009, just a few months before the launch of quantitative easing by the Federal Reserve in March of 2009. Like previous currency regimes, the floating-currency regime may come to an end at some point (likely in a period of crisis) but to insinuate it is happening already is a stretch. The second quote again underscores an increasingly popular view; the fiat currency will necessarily be replaced by a digital one. Again, we find that it is a stretch to assume that a digital currency will necessarily be the natural replacement.
The chart above shows the market capitalization of cryptocurrencies since 2017 compared to the size of the Federal Reserve balance sheet. When crypto investors realized that the balance sheet was stable or shrinking from 2018 to 2020, the action stopped. Once the Fed’s balance sheet expanded again in 2020, Coins followed. The growing balance sheet of the Federal Reserve is lifting many boats and fostering financial opportunism. Crypto is benefiting from both. Its price behaves like a risky asset and the space is full of opportunists.
The above chart shows the legal treatment of cryptocurrencies around the world. As adoption in the global population increases, countries will need to determine their legal status. With more countries looking to launch e-currencies backed by their own currency like China did this year, the potential for wider popular adoption and financial disintermediation is growing.
From an ESG perspective, other quotes from Michael Saylor caught our attention.
“Bitcoin is the most efficient system in the history of mankind for channeling energy through time and space.”
“Bitcoin links together 8 billion people, links together a hundred million companies, it synchronizes the world across political jurisdictions, and it returns rationality to the entire financial system, and it returns freedom and property rights to the entire human race.”
“Imagine a world where everyone used something fair & equitable to settle their economic differences.”
“Bitcoin is a swarm of cyber hornets serving the goddess of wisdom, feeding on the fire of truth, exponentially growing ever smarter, faster, and stronger behind a wall of encrypted energy.”
These quotes lead one to believe that Bitcoin is the holy grail for the environment, for social health and for improved governance. We do not adhere to this view. As of now, there are many issues that need to be resolved with Bitcoin and Crypto in general.
From an environmental perspective, the proof-of-work method of confirmation that requires tremendous amount of energy is destroying the environment. Currently, more than half of all cryptos is mined in China where the energy sources shift from hydro to coal depending on the season. This is not green.
From a social perspective, access to crypto is clearly not for everyone because it requires technical knowledge, is very volatile and therefore finance has not been democratized for now. Using the blockchain for medical information could mark a major leap but it is not in wide use currently. In the same vein, tracking property title for real estate transactions could be dramatically improved for everyone. The time, cost and effort devoted to confirming transactions could be drastically reduced and simplified. Imagine the productivity benefits, if a country like India, where it is unbelievably complex and takes a very long time to acquire a property, used the blockchain to trace title information. Tremendous potential practical applications to improve social conditions exist though it is hard to find many that are currently in advanced development stages (i.e., are investable today).
From a governance angle, the decentralized nature of cryptocurrencies brings added freedom. On the other hand, cryptocurrencies do not have a mechanism to penalize unethical or harmful behavior.
Detractors of ESG investing like to point out that the growth in ESG assets is mainly due to investors willing to overpay for stocks at a given level of profitability. Sceptics might say that the premium is not really warranted and that it is all hype. However, there are also fundamental reasons, such as lower non-financial risks, that would justify fundamentally higher valuations for ESG branded companies. Nonetheless, we wanted to find out if ESG portfolios were outperforming mostly due to P/E ratio expansion, rather than hard-earned EPS growth. We decided to go and find out for ourselves, by looking at the drivers of global equity returns in recent years based on their ESG ratings. To do that we simply decompose the total return of S&P 1200 stocks into changes in trailing P/Es, trailing EPS (which includes the effect of buybacks), and dividends. We group these stocks into three categories by industry-adjusted consensus ESG scores, which aggregate the ratings of different ESG data providers. Securities are aggregated in each group using free float adjusted market cap. Despite some missing data, our resulting stock universe covers about 90% of the S&P 1200 market cap, which itself represents 70% of the global market cap.
We look at the 2 years before COVID-19 began, (2018 and 2019), when ESG equity flows started accelerating and global P/E ratios were falling from their early-2018 highs. It turns out that stocks with higher ESG scores (top 33% of stocks by ESG score) did outperform thanks to rising valuations. However, the P/E return boost was only relative: the higher the ESG score the lower the fall in trailing P/E ratios was, but P/Es fell nonetheless.
Since COVID-19 started hitting the global economy in early 2020, stocks with good ESG ratings (top 33%) have actually had less P/E expansion (19%) than the overall universe (21%), while their EPS and dividend return contributions were in line with the broader universe. It is hard to notice any sign of a global ESG bubble in equities since 2020, contrary to popular belief.
At the other end of the spectrum, low-rated ESG stocks have been the worst performing group since 2020: they are the only group with negative EPS contribution (-10%) and the worst performer out of our 3 stocks groups. The best-performing group, in terms of both EPS and total returns, was the middle-ground group of stocks with average ESG scores, which was overweight Communication Services (Facebook, Alphabet, Tencent, Walt Disney), and underweight Health Care and IT. Regionally, it was also overweight the U.S. and Japan.
We can also use total return decomposition to identify pockets of potential ESG bargains: stocks with good ESG scores, which have trailed their industry due to slower P/E expansion rather than lower EPS growth. One of these pockets of ESG opportunities lies in US industrial stocks, where well-ESG rated firms have trailing their sector in total return terms since the beginning of 2020, while having more resilient earnings. A portfolio of the top 33% US industrials by ESG scores includes no airlines and is overweight road & rail companies. We would focus particularly on rail companies in light of the recent Biden administration’s infrastructure plan, which is calling to “invest $80 billion to address Amtrak’s repair backlog; modernize the high traffic Northeast Corridor; improve existing corridors and connect new city pairs; and enhance grant and loan programs that support passenger and freight rail safety, efficiency, and electrification.”
In Japan, a DM industrial powerhouse, industrial stock returns have been largely proportional to their ESG ratings, with top rated firms beating the overall Industrials sector by almost 10pp since the end of 2019, while ESG laggards trailed by just as much. This recent ESG outperformance in Japanese industrial stocks has mostly been driven by P/E expansion, which makes US industrials more attractive in comparison. Japanese machinery exporters also benefited from a strong Chinese industrial rebound over the past year, while in 2021 the US will be the main global growth engine.
Finally, another cyclical ESG play can be found in European consumer discretionary stocks. With a slower vaccine rollout than in US and Europe-wide rescue funds that have not yet fully been allocated, the pent-up demand and cyclical outperformance story has further to run in European stocks. Interestingly, European consumer discretionary names with higher ESG scores have had their trailing earnings even more affected by the pandemic than the sector average: their combined net income fell by 78% (!) since the end of 2019 vs. 71% for the sector average. Investors were clearly unhappy with this and respective P/E ratios were also more penalized than European Industrials as a whole. We believe that this development only makes the case even stronger for a European Consumer Discretionary rebound led by well-rated ESG stocks. This top 33% European industrial stocks by ESG scores is underweight autos and hotels, overweight retail, and neutral on apparel.
As ESG investors, sportswear companies are generally not attractive as they often thrive on environment-damaging fast fashion. However, in terms of inspiration, they do come up with the catchiest slogans that we use to illustrate our topic this week.
Impossible is nothing (Adidas). We saw an unimaginably successful vaccine response. Prior to coronavirus COVID-19, no mRNA-based drug or vaccine had been licensed for use in humans and many pharmaceuticals were abandoning the technology. Now, the two mRNA vaccines are the most sought after. Excitement is palpable for curing some forms of cancer. Hopefully, this will be a spark for healthcare as a whole.
Forever faster (Puma). Improving productivity in the sector is required to keep the overall cost reasonable compared to other sectors. During the pandemic, experimentation was a necessity and it spurred ingenuity. Telehealth was live tested and holds large productivity improvement potential. Covid testing techniques will be applied to other existing health issues. Large-scale vaccine was deployed quickly and illustrated what can be accomplished. Device companies were involved in all of those aspects and will be a large part of the solution for productivity improvements with longer and healthier lives. For example, next-generation sequencing technology enabling streamlined research workflow for complete viral genome sequencing for SARS-CoV-2 were critical during this past year.
Reach beyond (Mizuho). Better health for longer at a reasonable cost; this is the goal.
I am what I am (Reebok). As people age, health issues occur naturally. All OECD countries witnessed an increase in the percentage of their population over 65 years old. Japan had the biggest increase with 11% more seniors than in 2000 for a total of 28% of its population. This trend will continue for the foreseeable future. Demographics change slowly. You cannot create a new 20-year-old. Health care needs will grow accordingly.
Health care costs are already a substantial and rising portion of most economies. If countries want to control spending, while still offering adequate health services to its population, then the equation that needs to be optimized is the occurrence of illnesses multiplied by the average cost of treating such illnesses. Rich nations tend to have higher rates of spending, with average spending around 10% of GDP. The United States is an outlier; at roughly 17% of GDP, health care spending is higher here due primarily to higher prices.
The fastest growing risk factors of death globally are all correlated to excess weight (high blood pressure, high blood sugar and obesity). This is not a rich world problem, many countries in South America and the Middle East are at the top of this unenviable list of countries.
In 1990, only 9 countries had more than 15% of death directly linked to obesity, but this figure increased to 51 countries by 2017. Contrary to general opinion, the United States is yet part of the group. Its obesity-linked death percentage jumped from 11% to 14% from 2000 to 2017. Globally, 13% of adults are obese with a body mass index over 30.
The reasons behind the rise in obesity and its health problems are complex and are beyond the scope of this report. Suffice to say, both the socioeconomic factors and individual behaviors involved in obesity are long-term and difficult to change.
Habits can change but it usually takes time. For this reason, companies active in health care have a positive long-term tailwind because an older and heavier population means more clients.
Sound mind, sound body (Asics). Prevention is the best tool to reduce the occurrence of illness. We have written about improving nutrition to improve health (see our notes “Veganomics: greening your plate and your portfolio”, May 9, 2019 and “Health is the New Wealth”, November 12, 2020) where we identified companies we expect to be winners and losers from the sustainable long-term investing trend of healthier living.
This is what it feels like (Under Armour). Apart from prevention, the next best things one can hope for are early detection to reduce the damage once an illness occurs, better effectiveness of the different remedies, and continued surveillance of the situation. Health care medical devices companies have a very strong fundamental edge in addressing the multiple issues for delivery of services.
Power Style (Fila). Detection, effectiveness and continued surveillance all benefit from greater utilization of medical devices and technological improvement. Telemedicine, behavioral science to improve health, artificial intelligence to improve diagnostics, genomics, and 3-D printing are amongst new approaches progressively deployed. They are no longer dreams and opportunities for future medical advances seem infinite.
Companies that provide medical devices have participated in the evolution of healthcare with clear innovations and strong financial performance. The high relative cost for health care of the United States has resulted in domination of the global health care devices market by US companies. The devices bring large productivity gains but have also benefitted from a generous pricing system. We never hear about a medical device in US industrial policy but the results are similar to China’ technology industrial policy where the sheer size of their market and some barriers to entry have created champions that use their home base to compete globally. The company names are not as well known as in other sectors but they have a large revenue base and provide a lot of well-paying jobs, according to ZipRecruiter.com, the average annual pay in the medical device industry is slightly above $78,000. Growth in revenues has been strong and looks to remain strong for the foreseeable future.
In the United States, Medicare is important for medical device companies. In their February 2021 paper “Getting the Right Price? The Impact of Competitive Bidding Program”, the authors found that the introduction of a competitive bidding program for durable medical equipment reduced the cost of the equipment by close to 50%. Similar processes will likely be expanded to cut costs. Although this could slow the tailwind of the industry for a period, it will not jeopardize its long-term outlook.
Time to play (Salomon). The SMS Health Care Devices Index has outpaced the health care sector as well as the stock market in general over the last five years. With an ageing population that will need more care and the need for productivity improvement in the sector, we expect health care devices company to continue to outpace the overall market.
Perhaps the most surprising element of the U.S. administration’s call for a global minimum corporate tax is that it took so long to happen. Despite its bad reputation with the general public, tax avoidance has long been tolerated – if not even encouraged – by some OECD countries (e.g., Ireland). Others, such as France and the U.K. – who benefit from the proximity of complacent tax jurisdictions (Monaco and the Channel Islands, respectively) still support their high-earning companies (and individuals) in the fiercely competitive global economic game through such tax avoidance schemes.
It also seems that the IMF and other organizations are now all out about tax collection to finance monster COVID-related deficits – and they are now championing global cooperation on the issue. The good news is that similar to the fiscal and monetary response given to the COVID crisis, we see a high chance that governments will cooperate more seriously on the issue of tax evasion and tax avoidance to fund ever-growing government deficits.
In a note last year (see “ESG investors vs. the taxman”, January 9, 2020), we foresaw such an increase in America’s corporate tax rates following Trump’s fiscally unsustainable cuts of December 2017. The increase in corporate taxes is also on the radar as corporate America expects a solid earnings’ year from the COVID boost to several industries (Construction, Materials, Tech, etc.).
While many welcomed the previous White House’s reduction of the U.S.’ corporate tax rate to 21% – in-line with other developed countries – it seems that the new world in which we are living is asking for much stronger action, i.e. a substantial increase in corporate “tax effort”. In our note of last week (see “Working-class hero”, April 8, 2021), we underlined the decreasing tax effort of American corporations since 1950 as a share of GDP. It seems that governments are giving in to the “populist” impression that Big Business is not paying its fair share – and they are right.
In our note of January 2019, we had also suggested ESG-minded investors to engage with their investee companies on the issue – albeit a very delicate one for the asset management industry. Indeed, financials are often pointed as serial tax avoiders and important users of tax heavens to preserve profit margins. We also underlined that sectors most exposed to a change-of-tack in U.S. corporate tax policy were chemicals, hospitality, casinos, and tech sectors.
That said, investors – which are typically much more avid of tax cuts than they are about tax hikes – benefitted largely from Trump’s tax policies. In fact, the S&P 500 increased by about 7% in late 2017 following the enactment of Trump’s corporate tax plan.
Interestingly, the P/E ratio of the S&P 500 decreased following the tax cut announcement in a context of strong growth and a tight labor market.
While Biden’s tax plan will first target a 15% minimum tax rate on profits for companies in “high tax avoidance” industries with a minimum of USD 100 million of revenue, some sectors and industries will suffer more than others. In our view, sectors with high earnings’ yield and low effective tax rates could suffer some level of reputational risk as the Biden administration looks to re-tax corporate America.
One other way to look at where the IRS will find its “fiscal nuggets” is to look at corporate America’s “fiscal space” – i.e. its tax “effort” as a percentage of EBIT. Here, and perhaps surprisingly, one sees that cash paid in taxes as a percent of EBIT can represent a substantial portion of EBIT in industries such as apparel, hospitality, and systems software.
Conversely, the IRS could look for some corporate fiscal space in industries such as semiconductors, steel and passthrough structures such as REITs which display a much higher potential of being re-taxed.
Finally, Biden’s re-tax plan also sheds light on the current level of corporate welfare – which will likely come under greater scrutiny in the coming months. Here, the rather interventionist Biden administration will likely give back some of the money it will take through taxes to corporations that are in harmony with the agenda of the government.
According to the GoodJobsFirst NGO, subsidies to America’s 20 biggest “corporate welfare queens” amounted to more than USD 80 billion last year. This is something that certainly will be looked at by policymakers as they re-tax corporations in the months to come and unwind the unprecedented level of public support provided to corporates this past year.
Last week’s disastrous IPO of Deliveroo, another UK-based online delivery food company that offers poor working conditions to its “associates” is a sign that bad worker treatment may have met its Waterloo. Moreover, the attempt for unionization by Amazon’s workers in Bessemer, Alabama, is another indication that the tide may be turning in favor of workers.
From an ESG standpoint, we should be putting greater emphasis on worker treatment when evaluating the prospects of a company. Not only is this appropriate from a long-term sustainability standpoint, but it will likely coincide with a change in attitude from governments with regard to taxation, regulations and incentives.
Using CSRHub data, we looked at employee treatment scores for very large employers in the United States to see how it evolved over time. Employers like Home Depot, Kroger and Walmart are ranking among the better companies and have improving scores for the way they treat their employees. At the other end, gig economy companies like Uber, Lyft and Herbalife have very poor scores with no signs of improvement as we can see from the table below which shows data as of the end of 2020.
Employee treatment scores are yet to be released for DoorDash and Deliveroo as they have become public during the last year but we expect results similar to other gig economy companies. DoorDash has been called the worst of the gig companies by commentators for the payout Dashers receive.
The business model of Uber, Lyft, DoorDash and Deliveroo, where barriers of entry are low, seem to be predicated on poor conditions for employees in exchange for work flexibility. Herbalife has a different business model that focuses on recruitment more than on product sales. Close to 90% of Herbalife distributors make no money and the distributors at the top of the food chain benefit the most as they get a percentage of what their recruits purchase. Its checkered legal past and the 2016 movie Betting on Zero have permanently labelled the company as being controversial from a working condition standpoint.
Over the last two years, the poor performers from a worker treatment point of view have slightly trailed the good performers with much greater volatility. While no clear conclusion can be reached from this graph as the companies that comprise the SMS Good Working Conditions Index are larger and more stable than those in the SMS Bad Working Conditions Index, we think that going forward, a wedge could appear between both indices as markets start rewarding good performers over laggards. It is also interesting to see how both sets of companies reacted during the Covid crisis, with the “good” companies being a lot more resilient to the drawdown than the “bad” companies.
It’s been a hard day’s night for workers over the last 40 years as their share of total income in the United States has gone down consistently. The usual culprits of globalization and technological improvements are well-recognized but industry consolidation and intellectual property rules are also significant and they have been found to reduce competition which has favoured capital over labor.
At the same time, the share of US corporate profits after tax has gone up to compensate. Moreover, the share of corporate income taxes has gone in the opposite direction. Owners of capital have been handsomely rewarded with greater profits and less taxes to the relative detriment of workers. The rise of political activism for more fairness, nationalism and populism attests to the need for better distribution of wealth and a relative shift to wage-earners.
“She works hard for the money, so you better treat her right” is echoed by President Biden’s words last week when he said: “I’m a union guy, I support unions. Unions built the middle class, it’s about time they get a piece of the action.”

As we can see from the table above, nearly half of the U.S. total working population makes less than $30,000 per year. The middle class has been gutted. The United States has the worst GINI index, a measure of income disparity between citizens, amongst developed economies. This is unsustainable.
Right after its election, the new administration has pushed hard to support people by passing a huge stimulus bill along party lines. Unsurprisingly, the cash handouts provisions included in the bill are proving very popular with the electorate. The bill also made an aggressive proposal for infrastructure spending that aims to create jobs while increasing taxes for corporations and the wealthy. It is not clear how the proposal will turn out just yet but what we see it is that there is a clear attempt to better redistribute wealth.
The trend to prioritize jobs and wages over profits and fiscal rectitude will continue – especially if we consider that the White House now has on staff Janet Yellen and Cecilia Rouse, respectively Treasury Secretary and Chair of the Council of Economic Advisers, both well-known labor economists who’ve made labor issues a hallmark of their academic careers. In our view, after Covid, the job market may not go back to working 9 to 5 but we see a good chance that the administration will favor companies that are good job creators and will make life difficult for companies that are taking advantage of employees.
If, as we expect, labor starts to be favored by governments and regulators, there will be winners and losers and the relative performance will start to diverge and companies that treat their employees poorly will be on the losing end. ESG investors would be well-advised to consider worker treatment as a key performance metrics.
Municipal bonds in the United States are typically non-taxable. The economic logic for exemption is that it encourages investments in projects that benefit the collectivity. There is an ongoing debate as to the usefulness of the tax-exempt status of municipal bonds. Detractors argue that most of the benefits associated to tax-exempt muni bond issues go to the rich living in high income tax states with little left to the issuer.
As the global consensus evolves towards fighting climate change aggressively and the need for greater community-level involvement, many countries could get inspiration from the municipal bond market in the United States. For now, ESG investors looking to support impact projects can easily build a diversified portfolio in line with their desired credit and duration characteristics.
The table below details this week’s list of issuers with more than 100 million to finance. Most of the bonds issued have maturities that span the next 20 years making portfolio construction flexible.
To establish if investments have a positive impact, we have found the Impact Management Project methodology very useful and intuitive. The Impact Management Project is a forum for building global consensus on how to measure and manage impact and has contributors across the spectrum of the ESG community. It proposes an approach that focuses on the 17 Sustainable Development Goal of the United Nations and their 169 targets for 2030.
![]()
The first step of the methodolgy is to identify the impact and determining if it is important (What). The second step is to determine if the recipient is underserved (Who) then the goal is to measure the size of the effect and the duration (How much) and finally to see if the effect would have happened anyway (Contribution) and the risk if it does not happen (Risk).
The next step is to determine the degree to which there is an impact.
Using this approach, we have developped a star-system with the most impactful investments receiving 5 stars and the least impactful receiving no star.
We have applied this system to the largest non-taxable issuers for this week and have found that 7 of 13 received 5 stars meaning they have a significant impact and another 3 received 4 stars.
For example, our analysis shows that Regional Transportation District of Colorado – which is issuing USD 298 millions worth of green bonds (climate bond certified) merits the 5-star classification from our rating system. Its issuance supports SDG 11.2 that aims to provide access to safe, affordable, accessible and sustainable transport for all and improve road safety. Here again, the issuer’s operations have a positive impact on SDG 7.2 which seeks to increase substantially the share of renewable energy in the global energy mix with the Electric Free Mall Ride Shuttles that uses batteries and regenerative braking. Finally, the issuer’s activities also impacts 6.3 which pertains to the improvement of water quality by reducing pollution and reducing untreated wastewater with its stormwater management program.
For the sake of simplicity, we have concentrated our analysis on one week of issuance using the largest non-taxable issuers. We have found that a portfolio using only 4-stars and 5-stars issuers covers 6 of the 17 SDG and can meet the needs of most investors with advantageous tax treatment. With that in mind, a US taxable ESG investor can build a truly diversified portfolio simply by participating in the most impactful municipal issuances.
Interestingly, while we often hear that the United States is behind the curve in terms of ESG compared to Europe, the tax-exempt muni market provides an interesting opportunity for taxable investors. As a result, when it comes to fixed income for taxable individuals, the U.S. muni market has a variety of solutions that do not exist elsewhere for ESG-minded investors.
With the Biden administration looking to pass its large stimulus plan that would shore up the finance of states and the administration intent on fighting climate change, we expect to see significant issuance with positive impact characteristics.
For those looking to achieve impact and earn extra return, allocating a greater share of their fixed income (FI) portfolio to supranational paper could make sense. As it happens, the fallout of the global COVID crisis will likely generate massive lending from supranational institutions such as the IBRD (World Bank), EBRD (European Bank for Reconstruction and Development), IDB (InterAmerican Development Bank), and other International Financial Institutions (IFIs) – which also happen to specialize in impact lending for developing countries.
As a reminder, these institutions typically attach strings to the loans they make to governments enticing their sovereign clients to make progress in areas such as health care, education, and climate change. As a result, supranational bonds offer an interesting way of leveraging IFI impact frameworks towards measurable results while improving and diversifying your overall bond portfolio. More importantly, as the COVID crisis will likely linger in several of the world’s poorest nations, financial lifelines from IFIs will become even more important to sustain the fight against the virus and its economic repercussions.
One interesting class of bonds we have identified back in 2018 (see our note “World Bank bonds: A “macro” impact Opportunity”, October 10th, 2018) were IBRD (World Bank) bonds. Overall, the Bloomberg Barclays World Bank Global Aggregate Index has outperformed USTs since 2012, with 300+ bps of outperformance on an aggregate, total return basis. With 10-year USTs trading below 1% amid aggressive QE operations from the Fed, such an outperformance could continue to benefit even the most conservative bond portfolios.
Looking at duration, World Bank bonds started to display a lower duration than their USTs equivalents before the COVID crisis. When the Fed starts to normalize its policy, one can expect WB bonds to become interesting once again from a duration perspective.
Interestingly, the spread between both indices compressed substantially until March 2020, time at which the Fed reignited its QE purchases. While the spread increased significantly these past few months, we would expect it to resume its path towards zero as an increasing amount of impact and search-for-yield investors increase their allocation to IBRD paper in the coming months and years and the Fed starts to reduce its monthly purchases of USTs.
Impact investors’ effect on the IBRD yield curve and spreads against USTs is especially visible if one considers the change in IBRD/UST spreads at every maturity. One could also expect that the IBRD yield curve spread will continue to compress given the relative health of the IBRD’s credit outlook versus that of the U.S. Treasury – which has not yet finished to pick up the US fiscal AND COVID policy messes. To this end, IBRD paper is rated at lesser credit risk (AAA) than the USTs (AA+) while the institution’s balance sheet is solidly diversified and backstopped by the Banks’s contributing members.
Many market participants have entered the IBRD Green bond market. The institution increased its green bond issuance program these past few years and we expect those trends to continue in 2021. While many Green bonds displayed even more spread compression against their comparable non-green issues given strong demand and limited offer, the “greenium” mostly disappeared in FI markets these past few months.
Looking ahead, we expect the liquidity on IBRD benchmark bonds to increase as the World Bank increases its own lending to its developing country clients post-COVID. Moreover, an increasing number of search-for-yield and impact investors will continue to enter the supranational market, which should help reduce bid-ask spreads of IBRD paper and make IBRD bonds a staple holding within diversified portfolios. Finally, the recent reflation trade and growing inflation expectations in the U.S. should also signal that U.S. bond yield have perhaps touched the bottom these past few weeks.