When a 2018 Supreme Court ruling reversed the decision to outlaw sports gambling in the U.S., state governments and sports leagues saw dollar signs. State governments saw an easy path to higher tax revenues. Sports leagues backtracked on a long-held stance that sports betting was bad for the integrity of the game and made sponsorship deals with gambling companies in hopes of reaching new levels of engagement in their respective sports. As of the beginning of 2022, thirty states have legalized betting and numerous sports teams have inked advertising deals. This has led to strong growth in the betting industry, but at what cost?
Why Gambling is Currently a Growing Industry
The history of gambling in the United States goes back to the first settlers in the colonies. Periods of greater acceptance are generally followed by retrenchment under moral grounds. We are currently in a phase of acceptance. Right now, the winners (casino operators and taxing authorities) promote their effect on local job creation with success while the losers (gamblers with impulse issues and their families) are not visible.
The graph below shows the growth in revenues for the U.S. sports gambling industry and tax authorities since the Supreme Court ruling. As more states allow sports gambling, revenues are growing fast and collected taxes are following.
California is set to vote on legalization of sports betting in November 2022. Following that, Texas is the next big target. Those two states are among the last growth opportunities. The road may be narrower with more competition for entertainment dollars following the end of lockdowns.
The graph below highlights the evolution of the monthly wagers in the United States as a whole since 2018. With more new states legalizing sports gambling, the amounts placed have definitely been on an uptrend.
Socio-economic Problems of Gambling
As the U.S. ramps up its gambling activities, the UK is cracking down. Sports gambling was already legal in the UK when betting opportunities began to be available on smart phone apps. Through this head start, Britain has already started to see the consequences of easier access to sports betting. Online casinos make most of their money with a small percentage of their gamblers. Over the last 20 years in the UK, problem gambling has been measured to affect 1 out of 200 gamblers and 7% of adults are negatively impacted by their own gambling or those of a family member. One UK study shows that online gambling losses are very skewed towards deprived areas. The industry typically praises upon the poor, many with mental health and self-esteem issues. After all, gambling is a zero-sum game, it does not improve productivity. For the gamblers, it is a negative-sum game because of operational fees, taxes and profits of the service provider (gambling app/casino).
It is one thing to allow gambling, but relentlessly promoting it is another. The same complacency does not apply to other addictions prone industries like alcohol and tobacco, which have heavily regulated advertising. The UK has started to address this issue with restrictions on the timing and amount of gambling ads. In 2018, fearing a stronger crackdown, gambling companies voluntarily agreed to a ‘whistle-to-whistle’ ban on advertising. In April of this year, new rules were approved to limit marketing tactics appealing to younger demographics. Additionally, a white paper to be presented at British Parliament could see the removal of betting sponsorship of Premier League teams. While it is early days in the U.S.’s relationship with sports betting and sponsorship, one should anticipate that regulation is coming.
Evolution of Gambling Culture
While legal changes triggered the sports betting boom, it was further amplified by the mood during pandemic lockdowns. There are some surprising examples highlighting the desire to bet for the sake of betting: a pause on major sports leagues resulted in a boon for Russian table tennis; and just this year, Russian gamblers were duped out of their money by wagering on fake cricket matches staged by inhabitants of an Indian village. These behaviors are consistent with the big bump in risk taking or gambling culture across society, over the last couple of years. People have become mesmerized by the possibility of short-term, one-off gains. Gamification of the world went feverish in 2021 when people were looking for anything after the novelty of lockdowns waned: crypto-trading platforms proliferated and Robinhood created a gaming-like experience for small investors. The problem is exacerbated as “players” are pushed by relentless promotion, easy access, the cashless effect and algorithms that know exactly when to prompt to keep someone engaged.
Instant access to everything gets us to only tune in for immediate outcomes. But, in order to reach long-term goals such as improving health care, education and incomes; short-term thinking will fail. Our proximity to planetary boundaries leading to global warming and the current timid response by society is a clear example of this short-termism. The rise of online gambling is an example of an unproductive use of capital.
As the graph below shows, sports betting in the traditional markets of Nevada and New Jersey (where it has been legal since 2018) have not seen a dip in the amount of gambling activity, even with the explosion of betting in new legalized states. This new activity is not coming from gamblers switching from betting in the previous legal states or switching from illegal betting with bookies; it is coming from new gamblers. Timing suggests stymie cheques and lockdowns have also contributed to the rise.
When interest rates were at zero, and stimulus cheques from governments were the norm, this type of zealous behavior was to be expected. However, with recent inflation, the easy money times are coming to an end, as governments and central banks look to tighten their purse. The invisible hand will likely redress the excesses and the gambling culture should erode with time.
Why Most Will Fail?
If we look globally, Asia is a tough market because China is closed off. Europe is a mature market where the excitement has peaked and regulations are being introduced. For now, North America is the wild west as sports betting is becoming legal in most states. The immediate tax revenues and the lack of regulation gives some temporary leeway in this market.
Gambling companies are playing the market capture game with profits far away. As the hype for new entrants peaked in 2021, along with other craziness like SPACS and Crypto fever, the business strategy of PENN and DKNG has not changed much: they are looking to acquire new clients with incentives. We expect consolidations in the industry once high client acquisition costs are recognized and enough pain has been endured. The chart below highlights the share price of the top 4 public online gambling companies in the United States over the last 30 months. Euphoria has been followed by pain, we expect to see some more pain in the future.
The 1% has the potential to change from being the greatest climate change offenders to the leaders; these wealthy individuals have disproportionate climate influence via their roles as consumers, investors and by leveraging their social networks. It is promising that younger members of the 1% are beginning to act in favor of improved environmental outcomes.
Much of the attention about inequality is focused on income and wealth. However, inextricably tied to wealth and income disparity is carbon emissions, both in terms of those who emit (the wealthy) and those who suffer (the poor). The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the UN group responsible for evaluating climate change related matters, has issued a series of science-based reports documenting the impact of climate change on the planet and its inhabitants. Its analysis of how GHG emissions have and will disproportionately hurt the poor is a reminder of inequality in the world, and the responsibility that the richest have for the living conditions of the poorest.
In this note, we provide an overview of the current situation, what systemic approaches can be utilized to improve outcomes and perhaps, most importantly, what investment tools are at the disposal of wealthy individuals to rectify their current carbon footprint.
State of the World Today: In the Eye of the Storm
Just as the top 1% captured 38% of all additional wealth accumulated since the mid-1990s, the production of GHG emissions is also extremely concentrated among a small share of the population: the charts below show that the top 10 per cent of income earners is responsible for close to half of all emissions, whereas the lowest 50 per cent of income earners account for around 7–15 per cent of all emissions. In terms of volume, each member of the 1% on average is responsible for 110 tonnes of CO2 equivalent emissions, compared to only 6.6 tonnes for the median wage earner.
Perhaps even more dramatic, in many rich countries, per capita emissions among the bottom half of emitters have declined since 1990: their current emission levels are close to the 2030 per capita climate targets set by the US, the UK, Germany and France. In contrast, highest emitters continue to do so at ever increasing rates.

Looking forward, if the world is to comply with the Paris agreement to limit warming to 1. 5°C, the wealthiest 1% will need to reduce their current emissions by 97% by 2030. In other words, all emission reductions efforts “should” be made by citizens in the top half of wealth distribution. The climate crisis shows how rich people blow through their “fair share” of carbon emissions.
These statistics underscore that it is overwhelmingly a wealthy minority that is fuelling the climate crisis. But what is it precisely about wealthy individuals that makes their carbon footprint so drastically different? The main culprit is their choices regarding transportation and leisure, and to a lesser extent, their choice of residence(s). The chart below shows the environmental footprint of several high-profile billionaires: although transportation in private jets, helicopters and luxury cars are a well known high-emitting pleasure of the super-rich, yachts are actually the biggest contribution to their mammoth carbon footprint.
Toward a more equal outcome: Policy, People, and Portfolio Impacts
Policy makers are traditionally focused on reducing income inequality, yet for the future of the Earth to be secured, they must shift the focus to addressing carbon inequality.
Carbon inequality differs from income and wealth inequality in that in the case of the latter, the aim of policymakers is generally to increase the income and wealth outcomes of those in the bottom half, without negatively impacting the level of income and wealth of those that are better off. In other words, the goal is to “increase the pie,” and improve the quality of life – as measured in financial terms – for everyone.
Unfortunately, unless consumer preferences change naturally, or unless policymakers devise an improved set of policy tools to impact consumer preferences, increasing the pie for everyone would tragically mean increasing GHG emissions per capita.
Since the bottom half of the population is responsible for only a very small share of carbon emissions, it follows then that in order to be successful, policies must focus on the largest emitters, i.e., wealthier nations and wealthier individuals. Possible solutions include:
Carbon wealth tax: A carbon wealth tax involves applying a supplemental tax to high earners and spending the proceeds on green energy investments and/or other tools that redistribute in favor of lower carbon emitters.
Policy and Consumer Preferences: COVID-19 has shown how rapid lifestyle changes can be brought about by governments, through lockdown periods establishing new routines. While lockdowns are draconian, they highlight that spending patterns can shift meaningfully in the near term when there is a strong government action, or exogenous shock (COVID). Consumer preferences can be shifted by government policies, and this shift is a critical part of addressing the climate crisis. One approach, called Choice Editing, refers to the active process of controlling or limiting the choices available to consumers end goal, specifically by banning or imposing punitive taxation on certain products and services. In the case of forcing habit changes of the super-rich, authorities can restrict carbon-intensive products (like private jets or mega yachts) from coming to the market in the first place, or by taxing specific products so that lower-carbon options are favored. Tax incentives for modifying consumer behavior are a long established part of the policy took kit. For example, in the U.S., there are significant tax incentives for individuals to purchase municipals bonds to help finance local and state governments - these incentives largely help the wealthy and encourage them to direct their wealth to public infrastructure projects and financing the activities of municipalities. It would be reasonable to provide both taxes and tax incentives to shift the consumer preferences of the richest to save the planet.
In theory, both of the above approaches are straightforward. But in practice, both can be difficult to implement and in the case of taxation, difficult to assess the impact. Wealthy individuals not only have outsized financial resources but they also tend to have substantial social resources, meaning that their ability to lobby and influence regulatory incomes is high relative to other socioeconomic groups. Therefore, the likelihood that choice editing would occur in a way that would crimp the lifestyles of the rich and famous is lowered. In any case, there are currently few such restrictive measures in place. A lone exception is the UK labour party’s proposal to ban private jets from airports beginning in 2025. Meanwhile, carbon taxes have, historically, had little impact on the consumption of high-income households since demand inelasticity is greatest among this group.
A third approach in curbing carbon emissions by wealthier households is by targeting non-financial factors of decision-making. Much of consumer behaviour is influenced not only by rational choice regarding prices, but also by other factors including routines, normative influences, and heuristics and biases. Nudge theory is a concept in behavioral economics that proposes positive reinforcement and indirect suggestions as ways to influence the behavior and decision-making of groups or individuals. In other words, it attempts to alter people’s behavior in a predictable way without forbidding any options or significantly changing their economic incentives.
Nudging has been recognised as an effective policy tool to align intention and action in facilitating behavioural change with regard to environmental outcomes, especially in the areas of waste management, energy conservation and sustainable travel. Since high-income individuals are often viewed as role models (influencers) and set the tone to which others aspire, they could play an important positive role in changing consumer behavior at large in favor of “greener lifestyles”.
Generational Shifts: All Hands on Deck
An expected $68 trillion will change hands over the next two decades as part of the “Great Wealth Transfer” from the baby boomer generation (born 1946 - 1964) to millennials (born 1981 - 1996) and Gen Z (born 1997-2012). As the survey data in the Chart below highlights, the latter generations place a stronger importance on environmental issues, suggesting that as this wealth transfer occurs, the likelihood that behavior is more aligned with sustainable consumption will increase.
Moreover, a Deloitte survey shows that millennials and Gen Zs are willing to align their spending with their values: 90% of millennials and Gen Zs are taking action to limit environmental impact and are willing to pay a premium for more sustainable products.
This finding is especially true for the wealthiest of these generations. A 2020 report by Wealth-X exploring global luxury highlights that younger members of the ultra wealthy (defined as those having wealth over $30 M) do not have the same affinity for luxury items as those over 50 years old. They are less likely to own a yacht, private jet, art collection or other asset collection (real estate, cars, watches and jewelry, sports team, etc.) of significant value.
Further impact can be achieved through philanthropic activity. There is approximately US$1.5 trillion dedicated to all philanthropic assets and endowments around the world, but less than 1% was spent on curbing climate change in 2020. Philanthropic spending tends to be centred on health, public safety, community development and education, but since millennials tend to prioritize environmental projects, one can expect that giving to environmental causes will skew favourably in the future.
Finally, millennials are likely to invest in portfolios that are different than their parents and grandparents, by placing greater emphasis on environmental impact relative to financial metrics. This is good news since investments in stocks, bonds, businesses and real estate are disproportionately made by those in the top 1% of income and wealth. Through shifting investments to low-emissions companies and mutual funds, the 1% can push companies to lower GHG emissions and thereby drive structural change. By contrast, investments that favour continuing fossil fuel use will delay emissions reductions.
Central bankers in developed economies have finally woken up to the reality of high and sticky inflation. The Federal Reserve is leading the charge to quell inflation, while the Swiss National Bank and the European Central Bank are projecting an exit from negative interest rates. The Bank of Japan remains on its own course by keeping its yield curve control.
Until May, higher interest rates were mainly affecting high-growth companies but, since then, higher financing and energy costs are slowing the economy and it is progressively being reflected across all sectors and financial markets.
At the end of the first quarter, we published our revised outlook for the year (ESG Meets Macro Shifts: The Outlook for Q2 and Beyond). In today’s note, we are updating our calls, as summarized in the tables at the end of the note.
We see four key developments that will drive equity movements for the next twelve months.
1. Higher interest rates slowing the economy.
After qualifying it as transitory in 2021, central banks are doing their best to regain control of inflation by increasing their overnight rate and projecting future increases along with quantitative tightening. As a result, interest rates of all maturities have risen fast in 2022. Higher interest rates act with a lag on the economy but their impact has been immediately felt on housing and auto sales, sectors heavily dependent on financing.
We still believe that the inflation genie is out of the bottle and that it will average closer to 4% than 2% over the next decade. Contrary to the previous 20 years, higher prices are animating public discourse and the recent increases are shaping consumer behaviour. The record profit margins observed in recent years are under pressure; producer price indices are growing much faster than consumer price indices as can be seen from the graph below. These circumstances generally lead to lower profit margins that pressure companies to slow down new expenses.
In a slowing economy, defensive sectors that have low variability in revenues and earnings like health care and consumer staples tend to shine compared to other segments of the equity market. As financial markets reflect a greater probability of recession, we favor the low growth portion of the graphic below.
Health care has performed exceptionally well in previous bear markets, not just the pandemic-related bear market. In our note of June 2, 2022, “High Impact: Surviving a Recession with Care”, we included the chart below that shows the performance of the health care sector during the previous four bear markets; positive performance in all cases.
2. Stubborn cost pressures from commodities and other factors
The previous decade saw commodity prices fall. Exploration investments followed in the same direction and, as is typical for commodities after such a period, we find ourselves in an uncomfortable supply and demand position where forecasted demand outstrips projected supply. The transformation of industrial processes towards a greener world will also contribute to commodity demand, especially for transition commodities.
Even though a recession may be near, we expect commodity prices to remain elevated. They may fall as we experience a slowdown but any sign of recovery will soon reflect underlying supply issues. Moreover, the relative isolation of Russia from the global economy will continue to menace supply.
Higher commodity prices, continuing supply shocks for goods and tighter labour markets with the retirement of baby-boomers will continue to exert input cost pressures on companies. In our note on May 12, 2022, “Inflation Protecting your ESG Equity Portfolio”, we examined companies that have shown the ability to increase profit margins in a rising cost environment. The table below shows the ESG leaders able to do so.
3. Return on Capital ≤Cost of Capital
The financial system starts to have hiccups when the expected return on capital falls below the cost of capital. Over the last quarter century, we witnessed such an event during the bear market of 2000-2003 for a portion of the economy: high growth companies that could not meet excessive growth expectations. Central banks came to the rescue with interest rate cuts that reduced the cost of capital and re-established confidence that the return on capital of the economy was greater than the cost of capital. We lived through a more dangerous episode from 2007-2009 that started with real estate but propagated to the financial system and the rest of the economy. In this case, a combination of interest rate cuts and asset purchases from central banks and fiscal stimulus to recapitalize the banking system were necessary to re-establish confidence.
The current financial situation has more similarities with the 2000-2003 period where growth expectations for a portion of the economy are unlikely to be met. The banking system is not currently under pressure. The risk lies to the cost of capital part of the equation because, contrary to the previous episodes, inflation is out of control and it is unknown if central banks will have the ability to reduce the cost of capital once the expected return on capital falls below the cost of capital.
Under these circumstances, growth companies should continue to underperform value companies and most forms of private equity (venture capital, growth equity and leveraged buy-outs) should experience much tougher times than the benign conditions of the past decade.
4. Unsustainable Business Model Crash
With financial markets dropping precipitously so far in 2022, business models that rely on cheap access to capital to fund their operations and/or stock options to retain employees as in our note from February 17, 2022, “Buying the dream – Tech Sector stock options at a time of high volatility” are at risk. The graph below shows a list of companies that have aggressive option compensation practices.
Similar to 2000-2003 when the dotcom bubble imploded and financing became more complicated, we expect the situation for companies with financing needs and aggressive compensation approaches to deteriorate further.
A main difference between “impact” investors and “ESG” investors is that the former are primarily looking for companies that have positive impact on the planet, while ESG investing is often about evaluating what impact the world will have on a company. For investors in the first camp – seeking out companies that are transformative – the health care sector is an excellent place to start. After all, health care companies have a straight line to the UN’s Sustainable Development Goal number 3: Ensure healthy lives and promote well-being for all at all ages.
In today’s note, we analyse which parts of the health care industry can help investors maximize their impact, while keeping an eye on financial metrics in this changing macro landscape.
Characterizing Health Care Companies
The way in which securities are classified into asset classes often form the basis of investment decisions. For investors looking to build thematic portfolios, the ability to classify a stock according to specific properties, such as financial characteristics and economic exposures, is critical. Investors looking to build thematic ESG or impact portfolios are in this situation as well.
The Global Industry Classification Standard (GICS) is a well-know classification system that uses a company’s revenue to assign it so an industry and sub-industry. A second well-known classification system – SASB Standards – is used to guide the disclosure of financially material sustainability information by companies to their investors. Under SASB, the industry classification is constructed based on sustainability profiles of companies.
Although frameworks exist to assess projects within some sectors (see here for example), there is no standardized classification for impact yet. Therefore, we have leveraged these two major classification systems to create SMS’ health care sub-sectors to capture the companies that are tackling the most pressing health and wellness challenges. Each of the ten sub-sectors are expected to deliver impact and fall under one of two broad categories: health care innovation and health care access. They are described below:
- Health Care Innovation
Research: Health care companies that are enabling drug discovery and development by either providing analytical tools, clinical trial services and contract research services or by researching and developing products based on genetic analysis and engineering. These companies are typically found at the beginning of the “health care supply chain” and have high rates of R&D spending.
Solutions to critical diseases: Companies engaged in the research and development of drugs and therapies to find treatments for critical diseases such as cancers, brain diseases, autoimmune diseases and other life-threatening medical issues. These companies typically use inputs from research companies as well as employ high-skilled professionals to advance science and have high rates of R&D spending. However, these companies are also susceptible to controversy, particularly in relation to collusion and price fixing.
Equipment & devices: These are companies that manufacture technological health care equipment, devices and supplies that include medical instruments, drug delivery systems, hospital supplies, etc.
Health technology: Companies that provide information technology services such as IT consulting services and internet-based tools. One area of significant development in recent years in health technology is the field of telemedicine (the remote diagnosis and treatment of patients by means of telecommunications technology).
- Access to Health Care
Care facilities & services: Owners and operators of care facilities, including hospitals, nursing homes and rehabilitation centers. Businesses models vary within this sub-sector, but an important similarity is the importance of adequate staffing.
Drug production (pharmaceuticals): Companies engaged in the production of pharmaceuticals for common diseases and diseases for which treatments are already well developed. They tend to spend less on R&D than research companies. Controversies tend to be elevated for companies in this sector, due especially to price fixing allegations.
Diagnostics: Companies providing devices, tools and tests to diagnose diseases.
Wellness: Companies that design and manufacture products and devices destined to improve the quality of life of patients (for example, dentistry and hearing solutions, ophthalmic and orthopedic reconstructive products, hygiene and nutrition).
Health care distributors & services: Companies providing health care services such as distribution and wholesale of health care products and medicines like pharmacies and other retailers, staffing services, etc.
Health insurance providers: Companies offering health insurance coverage. Their products are usually already well established in the market. Insurance providers have seen high 5-year revenue growth.
We have assigned over 80 large-cap health care companies to one of our ten sub-sectors; each company has been pre-screened for both positive impact and ESG criteria, using our proprietary framework that combines evaluating alignment with UN’S Sustainable Development Goals, SASB materiality, and the Impact Management Framework.
Financial Characteristics
Given the sub-sector descriptions above, it is easy to see that health care companies cover a diverse set of problems. Unsurprisingly, they also have widely divergent financial characteristics. For example, research companies are well-known for having significant R&D expenditures and hefty valuations, health care facilities tend to pay out high dividends, and pharmaceutical companies provide stable growth and high margins.
The table below displays the average of key financial metrics across our sub-sectors.
Health Care and the Business Cycle
Given these diverse financial characteristics and the current volatility in financial markets, investors looking for both financial returns and impact will need to be either extremely selective about entry points if pursuing a buy-and-hold strategy, or else be nimble regarding the macroeconomic and business cycle environments. In the case of the latter, we have articulated in past research notes that we expect the investment environment to continue to favor value stocks relative to growth stocks, owing to the rising interest rate environment. We also expect elevated inflation to linger and global economic growth prospects to moderate (with risks to the downside elevated in Europe). The health care sector is known for being a defensive sector that holds up well in recessions and equity bear markets (see chart below).
The SMS sub-sectors that are most defensive in nature – and thus positioned well for the environment described above - include care facilities, drug production, and health insurance providers. Within these sub sectors, several companies are positive stand outs:
These 8 companies also bring returns. They have outperformed the S&P Health Care Select Sector Index returns over the last 4 years, as show in the chart below:
The growing dependence on digital records and systems is making organizations increasingly susceptible to cyber attacks. Consequently, the handling of personal data is facing greater scrutiny from the public. Cybersecurity service providers can help customers with both threat surveillance and data privacy. By helping to protect personal data, mitigate threats and discourage criminal ransom demands, the services provided by cybersecurity companies provide important social and governance benefits and are included in Sustainable Market Strategies equity universe under the Productivity with Purpose theme (see note, “Productivity with Purpose” November 11, 2021).
Cybersecurity companies may seem like a great investment opportunity following the recent drop, especially given that these are considered tech companies with superior potential for sustainable long-term growth. However, a look beyond the robust revenue growth expectations exposes a challenging backdrop for investors. Competition is fierce and valuations run high, with many of these companies operating at a loss despite their strong revenues.
The Battlefield
The pandemic accelerated the transition to a digital world. Over the past two years, entertainment, learning, shopping and even the office went virtual. While these trends may slow, they are unlikely to reverse. This rapid digital expansion with increasing interconnectedness created ample opportunity for attackers who aim to make money from ransom payouts or gain access to valuable information. As online presence rose during the pandemic, so did the number of attack attempts with malware and ransomware among the most common types of attacks. Malware is a “malicious software” designed to disrupt a system or gain unauthorized access. Ransomware is a type of malware that holds a system or data hostage in demand for a ransom sum. Deep Instinct’s bi-annual cyber threat report showed a 358% increase in attack attempts through malware and 435% increase in attempts using ransomware in 2020 versus the previous year. In 2021, the overall number of attempted attacks increased another 125% relative to 2020. This is consistent with results from CyberEdge’s annual survey of IT security professionals; a record number of respondents believe a successful cyberattack is likely in the next 12 months.
The main takeaways from the Cyber Threat Landscape report stress the need for a strong defense. Supply chains are facing enough woes without cyberthreats, but they are an increasingly popular target. Companies would be smart to limit additional risks that could arise from security vulnerabilities. Working “in the cloud” is also here to stay and broadens access to entry points for attackers, requiring protection beyond a local network. Attackers are also getting faster, able to exploit a weakness within the same day it is disclosed: known as a zero-day threat. In addition, there is an anticipated higher threat level given the current geopolitical backdrop as Russia and China are known to be prevalent attackers. All of this reinforces the need for organizations to protect their digital assets and will lead to increased spending on cybersecurity.
Insider Threats
With strong projections for sustainable growth in the demand for cybersecurity, one can jump to the conclusion that there is a boon for cybersecurity companies. A closer look reveals otherwise. Competition for market share and talent, along with the significant investment in R&D required to keep pace with an ever-evolving landscape, make it challenging for these companies to turn a profit. Cybersecurity companies are in a battle not only against cyber threats, but also against their peers. Revenue growth has been strong but spending on sales and marketing and research and development account for a significant portion of revenues. Costs are further strained as the industry faces a labor shortage.
Reputation is of critical importance in this industry. A breach can have an outsized impact on market valuation, elevating the risk of loss as successful attacks are nearly impossible to foresee. However, cybersecurity companies do exhibit healthy gross profit margins. Though it is still too early to distinguish clear winners, investors should focus on companies that strike a balance between investments in sales and marketing and R&D, since insufficient investment in the latter can pose challenges as attackers’ tactics can change quickly in the cyberworld. Comparing price to sales ratios across companies can help put valuations in perspective. Moreover, given the intense competition for high-skilled labor, attention to company policies for employee engagement and retention are relevant metrics aligned with SASB materiality for the Software and IT Services industry. Companies performing well in these areas will have more staying power and a greater likelihood of beating their competitors. The table below provides a comparison of these indicators for the top 5 (i.e. Largest market cap) pure play cybersecurity companies.
This week’s U.S. CPI release for April underscores that inflationary pressures are not yet letting up and it is too early to expect a peak in global inflation. To be sure, monetary policymakers are now on the job – the Fed hiked the policy rate by 50 basis points last week and another 200 basis points are expected by the end of the year. Note that policymakers target price stability for consumers, but rising prices are wreaking havoc all throughout the supply chain. Moreover, distortions in prices for economic goods and services – and the policy reaction to them – have important consequences for investment returns both across and within asset classes. This is as true for ESG investments as it is for broader mandates. In today’s Note, we look for ESG investment opportunities that are well protected and/or can benefit from inflation.
Inflation and Asset Allocation
Most investors are familiar with the macroeconomic idea that specific asset classes perform better (or worse) depending on the economic growth and inflation backdrop. The diagram below is an update on the classic “asset allocation quadrants”; our version includes the ESG asset classes that we expect to perform well in each of the growth/inflation quadrants, alongside conventional asset classes. As per our previous research, we have been advocating for ESG investors to be positioned within the top and bottom right quadrant: transition metals, carbon prices, forestry and agriculture have been among our high conviction investment calls over the past six months. We expect to move further toward the bottom right as the year progresses: with China’s zero COVID policy still in place, energy prices becoming particularly taxing in Europe, and several central banks raising interest rates, our expectations are that growth momentum will slow further and eventually peak later this year.
Inflation and Equity Investors
Equities as an asset class tend to perform best in low, stable inflation backdrops and struggle to deliver returns in high (and uncertain) inflation periods. When inflation is rising, the discount rate applied to earnings also tends to be higher, and therefore stock valuations (i.e. the P/E ratio) are lower.
That said, the impact of inflation on earnings varies by economic sector and also by individual company. In high inflation environments, the ability to pass on higher input costs further down the supply chain (and eventually onto final consumers) can be an important distinguisher. Indeed, as the chart below shows, producers have been increasing their prices much faster than businesses that sell to consumers especially in the past two years: intermediate non-energy goods prices, as measured by the U.S. core producer price index, have surged far more than (core) consumer prices.
This is inevitably reflected in stock price returns. The table below shows the average S&P 500 stock price returns by sector. In general, sectors that are considered to be at the beginning of the supply chain (energy, materials) and companies that offer services that are non-discretionary (i.e. end users can not substitute away from them) tend to do better in high inflation environments. It is no coincidence that Sustainable Market Strategies has favoured carbon and ESG real estate plays such as forestry and agriculture.
What’s In It For ESG?
The exercise of finding companies with superior pricing power by screening for stable or rising margins can be done for the broad market. However, investors certainly do not need to sacrifice on ESG characteristics to achieve similar results. In other words, we do not see any reason why companies with strong sustainability characteristics would perform differently than sustainability laggards. In fact, to the extent that companies leading in ESG often have a reputational advantage, it may be the case that ESG/sustainable leaders have a better ability to maintain or increase margins relative to their peers. Moreover, as we wrote last year, several ESG factors are contributing to higher inflation (please see our Note, “Inflation is an ESG Phenomenon” November 25, 2021).
Regardless, we focus exclusively on investing in companies with strong, positive ESG characteristics. Therefore, our initial universe includes the winning companies that have surfaced in our historical notes, based on our six investable ESG themes. From this ESG universe, we then look for companies that have stable or rising profit margins over the past five quarters, i.e. while inflation has been increasing significantly. The table below highlights the top companies by sector from our ESG universe that have stable or rising profit margins. Note that although we expect that superior profit margins will be a positive distinguisher, some of the companies on our list have nonetheless struggled to deliver positive equity returns due to a variety of factors, including poor valuation starting points. We expect this trend will reverse in due course.
Trucking is critical to the supply chain. Approximately 70% of goods in America are transported by truck, and similar stats are true around the globe. However, like many essential workers, the role of drivers is underappreciated. Prior to the pandemic, the cost of shipping had remained relatively stable since the 1980’s (see our note “Global Supply and Its Chains”, March 3, 2022). This was in part at the expense of truckers, who experienced declining real wages over the same period. Consequently, the trucking industry already had its own backlog of issues when pandemic pressures arrived. Challenges within supply chains were exacerbated by long-standing employee retention issues. With this in mind, to improve their supply chains, employers will have to revaluate the treatment of drivers. In this context, companies offering competitive compensation and benefits will have an advantage in retaining drivers, securing deliveries and maintaining their profit margins going forward.
Priority Shipping
Trucking is an integral part of the transport of goods. In America, it plays a much bigger role than marine, air or rail in domestic logistics and employs more than twice as many people than the number of workers in the rail, marine and air sectors combined. Forecasts from the Bureau of Transportation statistics show these numbers are expected to remain stable over the next two decades.
When disruptions in trucking arise, the impact is felt quickly. During the petrol shortage in October 2021, Britain had to call in the army to help distribute petrol given the lack of truck drivers. The Canadian “freedom convoy” resulted in the loss of $300 million for the auto industry in just one week. Just this month, protests against new inspections targeting smuggling resulted in a blockade at a U.S./Mexico border in Texas where $12M in produce enters the U.S. daily. As a result, truckers should not be neglected; their critical role in supply chains has long been under appreciated.
Back It Up
The lack of drivers is often attributed to the labor shortage, but 2021, the number of truckers surpassed pre-pandemic levels in the U.S. As this article from 2017 describes, the lack of drivers is not new and the labor issues that cause it remain today. In America, the industry faces a 90% annual turnover rate! The problem extends beyond the U.S. In Europe, the driver shortage is also linked to poor working conditions and compensation.

Trucking jobs have experienced a race to the bottom since the 1980’s with a decline in real wages. Union representation, nearly 40% in the 1983, has been falling at a faster pace than overall industry rates, and currently sits near 15%. The introduction of independent contracting models (similar to Uber and Deliveroo - see our note “Working Class Hero”, April 8, 2021), sometimes with predatory truck leasing arrangements, encourages workers to run their own operations; all in an effort to maintain low freight costs. The new consumer expectation of free next day delivery born out of the pandemic is not making things any easier. Drivers complain of increasingly long wait times to load or unload; time for which they are not paid as compensation plans are typically by the mile, not the hour.
While automation in the form of self-driving trucks could provide a solution, wholehearted adoption of this technology is still years in the making given regulatory hurdles on safety. Even so, the need to improve supply chain resiliency is here NOW. The introduction of AI into truck hauling is likely to progress gradually through several more years of a human driver/robot combination. Some of this technology creates an additional irritation for drivers, many of whom view their trucks as second homes and perceive the increased surveillance as an invasion of privacy and a reduction of their autonomy.
Next Stop
In order to improve supply chain resiliency, the treatment of truckers needs to be properly addressed. In the U.S., the Biden administration has recognized this, launching the Trucking Action plan in December 2021. The plan promises an investigation into compensation issues and problematic truck leasing in an initiative to “support drivers and driver retention by improving the quality of trucking jobs”. Companies willing to offer quality trucking jobs will be better positioned to face snags in the supply chain. Walmart has stepped up, announcing a salary range of $95,000 to $110,000 for new drivers who the company also recognizes as employees, meaning they have many of the same benefits as their in-store colleagues.
We see two investment angles: logistics companies and retailers. Logistics providers with a reliable driver force will be more likely to win contracts, growing their market share. For retailers, those offering competitive wages and benefits to their truckers – most likely through greater vertical integration - will see less turnover and more dependable delivery of goods and pricing. Not to mention the reputation risks both industries could face if poor working conditions were brought to light.
As we often say, there is no substitute for doing your homework. One should always verify if drivers are employees or independent contractors. Proceed with caution when looking at ESG employee scores as these scores may not properly account for truckers who are independent contractors and scores for retailers will cover a broader range of positions than just drivers. An alternative option is to look up scores specific to driver positions on Indeed or Glassdoor. Driver recognition programs should be carefully examined, as they sometimes have a stronger resemblance to incentives for optimal delivery than anything prioritizing the drivers. Turnover rates are also key criteria, if disclosed. The table below provides an assessment of companies discussing the metrics used for the analysis. Old Dominion is a leading name in logistics with its low turnover rate and competitive benefits. In the retail space, Walmart trumps Amazon by recognizing its drivers as employees.
Undervalued Ecosystem
Soil is a complex ecosystem made up of organic matter, minerals, air and water. It is the home of many organisms like insects, worms and nature’s nutrients: bacteria and fungi. The soil ecosystem is critical for life on Earth. Healthy soil can be a productivity booster, improving drainage and air exchange. It also serves as a carbon sink. Unfortunately, rather than working with the soil, current farming practices are contributing to its degradation. The table below depicts the positive contributions of healthy soil and the negative contributions of compacting and tilling.
Soil, like forests and water, is undervalued because it is abundant. Currently, the value of soil is mainly reflected by its ability to generate revenues from growing food. The other contributions of the soil do not directly generate cash flows, even if they are crucially beneficial. As awareness of those benefits increases, the value of soil should also rise. This should result in actions by land owners to protect and nurture their soil. Unfortunately, economic pressures are putting land owners in survival mode, distracting them from the longer term viability of their land.
Food Armageddon
Fast population growth since the Industrial Revolution owes a lot to our collective ability to produce food. This ability is facing new challenges. Climate change is making the weather unpredictable, more aggressive, warmer and drier in places where food is produced. The map below shows the agricultural potential of the soil in different parts of the world. Bare areas with large populations and low incomes are clearly dependent on imports for food. The outlook for agriculture is poor in some important agricultural hubs: the U.S., Australia and Brazil.

Additionally, the major conflict in Ukraine will affect a very productive agricultural area and the consequent sanctions on Russia could curb Russian food exports. As a result, the poorest people in each country will see higher food prices and some of the poorest regions of the world will struggle to access food from to their usual exporters. To continue to feed the globe, we need seeds, water, fertilizers, soil and labor. So far in 2022, we foresee major issues for at least three of the five elements (water, fertilizers, and labor) in the form of shortages and rising costs. The issues of climate change, supply chain challenges, and rising input costs are increasing the probability of a large global humanitarian crisis. The chart below shows the food price index before the Russian invasion.
While these issues are alarming, there is potential for them to serve as a catalyst in returning to farming practices that put soil health at the forefront and are therefore more sustainable over the long term.
Effective Water Management
Regarding water issues, climate change is wreaking havoc from floods to extreme heat and drought. The map below superposes long-term drought conditions with the drought outlook for the next 3 months for the United States as of March 17th, 2022. It does not look promising again this year.

The increasing frequency of drought will have farmers very attentive to their water usage, securing supply and maximizing its efficiency. Soil is one way to optimize water usage. Healthy soil is productive, it interacts more efficiently with water. Ironically, drought-ridden areas are also prone to flooding as dry ground does not have the capacity to absorb water when rain does fall. Farms that prioritize their soil will be more resilient to both droughts and flooding in the long term and continue to yield crops. A company like Plasson (PLSN IT) is well positioned to help farmers with water management and optimization. The use of fertilizer can also impact water efficiency, as it can contribute to runoff where crops absorb only a small portion of the water poured onto it.
Fertilizer Optimization
Access to fertilizers is becoming a challenge. The war in Ukraine, the accompanying sanctions and export bans are creating the potential for significant fertilizer shortages. The chart below shows the portion of fertilizer exports that Russia typically represents. If Russia does not export fertilizers in 2022, it would mean that approximately 20% needs to be produced elsewhere. Considering Belarus is under similar sanctions as Russia, it is even worse. Belarus represents another 20% of global potash export volume. Moreover, unbearable natural gas prices have already been curtailing nitrogen fertilizer production, especially in Europe where natural gas prices are relatively higher.
Farmers are already being challenged by input price squeezes. The rising cost of fertilizer due to the conflict in Ukraine is not making it any easier. This could provide some momentum to begin reducing the use of fertilizers. One alternative is cover crops. Planting these crops improves soil health and reduces the need for herbicides as it covers the land, limiting the growth of weeds. Seed companies such as Sakata Seeds (1377 – JP) and Corteva (CTVA – US) could benefit. Corteva also offers products beyond seeds, including fertilizer and some digital tools. The transition won’t happen overnight – farms are more likely to slowly wean themselves off fertilizers. Precision agriculture can facilitate this transition, using a targeted focus to apply less. There are many actors in this growing space that stand to gain (e.g. Deere & Co., CNH Industries, Raven Industries, Yara, Bayer, IBM, Trimble, etc.)
Please, Grow Food
With higher food prices, a simple conclusion would be that farmers are making a lot of money from their operations, but the reality is very different. They are suffering from weather shocks, labor shortages, energy cost increases and fertilizer cost increases. The USDA forecasted a 12% rise in fertilizer for 2022 after a 17% increase in 2021. This was before the war Ukraine. As the conflict exacerbates food prices, governments will face increasing pressure to help farmers. In addition, those that are hedging their production in the futures’ market need to put more collateral with price rises, worsening their cash flow situation further.
Fortunately, some government initiatives to help long-term farming were already underway and we expect them to accelerate commensurate to the potential impact of a food crisis. The COP26 held in October included an event to encourage investment in digital agriculture. The Biden administration is proposing a shift from USDA commodity credits to carbon credits, incentivizing farmers to prioritize healthy soil for its carbon holding properties. Corporations are also seeing the value in dirt. Companies in both the food and fashion industries have pledged to source crops produced from regenerative practices. From that standpoint, we believe that companies addressing water efficiency, precision agriculture and soil management will benefit from a tailwind.
The opening months of 2022 have brought turbulence to financial markets that require agility for ESG investors, even those with long time horizons. Indeed, even before the vast majority of investors were caught off-guard by the events in Ukraine, a major shift in equity markets was already underway due to the looming turning point in the monetary policy cycle.
At the start of the year, we published our top investment ideas for 2022 (Investment Trends in 2022: Don’t Put Your ESG All in One Basket, January 6, 2022). In today’s Note, we reflect on what is working, what ideas require adjustment and how we believe investors should tilt their portfolios to ensure that their ESG investments remain aligned with the major macro forces. These views are summarized in the table at the end of the Note; the table will now be a regular feature of Insight notes, with the aim of providing a quick guide to SMS’ thematic positioning.
We see three key developments that will underpin equity movements for the foreseeable future.
1. Persistent global inflation as demand holds steady (for now) and supply remains constrained.
In our November Insight report (Inflation is an ESG Phenomenon, November 25, 2021), we articulated our view that “frequent and significant supply chain challenges will make relative price shocks commonplace, while a tight labor market means that initiatives to create better working conditions globally will act to raise the cost of labor (wage inflation).” This view is still in place and we continue to expect that a structurally tighter labor market will help strengthen employee bargaining power: annual wage cost growth in the EU is already approaching 3% and is over 5% in the U.S. Even when a recession occurs, it is unlikely that wage inflation will fall to previous cycle lows given the structural tightness in labor markets. As for pricing pressures due to supply chain hiccups, the war in Ukraine has solidified the likelihood that several key industries will grapple with high input costs for many months to come. While not strictly an ESG factor, the value of land and other finite resources has most certainly come into investor focus in the past several weeks.
Two of our favored long-term inflation plays that stem from our themes of protecting natural capital and the energy transition are overweight positions in transition metals and forestry. Both ideas have performed well since the beginning of the year, due to the rising inflation theme and revaluation of hard assets during wartime. Investors should beware of near-term pullbacks should a Russian ceasefire occur, but the long-term investment thesis of favoring “green” inflation hedges is still intact. Holmen, Svenska Cellulosa AB (SCA) CA, Umicore and Boliden are among our favored long-term investments in this space.
2. High and volatile oil prices will remain for the foreseeable future, eventually damaging economic activity, especially in Europe. A renewable and fossil fuel capex cycle is imminent.
Last week’s note outlined our views on the prospects for ESG investors in the energy sector. Suffice to say, we expect that both fossil fuel prices and alternative energy prices will remain elevated and volatile for some time; it will take several months (years) for investment to catch up to current energy demands. In the meantime, elevated oil prices will act like a tax on economic activity and suppress growth. The pressure will be most acute in Europe, given the region’s greater reliance on Russian oil and gas supply that is currently.
As a result of higher oil prices, we expect economic activity to cool in the second half of the year, with the euro area particularly at risk.
There are several investment implications. First, as we wrote last week, despite our bullish long-term stance on the price of carbon, the carbon market is unlikely to rebound forcefully in the months ahead and patience is required. Second, companies that rely on euro area demand risk underwhelming relative to those geared to the U.S., given headwinds from higher energy- in the euro area. Third, companies that are able to pass on the price of energy will be in a distinctly better position than those that cannot. Finally, a capex cycle in both renewable energies and fossil fuel is imminent.
ESG investors with fossil fuel exclusions risk underperforming broad benchmarks in the near term, but trying to pick ESG leaders vs. laggards within the traditional energy sector is risky business. We recommend that investors focus on renewable energy companies, including Cameco and Nextera Energy Partners and companies that provide services to alternative energy providers like Ameresco and Hannon Armstrong.
3. A turning point in the monetary policy cycle.
The inflation conditions described make it inevitable that policy rates around the world will rise. Indeed, after a rush of global accommodative policy to help deal with the economic effects of the pandemic, central banks now must focus on curbing inflation. Yesterday, the Fed raised interest rates by 25 bps, while the BoE will remain in hiking mode, and the ECB has also made plans to end its bond-buying programme earlier than previously expected.
Recent months have shown that ESG portfolios are equally exposed to shifts in the macro outlook as traditional portfolios. The overall economic backdrop is still mildly bullish for stocks, but as the cost of capital increases, stocks with high valuation multiples are most exposed to price declines/price stagnation; the rotation from growth stocks to value stocks is likely to continue.
Investors can still find good, sustainable, fairly valued companies across economic sectors, but given the current geopolitical cross-currents and lower risks outside of Europe, we recommend seeking plays within non-Russian commodity-producing countries like Canada, Australia and Latin America. Note that investors must be extremely selective in these countries, since buying the benchmark indices means buying tar sands, coal producers and other destructive environmental practices. Industrial companies focusing on environmental and energy efficiency solutions (see our note last week), as well as sustainable agriculture, are two areas that are ripe for further capital inflows. The latter – sustainable agriculture – is the subject of next week’s note, stay tuned.
The fast fashion business model may perhaps be the best representation of the combined pitfalls of globalization, deregulation, and consumer behavior.
In today’s note, we describe how the fast fashion industry has navigated each one of the above factors to produce apparel at an increasingly cheap financial price, while exacting an ever-increasing environmental price on the planet.
What Is Fast Fashion And How Did We Get Here?
The overall fashion industry is quite fragmented (Nike has the largest market share at less than 3%), but the fast fashion industry is a significant sub-sector and includes behemoth apparel companies like Zara, H&M, Uniqlo, etc. As the Chart below shows, among the largest 14 global apparel brands, half are considered fast fashion companies.
Contrary to the more traditional fashion industry, fast fashion manufacturing is on a cycle that can be as short as two weeks. The business model is built on low price and perceived scarcity, and has taken something that once was considered a basic need and turned it into an entirely discretionary (and disposable) product. We outlined the environmental and social burden of this industry in a note two years ago (A Fashionably Unsustainable Industry, January 23 2020), and unfortunately, little has changed since: apart from a short, Covid-related pause in apparel spending, the volume of clothes being manufactured and sold continues to increase.
Interestingly, some of the largest fast fashion companies are the same companies that receive top rankings for ESG initiatives. For example, Inditex (Zara) routinely scores well on E, S and G sustainability rankings and have made good progress toward some of their objectives, such as reducing plastic and increasing renewable energy use. However, the company does not address the problematic nature of the business model: over the past twenty years, the clothing industry has evolved from having two “seasons” (production cycles) per year to as many as twenty-four. The constant stocking of new trends incites consumers to buy ever more frequently and a negative feedback loop is in place whereby low prices encourage consumers to cycle through clothes more quickly, which drives companies to make clothes that are increasingly disposable.
Moreover, the ability to produce low-cost clothes in the first place is in large part due to the few barriers to global trade in the apparel industry.
Globalization and The Deflationary Tailwind: The Apparel Industry Changed Forever?
There are few industries that are better-suited to be the poster child for globalization. The cross-border trade in goods and services, technology, investment and people mean that any given manufactured garment will travel on average to five countries, spanning three continents, before it is fully constructed and sold and to a customer. Apparel manufacturing remains a comparatively low-technology endeavor and a highly competitive industry; free trade among nations has meant that factories move to the cheapest international labor markets and the savings are generally passed on to consumers.
Indeed, as the below chart shows, for the majority of the past three decades (i.e. since China joined the World Trade Organization), the price of clothing in advanced economies like the U.S. has been in deflation territory. True, recent supply chain challenges have paused this trend for now and we do not expect prices to fall significantly further given our view that globalization has peaked. Nonetheless, clothing prices remain extremely cheap relative to historic norms.
It is thus astounding that, although the average consumer today purchases 15 more new items per year as they did only fifteen years ago, they spend only a fraction of their budget on apparel. Indeed, if one goes further back in time, consumers of the 1950s spent 12% of their overall budgets on clothing, compared to just 2.5% today. This has by and large been made possible due to cheap labor and intensive use of natural resources – the apparel manufacturing industry is considered a low-tech industry whereby productivity improvements have significantly lagged other economic sectors.
Consumers: Compelled To Shop?
The above paragraphs underscore that both the disposability and affordability of clothes have never been greater. Awareness about the problems -namely environmental degradation and worker treatment – has also never been greater. Indeed, since the Rana Plaza tragedy in 2013, there has been more media attention paid to the plight of garment workers in Bangladesh and elsewhere; the table below describes just a few of the controversies over the past decade.
It is increasingly difficult for consumers anywhere to feign ignorance about where their clothes come from and in what conditions they may be produced, thanks to organizations like the Fashion Transparency Index, whose mission is to push the world’s largest fashion brands to be more transparent about their social and environmental efforts.
There is some indication that awareness campaigns are paying off. A recent McKinsey survey revealed that consumers are becoming less inclined to factor in “newness” or “season trend” into their fashion purchase and are increasingly willing to invest in durability. Moreover, there are some tentative signs that younger shoppers have different priorities and could drive a re-make of the fast fashion business: the demise of fast fashion’s Forever 21 brand is widely viewed to be driven by Generation Z’s eschewing the values that the brand represents.
Whether this translates adopting different shopping habits is difficult to forecast, albeit the evidence from other sectors does not inspire confidence. Take food: year after year, survey data shows that respondents desire to eat healthier and yet the data show otherwise: each decade, average Western diets become more processed and fattier. Just like for fashion, the decreasing cost of food is a major factor in spurring increased consumption.
Regulation: A Powerful But Underutilized Force
In the case of fast fashion, for the past twenty years, market forces have meant that consumers’ insatiable demand for trendy goods has been more than supplied by companies that leverage the global free-trade backdrop to bring (dump) ever more goods to market.
But more recently, there has been a call for increased regulation and laws have passed in some developed countries, as the table below highlights. However, most clothing manufacturing occurs in underdeveloped countries (such as India, Vietnam, and Bangladesh) that do not have the organizational structures in place to hold apparel manufacturers accountable for pollution and worker conditions. By subcontracting in these countries, western brands can buffer themselves from regulations in their home jurisdiction and evade legal liability.
The European Union is leading the charge from a regulatory standpoint. Although EU law can not control conditions where the goods are produced, they can impact companies where they sell their products. Earlier this week, the European commission proposed a law that aims to force EU companies to increase due diligence in supply chains across various industries.
Perhaps most damning is that most regulatory initiatives are intended to improve environmental and social conditions but do nothing to attack the business model of fast fashion, which equates to unnecessarily producing low-cost disposable clothing. Laws that are aimed to reduce or eliminate planned obsolescence, i.e. designing a product with an artificially limited life span so that it becomes obsolete after a certain pre-determined period of time, are one way that countries could curtail the fast fashion industry. In some countries (France), planned functional obsolescence is punishable both through fines and jail. However, legislation around planned perceived obsolescence – the re-styling of products so consumers will purchase the latest trends - is still absent.
On the whole, it is unlikely that a regulatory push will drastically impact the fast fashion industry within a medium-term investment timeframe.