Investors of all stripes are now familiar with climate change as a material risk to their portfolios. Biodiversity is an equally large, but a less understood environmental challenge. It is underappreciated by investors from both the risk and opportunity perspectives. Below, is a series of questions and answers on the most pressing biodiversity concerns for investors.
What are biodiversity and ecosystem services? Why should investors care?
Biodiversity is the variety of natural capital’s living components (for example, species and habitats). Biodiversity ensures the resilience of natural capital assets and secures them for the future. In other words, biodiversity is for nature what portfolio diversification is to investors: just as asset managers reduce the risk of negative tail outcomes by holding assets with a variety of financial characteristics, natural capital requires diverse species and habitats to thrive.
Ecosystem services is a term used to describe the outputs, conditions, or processes of natural systems that benefit humans. Carbon sequestration by forests is one example of an ecosystem service, but hundreds exist. Importantly, biodiversity loss and ecosystem services go well beyond the agricultural sector and include land, fresh water, oceans and air. Ecosystem services can be recorded in monetary terms, which facilitates understanding of the value that these services represent.
These ecosystem services, which are vital to human survival, exist because there is variety in natural capital, i.e., because Earth is biologically diverse. As biodiversity declines, the ecosystem services that humans rely on also decline.
For investors, biodiversity is important because significant economic rents in the past several decades have been achieved by using the ecosystem’s services without having to pay for them.

Why should investors care now?
Although losses in biodiversity have been recorded for several decades, healthy natural capital (biodiversity) was so sufficiently abundant that economic actors of all types (governments, consumers, corporates) could take the services that ecosystems provide for granted. The situation has changed drastically: according to the WWF and the Living Planet index, there has been a 68% average loss in animal population since 1970!
Animal population loss is highly correlated to the natural world that they live in, and biodiversity loss means loss of the ecosystem services that go along with it. In this sense, traditional business models that take ecosystem services for granted risk not being able to operate for lack of services and/or will have to secure these services at a much higher cost.
Concretely, which businesses are most at risk of losing undervalued ecosystem services and/or which businesses are most dependent on nature?
Biodiversity loss is happening to land, sea, freshwater and air and estimates are that $44 trillion of economic value generation—over half the world’s total GDP—is moderately or highly dependent on nature and its services, and therefore at risk. The industries that are most dependent on biodiversity are construction, agriculture and food and beverages. These industries rely on either the direct extraction of resources from forests and oceans or the provision of ecosystem services such as healthy soils, clean water, pollination, etc. That said, many other industries have significant “hidden dependencies” on nature in their supply chain and are at risk of disruption. Chemicals and materials, tourism, real estate, mining and metals; transportation are all industries whereby over half of their supply chains’ gross value added is highly or moderately nature-dependent.
How can investors know which portfolio companies are aware of their risks and are doing something about it?
Similar to investor risks associated to climate change, several initiatives have gathered momentum for investors to better understand portfolio management through a biodiversity lens.
A well-known reporting framework, the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), defines material topics for companies based on their industry and presents accounting metrics for each category. While “biodiversity” is not its own category, many of the key elements and ecosystem services are accounted for within the SASB framework. Investors that consult the CSR reports of their portfolio companies will have a first inkling of the degree of nature dependency.
Why can’t investors focus on just one biodiversity indicator like GHG emissions and the cost of CO2 for climate?
Biodiversity is extremely difficult to distill into one indicator since it has multiple dimensions and not all dimensions will be relevant for all types of businesses. Exposure to biodiversity loss depends on a complex array of factors: geography, operational arrangements, value chain position (upstream vs. downstream), extent of dependency on one or more aspects of diversity (e.g. water AND soil health AND air quality), impact on biodiversity, ability to substitute materials, etc.
It is for this reason that for investors, a financial metric that expresses the monetized value of ecosystem services—the services that nature provides to benefit humans—is useful. This method would help to reveal the economic contribution of nature and its services to an underlying investment.
Are there regulatory headwinds/tailwinds associated with biodiversity?
The 15th Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity (COP15) to be held in Kunming, China, in the third Quarter of 2022 (dates to be confirmed), will finalize a global biodiversity conservation framework for 2020-2050. This meeting is to biodiversity what the Paris Agreement is to climate change i.e., a once in a generation opportunity for the global community to commit to significant necessary actions to protect the planet. The expected outcome is to articulate global targets to preserve and protect 30% of land and sea by 2030.
However, just like for climate change, any resultant accords will not be legally binding. In other words, there are no international laws designed to enforce the preservation of biodiversity.
For investors, perhaps the biggest regulatory risk will come from the reversal of economic subsidies in certain industries. Take agriculture: according to the United Nations, nearly 90% of the $540bn in global subsidies given to farmers every year is considered harmful to the environment. These subsidies include price incentives for specific livestock and crops, subsidies for fertilizers and pesticides, and export subsidies and import tariffs. Equally frustrating is that often these subsidies and their concomitant environmental degradation, serve only to prop up certain parts of the agricultural market that would not otherwise be profitable. This tactic is no different than keeping zombie banks in operation after a banking crisis!
We expect that harmful subsidies will eventually be repealed (COP15 is likely to be influential in this regard). And there is already supportive evidence in the UK regarding the agricultural industry. Investors that are exposed to industries that rely on subsidies known to have deleterious environmental impacts will be on the wrong side of the trade.
How can I understand the environmental depletion—and therefore the biodiversity risk—of my investment?
The first step for investors is to have access to appropriate disclosure about biodiversity risks.
Regional and national disclosure endeavours already exist: France has already implemented a decree requiring all financial institutions to disclose biodiversity and climate-related risks as well as disclosing their strategy to reduce impacts. Meanwhile, the EU taxonomy does include significant drivers for preventing biodiversity loss, and the EU government is also expected to adopt a Directive on Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence in 2022, requiring companies with significant turnover in the EU to understand whether value chain activities have an adverse impact on biodiversity.
A non-exhaustive list of frameworks is provided in the table below, but the most significant development in nature-related financial disclosures is the Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures (TNFD), which is a framework that builds on the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD). A beta version was released earlier this month, with the aim to provide a framework for corporates and financial institutions to assess, manage and report on their dependencies and impacts on nature. A key feature of the framework is that it proposes location-specific disclosure given that dependencies and impacts on nature are inherently local. Indeed, the TNFD framework encourages transparent data to be reported about both impact and dependency (i.e., double materiality) on biodiversity.
We expect that over time, the TNFD will become a necessary, widely used disclosure framework that ultimately will influence how capital is allocated. It is significant that the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) last week issued a proposed rule change that would require companies to make specific climate-related disclosures. The new requirements are based on the TCFD disclosure framework. While legislation takes time, the TNFD will be the roadmap for enforced disclosure of a broader array of environmental factors.
Disclosure means that investors will be in a better position to make decisions. That said, forward-looking investors do not need to wait for disclosure regulation to act. The majority of public enterprises now publish some environmental data related to their operations, most often in a CSR report. With regards to biodiversity, companies that report according to SASB materiality risks already divulge significant information (see the table above).
Like many of our readers, we are troubled by geopolitical developments of the past week. At Sustainable Market Strategies, our mission is to deliver investable insights with respect to ESG topics. To us, the war in Ukraine, as well as several recent developments in China, will have long-lasting significant implications on financial flows, many of which are directly linked to sustainability themes.
In today’s Insight note, we focus on the changing global backdrop and what this means for supply chains. The latter is one of six investable ESG megatrends that we expect will impact investors in the year ahead.
A De-Tangling of Relations
It is a fairly consensus view to believe that the globalization of the world economy has matured and possibly even peaked, and it is one that SMS’ editors share. The term hyper-globalization was first coined in 2011 by acclaimed Professor of International Political Economy, Dani Rodrik. The term refers to globalization aimed at the elimination of all transaction costs associated with the movement between borders of goods, services, capital and finance. These costs include tariffs and quotas, but also domestic regulations, standards, rules on product safety, rules on intellectual property, banking regulations, etc.
A careful reading of Rodrik shows two things:
First, sustaining openness (globalization) requires a domestic social consensus in its favor. Unfortunately, there is mounting evidence that this social consensus is weakening. Take for instance the survey results below: according to IPSOS polling, just under half of global respondents still believe globalization is a good thing, but the percentage of people that feel this way has dramatically fallen over the past two years.
Second, sustaining openness also requires that nation states harmonize monetary, legal and regulatory regimes so as to minimize costs that arise from jurisdictional discontinuities. Today, there are multiple examples of countries who choose policies that deviate from the global norm and are unconcerned with the international and investment consequences. Much of the focus of globalization has been on China given the strong reliance on this nation. Just one example is the treatment of Uyghurs. China has come under scrutiny for these human rights violations but has faced limited consequences. Companies who pledged to remove connections to the forced labor of Uyghurs from their supply chains encountered a backlash from Chinese consumers and even lost market share in China. The sheer size of China’s domestic market means that foreign brands need to perform a balancing act – they rely on both Chinese workers to produce their products and increasingly, on Chinese consumers to buy them. Industrial policies are also gaining prevalence as politicians look to replicate the manufacturing success of China; these policies move us away from global norms.
The war in Ukraine and the accompanying sanctions from the West are the most recent reminder of the side effects of dependence from other nations: the energy needs of many European countries are satisfied by Russia and they cannot be switched rapidly. The implication is that the likelihood of such an entwined global system in the future is diminishing. Until recently, globalization has implied reliability and efficiency: inputs are widely available and competitiveness continuously drives costs lower. However, both the war in Ukraine and the pandemic reveal the vulnerabilities of this model: a divergence in national policies means that the securitization of key resources, like energy and commodities, and the reliability of goods-producing supply chains depends on the alignment of priorities and commitment of global trading partners.
The peak in globalization will have several long-term implications for investors; perhaps the most direct is related to global supply chains. Indeed, based on the above topography, we see three major trade factors that will change supply chains.
WTO and the access to competitive labor: When China entered the World Trade Organization in 2001, the global economy gained an extra 740 million workers that were willing to work at a small fraction of the cost elsewhere in the world. This was an enormous cost savings to any business that could relocate to China and encouraged companies to overwhelmingly offshore their operations.
However, by the end of the last decade, the China cost advantage for labor is gone compared to Vietnam and even Mexico which is much closer geographically to the United States. Moreover, as China has become wealthier, domestic demand for goods and services have risen; Chinese employees are increasingly working for companies that satisfy local demand, rather than working for companies that primarily export goods. On top of it, the labor force is aging rapidly; the average Chinese worker is a year older than in the U.S. The bottom line is that the supply of competitively priced labor is no longer a tailwind. Even if one assumes the status quo with respect to free-trade rules, strictly from a labor perspective, there is a diminishing reason to produce goods in China.
The Energy Transition and the Global Cost of Carbon
Despite the secular rise in global trade over the past several decades, the financial cost associated with shipping goods around the world have stayed relatively constant. The chart below shows transportation costs as a share of sales for U.S. businesses; since 1985, transportation costs have stayed in a range of 2.5% - 4% of sales. that all changed during the pandemic; shipping prices have gone up by a factor of 8 and are now crimping profit margins.
Energy prices are clearly in a cyclical bull market. Longer term, if the energy transition is to be successful, it will require the negative externalities that are currently cheap or free to be priced and accounted for: we expect the price of carbon to increase substantially in the years ahead. Unless renewables quickly replace fossil fuels, the cost of transportation is assuredly set to rise. As the cost of transportation as a share of sales rises, the economics of globalized supply chains will, at the margin, become increasingly difficult to rationalize.
Securing Access to Resources
In acknowledgement of this reality and in response to numerous supply chain hiccups during the pandemic, one of Biden’s first actions as U.S. president was to order a review of supply chain vulnerabilities. Industries under review range from semiconductor manufacturing, batteries, minerals and materials and pharmaceuticals. Policy is gearing up to influence the geographic location of key industries that can relocate, and while the geography of geological deposits is static, the geopolitics of transition metals is a major argument in favor of an important investment cycle in metal recycling (please see our Note, Transition Metals: Wicked Problem, Smart Solutions, October 14, 2021).
Indeed, the energy transition also contains a more complex, geopolitical factor. Clean energy technologies use raw materials that are often more geographically concentrated than conventional fossil fuel energy and China is an extremely important link in the supply chain. The two tables below show that the country dominates the processing of key transition metals and also has significant clout in metal production.
The recent rout in tech stocks presents a timely opportunity to look at the sustainability of pay packages in this sector. A first consideration is that some tech companies—such as Meta Platforms—have seen their cost of revenue increase fivefold (when salaries and stock options are accounted for) while top-line revenue witnessed only a three-fold increase over the past five years. This tells us that increasingly, many pay packages in the sector will be scrutinized by top management as the financial sustainability of several stock options programs in the tech sector is currently being tested by the recent correction in tech stock prices.
Moreover, with labor shortages abounding and the harsh fight for talent at play, one could also expect that this industry will also become vulnerable to “brain drain”. This becomes especially salient when things don’t go as planned—like seeing your stock option plan go to zero—which could be the case if you were hired in 2020 and 2021. Indeed, if you were hired by Meta Platforms back in 2021—and now with the company’s stock price now back to where it was back in mid-2020—some recent hires will be tempted to “jump ship” in the coming months given the deceptive valuation of their stock option package. To this end, the prospect of 1) higher interest rates and 2) the scrappy equity markets of late does not bode well for those who are hoping to cash-in their options in the coming months.
It seems that employees in tech are accelerating the pace at which they are moving away from their current firms. A look at the December 2021 JOLTS report in the U.S. suggests that “quits” in the Information sector (which is part of the NAICS classification under the “Information sector” and includes tech and IT workers) are currently at their highest level since 2013 (barring the 2020 COVID-resignation crisis). This has occurred while stock prices in tech also reached their peak in early 2022.
Furthermore, supplemental pay in the information sector – i.e. the pay which comes above your normal salary – doubled as a percent of total compensation this past decade. With this in mind, employees that have become accustomed to generous bonus schemes may be disappointed in the coming months: given the recent drop in tech stock prices, it is plausible to expect that supplemental pay will become a less important part of total compensation in the sector—which could even result in diminishing total compensation in the near-term.
The challenge is that several tech companies certainly benefitted strongly from stock option-based remuneration packages these past few years. In fact, looking at the value of stock option packages provided annually to employees of the top 20 Nasdaq companies (by market cap), one sees that the value of these packages moved up at the same rate as the price of the overall index this past decade. In this context, it would be surprising to see the value of these packages be maintained in the coming months as financial conditions will likely continue to pull back multiples in the tech sector.
Finally, companies which appear the most vulnerable to the above-mentioned “brain drain” are those firms which display an outsized stock options plan compared to their financial ability to pay for them. This seems especially true for companies such as Netflix and Facebook; last year they allocated between 95 and 160 percent of their free cash flow in stock options to their employees amid a YTD return of their stock price of roughly -30 percent.
Investors that have looked to buy ESG investment products with the goal of adding or subtracting specific non-financial characteristics from their portfolio in recent years would have been right to be sceptical. Many of the most well-known ESG products break several rules of basic investing and don’t live up to their hype. In today’s note, we address the current weaknesses of many ESG funds, what needs to be done to correct this, and offer investors some possible solutions to ensure that ESG dollars are put to work most effectively.
For our analysis, we collect data from the approximately 42 U.S. listed ETFs that focus on ESG equities. Total assets under management (AUM) of these funds stands at $55.5b, with impressive inflows of $17.3b in 2021. Market concentration is quite high: the top 10 ESG ETFs by AUM have 92.4% of the assets and enjoyed 87.8% of 2021 flows.
Part A: The Issues
1: A Rose by Any Other Name…
A major criticism of many ESG funds is what is hiding behind the label. As the table below displays, out of the top 10 largest (market capitalization) holdings in the S&P 500, nine are featured in the top ten holdings of U.S. ESG funds. The exception is Home Depot, which is a regular in ESG funds and replaces Berkshire Hathaway in the overall S&P 500 index. In other words, the top ten holdings, representing nearly 30% of the standard investment benchmark, are the same companies that represent roughly 30% of most popular ESG funds. Similar results are also displayed for international funds in the second chart below – of the top ten holdings, only SAP is found in ESG funds and not in MSCI EAFE.
Given the huge overlap in the major holdings of the benchmark and ESG companies, it is not overly surprising that there is little air between the price performance of the S&P 500 and well-known ESG ETFs and funds (see the chart below).
Since not even the most fervent proponents of these funds would believe that the S&P500 qualifies as an ESG index, it is more likely that the rapidly increasing consensus is correct: most ESG funds are labelled as such simply due to a bare-minimum exclusion policy. By weeding out a few names with unsavory practices and/or higher carbon footprints, an ESG label can be applied. The chart below offers substantial evidence that this has been the case.
The S&P energy sector accounts for 2.3% of the overall S&P 500. In the past year, S&P500 ex-energy has underperformed the broad index due to the substantial price gains in oil prices over the same time frame. This behavior matches almost perfectly the performance of ESG funds over the past two years: just as S&P 500 ex-energy underperforms (outperforms) the broad index when oil prices rise (fall), ESG funds outperform the S&P 500 when oil prices sink and underperform when they rise.
Bottom line: there is negligible tracking error between many conventional ESG funds and their benchmarks. These products offer no discernable diversification or specific properties to investors.
2: Condemned to Have an Itching Palm?
If the results above are discouraging for investors that may buy ESG funds with the expectation that they are making a difference, the second issue at stake with many ESG products will perhaps dishearten them further. Using the same basket of U.S.-listed ESG ETFs, we find the average AUM-adjusted MER is 16.2 bps. This compares to just 3 bps for the cheapest S&P 500 Index ETF! Note that the same phenomenon exists in Europe: the average AUM adjusted MER is 17.4bps versus 7bps for the cheapest MSCI EAFE Index ETF.
Bottom line: Investors tend to pay two-to-three times the expense ratio to have 3 letters (ESG) added to the name of their holdings. Save for the letters, there is little else that justifies the management fees; investing in these products often amounts to overpaying for a generic basket.
Part B: Emerging Solutions
1. We Must Not Make a Scarecrow of the Law
Initially, the label ESG came about in part because there is a general belief that it would help investors recognize opportunities that can positively impact society and the environment. However, since there are many shades of green and impact is subjective, our analysis above shows how easy it is to be ESG, without actually shifting capital in a meaningful way.
In Europe, regulators are beginning to get out in front of this phenomenon, by putting in place the Sustainable Financial Disclosures Regulation (SFDR). The SFDR came into effect in March 2021 and is designed to help investors understand, compare, and monitor the sustainability characteristics of investment funds by standardizing sustainability disclosures. Although, there are only 10 months of data, it is already clear that this regulation has influenced the offering of investment products and have helped investors discriminate among them. The table below shows the most commonly held holdings in “Article 9” funds, i.e. funds that are held to the strictest level of environmental disclosure. Apart from Microsoft and Alphabet, there is no overlap between the top holdings of the S&P 500 and conventional ESG Funds.
Note that SFDR is meant to provide transparency on both environmental and social characteristics. However, the regulation has been particularly effective so far as it relates to the environment because EU taxonomy regulation has provided specific environmental criteria related to economic activities for investment purpose. A similar taxonomy for social issues is in development, but will not be enforced for at least two more years. Moreover, SFDR is a European regulation, and applies to only to European market players and non-European players that do business in Europe. Implementing SFDR and/or introducing similar legislation at a global level would no doubt go a long way to improving the labelling of ESG-related investment products.
2. He Thinks Too Much; Such Men Are Dangerous
A second necessary ingredient to improving the ESG investment product offering is increased volume from the unofficial arbiters. This is already at work; investigative journalists like Saijel Kishan and Cam Simpson at Bloomberg are helping to expose the incongruencies between the marketing of solutions and the actual positions of portfolios.
Just slapping the name ESG on a fund and excluding a few names from the universe of investments is unlikely to cut it in the future as more information becomes available and investors realize they are not getting their money’s worth.
Part C: Practical Advice for Investors Seeking True ESG
Given the emerging solutions outlined above, it is clear that there is no substitute for doing one’s homework. Investors that truly aim to invest in sustainability themes will find that using broad ESG ETFs as a short-cut is often expensive without necessarily arriving at the correct destination. Some ways to avoid the pitfalls of broad ESG ETFs include the following:
- Invest in Article 9 funds and/or replicate their holdings: as highlighted above, funds that adhere to Article 9 standards offer a much higher level of differentiation.
- Verify the top 10 Holdings: A quick scan of the top 10 holdings of ETF funds is an effective way to reject paying supplemental management fees should the holdings significantly overlap with standard equity benchmarks like the S&P 500.
- Understand the methodology: funds based solely on exclusion policies have a greater likelihood of resembling benchmarks with only minor tweaks.
- Consider active management, high-tracking errors, single-theme bespoke products: the only way to have different results is to do something different! ETFs that aim to tackle a single problem and/or theme will have a higher propensity to provide differentiation, although even here, many ETF providers stretch definitions to cast a wider net of investable companies. KRBN (carbon), LIFE (environment), are examples of ETFs with a high concentration of holdings that strongly reflect the desired properties suggested in their name.
One of the most frequently asked questions from clients and prospective clients is “where do you get your ideas?” The question is tougher than it may seem and our answer is rarely eloquent! As a result, and in the interest of always improving, our 2021 end-of-year reflection included identifying the secret sauce of (good) idea generation.
At SMS, we think there might be three factors that invariably help professional teams that strive to produce original, insightful research: cognitive diversity across team members, an institutional culture of freedom of speech, and an extremely healthy dose of curiosity! Today’s Note addresses the latter: we share with you some of our favourite published work that we have uncovered through jumping down internet rabbit holes and participating in lively back-to-office discussions. From classics to newly published work, we hope you find a few nuggets to fuel your holiday conversations and merrymaking (Omicron permitting of course). From all of us at Sustainable Market Strategies, we wish you the very best end to 2021 and prosperous 2022 beginnings.
The New Climate War by Michael Mann
In The New Climate War, Michael Mann discusses the next front in tackling rising global temperatures now that climate change is generally accepted as real. Mann disarms the arguments (division, deflection and doomism) deployed to hamper the efforts and changes necessary to avoid a climate disaster. In exposing these tactics, he offers an important lesson in greenwashing and the key elements to address it: education, systemic change and the next generation of voters.
Deaths of Despair and the Future of Capitalism by Anne Case and Angus Deaton
The book questions the future of excessive capitalism by examining education, income and health inequalities. This information is vital for investors since understanding the flaws in the status quo can help forecast which parts are most subject to change over time. For capitalism to evolve in the right direction, the weaknesses in the triangle of health, education and income inequalities need to be addressed.
The Fourth Turning by William Strauss and Neil Howe
A 1997 classic describing the specific generational traits and the characteristic evolution of society through time from the passage of leadership from generation to generation. Those cycles are illustrated with seasons from the High (Spring), the Awakening (Summer), the Unraveling (Fall), the Crisis (Winter). The book forecasted a transition to Crisis (Winter) during the mid-2000 based on generational characteristics. We had the Great Financial Crisis in 2008 and since then, the mood of the population has eroded and we are reaching a critical point. This information coincides with our macro view (link to Macro Goes ESG) that the make-up of society will change because of the climate crisis and social inequalities. This transition will be disruptive and we see the imprints of the Millennials in the political make-up pushing society forward towards a new High (Spring).
New Climate Capitalism by Denise Young
This podcast is about change-makers working at the intersection of activism, finance and investment. A wide range of topics are discussed from the role of activist hedge funds (see our Note on April 22, 2021) to recent degrowth ideas at the IPCC. The podcast’s (mostly) practical and pragmatic nature helps investors understand climate challenges and what can be accomplished by the private and public sectors.
Just Have a Think by David Borlace
Just Have a Think is a Youtube channel with short, easy-to-digest videos about sustainable technology and the environment. In each episode, David Borlace explains complex problems and their potential solutions simply. The content is particularly useful in deciphering what are true technological solutions (on an appropriate timeline) from those that are not.
The Beckisphere Climate Corner by Becky Hoag
Becky Hoag is an under-30 science writer and communicator. On her Youtube channel, she produces a bi-monthly clip that summarizes the previous two weeks of climate news. The Beckisphere is an easy, fun way to keep abreast of science and climate issues with far-reaching implications, including investment portfolios.
Thinking, Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahnerman
This well-known book is one that we keep coming back to over and over again. Kahneman’s behavioral experiments that uncover human irrationality, overconfidence and the role of luck are particularly fascinating and have multiple implications for investors and for everyday life. Although Kahneman’s seminal book does not explicitly address climate change and other environmental and social factors, the cognitive barriers that he outlines in this book are extremely compelling to understand environmental (non-) action. Our use of heuristics, which evolved to equip us with faster decision-making abilities, also leads us to make systematic and predictable errors. There is now a wide body of research at the intersection of the environment and behavioral science but for investors, the original Kahneman work remains a must-read.
Unraveled The Life and Death of a Garment by Maxine Bedart
The author goes on a mission to track the life and death of a pair of jeans, starting with a cotton grower in Texas, to a textile factory in China, Bangladesh to be cut and sewn, with inputs from various nations along the way … back to America to be worn and finally, to be burned in a trash pile in Ghana. For investors that have been particularly jolted by supply chain disruptions over the past two years, this book offers an extreme close-up view of just how complex supply chains are – even for simple items like a pair of jeans. It isn’t hard to imagine which parts of the supply chain could be altered should regulation and/or price signals from labor and other inputs shift.
The Lorax by Dr. Seuss
Another 15 billion trees died on earth in 2021. Dr. Seuss’ classic children’s story – which turned 50 this year – feels more relevant today than ever. Trees, along with other vegetation, continue to be the most effective carbon sink available. And yet, although this year’s forest fires were tragic, most of the trees were once again lost to planned human deforestation. In April 2022, the U.N.’s COP 15 on biodiversity will be an excellent opportunity for investors to sharpen their focus around nature-based solutions to climate change. Beyond the moral message of taking a stand, The Lorax offers an important reminder of the value of nature – trees – when viewed as an increasingly scarce resource – are worth more when standing in healthy forests than when exploited as resources.

Question 1: What is “net zero” and why is it important for the planet and for investors?
Net zero refers to the amount of greenhouse gases (GHG) emitted into the atmosphere. These emissions contribute directly to global warming and if emissions continue unchecked, limiting the temperature increase to 1.5 degrees will no longer be attainable. Net zero pledges aim to stabilize the total amount of CO2 present in the atmosphere, either by reducing an emitting activity and/or by offsetting the emissions with actions that remove CO2.
For investors, ignoring net zero poses not only climate risk but also missed investment opportunities. As the world transitions to a low carbon economy, demand for assets that lower - even cancel - emissions will increase and will be further supported through policy and regulation (see The Inevitable Policy Response 2021: Policy Forecasts).
Question 2. What is scope 1, scope 2 and scope 3? And what does Net Zero mean for asset owners and asset managers?
Net zero pledges are typically designed based on the level of business activity or “scope” that will be included in an emissions target. Scope 1 emissions are those that a company is directly responsible for within its operations and is the lowest level of ambition for pledges. Scope 2 emissions include those that result from the acquisition or purchase of energy (electricity, steam, heat, coolant). Finally, Scope 3 considers the emissions not covered by Scopes 1 and 2 by looking at the upstream and downstream value chain of a company. In theory, since one company’s scope 3 emissions are another company’s scope 1 emissions, if every entity in the world participated in net zero, simply accounting for scope 1 emissions would suffice. However, since the latter is not yet the case (plenty of companies have not made commitments and/or commitments are not creditworthy – please see question 3 below), the need for measuring scopes 2 and 3 emissions arises. Overall, what is important is that ALL emissions are accounted and pledged for, whichever scope captures it.
For investors, pledges can be important. First, asset managers and owners increasingly use net zero pledges as a basis for aspects of proxy voting (investors generally have focused on scope 1 and scope 2 for voting purposes). These actions provide incentives for corporations to divest from high emission activities.
Second, the prevalence of net zero pledges has given rise to the Net Zero Investment Framework (NZIF). Created by the Institutional Investors Group on Climate Change (IIGCC) which has over 360 members, the framework has two objectives: decarbonize by 2050 and increase climate solutions. Importantly, participants in the Net Zero Investment Framework do not necessarily have portfolios with Net Zero carbon emissions but they commit to investing in companies that are measurably reducing their emissions and/or provide solutions to reduce overall emissions.
While the commitment by many asset owners and managers is a step forward, the NZIF remains lenient and subject to wide interpretation. Government rules will accelerate the process.
Question 3: How can investors trust that a company with a net-zero pledge is truly reducing emissions and will achieve their ambitions?
The first major hurdle is the credibility and strength of corporations’ pledges and as with any element of investing, there is no substitute for doing the research. As stated above, about 90% of world GDP is covered by net zero pledges, but that number shrinks to 10% (and 5%) of global emissions, if only institutions with strong commitments and clear plans are included. Sustainable Market Strategies investigates the strength of companies’ pledges as one input to our research process. For investors that desire to cross-reference, the Net Zero Tracker is a free, web-based tool that tabulates net zero targets and indicates the integrity of those targets.
A second test of credibility is whether a company has set Scope 3 GHG emissions reduction targets, since including these emissions sets a much higher bar for success. Companies that subscribe to standards or certify their engagement with third-party auditors also show that they are transparent about their efforts.
The Science-Based Targets initiative (SBTi) is the most advanced initiative regarding GHG emissions reduction targets, as it certifies reduction targets submitted by companies based on science. The SBTi has translated the scenarios and pathways underlying the IPCC Special Report on 1.5°C into a set of resources that companies can use to model 1.5°C-aligned targets, or well-below 2°C targets. Certified SBTi targets are one of the main elements used to determine the credibility of a company’s climate strategy.
Question 4: To what precision is carbon being measured?
Companies that report carbon emission are using either their own company data, the average emissions in their sector, or modelled data. The disclosure of carbon data by companies is loosely regulated, and is therefore often subject to company goodwill.
The least degree of precision is in quantifying methane emissions (from farm animals, leaks in natural gas systems, leaks from melting permafrost, etc.) which represent 11% of global GHG emissions and are significantly more harmful than carbon emissions.
The Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Protocol, which supplies the world's most widely used greenhouse gas accounting standard, could serve as a standard for GHG accounting, given that it also takes into account scope 3 emissions and presents a calculation guide for these emissions. Obviously, standardization and more regulation would lead to better carbon calculation.
Question 5: How does this “translate” to investing? How can asset managers and owners influence outcomes by using net zero pledges?
Asset managers cannot “front run” the real economy with regard to climate change, which remains a real economic issue as opposed to a financial market issue. So unfortunately, it is possible to have “net zero” portfolios and a planet that is still warming.
Some of the smartest ESG investment strategies offer negative carbon footprints (according to SBTi methodology) in a total portfolio context by using long/short portfolios. This can put additional pressure on real-economy players (i.e. the management teams of listed companies) to adopt more aggressive decarbonization.
Credibility remains an issue. As Keynes famously said, “In the long run, we are all dead.” Commitments to become net zero in 2050 (another 29 years of emissions) will be nowhere near sufficient if implementation plans are too timid in the short run. An excellent way to avoid this pitfall is for investors to prioritize allocating capital to companies led by management teams who prioritize science-based targets for GHG reduction and even tie them into pay packages
Question 6: How much of the net zero commitments rely on technology that does not exist or is clearly not economical today?
The International Energy Agency posits that half of 2050 reductions in emissions will have to come from technologies at demonstration or prototype phase. The Net Zero Investment Framework highlights the need for new investments to reduce our carbon footprint. For investors, the natural response to a problem is to invest in technology to get it solved. Those technologies generally require more resources. We may be at a critical point where the resource use of the planet for industrialization is reaching its limit and we have to think about resource optimization and significant reduction in GHG emissions instead of counting on technology.
Question 7: Do net zero pledges reduce the perceived need for carbon taxes? Don’t they also shift the responsibility away from the consumer?
In our view, it is almost certainly the case that (voluntary) net zero pledges and SBTis remove some amount of pressure from policymakers and regulators to impose strict legislation on emitters. Absent net zero pledges, we have no doubt that governments would feel a greater responsibility to act, but it is an open question whether elected politicians would act. It is not clear that the degree of global cooperation is sufficient to deal with (global) climate change in the current geopolitical backdrop.
Ultimately, the burden of the transition towards a cleaner future will fall to citizens and consumers and this reality has not yet sunk in for most. Carbon taxes, either emissions taxes or border adjustment taxes, are a financial penalty that will be passed on in large part by corporations to consumers. If these financial penalties are not imposed, much steeper non-financial penalties (i.e. reduced quality of life) will occur. The upside of initiatives like the SBTi is that they incentivize companies to act in the short term to reduce their GHG emissions and avoid paying a carbon tax when and if they will be applicable.
Question 8: How do carbon offsets fit it in and what is the share of carbon offsets vs. carbon cutting in the net zero game? Isn’t this “cheating”?
In waste management, there is a hierarchy when it comes to the 3 Rs: “Reduce” is more important than “Recycle.” It’s the same in carbon management. The priority should be on reducing emissions, then offsetting the hard to abate emissions remaining. On top of this, all carbon credits are not created equal. For a carbon credit to be qualified as strong, it needs to have all of the following criteria:
- Real – there is evidence that the project actually removes or prevents emissions
- Additional – the emissions reductions would not occur without those project activities
- Measurable – the volume of emissions reductions can be accurately measured
- Verifiable – a neutral, third-party auditor has verified the emissions reductions
- No double counting – a registry ensures that the offset credit is used only once.
Increasingly, offset buyers are looking beyond the “carbon” of “carbon offsets” and are looking for environmental and social co-benefits. The more SDGs a carbon credit hits, the more valuable it becomes.
That said, it is still very much “the Wild West” when it comes to the voluntary market. Mark Carney’s Taskforce for Scaling Voluntary Carbon Markets aims to standardize and scale up the market as quickly as possible – which is welcome news. Even the Science Based Target Initiative is that offsets have a role to play in the path to net zero. So, is it cheating? Not if used correctly. And the increase in price of the most credible credits should de facto discourage ill-intentioned companies who wish they could pay a cheap price to tick the “net-zero” box.
Inflation has become a central issue for investors of all stripes; consumer prices are rising faster than seen in over two decades.
The current debate about whether inflation will be transitory is not trivial since inflation is an important factor in asset class performance. In our view, investors that are in the “inflation is transitory” camp risk overlooking a key change in the macroeconomic landscape: the increasing importance of ESG-related cross-currents.
In this Insight Report, we describe and evaluate the potential for inflation to emanate from each of Sustainable Market Strategies’ six major ESG investable themes. After netting out all of the cross-currents, we conclude that ESG factors on the whole have the firepower to boost global inflationary pressures.
Making Supply Chains Resilient: Inflationary
Among all our themes, the trend toward more resilient supply chains is, in our view, the theme whereby the link to rising inflation is most direct.
The past two years of logistics’ challenges can be explained more as a series of relative price shocks rather than “too much money chasing too few goods”: a lack of semiconductor chips meant that fewer cars were assembled (and car prices went up), lumber shortages meant that construction activity slowed (and building prices went up), etc. Although it is enticing to view each event as a one-off, we expect relative price shocks will become frequent and we are in good company: according to President Biden’s 100-day Supply Chain Review, “the U.S. needs to ensure resilient, diverse, and secure supply chains … pandemics and other biological threats, cyber-attacks, climate shocks and extreme weather events, [etc] reduce critical manufacturing capacity and the availability and integrity of critical goods, products, and services.”
Standard business practice has been to leverage technology as well as stable international trading to maximize efficiency. As the chart shows, companies were able to pass on savings to consumers, and still maintain high profit margins within a globally competitive backdrop. However, this has become increasingly difficult.
An important question for investors is how this dynamic will impact interest rates. Monetary policymakers tend to look through transitory price changes (relative price shocks) as policy is geared toward longer term outcomes. However, the task of forecasting longer term inflation becomes challenging when relative price shocks frequently cloud underlying trends. Recent research by the Federal Reserve acknowledges that during the pandemic, there was an unprecedented increase in inflation uncertainty among consumers. This was also witnessed in the volatility of inflation expectations in the bond market.
Key takeaway: global supply chain disruptions emanating from various ESG factors will be increasingly frequent and economically significant. These disruptions will in turn cause more significant relative price changes. These price shocks may not result in “generalized inflation” but will nevertheless result in rising costs to consumers and businesses and will make it more difficult for policymakers to diagnose the underlying trend.
Leaving No Person Behind: Inflationary
Perhaps the most straightforward link between inflation and ESG factors is through the labor market. After decades of rising inequality within nations as well as an inability to close the gap between rich and poor countries, there is mounting pressure and societal desire for a fairer playing field. There are several issues at work, but among the most significant:
(1) Shareholders versus stakeholders: There is a growing understanding that companies that create value exclusively for shareholders without regard for other stakeholders will be scorned by consumers and investors alike. The implication is that the share of profits that go to shareholders is likely capped in favour of a greater share going to labor: wages are likely to rise on a multi-year basis to reflect this societal desire for companies to consider a greater range of stakeholders.
(2) Workplace gender equality: Although equality among all workers is a significant issue, we believe that the role of women in the labor market, in particular, has the potential to raise wages and overall inflation. Recent headlines have focused on the sharp drop in overall female participation rates (especially in the U.S.) as women left the workforce to be caregivers. However, focusing on prime working age (25-54 years old) tells a different story: the participation in this age bracket for both men and women have returned to pre-pandemic rates (and the participation rate for women in this bracket is near historic highs). This suggests that that the likelihood of adding a “new pool” of labor, such as occurred from 1950–1990 when women marched into the labor market, is unlikely. Employers will need to pay more to compete for labor resources in a generally tight labor market, which will create an upward tilt to wage inflation.
(3) Human rights practices: companies with supply chains in developing countries will face pressure to improve social conditions in the countries in which they operate. Eradicating child labor and implementing fair pay initiatives implies that the “global minimum wage” will increase and/or the supply of available labor will shrink.
Key takeaway: a strengthening position of labor will put upward pressure on wages.
Productivity With Purpose: Disinflationary
The creation of tools to improve productivity (and therefore standards of living) is primarily deflationary: if improved productivity means that the production of goods and services can scale efficiently enough to satisfy the market's present and future demand, then the price of those goods should not increase even if demand goes up.
Note that the role of technology in setting prices is no different within an ESG framework than outside of one. The major challenges of the coming decade will be mitigating and adapting to climate change, as well as reducing social inequalities. Therefore, to the extent that these challenges can be resolved with the use of technology, these tools will act as a damper on inflation. Indeed, this is what has occurred across industries for several years.
Key takeaway: Technological advances will be necessary to confront the challenges of the next decade. Associated productivity gains will put downward pressure on prices.
Building Better Markets: Neutral/inflationary
Our theme of building better markets encapsulates our conviction that a wave of regulation – both for the financial industry and corporations – is likely (and necessary) in the coming years. The broad premise is that over time, regulation will: help ensure that private industries continue to operate in areas where for-profit models produce superior outcomes, while exiting those where they don’t (e.g. prisons); will increase the likelihood that for-profit industries increasingly pay for the negative externalities that they create (e.g. carbon, pollution); ensure that a broad set of rules are followed to guarantee that the private sector creates value for a broader set of stakeholders than simply shareholders.
To the extent increased regulation is employed to build better markets, these increased rigidities (regulation) are likely to mean that inflation will be “stickier” than would otherwise be the case.
Key takeaway: greater regulation of key industries introduces macroeconomic rigidities that would put upward pressure on inflation.
Achieving the Energy Transition & Protecting Natural Capital: Neutral/Disinflationary
In the case of our two environmental themes, there are two main factors to consider:
(1) the price of fossil fuel energy and how it will impact demand/supply fundamentals of other goods and services
(2) the likelihood that negative externalities that are currently cheap or free will need to be priced and accounted for.
In the case of fossil fuel prices, a critical point is that energy is a relatively inelastic good: there is little change in the quantity demanded when the price changes. Although “green” energy can be a substitute for fossil fuels (and therefore fossil fuel demand will change), the overall demand for energy is unlikely to be altered significantly in the years ahead. As the chart shows, since the mid-1980s changes in the price of energy (fossil fuels) have not affected the price of other goods and services. Rather, a rise (fall) in energy prices acts as a tax (windfall) to the consumer. Forecasters purporting that the energy transition will be inflationary are therefore making a significant (and unproven) assumption – that any increase in energy prices will be passed on to end users. Although this may occur, it would be a marked break from the inflation dynamics of the past thirty years. For now, we expect that any rise in energy prices will continue acting as a tax on growth, rather than sparking a wave of generalized inflation.
Similarly, to the extent that other environmental costs (e.g. carbon) that have hitherto not been borne by consumers begin to be accounted for, we would view this cost in a similar fashion as energy prices: any inflationary pressure will depend on the ability for producers to pass on increased costs to consumers. This is far from a foregone conclusion.
Key takeaway: energy price swings have not impacted generalized inflation dynamics for decades and it is premature to expect this to change anytime soon.
The ESG “industry” suffered a double blow recently when the former CIO of BlackRock’s Sustainable Investing arm published a 30-page essay on why he thinks ESG investing is – and will remain – mostly a smokescreen for asset owners looking to change the world with their assets. At the same time, the ex-head of Sustainability at DWS, a large European asset manager, also blew the whistle on the firm’s ESG foundations – or the lack thereof – which sent the company’s stock plummeting.
While one should remain critical of any ex-employee allegations of their previous employer, today’s note examines the arguments put forth from highly visible “ESG whistleblowers” and provides our view on whether the skepticism is warranted. We also conjecture on the future of ESG investing and its potential impact on the real world.
ESG teams don’t talk to investment people: Kind of true.
Given the nature of SMS’ business, we interact with several of the world’s largest ESG and investment teams within some of the largest investment groups. In some cases, these teams remain quite separate, with, on one hand the Head of ESG and, on the other hand, the Head of Investments. We have observed that sometimes these two silos don’t communicate much, save for marketing and client servicing purposes. We believe that full ESG integration will come once there is attribution of some P&L to the ESG function – or the “ESG overlay of a portfolio” perhaps akin to the macro function in asset management. This trend is beginning but has much further to go.
ESG is useful for the industry to talk about itself: True.
The financial world is quite good to put up pay-to-play type conferences to talk about itself. In this context, ESG remains a great “narrative” for the industry to justify its social mission and mitigate its reputation after the massive tarnishing following the 2008 financial crisis. As such, ESG conferences, have become the hallmark of financial and asset management communication strategies. One potential indicator of the asset management industry’s commitment to ESG objectives would be the changing nature of industry perks. For example, do conference hosts dare serve meatless meals? Do executives continue to fly business class, given the extra GHG emissions related to this type of travel? Unfortunately, our observations are that these “soft” indicators do not yet show much change in behavior. Interestingly, it also seems that ESG/Sustainability heads are now becoming even more present than Chief Economists when talking up their firms’ investment strategies and how they can align "doing good" with financial performance.
The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase its Profits. An irrelevant discussion
Investing in ESG inevitably brings about a discussion about what the mission of business is since ESG skeptics assume that it is impossible to construct a portfolio that delivers positive externalities (higher wages, cleaner water, lower carbon footprint, etc.) while delivering performance on par with portfolios without positive externalities. To us, this argument is extremely dangerous, not because this narrow definition of responsibility risks favoring the greedy and the ruthless, but rather because it shows a failure to understand the wider investment landscape. At SMS, one of our central investment beliefs is that successful investing requires anticipating what society will care about in the future; we have repeatedly shown evidence that a myriad of social and environmental causes are increasingly mobilizing societies. Investing in companies that embrace these societal goals will deliver superior returns, not despite their ‘loftier goals’ but precisely because they will be more highly valued from the goods, services and business models they offer. This value creation might be direct (e.g., providing a technological solution to an environmental or social problem) or indirect (e.g., decreasing reputational risk via exemplary social and governance practices).
The Rules of the Game Are Broken. True, but it is dishonest to shift the blame on another part of the system.
Investors who shun ESG as an investment strategy often argue that their profession is powerless: it is government that needs to ‘fix’ important issues like climate change and income inequality. This is true: a myriad of rules (e.g., imposing caps on CEO pay, instituting a highly punitive carbon tax) could be administered to severely mitigate risks in the ESG universe. Bold policy initiatives take courage and willful leaders; it also takes engaged citizens to elect them. But the necessity for stronger regulation does not excuse financial participants and investment professionals from using the tools at their disposal to influence outcomes.
Sustainable investing is becoming a deadly distraction that is doing more harm than good.False, but the propensity and facility of greenwashing is way too high.
Marketing investment products that proclaim to be making a difference, but actually do very little, allows for the general public to ‘feel good’ about ESG while absolving them from taking decisive action. There is no doubt that this form of greenwashing is alive and well in the investment industry (‘ESG-aware’ ETFs should not be fooling anyone). But dishonest marketing is as old as snake oil and is perhaps inevitable in the nascent phases of ESG adoption. Recall that FASB accounting rules were established in the 1970s but took over twenty-five years before becoming the international golden standard (remember Enron in 2000). Regulatory instruments related to ESG are only in their infancy (SFDR) and it is certainly not the first time that financial markets and their participants are ahead of the regulatory backdrop.
ESG lacks a “theory of change”: False, remember that people respond to incentives
A common argument among ESG skeptics is that ESG lacks a theory of change. Therefore, for those asking what ESG can achieve besides fees for the financial industry, one has to look at how ESG investors have been reshaping markets these past few years. Here’s how we see ESG impacting the real world beyond the financial space.
For one, with ESG flows towards sustainable strategies (at least in name) forecasted to be in the hundreds of trillions over the next decade, one can easily say that the ESG tsunami of money is already reshaping markets – and individual stock and sectoral valuations with it. As such, the flow-of-funds into ESG themes and companies which are developing solutions to real-world problems (as opposed to developing problems such as tobacco or gaming) is giving a powerful price signal to investors. By doing so, investors are pushing up prices of companies that they think are actually changing the world for good.
The corollary effect of the tsunami of “sustainability-themed” money now going into the equity market acts as a powerful incentive for company executives to deliver the real-world impact that ESG investors are looking for. With more than 7% of a typical S&P 500 company’s float in possession of executives (according to Bloomberg data), feeding ESG investors the meal they’ve been craving can have a powerful impact not only on the real world – but also on their total pay package – which is probably the strongest ESG incentive of all. To this end, the emergence of a greater number of models of sustainability-linked pay packages should be a key engagement focus area ahead.
Secondly, one can see that firms that achieve superior ESG scores (taking the aggregate of all ESG scoring agencies) are rewarded with access to cheaper financing for debt and equity – suggesting that ESG can actually have a very material impact on a company’s cost of capital, capital structure and profitability. While many executives are now “gaming the ESG report” of their own companies (such as the likes of Philip Morris), one could think that companies which are actually producing something useful to solve our world’s problems – the true definition of impact investing – are also benefitting from ESG-minded investors’ appetite of for future-positive investment assets.
For the past three decades, equity investors could reliably count on central bankers around the world to ensure investment opportunities. Regulating the business cycle via interest rates meant that a certain rhythm and predictability to economic expansions and contractions could be capitalized upon to make investment decisions. However, although monetary policy was the right tool for its time, it is becoming increasingly clear that current challenges require something more.
The structural transition to fiscal as the dominant policy force is already in full swing. The investment implications of this shift will be major. In this report, we detail how this phenomenon will take ESG from a niche investing theme to a central force that will drive returns across asset classes.
Monetary Policy Dominance: The End of an Era
Business cycles and macroeconomic conditions are the foundation of investment decisions. Although each business cycle is different, the various stages – if properly identified – have reliably offered periodic entry and exit points to different assets and asset classes.
For investors, over the past thirty years, identifying and capitalizing on the various stages of the business cycle has overwhelmingly centred on one thing: positioning for the monetary policy backdrop.
Of course, it wasn’t always this way: prior to the 1980s, both fiscal and monetary policy levers worked – sometimes together and sometimes in opposition – to steer the economic path of various nations.
However, the watershed moment for U.S. monetary history – with global repercussion – is undeniably when Fed Chairman Paul Volcker, in the fall of 1979, took dramatic steps to rein in runaway inflation. After elected officials – headed by Presidents Nixon and Carter – failed to solve skyrocketing prices with wage and price controls and currency debasement, it was Volcker who ultimately proved that rampant prices could be corrected by curbing the money supply.
Not only did Volcker set the table for long, prosperous economic expansions for subsequent decades, but he shifted – and cemented – the place of monetary policymakers at the head of that table.
The Fed, using interest rates as its primary tool, was wildly successful at fulfilling its dual mandate: the below chart shows that from 1985 to 2009, the Fed was largely able to adjust monetary policy in order to deliver the level of interest rates required to generate economic growth and price stability. However, as the chart shows, that all changed at the time of the Great Recession. At the zero bound on interest rates, central banks have had to resort to unconventional policy tools (quantitative easing). There has been much debate about the efficacy of QE programs, and a detailed analysis is outside the scope of this report. We simply note that while QE is broadly effective at ensuring market liquidity and therefore reducing financial market and banking system stress, its ability to manage economic growth is far less impactful.
Even the most fervent monetarists would concede that most of today’s economic challenges are ill suited to the prescription; rising inequality, the hollowing out of middle class, jobs outsourced to robots and overseas workers… these are not things that can be fixed by adjusting the level of interest rates and the money supply.
The bottom line is that monetary policy has been wildly successful at managing business cycles and inflation over the past 30 years; this monetary dominance has made for a methodical, iterative framework for investors. However, since the Great Recession of 2007-2008, it has become increasingly clear that new tools – outside of the monetary sphere – are necessary to tackle the most pressing economic issues.
Fiscal Policy: Into the Overton Window
As it happens, it was a central banker that most powerfully and presciently called the peak in monetary policy dominance. Writing in the Washington Post while at the helm of the U.S. Federal Reserve in November 2010, Ben Bernanke declared, “The Federal Reserve cannot solve all the economy's problems on its own.” He subsequently called on Congress, the administration, and regulators to do more.
To be sure, Trump’s four-year Presidential interlude paused the advancement of fiscal policy as a tool to manage the economy. However, it has been abundantly clear since Joe Biden’s first day in office that taxation and spending are no longer dirty words in Washington. Indeed, by most accounts, fiscal policy has now transited from the Reagan-era ‘big government is bad’ to something that is socially acceptable. The Overton Window refers to the notion that policymakers must choose from the range of policies that are politically acceptable at the time. We posit that since 2010, fiscal policy has moved within the window of acceptable policy. Indeed, the American electorate is increasingly comfortable with the role of government (i.e. fiscal policy) and would like it to play a larger role (see Chart).
The key takeaway is that there is a fundamental shift in the importance between the two branches of macroeconomic policy. The multi-decade era of monetary policy dominance has ceded to one where fiscal levers – taxation, spending and regulation – will be far more important. This has significant implications for the business cycle and by extension, investors.
Monetary is to Fiscal as Hammer is to Scalpel
As is now well known, monetary policy – controlling the money supply – is a blunt and rather undiscriminating instrument for producing economic outcomes. Indeed, in the Fed’s own words in 2003, “monetary policy …is a ‘blunt instrument’ that can not be selectively used to stimulate the economies of particular regions or industries.” It follows that the same blunt instrument cannot be selectively used to stimulate the growth of particular socioeconomic groups, demographic tranches, etc. Some would say, in fact, that recent monetary policy has contributed to income equality.
Fiscal policy, on the other hand, almost by definition is rather like a scalpel; there are almost infinite ways to slice, dissect and attempt to reconstruct the economy through legislation (spending and taxation) and regulation.
There are several implications for financial markets, but we focus on those that we view as most critical for investors:
- When central banking dominates, progress can be easily measured against the two stated policy goals: inflation and employment. In contrast, when fiscal policy dominates, measuring progress is more complex, since stated policy goals can be multiple, competing and can change over time. Thus, the era of iterative, business cycle investing based on transparent, rules-based monetary policy will give way to more irregular market outcomes.
- When compared to monetary policy, economic management through fiscal policy will create specific winners and losers, which leads to more dispersion in prices across companies and industries.
- These winners and losers will be an approximation of voters’ desires, since dominant policymakers (elected officials) decisions are strongly tied to their re-election prospects. Thus, the prevalent concerns of voters - through their ability to trigger policy outcomes - will become a critical factor in investor success in the decade ahead.
Macro Goes ESG
As detailed above, when fiscal policy begins to shape the macro landscape, understanding voter preferences becomes key to investing. Historically, voters have almost always prioritized economic growth and although this remains the top concern, its relative importance to voters has declined (the abrupt halt to economic activity due to the pandemic caused a major flare-up in economic worries in 2020, but we do not expect this to reverse the trend that has been in place since 2012).
A raft of environmental and social issues are fast becoming the prevalent concerns. Inadequate health and education, racial injustice, stagnant wages, climate change are just a few of the growing priorities among voters.
The link to ESG investing thus becomes clear: the preferred macroeconomic policy (fiscal) will increasingly reflect voter preferences that are governed by environmental, social and governance issues. These ESG themes - previously viewed as a niche investment class – will become major drivers of investment strategies.
Indeed, this phenomenon is already being borne out in the data. It is widely known that investment flows to ESG funds has skyrocketed in recent years. Moreover, general interest in ‘ESG’ has seen a secular rise, while the peak in ‘macro’ has already occurred.
Fiscal Policy As A Driver of (ESG) Productivity
Governments around the world are increasingly aware of this shift of voter preferences. But perhaps nowhere is it more clear than in the United States, where the Biden-Harris government’s stated policy priorities mirror the social and environmental concerns of our time. Even more important, there appears enough political support for these projects that government spending will follow; Biden’s infrastructure plan has good chances of passing and will release over 1$ trillion in new spending over the next five years.
Crucially, the importance of infrastructure spending goes well beyond the direct impact of boosting GDP in the short term and providing an immediate improvement to services for citizens. While the empirical magnitude of the effect is often debated, there is academic consensus that government infrastructure has been a determinant to aggregate productivity growth.
The implication is that the much-needed boost to U.S. infrastructure will pay dividends long after the initial spending boost is over. In this way, expansive fiscal policy has the potential to boost sectoral productivity by unleashing the next innovation wave, producing winners (and losers) along the way. By earmarking spending to particular sectors (e.g. ‘green’ infrastructure, health and long-term care), there are good odds that superior productivity and investment returns will be generated in corresponding industries.
What is the Crypto Space? Blockchain, cryptocurrencies, stable coins backed by traditional assets, a disintermediation tool, an anonymous medium of exchange for criminals, a tool of amusement for Elon Musk or maybe something else.
The two trends the financial media is getting excited about are ESG (as are we), and Crypto, more specifically Bitcoin. For Crypto, the hype often reduces the discussion to superficial analysis and binary beliefs. Notwithstanding the hyperbole, there is a massive potential for finance, health care, law and product tracing to improve exactness, speed and costs from blockchain. While the hype remains elevated these days for all things Crypto – it seems that its interest as a “world-ending” monetary debasement trade could fade.
That said, the brainpower attracted to the space due to its potential applications holds significant hope for developments to rival the impact of the Internet. Since our last note on the topic (“An ESG Building Block(chain) for your Portfolio?”, October 18, 2018), there has been tremendous activity in the Crypto space but very little visibility on significant developments with life-changing effects. Reminiscent of the Dot-com craze, get-rich quick schemes are a natural consequence. The winners of the space are not known in advance. Few people thought that an online bookstore like Amazon would dominate retail commerce 20 years later. Our view is that the number of survivors will be few, the big winners even fewer, but they could change our world.
Michael Saylor, the president of MicroStrategy and a big proponent of Crypto, has some of the most savoury quotes about Bitcoin: “Bitcoin is a bank in cyberspace, run by incorruptible software, offering a global, affordable, simple and secure savings account to billions of people that don’t have the option or desire to run their own hedge fund.” One of the reasons why the Crypto world is concentrating on finance is because the industry has a lot of monopolistic rents in areas such as trade settlement for public markets or private transactions such as real estate. T+2 or T+3 trade settlement for public securities does not align with instantaneous trading. But just like Kodak Eastman developed digital pictures but fought it to its grave to protect its existing business, financial innovation faces barriers emanating from within the financial system itself.
The chart above shows the extent of Cryptos issuance. More widespread adoption has led to general price increases, but also, many dodgy coins are already dead. This may remind history buffs of wildcat banking in the United States during the Free Banking Era when the country did not have a central bank. Back then, many shady banks operated scams by issuing their own currency back then, dispossessing unsuspecting individuals just like now for Coins.
Two other interesting quotes from Michael Saylor: “The signal is monetary expansion everywhere. The problem is people are going to lose half their wealth in a few years. The solution is Bitcoin. The rest is noise.”, and “The destiny of money is to be encrypted.” Bitcoin was launched on January 3, 2009, just a few months before the launch of quantitative easing by the Federal Reserve in March of 2009. Like previous currency regimes, the floating-currency regime may come to an end at some point (likely in a period of crisis) but to insinuate it is happening already is a stretch. The second quote again underscores an increasingly popular view; the fiat currency will necessarily be replaced by a digital one. Again, we find that it is a stretch to assume that a digital currency will necessarily be the natural replacement.
The chart above shows the market capitalization of cryptocurrencies since 2017 compared to the size of the Federal Reserve balance sheet. When crypto investors realized that the balance sheet was stable or shrinking from 2018 to 2020, the action stopped. Once the Fed’s balance sheet expanded again in 2020, Coins followed. The growing balance sheet of the Federal Reserve is lifting many boats and fostering financial opportunism. Crypto is benefiting from both. Its price behaves like a risky asset and the space is full of opportunists.
The above chart shows the legal treatment of cryptocurrencies around the world. As adoption in the global population increases, countries will need to determine their legal status. With more countries looking to launch e-currencies backed by their own currency like China did this year, the potential for wider popular adoption and financial disintermediation is growing.
From an ESG perspective, other quotes from Michael Saylor caught our attention.
“Bitcoin is the most efficient system in the history of mankind for channeling energy through time and space.”
“Bitcoin links together 8 billion people, links together a hundred million companies, it synchronizes the world across political jurisdictions, and it returns rationality to the entire financial system, and it returns freedom and property rights to the entire human race.”
“Imagine a world where everyone used something fair & equitable to settle their economic differences.”
“Bitcoin is a swarm of cyber hornets serving the goddess of wisdom, feeding on the fire of truth, exponentially growing ever smarter, faster, and stronger behind a wall of encrypted energy.”
These quotes lead one to believe that Bitcoin is the holy grail for the environment, for social health and for improved governance. We do not adhere to this view. As of now, there are many issues that need to be resolved with Bitcoin and Crypto in general.
From an environmental perspective, the proof-of-work method of confirmation that requires tremendous amount of energy is destroying the environment. Currently, more than half of all cryptos is mined in China where the energy sources shift from hydro to coal depending on the season. This is not green.
From a social perspective, access to crypto is clearly not for everyone because it requires technical knowledge, is very volatile and therefore finance has not been democratized for now. Using the blockchain for medical information could mark a major leap but it is not in wide use currently. In the same vein, tracking property title for real estate transactions could be dramatically improved for everyone. The time, cost and effort devoted to confirming transactions could be drastically reduced and simplified. Imagine the productivity benefits, if a country like India, where it is unbelievably complex and takes a very long time to acquire a property, used the blockchain to trace title information. Tremendous potential practical applications to improve social conditions exist though it is hard to find many that are currently in advanced development stages (i.e., are investable today).
From a governance angle, the decentralized nature of cryptocurrencies brings added freedom. On the other hand, cryptocurrencies do not have a mechanism to penalize unethical or harmful behavior.