In the first of our Strategic Asset Allocation “SAA” notes series: “Climate Change and Strategic Asset Allocation” published on August 24th, 2023, we looked at the likely effects of climate change on different asset classes. We focused on the expected rate of return that large asset owners use to establish their strategic allocation. Building on this, this note recalls the evolution of “SAA” over the last 50 years. This historical perspective reveals how asset allocation has changed in response to market dynamics and economic influences; it also provides clues to what will be necessary to deliver adequate returns in the future.
Current Positioning
The chart below highlights the evolution of the typical U.S. pension fund since 1980. The 1980s and 1990s were dominated by equities and bonds. Starting in 2000, alternatives started to occupy a much larger part of the portfolio and their share has continued to grow since. Alternatives were first introduced to diversify portfolios, but after the Great Financial Crisis, they were increasingly used to compensate for low government bond yields. The smoothed and infrequent pricing of illiquid assets was an added benefit that also contributed to their increased allocation.
The following table highlights how allocation to assets has evolved over the past few decades:
- In the 1980s and 1990s, bond managers became more dynamic and equity managers became excited by the prospects of small and growing companies, exemplified by the Nasdaq index success. Investors during this period also began looking toward global markets and reduced their home bias.
- After the Nasdaq imploded during the 2000-2002 bear market, the entry of China in the WTO became an enticing investment opportunity and investors focused increasingly on emerging markets. Hedge funds also became popular because many were able to generate positive returns during and after the tech bubble.
- After the 2008 crisis – and with interest rates falling to near zero - the focus of investors moved to longer duration assets (liability-driven investing, quality growth companies, infrastructure and private equity).
To this day, pension funds continue to expand on these strategies, implying expectations for a continued low inflation, low interest rate environment. However, we believe that the low inflation-low interest rate environment is over for the foreseeable future.
In our previous SAA note, we emphasized the need to comprehend the factors influencing long-term returns. In addition to climate change, fiscal dominance, demographics, deglobalization and national security are all intertwined factors that will affect portfolio returns more significantly in the future.
Fiscal Dominance
As we have shown in the past (see Macro Goes ESG, July 8th 2021), many of the challenges of the next decade will be met with fiscal policy, given that monetary policy is ineffective at addressing important issues like climate change, structural worker shortages, protectionism, rising income inequality, etc. The increasing importance of fiscal policy implies government decisions will have a greater impact on investment returns.
The accompanying chart underscores this shift in importance of fiscal policy: fiscal deficits as a percentage of GDP are getting steadily larger.
When fiscal policy dominates, winners and losers become apparent across various sectors and companies, emphasizing the need for sector-specific insights to guide allocation strategies. Voter preferences, increasingly aligned with sustainability principles, steer fiscal policies, thus elevating the significance of sustainability considerations as drivers of investment strategies. Additionally, the focus on infrastructure spending as a prominent fiscal tool spotlights sectors poised to benefit which, in turn, should influence allocation decisions.
Bottom line: A growing role for fiscal policy can be inflationary and a political economy creates winners vs. losers. In this environment, absolute return strategies that can be nimble in face of changing political winds have to the potential to outperform.
Demographics
Rapidly aging populations and declining birth rates could potentially lead to a shrinking workforce in developed countries, resulting in structural labor shortages and increased wages. Moreover, an aging population typically requires more healthcare services, often provided by the government sector via taxation. The table below highlights the evolution since the 1950s of the ratio of incoming workers compared to retiring workers in the United States, Germany, China and Japan. The period of excess labor ended at the beginning of the century in Japan and Germany but the impact was mitigated by the arrival of cost-effective Chinese labor. As we look forward, the relative wage suppression of the past may give place to greater worker wage negotiating power.
Bottom line: Structural labor shortages associated with aging populations are proving to be inflationary and it is so far very uncertain about the extent to which automation and AI can offer an offset.
Deglobalization
After decades of globalization's steady rise, there is a discernible trend towards reduced international interdependence, as shown in the chart below.
The promulgation of the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) in 2022 is likely to reinforce this trend, given its focus on bolstering U.S. domestic production.
Deglobalization means heightened volatility for financial markets due to the potential for trade tensions and less predictability in supply chains, at least during the transition phase. In recent decades, geographical asset allocation decisions were driven primarily by a country’s potential growth rate and its ability to export to either the U.S. or China. In the future, desired exposure to a particular geography will depend more on other factors such as the healthiness of its trade relations, its ability to secure resources, its access to frontier technologies, etc. In other words, it means the focus will be on a country’s ability to replicate production capacity that was previously provided by trading partners.
Bottom line: The transition to reduced globalization is inflationary as production capacity will be replicated, displaced and/or replaced. The value of critical resources like agricultural land and other commodities will accrue, making commodities and agriculture an attractive asset class. In addition, a return to manufacturing and other basic industries within developed economies means that many companies in established industries, i.e. “value stocks” have powerful tailwinds working in their favor.
Conflicts
After World War II, the world experienced a period of relative calm, although it was punctuated by significant armed conflicts, such as the Korean War and the Vietnam War. However, According to the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) more state-based conflict-related deaths took place last year than in any year since 1994 and the world has witnessed a worrying increase in state-based conflicts in the past decade, with over 50 such conflicts each year for the past eight years.
The map below highlights the countries where conflicts have erupted (Russia-Ukraine, Azerbaijan-Armenia, Serbia-Kosovo, Israel-Palestine) since February 2022 and where coups have taken place (Gabon, Niger, Sudan).
Conflicts have significant repercussions on material procurement and global supply chains. Disruptions in regions embroiled in conflict can lead to interruptions in the production and transportation of critical materials and resources, affecting populations, industries and businesses worldwide.
Bottom line: Beyond the terrible humanitarian toll of armed conflicts, military actions are inherently inflationary as the cost to finance war as well as the funding necessary to reconstruct puts a burden on public finances. Agriculture and natural resources, particularly those that act as a store of value, will likely be in higher demand.
Transition Phase
In our previous discussion on strategic asset allocation (SAA), we explored the impact of climate change on portfolio decisions. Beyond climate change, many of the major developments that were discussed in this note – fiscal policy importance, demographics, reshoring, armed conflicts – will affect the risk/reward backdrop for various asset classes, primarily via the long-term trend change in inflation.
The trends of the past are still shaping strategic allocation decisions today and pensions may be underestimating the effect of the changes we are witnessing. The implied assumption of many current SAAs is that we are going back to 2019 with low inflation, slow growth and low interest rates. On the contrary, at Sustainable Market Strategies we expect that climate change, fiscal dominance, demographics, and geopolitical volatility will force a transition to a more inflationary regime. In this context, we believe a shift to strategies geared to inflation protection is warranted.
Remember when some pundits were talking about inflation being “transitory” a couple years back? So much for that! The overwhelming consensus, as reported in our note from last week, Macro Meets Sustainability: Outlook for Q4 and Beyond (September 28, 2023), is now that high(er) structural inflation is here to stay, along with high(er) rates. The immediate consequence of this situation is that stocks and bonds are more correlated, which dampens the traditional “shock absorber” role that bonds historically played in asset allocation.
At the same time, global leaders have collectively committed to build a safer, cleaner, and fairer world for our children; an ambition that will require levels of investments previously unheard of.
This situation is where real assets – and infrastructure in particular – shine and maximising exposure for asset owners will be beneficial. The good news is that more and more options are becoming available to investors, including retail, to participate in this asset class. As shown below, the assets under management for both private and listed infrastructure strategies are on the rise, with the listed segment growing slightly faster. In the UK alone, where listed options are more prominent than in other geographies, the market grew 9-fold from just six infrastructure investment trusts totaling £4.3bn in 2012 to £35bn today. Taken together, private and listed infrastructure AUM is growing three times faster than the global AUM (45% between 2017 and 2022 versus 15% for global AUM).
Furthermore, in today's economic climate, infrastructure assets’ ability to act as a shield against inflation adds to its allure. This characteristic is because many infrastructure subsectors are the quasi-exclusive providers of their services within a certain region, which means they have strong pricing power given the inelastic demand for their services. When prices go up, they can simply pass on those increases to consumers through higher tariffs. As a result, they maintain steady revenue and profit margins during periods of rising inflation, safeguarding the returns for investors. Furthermore, most of these inflation-adjustment provisions are built-in either through regulation or concession agreements or contracts. On average, about 70% of revenues generated by infrastructure assets have some sort of inflation protection, but its level varies widely across subsectors, as shown below.
Thanks to this fairly unique feature, infrastructure investments tend to perform much better than other asset classes under higher-than-normal inflation environments. The chart below shows that the annualised performance of infrastructure investments during times of above-average inflation was more than double the returns for US Equities during the same periods.
Obviously, blindly investing in in the asset class does not guarantee a hedge to inflation. Just ask any NextEra Energy investor how his week was, and you will quickly understand that there are other qualitative and macro factors to consider. While utilities as a whole has been the worst-performing MSCI sector so far this year, the renewable energy subset of that sector has fared 2.5 times worse (-38% vs -15%).
As discussed in last week’s note, Macro Meets Sustainability: Outlook for Q4 and Beyond (September 28, 2023), the higher-rate environment disproportionately affects the renewables sector as the majority of the project costs are front-loaded due to the fact that the “fuel” is free (wind, sun, etc.). Even though utilities have stable long-term cash flows which allows them to be highly levered with long-term debt, the recent jump in long-term interest rates is changing the economics of greenfield projects. With interest rates cost forecasted to occupy a much larger proportion of the expenses than predicted, some renewable energy developers and operators have delayed projects and asked to re-negotiate previously agreed power purchase agreements (PPAs) – and got whacked by the Market.
Without attempting to excuse the sector for its dismal performance, it is worth noting that this is essentially the first time the renewable energy sector has faced a high interest rate environment. This situation should serve as a teachable moment to structure deals that account for inflation and higher rates. Consequently, the renewable energy troubles should therefore be, shall we say, “transitory”.
Looking ahead, there is no scenario in which renewable energy is not a key sustainable infrastructure subsector where investment opportunities will abound. According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), annual clean energy investment worldwide will need to more than triple to around $4 trillion to reach net zero emissions by 2050, the majority of which falls in the infrastructure bucket.
Sustainability-minded investors will probably want to focus on the “Sustainable” part of the infrastructure asset class. One may think it would be a small subset of the larger pie, but they would be wrong. Using the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) as the reference framework, researchers have found that infrastructure either directly or indirectly influence all 17 SDGs, including 121 of the 169 targets (72%). For 15 of the 17 SDGs, more than half of the targets are influenced by infrastructure, including for 5 of the 17 SDGs (SDGs 3, 6, 7, 9, and 11) for which all the targets are influenced by infrastructure.
The Thacker et al paper also argues that infrastructure assets beyond the usual suspects (renewables, water, passenger rail, health care, education) play an important role in achieving the SDGs. For example, transportation infrastructure assets such as ports and airports are crucial for the economic development and betterment of millions of people around the world. And digital assets such as towers and data centres allow for better information and communication which are known social and economic equalizers.
In upcoming Alpha notes, we will unpack some of the infrastructure subthemes and provide our top sustainable investment ideas. Stay tuned.
The term greenwashing has gained attention over the past few years, but the world of corporate “washing” spans a far more vibrant spectrum of colors.
In May 2023, as part of their preparations for Pride Month, retail giant Target introduced a range of LGBTQ-themed merchandise, ostensibly to show their support for the cause. However, their actions took a different turn when they faced substantial customer backlash. In response, Target then removed these items from shelves. But this just further amplified the controversy: by not standing their ground, the company then faced additional criticism from LGBTQ supporters.
This one example underscores the complexity of corporations engaging in marketing related to social causes. Is support genuine or merely a marketing tactic? In the case of Target, there were no meaningful incentives for LGBTQ+ employees, but merely rainbow-colored products and marketing campaigns: a potential candidate of “rainbow washing”.
Washing- whatever the colour – should not be construed merely as an unsuccessful marketing campaign. Washing is a deliberate and deceptive strategy where companies falsely tout their environmental or social responsibility to attract conscious consumers, all while seeking to bolster sales and reputation without making substantial improvements. In contrast, an unsuccessful marketing campaign typically stems from poor planning or execution, failing to resonate with the intended audience due to messaging flaws or product-marketing mismatches. An unsuccessful marketing campaign might lead to missed business objectives but typically lacks the deceptive nature of washing.
Washing comes in many colours, as the table below highlights.
The Allure of Washing
Although 2022 was marked by greater criticism of “ESG”, there is nonetheless an ongoing incentive for companies to pursue sustainability strategies. There is a consistent perception that companies that pursue lower carbon footprints merit a “greenium” and tend to have higher valuations than those that do not. Consequently, if management believes their stock price will be rewarded, there is a clear incentive for companies to pursue implementation of ESG business strategies - or at the very least, pursue an image of implementing ESG strategies.
Washing occurs when there is information asymmetry. When a seller has greater knowledge than the buyer, the seller can charge a premium for products or services. In an environment where specific, sometimes difficult to verify, product or service traits are desired, there can be a high incentive for a company to make its products more attractive to increase sales volumes, charge higher prices, and/or retain workers inspired by strong sustainability credibility.
Ultimately, if washing is successful at doing the above, then it will have a positive impact on a company’s stock price – so long as the firm does not get caught. A 2022 study of SP1500 companies showed just that: the authors divided companies between those that greenwash without repercussion and those that don’t, it was found that the financial market reaction was positive in the medium term (i.e., six months) for the companies that greenwash.
The Deterrent to Washing
What about those that do get caught?
There are two main ways that greenwashing gets punished. The first is through a company’s social license to operate, i.e. their reputation. Quantifying the value of reputation and reputational risks is a daunting task, but one straightforward way is to consider changes in the goodwill value of a company. Goodwill refers to the value a company derives from its brand, customer base and reputation associated with its intellectual property. Third-party sources also estimate the value of brands and have shown that “greenwashing” affects this metric. For example, in the wake of Volkwswagen’s Dieselgate, Brand Finance estimated that in 2015, VW’s brand value dropped from $31 billion to $21 billion. While this is impressive, keep in mind that in the same year, VW’s non-current assets were over 230 million euros: the overall balance sheet effect of their brand loss shouldn’t be overstated.
The second way that greenwashing gets punished is through litigation. One example is the Keurig class action suit that settled in 2022. Keurig Doctor Pepper (KDP US) deceptively advertised its K-Cups coffee pods’ recyclability by misleadingly labeling and marketing them as “recyclable” when the pods were not actually accepted for recycling in most municipalities. The complaint was filed in December, 2018 and was settled in February, 2022; the company agreed to pay USD 10 million. Coffee product sales represent about one-third of the company’s revenues (total company sales were about USD 14 billion in 2022).
The chart below shows the stock performance of KDP at the time of the announced lawsuit, during the proceedings and after the case; the company’s results are hardly distinguishable from its peers in the rest of the beverage industry!
A second example of washing litigation is the case of Credit Acceptance Corporation (CACC), which, over the past three years, faced no less than four significant litigations, each related to its business practices within the automotive lending sector. These controversies have raised questions about compliance, consumer relations, and predatory lending. Note that contrary to Keurig, where the lawsuit did not question the legitimacy of the company’s product (coffee), the CACC cases were all aimed directly at the service provided. The effect of legal proceedings on CACC's stock price have been pronounced, with declines exceeding 10% in three out of four cases, as shown in the chart below.
The Net Present Value Of Greenwashing: Currently Positive, But….
The above examples show that the penalty for washing, as measured by stock market return, can range from paltry (Keurig) to material (CACC). We expect, however, that the deterrence to washing is about to become more substantial.
Investors can think about washing in financial terminology. The net present value (NPV) of washing, for most companies, has been net positive: the projected earnings generated by washing activities - misleading marketing campaigns, making donations to improve a company’s corporate image, other investments made to appear more sustainable - exceed the anticipated costs.
But the costs of getting caught are beginning to rise, making the NPV less favorable. For one thing, the number of greenwashing cases that end up in litigation is surging. Climate litigation in general is skyrocketing higher, and greenwashing cases are a rising portion within that trend. The chart below shows the number of greenwashing cases that are in litigation.
Moreover, greenwashing cases are increasingly being reported on by media, implying that the public is far more aware of the practice.
Importantly, although the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has yet to finalize proposed new rules for company disclosures regarding environmental, social, and governance (ESG) policies, last November, the SEC gained broader authority under the Marketing Rule to examine all of firms’ compliance processes for advertising and marketing material, including ESG claims. In addition, the SEC has also created a 22-member Climate and ESG Task Force in its Division of Enforcement to better monitor firms’ and issuers’ ESG practices. On their website, they cite six examples of enforcement actions that occurred in 2022 alone. These range from an Adviser charged for failing to follow its policies and procedures involving ESG investments to a health insurance distributor and former CEO charged with making false statements to investors as well as a sham environmentally-friendly bottling company.
In Europe, rooting out washing is further advanced. In the financial sector, the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) has been in effect since 2021 and gives transparency to investors on how providers and products affect the environment and society. In addition, the European Commission published a proposal for a Green Claims Directive in the spring 2023, with the goal to ensuring that environmental labels and claims are credible and trustworthy.
For long-term asset owners like pension and sovereign wealth funds, the most important investment decision is strategic asset allocation, i.e. determining the target weight of each asset class to deliver sufficient returns to match or exceed liabilities. After all, empirical research shows that over a longer time horizon (10+ years) more than 80% of returns and risks are the result of Strategic Asset Allocation (SAA).
Meanwhile, climate change is being recognized as a critical factor in potential long-term returns; the largest capital expenditure program we will witness in our lifetimes is the worldwide shift towards emission reduction. Every asset will be impacted in some way by climate change and the low carbon transition, either directly, via supply chains, or by changing consumer preferences.
Given this shift, how should climate change alter strategic asset allocation decisions among institutional asset owners?
In part one of today’s report, we analyze the impact of climate change on the various drivers of asset class returns. In part two, we apply these adjusted return expectations to asset classes to uncover how climate change are likely to impact strategic asset allocation.
Part One: Climate Change as a Driver of Long-term Returns
Long-term capital market assumptions (LTCMAs) are the traditional backbone of decision-making for strategic asset allocation. To establish LTCMAs, each asset class is decomposed into the main drivers of return to build a reliable estimate of forward-looking risk and return. The long-term risk/reward profile of each asset class then determines the strategic asset allocation.
Generating LTCMAs traditionally uses historical data (for example, expected default rates on corporate bonds are modeled from historical averages). But the emergence of new and difficult-to-measure environmental – and social – phenomenon mean that related risks are less likely to be reflected in any historical data. That said, there is an increasingly large body of academic work that supports an emerging consensus about how climate change, arguably the most pressing environmental and social risk, will affect various fundamental drivers of returns.
We leverage this research to provide estimates of the main return drivers:
- Inflation: Inflation is forecast to be higher across both developed and developing nations due to climate change. In a recent paper, the ECB shows that in the absence of historically unprecedented adaptation, future warming will cause global increases in annual food inflation of 0.92% – 3.23% annually and headline inflation of 0.32%-1.18% per year, under 2035 projected climate change scenarios. They also find that climate change will alter the seasonal dynamics of inflation.
- Global GDP growth: Global GDP growth is expected to be lower across both developed and developing nations due to climate change. Estimates vary widely across time horizons and depending on the magnitude of climate warning. However, our literature review concludes that the adverse effects on growth are expected to be muted relative to the inflationary effects. The table below compiles major studies of the climate change impact on global growth; by and large, global economic growth is expected to be lowered by 0.1% to 2% annually from now until 2030, with most forecasts near the lower end of this range.
- Equilibrium interest rate: It is not obvious in which direction climate change will impact the natural rate of interest. It is plausible that natural rates are depressed through negative effects on productivity, such as the impact of higher temperatures on labour supply and the destruction of capital stemming from natural disasters. Moreover, increased economic uncertainty associated with the impact from climate-related risks could lead to higher precautionary saving and further pull natural interest rates down. The opposite potential outcome is that the transition toward a more sustainable economy will require substantial investment in green technologies, which may push equilibrium interest rates up. And if such investment succeeds in raising trend productivity growth, it could partially undo or reverse the decline in natural interest rates.
- Valuation: The impact of climate change on valuations will be different across asset classes and highly dependent on underlying portfolio characteristics (long-term valuations of real estate assets in coastal regions will be affected differently than those further inland, for example). The table below shows the direction of travel that we expect for valuations according to asset class.
The key takeaways from this exercise so far are:
- Climate change is expected to have a greater impact on inflation (upward) than on growth (downward). This means that investors should, all else equal, position themselves for a world that is more “stagflationary”’ than we have experienced in recent decades and ensure adequate exposure to assets that offer inflation protection.
- Note, however, that some assets that have historically behaved as “inflation hedges” may not carry the same properties in the future. For example, infrastructure investing has long offered relatively low-maintenance investments with predictable risk profiles and consistent returns. But new types of infrastructure (e.g. electric-vehicle (EV) charging networks, battery storage, smart mobility, data centers, etc) will, in many cases require investors to accept a period of significant investment and negative cash flow, along with development, technology, and commercial risks.
- The highly variable, physical consequences of climate change introduce higher uncertainty into expected returns, especially from a geographic perspective. Less heterogeneity within asset classes, i.e. the possibility that a benchmark index delivers insufficient results because a specific geographic or industrial sector is hit with catastrophic climate change events in any given period, argues in favor of a much more thematic and active management approach.
Part Two: How to Incorporate Climate Change in SAA
Perhaps the most straightforward approach to accounting for climate change in strategic asset allocation is to embed climate change impacts directly in long-term capital market assumptions.
By using assumptions of how climate change will affect fundamental drivers of returns, we can compute new forecasts of asset class returns expectations. The table below displays how we expect climate change to impact each asset class driver relative to a base case scenario where climate change is not considered. Note that for the base case capital market assumptions (i.e. those not affected by climate change), we use a consensus average estimate of long-term capital market assumptions, using various sources such as Oxford Economics, J.P. Morgan, AQR, etc.. Our goal is to demonstrate the direction and magnitude that we expect climate change to affect asset returns, not to precisely predict long-term capital market assumptions (the latter is outside the scope of our research).
There are several significant takeaways that should stand out:
- The magnitude of the estimated impact of climate change on returns varies across asset classes; it is more meaningful for equities than for fixed income (see the last column in the table).
- In terms of private assets, the asset class that is likely to have the largest positive change in asset returns is land. This is largely because the supply of “productive” land will become tighter, while the demand for agricultural and forestry products will continue to increase, having a net positive effect on valuations. In addition, there is more inflation passthrough expected since food inflation is expected to be higher than generalized inflation.
Putting it all together, we can apply the revised long-term capital market assumptions to a benchmark portfolio to get a sense of how a “climate change embedded” portfolio might differ relative to a return outcome whereby climate change is ignored.
Suppose an investor has a mandate to deliver 5% annual real returns plus inflation, “without undue risk of loss”. She repeats the assumption about inflation that she has been making for years: 2% per annum. Therefore, she constructs the portfolio that we call, “Living in the Past”. Living in the Past portfolio attempts to achieve 7% annual returns while ignoring the impact of climate change. With this portfolio, our investor believes she is generating 5% real and 7% nominal by allocating 70% to equity (evenly split between private and public), 20% in government bonds and 10% in infrastructure.
However, if we update the asset class return forecasts by using the climate change-embedded expectations, we see that the investor, when using this portfolio, significantly underperforms her return objectives (lines in red in the below table).
Conversely, using climate change-embedded capital market assumptions, we construct a new portfolio, “Climate Change Embedded Portfolio” in the table below. In order to achieve her mandate of 5% + inflation (she now knows that inflation will be higher with climate change and therefore strives for a nominal portfolio closer to 8%), the investor needs to have a significant allocation to assets that offer greater inflation protection and are mostly likely to have a positive valuation change to offset the decline in real growth that is expected from climate change. An effective portfolio is highlighted below: it is invested significantly in natural resources and infrastructure.
So what have we learned? First, there is a building consensus that climate change will, on a net basis, detract from economic growth while adding to inflation. The impact on inflation is expected to be larger (about 1% for headline, but considerably higher in the food sector) than the headwind to growth (-0.2% per year globally).
Our illustrative portfolios suggest that higher allocations to asset classes like natural resources and infrastructure are the best way to account for the changes in return expectations related to climate change. The drawback is, of course, liquidity. In future research, we will explore options for investors that are keen to gain exposure to infrastructure and renewable resources plays through public/liquid markets.
Second, it is becoming obvious that the consequences of climate change are extremely uneven from one year to the next as well as from a geographic perspective. This makes overall uncertainty increase as well as introduces more heterogeneity in returns within asset classes.
Our illustrative portfolios also suggest that the overall increase in return heterogeneity creates a powerful argument for active management. In other words, if the role of beta becomes increasingly challenged, the role of alpha in portfolio construction is more important than ever. Generating alpha through greater active management can take many forms, such as a dynamic asset allocation that overlays SAA, or by taking thematic positions within asset classes (e.g. focusing exclusively on exposure to “green” infra, implementing a strategic underweight to specific GICs sectors within public equity portfolios, or allocating to specific alternative public equity strategies in climate themes).
When it comes to grocery shopping, it’s more likely than not that you will purchase products from large conglomerates owning some of the most well-known brands. Products like Activia yoghurt, Ben & Jerry’s ice cream, Oral-B toothbrushes, Palmolive soap and Nespresso machines all originate from influential conglomerates such as Danone, Unilever, Procter & Gamble, Colgate-Palmolive, Nestlé, General Mills, and Reckitt Benckiser. Data reveals that Unilever, Colgate, P&G, L’Oreal, and Kimberly-Clark collectively command a substantial 35% of the worldwide revenue share in personal care and cleaning products. In the food and beverage market, Danone, Nestlé, PepsiCo. JBS, AB InBev, and Tyson amass a significant worldwide 17% market share.
These conglomerates not only have significant market presence, but some enjoy recognition as ESG darlings. To provide valuable insights, we conducted an analysis that focuses on the top performers among GICS Consumer Staples companies in personal care, household and food products industries with a market capitalization exceeding 30 billion USD. Our nine “darlings of ESG” are identified through their high ranking (above 85th percentile) among an aggregate of ESG score providers as well as their significant presence in SDFR Article 9 funds. Within these nine companies, an unsettling irony emerges; five of them hold positions among the world’s top ten plastic polluters, according to the Break Free from Plastic movement.
In a previous note, titled "A Reality Check About Plastic Fantasies" on April 20, 2023, we shed light on the environmental issues stemming from the production and disposal of plastics and the difficulty in finding alternatives to plastic. It seems counterintuitive that the five giants – Danone, Nestlé, Unilever, Procter & Gamble and Colgate-Palmolive - are receiving accolades for their sustainability practices given their massive involvement in plastic production. In the table below, we summarize the main reasons why the consensus accepts these companies as sustainability leaders within their industry.
While these initiatives and commitments appear commendable, it’s difficult to assess which of these companies are truly leading. We therefore apply SASB standards to analyze operational performance. The latter are designed to facilitate the disclosure of financially material sustainability information to investors. Our analysis uncovers disparities in the level of disclosure among the companies, as shown in the table below.
The table demonstrates that each of these companies possess operational strengths as well as areas for improvement. That said, Nestlé and Unilever have demonstrated superior performance in their respective industries. Their comprehensive disclosures and proactive approaches to water management, energy efficiency, product safety, and sustainability initiatives set them apart from competitors. On the other hand, despite their image as “ESG darlings,” we believe that Danone, Procter & Gamble and Colgate-Palmolive have more room to improve.
The table below compares companies across the primary SASB materiality metrics, with multiple companies from the same industry.

It is evident that Nestlé, Danone and Unilever stand out among their industry peers, Procter & Gamble, and Colgate-Palmolive, in terms of their lower environmental intensities, higher representation of women on boards, and stronger percentile ranks across various sustainability metrics, even though it varies between metrics. They have demonstrated a commitment to reducing their greenhouse gas emissions, water consumption, and waste generation, while also promoting gender diversity in leadership positions.
However, it is important to acknowledge that each company has its own weaknesses in certain areas. Colgate, despite not facing significant controversies in the past, lags behind its competitors in terms of its environmental performance. Nestlé, although seen as a leader in sustainability practices, continues to face accusations of child labor, which raises concerns.
Critically, the information cited above is primarily sourced from the companies themselves and may not provide a complete picture, particularly when it comes to addressing the controversies they face. The proceeding table lists the major controversies that have occurred at these firms over the past 2 years.
Of particular note is that despite strong commitments made by these companies to affordability and product access, there have been several instances of backlash regarding pricing practices. This misalignment raises questions about their ability to uphold the values they promise to deliver.
A final point is that some of the products offered by companies such as Unilever, Colgate-Palmolive, and Procter & Gamble, Danone and Nestlé seem extremely counterintuitive from a sustainability perspective. For example, Danone, a company that is predominantly focused on food and dairy products derives 16% of its revenues from (plastic!) bottled water manufacturing. Moreover, Nestlé took the decision mid-2023 to abandon its net-zero commitments for certain brands.
Even after a thorough analysis, it remains challenging to determine which consumer conglomerates - if any - truly stand out, given their mixed performance on various sustainability indicators. This poses a question of whether investing in these “ESG darlings” is the right choice. While they bear a great responsibility as some of the most influential companies in the world, it is noteworthy that their large sales volumes also contribute to higher pollution levels.
Corporate scandals, like those which emerged following the Global Financial Crisis have shed light on the need for improving the economic system. We recognize that reforms are necessary to ensure a more inclusive and sustainable economic environment, and this is captured in our Building Better Markets theme. Shareholder rights should evolve to align the financial system with broader stakeholder objectives. By balancing profitability with social and environmental considerations, businesses can help to address the shortcomings of the current system in favor of a more desirable outcome. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for investors to identify opportunities.
The significant decrease in the average equity holding period on the NYSE as shown below is an example of the impact of changing market dynamics towards gambling in the stock market instead of investing. A short-term focus over long-term performance and sustainable advancements presents a notable hurdle to effectively integrate responsible considerations. The emphasis on the short-term can divert attention and impede progress towards lasting positive transformations within companies.
In this note, we examine the current issues of capitalism and the calls to rethink the contemporary economy. We analyze the implications of this growing awareness and the anticipated developments for the financial system to support the goals of stakeholder capitalism. Our analytical framework considers four critical economic drivers: demography, international relations, regulations, and technology. The call for companies to embed sustainability and social progress aligns with the focus on broader stakeholder objectives in Sustainability DNA, while the pressure for inclusivity and fair access to financial services relates to Economic Participation.
From Trends to Transformation: Current Demographic Forces
Increased awareness of environmental and social issues is driving a shift towards ethical and sustainable consumption practices. As shown in the chart below, 71% of consumers surveyed have shifted their purchasing behavior in favor of the planet.
Demographic factors play a significant role in the need for better markets, as baby boomers are retiring and younger generations will take over as consumers and leaders, therefore changing consumption patterns landscape. The younger consumer is more concerned about the sustainability of the products they purchase.
Gen Zs and Millenials are recognized for their environmental consciousness, but their love for fast fashion poses a conflict between their stated values and their purchasing habits. Still, they share a strong commitment to aligning their spending with their environmental values, as indicated by a willingness to pay a premium for sustainable products, prioritize philanthropic giving to environmental causes, and invest in portfolios that emphasize environmental impact over purely financial metrics, as we highlighted last summer in the note “Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous and the Future of Global Warming”, July 7th, 2022.
As consumers increasingly seek products aligned with their values, businesses are compelled to demonstrate their social and environmental responsibility. Societal pressure is mounting to include a wider range of stakeholders in company decision-making processes. This inclusive approach acknowledges the significance of employees, communities, and the environment. As companies opt for greater disclosures, the laggards (or those who greenwash) are at risk while truly good corporate citizens could gain market share, as reflected in our theme.
Beyond Borders: The Chess of Geopolitical Relations
In recent years, political activism advocating for fairness, nationalism, and populism has gained traction. Elections increasingly highlight wealth inequalities as a central issue. Political campaigns often focus on policies that prioritize economic fairness and wealth redistribution. The outcomes of these elections can shape economic policies, regulations, and initiatives aimed at making markets more fair for all.
Global Disparity Atlas: Wealth Inequity Unveiled
World map highlighting in which countries the top 1% owns more wealth than the bottom 80%.
Source: World Inequality Database, 2021
Dynamics in France offer an interesting case. Following social unrest from a police shooting of a 17 year-old, multiple French executives asserted in an article in Le Monde that current economic divides are having repercussions not only on the economy itself but also on democracy and the social contract. In the context of successive crises, including the “yellow vest” movement, the COVID-19 pandemic, the war in Ukraine, and the impending climate crisis, it is imperative for the country, just like others, to stop neglecting the most vulnerable.
Geopolitical tensions and power struggles also have far-reaching implications for the pursuit of inclusive and sustainable markets. They can disrupt global trade, create trade barriers, and shape government policies and regulations. Trade conflicts can hinder the import and export of goods, including those related to sustainable technologies and practices. These have a direct impact on companies’ abilities to produce their products, source materials and sell their goods globally. Increasingly, governments and large multinationals are seeking security and resilience over global value chains. This is apparent in the push for deglobalization, reshoring and nearshoring and will inevitably impact supply chains, hopefully for the good. These elements underscore the need for companies to prioritize supply chain resilience, sustainable sourcing and production, regulatory adaptation, market diversification and strategic partnerships. These are the types of companies found in our Building Better Markets theme.
International collaboration and cooperation are essential in addressing wealth inequalities and navigating geopolitical challenges. In an effort to counter potentially stronger ties between Russia and China, Western countries have come together to impose sanctions and export bans. Frameworks like the EU 10-Point plan have also had success in coming together to meet the energy needs of their population Multilateral frameworks and agreements can foster shared objectives, facilitate knowledge exchange, and promote sustainable practices across borders. Countries with stronger environmental and labor practices will be well positioned for friendshoring and more favourable to foreign investment opportunities.
Redefining the Rules: Regulation’s Role
Regulation plays a pivotal role in driving the movement towards better markets. Government policies and mandates are instrumental in setting the stage for companies to prioritize sustainability and responsible practices. Regulations related to ESG reporting, corporate governance, environmental protection, social welfare, and responsible investing set the standards for corporate sustainability.
There are an increasing number of laws pushing companies to adopt better operational practices. One example is the EU law, passed in 2022, that mandates mobile phones, tablets and cameras sold in the EU to have a USB Type-C charging port by the end of 2024. Other laws in the lineup are "the right to repair" as mentioned in the table below. Companies that already embody these practices will be ahead of the game.
For a list of recent social regulations, see our note “Fast and Furious: A Distressing Tale of the Fashion Industry”, February 24, 2022.
Investor expectations and activism also play a significant role in shaping the regulatory landscape. Investors are increasingly incorporating ESG factors into their decision-making processes and demanding transparency and accountability from companies. This has led regulatory bodies and financial institutions to adopt rules and frameworks that require companies to disclose relevant ESG information and adhere to sustainable practices, like the GHG emissions disclosure rules from the SEC. Governments and regulatory bodies are pushing for greater disclosure of environmental, social, and governance data through initiatives like the EU taxonomy, which provides guidelines for classifying sustainable economic activities.
This evolving regulatory environment emphasizes the importance of data disclosure and transparency. Financial market regulations are becoming more proactive in addressing income inequality and favoring wealth redistribution through corporate and income tax policies. Again, early adopters of these frameworks, considered as sustainability leaders, will be ready and rewarded. This type of companies make up our Sustainability DNA subtheme.
Wired for Change: Technology as a Catalyst
Technology is a driving force in enabling transformative changes and reshaping the financial landscape. Technological advancements, such as digital platforms, data analytics, artificial intelligence, and blockchain, are enabling the integration of ESG factors into core business processes. These advancements allow companies to gather, analyze and report relevant data, improve supply chain transparency, develop sustainable products and services, and enhance stakeholder engagement.
Technological innovation plays a crucial role in developing sustainable solutions across industries. Advancements in clean energy technologies, circular economy models, smart cities, and sustainable transportation are all examples of how technology can drive economic growth while minimizing environmental impact.
In some cases, technology is helping to bridge unequal access to important services. One example of this is the expansion of financial services through apps and digital platforms has increased access to investment and wealth management, reaching a broader population. The worldwide market size of neobanks is expected to be multiplied by over 40 within 10 years, in 2030, with innovations empowering individuals who may have previously been underserved by traditional institutions, and emerging markets are its best example. As shown in the chart below, the penetration of digital banking in Latin America is high, with Brazil leading the way.
Furthermore, nearly nine in ten consumers across the emerging and developed markets of the Asia–Pacific region use digital banking actively, and most of these are open to purchasing more banking services through digital channels. Companies enabling this are reflected in the economic participation subtheme of Building Better Markets.
The world is undergoing a major transformation as the transition to a low-carbon economy gains momentum. This shift is being driven by a range of factors, from climate change and growing public awareness of its impacts, to technological advancements and shifting economic and regulatory landscapes. As the transition progresses, it is becoming increasingly clear that the energy sector will play a critical role in shaping the future of the global economy. In this note, we review the main structural growth drivers and their anticipated effects on the energy transition as an investment theme.
Demographic Shifts Are Reshaping the Energy Landscape
The UN projects the world population to reach 9.7 billion people by 2050. This rise in population will mostly come from the middle class, which is expected to grow by 1.7 billion to reach 5.3 billion by 2030 from 2020 levels and especially in Asia – which will represent almost 9 in 10 of the next billion middle-class consumers – (spread out between China, India, and South and Southeast Asia). As the global population continues to grow, the demand for energy is expected to surge significantly, especially since the rate of increase in energy intensity is outpacing the rate of population growth. As the chart below shows, there is a critical need for an increase in energy supply to meet rising demand.
Note that the increase in demand for energy services is largely driven by middle-income countries that are experiencing both population growth and a rise in the middle-class, which is being fueled by a fast rate of wage increase. This growing middle class tends to adopt more energy-intensive behaviors, as reflected in the graph below.
Space cooling accounts for a large share of the increase in energy demand, as it requires a significant amount of electricity. There is some irony here that need for more air conditioning will make it hotter if we fail to transition from GHG energy sources. It is projected that an additional 2,800 terawatt-hours of electricity will be needed globally by 2050 to meet this demand. If we don’t transition rapidly to clean energy production, this will create a negative feedback loop, wherein the more we rely on fossil fuels to generate energy for cooling, the more we contribute to the vicious circle we find ourselves in. Furthermore, the transport sector is also expected to more than double by 2050, propelled by the rising mobility needs in developing countries, where the transition to electric vehicles is far from guaranteed (see “A Two-Speed Transition: Why it's Time to Park the EV Frenzy in EMs”, February 16, 2023). Additionally, the trend towards urbanization, improvements in health and living conditions, and increasing life expectancy are among the many factors that have significant implications for the patterns of energy use.
The Rise of the Green Regulators
The scale of action required to achieve a successful energy transition should not be underestimated. It entails a comprehensive overhaul of all sectors, including energy, manufacturing, transport, infrastructure, agriculture, forestry, and land use. Governments need to increase their efforts and scale up interventions to meet the requirements for transitioning to green energy. With more than 70 countries, including major polluters such as China, the United States, and the European Union, committing to a net-zero target, there is expected to be a surge in clean energy demand. In this context, electrification and a shift away from fossil fuels are essential for achieving a net-zero emissions system. The table below illustrates how governments are taking action to promote this transition.
As previously stated ("Macro goes ESG", July 8, 2021), the realm of sustainability issues is increasingly intertwined with politics, leading governments to prioritize climate considerations in their industrial and economic policies. The key takeaway is that the regulatory backdrop around the world is now pushing in one direction: to limit higher intensity GHG emissions products. This means that, relative to previous decades, the ability to ramp up energy production to meet increased demand will be constrained.
Technological Solutions Exist but Costs Need to Come Down
Should population growth and energy intensity forecasts to 2050, as mentioned above, be accurate, we will require much more energy than we currently have. If we are to achieve climate goals, the need to lower the emission intensity of energy is obvious.
Solar panels and wind turbines have advanced significantly in recent years, becoming more efficient and cost-effective. The table below shows the relative cost of producing electricity from different sources as of 2021. These costs can vary depending on several factors, such as the location of the power plant, the availability of resources, and the efficiency of the technology used. The low level of GHG emissions emanating from renewable energy relative to traditional fuel sources highlights the need to produce more energy from wind, hydro, nuclear, geothermal, and solar and less energy from coal, oil, and natural gas in order to reach net zero goals.
An ongoing challenge for the energy transition is storage, especially considering the intermittent nature of wind and solar. Energy storage technologies, such as batteries and pumped hydro storage, allow excess energy to be stored and used when demand is high, ensuring a reliable and stable energy supply. The cost is still high but the prize for success in improving the efficiency and cost is also high.
Electrification is another necessary ingredient of the energy transition and one where technology will play an important role. Electricity is a highly efficient form of energy, and electrifying various systems and processes can lead to significant improvements in energy efficiency. For example, electric motors are typically more efficient than internal combustion engines, and electric heating systems can be more efficient than gas heating systems.
Smart grid technologies will be needed to optimize the distribution and management of electricity across the grid. These technologies enable better monitoring, control, and coordination of energy resources, and can help to increase the efficiency and reliability of the grid. Grid modernization technologies include sensors, communication networks, and advanced analytics that enable the grid to operate more efficiently and effectively.
While electrification offers many benefits, there are also several challenges that must be addressed to increase its adoption. Some of the main challenges include cost, resilience and grid integration.
The upfront cost of new electric vehicles, appliances, and infrastructure. The performance and cost of battery technology is a key factor in the adoption of electric vehicles and other electrified systems. While battery technology has improved significantly in recent years, further advancements will be necessary to improve the range, charging time, and durability of batteries. Electric vehicles and appliances may be more efficient and cost-effective over the long-term, but the initial investment can be a significant obstacle for many consumers and businesses.
Meanwhile, the integration of renewable energy sources like wind and solar can also present challenges for electricity grids, as these sources are intermittent and can be difficult to predict. Energy storage technologies like batteries and pumped hydro storage will be critical to balancing supply and demand on the grid.
The graph below highlights the mid-point of global investments required to achieve the energy transition. The size of the needed investments is so large that we can expect tremendous activity for the energy transition for years to come.
Tougher Relationships
Deglobalization refers to the process of reducing the interconnectedness and interdependence of economies across the world. The effects of deglobalization on the energy transition can be both positive and negative, depending on the extent of deglobalization, the policies and regulations implemented, and the availability of alternative energy sources.
On the positive side, deglobalization may lead to a reduction in global energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions, as trade and transportation activities decrease through the promotion of local production and consumption of goods and services, reduction in long-distance commuting, and energy efficiency in buildings and transportation. Additionally, deglobalization may increase the resilience of local energy systems, as countries focus on developing their own energy sources and reducing their dependence on imported fossil fuels.
However, there are also potential negative effects of deglobalization on the energy transition. Some countries may choose to prioritize their own economic interests over environmental concerns. While, global collaboration and knowledge-sharing are crucial for accelerating the development and deployment of renewable energy technologies, deglobalization may slow down the pace of innovation and limit the availability of renewable energy technologies, as countries become more isolated and less willing to share knowledge and resources.
Overall, the effect of deglobalization on the energy transition is complex and multifaceted. While it may provide some benefits in terms of reducing emissions and increasing energy resilience, it also poses significant risks to the pace and scale of the transition to a low-carbon economy.
As the graph below shows, the growth in global trade has been slowing since the Great Financial Crisis.
The Russian invasion of Ukraine and the deteriorating relationship between the United States and China are recent indications of greater geopolitical tensions that can have significant impacts on the energy transition, affecting the production, distribution, and consumption of energy resources in various ways. Geopolitical tensions can disrupt global supply chains, leading to shortages and price spikes in critical components needed for renewable energy technologies. For example, conflict or sanctions on countries that produce key minerals such as lithium and cobalt, which are essential for manufacturing batteries, can impact the availability and cost of these materials.
Geopolitical tensions can lead to an increase in fossil fuel prices due to supply disruptions and production cuts. This may incentivize a shift to renewable energy sources that are less affected by geopolitical tensions but may also slow down the transition if renewable energy prices remain higher than fossil fuel prices. Geopolitical tensions can also lead to changes in government policies and regulations, affecting the development and adoption of renewable energy technologies. For example, sanctions or trade barriers can limit the export and import of renewable energy products, while subsidies and incentives for fossil fuels can slow down the transition to renewable energy. Barriers create uncertainty and risks for investors, leading to a reduction in investment in the renewable energy sector which can slow down the pace of innovation and deployment of renewable energy technologies, critical for achieving the energy transition.
Investors continue to witness the political, economic, and social impacts of the demographic transitions playing out around the world – a recent example is the pension reform protests in France. More than other countries, however, China has the potential, as its population profile changes, to impact the global economy. In 1978, when Deng Xiaoping opened the country’s doors to direct foreign investment China had a working-age population of some 546 million people – a proportion of the total population which had been flat for 20 years at roughly 55%. A demographic dividend occurred as the working-age population surged to more than 70% of the total population by 2015, adding over 450 million potential workers. China became the manufacturing center of the world, riding a wave of globalization.
China’s demographic dividend is now moving in reverse and persistent declines in the working-age population may have implications for sustainable economic growth, domestic fiscal balances, and social policies.
Japan - Demographic Roadmap for China
Following World War II, Japan experienced significant direct foreign investment flows from the US and other countries and also benefited from a major demographic dividend as its working-age population increased from 50 million people in 1950 to 87 million people by 1994. Like China two decades later, Japan experienced an extended period of growth as the growing population of working-age Japanese benefitted from foreign investment, new jobs, training, education, increasing urbanization, and improved healthcare. In both Japan and China, expansion of the working-age population corresponded with sustained increases in per-capita GDP. Over the 35 years until the working age population peaked (1960-1994 in Japan and 1982-2016 in China), per-capita GDP grew at compounded annual growth rates of 14% and 12% respectively.
The Reverse of the Medal
By 1994, the last year when Japan’s working-age population increased, per-capita GDP in Japan had reached approximately US$40,000 putting Japan in the same league as Luxembourg and Switzerland. Only Monaco and Liechtenstein were meaningfully higher. The significant household wealth that was created in Japan is now an important source of ongoing fiscal revenue through Japan’s non-trivial inheritance tax. In China, when the working-age population peaked in 2015, per-capita GDP had reached only $8,000. Whether China’s GDP per-capita can continue to grow as it has in the past has important implications for the country’s fiscal balances and social spending.
If the relationship between growth in the working-age population and per-capita GDP continues to follow that observed in Japan, future per-capita GDP increases in China may be limited. While there have been years since 1994 (the year the working-age population peaked) in which Japan’s per-capita GDP increased, and even spans of years (2007 to 2012), the country’s average annual increase in GDP per-capita since 1994 has been zero. Growing dependency ratios tend to hold back growth.
Dependency Ratios and Sustainable Economic Growth
The reasons for Japan’s per-capita GDP stagnation are largely the reverse of what happens when the working age population expands. When the proportion of working age people (“net producers”) declines, the proportion of non-working people (those aged 0-14 and those 65 and older who are “net consumers”) increases. The proportion of net consumers to net producers is called the “dependency ratio”. Very generally, dependents do not engage in household formation or the widespread purchase of big-ticket items, they do not borrow money to buy homes, go to university, or start businesses, they do not pay high levels of income tax to the government but instead draw government benefits. A rising dependency ratio is often associated with falling consumer spending, declining income tax revenues, a rising medical-care and elder-care burden, and increased government reliance on borrowing. Japan’s dependency ratio started to rise in 1994, the year its working-age population peaked. China’s dependency ratio followed the same trend, beginning to rise just before the working age population peaked in 2015.
While there may be no particular tipping point beyond which dependency ratios trigger fiscal strain, Japan provides a study of what happens to the national accounts as the burden of a growing number of net consumers is shouldered by a falling number of net producers. Since the early 1990s when the working-age population peaked and began to decline, not only did per-capita GDP stagnate in Japan, tax revenue from income tax and corporate tax began to fall. At the same time, social security-related expenses increased, nearly doubling from 17.5% of expenditure in 1990 to 34% in 2021. The widening gap between tax revenue and expenditure has been filled by a consumption tax (which itself is inimical to growth), other taxes (the most important of which is Japan’s inheritance tax), and the increasing issuance of government bonds. With China’s lower level of per-capita GDP, raising consumption taxes and instituting an inheritance tax may not be sustainable long-term policy options.
Must Rising Dependency Ratios Lead to Slower Growth?
Three things affect the dependency ratio: the death rate (mortality), the birth rate (fertility) and immigration. In countries where both the death rate and the birth rate are high, dependency ratios can be very high yet portend growth rather than stagnation. Niger has one of the world’s highest dependency ratios (much higher than Japan’s) but the dependents, instead of being 30% retirees, are almost exclusively in the 0 to 14-year-old age cohort - an enormous potential pool of future workers (human capital).
Countries that can boost the working age population through pro-growth immigration policies can reduce their dependency ratios, in some cases to very low levels. For an extreme example, see (above) the United Arab Emirates (UAE) where immigrant workers make up a large part of the population. Dependency ratios in countries like Japan and China, with little or no immigration, are subject purely to the interaction of birth rates and death rates. Between 2016 and 2021, China’s working-age population fell by nearly 12 million people. Between 2016 and 2050, it is estimated that China’s working-age population is expected to decline by over 230 million people. Over the same period, the population aged 65 and older is forecast to increase by 243 million. By 2050, China’s dependency ratio is expected to be the same as Japan’s is today, with the same proportion of the dependent population in the 65 and older age cohort (30%).
Dependency Ratios Increasing Across the G20
China is not alone in following Japan. All but two G20 countries (Indonesia and South Africa) are headed toward dependency ratios like Japan’s this century.
Investment Implications
The Chinese demographic transition that is underway may have significant implications for global sustainability investors. Whereas the ramifications of Japan’s contracting workforce after 1994 have so far been mostly domestic (because the global labor pool continued to grow while Japan’s relatively small labor pool contracted) declines in China’s working-age population could have domestic and global repercussions. These go beyond manufacturing and trade and include global capital flows.
- As China becomes less able to supply the global labor market with workers, there may be a “higher floor” on the cost of global labor. The wildcard here is Africa where the population of working-age people is expected to increase by some 750 million people by 2050 but across diverse countries with widely varying infrastructure and degrees of integration into the global economy. All else equal, the decline in China’s working-age population may act as an inflationary force in the global economy and spur further capital deepening in order to maintain productivity growth.
Beyond the geopolitics of deglobalization, a narrowing difference between wages in China and in other manufacturing centres may further reduce the incentive to offshore to China. In some industries, i.e., those in which China enjoys technology leadership, foreign companies already operating in China may stay. In industries in which a young, low-cost labor force is the main competitive advantage, however, reshoring could occur quickly. Vulnerable industries could include garments, furniture, and bedding.
- There are powerful links between demographic imbalances and fiscal imbalances. Japan’s demographic dependency ratio is mirrored by a bond dependency ratio that has grown since the early 1990s as the rising benefits paid to elders in the form of social security coverage have outstripped the burdens of tax and social security payments collected from the working-age population.
Over the period that Japan’s bond dependency ratio has increased, the credit rating of Japanese government bonds has decreased. While most Japanese government bonds have been held domestically and at low interest rates maintained by financial repression, foreign investor participation in the market is increasing. While foreign investors help diversify the funding base, they may demand higher yields for lower-rated sovereign bonds. Rising yields and stagnant or declining GDP growth could result in yet further deterioration in Japan’s debt to GDP ratios and increased risk of global contagion. While foreign investors still make up a small part of China’s bond market, foreign participation is increasing. As in Japan, domestic demographic and fiscal imbalances in China will have a greater ability to impact the world economy as China’s capital market integration deepens.
In every economic cycle, rising interest rates shake out the weakest links first. In the U.K. last autumn, it was the pension system that came under pressure as U.K. rates spiked. Last week in the U.S., it was Silicon Valley Bank. Today’s note discusses the implications of the bank failure for sustainability investors, as well as two other brewing issues that have been temporarily sidelined during the bank meltdown: worsening China-U.S. trade relations and growing investment momentum related to U.S. and European green fiscal tailwinds.
Below, we detail how these three factors – SVB bank, global trade tensions and fiscal policy – are likely to play out for sustainability investors in the months ahead.
SVB: Implications For Sustainability Investors
In any given year – especially in periods where interest rates are rising – a handful of U.S. banks go bankrupt. From 2010- 2022, a total of 371 U.S. banks have gone bankrupt. What makes Silicon Valley Bank’s misfortunes newsworthy is its size and concentration. At $209 billion assets, it is among the largest banks to fail in recent history (the average inflation-adjusted bank failure is $6 billion). The bank’s customers were highly concentrated in tech innovation; as is now well known, the bank had few retail investors and catered almost exclusively to venture capital funds.
For sustainability investors, we see two main questions to be tackled: what is the overall macroeconomic implication of the bank failure, i.e. will SVB trigger a more significant risk-off phase for investors and 2) how does the SVB failure impact various sustainability-linked themes (e.g. climate tech) that are dependent on early stage financing?
In terms of the overall macro picture, the SVB debacle does little to change our business cycle view. As interest rates rise, the cost and availability of capital tightens, which tends to shake out the weakest hands. Banks that do not appropriately handle rate risk (SVB did not have a Chief Risk Officer!) are vulnerable.
At Sustainable Market Strategies, our view for some time has been that a prolonged higher inflationary environment would oblige the Fed to keep tightening rates “higher for longer” to force a decrease in the supply of cheap funding (i.e. slow the economy). The failure of SVB is testimony that this process is at work. The Fed’s mandate continues to be to bring inflation down to about 2%; until monetary policymakers are successful, rates will rise and growth is likely to weaken. We continue to advocate for investors to maintain defensive portfolio positions – the downfall of SVB simply means that credit conditions will tighten more quickly as remaining banks become more prudent (either by regulators imposing stricter rules or by choice) and that real economic activity will slow down another notch.
In the short-term, the Fed will be focused on its mandate of financial market stability, but the rate cycle will only reverse when the inflation is in sight.
For sustainability-themed investments, a loss of funding and/or a reticence to take risk at early financing stages means that the potential for innovative solutions (carbon capture, vertical farming, non-animal protein, etc.) to some of the world’s largest problems (climate change, soil degradation, deforestation) will likely slow. Given that SVB was known for backing startups, the failure of the bank may leave a hole that other banks will be weary to fill in. Two themes are particularly vulnerable: health care and climate. Many of SVB’s clients are innovators in the health sector that are trying to find novel solutions to improve outcomes for patients with a range of diseases.
In terms of climate change – a particularly urgent sustainability theme – Silicon Valley is only at the beginning of a long-term investment cycle. SVB appeared to be well entrenched in the climate-tech ecosystem; the bank reportedly had relationships with more than 1,500 companies working on technologies aimed at curbing global warming. In 2022, climate tech raised US$82 billion globally; an all-time high for funding despite a tough year for venture capital. From a geographic perspective, the U.S. – of which Silicon Valley is a major contributor – is accountable for roughly half of that funding.
To the extent that a global risk-off environment takes hold in the face of perceived or real financial stresses, funding to climate ventures will become more restrained. However, as we discuss below, fiscal policy is acting as a substantial positive tailwind. In other words, we expect that industrial policies targeting climate change will partially offset lower risk-taking in the private sector.
Geopolitical Risk Premium Rising
The collapse of SVB has temporarily taken investor focus away from another brewing risk for equity markets: international trade relations. One of the primary secular drivers of our investment research is the notion that globalization has peaked, with important consequences for global supply chains, sector-level investment returns as well as the overall pricing of risk assets.
Recent rhetoric from China, the U.S. and Europe all give credence to this view. China’s appointment this week of a defense minister under U.S. sanctions will surely make any dialogue between China and the U.S. even more challenging. Note that the appointment follows the foreign ministers’ comments last week that there “will surely be conflict” unless Washington changes its stance on several issues.
We believe that there are both macro and industry-level consequences of the mounting international trade tensions.
- Macro: it is challenging to isolate a geopolitical risk premium from other confounding factors. Nonetheless, it is intuitive that as the cost and risks of doing international business (tariffs, financing, regulation) rise, the premium required on risky assets reliant on global trade also rises. We believe we have entered a period where investors will need to be compensated for taking on these extra risks relative to the risk-free rate of return; a premium will be paid for the equity of companies that are showing success at reorienting supply chains away from China.
- Industry-level: we have repeatedly written in recent months about the global impetus to rebuild supply chains to be more regional. This theme is now well underway, beginning first with industries that are considered national security issues for various governments. Renewable energy solutions (solar power, batteries), semiconductors, pharmaceuticals are all industries that are ripe for transition. Indeed, many of these areas have already benefitted – and will continue to benefit – from aggressive industrial policy (see below).
Fiscal Tailwind Is the Best Game in Town
Very much tied to the geopolitical headwinds described above, currently the only major offset to a tightening in financial conditions (both credit and monetary) is the sizeable fiscal tailwind from the U.S. Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) as well as Europe’s response to it, the European Commission’s Green Deal Industrial Plan (GDIP). There are already multiple signs that policies aimed to spur investment in clean energy and other key environmental areas are impacting business decisions. For example, Volkswagen recently announced plans to set up battery plants in the U.S. and Canada instead of Europe due to generous conditions. The sectors that are natural “hiding places” from geopolitical strains are the same sectors that are benefitting from U.S. and European industrial and fiscal policy. Energy efficiency and sustainable building companies that are demonstrating weak ties to China will do especially well.
The recent spotlight on the Adani Group, an EM darling for several sustainability-driven investors and its involvement in many renewable power projects, underscores the perils of investing in EMs. Subsidiaries within the wider Adani Group are trading at a 30-45 percentage point discount to their January levels following a report from Hindenburg Research suggesting that the Group’s leaders have been fudging numbers while artificially inflating the stock price.
This scandal emerged as low interest rates of the past decade made EMs relatively attractive – which may have encouraged investors to look away from the region’s generally weaker governance structures. After all, many investors look hard to find investments with acceptable level of ESG risk and impact potential in EMs despite their relatively low level of ESG disclosures. Interestingly, in the case of Adani Enterprises, the company faired well in global ESG scoring databases, as evidenced by its “top tier” rank in governance percentile scores not only among its Indian peers – but also globally – in CSRHub.
While such “governance fails” are somewhat expected in less stringent regulatory environments such as those found in many EMs, it is worth reminding that these cases can still happen in very large groups such as Adani, despite the amount of investor scrutiny these conglomerates are under. For instance, the case of Azure Power, another Indian renewable power company facing issues with its internal controls and accounting, has ballooned into the media and is rapidly becoming an issue for its investors, which include large Canadian pension funds such as CDPQ and OMERS.
Despite these alarming headlines, corporate scandals – at least those that have been made public – are actually less frequent in EMs than in DMs, perhaps due to the over-representation of DM-listed companies over EM-listed companies in global markets. To this end, a recently published study suggests that as much as 10% of publicly-listed firms could commit securities fraud every year. In this context, when data is weak and goes missing like it is the case in many EM-based companies, looking at an alternative set of data points becomes a necessity for investors to add additional safeguards. Today’s note looks at 1) EM attractiveness in a context of growing scrutiny and 2) relevant metrics to assess corporate governance risks in EMs.
Are EMs a missed opportunity?
Despite their promises – and even since China’s incredible economic ascension since the 1990’s – EM companies have considerably underperformed their DM peers over the last decade. Looking at price indices only, a DM investor would have doubled her money if she had chosen to invest in DMs over EMs over the past ten years. In that, one could say EM investors lost another decade in markets since 2013.
More recently, although EMs’ relative performance to DM improved in the second half of 2022, it seems that like their DMs peers, EM companies are also suffering from their elevated corporate debt ratios – especially in hard currency– and slowing global trade flows. According to the IMF’s 2022 Global Debt Monitor, both DMs and EMs corporates now have above-100 percent debt-to-GDP ratios.
Given the global slowdown and mounting pressures in EMs, the Citi Economic Surprise index of EMs had already started underperforming that of G10 economies in late 2022. While China’s re-opening post-COVID restriction somewhat boosted economic activity in EMs, and with it the CESI EM index, it’s hard to see how the momentum will be maintained through 2023. Moreover, growing interest rate differentials between DMs over EMs will also create additional liquidity shortages in EMs which could further hamper their ability to deliver interesting returns to investors going forward. That said, there are still some positive stories developing in some EM countries such as Mexico (and other Latam countries) as well as in Asia (such as Korea) which could benefit from and near-shoring strategies out of China over the medium term.
EM Companies’ governance performance – the good, the bad and the ugly
One way to look at EM management teams’ relative governance performance over their DM peers is to look at metrics around leadership, ethics and transparency. In this case, CSRHub defines “leadership & ethics” as “the effectiveness in treating all shareholders equitably” while “transparency” is defined as “the management of the company being transparent to its stakeholders”.
Looking at leadership and ethics data from CSRHub, the good news is that between 2017 and 2022, leadership and ethics in EM companies’ management teams has improved in many—if not all industry groups in the top 100 companies (by market cap) included in the MSCI EM Index. The level of leadership and ethics demonstrated in the largest EM companies is now in the top tier on a global basis.
Conversely, the top 100 EM companies’ (by market cap) transparency and reporting efforts have lost some ground compared to their global peers among between 2017 and 2022. In this context, EM companies—and indeed stock exchanges and regulators—ought to review their disclosure requirements for EM companies to remain attractive to the growing number of sustainability-minded investors always looking for more transparency.
Furthermore, there remain industries where management teams’ EM leadership and ethics skills are surpassing that of DM counterparts; this is especially the case for Travel, Sports & Leisure and Education & Government. However, overall, where EM companies closely track DM companies on leadership and ethics grounds, transparency still falls short of what can be expected in DM companies in all industry groups.
A secondary check that can help investors decrease the risk of being sidelined by EM governance issues is to look at what management – especially insiders – are doing with their equity. Indeed, as far as governance standards go, legal frameworks and ESG disclosures of many EM companies are often lower than those of their DM counterparts, and investors must thus use an additional amount of “street sense” when looking to invest in EM companies. One way to see how broader investors’ interests may “align” with that of the management team of EM-listed companies is to look at insider interest as a percentage of total share ownership, and its link to profitability and performance metrics such as ROE and/or ROA.
For this exercise, we looked at the relationship between insider holdings and ROE of companies included in the MSCI iShares MSCI Developed Core ETF; one sees that the relationship appears flat.
Conversely, if one looks at companies included in the iShares MSCI EM ETF, the amount of insider interest appears positively correlated with ROE – albeit with a weak statistical link. One way to think about this is that in the absence of clear data and low access to management, investors might as well “line up” with management teams to boost their chances of making positive returns.