For investors that had high hopes that COP29 would deliver some sort of direction about where to allocate capital in a world desperately needing climate solutions, they would be right to be disappointed. Nations failed to agree on binding commitments to phase out fossil fuel subsidies, but perhaps most disappointing relative to expectations is the paltry commitment to emerging economies. The “New Collective Quantified Goal on Climate Finance (NCQG)” was officially drafted and agreed upon during COP29 and earmarks an underwhelming USD 300 billion annually. This sum falls far short of the estimated needs reported by developing countries. Given this modest commitment, it becomes obvious that the role of private finance is critical for a green transition in EM.

In today’s note, we argue why the energy transition in EM will be different than what has occurred so far in developed economies and we outline where we see the most practical opportunities for investors.

 

It’s Different in EM

For developed economies like European countries and the U.S., energy transition means primarily decarbonizing established energy systems by replacing fossil fuel energy sources with renewable ones. In other words, there is a singular objective of energy substitution.

In emerging markets, the energy transition must satisfy multiple goals, sometimes referred to as the energy trilemma: energy security, energy equity (both access and affordability), and energy sustainability. To achieve this, many factors need to be taken into account:

A key point in the energy transition in EMs is that achieving one goal cannot risk sacrificing another. Take the current electricity situation in South Africa. ESKOM is the public utility in South Africa and generates about 95% of electricity for the country and it is also the largest emitter of sulphur dioxide in the power industry in the world. ESKOM has periodically implemented rolling blackouts (a.k.a. load shedding) since 2008, unable to maintain enough power production to consistently meet demand. Ever since, ESKOM has been caught in a death spiral, i.e. a financial and operational catastrophe whereby declining revenues lead to higher costs, which in turn drive more customers away, perpetuating the cycle). Add to this, major governance scandals that make it difficult for ESKOM to attract new capital.

Frustrated by blackouts and rising bills, South Africans that can afford to have invested in private electricity generation (mainly via rooftop solar panels) and therefore have migrated away from Eskom’s grid. This leaves a smaller (and less well-off) base of customers to shoulder ever-rising costs. Faced with fewer (and poorer) consumers and therefore less revenues, ESKOM’s services – reliable electricity output – worsens. In this way, some South Africans that can afford it manage to have access to clean, renewable energy, but those that are left behind see the quality of their (dirty) electricity deteriorate sharply. South Africa may achieve one goal of having a cleaner energy mix through greater use of solar panels, but at the expense of improving energy access to all.

The bottom line is that investors interested in the energy transition in emerging markets are faced with a far more challenging set of variables than in DM. However, the potential for impact is also much higher.

 

Where to Start: An Investors Guide to EM Energy Transition

Investors can have the most impact in countries where access to reliable electricity is weakest. In these regions, clean energy initiatives will offer more than just decarbonization, they will also support improved living standards and economic participation.

Developing nations’ frustrations at the recent COP negotiations is understandable considering the substantial need for investor capital in fund green initiatives. In 2023, only 15% of the $1.8 trillion invested in clean energy infrastructure went to emerging and developing economies according to the World Economic Forum. Moreover, it is estimated that emerging markets will require $2.6 trillion annually for energy investment if 2050 net zero goals are to be achieved. Needless to say, there is a significant funding gap to fill.

Part of the reluctance to fund green energy projects in emerging markets can be explained by the much higher cost of capital. Higher risk premiums are demanded due to a slew of risks (higher volatility in exchange rates, political risks, etc). The chart below highlights the massive range in cost of capital for solar projects in various countries; other renewable energy projects face similar cost of capital ranges.

A Just Transition Means Significantly Higher Cost of Capital

Source: IRENA 

According to the International Agency for Renewable Energy (IRENA), for purposes of energy-transition investments, emerging economies fall into three broad contexts:

Category 1: Countries that already have well-established power markets (e.g.  China, and Brazil). Renewable projects are generally bankable and thus capital costs are lower.

Category 2: Jurisdictions that successfully mobilised large amounts of private capital for certain renewable technologies but are now hitting a ceiling due to technical challenges (e.g. risk of curtailment) or bankability risks (e.g. off-taker risk). Vietnam and South Africa are in this category.

Category 3: Countries that have not been able to attract investments owing to constrained macroeconomic conditions or political conflicts. Projects may not become bankable in the near term, but investments are urgently needed. Even if some projects have already been completed, system integration, transmission constraints, utility creditworthiness are all headwinds. Here, the role of concessional loans and grants and partnering with international organization and/or local government is almost always necessary since investment decisions must be based on factors that go beyond realising financial profits for private investors. Many African countries fit here.

Category 1 economies like China and India experienced a massive growth in energy consumption since 2000, reflecting both demographics and overall economic development over the past 20 years. Electricity consumption per capita increased a whopping 516% in China and 182% in India, far outpacing Africa’s 17% growth. The chart below shows the increased level of energy consumption for industry during this timeframe.

Given that big energy gains have already been achieved, investing in the energy transition in China and to some extent in India, is in many ways like investing in advanced economies: there will be an increasing focus on energy substitution, i.e. decarbonization of current energy systems, rather than building new ones.

Brazil’s slower growth in energy demand reflects its relatively smaller manufacturing sector. The country certainly has an important role to play in lowering emissions; along with China and India, Brazil is among the largest emitters globally. However, its large emissions are far more related to agriculture (nearly 50% of Brazil’s greenhouse gas emissions stem from this sector). Brazil’s heavy reliance on hydroelectricity (see chart further below “Breakdown of Energy Supply by Region”) makes its energy consumption less carbon-intensive compared to other developing nations.  

To be sure, decarbonisation of these countries (category 1) is necessary as the chart above shows that China, India and other BRICs countries (Brazil is an exception) still rely heavily on fossil fuels. However, investors seeking to make greater impact should look to other emerging markets, i.e. countries that are striving to improve access to (renewable) energy, like those in “category three” described above. In frontier markets, particularly Africa, energy needs remain largely unmet. Data from the World Bank shows almost 50% of the population of Sub-Saharan Africa did not have access to electricity in 2022 and still has significantly lower electricity consumption per capita (0.632 MWh) compared to other parts of the world (global electricity per capita is 3.4 MWh). We mentioned earlier the electricity woes of South Africa, yet South Africa has the highest rate of electricity production of African countries.

The following table shows the breakdown of total energy supply by source for various countries and regions. There is plenty of room to expand clean energy in Africa. Notice the high share of biofuel use; this could seem positive, but it is actually a clear example of inequalities in energy access.

The high share of biofuel use comes from the traditional cookstoves that rely on firewood, charcoal and biomass (even animal dung) or high polluting fuels like kerosene. Widespread reliance on cookstoves is a clear consequence of energy poverty and is not only more common in lower-income populations, but also disproportionately affects women and children who have the responsibility of collecting these fuel sources and are also more exposed to the associated pollutants. Cookstoves are used in parts of South Asia and South America but are most common in Africa. Improving accessibility to electricity can facilitate the transition to cleaner cooking technologies.

It is perhaps surprising that nuclear energy is represented in the table above, even at modest shares, in developing economies, given the large capital costs and long pay-off times. Several EMs successfully built nuclear power plants in the 1970s and the 1980s through support from the Soviet Union within the Council for Mutual Economic Cooperation (COMECON) framework or by the United States. Today, however, lack of international cooperation implies that most EMs don’t have the capacity to build reactors. According to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), only a handful EM countries have any plans at all to invest in nuclear.  

The election of Donald Trump has cast a pall over many investors that adhere to the idea that purchasing stocks using both financial and non-financial criteria deliver superior long-term returns.

To be sure, the turn away from “ESG” investing has been underway for quite some time – the chart below shows that fund outflows from U.S. ESG ETFs occurred throughout 2023 and 2024.

President-elect Donald Trump will most likely move to dismantle ESG-related regulations in the U.S. when he takes office in January, including blocking Securities and Exchange Commission rules for corporate and fund disclosures and putting limits on ESG-related shareholder proposals filed during proxy season. U.S. companies have already taken the hint that ESG is no longer a sales or marketing advantage and have been working fast to erase the phrase “ESG” from corporate speak: the chart below shows the precipitous drop-off of the number of mentions during quarterly earnings calls.

The turn away from ESG is not, however, a death knell for investors that focus on sustainability. Investors should recall that Trump’s first term was an excellent time for many thematic sustainability funds and many equity sectors moved in a contrary fashion to consensus expectations:

The key takeaway is that despite the anti-ESG trend, successful investing remains about understanding the macroeconomic backdrop and anticipating the needs and desires of the future. As climate change and related environmental challenges continue to mount at a time when social inequalities are ever-present, sustainability themes will not fade from focus.

That said, President-elect Trump’s policy aims will nonetheless shift the macroeconomic backdrop in ways that impact key sustainability themes. In today’s note, we outline how inflation, industrial policy and climate change will affect the outlook for these themes.

  1. Inflation: Yes. But Where and How Much?

It has become a consensus view that a Trump presidency will exacerbate inflation. We find it difficult to disagree. After all, economic theory, borne out in practice time and again, shows us that large fiscal deficits (which are expected thanks to the extension of tax cuts under Trump) stoke inflation. Tariffs are also inflationary – historically, about half of the cost of tariffs is assumed by producers (via smaller profit margins) and the other half by consumers (rising prices).

Pile on a restrictive immigration policy that will further constrain an already cyclically and structurally tight labor market and labor costs will face upward pressure, all else equal.

Nowhere will the labor squeeze be felt more acutely than in agriculture and our forecast is that food prices are the most likely source of consumer price inflation in the intermediate term. A recent article in the Atlantic estimated that if the Trump administration were to enact “the largest deportation operation in American history, somewhere between 40 and 50 percent of the people who plant U.S. crops would leave the domestic workforce.”

Already, food inflation has been running hotter than overall CPI due to structural reasons: the global population is projected to increase by 10% this decade while the lower and upper-middle-class increase by 30%. As more people reach the middle class and adopt a more calorific diet as is characteristic of that class, the demand for food will continue to increase. Meanwhile, on the supply side, it is unlikely that more of the earth’s land surface can be dedicated to food production and climate change is also complexifying food production as we know it.

Though the nomination of Robert F. Kennedy Junior as Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) is not yet a done deal (RFK Jr’s aberrant views on vaccines, fluoride, cell phone radiation and other topics mean that many groups are already lobbying against his nomination); when it comes to food, RFK’s desired policy path would unequivocally result in higher food price inflation. The current U.S. food system is designed to maximize yields at the lowest cost. An overhaul that includes solving for multiple variables, i.e. improving human health and environmental outcomes, will not come without financial cost for consumers.  

At Sustainable Market Strategies, we have high conviction that sustainable food production will be an important investment theme over the next decade (for example, please see our note “Food for Thought”, September 21, 2023). Readers can expect updated research from us, especially should RFK be nominated. Investors should closely watch the policy backdrop for opportunities on both the long and short side within the food and health sectors.

  1. Industrial Economy 2.0: Bring the Companies Home

We have written extensively over the past several years about the rising dominance of fiscal policy that has occurred since 2010. Notably, in 2021, we quoted ex-Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke, who, after dropping the Federal interest rate to zero and undertaking the largest quantitative easing program in history, declared, “The Federal Reserve cannot solve all the economy's problems on its own.” He subsequently called on Congress, the administration, and regulators to do more to prop up the U.S. economy. Washington policymakers jumped to the call and have never looked back. Since that time, both Republican and Democrat governments have announced major fiscal packages that have totaled over 9 trillion USD. In the table below, we list, describe and colour-code (features in red denote fiscal measures targeting specific industries) the main features of the various spending bills. A pattern emerges: spending packages are increasingly being used to deploy industrial policy.

Investors may recall that soon after Biden was elected, the White House published a list of key priorities for the government (see the table below). These priorities were reflected in the spending bills of the past four years, and to a great extent (the proliferation of AI notwithstanding) were apparent in the growth prospects and stock performance of U.S. companies.

There is a strong consensus that at the top of Trump’s priority list is the reshoring of U.S. manufacturing as well as other key industries critical to national security and autonomy (e.g. energy and semiconductors).

To be sure, manufacturing re-shoring and rebuilding should be viewed as a continuation of a trend that got underway with the Inflation Reduction Act, since the bill inherently favored onshoring jobs and production in key sectors. In this sense, many of the excelling companies that have benefited from the process of “deglobalization,” i.e. the building out of domestic supply chains, will continue to thrive in the years ahead. Sustainability focused investors should look for industrial companies with most of their revenues in the U.S. and that support resource efficiency, climate adaptation, automation as these will be in high demand, some of which are highlighted in the table below.

 

  1. Investors Must Make Room for Climate Change Adaptation

Should the U.S. withdraw from the Paris Agreement - as is most likely under Trump – there are lower odds that the planet will warm at less than two degrees in the coming decades.

A study by McKinsey found that even if the global temperature warms only by 1.5°C by 2030 –an increasingly elusive target as we drag our feet on concrete actions – almost half of the world's population will still be exposed to climate hazards, such as heat stress, drought and floods. On this basis, it makes sense for investors to make greater space in their portfolios for companies focused on climate change adaptation.

As it stands, climate adaptation is mitigation’s poor little brother when it comes to financing, with 93% of total climate funding going towards reducing greenhouse gas emissions instead of building resilient infrastructure.

President-elect Trump’s distaste for global cooperation on climate change implies that investors should now be looking for opportunities beyond mitigation. The climate adaptation trade can take many forms, from betting on the long-term success of the most prepared insurance companies to banking on the increased demand for data from firms that feed insurance models, to positioning for increased spending on resilient infrastructure.

With market breadth at historical lows and only a handful of tech stocks moving entire indices, monopolistic behavior is in the spotlight. Antitrust issues are in the forefront, as seen in legal cases involving real estate services, Live Nation in the entertainment industry, Big Tech like Alphabet, Amazon and META and even in the groceries sector with players like Loblaws and George Weston.

We previously remarked that the current frenzy over AI deserves a closer look over concerns of concentration of economic power in this nascent industry (see our note “History Lessons for an AI Future”, June 20, 2024). Interestingly, it seems that the U.S. FTC might have read our note as it just released a statement whereby the antitrust enforcers of the U.S. (DOJ+FTC), the UK and the EU pledged to “remain vigilant for potential competition issues and expressed their determination to use available powers to safeguard against tactics that would undermine fair competition or lead to unfair or deceptive practices in the AI ecosystem”.

In addition to the technology sector, today’s note looks at pricing power in key industries such as real estate services, entertainment and groceries, and suggests that investors beware of companies that exert too much control and influence.

Case 1: The People vs. Realtors

Every year in the U.S., USD 100 billion worth of commissions go to some 2 million realtors in exchange for their brokerage services. According to a recent report from the Brookings Institute, the lack of price transparency and the opaque commission plans of realtors come at a serious cost to homebuyers and the overall U.S. economy. Recent lawsuits and settlements suggest that real estate brokers, particularly through the workings of the Multiple Listing System (MLS), are coordinating their actions to control the market, limit competition, and keep prices high. This behavior undermines consumer rights and fair market practices and is indicative of broader issues of anti-competitive behavior within the real estate sector. While the stock price of listed real estate brokerage firms did not move much since the latest USD 418 million antitrust settlement in April 2024, the sector has underperformed the S&P 500 substantially since the COVID-era real estate frenzy.

Case 2: The People vs. Canadian Grocers

Canada, like many smaller developed economies, is prone to antitrust behaviors due to its large geographical size and small population, which can justify limited competition in sectors like banking, telecoms, transport, and grocers. The most recent ruling against antitrust-like behavior was addressed last week following a settlement that was reached after Canada’s competition bureau inquired into a potential bread price-fixing scheme among players in Canada’s tightly knit groceries sector. The grocer Loblaw agreed to pay CAD 500 million to settle the lawsuit. While the profit margin of Canada’s main grocers has remained stable since 2019, that of Loblaws has increased.

Interestingly, the stock prices of companies in this sector barely budged following the news, likely reflecting that investors had anticipated the fine and priced it in before the announcement, as the case had been ongoing for years.  

 

Case 3: The People vs. Live Nation

The merger of Live Nation and Ticketmaster in 2010 has resulted in a near-monopoly in the live event ticketing industry. This consolidation has led to increased ticket prices and numerous operational issues, drawing public and legal scrutiny. In a previous note in 2022 (“Miss Materiality’s Night Out: A Lesson in Consumer Choice” December 8, 2022), we highlighted Live Nation’s monopolistic practices, the debate over its market dominance, and its poor operational performance.

This year, among multiple litigation cases regarding the company’s poor practices, the U.S. government and dozens of States sued Live Nation in May, alleging that for years the parent company of Ticketmaster abused its industry dominance at the detriment of fans nationwide. The long-expected suit is seeking a jury trial and a breakup of the company. Live Nation is monopolizing the ticketing and live events industry by cutting exclusive deals with major venues, which has led to higher fees and limited competition. As illustrated in the chart below, Live Nation's venue operations expanded significantly from 2016 to 2023:

If the company were broken up, it could lead to a more competitive market, potentially lowering ticket prices as venues and promoters have more options for ticketing services. However, the complexity of unravelling Live Nation's operations means that immediate changes might not be drastic. Ticketmaster's well-capitalized structure enables it to offer significant financial incentives to major venues and event promoters, that other companies might struggle to match. The impact on fees and prices could be limited unless other competitors can scale their operations quickly.

For investors, the regulatory risks associated with Live Nation are substantial. A breakup could lead to market volatility in the entertainment industry, with potential short-term declines in Live Nation's stock prices. However, if managed properly, a more competitive landscape could benefit the industry in the long run by improving customer satisfaction and operational efficiency.

 

Case 4: The People vs. Big Tech

Since the beginning of Biden's mandate, there has been a clear focus on addressing the monopolistic behaviors of major tech companies such as Meta, Alphabet, and Amazon. The administration's intent was to curb tech giants' overwhelming market dominance. The following chart illustrates the number of new litigation cases per year against these companies, highlighting increasing legal scrutiny in recent years.

Despite the growing number of litigation cases, Big Tech companies remain dominant in digital services and market share. During Trump’s presidency, there was a notable push against Big Tech, which included actions against Alphabet for monopolistic practices. His current running mate, J.D. Vance, is also an advocate for strong antitrust measures against Tech monopolies. If Kamala Harris continues on the trajectory of the current administration, we can expect ongoing antitrust enforcement.

The future administration could also heavily influence the development and regulation of AI. While Harris supports Biden’s executive order to advocate for greater public oversight and regulation of AI, Trump has vowed to reverse these measures, potentially loosening the constraints on Tech companies. As it stands, companies like OpenAI, Alphabet, and Meta face significant hurdles in sourcing sufficient high-quality data to train their AI models. This has led them to adopt questionable practices, such as transcribing YouTube videos against the platform's rules and using copyrighted data without proper licenses, highlighting their monopolistic tendencies in circumventing regulations to maintain their dominance.

Meanwhile in Europe, the EU has attempted to regulate the growing influence of AI with the newly enacted EU AI Act. That said, the Act has already faced criticism for not adequately addressing the monopolistic power of dominant tech firms, which continue to control vast amounts of data and market share.

While waiting for more decisive actions against these Big Tech companies, investors can proactively engage with these firms to ensure transparency in practices, avoid regulatory risks, and prevent greenwashing.

Shareholders Vs. Anti-competitive behavior

Following our analysis of anti-competitive practices in various industries, we dive into how investors can drive change within these companies through active engagement and shareholder. We have compiled the following table of shareholder proposals from this year's AGMs for the mentioned companies, focusing on topics related to their oligopolistic practices. These shareholder proposals come from the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility (ICCR), a coalition of organizations that advocate for corporate social responsibility through shareholder engagement and activism.

As an investor, supporting and/or filing proposals can play a crucial role in changing corporate practices. Another form of engagement, dialogue, allows investors to engage directly with companies to discuss concerns and advocate for changes in policies and practices. This method can be particularly effective in addressing monopolistic behaviors by encouraging transparency and accountability. Though finding public data on investor-led dialogues and collaborations can be challenging, when combined with proxy voting, it has a complementary role in influencing corporate behavior. While anticompetitive behaviors and the regulatory risk of being fined or caught do not always affect stock performance, investors should care about their non-financial repercussions, such as investor reputation. Furthermore, it is important to note that while regulatory risks from monopolistic practices do not always impact stock prices immediately, they pose long-term threats to company valuations and investor returns.

Investors can bolster their reputation by engaging on relevant topics that create healthier market structures, thereby avoiding the reputational risk of greenwashing. By leveraging their influence through active engagement and shareholder proposals, investors can play a pivotal role in promoting transparency, and mitigating regulatory risks in companies with monopolistic tendencies.

Sustainable Market Strategies’ research team is an eclectic mix of analysts and strategists that are not afraid to debate contentious issues. One particularly contentious topic is gender; we note that the recent past has been bi-polar for gender issues. At one extreme, reproductive rights in the U.S. have been severely curtailed, leading to questions about the overall state of women’s rights. At the other extreme, the proliferation of women’s professional sports and a marked uptick in capital allocation to female health care suggest that some industries are becoming more gender balanced and are in fact providing potentially exciting investment opportunities.  

What follows in today’s Note is a summary position of our ongoing, internal debate regarding various gender issues (by no means a complete list) that have the potential to impact investment decisions.

 

True or False: The gender pay gap has deleterious effects on economic growth.

True. It’s no great secret that women earn less than men. The reasons behind this are many and range from blatant discrimination, sub-optimal parental benefits and structures and the preponderance of pink-collar industries, e.g. nursing and education, to be less lucrative than blue collar jobs (despite often requiring more advanced education). In the U.S., the gender pay gap has not budged in the past twenty years, though many other countries have made substantial progress.  

What would it mean for economic growth if the gender pay gap were to close? A lot. In 2023, Moody’s estimated that closing the gender gap in OECD countries would raise global economic activity by approximately 7%, or about $7 trillion USD.

Amazingly, the Moody’s report came up with this estimate solely based on the assumption that women could actually access the jobs that matched their education level. In most OECD countries and major emerging markets, the number of women aged 25 to 64 with a master’s degree or equivalent exceeds that of men.

And yet, as the chart below highlights, the proportion of women in senior and middle management positions is paltry compared to men. The implication is that the return on investment of education is sub-optimal and the underutilisation of women’s skills and time, causes an economic loss at both the individual and macroeconomic levels.

True or False: Women-run companies produce better financial returns

False: being female isn’t a superpower, but diversity is. The question of whether women-run companies produce better financial returns has garnered significant attention and research. We tackled this subject in a previous note in 2019 (“Gender Diversity: What’s the data telling us?”, August 8, 2019), which highlighted the difficulty of finding data points linking financial performance and gender diversity.

As discussed in the previous section, women are still far outnumbered in senior roles. They make up less than 10% of CEOs of S&P500 companies (see chart below).

In 2023 however, women CEOs had a breakthrough, finally outnumbering CEOs named John (!) as more women are taking the top job. This milestone reflects broader trends suggesting growing recognition that diversity in leadership positions is advantageous.

Indeed, research from McKinsey shows that diverse boards and executive teams are positively correlated with better non-financial performance, including higher social and environmental impact scores. Specifically, companies with increased gender diversity in leadership show improved performance in community, workforce, and environmental scores. The following chart highlights how a 10% increase in women’s representation on leadership teams correlates with higher scores across various impact metrics.

While women-led companies often see strong financial returns, the true driver of success is the diversity they bring—encompassing varied perspectives and cognitive multiplicity.

 

True or False: Women sports teams are having a breakout moment and it matters for investors.

True. Fueled by shakeups in media consumption, women’s professional sports are experiencing significant growth and popularity.

Recent years have shown how more diverse content can be a driver of success. Netflix’s business model is a key example: more varied programming has helped to uncover audiences previously neglected by traditional content creators and video streaming facilitates access to this content. Just like Netflix did for film and television programs, the proliferation of women’s teams boosts diversity in sports entertainment, therefore drawing in a wider audience. Social media has further bolstered the impact of these changes by delivering tailored content to target likely fans. And female athletes who previously faced a coverage gap compared to their male counterparts can now connect directly with supporters via social media platforms.

The result has been a spike in popularity for women’s sports. Momentum from a record setting 2023 has carried into this year. The Professional Women’s Hockey League (PWHL) kicked off its inaugural season. Initially scheduled in smaller arenas, sold out venues prompted organizers to move some games to larger capacity locations including the largest hockey arena in North America: the Bell Centre (which also sold out). At just the midpoint of its 11th season, the National Women’s Soccer League (NWSL) attendance had increased 42% over last year’s record numbers and merchandise sales were up a staggering 290%! The Kansas City Current became the first NWSL team to have their own dedicated home stadium. Financed with support from JP Morgan, the ownership brings more control and choice, helping to unlock new revenue streams and drive growth. It is seen as a template for other teams to follow. And in basketball, (if you hadn’t heard already), the women’s march madness final drew in nearly 4 million more viewers than the men’s championship game. This wave of enthusiasm is expected to have a ripple effect on the WNBA as top college players enter the professional league.

These previously unmeasured metrics (thanks to a lack of coverage for women’s sports) suggest significant growth prospects. A report by Deloitte released at the end of last year projects women’s sports to earn over $1 billion USD in 2024, some 300% higher than their forecast from 2021, underscoring the immense upside potential. Though past iterations of women’s leagues have folded, today’s teams are supported by a changed media landscape and a flywheel effect in full swing (see diagram below). With sponsors and broadcasters already taking notice, this self-reinforcing cycle suggests the momentum behind women’s sports is here to stay. As market value continues to rise, there is the potential for valuation convergence with men’s sports.

Investment opportunities in women's sports primarily lie in the private equity space, as there are few pure plays in publicly traded companies. However, as viewership increases, so does the potential for merchandise and sponsorship deals, leading to revenue growth for broadcasters, stadiums, concessions and jersey sales. Though the companies in these segments predominately serve men’s teams (at least historically), their allyship is a key step forward.

 

True or False: Women have been shortchanged in health care and an investment catch-up phase is likely.

True. Health care is another area where a prevailing data gap has adversely affected women. Historically, women have been consistently underrepresented in medical research. There are issues of overreliance on male mice for preclinical studies, an insufficient number of women at the trial stage and failure to account for sex-based differences in outcomes (all of which are well documented in Criado-Perez’s book Invisible Women). Furthermore, when it comes to female-specific ailments, research is extremely underfunded. A 2022 McKinsey report showed that, excluding women’s cancers, only 1% of health care research spending is focused on female-specific conditions (women’s cancers receive 4%). As recently as 2015, studies on erectile dysfunction (affecting 19% of the male population) outnumbered studies on premenstrual syndrome (affecting 90% of women) by three times!

Signs of a catch-up are beginning to emerge. This year alone, the Global Alliance for Women’s Health was launched at the World Economic forum in Davos; in March, Biden signed an executive order prioritizing women's health research and a significant portion of Melinda French Gates’ announced donation of $1 billion towards women’s causes is specifically tagged for health projects. Such initiatives should provide momentum to ongoing efforts, help to spur further action and encourage greater investment in women’s health research.

As this wall of money floods the sector, both start-ups and existing companies that focus on treating female-specific maladies will benefit. Operating in a more nascent industry, women’s health companies are at earlier phases of development. These could be prime candidates for acquisition by larger, more established health care players. There are a number of female-focused companies under $1 billion USD in market cap. Alternatively, investors can study how the major pharmaceutical companies are incorporating women’s health into their growth strategies. Are their acquisitions and R&D spend being directed to women’s health solutions?

Two of the largest publicly traded companies in women’s health are Hologic (market capitalization of $17 billion USD) and Organon ($5 billion USD). Hologic operates as a health care equipment company specializing in diagnostics, focusing on products such as mammography and breast biopsy systems as well as skeletal health and gynecological surgical devices. Like other health care companies, Hologic experienced outsized sales during the pandemic from its Covid diagnostics test product, but growth in its more female-centric segments remained strong in 2023. Organon is in the pharmaceuticals sector, concentrating on reproductive health and hormone therapy. Its stock price has struggled somewhat since the spinoff from Merck in 2021 but is rebounding in this first half of 2024. In terms of valuation, Organon comes at a much lower valuation (FWD P/E 4.5) than Hologic (FWD P/E 17.1) and the SP500 Healthcare sector (FWD P/E 19.1).

 

True or False: The Pink Tax Is real and presents a business risk to some consumer discretionary companies if it were “abolished”.

True, but it is an overstated risk. The pink tax refers to the tendency for products marketed specifically toward women to be more expensive than those marketed toward men and the phenomenon is often attributed to gender-based price discrimination. If it exists, the ramifications are quite obvious. First, from a consumer perspective, it would mean that women – who already suffer from an income and pension gap – have a higher cost of living than men, all else equal. Second, it means that companies using this strategy can generate higher profit margins based on discriminatory pricing and would be at risk of margin squeeze if/when the practice were to be abolished (either via consumer or shareholder pressure or a regulatory change).

Much of the pink tax attention has focused on personal care products whereby gender segmentation is ubiquitous, as more than 80% of products in this category are gendered. Various studies show pricing discrepancies exist, although some argue it is for valid reasons, e.g. product composition, women’s higher willingness to pay for quality. Studies in Argentina, the U.S., the U.K. and Canada all show evidence of this practice with the price gap of various consumer goods products averaging between 5 and 20%. 

Attempts to do anything about gender pricing have been mostly futile from a regulatory perspective. There are two U.S. states (NY and California) that explicitly outlaw a “pink tax”. At the U.S. federal level, the Pink Tax Repeal Act, has been introduced several times in different iterations since 2016, most recently in 2021, but has never passed. We are not aware of regulation regarding the pink tax elsewhere in the world.

In any case, personal care product companies do not view gendered pricing as a problem or risk to their business. Using Bloomberg’s “docusearch” tool, we find only a handful of companies addressing the pink tax in any sort of way. In the personal care segment, only CVS Health (CVS), Boxed and Billie (the latter two are private companies) are flagged as addressing the issue.

The bottom line is that for investors, absent meaningful consumer pressure, there is low risk that a meaningful change in pricing strategy would negatively impact profits (we did not find any companies that divulge profit margins disaggregated by gendered sales).

 

True or False: Women’s rights are regressing and it matters for capital markets 

False. Media coverage on the threat to abortion access in the United States is surely overshadowing progress in gender equality that has been achieved in recent decades (at least in the developed world). To be sure, the U.S. is not alone. In Italy, the rise of right-wing political forces has led to increased opposition to reproductive rights and other gender equality measures. And we note that there is a correlation between far-right uprisings and regression of women’s reproductive rights.

The threat to reproductive rights should absolutely be taken seriously, but there have nonetheless been substantial progress on several women’s rights issues, including reproductive rights. Most recently, France became the first country to enshrine women’s right to abortion in their constitution.

Though women still hold a minority of positions in government, there has been some progress in this area, as shown in the chart below. Mexico serves as a powerful example of the effectiveness of representation: five years ago, a constitutional reform required equal numbers of male and female candidates for government positions. In 2024, both of the country’s top political parties chose female candidates as their presidential nominees!

Women are also making gains in the boardroom as discussed in the previous sections. And despite a persistent wage gap, data from the United States shows that women who entered the workforce in 1983 have seen their lifetime earnings increase 33% in real terms compared to the previous generation (for the same period, men can expect to earn 10% less).

Still, according to the World Economic Forum’s report on the global gender gap, it will take 134 years for women to reach full parity globally at the current rate of progress. Given that gender parity would, as highlighted above, significantly increase economic output and prosperity, there is a massive incentive to more rapidly close this gap. Investing in areas that promote gender equality is just one way to contribute to reducing this disparity, and the widening opportunity set shows increasing promise.

 

Shareholder engagement, defined as various strategies investors can use to influence the operational practices of the companies they hold, plays a critical role in driving corporate accountability and sustainable practices. While research suggests no direct link between governance practices and financial returns (see our last note on the topic, “Governance, Are the Efforts All in Vain?”, July 21, 2022), these practices improve the corporate environment by reducing ineffective boards, fostering better decision-making, and curbing overly dominant CEOs. Institutional investors have an outsized influence on corporate governance action. According to Broadridge, in 2022, U.S. retail investors voted only 29% of the shares they owned whereas institutional investors voted 82% of theirs.

In this week’s note, we provide a preliminary analysis of the 2024 proxy voting season results, on compensation, directors’ elections and main trends in shareholder proposals, with a focus on North America.

Paychecks Under the Microscope

Top executive compensation is assessed by shareholders in a say-on-pay vote, a process where shareholders have a non-binding vote on the compensation of top executives, typically occurring annually during a company’s annual general meeting.

Proxy advisors provide research and recommendations on how shareholders should vote on various corporate governance issues, including executive compensation and director elections. Their objective is to guide institutional investors in making informed voting decisions that align with best practices and shareholder interests. The biggest proxy advisors in the world, Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) and Glass Lewis, significantly influence voting outcomes with negative recommendations leading to substantial declines in support on say-on-pay. For instance, a negative recommendation from ISS can lead to a 33% decrease in support for Say-on-Pay proposals, while Glass Lewis’s negative recommendations result in a 12% decline. This year, both advisors focused their decisions on issues such as non-rigorous performance goals, lack of transparency, and the use of discretion in bonus plans. These advisors’ compensation analyses scrutinize performance targets linked to remuneration rather than just looking at the total compensation figures, emphasizing the importance of aligning executive pay with company performance and long-term shareholder value.

A preliminary analysis of the 2024 proxy season on Say-on-Pay voting among S&P 500 and Russell 3000 companies shows higher rates of approval (over 50% votes for) and increased support compared to previous years. No company with a compensation proposition that failed in 2023 failed again in 2024, indicating satisfactory changes to last year’s failed proposals.

The table below highlights the increased support for executive compensation proposals among S&P 500 and Russell 3000 companies from FY 2023 to May 2024.

In corporate governance standards, a Say-on-pay support under the 70% threshold is often seen as a clear signal to the board that the current compensation plan may need reassessment. Low support levels can lead to increased scrutiny from investors and proxy advisors. Recent voting results show that these phenomena remain low, below 5%.

One compensation package that caused quite a stir this season was that of Tesla CEO Elon Musk. Back in January of this year, the Delaware Court struck down the $55 billion pay package for Tesla CEO Elon Musk proposed back in 2018. Even though the package was approved by 73% of unaffiliated Tesla shareholders at that time, the court found that Musk, as a controlling shareholder, had too much influence over the Board and that conflicts of interest were not fully disclosed. As a result, the court decided the package was unfair and rescinded it. Tesla decided to once again submit this package for shareholder approval at the 2024 AGM in June. Despite a campaign from the New York City Comptroller’s Office and other investors urging shareholders to reject Musk’s pay (one which significantly impacted discussions and was noted in reports by ISS and Glass Lewis), the proposal was approved by shareholders. And it came in addition to approval to change Tesla’s state of incorporation from Delaware to Texas.

The season highlights that transparent and performance-aligned executive compensation remains crucial for shareholder approval, underscoring the influential role of proxy advisors in guiding voting decisions.

Boardroom Battles

Support for director nominations remained high in the U.S. in 2024, with average support rising from 95.9% to 96.4%. The season saw significant impacts from the Universal Proxy Card (UPC) rule, which mandates the inclusion of all director nominees on a single ballot when there is a proxy fight and a shareholder want to elect other directors than proposed by the company. This change makes it easier for shareholders to vote across slates, referring to the lists of candidates nominated by different parties. Previously, shareholders had to choose between separate ballots for the company's and the dissident's candidates, but the new rule allows for a mix-and-match approach, simplifying the process and enhancing shareholder choice in proxy contests.

Notable proxy contests were seen this year at Crown Castle Inc. and The Walt Disney Company, where management achieved clean sweeps despite proxy advisor recommendations for some dissident nominees. Meanwhile, at Norfolk Southern Corporation three dissident nominees were elected.

Gildan’s case was the major event of the Canadian proxy season: in May 2024, Browning West, a California-based hedge fund manager, led a historic and successful proxy campaign at Gildan Activewear, resulting in the complete replacement of Gildan’s board and the reinstatement of co-founder Glenn Chamandy as CEO. This campaign was supported by unanimous recommendations from major proxy advisory firms and led to the resignation of Gildan’s entire board and CEO just days before the annual meeting. The full timeline can be found in the table below:

This year's proxy season demonstrates the importance of shareholder choice and robust governance practices, with the Universal Proxy Card rule enhancing the ability of shareholders to influence board composition effectively.

Shareholders’ Frontline

United States

In the 2024 proxy voting season, significant trends emerged regarding shareholder proposals. According to Ceres, a nonprofit organization advocating for sustainability leadership, there was a noticeable support for climate transition plans, particularly within the banking sector. This indicates growing investor demand for more detailed disclosures on how companies plan to mitigate and adapt to climate change. However, overall support for environmental proposals, which include a range of issues from biodiversity protection to sustainable resource use, declined, highlighting varying levels of investor interest in different aspects of environmental sustainability.

Diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) proposals faced increased scrutiny and declining support, reflecting a more critical view from investors​. This underscores the importance of carefully framing and justifying ESG initiatives to garner investor backing. According to the Groupe Investissement Responsable Inc. (GIR), a Canadian leading proxy advisor, among Fortune 250 companies, five shareholder proposals received majority votes. These proposals were predominantly governance-focused, including measures to adopt simple majority voting, the right to call a special meeting, and the repeal of rules enacted without shareholder approval. The GIR also mentions that shareholder proposals (excluding anti-ESG proposals) garnered an average support of 19.94%. The ten most frequently filed environmental and social (E&S) proposal categories are presented below:

Tech companies were heavily targeted, with fifteen shareholder proposals for Amazon, twelve for Alphabet, and eleven for Meta Platforms. The E&S proposals that received the highest support are presented in the next table, as highlighted by the GIR:

Canada

In Canada, the GIR highlighted notable shareholder proposals that received majority approval at BMO, CIBC, Air Transat, and Metro. These proposals advocate for in-person shareholder meetings supplemented by online options, reversing the trend of virtual meetings necessitated by the COVID-19 pandemic. The Movement for the Education and Defense of Shareholders (MEDAC), known for its advocacy efforts, particularly with major banks, saw relative success in support on its environmental proposals, reflecting a certain level of influence for its shareholder initiatives.

Key proposals that garnered substantial support in Canada are included in the table below:

Anti-ESG Shareholder Proposals

In the first five months of 2024, the number of anti-ESG proposals saw a significant increase. Despite this surge, they remain unpopular among investors, with average support declining slightly to 1.6%. The increased number of these proposals is partly driven by recent regulatory initiatives in some red states. However, their arguments have not gained traction with larger institutional investors. Overall, while anti-ESG factions are more vocal, their efforts have yet to translate into substantial support. According to GIR, anti-ESG proposals in Canada showed similar levels of support.

This season's proxy voting outcomes on shareholder proposals underscore the ongoing tension between pro- and anti-ESG perspectives within the investment community. While anti-ESG proposals continue to receive minimal support, the substantial backing for governance reforms suggests that investors prioritize strong governance structures, which they view as foundational to effectively addressing environmental and social issues. This indicates a nuanced stance where investors may support ESG initiatives, but with a particular emphasis on robust governance as a critical component of overall corporate responsibility.

Since its launch in November 2022, ChatGPT has become hugely popular and it’s no wonder: with an IQ of above 120 (placing it among the top 10% of humans), the generative AI tool can do things that many humans can’t.

But ChatGPT and the like are just a small sliver of what artificial intelligence can and will be able to do.

General purpose technology (GPT), which artificial intelligence is presumed to be, is defined as ‘a single generic technology, which initially has much scope for improvement and eventually comes to be widely used and to have many spillover effects. Examples of GPTs include electricity and the personal computer. In other words, a technology that is pervasive and significantly impacts aggregate productivity growth.

However, the pervasiveness and productivity growth associated with GPTs often take very long to develop. A popular example is electricity: the big impact of electricity came in the 1920s, about 40 years after Thomas Edison first distributed electrical power in New York in 1882.

The long lag time between invention and widespread application occurs because GPTs tend to entail major investments, learning costs, and complementary innovations. Often, the net benefits of the new technology itself are low early for the earliest adopters.

Prior to artificial intelligence, the most recent example of a GPT is the personal computer. The first desktop computers available for the mass market were introduced in the 1970s, but it took two decades before a significant share of households had adopted them. In 1993, still only 23% of American households owned a computer. The share of workers using computers in their jobs also grew relatively slowly before becoming ubiquitous in the 2000s.

This widespread adoption of computers was followed by an increase in U.S. productivity growth. Between 1991 and 2004, total factor productivity (TFP) grew 1% per year on average, almost twice as fast as its average growth rate in the 1980s (about 0.6%).

Like other GPTs, it is highly likely that artificial intelligence will spur a strong, sustained increase in productivity growth across whole economies that could last decades. Like past GPT related productivity booms, however, these advances could surprise by how long they take to be truly transformative.

An early indicator of enhanced penetration of AI into the overall economy should be the observation of a wave of increased capex, IT and training expense. This has clearly started, but remains timid in most areas.

Capex is currently significantly greater for Nasdaq listed (i.e. tech-focused) companies compared to indexes that reflect the broader economy, as shown in the chart below. This suggests that so far, much of the acceleration of IT spending has been fairly concentrated.

A sign of AI pervasiveness could be when the capex efforts of financials, health care or other sectors match levels in the IT space.

In the meantime, we examine what the overall effects (and roadblocks) of artificial intelligence might be beyond sheer productivity gains.

Artificial Intelligence Will Create More Jobs Than It Destroys

AI, like all new technologies, has been accompanied by a raft of concerns about how its usage will affect certain aspects of society. The first is that job automation will lead to significantly higher unemployment rates. In our view, this fear is widely exaggerated.

The periods of greatest unemployment tend to occur during economic recessions, typically brought on by financial crises and spikes in oil prices.

In fact, studies have shown that technology tends to create more jobs than it destroys. Deloitte has recently published a convincing set of charts across a number of industries where jobs were created/and destroyed over the past 140 years of innovation. No doubt the debate suffers from a common cognitive bias, loss aversion. Analysts tend to focus on the job-destroying effects of technological change (because they are more easily observed) rather than its creative aspects.

Moreover, there is already evidence that the impact of artificial intelligence on the job market is playing out exactly as described above: census bureau data of U.S. firms show that adoption of AI (and other technologies like robotics) so far varies substantially across industries, but is concentrated in larger firms. Adopters have higher labor productivity and greater demand for skilled labor, but the effects on overall employment levels at these firms were limited or ambiguous. This is also borne out by survey data, as highlighted in the chart below.

Importantly, while general purpose technologies prior to the personal computer most severely impacted “blue collar jobs”, it is most likely that service sector employment, such as IT and finance, will see their operations being the most impacted by AI in the coming years.

 

The bottom line is that there is no precedent that suggests the introduction of artificial intelligence will be different than past GPTs: job losses will occur - but will be offset by job growth in new sectors, This topline approach, however, does mask important weaknesses in the labor market, most notably income inequality.

Artificial intelligence Will Exacerbate Income Inequality

A more serious potential concern regarding AI adoption is a rise in socio-economic inequality.

There is a great deal of historical evidence to suggest that general purpose technologies have increased economic inequalities and there is potential – though not a foregone conclusion – that artificial intelligence will accentuate this trend.

Previous technological advances have been skill-biased, meaning that high-skill workers experienced wage gains due to productivity improvements while people in lower-skilled jobs, (i.e. more repetitive tasks), experienced both job losses and decreased real wages due to automation. It’s estimated that between 50% and 70% of changes in the U.S. wage structure (among the most flexible job markets in the world) over the past four decades are due to the relative wage declines of workers specializing in routine tasks in industries that experienced rapid automation.

This phenomenon, unsurprisingly, bears heavily on the financial outcomes of those with low levels of educational attainment. In the U.S., real earnings of individuals without a high-school degree are now 15% lower than they were in 1980, whereas real wages of workers with a post-graduate degree rose significantly.

The next phase of technological innovation is no different. In the words of technologist and investor Kai-Fu Lee, “corporate profits will explode, showering wealth on the elite executives and engineers lucky enough to get in on the action….”.

The remedy to income inequality stemming from general purpose technologies is already known and well documented. It requires a redistribution of wealth via taxation and assurance of a social safety net that includes access to quality health care and education. Differences in Gini coefficients among the most technologically advanced countries underscores that the tendency toward technologically-induced income inequality can be counteracted through policy. In this sense, although it is a foregone conclusion that increasing automation means greater dispersion in the price of labor according to skill, it is not inevitable that artificial intelligence will lead to greater social inequalities.

Contrary to income inequality within nations, income inequality between countries has been falling in recent decades as faster-growing emerging economies like China and India have narrowed the income gap with advanced economies. This trend is in danger of reversing, given that AI is developing in a monopolistic fashion that risks concentrating economic power within a handful of actors.

Left Unchecked, Artificial Intelligence Will Concentrate Economic Power Even More

A common tendency among general purpose technologies is that they tend to create monopolies. Anti-trust laws exist and are enforced to prevent customers from punitively high prices and to ensure that economic power does not translate into egregious political power (witness the U.S. oil industry). In a review of general purpose technologies, the U.S. Department of Justice concludes that in all cases, “dominant firms have accumulated far more monopoly power than is necessary to motivate and sustain the most rapid and beneficial rate of technological progress”.

Thus, fears about monopolistic power concentrated in the hands of artificial intelligence “first movers” is warranted, based on the historical precedent of previous GPTs.

Aspects of the AI industry are already acting as a monopoly. The table below shows the major links in the artificial intelligence supply chain (more commonly known as the “AI stack”) with the degree of market concentration at each step.

Currently, it is the early inputs that are most monopolistic. For example, TSMC, the semiconductor manufacturer, is known to prioritize its contracts with Apple over other chip consumers during periods of shortages. Note that the companies in the “AI supply chain” with the most monopolistic power (NVDA, TSMC, ASML, AMZN, MSFT, GOOG) are also the stock prices that have been among the biggest gainers in dollar terms since the launch of ChatGPT.  

The stakes of monopolistic behaviour are arguably far higher with artificial intelligence relative to past GPTs. Concentration in the number of foundation models, i.e. the number of artificial intelligence models on which data is trained and uses self-supervision, means that model providers can have an outsized influence on information and can shape the public discourse in profound ways. The current concerns about the outsized influence of media platforms owned by Meta would pale in comparison to the control possible by AI models in the hands of a select few.

The bottom line is that the artificial intelligence industry currently displays monopolistic tendencies. Similar to income inequality, there are policy prescriptions to counteract this, but left unchecked, historical precedents suggest that artificial intelligence will facilitate a higher concentration of economic power.

 

Artificial Intelligence’s Biggest Roadblock: Less Energy Inefficient Than the Status Quo

By status quo, we mean the human brain.

Artificial intelligence is different from previous general purpose technologies in that it is - in its current form – highly energy inefficient compared to a human. Note that in all other general purpose technologies, the energy needs of the technology to complete a task were vastly inferior to the preceding method of task completion. Consider the steam engine: the very first steam engine trains are estimated to have the power of approximately 300 horses and while steam engine powered locomotives are not energy efficient by today’s standards, they are vastly superior to the horse.

Artificial intelligence is already more powerful (i.e. smarter) than the human brain to solve problems with defined scope. However, to complete tasks, artificial intelligence today is less energy efficient than the human brain. The chart below shows the energy requirements of a mouse and human brain compared to computers. To pass from artificial intelligence to general intelligence, i.e. to move from solving defined tasks to solving problems in various domains (i.e. like a human being can) would take almost unimaginable quantities of energy.  

Indeed, according to the Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence, researchers estimate that biological computing is about 9 × 108 times more energy efficient than artificial computing architecture. The authors uncover that to compete with the human brain across an economy, artificial intelligence’s energy use would need to be orders of magnitude higher than that of a large, highly industrialized nation. In other words, the authors conclude that “the principles of thermodynamics of computation pose a significant, if not insurmountable barrier, to the emergence of any artificial general intelligence system”. Of course, AI energy efficiency will no doubt see gains in the coming years, but it seems that humans have an important head start.

The past month has seen a flurry of activity in the U.S., China and the euro area regarding competition in key “green” industries. The European commission has launched several new probes into Chinese companies for anti-competitive behaviour in wind, electric vehicles and batteries. Meanwhile, U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen visited China aiming to address U.S. concerns that China is dumping their overproduction of renewable energy equipment onto other nations. There is talk of imposing more tariffs on China as Chinese exports of solar panels have helped push prices down over 40% in the last year, making it difficult for solar panel producers in other countries to compete.  

From a climate change perspective, a glut of solar panels and wind turbines is hardly a bad thing. After all, according to the IEA, the decline in solar panel prices is related to a three-fold increase in manufacturing capacity since 2021. The result: an estimated 96% of newly installed, utility-scale solar PV capacity now has lower generation costs than new coal and natural gas plants. This is excellent news –the economics of renewable energy support an ongoing shift away from dirty energy sources.

Unfortunately, however, what is good for the planet does not always align with national interests: attempts by governments to turn green growth into a competition for green jobs has translated into a wave of disputes. Below, we explore the past and current state of global green trade and outline a possible path forward.

 

Origins of a Trade War

China joined the WTO in 2001 and in the beginning, there was a highly symbiotic relationship between China and the U.S. (and many other developed economies). China, thanks in large part to comparatively cheap labor, supplied U.S. consumers with low-cost goods in exchange for much-needed U.S. dollars to fuel a move up the development curve.

For a long time, this relationship worked, since the two economies did not compete – China largely produced items at a cost efficiency too difficult for American firms to achieve on domestic soil, lowering the price of many consumer goods, while China did not have the skilled workforce or capital savings needed to produce in critical sectors where America excelled.

However, for the past decade or so, the relationship has become less mutually beneficial, in no small part because China and America no longer operate in different spheres: the Chinese economy has advanced so much that China is now equipped to compete across a plethora of high-skill industries. Indeed, the chart below shows the economic complexity indexes (ECI) of China and the U.S. The ECI is a measure of knowledge intensity of an economy. While China still lags the U.S. somewhat, the convergence underscores that China is competent in many of the areas that used to be the domain of the U.S. and a handful of other developed economies.

Green Goods Dumping

In retrospect, it shouldn’t have been a surprise to anyone that China became a leader in green goods industries. After all, the Chinese government’s economic plan “Made For 2025” which was laid out in 2015 made clear the ten industries for which China aimed to reduce the country’s reliance on foreign technology imports and to create domestic companies relying on domestic innovation. Of the ten industries targeted, “energy saving” and “power equipment” are among the loftiest goals.  

By all accounts, China was wildly successful at creating flourishing domestic industries in ‘new energy vehicles’ and ‘renewable energy equipment’.

In fact, China has been so successful that export markets have taken a keen interest in their products. BYD, the main Chinese electric car manufacturer currently already sells about 8% of its cars outside of China.

Meanwhile, China’s ‘renewable energy equipment’ industry is a true global phenomenon. Returning to solar panels, while China represents less than 40% of total solar panel demand, the country accounts for virtually all global production.

State of Play

Anti-dumping and anti-subsidy tariffs on the Chinese solar panel industry began in 2012 and 2013 by the U.S. and euro area, respectively. As a result of these moves, many Chinese companies spent the rest of the decade moving their manufacturing facilities to other countries to avoid the duties. In other words, actions against China were not successful at curbing Chinese solar power capacities.

Although the euro area dropped their tariffs in 2018, the U.S. added a new 30% tariff on solar imports which is still in place today. The U.S. is contemplating further tariffs, while the euro area recently launched new probes into Chinese manufacturers of solar panels suspected of benefitting from "distortive" state subsidies and gaining an "unfair advantage." The EU has also launched subsidy investigations into Chinese wind turbine companies and Chinese EV manufacturers.

All of these moves by Western countries are happening under the guise of protecting national industries. But what’s left to protect? Of the top producers of solar panels (listed companies by market cap), only four are U.S. or European companies. By most accounts, it is extremely unlikely that other nations can catch up to China on production. As for other green industries, although China has a formidable wind turbine manufacturing base, Chinese manufacturers have not yet been able to penetrate markets abroad (where roughly 95% of demand in 2023 was covered by European and American companies).

What Comes Next?

Despite China’s total dominance in solar panel manufacturing, it is highly unlikely that policy and trade friction between China and other nations will disappear. It is well known that China is suffering from an economic growth slowdown and will continue to support its local industries in order to maintain jobs and stability. Meanwhile, in Western countries, it is politically popular to “target” China irrespective of the efficacy of policies. In other words, we do not expect any major policy change that will disrupt the current status quo of a strong, steady stream of Chinese-sourced renewable energy equipment. We do not wish to bet against U.S. and European manufacturers, though we do not expect current headwinds to diminish for the foreseeable future.

A key point is that Chinese solar panel manufacturers are producing goods that are inexpensive, but not “cheap”.  One of the main reasons that Chinese panels have fallen in the past decade is due to improvements in design. A notable metric for solar panel quality is bankability, i.e. the likelihood that investors are willing to invest because data indicates the quality and long-term durability of the solar module, as well as the trustworthiness of the manufacturer. 

Chinese companies such as Longi and Jinko Solar receive the same bankability ratings as U.S. companies like First Solar. On this basis, it seems unlikely that a major shift in the industry is likely to occur.

 Investment Implications

As China attempts to stabilize its domestic economy and reach its Made for 2025 objectives, it is highly likely that renewable energy equipment manufacturers will remain in high gear, maintaining the global supply glut, particularly in solar panels but also for other equipment.

This trend is developing at a time when it is becoming increasingly well known that grid investment has not kept pace with renewable energy development. This is evidenced by longer and longer grid connection queues (the IEA estimates that over 3 000 GW of renewable energy projects are in connection queues globally, with nearly 1 500 GW of wind and solar PV projects in advanced stages of development). This is enough to nearly double current installed global capacity for these technologies, all of which is just sitting in queues!

We have written in past notes about our preferred investment picks to invest in the coming buildout in grid capacity (for example, please see “From Gridlock To Gridsmart”, April 4, 2024). In the simplest terms, given the oversupply in manufacturers vs the building demand for transmission, investors should be looking to go “long renewable energy operators and grid producers” and avoid “renewable energy equipment manufacturers”.

Less Talk, More Action

Eradicating forced labor and ending modern slavery is a target of the UN’s Sustainable Development Goal number eight: Promote sustained, inclusive and sustainable economic growth, full and productive employment and decent work for all.

Human Rights Violations are the result of a few factors:

The risk of forced labor in global supply chains remains one of the most significant human rights issues for companies and their investors. At least 25 million people are currently estimated to be victims of forced labor in supply chains supporting many of the world’s favorite brands.

Awareness on these issues continues to grow since the Rana Plaza tragedy in 2013, as dissemination of information regarding supply chain practices becomes more accessible thanks to the global digital age. Consumers, advocacy groups, and governments are increasingly demanding transparency, accountability, and ethical practices in supply chains. However, tangible progress from corporations is sporadic. Many firms have formally pledged to enhance their supply chain oversight, but these commitments rarely translate into substantive change. This gap between promise and practice is starkly illustrated by a December 2023 study that shed light on 39 European clothing brands (including Prada, Levi’s and Inditex), at probability of using Uyghur forced labor in their supply chains. This is far from being the first report on the topic: issues of forced labor of the detained Uyghur population in China’s Xinjiang region, and its presence in supply chains of major companies have been known since 2009!

A significant percentage of companies assessed by the Corporate Human Rights Benchmark claim high standards for supplier conduct, with 85% stating prioritizing human rights in their supplier contracts. However, there is a clear shortfall in transparency and practical support. Only 27% of these companies offer evidence of aiding their suppliers in upholding these human rights standards, indicating a disconnect between stated policies and actions fostering responsible supply chains. Additionally, the Fashion Transparency Index reveals that none of the companies it has assessed have fully disclosed their first or second-tier supplier lists.

Moreover, placing the responsibility for upholding human rights solely on suppliers risks falling short of objectives to create decent work for all. Improvements like reduced overtime and on-site healthcare in factories, frequently showcased during audits, are often not maintained. Companies operating in Asian countries often lack a thorough understanding of their supply chains, making it challenging to ensure they are not involved in human rights abuses. Western companies seeking to verify the integrity of their suppliers in Xinjiang face potential backlash from the Chinese government.

This persists despite company claims that they are responding to the issue.

The Regulatory Mirage

Understanding the gaps between corporate promises and supply chain realities means examining regulatory responses. The table below highlights many recent regulations in various jurisdictions that aim to transform voluntary principles into enforceable laws. The impact of these new regulations is highly uncertain due to the challenges of interpreting supply chain disclosures. Regulations tend to expand disclosure requirements, but can result in a deluge of data that investors find challenging to navigate. Moreover, regulations frequently lack a clear mandate for companies to take concrete corrective actions.

Unfortunately, recent regulations have not always been effective in preventing violations. A high-profile example occurred in 2020: despite the UK Modern Slavery Act being in effect, fashion retailer Boohoo came under intense scrutiny for perpetuating modern slavery conditions within its supply chain. Reports emerged detailing workers in Leicester's garment factories, which supplied Boohoo, being paid significantly below the minimum wage, with some wages as low as £3.50 an hour, alongside working in unsafe and exploitative conditions. The repercussions were immediate and severe for Boohoo. Following these allegations, Boohoo's share price fell by more than 20% in two days after major online retailers such as ASOS, Zalando, and Next dropped the brand from their platforms. It ultimately wiped £1.1bn off the value of the business.

As for the consequences of non-compliance, companies may face substantial fines. Under the proposed Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD) in the EU, whether such sanctions truly deter companies may hinge on the level of enforcement by member states. It remains to be seen whether this will have a significant impact on corporate behavior. ​

 

Unveiling Delusions

Moving beyond regulatory efforts, it is crucial to consider the interplay of corporate advocacy and accountability. Some entities actively lobby against more stringent measures designed to ensure accountability and protect human rights. These tactics highlight the tension between corporate interests and the push for greater corporate responsibility.

There is further evidence of this disconnect in stakeholder actions, where companies’ ethical commitments are questioned - yet go un-penalized in the market. The following table examines the market's response—or lack thereof—to significant human rights controversies involving major corporations.

The observed market data underscores a concerning trend: stock prices remain largely unaffected by the disclosure of human rights violations. This indifference signals a disconnect between ethical corporate behavior and financial consequences, indicating the market's challenges in serving as a corrective force. Boohoo's stock decline, as stated above, was an exception, attributed to the company’s lack of Human Rights Due Diligence (HRDD) systems. This contrasts sharply with other industry giants, which have purportedly demonstrated commitment through the implementation of more effective HRDD systems.

 

The Investor as a Catalyst

As an investor committed to responsibility, it is crucial to understand that regulatory measures alone are currently insufficient and market responses can be unpredictable. Human rights concerns, while recognized, are not yet a priority for the majority of investors.

This highlights an opportunity for investors to lead the way in elevating human rights. It is crucial for investors to conduct thorough research. Frameworks exist to guide investors in this path.

The OECD Human Rights Due Diligence (HRDD) framework guides companies in identifying, preventing, and mitigating their impacts on human rights throughout their operations and supply chains. The framework offers a structured approach to assess risks, integrate responsible practices, track progress, and communicate actions, aligning business conduct with international human rights standards, as shown in the chart below.

While the HRDD Guidance is designed for companies to ensure responsible business conduct, these key principles are equally critical for investors to apply in their assessment and engagement strategies.

To operationalize these principles, there are a variety of tools investors can access. However, investors must be cautious when navigating these resources as some have faced recent controversies. One such example is the Higg Index, a system developed by major fashion brands to gauge environmental impact. This tool has been criticized for favorably rating synthetic materials, derived from fossil fuels, over natural ones. Critics argue that some of the underlying data is industry-funded and not fully open to independent verification, potentially misleading consumers about the sustainability of products.

Acknowledging these complexities, we have compiled a list of our top tools and resources for investors’ evaluation of human rights practices.

Investors can also play a role in advocating for human rights through proxy voting and shareholder proposals. Recent trends show progress in this area. In 2023, the number of shareholder proposals in the U.S. on human rights saw an uptick to 37 (compared to 16 in 2022). Despite typically not gaining majority support, average approval rates have improved, reaching a median support of 31.4% (compared to a 24% median support between 2020 and 2022). This signals growing acknowledgment of human rights issues in corporate governance. Investors leveraging these mechanisms are contributing to a heightened corporate focus on human rights matters.

So far in our strategic asset allocation research (see Climate Change and Strategic Asset Allocation, August 24, 2023 and Strategic Asset Allocation – Back to the Future, October 19, 2023), we have described how factors like climate change, fiscal dominance, demographics, and geopolitical volatility are impacting the economic context and thereby affecting expected returns The table below highlights where we believe institutional investors will direct their attention in the next decade.

 

 

 

Starting in 1982, interest rates fell from more than 10% to close to 0% in 2021. Along the way, pension funds were tired of seeing their traditional 60-40 portfolio being outpaced by their long duration liabilities. They increased the duration of their bonds and migrated to asset classes that were doing well. Lost in the analysis was the sensitivity of all these asset classes to interest rates. We believe that many pension funds will struggle to perform in an environment where the secular decline in bond yields is over.  Furthermore, threats from climate change and geopolitical uncertainties introduce heightened volatility and a drag on return expectations, making the case for absolute return strategies and value-oriented equity holdings. In this week’s note, we take a closer look at these investment opportunities.

Inflation Protection

If we are correct that the future is more inflationary than the recent past, inflation sensitivity will regain in importance. With that in mind, the lowest risk approach is to purchase inflation-linked bonds whereby the sensitivity to inflation is contractual. Unfortunately though, there are not that many inflation-linked issuances and more than 50% of them over the past 4 years are from Brazil and Chile (see the chart below). In Latin America, there are many corporate issuers whereas elsewhere, government and financial institutions are the only issuers of inflation-linked bonds. Moreover, it can be challenging for large pension funds to find enough bonds to meet their allocations – some issuing governments even have caps on foreign holdings. Given this rather of developed market inflation-linked securities - which offer the best inflation match for developed market pension assets - institutional investors will need to look to alternative assets for additional inflation protection. 

 

 

Agriculture

As the foundation of our food system, agriculture products are a basic need and ag businesses can more easily pass on rising costs. Food prices also drive the valuation of farmland, establishing it as an inflation hedging asset.

In the coming years, food prices are expected to continue to rise. The global population is still growing, but the area of available arable land is limited, imposing constraints on food production capacities. Furthermore, extreme weather events due to climate change will add to supply pressures.

With recent farmland appreciation linked to historically low interest rates, some may be concerned about the risk of a correction in farmland prices resulting from higher rates; however, we anticipate that rising food prices will outweigh these effects. Historical correlations between farmland value and interest rates have alternated between positive and negative (see chart below), suggestive of other factors at play. The income derived from land’s farming productivity is expected to be a primary driver of value.

Another potential upside to the value of farmland is the ability to sequester carbon. Both Europe and the U.S. are pushing for the development of carbon markets that will compensate landowners to adopt practices that improve the carbon storage capabilities of their land. One might also be interested in forest assets which benefit from carbon markets as well and have similarly advantageous inflation hedging characteristics.

Agriculture assets offer many attractive characteristics: inflation protection, defensiveness and potentially even some liquidity in the form of rent revenue from leased farmland. Investors can add exposure through private assets, publicly listed REITs or food producers.

Commodities

Very few institutional investors have explicit exposure to commodities currently, as most are satisfied with gaining exposure through the materials sector within their equity portfolio. Electrification, re-shoring, climate change and a volatile geopolitical environment are likely to stimulate demand for commodities over the next decades. Greater barriers to entry from environment concerns and protectionism and the poor profitability for resource extraction activities since the GFC are dampening new supply even with strong demand prospects. Growing demand and uncertain supply are a good recipe for higher prices.

For sustainability-oriented investors, copper, nickel, aluminum and uranium will be cornerstones of the energy transition. The chart below highlights the evolution of these commodity prices since 1990. Increases in price for all four started with the last commodity boom when China joined the World Trade Organization in 2001 and peaked close to the GFC in 2008. Prices during the 1990’s and 2010’s were flat to down, coinciding with a lack of investor interest. We anticipate a new upward cycle for those commodities. Such cycles typically last until a supply response occurs. The time it takes to start copper or uranium mines is very long, so time is on investors’ side.

 

A basket approach to sustainable commodities could also include carbon reduction commodities like wood as a store of carbon and even carbon credits; though not a commodity, carbon credits share similar supply and demand characteristics as a way to incentivize polluters to reduce their carbon emissions. Furthermore, some markets like the California-Quebec carbon market have an embedded inflation floor.

 

Absolute Return and Value Equities

As per our previous research, including the July 8, 2021: “Macro Goes ESG”, we expect fiscal policy to be a bigger driver of economic cycles in the future. Absolute return strategies (global macro, long short, event-driven) that position accordingly should reap the rewards. Specifically, a thematic strategy focused on climate change can generate alpha by anticipating important structural shifts and consequent fiscal policy. It is worth noting that these themes extend beyond the energy transition (see Building an All-Weather Environmental Strategy, December 7, 2023).

A shift from growth to value can also insulate against higher interest rates. The chart below highlights the difference in sector composition and selected financial ratios for large cap value and growth ETFs in the United States. For the Growth index (in blue) two sectors, technology and consumer discretionary, represent three quarter of the exposure. In green, the Value index shows Price to Earnings and Price to Book that are less than half of the Growth index. If history is a guide, such concentration generally does not last and mean reversion occurs at extremes. For stronger diversification and sustainability, allocators can consider tilting equity exposure to impactful healthcare and telecom, green energy, industrials and utilities.

 

The switch to absolute return strategies and value equities does not have as direct a link to inflation as the other asset classes mentioned but mean reversion generally follows a change of regime and after 15 years of underperformance, their time in the sun is forthcoming.

In the table below, we summarize the role of each of the recommended assets in a portfolio’s allocation. These assets provide attractive diversification opportunities that fit well with the evolving economic backdrop.

The U.S. healthcare system is distinct from other developed economies, marked by its absence of universal coverage and a complex mix of private and public elements. This makes healthcare accessibility and affordability ongoing national challenges and also presents important opportunities and risks for sustainability investors. After all, the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health is considered a fundamental human right.

America’s Dysfunctional Healthcare System

Despite spending the most on healthcare compared to other rich countries, as illustrated in the chart below, the U.S. has worse outcomes for metrics such as life expectancy, avoidable hospital stays, suicides, and maternal mortality.

About 65% of Americans rely on private health insurance, but the quality and cost of coverage is extremely heterogeneous. Moreover, nearly 26 million American (8% of the population) are uninsured or underinsured. The table below provides a snapshot of health coverage distribution in the U.S. 

This discrepancy in coverage is further exacerbated by the U.S.’ complex drug pricing system. The U.S. healthcare system is characterized by its limited capacity for insurers to effectively negotiate drug prices, in stark contrast with nations like Germany where government-led negotiations help maintain cost controls. This disparity in bargaining strength contributes to higher medication costs in the U.S. The chart below shows the complex journey of how drugs are priced, involving many players including consumers, pharmacies, wholesalers, and manufacturers.

Insurers, through negotiated payments and rebates with Pharmacy Benefit Managers (PBMs) and drug manufacturers, struggle within a system that favors opaque transactions and inhibits straightforward price bargaining. This visual representation underscores the critical vulnerability in how the U.S. manages prescription drug pricing, driven by market dynamics rather than patient need and health outcomes.

In the face of such complexity, costs for crucial medications like insulin have soared, as we discussed in the note “Basic Instinct: The Insulin Profit Machine” (September 22, 2022). These costs are born by those with private insurance and also by public healthcare programs.  

 

The Patchwork of Public Healthcare

In a system with no universal coverage and high drug prices, government initiatives like Medicare and Medicaid play a vital role, offering an alternative to private insurance to more vulnerable populations. Established in 1965, Medicare provides health insurance for those aged 65 and older, while Medicaid caters to people with limited income; both are funded through taxes from employees and employers.

Medicare, comprising Part A (hospital insurance), Part B (medical insurance), Part C (advantage plans) and Part D (prescription drug coverage), cover most healthcare services, but not all, with the costs partially shared by the insured. This cost-sharing structure underscores the critical role of these programs, especially since there has been a steady increase in the share of Americans covered by Medicare and Medicaid (see chart below).

 

The increase in Medicare beneficiaries coincides with an ageing population, which is leading to exploding costs, projected in the following chart:

It is notable that in 2010, the Affordable Care Act (ACA) was the first major regulatory change to Medicare and Medicaid. The aim of the ACA was to expand coverage and was successful at eliminating some coverage gaps, although 8% of the population still remain uninsured. What’s more, these efforts, while critical in expanding access, came with substantial fiscal implications for the government: in 2021, Medicare spending comprised 13% of the federal budget and 21% of national healthcare spending.

 

Next Battle: Addressing Drug Prices

The next battle for improving the U.S. healthcare system involves tackling high drug prices. The Biden administration campaigned on a promise to lower the cost of prescription drugs and intends to make lowering healthcare costs a theme of the 2024 re-election campaign. This follows on its initial tackling of prescription drug prices in the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022. The act includes provisions to lower prescription drug costs for Medicare beneficiaries and to reduce federal drug spending. A notable aspect of this legislation is the cap on insulin costs at $35 per month for seniors on Medicare since January 2023.

Following this legislative change, Eli Lilly and Novo Nordisk – major producers of insulin - announced in early 2023 significant price reductions and expanded accessibility programs. Eli Lilly announced reducing prices for key insulin, impacting 10.5% of its U.S. revenue, and the expansion of its Insulin Value Program (that caps out-of-pocket costs at $35 per month). Novo Nordisk's price cuts, effective for several of their insulin products, will influence 59% of their insulin sales in the U.S. Despite these changes, advocacy groups like T1International demand further reductions, highlighting the significant gap between production costs and retail prices.

In a broader context, the IRA mandates the federal government to negotiate prices for select high-expenditure drugs covered under Medicare Part B and Part D, starting in 2026. This measure aims to put downward pressure on Part D premiums and out-of-pocket costs for Medicare beneficiaries. The program is projected to save $98.5 billion over ten years, although the pharmaceutical industry cautions that it might deter the development of new drugs,. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects that the impact of these provisions on the introduction of new drugs to the U.S. market will be very modest (i.e. a potential reduction of 1% over the next 30 years, which translates to about 13 fewer drugs out of an estimated 1,300 new drugs. In other words, the Act offers solutions to control costs while expanding coverage, without stifling pharmaceutical innovation.

The Medicare drug price negotiation process targets high-cost drugs, with the inaugural selection representing 20% of Part D costs, or $50.5 billion, from mid-2022 to mid-2023. These drugs are produced by major pharmaceutical companies, and often account for a significant share of their revenue (see table below).

Following the U.S. government's announcement about Medicare drug list for price negotiations at the end of August, AbbVie disclosed a $2.1 billion charge in anticipation of reduced revenue from its cancer drug Imbruvica. Six pharmaceutical manufacturers—Astellas Pharma, AstraZeneca, Boehringer Ingelheim, Bristol Myers Squibb, Johnson & Johnson and Merck—took the Biden administration to court in an attempt to block the negotiation program, but finally agreed in early October to negotiate drug prices with the government.

Pharma Under Pressure

Since the IRA was announced, the performance of U.S. big pharma stocks has lagged the broader S&P 500 Index. Removing the effect of the largest tech companies and using the equal-weight S&P 500 index (the latter corrects for the massive performance bias of the Magnificent 7) shows U.S. big pharma stocks have slightly outperformed. However, within U.S. big pharma, Eli Lilly has been the star performer, up 96% during the period, primarily due to the obesity drug craze (see note “You Can Have Your Cake and Eat it Too” from November 16, 2023). The rest of U.S. big pharma have underperformed by a substantial margin (as seen in the chart below). We believe that government regulation is hanging a dark cloud over the industry and is affecting industry performance, just another example of how fiscal policy and regulation influence market performance in the current era.

With only the initial phase of negotiations underway, there is potential for further impact on other major pharmaceutical companies in the subsequent rounds, with ultimately 60 drugs to be affected between 2026 and 2029. Of course, this is highly dependent on the outcome of the 2024 election; Republicans are not in favor of interventionist pricing.

The table below highlights the drugs (and the companies producing them) that represent the highest costs in Medicare Part D, as of 2021, which could potentially be implicated in future Medicare negotiations.

 

Overall, the IRA represents a serious government effort to address high prescription drug costs in the United States. While the Medicare drug price negotiations specifically target costs for government-funded healthcare, there is potential for a ripple effect that could lead to broader price reductions if negotiations set new benchmarks for drug pricing. This could have a meaningful impact on pharmaceutical companies.