Groundhog Day: Meme Fever Last Year, Meme Fever This Summer
In early 2021, financial market liquidity was plentiful and many investors bought the hype about a new epoch of investing. There were record new issuances in the stock market with the SPAC craze (see our note on February 4, 2021: “2021, A SPAC Odyssey”), and cryptocurrencies were going through the roof (see our note on June 24, 2021: “Cryptocurrency…”. Through all of this, a particularly interesting aspect of the market mania was the meme fever that saw financially-challenged companies’ stock price rise by gigantic percentages, supported by an army of retail investors looking to stick it to the system. The fever was at its peak in the first half of 2021. This summer, it came back as an echo with Bed Bath and Beyond, AMC and Gamestop. The echo now seems to be once again dying down.
Rise of the Planet of the Apes
Here is a quick description of how the fever proceeded: companies like Gamestop and AMC, that were negatively impacted by lockdowns, were heavily shorted by investors who believed these companies had dim prospects. With the growing popularity of online trading and new investors joining the market during the pandemic, cunning investors/promotors started to build a cult-like following online on platforms like Reddit and capitalized on the market structure weaknesses. They were armed with a message well-suited for their crowd: earn lottery ticket type gains by crushing the rich short-sellers that want to kill the beloved brands of our youth. In so doing, they were able to move the stock price of beaten-down companies sufficiently to start a cascade of events. As the price went up, short-sellers started to cover and buy, so the price increased further because there were new buyers and no sellers.
Being short a stock, there is limited upside as the maximum gain is if the share price goes to zero and unlimited downside as losses continue as the price goes higher. This means that when the price rises, an investor that is short sees the absolute size of his position grow as he loses, therefore, he has to cover much more quickly than when he owns shares. He is pro-cyclical on the upside; as the price rises, he buys more.
The new investors got more sophisticated by using call options. With call options, as the stock price moved higher, the market maker that sold the position had to buy more shares to hedge his risk, again, new buyers and no sellers. The options market for calls and puts on stocks is structured with market makers at banks showing a bid and offer price for those calls and puts. The bank legally needs to manage its overall risk and will therefore manage its exposure to options through delta-hedging and more sophisticated techniques.
The combination of high short interest in relatively small stocks and pro-cyclical investors was the weakness in capital market structure that led to the meme stock fever: you have forced buyers with margin calls or regulatory requirements that are caught once the cascade starts in a self-reinforcing loop. “Apes Together Strong” taken from the movie “Rise of the Planet of the Apes” became a rallying cry for retail investors to maintain their positions and outduel the short sellers. T-shirts, stickers and all kinds of merchandise were created based on the motto. Everything was in place for fireworks.
Below is a timeline of Gamestop, the original meme stock, from the beginning of 2021. The price is still much higher than in January 2021 even if the company’s prospects remain poor. The actions taken by the company look very cosmetic (share issuance, experimental blockchain, stock split) and do not warrant such excitement.
Dawn of the Planet of the Apes
As stock prices of Gamestop and others increased by multiples in a short period and the hedge fund Melvin Capital was caught, the frenzy attracted more people. It became “cool” to be part of Wallstreetbets with its own slang language: “JPOW will make you tendies because stonks are going to the moon” meant that Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell (JPOW)” will make you profit (Tendies) because stocks (Stonks) are going much higher (To the Moon).
So what is the link between meme stocks and sustainability? To be sure, any investor, whether professional or aspiring, can invest in capital markets as they see fit so long as they follow the law. However, there are major issues with many of the practices that were undertaken by powerful influencers. For capital markets to be effective in allocating capital where it is needed most, strong governance practices must be enforced and adhered to. Indeed, alongside having powerful “cult promotors” a common element to the majority of meme stocks is that the underlying companies all have very poor governance practices and records.
Ryan Cohen who is Chairman of Gamestop and was a large holder of Bed Bath and Beyond and Adam Aron who is the President of AMC are promotional and situational marketers looking out for themselves. They are taking advantage of the system in ways that may not be illegal but certainly look unethical.
The table below shows some of the questionable governance actions that were taken since the start of meme fever.
Below is a timeline of AMC, the most aggressive corporate organization behind a meme stock. The price is currently higher than at the beginning of 2021 and similar to Gamestop, the actions taken are cosmetic (shady share issuance to Mudrick Capital, more share issuance, attempt to issue more shares, mine purchase, convoluted special dividend).
War of the Planet of the Apes
Below is a timeline of Bed, Bath and Beyond, the most active participant in the recent echo boom for meme stock, since the beginning of 2021. In this case, the price is lower than in January 2021 as the company’s prospects are even more dire. The recent actions taken by Ryan Cohen look like a pump and dump scheme and we would be surprised if the SEC does not launch an official investigation.
Finally, below is a table of the largest holders of AMC, Bed Bath and Beyond and Gamestop as of June 30, 2022. We can see that index fund providers like Blackrock, Vanguard and State Street are generally the largest holders because they invest mechanically in a stock if it is part of its index. It is more surprising to see discretionary investment firms participating in companies with such poor fundamentals. These investors know the weaknesses of the system better than most and they are probably taking advantage of it.
The winners of the meme stock fever (so far) are the promoters (Ryan Cohen, Adam Aron, etc.), the lucky investors that were invested before and those that understand the weaknesses of the system much better (Millennium, Citadel, Susquehanna, etc.).
The losers are those that were caught short like Melvin Capital who were too stubborn to cover their positions, also the individual investors that got caught up in the cult-following, believing they could win against the system in the long run by investing in zombie companies.
The new meme-derived slang language can also be applied to the more tragic aspects of the meme fever: “YOLO, so hold the line with your diamond hands until you are the bagholder” translates to: you only live once (YOLO), so keep your positions (Hold the Line) with infinite resolve (Diamond Hands) until you lose all of your money (bagholder).
Planet of the Apes Legacy
One of the lessons in this tale is to be critical of cult heroes: recent success does not guarantee future results and when these cult heroes lead you where it is too good to be true, you should worry. Another lesson on long-term investing from the father of value investing Benjamin Graham; in the short run, the market is like a voting machine--tallying up which firms are popular and unpopular. But in the long run, the market is like a weighing machine--assessing the substance of a company.
“ESG” has gotten a bad rap especially over the last year as many media outlets have focused on everything that isn’t working in the ESG industry. At SMS, we pride ourselves on taking a pragmatic approach to investment and research: in today’s note, we uphold the view that ESG has been an excellent tool for risk management; how the ESG and investor movement has effected real change on concrete, measurable corporate operations; and why ESG is ripe to become a popular (and potentially successful) “active” investment strategy. “ESG” is not a cure-all, but when done properly, it can influence and amplify social and environmental trends that are important to the broader world, as well as generate superior returns.
ESG: A Proven, Successful Investment Risk Management Tool
Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) – the term used to identify matters associated with corporate responsibility beyond generating financial profit (extra-financial items) – has been an excellent tool for businesses (and investors who take ownership stakes in them) to safeguard themselves from future risks. The clearest demonstration of this is through the lower cost of financing that is accorded to businesses with strong ESG records. Study after study concludes that the cost of financing is cheaper for firms with strong ESG records (see chart below). To be sure, a size bias sometimes overstates this impact (large companies tend to access cheaper funding and also tend to have strong ESG records) but it is not hard to understand why lenders view ESG leaders in a better light: businesses that demonstrate they are at lower risk from controversies, whether it be environmental accidents, or fraudulent financial activity are viewed as more creditworthy by lenders than those that don’t. For investors, the corollary is simple: businesses that have access to cheaper capital, all else equal, offer better risk/reward than investments with higher funding costs.
The overwhelming number of publicly-traded companies that publish sustainability reports is testament to this fact; it is no doubt cheaper to dedicate financial resources to showing transparency about ESG topics than to pay higher borrowing costs.
ESG naysayers will rightly point out: there is a monumental difference between reporting on sustainability and being sustainable and that ESG data can be of poor quality and is fallible. These critiques are true. Few ratings of any kind are ever perfect - one only needs to look back to the rating agencies’ view of U.S. residential mortgage debt in 2008 for a reminder – but imperfect scores have nonetheless yielded results. As the section below demonstrates, the act of reporting on sustainability - and the imperfect ESG ranking of companies has led to corporate change.
ESG: Real World Results
Plenty of corporate behaviours and practices have shifted in recent years. It is impossible to prove causality, but the link between increased, quality sustainability reporting and several changes in corporate behavior is nonetheless present. Although it has been over a decade now that the majority of large and mega-cap (i.e. the world’s 250 largest companies by revenue) produce sustainability reports, it is only very recent that the quality of reporting has improved. What is quality reporting? It is materiality reporting. Materiality refers to an organization's significant economic, environmental and social impacts and risks.
SASB is the gold standard on materiality reporting and as the chart below shows, despite a flourishing ESG reporting trade for the past decade, SASB reporting has only accelerated in the past three years.
This has corresponded to change in several issues that are widely considered to be urgent (i.e. material) environmental and societal issues.
A first example is the role of women in decision-making roles. The increased attention attributed to issues like #Metoo, working conditions in “pink collar” jobs during the pandemic, and the repeal of U.S. abortion laws mean that companies and investors are increasingly exposed to reputational risk if they cannot show improvement on gender issues. Although women continue to make up a paltry minority of senior corporate roles, the rate of change has accelerated markedly in the past three years, which has coincided with the number of businesses reporting gender diversity – or the lack of thereof - as a “material” risk.
A second example is the use of voluntary carbon offsets. As the chart below shows, the voluntary carbon offset market has exploded higher in the past two years, at exactly the same time that businesses are feeling pressure to react to the very material risk that climate change has on their operations. While the voluntary market is extremely imperfect and there is most certainly some greenwashing at play, the development of voluntary carbon offsets is an important step toward internalizing the costs of greenhouse gas emissions, especially for industries where emission regulation is weak or absent.
Similarly, net zero pledges have existed for quite some time and by some estimates, now cover 80% of world GDP. However, it has been far too easy to commit to a vague plan about something far in the future, such as what was done by several countries and oil companies in the past years. Fortunately, along with the materiality of climate change on corporations, the number of independently verified, science-backed targets, has had unprecedented growth in the past two years (see chart below).
The bottom line is that investors who may have initially been keen to see companies publish ESG reports to better analyze, gauge and quantify risks, have no doubt participated in spurring companies to take steps on materially important ESG issues!
From ESG to ESG Investing: A “Passive” Fail but a Massive “Active” Opportunity
In as much as the track record for ESG as a risk management tool and as a force for corporate behavior change has been a success, the same case cannot be made for ESG investing (yet). There is burgeoning evidence that although overall ESG scoring does not correlate consistently with stock performance, firms with good ratings on material sustainability issues do significantly outperform companies with poor ratings on material issues. And in contrast, firms with good ratings on immaterial sustainability issues do not significantly outperform firms with poor ratings on the same issues.
Still, we stand by our conclusions from our February report (“Authentic ESG Funds: Looking for the (Tracking) Error”, February 10, 2022): the bulk of ESG funds are passively managed, and more often reflect growth funds masquerading as low-carbon.
Indeed, the chart below shows the performance of ESG-aware passive investments. In rising oil price environments, ESG-aware ETFs underperform their benchmarks and in declining oil price environments, they outperform. Over long periods of time, net of management fees, ESG ETFs have generally underperformed, or in the best of cases, tied the broader benchmarks.
To us, this makes sense and we agree with others that point out that ESG investors that pursue a strategy of divestment (or passive investment with exclusions) should not be surprised by potentially lower financial returns because they’re constraining their universe. In other words, if diversification is good for portfolios over the long run, then by excluding certain types of stocks with particular properties, a passive ESG investor is reducing the ability to diversify, and therefore, should expect lower returns.
But let us be clear, it is not because passive investing in ESG has under-delivered that ESG investing can not be successful. We believe that active investing in select ESG themes will be successful for precisely the same reason that materiality reporting has affected corporate change: financial markets are a reflection of (and sometimes influence on) societal themes that unfold.
Share prices assist in the efficient allocation of capital, helping to steer savings toward the most promising investments; when investors allocate to a particular theme, they are taking an active stance on an anticipated change in the world.
One of the major critiques of ESG investing is that it lacks precise goals and it is difficult to measure since the number of objectives is almost infinite and varies from one company to the next. But active ESG investors, i.e. those that do not simply subtract the companies they don’t like, are in fact actively pursuing particular themes that align with - or reside within - broad ESG goals.
A Tale of Three Sustainability-Minded Investors
Take three different investors. The first - The Divestor - purchases an ESG-aware fund that reports low carbon emissions. The second - Passive Clean Investor - has more conviction in the energy transition theme and therefore invests in a (passive) clean energy ETF. The third - Active Transition Investor - recognizing the importance of the energy transition thematic, but also cognitive of the broader macro landscape, devises an active energy transition strategy.
The Divestor does particularly well when energy prices are in a bear market but underperforms when oil prices rise. This is because there are not enough “green” energy transition companies in the broad index to compensate for outsized positive contribution of dirty fossil fuel producers when oil prices rise. The Divestor may post returns in some macroeconomic environments but is unlikely to do well over an entire business/financial cycle.
Similarly, Passive Clean Investor has an even more constrained universe to choose from (companies with low carbon footprints and that produce energy) and is even more beholden to the economic and financial cycle: non-fossil fuel energy companies typically have similar characteristics in that they tend to be technology-centric and therefore extremely long duration assets with high P/Es. Under the right conditions, such as low interest rates and strong economic growth, the Passive Clean Investor’s high conviction views of the energy transition will be rewarded, but under other macro backdrops the strategy will struggle to outperform.
Finally, the Active Transition Investor understands that the energy transition will occur, albeit its trajectory will be highly dependent on the macroeconomic and geopolitical backdrop. The Active Transition Investor overweights her portfolio to cleantech companies when rates are low, but dials back this exposure in favor of “boring”, lower P/E names that are early in the energy supply chain (like cable providers to the electricity grid industry) when recession fears strike. The Active Transition Investor may also dabble in renewable natural gas stocks or nuclear solutions when necessary, knowing that intermediate solutions are urgently needed to fill the gap left from coal and tar sands before renewable solutions can entirely take over. Active Transition Investor, in fact, may sometimes look indistinguishable from a macro hedge fund investor in that she seeks to deliver returns based on market developments caused by political or economic events.
When a 2018 Supreme Court ruling reversed the decision to outlaw sports gambling in the U.S., state governments and sports leagues saw dollar signs. State governments saw an easy path to higher tax revenues. Sports leagues backtracked on a long-held stance that sports betting was bad for the integrity of the game and made sponsorship deals with gambling companies in hopes of reaching new levels of engagement in their respective sports. As of the beginning of 2022, thirty states have legalized betting and numerous sports teams have inked advertising deals. This has led to strong growth in the betting industry, but at what cost?
Why Gambling is Currently a Growing Industry
The history of gambling in the United States goes back to the first settlers in the colonies. Periods of greater acceptance are generally followed by retrenchment under moral grounds. We are currently in a phase of acceptance. Right now, the winners (casino operators and taxing authorities) promote their effect on local job creation with success while the losers (gamblers with impulse issues and their families) are not visible.
The graph below shows the growth in revenues for the U.S. sports gambling industry and tax authorities since the Supreme Court ruling. As more states allow sports gambling, revenues are growing fast and collected taxes are following.
California is set to vote on legalization of sports betting in November 2022. Following that, Texas is the next big target. Those two states are among the last growth opportunities. The road may be narrower with more competition for entertainment dollars following the end of lockdowns.
The graph below highlights the evolution of the monthly wagers in the United States as a whole since 2018. With more new states legalizing sports gambling, the amounts placed have definitely been on an uptrend.
Socio-economic Problems of Gambling
As the U.S. ramps up its gambling activities, the UK is cracking down. Sports gambling was already legal in the UK when betting opportunities began to be available on smart phone apps. Through this head start, Britain has already started to see the consequences of easier access to sports betting. Online casinos make most of their money with a small percentage of their gamblers. Over the last 20 years in the UK, problem gambling has been measured to affect 1 out of 200 gamblers and 7% of adults are negatively impacted by their own gambling or those of a family member. One UK study shows that online gambling losses are very skewed towards deprived areas. The industry typically praises upon the poor, many with mental health and self-esteem issues. After all, gambling is a zero-sum game, it does not improve productivity. For the gamblers, it is a negative-sum game because of operational fees, taxes and profits of the service provider (gambling app/casino).
It is one thing to allow gambling, but relentlessly promoting it is another. The same complacency does not apply to other addictions prone industries like alcohol and tobacco, which have heavily regulated advertising. The UK has started to address this issue with restrictions on the timing and amount of gambling ads. In 2018, fearing a stronger crackdown, gambling companies voluntarily agreed to a ‘whistle-to-whistle’ ban on advertising. In April of this year, new rules were approved to limit marketing tactics appealing to younger demographics. Additionally, a white paper to be presented at British Parliament could see the removal of betting sponsorship of Premier League teams. While it is early days in the U.S.’s relationship with sports betting and sponsorship, one should anticipate that regulation is coming.
Evolution of Gambling Culture
While legal changes triggered the sports betting boom, it was further amplified by the mood during pandemic lockdowns. There are some surprising examples highlighting the desire to bet for the sake of betting: a pause on major sports leagues resulted in a boon for Russian table tennis; and just this year, Russian gamblers were duped out of their money by wagering on fake cricket matches staged by inhabitants of an Indian village. These behaviors are consistent with the big bump in risk taking or gambling culture across society, over the last couple of years. People have become mesmerized by the possibility of short-term, one-off gains. Gamification of the world went feverish in 2021 when people were looking for anything after the novelty of lockdowns waned: crypto-trading platforms proliferated and Robinhood created a gaming-like experience for small investors. The problem is exacerbated as “players” are pushed by relentless promotion, easy access, the cashless effect and algorithms that know exactly when to prompt to keep someone engaged.
Instant access to everything gets us to only tune in for immediate outcomes. But, in order to reach long-term goals such as improving health care, education and incomes; short-term thinking will fail. Our proximity to planetary boundaries leading to global warming and the current timid response by society is a clear example of this short-termism. The rise of online gambling is an example of an unproductive use of capital.
As the graph below shows, sports betting in the traditional markets of Nevada and New Jersey (where it has been legal since 2018) have not seen a dip in the amount of gambling activity, even with the explosion of betting in new legalized states. This new activity is not coming from gamblers switching from betting in the previous legal states or switching from illegal betting with bookies; it is coming from new gamblers. Timing suggests stymie cheques and lockdowns have also contributed to the rise.
When interest rates were at zero, and stimulus cheques from governments were the norm, this type of zealous behavior was to be expected. However, with recent inflation, the easy money times are coming to an end, as governments and central banks look to tighten their purse. The invisible hand will likely redress the excesses and the gambling culture should erode with time.
Why Most Will Fail?
If we look globally, Asia is a tough market because China is closed off. Europe is a mature market where the excitement has peaked and regulations are being introduced. For now, North America is the wild west as sports betting is becoming legal in most states. The immediate tax revenues and the lack of regulation gives some temporary leeway in this market.
Gambling companies are playing the market capture game with profits far away. As the hype for new entrants peaked in 2021, along with other craziness like SPACS and Crypto fever, the business strategy of PENN and DKNG has not changed much: they are looking to acquire new clients with incentives. We expect consolidations in the industry once high client acquisition costs are recognized and enough pain has been endured. The chart below highlights the share price of the top 4 public online gambling companies in the United States over the last 30 months. Euphoria has been followed by pain, we expect to see some more pain in the future.
Testing Good Governance Reliability
There is a lot of attention and media coverage on better governance practices, but accounting scandals and outrageous executive compensation still make headlines. Does greater board independence and diversity lead to better financial performance and/or less controversies?
Studies have failed to find a link between board independence and performance. We tackled the subject in a previous note (“Why Warren Buffet isn’t a big fan of ESG”, May 16, 2019), and even showed negative correlations between board independence and returns, and good governance and returns.
In another note on gender diversity (“Gender Diversity: What’s the Data Telling Us”, August 8, 2019), we found no link between performance and gender diversity, at that point in time.
In this note, we looked again, 3 years later, to see if good governance leads to fewer controversies and/or to better returns.
For our first test, we took information for 3,000 developed market companies. Using Refinitiv Eikon, we analyzed five governance criteria and their effect on controversies. Our findings are presented in the table below:
The results are counterintuitive. Companies with recent accounting scandals had more independent board members, paid less non-audit fees, and had better transparency and governance scores than companies with no scandals. Only low independence of the audit committee seemed to have a negative impact on company controversies.
With the same sample of companies, we examined the returns over the last 5 years compared to 3 governance criteria: CSRHub transparency score and governance score as well as Refinitiv Eikon board independence. The results are shown in the charts below.
The results are again counterintuitive. Companies at the lowest percentile for transparency have generally delivered better returns than those that are more transparent.
In a similar fashion, companies at the higher end of the governance scale have lower performance than those with weaker governance. Maybe a strong bull market hides all sins.
For board independence, the results are inconclusive.
On the other hand, a study from MSCI from 2006 to 2019 showed that companies with the best governance scores performed better than companies with the worst governance scores as seen in the table below. The dataset and period of analysis are obviously different than our analysis above.

A Glimpse at Executive Compensation
As You Sow (a non-profit foundation chartered to promote corporate social responsibility through shareholder advocacy), publishes a report flagging the 100 most overpaid CEOs every year since 2015. In each report, they highlight the most highly-paid CEOs. Companies with overpaid CEOs have generated lower returns for shareholders than the average S&P 500 company, as shown in the graph below:
Translating Governance Concerns in Proxy Voting
As the esteem of sustainable investing as a capital allocation tool grows, proxy votes and company engagement are gaining importance for investors. Their main governance concerns can be found in how they vote their shares during general assemblies. The following table presents initial results for the 2022 proxy voting season:
Proxy Advisors Recommendations
The table below shows how ISS and Glass Lewis, two of the biggest proxy voting advisors in the world, typically advise their clients on votes related to governance for U.S. companies (these topics are relevant for other countries, but some recommendations can differ based on the country’s practices and laws).
Corporate Scandals
Codes of good governance and best practices were thrown into the spotlight following corporate and accounting scandals in the early 2000’s (such as Enron with the audit firm Arthur Anderson, WorldCom and Tyco). Staleness, entrenchment, and lack of oversight were key factors that led to these major corporate scandals. According to a study by Stewart Hamilton and Alicia Micklethwait, the most common reasons for scandals are ineffective boards, poor strategic decisions, poor acquisitions, and dominant CEOs. Greed, power hunger and the failure of internal controls were also important.
When we examine today’s corporate landscape, we find examples of recent common governance issues. They are provided in the table below.
Impact on Company Behavior
Boards: Votes are favoring better diversity and greater care of environmental and social issues. Proxy voting advisors are recommending minimum gender and racial diversity as well as tending to support greater independence and a split of the CEO and Chairman positions. When it comes to CEO/Chairman duality, the jury is still out as a combined role allows for quick decision-making but it may hinder the board’s ability to properly counterbalance executive management.
Meta Platforms is one example where the separation of the CEO and Chairman positions could help. By creating different classes of shares with different voting power, Mark Zuckerberg, CEO and Chairman of the company, has retained operational control while selling shares. The move to change Facebook from a social media company to a metaverse company was his decision. Another example is Michael Saylor, CEO and Chairman of MicroStrategy, who also owns 68% of the company, making him fully responsible for the risky leveraged play on Bitcoin the technology company has made.
Directors: Investors are voting against directors slightly more often than in the past and they are putting greater scrutiny on directors that are on too many boards or when there is a lack of diversity on a board.
Softbank and its founder, CEO, Chairman and shareholder (with 21% of shares) Masayoshi Son have invested over US$84 billion in start-ups between 2017 and 2021, with decisions made on “feeling the force”, that lacked transparency. The company has been part of several scandals through its investments (such as Wirecard). Activist hedge fund Elliott Management tried to improve governance at Softbank in 2019 and appointed a woman on the board. Still, Kawamoto Yuko, the first female director, left after a year because her calls for more internal checks and more dissenting voices were not being heard.
Compensation: Aligning compensation with financial and sustainability metrics is gaining. The approval rate on Say-on-Pay votes for executives is above 90%, relatively low levels of support are therefore concerning. We believe that excessive compensation for the leaders of an organization and directors is a major problem and proxy voting advisors are examining compensation packages in more detail, suggesting to vote against them more frequently.
Companies that keep increasing the pay of its executives while facing financial concerns generally cause a stir with investors. AMC Entertainment’s US$19 million CEO pay, was awarded by a compensation committee with low independence (only 40% of its members are independent according to the company). This grant occurred while the company’s stock had fallen by 57% over the previous year. Fortunately, it was rejected by a majority of shareholders at the June 2022 annual general meeting.
Food for Thought
Requirements for board independence are sometimes scorned as the link to better performance is unclear. Moreover, as Warren Buffet flagged: independent directors are not so independent because of the compensation they receive; they are often tied to the company and its executives (through undisclosed relationships and other interests).
Current issues such as expectations for shareholder engagement, cybersecurity threats, disruptive technologies, climate change, human capital management, and company culture require a new skillset that can be achieved through board renewal with more diverse professional backgrounds, skills, and experience. Board refreshment should be more about skills than independence. For example, the actress Emma Watson, who is on Kering’s board since 2020, has the attributes of the perfect director: she is a young and socially engaged female with sustainability credentials. The problem is that she only participated in 18% of the board meetings and missed the sustainability committee meeting in 2021 for which she is still the chairwoman. There is a need for directors with new and relevant skills like Emma Watson. They need to have more spare time and be selected for their skills, not their fame.
Central bankers in developed economies have finally woken up to the reality of high and sticky inflation. The Federal Reserve is leading the charge to quell inflation, while the Swiss National Bank and the European Central Bank are projecting an exit from negative interest rates. The Bank of Japan remains on its own course by keeping its yield curve control.
Until May, higher interest rates were mainly affecting high-growth companies but, since then, higher financing and energy costs are slowing the economy and it is progressively being reflected across all sectors and financial markets.
At the end of the first quarter, we published our revised outlook for the year (ESG Meets Macro Shifts: The Outlook for Q2 and Beyond). In today’s note, we are updating our calls, as summarized in the tables at the end of the note.
We see four key developments that will drive equity movements for the next twelve months.
1. Higher interest rates slowing the economy.
After qualifying it as transitory in 2021, central banks are doing their best to regain control of inflation by increasing their overnight rate and projecting future increases along with quantitative tightening. As a result, interest rates of all maturities have risen fast in 2022. Higher interest rates act with a lag on the economy but their impact has been immediately felt on housing and auto sales, sectors heavily dependent on financing.
We still believe that the inflation genie is out of the bottle and that it will average closer to 4% than 2% over the next decade. Contrary to the previous 20 years, higher prices are animating public discourse and the recent increases are shaping consumer behaviour. The record profit margins observed in recent years are under pressure; producer price indices are growing much faster than consumer price indices as can be seen from the graph below. These circumstances generally lead to lower profit margins that pressure companies to slow down new expenses.
In a slowing economy, defensive sectors that have low variability in revenues and earnings like health care and consumer staples tend to shine compared to other segments of the equity market. As financial markets reflect a greater probability of recession, we favor the low growth portion of the graphic below.
Health care has performed exceptionally well in previous bear markets, not just the pandemic-related bear market. In our note of June 2, 2022, “High Impact: Surviving a Recession with Care”, we included the chart below that shows the performance of the health care sector during the previous four bear markets; positive performance in all cases.
2. Stubborn cost pressures from commodities and other factors
The previous decade saw commodity prices fall. Exploration investments followed in the same direction and, as is typical for commodities after such a period, we find ourselves in an uncomfortable supply and demand position where forecasted demand outstrips projected supply. The transformation of industrial processes towards a greener world will also contribute to commodity demand, especially for transition commodities.
Even though a recession may be near, we expect commodity prices to remain elevated. They may fall as we experience a slowdown but any sign of recovery will soon reflect underlying supply issues. Moreover, the relative isolation of Russia from the global economy will continue to menace supply.
Higher commodity prices, continuing supply shocks for goods and tighter labour markets with the retirement of baby-boomers will continue to exert input cost pressures on companies. In our note on May 12, 2022, “Inflation Protecting your ESG Equity Portfolio”, we examined companies that have shown the ability to increase profit margins in a rising cost environment. The table below shows the ESG leaders able to do so.
3. Return on Capital ≤Cost of Capital
The financial system starts to have hiccups when the expected return on capital falls below the cost of capital. Over the last quarter century, we witnessed such an event during the bear market of 2000-2003 for a portion of the economy: high growth companies that could not meet excessive growth expectations. Central banks came to the rescue with interest rate cuts that reduced the cost of capital and re-established confidence that the return on capital of the economy was greater than the cost of capital. We lived through a more dangerous episode from 2007-2009 that started with real estate but propagated to the financial system and the rest of the economy. In this case, a combination of interest rate cuts and asset purchases from central banks and fiscal stimulus to recapitalize the banking system were necessary to re-establish confidence.
The current financial situation has more similarities with the 2000-2003 period where growth expectations for a portion of the economy are unlikely to be met. The banking system is not currently under pressure. The risk lies to the cost of capital part of the equation because, contrary to the previous episodes, inflation is out of control and it is unknown if central banks will have the ability to reduce the cost of capital once the expected return on capital falls below the cost of capital.
Under these circumstances, growth companies should continue to underperform value companies and most forms of private equity (venture capital, growth equity and leveraged buy-outs) should experience much tougher times than the benign conditions of the past decade.
4. Unsustainable Business Model Crash
With financial markets dropping precipitously so far in 2022, business models that rely on cheap access to capital to fund their operations and/or stock options to retain employees as in our note from February 17, 2022, “Buying the dream – Tech Sector stock options at a time of high volatility” are at risk. The graph below shows a list of companies that have aggressive option compensation practices.
Similar to 2000-2003 when the dotcom bubble imploded and financing became more complicated, we expect the situation for companies with financing needs and aggressive compensation approaches to deteriorate further.
The growing dependence on digital records and systems is making organizations increasingly susceptible to cyber attacks. Consequently, the handling of personal data is facing greater scrutiny from the public. Cybersecurity service providers can help customers with both threat surveillance and data privacy. By helping to protect personal data, mitigate threats and discourage criminal ransom demands, the services provided by cybersecurity companies provide important social and governance benefits and are included in Sustainable Market Strategies equity universe under the Productivity with Purpose theme (see note, “Productivity with Purpose” November 11, 2021).
Cybersecurity companies may seem like a great investment opportunity following the recent drop, especially given that these are considered tech companies with superior potential for sustainable long-term growth. However, a look beyond the robust revenue growth expectations exposes a challenging backdrop for investors. Competition is fierce and valuations run high, with many of these companies operating at a loss despite their strong revenues.
The Battlefield
The pandemic accelerated the transition to a digital world. Over the past two years, entertainment, learning, shopping and even the office went virtual. While these trends may slow, they are unlikely to reverse. This rapid digital expansion with increasing interconnectedness created ample opportunity for attackers who aim to make money from ransom payouts or gain access to valuable information. As online presence rose during the pandemic, so did the number of attack attempts with malware and ransomware among the most common types of attacks. Malware is a “malicious software” designed to disrupt a system or gain unauthorized access. Ransomware is a type of malware that holds a system or data hostage in demand for a ransom sum. Deep Instinct’s bi-annual cyber threat report showed a 358% increase in attack attempts through malware and 435% increase in attempts using ransomware in 2020 versus the previous year. In 2021, the overall number of attempted attacks increased another 125% relative to 2020. This is consistent with results from CyberEdge’s annual survey of IT security professionals; a record number of respondents believe a successful cyberattack is likely in the next 12 months.
The main takeaways from the Cyber Threat Landscape report stress the need for a strong defense. Supply chains are facing enough woes without cyberthreats, but they are an increasingly popular target. Companies would be smart to limit additional risks that could arise from security vulnerabilities. Working “in the cloud” is also here to stay and broadens access to entry points for attackers, requiring protection beyond a local network. Attackers are also getting faster, able to exploit a weakness within the same day it is disclosed: known as a zero-day threat. In addition, there is an anticipated higher threat level given the current geopolitical backdrop as Russia and China are known to be prevalent attackers. All of this reinforces the need for organizations to protect their digital assets and will lead to increased spending on cybersecurity.
Insider Threats
With strong projections for sustainable growth in the demand for cybersecurity, one can jump to the conclusion that there is a boon for cybersecurity companies. A closer look reveals otherwise. Competition for market share and talent, along with the significant investment in R&D required to keep pace with an ever-evolving landscape, make it challenging for these companies to turn a profit. Cybersecurity companies are in a battle not only against cyber threats, but also against their peers. Revenue growth has been strong but spending on sales and marketing and research and development account for a significant portion of revenues. Costs are further strained as the industry faces a labor shortage.
Reputation is of critical importance in this industry. A breach can have an outsized impact on market valuation, elevating the risk of loss as successful attacks are nearly impossible to foresee. However, cybersecurity companies do exhibit healthy gross profit margins. Though it is still too early to distinguish clear winners, investors should focus on companies that strike a balance between investments in sales and marketing and R&D, since insufficient investment in the latter can pose challenges as attackers’ tactics can change quickly in the cyberworld. Comparing price to sales ratios across companies can help put valuations in perspective. Moreover, given the intense competition for high-skilled labor, attention to company policies for employee engagement and retention are relevant metrics aligned with SASB materiality for the Software and IT Services industry. Companies performing well in these areas will have more staying power and a greater likelihood of beating their competitors. The table below provides a comparison of these indicators for the top 5 (i.e. Largest market cap) pure play cybersecurity companies.
This week’s U.S. CPI release for April underscores that inflationary pressures are not yet letting up and it is too early to expect a peak in global inflation. To be sure, monetary policymakers are now on the job – the Fed hiked the policy rate by 50 basis points last week and another 200 basis points are expected by the end of the year. Note that policymakers target price stability for consumers, but rising prices are wreaking havoc all throughout the supply chain. Moreover, distortions in prices for economic goods and services – and the policy reaction to them – have important consequences for investment returns both across and within asset classes. This is as true for ESG investments as it is for broader mandates. In today’s Note, we look for ESG investment opportunities that are well protected and/or can benefit from inflation.
Inflation and Asset Allocation
Most investors are familiar with the macroeconomic idea that specific asset classes perform better (or worse) depending on the economic growth and inflation backdrop. The diagram below is an update on the classic “asset allocation quadrants”; our version includes the ESG asset classes that we expect to perform well in each of the growth/inflation quadrants, alongside conventional asset classes. As per our previous research, we have been advocating for ESG investors to be positioned within the top and bottom right quadrant: transition metals, carbon prices, forestry and agriculture have been among our high conviction investment calls over the past six months. We expect to move further toward the bottom right as the year progresses: with China’s zero COVID policy still in place, energy prices becoming particularly taxing in Europe, and several central banks raising interest rates, our expectations are that growth momentum will slow further and eventually peak later this year.
Inflation and Equity Investors
Equities as an asset class tend to perform best in low, stable inflation backdrops and struggle to deliver returns in high (and uncertain) inflation periods. When inflation is rising, the discount rate applied to earnings also tends to be higher, and therefore stock valuations (i.e. the P/E ratio) are lower.
That said, the impact of inflation on earnings varies by economic sector and also by individual company. In high inflation environments, the ability to pass on higher input costs further down the supply chain (and eventually onto final consumers) can be an important distinguisher. Indeed, as the chart below shows, producers have been increasing their prices much faster than businesses that sell to consumers especially in the past two years: intermediate non-energy goods prices, as measured by the U.S. core producer price index, have surged far more than (core) consumer prices.
This is inevitably reflected in stock price returns. The table below shows the average S&P 500 stock price returns by sector. In general, sectors that are considered to be at the beginning of the supply chain (energy, materials) and companies that offer services that are non-discretionary (i.e. end users can not substitute away from them) tend to do better in high inflation environments. It is no coincidence that Sustainable Market Strategies has favoured carbon and ESG real estate plays such as forestry and agriculture.
What’s In It For ESG?
The exercise of finding companies with superior pricing power by screening for stable or rising margins can be done for the broad market. However, investors certainly do not need to sacrifice on ESG characteristics to achieve similar results. In other words, we do not see any reason why companies with strong sustainability characteristics would perform differently than sustainability laggards. In fact, to the extent that companies leading in ESG often have a reputational advantage, it may be the case that ESG/sustainable leaders have a better ability to maintain or increase margins relative to their peers. Moreover, as we wrote last year, several ESG factors are contributing to higher inflation (please see our Note, “Inflation is an ESG Phenomenon” November 25, 2021).
Regardless, we focus exclusively on investing in companies with strong, positive ESG characteristics. Therefore, our initial universe includes the winning companies that have surfaced in our historical notes, based on our six investable ESG themes. From this ESG universe, we then look for companies that have stable or rising profit margins over the past five quarters, i.e. while inflation has been increasing significantly. The table below highlights the top companies by sector from our ESG universe that have stable or rising profit margins. Note that although we expect that superior profit margins will be a positive distinguisher, some of the companies on our list have nonetheless struggled to deliver positive equity returns due to a variety of factors, including poor valuation starting points. We expect this trend will reverse in due course.
The opening months of 2022 have brought turbulence to financial markets that require agility for ESG investors, even those with long time horizons. Indeed, even before the vast majority of investors were caught off-guard by the events in Ukraine, a major shift in equity markets was already underway due to the looming turning point in the monetary policy cycle.
At the start of the year, we published our top investment ideas for 2022 (Investment Trends in 2022: Don’t Put Your ESG All in One Basket, January 6, 2022). In today’s Note, we reflect on what is working, what ideas require adjustment and how we believe investors should tilt their portfolios to ensure that their ESG investments remain aligned with the major macro forces. These views are summarized in the table at the end of the Note; the table will now be a regular feature of Insight notes, with the aim of providing a quick guide to SMS’ thematic positioning.
We see three key developments that will underpin equity movements for the foreseeable future.
1. Persistent global inflation as demand holds steady (for now) and supply remains constrained.
In our November Insight report (Inflation is an ESG Phenomenon, November 25, 2021), we articulated our view that “frequent and significant supply chain challenges will make relative price shocks commonplace, while a tight labor market means that initiatives to create better working conditions globally will act to raise the cost of labor (wage inflation).” This view is still in place and we continue to expect that a structurally tighter labor market will help strengthen employee bargaining power: annual wage cost growth in the EU is already approaching 3% and is over 5% in the U.S. Even when a recession occurs, it is unlikely that wage inflation will fall to previous cycle lows given the structural tightness in labor markets. As for pricing pressures due to supply chain hiccups, the war in Ukraine has solidified the likelihood that several key industries will grapple with high input costs for many months to come. While not strictly an ESG factor, the value of land and other finite resources has most certainly come into investor focus in the past several weeks.
Two of our favored long-term inflation plays that stem from our themes of protecting natural capital and the energy transition are overweight positions in transition metals and forestry. Both ideas have performed well since the beginning of the year, due to the rising inflation theme and revaluation of hard assets during wartime. Investors should beware of near-term pullbacks should a Russian ceasefire occur, but the long-term investment thesis of favoring “green” inflation hedges is still intact. Holmen, Svenska Cellulosa AB (SCA) CA, Umicore and Boliden are among our favored long-term investments in this space.
2. High and volatile oil prices will remain for the foreseeable future, eventually damaging economic activity, especially in Europe. A renewable and fossil fuel capex cycle is imminent.
Last week’s note outlined our views on the prospects for ESG investors in the energy sector. Suffice to say, we expect that both fossil fuel prices and alternative energy prices will remain elevated and volatile for some time; it will take several months (years) for investment to catch up to current energy demands. In the meantime, elevated oil prices will act like a tax on economic activity and suppress growth. The pressure will be most acute in Europe, given the region’s greater reliance on Russian oil and gas supply that is currently.
As a result of higher oil prices, we expect economic activity to cool in the second half of the year, with the euro area particularly at risk.
There are several investment implications. First, as we wrote last week, despite our bullish long-term stance on the price of carbon, the carbon market is unlikely to rebound forcefully in the months ahead and patience is required. Second, companies that rely on euro area demand risk underwhelming relative to those geared to the U.S., given headwinds from higher energy- in the euro area. Third, companies that are able to pass on the price of energy will be in a distinctly better position than those that cannot. Finally, a capex cycle in both renewable energies and fossil fuel is imminent.
ESG investors with fossil fuel exclusions risk underperforming broad benchmarks in the near term, but trying to pick ESG leaders vs. laggards within the traditional energy sector is risky business. We recommend that investors focus on renewable energy companies, including Cameco and Nextera Energy Partners and companies that provide services to alternative energy providers like Ameresco and Hannon Armstrong.
3. A turning point in the monetary policy cycle.
The inflation conditions described make it inevitable that policy rates around the world will rise. Indeed, after a rush of global accommodative policy to help deal with the economic effects of the pandemic, central banks now must focus on curbing inflation. Yesterday, the Fed raised interest rates by 25 bps, while the BoE will remain in hiking mode, and the ECB has also made plans to end its bond-buying programme earlier than previously expected.
Recent months have shown that ESG portfolios are equally exposed to shifts in the macro outlook as traditional portfolios. The overall economic backdrop is still mildly bullish for stocks, but as the cost of capital increases, stocks with high valuation multiples are most exposed to price declines/price stagnation; the rotation from growth stocks to value stocks is likely to continue.
Investors can still find good, sustainable, fairly valued companies across economic sectors, but given the current geopolitical cross-currents and lower risks outside of Europe, we recommend seeking plays within non-Russian commodity-producing countries like Canada, Australia and Latin America. Note that investors must be extremely selective in these countries, since buying the benchmark indices means buying tar sands, coal producers and other destructive environmental practices. Industrial companies focusing on environmental and energy efficiency solutions (see our note last week), as well as sustainable agriculture, are two areas that are ripe for further capital inflows. The latter – sustainable agriculture – is the subject of next week’s note, stay tuned.
The recent rout in tech stocks presents a timely opportunity to look at the sustainability of pay packages in this sector. A first consideration is that some tech companies—such as Meta Platforms—have seen their cost of revenue increase fivefold (when salaries and stock options are accounted for) while top-line revenue witnessed only a three-fold increase over the past five years. This tells us that increasingly, many pay packages in the sector will be scrutinized by top management as the financial sustainability of several stock options programs in the tech sector is currently being tested by the recent correction in tech stock prices.
Moreover, with labor shortages abounding and the harsh fight for talent at play, one could also expect that this industry will also become vulnerable to “brain drain”. This becomes especially salient when things don’t go as planned—like seeing your stock option plan go to zero—which could be the case if you were hired in 2020 and 2021. Indeed, if you were hired by Meta Platforms back in 2021—and now with the company’s stock price now back to where it was back in mid-2020—some recent hires will be tempted to “jump ship” in the coming months given the deceptive valuation of their stock option package. To this end, the prospect of 1) higher interest rates and 2) the scrappy equity markets of late does not bode well for those who are hoping to cash-in their options in the coming months.
It seems that employees in tech are accelerating the pace at which they are moving away from their current firms. A look at the December 2021 JOLTS report in the U.S. suggests that “quits” in the Information sector (which is part of the NAICS classification under the “Information sector” and includes tech and IT workers) are currently at their highest level since 2013 (barring the 2020 COVID-resignation crisis). This has occurred while stock prices in tech also reached their peak in early 2022.
Furthermore, supplemental pay in the information sector – i.e. the pay which comes above your normal salary – doubled as a percent of total compensation this past decade. With this in mind, employees that have become accustomed to generous bonus schemes may be disappointed in the coming months: given the recent drop in tech stock prices, it is plausible to expect that supplemental pay will become a less important part of total compensation in the sector—which could even result in diminishing total compensation in the near-term.
The challenge is that several tech companies certainly benefitted strongly from stock option-based remuneration packages these past few years. In fact, looking at the value of stock option packages provided annually to employees of the top 20 Nasdaq companies (by market cap), one sees that the value of these packages moved up at the same rate as the price of the overall index this past decade. In this context, it would be surprising to see the value of these packages be maintained in the coming months as financial conditions will likely continue to pull back multiples in the tech sector.
Finally, companies which appear the most vulnerable to the above-mentioned “brain drain” are those firms which display an outsized stock options plan compared to their financial ability to pay for them. This seems especially true for companies such as Netflix and Facebook; last year they allocated between 95 and 160 percent of their free cash flow in stock options to their employees amid a YTD return of their stock price of roughly -30 percent.
Investors that have looked to buy ESG investment products with the goal of adding or subtracting specific non-financial characteristics from their portfolio in recent years would have been right to be sceptical. Many of the most well-known ESG products break several rules of basic investing and don’t live up to their hype. In today’s note, we address the current weaknesses of many ESG funds, what needs to be done to correct this, and offer investors some possible solutions to ensure that ESG dollars are put to work most effectively.
For our analysis, we collect data from the approximately 42 U.S. listed ETFs that focus on ESG equities. Total assets under management (AUM) of these funds stands at $55.5b, with impressive inflows of $17.3b in 2021. Market concentration is quite high: the top 10 ESG ETFs by AUM have 92.4% of the assets and enjoyed 87.8% of 2021 flows.
Part A: The Issues
1: A Rose by Any Other Name…
A major criticism of many ESG funds is what is hiding behind the label. As the table below displays, out of the top 10 largest (market capitalization) holdings in the S&P 500, nine are featured in the top ten holdings of U.S. ESG funds. The exception is Home Depot, which is a regular in ESG funds and replaces Berkshire Hathaway in the overall S&P 500 index. In other words, the top ten holdings, representing nearly 30% of the standard investment benchmark, are the same companies that represent roughly 30% of most popular ESG funds. Similar results are also displayed for international funds in the second chart below – of the top ten holdings, only SAP is found in ESG funds and not in MSCI EAFE.
Given the huge overlap in the major holdings of the benchmark and ESG companies, it is not overly surprising that there is little air between the price performance of the S&P 500 and well-known ESG ETFs and funds (see the chart below).
Since not even the most fervent proponents of these funds would believe that the S&P500 qualifies as an ESG index, it is more likely that the rapidly increasing consensus is correct: most ESG funds are labelled as such simply due to a bare-minimum exclusion policy. By weeding out a few names with unsavory practices and/or higher carbon footprints, an ESG label can be applied. The chart below offers substantial evidence that this has been the case.
The S&P energy sector accounts for 2.3% of the overall S&P 500. In the past year, S&P500 ex-energy has underperformed the broad index due to the substantial price gains in oil prices over the same time frame. This behavior matches almost perfectly the performance of ESG funds over the past two years: just as S&P 500 ex-energy underperforms (outperforms) the broad index when oil prices rise (fall), ESG funds outperform the S&P 500 when oil prices sink and underperform when they rise.
Bottom line: there is negligible tracking error between many conventional ESG funds and their benchmarks. These products offer no discernable diversification or specific properties to investors.
2: Condemned to Have an Itching Palm?
If the results above are discouraging for investors that may buy ESG funds with the expectation that they are making a difference, the second issue at stake with many ESG products will perhaps dishearten them further. Using the same basket of U.S.-listed ESG ETFs, we find the average AUM-adjusted MER is 16.2 bps. This compares to just 3 bps for the cheapest S&P 500 Index ETF! Note that the same phenomenon exists in Europe: the average AUM adjusted MER is 17.4bps versus 7bps for the cheapest MSCI EAFE Index ETF.
Bottom line: Investors tend to pay two-to-three times the expense ratio to have 3 letters (ESG) added to the name of their holdings. Save for the letters, there is little else that justifies the management fees; investing in these products often amounts to overpaying for a generic basket.
Part B: Emerging Solutions
1. We Must Not Make a Scarecrow of the Law
Initially, the label ESG came about in part because there is a general belief that it would help investors recognize opportunities that can positively impact society and the environment. However, since there are many shades of green and impact is subjective, our analysis above shows how easy it is to be ESG, without actually shifting capital in a meaningful way.
In Europe, regulators are beginning to get out in front of this phenomenon, by putting in place the Sustainable Financial Disclosures Regulation (SFDR). The SFDR came into effect in March 2021 and is designed to help investors understand, compare, and monitor the sustainability characteristics of investment funds by standardizing sustainability disclosures. Although, there are only 10 months of data, it is already clear that this regulation has influenced the offering of investment products and have helped investors discriminate among them. The table below shows the most commonly held holdings in “Article 9” funds, i.e. funds that are held to the strictest level of environmental disclosure. Apart from Microsoft and Alphabet, there is no overlap between the top holdings of the S&P 500 and conventional ESG Funds.
Note that SFDR is meant to provide transparency on both environmental and social characteristics. However, the regulation has been particularly effective so far as it relates to the environment because EU taxonomy regulation has provided specific environmental criteria related to economic activities for investment purpose. A similar taxonomy for social issues is in development, but will not be enforced for at least two more years. Moreover, SFDR is a European regulation, and applies to only to European market players and non-European players that do business in Europe. Implementing SFDR and/or introducing similar legislation at a global level would no doubt go a long way to improving the labelling of ESG-related investment products.
2. He Thinks Too Much; Such Men Are Dangerous
A second necessary ingredient to improving the ESG investment product offering is increased volume from the unofficial arbiters. This is already at work; investigative journalists like Saijel Kishan and Cam Simpson at Bloomberg are helping to expose the incongruencies between the marketing of solutions and the actual positions of portfolios.
Just slapping the name ESG on a fund and excluding a few names from the universe of investments is unlikely to cut it in the future as more information becomes available and investors realize they are not getting their money’s worth.
Part C: Practical Advice for Investors Seeking True ESG
Given the emerging solutions outlined above, it is clear that there is no substitute for doing one’s homework. Investors that truly aim to invest in sustainability themes will find that using broad ESG ETFs as a short-cut is often expensive without necessarily arriving at the correct destination. Some ways to avoid the pitfalls of broad ESG ETFs include the following:
- Invest in Article 9 funds and/or replicate their holdings: as highlighted above, funds that adhere to Article 9 standards offer a much higher level of differentiation.
- Verify the top 10 Holdings: A quick scan of the top 10 holdings of ETF funds is an effective way to reject paying supplemental management fees should the holdings significantly overlap with standard equity benchmarks like the S&P 500.
- Understand the methodology: funds based solely on exclusion policies have a greater likelihood of resembling benchmarks with only minor tweaks.
- Consider active management, high-tracking errors, single-theme bespoke products: the only way to have different results is to do something different! ETFs that aim to tackle a single problem and/or theme will have a higher propensity to provide differentiation, although even here, many ETF providers stretch definitions to cast a wider net of investable companies. KRBN (carbon), LIFE (environment), are examples of ETFs with a high concentration of holdings that strongly reflect the desired properties suggested in their name.