You probably remember Miss Materiality from our December 2022 note: Miss Materiality’s Night Out: A Lesson in Consumer Choice and our August 2023 note: Miss Materiality’s Summer Vacation. She is back for a third year, this time, at the grocery store. In 2022, right after the pandemic, she just wanted to go out. Last year, she wanted to get away. This year, she is concerned about meeting her basic needs because the reality of higher and more volatile food prices is becoming a greater preoccupation for her.

Miss Materiality has become more cost-conscious this year and this is translating to how she spends on food she cooks at home.

On her list, she has the basics that are difficult to replace, things like olive oil, milk and sugar. She needs protein: salmon, eggs, tofu and some meat and she cannot live without coffee, orange juice, bananas and chocolate. Recent sticker shock for some of these items leaves her curious about the evolution of prices over the past five years.

As can be seen from the graph below, the overall cost of her basic foodstuffs has increased, with olive oil leading the way higher, albeit milk has reverted to pre-pandemic price levels.

 

Researching the salient points for each food item (see table below), Miss Materiality notices a common theme: the impact of the weather. Olive oil and sugar price inflation is the result of supply disruptions from droughts.

For proteins, the trend toward higher prices has been volatile and she was happy to see recent price drops after massive run-ups in basic ingredients like eggs.

Traditional supply and demand factors have been at play in proteins; except for eggs where the H5N1 disease created a shortage in 2023 that is still not completely resolved.

 

Miss Materiality noticed large price moves for the things she loves most. The cost of cocoa is a relatively small portion of the price of chocolate bars but with cocoa price shooting up in recent years, chocolate bars have followed suit with, higher prices per gram.

From a nutrients and calorie perspective, her other favorite snack, bananas, are cheaper than other fruits and have remained so for many years. Miss Materiality was wondering why and she found that bananas are produced in many countries. India, China and Indonesia are the top 3 producers but they have large populations to feed. The top exporters are in Latin America: Ecuador, Costa Rica, Colombia and Guatemala. Other reasons for the low prices of bananas are the fact they are picked green and ripen during their transportation, the trees are perennials and there is a strong global system for bananas. In other words, diverse geographic crop location and ease of transport makes bananas one crop that is relatively insulated from many of the major threats of global food supply disruption. That’s a good thing for Miss Materiality!

Just like for the basics, Miss Materiality realized that the weather played a significant role in the prices of indulgence items. For some of her other favorites like coffee and orange juice, weather and diseases – both directly linked to climate change – are creating episodic shortages that drive prices higher.

 

These price surges underscore that concentration of production is a major consideration in food supply chains. Theoretically, food items that are produced in only a few countries are at greater risk of supply disruption from the weather, local diseases or internal politics leading to export bans. In the chart below, Miss Materiality shows the share of global production of her grocery items by the top 5 and top 10 producing countries. She posits that those with the lowest concentration have a reduced risk of supply shortages. This is consistent with preceding charts, where the price of bananas and milk are the only prices that fell during the period (both have among the lowest concentration of production). Eggs are the exception to the assertion that low concentration reduces the risk of shortages which is explained by the effects of H5N1, a global disease.

 

Since Miss Materiality is doing as much as she can to adapt to higher food prices, she wonders if her investments could compensate for those higher costs. The map below shows the publicly-listed companies with strong sustainability practices that she could potentially invest in. For salmon, Mowi has strong sustainability practices and is a relatively low-cost producer. For soybeans which get transformed into tofu, House Group Food fits the bill. Adecoagro scores highly for a sugar producer, while JDE Peets is a positive standout for coffee and tea that is on pace to have 100% of its tea and coffee certified as responsible this year. For orange juice and olive oil, she did not find interesting candidates. For cocoa and meat, she cannot find attractive long candidates; she has a negative view on Mondelez, Tyson Foods and JBS. For eggs and bananas, she found four companies: Vital Farms, Cal Maine, Dole and Fresh Del Monte.

 

From an investment perspective, we agree with Miss Materiality that it is better to own low-cost producers in a concentrated industry where one can benefit from shortages. From that standpoint, MOWI, House Food Group, JDE Peets and Adecoagro are companies that are likely to benefit should a shortage occur in a related foodstuff. The chart below shows financial ratios for the companies mentioned above, with Cal-Maine and Adecoagro having the most attractive historical financial ratios. Miss Materiality is not surprised to see a company from an emerging market country, Adecoagro, in a concentrated industry with attractive financial ratios. Emerging markets have lagged developed markets over the last 15 years.

In terms of helping farmers and finding solutions that mitigate climate change risks with the view to stabilize prices, Miss Materiality found four leading irrigation companies with the greatest irrigation revenues as shown on the map below. Irrigation is key because droughts and excess heat can ravage crops. Miss Materiality could not believe that both, Valmont Industries and Lindsay Corporation are based in the home of Warren Buffett, Omaha, Nebraska.

Companies heavily involved in irrigation have comparable financial ratios, with the exception of Orbia Advance Corporation from Mexico, another company that operates in an emerging market. Note also that Orbia has a smaller exposure to irrigation compared to other companies in the chart. Beyond irrigation, Orbia is involved in other aspects of the chemical product industries.

 

Shareholder engagement, defined as various strategies investors can use to influence the operational practices of the companies they hold, plays a critical role in driving corporate accountability and sustainable practices. While research suggests no direct link between governance practices and financial returns (see our last note on the topic, “Governance, Are the Efforts All in Vain?”, July 21, 2022), these practices improve the corporate environment by reducing ineffective boards, fostering better decision-making, and curbing overly dominant CEOs. Institutional investors have an outsized influence on corporate governance action. According to Broadridge, in 2022, U.S. retail investors voted only 29% of the shares they owned whereas institutional investors voted 82% of theirs.

In this week’s note, we provide a preliminary analysis of the 2024 proxy voting season results, on compensation, directors’ elections and main trends in shareholder proposals, with a focus on North America.

Paychecks Under the Microscope

Top executive compensation is assessed by shareholders in a say-on-pay vote, a process where shareholders have a non-binding vote on the compensation of top executives, typically occurring annually during a company’s annual general meeting.

Proxy advisors provide research and recommendations on how shareholders should vote on various corporate governance issues, including executive compensation and director elections. Their objective is to guide institutional investors in making informed voting decisions that align with best practices and shareholder interests. The biggest proxy advisors in the world, Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) and Glass Lewis, significantly influence voting outcomes with negative recommendations leading to substantial declines in support on say-on-pay. For instance, a negative recommendation from ISS can lead to a 33% decrease in support for Say-on-Pay proposals, while Glass Lewis’s negative recommendations result in a 12% decline. This year, both advisors focused their decisions on issues such as non-rigorous performance goals, lack of transparency, and the use of discretion in bonus plans. These advisors’ compensation analyses scrutinize performance targets linked to remuneration rather than just looking at the total compensation figures, emphasizing the importance of aligning executive pay with company performance and long-term shareholder value.

A preliminary analysis of the 2024 proxy season on Say-on-Pay voting among S&P 500 and Russell 3000 companies shows higher rates of approval (over 50% votes for) and increased support compared to previous years. No company with a compensation proposition that failed in 2023 failed again in 2024, indicating satisfactory changes to last year’s failed proposals.

The table below highlights the increased support for executive compensation proposals among S&P 500 and Russell 3000 companies from FY 2023 to May 2024.

In corporate governance standards, a Say-on-pay support under the 70% threshold is often seen as a clear signal to the board that the current compensation plan may need reassessment. Low support levels can lead to increased scrutiny from investors and proxy advisors. Recent voting results show that these phenomena remain low, below 5%.

One compensation package that caused quite a stir this season was that of Tesla CEO Elon Musk. Back in January of this year, the Delaware Court struck down the $55 billion pay package for Tesla CEO Elon Musk proposed back in 2018. Even though the package was approved by 73% of unaffiliated Tesla shareholders at that time, the court found that Musk, as a controlling shareholder, had too much influence over the Board and that conflicts of interest were not fully disclosed. As a result, the court decided the package was unfair and rescinded it. Tesla decided to once again submit this package for shareholder approval at the 2024 AGM in June. Despite a campaign from the New York City Comptroller’s Office and other investors urging shareholders to reject Musk’s pay (one which significantly impacted discussions and was noted in reports by ISS and Glass Lewis), the proposal was approved by shareholders. And it came in addition to approval to change Tesla’s state of incorporation from Delaware to Texas.

The season highlights that transparent and performance-aligned executive compensation remains crucial for shareholder approval, underscoring the influential role of proxy advisors in guiding voting decisions.

Boardroom Battles

Support for director nominations remained high in the U.S. in 2024, with average support rising from 95.9% to 96.4%. The season saw significant impacts from the Universal Proxy Card (UPC) rule, which mandates the inclusion of all director nominees on a single ballot when there is a proxy fight and a shareholder want to elect other directors than proposed by the company. This change makes it easier for shareholders to vote across slates, referring to the lists of candidates nominated by different parties. Previously, shareholders had to choose between separate ballots for the company's and the dissident's candidates, but the new rule allows for a mix-and-match approach, simplifying the process and enhancing shareholder choice in proxy contests.

Notable proxy contests were seen this year at Crown Castle Inc. and The Walt Disney Company, where management achieved clean sweeps despite proxy advisor recommendations for some dissident nominees. Meanwhile, at Norfolk Southern Corporation three dissident nominees were elected.

Gildan’s case was the major event of the Canadian proxy season: in May 2024, Browning West, a California-based hedge fund manager, led a historic and successful proxy campaign at Gildan Activewear, resulting in the complete replacement of Gildan’s board and the reinstatement of co-founder Glenn Chamandy as CEO. This campaign was supported by unanimous recommendations from major proxy advisory firms and led to the resignation of Gildan’s entire board and CEO just days before the annual meeting. The full timeline can be found in the table below:

This year's proxy season demonstrates the importance of shareholder choice and robust governance practices, with the Universal Proxy Card rule enhancing the ability of shareholders to influence board composition effectively.

Shareholders’ Frontline

United States

In the 2024 proxy voting season, significant trends emerged regarding shareholder proposals. According to Ceres, a nonprofit organization advocating for sustainability leadership, there was a noticeable support for climate transition plans, particularly within the banking sector. This indicates growing investor demand for more detailed disclosures on how companies plan to mitigate and adapt to climate change. However, overall support for environmental proposals, which include a range of issues from biodiversity protection to sustainable resource use, declined, highlighting varying levels of investor interest in different aspects of environmental sustainability.

Diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) proposals faced increased scrutiny and declining support, reflecting a more critical view from investors​. This underscores the importance of carefully framing and justifying ESG initiatives to garner investor backing. According to the Groupe Investissement Responsable Inc. (GIR), a Canadian leading proxy advisor, among Fortune 250 companies, five shareholder proposals received majority votes. These proposals were predominantly governance-focused, including measures to adopt simple majority voting, the right to call a special meeting, and the repeal of rules enacted without shareholder approval. The GIR also mentions that shareholder proposals (excluding anti-ESG proposals) garnered an average support of 19.94%. The ten most frequently filed environmental and social (E&S) proposal categories are presented below:

Tech companies were heavily targeted, with fifteen shareholder proposals for Amazon, twelve for Alphabet, and eleven for Meta Platforms. The E&S proposals that received the highest support are presented in the next table, as highlighted by the GIR:

Canada

In Canada, the GIR highlighted notable shareholder proposals that received majority approval at BMO, CIBC, Air Transat, and Metro. These proposals advocate for in-person shareholder meetings supplemented by online options, reversing the trend of virtual meetings necessitated by the COVID-19 pandemic. The Movement for the Education and Defense of Shareholders (MEDAC), known for its advocacy efforts, particularly with major banks, saw relative success in support on its environmental proposals, reflecting a certain level of influence for its shareholder initiatives.

Key proposals that garnered substantial support in Canada are included in the table below:

Anti-ESG Shareholder Proposals

In the first five months of 2024, the number of anti-ESG proposals saw a significant increase. Despite this surge, they remain unpopular among investors, with average support declining slightly to 1.6%. The increased number of these proposals is partly driven by recent regulatory initiatives in some red states. However, their arguments have not gained traction with larger institutional investors. Overall, while anti-ESG factions are more vocal, their efforts have yet to translate into substantial support. According to GIR, anti-ESG proposals in Canada showed similar levels of support.

This season's proxy voting outcomes on shareholder proposals underscore the ongoing tension between pro- and anti-ESG perspectives within the investment community. While anti-ESG proposals continue to receive minimal support, the substantial backing for governance reforms suggests that investors prioritize strong governance structures, which they view as foundational to effectively addressing environmental and social issues. This indicates a nuanced stance where investors may support ESG initiatives, but with a particular emphasis on robust governance as a critical component of overall corporate responsibility.

This week saw yet more bad news for proponents of the famous Hydrogen Economy. One of the Biden administration’s flagship projects to derive energy from hydrogen, the $6bn Appalachian Regional Clean Hydrogen Hub (ARCH2), is in jeopardy due to unrealistic project economics and strong community opposition, as well as another minor obstacle: fundamental physics.

The demise of a variety of hydrogen projects is becoming increasingly common. There are example in the transportation, industrial, energy, and heating sectors.

In this week’s note, let’s bust some myths around the hydrogen economy.

 

How Did We Get Here?

The Climate Crisis is often described as a wicked problem which involves numerous interconnected factors, including economic, environmental, political, and social elements, with no straightforward solutions, and each intervention often leads to unforeseen consequences and trade-offs. So when a visibly simple solution is presented, like 'transitioning to the hydrogen economy,' people want to believe it and jump on the bandwagon.

These promises are then being amplified by powerful people with large audiences: politicians and Big Oil. For both groups, the idyllic image of a hydrogen economy allows them to delay any real and difficult transition decisions. By dangling this shiny catch-all technological solution that will solve (almost) all our climate problems, they can continue their business as usual: producing fossil fuels. And they are putting their money where their mouth is: fossil fuel companies rank among the top lobbying firms for hydrogen and outnumber companies from every other industry, including the renewable energy sector!

In fact, hydrogen lobbying efforts by all industries seriously took off with the inauguration of Joe Biden in 2021, in anticipation of a massive environmental Bill which the industry hoped would include generous subsidies for several technological solutions, including hydrogen. In August 2022, that Bill took form as the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) and indeed included the largest and most generous hydrogen subsidies in the world, known as the 45V credit for hydrogen. The lobbying efforts seems to have paid off as blue hydrogen, the kind that is produced by fossil fuels assisted by some CO2 capture technology, does qualify for the tax credit.

The situation in Europe is very similar. A 2023 study by LobbyFacts showed that more than €75 million a year is spent on lobbying efforts by the EU hydrogen promoters, among which the top players are Shell, ExxonMobil, Dow, BASF, TotalEnergies, Equinor, BP and Siemens Energy.

 

“It’s physics, stupid”

The fact that Oil & Gas majors are aggressively promoting a technology does not automatically disqualify it, although it should raise flags and call for more scrutiny. The main disqualification for hydrogen is much more clear-cut: thermodynamics.

Without going into the details of hydrogen’s physical properties, there are a few killer facts that demonstrate that betting the climate farm on the hydrogen economy is a dead end.

First things first: hydrogen is not an energy source. It’s an energy vector. Since hydrogen can’t be found – in sufficient quantities – in its natural form, it needs to be extracted from compounds like water (H2O) or hydrocarbons (e.g., methane, CH4). Producing hydrogen requires energy, typically through processes like electrolysis (the green-ish way, by splitting water using electricity which itself may or may not be green) or via steam methane reforming (SMR), the gray or black way, which involves reacting methane with steam (which emits a lot of CO2 as a by-product). In this sense, hydrogen serves as a medium to store, transport, and utilize the energy that originated from those primary sources.

How efficient is this whole process? Not very, unfortunately. When considering the entire hydrogen value chain – from production to end-use – the overall efficiency, expressed as the resulting energy as a share of initial energy input, is quite low. For example, starting with electricity from a renewable source to produce hydrogen via electrolysis (70% efficiency), then compress it for storage (90% efficiency), transport it (95% efficiency), and finally use it in a fuel cell (60% efficiency), the overall efficiency would be:

0.70 (electrolysis) * 0.90 (compression) * 0.95 (transport) * 0.60 (fuel cell) = 0.36 or 36%

This means that only 36% of the original energy input is converted into usable energy at the endpoint, with 64% lost along the way! Of course, the industry would like us to believe that they can improve these efficiencies with a few additional billions in subsidies, but if there is one thing that money can’t change, it is the Second Law of Thermodynamics (i.e. energy transformations are inherently irreversible and always generate some amount of waste heat, leading to inefficiencies).

 

“Ok, so the hydrogen space is uninvestible?”-  Not so fast…

There’s physics, and then there’s politics. The reality is that there is so much public money being poured on this issue that not every project will be kiboshed. It won’t be the first time, nor the last, that governments go ahead with the most expensive option possible to accomplish something. However, our expectation is that the vast majority of the hydrogen applications that are being discussed right now will not go ahead. For example, hydrogen as a transportation solution is a hard sell, even for trucks, trains and planes (biofuels make more sense for economics and logistical reasons). What about hydrogen as a heating source? Why would we use electricity to inefficiently convert it to hydrogen to inefficiently transport it to ultimately inefficiently re-convert it to an energy source? By cutting out the molecular middleman, one saves energy and capital. Other applications like energy storage face the same inefficiencies. Furthermore, competition with other energy storage technologies is strong (batteries, pumped hydro, and compressed air energy storage (CAES) are more efficient for large-scale energy storage and have established infrastructure).

From an investment perspective, this suggests that investors should stay away from unprofitable, unproven-at-commercial-scale, single-technology-dependent, narrow-focused hydrogen companies like Plug Power (PLUG US), FuelCell (FCEL US), Ballard Power Systems (BLDP CN), NEL ASA (NEL NO), Bloom Energy (BE US), and ITM Power Systems (ITM LN). For reference, these companies lost between 55% and 92% of their market capitalisation since Joe Biden took office, promising to make the hydrogen economy a reality.

The remaining opportunity for a sustainability-minded investor to play the hydrogen theme lies in the transition from dirty to clean hydrogen production. Global hydrogen production currently stands at around 100-125 million tonnes per year, with approximately 60% used in oil refining (hydrocracking and desulfurization), 30% in ammonia production (a key ingredient in fertilizers), and about 10% in methanol production (used as a feedstock for chemicals). Presently, almost all (99%) of this hydrogen is produced from fossil fuel sources—50% from natural gas, 20% from coal, 22% from oil, and only about 1% from electrolysis powered by clean electricity.

Only a handful of companies produce the vast majority of this hydrogen. First Principles Thinking suggests that market incumbents have competitive, technological, economic, and reputational advantages over the numerous narrow-focus start-ups that must fight an uphill battle to gain any market share. This advantage is due to the incumbents' established infrastructure, experience, and resources, which position them better to transition to cleaner hydrogen production methods.

The four major incumbents are Air Liquide SA (AI FP), Air Products and Chemicals Inc (APD US), and Linde PLC (LIN US) for the industrial segment, and Yara International ASA (YAR NO) for the fertilizer segment. Any of these companies would make a justifiable investment in the greening of hydrogen production, as they all have major projects underway. Moreover, despite being at the center of the green hydrogen theme, their valuations are very reasonable, with price-to-earnings ratios between 20 and 27 for the industrial names and 12 for Yara. These investment options make more economic and scientific sense compared to the small-cap, unprofitable names mentioned above.

Since its launch in November 2022, ChatGPT has become hugely popular and it’s no wonder: with an IQ of above 120 (placing it among the top 10% of humans), the generative AI tool can do things that many humans can’t.

But ChatGPT and the like are just a small sliver of what artificial intelligence can and will be able to do.

General purpose technology (GPT), which artificial intelligence is presumed to be, is defined as ‘a single generic technology, which initially has much scope for improvement and eventually comes to be widely used and to have many spillover effects. Examples of GPTs include electricity and the personal computer. In other words, a technology that is pervasive and significantly impacts aggregate productivity growth.

However, the pervasiveness and productivity growth associated with GPTs often take very long to develop. A popular example is electricity: the big impact of electricity came in the 1920s, about 40 years after Thomas Edison first distributed electrical power in New York in 1882.

The long lag time between invention and widespread application occurs because GPTs tend to entail major investments, learning costs, and complementary innovations. Often, the net benefits of the new technology itself are low early for the earliest adopters.

Prior to artificial intelligence, the most recent example of a GPT is the personal computer. The first desktop computers available for the mass market were introduced in the 1970s, but it took two decades before a significant share of households had adopted them. In 1993, still only 23% of American households owned a computer. The share of workers using computers in their jobs also grew relatively slowly before becoming ubiquitous in the 2000s.

This widespread adoption of computers was followed by an increase in U.S. productivity growth. Between 1991 and 2004, total factor productivity (TFP) grew 1% per year on average, almost twice as fast as its average growth rate in the 1980s (about 0.6%).

Like other GPTs, it is highly likely that artificial intelligence will spur a strong, sustained increase in productivity growth across whole economies that could last decades. Like past GPT related productivity booms, however, these advances could surprise by how long they take to be truly transformative.

An early indicator of enhanced penetration of AI into the overall economy should be the observation of a wave of increased capex, IT and training expense. This has clearly started, but remains timid in most areas.

Capex is currently significantly greater for Nasdaq listed (i.e. tech-focused) companies compared to indexes that reflect the broader economy, as shown in the chart below. This suggests that so far, much of the acceleration of IT spending has been fairly concentrated.

A sign of AI pervasiveness could be when the capex efforts of financials, health care or other sectors match levels in the IT space.

In the meantime, we examine what the overall effects (and roadblocks) of artificial intelligence might be beyond sheer productivity gains.

Artificial Intelligence Will Create More Jobs Than It Destroys

AI, like all new technologies, has been accompanied by a raft of concerns about how its usage will affect certain aspects of society. The first is that job automation will lead to significantly higher unemployment rates. In our view, this fear is widely exaggerated.

The periods of greatest unemployment tend to occur during economic recessions, typically brought on by financial crises and spikes in oil prices.

In fact, studies have shown that technology tends to create more jobs than it destroys. Deloitte has recently published a convincing set of charts across a number of industries where jobs were created/and destroyed over the past 140 years of innovation. No doubt the debate suffers from a common cognitive bias, loss aversion. Analysts tend to focus on the job-destroying effects of technological change (because they are more easily observed) rather than its creative aspects.

Moreover, there is already evidence that the impact of artificial intelligence on the job market is playing out exactly as described above: census bureau data of U.S. firms show that adoption of AI (and other technologies like robotics) so far varies substantially across industries, but is concentrated in larger firms. Adopters have higher labor productivity and greater demand for skilled labor, but the effects on overall employment levels at these firms were limited or ambiguous. This is also borne out by survey data, as highlighted in the chart below.

Importantly, while general purpose technologies prior to the personal computer most severely impacted “blue collar jobs”, it is most likely that service sector employment, such as IT and finance, will see their operations being the most impacted by AI in the coming years.

 

The bottom line is that there is no precedent that suggests the introduction of artificial intelligence will be different than past GPTs: job losses will occur - but will be offset by job growth in new sectors, This topline approach, however, does mask important weaknesses in the labor market, most notably income inequality.

Artificial intelligence Will Exacerbate Income Inequality

A more serious potential concern regarding AI adoption is a rise in socio-economic inequality.

There is a great deal of historical evidence to suggest that general purpose technologies have increased economic inequalities and there is potential – though not a foregone conclusion – that artificial intelligence will accentuate this trend.

Previous technological advances have been skill-biased, meaning that high-skill workers experienced wage gains due to productivity improvements while people in lower-skilled jobs, (i.e. more repetitive tasks), experienced both job losses and decreased real wages due to automation. It’s estimated that between 50% and 70% of changes in the U.S. wage structure (among the most flexible job markets in the world) over the past four decades are due to the relative wage declines of workers specializing in routine tasks in industries that experienced rapid automation.

This phenomenon, unsurprisingly, bears heavily on the financial outcomes of those with low levels of educational attainment. In the U.S., real earnings of individuals without a high-school degree are now 15% lower than they were in 1980, whereas real wages of workers with a post-graduate degree rose significantly.

The next phase of technological innovation is no different. In the words of technologist and investor Kai-Fu Lee, “corporate profits will explode, showering wealth on the elite executives and engineers lucky enough to get in on the action….”.

The remedy to income inequality stemming from general purpose technologies is already known and well documented. It requires a redistribution of wealth via taxation and assurance of a social safety net that includes access to quality health care and education. Differences in Gini coefficients among the most technologically advanced countries underscores that the tendency toward technologically-induced income inequality can be counteracted through policy. In this sense, although it is a foregone conclusion that increasing automation means greater dispersion in the price of labor according to skill, it is not inevitable that artificial intelligence will lead to greater social inequalities.

Contrary to income inequality within nations, income inequality between countries has been falling in recent decades as faster-growing emerging economies like China and India have narrowed the income gap with advanced economies. This trend is in danger of reversing, given that AI is developing in a monopolistic fashion that risks concentrating economic power within a handful of actors.

Left Unchecked, Artificial Intelligence Will Concentrate Economic Power Even More

A common tendency among general purpose technologies is that they tend to create monopolies. Anti-trust laws exist and are enforced to prevent customers from punitively high prices and to ensure that economic power does not translate into egregious political power (witness the U.S. oil industry). In a review of general purpose technologies, the U.S. Department of Justice concludes that in all cases, “dominant firms have accumulated far more monopoly power than is necessary to motivate and sustain the most rapid and beneficial rate of technological progress”.

Thus, fears about monopolistic power concentrated in the hands of artificial intelligence “first movers” is warranted, based on the historical precedent of previous GPTs.

Aspects of the AI industry are already acting as a monopoly. The table below shows the major links in the artificial intelligence supply chain (more commonly known as the “AI stack”) with the degree of market concentration at each step.

Currently, it is the early inputs that are most monopolistic. For example, TSMC, the semiconductor manufacturer, is known to prioritize its contracts with Apple over other chip consumers during periods of shortages. Note that the companies in the “AI supply chain” with the most monopolistic power (NVDA, TSMC, ASML, AMZN, MSFT, GOOG) are also the stock prices that have been among the biggest gainers in dollar terms since the launch of ChatGPT.  

The stakes of monopolistic behaviour are arguably far higher with artificial intelligence relative to past GPTs. Concentration in the number of foundation models, i.e. the number of artificial intelligence models on which data is trained and uses self-supervision, means that model providers can have an outsized influence on information and can shape the public discourse in profound ways. The current concerns about the outsized influence of media platforms owned by Meta would pale in comparison to the control possible by AI models in the hands of a select few.

The bottom line is that the artificial intelligence industry currently displays monopolistic tendencies. Similar to income inequality, there are policy prescriptions to counteract this, but left unchecked, historical precedents suggest that artificial intelligence will facilitate a higher concentration of economic power.

 

Artificial Intelligence’s Biggest Roadblock: Less Energy Inefficient Than the Status Quo

By status quo, we mean the human brain.

Artificial intelligence is different from previous general purpose technologies in that it is - in its current form – highly energy inefficient compared to a human. Note that in all other general purpose technologies, the energy needs of the technology to complete a task were vastly inferior to the preceding method of task completion. Consider the steam engine: the very first steam engine trains are estimated to have the power of approximately 300 horses and while steam engine powered locomotives are not energy efficient by today’s standards, they are vastly superior to the horse.

Artificial intelligence is already more powerful (i.e. smarter) than the human brain to solve problems with defined scope. However, to complete tasks, artificial intelligence today is less energy efficient than the human brain. The chart below shows the energy requirements of a mouse and human brain compared to computers. To pass from artificial intelligence to general intelligence, i.e. to move from solving defined tasks to solving problems in various domains (i.e. like a human being can) would take almost unimaginable quantities of energy.  

Indeed, according to the Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence, researchers estimate that biological computing is about 9 × 108 times more energy efficient than artificial computing architecture. The authors uncover that to compete with the human brain across an economy, artificial intelligence’s energy use would need to be orders of magnitude higher than that of a large, highly industrialized nation. In other words, the authors conclude that “the principles of thermodynamics of computation pose a significant, if not insurmountable barrier, to the emergence of any artificial general intelligence system”. Of course, AI energy efficiency will no doubt see gains in the coming years, but it seems that humans have an important head start.

Heightened awareness of the environmental and social issues associated with global economic activities is driving demand for greater transparency and prompting governments to take regulatory action. Greater consumer scrutiny and a more stringent regulatory backdrop add to reputational risks that investors must consider, but also create opportunities: companies that provide the testing and certifications needed to comply with these evolving standards will benefit from increased demand. In this note, we explore investment opportunities in the testing, inspection and certification (TIC) market.

The Growing Testing, Inspection and Certification Market

Despite recent backlash on ESG, companies appear to recognize its merits. The need to comply with government regulations and meet expectations of various stakeholders (customers, board, senior management, and shareholders) were identified among the top (“very significant”) reasons for having a sustainability strategy in a recent Morgan Stanley survey where 85% of respondents see sustainability as a value creation opportunity. Both factors translate to greater demand for testing and certification. The market is expected to achieve a cumulative annual growth rate of 4.5% over the next decade.

1) Government Regulations

Over the past two decades, there has been a notable tightening of environmental policies globally (see chart below). Though data for the Environmental Policy Stringency index is only available up to 2020, the trend continues as protection of the environment protection remains a key public issue.

For example, in the U.S., the Biden Administration has sought to pass a slew of environmental policies. The EPA has published new standards addressing vehicle tail-pipe emissions, acceptable air, water and waste levels from fossil-fuel power plants, mandatory independent audits for chemical plants and utilities’ responsibility in monitoring and treating PFAs in the water supply. Efforts have been made to try and safeguard these laws from a change in administration. Though a Trump presidency creates a more challenging context for passing environmental policy, reversing pollution controls (like tracking PFAs in water) could be unpopular with the public. This suggests that more stringent standards are likely to continue as public awareness of environmental health risks grows.

Europe is recognized as the leader when it comes to environmental policy, and the EU continues to introduce new policies, most recently the ecodesign regulation that sets sustainability requirements for a broad array of goods sold in the EU.

While new, more stringent environmental regulations are found mostly in richer countries, the environmental standards in developing nations are likely to tighten as these countries attain greater economic wealth. We can see this in the progress of both China and India’s Environmental Policy Stringency numbers in the past ten years, shown in the chart. As developing countries continue to improve environmental policy, the demand for testing and certification will also increase in these regions.

 

2) Green Credibility

In addition to adhering to new laws and regulations, companies are also striving to live up to consumers’ higher standards. Environmental criteria are growing in importance in purchasing decisions. Although this trend has given rise to the issue of greenwashing - where companies make misleading claims about environmental benefits of their products with the hopes of capitalizing on demand - growing awareness is driving a push for standardized metrics and disclosures. Companies can gain credibility by providing specific environmental data points and disclosures and obtaining third-party verifications. Moreover, the pressure for companies to disclose on a growing number of data points including water usage, biodiversity impacts, worker and product safety and supply chain traceability will broaden the testing, measuring and certification needed to meet higher standards.

 

The Testing, Inspection and Certification Companies

The TIC market is involved in a wide variety of industries ranging from health care and food to mining and automotive. There are a few exceptions like Eurofins Scientific, that focus almost exclusively on bio-analytical testing. In today’s note, we focus on the companies that are most highly levered to the trends described above, i.e. increasing regulation and sustainability adherence, and that are exposed to a wide array of industries.  

The TIC market is considered to be highly fragmented, with only a few large global players competing against many highly specialized local entities. To this end, it is an industry that is ripe for M&A activity.  The large, publicly traded TIC companies tend to be long-standing, established companies with entrenched relationships. It should not be a surprise that companies operating in the quality assurance and certification space have impeccable ESG records; after all, they are paid to ensure the quality of others! All five of the names that we have identified rank above the 90th percentile for ESG practices, according to CSRHub scores. They are also all headquartered in Europe, except for ALS in Australia.

The stock prices of the five companies we analysed – Intertek, Bureau Veritas, Applus, ALS, and SGS – tend to be highly correlated and have a beta to the global equity market of well under one. This is no doubt because many of the companies derive significant revenue from the public sector and because it is difficult to reduce expenditure on testing and assurance, even during economic downturns. All of the companies’ annual reports cite the importance of the two megatrends we described above – sustainability and regulation. Note that we include Applus in our analysis in order to have a larger company sample size, despite the fact that the company will (finally) be taken private: last month Spanish regulators approved the takeover by two private equity firms, making it no longer investable for public equity participants.

The chemical industry is low on the list of what comes to mind for sustainable investors. It is generally considered to be among the largest sources of industrial greenhouse gas emissions, with steel and cement being the other major contributors. The chemical industry is complex, covering a wide variety of processes and applications that are present in nearly 95% of manufactured products. As an industry with a tight regulatory framework and large emissions, it is devoting significant efforts to reduce its carbon footprint.

The industry is divided into four major categories: commodity chemicals, fertilizers, industrial gases, and specialty chemicals. In this note, we start at the base and focus on commodity chemicals which encompass petrochemicals and inorganic commodities.

 

Chemicals Outlook

The overall outlook for the chemical industry is one that is intimately tied to the state of global manufacturing. The chart below shows that global manufacturing is starting to recover after more than a year of slow manufacturing activity.

To identify investment ideas, we focused more on the operational performance of companies than their products. The list of end-products produced from chemicals is vast, making it difficult to narrow down a company to a single product. The purpose of this note is to guide sustainability-minded investors through this sector to make more informed investment decisions mainly based on operational performance.

 

Commodity Chemicals

 Commodity chemicals remain at the bottom of the chemical product value chain. Compared to more complex sectors of the chemical industry like industrial gases and specialty gases, technical barriers to entry are low and differentiating factors are smaller.

There are two types of commodity chemicals: petrochemicals and inorganic chemicals. Polyvinyl chloride (PVC) is a combination of the two. In our search for companies, we included PVC in the petrochemical segment.

Petrochemicals are obtained through the process of refining oil, they are fossil fuel-based products.  Their most common use is as plastic in packaging and containers. Though plastic packaging can draw the ire from environmentalists, a lack of good alternatives means they do have a role to play in preserving food, among other uses (see notes A Reality Check about Plastic Fantasies, April 21, 2023 and Good Things Come in Minimal Packaging, May 16, 2024).

Inorganic commodities are co-products from the chlor-alkali process. This process is very energy-intensive, accounting for about 40 to 50% of manufacturing costs. There are two main products: chlorine and sodium hydroxide. Chlorine is a disinfectant, a solvent and is used in solar panels and PVC. Sodium hydroxide, also known as caustic soda, is a cleaning agent commonly found in soaps and detergents, used as a water treatment product and in aluminum production to break down bauxite. These products have very useful applications where alternatives are limited.

 

Commodity Chemicals Outlook

 The short-term outlook for ethylene depends on the resolution path of the current oversupply; improved demand and/or shutdown of capacity. Improved demand prospects for the Chinese economy and recent capacity reduction have resulted in a recent increase in prices.

The short-term outlook for PVC is slightly better than ethylene because oversupply is not as pronounced. Just like ethylene, the recent price increases reflect improved prospects from China.

The caustic soda market is in better balance between supply and demand. This market is not as economically sensitive as ethylene which explains the less dramatic price increases observed recently.

Just like the United States, which used to be the biggest importer of energy and is now a net exporter, China was the world's largest importer of chemicals but has now become a net exporter. The significant growth in supply from China across the chemical industry is transforming the landscape.

The price and proximity of energy determines where commodity chemicals are produced. The shale revolution and the war in Ukraine have put significant pressure on European plants. The shale revolution improved access to petroleum in the United States with very cheap prices relative to other jurisdiction for natural gas. The war in Ukraine deteriorated access to cheap Russian energy for European chemicals company. As a result, many chemical producers are curtailing their operations in Europe. Higher cost of production and lower prospects for increasing demand from Europe are the driving force behind those shutdowns.

 

Petrochemical Companies

To find the most attractive companies within ethylene and PVC from a long and short perspective, we constrained our analysis to a minimum market capitalization of 1B$ and at least 30% of revenues from plastic resins and materials manufacturing industry. We use the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) materiality framework to identify key issues such as GHG emissions, hazardous waste management, and safety & environmental stewardship of chemicals. To rank the companies within the industry we referred to their CSRhub scores for energy and climate change, and resources management and evaluated the number and importance of recent safety controversies to assess safety aspects.

The following table provides a ranking of petrochemical producers based on their percentile score in energy and climate change, resource management, and safety controversies.

Despite its top ranking, we decided to exclude Daicel Corp from long opportunities as it is also the leading Japanese producer of materials used in cigarette filters, as we try to avoid exposure to the tobacco industry.

We also excluded Alfa SAB de CV from short opportunities despite its bottom ranking because of conflicting signals: Alfa operates in the petrochemical and synthetic fibers industry (polyester, plastics, and chemicals), its petrochemical segment – Alpek - was spun off and is now a public company. Alpek has high CSRHub rankings and still represents 40% of the market capitalization of Alfa.

The two long opportunities derived from our analysis are Shin-Etsu Chemical and Covestro given their strong operational scores in high materiality elements of the business. Westlake and EMS-Chemie are short opportunities, especially given their poor operational scores, but also because of the concerns raised about Westlake's safety practices following the plant explosion at their Louisiana facility.

Inorganic Companies

To select companies in the inorganic chemical industry, we used the same methodology as for petrochemicals.

Based on our analysis, we identified 2 long opportunities, Tata Chemicals and Tokai Carbon, and 2 short opportunities, Genesis Energy and Olin Corp.

Finally, we looked at financial ratios to determine the most attractive long and short for each of petrochemicals and inorganics. From the graph below, we see that Shin-Etsu has good margins, strong growth, decent valuation and no debt whereas EMS-Chemie has similar margins with no debt but much lower growth and much higher valuation. For inorganics, Tokai Carbon has high margins, strong growth, decent valuation and no debt whereas Genesis has low margins, low growth, high valuation and a high debt load.

It is not hyperbole to say that there is a packaging waste crisis underway. Plastic packaging pollution is by far and away the biggest problem, but virtually all packaging materials have some associated environmental challenges.

For investors, packaging is considered a defensive sector, given the industry’s link to the stability of the consumer staples and healthcare sectors. The bulk of packaging companies have a beta of 1 or less. However, this “boring” backdrop masks key risks and opportunities in the industry, virtually all driven by environmental concerns. This makes the packaging industry a more exciting investment opportunity than what first meets the eye.

Overview of the Packaging Industry

Packaging is used to wrap and protect all sorts of goods, virtually everything that is sold to consumers has some sort of packaging or labelling, meaning that container and packaging companies are a key cog in all consumer discretionary and staples companies. Their presence is most ubiquitous in the food, beverage and healthcare industries. Indeed, according to SASB, packaging is a material topic primarily for consumer staples but also consumer discretionary-related companies; the table below describes packaging’s relevance for all industries whereby SASB deems it to be a material topic. 

In recent years, the shift toward e-commerce has provided a major increase in demand for packaging materials related to shipping (cardboard boxes and envelopes), while the COVID pandemic saw a surge in protective plastic packaging that has been slow to fade. However, the largest driver of change for the next several years is the desire by both consumers and regulators to reduce the environmental degradation caused by packaging. The 2023 Buying Green Report from Trivium Packaging released in conjunction with Earth Day, showed that of the over 9,000 consumers surveyed across different continents, 82% were willing to pay more for sustainable packaging, and 59% were looking at information on recyclability or sustainability when buying a product. Moreover, the Plastic Pollution Coalition, tracks over 1200 (!) plastic laws worldwide, many of which have come into force in the past five years. Not surprisingly, most of the packaging companies we track acknowledge escalating regulatory risks with regard to reducing packaging pollution.

From a sustainability perspective, there is no doubt that plastic packaging gets the worst (w)rap by far. After all, packaging accounts for about 36% of all plastic produced, according to the United Nations, and 85% of it ends up in landfills. Even in industries like fresh food packaging, where there is some justification for the use of plastic packaging to prolong shelf life and avoid bacterial contamination, overuse is preponderant.

Plastic and paper account for almost 80% of all packaging. Metal and glass are often touted as superior eco-friendly packaging options because they are infinitely recyclable. However, glass is heavy, meaning that transportation costs and related emissions are significantly higher than for plastic. Metal has similar constraints. Paper and cardboard are recyclable, albeit not infinitely (fibres become too short to adhere to each other after the fifth or sixth use) and their uses are not as universal as plastic (it is not waterproof or airtight). The reality is that there are no miracle substitutes to plastic packaging without introducing major changes to consumer behaviour (and costs).

It is also significant that despite some packaging being more recyclable, it does not mean that it is actually recycled to its potential. Recycling rates vary by material, about 5% for plastic, 30% to 40% for glass and metal, and about 60% for paper. And for all the talk about moving away from plastic, nothing has changed in terms of the composition of packaging waste; according to EU data, the relative share of plastic, metal and paper in packaging waste of has remained unchanged in the past decade.

Each of the prevalent packaging materials have their flaws, but they remain essential in meeting the demands of the market as there are no other scalable alternatives. Understanding the pros and cons for their use is crucial to assess their sustainability, as highlighted in the table below.

Investment Opportunities

Given the less than stellar reputation of packaging, it’s tempting to want to divest or short the entire industry! However, we desperately need solutions. After all, packaging is necessary to protect goods, preserve food, and deliver medicines.

Since packaging materials have different properties, and none are a perfect substitute for another, finding best-in-class investment opportunities from a sustainability perspective is a superior investment approach than simply excluding or divesting from packaging.

For this reason, we find it compelling to create long/short strategies with industry leaders and laggards, promoting packaging companies with innovative solutions while punishing those that continue to contribute to the packaging crisis. In addition, not all clients are considered equal: packaging companies that address essential needs like food and pharma should be more appealing to investors concerned with sustainability than companies addressing more discretionary goods such as alcoholic beverages.

 

To find packaging pair trades, we do the following:

The following summary table highlights key data from our approach described above:

Results

Based solely on controversies and poor CSRHub scores, the following companies are “short” candidates in our packaging universe: Silgan Holdings, Nine Dragons Paper and Winpak. Of the remaining companies that are free of controversies and rank in the top quartile operational scores, we add Berry Global to our short candidate list: this plastic packaging producer is a supplier across consumer discretionary and staples that shows little interest in adapting its business model to the environmental reality of plastic. With less than 1% of revenues invested in research and development, we expect this company will find it difficult to pivot away from problematic plastics.

Second, our analysis uncovers a list of packaging companies that are difficult to get excited about; we take these companies as “neutral”. In many instances, these are companies that operate in highly recyclable markets — either glass or metal packaging — but their main clients are either beverage companies or consumer discretionary industries. Take Verallia as an example: this 100% recyclable glass company is free from controversy and delivers respectable CSRHub scores, but almost three quarters of its product is used for…alcoholic beverages.

Finally, our third list contains packaging companies that are free from controversy, display good operational performance and tend to serve important end markets like food and pharmaceuticals. We do not exclude plastic companies, though we note that Amcor, Avery Dennison and Aptar are the only packaging companies that derive significant revenues from plastic that make our list. In recent years, Amcor has been consistently recognized by its peers for sustainable packaging innovation in both plastic and paper. Avery Dennison primarily makes product labels, an essential component of all packaging, regardless of material. Other companies that sustainability investors can be excited about are primarily in the paper industry, such as Graphic Packaging and Sonoco Products. We note that WestRock – a maker of corrugated paper and fibre packaging initially fulfilled our criteria as a potentially sustainable packaging company, but the announced takeover by Smurfit Kappa calls for caution. Smurfit Kappa is an integrated paper packaging company that is rife with environmental controversies, especially related to their Latin American forestry holdings.

Interestingly, we note that the companies we are most inclined to support tend to be more frequently included in Article 9 funds, i.e. funds that, according to the EU taxonomy, have sustainable investment as their objective. Very few packaging companies that use plastics are included in Article 9 funds, but we note that metal, glass and paper packaging companies appear frequently, irrespective of what the packaging is used for.

Recent news about carbon sequestration projects is yet another demonstration of the gyratory nature of carbon markets – at least in the voluntary sector. The first one is encouraging as it highlights recent developments in Brazil where some farmers are accepting to replant trees in lieu of grazing land for cattle. On the flipside, in Alberta, Shell is in the middle of a major mishap along with the provincial government regarding its carbon credit scheme, where millions of “phantom” carbon credits were sold to other oil sands polluters thanks to the generous “capture 1 tonne, get 2 credits” program. And how could we not mention the ongoing debate within the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) regarding their recent policy shift to allow companies to use carbon credits for offsetting Scope 3 emissions has certainly stirred considerable discussion within the sustainable finance community.

Today’s note reviews recent developments in compliance – or regulated carbon markets – which still offers the best play for carbon-savvy investors in our opinion. Second, we look at Voluntary Carbon Markets (VCM) and various Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) techniques, which in some cases can offer high-risk high-reward VC-like investment opportunities.

 

Regulated Carbon: Looking for its Next Leg of Growth

A first look at EU and North America carbon futures’ prices shows that some sort of continental rift has appeared between the two regions these past few months.

In Europe, the market has been affected by lower-than-average electricity consumption due to softer industrial production, which typically puts a ceiling on carbon prices. Conversely, the resiliency of the U.S. economy and its current “industrial resurgence” supports carbon prices in regulated markets such as Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) and Quebec-California cap-and-trade scheme.

Furthermore, taking a longer-term view on the European economy, the possible demise of Germany’s industrial sector will surely negatively impact carbon prices. A decline in this industrial powerhouse would mean even less demand for commensurate carbon credits within the EU. Meanwhile, in North America, it is the political backdrop that remains the biggest risk for regulated carbon markets – although key players like Québec and California show no sign of walking away from the cap-and-trade scheme. Moreover, the State of New York is looking to launch its own cap-and-trade program which could one day join the Western Climate Initiative (WCI). That said, we continue to favor the North American market over the EU as we view that U.S./Canadian federal-level political risk as less of a concern than muted industrial activity in Europe.

 

A Voluntary Mess?

The voluntary carbon market (VCM) occupies a curious position of both promise and caution. On one hand, the VCM's potential is underscored by the substantial demand from global corporations eager to mitigate their environmental impact through carbon offsets. However, the market's expansion has not been as rapid or robust as some proponents of the VCM might suggest. It's both surprising and expected; surprising because of the undeniable corporate demand, and expected due to persistent concerns that cast long shadows over the market.

The 2023 State of the Voluntary Carbon Markets report by Ecosystem Marketplace highlights a telling stagnation: the price of carbon offset credits in 2022/2023 mirrors those of 2008, accompanied by only a modest increase in trading volume over the same period. These figures suggest that while the VCM could be a pivotal tool in our climate response toolkit, it still struggles to escape the perception that it is more of a future promise than a present solution. We can almost say that VCM is the carbon solution of tomorrow, and might always be!

 

Other Solutions Exist (for Those with Deep Pockets)

For those who want to avoid the credibility, transparency and permanence issues that comes with lower quality forest projects, there are options. The carbon dioxide removal (CDR) space is rich in options, for those ready to pay the rich price! Compared with the average forestry carbon credit price for 2022/2023 according to Ecosystem Marketplace, the other CDR options are 5 to 140 times more expensive!

Interestingly, the demand for high-quality CDR credits such as Direct Air Capture (DAC) currently outpaces the offer of such credits, which is creating a rapidly growing market and VC-like investment opportunities.

Investing in DAC is not for the faint of heart, however. With DAC credit prices over $700 per tonne, we are still far from commercial viability, and it is difficult to see a time when it will be. In our opinion, it is likely to remain a niche market for the carbon removal purists.

Among the other CDR technologies, biochar is gaining global recognition as a potentially more effective carbon solution compared to direct air capture (DAC) for several reasons. Firstly, the production of biochar through pyrolysis not only captures carbon but also returns nutrients to the soil, improving soil health and agricultural productivity. This dual benefit enhances the sustainability and economic viability of biochar as a carbon solution.

Moreover, biochar can be produced using organic waste materials, making it a form of waste-to-value technology that contributes to circular economy principles. This use of readily available biomass can significantly reduce the operational costs associated with capturing and storing carbon when compared to DAC technologies, which require large amounts of energy and sophisticated infrastructure.

Despite their environmental benefits, biochar start-ups often lag behind direct air capture (DAC) in terms of early-stage financing. This discrepancy may stem from the perceived “unsexyness” and complexity of biochar solutions by non-technical investors. Unlike DAC's more straightforward, large-scale mechanical processes – often likened to giant vacuums – biochar and biocarbon involve nuanced biochemical processes, soil enrichment, and pyrolysis and plasma technologies which can be more challenging to quantify and explain in investment pitches. In our opinion, this could be a better CDR solution for investors to get behind considering that the space is not as crowded, the economic case is better, and the environmental benefits are greater.

The past month has seen a flurry of activity in the U.S., China and the euro area regarding competition in key “green” industries. The European commission has launched several new probes into Chinese companies for anti-competitive behaviour in wind, electric vehicles and batteries. Meanwhile, U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen visited China aiming to address U.S. concerns that China is dumping their overproduction of renewable energy equipment onto other nations. There is talk of imposing more tariffs on China as Chinese exports of solar panels have helped push prices down over 40% in the last year, making it difficult for solar panel producers in other countries to compete.  

From a climate change perspective, a glut of solar panels and wind turbines is hardly a bad thing. After all, according to the IEA, the decline in solar panel prices is related to a three-fold increase in manufacturing capacity since 2021. The result: an estimated 96% of newly installed, utility-scale solar PV capacity now has lower generation costs than new coal and natural gas plants. This is excellent news –the economics of renewable energy support an ongoing shift away from dirty energy sources.

Unfortunately, however, what is good for the planet does not always align with national interests: attempts by governments to turn green growth into a competition for green jobs has translated into a wave of disputes. Below, we explore the past and current state of global green trade and outline a possible path forward.

 

Origins of a Trade War

China joined the WTO in 2001 and in the beginning, there was a highly symbiotic relationship between China and the U.S. (and many other developed economies). China, thanks in large part to comparatively cheap labor, supplied U.S. consumers with low-cost goods in exchange for much-needed U.S. dollars to fuel a move up the development curve.

For a long time, this relationship worked, since the two economies did not compete – China largely produced items at a cost efficiency too difficult for American firms to achieve on domestic soil, lowering the price of many consumer goods, while China did not have the skilled workforce or capital savings needed to produce in critical sectors where America excelled.

However, for the past decade or so, the relationship has become less mutually beneficial, in no small part because China and America no longer operate in different spheres: the Chinese economy has advanced so much that China is now equipped to compete across a plethora of high-skill industries. Indeed, the chart below shows the economic complexity indexes (ECI) of China and the U.S. The ECI is a measure of knowledge intensity of an economy. While China still lags the U.S. somewhat, the convergence underscores that China is competent in many of the areas that used to be the domain of the U.S. and a handful of other developed economies.

Green Goods Dumping

In retrospect, it shouldn’t have been a surprise to anyone that China became a leader in green goods industries. After all, the Chinese government’s economic plan “Made For 2025” which was laid out in 2015 made clear the ten industries for which China aimed to reduce the country’s reliance on foreign technology imports and to create domestic companies relying on domestic innovation. Of the ten industries targeted, “energy saving” and “power equipment” are among the loftiest goals.  

By all accounts, China was wildly successful at creating flourishing domestic industries in ‘new energy vehicles’ and ‘renewable energy equipment’.

In fact, China has been so successful that export markets have taken a keen interest in their products. BYD, the main Chinese electric car manufacturer currently already sells about 8% of its cars outside of China.

Meanwhile, China’s ‘renewable energy equipment’ industry is a true global phenomenon. Returning to solar panels, while China represents less than 40% of total solar panel demand, the country accounts for virtually all global production.

State of Play

Anti-dumping and anti-subsidy tariffs on the Chinese solar panel industry began in 2012 and 2013 by the U.S. and euro area, respectively. As a result of these moves, many Chinese companies spent the rest of the decade moving their manufacturing facilities to other countries to avoid the duties. In other words, actions against China were not successful at curbing Chinese solar power capacities.

Although the euro area dropped their tariffs in 2018, the U.S. added a new 30% tariff on solar imports which is still in place today. The U.S. is contemplating further tariffs, while the euro area recently launched new probes into Chinese manufacturers of solar panels suspected of benefitting from "distortive" state subsidies and gaining an "unfair advantage." The EU has also launched subsidy investigations into Chinese wind turbine companies and Chinese EV manufacturers.

All of these moves by Western countries are happening under the guise of protecting national industries. But what’s left to protect? Of the top producers of solar panels (listed companies by market cap), only four are U.S. or European companies. By most accounts, it is extremely unlikely that other nations can catch up to China on production. As for other green industries, although China has a formidable wind turbine manufacturing base, Chinese manufacturers have not yet been able to penetrate markets abroad (where roughly 95% of demand in 2023 was covered by European and American companies).

What Comes Next?

Despite China’s total dominance in solar panel manufacturing, it is highly unlikely that policy and trade friction between China and other nations will disappear. It is well known that China is suffering from an economic growth slowdown and will continue to support its local industries in order to maintain jobs and stability. Meanwhile, in Western countries, it is politically popular to “target” China irrespective of the efficacy of policies. In other words, we do not expect any major policy change that will disrupt the current status quo of a strong, steady stream of Chinese-sourced renewable energy equipment. We do not wish to bet against U.S. and European manufacturers, though we do not expect current headwinds to diminish for the foreseeable future.

A key point is that Chinese solar panel manufacturers are producing goods that are inexpensive, but not “cheap”.  One of the main reasons that Chinese panels have fallen in the past decade is due to improvements in design. A notable metric for solar panel quality is bankability, i.e. the likelihood that investors are willing to invest because data indicates the quality and long-term durability of the solar module, as well as the trustworthiness of the manufacturer. 

Chinese companies such as Longi and Jinko Solar receive the same bankability ratings as U.S. companies like First Solar. On this basis, it seems unlikely that a major shift in the industry is likely to occur.

 Investment Implications

As China attempts to stabilize its domestic economy and reach its Made for 2025 objectives, it is highly likely that renewable energy equipment manufacturers will remain in high gear, maintaining the global supply glut, particularly in solar panels but also for other equipment.

This trend is developing at a time when it is becoming increasingly well known that grid investment has not kept pace with renewable energy development. This is evidenced by longer and longer grid connection queues (the IEA estimates that over 3 000 GW of renewable energy projects are in connection queues globally, with nearly 1 500 GW of wind and solar PV projects in advanced stages of development). This is enough to nearly double current installed global capacity for these technologies, all of which is just sitting in queues!

We have written in past notes about our preferred investment picks to invest in the coming buildout in grid capacity (for example, please see “From Gridlock To Gridsmart”, April 4, 2024). In the simplest terms, given the oversupply in manufacturers vs the building demand for transmission, investors should be looking to go “long renewable energy operators and grid producers” and avoid “renewable energy equipment manufacturers”.

Record temperatures for sea and air surface are continuing in 2024 after a record 2023. Due to above normal sea surface temperatures and expected La Niña conditions, a busy hurricane season is expected this summer; warm water adds more energy to the tropics and La Niña1 usually reduces vertical wind shear that lets hurricanes come to shore. These factors are supporting forecasts for more than twenty named storms in the Atlantic Basin to occur in 2024. The presence of warm water earlier in the year has the potential to advance and extend the period of intense hurricanes that causes the most damage.

Longer term, warmer temperatures should increase the frequency of consequential weather events from high winds. Higher sea surface temperature also has the potential to increase flooding.

These consequential weather events have implications all across our built environments. Instead of measuring physical risks, we identified four equity investment plays that are leveraged to climate adaptation: residential rebuild, electric connections, electricity grid buildout and engineering services.

From the household sector, residential repairs and more construction activity will increase demand for all sorts of building supplies such as lumber, plywood, shingles, roofing panels, windows, doors, etc.

From corporations and governments, infrastructure repairs and resiliency improvements are necessary. In a note on April 4: “From Gridlock to Grid Smart: AI’s Role in Electricity Efficiency”, we argued that greater electricity demand will bring further strains on the grid. Indeed, there are already supply chain issues for switchgear and other electrical components, but destructive weather is likely to supercharge this demand.

In this note, we focus on building materials, grid connections, grid buildout and design. The table below lists companies and their respective products. Among the companies listed, only a few, mention climate change as a potential source of activity: Owens Corning highlights that 16% of its roofing business comes from climate events, Stella Jones highlights fire-resistant wrap utility poles as a strong growth driver and all of the engineering firms discuss climate change as a source of growth in revenues. The other companies on the list focus on residential construction. We believe that all the firms on the list could benefit from a busy hurricane season.

The chart below highlights a few public companies likely to benefit from increased demand from hurricanes this year and a more volatile climate in the future. These companies have been identified due to the likelihood of higher revenue streams associated with building reconstruction. These companies are characterized by decent margins, strong sales growth and reasonable valuations.

The next chart shows a few companies with products and solutions such as switchgear, structural connectors, cable and wire baskets that will be needed for infrastructure. Strong demand for their products, good margins with commensurate valuation metrics make them interesting investment opportunities. Simpson Manufacturing just reported its Q1, 2024 results and its price fell by 10% because construction activity was weaker than expectations. This could just be a temporary drop if demand for their products recover as we anticipate. In contrast, Owens Corning just reported better earnings, in part because of weather-related replacements.

Similarly, companies involved in the expansion and repair of the grid – including wooden poles to towers - will also benefit from extreme weather-related demand. The chart below displays the financial characteristics of Valmont Industries (a company that specializes in grid infrastructure among other things) and Stella Jones, a supplier of utility poles and other wood products. These two companies have low margins, strong sales growth and relatively fair valuations.

Finally, the engineering companies that design and manage construction and reconstruction should remain very busy. The following chart shows various financial ratios for select engineering firms. From a pure financial ratio perspective, investors seem to have anticipated better times than for the other groups highlighted above since margins and sales growth are relatively low but price to earnings and price to cash flows are relatively high.

Note that relative to a U.S. equity broad benchmark, each of the groups identified has outperformed over the past two years, suggesting that investors are already excited about these plays and their prospects. If our analysis of bigger climate events is correct, further strong results will follow.

 

Note

1: La Niña is a climate pattern that describes the cooling of surface-ocean waters along the tropical west coast of South America. It is considered to be the counterpart to El Niño, which is characterized by unusually warm ocean temperatures in the equatorial region of the Pacific Ocean. In this pattern, strong winds blow warm water at the ocean’s surface from South America to Indonesia. As the warm water moves west, cold water from the deep rises to the surface near the coast of South America. La Niña has significant effects on weather and climate. It can lead to severe weather conditions, affecting sectors such as agriculture, health, water resources, and disaster management. For example, during La Niña events, southern states in the U.S. tend to experience drought, while the Pacific Northwest and Canada see heavy rainfall and flash flooding.