Three weeks ago, at 12:33 p.m. CEST on April 28, 2025, the entire Iberian Peninsula was plunged into darkness. Europe’s largest blackout in two decades affected tens of millions of people across Spain and Portugal. Trains screeched to a halt. Planes were grounded. Traffic lights blinked out. Hospitals ran on backup generators. Power wasn’t fully restored for 23 hours, and the economic fallout is estimated at €2.3–4.5 billion.
While a full forensic analysis will take months, we already know the basics: a sudden loss of ~15 GW of generation in southwestern Spain – roughly 60% of the system’s online capacity – triggered a rapid frequency drop to 48.0 Hz. Under-frequency load shedding (UFLS) was automatically deployed in Spain and Portugal, but it wasn’t enough. Within 21 seconds, the overhead lines linking France and Spain were tripped by protection systems. The Iberian grid was isolated – and collapsed.
Anti-renewable pundits were quick to blame the blackout on the intermittent and non-synchronous nature of renewable energy. But as with most complex systems, the reality is more nuanced. As we will explore in this note, renewables should not be singlehandedly blamed for the failure. That said, the pace at which Spain integrated variable renewable energy production relative to the pace of investment in modernizing its grid warrants some scrutiny.
What the Iberian blackout underscores is that grid stability in the modern era is a multifaceted challenge. The event’s implications go far beyond a lack of power; it risks eroding public and investor confidence in the grid’s ability to support the energy transition. The rush by “armchair experts” to blame renewables reveals something deeper: a pressing need for clear, fact-based communication about how grids actually function.
Grids are among the most intricate human systems ever built. Their complexity comes not just from scale, but from their very nature: a network of networks. This makes them difficult to control and predict, especially under stress. In older regions like Europe and North America, grids have evolved into a patchwork of mid-century infrastructure layered with newer technologies – sometimes described anecdotally as a “Frankenstein of 3,000 utility companies held together by duct tape, Windows 98, and prayers”. The system is so fragile that even a small rodent can wreak havoc. In fact, the American Public Power Association maintains a Squirrel Index (TSqI) to track power outages caused by squirrels – the second leading cause of power outages in the U.S. (after weather events).
These fragile systems now face a rising tide of stress. Climate change is triggering more frequent and severe weather events: heatwaves that sag transmission lines, floods and hurricanes that knock out substations, and wildfires that torch entire grid corridors. For example, the U.S. saw major grid disruptions jump from fewer than 20 in 2000 to over 180 in 2020. At the same time, electricity demand is shifting dramatically. The electrification of transportation and heating, along with the explosion of energy-hungry data centers, is creating load shapes and peak demands that legacy infrastructure was never designed to handle. On top of it all, grid digitalization – while offering valuable control and efficiency – has opened up new vulnerabilities to cyber threats, that often target systems with outdated or underdeveloped security protocols.
In the global push to decarbonize, the lion’s share of attention and capital has gone toward replacing fossil fuel generation with wind and solar. That’s a worthy goal. And to be sure, a gleaming offshore wind farm is a far sexier photo op than a synchronous condenser buried in a substation; politicians and investors have gravitated toward the optics of generation, not the plumbing of grid transmission. As a result, investment has skewed heavily toward supply, while the grid itself remains chronically underfunded.
Figuratively speaking, we are replacing coal-powered steam locomotives with shinny high-speed bullet trains – while still running them on 19th-century tracks. The result is a sleek, modern fleet of renewable generation that risks derailing on fragile infrastructure. It’s time to reframe the energy transition: before renewables can finish the race, grids need to be brought up to speed.
According to BloombergNEF, annual investments in renewable energy generation are expected to plateau around 2028, while spending on power grid expansion and modernization will continue to grow until 2040. By that point, grid investment will have tripled compared to 2020 levels.
As Winston Churchill famously said, “Never let a good crisis go to waste.” In that spirit, this note outlines solutions to two of the main structural weaknesses revealed by the Iberian blackout: the loss of natural grid inertia due to the replacement of conventional power plants with renewables, and the insufficient interconnectivity of national grids.
We also recognize the critical role of energy storage in enhancing grid stability and flexibility. However, as we’ve covered that sector in detail in our November 28, 2024 note, What’s In Store for Energy Storage?, we refer readers to that publication for a deeper dive.
Grid Inertia: Some Moving Technologies
Traditional power plants – coal, gas, nuclear, and hydro – contribute rotating mass that provides mechanical inertia, helping to stabilize grid frequency and absorb shocks from sudden imbalances. At the time of the Iberian outage, solar generation was dominating supply: 59% of electricity came from solar, or a total of 71% from renewables if wind is included. In contrast, nuclear and gas provided just 11% and 5%, respectively. With such low conventional output, the grid’s natural inertia was limited.
When inertia is low, even routine disturbances can result in sharp frequency swings. These rapid changes can trip protection systems across generation fleets, cascading into larger failures – as likely happened here.
Some countries, like Germany, are planning to build gas-fired plants as a backup to renewables, in part to provide mechanical inertia. But technology already offers cleaner alternatives. Solutions like grid-forming inverters and synchronous condensers can deliver synthetic inertia – fast, controllable responses that mimic the stabilizing role of spinning turbines.
Leading manufacturers of these technologies include Siemens Energy (ENR-DE), GE Vernova (GEV-US), and Eaton (ETN-US). All are well-positioned to benefit from the surge in demand for grid stability solutions as renewables take center stage.
Grid Interconnectivity: Stronger Together
Another top priority is reinforcing transmission links – both within countries and across borders. Stronger interconnections allow power to flow more flexibly, enabling regions to support each other during imbalances and preventing isolated grid collapses. This means building new high-voltage transmission lines, especially HVDC (high-voltage direct current) systems, which are more efficient for long-distance electricity transport and better suited for integrating large-scale renewable projects.
Europe is now actively evaluating new cross-border projects to boost Spain–France transfer capacity, which currently sits at a meager 3% of Spain’s peak demand – far below the EU’s recommended minimum of 15%. This bottleneck played a key role in the Iberian blackout.
Once again, HVDC system manufacturers like Siemens Energy and GE Vernova are at the center of the solution. But equally important are the companies that actually build the infrastructure.
Two standouts on either side of the Atlantic are Quanta Services (PWR-US) and SPIE Group (SPIE-FR). While not equipment manufacturers, they are critical EPC (engineering, procurement, and construction) partners for large HVDC transmission lines and converter station infrastructure. Quanta, for example, is involved in the TransWest Express and Champlain Hudson Power Express – two high-profile HVDC projects in North America. Meanwhile, SPIE has made a series of strategic acquisitions that position it as a continental leader in Europe’s push for HVDC interconnectivity.
For sustainability-minded investors who agree that grid modernization will rapidly climb up the priority list in the wake of the Iberian Peninsula blackout, we recommend a closer look at the companies mentioned above – with one potential exception: GE Vernova (GEV-US). Our hesitation with GE Vernova is threefold:
- It trades at a notably higher valuation than its peers;
- It remains newly independent, with only one full calendar year under its belt post-spin-off; and
- Roughly 70% of its revenue still comes from renewable generation equipment, a segment that could underperform if investor focus shifts decisively toward grid infrastructure.
From a performance standpoint, it has been an electrifying two years for this group of stocks – all have handily outpaced the MSCI World Index. And with a massive wave of grid investment now on the horizon, we believe the ceiling could be even higher.
The United States is deeply unsettled by the prospect of losing its global hegemonic status to China, a shift that challenges its national identity. Since the Second World War, America has been positioned as the world’s economic, technological and military leader, a role intertwined with its sense of exceptionalism. China’s rapid ascent, backed by state-led industrial strategy, expanding global influence, and technological ambition, poses a direct threat to U.S. supremacy.
Countries with current account deficits should find it easier to strike deals with the Trump administration because they have more flexibility in reaching a balanced trade position with the USA, i.e. they can buy stuff from the United States to appease politicians. Trump has repeatedly framed global trade as a zero-sum game, where US deficits equate to losses, and surpluses indicate exploitation. This is how Liberation Day was framed where countries with bilateral deficits with the USA had the minimum 10% tariffs and trade surplus countries had much higher tariffs. In this context, countries that run deficits are less threatening and more likely to be dependable trading partners. Moreover, deficit countries often share concerns about global imbalances and may be more amenable to bilateral arrangements that emphasize domestic industry protection, supply chain re-shoring, and nationalist economic policies. The initial information we have on the trade deal between the United Kingdom and the United States is an example where the UK has essentially given a veto to the US to reject Chinese company purchases. The table below highlights some of the countries that run current account deficits. The first deal announced is with the UK. Discussions with India seem to be advancing. The case of Japan is slightly more complicated because its current deficit account status is highly dependent on the price of commodities since they import most of them. With lower commodity prices, a current account deficit will rapidly swing to a surplus. Initial indications are that Japan will be among the early deals. We added Canada to the list, even if it currently runs a surplus, since Canada, Mexico and the USA will probably modify their current trade deal (USMCA). Canada is the opposite of Japan where low commodity prices can swiftly shift it to a current account deficit country.
Countries with large current account surpluses—such as those in the graph below, are likely to face tougher trade negotiations with the United States because they are seen as benefitting disproportionately from global trade. A surplus implies these countries export significantly more than they import, often into large consumer markets like the U.S. The White House argues that imbalances reflect unfair advantages such as undervalued currencies, protectionist policies, or state support for export-driven sectors. The U.S. will demand concessions like greater market access, reduced subsidies, or currency adjustments and tariff rates greater than the minimum 10% are likely to stay for the countries that run current account surpluses. China and re-routing countries such as Indonesia, Vietnam and Malaysia are the main targets. The European Union may also encounter more difficult negotiations than currently expected, even if it is a historical ally.
It is clear that pursuing maximum cost efficiency is no longer the main goal of our evolving economic system; the prospects for globalization are dimming. GDP for consumption sake will get replaced by industrial policy where resiliency is more important and how money is spent counts. For example, investments in the US shipbuilding industry are more important than purchases of dolls even if each dollar spent results in the same when measuring economic output.
Biden used carrots to re-industrialize with the Inflation Reduction Act, the Chips Act and the Infrastructure Bill. Trump is using sticks with tariffs and other coercive measures. Earlier this week, China and the United States announced a 90-day truce period to negotiate a comprehensive trade agreement. During the press conference, Scott Bessent, the US Treasury Secretary, confirmed that the United States is seeking strategic decoupling from China. This helped to reduce the temperature of the trade war, but the direction of travel is clear to both sides. Companies have been warned: do not invest in China, bring your supply chain closer to the consumer and create jobs.
When production is closer to major markets, companies can iterate products faster, ensure better quality control, and maintain greater control over labor and environmental standards. While shorter supply chains may raise production costs, it can reduce exposure to supply risks in a transforming World Order. This change signals a broader move away from a purely globalized efficiency model toward one rooted in strategic autonomy and resilience.
In the context of strategic decoupling, we identified 20 sustainable companies from our investment universe, across sectors and investment themes, that are best positioned to thrive in a deglobalizing world, specifically related to the eventual strategic decoupling of the United States from China.
The table below highlights the 20 companies, their sector, what they do and why they are not affected by the trade conflict.
Next, we examined historical performance over the last 10 years to align with the long perspective of this note. The chart below shows a list of strong performers over the last 10 years in health care (Intuitive Surgical, Vertex and Quest), utilities (Constellation) and energy (Cameco). As we can see, our selection of health care companies have done very well and they remain well-positioned for the upcoming mayhem. Cameco and Constellation Energy are both beneficiaries of the nuclear renaissance.
The following chart shows companies in the same sectors that have some catch up to do. Ormat is a geothermal utility which has not yet benefitted from the same excitement as nuclear but it could come soon since the Trump administration supports geothermal. LKQ is an auto parts recycler and Americold is a cold storage real investment trust which have not been top of mind. Vital Farms is a pasture-raised egg producer that has not yet completely recovered from the pandemic.
The next chart looks at strong performers in technology, industrials and materials. Fortinet and ServiceNow, and even Parker Hannifin benefitted from the strong performance of technology-related companies. Republic Services and Waste Management rode the wave of increased demand and consolidation in waste and recycling.
And finally in the chart below, we look at companies that have lagged in industrials and materials over the last decade. Most of the companies on the chart below were performing very well until recently when the risk of recession increased and engulfed Commercial Metals, First Solar, Freeport, ArcBest and even Packaging Corporation. We believe those companies will benefit from strategic decoupling that will favor local producers and shorter supply chains. Their recent drops in price reflects the risk of a recession emanating from less global commerce. In our view, these companies could reverse higher once/if a recession gets fully reflected in their price.
Lanthanides, or more commonly referred to as rare earth elements (REEs), are a set of 17 silvery-white soft, heavy metals. The interest and insatiable demand for REEs is due to their widespread use in LED monitors, catalytic converters, electric vehicles, X-ray machines, superconductors, military equipment and so much more. In other words, REEs have become integral and unavoidable constituents in today’s economy.
Rare earth metals (REE) are actually very abundant in the Earth’s crust, but the “rare” moniker stuck because minable concentrations are far less common than for most other mineral commodities. They are rarely found in large, concentrated deposits on their own, but rather among other elements. This makes them difficult to mine – and also difficult to process and purify –current production methods require a lot of ore and generate a great deal of harmful waste. Along with the usual environmental degradation associated with mining activities (toxic wastewater, tailings, air pollution, biodiversity loss, etc), processing REEs often also creates radioactive waste. Until very recently, any countries that had allowed mining of REEs on their territory shipped their ore to China for processing and purifying to reduce the negative environmental impacts on domestic soil.
Indeed, it’s becoming well known that China dominates the rare earths market. The country has vast reserves, but most importantly, processes 90% of the world’s REEs.
China’s production dominance of REEs is not arbitrary. Rather, it is a result of calculated efforts beginning in 1990, when the Chinese government declared rare earths as protected and strategic minerals. Other countries became aware of the need for REEs and their reliance on China in 2010; the Senkaku boat collision incident sparked a diplomatic standoff whereby China drastically reduced critical mineral exports and triggered an unanticipated rise in REE prices. Furthermore, supply chain havoc during the COVID pandemic turbocharged various governments’ plans to diversify REE sources away from China.
It is within this context that President Trump’s government has threatened to purchase Greenland, taunted Canada about becoming a U.S. state, and signed a minerals deal with Ukraine. What all of these countries have in common is their relative abundance of critical resources, especially REEs (resources of rare earths were estimated to include 2.7 million tons in the U.S. versus more than 15 million tons in Canada).
It’s true that one day, the U.S./Ukraine mineral deal could change the global supply dynamics of REEs. However, that day will be far in the future:
- no one really knows how much REEs are under Ukraine soil; the region has not been surveyed in over three decades (during the Soviet regime)
- the deal is on new mines, not on operations already in existence. Building an REE mine will likely not pay dividends for over a decade, and this is in a best-case scenario whereby the Russia/Ukraine war ends imminently.
Given this backdrop, it is clear that any incremental demand for REEs will be supplied by current producers. Since China has now restricted exports around the world in retaliation for Trump’s tariffs, it stands to reason that any company that can replace Chinese REEs will reap rewards.
Price Outlook
The price of REE mining stocks, like most mining stocks, is positively correlated with the underlying price of the mineral or metal in question: REE mining stocks observe price appreciation when the selling price of REEs rise. Major upswings in REE prices and related company stock prices have previously coincided with Chinese policy (see the Chart below). In 2016, the Chinese government undertook a massive stockpiling of rare earths, purchasing over 10 000 tons of oxides that year. Another significant upswing occurred in 2021, when China further consolidated the industry by forming the China Rare Earth Group, effectively merging several of the biggest state-owned firms and allowing the government to have greater control of output.
Over the past two years, however, REE prices have been weak. This is because demand for REEs slowed primarily due to softer global EV sales and slower Chinese consumption. Existing inventory is slowly being worked off, just as China has announced export restrictions.
Indeed, prices of some rare-earth metals have rebounded sharply since April 4th, when China announced it was clamping down on exports to all nations, a move widely seen as retaliation against Trump’s tariffs on China.
It is impossible to predict how long the export restrictions will stay in place. Nonetheless, given that the inventory overhang had already been reduced, even if China re-starts exporting, there is a good chance that REE will stay in a cyclical uptrend. However, as demonstrated below, there are only a handful on non-Chinese companies that can capitalize on this dynamic.
Who Can Displace China In REEs?
There are few viable substitutes for REE for the vast majority of current uses and replacing Chinese supply is a tall order, especially if environmental risks are taken into account. Mining is a classic, environmental Wicked Problem, i.e. one whereby the end-use of many products that contain metals offer major improvements in quality of life and are strong enablers of social progress but the mining activity that produces these goods is environmentally destructive and tends to be rife with negative social impacts (i.e. human rights abuses). We wrote about this in detail in a note on October 14, 2021 (Transition Metals: Wicked Problem, Smart Solutions) and the investment approach we outlined then is valid to REE production as well. Indeed, there are two viable strategies for investors that wish to ensure that a vital economic activity affected by wicked problems is carried out in an optimal way: the first is choosing best-in-class companies and the second is supporting companies with recycling activities.
Rare Earth Best-in-Class Is a Challenge
Searching for non-Chinese producers of REEs produces slim pickings, let alone those that have strong environmental, social and governance records. We find only three companies to consider:
- MP Materials Corp. (NYSE: MP): MP possesses the only integrated rare earth mining and processing site in North America, with a focus on REEs that are essential for magnets in EVs, wind turbines, and defense systems. Until April, 2024, the company sent concentrate to China for final processing, though MP is building downstream capabilities in the U.S.
MP has a far from stellar sustainability record. The company is in the bottom quartile relative to mining peers when it comes to resource management (according to CSR Hub), and in 2022 there was a class action lawsuit against MP for violating securities laws, alleging an abusive transfer pricing manipulation scheme.
- Lynas Rare Earths Ltd. (ASX: LYC): LYC is an Australian company and is the largest rare earths producer outside of China. Mining is done in Australia, with current processing facilities in Malaysia. However, the company is currently building a U.S. processing facility in Texas in partnership with the U.S. Department of Defense, which will help to bypass tariffs for the goods produced in the U.S. Importantly, LYC was profitable throughout 2024 when REE prices were considerably weaker, suggesting that the company can maintain decent earnings in the current environment. Note that LYC has a considerably better track record than MP on sustainability issues., ranking in the top quartile on all issues according to CSR Hub.
- Neo Performance Materials (TSX: NEO): NEO is a smaller company (500 million USD market cap), but its competitive edge is that it operates one of the only rare earth processing facilities in Europe, located in Estonia. Similar to LYC, NEO managed to turn a profit last year amid difficult pricing conditions, suggesting that any upside in 2025 to REE prices will improve their bottom line. From an operational perspective, NEO displays no environmental, social or governance red flags.
Of these three companies, Neo Performance Materials has been the biggest winner in terms of stock price appreciation since April’s Chinese export restrictions were put in place (see the chart below). This is no doubt because both MP Materials and Lynas Rare Earths are not completely detached from China for processing their ore.
REE Recyling: E-Waste Trash To Treasure
Recovering REEs from electronic waste (i.e. recycling) is appealing from a geopolitical perspective because it gets around the problem of geographical concentration of key resources: recycling companies have no geographic constraints and they also relieve pressure on primary supply (i.e. helps to leave more metals in the ground).
Humans create over 60 million metric tons of e-waste each year, much of it containing rare earth metals that are never recovered (recycling rates of REEs are estimated at under 1%). This makes electronic trash a rich and relatively abundant supply of REEs.
Much like the miners however, there are only a handful of companies that have e-waste REE recovery solutions:
- Solvay (BRU: SOLB): Solvay manufactures and distributes chemical products, including the production of soda ash for glass for buildings, solar panels, glass containers, packaging, and lithium-ion batteries. Although recycling is far from its core business, the company has developed an expertise in rare earth materials processing. The company recently signed a memorandum of understanding with metals recycling group Cyclic Materials (a private firm in Canada) to source technology to turn waste into oxides. Solvay aims to produce 30% of European demand for rare earths used in so-called permanent magnets by 2030.
- Envipro (Japan: 5698): Envipro (market cap about 100 million USD) has an extensive business portfolio which includes recycling of a wide range of wastes, end of life products, and Lithium ion batteries. The company also operates in the international trading sector for recycled/recovered materials and used vehicles. About 30% of Envipro’s revenues are generated through resource recycling, of which REEs make up a small, but growing portion. Similar to Solvay/Cyclic Materials, last year Envipro launched a collaboration with HyProMat, a UK firm with rare earth magnet recycling technology.
Other REE recycling ventures include Ionic (Ireland), REEcycleinc (US), REETec (Norway), LKAB (Sweden) and Heraeus Remloy (Germany), which are all seeking to extract rare earths from magnets, batteries, mining and other products, but these groups are relatively young and not yet commercially viable.
The global economy stands at an inflection point. Following the sharp escalation of U.S. tariffs in early April, most countries — including allies like South Korea, Japan, and the EU — now find themselves in a strange 90-day negotiation window. This isn’t business as usual; it’s a fork in the road between the good old days of globalization and more fractured, politically-driven, self-centered economies. Shifts like this create potential winners and losers, determined by who is best (and worst) positioned to seize the opportunity to reset their role in a changing world.
While the outcome of the 90-day negotiations with many countries might still fizzle into a nothingburger — much like the USMCA reset with Canada and Mexico in 2018 — the U.S.-China relationship is heading for a hard break. Trump has been blunt: the goal isn’t tweaks around the edges; it’s a take-no-prisoners approach for a full reset of their economic relationship.
That reset is already underway. For the past 25 years, China was the beating heart of global supply chains. Now, companies and capital are being pushed — or pulled — to look elsewhere. Even if tariffs are reduced for allies, the supply chain fracture with China will not simply reverse. In this emerging reality, countries like South Korea, with trusted political ties, advanced manufacturing, and leadership in critical green sectors, could take a much larger role in the global economy. In short, thanks to Korea’s strong industrial base and US-aligned trade relations, the country makes a perfect “friend-shoring” partner.
To be sure, no investment is a slam dunk in the current geopolitical climate. Although Korea could be a relative winner from deglobalization, the country faces structural headwinds that investors must weigh carefully. Demographically, Korea holds the world’s lowest fertility rate — at just 0.72 births per woman in 2024 — putting long-term pressure on domestic consumption and labor supply. Politically, governance risks persist: four of the last six former Korean presidents and one Prime Minister have either been jailed, impeached, or convicted of criminal charges, underlining a volatile political backdrop that periodically spills into corporate affairs.
On the other hand, South Korea’s reaction to the tariff announcement has been cool, calm and collected. They are most likely to have a new deal in place with the US before the tariffs kick in on July 9, 2025.
In addition, while Korea is often viewed as a supply chain alternative to China, the reality is more complicated. Korean industries remain highly dependent on China for critical primary materials — from rare earths to battery metals — leaving them exposed to upstream supply shocks or geopolitical tensions beyond their control. But Korea has seen a lot of foreign investment coming in the last couple decades which put them on a path to becoming a powerhouse in their own right.
Given these realities, selectivity is essential. In this note, we focus on Korean companies that (1) generate a majority of their revenues outside Korea and China, (2) are investing heavily in R&D and supply chain diversification to mitigate input risks, and (3) operate in green sectors that should remain resilient, even amid the growing politicization of sustainability themes. These companies offer the best combination of exposure to global growth, alignment with energy transition trends, and insulation from Korea’s domestic vulnerabilities.
And while Korea’s green leaders have outperformed the KOSPI in recent years, we now need to go a step further: to identify those with real upside left — not because of current macro conditions, but in spite of them.
Seoul Mate #1: Batteries
Korean companies dominate the global battery supply chain outside of China. LG Energy Solution (LGES), Samsung SDI, and the SK Group (SK On and SK ie Technology) – collectively referred to as the “K-battery trio” – together account for roughly a quarter of the world’s EV battery output, supplying automakers across Asia, Europe, and North America. With Chinese battery giants like CATL facing restricted access to the U.S. market, global automakers have increasingly turned to Korean cell suppliers. Several multi-year supply agreements have recently been announced with Ford (SK On), General Motors (LGES via their Ultium JV), Stellantis (Samsung SDI in a JV), and others. In Europe, LGES and Samsung SDI operate large plants in Poland and Hungary, respectively, giving European automakers a non-Chinese source for batteries as well.
However, recent earnings reports from Korea’s major battery manufacturers indicate a cautious short-term outlook, influenced by global trade uncertainties and a temporary deceleration in electric vehicle (EV) demand. LG Energy Solution (LGES) reported a 138% increase in Q1 operating profit, attributed to favorable exchange rates and U.S. tax credits. However, the company anticipates a revenue decline in Q2, citing automakers’ hesitancy due to U.S. tariff policies. In response, LGES plans to reduce its 2025 investments by approximately 30% and has paused construction of its Arizona battery plant, opting instead to accelerate lithium iron phosphate battery production at its Michigan facility to meet growing battery energy storage systems (BESS) demand.
Samsung SDI experienced a significant downturn, with a net loss of 216 billion won in Q1, primarily due to decreased sales in EV batteries, along with lower utilization rates and higher fixed costs. The company also highlighted that upcoming U.S. tariffs are expected to increase production costs for its U.S.-made batteries, as many components are imported.
SK Innovation, the parent company of SK On, reported an unexpected operating loss of 45 billion won in Q1, with losses deepening in its battery segment amid a global economic slowdown. Despite these challenges, SK Innovation expressed cautious optimism for gradual improvement in Q2.
Collectively, these developments signify a strategic pivot among Korean battery manufacturers, with a heightened focus on battery energy storage systems (BESS) to counterbalance the volatility of the EV market. This shift underscores the industry’s adaptability in navigating geopolitical and market challenges.
While competition remains— (Japan’s Panasonic, and emergent players in Europe or U.S.), Korea’s multi-year head start, and massive ongoing investments make it likely the country’s battery champions will retain global leadership. Barring a sudden U.S.-China trade truce that removes all barriers, the structural trend of supply-chain de-Sinicization should keep Korean battery giants on a high-growth trajectory for years to come. True, this positive view is not reflected in the stock performance of Korean battery makers. That said, the repricing of battery stocks is a global phenomenon, as captured by dismal performance of the global battery ETF BATT-US.
Seoul Mate #2: Nuclear Energy
South Korea is an often-underappreciated nuclear powerhouse that is now leveraging trade realignments to its advantage. Korea’s state-backed players, led by Korea Electric Power Corp. (KEPCO) and its subsidiaries (KEPCO E&C and KEPCO KPS) plus Doosan Enerbility have decades of nuclear experience. They designed and built the APR-1400 reactors, which have a proven track record domestically and overseas (the UAE’s Barakah plant was delivered by a Korean consortium, marking the first full export of Korean reactor technology).
With global demand for nuclear new-builds on the rise (driven by energy security and decarbonization), there is a lot of room for these Korean firms to export their expertise to other markets.
The Korean government set a formal goal of exporting ten nuclear reactors by 2030, and a dedicated task force now coordinates nuclear export efforts (spanning financing, diplomacy, and technical support).
The large-cap companies positioned here include: KEPCO, which would typically take on operator roles or equity stakes in overseas projects, is the parent of reactor designer KHNP; Doosan Enerbility, the main equipment manufacturer for reactors (pressure vessels, steam generators) and a contractor for construction; and Hyundai Engineering & Construction and Samsung C&T, which bring project management and engineering expertise (the nuclear revenue for these firms is low so we kept them out of the final list).
Beyond traditional reactors, Korea is also investing in advanced nuclear technologies such as small modular reactors (SMRs). Doosan has partnered with U.S.-based NuScale to supply components for SMRs, and several Korean startups/consortia are developing their own SMR designs. The government’s inclusion of nuclear in its green taxonomy and export financing means Korean banks and funds can more easily invest in these projects, which should lower the cost of capital for nuclear projects relative to peers.
Seoul Mate #3: Air and Water Pollution Control Technologies
While high-profile sectors like batteries and nuclear power grab headlines, Korea also hosts leading companies in other environmental technologies. These firms address industrial emissions, waste management, and air/water quality. Trade tensions indirectly benefit this segment too: as China historically exported low-cost environmental equipment (e.g. basic filters, cheap sensors), its reduced global presence creates opportunities for Korean providers, especially in emerging economies looking for reliable partners to improve environmental standards.
One notable player is Samsung E&A, a large-cap engineering firm (part of Samsung Group) that has diversified into environmental projects. It designs and builds flue-gas desulfurization units (to reduce sulfur emissions at power plants), wastewater treatment facilities, and chemical recycling plants worldwide. Samsung Engineering has won contracts in the Middle East and Southeast Asia that might have otherwise gone to Chinese firms. Its revenue from environmental projects has been growing, contributing to improved profitability.
With regards to water, Korean companies have quietly become world leaders in desalination and water purification technologies. Doosan Enerbility (mentioned above) ranks among the top global desalination plant builders. Over the past decades, Doosan delivered dozens of large-scale desalination facilities in the Middle East (Saudi Arabia, UAE, Oman), leveraging its thermal desalination technology. It is now also a leader in reverse osmosis (RO) desal, often partnering with international firms.
Another major player is GS Engineering & Construction, which acquired Spain’s Inima (a water treatment specialist) a decade ago. GS E&C has since expanded in wastewater recycling and seawater desalination, operating plants in Brazil, the Middle East, and North Africa. It positions itself as a global water project developer, not just an EPC contractor, which means recurring revenue from operating concessions. This strategic shift was driven partly by the recognition that Korean firms could move up the value chain in water; historically, Western companies like Veolia won operating concessions, while Korean firms were subcontractors. Now, with more competitive financing and support, GS E&C and others can take on full project roles.
Top Picks
From a market standpoint, many of these Korean stocks have rerated upward in 2025 as investors recognize the dual themes of deglobalization beneficiary and sustainability play. Yet valuations in Korea often remain below global peers, partly due to the historical “Korea discount.”
There is room for further upside if companies continue to execute and if corporate governance reforms attract a broader investor base. For sustainability-minded investors, Korea offers a unique sweet spot: exposure to critical green technologies without the geopolitical baggage of China at reasonable valuations relative to U.S. or European pure-plays in these areas.
Based on their strong market positions and superior alignment with our selection criteria, our top three picks are: Samsung E&A (air and water treatment), Doosan Enerbility (nuclear and water infrastructure), and LG Energy Solution (batteries and energy storage).
Forestry is a key industry for sustainability and macro investors but for very different reasons. As the most important countermeasure to human carbon emissions, trees are a vital key to carbon storage. Investors with an eye on sustainability know this and have steadily allocated to forestry carbon credits.
Meanwhile for macro investors, lumber along with other commodities, acts as a bellwether for economic growth; as a major input to the (highly cyclical) construction industry. Fluctuations on lumber prices give early signals about the health of economic activity.
With this in mind, it’s not surprising that lumber prices and the related companies’ equity prices have taken it on the chin. Leadership in Washington has made it such that valuing carbon storage assets is inconsequential for now and the spike in global recession probability suggests that the demand for lumber products will weaken in the months ahead. In North America, this view is even more clouded by the current trade tensions between the U.S. and Canada, as well as Trump’s recent executive order to increase the exploitation of Federal forests.
In today’s note, we explore how deglobalization will affect the North American forestry industry. We argue that while sustainability concerns are not driving equity performance, there is a handful of sustainability leaders positioned to outperform their peers by virtue of having already reduced cross-border dependency risks.
North American Forests: Trees Aplenty
More than half of the world’s forests are located in only five countries – the Russian Federation, Brazil, Canada, U.S.A., and China. Forest cover in North America has been broadly stable over the past decade. In the U.S., forest cover has actually grown and ranks among the top ten countries for forest growth, Forest cover has shrunk slightly in Canada, due to climate change: in the late 1990s, after several relatively warm winters, a massive pine beetle infestation resulted in the loss of millions of hectares of pine forest in British Columbia over the following 15 years. In addition, more frequent and devastating wildfires have also decreased the overall forest cover in Canada.
Importantly, although not considered the most significant forests from a carbon sink perspective despite their size, North American forests nonetheless captured more carbon in 2020 than in 1990, helping to mitigate the loss of carbon sinks elsewhere. Moreover, North American forests can be considered among the most sustainable in the world, with the U.S.A. and Canada accounting for almost half of the worlds’ certified sustainable forests (note Canada far outpaces all other countries, with 167 million ha, versus 38 million ha in the U.S.).
Despite this commendable reputation, laggards do exist and can be found on both side of the U.S.-Canada border. In the table below we present sustainability leaders and laggards (note that we include companies with overlap in both wood products and pulp & paper companies).
Navigating The Lumber Trade Dispute
One major difference in forestry management, however, is that in the U.S., productive forests are generally privately owned, while in Canada they are mostly on public land. This is a major distinction that plays a part in the long-standing North American lumber dispute.
Cross-border duties are hardly a new phenomenon for the North American lumber industry. The origins of the U.S./Canada lumber dispute date back to at least the early 1980s. The U.S. claims that Canadian lumber is “unfairly” subsidized because in Canada, the prices charged to harvest timber (i.e. the stumpage fee) are set administratively by the government rather than on an open market, as is the norm in the U.S. Note that cases against Canada have been brought before the WTO, which has consistently sided with Canada.
Currently, the U.S. levies countervailing and anti-dumping duties total 14.4% and this is slated to increase later this year to 34%. This was before Trump’s tariff war. Some analysts believe that this level of duties would be as detrimental to the U.S. as it would be to Canada because the U.S. housing market “needs” Canadian softwood lumber to build homes.
We take a more nuanced view. It is true that, as the table below shows, Canadian imports account to about one quarter of total American consumption of softwood lumber and almost 30% of oriented strand board (OSB, also known as structured panels). This will be difficult to replace completely in a short period of time, but it is not insurmountable. To be sure, tree shortage is not the problem that is curtailing American production. As noted above, forest cover has increased in the U.S. over the past decade but most importantly for the industry, the supply of productive forests, especially in the U.S. south, has increased as well.
American sawmills are currently running just under 80% capacity, which is within the range of normal operations, according to government statistics. Historically, mills have been able to operate at 85% and even 90% capacity. Of course, this would require attracting workers to the job site, no doubt through higher wages. Nonetheless, a back of the envelope calculation suggests that American production could be ramped up and replace up to half of Canadian production.
Importantly, an entire decoupling of the Canadian and U.S. forestry industries is unlikely because although lumber is a commodity, products are not completely perfect substitutes. Canada’s northern climates mean that trees grow slower and are therefore denser, creating a sought-after product for specific applications versus the faster growing U.S. southern pine.
Overall, lumber is one industry where it is economically sensible to expect further “reshoring”. Alas, as Trump and his advisors are quickly discovering with the auto industry, decoupling North American trade is hardly straightforward. U.S./Canada lumber supply and demand is very integrated: both American-listed and Canadian-listed companies produce much of their products in both countries and cross the border to sell their products in the reciprocal nation.
A Forestry Pair Trade
Given this backdrop, we believe that rather than classify lumber companies according to nationality, it is more useful to rank companies by their openness, i.e. by the percent of production located outside of the jurisdiction where they sell. We rely on company reports and earnings call transcripts to determine the level of openness of the wood companies highlighted earlier, assigning each company a rating for “openness risk” in the table below.
For investors concerned about the duty and tariff risk, investing in forestry companies that combine “low openness risk” with superior sustainability scores is a laudable strategy. However, the overreaching driver of forestry companies’ returns is the economic cycle. In the event that Trump trade policy triggers a recession, even the companies that are most insulated from the application of tariffs will not escape lower lumber prices as demand diminishes. In this context, for investors eager to have exposure to the forestry sector, a pair trade strategy that reduces exposure to recession may be more suitable.
Companies like Boise Cascade that are sustainability laggards and have high tariff risk relative to their peers make good short candidates, while Weyerhaeuser and PotlatchDeltic offer superior sustainability records and are more insulated from tariff risk by virtue of having their geographic operations aligned with their end markets.
Events of the past week have left market pundits, economists and geopolitical strategists in both shock and awe in the face of U.S. trade policy and more generally, about the country’s overall policymaking process (or lack of thereof). Although the main target of the U.S.’ trade war is China (please see last week’s note), the collateral damage is far and wide.
Indeed, the endgame for the U.S. is to repatriate manufacturing to domestic soil and diffuse the threat that China could replace the U.S. as the world’s hegemon. However, success is not guaranteed, and the unwinding of the current trade regime will come at a significant cost to corporate profitability. The chart below shows U.S. profits as a share of GDP over the long-term. In 2001, China’s entry into the World Trade Organization meant that American businesses could take advantage of cheap labor and lax environmental standards: as a result, profits as a share of GDP went from a structural low of 7% in 2000 to a multi-decade high of 18% just before the global pandemic. The aggressive tariffs in place since March are meant to be sufficiently punitive to drive production back on American soil, which also means that the U.S. economy is about to stop profiting from lower production costs elsewhere. While profits as a percentage of GDP in the U.S. are now close to their World War II highs, it seems implicit that corporate profitability will decline given Trump’s tariffs policy and the uncertainty that it has created.
In this context, investors ought to pick tariff-winning companies, i.e., those companies that already produce locally or those that are offered carve-outs and/or can effectively onshore their activities to avoid the profit margin squeeze.
Interestingly, the current environment holds several parallels to what we experienced during the pandemic. In most industries, COVID-19 sparked a major turning point in operational strategy. After decades of hyper-focus on efficiency, businesses learned the value of building resilience into supply chains and operations.
From a sustainability perspective, this turning point is generally positive as shorter supply chains (i.e. more local supply chains) and the utilization of local labor pools have both environmental and social advantages. As we wrote in a note in September, 2021, “not all the supply chain hiccups encountered of late are strictly due to sustainability issues. However, many of the consistently cited global supply risks are of an environmental, social, or political nature and in all circumstances, the investment implication is always the same: there is a trade-off between operational efficiency and resilience. For the past several decades, investors have rewarded operational efficiency, but the future will increasingly favor those companies that bet on the side of resiliency”. We stand by that conclusion and although the driving forces are different, we expect that resiliency will be increasingly valued by investors and/or forced by rule.
In today’s note, we look for pockets of opportunity in our sustainability themes that will benefit from the U.S.’ efforts to repatriate manufacturing.
Sustainability Under Pressure
At SMS we have a “Long” investment universe of about 500 companies that meet sustainability criteria based on our proprietary double materiality framework. The year-to-date performance of an equal-weighted index of our universe is broadly in-line with conventional global stock indices. In other words, sustainability themes have fared no worse than the broad market despite Trump’s anti-climate measures. It is worth noting that the SMS universe has relatively less exposure to U.S. tech firms, while being highly exposed to EU and Japanese industrials – both of which were crushed during the recent selloff.
It is understandable that in the face of Trump’s cataclysmic trade policy, climate change and broader sustainability themes are not currently top of mind for investors: tariffs and the economy remain their number one priority. Nonetheless, as tectonic shifts in the global trade backdrop occur, opportunities that fit squarely within sustainability themes are being created.
Our approach to finding the “green diamonds in the rout” is to favor: 1) stocks with a limited exposure to the U.S. market that are relatively immune to the ongoing tariff war; 2) explore defensive themes less affected by the anticipated recession; and 3) look for names focused on services’ in countries outside the U.S. Here again, one should note that our starting sustainability investment universe is slightly more exposed to the U.S. market than global benchmarks.
1. Look for stocks with a limited exposure to the U.S. market that are relatively immune to the ongoing tariff war
Japan is one market that fits the bill – the Japanese stock market has a relatively low exposure to the U.S. (and the U.S. consumer in particular). Moreover, at the time of writing, President Trump has issued a 90-day reprieve on all countries that have not retaliated, basically leaving China. According to Trump, Japan is first in line to negotiate a more lasting reprieve, putting the country’s companies in a relatively better position than non-Japanese competitors. One could also expect South Korea to follow suit as a close ally to the U.S. Australia, which does not have a trade deficit with the United States, could also prove an interesting market to look for sustainability plays in the current context.
2. Explore defensive themes less affected by the anticipated recession
Exhorbitant tariff on Chinese goods means, along with a major erosion in consumer and business confidence, that there is a high chance that a global recession occurs before the end of 2025. In the face of recession risks, stocks in the renewable energy and utilities sectors look appealing: both were hit hard by the elevated yields since 2022. Moreover, one could think that the current set of policy choices in the White House, coupled with higher volatility in markets also supports companies with stable cash flows.
One idea is NextEra, which is a stable company operating in the renewable space with long-term PPAs. Another idea is First Solar. To be sure, this company is hardly considered defensive with a beta around 1.5. However, it is one of the very few solar manufacturers that do not rely on China. To the extent that solar remains even a partial solution for the U.S.’ surging energy needs, this company is well-positioned.
3. Look for names mostly focused on services’ that are less exposed to the U.S. consumer
One area of interest is engineering services. Stock prices of these companies reacted sharply to the recession risks these past few months. Nonetheless, many of these companies have business segments that are relatively recession-proof – such as infrastructure projects – since minimum maintenance and replacement of infrastructure must take place. In addition, global engineering service companies are well positioned to benefit from countries that announcing fiscal measures to ease the tariff shock (e.g., Germany, Canada and potentially others). Favored engineering service companies include AtkinsRealis, Stantec and WSP.
The Macro Picture
For the last 20 years, the global investment landscape went like this: China manufactures, the United States consume, and corporate margins increase. When financial issues come up, Central Banks save the day. We occasionally hear that inequalities are unsustainable like in “Deaths of Despair”, the 2020 book by Anne Case and Angus Deaton that details the impact of the loss of manufacturing in Middle America. While nothing happened in the past, the election of Donald Trump, who ran as a populist rule breaker, is pushing us into a transformational period, for better or worse. The chart below shows the fall in wages as a % of GDP in the United States.
Donald Trump’s support came from those that have been most negatively affected by the drop in wages. The next chart highlights that hourly workers did not reap the rewards of improved productivity.

The current US administration has identified the unsustainability of the commercial trade deficit as a key economic target to bring jobs back to the United States. This administration has an unusual style of moving fast and breaking things akin to how Sillicon Valley operates. Einstein said: “Nothing happens until something moves”. Investors underestimate the likelihood of drastic changes in the way economic relationships operate; statecraft could dominate economics. Recent tantrums like the one over the Panama Canal could be a sneak peek. The picture below highlights historical tariffs dating back to the 19th Century. 
In this context, the natural inertia of the economic and political environment should not be the base case because things are now moving. The table below highlights the likely transformation of the global investment landscape.
To expand more on statecraft: Trump clearly has his eyes set on critical minerals in Greenland, Canada, and Ukraine. Given the strategic importance of these materials, we’re not surprised they’ve caught his attention. In this changing world, metals and mining are likely to attract interest from investors, as well.
On the one hand, the U.S. wants to reshore manufacturing, build locally and maintain its technological lead with more electrical power. On the other hand, Europe recognizes the urgent need for defense and infrastructure spending. For its part, China wants to continue its manufacturing build-out. Finally, the Global South wants to build better infrastructure and move up the economic ladder. As the chart below shows, electricity consumption increases with income. Increased electricity consumption is directly linked to an increase in metals demand.

Build, build, build will imply more demand for metals -and probably some excess manufacturing capacity in the long run considering slowing demographics. The effects of climate change on the frequency and intensity of destructive climate events that require rebuild, using metals, will add to demand. Moreover, the desirability of a greener industrial base that needs modified processes requiring new infrastructure will also use more metals.
Inflation Hedge
For more than ten years after the Great Financial Crisis of 2008, policymakers grappled with how to raise inflation closer to their target (generally around 2%). As a result, central banks performed aggressive quantitative easing, but the only prices that rose were those of financial assets.
When the 2020 pandemic hit the world and budget deficits increased significantly, the inflation genie was out of the bottle and main street prices finally rose – but this time, a bit too much. Since then, inflation has remained above target in most countries and politicians are much looser with public purses. When we examine the table above that lists the changing world drivers (reshoring, defense, infrastructure, inward focus, increasing electricity demand), we anticipate the next 5-10 years to be inflationary.
At the same time, while most large investors are trend followers (even if they will not admit to it), most have very little exposure to inflation hedges. Some argue that equities are a strong inflation hedge even if popular equity indices are heavily weighted in technology and communication which have both have very long duration – probably not very good inflation hedges. However, they have close to no exposure to commodities or mining, which are strong inflation hedges. The chart below highlights the evolution of metals prices compared to U.S. inflation since the 1970’s. As we can see, there are long periods of divergence, but in the long run, metals have been good inflation hedges.
Sustainable Mining
Mining has long been associated with environmental degradation; However, regulatory pressure, investor scrutiny, and growing consumer demand for ethically sourced materials are pushing companies to adopt cleaner technologies and more responsible mining practices. The Towards Sustainable Mining (TSM) Protocol, developed by the Mining Association of Canada (MAC), is one of the most recognized frameworks for improving mining sustainability. Adopted by countries, including Argentina, Australia, Brazil, Finland and Mexico, it provides a structured approach for companies to measure, report, and improve their environmental and social performance. It focuses on key sustainability areas such as: climate change mitigation through carbon reduction, indigenous and community engagement, water stewardship, tailing management and biodiversity conservation.
Another major shift is how the electrification of mining operations has enabled digitization and greater automation, which through improved efficiency help to reduce waste and energy consumption. Technologies like artificial intelligence and real time monitoring also help optimize resource extraction, minimizing environmental impact.
Supply and Demand for Critical Minerals
The last period of investor excitement for mining was during the 2000s, when China industrialized. But now, governments have a renewed interest in mining. Worried about China’s dominance in metals processing, governments in the US, Canada, the EU, India, the UK and Australia have created lists and strategies for critical minerals. The table below shows the supply and demand outlook for the main minerals that appear on most critical minerals lists.
Considering the supply and demand outlook and the uses of the different minerals, we have created a an attractiveness ranking that shows our subjective view of the most desirable metals. Copper, uranium, silver figure at the top of our list. We assume that import constraints will be put on metals dominated by China, like rare earths, lithium, manganese and graphite. This will make these more attractive.
Which Companies Stand Out
Considering our positive outlook on metals, we identified global sustainable companies involved in the mining the critical minerals listed in the previous chart. The table below highlights these companies alongside the metals they produce.
Looking at the financials of those companies, our next step is to assess profitability, leverage and sustainability for each company as can be seen from the picture below. The starting point for all of those companies is decent: They have positive margins with reasonable debt levels except for Eramet and Impala. Investment in mining remains tricky and cannot rely only on financial ratios because the quality of the assets is paramount for future profitability.
Canada remains the most active market for mining companies looking to raise funds. Even so, the lack of interest in mining has resulted in companies moving their listings out of Canada to attract Chinese capital, which has been the only game in town for the past 10 years. Considering our view that Canada will remain a very strong player in the mining space, we did a similar analysis for Canadian companies and the metals they cover.
Most of those companies are profitable (Hudbay and First Quantum, not so much) and have decent leverage.
Our view is that higher commodity prices will lift all boats and rekindle interest in mining. If prices do not increase as much as we expect, finding the right companies is critical because they will create value even if commodity prices remain stable.
At a time when some sustainability themes face headwinds, water offers stability. While funding for some “green” initiatives is at risk of being reduced, water will remain a priority as it is an essential resource with no substitute. Regardless of corporate “Water Positive” commitments, businesses need reliable supply for their operations. And ensuring a secure supply is paramount for countries’ citizens and industry; water infrastructure will continue to receive investment. We note the allocation of €500 billion for infrastructure in Germany’s historic spending bill, some of which is sure to go to the nation’s water woes. Trump is also wading in; part of the appeal of Canada as a 51st state is its abundance of freshwater.
Across the globe, freshwater supply is already challenged. Projections by the Global Commission on the Economics of Water show demand will outpace supply by 40% by 2030 (that is just five years away!). The map below shows current annual water risk. Unfortunately, demand is set to increase: The rapid expansion of AI use and data centres is adding pressures and the reshoring of industry in the wake of peak globalization will further compound the problem. Moreover, it is not just a question of quantity, but also quality – note the new PFAS regulations introduced in the U.S. last year.

Source: Aqueduct Water Risk Atlas
These challenges create a broad set of investment opportunities across our water theme, from utilities to advanced water technologies. The SMS water theme has performed relatively well over the past three years (see table below) and shown resilience in the turmoil of the first quarter of 2025 – up +3.10% versus the global index -0.15% year-to-date.
We have written several notes on water, notably on smart water technologies (The Digital Water Revolution, June 17, 2021), and innovations in water treatment (Drowning in Denial, March 30, 2023). In this note, we focus our attention on a water sub-sector which is very attractive in the current market environment where economic and policy uncertainty is rising: water utilities.
Stable Currents: The Water Utility Leaders
As discussed in our latest quarterly macro outlook: Macro Meets Sustainability: Outlook for Q2 2025 and Beyond (March 13, 2025), sectors with defensive characteristics are attractive in the current economic context. Water utility companies fit this description, offering stable cash flows and strong dividends along with a key advantage: the ability to pass through infrastructure investments and rising costs. This creates a well-timed investment opportunity as capex on upgrades will translate to higher rates in the future.
Publicly traded water utility companies with a sizable market cap (at least 1 billion USD) are concentrated in the United States, the UK and Brazil. Other utilities operating in the water sector do exist but have energy, or some other segment, as their primary business. For the purpose of this note, we exclude these energy-water utilities from our analysis. Companies with majority state ownership are also excluded.
Sink or Swim: Water Utilities’ Debt
Debt is an important consideration for water utility companies as it is used to finance infrastructure improvements. Of course, this means investors should be mindful of the interest rate environment when assessing opportunities. Our economic outlook for a stagflation scenario (lower growth, higher inflation) means that interest rates are likely to be less aggressive than in 2022; moreover, higher inflation tends to be passed through via regulated utility rate increases, further enhancing the appeal of these investments.
SABESEP has the lowest debt-to-equity of all the companies in our table. Prior to July 2024, the Sao Paulo State Government had 50% ownership in SABESAP facilitating access to low interest public financing. Sao Paolo State has since reduced its stake to 18%. UK water utilities have much higher Debt-to-Equity ratios, partly due to their national regulatory framework that encourages more borrowing to finance infrastructure investments. This has led to issues for UK water utilities; most notable is the debt scandal embroiling private company Thames Water. In contrast, rate setting frameworks in the U.S. tend to be more conservative, typically using a “cost-of-service” model that sets rates based on incurred costs. This difference is also reflected in the higher betas of UK water companies. SABESP also has higher beta versus American utilities, reflecting the risks of emerging market volatility. It is also subject to a more complex rate-setting mechanism. Given these differences, we prefer the stability of American water utilities in the current context.
Open the Taps: Growth Beyond Rate Increases
Aside from rate increases, water utilities can achieve growth through M&A and enrolling new customers. The U.S. is a bigger prospective market for M&A deals since their water system remains fragmented with many operators in regional monopolies. American Water Works is the standout for its M&A activity. As the largest player, it has been the most active in pursuing acquisitions by far.
M&A activity among UK companies is lower. Only Pennon Group and Severn Trent had any acquisitions in the last five years, totalling four and three, respectively. The single deal for SABESP in the same period was a minority stake.
American Water Works is also the most geographically diverse. Since rates are regulated at the state level, this diversification is advantageous in that the company is not subject to one single rate decision. SJW only operates in four states but offers exposure to Texas, one of the fastest growing states in terms of population. The majority of regulated revenues for California Water Services and American States Water co. are highly concentrated in California.
The Infrastructure Imperative
Investing in infrastructure upgrades is essential to ensuring supply, addressing inefficiencies like leaks and improving water and wastewater treatment. Due to aging infrastructure, significant capital investments are expected. The American Society of Civil Engineers’ latest infrastructure report card grades the U.S. infrastructure for Drinking Water, Stormwater and Wastewater as C, D and D+ respectively. The report also projects a persistent funding gap over the next ten years, which could prompt federal and state initiatives. Existing support from the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act will expire in 2026.
For their part, American water utilities are already announcing increases in their capital expenditure compared to previous years. The chart below shows the American water utility companies with the highest and lowest FWD P/E ratios; this rank has generally persisted throughout the presented history. While valuations for these companies remain elevated, they reflect expectations for growth that will be driven by these infrastructure investments, which will be passed on to customers through rate increases. Note that rate adjustments must be approved by state level regulatory boards; but the regulatory backdrop looks favorable. Each of the companies touted revenue increases from rate case outcomes in 2024 with positive outlooks for decisions to come.
The opening months of 2025 have seen market swings, volatility spikes and ripening conditions for a bear market. Politics and geopolitics have taken central stage and will drive investment outcomes for sustainability portfolios for the remainder of the year and beyond. In this installment of our quarterly update on Macro Meets Sustainability, we argue that despite the noise emanating from Washington, in terms of concrete policy action, the euro area’s recent (fiscal) policy moves are the more significant market driver. We also underscore our view, outlined in several recent notes, that global inflation risks are rising while economic growth momentum is slowing, creating a stagflationary environment. The implication is that the rotation to defensive sectors and to euro area stocks has further to go.
U.S. Noise and Euro Area Action
Contrary to mainstream media and financial pundits, our observation is that U.S. policy changes have underwhelmed so far in 2025; the biggest surprises and significant policy action have occurred in the euro area:
In the U.S., the daily headlines of federal firings, deportations, and tariff threats means the Trump’s administration occupies most of the space. However, what has actually been accomplished on any of these fronts?
In terms of DOGE, it’s difficult to know exactly how many layoffs have taken place but estimates of federal job separations in February were about 60 000, an insignificant number in an economy that employs over 160 million people. To be sure, the immeasurable loss of experience in federal institutions is lamentable and sows the seeds for challenges in the future. However, the impact on economic activity in the near term is likely to be very low.
Meanwhile, although much has been threatened, tariffs imposed on trading partners are so far only slightly more punitive than what occurred during Trump’s first term, which had little impact on overall global activity. The range of possibilities on what comes next is extremely wide, but a pattern has emerged whereby U.S. tariff barks have been worse than the bites.
Finally, while we continue to believe that over time, the level of illegal (and legal) immigration to the U.S. will be aggressively curbed, ICE is operating with the same budget that it had on Jan. 19. This suggests that it is highly unlikely that the government’s targets of over 1000 arrests per day are even close to being met; only the most migrant worker-dependent sectors like agriculture will feel the near-term impacts of current U.S. immigration policy.
In contrast, the threats and proclamations of the Trump administration have been sufficient to shake European policymakers out of their torpor as they seem to be working with renewed vigor. On Tuesday, the German parliament approved Chancellor Merz’s plan to spend up to €1 trillion in coming years on infrastructure and defense. EUR500B is earmarked for infrastructure and green initiatives. This massive spending deal means that just the infrastructure fund alone adds over 1% to GDP over the next decade, even without applying a fiscal multiplier (i.e. positive knock-on effect). Added on to this is the announcement in early March by Ursula von der Leyen that the new “ReArm Europe” investment plan will unlock a €150 billion loan scheme to help Member States invest in key military capabilities.
Our key takeaway is that while investors must stay attuned to possible impacts on global growth and financial markets stemming from the U.S., so far in 2025, realized policy activity has been more significant in Europe than in North America. This provides at least a partial foundation for why we expect the outperformance of euro area equities to continue for the next few quarters.
It’s Still The Economy, Stupid
Although it is well known that financial markets respond poorly to economic and policy uncertainty, the current instability in risk assets can not be solely attributed to uncertainty arising from Trump’s leadership style (described as “flooding the zone”). Indeed, U.S. economic growth was losing momentum well before Trump moved into the White House, and earnings expectations were also ratcheting down prior to Trump’s inauguration.
One very well-known and favored indicator is the economic surprise index, which tracks the strength of incoming data relative to expectations. In the U.S., the economic surprise index peaked in November and is now in negative territory, meaning that data is weaker than forecasted. In the euro area the indicator displays the opposite trend (data is surprising to the upside). The chart below shows the surprise indicator for the U.S.
Of course, the above analysis is only useful in that it helps explain what has already happened. However, in the U.S. there is likely to be more months of negative surprises before an inflection point is reached because economic surprise indices tend to be mean-reverting and swing in regular patterns – it takes time for expectations adjust to economic reality.
Beyond this, there are three reasons we expect that the environment for euro area stocks will support continued performance for the next few quarters:
1. More room for fiscal and monetary support outside of the U.S.: though it’s unknown to what extent Trump’s ambitions will translate into action, the direction of travel on virtually all of his stated plans translates to: more inflation and less growth in the near-term. We have written about the inflationary impulse in previous notes (for example, see “Food Fight: Policy’s Effect on Food Producers & Inflation”, February 13, 2025 and “Playing the Trump Card”, November 21, 2024) and the Fed’s updated FOMC projections yesterday are very much in line with our view. In plain language, Federal Reserve Chair Jay Powell acknowledged that further progress on inflation was likely to be “delayed for the time being”. The corollary is that the U.S. Federal Reserve may not have the leeway to loosen monetary policy given its 2% inflation target. Indeed, the OECD recently updated its inflation forecasts. With assumptions about future tariffs, the inflationary impact is strongest in North America.
As discussed above, Germany is already forging a new path for fiscal policy and we expect other countries with the fiscal space will follow suit, whether it be in the form of relief to businesses to offset the tariff shock (as announced in Canada) or to raise defense spending.
2. Euro area sustainability stocks still trade at a discount relative to their U.S. counterparts. Euro area stocks have been comparatively cheap for years, but the recent divergence in price performance has done little to correct this gap. This is also true for the Sustainable Market Strategies’ sustainability universe. The average forward P/E for euro area stocks in our universe is 18 compared to 29 for the U.S.
3. The U.S. has Mag 7, but the euro area has defense stocks. The U.S. equity outperformance streak in 2023-2024 was without a doubt characterized by a strong tailwind emanating from the Magnificent 7 stocks and a bubble for everything artificial intelligence. China’s Deepseek helped to burst the bubble earlier this year. In contrast, we believe the prime candidate for a future “bubble” sector in the euro area is still in full swing. As we wrote in a recent note, “The European Defense Offensive: From Peace Dividend to War Premium”, the European Commission has recently unveiled an ambitious plan to mobilize approximately $840 billion to bolster the EU’s collective defense capabilities. There is a clear bias for European countries to invest in European defense companies, and despite the near parabolic rise in the biggest defense names, there are still several companies with moderate valuations that satisfy our strict sustainability criteria. But even for investors that do not wish to be long defense companies, the “euphoria” surrounding this sector will likely lift related stocks, especially euro area industrials. On this basis, just as the U.S. tech sector is becoming a drag on broad U.S. equity indices, the bull market in the euro area defense sector could boost European indices.
In sum, despite the fact that geopolitical tensions are emanating from the U.S. and onto the rest of the world, we expect that euro area stocks will continue to outperform.
Defensive Rotation Is Justified
Stocks in defensive sectors like health care, consumer staples and utilities outperform when uncertainty is high and/or when recession risks are elevated because it is difficult to cut back on essential spending.
From a sustainability standpoint these sectors are often appealing because underlying products and services can create positive impact on individual lives. In recent weeks, we have written notes on two of these critical sectors – health care and food staples – and how sustainability investors should maintain a postive bias in this space despite needing to navigate the ongoing policy crosscurrents. Developments over the past few weeks only serve to strengthen our conviction. Interestingly, euro area stock markets tend to have a greater exposure to defensive sectors (healthcare is about 16% in the Eurostoxx 600 index versus 10% in the S&P 500), which also helps to explain some of the European outperformance in recent weeks.
The election of Donald Trump and the resurgence of European populist parties does not augur well for global policy regarding environmental challenges. Trump already pulled the U.S. out of the Paris 2015 Climate Accord (again) and started rolling back most of Biden’s environmental regulations of the past four years. In Europe, the European Commission watered down its ambition as it looks to impose the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM, see our note “Carbon Protectionism: Winners and Losers under EU’s Carbon Border Plan”, July 25, 2024). In this context, some investors and carbon market participants are already asking whether regulated carbon markets – both in Europe and in North America – are poised to end.
Many speculators – mostly financial market participants, as opposed to regulated entities – have indeed left the market these past few months looking for better return opportunities elsewhere. Looking at recent carbon market auction data from the California Air Resource Board (CARB), one sees that the share of “voluntarily associated bidding entities” (i.e. speculators) was lower at the end of 2024 if compared to 2022-2023 averages. This has pressured carbon prices lower.

Why is the WCI Carbon Markets so Attractive?
While market sentiment and recent price-action of global regulated carbon markets have been negative lately, carbon market fundamentals remain strong – which is mostly true in North America. Interestingly, EU ETS market has been less affected by the current political environment in the U.S. and Canada than its WCI counterpart, which could explain the relative resilience in the price of EU emission allowances vis-à-vis those traded in the WCI market. That being said, current woes of the German industrial sector – a key player in EU emissions – could also mean that there will be less upwards price pressure on EUAs in in the coming years vis-à-vis WCI allowances.
This is why we think that the most interesting investment opportunities can be currently found in the Québec-California market. First, North American carbon markets are trading close to their regulated floor price. To this end, the most recent WCI auction (on February 19th) shows that the current price of $29.27 (a $2.64 decrease from the previous auction in November 2024) is just $3.40 above the 2025 Reserve Price.
Second, Québec and California issued fairly ambitious and restrictive emission reduction targets in the Fall of 2024 (good for carbon prices) for the period going up to 2030. While market rules for the post-2030 period have been delayed because of wildfires and a tough political environment (tariffs on Québec industrial exports), both Québec and California should publish them later this year, which should provide support for higher prices going forward.
Third, states like Washington – who are toying with the idea of linking their market with the WCI – are not afraid to buck the current political trend and press ahead with their climate ambitions.
Fourth, while the price of carbon – and its “social acceptability” – has been negatively affected by the current political context, many of the U.S. and Europe’s “Big Businesses” – most of them being regulated entities – are re-iterating their preference for keeping a price on carbon.
Finally, one could think that energy demand coming from AI data usage added to the reshoring of industrial activities in North America in many sectors required to comply with emission reductions should also put a floor on carbon prices going forward.
Could Populism Kill Carbon Markets?
In theory, both California and Quebec could eliminate their carbon market; in practice they won’t. That’s because those jurisdictions would probably have to repay emission rights holders – or else face a series of costly lawsuits, such as the one initiated under NAFTA’s Chapter 11 by Koch Industries against Government of Ontario in 2020. In that, the idea of repaying emission rights holders for the value of their carbon credits in the current fiscal context seems unfeasible.
After all, carbon markets, both in Europe and North America, have been in operation for more than a decade. For businesses, this means that some regulated industry participants have built a significant vested interest in these markets over time. Companies such as Tesla, which has reaped a USD 10 billion windfall from the sales of its carbon credits since 2017, are still seeing their revenues being bankrolled by the value of their carbon credits.
Turning to governments, many jurisdictions are seeing carbon markets as a precious source of revenue in times of fiscal consolidation. According to the World Bank, the EU and governments of California and Québec have respectively collected USD 160, 21 and 6 billion worth of cumulated fiscal revenue since 2018 through their carbon pricing schemes.
In all, the most likely course of action is that carbon markets are here to stay – even if we could expect them to be somewhat less buoyant than what was expected in 2024 due to current political headwinds. Other risk factors could come from the prevalence of natural disasters such as the recent wildfires in California – which have delayed rule making with regard to carbon market for the post 2030 period - and the fact that elevated carbon prices could be perceived as contributing to higher cost of living for consumers - notably through higher food and energy prices. In Europe more specifically, difficulties in in the industrial sector amid the need to produce more energy domestically (e.g. natural gas, coal) could also reduce policymakers’ appetite to make carbon markets more stringent than what was planned.