Trains – or at least train stations – were back in the news last week when Trump and his team made a high-profile seizure of Washington’s Union station. This act, as part of the federal government’s bid to exert more power over the nation’s capital, overshadowed what we deem as far more important activity: the launch of a new fleet of high-speed trains that will service the U.S.’ northeast and reduce emissions on these routes by over 50%.
Trains are a fantastic way to move people (and goods) and the Acela Washington launch is just the tip of the iceberg. All over the world, there has been an uptick in interest to build passenger rail.
Take Germany for example, where in March, the government announced a historic € 500 billion infrastructure bill with a significant portion earmarked for rail. Over half of the spending announced for 2025 targets upgrading the country’s aging railway system. Amidst increased urbanization, this low-carbon mode of transportation is a politically attractive solution – good for the public and good for the environment. Furthermore, with ongoing shifts in global trade, freight rail is also primed for upgrades to adapt to new supply chains and/or support rising domestic manufacturing.
These developments signal a renewed focus on both passenger and freight rail and investment opportunities abound among the companies that supply the rail equipment, systems and services for the next generation of rail projects.
Full Speed Ahead on Passenger Rail Projects
The trend in global urbanization persists (see chart below). Currently, 50% of the global population lives in cities, and this is expected to increase to 70% by 2050 – adding 2.5 billion urban residents. Expanding automobile use accordingly is neither practical nor sustainable.
In high-income countries, momentum is building for upgrading passenger rail systems as a solution to congestion from growing sprawl. Remote work has reshaped ridership and also increased the demand for semi-regular longer distance commutes. For example, Canada announced federal backing for a 1000km high-speed rail line connecting Toronto to Quebec City, a corridor inhabited by roughly half of Canada’s population. Meanwhile, the U.S. has begun construction of its first high-speed rail network in California, with other lines in the works.
In Europe, governments are modernizing mature networks. The UK is re-nationalizing three operators to improve reliability; France has opened SNCF tracks to competitors (albeit under strict conditions); and Eurostar is planning an expansion to Frankfurt and Geneva to meet growing demand for low-emission travel. The EU’s Smart Mobility Strategy aims to double high-speed traffic by 2030 and build a trans-European network (TEN-T) with dedicated funding. Italy’s new rail plan is an early beneficiary.
India and China are also investing heavily in rail because it is seen as a means to meet climate goals. Though not discussed in our recent China green tech note, the country is a global rail leader with over 45 000 km of high-speed track installed and a target of 60 000 km by 2030.
In developing countries, leapfrogging car-focused urban development through quality public transit networks has both economic and environmental benefits. Intra-city systems will be prioritized over long-distance lines, but this is still beneficial for equipment makers, as many offer both large- and small-scale systems.
This abundance of projects bodes well for engineering companies as well as rail equipment makers.
The Next Stop for Freight Rail
For freight rail, geopolitical tensions are spurring investment. China is funding construction of a new rail route that bypasses Russia to secure its access to European markets. The U.S., meanwhile, is investing $500 million in Africa’s Lobito corridor, a key supply line for critical minerals such as copper.
North America’s domestic freight rail industry is being reshaped by further consolidation. In July, it was announced that Union Pacific will buy Norfolk Southern – pending regulatory approval – and there are rumors of a CSX-BNSF merger. This would reduce the number of major Class I U.S. rail operators to just four. Greater concentration offers pricing power, cost savings and efficiency gains with single-operator coast-to-coast routes. With stronger margins, rail operators may have more capital to invest in modernization – investments which could also serve to strengthen competitiveness with trucking.
Indeed, competition with trucking is one of the greatest challenges for freight rail in Europe. Rail’s share of freight transport in the EU-27 has stagnated around 12% in recent years (see chart below), hampered by cross-border interoperability issues, slower speeds, and aging infrastructure. The EU has made freight rail a key part of its Green Deal targets, aiming to boost the rail share of total freight transport to 30% by 2030. Reaching this target will require significant investment in the form of improved routes, infrastructure upgrades and adoption of advanced digital systems.
Rail Suppliers: The Golden Ticket
With the acceleration of global demand for improved rail networks, we see the more compelling investment opportunities among the companies supplying the technology, equipment and infrastructure for these projects. Investing directly in rail operators is less attractive: they face greater exposure to economic downturns (weaker passenger and freight volumes), high capital requirements to remain competitive and limited revenue diversification. As we wrote in a past note (The Freight Rail Industry is a Trainwreck, April 6, 2023), ESG challenges also weigh on operators, especially freight. As detailed in the following chart, rail equipment companies have outperformed rail operators and equity indices over the last three years.
In contrast to operators, suppliers benefit from a steadier growth outlook, as modernization and expansion remain priorities regardless of the short-term economic cycle. Furthermore, many large projects are supported by private-public partnerships. We find opportunities in two categories: infrastructure builders and equipment providers.
Infrastructure builders: Global engineering and infrastructure firms with strong rail expertise stand to benefit from the planned boom in rail investment. North American engineering firms such as AtkinsRealis, AECOM and Jacobs Solutions, along with European majors Vinci and Ferrovial, have established track records in delivering large-scale rail projects, which make them well-positioned to win contracts. The appeal of these large players extends beyond rail; their businesses also tap long-term infrastructure demand, offering investors exposure to multiple infrastructure themes. We have written in past notes about the appeal of engineering companies in the context of aging infrastructure, most importantly for climate adaptation, water and the electricity grid.
Equipment providers. Alstom, Wabtec, and Siemens are the three major Western players in rail equipment (CRRC Corp, a Chinese company, is the largest but derives nearly 90% of revenues from China). Each exhibits strong geographic diversification. Alstom and Wabtec are rail pure plays, while at Siemens, rail accounts for 15% of revenues (the German conglomerate’s other business segments are healthcare and industrial machinery and are appealing revenue diversifiers).
Suppliers Knorr-Bremse and Vossloh – both listed in Germany – provide specialized rail components. Knorr-Bremse’s focus is on railcar systems for braking, communication, safety and more. Vossloh offers various solutions for rail tracks serving a global client base. Though smaller than the railcar manufacturers, these companies can benefit from maintenance and upgrades for recurring demand.
Performance-wise, the equipment providers have outpaced the S&P 500 and global equity indices in the past year and valuations are in line with these broader indices (Vossloh experienced a significant surge after the announcement of Germany’s infrastructure bill in March).
Real assets are uniquely positioned to thrive in a higher inflation environment because they derive revenue from long-term contracts or have built-in inflation pass-through mechanisms. Whether it’s regulated utilities with tariff escalators, toll roads indexed to inflation, or real estate entities adjusting rents upward, their cash flows tend to preserve purchasing. Moreover, these assets often own tangible, hard infrastructure that can reprice in line with rising input costs, providing both income stability and inflation protection for investors. On top, they have underperformed over the last five years.
Demand for real assets is poised to strengthen as investors seek stable, long-term cash flows with pricing power against a backdrop of chronic undersupply, following decades of underinvestment in real assets outside of China. Real assets align with sustainable investors’ goal by being involved in the energy transition, urban development and digitalization.
Moving away from 2% inflation
During the 2010s, inflation in advanced economies consistently undershot central banks’ 2% targets. Structural factors such as globalization, geopolitical stability and subdued wage growth kept price pressures muted. This led to accommodative monetary policy and historically low interest rates as policymakers were concerned about disinflation and the risk of inflation remaining too low. As the chart below shows, since 2020, the backdrop has shifted dramatically. A combination of pandemic-related supply disruptions leading to expansive fiscal stimulus and the reversal of structural factors such as demographics, de-globalization and geopolitical instability have pushed inflation well above 2%.
Moreover, the recent firing of the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) commissioner following a weaker-than-expected payroll report underscores the risks of politicizing economic data and undermines the perceived neutrality of the U.S.’s economic reporting agency. Inflation is one area where the temptation to tamper with the data is greatest: social security outlays are often tied to inflation and central banks target inflation. Nudging official inflation numbers lower would reduce the cost of social security and could lower interest rates to decrease the interest cost of the debt.
Recent actions by President Trump leads us to believe that coercive actions to let the inflation target drift higher than 2% by keeping interests rate lower are likely to take place in the United States while the outlook for inflation seems tilted to the upside.
Outlook for Inflation: Upward Pressure
The table below highlights the drivers most likely to influence inflation in the future. The majority of these are likely to push inflation higher over the next five years unless artificial intelligence (AI) provides enough productivity gains to offset a shrinking labor force, re-industrialization, tariffs and growing geopolitical tensions.
Higher inflation combined with political pressure to keep interest rates low could propel a real assets recovery.
What are real assets?
At their core, real assets are tied to physical, tangible infrastructures that provide essential services. Because of their underlying economic function, they tend to offer stable and predictable cash flows, often supported by regulated pricing frameworks or long-term contracts. This income stability allows many real asset companies to maintain attractive dividend yields, making them appealing to investors seeking current income alongside potential capital appreciation. Because of the relative predictability of their cash flows, they generally carry more debt than most companies.
Another defining feature of real assets is their sensitivity to macroeconomic conditions, particularly inflation and interest rates. The long-duration nature of their cash flows means valuations can be pressured when rates rise, but the essential nature of their services often provides inflation pass-through mechanisms. This makes them valuable as a hedge against inflation, while their tangible asset base offers downside protection in periods of market stress. Furthermore, many of these assets align closely with long-term themes such as decarbonization, elder care and digitalization, often giving them defensive qualities and exposure to secular growth drivers and sustainability themes.
Sustainable Real Assets
The table below highlights how real assets are represented throughout economic sectors and how they can contribute sustainably to society.
A Sample Portfolio of the Best Aligned Companies
We single out one company in each economic segment that has the best combination of sustainability scores (using CSRHub) and alignment to sustainability according to our proprietary SMS Sustainability Alignment percentage that reflects revenue assigned to sustainability themes. As we can see from the graphic below, the companies have much better scores and alignment than the median market company.
Is the rough patch behind us?
Below are performance charts for the stock price for each real asset segment compared to a World equity Index since 2020. Very few of the companies have been able to outperform the market Index. The main reason is that interest rates were rising during the period (in response to higher inflation). Since 2023, the overall market has recovered but, for real assets, the negative effects of higher interest rates continue to be felt.
Looking specifically at each segment, starting with the sustainable environmental infrastructure companies selected, performance has been positive albeit has lagged the world index. The company Waste Management is the exception, benefitting from exceptional operational efficiency, organic growth and a good acquisition strategy.
Transportation has been having difficulties since 2022.
Social infrastructure has generally done better, especially Ensign which is providing post-acute care. It has expanded rapidly while delivering from an operational basis to a population getting older.
For natural capital and digital infrastructure, Weyerhaeuser, SBA Communications and Digital Realty have lagged the market.
Finally, to round out to 20 companies, we added a group of diversified names that operate across a few segments of real assets. Increasing interest rates have been especially difficult for them but they have been recovering lately.
Why invest now
As articulated above, the path of least resistance is higher inflation that will not be fought too hard by central banks. This should benefit companies with pricing power insulated from inflation that can tolerate a relatively high debt load.
Below is a table comparing an equal-weight portfolio of the sustainable companies we identified with a global index. The portfolio delivers greater dividends, has a lower return on equity and a higher debt load than the broad market. In other words, inflation with a weak central bank response should be a good recipe for this portfolio.
As the effects of climate change go from being a worry for the future to a problem for the here and now, dealing with heat is one of the most frequently experienced challenges. Heat stress is the leading cause of weather-related deaths – as extreme heat now claims more lives annually than hurricanes, floods, or any other natural hazard combined. Heatwaves and prolonged excess heat conditions are increasing in frequency, duration, intensity, and magnitude, turning what was once an occasional threat into a persistent and deadly climate risk.
The necessity for improved cooling solutions runs across economic sectors and industrial processes, however, there are three areas whereby the need for cooling is rising at a particularly fast clip: buildings, food supply and data centres. Each of these sectors have unique challenges.
1. Keeping Cool Inside
According to the IEA, by 2050, there will be 1.5 billion more air conditioners in operation than there is today, driven by the need to combat extreme heat. Unsurprisingly, the increase in use of air conditioning will also have an impact on global emissions, unless energy efficient solutions are deployed.
In most places, heat pumps are a better solution than simple air conditioning because they offer both cooling and heating and are more energy efficient thus offering lower operating costs and emissions.
Fortunately, heat pump technology has made impressive strides in efficiency and ability since our last note on cooling in 2022 (please see, Some Like It Cold, August 4, 2022). Much of the improvement has occurred due to a necessity to comply with more stringent regulatory requirements. For example, updated energy efficiency requirements in the U.S. came into effect in 2023. The outcome of this regulation is that HVAC companies offer more heat pump solutions that are not only more efficient in diverse temperature zones but are also suitable to a wider range of construction types (e.g. retrofits, multi-story buildings, etc.). To the extent that the regulatory backdrop can be a driver of innovation, it should be a relief to investors that last week U.S. Congress vociferously pushed back on the White House’s ambitions to eliminate the Energy Star efficiency rating program, which sets efficiency standards for a range of products and materials, including air conditioners and heat pumps.
Heat pump improvements are not only good for reducing emissions, it’s also been good for portfolio returns. Indeed, investors could be forgiven for mistaking the 5-year returns of “boring” HVAC company Comfort Systems (FIX) with tech super star NVIDIA.
To be sure, FIX’s phenomenal stock performance stands out among large HVAC players. While peers have benefitted from rising demand for cooling, FIX has gained outsized momentum – particularly from its exposure to data center cooling and modular infrastructure. In addition to mechanical services (heating, cooling, plumbing, etc.), the company also runs a significant electrical business, which has grown steadily alongside the bull market in electrification. Nonetheless, HVAC companies that are considered more pure plays have also fared well and continue to offer decent value (see the table below).
2. Food Supply
Cold chains are essential to preserve and maintain the suitability of foods such as fruits, vegetables, dairy, etc. According to recent data by the FAO, roughly 13% of total food production is wasted through spoilage, due in large part to inadequate refrigeration. This food waste could theoretically feed 950 million people a year if access to refrigeration was possible.
Most importantly, investing in refrigeration solutions actually reduces overall GHG emissions. Not only is food waste a huge lost opportunity to feed more people, but it is also a significant contributor to GHG emissions and overall environmental degradation. The EPA estimates that each year in the U.S. alone, food loss and waste equals the annual CO2 emissions of 42 coal-fired power plants. This does not include the significant methane emissions from food waste rotting in landfills.
The need for energy efficient, widespread cold supply chain networks is accelerating, in part because of rising temperatures and due to the increasing desire of countries to stockpile food to improve resilience and crisis management capabilities (in the EU, for example, cold chains are being considered as critical infrastructure.
There are only a handful of publicly traded companies that could be considered cold chain pure plays. Americold (COLD) is an American real estate investment trust (REIT), which owns and operates temperature-controlled warehouses for frozen and perishable food. Lineage (LINE) is a similar REIT, though with operations slightly more diversified outside of the U.S. LINE was the biggest U.S. IPO of 2024 but both companies have significantly underperformed global equity benchmarks (see the chart below) in the past year.
Cold chain REITs have also underperformed diversified REITs in recent months, not least because of U.S. tariff uncertainty. Many food importers have curtailed shipments to the U.S., reducing the need for temperature-controlled warehouses (the chart below shows how total food and beverage import – of which an important subset must be chilled or frozen – have slowed since tariff talk has warmed up).
- Data Centres
Efficient cooling systems play a critical role in a myriad of industrial operations including manufacturing, chemical reactions, data processing: essentially anything that generates significant heat. But far and away the recent game changer is the scaling up of data centres due to the increased usage of artificial intelligence. Data centres produce huge quantities of heat – a typical large data centre can generate 20 to 50 MW of heat, while a data centre campus can generate up to 300 MW – the equivalent of powering a mid-sized city.
But for the most part, we don’t power mid-size cities with heat from data centres (though there are a few exceptions like here and here). Excess heat is not captured and there are huge costs associated with cooling data centres to avoid heat-induced equipment failure. Indeed, cooling costs represent a significant portion of overall operational expenses and can account for 40% or more of a data centre’s total energy consumption.
Cooling options fall under either air or water cooling and the most common modes include:
- Air conditioning: units circulate chilled air through raised floors or overhead ducts to cool IT equipment. Power-hungry fans are used to distribute the cool air around the data hall and through the servers to remove their heat.
- Chillers: Chillers generate cold water, which is then circulated through pipes to absorb heat from servers and other hardware.
- Direct to Chip Cooling: Cold water generated by chillers is circulated directly to chips or components via pipes to absorb heat efficiently.
- Liquid Immersion Cooling: Servers are submerged in large tanks filled with cold liquid to absorb and transfer heat away from the hardware.
- Precision Liquid Cooling: Coolant is applied directly to components, offering efficient heat transfer and reducing energy consumption.
Both air and water cooling have environmental drawbacks. Air cooling consumes no water, but significantly more energy and is the major source of CO2 emissions for data centres that use this method of cooling, particularly where the carbon intensity of the power grids is high. The main (obvious) problem with water cooling methods is that, with the exception of closed loop systems where water is recycled, water waste is enormous – according to a Bank of America study last year, data centres are now the tenth largest industry for water consumption.
Historically, almost all data centres used air cooling but increasingly, water is being used. Since all major companies host data centres with legacy operations, investors that are keen to understand the environmental impacts – as well as the dependency on nature – of data centres need to track two measures: water usage effectiveness and power usage effectiveness.
- Water Usage Effectiveness (WUE) measures the amount of water used to cool the facility’s equipment and is calculated as the ratio of the data centre’s annual water use to the energy consumed by its IT computing equipment.
- Power Usage Effectiveness (PUE) measures how efficiently a data centre uses energy, i.e. how much energy is used by the computing equipment relative to cooling and all other energy consumed in the facility (lighting, etc.). PUE is calculated as the ratio of Total Facility Energy / IT Equipment Energy.
Unfortunately, not all companies publish PUE and WUE statistics consistently, with particular gaps for water usage. For example, Google publishes PUE and is considered an industry leader for energy efficiency. However, the company does not publish WUE and neither does Microsoft (Azure). In 2023, Microsoft reported that 42% of its water consumed globally came from “areas with water stress”, while Google reported that 15% of its freshwater withdrawals are from areas with “high water scarcity”. The implication is that during periods of drought, the ability for data centres to operate normally is called into question. This was exemplified in the UK in 2022, when, amid a severe drought, Thames Water warned that water supplies to data centres could be restricted due to concerns over drinking water shortages..
Given the lack of uniformly reported data, it is complex to rank companies (Meta, Google, Microsoft, Amazon, etc.) based on their energy and water usage efficiency and/or their level of exposure to water/electricity scarcity in their data centres. However, it is safe to say that all of these companies are keen to improve energy and water efficiency due to cost, environmental risk, regulatory, and reputation considerations.
Most of the innovative cooling solutions are provided to data centres by private companies. JetCool, Iceotope, Asperitas and others focus on water cooling solutions, often in closed loops where water is infinitely recycled. Public companies that offer data centre cooling solutions include U.S. based Vertiv (VRT-US) and Ecolab (ECL-US) as well as France’s Schneider Electric (SU-FR).
We note the domicile of these companies because the geopolitical backdrop is important. In 2024, global installed data centre capacity stood at 122.2 gigawatts (GW). The chart below shows the geographic breakdown of that capacity – it is widely expected that the U.S.’ leadership status will only grow since the major tech companies are located there. When it comes to cooling options, “Made in America” will favor domestic solutions.
In the end, Donald Trump wasted no time completing the Investigation Into the National Security Impact of Copper Imports (as per the White House’s Feb 25 fact sheet). Last week, the U.S. administration announced that a tariff of 50% would be placed on imported copper and would come into effect in the coming days.
Copper prices are surging to near multi-decade highs, an unsurprising development given the tight demand/supply backdrop for the metal. For some time, we have warned that investors should consider $5/lb the long-term price floor, given copper’s role in the energy transition and the increasing difficulty in mining the metal affordably. In fact, copper is a poster child for the challenges involved in procuring most transition materials; traditional energy sources, i.e., oil and natural gas, are abundant in the U.S. and its allied nations, but the materials needed for electrification are currently produced in locations that have somewhat more tense trade relations (and also where loose regulatory backdrops and high rates of corruption prevail, i.e., where environmental and social protection is lax).
The table below shows the top three producing countries for various fuels and metals (note that while China has a foothold in most transition metals production, the U.S. does not) as well as the amount of production according to the geopolitical stability. In this context, it shouldn’t be a surprise that from a strategic geopolitical perspective, the U.S. wants to create the conditions that would incentivize the mining and processing of the resources that it has. Note that in the case of both copper and rare earth elements, the U.S. has significant deposits that could potentially be exploited (please see our Note from May 7, 2025, Critical Minerals, Critical Moves: The Scramble for Rare Earth Metals).
That said, while wanting to become self-sufficient in critical metal supply may be a laudable objective, we place low odds that tweaking economic policy can do much to change the overall outlook. The procurement of copper remains more than a political challenge; it is very much a physical one. In today’s note, we evaluate the three available strategies (new mines, productive gains in existing mines, recycling) for increasing copper supply and the related winners and losers.
Strategy #1: Build New Mines
Relying on the build-out of new mines to meet the expected demand increase in copper is, in our view, a surefire way to see a parabolic rise in copper prices. Under even the most cautious forecasts, copper demand is expected to increase substantially, even if one assumes that demand from the Chinese residential sector remains weak and that China’s next 5-year plan is less aggressive regarding renewables than the previous five years.
As shown in the chart below, estimates from the IEA suggest that the shortfall in supply widens consistently over the next decade and beyond. Even, if demand does not increase, current supply will still not meet demand.
Mining executives are already sounding the alarm. Earlier this year, the CEO of Anglo American’s Chilean business, Patricio Hidalgo, stated that “we’re going to need 80 mines the size of Los Bronces by 2040”. Los Bronces is a medium-sized mine with an output of about 170,000 tonnes of copper annually. The problem is that under existing conditions, it takes almost 18 years for copper mines to be up and running (see the chart below)!
The bottom line is that the likelihood that new mines can close the supply/demand gap in a meaningful way is low. This leaves us searching for other ways to procure copper.
Strategy #2: Squeeze Harder!
Even if new mines can be commissioned, there is the additional challenge that copper ore is not what it once was: easy-to-access deposits are being exhausted, and remaining ores are more complex and of lower grade (ore grades have fallen from around 3% a century ago to an estimated 0.7% now). This means that today, mining operations tend to produce large volumes of tailings. Indeed, approximately 8 billion tonnes of mine tailings is generated annually, a bit less than half come from copper production. Mine tailings have been broadly considered simply as waste; leftover rocks that environmentally aware governments oblige mining companies to store. But tailings are far from devoid of economic value; this leftover rock can often contain higher metal concentrations than what can be currently found in primary (virgin) mine sites. To be sure, reprocessing of tailings to extract any leftover copper (or other beneficial material) is a costly process. However, as copper prices rise and technological capacities improve, the economics of copper reprocessing, i.e., squeezing more out of existing mines, is improving.
The key to squeezing out more from the rock is through better leaching techniques. Leaching is the process of separating the copper (or any other desired material) from the rest of the ore. There are two main leaching methods: heap leaching and in situ leaching. Heap leaching occurs at traditional open-pit mines and involves using chemicals (typically acid) to seep through ore that is piled up in heaps. The acid dissolves copper and the liquid is then collected and contains the dissolved copper to be processed. In situ leaching is similar but involves injecting the leach ingredient through wells, i.e. it allows for extracting copper directly from the ground without open pit mining first.
Both methods of leaching rely on harmful chemicals that risk contaminating soil and groundwater. That said, in situ leaching is considered to have a lower ecological footprint since there are no large open pits, waste dumps, or tailings ponds. Companies that are considered leaders in efficient in situ copper leaching are Canadian companies with mine operations in Arizona, U.S.A: Taseko Mine and Gunnison Copper.
A significant improvement from both an environmental and efficiency perspective over conventional leaching is bioleaching. Bioleaching extracts more copper from new and existing mines – including copper previously considered uneconomical because of low grades or small deposits – more sustainably AND quickly. Bioleaching relies on bacteria that naturally produces heat when applied to certain types of rock, helping to pull out the copper.
The process is not new (bioleaching was used in the 1970s in Canada to recover uranium) but new technologies mean that bioleaching can now be used at sites and grade ores that were previously incompatible with the process. Bioleaching is said to require 50% lower capex and is considered environmentally benign.
Indeed, bioleaching is now being put to work in several existing sites, such as the Johnson Camp in Arizona (Gunnison Copper Mines Inc). Rio Tinto developed the bacteria through its Nuton LLC venture and is working the Gunnison Copper. Meanwhile, Freeport is also using new leaching technologies in Arizona, where it estimates 19 billion pounds of copper that were previously unrecoverable can now be produced.
Importantly, superior leaching methods do not require fresh regulatory approval, meaning that they can help boost supply quickly and are an environmental improvement over virgin mining and traditional leaching methods.
Strategy #3: Recycling
From an environmental perspective, recycling is the superior choice for copper production. On average, traditional mining of 1 kg of copper produces approximately 4.5 kg of CO2e emissions, compared to 1.5 kg of CO2e emissions through recycling. Reduced mining also mitigates other environmental (e.g. water quality, land degradation, etc.).
Copper recyclers benefit from the same optionality in price and potentially less operational risks because recycling avoids the geopolitical risks associated with mining: there are few geographic/physical constraints to building recycling facilities. It is estimated that two thirds of all the copper produced in the past century is still in productive use today (i.e., in computers, cars, plumbing, etc.) – the implication is that “dormant” copper available to be recycled and used is estimated to be the equivalent of three decades of mine production!
This stockpile of unused copper exists because recycling is expensive and copper is becoming increasing complex to collect and reprocess (electronic waste is the world’s fastest growing waste stream). The good news is that recycling technology has also become increasingly complex, including laser object detection, MRI scanning, A.I., and hydrometallurgy.
Currently, academic forecasts suggest that copper recycling rates can be increased meaningfully. One such study shows that there is an opportunity to increase scrap supply in the next fifteen years by close to 50% compared to a status quo baseline. It would require improvements in both collection and recycling rates, but would go a long way to meet future copper demand. We have written about the publicly listed companies that are at the forefront of copper recycling in previous notes (for example, please see Copper in Short Supply March 2, 2023). A review of the recent performance of these companies reveals that the companies’ stock performances have held up reasonably well (either in line or ahead of their regional benchmark index) and yet – except for American recyclers – valuations are cheap. In the table below, we show the current P/Es relative to their historic norms for our favored metal recycling plays, i.e., companies that derive most of their revenues from metal recycling and also post superior operational performance sustainability scores.
Globalization has been challenged by a series of systemic shocks: the COVID-19 pandemic exposed supply chain fragility, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine reignited geopolitical risk in Europe, and rising tensions between the West and China have turned strategic dependencies into security liabilities. In response, governments across advanced and emerging economies are reorienting their industrial strategies by prioritizing defense preparedness, energy resilience, and industrial sovereignty. This includes reshoring critical manufacturing, securing supplies of key technologies and materials, investing in clean energy capacity, and generally improving domestic capabilities in a variety of economic sectors. “Just-in-case economics” that favors resiliency, redundancy, and sovereignty have become the consensus; Donald Trump may be isolated in style on the global stage, but the mood has shifted towards his kind of self-centered policies.
Defense, Energy Resilience and Industrial Sovereignty
Three areas are especially ripe for change over the next decade: defense, energy and industrial production. Starting with defense, the chart below shows projections on spending as a percentage of GDP in 2035 compared to 2025 for the fifteen largest defense spenders in the world. Countries that spend a lot already (Ukraine, Russia, Israel, Saudi Arabia) are scheduled to maintain big defense budgets, while those that have historically spent little, i.e., were strong believers that globalization would eliminate conflicts (most NATO members), have committed to increase their defense budget to 3.5% of GDP by 2035. That increase is also accompanied by an extra 1.5% towards defense-adjacent sectors like infrastructure. In other words, the largest marginal investments are likely to originate from NATO countries.
In terms of energy resilience, many governments are demonstrating an urgent commitment to energy resilience, driven by the strategic need to safeguard national interests. For example, the war in Ukraine exposed Europe’s deep reliance on foreign energy, prompting an aggressive shift towards securing alternative supply routes, expanding domestic production, and reinforcing storage infrastructure. The U.S. has also taken major steps to strengthen its energy independence by supporting domestic oil and gas production and modernizing the electric grid. China is investing heavily in long-term energy security through solar, wind and coal capacity, nuclear power, and strategic stockpiling, while also controlling key upstream inputs like critical minerals and refining capacity. India is working to stabilize its energy mix by expanding domestic coal output, developing infrastructure for energy transport, and reducing exposure to global fuel price swings. Canada is also adapting its strategy by emphasizing reliability and capacity building across its oil, gas, and electricity networks. There is a clear trend towards reasserting control over national energy systems as energy resilience becomes a pillar of national security.
The chart below shows the major economies in terms of energy dependency. Countries where energy resilience is most critical are in red and include the EU, South Korea and Japan.
Finally, in terms of manufacturing, countries with persistent account deficits, deindustrialized regions, and hollowed-out middle classes are those that are most likely to prioritize reshoring. Concretely, many governments are now pursuing industrial and trade policies that aim to rebuild domestic manufacturing capacity, reduce reliance on foreign suppliers, and anchor critical supply chains. In the U.S., Joe Biden attempted to use “carrots” by introducing supply side legislation) such as the CHIPS and Science Act and the Inflation Reduction Act. Trump has the same objective but is using sticks (i.e., tariffs). In the EU, the Green Deal Industrial Plan and the EU Chips Act are designed to lessen dependencies on foreign entities.
The chart below shows the countries that import more than they export (in red) and thus have the greatest incentives to reindustrialize.
Now, that we have made the case for defense, energy and the industrial sector to be favored by government policies, let’s look at investment thematics that will benefit from it.
From Defense Preparedness to Space-Defense and Shipbuilding Investments
Countries with renewed focus on defense are investing in a range of strategies. For example, the U.S. hopes to expand capabilities in space and cyber domains, India is accelerating in military modernization, Saudi Arabia and the UAE are choosing to heavily invest in drones, missile defense, and naval platforms. While each country may have a particular focus, the common thread is clear: a multi-domain buildup across land, sea, air, cyber, and space is underpinning defense spending.
In recent months, we have written about defense-related stocks that are poised to continue to benefit from increased military spending. However, one related and perhaps overlooked sector is shipbuilding.
Maritime power in armed conflict is critical and as the chart below shows, China is the dominant power in building ships, with South Korea and Japan, the only other significant builders. It is perhaps no surprise that the U.S. is now attempting to revitalize its shipbuilding industry through legislative measures like the SHIPS for America Act and financial incentives such as the Maritime Security Trust Fund. These efforts will take time but the aim to enhance national security and reduce reliance on foreign vessels should support companies involved in building ships on U.S. soil.
In the table below, we list our favored companies that will benefit from a growing defense sector and present superior sustainability characteristics.
We also highlight below the relevant financial ratios for these companies. As we can see, some future growth has already been factored into their valuation metrics. That said, we expect the strong tailwinds detailed above to remain in place, creating further room for appreciation.
From Energy Resilience to Grid, Nuclear, Geothermal, Energy Storage Investments
Achieving domestic energy resilience and independence often favors renewable and nuclear energy strategies since these energy sources are less dependent on the geological endowments of a particular nation. That said, grid reliability becomes an increasing priority in countries that prioritize electrification. Along with investments in the grid, advancing energy storage technologies is crucial for managing energy variability.
In the table below, we list companies that are best placed to benefit from dual supports of growing energy resilience and sustainability.
Relevant financial ratios are presented below. Growth has been relatively strong recently and we should expect it to get stronger in the next decade.
From Industrial Sovereignty to Critical Minerals, Water, Waste, AI, Quantum and Automation
Industrial sovereignty is driving investments in critical sectors such as minerals, water, waste management, AI, quantum computing, and automation. We have written in detail about the various companies that are best positioned to benefit from a reshoring revival in past research (see notes highlighted at the top of this document) and a summary is provided in the table below.
Many of these companies have already seen a significant increase in valuations as this theme picks up steam, though we remain convinced that conditions will remain in place for further gains.
Just as global energy demand is set to soar – fueled by the explosive growth of AI, population expansion, and the electrification of industry – an equally profound, though often overlooked, surge in water demand is looming. This “water-equivalent” consumption – driven by the immense cooling needs of AI-powered data centers, the water intensity of feeding a growing population, and the critical role water plays in manufacturing and energy generation – is poised to place unprecedented strain on an already dwindling resources.
The limits are already visible: TSMC is trucking water to its Taiwan fabs; and cities from Barcelona to Johannesburg are imposing rationing. Water is no longer a background issue – it’s becoming the invisible constraint on production, supply chains, and entire economies.
As global populations grow – especially in water-stressed regions – understanding and mitigating this nexus will be essential for protecting portfolios and ensuring sustainable returns.
One commonality among nearly all the critical areas highlighted on the map above is their proximity to the coast – most lie within 100 km of the sea – making desalination a viable long-term solution for their clean water needs. Even inland regions aren’t excluded: desalination technologies are increasingly used to treat brackish groundwater, drawn from aquifers or saline rivers, as is the case in parts of the U.S. Southwest and Central Asia.
Those unfamiliar with recent advancements may still associate desalination with high costs and extreme energy use – essentially disqualifying it as a climate-friendly solution. Just look at how Elon Musk was mocked a little over two years ago for claiming that “desalination is absurdly cheap.” He may have been early on the adjective, but he wasn’t wrong on direction. Over the past two decades, the cost of desalinated water has fallen from over $2.50/m³ to below $0.40/m³ today. By comparison, freshwater extracted from groundwater sources in Europe typically costs between $0.15 and $0.30/m³ – not as cheap, but not wildly different either.
In a way, desalination is to water what solar PV is to energy: once dismissed as too costly and impractical, both have rapidly gained traction thanks to steep cost declines, technological breakthroughs, and growing public acceptance. In solar’s case, the transformation is already a fait accompli – it is now one of the cheapest sources of electricity in much of the world, and the sector has matured both technologically and financially. Desalination is a few years behind on this trajectory, but it is catching up fast. Savvy investors should start tracking the companies driving this transformation now, ahead of the inevitable surge in projects expected in the coming decades.
Three main technological advancements account for the drastic (80–90%) drop in desalination costs over the last 20 years. First, the source of energy. A recent scientific study showed that pairing desalination with solar PV and battery storage could halve desalination costs compared to fossil-powered plants. Second, massive gains in energy efficiency – especially through energy recovery devices (ERDs), which capture the hydraulic energy in brine (the waste stream) and cut energy use by up to 60%. Third, the shift from thermal desalination to reverse osmosis (RO) has revolutionized the industry. Where thermal systems relied on massive boilers to evaporate seawater – high-cost and highly energy-intensive – RO now dominates, driven by advances in membrane technology. Today’s membranes offer higher salt rejection (~99.8%), longer lifespans (up to seven years), and require far lower pressure, reducing energy use by nearly half compared to systems of the early 2000s.
Looking ahead, a new wave of innovation promises even lower costs and higher efficiency. Graphene-based and biomimetic membranes, AI-optimized cleaning systems, and smarter automation are pushing performance boundaries. At the same time, companies are exploring ways to recover valuable minerals – magnesium, lithium, bromine – from brine waste, turning an environmental liability into a potential revenue stream.
How to invest?
Investors can approach desalination through three main categories of listed companies, each offering a different blend of growth, risk, and exposure to the global water transition.
Technology and component specialists – like DuPont (DD-US), Toray (3402-JP), and Energy Recovery (ERII-US) – offer the clearest “picks-and-shovels” exposure. These firms supply the membranes, filters, and ERDs essential to every RO project. They don’t rely on winning specific tenders; instead, they benefit from the overall growth in desalination capacity. With capital-light, IP-driven business models and recurring consumables revenue, they’re also more resilient to project delays and regional volatility. Growth-oriented investors will appreciate their reinvestment profile, particularly names like ERII, which invests about 10% of revenue into R&D and carries no debt.
Project developers and EPC contractors – such as Acciona (ANA-ES) and Doosan Enerbility (034020-KR) – offer high-beta exposure to the global buildout of desalination infrastructure. These firms design, construct, and often operate some of the world’s largest reverse osmosis plants, particularly in water-stressed regions like the Middle East, North Africa, Australia, and Southern Europe. Their business models benefit from upfront project revenues as well as long-term operations and maintenance contracts, although earnings can be lumpy and sensitive to tender cycles. With extensive track records in large-scale public-private partnerships and desalination buildouts, these companies appeal to infrastructure-focused looking to capitalize on national investment pipelines and growing regulatory pressure to secure water supplies.
Utilities and long-duration operators – like Veolia (VIE-FR) and Consolidated Water (CWCO-US) – provide the most stable exposure to desalination. They operate plants under long-term Build-Own-Operate (BOO) or concession agreements, generating predictable, inflation-linked cash flows. Veolia, while diversified, has a growing desalination presence within its Water Technologies & New Solutions division. CWCO is a near-pure-play, operating in the Caribbean and Hawaii with a clean balance sheet and rising regulatory tailwinds such as mandated diversification from groundwater and pro-desalination utility rulings. These companies are best suited to yield-seeking or defensive investors looking for long-term ballast in their water portfolios.
A balanced, high-conviction trio for desalination exposure would include Energy Recovery (ERII-US), Acciona (ANA-ES), and Consolidated Water (CWCO-US) – each representing a distinct point along the value chain. ERII offers the purest play on technology, with a dominant position in pressure exchanger (PX) energy recovery devices that are embedded in about 70% of global seawater RO plants. It combines high margins, strong R&D reinvestment, and leverage to both new builds and retrofits, making it a strategic bet on efficiency gains. Despite their low materiality score, we believe they are well positioned to capture a large part of the sector upside in the years to come. Acciona, while not a pure-play, is a global leader in RO desalination EPC and O&M contracts, giving investors exposure to capex cycles and infrastructure growth, especially in water-stressed markets. It trades at a reasonable multiple (13× forward P/E) and benefits from a growing backlog of mega-projects. CWCO, meanwhile, anchors the portfolio with long-term, regulated cash flows as one of the only public desalination utilities. Operating in the Caribbean and Hawaii, it offers stable yield, no net debt, and direct leverage to rising water demand in climate-sensitive geographies. Together, this trio delivers a well-rounded mix of innovation, project leverage, and defensive income – ideal for investors seeking exposure to desalination as a scalable, investable climate adaptation theme.
China is a dominant player in several technologies that are key to the energy transition. This should make it an appealing opportunity for sustainability-minded investors, but that appeal is offset by persistent human rights and environmental issues, not to mention a heavy-handed government. Despite its critical role in the production of solar panels, EVs and battery materials, many investors have deemed China uninvestable. In this note, we explore whether Chinese green tech companies present a viable sustainable investment opportunity.
China is a Green Giant…
Our past notes on the Energy Transition theme have acknowledged China’s role in critical green technologies (The Range of the EV Battery Trade, May 25, 2023; China’s Solar Power and Deglobalization: An Irresistible Force Paradox, March 9, 2023 and China will Single-handedly Pick the Next EV Winner, March 4, 2021). The nation is difficult to ignore when it comes to investing in green tech, providing a significant majority of the manufacturing capacity for Solar PV, batteries, technology and EVs as well as mining and processing of rare earths. In 2024, clean energy-related sectors accounted for 10% of China’s GDP and 25% of its growth.
Supportive industrial policy has fueled the growth of Chinese companies in these industries. And while similar “carrot” approaches for green tech industries have existed in Europe and the U.S. matching China’s cost competitiveness is a huge challenge; the nation’s ability to manufacture products cheaply often relies on compromises in labor and environmental standards. In other words, China’s low costs carry hidden costs.
… With Lots of Red Flags
For one, Chinese manufacturing relies on a lot of coal. China leads global coal consumption. The amount of coal used continues to rise year after year, with industry accounting for a large share of demand, around 75%. Unsurprisingly, China is the world’s largest carbon emitter in absolute terms. While per capita emissions are lower than those of developed countries, its carbon intensity measured per unit of GDP remains significantly higher (see chart below). Water pollution and air quality concerns also persist, though government efforts to improve in these areas have delivered some progress.
In addition, China has a poor record on human rights, especially in its manufacturing sector. Despite efforts by the U.S. and the EU to ban imports of goods that relied on forced Uyghur labor from Xinjiang, recent evidence suggests such practices are still occurring. These methods seem hard to shake; even in Brazil, EV powerhouse BYD has been accused of “slave-like” labor conditions in the construction of its first EV factory outside of Asia. Cheap labor is a major factor in China’s cost competitiveness in manufactured goods.
Finally, on governance, many Chinese companies face challenges including significant state ownership, which further contributes to an already elevated level of regulatory unpredictability/influence (see note: Chinese Capitalism’s Long March, September 30, 2021). Companies show limited transparency and corporate social responsibility reporting is less robust than global peers, though efforts are being made to improve. Enforcement of shareholder rights is also considered weak.
In sum, the environmental, social and governance practices in China mean that the environment in which Chinese companies operate make it difficult for them to meet the SMS requirements for responsible investment using a Double Materiality framework: positive impact of green tech products is offset by poor governance, labor concerns and environmental practices. For these reasons, China remains a conundrum for sustainability-focused investors.
A Best-in-Class Approach to China
For instances when a product or service’s positive impact might be undermined by poor operational practices (mining is another example of this), a sustainability best-in-class approach is often the most appropriate way to assess opportunities. This consists of screening the companies within a given industry to find those with the highest operational performance and no recent controversies.
In the case of Chinese green tech companies, we focus on those having significant revenue (>30%) in industries that support the energy transition: renewable energy products (wind and solar), EVs and battery technology. While China also dominates in the processing of materials critical to the transition, the complexity of assessing a controversial industry within a controversial region merits a separate analysis. Alternatives to Chinese Rare Earth Elements companies were discussed in two recent notes: Critical Minerals, Critical Moves: The Scramble for Rare Earth Metals, May 8, 2025 and Macro Meets Sustainability: The Outlook for Q3 and Beyond, June 19, 2025.
Our screening process excludes companies with a market cap below $5 billion USD; as larger companies are more likely to be traded on international exchanges (Hong Kong or U.S.) and therefore to have greater transparency. To identify best-in-class, we look for low level of controversies, strong ESG-materiality scores and in the case of China, add a particular focus on transparency scores. The tables below present the results for renewable energy equipment manufacturers and EV and battery-makers.
1- Renewable Equipment Manufacturers
Chinese wind equipment manufacturers leave much to be desired: two have high controversy levels, and the third ranks below the 50th percentile on key sustainability metrics. Both CRRC and Goldwind are also over 50% state owned.
Among solar companies, the two largest stand out for their scores: LONGI Green Energy Technology and Sungrow Power Supply. Jiangsu also has good scores and a low controversy level, and although only 15% of its revenues are from solar, the remainder are tied to grid efficiency, another key transition enabler.
2- EV and Battery-Makers
Among the EV and battery-makers, there are more large cap companies with over $10 billion USD in market cap. Still, only Li Auto and XPeng have sufficient materiality scores and low controversy levels. EVE offers a similar ESG profile among the battery producers. While CATL and Gangfeng have strong scores, they have higher controversy levels.
Overall, few companies meet the mark for best-in-class. Only 3 of the 23 Chinese companies identified across the four segments exhibit both low controversy levels and Materiality scores above the 65th percentile (Jiangsu is included if we lower the threshold to 60th percentile). Transparency scores are especially weak. Moreover, passing the sustainability screen is only one part of the story – macroeconomic pressures and geopolitical tensions further complicate the investment case for China.
Beyond the Green Screen
With its lofty decarbonization goals, China is a key market for green tech; actually, the world’s largest for EVs, solar and batteries. Domestic companies can benefit from national policy support, but they also face significant challenges if this support were to cease. And despite the global urgency for green tech deployment, most of the companies we examined exhibit a very high concentration of sales in China, making them vulnerable to a Chinese economic slowdown.
China’s economy has struggled following strict pandemic lockdowns and lingering effects of the property crisis. Long-term, there are significant demographic headwinds given the nation’s aging population. Despite stimulus efforts, there are concerns about the Chinese consumer. This is particularly problematic for EV makers, most of whom generate the bulk of their sales in China. And with an ongoing trade war, it is unlikely that an increase in exports will materialize to offset weaker consumption at home.
There appear to be few bright spots for Chinese green tech segments. With the exception of EVs, each Energy Transition segment has underperformed Chinese equities in the past two years. A significant negative divergence from the broader Chinese market has occurred especially in the past month for EVs, Solar and batteries.
Despite their scale, both the EV and solar industries are suffering from supply gluts characterised by a race to the bottom pricing. This leaves batteries and wind as potential alternatives for investors seeking green tech opportunities; however, Chinese firms face stiffer international competition in these areas. The wind industry has its own set of challenges, but alternatives to Chinese wind turbine suppliers do exist. For battery-makers, South Korean companies are competitive and well-positioned to benefit from more favorable trade terms with Western governments (see Seoul Mates: The Case for Korean Sustainability Plays, May 1, 2025). Even when extending the focus to grid efficiency plays – an increasingly important area of the energy transition (see From Solar Panels to Control Panels: Why It’s Time to Focus on the Grid, May 22, 2025), a number of quality companies exist in Europe and the U.S.
In short, given China’s woes (both sustainable and economic), we reiterate our conviction that investors will be better served looking at Energy Transition plays in other countries that have built friendlier trade relations.
Since our last Macro Meets Sustainability update (March 20th), the equity market has been climbing a wall of worry. The S&P 500 has recovered all the losses of “Liberation Day” and has increased 6 %, despite several economically threatening events in the past three months: the Big Beautiful Bill passed the House (summarily wiping out fiscal support to green initiatives in Biden’s Inflation Reduction Act); Middle East conflicts have once again escalated (though oil prices have stayed somewhat muted); major crackdowns in U.S. immigration have shocked international observers (and created a never-seen-before shortage in agricultural workers), tariffs have been threatened, imposed, lifted…and in some cases re-imposed (earning Donald Trump the nickname TACO).
In today’s Note, we evaluate the potential for equity markets to continue climbing a wall of worry and articulate where we expect the biggest risks and opportunities lie within sustainable themes.
Global Growth Divergences: More Europe, Less U.S.
According to the OECD’s most recent projections, the global economy will grow at 2.9% in 2025, just a smidgen slower than last year. If the OECD is correct, this level of growth would mark an incredible feat given all the events listed above that have the potential to throw growth off-course. But what makes the forecast even more interesting is that these projections mask important regional divergences, and ones that are at odds with recent equity performance.
To the extent that equity market performance is a reflection of expected regional growth prospects, euro area large cap stock returns have outpaced those of the U.S. in 2025, albeit the U.S. has out-delivered relative to the euro area so far in Q2.
However, the OECD is forecasting weakening in economic prospects in the U.S. (and Canada) and China: U.S. growth was revised down to 1.6% in 2025. In the euro area, growth is forecast to accelerate over the next two years according to the OECD.
These forecasts are bearing out in the “surprises” data. The economic surprise index measures whether economic data points are better or worse than expected (a positive index number indicates the data is stronger than expected). The chart below shows that European economic news has been performing better than pundits had expected, while the opposite is true in the U.S. data.
From a policy perspective, we expect the euro area has more tailwinds than the U.S. Note that the U.S.’ Big Beautiful Bill (which was passed in the House) is expected to add a mere 0.2% to GDP in 2025 and 2026, and is expected to be a drag on growth in the long term due to significantly higher Treasury borrowing costs. Meanwhile in Europe, a major green light was given to member States earlier this month; the National Escape Clause (NEC) allows member States to temporarily deviate from their endorsed net expenditure paths to boost defence financing. No less than sixteen countries asked the Commission to implement this mechanism. Increased (defense) spending will be a tailwind to European growth in coming years.
The implication is that if these projections for regional growth materialize, then the recent outperformance of U.S. equities is likely to be short-lived. Note that our base case – as outlined in our previous macro update – is that the effective U.S. tariff rate climbs to 10% (from about 2% in 2024). As highlighted below, recent negotiations between China and the U.S. reinforce our position.
Tariff Strategy: China Found the U.S.’ Achilles Heel
U.S.-instigated tariffs continue to offer a cloud of uncertainty for equity investors and have earned Trump the TACO moniker (Trump Always Chickens Out). While the name may be cute, we expect that the situation is less about “chickening out” and more about finding out the true pain points of trade in the U.S. economy.
One particularly sore spot is rare earth metals. In retaliation to Trump’s tariffs, China imposed an export ban on rare earth metals in early April. It took only six weeks before the U.S. cried “uncle” and removed the 115% sweeping tariffs on China in exchange for removing the export ban.
Although the export ban has been temporarily lifted for 90 days, we stand by the conclusions in our May 7th note on the subject; countries around the world will prioritize establishing non-Chinese rare earth metals sources. Currently, there are only a handful of companies that have processing capacity outside of China. All of these stand to benefit from the wake-up call that the rest of the world’s dependency on China is extreme. Recent corporate announcements buoy this view:
- MP Materials (MP US):S. officials recently announced they are considering invoking the Defense Production Act to fund rare earth projects, including mining and processing, to strengthen the domestic supply chain. As the only U.S. rare earth producer, MP Materials stands to benefit.
- Neo Performance Materials (NEO CA): Earlier this month, management announced a share buyback program representing about 10% of the total float. The company believes that current prices, its shares do not adequately reflect the value of the business of Neo and its future business prospects.
- Cyclic Materials: Amazon and Microsoft announced last week new plans to invest $25 million in the private Canadian company Cyclic Materials to build a rare earth recycling plant and research centre in Canada.
Along with rare earth metals, copper is also on our radar due to similar, albeit less extreme, supply dynamics. It is no secret that China has been trying to build a dominant global position in copper processing. To do this, China currently offers negative smelter fees in order to obtain enough copper concentrate to run its copper processing operations. In a market where copper concentrate supply is tight, the overall impact is that rival smelters outside of China struggle to compete. A case in point: in March, Glencore halted smelter operations in Philippines, citing increasingly challenging market conditions. The implication is that while copper mining remains geographically diversified, the processing of copper is becoming increasingly a Chinese affair.
We are both short-term and long-term bulls on copper. The long-term story for copper is well understood; electrification is driving a once-in-a-generation surge in copper demand at a time when the mining industry has underinvested. In the short-term, tariffs have put upward pressure on copper prices (alongside China’s negative smelter fees) as “hoarding” behavior has occurred. Although U.S. recession risks are a headwind for copper prices, we nonetheless expect that supply/demand dynamics will be such that 4.50 USD/lb will hold as the new floor.
Our preferred copper strategy is a mix of owning best-in-class for sustainability and recyclers. Since mining is inherently a dirty business, it is imperative to own companies with the highest ‘all-in sustaining cost’ (AISC). The AISC includes not only direct mining and processing costs (labor, energy, etc.) and royalties but also other expenses like site rehabilitation at the end of the mine life. Mines with a lower AISC are generally the most profitable; those with high all-in sustaining costs are properties that are most likely to adhere to only the lowest acceptable environmental and social standards.
Oil & Geopolitics: A Break-down in Relationships
At the time of writing, Israel was on its fifth day of offense in Iran; Trump was singing the praises of Putin at the G7 summit in Canada, and; European countries are scrambling to increase military capacity. Most of the geopolitical risk indicators traditionally monitored by investors reflect this uncertain world, with one major exception: oil prices. Below, we review the recent behavior of risk bellwethers:
Gold prices and : gold is making new all-time highs, suggesting some flight-to-safety is at work. Note that the Swiss Franc/USD is also at decade highs and is among the strongest currencies this year.
VIX volatility index: a common measure of equity risk, it has scaled back from its April tariff highs, but is nonetheless in what appears to be a cyclical uptrend since Trump took office.
Economic policy uncertainty index: has blown past all levels reached in previous uncertain times (COVID, the Great Recession, etc.)
Oil prices: sitting in the middle of their 52-week trading range, showing no signs of panic.
Of all of these indicators, we are inclined to heed the message from gold, VIX and the uncertainty index. Historically, oil prices rise in times of war, especially when oil-rich and/or logistically important regions are involved. Thus, it may seem surprising that oil prices have not surged given the current backdrop. However, as we have written in recent notes (“Chill Baby Chill, A Transition Tipping Point” May 28th), the dynamics of fossil fuel energy supply and demand are changing. A supply glut in both natural gas and oil means that fossil fuel prices are comparatively less sensitive to supply disruptions.
As Spring turns to Summer in the Northern Hemisphere, along with the canopies coming back to our communities, this year once again brings smoke from forest wildfires in Western Canada. In a world where ESG investing continues to face an uphill battle, it seems that themes like natural capital and biodiversity are more relevant than ever and to many a surprise, are still showing some momentum as a way of trying to find value while protecting the invaluable.
What’s the Difference Between Biodiversity and Natural Capital?
According to the UN, the term “natural capital” includes the stock of renewable and non-renewable resources (e.g. plants, animals, air, water, soils, minerals) that combine to yield a flow of benefits to people. In this definition, the concept of natural capital extends beyond nature as a source of raw materials for production (e.g. timber) to include the role of the environment and ecosystems in supporting human well-being through the supply of important goods and services such as clean water, fertile soils and valuable genetic resources. For its part, biodiversity has a narrower focus and refers to the variety and variability of life forms. Therefore, whereas biodiversity focuses specifically on the variety and variability of life forms, natural capital includes biodiversity and covers all natural resources and ecosystem services that contribute to human well-being and economic value.
In 2024, over 30 global equity funds with a biodiversity focus were launched. Furthermore, a recent survey by MSCI shows that AUM in biodiversity funds grew by around 50% in the year to September 2024 to USD 1.6 billion. Most of these funds apply exclusion screens and are characterized by a predominant exposure to the GICS Industrials sector.
However, the prominence of greenwashing has gotten us used to looking beyond the label – i.e. it is not because “biodiversity” is in the name that it is necessarily investing in the service of biodiversity and natural capital. After all, the financial sector has been quick to jump on the opportunity to sell to investors the idea that companies like Microsoft, Google and Apple are a good biodiversity play because their level of emissions per dollar of revenue is low. While the ultimate goal of these funds should be to improve biodiversity, applicable investment opportunities in public markets are hard to come by.
In our view, investors looking for real impact on biodiversity should look for funds (or holdings) which aim to restore/protect – if not provide solutions in service to the environment – or at the very least aim to “Do No Significant Harm” (DNSH). Indeed, of the hundred or so biodiversity funds that exist, we identified only a handful whereby the major holdings appear to have strong alignment with biodiversity. The following table highlights some of these “better aligned” funds.
Our observation is that currently, the strongest funds have adopted a DNSH approach to natural capital and biodiversity – i.e. they invest in companies that – while not necessarily providing products and services in service to natural capital – at least contribute to slowing the pace of destruction of the natural world. In this context, investment themes such as circularity, water, packaging, waste management are consistent with this approach.
Some (Financial) Resilience in Nature
Investing in highly aligned biodiversity funds offer both real-world resilience to climate change, and portfolio protection in times of high financial volatility. In fact, the biodiversity and natural capital themes have outperformed the MSCI World Index these past few months as the financial world gyrates in attempting to price-in Trump’s policies.
Biodiversity Data: Hardly Investment Grade
Several data providers and data tools developed by non-profit organizations now offer to benchmark public equity portfolios against difference biodiversity frameworks. As an example, the Finance for Biodiversity Foundation has published an extensive study looking at the impact of companies included in the MSCI ACWI index on biodiversity. Notable conclusions are: 1) the importance of including the full value chain in biodiversity analysis and 2) the food industry has the largest impact on biodiversity. For private assets, platforms such as the UNEP-funded Encore initiative offers resources assessing biodiversity “damage” according to the materiality of the impact of private projects in different economic sectors.
However, there remain several limitations regarding the methodologies used to build these datasets. As an example, the association of revenue segments/industry sectors to specific biomes or ecosystem services – and the scope of the damage inflicted on biodiversity – remains patchy at best and still involves an important number of assumptions. By comparison, obtaining scope three GHG emissions for a company, or even evaluating avoided emissions, appears straightforward compared to evaluating the butterfly effect of the damage on biodiversity by a given company.
The Hardest Part – How to Invest?
If one were to translate natural capital and biodiversity concepts into financial asset classes lingo, then timberland as well as companies building products and services which are in service to natural capital and the protection of biodiversity could be investable. These would include asset classes such as timber, water, food and industries which focus on anything that reduces waste and/or supports a more efficient use of resources. Conversely, those looking to invest in pure-play “biodiversity” assets ought to look at asset classes such as private assets (PE or credit) where the impact of the investment on biodiversity could be answered in hefty pre-investment questionnaires as part of loan covenants. Another emerging sector are biodiversity credits in the voluntary sector.
To this end, the Biodiversity Credit Alliance (BCA) is emerging as a standard bearer in developing the biodiversity credit “industry”. Some estimates suggest that while nascent, the biodiversity credit market could be worth some USD 40 billion by 2040. According to BCA, a biodiversity credit is a certificate that represents a measured and evidence-based unit of positive biodiversity outcome that is durable and additional to what would have otherwise occurred. Emerging schemes stipulate that a biodiversity credit is a financial instrument that supports the conservation of nature and typically includes some aspect of a conservation activity or outcome, over a certain area, during a certain time period. For those hoping to see a significant rise in the price of biodiversity credits this past couple of years, we were unable to find any proper pricing data for the most traded biodiversity credits. For this reason, and despite the efforts made so far in structuring the industry, the murkiness of the concept of biodiversity credits suggests that this industry is hardly investable.
For all the promise of a transition to low-carbon energy (and the fear of trillions in stranded fossil fuel assets), it may not be obvious in the aggregate data that much has happened. Against a backdrop of unrelenting increases in total energy demand, the share that has been supplied from renewable sources has hardly been transformative. The chart below shows the world’s energy mix in 2010 vs 2023: oil and coal accounted for 61% of total energy in 2010. Thirteen years later, 57% of the world’s energy supply remain oil and coal.
But since transitions are never linear, it is not a useful exercise to extrapolate the current pace of transition to suggest a date in the future whereby our reliance on fossil fuels is negligible. Indeed, almost all successful technological transformations have followed an S-curve, which begin with a period of exponential growth, followed by linear growth, then exponentially declining growth before settling at a fixed level. A well-known example of the S-curve is mobile phone adoption (see chart below). Typically, a technological transformation may take several years (decades) to reach between 5 – 10% market share and is often supported by subsidies or other incentives to get them off the ground. Once this threshold is reached, new transformative technologies will then rapidly gain a high market share (i.e. greater than 50%) even in absence of government support, before levelling off.
The S-Curve for Energy Technology
In terms of the energy transition, one example of the S-curve at work is EV sales in Norway. Despite being introduced to Norwegian consumers in the 2000s, electric vehicles only accounted for about 5% of car sales by 2012. Sales penetration really sped up in 2015 and by 2021 over 85% of car sales were electric. The pace of penetration has now clearly slowed, increasing by only 1% between 2022 and 2023.
Dying technologies also follow an (inverted) S-curve. For example, coal consumption in the U.S. peaked in 2008 and is charting a textbook trajectory toward collapse. Interestingly, forecasts from respected organizations like the U.S. EIA erroneously made linear projections for the recovery/stabilization of coal power. The 2025 annual report, that projects out to 2050, is the first year that the EIA estimates an S-curve for coal consumption, essentially flat-lining at less than 1% of levels experienced in the 1990s and 2000s. Once the economics of substitutes (e.g. solar) became attractive, the collapse began happening at a faster rate than expected.
Note that in the case of coal, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the ensuing energy shortage caused a temporary increase in coal demand. Today, despite the ongoing war, coal is experiencing a multi-year supply glut, with prices now at a four-year low. This is despite the U.S. government accusations that coal companies are conspiring with their major shareholders (BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street) to reduce their coal production!
U.S. COAL CONSUMPTION IS FOLLOWING AN INVERTED S-CURVE

The S-curve has major implications for coal-related stock prices. There used to be several ways for equity investors to participate in the coal market. However, by 2020 most popular products for gaining exposure to coal were discontinued: the Dow Jones U.S. Coal Index (DJUSCL) and ETFs like KOL (Van Eck), TONS (Wisdom Tree) were all among the dead. Note that a new ETF was launched in early 2024 (ticker COAL) and, not surprisingly for those that predicted an S-curve in coal, has lost 30% of its value since inception and has stagnated at $15M in AUM.
When To Invest…
As the above example shows, understanding where renewable technologies are on the S-curve – rather than making linear extrapolations about adoption – is key to investment timing for long-term investors, both in entering long positions in new technology and also exiting from losing energy assets.
Solar, wind and battery storage are all candidates for hitting the steep positive slope of the S-curve for electricity production. For example, the chart below shows the share of electricity production from solar; at 7% of total electricity production, it is in the range whereby rapid market share gains will be imminent if it is to be a transformative technology.
But how to we do know if solar will follow the S-curve? To be sure, public policy can speed up (or slow down) the adoption of new technology. In the example regarding EV adoption in Norway, that government put in place an aggressive program of fiscal incentives and practical advantages beginning in the 2000s to kickstart the transition away from ICE vehicles.
A second consideration is connection. In last week’s note, we argued that the major bottleneck for renewable energy deployment is the urgent need to expand and modernize electricity grids. Renewable energy will not realize its potential if it is hampered by unstable, unreliable grids (or if solutions to mitigate intermittency are not deployed). This is, in our view, the largest remaining challenge to rapid, mass deployment of renewable energy strategies.
In other words, we have already surmounted the most significant hurdle, which is cost. Indeed, a necessary condition of scaling the S-curve is that, in absence of government support, the cost of the new technology must be less than the incumbent. We have written about the relative cost of renewables versus fossil fuels in the past, and it is fast becoming common knowledge that both wind and solar systems for electricity production are now cheaper than fossil fuels. In many ways, a virtuous cycle is already in effect, whereby many renewable technologies are getting cheaper the more they are deployed and will see greater deployment the cheaper they get. Solar panels, wind turbines, and lithium-ion batteries have all declined in cost by over 90% in the past two decades.
We note that renewable energy stocks hardly reflect this upbeat view relative to fossil fuel companies. First Solar (FSLR), the closest company to a U.S. solar national champion, has declined 20% ytd, and is highly sensitive to tariff and federal policy news. Perhaps too sensitive - after all, the economics of solar suggest that although IRA subsidies provided a nice tailwind, they aren’t crucial to choosing solar over dirty alternatives. Nonetheless, as we wrote in recent research, companies involved in the buildout of the electricity grid, and not the energy producers, offer the most upside in the current environment (please see From Solar Panels to Control Panels: Why It’s Time to Focus on the Grid, May 22, 2025).
…And When To Divest
Many sustainability minded investors will have already divested from fossil fuel stocks years ago, not wanting to be investing in products that are known to be harming the planet. When it comes to coal, this clearly was the right investment decision, since most coal stocks have had a disastrous performance over the past fifteen years as the switch to natural gas and some early renewables were easy “wins” over coal. But the same has not been true for conventional oil and gas: over the past five years, investors in this part of the energy sector have been rewarded with equity gains of over 100%.
However, if we are correct that renewables are ripe to gouge fossil fuel market share, then the risk of stranded assets is no longer tomorrow’s problem.
The most recent wave of significant write-downs in the energy sector occurred in 2020, after a prolonged period of weak oil prices (and a wave of high-profile asset manager commitments to net zero). This makes sense since the underlying commodity price is a key input to oil and gas companies’ asset valuations. At that time, write-downs were on average less than 5% of major oil companies’ assets and were, in most cases, due to a downward revision in long-term expected oil prices (see the table below). Note that in 2020, renewable energy alternatives were far less competitive than they are today, while the breakeven price of oil (i.e. the cost to bring oil out of the ground and bring it to market) has increased over the past five years.
Indeed, knowing the oil price forecast that a company uses is a key way for investors to estimate how susceptible its assets are to write-downs. This information is not always readily available/disclosed, especially in the U.S. However, among the U.K. and European companies that do disclose this information (Shell, TotalEnergies, BP, Equinor, Repsol), the vast majority have forecasts for oil prices over the next decade to stay above 60 USD/barrel.
Coincidentally, oil prices have been trading at around 60 USD/barrel over the past month and market participants and observers have been systematically revising down oil price forecasts for 2025 and 2026. To be sure, it will take a more prolonged period of weak oil prices before the oil majors make major asset price revisions. However, if we use the 2020 write down cycle as a roadmap, it is most likely that stock prices will take a significant hit before write-downs (stranded assets) are announced.