Few moments may feel less “sustainable” than a Trump-led government waging a war in the Middle East. Most people will agree that Trump’s second stint in the White House has been remarkably controversial — though perhaps not for the reasons one might expect. The U.S. president has rolled back major environmental policies, ignited a conflict without clearly communicating the strategic objective, and unleashed AI technologies without giving too much thought to its societal consequences. Yet, in a twist reminiscent of the early 2020s, Trump is now indirectly fueling an uptrend in equity prices of many companies that fit squarely within sustainability portfolios.  

After a strong run in the early 2020s, sustainability had become a fatigued investment theme between 2022 and 2025, with a few exceptions, such as nuclear energy and grid plays. Whereas the pre-2022 wave of enthusiasm centered on EVs strongly participating in the energy transition (witness the run-up in stock prices like Tesla and ChargePoint) and themes such as plant‑based food (Beyond Meat, Oatly), this new cycle is being driven by transition-oriented segments such as solar, grid infrastructure, batteries, and transition materials.

With the exception of food sustainability, most SMS environmental themes have outperformed the MSCI World ACWI since April 2, 2025 — the day Trump announced that his economic agenda would once again unleash the U.S’. “animal spirits”.

A look at the composition of these themes shows that they are mostly tilted toward industrials and transition plays, explaining their resilience in the current environment -whereby a rotation away from AI and tech appears underway.

In this context, our alternative energy theme (top ten equal-weighted companies per SMS theme average) has performed strongly – but certain names appear expensive, especially as grid and AI-related investments have dominated investor attention over the past year. Looking at materials in particular, the AI and Grid themes have pushed multiples of companies producing copper and nickel to record levels.

A Look at SMS’ Resilient ‘Nuggets’

Looking at SMS’ long universe of 500+ investable names out of the MSCI World Index, we find a few interesting plays which have derated perhaps a bit too much considering their fundamentals amid current technological and economic tailwinds. What’s more, these names remain on the margin of the AI trade – i.e. they’ve either somewhat already derated because of the software-to-AI rotation and remain relatively immune from a further markdown in AI-related plays.

LKQ — One of the world’s largest automotive recyclers. LKQ’s industry‑leading car‑part sorting technology should help consumers extend the life of their vehicles, particularly in an environment of elevated fuel and car prices amid persistent inflation. The stock is trading near recent lows, offering attractive upside potential.

Autodesk — Despite suffering from a rotation away from software toward AI, Autodesk remains deeply embedded in engineering workflows. While AI will without a doubt reshape its business, it will more likely be integrated into existing processes than replace them. Autodesk offers a compelling entry point, supported by strong ROE and a growing water‑efficiency business — increasingly valuable in a world where water assets are becoming scarce and pricier.

Kepco Electric — Korea’s main electric utility. The country remains a major industrial hub and stands to benefit from its renewed alignment with the U.S. Like other Korean equities, Kepco trades at a low P/E despite a stable economic backdrop and global momentum behind nuclear power – including from sustainability-minded investors who now consider nuclear as a sustainable power source.

WSP — The world’s largest engineering. As Europe, the U.S., and Canada strengthen their push for a more resilient economic foundation, WSP is well positioned to play a central role.

Alstom — The global leader in rail solutions. Alstom stands to benefit from its sizable backlog and the growing need to refurbish and expand rail infrastructure worldwide.

LG Energy Solutions — A key battery supplier to major automakers. The slowdown in U.S. EV manufacturing appears mostly priced in. Elevated energy prices should support the broader EV ecosystem, where sentiment has turned excessively negative. LG Energy Solutions also benefits from the expansion of its energy‑storage division.

Sustainability shifting toward the “Resiliency Trade”

Finally, a notable feature of Trump’s second term is the shift from the early‑2020s sustainability narrative to one centered on resiliency. Many companies and investors have adjusted their framing accordingly, often without altering their actual strategies. Aside from a few U.S. automakers withdrawing from EV development — at a time when gas prices have reached five‑year highs (see our February 26 note, Detroit Goes Into Full Reverse) — SMS themes have largely stayed true to their underlying objectives despite this new investment regime.

In reality, resiliency is not so different from sustainability. It refers to an organization’s ability to withstand shocks, adapt to structural change, and preserve long‑term value creation. For investors, this spans several dimensions:

Markets are increasingly rewarding companies capable of navigating environmental, regulatory, and economic disruptions while capitalizing on innovation and the transition to a low‑carbon economy. As such, resiliency is not merely a defensive trait — it is becoming a driver of durable returns and downside risk mitigation. This dynamic explains why the Industrials and Materials sectors align well with the sustainability–resilience nexus.

As an example of how this also translates into the political sphere, energy efficiency is being promoted as a nation-building priority in countries like Canada. Many other countries are reviving energy-saving policies that were enacted during the early days of the Russian invasion of Ukraine. In Asia, work from home policies are increasingly promoted as one way to save fuel. So it seems that resiliency is the new yet less politically loaded word for sustainability.

2025 proved to be a pivotal transition year for global carbon markets, marked by geopolitical upheaval and sharply diverging regional dynamics. The total global value of carbon markets declined slightly to €791 billion, representing a modest 4% drop from the €825 billion recorded in 2024 and placing the market broadly in line with levels observed in 2021. At first glance, this contraction may appear surprising given the continued expansion of carbon pricing schemes worldwide. In reality, the slowdown reflects a year in which climate policy temporarily lost political momentum across several major jurisdictions.

Europe itself was not immune to this shift. Political support for climate policy in the European Union weakened during 2025, with a watered-down agreement on the bloc’s 2040 climate targets and the partial unravelling of the EU’s flagship 2035 internal combustion engine ban late in the year. Decarbonization policy increasingly had to compete for political oxygen in a tense geopolitical environment dominated by security concerns, trade tensions, and economic uncertainty.

Across the Atlantic, political turbulence in the United States amplified these headwinds. In April 2025, the Trump administration issued an executive order explicitly targeting state-led cap-and-invest programs, triggering fears of federal intervention in sub-national carbon markets. International climate cooperation also faced significant setbacks. The International Maritime Organization’s proposed Net Zero Framework was effectively shelved following aggressive pushback from the United States, while Washington’s withdrawal from the Paris Agreement introduced new uncertainty into global climate diplomacy and contributed to turbulence in the CORSIA aviation carbon framework.

Yet while policy uncertainty slowed momentum in some areas, the year also revealed a striking divergence in carbon price performance across major markets. European Union Allowances (EUAs) rallied strongly, while carbon prices within the Western Climate Initiative (WCI) weakened considerably.

In Europe, EUA prices averaged €74.40 per tonne in 2025, up from €66.50 the previous year. The rally was fueled by growing expectations of structural supply tightening, combined with record long positions accumulated by investment funds ahead of a sharply reduced auction calendar in 2026. In North America, however, WCI prices moved in the opposite direction, falling below the $30 per tonne threshold by the end of the year. This regional decoupling reflects two very different policy environments: Europe continued tightening supply and embedding carbon pricing deeper into its industrial framework, while the WCI faced prolonged regulatory uncertainty tied to delayed rulemaking by the California Air Resources Board and the lingering psychological overhang of federal legal challenges.

As the dust settles on this volatile year, however, 2026 may mark the moment when carbon markets move into structural expansion. In Europe, a major review of the EU Emissions Trading System and the operational launch of the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism will further tighten the link between carbon pricing, trade, and industrial policy. In North America, the potential expansion of the Western Climate Initiative suggests that regional carbon markets may continue to grow even in the absence of federal climate leadership.

 

The EU ETS: 2026 Review and the CBAM Reality

The European Union’s carbon market is about to enter another defining phase as it marks its 21st anniversary. In 2026, the European Commission will undertake a comprehensive review of the EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS), examining key structural features including the Market Stability Reserve (MSR), free allocation mechanisms, and the potential expansion of the system to additional sectors. The review will also integrate several recent political compromises, including the newly negotiated 2040 climate targets and broader adjustments to the EU’s decarbonization strategy.

Investors vividly remember the last major ETS overhaul. The 2021 review fundamentally reshaped the system by tightening the emissions cap and strengthening the Market Stability Reserve – changes that helped drive the price of EU carbon allowances to triple over the following two years. The upcoming 2026 review is unlikely to produce changes of the same magnitude; most analysts view it as a fine-tuning exercise ahead of the next phase of the ETS beginning in 2031. Even so, regulatory clarity matters enormously in carbon markets. When emitters and investors gain visibility into the long-term trajectory of supply, they are far more willing to implement sophisticated carbon management strategies that rely on banking, hedging, and actively trading EUAs to optimize compliance costs.

Overlaying this regulatory review is another structural shift: 2026 marks the first operational year of the European Union’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM). As we stated in our note “Carbon Protectionism: Winners and Losers under EU’s Carbon Border Plan” (July 25, 2024), the mechanism represents one of the most consequential developments in global carbon pricing, fundamentally altering the incentives facing companies that export carbon-intensive goods into the European market.

Under CBAM, importers of products such as steel, cement, aluminum, fertilizers, hydrogen, and electricity must purchase and surrender CBAM certificates reflecting the carbon content of those imports. The price of these certificates is directly linked to EU ETS allowance prices, effectively extending the influence of the EU carbon market beyond the bloc’s borders.

The CBAM phase-in also triggers an equally important transformation within Europe itself. The policy is designed to gradually eliminate the free allocation of EU ETS allowances for sectors covered by CBAM over a nine-year period from 2026 to 2034. The phase-out begins slowly before accelerating toward the end of the transition period and corresponds directly to the CBAM ramp-up. During the transition phase, CBAM will only apply to the portion of emissions that is no longer covered by free allowances under the EU ETS. 

In other words, the incentives game is changing. European industry will progressively lose the buffer of free permits while foreign producers face a growing carbon price at the border. Early commentary around the system suggests this dynamic may already be creating a new category of market activity sometimes referred to as “CBAM proxy hedging.” Industrial importers and traders are beginning to position themselves in the EUA market to hedge future CBAM liabilities, in some cases securing a significant portion of expected carbon exposure several years in advance.

The combined effect of CBAM implementation and the gradual disappearance of free allocations ensures that an ever-larger share of industrial emissions in Europe will be exposed to the full market price of carbon. For companies operating in carbon-intensive sectors, carbon management is no longer a theoretical policy discussion – it is rapidly becoming a central financial variable.

 

WCI: Sub-National Resilience and North American Expansion

While Europe’s carbon market tightens structurally, North America’s Western Climate Initiative (WCI) is quietly demonstrating that sub-national jurisdictions are not waiting for Washington to resolve the climate debate.

The release of a draft linkage agreement on March 3, 2026 outlining the integration of Washington State’s Cap-and-Invest program into the California–Quebec carbon market marks a potentially historic moment for North American carbon pricing. If implemented, the agreement would harmonize compliance instruments, enable joint auctions, and integrate registry systems across participating jurisdictions – effectively expanding the WCI into a larger regional carbon market spanning multiple economies.

For investors watching the political drama unfold in Washington, the move also sends a clear signal: state-level carbon markets are far more resilient than many feared. Despite the Trump administration’s attempts to challenge state cap-and-trade systems, legal scholars and environmental policy experts widely argue that federal executive actions face significant jurisdictional hurdles when attempting to dismantle state-regulated emissions markets. California’s cap-and-trade system is deeply embedded in state law and supported by an established regulatory framework, making it difficult to unwind through federal intervention alone.

At the same time, the broader economic environment could unexpectedly provide support for carbon prices within the WCI system. A new wave of tariffs and industrial policy aimed at reshoring manufacturing to North America is beginning to reshape supply chains across several sectors. As production capacity shifts back toward domestic markets, a greater share of industrial emissions may fall under the jurisdiction of regional cap-and-trade programs.

In a market where emissions caps tighten year after year, increased industrial activity within participating jurisdictions translates directly into greater demand for compliance allowances. If Washington State successfully joins the Western Climate Initiative – with trading potentially beginning as early as 2027 – the expansion of the market, combined with a resurgence in domestic manufacturing, could create the conditions for stronger carbon prices in North America over the coming decade.

For now, however, the key takeaway is simple: while federal climate policy in the United States remains politically contested, regional carbon markets continue to expand and evolve, quietly reinforcing their role as one of the most durable pillars of North American climate policy.

In just the last week, OpenAI (ChatGPT) has come under scrutiny for failing to report the Tumbler Ridge mass killer while Anthropic (Claude) was in a standoff with the U.S. government for refusing to remove restrictions on how the military can use its models; it may seem like the wild west in the AI industry.

To be sure, artificial intelligence capabilities are accelerating far faster than legal frameworks: in the U.S. and Canada, there are no federal regulations outlining any prohibitions on AI or surrounding the safety of the technology. The European Union passed the AI act in 2024, with most high-risk AI obligations only taking effect in 2027.

This leaves the private sector largely in charge of overseeing their own AI activities. While this may seem extremely imprudent, it creates a significant opportunity for the testing, inspection and certification (TIC) industry.

What is TIC?

The TIC sector consists of conformity assessment bodies who provide services ranging from auditing and inspection to testing, verification, quality assurance and certification. Many TIC companies were founded in the 18th and 19th century to provide information to shipping underwriters about the condition of ships and equipment. Today, TIC companies may be most associated with standards like ISO 9001, though their operations are far reaching and span across industries that are at the core of sustainability mandates: environmental protection, food, crop, health science, road safety, etc.

Indeed, we wrote about the sustainability merits of TIC companies in previous research (please see our note “Testing the (TIC) Market”, June 6, 2024). Given that TIC companies are paid to ensure the quality of others, it should not be a surprise that the household names in this industry have impeccable ESG records.

TIC companies – the majors include Bureau Veritas (BVI-FR), SGS (SGSN-CH) and Intertek (ITRK-GB) – are considered to operate in staid business lines; their stock prices tend to be highly correlated and have a beta to the global equity market of well under one. This is no doubt because many of the companies derive significant revenue from the public sector and because it is difficult to reduce expenditure on testing and assurance, even during economic downturns. These companies operate with high moats: relationships and reputation are crucial.

The TIC industry typically grows at a reliable 3 – 4% per year, avoiding major dips, but rarely experiencing excessive growth spurts; most third-party market insight reports forecast 3% CAGR for the 2026 – 2030 period. We believe these underestimate the role of AI, not least through novel new business lines like AI assurance.

TIC and AI: An Underpriced Opportunity

Historically, the TIC industry has thrived by monetizing both regulation complexity and safety requirements. AI is likely to massively increase both of these things as governments will eventually require proof that AI is safe, non-biased, cybersecure, and explainable. This creates a new industry involving the auditing of algorithms: AI assurance.

There are already new standards emerging for AI, such as ISO 42001, which is an ISO standard for AI management systems. Many TIC companies have received accreditation to certify companies under ISO 42001 thus enabling global AI audits.

Since the standard is relatively new – officially launched in December 2023 – no information is yet available on how many companies have implemented the standard. However, there are over 1.3 million companies that use ISO 9001, the global benchmark in quality management systems. The market size for AI management is likely to be equivalent.

TIC companies are just getting started when it comes to capitalizing on AI certification opportunities. SGS acquired AI certification specialist CertX in late 2024 specifically to build digital trust capabilities. They then joined NVIDIA’s Halos AI Systems Inspection Lab ecosystem, which is an inspection framework for physical AI systems (autonomous vehicles, robotics, industrial AI). The lab is intended to integrate functional safety, cybersecurity and AI assurance, provide standardized inspection reports and accelerate certification for AI systems globally,

Since NVIDIA cannot certify every AI system themselves without losing neutrality, independent certification via companies like SGS provides regulatory legitimacy, liability protection, and standardized compliance pathways.

SGS’ role is to verify that AI systems using NVIDIA platforms are safe enough for deployment: NVIDIA builds the AI engine and SGS certifies it is safe to operate in society.

In this sense, the potential role for TIC companies can be viewed as the equivalent of the big four auditors for accounting rules. Just like accountants, AI auditors will be needed across industries and sectors: AI deployment will likely require third-party verification across regulated sectors such as autonomous driving, medical AI, industrial robotics, defense systems, smart infrastructure, data centers, etc.

It is likely that established TIC companies will dominate the third-party verification (auditing) market because they already have accreditation authority, regulator relationships and global audit networks; they already have the credibility and reputation to provide this trust layer.

 

TIC Upside

Investors currently price TIC companies as slow industrial service providers, reflecting stable dividends and modest growth assumptions. But AI is opening new streams of revenue including recurring AI certification and embedded partnerships with hyperscalers like NVIDIA: TIC entities may just become mandatory infrastructure for AI deployment and regulation.

Indeed, once government regulations inevitably fall into place (e.g. the EU AI Act, automotive AI safety, etc.) demand for AI assurance services is likely to rise exponentially.

In this environment, a re-rating of TIC companies is possible with several possible triggers including:

Note that so far, our bullish case for TIC and AI outlined above only hinges on the possibility of new AI revenue streams becoming available. TIC companies present solid use cases for artificial intelligence given that most aspects of testing, certification and inspection involves processing large amounts of data; machine learning and computer vision are already automating high-precision inspections, predictive analytics are catching defects earlier and generative AI can streamline report generation and anomaly detection. In other words, we believe that AI assurance is additive to TIC revenues while traditional business lines will also benefit from productivity improvements.

Our thesis that AI will bring new revenue streams to TIC companies is not currently reflected in stock prices. The table below shows financial details of the three major TIC incumbents: SGS, Bureau Veritas and Intertek. Note that in all three cases, P/Es remain at the low end of their historic range – there has been no re-rating to date.

To be sure, these companies are just beginning to discuss the upside to their businesses. Below are highlights from recent earnings calls:

SGS: The company has a “digital trust” unit where management sees “demand for digital trust services particularly strong in the U.S., with significant requirements around cyber resilience, AI algorithm validation for bias, and compliance testing. SGS is investing in building new service offerings in digital trust through both organic development and strategic acquisitions, with this area representing a key component of the megatrends driving future growth”.

Bureau Veritas: the company achieved 30% organic growth year-on-year in data center activities and continues to benefit from the structural need for data center expansion driven by AI infrastructure buildup. “Bureau Veritas is building AI assurance capabilities to help customers verify and validate that AI models are aligned with their values and policies, compliant with legal frameworks, and responsive to stakeholder expectations, especially as the regulatory landscape around AI assurance evolves”.

Intertek: The company has launched an AI lab to support global teams to develop the right AI solutions for the business. The company believes “there is a significant opportunity to help clients manage risk associated with investment in AI, and has launched AI², an independent end-to-end AI assurance program to help customers operate smarter and safer with the right trust in AI algorithms”.

Note the recent stock performance of TIC companies in the chart below. Over the past two years, the companies that now seem destined to become the auditors of AI have massively lagged the AI producers and first users (tech companies). We expect a catch-up phase is ahead as investors recognize the role TIC companies will play in the AI supply chain. Note that Intertek looks like a particularly interesting buying opportunity; the company announced earnings earlier this week and investors did not like that the strengthening sterling against major currencies significantly impacted results. On a day when the FTSE was down sharply due to geopolitical turmoil (Iran), Intertek stock took an exaggerated dive which we believe makes an alluring buying opportunity.

Recent news that America’s leading automakers have effectively written down the value of their EV divisions to zero signals a significant strategic reset in the U.S. auto industry. This shift coincides with the Trump administration’s announcement of the end of EPA emissions rules—removing regulatory pressure to boost fleet fuel efficiency. Together, these developments mark a notable retreat from the aggressive electrification plans of the past decade.

While EV demand has slowed in the U.S. and Canada, global markets tell a different story. Sales remain robust across Europe and Asia (see Charging Up on Cheap EV Stocks, Nov. 13, 2025). Norway is an extreme case: only seven gas‑powered vehicles were sold in December 2025. Yet American consumers remain unconvinced that EVs meet their needs as well as ICE vehicles have over the past century. High sticker prices (even if total cost of ownership is competitive) and an inconsistent national charging network continue to hold back adoption. Layered on top are waning auto sales overall amid rising living costs and declining consumer confidence.

Bank lending has also tightened. Auto loan growth has slowed as subprime delinquency rates reach 30‑year highs, constraining access to financing at a time when affordability is already stretched.

Despite these pressures, America remains a car‑centric society, and purchase intentions remain resilient. Surveys indicate more Americans plan to buy a vehicle within the next six to twelve months than at any point in the past three years. A recent TransUnion survey finds that 40% of U.S. adults are considering purchasing a vehicle within the next year.

This backdrop helps explain why U.S. automaker stock prices more than doubled over the past year—with the exception of Stellantis, whose sizable European operations and its own EV write‑downs weighed on performance. GM and Ford in particular have rallied sharply: GM trades at a 3‑year high and Ford at a 10‑year high.

Both have benefited from the AI‑driven industrial construction boom and the ongoing demand for work trucks (notably Ford Pro and GM’s truck lineup). Yet the combination of stretched consumers and rising subprime defaults signals that the domestic auto cycle may be nearing a turning point. Moreover, prices of foreign EVs continue to fall much faster than those of U.S.-made EVs or ICE vehicles—raising other concerns about U.S. competitiveness.

By comparison, Korean automakers have soared. Following Hyundai’s robotaxi debut at CES 2026, Hyundai and Kia shares are up 80% and 60% YTD, respectively, and have tripled over the past year (see Back to Basics: Sustainable Alpha for 2026, Jan. 8, 2026).

Financial and operational metrics underline the widening performance gap. Ford continues to trail GM in its transition from a legacy automaker to a more EV‑ready competitor. GM appears better positioned domestically in EVs, while Ford’s debt-to-equity ratio above 4 leaves it more exposed than GM and most foreign peers. With both stocks sitting near multi‑year highs, valuations appear stretched given a slowing economy and rapidly falling EV prices.

Sustainability investors love a good cost-decline chart. Over the past decade, solar delivered the mother of all learning curves: a >90% drop in module prices that transformed photovoltaics from a subsidized niche into the cheapest source of electricity across much of the world.

What rarely makes it into the slide deck is that this cost revolution was quietly enabled by a commodity that traded sideways for years. Silver—the most conductive metal and a critical input in solar cell metallization—remained a stable $20–25/oz for most of the early 2020s. That era has ended.

Silver reached an all-time high of $121/oz on January 29, 2026. Even after speculative liquidation drove a sharp correction, prices remain near ~$75—roughly triple early-2024 levels. The structural backdrop remains intact: five consecutive years of supply deficits, cumulative shortfalls of ~820Moz, and a supply base that is largely unresponsive to price signals because 70–80% of silver production is a byproduct of copper, lead, zinc, and gold mining.

 

Not All That Glitters Is Gold

The distinction between gold and silver is fundamental. Gold functions primarily as a monetary asset: jewelry and central bank reserves account for roughly 70–75% of demand, while industrial uses represent only ~7–8%. When gold rallies, it is typically a macro story—currency hedging, inflation protection, geopolitical stress. Please see our note “Go for the Gold” on this subject, March 13, 2024

Silver is structurally different. While still used as an investment and store of value, industrial applications now represent 59% of global demand, up from 50% a decade ago, driven by solar PV, electronics, EVs, 5G infrastructure, and AI-related hardware. This dual identity—monetary and industrial—amplifies volatility. It attracts safe-haven flows while remaining highly sensitive to economic demand. The “Devil’s Metal” nickname reflects precisely that dynamic.

The implication is straightforward: when gold prices double, jewelers absorb the cost. When silver prices triples, manufacturers’ margins compress. For solar producers, that distinction is existential.

Silver’s Role in Solar: From Rounding Error to Margin Pressure

Silver paste is screen-printed onto silicon solar cells to form conductive grid lines (“fingers” and “busbars”) that collect current. The quantity per cell is small—roughly 10–13 mg/W for mainstream TOPCon technology—but at current prices, those milligrams are economically material.

In 2023, at ~$23/oz silver, paste costs were roughly $0.008/W, or 3–5% of total cell production costs. By late 2025, at $80+/oz, that figure rose to approximately $0.022/W—approaching 30% of module selling prices in certain markets. When industry gross margins hover near $0.01/W, a $0.014/W increase in a single input materially alters profitability.

Manufacturers have aggressively “thrifted” silver—reducing loadings from ~40 mg/W a decade ago to <10 mg/W today through thinner lines and multi-busbar designs. However, incremental efficiency gains are reaching diminishing returns. Further reductions increasingly require architectural change rather than process optimization.

The Great Decoupling: Technologies and Their Silver Dependencies

Silver inflation is accelerating technological bifurcation within solar manufacturing. Architectures capable of copper substitution gain structural leverage; those dependent on high-temperature silver processes face prolonged margin risk.

TOPCon: The 70% Constraint
Tunnel Oxide Passivated Contact (TOPCon) cells command about 70% global market share but face the most complex copper substitution challenge. The high-temperature manufacturing process (~800°C) enables copper atoms to diffuse into the silicon and degrade cell performance. This leaves the technology’s dominant producers — JinkoSolar (JKS-US), Canadian Solar (CSIQ-US), and Hanwha Qcells (009830-KR) — structurally exposed to silver prices for the foreseeable future.

HJT and Back-Contact: Copper-Compatible Alternatives
Two minority cell architectures offer a faster path off silver. Heterojunction (HJT) and Back-Contact (BC) cells represent just 13–15% of global production today, but their low-temperature manufacturing processes make copper substitution far more feasible than in TOPCon. This compatibility advantage, once a technical footnote, has become a commercial selling point as silver prices force the industry to rethink its metallization roadmap. LONGi (601012-CN), the world’s largest solar manufacturer, is betting on this shift: the company is targeting mass production of copper-metallized BC cells by Q2 2026, which would make it the first top-five producer to achieve silver-free output at scale.

CdTe Thin Film: The Structural Outlier
First Solar (FSLR-US), the only American/non-Chinese top-five solar panel manufacturer, relies on cadmium telluride (CdTe) technology that uses no silver. Its cost structure is structurally insulated from precious metal volatility. While CdTe historically trailed crystalline silicon on efficiency, the new Series 7 modules are narrowing the gap. As silver prices rise, CdTe’s technology becomes incrementally more competitive.

 

The Innovators’ Edge: Financial Positioning

Our preferred companies within the solar panel manufacturing industry share a defining characteristic: structural insulation from sustained silver inflation—through technology differentiation (First Solar), architectural pivot (LONGi), or policy-protected manufacturing (Hanwha Qcells).

In the section below, we contrast these companies with Canadian Solar, which remains exposed to conventional TOPCon economics without a visible substitution roadmap.

1. First Solar (FSLR-US): The Silver-Free Fortress

First Solar remains the clearest structural beneficiary of high silver prices. The company delivered 5.3 GW of module sales in Q3 2025 and is adding 3.7 GW of incremental US finishing capacity. Its ~54.5 GW contracted backlog provides multi-year visibility.

Risks center on execution (Series 7 ramp) and contract dynamics, but not commodity exposure. In a sustained silver inflation regime, relative margin stability is a differentiator.

2. LONGi Green Energy (601012-CN): Architectural Pivot

LONGi’s HPBC 2.0 platform, targeting Q2 2026 copper mass production, positions it as an early mover in base-metal metallization. BC modules already represented >25% of shipments by Q3 2025. Execution risk remains elevated given 2025 losses, but a successful copper transition would structurally rebase its cost curve into 2026–27.

3. Hanwha Solutions (009830-KR): Policy + Integration

Hanwha Solutions continue to be exposed to rising silver prices, however the company’s U.S. manufacturing footprint (8.4 GW planned capacity in Georgia) provides tariff protection and 45X tax credit eligibility. Near-term execution remains challenged—shipment guidance reduced from 9 GW to 6 GW and plant delays into 2026—but vertical integration (ingots through modules) directly addresses tightening U.S. trade enforcement.

Overall, although Hanwha’s commodity exposure is intact, policy support will at least partially offset input cost volatility.

4. Canadian Solar (CSIQ-US): Structural Exposure

Canadian Solar operates conventional TOPCon technology without disclosed copper metallization initiatives. The company’s energy storage division (e-STORAGE, $3.1B backlog) has provided a partial buffer, but not enough to offset the damage at the cell level: three consecutive quarters of net losses (~$75M cumulative) illustrate how little insulation conventional TOPCon offers against input cost inflation.

If silver remains above $60/oz through 2027, TOPCon producers without substitution pathways face sustained profitability pressure.

Financial Divergence: Growth and Margin Separation

The divergence in cost structure between these four companies is increasingly visible in reported fundamentals. Over the past three years, First Solar delivered 24% revenue CAGR with 44% gross margins — an outlier versus peers experiencing revenue contraction (–13% to –26%) and single-digit or negative margins. R&D intensity also diverges, with First Solar allocating materially more capital to innovation relative to revenue.

Equity markets have noticed. Since January 2024 (see chart below), First Solar — the only manufacturer with zero silver exposure — has outperformed the MSCI World index, while every silver-dependent manufacturer has underperformed. The gap is striking: First Solar trades roughly 40-50% higher than in 2024, while Hanwha Solutions has been cut in half and Canadian Solar has lost roughly a third of its value. The message is unambiguous: investors are already rewarding silver immunity.

In a world where inflation tends to be sticky, any economic model that is based on using less raw inputs or substantially improves resource performance will be seen as increasingly attractive – and has the potential to become a major differentiator. Enter the circular economy. Contrary to the current linear mode of industrial production (take-make-waste), a circular economy refers to an economic system whereby the value of products, materials and other resources in the economy is maintained for as long as possible and whereby resources no longer used in one system become inputs in another. From an environmental perspective, transforming from a linear to circular economy is widely viewed as necessary because it is considered the only legitimate solution to limiting environmental degradation – the ultimate goal is to decouple resources consumption from economic growth.

Although the term circular economy has been around for some time, the necessary conditions to achieve it have been absent.  Despite the obvious environmental advantages to circular models, industries tend to only become more circular when:

In today’s note, we rank various industrial sectors based on “circular readiness”. Our first pool of candidates are those that have at least two of the above conditions for circularity in place. Our second pool of candidates are those that have at least one condition in place.  Our third pool of candidates are those industries that create significant environmental problems and should become more circular and yet do not have the right conditions in place to make the transition. Finally, we highlight our top investment picks most likely to benefit from a transition to more circular production.

1.  Circularity Best Bets: Metals & Batteries

Both metals and batteries are ripe to transition to more circular model because there is some combination of economic incentive, supply risks and regulatory force that is present. We wrote extensively about the possibilities for copper recycling and recovery in a recent note (please see Dig, Squeeze and Recycle: Rewiring the Copper Market July 17, 2025). In short, supply risks are becoming real as geopolitics make copper processing more complicated and ore grades are declining. Meanwhile, the economics of copper recycling are becoming increasingly favorable as the copper selling prices remain in a structural bull market.

For batteries, while regulation and supply risks are already spurring circular models, economic incentives are not In terms of regulation, the EU so far has the strictest standards, with a comprehensive and binding legal framework that addresses the entire life cycle of batteries. The Digital Battery Passport will become mandatory in early 2027 and it should form the basis for a functioning circular economy in batteries, as it facilitates dismantling, reuse and recycling. Meanwhile, supply risks are clearly present; the International Energy Agency has repeatedly warned that disruptions to critical mineral supplies could significantly slow the adoption of clean technologies like batteries. This week’s jump in nickel prices is a case in point, as a single producer’s (Indonesia) change in production quota changes the supply outlook for the entire world.

2.  Circularity Hopefuls: Plastics & Other Packaging

The eighth continent, the world’s biggest ocean waste repository, with 1.8 billion pieces of floating plastic is enough of a visual image to understand why plastics is an excellent candidate to transitioning to a circular model. Most plastics have short lifecycles, clear waste externalities and tend to be a high-volume business.  Clearly, there is no supply risk when it comes to plastic, since about 98% of virgin plastics are made from fossil fuels in an industry which remains ever-ready to keep on producing.  

 

The economic incentive to recycle plastic is also relatively absent; it is usually more economical for plastic manufacturers to use Virgin PET (and pay a plastic tax when in place) rather than to pay a steep premium for recycled pellets (rPET). Indeed, the current price of Virgin PET is around €1000 per tonne, while rPET flakes are €1800 per tonne.  Although regulations around plastic have been in place for a long time, in most jurisdictions they are simply not stringent enough to change behaviour: global plastic recycling is effectively stagnant at under 10% only a small portion of  newly produced plastic is sourced from recycled feedstocks. That said, in Europe, the regulatory backdrop for plastic may become more restrictive. The EU Circular Economy Act, expected to be adopted in 2026, sets ambitious targets to double the EU’s circularity rate from approximately 12% to 24% by 2030. The draft act puts a particular emphasis on the plastics sector and aims to set EU-wide standards creating a single market for plastic materials and simplifying procedures for recycling businesses.

The bottom line is that although plastics is an excellent industry to transition to a circular model, the conditions needed to significantly alter the industry are still absent; it will take strict regulation and/or taxation to flip virgin plastic’s price advantage. 

Other packaging materials fare somewhat better. The chart below shows recycling rates of various packaging materials (European data only); high rates for paper, metal and glass suggest that at least some of the conditions for circular packaging models are in place. Indeed, as we wrote in a previous note (Good Things Come in Minimal Packaging, May 16, 2024) glass, metal and paper all benefit from strong recycling programs (regulation) in most countries and the economics of re-use are in place.

 

3.  Circularity Laggards: Construction Materials

The EU’s Circular Economy Action Plan 2020 in identifies construction materials as “Key Product Value Chains” where the need to transition towards greater circularity is highest: the built environment requires vast amounts of resources and accounts for about 50% of all extracted material. The construction sector is responsible for over 35% of the EU’s total waste generation. Just like plastics, construction materials like cement, aggregates and steel are good candidates for circularity due to their massive waste streams. Unfortunately, again like plastics, there are missing conditions to transition away from a linear model. Supply of cement and steel is not particularly constrained and without paying for negative environmental externalities, the economic incentive for re-use is low. That said, the main route to changing economic incentives in this sector are through carbon pricing – as carbon prices rise, the gap between virgin and recycled materials will shrink. 

Overall, despite the massive environmental benefits that will accrue once industries flip to more circular models, the conditions necessary for doing so are only in place select sectors. The table below summarizes circular readiness of industries based on the criteria that we highlight above. Given these conclusions, we expect that investors looking to invest for circularity will find the best opportunities in metals and battery recycling and select packaging plays.  

Long Ideas for Circular Uptake

Given the above framework, we concentrate on circular investment ideas in the metals, battery and packaging industries and re-visit long candidates from previous research notes in these areas. Taking into account the cyclical outlook and valuation concerns, two long themes stand out from these three sectors:

At the time, historically cheap valuations and our high-conviction view on the structural uptrend in copper (and other transition metal) prices formed the backbone of our bullish view. Today, nothing has changed about the latter, although valuations are no longer cheap. Given the tight supply backdrop for many metals, we expect bullish inventory arguments will sustain the bull market for now, irrespective of less attractive value.

We note that valuations for some of our long packaging companies are now excellent. Both Graphic Packaging (paperboard) and Sonoco Products (metal and paper packaging) are trading at single digit P/Es, which constitutes multi-decade lows. This is somewhat merited, given that paper packaging (paperboard) is considered in cyclical oversupply; both companies mentioned the need to reduce inventory in the coming months. Nonetheless, the long-term demand for recyclable packaging is here to stay; we expect that bargain hunters will be rewarded by holding long positions in GPK and SON.

If 2025 taught us anything, it is that the impact of Trump’s political orientations on equity prices is often far from what conventional wisdom would predict. In our final note of last year, we highlighted a plethora of sustainability themes that performed far differently than consensus expectations predicted under a Trump government.

Indeed, last year showed investors, including your SMS editors, the need for critical ignoring in order to truly parse the signal from the noise. Though we doubt that Trump will take less space in the news cycle, our 2026 investment outlook is a return to two fundamental questions of investing:

Our relatively sanguine view on equity markets stems from a cool-headed analysis of policy settings. In the U.S., fiscal policy is projected to be modestly positive in 2026 whereas it was restrictive in 2025. There is likely to be Q1 pop in fiscal thrust – thanks to a resumption in federal spending after the shutdown, as well as OBBBA tax cuts that will boost spending (see chart below).

Meanwhile, as the chart below highlights, overall financial conditions have been favourable for some time, and it is hard to see that changing for the foreseeable future; politics at the Fed suggest a dovish configuration for 2026 and beyond.

To be sure, an economic recession in the U.S., occurring in parallel with major weakness in China would put a damper on our moderately bullish thesis. The American labor market is a sore spot – the majority of jobs created over the past year have been in the hospitality and health care sectors, both of which offer under-average wage compensation. But hiring managers still report unfilled positions and continue to be optimistic about hiring; we are resolved to wait until there are definitive signs of a labor market breakdown or unmistakable evidence of a recession before becoming more bearish on risk assets.

Given the above-described policy settings: which sectors offer an attractive risk/reward backdrop to investors in 2026?  Below we highlight six sustainable equity investment ideas that can benefit from mildly favorable policy settings that we believe are primed to outperform.

 

Idea #1: The Grid Super-Cycle: Expansion vs. Integration

Investing in the grid is hardly a contrarian take in 2026. In fact, it is arguably the most crowded trade on the street – but the “why” matters more than the “what.” Most analysis treats the grid as a monolith, indiscriminately buying utilities and equipment makers. We see it differently. The global grid trade has bifurcated into two distinct markets with opposing drivers: the U.S. is in a frantic race for expansion (more capacity for AI), while Europe is fighting for integration (more stability for renewables).

The U.S. “Expansion” Trade:  As we discussed in our October 16, 2025, note “The Energy Transition Just Switched Time Zones”, the U.S, power grid is in aggressive growth mode for the first time in two decades. The driver is no longer just replacing aging poles; it is raw load growth from data centers requiring massive amounts of firm power.

The Rest of World “Integration” Trade:  Outside of the U.S., the narrative flips. Europe isn’t just fighting for more power; it is fighting to stabilize it. As renewable penetration crosses 50%, national grids are breaking under the volatility.

 

Idea #: 2 Dreading Natural Disasters?  Add Long Positions in Dredgers

Despite the political rhetoric, the cost of natural disasters and the need for climate resilience are not going away. Finding climate adaptation plays that go beyond insurance and engineering services companies is sometimes challenging, but one niche segment that deserves more attention from investors is dredging.

Dredging companies are on the front line of combatting rising sea levels and stronger storms that threaten the reliability of ports, flood control channels, and coastal waterways. And beyond climate considerations, dredging is a necessary economic investment. Ports and inland waterways are the backbone of domestic commerce in many countries and in international trade, yet many are not maintained to their necessary depths. Inadequate dredging leads to shipping delays and higher transportation costs. Strengthening supply chains and supporting domestic manufacturing requires well functioning ports and dredging companies are critical.

Two public dredging companies of interest are Great Lakes Dredge & Dock (GLDD), which operates mostly in the U.S., and DEME Group (DEME) that derives most of its revenues in Europe.  

GLDD:  A large share of U.S. dredging revenue is tied to government contracts, which are influenced by appropriations cycles, regulatory approvals, and political priorities.  Fortunately for GLDD, despite Trump having gutted disaster relief agencies like FEMA, funding tailwinds for coastal resiliency and port deepening remain intact -the company has strong backlog visibility (total backlog is over 1.3 times total 2024 annual revenue). Indeed, the company’s value proposition hinges on pairing the industry’s youngest and largest dredging fleet with complex project execution expertise, allowing it to capture market share and higher margins in capital deepening and coastal resiliency work. Importantly, in the U.S., dredging projects are protected from international competition:  the Jones Act requires U.S.-built, U.S.-crewed vessels for domestic dredging, which provides an important moat around the company’s core revenue base:  there are no real U.S. dredging companies that can compete with GLDD.

DEME:  Similar to GLDD, DEME operates in both port and coastal infrastructure dredging, as well as soil and sediment remediation and the company also has significant revenue associated with Engineering, Procurement, Construction, and Installation of offshore wind (foundations, turbine installation, cables) plus oil & gas decommissioning).  The company’s most important moat is its fleet modernization:  DEME operates cutting-edge vessels that allow it to do work in deeper waters and complex installations that legacy fleets cannot match. Investors should note however that DEME is stock is less liquid, given that two major investors own over 70% of outstanding stock.

Over the past year, GLDD stock performance has kept pace with the S&P500, though DEME has lagged. What is more, while the S&P 500 is reaching ever higher valuations (P/E of 29 for the entire market and 23.7 excluding tech), dredging companies have been consistently getting cheaper over the past three years.  Both companies currently trade at 12 times earnings, compared to historical valuations closer to 16 times. With structural tailwinds in place and large project backlogs, both companies offer good value in a critical climate adaptation sector.

 

Idea #3: Short Peabody Coal – The King of a Shrinking Castle

According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) and market reports from late 2025, coal consumption by the electric power sector rose by approximately 9% to 11% compared to 2024 in the United States. This was the first year when usage of thermal coal for power generation purposes increased in more than two decades of decline. Stronger power demand coming from data centers and a frigid winter in North America both supported the price of coal pure plays such as Peabody Energy (BTU), which is trading at a five year high.

However, our expectation is that it will be difficult to notch out more coal demand from here. Although it may be true in theory that that the U.S.’ fleet of thermal coal plants has a massive amount of “spare capacity” (roughly half of the fleet sits idle on any given day), most of that capacity is unusable: old  coal plants are hard to restart and are unreliable, and grid capacity near offline plants is insufficient. Overall, we do not expect that the 2025 increase in thermal coal usage is the start of a new trend. In this context, stock investors are currently pricing BTU as if their earnings are far more durable than they are.

Idea #4: Long GLP-1s: The Transition to Essential Medicine

The investment thesis for weight loss drugs is evolving from a consumer discretionary theme to a medical necessity. While 2024 and 2025 were defined by lifestyle adoption, 2026 will likely be driven by clinical indications. Recent data confirms GLP-1 efficacy in treating chronic kidney disease (CKD), heart failure, and addiction disorders. As these drugs secure approval for such indications, insurance reimbursement rates should improve, transitioning the Total Addressable Market (TAM) from a self-pay model to a covered, essential medicine model. Furthermore, the anticipated rollout of oral formulations, led by Novo Nordisk’s oral Wegovy, promises to democratize access by removing the barriers associated with cold-chain storage and injection administration.

A significant investment performance gap emerged in 2025, with Eli Lilly (LLY) appreciating approximately 40% while Novo Nordisk (NVO) corrected by roughly 40%. While Lilly executed well on its pipeline, we believe investors have over-penalized Novo for temporary supply chain constraints. Novo Nordisk remains the global incumbent with the deepest clinical data repository. We view the current valuation disparity as irrational and expect mean reversion in 2026 as Novo resolves supply bottlenecks. For investors seeking diversified exposure to the theme – and protection against single-stock volatility – the Roundhill GLP-1 & Weight Loss ETF (OZEM) offers a balanced basket of approximately 25 companies, capturing both the established duopoly and emerging biotech acquisition targets.

 

Idea #5: Buy a Korean Car – and the Stock

We have outlined in past notes the bullish case for Korea stocks (for example, please see “Seoul Mates: The Case for Korean Sustainability Plays”, May 1, 2025). We especially like Korean EV carmakers.

Korean car makers appear to be much more engaged in electrification compared to their U.S./Japanese counterparts, and the trade deal with the US takes some uncertainty away on the country’s ability to export to the U.S.

To be sure, consensus forecasts for global EV sales in 2026 are not particularly rosy. However, the Korean brands are poised to steal market share from other manufacturers. After all, their build quality is impressive especially given the price. For example, Kia is putting out its K5 EV car at the same price as its ICE sister K4 car. Meanwhile, Hyundai just unveiled it’s robotaxi –a testament to the company’s recent technological catch-up.

We especially like Kia at its current price – the stock is training at very low multiples relative to its peers.

Idea #6: A Word About Oil

Prior to events in Venezuela, short positions in U.S. oil services companies SLB and Halliburton were among our top 2026 investment ideas. The thesis is straightforward: oil services are the part of the supply chain most sensitive to oil prices. With WTI trading at cyclical lows below $60/bbl and a strong consensus for little upside in 2026, drilling activity is likely to remain weak. Historically, after a prolonged period at these prices, oil companies prepare to strand certain fossil fuel assets.

SLB and HAL stock prices traded higher in late 2025 while oil prices traded down—a rare deviation that doesn’t tend to last and often makes for an interesting entry point in short positions.

However, Trump’s intervention in Venezuela and plans for U.S. oil companies to re-enter the country drove a significant pop in U.S. oil companies over the past week. Our editorial team is divided as to whether this price action produces a better opportunity to short or whether to stand aside. Note that oil prices have not rallied since the January 2nd intervention and the world remains well-supplied with heavy crude. The price pop likely reflects optimism that drilling contracts will be awarded to U.S. companies at the expense of other suppliers like Alberta. Trump meets with U.S. oil executives next week to discuss Venezuela; we will wait for more clarity before becoming more bearish on related investments.

As the holiday season approaches, we expect a familiar topic to come up around dinner tables: the value of learning an in-demand trade as a path to a successful—and resilient—career in the decade ahead. Families who once urged the next generation to pursue a four-year degree (and maybe even learn Mandarin) in computer science may soon be encouraging something different: enroll in technical school and become an electrician, HVAC technician, or a plumber.

Why the shift? As AI and automation make knowledge and many service-sector tasks easier to access and less scarce, the economy is placing a premium on work that still has to be done by someone in the real world. For this, we urgently need more skilled tradespeople to install, maintain, and repair the physical systems that allow all these powerful tools to show up in our day-to-day workflows.

Investors are also increasingly putting a premium on the physical inputs to our automated world. Whereas in the past several decades, business strategies of developed economies have increasingly favored capital-light models – ones that prioritize intellectual assets, technology, branding, and nimble operations over the ownership of heavy physical infrastructure or large inventories – it seems that the world is going back into the heavy stuff.

This Time is Different – Investing in Hard Stuff

Key strategies underpinning capital-light models have included outsourcing with manufacturing contracts to partners, franchising, licensing, and shared platforms. As SaaS and third-party data storage displaced on-premise hardware, even IT operations trended towards asset-light models. The chart below shows the vertiginous fall of tangible assets for S&P 500 companies over the last fifty years.

The Return of Asset-Heavy Ambitions

As governments intensify their focus on building economic autonomy and national security, scarcity assets have become a central theme. This type of assets is one where goods and services tend to hold (or gain) value because they are limited in supply and hard to create. For investors, these assets, which are often physical in nature, are increasingly perceived as natural hedges against inflation. Scarcity assets can be natural resources (fertile soil, copper, etc.), critical infrastructure (ports, rail, power grids, data centres), but also regulatory-based (e.g. taxi medallions) or cultural (fine art, collectibles).

Importantly, while financial assets can be diluted through monetary expansion or leverage, scarcity assets have a relatively fixed quantity and makes them a crucial store of purchasing power across business cycles.

These also include capital-heavy industries like energy, mining, utilities, telecom, airlines, manufacturing and data-center infrastructure (including compute) require large upfront investment in fixed assets that produce long-term cash flows and tend to be considered scarcity assets as they are costly and take a long time to build. The trade-off is that returns are extremely sensitive to capacity utilization, commodity or service price and financing cost, creating boom-bust return cycles. The table below highlights the differences between capital light and capital heavy industries.

Identifying Scarcity Assets Opportunities

The shift to clean energy has deepened dependence on scarce natural inputs. Critical minerals such as lithium, nickel, and rare earths are finite and geographically concentrated. Meanwhile, water, sand and arable land once believed to be extraordinarily abundant – are not anymore. Finally, electricity infrastructure and semiconductor chips – the key inputs to computing power – are rapidly becoming the new “hard assets” of this century.

To be sure, investing today in semiconductors would be a late move – after all, Nvidia stocks have 5x in the past three years and is already among the most valuable global companies due to the tremendous pricing power its chips have in this AI build-out phase. However, we expect that the electricity infrastructure underpinning those chips – the second hard asset input to computing power – still has some upside. The table below outlines a few of the scarcest plays in the tech commodities nexus. One column shows the number of years for which we expect the current level of undersupply to perdure. The other gives a financial score to that play based on price momentum and value.

In this context, the Tech theme seems to be already fully valued. That said, with the hype in chips maybe mostly behind us, we think we may still be at the early innings of a grid transition Supercycle. We have written about this theme in several past notes, (please see our October 23, 2025 note “Power Hungry: The Real Cost of a Digital Future”) have highlighted several electrical equipment companies that will benefit from rising demand for their services.

Additionally, investors can gain exposure to chips and electricity themes by investing in the associated natural resources that they rely on – ones where prices may not yet be accurately reflecting their status as scarcity assets. Two such areas are water (high usage in chips production) and copper (input to the grid buildout). Although both equity plays associated with water and copper have performed positively this year, returns have nonetheless lagged that of chips and grid names (see the chart and table below). Should our thesis – one where these resources will increasingly be viewed as scarcity assets – pan out, more upside for water and copper themes lies ahead.

Looking at some specific plays, we still like grid and copper plays as we feel that the market underappreciates the scarcity in these areas. We also like nuclear plays as the path of least resistance to grow grid capacity over the next decade. Looking at copper (see our July 15 note “Dig, Squeeze and Recycle: Rewiring the Copper Market“, the recent announcement of the merger between Teck Resources and Anglo American, we also think that it remain underinvested.

Investors looking to gain commodity exposure related to the energy transition theme often look no further than copper. After all, copper is considered the backbone of electrification as wiring, motors, grids, and charging networks require huge amounts of the metal. But other materials are arguably just as important and are somewhat neglected by investors: aluminum, a key material for lightweighting,  has several tailwinds that make aluminum producers – both primary and secondary (scrap) – an interesting investment proposal.

Aluminum: What is it?

Unlike copper or gold, aluminum never appears as a pure metal, it is bound up mostly in bauxite, a rock found on the earth’s surface, primarily in Guinea, Australia and China. To make aluminum, alumina is extracted from the bauxite (rock) using caustic soda. Alumina is then turned into aluminum in liquid form using electrolysis, which is hugely electricity intensive. Indeed, aluminum has often been called electricity in a solid form because it takes a huge amount of electricity to produce it.

Because bauxite and alumina are relatively common, aluminum is an abundant material that is used in a myriad of applications and across economic sectors (see chart below).

Importantly, unlike fossil fuels and some other industrial inputs, aluminum intensity is increasing in the global economy. The charts below show the trajectory of oil and aluminum per unit of GDP. Fossil fuel intensity in the global economy has been dropping for several decades. Conversely, aluminum and copper intensity of GDP stabilized around 2010 and is widely forecast to increase in the years ahead.

The largest increase in aluminum demand – both now and for the next several years- is in the transportation sector, which is already the single largest consumer of aluminum, accounting for almost 30% of global demand.  Lightweight vehicles and aircraft, designed for fuel efficiency and lower emissions, rely heavily on aluminum components. This trend will increase as automakers continue to adopt aluminum for lightweighting, especially in electric vehicles whereby manufacturers look for ways to offset the weight of batteries, and to comply with emissions standards.

Outside of transportation, other tailwinds for aluminum demand include:

On the supply side, bauxite is considered a plentiful resource that is relatively easy to access given that it is found near the earth’s surface. The chart below shows how aluminum compares to other metals – aluminum production is relatively resource efficient in that it takes only 7 kg of rock (bauxite) to produce 1 kg of aluminum. This ratio has held fairly steady over the past several decades.  

Although there are no physical constraints to aluminum supply, most forecasters expect aluminum supply to tighten relative to demand beyond the next three years.

Most notable is that China, currently responsible for about 60% of global aluminum production, has implemented a national ceiling of 45 million tons per year on primary aluminum production. The cap was established in 2017 to address overcapacity and environmental concerns. 2024 was the first year that the cap appeared to be binding (Chinese aluminum output was about 45 mt in 2024) and it is very likely that it is binding again this year.

In March 2025 the Chinese government issued a formal plan: “Aluminum Industry High‑Quality Development Implementation Plan (2025–2027)”, in which supply-side controls on primary aluminum capacity and output were reaffirmed. The implication is that Chinese supply is unlikely to meet rising global aluminum demand.  

The second supply-side risk is electricity constraints. Given the quantity of electricity necessary to produce aluminum, the economics of aluminum are essentially the economics of power. It’s no wonder that smelting capacity is clustered where electricity is relatively cheap (e.g. Norway, Canada and increasingly in the Middle East).

Green Aluminum Plays

Since electricity is such a major input to aluminum production, competitive advantages are available for producers that can either reduce the cost or the volume of the electric input. Enter recycling.

One of the defining features of aluminum is its ability to be recycled infinitely without losing its original properties. Moreover, making recycled aluminum only takes around 5% of the energy needed to make new aluminum. Therefore, there is a strong economic incentive to recycle: about 75%  of all aluminum ever produced is still in use today.

Given the supply risks mentioned above (limited Chinese output of primary aluminum and a potential shortfall of electric power), there are strong incentives to improve aluminum recycling rates. In this context, it should be no surprise that we favor non-Chinese companies with the technology and capacity to produce with high recycled content, especially those with access to low-emissions electricity like hydropower.

In the table below, we show GHG emissions for large cap aluminum producers as a share of revenue.  Note that emissions are particularly important to monitor for aluminum companies, since the vast majority of emissions are related to the source of energy used in producing electricity used smelting. What sets the low-emissions companies apart from their peers is that they all have sizeable recycling operations.

Apart from a comparatively low carbon footprint, aluminum recycling companies have also distinguished themselves from their peers by their stock market performance, both over the past three years and especially in 2025.

As we have written in past notes, since recycling is geographically agnostic, it bypasses many geopolitical and trade issues – one can build a recycling plant anywhere so long as there is access to reliable energy and labor. Importantly, input feed (scrap aluminum) generally trades at a discount to the index price of aluminum, but a significant risk is the availability of scrap. Several countries, but most notably the EU, are set to place export bans on aluminum scrap, precisely because they view it as a national security issue, just like access to copper and rare earth metals. So far in 2025, the price margin between scrap and primary aluminum prices is worth monitoring even if it has remained stable up to now.

Overall, in a world that risks becoming increasingly energy constrained, we expect that aluminum producers most exposed to recycling will outperform and should command a premium over those companies that compete for (higher priced) electricity inputs.

Interestingly, there is currently little valuation discrepancy between the companies in our recycling leaders and laggards baskets (see the chart below).  

Earlier this year, we published a note explaining why only three publicly traded companies were poised to reap the gains of a bull market in rare earth metals in 2025. Since our note (“Critical Minerals, Critical Moves: The Scramble for Rare Earth Metals”, May 7, 2025) an equally weighted basket of MP Materials, Lynas Rare Earths and Neo Performance Materials has gained almost 100%.

Rare earth metals are the lifeblood of most new technologies, both military and civilian (many of which sit squarely within the energy transition theme).

We were compelled to write our previous note due to the geopolitical context of procuring rare earth metals. Recall that in April, China implemented export restrictions on seven rare earths in retaliation to tariffs imposed by the U.S. Trump administration. Then in October, China further restricted supply by adding wide-ranging controls on several rare earths, as well as on battery precursors and superhard materials. At the end of October, U.S. and China leaders reached a trade truce, whereby the most recent restrictions have been temporarily suspended. History suggests, however, that Chinese export restrictions are far from over.

In our last note, we focused on recycling as a possible means to improve rare earth elements (REE) supply. After all, recycling can be geographically agnostic and would lessen the ecological footprint of extremely dirty mining activity. We stand by our previous conclusions: recycling offers a path to increased REE autonomy. However, with recycling rates of REEs currently under 1% and very few operations commercially viable, even an aggressive ramp up in recycling will not be a significant solution to diversify REE supply over the next five years.

In today’s note, we explore whether there are other means to avoid sleepwalking into an REE crisis and how investors should position within this sector.

REE Substitution?

It is not hard to understand that the motivation to find substitutes to REE use is high and rising. After all, companies that use REEs as an input to production are currently held hostage by a tightly controlled supply chain. Moreover, mining and processing REEs creates massive environmental degradation and human health risks. And the costs to procure REEs are forecast to rise sharply as demand swamps available supply.

Unfortunately, however, it seems that REE mining is here to stay for some time. Of the major industries that rely on REEs (defense, renewable energy, consumer electronics), we could only find evidence in the electric vehicle industry for a potential pathway to significantly reduce REE use.

Currently, most electric vehicles run on permanent-magnet motors that are comprised of REEs (Nd, Pr, Dy, Tb). However, alternatives exist. For example, BMW produces electric SUVs with motors that contain no rare earth metals; the development of these motors began in reaction to the 2011 neodymium price spike triggered by Chinese policy. These vehicles will be available for sale in North America in 2026 and may offer a pathway for larger adoption of REE-free electric vehicles.

Conversely, catalytic converters that are used in the exhaust systems of non-EV vehicles are still entirely reliant on REEs such as cerium oxide. While this is not the prime reason, the potential divergence in REE dependence adds more credence to our view that the combination of technological developments and scale are making wider EV adoption the path of least resistance (please see our recent note, “Charging Up on Cheap EV Stocks”, November 13, 2025).

Nonetheless, the likelihood of a widespread conversion across industries away from rare earth metals is unlikely. A “simple” swapping out materials often requires a costly redesign of components, systems, or supply chains. Many substitutions and alternative‐material efforts are still at the research or pilot stage and are far from economically viable.

Follow The Money?

In the absence of private sector capabilities to re-orient away from REEs, governments are increasingly throwing money at the problem. While there are newly announced programs to jumpstart R&D for substitute materials, the bulk of government attention so far has been allocated to building national champions with the aim to re-build global supply chains. The table below highlights various government investments and interventions in 2025 alone:

There are several potential drawbacks for investors when governments intervene in public corporations (reduced operational efficiency, deprioritizing shareholder returns, distorted market signals, etc.) but in the case of rare earth metals, we expect that the advantages outweigh any problems. Since rare earth metal mining is inherently a risky business, governments as stakeholders tend to lower the overall risk for other shareholders and improve financing conditions (i.e. cost and access to capital). Additionally, from a sustainability perspective, there is some evidence that environmental standards tend to be higher when governments take stakes, which is especially significant in the mining sector.

In the U.S., MP Materials has become the government REE “darling”. Earlier this year, the Department of War created a Public Private Partnership (PPA) with the company that established a 10-year price floor of $110 per kg (roughly $40/kg above the current market price) for NdPr. The government will purchase 100% of the magnets produced for defense and commercial use for a decade following commissioning. Needless to say, these actions materially stabilize the near-term earnings outlook and helps support the stock price, irrespective of China’s next moves.

Meanwhile, smaller REE companies (miners) have failed to keep up. With no deal from Uncle Sam, these companies trade similar to junior miners of other commodities (gold, copper, nickel).

Investment Strategy

Given our analysis above, there are three crucial points that investors looking to play the rare earth metals theme need to keep in mind:

Taken this information together, we believe investing in rare earth elements should be framed as such: