As the global population keeps growing and planetary boundaries are being tested, the creation of tools that enhance our well-being is being observed across a spectrum of sectors. Many of these tools rely on the application of new and existing technologies to improve productivity. This week’s note concentrates on how we can assess technologies for productivity enhancement with positive and purposeful intent and highlights which technological applications to avoid.
Productivity enhancing tools will play an important role in transitioning to a low carbon, high care global economy. Alongside the thematic of Productivity with Purpose, we have identified four sub-themes: Data Analytics that includes artificial intelligence and the Internet of Things, Information Sharing that includes the Blockchain and social media, Physical Structure Enhancements that cover 3D printing and industrial robots and lastly, Technology Infrastructure that spans data servers, microchips, 5G-6G and quantum computing. Each of these four areas of technological innovation has the potential to improve our world for the better, if adopted with the right goals in mind.
Our analytical process examines various technological applications and maps them along two dimensions: innovation and purpose. On the innovation axis, we ascertain the extent to which an application is an adaptation of an existing process or whether it is a pure innovation that can revolutionize the way things are currently done. On the purpose axis, we establish the extent to which an application is motivated by profit or by purpose. Technologies – and the companies that champion them – that have high scores on both innovation and purpose should provide for lasting impactful success. The results of our mapping are described below.
In terms of data analytics:
(1) Visualization is the most innovative and can have very purposeful applications in training and performing tasks from a distance. However, there is often a greater focus on addictiveness of gaming as a downside.
(2) AI unsurprisingly ranks highly on innovation and can improve our livelihood by improving decision-making, among other things. On the negative side, AI has been used aggressively for profit in social media with clustering opinion as a side effect.
(3) The Internet of Things has a lot of purposeful endeavour and is somewhat innovative.
(4) Finally, surveillance is not a new idea, placing it lower on the innovation scale and its increased pervasion is generally not well intentioned.
For information sharing, we note the following:
(1) Blockchain to track inputs is the most innovative and very purposeful; as it becomes more widely used, it is a good opportunity. While Cryptocurrencies are equally innovative, their energy consumption and use as a ransomware tool currently make them much more profit-driven than purpose driven.
(2) The same applies to novel payment systems that seem more interested in replacing financial firms with the same focus on profits instead of expanding access to finance.
(3) There is still some innovation in social media, but the monetization objective of most platforms will affect their long-term viability under the current construct. Cybersecurity is not very innovative but largely purpose driven.
We find that in our physical structure enhancements, sub-theme, all of the technologies rank highly on innovation:
(1) 3D printing and industrial robots both have the potential to improve working conditions, reduce waste and shrink the complexity of supply chains. On the other hand, drone innovation can be useful in transport and remote servicing but recreational use mainly targets profits and it has also been applied as a warring tool.
Finally, in our technology infrastructure category:
(1) Quantum computing has the potential to revolutionize computing power that can be put to good use. We are eagerly awaiting convincing commercial proof of concept in quantum computing.
(2) 5G, and eventually 6G, will improve the availability of information, while older technologies like servers and microchips are improving in capabilities with optimization and are continuing to be better utilized to improve lives. Although servers and chips require a lot of energy and material to create and operate, their ultimate uses are increasingly essential to supporting data needs (see our note: “Chips Ahoy, Let’s Make semis at Home”, October 21, 2021).
Looking at the big picture, we view AI, Blockchain, Quantum computing and 3D Printing as the most promising technologies in each of our subthemes that have the greatest potential for applications aimed at improving productivity with a purpose. Think transparency, waste reduction, access to information and healthcare. We are less optimistic about social media, Cryptocurrency and Surveillance which tend to be more profit-driven than ESG-minded.

Since the launch of our research services in 2018, we have touched upon many of the sub-themes identified in this note from various angles as can be seen from the table below. Future research will put greater emphasis on productivity with purpose as we strongly believe that the challenges facing society require a concerted effort: companies that can find novel applications of these technologies that help tackle these challenges will be rewarded.
Consumers around the world are beginning to have sustained confidence in the economic outlook. The Covid ‘4th wave’ is peaking but more importantly, employment prospects are good and consumers are flush with cash. True, gasoline prices have risen in recent months – which acts as a tax on consumers – but they nonetheless remain below the peaks achieved in the past decade. It remains an exceptionally strong backdrop for consumer spending and indeed, consumer confidence is running high, both in North America and Europe.
Admittedly, there are headwinds as well. In this report, we attempt to unravel the various cross-currents that are currently at work in the retail industry. First, we describe three major trends in the retailing sector (supply chain challenges, micro-moment shopping and buy now, pay later) and identify a basket of companies that are likely to be stock market winners from these trends. Second, we shine a spotlight on a fourth, particularly important, trend at work among consumers: the growing preference for brands that have demonstratable sustainability qualities. Here as well, we identify publicly traded companies that stand out for their ESG reputation. Finally, we identify those companies that overlap in the two analyses: i.e. retailing companies that are strong candidates to capitalize on multiple trends, both ESG and non-ESG related.
Retail Trend #1: Supply Chain Angst
Global supply chains have been disrupted on many fronts; the list of challenges that we published in our Note on September 16th (see “Supply Chain Resiliency Ensuring A Full Plate, September 16th, 2021) has not shrunk and a growing number of pundits believe these issues cannot be resolved until the second half of 2022 or even later.
One of our long-term investable ESG themes is building resilience into supply chains. We believe that retailers with strong supply chains will distinguish themselves as winning equity choices and will be rewarded.
However, in the immediate term, the ability to get sufficient products onto shelves in the coming weeks will be critical, since for many retailers, roughly a third of annual sales are generated during the winter holiday season.
One short term investment implication of this theme is that generalist giants (e.g. Walmart, Amazon, Target, Costco) will likely have greater tailwinds than specialty stores. The generalists have comparably large cash and capital resources, which help them maintain superior pricing power all along the supply chain.
Retail Trend #2: Shopping in Micro Moments
The ubiquitous use of smartphones means that consumers are researching and making purchases virtually anywhere and anytime. These shopping experiences last only a few minutes and are vastly different than the shopping ‘outings’ that used to occur. Micro-moment shopping is certainly not new, as this tendency has been underway for at least the past five years. Nonetheless, some retailers stand out and are recognized as having superior on-line shopping platforms.
Retail Trend #3: Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL)
Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) is an emerging trend that allows shoppers to defer or stagger payment of a purchase and repay the provider with interest-free payments. Although offering loans at the check-out are not new, the current BNPL, in digital form, is especially useful for on-line shoppers. BNPL providers platforms that are independent of retail merchants. According to a recent Bain & Company study, one implication is that BNPL solutions at checkout lends credibility and makes shoppers more likely to trust smaller merchants online. A second known advantage is that BNPL allows consumers to try products and return them if not satisfied without out-of-pocket outlays. Several BNPL companies exist, but the main BNPL players include Quadpay, Afterpay, Affirm and Klarna. Retailers that are most advanced at providing BNPL options to shoppers will have multiple BNPL platforms available to consumers.
Retailers For The Future
2020 was a turning point for consumers and their desire to purchase goods and services that are more closely aligned with their values. Indeed, in a recent IBM survey, 80% of respondents cited ‘sustainability’ as important to them and were willing to pay a premium for products and services that they felt aligned with their values.
But what specifically are shoppers concerned with and what do retailers need to do to distinguish themselves as ‘sustainable’?
In the retail sector, the desire for consumers to align their purchases with their values translates primarily into concerns about the environment, employee treatment and product quality.
Indeed, according to the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), the most material risks for companies operating in the consumer goods sectors re:
(1) Energy & wastewater management: consumers want to understand how key natural resources are used in the production of their products and will favour companies that report clearly on these topics and have a reputation for superior practices relative to their peers.
(2) Consumer privacy & data security: shoppers want assurance that any data collected both at time of purchase and throughout the product life are not being used unwittingly and that all personal information is not at risk of breach.
(3) Product quality & safety: consumers are concerned more than ever about health and wellness. This translates into purchases of healthier products as well as higher awareness about the potential environmental dangers of certain products.
(4) Product & design & lifecycle management: For some goods, understanding what happens at the end of the product’s life is important to consumers. This is particularly relevant for electronic goods and household appliances.
(5) Supply chain management & sourcing: Understanding where products (and services) are sourced and produced as well as under what conditions has become an important concern for consumers, given the digital tools that now exist to trace items throughout the supply chain.
(6) Employee engagement, diversity, equity and inclusion: Consumers increasingly view employees as significant stakeholders in retail companies and will more frequently avoid companies with controversies related to treatment of workers.
Companies that can demonstrate a superior commitment to these values should, over time, be favorably rewarded with better sales growth relative to their peers.
Below, we present two tables. The first shows publicly traded companies across retail spending categories that will potentially benefit from Retail Trends #1, #2, or #3, while the second table lists the publicly listed companies that rank highly on the material ESG issues that consumers consider when shopping at retailers. For the latter table, we use rankings available from the score aggregator CSRHub, but focus exclusively on the ratings components that reflect the six issues highlighted above. We display the top companies per retailing sub-industry; investors that are looking for companies that have potential to benefit from consumers’ desires to align their sustainability values with their purchases could explore these businesses. Note that a handful of companies appear in both tables and are stressed in bold in the second table: this shortlist of names are companies that appear set to benefit from both the major trends in the retail space. Indeed the final chart shows that this group of companies has outperformed the benchmark index since the beginning of the year and we expect the streak to continue well into 2022.
There has been quite a bit of discussion around the idea that ESG investors have left an important chunk of the stock market uninvested these past years – all things fossil fuel-related. This proved a boon to lesser-principled investors who have feasted on cheaply priced stocks in recent months as commodity prices rose to five-year highs. To the latter’s credit, it is generally a smart idea to invest in disregarded stocks with fat profit margins – especially if these underlying companies offer a source of strong and stable profits.
To this end, the recent increase in fossil fuel prices – be it oil, natural gas or even coal – has been a great source of returns this past year. From an ESG-minded investor perspective who is in for the long run, the financial attractiveness of fossil fuels should not be a good enough reason to allocate a greater part of their portfolios in these industries. After all, fossil fuels remain technologically surpassed and increasingly economically unviable if compared to renewables.
Interestingly, the pace at which large institutional investors have been divesting from fossil fuels has not slowed during this last fossil fuel price rally. Behemoths such as ABP (The Netherlands) and CDPQ (Canada) have added to the chorus of voices that are selling their fossil fuel-related holdings. Going forward, this will likely prove smart amid decade-high prices when fossil fuel return to more normal price levels over the next 24-36 months.
Recent commitments to divest out of fossil fuels are rather timely: many policymakers and ESG investors are gathering nest week at the COP 26 summit in Glasgow, where the subject of the speed at which the world is transitioning toward a renewable future will be top of mind.
But there remains reasons to be worried: the International Energy Agency, a division of the OECD, recently articulated in its World Energy Outlook report that the current level and speed of investment in renewables remains vastly insufficient in light of commitments towards a Net Zero future. The IEA still foresees a need to invest as much as USD 4 trillion per year between 2030 and 2050 year to modernize the world’s energy infrastructure for the world to become net zero. As a reference, this figure is equivalent to the combined market capitalizations of the MSCI World Energy AND that of the MSCI World Utilities indices.
To explain the underinvestment, many media pundits have suggested that 1) the divestment operations of ESG-principled divestors of the past few years have increased the cost of capital of fossil fuel companies and 2) that fossil fuels are increasingly being phased out by the entire financial system (banks), which is also increasing the cost of capital (if even available at all). According to their arguments, banks and asset managers getting out of fossil fuels has caused some supply bottlenecks in the production of fossil fuels - which could explain the recent increase in prices amid the growing post-covid demand for energy. For our part, we don’t think these channels are to blame, especially for 2) as most banks have yet to substantially reduce their fossil fuel financing and that the cost of capital of these companies has not materially increased just yet.
To this end, capex levels in the two most important sectors relevant to the Energy Transition - Energy and Utilities - remain depressed. They have yet to recover from the COVID-related episode of negative oil prices and lower energy demand and re-adjust to a booming economy.
What to do if you can’t invest in fossil fuels? Time for carbon and uranium
Investors that have divested from fossil fuels and are at risk of underperforming as energy prices rise can implement tactical hedging strategies. This could be especially relevant for investors superposing fossil-free strategies atop other portfolios. In previous Notes, we have written about the strong diversifying and positive return potential of carbon (see our note “Carbon as an emerging asset class”, December 10th, 2020).
Indeed, global fossil fuel underinvestment, allied to short-term demand pressures, should support oil prices in the short term. Conversely, carbon prices in Europe and more globally should also be lifted by the need to decarbonize at a much faster rate which should created additional rarity on EU and other emission rights – at least more than what we’ve seen so far. To this end, outcomes of the COP 26 summit should provide clues to the future trend of carbon prices; a long position in carbon could replace one in oil.
A second hedging idea is to take a second look at nuclear options. Since weaning ourselves off fossil fuels takes time and there is still a current need for a reliable, low carbon power infrastructure, a resurgence in the demand for nuclear power (and all-things related) is likely. This is especially true for countries and utilities looking to phase out fossil fuel-based power grids in a context of higher fossil fuel prices. As a result, demand for nuclear – uranium miners and nuclear servicers alike – should increase substantially, and given the complexity and the limited supply in this industry, uranium prices and those of companies in the nuclear sector could also increase.
Finally, a favorite long/short pair in the Energy Transition theme is energy transition leaders versus laggards. Exxon, is a fossil fuel pure-play lagging in the global transition game, while TotalEnergies is rapidly establishing itself as a leader in changing its fossil fuel base to a more renewable production mix. Contrary to expectations, these two companies have shared similar price patterns over the past six months as oil prices doubled. One would have expected Exxon stock to rise more than Total given 1) the level of divestment done by ESG-minded investors over Exxon, 2) the pure-play nature of Exxon with regard to oil exploration and production, and 3) the rapidly improving bottom of Exxon line compared to Total amid higher oil prices. With this in mind, it seems that Total’s investor likability proved relatively resilient during the recent doubling of oil prices. We expect this trend to continue going forward.
Chips Everywhere
We need chips for everything: phones, cars and fridges. It has become critical to our daily lives. As we transition to a high care, low-carbon economy, a significant amount of infrastructure investment will be needed. This should provide demand support for semiconductors in the foreseeable future.
At SMS, we have been highlighting six investment themes that should play out for investors over the next decade and each of them will require an increasing use of technology in which semiconductors are critical.

Another Wicked Problem
Just like last week’s note (“Transition Metals: Wicked Problem, Smart Solutions”, October 14, 2021), we find that access to the necessary inputs to achieve the energy transition and improve collective standards of living like semiconductors have negative side effects on the environment. Moreover, just like many critical physical commodities, semis can only be sourced from a limited number of places. On the environmental side, water use, energy requirements and gas pollution from the specialized industrial gases used in semiconductor processes are the three main problems. In terms of geographical challenges, although the concentration of semiconductor manufacturing operations improves economic efficiency, it reduces supply chain resiliency as we are experiencing these days. Covid-related delays, lower precipitations in Taiwan and dry weather in the Southwest of the United States that reduced output have all contributed to the creation of bottlenecks in the semiconductor supply chain. In the past, earthquakes, explosions and even polar vortexes created similar issues that were resolved faster than the current episode.
With climate change affecting weather patterns for the long run, we can expect more similar weather-related interruptions going forward. Moreover, Taiwan and South Korea, which are currently the only countries producing the most advanced chips, are located in an increasingly hot geopolitical zone.
An important goal of the United States, 15 years ago, was to become energy independent. High oil prices, large investments and shale oil technology allowed the US to reach its goal. In the same vein, one could expect the United States, or even Europe, to target semiconductor independence. China has already invested massively in this field and is in position to become self-sufficient in the next 10 years.
Made in Asia
As the chart below shows, the U.S., China and Europe all use more than 20% of the chips manufactured but produce a lot less. On the other hand, Taiwan, South Korea and even Japan, manufacture a lot more than they use. In a world where globalization is stagnating and national? industrial policies are gaining popularity, we should expect a reshoring even if the three large producing countries are close allies to the United States.
The graph below looks at global semiconductor producers’ revenue growth on an annual basis compared to global GDP growth on the same basis. As we can see, there are large variations in chip revenues. This helps explain why manufacturing has concentrated in jurisdictions where local governments instituted aggressive semiconductor industrial policies. Building semiconductor fabs require large initial investments and companies go where they are best supported.
Efficiency or Effectiveness
The chart below shows that the United States are leaders in the overall semiconductor value chain because they dominate the design of chips, which requires talent but significantly less initial capital outlays compared to manufacturing. Manufacturing leadership was left to Asia in order to improve efficiency and optimize capital allocation.
In a previous note (“Supply Chain Resiliency: Ensuring A Full Plate”, September 16, 2021), we looked at resiliency of supply chains compared to their efficiency in the restaurant industry. The conclusion was that employee loyalty, simplicity and proximity are strong assets for restaurant chains. A similar conclusion probably applies for chips, an industry which could also be “re-shored” in the coming years closer to final production centres.
Dirty Chips
Semiconductor manufacturers use a variety of high global warming potential (GWP) gases to create circuitry patterns and clean chemical vapor chambers. The continued availability of these gases is critical to the success of the industry. It is now known that anywhere between 10 to 80 percent of the fluorinated greenhouse gases (GHG) pass through manufacturing unreacted and are released in the air.
Pure water is a necessary ingredient for chips and wastewater is a negative aspect of the production process. This article highlights the need for continuous water availability for manufacturers which supports having geographical diversification.
That said, many companies in the semiconductor manufacturing industry have successfully identified, evaluated, and implemented a variety of technologies that protect the climate and improve production efficiencies, including reutilization of water. Recent research shows the opportunities to improve water recycling and the interrelationship between water and the energy requirements to treat water.
Energy use is also a key ingredient in the production of semiconductors and it typically represents up to a quarter of the total operating cost of a manufacturing facility. Large manufacturers have committed to increase their non-emitting sources of electricity in the future. To this end, Intel (2030) and TSMC (2050) have both committed to completely green sources of power.
Where to build?
Proximity to talent, adequate rainfall and, now, the availability of green energy are becoming key criteria in determining where semiconductor fabs will be set up. Considering the enormous initial capital requirements to build from scratch, country and local enticements are even more critical to determine the location of a new manufacturing facility. For example, the United States has passed the Chips Act to support the industry and Europe anticipates legislating its own European Chips Act.
The table below looks at the location of the leading chips manufacturer plants. Most production takes place in Asia and the Western United States. Water is typically less of an issue in Asia even though it was, this year, in Taiwan. On the other hand, it will likely be a recurring problem in Arizona. Maybe, moving further north in the United States or to the East Coast would make more sense than building more in the desert – as long as talent follows.
Who will win?
Samsung and TSMC are the only producers of high-performance chips. From that standpoint, Intel, Micron and STM seem like natural beneficiaries to upgrade their manufacturing platform with some help from governments in the US and Europe to catch up with the two current leaders.
Moreover, semiconductors should see increasing demand in the future since we use chips everywhere and market penetration should deepen. However, it is still a very cyclical business with large swings in demand. As governments step up their incentives to companies to ensure more resilient supply and mitigate geopolitical risks, overcapacity could surface in a few years.
By now, it is widely understood that the energy transition is underway and will eventually allow us to pivot away from fossil fuel energy…and that it will require an enormous amount of ‘other’ natural resources.
Indeed, according to the International Energy Association (IEA), the energy transition is already the major driving force for total demand growth for certain metals and minerals, “since 2015, EVs and battery storage have surpassed consumer electronics to become the largest consumers of lithium, together accounting for 30% of total current demand”. Minerals and metals that are forecast to experience massive new demand from the energy transition include copper, nickel, cobalt, and certain ‘rare earth metals’.
On this basis, it is enticing to be a long-term metal bull. In this report, we review the main challenges to the transition metals mining sector; outline appropriate investment strategies in face of these challenges, and then review select investment opportunities.
Metals Mining: A ‘Wicked Problem’
The term ‘wicked problem’ emerged in the 1970s to describe situations whereby multiple risks and uncertainties combine with sharply divergent public values to generate stalemates. In the environmental arena, these problems usually arise from entrenched conflicts over natural resource management and over the prioritization of economic and conservation goals. Metals mining fits the description on several fronts:
(1) The end-use of many products that contain metals serve the mission of reducing our dependence on fossil fuels and therefore decreasing global carbon emissions. However, the extraction process of these ‘critical’ metals is itself environmentally noxious.
(2) What is more, due to declining resource quality, the production and processing of energy transition minerals are energy-intensive and water intensive, involving ever higher emissions and water depletion to produce the same quantity of product; it creates a vicious circle of costs and negative externalities.
(3) The end-use of many products that contain metals offer major improvements in quality of life and are strong enablers of social progress. And yet, mining continues to be a relatively dangerous activity, rife with negative social impacts (i.e. human rights abuses) often stemming from corruption.
A final (significant) challenge associated with procuring metals and minerals necessary for the energy transition is that the supply chains for clean energy technologies are complex and their raw materials are often more geographically concentrated than conventional fossil fuel energy. Moreover, these geographic concentrations (see the Table below) are often in countries with loose regulatory backdrops and high rates of corruption; the likelihood that strict environmental and social protection is enforced is low.
For investors attuned to this wicked problem, there are several courses of action. The first is to choose to ignore; these investors acknowledge that the business of mining is complex and contentious but choose to invest anyway since the long-term demand and supply fundamentals warrant having significant exposure to the mining industry. Generally, this approach has little regard for ESG issues. The second is refusal to participate; by divestment or by exclusion, investors can dissociate themselves from potential negative aspects of an investment or sector. While this strategy absolves the investor, it does nothing to mitigate/reduce problems at a systemic level. The third is to participate and influence; investors acknowledge that the economic activity being funded is useful and important, and therefore attempts to support and influence outcomes in a positive way.
Divestment, exclusion and outright short selling are wholly appropriate strategies for dealing with economic sectors or business models that are unproductive and/or have little social value. However, when it comes to vital economic activities with wicked problems such as metals mining, investors have an important role to positively influence outcomes.
Smart Solution #1: Best-in-Class Investing
The first investment strategy to help ensure that vital economic activity affected by wicked problems is carried out in an optimal way is to choose best-in-class companies, i.e. companies with superior ESG characteristics. A best-in-class approach is effective because it can stimulate competition among companies for inclusion in specific indices and therefore lifting standards across an industry. Moreover, return on equity tends to be higher for companies with better ESG scores, while the cost of capital for these companies tends to be lower (please see our Note “Keep digging for sustainable mining”, November 21, 2019).
How to choose best-in-class in the transition metals and minerals mining industry?
Like all industries, mining is not immune to greenwashing. Indeed, it is not rare in the industry to observe companies battle with environmental and social controversy, while simultaneously taking top ranks in ESG ratings. For this reason, to choose best-in-class companies, we propose a process that takes into consideration both ESG commitments as well as the likely profitability of the firm: after all, only companies that are in a sufficiently strong financial position to weather the volatility of commodity markets are likely to be able to make lasting commitments to environmental and social goals.
In mining, the metric of profitability considered most useful is the ‘all-in sustaining cost’ (AISC). The AISC includes not only direct mining and processing costs (labor, energy, etc.) and royalties but also other expenses like site rehabilitation at the end of the mine life. Companies with a lower AISC are generally most profitable.
Below, we use the copper industry as an illustrative example. The first table shows ESG scores for large copper producers, while the second table shows the top ten copper mines with all-in sustaining costs significantly below the average copper price (i.e. the table showcases copper companies that are most likely to have positive, long-term profitability).
Putting the information from the two tables together, BHP, Teck, Freeport McMoRan and Anglo American all have the desired combination of low AISC and high ESG scores – which would make them potentially ‘best-in-class’ companies within copper markets. Investors looking to participate in the energy transition by owning companies that will supply critical copper resources could start by analysing this group of companies.
Smart Solution #2: The Intersection of Recycling and Tech
The above strategy is helpful in ensuring that any new (virgin) metal that is extracted from the ground is done in the most environmentally and socially positive way possible. However, as mentioned above, geographical concentration of key resources mean that the geopolitical risks associated with mining are ever-present. In contrast, metal recycling companies have no geographic constraints and they also relieve pressure on primary supply (i.e. helps to leave more metals in the ground).
In theory, metals and minerals can be re-used infinitely. In practice, current recycling rates range from almost 0% (lithium) to upwards of 80% (gold). The variation in recycling rates is a function of several factors, but most notable are underlying commodity price (higher priced, precious metals experience higher recycling rates) and technology.
In terms of technology, recycling can range from very low-tech ( e.g. hand sorting of materials) to extremely high-tech (e.g. laser object detection, MRI scanning, artificial intelligence and hydrometallurgy).
Many of the ‘transition metals’ that are used in batteries are excellent candidates for progress in recycling. For example, there is a strong desire among battery manufacturers to diversify cobalt sourcing away from the Democratic Republic of the Congo. Currently, battery recycling remains in the early stages, but there are a handful of companies that are making great strides. For example, to date there is no operating facility in North America that can recover nickel, cobalt, copper, lithium, graphite and manganese from battery ‘black mass’ on a large scale. First Cobalt, a Canadian-based company (FCC CN) recently announced plans to do so and if successful, will be an early entrant in this industry. In Europe, where metals recycling is further advanced, Umicore (UMI BB) is the established leader.
Interestingly, First Cobalt equity prices currently trade in unison with cobalt prices, suggesting that, so far, the company continues to be viewed solely as a producer of cobalt. An important signal that the company’s ability to recycle batteries becomes more advanced will be a weakening in this relationship.
Headlines abound about bottlenecks, backorders, stoppages, empty shelves and exorbitant shipping costs. Indeed, global supply chains that were previously built for a world with peaceful borders, regular weather patterns and steady demand – have faced multiple challenges over the past two years and have forced some companies to rethink their operational strategies.
Of course, not all the supply chain hiccups encountered of late are strictly due to ESG issues. However, many of the consistently cited global supply risks are of an environmental, social, or political nature and in all circumstances, the investment implication is always the same: there is a trade-off between operational efficiency and resilience. For the past several decades, investors have rewarded operational efficiency, but the future will increasingly favor those companies that bet on the side of resiliency.
Over the past several months, the covid-19 pandemic has altered both demand and supply patterns across multiple goods and services. Eventually, demand patterns will normalize (albeit they may be different than before for some goods and services). However, supply-side challenges are rooted in several factors that go well beyond the pandemic and will be longer lasting. For example, while factory shutdowns in Vietnam are directly due to virus breakouts, the lack of McDonald’s milkshakes in the U.K. is due to a truck driver shortage. And while storms in Texas meant that it was impossible to buy paint in North America for most of the first half of 2021, leather furniture prices in Canada have skyrocketed since anti-dumping tariffs imposed on Vietnam and China have occurred at a time of no domestic production…the list goes on and on.
There are almost no industries that escape supply chain challenges. However, today’s note considers goods and services where the consumer is the end-user, because we believe that given current macroeconomic trends, resilient supply chains may be a particularly decisive success (fail) factor for companies selling to consumers.
The Consumer Spending Spree Has Much Further To Run
There are several important tailwinds that suggest U.S. consumers, who continue to be the largest single driver of global growth, will continue to spend at an above-trend pace. The charts below highlight the excellent financial position of consumers: the savings rate is higher than it has been in decades and with interest rates at multi-decade lows, the ability to service outstanding debt is extremely good. Moreover, the labor market has tightened substantially, indicating that job security has improved; strong government support from the Biden administration has no doubt also improved consumer confidence.
These superior consumer conditions have been in place for some time and spending in some sectors has already rebounded sharply. Housebound consumers have already upgraded their furniture, appliances and electronics and now that vaccination rates are rising, consumers with the wherewithal to spend, will do so outside of the house: spending sectors like restaurants, recreation services and clothing are most likely to play catch up to the consumer durable goods sector.
Given this backdrop, our investment thesis is that companies that provide nondurable consumer goods and services that are best prepared to handle ongoing supply chain hiccups will be particularly well-positioned to reap gains from the ongoing consumer spending revival.
Restaurants: A Case Study
We, by no means, expect that consumer activity will return to pre-covid norms in the very near future. However, adequate Covid vaccinations mean that the worst-case outcome is likely behind us and there is a budding consensus that we will begin to “live with the virus”. This means that domestic hibernation has likely peaked as activities like eating outside of the home resume. In this context, the restaurant industry is an interesting case study for our supply chain resilience thesis.
In the case of restaurants, there are three stand-out supply chain hiccups: shortage of labor, constraints in shipping and transport and the unavailability of certain items.
We discussed the backdrop for wages in a note on August 26 (Pay Up And They Will Come) and made the case that companies that manage to retain workers by paying above current market rates would be rewarded with higher stock prices. This is also a primary tactic in confronting the problem in supply chains, from front-line restaurant staff to truck drivers transporting raw materials to farm workers growing necessary ingredients.
As for shipping bottlenecks, a full exploration of this subject is beyond the scope of this report but suffice to say that companies that can minimize the distance travelled between products sourced and their customers can avoid unexpected/volatile costs associated with the transportation of goods.
Finally, in terms of availability of items, in the food industry, shortages tend to be of a short-term nature, measured only in hours or at most, days. The impact on profitability is mostly through reputation and client satisfaction.
In the supply chain literature, three of the main determinants of supply chain resilience are as follows:
(1) The degree to which product sourcing is diversified: the ability to source inputs from various suppliers and from various locations limits the likelihood that an isolated problem will shutdown production.
(2) The number of products and SKUs (bar codes) that are carried by a brand/company: fewer components to produce the end product, as well as fewer options/variations offered limits the likelihood that customers will be disappointed when items are out of stock.
(3) Product pricing: companies that have higher profit margins to begin with - which are often companies offering higher end products - will tend to have more room to absorb the costs associated with tighter supply of input products.
In the following table, we apply these principles to the restaurant industry and within the current context of restaurant supply chain challenges.
Using the above table of risk mitigating factors, we analyse the current strategies of the companies in the S&P 500 restaurant index (Chipotle, McDonald’s, Darden, Domino’s Pizza and Starbucks). The following stand out:
Offer superior wages: as highlighted in our previous note, both McDonald’s and Chipotle have offered pay hikes above the minimum wage in order to retain workers. While this is certainly positive, and sets them apart from their peers, it does not mitigate risks emanating further upstream. Nonetheless, both companies have reported that the “acute labor shortage” has diminished, which helps build resilience at the end of the supply chain.
Improve technology: Obviously, digitising menus and orders is only one example of how technology can reduce the number of tasks assigned to employees, but this has proven to be an effective strategy. McDonald’s had been a leader in this area prior to the pandemic, but QR code menus is increasingly becoming the norm; there appears to be little competitive advantage among the restaurant chains analysed.
Locally-sourced ingredients: Out of the five restaurant companies in the index, Chipotle is far and away the company that relies most on fresh ingredients and therefore, by design, has some of the shortest distances travelled between suppliers and restaurants.
Limit number of menu items and ingredients: All of the five restaurants have made efforts in order to reduce the number of menu items and SKUs in their locations over the past two years. For example, both Starbucks and McDonald’s have simplified their menus. Meanwhile at Chipotle, the necessity to reduce items was already low because keeping a simple ingredient list has been a fundamental business strategy since the company was created.
Diversify suppliers of equivalent products: Our analysis of the level of diversification for suppliers among the five restaurants in the index is incomplete to date. Using the supply chain function in Bloomberg, investors can track the supply chains of each company, and we did indeed find a large variation in the number and geographic locations of suppliers. McDonald’s and Starbucks have by far the most diversified supply chains (161 suppliers in 46 countries at Starbucks and 185 suppliers in 57 countries for McDonald’s) but this is most likely more a result of the globalized nature of their businesses rather than a concentrated effort to diversify suppliers.
Taking all of these elements together, our qualitative analysis suggests that features in both Chipotle and McDonald’s supply chain put them in a better position than their peers. Chipotle in particular - by focusing on a limited number of fresh and widely available ingredients - has reduced the risk of encountering unforeseen transportation costs and/or supply shortages (not to mention offering a healthier menu to customers!) As highlighted in a previous note, this company has also gone further than its peers in tackling the challenge of labor shortages by offering higher wages. On the flipside, Domino’s and Darden appear to be lagging on many fronts that help determine the resiliency of supply chains. Interestingly, this positioning is also reflected in overall ESG scores, with Domino’s in particular consistently in the bottom ranking among its peers.
The ESG “industry” suffered a double blow recently when the former CIO of BlackRock’s Sustainable Investing arm published a 30-page essay on why he thinks ESG investing is – and will remain – mostly a smokescreen for asset owners looking to change the world with their assets. At the same time, the ex-head of Sustainability at DWS, a large European asset manager, also blew the whistle on the firm’s ESG foundations – or the lack thereof – which sent the company’s stock plummeting.
While one should remain critical of any ex-employee allegations of their previous employer, today’s note examines the arguments put forth from highly visible “ESG whistleblowers” and provides our view on whether the skepticism is warranted. We also conjecture on the future of ESG investing and its potential impact on the real world.
ESG teams don’t talk to investment people: Kind of true.
Given the nature of SMS’ business, we interact with several of the world’s largest ESG and investment teams within some of the largest investment groups. In some cases, these teams remain quite separate, with, on one hand the Head of ESG and, on the other hand, the Head of Investments. We have observed that sometimes these two silos don’t communicate much, save for marketing and client servicing purposes. We believe that full ESG integration will come once there is attribution of some P&L to the ESG function – or the “ESG overlay of a portfolio” perhaps akin to the macro function in asset management. This trend is beginning but has much further to go.
ESG is useful for the industry to talk about itself: True.
The financial world is quite good to put up pay-to-play type conferences to talk about itself. In this context, ESG remains a great “narrative” for the industry to justify its social mission and mitigate its reputation after the massive tarnishing following the 2008 financial crisis. As such, ESG conferences, have become the hallmark of financial and asset management communication strategies. One potential indicator of the asset management industry’s commitment to ESG objectives would be the changing nature of industry perks. For example, do conference hosts dare serve meatless meals? Do executives continue to fly business class, given the extra GHG emissions related to this type of travel? Unfortunately, our observations are that these “soft” indicators do not yet show much change in behavior. Interestingly, it also seems that ESG/Sustainability heads are now becoming even more present than Chief Economists when talking up their firms’ investment strategies and how they can align "doing good" with financial performance.
The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase its Profits. An irrelevant discussion
Investing in ESG inevitably brings about a discussion about what the mission of business is since ESG skeptics assume that it is impossible to construct a portfolio that delivers positive externalities (higher wages, cleaner water, lower carbon footprint, etc.) while delivering performance on par with portfolios without positive externalities. To us, this argument is extremely dangerous, not because this narrow definition of responsibility risks favoring the greedy and the ruthless, but rather because it shows a failure to understand the wider investment landscape. At SMS, one of our central investment beliefs is that successful investing requires anticipating what society will care about in the future; we have repeatedly shown evidence that a myriad of social and environmental causes are increasingly mobilizing societies. Investing in companies that embrace these societal goals will deliver superior returns, not despite their ‘loftier goals’ but precisely because they will be more highly valued from the goods, services and business models they offer. This value creation might be direct (e.g., providing a technological solution to an environmental or social problem) or indirect (e.g., decreasing reputational risk via exemplary social and governance practices).
The Rules of the Game Are Broken. True, but it is dishonest to shift the blame on another part of the system.
Investors who shun ESG as an investment strategy often argue that their profession is powerless: it is government that needs to ‘fix’ important issues like climate change and income inequality. This is true: a myriad of rules (e.g., imposing caps on CEO pay, instituting a highly punitive carbon tax) could be administered to severely mitigate risks in the ESG universe. Bold policy initiatives take courage and willful leaders; it also takes engaged citizens to elect them. But the necessity for stronger regulation does not excuse financial participants and investment professionals from using the tools at their disposal to influence outcomes.
Sustainable investing is becoming a deadly distraction that is doing more harm than good.False, but the propensity and facility of greenwashing is way too high.
Marketing investment products that proclaim to be making a difference, but actually do very little, allows for the general public to ‘feel good’ about ESG while absolving them from taking decisive action. There is no doubt that this form of greenwashing is alive and well in the investment industry (‘ESG-aware’ ETFs should not be fooling anyone). But dishonest marketing is as old as snake oil and is perhaps inevitable in the nascent phases of ESG adoption. Recall that FASB accounting rules were established in the 1970s but took over twenty-five years before becoming the international golden standard (remember Enron in 2000). Regulatory instruments related to ESG are only in their infancy (SFDR) and it is certainly not the first time that financial markets and their participants are ahead of the regulatory backdrop.
ESG lacks a “theory of change”: False, remember that people respond to incentives
A common argument among ESG skeptics is that ESG lacks a theory of change. Therefore, for those asking what ESG can achieve besides fees for the financial industry, one has to look at how ESG investors have been reshaping markets these past few years. Here’s how we see ESG impacting the real world beyond the financial space.
For one, with ESG flows towards sustainable strategies (at least in name) forecasted to be in the hundreds of trillions over the next decade, one can easily say that the ESG tsunami of money is already reshaping markets – and individual stock and sectoral valuations with it. As such, the flow-of-funds into ESG themes and companies which are developing solutions to real-world problems (as opposed to developing problems such as tobacco or gaming) is giving a powerful price signal to investors. By doing so, investors are pushing up prices of companies that they think are actually changing the world for good.
The corollary effect of the tsunami of “sustainability-themed” money now going into the equity market acts as a powerful incentive for company executives to deliver the real-world impact that ESG investors are looking for. With more than 7% of a typical S&P 500 company’s float in possession of executives (according to Bloomberg data), feeding ESG investors the meal they’ve been craving can have a powerful impact not only on the real world – but also on their total pay package – which is probably the strongest ESG incentive of all. To this end, the emergence of a greater number of models of sustainability-linked pay packages should be a key engagement focus area ahead.
Secondly, one can see that firms that achieve superior ESG scores (taking the aggregate of all ESG scoring agencies) are rewarded with access to cheaper financing for debt and equity – suggesting that ESG can actually have a very material impact on a company’s cost of capital, capital structure and profitability. While many executives are now “gaming the ESG report” of their own companies (such as the likes of Philip Morris), one could think that companies which are actually producing something useful to solve our world’s problems – the true definition of impact investing – are also benefitting from ESG-minded investors’ appetite of for future-positive investment assets.
“Global warming of 1.5°C and 2°C will be exceeded during the 21st century unless deep reductions in CO2 and other greenhouse gas emissions occur in the coming decades.” IPCC, 2021: Summary for Policymakers
There is no ambiguity in this year’s IPCC report about the likely fate of the earth’s temperatures and the necessity to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
To this end, the data concerning which economic activities need an overhaul is also extremely clear: one quarter of all CO2 emissions are from the transportation sector, with passenger travel the largest culprit.
These facts make it abundantly clear that if there are any hopes to sufficiently curb CO2 emissions to restrain global rising temperatures, significant efforts are needed in passenger travel.
Indeed, regular SMS readers will know that one of the high-conviction themes that underpin our research is that a major weaning from fossil fuels is necessary and is just beginning. We have written about the prospects of electrification in the automotive sector and there is now increasing evidence that consumers, automakers and (especially) financial market participants are now aligning to our view. Surveys show that drivers are more likely to purchase an EV as their next vehicle; every major automotive producer has committed to offering electric vehicles; and equity markets have aptly rewarded the leading EV manufacturers, while punishing the laggards.
This by no means implies that transport emissions have been solved. To be sure, there are still hurdles to EV adoption (e.g. charging infrastructure) and it will be decades for the global car and light truck fleet are completely turned over and become electric. However, for equity investors there has already been significant action: over the past year, companies like Tesla and Volkswagen were handsomely rewarded for being a frontrunner in the EV trend. Now that EV production will become widespread, and there is ongoing convergence in EV strategy across major automakers, it is likely that the commitment to electric vehicle production will be a fading driver of automaker equity performance.
Nonetheless, there is plenty of work to be done in other sectors of passenger travel to ensure the transport sector can shrink greenhouse gas emissions. Indeed, the chart below indicates the year in which various transport modes are forecasted by the International Energy Agency (IEA) to stop consuming fossil fuels and hence no longer contribute to direct emissions of CO2 from fossil fuel combustion. These forecasts are a function of asset operating lifetimes, scope for electrification or adoption of alternative low-carbon fuels, and the scope for providing passenger mobility and freight services in more sustainable ways.

To us, it is noteworthy that the IEA expects two/three-wheelers (motorcycles) to reach near zero emissions by 2040, well before all other transportation modes. Although the motorcycle market – and therefore associated emissions – are far smaller than cars, there are over 50 million motorcycles sold each year, with several investable companies like Harley-Davidson (U.S. listed), Bajaj Auto and Hero Motocorp (both listed in India) with market cap well over the USD 6 billion mark. Could motorcycles be an investable solution to transport-related GHG emissions?
Motorcycles: Toy or Utilitarian Good?
Motorcycles can be considered both a mode of transportation and a mode of recreation. The former tends to be most true in developing countries and the latter is more accurate in wealthier nations. For example, in the official U.S. consumption accounts, motorcycles appear in the same basket as other recreational vehicles such as boats, camping vans, snowmobiles, etc, while in India, two-wheeled vehicles are very much considered an important means of transportation. These two classifications provide an important lens of analysis for motorcycles, especially in relationship to their attractiveness within an investment portfolio that considers transport electrification as a major theme.
Short Motorcycles as Leisure…
As highlighted above, in developed countries, motorcycles are generally considered a leisure good - and one that is declining in popularity at that. The chart below shows annual spending on recreational vehicles in the U.S. – it is clear that motorcycles are losing in popularity relative to other similar leisure products.
There are several possible explanations behind the declining popularity of motorcycles as leisure. A full analysis is beyond the scope of this report, but there are two that merit addressing:
(1) Demographics: the median age of motorcycle drivers continues to increase. According to survey data, in the U.S. in 2012, the median age of a motorcycle driver was 45 and by 2018 it had climbed to 50. The implication is that in the U.S. (and other developed countries), the allure of driving a motorcycle has not been transferred to younger generations. As the population continues to age, and if younger generations continue to rebuff motorcycles, manufacturers will continue to face a shrinking demand for their product, whether it be electric or ICE.
(2) Changing tastes: Interestingly, the same survey data revealed that millennials and other prospective new motorcycle riders are showing a strong preference for electric motorcycles. But so far, the major motorcycle companies that produce for the leisure market (North American and European) market have had difficulty producing electric models. Among the major brand names, only Harley Davidson has put to market an electric model (although with an MSRP of near $30,000, affordability is an extreme hurdle). Other household motorcycle brands continue to struggle to manufacture electric motorcycles, owing primarily to battery technology.
Importantly, the demographic headwinds facing motorcycle manufacturers like HOG are well-known and well understood. Thus, it is notable that even when HOG announces the launch of a new e-motorcycle, investor reaction is subdued. We view this as an indication that in the motorcycle market that failure to be ahead in the electric transition has put the incumbents in a poor fundamental position. Companies like Harley-Davidson – whose stock has not been able to break above its 2006 peak and has severely underperformed relative to the consumer discretionary index – have few fundamental supports and run a major risk of losing market share to up-and-comers, much like automakers allowed Tesla to have a running head start in the electric car market (see "Tesla in pole position", April 30, 2020).
…Consider Buying Motorcycles Brands Geared to Transport
The narrative in developing nations is vastly different, where motorcycles are considered a key mode of transport: dedicated policy measures are in place in various countries to incentivize motorcycle usage. In China, although some local governments are curbing support for two-wheeled motorized vehicles due to recent dangerous driving practices that have lead to pedestrian injuries, the country has nonetheless experienced years of strong regulatory support for electric motorcycles in the form of strict bans of gasoline-powered motorcycles. Meanwhile, in India, two-wheeled electric vehicles have become the primary target of the country’s vehicle electrification program: recent amendments to the central government’s FAME II EV subsidy program overwhelmingly incentivize purchase of the two-wheeled electric vehicles vs. four-wheelers.
The policies underscore the notion that electric two-wheel vehicles are considered a significant solution to improving mobility and reducing emissions is developing nations. Companies like India-based Hero MotoCorp and Bajaj each sell over 50,000 electric motorcycles per year. With battery ranges of up to 150km, these companies are showing that electric motorcycles can improve mobility while stemming greenhouse gas emissions.
Finance is getting increasingly interested in Nature for the right reasons. The World Economic Forum recently estimated that 50% of the global economy is dependent on nature, and environmental risks (water scarcity, biodiversity loss and climate change) routinely rank amongst the WEF’s top macro risks going forward.

A couple of funds are starting to develop around the holistic theme of nature and its solutions. HSBC has partnered up with Pollination to create its own Asset Management entity, and Lombard Odier has recently launched a fund focusing on nature-oriented solutions with an impact-dedicated boutique Atlas Partners.
These funds are just starting to design their investment universes around Nature and are often struggling to define its edges at the intersection of the climate, biodiversity, soil, and water crisis. The common denominator of all these crises is the loss of Nature itself and its capital, that economies and businesses unknowingly depend upon to survive. This is the fertile soil to make food and feed the population, it is the quality water to make pretty much any kind of product from textile to concrete, it is the natural barriers like wetlands, mangroves forests and salt marshes that act as buffers against storm and wildfire surges alike to protect communities, etc.
There are strong references like the Dasgupta Report on the Economics of Biodiversity that explain how our economies are dependent on Nature and its capital, but the long-story-short is that there is no Economy if there is no Nature. As this realization is gaining ground in the (sustainable) finance industry, so is the appreciation for the need for new solutions. Investors that will be the first to understand which solutions work, and which do not, will be first in the success stories of the Transition and the construction of a new economy that is in line with the natural world; a Nature-Positive Economy. And what better solutions than the ones from Nature itself?
Indeed, “why work against Nature when we can work with it?” is the mantra of Nature-Based Solutions, or the solutions that intend on using the strengths of nature to either fix it, or simply work in adequation with it, and therefore be truly sustainable in the long-term. This can be for example Sponge Cities, whose infrastructure is synchronized with the water cycle and allow rivers to naturally flood when heavy rainfall persists. This can be a revolutionary water treatment membrane that uses Nature’s filtration protein, Aquaporin, to filtrate contaminants in the water and make it pristine again.
As climate change and other environmental crises materialize, the need for working solutions will be needed more than ever, and markets will appreciate its value. Entering early in the right solutions can therefore not only be good investments but can also act as climate hedges in portfolios.
We have therefore identified a couple of solutions that we think will be the most successful. These represent solutions in Natural Water Treatment, Blue Carbon Credits and Sponge Cities.
Natural Water Treatment with Aquaporin (AQP DC): the company recently developed a new water treatment membrane replicating Nature’s filtration process and took its name after it. The company just recently launched on the Danish Nasdaq Exchange where its price remained mostly at par, along with its value potential. The company is still in a developing phase where it uses most of its financing cash flows for its R&D, but a recent deal in Turkey to install membranes for 95% industrial wastewater recuperation, as well as the launch of home-based side products speaks for promising business development.
Another way to invest in natural water treatment is to acquire forests to do the job. Not investing in the land itself, but financing the utilities that are ready to outsource some part of their treatment to Nature. Such is the case of the Central Arkansas Utility that used some of the proceedings of its Municipal Green Bond Facility to acquire a surrounding forest to protect the quality of the watersheds. Acquiring surrounding forests not only protects from urban expansion – and its pollution – but the natural filtration feature of forests on the watershed can go a long way in cleaning the water. This is a cheap way to outsource parts of the water treatment to Nature, and we recommend investors to keep a lookout for such Green Bonds that will use Nature as a very cheap and efficient way for new capital expenditures in water treatment. The State of New York is another example of a municipality that won big on nature, having invested $1.5B in land acquisition, watershed restoration and payment for eco-systems funding to keep naturally filtered water for its City, instead of investing $4B CAPEX and $200MN yearly OPEX in a new water treatment plant.
Another sub-theme in natural capital is (Blue) Carbon Credits. Voluntary Carbon Markets has been hailed by Mark Carney as a tool to fight Climate Change with the elaboration of its Scaling Task-Force. In this play, investors can acquire disaffected lands, restore them to their natural states and harvest carbon credits for keeping them intact hereafter, from companies wishing to offset their emissions. These becomes yearly income flows from big industries on their way to net-zero, which can make these lands new sorts of alternative yields through carbon credits. This historically involved forest conservation, but Blue Carbon Credits are gaining in recognition for their high carbon sequestration potency. Indeed, wetlands, mangroves forests and salt marshes have five times the carbon sequestration capacity than forests have, which shows the potential of these restoration investments to become high-yielding products. In exchange, these natural capitals offer water treatment and protection against storms, floods and wildfire to local communities. A win situation for everyone involved. One way to play this theme is by buying the recently IPO’d firm Carbon Streaming (NETZ CN) which invests in the development of carbon offset projects around the world using a rolyalty streaming business model.
The last sub-theme is Sponge Cities. We discussed previously that these are infrastructures that use some natural feature to synchronise themselves with nature’s cycles and therefore hedge its volatility. In the case of Sponge Cities, this includes leaving enough space in the riverbed for water to elevate, the use of wetlands to protect the riverside, stormwater recuperation for recycling water excess and permeable sidewalks to absorbs any water residuals. So far, the main adopters have been in China and especially the city of Wuhan, which underwent a complete ecological makeover in just 5 years, after its last severe flood 2016 showed that its original design of asphalt proved to be wholly inadequate to face such natural events. As climate change is increasing the likelihood of extreme events as we are currently seeing in Europe, Sponge Cities are tangible solutions for Cities to adapt to this climate volatility. We believe these solutions will gain in popularity and will be adopted globally throughout the Transition. Investors should therefore stay on the lookout for such developments in the Infrastructure, Real Estate and Green Bond space. In the meantime, the best way to access the trade is to invest in the engineering/consulting firms that are responsible for designing these Sponge cities. The main one, and that was behind Wuhan ecological redesign, is the Dutch engineering firm Arcadis (ARCAD NA), which is specialised in natural assets and therefore a pure-play for investors.
In a recent note the Digital Water Revolution (see “The Digital Water Revolution”, June 17th,2021), we discussed how modern water systems were ripe for a digital make-over.
In this note, we look at Water Utilities and their different levels of adoption for new technologies. Water disturbances from climate change will severely affect the supply of freshwater in the economy and create a wedge between more efficient and less efficient utilities. The ones that will have integrated digital tools in their systems will be better prepared and become a source of capital appreciation for investors through improved profitability.
Key use cases of digital devices in the sector include 1) the monitoring of devices along pipe systems which allows to detect leaks, and reduce Non-Revenue Water (water loss) and operations costs, 2) monitoring devices on water reservoirs which allow a more precise measurement of water reserves and better plans for water use and drought survival, 3) stormwater sensors in sewers which allow to monitor flood overflow and quickly react to prevent critical damage to systems, and 4) water quality monitoring devices which allow to detect all kind of real-time pollution and alert for potential contamination, thereby preventing Flint-like health disasters or further PFAS contamination to happen.
However, we think that this Digital Revolution will take time as it implies a game-changing make-over and massive capex into water systems with an embedded conservative mindset from older water engineers.
That said, we’ve witnessed a wave of CAPEX increase over the past 5 years, and the share price appreciation of the companies that followed suit – at least for the most innovative water utilities.
We expect the benefits of improved efficiency and resilience from the implementation of digital tools to play out as the increase frequency of droughts, floods and rainfall pattern change and get priced-in by markets and into business operations. As a result, we see an emerging Digital Water Premium as a source of capital appreciation on its own and a source of yield for investors.
As the Digital Differentiation plays out across many regions, at incremental steps of implementation (from being digitally “unaware”, to having integrated digital tools into one’s infrastructures, up to embracing full digital systems and transformation), this leaves many opportunities for investors to select the utilities with the best potential for digital transformation and climate readiness. We have made a short selection of the water utilities we think are the readiest: Suez and Veolia.
Suez has already been integrating digital tools in their systems by using smart metering to monitor climate and environmental data for better understanding the water cycle, its volatility and make more robust decisions when it comes to water management and planning. They have also been a frontrunner in monitoring ocean pollution with remote sensors and microplastic dispersion software analysis to better understand the flow of plastic into the ocean and how to remedy for it. This culture of digital innovation is firmly embedded within the company’s operations as they have created a post of Chief Digital Officer to structure data across the group, how to analyse it and derive insights for strategic decisions. Finally, one of their subsidiaries Macao Water China has been a frontrunner in the space by already adoption VR and Big Data solutions in their processes to the utility make better decisions. Suez has been recently bought by its historical rival Veolia at a price of US$20.50 a share. This is a fair deal and antitrust laws will leave a narrower version of Suez in place with dedicated water assets in France and globally. Their culture of innovation is likely to stay in place and their “new” specialisation in only water assets can actually make a better water pure play for ESG investors along the transition.
Veolia is probably the better-placed utility to be at the top of the Transition when it comes to dealing with water and recycling management. They have defined themselves as a company for Ecological Transformation and have put climate goals and digital technologies at the top of their business, their strategy follows. Veolia has also set up an innovation culture and lab within its ranks, which will make sure it stays at the top. An entire business line is about climate mitigation and how to deal with water challenges in the wake of climate change. They have also developed entire ranges of tools on how to digitally manage their utilities remotely. They have softwares to monitor environmental variability, water overflow and pollution and are able to react instantly when the systems spot a security threat. Making their business about dealing with the effect of climate change and adapt essential utilities to its worst effects, as well as given themselves all the new digitals tool to do so, is the reason why it makes Veolia the best prepared. Antoine Frérot, Veolia’s CEO, has been looking to acquire Suez for over 10 years and finally managed to secure a strong position.
Both companies have outperformed the overall global water sector this past year and their performance also remains above that of the S&P 1200. Whilst these two plays may appear similar because of the recent merger, they are not. As previously suggested, the deal will leave out two entities: Veolia becoming the new powerhouse of the water and waste industries, and a Suez spinout-out that will be dedicated to water assets in France and globally. Both companies will therefore ride on the digital differentiation trend, albeit at different sensitivities. Veolia will be a growth play that will also drive on its waste and ecological transformation business, whilst the new Suez will become a new pure play in water innovation. We recommend investors to keep them both on their radar and select the play(s) that best fit their portfolios.