The fast fashion business model may perhaps be the best representation of the combined pitfalls of globalization, deregulation, and consumer behavior.

In today’s note, we describe how the fast fashion industry has navigated each one of the above factors to produce apparel at an increasingly cheap financial price, while exacting an ever-increasing environmental price on the planet.

What Is Fast Fashion And How Did We Get Here?

The overall fashion industry is quite fragmented (Nike has the largest market share at less than 3%), but the fast fashion industry is a significant sub-sector and includes behemoth apparel companies like Zara, H&M, Uniqlo, etc. As the Chart below shows, among the largest 14 global apparel brands, half are considered fast fashion companies.

Contrary to the more traditional fashion industry, fast fashion manufacturing is on a cycle that can be as short as two weeks. The business model is built on low price and perceived scarcity, and has taken something that once was considered a basic need and turned it into an entirely discretionary (and disposable) product. We outlined the environmental and social burden of this industry in a note two years ago (A Fashionably Unsustainable Industry, January 23 2020), and unfortunately, little has changed since: apart from a short, Covid-related pause in apparel spending, the volume of clothes being manufactured and sold continues to increase.

Interestingly, some of the largest fast fashion companies are the same companies that receive top rankings for ESG initiatives. For example, Inditex (Zara) routinely scores well on E, S and G sustainability rankings and have made good progress toward some of their objectives, such as reducing plastic and increasing renewable energy use. However, the company does not address the problematic nature of the business model: over the past twenty years, the clothing industry has evolved from having two “seasons” (production cycles) per year to as many as twenty-four. The constant stocking of new trends incites consumers to buy ever more frequently and a negative feedback loop is in place whereby low prices encourage consumers to cycle through clothes more quickly, which drives companies to make clothes that are increasingly disposable. 

Moreover, the ability to produce low-cost clothes in the first place is in large part due to the few barriers to global trade in the apparel industry.

Globalization and The Deflationary Tailwind: The Apparel Industry Changed Forever?  

There are few industries that are better-suited to be the poster child for globalization. The cross-border trade in goods and services, technology, investment and people mean that any given manufactured garment will travel on average to five countries, spanning three continents, before it is fully constructed and sold and to a customer. Apparel manufacturing remains a comparatively low-technology endeavor and a highly competitive industry; free trade among nations has meant that factories move to the cheapest international labor markets and the savings are generally passed on to consumers.

Indeed, as the below chart shows, for the majority of the past three decades (i.e. since China joined the World Trade Organization), the price of clothing in advanced economies like the U.S. has been in deflation territory. True, recent supply chain challenges have paused this trend for now and we do not expect prices to fall significantly further given our view that globalization has peaked. Nonetheless, clothing prices remain extremely cheap relative to historic norms.

It is thus astounding that, although the average consumer today purchases 15 more new items per year as they did only fifteen years ago, they spend only a fraction of their budget on apparel. Indeed, if one goes further back in time, consumers of the 1950s spent 12% of their overall budgets on clothing, compared to just 2.5% today. This has by and large been made possible due to cheap labor and intensive use of natural resources – the apparel manufacturing industry is considered a low-tech industry whereby productivity improvements have significantly lagged other economic sectors.

Consumers: Compelled To Shop?  

The above paragraphs underscore that both the disposability and affordability of clothes have never been greater. Awareness about the problems -namely environmental degradation and worker treatment – has also never been greater. Indeed, since the Rana Plaza tragedy in 2013, there has been more media attention paid to the plight of garment workers in Bangladesh and elsewhere; the table below describes just a few of the controversies over the past decade.

It is increasingly difficult for consumers anywhere to feign ignorance about where their clothes come from and in what conditions they may be produced, thanks to organizations like the Fashion Transparency Index, whose mission is to push the world’s largest fashion brands to be more transparent about their social and environmental efforts.  

There is some indication that awareness campaigns are paying off. A recent McKinsey survey revealed that consumers are becoming less inclined to factor in “newness” or “season trend” into their fashion purchase and are increasingly willing to invest in durability.  Moreover, there are some tentative signs that younger shoppers have different priorities and could drive a re-make of the fast fashion business: the demise of fast fashion’s Forever 21 brand is widely viewed to be driven by Generation Z’s eschewing the values that the brand represents.

Whether this translates adopting different shopping habits is difficult to forecast, albeit the evidence from other sectors does not inspire confidence. Take food: year after year, survey data shows that respondents desire to eat healthier and yet the data show otherwise: each decade, average Western diets become more processed and fattier. Just like for fashion, the decreasing cost of food is a major factor in spurring increased consumption.

Regulation: A Powerful But Underutilized Force

In the case of fast fashion, for the past twenty years, market forces have meant that consumers’  insatiable demand for trendy goods has been more than supplied by companies that leverage the global free-trade backdrop to bring (dump) ever more goods to market.   

But more recently, there has been a call for increased regulation and laws have passed in some developed countries, as the table below highlights. However, most clothing manufacturing occurs in underdeveloped countries (such as India, Vietnam, and Bangladesh) that do not have the organizational structures in place to hold apparel manufacturers accountable for pollution and worker conditions. By subcontracting in these countries, western brands can buffer themselves from regulations in their home jurisdiction and evade legal liability.

The European Union is leading the charge from a regulatory standpoint. Although EU law can not control conditions where the goods are produced, they can impact companies where they sell their products. Earlier this week, the European commission proposed a law that aims to force EU companies to increase due diligence in supply chains across various industries.

Perhaps most damning is that most regulatory initiatives are intended to improve environmental and social conditions but do nothing to attack the business model of fast fashion, which equates to unnecessarily producing low-cost disposable clothing. Laws that are aimed to reduce or eliminate planned obsolescence, i.e.  designing a product with an artificially limited life span so that it becomes obsolete after a certain pre-determined period of time, are one way that countries could curtail the fast fashion industry.  In some countries (France), planned functional obsolescence is punishable both through fines and jail. However, legislation around planned perceived obsolescence – the re-styling of products so consumers will purchase the latest trends - is still absent.

On the whole, it is unlikely that a regulatory push will drastically impact the fast fashion industry within a medium-term investment timeframe.

Investors that have looked to buy ESG investment products with the goal of adding or subtracting specific non-financial characteristics from their portfolio in recent years would have been right to be sceptical. Many of the most well-known ESG products break several rules of basic investing and don’t live up to their hype. In today’s note, we address the current weaknesses of many ESG funds, what needs to be done to correct this, and offer investors some possible solutions to ensure that ESG dollars are put to work most effectively.

For our analysis, we collect data from the approximately 42 U.S. listed ETFs that focus on ESG equities. Total assets under management (AUM) of these funds stands at $55.5b, with impressive inflows of $17.3b in 2021. Market concentration is quite high: the top 10 ESG ETFs by AUM have 92.4% of the assets and enjoyed 87.8% of 2021 flows.

 

Part A: The Issues

1: A Rose by Any Other Name…

 A major criticism of many ESG funds is what is hiding behind the label. As the table below displays, out of the top 10 largest (market capitalization) holdings in the S&P 500, nine are featured in the top ten holdings of U.S. ESG funds. The exception is Home Depot, which is a regular in ESG funds and replaces Berkshire Hathaway in the overall S&P 500 index. In other words, the top ten holdings, representing nearly 30% of the standard investment benchmark, are the same companies that represent roughly 30% of most popular ESG funds. Similar results are also displayed for international funds in the second chart below – of the top ten holdings, only SAP is found in ESG funds and not in MSCI EAFE.

 

Given the huge overlap in the major holdings of the benchmark and ESG companies, it is not overly surprising that there is little air between the price performance of the S&P 500 and well-known ESG ETFs and funds (see the chart below).

 

Since not even the most fervent proponents of these funds would believe that the S&P500 qualifies as an ESG index, it is more likely that the rapidly increasing consensus is correct: most ESG funds are labelled as such simply due to a bare-minimum exclusion policy. By weeding out a few names with unsavory practices and/or higher carbon footprints, an ESG label can be applied. The chart below offers substantial evidence that this has been the case.

The S&P energy sector accounts for 2.3% of the overall S&P 500. In the past year, S&P500 ex-energy has underperformed the broad index due to the substantial price gains in oil prices over the same time frame. This behavior matches almost perfectly the performance of ESG funds over the past two years: just as S&P 500 ex-energy underperforms (outperforms) the broad index when oil prices rise (fall), ESG funds outperform the S&P 500 when oil prices sink and underperform when they rise.

 

Bottom line: there is negligible tracking error between many conventional ESG funds and their benchmarks. These products offer no discernable diversification or specific properties to investors.

2: Condemned to Have an Itching Palm?

If the results above are discouraging for investors that may buy ESG funds with the expectation that they are making a difference, the second issue at stake with many ESG products will perhaps dishearten them further. Using the same basket of U.S.-listed ESG ETFs, we find the average AUM-adjusted MER is 16.2 bps. This compares to just 3 bps for the cheapest S&P 500 Index ETF! Note that the same phenomenon exists in Europe: the average AUM adjusted MER is 17.4bps versus 7bps for the cheapest MSCI EAFE Index ETF.

 

Bottom line: Investors tend to pay two-to-three times the expense ratio to have 3 letters (ESG) added to the name of their holdings. Save for the letters, there is little else that justifies the management fees; investing in these products often amounts to overpaying for a generic basket.

 

Part B: Emerging Solutions

1. We Must Not Make a Scarecrow of the Law

Initially, the label ESG came about in part because there is a general belief that it would help investors recognize opportunities that can positively impact society and the environment. However, since there are many shades of green and impact is subjective, our analysis above shows how easy it is to be ESG, without actually shifting capital in a meaningful way.

In Europe, regulators are beginning to get out in front of this phenomenon, by putting in place the Sustainable Financial Disclosures Regulation (SFDR). The SFDR came into effect in March 2021 and is designed to help investors understand, compare, and monitor the sustainability characteristics of investment funds by standardizing sustainability disclosures. Although, there are only 10 months of data, it is already clear that this regulation has influenced the offering of investment products and have helped investors discriminate among them. The table below shows the most commonly held holdings in “Article 9” funds, i.e. funds that are held to the strictest level of environmental disclosure. Apart from Microsoft and Alphabet, there is no overlap between the top holdings of the S&P 500 and conventional ESG Funds.  

 

Note that SFDR is meant to provide transparency on both environmental and social characteristics. However, the regulation has been particularly effective so far as it relates to the environment because EU taxonomy regulation has provided specific environmental criteria related to economic activities for investment purpose. A similar taxonomy for social issues is in development, but will not be enforced for at least two more years. Moreover, SFDR is a European regulation, and applies to only to European market players and non-European players that do business in Europe. Implementing SFDR and/or introducing similar legislation at a global level would no doubt go a long way to improving the labelling of ESG-related investment products.

 

2. He Thinks Too Much; Such Men Are Dangerous

A second necessary ingredient to improving the ESG investment product offering is increased volume from the unofficial arbiters. This is already at work; investigative journalists like Saijel Kishan and Cam Simpson at Bloomberg are helping to expose the incongruencies between the marketing of solutions and the actual positions of portfolios.

Just slapping the name ESG on a fund and excluding a few names from the universe of investments is unlikely to cut it in the future as more information becomes available and investors realize they are not getting their money’s worth.

 

Part C: Practical Advice for Investors Seeking True ESG

Given the emerging solutions outlined above, it is clear that there is no substitute for doing one’s homework. Investors that truly aim to invest in sustainability themes will find that using broad ESG ETFs as a short-cut is often expensive without necessarily arriving at the correct destination. Some ways to avoid the pitfalls of broad ESG ETFs include the following:

After a tough 2021 year for ESG investors, the start of 2022 certainly does not look like the year ahead will be a walk in the park for those looking to build a better world through capital markets.

Indeed, all our ESG investment themes – composed of about 500 out of the 3,000 stocks included in the MSCI World index, have underperformed the index so far this year.

A primary investment thesis at Sustainable Market Strategies is that fiscal policy now plays an important role in macroeconomic business cycles and is a key reason why ESG themes are increasingly investable. Unfortunately, the support from both macroeconomic tools – monetary (see our note of last week: “Beware Drunken Sailors, the Tide is Turning”, January 20, 2022) and fiscal policy – appears set to fade in 2022. This makes the backdrop for ESG themes more challenging going forward.

In terms of fiscal policy, President Biden’s ambitious agenda has been somewhat torpedoed from within his own party in the past few weeks, which has forced him to scale back the amount of funds that he planned to inject in the economy through his “Build back better” plan. The risk of political gridlock will increase if the democrats lose either chamber in the mid-term elections later this year. Add on Trump’s 2024 covert political campaign that still looms large over U.S. politics and voters to the fading tailwinds for ESG themes in markets.

Moreover, as bond yields rise on the back of a more hawkish Fed, sky-high valuations in equities have triggered investors to cut back risk levels. This is becoming especially material for ESG-minded investors who are often positioned into growth-oriented or “concept stocks” (hello ARK investments) – i.e. those companies which are building technologies the world needs to make it a better place. The flipside is that these investors are often underweight “value stocks” (coal, oil, industrials, etc.) which have proven profitable and already provide earnings to investors. In this context, it is not overly surprising that key ESG themes have underperformed so far this year.

For our part, and testifying to our “ESG bias”, our “long” investment universe currently displays a median forward P/E ratio of 25, while our short portfolio (comprised of ESG laggards and greenwashers) has a median forward P/E ratio of 15. In comparison, the MSCI World currently displays a forward P/E ratio of 18. With this in mind, it is a challenge to shift a typical ESG portfolio into “value” type equities when the liquidity tide turns – such as the current “run-for-value” movement we’ve witnessed so far in 2022.

Nonetheless, for investors that expect the value rotation to be sustained for some time, it is possible to combine “value traits” with ESG. This week, we provide a list of attractive “value” plays within our ESG universe.

In terms of positioning an ESG portfolio for success in the current environment, real interest rates that are set to remain negative for a long while added to the current tailwinds supporting commodities - especially oil - suggest tilting your strategy to one that will benefit from a high growth, high inflation environment. In this context, we think that ESG-minded investors - which can hardly put themselves in a “net long” position in oil and oil stocks - ought to try to gain exposure to some proxies to oil such as 1) transition materials (cobalt, copper, lithium, and others), 2) related commodities such as carbon and 3) agricultural land and services. We expect these sectors to outperform in the near to medium term.

This research service has been a big fan of the KRBN ETF since its launch back in 2019, which provides access to traded carbon futures in markets around the world. We see this investment continuing to offer a secular, decorrelated play to higher commodity prices while contributing to higher carbon prices globally – a good thing for the environment. Moreover, as governments worldwide increasingly notch up carbon prices and limit the supply of emission rights, we see the price of carbon prices moving only higher in the months to come.

Meanwhile, increasing portfolio exposure to transition commodities, such as those included in the SMS transition commodities and materials index (i.e. copper, lithium and cobalt futures), could also make sense in this macroeconomic environment, whereby activity stays robust and inflation surprises are to the upside.  

As for an ESG-friendly play in agricultural commodities and land, it’s hard to find 1) listed assets in this sector and 2) many existing ETFs and funds typically greenwash their holdings to make them “look and feel” ESG. As much as we like the sector from a macro perspective (negative real rates, low correlation to other assets, inflation protection, etc.) we’d be inclined to suggest finding companies which are helping others increase their productivity in the sector such as machinery companies John Deere and Kubota or fertilizers such as Yara and Nutrien. To this end, SMS’ Agricultural Index forward P/E is currently about half that of the MSCI World, making it a great addition to a portfolio in the current context.

Finally, as forests are increasingly recognized for their impact on biodiversity and increasingly valued as such by both authorities and markets, looking at the global forestry sector as a value play could also make sense as we move closer to the COP 15 on Biological Diversity this April.

The current market narrative is that inflation is transitory and, even if it is not, the Federal Reserve will come to the rescue of stocks should there be a correction. Our view is different for two main reasons: the first is that it is highly probable that inflation will remain higher than the 2% target and the second is that the maximum employment mandate has essentially been fulfilled. Therefore, contrary to the past decade, the Fed’s leeway to support stock prices during corrective phases has dwindled.

During 2020, the mandate of the Federal Reserve was changed to loosely target average inflation over an undisclosed timeframe. This led investors to believe that the Fed would be supportive for a very long time. Lo and behold, 7% inflation in 2021 and all timeframes now have excessive inflation: the chart below shows that U.S. CPI inflation is averaging more than 2% on an annual, 5-year, 10-year and 20-year basis.

Moreover, the supply chain issues that drove the transitory inflation analysis are persisting much longer than expected as the chart below depicts. Generally, supply chain issues make their way onto price measures with a lag, which supports the view that inflation is unlikely to revert towards 2% anytime soon.

As for maximum employment, the unemployment rate is well below the average of the last 30 years. Wages are also increasing fast, suggesting that the maximum employment mandate looks to be achieved. The only aspect of the employment picture that goes against this view is that the labor market participation rate remains stubbornly below pre-pandemic levels.

We recognize that high debt levels within the economy and previous periods of relatively low inflation with strong employment have slowed the historical reaction function of the Fed and delayed policy normalization. Still, currently the Federal Reserve has interest rates at zero while inflation is 7% and its asset purchase program is still not completed; financial conditions are extremely loose.

For asset prices, interest rates are important as they affect leverage within the economy and margin debt, but the size of the balance sheet could be even more important. The chart below shows the evolution of the Fed Balance Sheet since the Great Financial Crisis. History does not repeat itself but it sometimes rhymes. When the size of the balance sheet was capped in 2015, market volatility ensued and returns were meagre for the year. When the balance sheet shrank in 2018, it led to a drop of 20% in the stock market during the fourth quarter. These episodes reflect market participants adjusting to a new liquidity backdrop rather than a change in underlying earnings dynamics. For our part, we anticipate a strong economy in 2022 so we are not expecting a bear market but a continued transition away from concept stocks and a volatile investment environment.

The following two charts illustrate the potential reaction of different portions of the equity market to a change in the discount rate coming from higher interest rates and reduced excess liquidity. We compare concept stocks that are not making money now but could make it big in the future, quality growth stocks that are growing rapidly with high price to earnings multiple, and value stocks that are not growing much but have low price to earnings multiple. In the first chart, we show the theoretical cash flows of a concept stock (losses at the beginning with strong growth afterwards), a quality growth stock (strong growth for a long time followed by stability) and a value stock (slow growth quickly followed by stability). The following chart shows the relative price according to a discounted cash flow model and P\E ratio under different discount rates (8%-12%-16%). The illustration shows that when the discount rate goes higher, concept stocks get crushed and quality growth performs worse than value.

Since 2008, we have seen continuously falling discount rates which explains the high level of IPO activity from concept stocks and the fabulous performance of quality growth companies. If discount rates increase in the near future, the table below shows some companies that you should examine. These companies are a sampling of strong winners and losers from an ESG perspective that we then assign along the lines of concept, quality growth or value. In a higher discount rate environment that favors ESG leaders, the light green portion is attractive with dark red unattractive.

We have also examined those same companies according to our ESG themes in the following chart. If we zoom in on Natural Capital and specifically for pollution control, we find two competitors in the pest control space: Ecolab and Rollins. Both companies trade at high multiples around 50X earnings. But from an ESG standpoint, these two companies are very different; Ecolab takes ESG seriously and treats it as a competitive advantage whereas the strategy for Rollins is hard to see. To this end, Just Capital released its 2022 rankings and Ecolab is part of the Top 100; ranking in the top decile whereas Rollins is in the bottom decile. For the environment, ECL is first in its industry and 81st overall while ROL is 647th. Overall, for workers, ECL is 21st, ROL is 894th and for governance, ECL is 240th and ROL is 733rd. For an investor looking to reduce exposure to quality growth, Rollins would be a better cut candidate than Ecolab for someone that emphasizes sustainability.

It is becoming increasingly well known that if we are to limit global warming, significant reform of the agriculture industry is necessary.

Much of the focus on food reform is about animal-sourced protein, since the rearing of livestock generates 14 per cent of all greenhouse gas emissions, similar to the amount generated by all cars and trucks worldwide.

It is easy to understand the problem of meat: it is an environmentally expensive food since large animals are inefficient at converting feed to muscle, meaning they make large demands for cropland, water, and fertilizers. An improvement in agricultural practices could help, but the enormity of the problem –  meat and dairy provide just 18% of calories consumed but use 83% of global farmland and make 60% of agriculture’s greenhouse gas emissions – mean that simply tweaking current processes will not be enough.

The solution – to eat less meat – also seems relatively simple. Unfortunately, as with many climate change problems, humans’ hardwiring makes it complex in practice. Human psychological biases and behavioral tendencies – such as preferring things stay the same (continuing to frequent the same stores and restaurants), avoiding things that are difficult (learning to cook with new ingredients), and discounting the future (giving up something today for a better future tomorrow) – mean that convincing people to reduce animal consumption is difficult.

For all the above reasons, we expect that the transition to a lower meat diet, although necessary, will take time. After all, those that are trying to reduce meat consumption are overwhelmingly driven by personal reasons (e.g. health and financial savings) rather than the environment.

A wholesale turn-away from meat is likely to occur only once meat-like alternatives become tastefully acceptable; environmental factors won’t trigger a significant shift toward vegetarianism. On this basis, the quest for a lower environmental footprint protein can be divided into three distinct groups: ‘Meat Is Meat’, ‘Vegetables As Protein’ and ‘Plant-based Meat Substitutes’.

‘Meat is Meat’

Meat lovers have the greatest resistance to lowering their steak intake: substituting a non-animal protein will only happen if high sensory standards were met on taste, look and texture. To achieve the meaty taste without the animal requires significant R&D. Many companies therefore look more like tech start-ups than food companies as they use AI, 3D Printing and biotechnology to develop their products. AI can be leveraged to find flavour combinations and plant proteins to replicate the taste; 3D printing can help achieve the look, but cell-based production will be the closest to the real deal.

 

Lab-grown meat is cultivated from cells taken from an animal and then grown into the fat or muscle people like to eat. The result is a product composed of the same proteins and cells as the animal of origin but requiring significantly less resources to grow it. While there are many companies exploring these technologies, the majority are privately owned, a testament to the remaining challenges of scalability and cost. Small-cap players like Agronomics, MeaTech 3D and Bio Meat Foodtech are publicly traded. As the chart shows, the first two names have not seen any price appreciation in their stock while Bio Meat has had a fantastic post IPO run-up but appears about to return to earth.  A larger name to watch is Amyris Inc.: while not a pure food play, the biotech company has recently signed a joint venture with Minerva Foods to explore more sustainable protein sources.

‘Vegetables As Protein’

At the other end of the spectrum are steadfast vegetarians and vegans. These dietary movements were around long before alt-meat and self-identified vegetarians do not necessarily require protein to resemble meat; unprocessed peas, beans, lentils, quinoa, tempeh, tofu, etc. are acceptable alternatives. Vegans and vegetarians also tend to have more produce in their diets. The denser texture of mushrooms, avocados and eggplants act as substitutes and Calavo Growers, Mission Produce and Yukiguni Maitake Co Ltd are recognized to fill this market.

However, it is challenging to find a strictly vegetarian investment opportunity: many of the companies growing produce and crops are small or private. There is often a direct link to the traditional meat industry since a significant portion of their yield is also sold as feed for livestock.

Demand for unprocessed vegetarian staple foods is expected to continue to grow somewhat as people try to lower their consumption of animal products. However, the greatest potential for demand increase will be from alternative meat producers using these plant-based proteins as ingredients in their products.

 

‘Plant-based Meat Substitutes (Flexitarians)’

Despite the relatively static share of strict vegetarians and vegans, it is an undeniable question that consumers seek alternatives to meat. They want simple changes to their diet that can be easily substituted in their existing recipe repertoire and restaurant options. Companies – whether it be food producers or restaurants – that can offer products that are healthier with little friction to the consumer will have a winning formula.

The leaders in plant-based meat substitutes – Beyond Meat and Impossible Foods – are young companies in a fledgling industry. Beyond Meat IPO’d in May 2019, while Impossible Foods is expected to go public later this year.  

There has been a lot of hype around plant-based substitutes (Bill Gates is a major promoter and investor in the industry). The health benefits of eating green and the major environmental problems that need to be overcome in the agricultural industry are well known and these companies offer a solution to both. However, sales of plant-based products have not fulfilled expectations of late. U.S. retail sales of plant-based meats in 2021 Q3 were 3% lower than in Q3 2020, which is a worrisome sign for an industry that should be in a high-growth phase (sales of conventional meat increased by 4% over the same period).

Despite recent disappointing sales, we do agree with Bill Gates that plant-based substitutes are an important innovation and will be part of the solution to replace environmentally inefficient protein sources (conventional meat). However, investing in this sector is not for the faint-hearted. We note several risks that make it difficult to decipher which companies will be long-term winners in this sector:

 

There is no doubt that Omicron is different from its earlier COVID cousins (more transmissible, more resilient to current vaccines). Yet to the untrained eye, an atom of Omicron or Delta is completely indistinguishable. In a similar fashion, although outcomes will surely be different, the investment outlook for 2022 has a lot in common with 2021! After all, many of the major drivers that were in place are relatively unchanged:

All of this means that many of the investment themes identified at Sustainable Market Strategies in 2021 will still be very much in play in 2022.

Most notably, the need to strengthen supply chains in a world where inflation surprises will continue to be to the upside will remain top of mind for investors (please see our Note on November 25, 2021, Inflation Is An ESG Phenomenon).

Reducing carbon emissions remains as critical as ever, but one theme that we expect will become more prominent in 2022 is biodiversity and the need to protect (and invest) in natural capital. The UN COP Biodiversity is scheduled to be held in person in April 2022 with the stated aim of elevating the protection of biodiversity to the same level of importance as climate. Additionally, while you may have heard of the Taskforce on Climate Change Disclosure (TCFD), the Taskforce for Nature Disclosure (TNFD) was launched this June with the goal of encouraging global financial flows toward nature-positive outcomes. We anticipate that these developments will help to sharpen investors’ focus around environmental risks and opportunities and that investment diversification beyond the “energy transition” will intensify in the coming months.

We kick off 2022 with a list of our high conviction investment ideas, with a particular eye on investments that deliver diversification benefits and can offer a hedge against inflation. Many of our recommendations are environment-based as there is a greater likelihood that capital will be allocated to the sector in coming months. However, no ESG investment list would be complete without addressing “washing”, i.e. paying lip-service to a cause with no discernable positive impact. Our top 2022 short ideas emanate from companies that have run afowl to this practice.

 

Idea #1: Transition Metals: Long Recyclers and Strong ESG-minded Miners

Long-time readers of our work will note that we have been recommending positions in transition metals for quite some time but our conviction that a structural overweight allocation to these metals will be profitable is too high to ignore on our list for 2022. Our view was even reinforced late last year by recent IMF research that showed copper, nickel, cobalt and lithium prices could rise several hundred percent (!) compared to their average 2020 levels in a net-zero emissions scenario.

After an impressive price run-up in the past year among some battery materials, the consensus is for flat to weaker prices in 2022 on account of additional supply that is forecasted to come on-line for copper and nickel: miners are expected to ramp up production. That said, bottlenecks are ongoing and even after the impressive increase in 2021, both copper and nickel prices are still below their ten-year peak (established well before the EV market was really born). Any pull back in these commodity prices should serve as an entry point to structural long positions.

Commodities are well known to be an effective inflation hedge. Of course, the relationship between oil prices and inflation will be challenged as the energy transition progresses, but the high correlation between industrial metals – especially those that are also considered transition metals (e.g. copper, nickel) and inflation is likely to stay in place. For investors concerned about upside inflation surprises, an overweight position to transition metals should be especially appealing.

At this stage, investing in other battery materials still broadly requires investing in the companies that mine and/or recycle them. Cobalt and lithium contracts have been introduced to both the LME and CME metal exchanges – the former enforces responsible sourcing requirements – but volumes are still low (albeit rising, see Chart) and are dominated by industrial players that are hedging their physical needs. Investors might rightly worry about the nefarious environmental and social impact of extracting these metals: our analysis identified indicators to help discriminate among mining companies (please see our note ‘Transition Metals: Wicked Problems, Smart Solutions’ on October 14, 2021). Our favourite transition metal plays are Umicore, Boliden and increasingly, Rio Tinto.

 

Idea #2: A Mighty Link In the Supply Chain: Long distribution warehouses (Prologis, Duke, STAG)

Real Estate investments are often seen as a go to for investors seeking inflation protection, given their reputation for high dividend yields and the capacity to increase rent in accordance with generalized price rises. However, desirable options in the REITs space are increasingly limited: the future of retail was already under question even before the pandemic tailwinds for e-commerce arrived and REITs in the hotel and office industries look less attractive. Competing strongly for hotel’s market share prior to 2020, private property rentals via Airbnb and Vrbo were the preferred accommodation for pandemic travellers seeking socially distanced time off. Office real estate is unlikely to fully recover as some offices will become obsolete and many are likely to downsize their current spaces as employees have adapted to working from home.   

Opportunities in the industrial REITs sector via warehouses and distribution centers can offer the benefits of inflation protection while also helping improve supply chain resiliency, one of our six investable ESG themes at SMS. Investors interested in this sector should look for REITs that focus on warehouses and distribution centers that are efficient in their internal operations and also lower the distance goods travel from warehouse to consumer, therefore reducing the carbon footprint of delivery.

We recommend three names that fit these criteria: Prologis, Duke Realty and STAG Industrial. Prologis is the largest, operating in 19 countries with 4675 facilities. Duke Realty and STAG Industrial are U.S.-based but are well diversified with over 500 buildings each. Each of these three REITs ranks above their peers in CSRHub consensus ESG ratings, with Prologis having the strongest showing. This suggests they are already well placed for the transition to a high care, low carbon economy.   

As supply chain issues continue in early 2022 due to the Omicron variant, we expect these companies, with their diversified locations, to be better positioned to face these challenges. Regardless of the next chapter in the pandemic chronicles, these REITs can be expected to benefit from consumers’ continued enthusiasm for at-home delivery.

 

Idea #3: Seeing the Forest and The Trees: Long Holmen, SCA and Weyerhaeuser

As mentioned above, we anticipate that investable opportunities for the environment will go beyond the energy transition in 2022. In a Note last year (Knock on wood, May 20, 2021), we concluded that while higher lumber prices were giving a boost to some lumber companies, the forest was the real asset: “If we look at the forest instead of the trees, the recent rise in lumber is a short-term boost to profitability for companies that produce lumber, but the long-term value will be derived in forestry and the ownership of trees”. The importance that Holmen and SCA (Svenska Cellulosa Aktibolaget) and Weherhaueser place on their forests is the reason they are included in our top ideas for 2022.

SCA is Europe’s largest private forest owner, with 2.6 million hectares of woods. Holmen counts 1.2 million hectares. Both Swedish companies, Holmen and SCA are committed to managing their forests in a sustainable manner with biodiversity as an important element in their processes. Both companies boast environmentally certified forests and have dedicated conservation areas - more than 20% for Holmen and 10% for SCA. Maximizing the use of resources by using every component of the trees that are harvested is another commitment common to both. Weyerhaueser operates on a similar basis in North America.

Aside from their sustainable approaches to forestry management, the increasing demand for more nature-based solutions also makes this an appealing investment. Trees offer eco-friendly building materials, emitting less carbon than cement or steel; and despite the fading print industry, paper is reinventing itself in sustainable packaging.

One caveat is the potential for regulation in Europe. In July 2021, the EU announced its revised forest strategy, with the aim to increase “the quantity and quality of forests” and “increase carbon sequestration through enhanced sinks and stocks”. For companies like SCA and Holmen that are both built on the thesis that healthy forests are ones that are actively managed, any new regulations that go against this principle could temper their operations. Overall, we expect the financial value of standing tree forests to increase over time and SCA and Holmen are particularly well suited to capitalize on this trend, given their long history in sustainable forestry management.

 

Idea #4: Emerging Asset Class and Diversifier: Long Carbon ETF (KRBN)

Well-functioning carbon markets are widely considered as essential to reach the globally agreed upon target of limiting the earth’s temperature rise to 1.5 °C. It has been well over a decade since the inception of the first carbon markets, but the concept of buying and selling emission credits has finally taken off: the traded value of the three major programmes exceeds $250 billion.

Now that carbon has proven itself as a liquid and investable asset class (over $1 billion per day is traded across physical carbon, futures and options), we expect investors to be increasingly attracted to this emerging asset class for two main reasons:  

The Kraneshare Global Carbon ETF (KRBN) tracks the most traded carbon credit futures contracts and covers the major European and North American cap-and-trade programs: European Union Allowances (EUA), California Carbon Allowances (CCA) and the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative. Long positions in this ETF or similar product should be a core holding in a diversified portfolio.  

One of the most frequently asked questions from clients and prospective clients is “where do you get your ideas?” The question is tougher than it may seem and our answer is rarely eloquent! As a result, and in the interest of always improving, our 2021 end-of-year reflection included identifying the secret sauce of (good) idea generation.

At SMS, we think there might be three factors that invariably help professional teams that strive to produce original, insightful research: cognitive diversity across team members, an institutional culture of freedom of speech, and an extremely healthy dose of curiosity! Today’s Note addresses the latter: we share with you some of our favourite published work that we have uncovered through jumping down internet rabbit holes and participating in lively back-to-office discussions. From classics to newly published work, we hope you find a few nuggets to fuel your holiday conversations and merrymaking (Omicron permitting of course). From all of us at Sustainable Market Strategies, we wish you the very best end to 2021 and prosperous 2022 beginnings.

 

The New Climate War by Michael Mann

In The New Climate War, Michael Mann discusses the next front in tackling rising global temperatures now that climate change is generally accepted as real. Mann disarms the arguments (division, deflection and doomism) deployed to hamper the efforts and changes necessary to avoid a climate disaster. In exposing these tactics, he offers an important lesson in greenwashing and the key elements to address it: education, systemic change and the next generation of voters.

 

Deaths of Despair and the Future of Capitalism by Anne Case and Angus Deaton

The book questions the future of excessive capitalism by examining education, income and health inequalities. This information is vital for investors since understanding the flaws in the status quo can help forecast which parts are most subject to change over time. For capitalism to evolve in the right direction, the weaknesses in the triangle of health, education and income inequalities need to be addressed.

 

The Fourth Turning by William Strauss and Neil Howe

A 1997 classic describing the specific generational traits and the characteristic evolution of society through time from the passage of leadership from generation to generation. Those cycles are illustrated with seasons from the High (Spring), the Awakening (Summer), the Unraveling (Fall), the Crisis (Winter). The book forecasted a transition to Crisis (Winter) during the mid-2000 based on generational characteristics. We had the Great Financial Crisis in 2008 and since then, the mood of the population has eroded and we are reaching a critical point. This information coincides with our macro view (link to Macro Goes ESG) that the make-up of society will change because of the climate crisis and social inequalities. This transition will be disruptive and we see the imprints of the Millennials in the political make-up pushing society forward towards a new High (Spring).

 

New Climate Capitalism by Denise Young

This podcast is about change-makers working at the intersection of activism, finance and investment. A wide range of topics are discussed from the role of activist hedge funds (see our Note on April 22, 2021) to recent degrowth ideas at the IPCC. The podcast’s (mostly) practical and pragmatic nature helps investors understand climate challenges and what can be accomplished by the private and public sectors.

 

Just Have a Think by David Borlace

Just Have a Think is a Youtube channel with short, easy-to-digest videos about sustainable technology and the environment. In each episode, David Borlace explains complex problems and their potential solutions simply. The content is particularly useful in deciphering what are true technological solutions (on an appropriate timeline) from those that are not.  

 

The Beckisphere Climate Corner by Becky Hoag

Becky Hoag is an under-30 science writer and communicator. On her Youtube channel, she produces a bi-monthly clip that summarizes the previous two weeks of climate news. The Beckisphere is an easy, fun way to keep abreast of science and climate issues with far-reaching implications, including investment portfolios.

 

Thinking, Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahnerman

This well-known book is one that we keep coming back to over and over again. Kahneman’s behavioral experiments that uncover human irrationality, overconfidence and the role of luck are particularly fascinating and have multiple implications for investors and for everyday life. Although Kahneman’s seminal book does not explicitly address climate change and other environmental and social factors, the cognitive barriers that he outlines in this book are extremely compelling to understand environmental (non-) action. Our use of heuristics, which evolved to equip us with faster decision-making abilities, also leads us to make systematic and predictable errors. There is now a wide body of research at the intersection of the environment and behavioral science but for investors, the original Kahneman work remains a must-read.   

 

Unraveled The Life and Death of a Garment by Maxine Bedart

The author goes on a mission to track the life and death of a pair of jeans, starting with a cotton grower in Texas, to a textile factory in China, Bangladesh to be cut and sewn, with inputs from various nations along the way … back to America to be worn and finally, to be burned in a trash pile in Ghana. For investors that have been particularly jolted by supply chain disruptions over the past two years, this book offers an extreme close-up view of just how complex supply chains are – even for simple items like a pair of jeans. It isn’t hard to imagine which parts of the supply chain could be altered should regulation and/or price signals from labor and other inputs shift.

 

The Lorax by Dr. Seuss  

Another 15 billion trees died on earth in 2021. Dr. Seuss’ classic children’s story – which turned 50 this year – feels more relevant today than ever. Trees, along with other vegetation, continue to be the most effective carbon sink available. And yet, although this year’s forest fires were tragic, most of the trees were once again lost to planned human deforestation. In April 2022, the U.N.’s COP 15 on biodiversity will be an excellent opportunity for investors to sharpen their focus around nature-based solutions to climate change. Beyond the moral message of taking a stand, The Lorax offers an important reminder of the value of nature – trees – when viewed as an increasingly scarce resource – are worth more when standing in healthy forests than when exploited as resources.

2021 was another bumper year for investors (S&P 500 up 25%) following never seen before stimulus from central banks and fiscal purses. In this context, it was hard for active investors to beat the market. As a result, ESG-minded investors – who got a great ride post-COVID by investing in emerging themes such as EVs and clean energy in 2020 – found it much harder to achieve high returns again this year. Indeed, some could say that some investors were forced into “unknown territory” by looking for investment ideas in a wider array of ESG themes.

This year, our short calls demonstrated that one can indeed generate returns not only by taking long positions in ESG megatrends, but also by shorting themes, sectors and names that will fall out of favor given the changing global investing landscape. In this context, we’ve managed to articulate several short ideas which in all represented about 1/3 of our calls this past year.

Show me your themes: SMS goes thematic

Furthermore, one key development at our firm this past year was the creation of our proprietary thematic research structure. For this, we’ve mapped our investment universe according to global, top down, ESG megatrends. These are also the themes that we are seeing being implemented by some of the world’s most advanced and innovative ESG investors.

In this context, it is worthwhile to measure the performance of our research against this thematic architecture. For starters, our overall average of long/short calls yielded 5.6% (on average) this year, a relatively modest performance compared to the overall market. That being said, SMS’ strives to inform its clients on both “long” and “short” opportunities in companies, sectors, and commodities according to their alignment with ESG megatrends – which we see as being one of the key differentiators of our research offering.

Interestingly, even our short positions displayed some positive price performance (4.7%, on average) amid a market that has tested the nerves of short sellers like never before. However, given the outperformance of the global Energy sector – in particular that of oil and coal companies’ stocks - our short calls under the Energy Transition theme have suffered from rapidly growing post-COVID demand for energy.

Looking at our performance in a more granular fashion using SMS’ Level 2 themes, one sees that our long/short performance is in the red under a few of our subthemes - including water management. The latter can be explained by our long position in Autodesk – a firm which is producing water management software (among other things) – which got hard hit by markets when it reported disappointing earnings last month.

Digging deeper, some of our short calls were right but their timing proved quite difficult, which is often the case when shorting – especially on ESG-related concerns. A case in point is our short call on the generic front-month lumber contract (See our note, “Knock on Wood,” June 20, 2021), for which the price doubled in the past six months, suggesting that we had prematurely called the top in wood prices earlier this year.

Top themes of the year: Labor Fairness and Energy Transition

Labor fairness: Among our most out-of-the-box calls of the year is our short position on food delivery companies (see our note, “Working Class Hero,” April 4, 2021) – DoorDash, Deliveroo, Uber, and others. Our recommendation to short these companies is motivated by the idea that they actually “make money” (although none has profits yet) by underpaying staff – mostly for-hire delivery people with zero social protection – to use their own bikes and e-bikes to criss-cross cities around the world and put themselves (and others) at a high risk of injury on the job. We view such business models as being unsustainable in the medium term – hence our short on the sector.

That said, we were not surprised earlier this week when the EU commission mentioned that it was looking to regulate the delivery industry in an effort to formalize workers’ contracts - forcing those companies to consider them as employees as opposed to contractors. Stock prices in the sector fell subsequently, further pushing our short call into profit territory and with it our investment thesis.

Energy Transition: Within our Energy transition theme, the most interesting calls of the year were on the Carbon ETF (KRBN) and Cameco (CCO CN, uranium) on the long side, and Peabody Energy (BTU), a pure-play coal producer, on the short side.

Carbon has been one of the best-performing commodities again this year. Adding fuel to the fire was the announcement last week that Germany’s incoming government would not let the EU carbon emission right fall below EUR 60 per tonne. This sent benchmark EU carbon contracts trading at above EUR 80 per tonne briefly last week. We view carbon emission rights as a play which will only increase in value through time (actually it is the only way the carbon market can work, i.e., higher price to pollute for emitters!) and one where the energy transition can be accelerated by increasing carbon emission prices.

Our call that uranium producers, nuclear power servicers and utilities could benefit from another leg up in the need for clean energy ahead of COP26 in Glascow was the right one (see our note “An ESG Investor’s Dilemma: Divesting from fossil fuels in times of high prices,” October 28, 2021). Indeed, while nuclear and related industries were seen with a negative eye in the 1980s and after the Fukushima nuclear disaster due to the risk of large-scale accidents, sentiment has turned and it is increasingly understood that the world has little choice but to rely on the nuclear industry more heavily to accelerate the clean-up of energy grids in Europe, Japan and the U.S. For this, we believe the sector will continue to benefit from tailwinds from both governments and consumer appetite for cleaner energy systems over the medium term.

This year we also witnessed the global resurgence of coal prices (see our note “Coal’s last dance,” July 29, 2021) – but not the coal industry. This was mostly due to a diplomatic feud between China and Australia – the biggest players in the global coal trade – and a particularly hot summer in the U.S. which forced a greater use of coal to power the national grid.

Here, SMS suggested to short coal a bit too early in late August only to see its position being crushed by the market in the following three months due to the energy demand shock. That said, we think that coal’s death has not been overexaggerated and that the industry will fade at an accelerated pace, at least as a source of power in developed economies.

Finally, again within the Energy transition theme, our favorite transition pair fared poorly as oil prices doubled this past year. That said, we would expect Total Énergies to outperform Exxon over the longer run when oil prices start resuming to a lower level.

Question 1: What is “net zero” and why is it important for the planet and for investors?  

Net zero refers to the amount of greenhouse gases (GHG) emitted into the atmosphere. These emissions contribute directly to global warming and if emissions continue unchecked, limiting the temperature increase to 1.5 degrees will no longer be attainable. Net zero pledges aim to stabilize the total amount of CO2 present in the atmosphere, either by reducing an emitting activity and/or by offsetting the emissions with actions that remove CO2.  

For investors, ignoring net zero poses not only climate risk but also missed investment opportunities. As the world transitions to a low carbon economy, demand for assets that lower - even cancel - emissions will increase and will be further supported through policy and regulation (see The Inevitable Policy Response 2021: Policy Forecasts).

 

 

Question 2. What is scope 1, scope 2 and scope 3? And what does Net Zero mean for asset owners and asset managers?

Net zero pledges are typically designed based on the level of business activity or “scope” that will be included in an emissions target. Scope 1 emissions are those that a company is directly responsible for within its operations and is the lowest level of ambition for pledges. Scope 2 emissions include those that result from the acquisition or purchase of energy (electricity, steam, heat, coolant). Finally, Scope 3 considers the emissions not covered by Scopes 1 and 2 by looking at the upstream and downstream value chain of a company. In theory, since one company’s scope 3 emissions are another company’s scope 1 emissions, if every entity in the world participated in net zero, simply accounting for scope 1 emissions would suffice. However, since the latter is not yet the case (plenty of companies have not made commitments and/or commitments are not creditworthy – please see question 3 below), the need for measuring scopes 2 and 3 emissions arises. Overall, what is important is that ALL emissions are accounted and pledged for, whichever scope captures it.

For investors, pledges can be important. First, asset managers and owners increasingly use net zero pledges as a basis for aspects of proxy voting (investors generally have focused on scope 1 and scope 2 for voting purposes). These actions provide incentives for corporations to divest from high emission activities.

Second, the prevalence of net zero pledges has given rise to the Net Zero Investment Framework (NZIF). Created by the Institutional Investors Group on Climate Change (IIGCC) which has over 360 members, the framework has two objectives: decarbonize by 2050 and increase climate solutions. Importantly, participants in the Net Zero Investment Framework do not necessarily have portfolios with Net Zero carbon emissions but they commit to investing in companies that are measurably reducing their emissions and/or provide solutions to reduce overall emissions.

While the commitment by many asset owners and managers is a step forward, the NZIF remains lenient and subject to wide interpretation. Government rules will accelerate the process.

 

Question 3: How can investors trust that a company with a net-zero pledge is truly reducing emissions and will achieve their ambitions?

The first major hurdle is the credibility and strength of corporations’ pledges and as with any element of investing, there is no substitute for doing the research. As stated above, about 90% of world GDP is covered by net zero pledges, but that number shrinks to 10% (and 5%) of global emissions, if only institutions with strong commitments and clear plans are included. Sustainable Market Strategies investigates the strength of companies’ pledges as one input to our research process. For investors that desire to cross-reference, the Net Zero Tracker is a free, web-based tool that tabulates net zero targets and indicates the integrity of those targets.  

A second test of credibility is whether a company has set Scope 3 GHG emissions reduction targets, since including these emissions sets a much higher bar for success. Companies that subscribe to standards or certify their engagement with third-party auditors also show that they are transparent about their efforts.

The Science-Based Targets initiative (SBTi) is the most advanced initiative regarding GHG emissions reduction targets, as it certifies reduction targets submitted by companies based on science. The SBTi has translated the scenarios and pathways underlying the IPCC Special Report on 1.5°C into a set of resources that companies can use to model 1.5°C-aligned targets, or well-below 2°C targets. Certified SBTi targets are one of the main elements used to determine the credibility of a company’s climate strategy.

 

Question 4: To what precision is carbon being measured?

Companies that report carbon emission are using either their own company data, the average emissions in their sector, or modelled data. The disclosure of carbon data by companies is loosely regulated, and is therefore often subject to company goodwill.

The least degree of precision is in quantifying methane emissions (from farm animals, leaks in natural gas systems, leaks from melting permafrost, etc.) which represent 11% of global GHG emissions and are significantly more harmful than carbon emissions.

The Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Protocol, which supplies the world's most widely used greenhouse gas accounting standard, could serve as a standard for GHG accounting, given that it also takes into account scope 3 emissions and presents a calculation guide for these emissions. Obviously, standardization and more regulation would lead to better carbon calculation.

 

Question 5: How does this “translate” to investing? How can asset managers and owners influence outcomes by using net zero pledges?  

Asset managers cannot “front run” the real economy with regard to climate change, which remains a real economic issue as opposed to a financial market issue. So unfortunately, it is possible to have “net zero” portfolios and a planet that is still warming.

Some of the smartest ESG investment strategies offer negative carbon footprints (according to SBTi methodology) in a total portfolio context by using long/short portfolios. This can put additional pressure on real-economy players (i.e. the management teams of listed companies) to adopt more aggressive decarbonization.

Credibility remains an issue. As Keynes famously said, “In the long run, we are all dead.”  Commitments to become net zero in 2050 (another 29 years of emissions) will be nowhere near sufficient if implementation plans are too timid in the short run. An excellent way to avoid this pitfall is for investors to prioritize allocating capital to companies led by management teams who prioritize science-based targets for GHG reduction and even tie them into pay packages

 

Question 6: How much of the net zero commitments rely on technology that does not exist or is clearly not economical today?

The International Energy Agency posits that half of 2050 reductions in emissions will have to come from technologies at demonstration or prototype phase. The Net Zero Investment Framework highlights the need for new investments to reduce our carbon footprint. For investors, the natural response to a problem is to invest in technology to get it solved. Those technologies generally require more resources. We may be at a critical point where the resource use of the planet for industrialization is reaching its limit and we have to think about resource optimization and significant reduction in GHG emissions instead of counting on technology.

 

Question 7: Do net zero pledges reduce the perceived need for carbon taxes? Don’t they also shift the responsibility away from the consumer?

In our view, it is almost certainly the case that (voluntary) net zero pledges and SBTis remove some amount of pressure from policymakers and regulators to impose strict legislation on emitters. Absent net zero pledges, we have no doubt that governments would feel a greater responsibility to act, but it is an open question whether elected politicians would act. It is not clear that the degree of global cooperation is sufficient to deal with (global) climate change in the current geopolitical backdrop.

Ultimately, the burden of the transition towards a cleaner future will fall to citizens and consumers and this reality has not yet sunk in for most. Carbon taxes, either emissions taxes or border adjustment taxes, are a financial penalty that will be passed on in large part by corporations to consumers. If these financial penalties are not imposed, much steeper non-financial penalties (i.e. reduced quality of life) will occur. The upside of initiatives like the SBTi is that they incentivize companies to act in the short term to reduce their GHG emissions and avoid paying a carbon tax when and if they will be applicable. 

 

Question 8: How do carbon offsets fit it in and what is the share of carbon offsets vs. carbon cutting in the net zero game? Isn’t this “cheating”?

In waste management, there is a hierarchy when it comes to the 3 Rs: “Reduce” is more important than “Recycle.” It’s the same in carbon management. The priority should be on reducing emissions, then offsetting the hard to abate emissions remaining. On top of this, all carbon credits are not created equal. For a carbon credit to be qualified as strong, it needs to have all of the following criteria:

Increasingly, offset buyers are looking beyond the “carbon” of “carbon offsets” and are looking for environmental and social co-benefits. The more SDGs a carbon credit hits, the more valuable it becomes.

That said, it is still very much “the Wild West” when it comes to the voluntary market. Mark Carney’s Taskforce for Scaling Voluntary Carbon Markets aims to standardize and scale up the market as quickly as possible – which is welcome news. Even the Science Based Target Initiative is that offsets have a role to play in the path to net zero. So, is it cheating? Not if used correctly. And the increase in price of the most credible credits should de facto discourage ill-intentioned companies who wish they could pay a cheap price to tick the “net-zero” box.

Inflation has become a central issue for investors of all stripes; consumer prices are rising faster than seen in over two decades. 

The current debate about whether inflation will be transitory is not trivial since inflation is an important factor in asset class performance. In our view, investors that are in the “inflation is transitory” camp risk overlooking a key change in the macroeconomic landscape: the increasing importance of ESG-related cross-currents.

In this Insight Report, we describe and evaluate the potential for inflation to emanate from each of Sustainable Market Strategies’ six major ESG investable themes. After netting out all of the cross-currents, we conclude that ESG factors on the whole have the firepower to boost global inflationary pressures.  

Making Supply Chains Resilient: Inflationary

Among all our themes, the trend toward more resilient supply chains is, in our view, the theme whereby the link to rising inflation is most direct.

The past two years of logistics’ challenges can be explained more as a series of relative price shocks rather than “too much money chasing too few goods”: a lack of semiconductor chips meant that fewer cars were assembled (and car prices went up), lumber shortages meant that construction activity slowed (and building prices went up), etc. Although it is enticing to view each event as a one-off, we expect relative price shocks will become frequent and we are in good company: according to President Biden’s 100-day Supply Chain Review, “the U.S. needs to ensure resilient, diverse, and secure supply chains … pandemics and other biological threats, cyber-attacks, climate shocks and extreme weather events, [etc] reduce critical manufacturing capacity and the availability and integrity of critical goods, products, and services.”

Standard business practice has been to leverage technology as well as stable international trading to maximize efficiency. As the chart shows, companies were able to pass on savings to consumers, and still maintain high profit margins within a globally competitive backdrop. However, this has become increasingly difficult.

An important question for investors is how this dynamic will impact interest rates. Monetary policymakers tend to look through transitory price changes (relative price shocks) as policy is geared toward longer term outcomes. However, the task of forecasting longer term inflation becomes challenging when relative price shocks frequently cloud underlying trends. Recent research by the Federal Reserve acknowledges that during the pandemic, there was an unprecedented increase in inflation uncertainty among consumers. This was also witnessed in the volatility of inflation expectations in the bond market.

Key takeaway: global supply chain disruptions emanating from various ESG factors will be increasingly frequent and economically significant. These disruptions will in turn cause more significant relative price changes. These price shocks may not result in “generalized inflation” but will nevertheless result in rising costs to consumers and businesses and will make it more difficult for policymakers to diagnose the underlying trend.

Leaving No Person Behind: Inflationary

Perhaps the most straightforward link between inflation and ESG factors is through the labor market. After decades of rising inequality within nations as well as an inability to close the gap between rich and poor countries, there is mounting pressure and societal desire for a fairer playing field. There are several issues at work, but among the most significant:  

(1) Shareholders versus stakeholders: There is a growing understanding that companies that create value exclusively for shareholders without regard for other stakeholders will be scorned by consumers and investors alike. The implication is that the share of profits that go to shareholders is likely capped in favour of a greater share going to labor: wages are likely to rise on a multi-year basis to reflect this societal desire for companies to consider a greater range of stakeholders.

(2) Workplace gender equality: Although equality among all workers is a significant issue, we believe that the role of women in the labor market, in particular, has the potential to raise wages and overall inflation. Recent headlines have focused on the sharp drop in overall female participation rates (especially in the U.S.) as women left the workforce to be caregivers. However, focusing on prime working age (25-54 years old) tells a different story: the participation in this age bracket for both men and women have returned to pre-pandemic rates (and the participation rate for women in this bracket is near historic highs). This suggests that that the likelihood of adding a “new pool” of labor, such as occurred from 1950–1990 when women marched into the labor market, is unlikely. Employers will need to pay more to compete for labor resources in a generally tight labor market, which will create an upward tilt to wage inflation.

(3) Human rights practices: companies with supply chains in developing countries will face pressure to improve social conditions in the countries in which they operate. Eradicating child labor and implementing fair pay initiatives implies that the “global minimum wage” will increase and/or the supply of available labor will shrink.

 

Key takeaway: a strengthening position of labor will put upward pressure on wages.

Productivity With Purpose: Disinflationary

The creation of tools to improve productivity (and therefore standards of living) is primarily deflationary: if improved productivity means that the production of goods and services can scale efficiently enough to satisfy the market's present and future demand, then the price of those goods should not increase even if demand goes up.

Note that the role of technology in setting prices is no different within an ESG framework than outside of one. The major challenges of the coming decade will be mitigating and adapting to climate change, as well as reducing social inequalities. Therefore, to the extent that these challenges can be resolved with the use of technology, these tools will act as a damper on inflation. Indeed, this is what has occurred across industries for several years.

Key takeaway: Technological advances will be necessary to confront the challenges of the next decade. Associated productivity gains will put downward pressure on prices.  

Building Better Markets: Neutral/inflationary

Our theme of building better markets encapsulates our conviction that a wave of regulation – both for the financial industry and corporations – is likely (and necessary) in the coming years. The broad premise is that over time, regulation will: help ensure that private industries continue to operate in areas where for-profit models produce superior outcomes, while exiting those where they don’t (e.g. prisons); will increase the likelihood that for-profit industries increasingly pay for the negative externalities that they create (e.g. carbon, pollution); ensure that a broad set of rules are followed to guarantee that the private sector creates value for a broader set of stakeholders than simply shareholders.

To the extent increased regulation is employed to build better markets, these increased rigidities (regulation) are likely to mean that inflation will be “stickier” than would otherwise be the case.  

 Key takeaway: greater regulation of key industries introduces macroeconomic rigidities that would put upward pressure on inflation.

 

Achieving the Energy Transition & Protecting Natural Capital: Neutral/Disinflationary  

In the case of our two environmental themes, there are two main factors to consider:

(1) the price of fossil fuel energy and how it will impact demand/supply fundamentals of other goods and services

(2) the likelihood that negative externalities that are currently cheap or free will need to be priced and accounted for.

In the case of fossil fuel prices, a critical point is that energy is a relatively inelastic good: there is little change in the quantity demanded when the price changes. Although “green” energy can be a substitute for fossil fuels (and therefore fossil fuel demand will change), the overall demand for energy is unlikely to be altered significantly in the years ahead. As the chart shows, since the mid-1980s changes in the price of energy (fossil fuels) have not affected the price of other goods and services. Rather, a rise (fall) in energy prices acts as a tax (windfall) to the consumer. Forecasters purporting that the energy transition will be inflationary are therefore making a significant (and unproven) assumption – that any increase in energy prices will be passed on to end users. Although this may occur, it would be a marked break from the inflation dynamics of the past thirty years. For now, we expect that any rise in energy prices will continue acting as a tax on growth, rather than sparking a wave of generalized inflation.

Similarly, to the extent that other environmental costs (e.g. carbon) that have hitherto not been borne by consumers begin to be accounted for, we would view this cost in a similar fashion as energy prices: any inflationary pressure will depend on the ability for producers to pass on increased costs to consumers. This is far from a foregone conclusion.

Key takeaway: energy price swings have not impacted generalized inflation dynamics for decades and it is premature to expect this to change anytime soon.