There are several long- and medium-term factors that imply that capital expenditures will be stepped up significantly in the years ahead. Climate change has led to net zero commitments from both the private and public sectors; in many cases, fulfilling these commitments will require new or retrofitted physical structures. Meanwhile, geopolitics are driving re-shoring or friend-shoring of supply chains which will necessitate investment in new facilities to run these operations closer to home. Also, an ageing population with low fertility rates is creating labor shortages which entice capital investments to substitute workers by machines. On top, public infrastructure programs in developed countries are determined to replace old infrastructure. Those are all factors pointing toward further construction spending.

Indeed, it is estimated that by 2060, the global total floor area of buildings will double. This massive construction boom will have significant environmental implications. As it stands, the construction industry is responsible for about 10% of global energy-related greenhouse-gas emissions, and this is primarily due to the materials used, namely minerals (dominated by cement), metals (steel), and a range of petrochemical-based and rubber materials. Therefore, the construction and building sector will need to undergo important changes if we are to avoid the worst of climate change.

Fortunately, there are numerous solutions that can contribute to reducing emissions related to building and construction. Researchers at the University of Leeds have analysed the potential emissions reduction of various solutions under different scenarios. The table below describes the potential solutions to reduce emissions.

The following table details how building emissions can be reduced by nearly one half. The progressive scenario presents expected emissions reductions based on the application of currently available technology coupled with progressive changes in consumer choice. The ambitious scenario presents additional reductions based on widespread application of technology that is currently in development and extensive changes in consumer choice.

Of these five (partial) solutions, the two with strong opportunities for investors include material switching and low-carbon cement, since these two solutions are likely to create capital allocations toward the materials in higher demand and in companies that can effectively produce low carbon cement. Sustainable Market Strategies addressed the opportunities for low-carbon cement in a note last year, “Cement and steel: the last mile of decarbonization”, March 25, 2021. Thus, in today’s note, we explore the trade-offs between steel and timber and analyze opportunities and risks in both markets.

Strong as Steel:

The Good:

Steel as a building material has several advantages including strength, safety, reliability, design adaptability, quality and speed of construction. Moreover, from an environmental perspective – and contrary to other building materials - steel is 100% recyclable. The table below shows the end-of-life scenarios for concrete, timber and steel. Only 1% of steel ends up in landfill, while 99% is either recycled or re-used. These rates beat other building materials by a significant margin.

In addition, as we face an increasing number of extreme weather events, steel is well adapted to withstand the ravages of climate change: steel structures perform well during earthquakes and other extreme weather events and are a non-combustible material that does not contribute to the spread of fire.

The Bad:

The primary disadvantage is that the steel industry is responsible for 7% of energy-related global greenhouse gas emissions, which is mainly because steel production is an energy intensive process: it requires high temperatures to transform iron ore into steel and the energy currently being used is primarily coal and/or other fossil fuels.

It is difficult to envision a future without material amounts of steel being used in construction. Indeed, steel will also be an important material for the energy transition, since solar panels and wind turbines depend on steel as an input. The IEA predicts that global demand for steel will increase by more than a third through to 2050.

Knock on Wood:

The Good:

Wood is fast and simple to build with and it is biodegradable and regenerative. It captures carbon, is a good insulator, absorbs sound, has good electrical resistance and tensile strength. It also uses less energy, creates less wastewater and has less toxic emissions than steel. Moreover, buildings made of wood are known to foster more comfortable and healthier environments.

The Bad:

Wood is not perfect. It burns, rots and lacks the engineering strength of steel. In regions where the energy required to produce steel and cement comes from relatively clean sources, it is unclear whether wood is less polluting: when the analysis considers a life-cycle assessment that accounts for soil disturbance caused by logging and incomplete recovery of the forest through time.

The Future Must Be Green (Wood and Steel)

Advances in science have created new processes to reduce the negative effects of steel such as CO2 emissions. In the same fashion, scientific progress is reducing the negative attributes of wood like flammability and engineering strength. As a result, we expect low emission steel production to ramp up and engineered wood to be a growing industry.

The solution to dirty steel in the construction industry will include not only material switching away from steel, but also energy switching within the steel industry.

According to the IEA, to meet global energy and climate goals, emissions from the steel industry must fall by at least 50% by 2050. About 40% of this reduction can come from material efficiency (i.e. using less steel), but the rest will need to occur by reducing the average direct CO2 emission intensity of steel production. In other words, new steelmaking processes are critical, and there is not one technology that will be the right answer. The chart below shows which strategies are likely to account for emission reductions until 2050: together, hydrogen, carbon capture, use and storage (CCUS), bioenergy and direct electrification are all potential avenues that can achieve 60% of the necessary emission reductions. Investors should focus on companies that are developing these innovation solutions. Steel production with renewable electricity and green hydrogen has already started, and zero-emission steel plants are scheduled to begin operations in less than 5 years.

Meanwhile, the potential for forestry to reduce emissions by replacing some steel usage is significant. Innovation on biofuels as renewable energy sources and advanced biomaterials used for long-lived constructions such as cross-laminated timber, laminated veneer lumber and Glulam beams are promising. This could reduce emissions for wood as a construction material and expand its construction spectrum to bigger projects previously reserved for steel because of the decreased flammability and greater strength of engineered wood.

Companies That Are Leading the Way  

The analysis above highlights that the construction industry will need to draw upon various strategies to tackle its GHG emission challenge. Material switching toward timber is a partial solution but steel will remain a critical building material. For these reasons, we recommend that investors focus on a basket of “green material companies” that are proving to be environmental innovators.

In the steel sector, we note that the Swedish firm SSAB owns an important stake of Hybrit, which produces steel with renewable electricity and green hydrogen. Voestalpine is an Austrian publicly traded company transitioning to steel using hydrogen, while ArcelorMittal has invested heavily in its Setao plant that will be the world’s first full-scale zero carbon-emissions steel plant, beginning production in 2025.

Meanwhile, for wood-based biomaterials, Stora Enso and Mayr Melnhof Holz are leaders in Cross-laminated timber (CLT); a lighter-weight material now used as a replacement for cement or steel in large construction projects because it resists to strong racking and compressive force. Boise Cascade is a leader in Glulam Beams that are replacing steel beams.

We constructed an equal-weighted index of these six companies; the chart below shows that the “SMS Green Building Materials” index is near its one-year low.

Interestingly, valuations in these companies are relatively attractive, especially when you consider the growth potential of low-emission steel and engineered wood.

This week’s U.S. CPI release for April underscores that inflationary pressures are not yet letting up and it is too early to expect a peak in global inflation.  To be sure, monetary policymakers are now on the job – the Fed hiked the policy rate by 50 basis points last week and another 200 basis points are expected by the end of the year. Note that policymakers target price stability for consumers, but rising prices are wreaking havoc all throughout the supply chain. Moreover, distortions in prices for economic goods and services – and the policy reaction to them – have important consequences for investment returns both across and within asset classes. This is as true for ESG investments as it is for broader mandates. In today’s Note, we look for ESG investment opportunities that are well protected and/or can benefit from inflation.

Inflation and Asset Allocation

Most investors are familiar with the macroeconomic idea that specific asset classes perform better (or worse) depending on the economic growth and inflation backdrop. The diagram below is an update on the classic “asset allocation quadrants”; our version includes the ESG asset classes that we expect to perform well in each of the growth/inflation quadrants, alongside conventional asset classes. As per our previous research, we have been advocating for ESG investors to be positioned within the top and bottom right quadrant: transition metals, carbon prices, forestry and agriculture have been among our high conviction investment calls over the past six months. We expect to move further toward the bottom right as the year progresses: with China’s zero COVID policy still in place, energy prices becoming particularly taxing in Europe, and several central banks raising interest rates, our expectations are that growth momentum will slow further and eventually peak later this year.

Inflation and Equity Investors

Equities as an asset class tend to perform best in low, stable inflation backdrops and struggle to deliver returns in high (and uncertain) inflation periods. When inflation is rising, the discount rate applied to earnings also tends to be higher, and therefore stock valuations (i.e. the P/E ratio) are lower.

That said, the impact of inflation on earnings varies by economic sector and also by individual company. In high inflation environments, the ability to pass on higher input costs further down the supply chain (and eventually onto final consumers) can be an important distinguisher. Indeed, as the chart below shows, producers have been increasing their prices much faster than businesses that sell to consumers especially in the past two years: intermediate non-energy goods prices, as measured by the U.S. core producer price index, have surged far more than (core) consumer prices.

This is inevitably reflected in stock price returns. The table below shows the average S&P 500 stock price returns by sector. In general, sectors that are considered to be at the beginning of the supply chain (energy, materials) and companies that offer services that are non-discretionary (i.e. end users can not substitute away from them) tend to do better in high inflation environments. It is no coincidence that Sustainable Market Strategies has favoured carbon and ESG real estate plays such as forestry and agriculture.

What’s In It For ESG?

The exercise of finding companies with superior pricing power by screening for stable or rising margins can be done for the broad market. However, investors certainly do not need to sacrifice on ESG characteristics to achieve similar results. In other words, we do not see any reason why companies with strong sustainability characteristics would perform differently than sustainability laggards. In fact, to the extent that companies leading in ESG often have a reputational advantage, it may be the case that ESG/sustainable leaders have a better ability to maintain or increase margins relative to their peers. Moreover, as we wrote last year, several ESG factors are contributing to higher inflation (please see our Note, “Inflation is an ESG Phenomenon” November 25, 2021).

Regardless, we focus exclusively on investing in companies with strong, positive ESG characteristics. Therefore, our initial universe includes the winning companies that have surfaced in our historical notes, based on our six investable ESG themes. From this ESG universe, we then look for companies that have stable or rising profit margins over the past five quarters, i.e. while inflation has been increasing significantly. The table below highlights the top companies by sector from our ESG universe that have stable or rising profit margins. Note that although we expect that superior profit margins will be a positive distinguisher, some of the companies on our list have nonetheless struggled to deliver positive equity returns due to a variety of factors, including poor valuation starting points. We expect this trend will reverse in due course. 

 

Global warming is progressing unevenly with the Northern hemisphere experiencing more rapid changes. The heat waves in the Pacific Northwest in 2021 and in Siberia in 2020 are just two recent examples.

Pakistan and India have broken numerous heat records for March and April of this year. Indian crop estimates are being reduced; extreme heat is affecting workers and the harvest.

The map below shows that agricultural potential will deteriorate in most places, but it will improve in the North.

A 2020 study published the map below that shows the suitability of different areas in the world to grow new crops in the next 40-60 years. The warming of the North will create harvest opportunities.

Climate Change and Agriculture

The latest IPCC report underscores the many adverse impacts of climate change including the likely effects on agriculture. Greater variability in weather means greater variability in output for farmers.

Below are two maps: the latest Drought Monitor of the United States and the one at the same time last year. We can see that the western portion of the United States is in drought again. Water is becoming a critical issue and states are fighting for it. California is often called the breadbasket of the world; the California Department of Food and Agriculture says it is the world’s fifth-largest supplier of food and agricultural products. This is a problem because the state is in a worsening drought.

Unstable Climate

Ecology is often governed by nonlinear dynamics: systems which respond disproportionately to initial conditions. Nonlinear relationships often include thresholds; incremental changes in drivers that provoke exceptionally large responses. Using historical analysis instead of climate models, researchers found that the threshold for dangerous climate change will be reached between 2027 and 2042 instead of the IPCC’s forecast of 2052. This means the scary window starts in 5 years. There are many events that should occur once every millennium that now happen every year.

Russian Invasion of Ukraine

Russia is likely to see the greatest increase in arable land from climate change over the long term. However, the invasion of Ukraine is bringing greater food uncertainty around the world for the next couple of years. Russia and Ukraine are among the largest exporters of food and fertilizers in the world. But Russia is now a pariah. Disruptions are currently happening for fertilizer exports and are likely to emerge over the summer for the export of their harvests; bulk carriers cannot get insurance on Russian exports, Ukrainian farmers are interrupted and the ports they use to export from are now in a combat zone.

Carbon Sink

To ensure that the world has enough food, we need to examine more places to grow it. On the other hand, we have seen the effects of unscrupulous deforestation on the Amazon. Land use and land cover changes have led to less carbon dioxide uptake in the tropics compared to untapped boreal forests. Thoughtless agriculture in the North could have a similar effect, if we are not careful. An editorial by researchers Adrian Unc, Bartosz Adamczyk and Nils Borchard provides more background on the topic of expanding northward.

Investment Opportunities

Russia and Ukraine are currently not investable. Canada is a very good place to benefit from the long-term trend of improved agriculture in the North. There are interesting investments in public markets like Nutrien, which is a global producer and distributor of fertilizers based in Saskatchewan and Ag Growth, which is a global leader in food infrastructure based in Manitoba. In private markets, there are funds that invest in Canadian farmland; AGinvest, Area One Farms and Bonnefield.

How favorable is the current sentiment towards green equities in the U.S.? The matter is crucial to ESG investors who, on top of anticipating corporate performance, must pay attention to fast-moving sentiment shifts towards green and ESG investments in general. In this note we build simple and intuitive indicators of green preference using U.S. ETF data. These show a green sentiment “boom” between 2017 and 2020 but have started to abate in December 2021, for the first time in two years. In this context, investors should favor individual, high-conviction stocks that are able to decouple from the broader green sentiment and move their green exposure towards defensive sectors.

Many approaches have been used to assess the shifting interest of investors for “green” companies. Great advances are being made in the realm of textual sentiment analysis, and the finance literature is now sprawling with ESG sentiment indicators extracted from news articles. A recent 2021 research piece from Apel, Betzer, and Sherer measures climate transition risk from 15 major news publications, including both financial and generalist newspapers. The authors manually labelled thousands of pieces of news, identifying specific climate change topics, to train a state-of-the-art natural language processing model based on the BERT framework developed by Google. The resulting Transition Risk Indicator (TRI) is then tested to determine whether it significantly explains the returns of the main green indices (see below) on the market. The test is performed controlling for standard equity characteristics such as exposure to the broad market, size, valuation, profitability, quality, and momentum.

Among the six green indices tested, five had their returns significantly explained by transition risk, at a 95% level of confidence. The chart below shows the statistical significance (t-stat) of this text-based climate indicator to explain green index returns. Half of the indices also saw a marked increase in the explanatory power of the Transition Risk Indicator from 2017 to 2020, suggesting climate transition concerns are here to stay.

However, this type of textual sentiment analysis has limits for investors, especially from a tactical perspective. Text-based indicators ultimately remain an indirect measure of investor preferences. Although they can explain a share of “green returns”, they can often miss important turning points in sentiment. In this context, to guide investors, we decided to build more direct, and simpler, measures of green “preference”. These indicators are based on two key ideas, which were inspired by a Brière and Ramelli 2021 paper:

  1. ETF trading is more influenced by sentiment than mutual funds or individual stocks trading due to a higher share of activity coming from retail investors. On the other hand, professional and institutional investors should give more weight to company fundamentals than sentiment in their trading decisions.
  2. The relative returns of green ETFs can be a proxy for sentiment, since investor demand pushes prices up, but a better approximation of green “preference” can be found in the evolution of the number of shares outstanding of these ETFs. Shares outstanding are net the number of shares of the ETF that have been issued, after daily creations and redemptions. If the prices of equities held by an ETF are stable or falling but investor demand for that ETF rises, shares outstanding will grow but this demand trend will not necessarily appear in returns.

We can therefore compare the evolution in total shares outstanding of a basket of green U.S. equity ETFs to the total shares outstanding of a basket of broader U.S. equity ETFs. This ratio gives us a clear proxy for the retail market’s interest towards green ETFs relative to plain vanilla ETFs.

We can also compare that metric to the relative evolution of total assets (instead of shares outstanding) using the same ETF baskets, to identify whether green stock performance overreacts or underreacts compared to investor green sentiment. These two concepts (total assets and shares outstanding) are the key inputs in determining the Net Asset Value (NAV) of ETFs, from ETF 101 math:

The selection of green ETFs is key to the relevance of our green preference metric. As we have argued many times, there are far more closet index strategies in climate ETFs than ETFs that actually make a difference for the planet – such as those picking companies that contribute to protecting or developing natural ecosystems. To perform this selection, we follow Brière and Ramelli in their choice of green ETFs, which have a clear green focus and are all classified by Morningstar as “sustainable”. This leaves us with the following 20 ETFs:

To avoid survivorship bias, we simply sum the number of shares outstanding across these 20 ETFs since 2015, without adjustments for addition or removal of single ETFs. The launch or liquidation of green ETFs are relevant events to our green preference indicator and should not be neutralized by, for instance, using an average number of shares outstanding per ETF in activity. To build a reference universe we perform the same calculation, adding the number of shares outstanding, but over the 20 largest U.S. equity ETFs[1] as of April 2022. Choosing the largest U.S. equity ETF as of today should result in a conservative green sentiment measure, since we compare the evolution of green ETFs to the most successful U.S. equity ETFs today.

The resulting U.S. Green “preference” indicator is shown below in light blue and has been through several distinct phases. The first one is indifference: between 2015 and mid-2017 the creation of new shares for green ETFs was in line with the broader U.S. equity market. A bumpy acceleration then followed up to mid-2020: the U.S. was catching up on global ESG trends, and green sentiment increased by 50%. Then came 2020: COVID and the Biden presidency generated an unprecedented surge in green interest. The relative evolution of green ETF assets to broader U.S. equity ETFs caught up to the trend suggested by relative share outstanding, and even overshot at the end of the year. In 2021 a new divergence occurs, the performance of our green ESG ETFs start to lag that of broader U.S. equity ETFs (dark blue line below), but the green investor sentiment, proxied by shares outstanding, is more resilient and continues to slowly go up until the end of November 2021. Then comes the breaking point. Our shares outstanding indicator started to fall last December, with a small rebound since early March. A reversal would require a pro-ESG catalyst, such as new incentives to improve energy efficiency amid already-high energy prices.

This shares outstanding indicator focused on the volume of green ETF shares that investors created or redeemed over time, relative to the market. Another equally useful piece of information can be obtained from ETF price action. More precisely, we can look at the difference between the closing price of an ETF, the price at which the ETF was bought and sold on exchanges, and its closing NAV, reflecting the value of its holdings. This measure, the NAV premium (or discount if it is negative), has the advantage or being quantifiable in total dollar terms if we simply multiply it by the number of shares outstanding. We calculated the daily dollar NAV premium of each green ETF in our basket, before summing its total amount across ETFs. We then simply computed the cumulative sum of that total green NAV premium since 2015 to obtain another indicator of green preference among U.S. equity investors. This green NAV premium suggests a faster increase in green ETF interest pre-2020, but its recent evolution is close to the shares outstanding indicator: both peaked in July 2021, have started to fall in December 2021, with only small rises since.

Combining these two indicators and assuming that the green premium favored higher growth companies, conclusions are clear: for the first time in years, green-minded investors in U.S. equities have been facing some sentiment headwind, since December 2021. This headwind was compounded by the recent increased volatility in rates and equities. Measuring sentiment shifts in real time, a task we modestly tried to achieve in this note, is key in timely adapting green portfolios to market conditions. Currently, that means moving to a more defensive stance, favoring green utilities and stocks with valuations that are not stretched. Our two green sentiment indicators are showing no signs of sustained rebound at the time of writing: green investors should keep a defensive bias for the time being.

_______________

[1] The largest US equity ETF by assets have the following tickers: SPY, IVV, VTI, VOO, QQQ, VTV, VUG, IJR, IWF, IJH, VIG, IWM, IWD, XLF, VGT, VB, XLK, VNQ, ITOT, VYM.

Since the beginning of the war in Ukraine at the end of February, we have published notes on the consequences of the invasion on supply chains (Global Supply and Its Chains: From Efficient Bounty to Complex Scarcity?, March 3, 2022), on energy markets (Some Reasons to Hope, March 10, 2022), and on the increased inflationary pressures it causes (ESG Meets Macro Shifts, March 17, 2022). The underlying theme of the notes we’ve written since the invasion is that costs of almost everything are accelerating. In fact, price inflation had already begun to rise far sooner, but the war has only served to exacerbate this trend.

In this context, any economic model based on using less raw inputs, extending the economic life of a product and aiming for substantial improvement in resource performance along the way will be seen as increasingly attractive and will become a major differentiator going forward. In this week’s note, we discuss the different angles of the circular economy theme and how to concretely position for them.

The current environmental challenges – whether it is climate change, biodiversity loss or water and land pollution – are unquestionably tied to the current, largely linear (take-make-waste) mode of industrial production. All three of the major chains in a linear production model are problematic for the environment:

In contrast to the linear model, a circular economy refers to an economic system whereby the value of products, materials and other resources in the economy is maintained for as long as possible and whereby resources no longer used in one system become inputs in another.

Transforming from a linear to circular economy is widely viewed as necessary because it is considered the only legitimate solution to limiting environmental degradation, while maintaining and/or improving human quality of life. The ultimate goal is to decouple resources consumption from economic growth.

From an investment perspective, the reflex is often to think of waste management companies as being the main beneficiaries of a transition to a circular economy. But upon deeper analysis, it is clear that recycling activities often represent a tiny fraction of their revenues (albeit a large portion of their marketing efforts).

A better investment opportunity – and a more environmentally impactful one – might be to look higher up in the Circular Economy “R” hierarchy.

Given that up to 80% of a product’s environmental impact is determined at the design phase, it is another good reason to focus on companies that have an impact at that stage. Further down the value chain, reuse strategies can be exploited to intensify and extend the use-phase of products. Examples exist within the sharing economy where rental models are transforming the utilization rates of goods like: cars, electronics, and clothing. Hand in hand with increased utilization, maintenance and repair business models are expected to gain importance to extend the lifetime of products. Refurbish and remanufacture strategies reintroduce used components and parts into the manufacturing process to retain their embedded value. Finally, the recycling stream aims to prevent waste by redirecting basic materials as an input into the supply chain.

The table below lists the different strategies and includes some examples of companies in our universe for each group of strategies.

While we use and consume EVERYTHING in excess, experts tell us we should prioritize the management of certain type of waste over others. These “Key Product Value Chains” are:

Another catalyst that should support the circular economy as an investable theme will come from policy makers as they increasingly adopt regulations on single-use plastics ban, right-to-repair, responsible sourcing etc. In addition, ecofiscal measures such as the internalization of environmental externalities like the price on carbon and other taxes on water and waste will act as strong incentives for the industry to better manage the lifecycle impact of their products.

Canada issued its first sovereign green bond last week; following many other countries who now look to take advantage of the market’s strong demand for green sovereign paper. The issue, which was two times oversubscribed by the market, was also accompanied by the government’s reviewed climate plan for 2030 along with its green bond framework.

As most countries are now looking to develop sovereign “green curves” – de facto creating some additional infrastructure to make green bonds go mainstream – investors and citizens are still waiting for the kind of policies that will actually reduce GHG emissions in line with a 1.5 degree warming by 2100. When green bonds made their debut in the mid 2010s, the market was trading them at a premium, a feature which has stuck for a while given the buy-and-hold nature of their owners. Now, the market has become more equilibrated and the “greenium” of the early days has all but vanished in most markets.

At SMS, we view the green bond market – or green loan market in the corporate world – as being one which essentially “gives comfort” to investors; providing a narrative that they are investing in green initiatives. However, bond or loan investors essentially finance the treasury of governments and companies, not specific projects. Because of the fungibility of funds, companies or governments can ultimately do what they want with the capital received. In the case of Canadian sovereign green bonds, the government only promises to invest 50% of the proceeds directly into climate-friendly initiatives, with the remainder going to the treasury’ central account for future climate-targeted spending. Yet, at the same time, the Canadian government could well authorize the development of Bay du Nord oil field in Newfoundland (Equinor), which would go directly against many ESG-minded investors’ values; some of whom perhaps already invested in the Canadian green bond.

Moreover, there’s the case of shale oil companies issuing green paper to fund their carbon capture operations; the latter accounting for a tiny fraction of their operations. In that, we find it more impactful to look at a country’s or company’s overall operation and direction of change, including the associated incentives to do so.

To this end, NGOs such as the Climate Action Tracker still suggest that Canada’s overall policy framework – to be updated with last week’s iteration – remains highly insufficient. So there remains some confusion around the efficacy and additionality of green bond investors in promoting adherence to a clear climate policy anchor.

Furthermore, even the financials of sovereign green bonds suggest some level of greenwashing. First, sovereign green bond investors – who invest first and foremost in the country’s treasury for a given amount of default risk – will likely be disappointed by the government’s future performance on its sustainability goals and climate policies. Second, considering the minimal greenium between Canada’s green bond and equivalent 7-Yr issues, one can conclude: if the tracking error between two different securities is the same, then the market considers both issues to be equivalent in terms of risk and return profiles and also bets that they likely have the same ultimate use of funds. In that, green or not green, ESG-minded investors are still investing into Canada’s overall budgetary and policy framework.

The rise of sustainability-linked loans

The tepid relation between sovereign green bonds and impact contrasts somewhat with the potential of sustainability-linked bonds (or loans in the corporate sector); especially those which have embedded options tied to sustainability indicators. Provided that 1) the covenants included in the loans or bonds are environmentally meaningful – i.e., that the policy effort from the government/company will exceed what can realistically be achieved from market or technological forces over the duration of the bond – and that associated KPIs remain anchored on strong policy frameworks (SBTi or Paris 2015) and that 2) the financial penalty or coupon bonus (for governments and investors, respectively) can be sufficiently meaningful to the country’s (company’s) reputation and finances. If both conditions were to be met, then we think that sustainability-linked loans could find their place in an ESG-minded investor’s portfolio.

Here, the case of Chile, which issued a 2042 sustainability-linked international USD bond last month is interesting. This bond promises to pay between 12.5 and 25 bps more to the holder if the Chilean government does not meet its overall emissions’ ceiling (KPI 1) and (KPI 2) share of renewable energy as percent of total energy produced in the next 8 years. Considering the USD 2 billion offering, the “embedded” performance kicker could represent a USD 2.5 to USD 5 million potential liability or bonus for the government or investors, respectively.

With more than 350 issues in 2021 using sustainability-linked covenants (corporate and sovereign), the good news is that the issuance of sustainability-linked loans is poised to increase substantially these coming years.

That said, smarter ESG-minded investors ought to look for those which will include “step-up” or “step-down” clauses tied to sustainability outcomes as in Chile most recent issue shown below. A quick search on Bloomberg suggests that there are about 250 active issues with such step-up clauses – and only one in the sovereign space in the case of Chile. The rest remain in the corporate sector.

While step-up (or step-down) coupon clauses could also apply in the corporate bond world, looking at performance-based incentives of execs and board members of companies probably makes even more sense than loan covenants themselves, especially as these may be hard to value for investors.

Looking at companies included in the S&P 1200 index, one sees that about one quarter of companies now have sustainability targets embedded in executive and board pay packages. That said, the number of firms with such targets has increased by about 25 percent since 2015; certainly not enough to foster systemic change in the corporate world just yet.

Investors of all stripes are now familiar with climate change as a material risk to their portfolios. Biodiversity is an equally large, but a less understood environmental challenge. It is underappreciated by investors from both the risk and opportunity perspectives. Below, is a series of questions and answers on the most pressing biodiversity concerns for investors.

What are biodiversity and ecosystem services? Why should investors care?

Biodiversity is the variety of natural capital’s living components (for example, species and habitats). Biodiversity ensures the resilience of natural capital assets and secures them for the future. In other words, biodiversity is for nature what portfolio diversification is to investors: just as asset managers reduce the risk of negative tail outcomes by holding assets with a variety of financial characteristics, natural capital requires diverse species and habitats to thrive.

Ecosystem services is a term used to describe the outputs, conditions, or processes of natural systems that benefit humans. Carbon sequestration by forests is one example of an ecosystem service, but hundreds exist. Importantly, biodiversity loss and ecosystem services go well beyond the agricultural sector and include land, fresh water, oceans and air. Ecosystem services can be recorded in monetary terms, which facilitates understanding of the value that these services represent.

These ecosystem services, which are vital to human survival, exist because there is variety in natural capital, i.e., because Earth is biologically diverse. As biodiversity declines, the ecosystem services that humans rely on also decline.

For investors, biodiversity is important because significant economic rents in the past several decades have been achieved by using the ecosystem’s services without having to pay for them.

Why should investors care now?

Although losses in biodiversity have been recorded for several decades, healthy natural capital (biodiversity) was so sufficiently abundant that economic actors of all types (governments, consumers, corporates) could take the services that ecosystems provide for granted. The situation has changed drastically: according to the WWF and the Living Planet index, there has been a 68% average loss in animal population since 1970!

Animal population loss is highly correlated to the natural world that they live in, and biodiversity loss means loss of the ecosystem services that go along with it. In this sense, traditional business models that take ecosystem services for granted risk not being able to operate for lack of services and/or will have to secure these services at a much higher cost.

Concretely, which businesses are most at risk of losing undervalued ecosystem services and/or which businesses are most dependent on nature?

Biodiversity loss is happening to land, sea, freshwater and air and estimates are that $44 trillion of economic value generation—over half the world’s total GDP—is moderately or highly dependent on nature and its services, and therefore at risk. The industries that are most dependent on biodiversity are construction, agriculture and food and beverages. These industries rely on either the direct extraction of resources from forests and oceans or the provision of ecosystem services such as healthy soils, clean water, pollination, etc. That said, many other industries have significant “hidden dependencies” on nature in their supply chain and are at risk of disruption. Chemicals and materials, tourism, real estate, mining and metals; transportation are all industries whereby over half of their supply chains’ gross value added is highly or moderately nature-dependent.

How can investors know which portfolio companies are aware of their risks and are doing something about it?  

Similar to investor risks associated to climate change, several initiatives have gathered momentum for investors to better understand portfolio management through a biodiversity lens.

A well-known reporting framework, the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), defines material topics for companies based on their industry and presents accounting metrics for each category. While “biodiversity” is not its own category, many of the key elements and ecosystem services are accounted for within the SASB framework. Investors that consult the CSR reports of their portfolio companies will have a first inkling of the degree of nature dependency.

Why can’t investors focus on just one biodiversity indicator like GHG emissions and the cost of CO2 for climate?

Biodiversity is extremely difficult to distill into one indicator since it has multiple dimensions and not all dimensions will be relevant for all types of businesses. Exposure to biodiversity loss depends on a complex array of factors: geography, operational arrangements, value chain position (upstream vs. downstream), extent of dependency on one or more aspects of diversity (e.g. water AND soil health AND air quality), impact on biodiversity, ability to substitute materials, etc.

It is for this reason that for investors, a financial metric that expresses the monetized value of ecosystem services—the services that nature provides to benefit humans—is useful. This method would help to reveal the economic contribution of nature and its services to an underlying investment.

Are there regulatory headwinds/tailwinds associated with biodiversity?

The 15th Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity (COP15) to be held in Kunming, China, in the third Quarter of 2022 (dates to be confirmed), will finalize a global biodiversity conservation framework for 2020-2050. This meeting is to biodiversity what the Paris Agreement is to climate change i.e., a once in a generation opportunity for the global community to commit to significant necessary actions to protect the planet. The expected outcome is to articulate global targets to preserve and protect 30% of land and sea by 2030.

However, just like for climate change, any resultant accords will not be legally binding. In other words, there are no international laws designed to enforce the preservation of biodiversity.

For investors, perhaps the biggest regulatory risk will come from the reversal of economic subsidies in certain industries. Take agriculture: according to the United Nations, nearly 90% of the $540bn in global subsidies given to farmers every year is considered harmful to the environment. These subsidies include price incentives for specific livestock and crops, subsidies for fertilizers and pesticides, and export subsidies and import tariffs. Equally frustrating is that often these subsidies and their concomitant environmental degradation, serve only to prop up certain parts of the agricultural market that would not otherwise be profitable. This tactic is no different than keeping zombie banks in operation after a banking crisis!

We expect that harmful subsidies will eventually be repealed (COP15 is likely to be influential in this regard). And there is already supportive evidence in the UK regarding the agricultural industry. Investors that are exposed to industries that rely on subsidies known to have deleterious environmental impacts will be on the wrong side of the trade.

How can I understand the environmental depletion—and therefore the biodiversity risk—of my investment?

The first step for investors is to have access to appropriate disclosure about biodiversity risks.

Regional and national disclosure endeavours already exist: France has already implemented a decree requiring all financial institutions to disclose biodiversity and climate-related risks as well as disclosing their strategy to reduce impacts. Meanwhile, the EU taxonomy does include significant drivers for preventing biodiversity loss, and the EU government is also expected to adopt a Directive on Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence in 2022, requiring companies with significant turnover in the EU to understand whether value chain activities have an adverse impact on biodiversity.

A non-exhaustive list of frameworks is provided in the table below, but the most significant development in nature-related financial disclosures is the Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures (TNFD), which is a framework that builds on the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD). A beta version was released earlier this month, with the aim to provide a framework for corporates and financial institutions to assess, manage and report on their dependencies and impacts on nature. A key feature of the framework is that it proposes location-specific disclosure given that dependencies and impacts on nature are inherently local. Indeed, the TNFD framework encourages transparent data to be reported about both impact and dependency (i.e., double materiality) on biodiversity.

We expect that over time, the TNFD will become a necessary, widely used disclosure framework that ultimately will influence how capital is allocated. It is significant that the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) last week issued a proposed rule change that would require companies to make specific climate-related disclosures. The new requirements are based on the TCFD disclosure framework. While legislation takes time, the TNFD will be the roadmap for enforced disclosure of a broader array of environmental factors.

Disclosure means that investors will be in a better position to make decisions. That said, forward-looking investors do not need to wait for disclosure regulation to act. The majority of public enterprises now publish some environmental data related to their operations, most often in a CSR report. With regards to biodiversity, companies that report according to SASB materiality risks already divulge significant information (see the table above).

Undervalued Ecosystem

Soil is a complex ecosystem made up of organic matter, minerals, air and water. It is the home of many organisms like insects, worms and nature’s nutrients: bacteria and fungi. The soil ecosystem is critical for life on Earth. Healthy soil can be a productivity booster, improving drainage and air exchange. It also serves as a carbon sink. Unfortunately, rather than working with the soil, current farming practices are contributing to its degradation. The table below depicts the positive contributions of healthy soil and the negative contributions of compacting and tilling.

Soil, like forests and water, is undervalued because it is abundant. Currently, the value of soil is mainly reflected by its ability to generate revenues from growing food. The other contributions of the soil do not directly generate cash flows, even if they are crucially beneficial. As awareness of those benefits increases, the value of soil should also rise. This should result in actions by land owners to protect and nurture their soil. Unfortunately, economic pressures are putting land owners in survival mode, distracting them from the longer term viability of their land.

Food Armageddon

Fast population growth since the Industrial Revolution owes a lot to our collective ability to produce food. This ability is facing new challenges. Climate change is making the weather unpredictable, more aggressive, warmer and drier in places where food is produced. The map below shows the agricultural potential of the soil in different parts of the world. Bare areas with large populations and low incomes are clearly dependent on imports for food. The outlook for agriculture is poor in some important agricultural hubs: the U.S., Australia and Brazil.

Additionally, the major conflict in Ukraine will affect a very productive agricultural area and the consequent sanctions on Russia could curb Russian food exports. As a result, the poorest people in each country will see higher food prices and some of the poorest regions of the world will struggle to access food from to their usual exporters. To continue to feed the globe, we need seeds, water, fertilizers, soil and labor. So far in 2022, we foresee major issues for at least three of the five elements (water, fertilizers, and labor) in the form of shortages and rising costs. The issues of climate change, supply chain challenges, and rising input costs are increasing the probability of a large global humanitarian crisis. The chart below shows the food price index before the Russian invasion.

While these issues are alarming, there is potential for them to serve as a catalyst in returning to farming practices that put soil health at the forefront and are therefore more sustainable over the long term.

Effective Water Management

Regarding water issues, climate change is wreaking havoc from floods to extreme heat and drought. The map below superposes long-term drought conditions with the drought outlook for the next 3 months for the United States as of March 17th, 2022. It does not look promising again this year.

The increasing frequency of drought will have farmers very attentive to their water usage, securing supply and maximizing its efficiency. Soil is one way to optimize water usage. Healthy soil is productive, it interacts more efficiently with water. Ironically, drought-ridden areas are also prone to flooding as dry ground does not have the capacity to absorb water when rain does fall. Farms that prioritize their soil will be more resilient to both droughts and flooding in the long term and continue to yield crops. A company like Plasson (PLSN IT) is well positioned to help farmers with water management and optimization. The use of fertilizer can also impact water efficiency, as it can contribute to runoff where crops absorb only a small portion of the water poured onto it.

Fertilizer Optimization

Access to fertilizers is becoming a challenge. The war in Ukraine, the accompanying sanctions and export bans are creating the potential for significant fertilizer shortages. The chart below shows the portion of fertilizer exports that Russia typically represents. If Russia does not export fertilizers in 2022, it would mean that approximately 20% needs to be produced elsewhere. Considering Belarus is under similar sanctions as Russia, it is even worse. Belarus represents another 20% of global potash export volume. Moreover, unbearable natural gas prices have already been curtailing nitrogen fertilizer production, especially in Europe where natural gas prices are relatively higher.

Farmers are already being challenged by input price squeezes. The rising cost of fertilizer due to the conflict in Ukraine is not making it any easier. This could provide some momentum to begin reducing the use of fertilizers. One alternative is cover crops. Planting these crops improves soil health and reduces the need for herbicides as it covers the land, limiting the growth of weeds. Seed companies such as Sakata Seeds (1377 – JP) and Corteva (CTVA – US) could benefit. Corteva also offers products beyond seeds, including fertilizer and some digital tools. The transition won’t happen overnight – farms are more likely to slowly wean themselves off fertilizers. Precision agriculture can facilitate this transition, using a targeted focus to apply less. There are many actors in this growing space that stand to gain (e.g. Deere & Co., CNH Industries, Raven Industries, Yara, Bayer, IBM, Trimble, etc.)  

Please, Grow Food

With higher food prices, a simple conclusion would be that farmers are making a lot of money from their operations, but the reality is very different. They are suffering from weather shocks, labor shortages, energy cost increases and fertilizer cost increases. The USDA forecasted a 12% rise in fertilizer for 2022 after a 17% increase in 2021. This was before the war Ukraine. As the conflict exacerbates food prices, governments will face increasing pressure to help farmers. In addition, those that are hedging their production in the futures’ market need to put more collateral with price rises, worsening their cash flow situation further.

Fortunately, some government initiatives to help long-term farming were already underway and we expect them to accelerate commensurate to the potential impact of a food crisis. The COP26 held in October included an event to encourage investment in digital agriculture. The Biden administration is proposing a shift from USDA commodity credits to carbon credits, incentivizing farmers to prioritize healthy soil for its carbon holding properties. Corporations are also seeing the value in dirt. Companies in both the food and fashion industries have pledged to source crops produced from regenerative practices. From that standpoint, we believe that companies addressing water efficiency, precision agriculture and soil management will benefit from a tailwind.

The opening months of 2022 have brought turbulence to financial markets that require agility for ESG investors, even those with long time horizons. Indeed, even before the vast majority of investors were caught off-guard by the events in Ukraine, a major shift in equity markets was already underway due to the looming turning point in the monetary policy cycle.

At the start of the year, we published our top investment ideas for 2022 (Investment Trends in 2022: Don’t Put Your ESG All in One Basket, January 6, 2022). In today’s Note, we reflect on what is working, what ideas require adjustment and how we believe investors should tilt their portfolios to ensure that their ESG investments remain aligned with the major macro forces. These views are summarized in the table at the end of the Note; the table will now be a regular feature of Insight notes, with the aim of providing a quick guide to SMS’ thematic positioning.

We see three key developments that will underpin equity movements for the foreseeable future.

1. Persistent global inflation as demand holds steady (for now) and supply remains constrained.

In our November Insight report (Inflation is an ESG Phenomenon, November 25, 2021), we articulated our view that “frequent and significant supply chain challenges will make relative price shocks commonplace, while a tight labor market means that initiatives to create better working conditions globally will act to raise the cost of labor (wage inflation).” This view is still in place and we continue to expect that a structurally tighter labor market will help strengthen employee bargaining power: annual wage cost growth in the EU is already approaching 3% and is over 5% in the U.S. Even when a recession occurs, it is unlikely that wage inflation will fall to previous cycle lows given the structural tightness in labor markets. As for pricing pressures due to supply chain hiccups, the war in Ukraine has solidified the likelihood that several key industries will grapple with high input costs for many months to come. While not strictly an ESG factor, the value of land and other finite resources has most certainly come into investor focus in the past several weeks.

Two of our favored long-term inflation plays that stem from our themes of protecting natural capital and the energy transition are overweight positions in transition metals and forestry. Both ideas have performed well since the beginning of the year, due to the rising inflation theme and revaluation of hard assets during wartime. Investors should beware of near-term pullbacks should a Russian ceasefire occur, but the long-term investment thesis of favoring “green” inflation hedges is still intact. Holmen, Svenska Cellulosa AB (SCA) CA, Umicore and Boliden are among our favored long-term investments in this space.

2. High and volatile oil prices will remain for the foreseeable future, eventually damaging economic activity, especially in Europe. A renewable and fossil fuel capex cycle is imminent.  

Last week’s note outlined our views on the prospects for ESG investors in the energy sector. Suffice to say, we expect that both fossil fuel prices and alternative energy prices will remain elevated and volatile for some time; it will take several months (years) for investment to catch up to current energy demands. In the meantime, elevated oil prices will act like a tax on economic activity and suppress growth. The pressure will be most acute in Europe, given the region’s greater reliance on Russian oil and gas supply that is currently.

As a result of higher oil prices, we expect economic activity to cool in the second half of the year, with the euro area particularly at risk.

There are several investment implications. First, as we wrote last week, despite our bullish long-term stance on the price of carbon, the carbon market is unlikely to rebound forcefully in the months ahead and patience is required. Second, companies that rely on euro area demand risk underwhelming relative to those geared to the U.S., given headwinds from higher energy- in the euro area. Third, companies that are able to pass on the price of energy will be in a distinctly better position than those that cannot. Finally, a capex cycle in both renewable energies and fossil fuel is imminent.

ESG investors with fossil fuel exclusions risk underperforming broad benchmarks in the near term, but trying to pick ESG leaders vs. laggards within the traditional energy sector is risky business. We recommend that investors focus on renewable energy companies, including Cameco and Nextera Energy Partners and companies that provide services to alternative energy providers like Ameresco and Hannon Armstrong.

3. A turning point in the monetary policy cycle.

The inflation conditions described make it inevitable that policy rates around the world will rise. Indeed, after a rush of global accommodative policy to help deal with the economic effects of the pandemic, central banks now must focus on curbing inflation. Yesterday, the Fed raised interest rates by 25 bps, while the BoE will remain in hiking mode, and the ECB has also made plans to end its bond-buying programme earlier than previously expected.

Recent months have shown that ESG portfolios are equally exposed to shifts in the macro outlook as traditional portfolios. The overall economic backdrop is still mildly bullish for stocks, but as the cost of capital increases, stocks with high valuation multiples are most exposed to price declines/price stagnation; the rotation from growth stocks to value stocks is likely to continue.

Investors can still find good, sustainable, fairly valued companies across economic sectors, but given the current geopolitical cross-currents and lower risks outside of Europe, we recommend seeking plays within non-Russian commodity-producing countries like Canada, Australia and Latin America. Note that investors must be extremely selective in these countries, since buying the benchmark indices means buying tar sands, coal producers and other destructive environmental practices. Industrial companies focusing on environmental and energy efficiency solutions (see our note last week), as well as sustainable agriculture, are two areas that are ripe for further capital inflows. The latter – sustainable agriculture – is the subject of next week’s note, stay tuned.

With geopolitical risks at a level rarely seen since the Second World War, it is not surprising to have witnessed a significant drop in the price of risk assets and a rise in safe-havens and commodity prices. For an ESG-minded investor paid to generate alpha, however, managing investment strategies which typically avoid sectors such as arms and fossil fuels, while often tilting towards growth-type companies, the past few weeks were somewhat challenging.

Looking at European policy developments, the cancellation of the Nord Stream 2 pipeline deal between Germany and Russia last week amid a growing movement looking to impose a global import ban on Russian oil and gas, supports higher energy prices for the coming months. In our view, this has important, and mostly positive consequences, for our energy and commodity plays. In light of developments in Ukraine and the global response so far, today’s note outlines our views on carbon markets, fossil fuels (gas, oil, coal), wind and energy efficiency themes.

Carbon: European carbon prices have receded since their February peak as many speculators are now factoring in higher energy prices as a key deterrent to current EU policies. Even before the Russian invasion, the EU’s industrial sector was very vocal about the combination of restrained carbon allowances and high carbon prices that were already hurting industrial activity. Recent events suggest that the industry may receive a breather from EU authorities to 1) alleviate the high costs of energy and 2) allow the industry to build up the EU’s defense capabilities to a level which could counter future threats from rogue neighbors. Carbon prices declined 30% in early March but have since rallied back somewhat. For now, we recommend investors stand aside and look to repurchase carbon allowances once the crisis abates.

Natural Gas, Wind, Coal: One of the more impressive turnarounds in global energy policy is certainly Germany’s (and to a lesser extent the U.K.) radical move towards weaning itself from Russian oil and gas. For its part, the EU also committed to reduce its Russian oil and gas imports by 2/3rds by the end of 2023, a move which could also extend to other G7 members soon. This suggests that these countries will have to find more stable – and less threatening sources – of supply, which in the short term, will most likely come from countries like the U.S. and Canada. To this end, Germany’s change of tack has also sent coal prices skyrocketing, while reigniting renewable energy producers and their associate suppliers’ equity prices.

A new cold war – this time powered with green(er) energy?

Oil: With oil prices at levels close to their 2008 highs, one could expect drilling to restart fast in swing-producing oil regions such as the U.S. and Canada. To this end, we are already seeing rig counts inching back to 2020 levels in the U.S., while the Alberta oil patch is also witnessing some level of revival. Interestingly, the recent bounce in oil prices and its associated financial bonanza could well enable both American and Canadian oil producers to finance their much-needed transition – something governments and investors will want to monitor (and incentivize closely) in the coming months.

An important indicator to look at will be these firms’ dividend payout ratios. We expect this ratio to decrease if firms start taking energy transition seriously and start investing their profits into clean energy projects at an accelerate pace in the near term. That said, for ESG-minded investors, the current outlook for oil is hard to play given the immediate “do what it takes” policy from the U.S. administration for the U.S. shale patch to start resupplying the global market as early as possible. The problem is that with the current undersupply of labor in the U.S. economy, including in Oil and Gas, it will be hard to jump-start the U.S.’ oil industry in the near-term. Indeed, it will take time to bring back production after a long hiatus – especially in labor-intensive sectors such as Oil and Gas. For this, we expect oil prices to remain very high until at least the latter part of this year.

Some reasons to hope

The Ukraine/Russia crisis risks bringing a heavy human toll and a global humanitarian crisis and likely be transformative for economies. A first consideration is that many Western countries will 1) significantly increase defense and military budgets and 2) make the energy transition a matter of national security. This likely will be positive from a cyclical growth perspective, while also adding to current inflationary pressures (see our note, “Global Supply and Its Chains: From Efficient Bounty to Complex Scarcity?” March 3, 2022). The implication for corporations, governments and consumers will be significant:

Corporations: From a corporate perspective, the pull-out of western firms from Russia suggests that the corporate world now feels comfortable to leave money on the table and withdraw (or at least suspend activities temporarily) from countries and/or sectors they feel no longer match their values. This was recently exemplified by Shell, BP, McDonald’s, Levi’s and Apple decisions to suspend their Russian operations.

Moreover, we expect a substantial increase in energy efficiency investments – especially in the corporate world. About 40-45 percent of firms invested in energy efficiency measures in 2019, and we expect this number and the amounts invested to increase even more in the coming months and years.

Investments Into Energy Efficiency Will Get a Boost From Russia’s Mistaken War

Governments/Central Banks: We are impressed by the growing coalition which has vowed to contain Russia economically, even at the risk of adding additional inflationary pressures in the economy. However, higher commodity prices, if added to the likeliness of a fiscal boost coming from increased military spending in G7 economies, could front load the necessity for Central Banks to hike rates at a faster pace over the coming months.

Consumers: The war in Ukraine will further curtail consumer spending power in the context of even higher inflation, putting more pressure on supply chains through higher energy and shipping costs. That said, high energy prices will only accelerate the willingness to improve energy efficiency in the transport (EVs) and housing (insulation, energy management) sectors. After all, higher prices are probably the most powerful incentive of all - to change consumers‘ behavior.

An Investment Idea

In this volatile context, one smart investment an ESG-minded could make is to increase exposure to the “energy efficiency” theme by finding companies who will help both corporates and consumers save on energy bills, and, in that, contribute to the ongoing “war effort” against global fossil fuel fueled wars against democracies AND fight climate change.

Many companies within SMS’ energy efficiency universe prove quite attractive on a valuation basis. We see companies like Johnson Controls and Owens Corning strongly benefitting from the current environment of high energy prices.

In the end, a reason to hope comes from the fact that governments, corporations and consumers now seem ready to pay the price - including the political price - to isolate Russia for its unacceptable actions. One can hope that acceleration of the willingness to contribute - in effort and in dollars - to solving global problems will continue and one day be applied to solving complex issues such as climate change and poverty.