“Achieving net zero emissions by 2050 will require nothing short of the complete transformation of the global energy system” says an International Energy Alliance (IEA) report. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has upped the ante, leading to what the European Commission has called the “double urgency”: achieving energy independence from Russia and avoiding a climate crisis. The transformation required to decarbonize the grid creates investment opportunities in infrastructure. While traditional infrastructure assets are often reputed as defensive plays with stable cash flows, newer opportunities in energy infrastructure will likely follow a more volatile trajectory before the energy infrastructure system is re-established. The technologies supporting clean energy vary in their scalability; and where the solution is scalable, the industry can be fragmented. Fortunately, there has been a sea change in government attitudes toward the necessity to support the renewable energy sector and fiscal incentives in the U.S. and Europe will help provide a favorable backdrop for major energy infrastructure projects. The European Commission’s most recent plan (REPower EU) looks to improve grid design and hydrogen as part of the solution for lower emissions energy systems. America’s infrastructure and Jobs Act included an allocation of $65 billion for power infrastructure as well as funding to support the adoption of electric vehicles, with additional EV incentives made available in the Inflation Reduction Act.
Driving Change
Government policy aimed at reducing emissions must focus on transport (given that transport accounts for 37% percent of global emissions). One potential solution – which witnessed quite a bit of hype these past few years – is hydrogen. Hydrogen gas can replace fossil fuels in aviation, marine, rail and long-haul trucking; there are also applications in heating and industrial processes. Though hydrogen is included as part of the REPower EU Plan, it still has to overcome important hurdles in safety and transportation, not to mention the expensive production process requiring energy as an input. This makes for a riskier opportunity as it remains unclear whether hydrogen can become anything more than a niche solution in specific industries and is not among our preferred investment choices.
Infrastructure related to electric vehicles (EV) is a safer bet. It is becoming increasingly clear that the full adoption of EV will occur over time and the technology behind battery charging is already proven. The market is currently fragmented and faces a chicken and egg problem: adding stations before there is enough demand is costly, but a lack of stations could hinder EV demand. That said, the latter issue will get resolved over time: many governments are initiating or widening rebate programs to lower the purchase price of electric cars to increase demand. In the U.S., $7.5 billion was earmarked for EV charging Infrastructure in the Infrastructure bill passed in November 2021. Chargepoint (CHPT) and Blink Charging (BLNK) compete with Tesla in the U.S. market and are pushing international expansion of their brands. In Europe, we believe that Alfen may be a standout company in this sector given that the company operates in both EV charging stations and smart grid technology; having a diversified revenue stream and complementary expertise for innovation in energy efficiency solutions.
A Clean Break
Electric vehicles won’t be entirely fossil fuel free unless the electricity used to charge them is. To achieve this, the electricity grid will need to run on clean energy sources like wind, solar and nuclear. These are the closest thing to brownfield assets in this new energy system. Though wind and solar are intermittent energy sources, their projects do offer more stability in terms of financial risk/reward. Already seen as a proven technology with an important role to play in achieving net zero goals, wind and solar projects face few hurdles. These technologies have benefitted from favourable government policy for many years, which has helped them reach economic viability. Nuclear, on the other hand, has seen costs rise and faces a negative public perception (see note June 9, 2022: Nuclear Revival); but the challenges in energy security and reducing emissions have generated renewed interest. Nuclear was included in the REPower EU Plan; France and Belgium have both paused phase outs of existing plants. In America, a $30 billion tax credit for existing nuclear reactors and $62.7 billion for emissions-free electricity (including nuclear) was included in the Inflation Reduction Act, helping to level the playing field with wind and solar. The Act also included an item supporting the fuels used in small modular reactors, creating positive implications for companies innovating in this space like: NuScale, GE and Rolls-Royce.
It Takes Two
Building the infrastructure for wind, solar and nuclear energy will not in itself be sufficient to reach goals of carbon-neutral energy. Significant investment in grid infrastructure will be necessary for effective transmission and distribution of the new clean energy; and intermittent sources like wind and solar will require energy storage solutions. For these infrastructure assets, the issue is not whether the technology can scale, but rather the extraordinary pace necessary to build fast enough. One article described the expansion needed to meet projected energy demand for 2030 as “a century of work to do in less than a decade”. It currently takes roughly 3.7 years in the U.S. from the request for grid connection to becoming operational. To meet net zero targets on time, the pace will have to pick up drastically. The European Comission’s REPower EU plan pushes for practices enabling faster approvals. In the U.S., the Infrastructure and Jobs Act passed in the Fall of 2021 included $65 billion dedicated to Power Infrastructure. These incentives should help to ease bottlenecks, ramping up demand for smart grid technologies and energy storage. This will benefit smart grid names like Siemens Energy and Itron. Itron’s smart city solutions could also see a boost from Europe’s ongoing measures to effectively manage energy. A pure-play in energy storage, Stem, uses “smart” technology to optimize energy generated from renewables.
“ESG” has gotten a bad rap especially over the last year as many media outlets have focused on everything that isn’t working in the ESG industry. At SMS, we pride ourselves on taking a pragmatic approach to investment and research: in today’s note, we uphold the view that ESG has been an excellent tool for risk management; how the ESG and investor movement has effected real change on concrete, measurable corporate operations; and why ESG is ripe to become a popular (and potentially successful) “active” investment strategy. “ESG” is not a cure-all, but when done properly, it can influence and amplify social and environmental trends that are important to the broader world, as well as generate superior returns.
ESG: A Proven, Successful Investment Risk Management Tool
Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) – the term used to identify matters associated with corporate responsibility beyond generating financial profit (extra-financial items) – has been an excellent tool for businesses (and investors who take ownership stakes in them) to safeguard themselves from future risks. The clearest demonstration of this is through the lower cost of financing that is accorded to businesses with strong ESG records. Study after study concludes that the cost of financing is cheaper for firms with strong ESG records (see chart below). To be sure, a size bias sometimes overstates this impact (large companies tend to access cheaper funding and also tend to have strong ESG records) but it is not hard to understand why lenders view ESG leaders in a better light: businesses that demonstrate they are at lower risk from controversies, whether it be environmental accidents, or fraudulent financial activity are viewed as more creditworthy by lenders than those that don’t. For investors, the corollary is simple: businesses that have access to cheaper capital, all else equal, offer better risk/reward than investments with higher funding costs.
The overwhelming number of publicly-traded companies that publish sustainability reports is testament to this fact; it is no doubt cheaper to dedicate financial resources to showing transparency about ESG topics than to pay higher borrowing costs.
ESG naysayers will rightly point out: there is a monumental difference between reporting on sustainability and being sustainable and that ESG data can be of poor quality and is fallible. These critiques are true. Few ratings of any kind are ever perfect - one only needs to look back to the rating agencies’ view of U.S. residential mortgage debt in 2008 for a reminder – but imperfect scores have nonetheless yielded results. As the section below demonstrates, the act of reporting on sustainability - and the imperfect ESG ranking of companies has led to corporate change.
ESG: Real World Results
Plenty of corporate behaviours and practices have shifted in recent years. It is impossible to prove causality, but the link between increased, quality sustainability reporting and several changes in corporate behavior is nonetheless present. Although it has been over a decade now that the majority of large and mega-cap (i.e. the world’s 250 largest companies by revenue) produce sustainability reports, it is only very recent that the quality of reporting has improved. What is quality reporting? It is materiality reporting. Materiality refers to an organization's significant economic, environmental and social impacts and risks.
SASB is the gold standard on materiality reporting and as the chart below shows, despite a flourishing ESG reporting trade for the past decade, SASB reporting has only accelerated in the past three years.
This has corresponded to change in several issues that are widely considered to be urgent (i.e. material) environmental and societal issues.
A first example is the role of women in decision-making roles. The increased attention attributed to issues like #Metoo, working conditions in “pink collar” jobs during the pandemic, and the repeal of U.S. abortion laws mean that companies and investors are increasingly exposed to reputational risk if they cannot show improvement on gender issues. Although women continue to make up a paltry minority of senior corporate roles, the rate of change has accelerated markedly in the past three years, which has coincided with the number of businesses reporting gender diversity – or the lack of thereof - as a “material” risk.
A second example is the use of voluntary carbon offsets. As the chart below shows, the voluntary carbon offset market has exploded higher in the past two years, at exactly the same time that businesses are feeling pressure to react to the very material risk that climate change has on their operations. While the voluntary market is extremely imperfect and there is most certainly some greenwashing at play, the development of voluntary carbon offsets is an important step toward internalizing the costs of greenhouse gas emissions, especially for industries where emission regulation is weak or absent.
Similarly, net zero pledges have existed for quite some time and by some estimates, now cover 80% of world GDP. However, it has been far too easy to commit to a vague plan about something far in the future, such as what was done by several countries and oil companies in the past years. Fortunately, along with the materiality of climate change on corporations, the number of independently verified, science-backed targets, has had unprecedented growth in the past two years (see chart below).
The bottom line is that investors who may have initially been keen to see companies publish ESG reports to better analyze, gauge and quantify risks, have no doubt participated in spurring companies to take steps on materially important ESG issues!
From ESG to ESG Investing: A “Passive” Fail but a Massive “Active” Opportunity
In as much as the track record for ESG as a risk management tool and as a force for corporate behavior change has been a success, the same case cannot be made for ESG investing (yet). There is burgeoning evidence that although overall ESG scoring does not correlate consistently with stock performance, firms with good ratings on material sustainability issues do significantly outperform companies with poor ratings on material issues. And in contrast, firms with good ratings on immaterial sustainability issues do not significantly outperform firms with poor ratings on the same issues.
Still, we stand by our conclusions from our February report (“Authentic ESG Funds: Looking for the (Tracking) Error”, February 10, 2022): the bulk of ESG funds are passively managed, and more often reflect growth funds masquerading as low-carbon.
Indeed, the chart below shows the performance of ESG-aware passive investments. In rising oil price environments, ESG-aware ETFs underperform their benchmarks and in declining oil price environments, they outperform. Over long periods of time, net of management fees, ESG ETFs have generally underperformed, or in the best of cases, tied the broader benchmarks.
To us, this makes sense and we agree with others that point out that ESG investors that pursue a strategy of divestment (or passive investment with exclusions) should not be surprised by potentially lower financial returns because they’re constraining their universe. In other words, if diversification is good for portfolios over the long run, then by excluding certain types of stocks with particular properties, a passive ESG investor is reducing the ability to diversify, and therefore, should expect lower returns.
But let us be clear, it is not because passive investing in ESG has under-delivered that ESG investing can not be successful. We believe that active investing in select ESG themes will be successful for precisely the same reason that materiality reporting has affected corporate change: financial markets are a reflection of (and sometimes influence on) societal themes that unfold.
Share prices assist in the efficient allocation of capital, helping to steer savings toward the most promising investments; when investors allocate to a particular theme, they are taking an active stance on an anticipated change in the world.
One of the major critiques of ESG investing is that it lacks precise goals and it is difficult to measure since the number of objectives is almost infinite and varies from one company to the next. But active ESG investors, i.e. those that do not simply subtract the companies they don’t like, are in fact actively pursuing particular themes that align with - or reside within - broad ESG goals.
A Tale of Three Sustainability-Minded Investors
Take three different investors. The first - The Divestor - purchases an ESG-aware fund that reports low carbon emissions. The second - Passive Clean Investor - has more conviction in the energy transition theme and therefore invests in a (passive) clean energy ETF. The third - Active Transition Investor - recognizing the importance of the energy transition thematic, but also cognitive of the broader macro landscape, devises an active energy transition strategy.
The Divestor does particularly well when energy prices are in a bear market but underperforms when oil prices rise. This is because there are not enough “green” energy transition companies in the broad index to compensate for outsized positive contribution of dirty fossil fuel producers when oil prices rise. The Divestor may post returns in some macroeconomic environments but is unlikely to do well over an entire business/financial cycle.
Similarly, Passive Clean Investor has an even more constrained universe to choose from (companies with low carbon footprints and that produce energy) and is even more beholden to the economic and financial cycle: non-fossil fuel energy companies typically have similar characteristics in that they tend to be technology-centric and therefore extremely long duration assets with high P/Es. Under the right conditions, such as low interest rates and strong economic growth, the Passive Clean Investor’s high conviction views of the energy transition will be rewarded, but under other macro backdrops the strategy will struggle to outperform.
Finally, the Active Transition Investor understands that the energy transition will occur, albeit its trajectory will be highly dependent on the macroeconomic and geopolitical backdrop. The Active Transition Investor overweights her portfolio to cleantech companies when rates are low, but dials back this exposure in favor of “boring”, lower P/E names that are early in the energy supply chain (like cable providers to the electricity grid industry) when recession fears strike. The Active Transition Investor may also dabble in renewable natural gas stocks or nuclear solutions when necessary, knowing that intermediate solutions are urgently needed to fill the gap left from coal and tar sands before renewable solutions can entirely take over. Active Transition Investor, in fact, may sometimes look indistinguishable from a macro hedge fund investor in that she seeks to deliver returns based on market developments caused by political or economic events.
There have been several key developments on the global energy and climate policy landscape during the past few weeks. First, Europe’s energy security has been seriously challenged by sanctions against Russia and their impact on energy flows to the continent. Second, the recent revival of President Biden’s climate change plan (conveniently renamed Inflation Reduction Act of 2022) also suggests that the U.S. will start moving in a direction more compatible with the Administration’s climate change targets. Third, Australia, a laggard given its previous government’s attitude toward climate change, just announced its own plan to transition to a cleaner economy.
All in all, these announcements have jolted global green themes since the market lows of mid June - the same themes that were depressed by increasingly hawkish central banks earlier this year. Still, SMS’ energy efficiency basket of companies (see below for companies) repriced substantially these past weeks and outperformed the MSCI World by more than 10 percentage points.
That said, high energy prices as well as new government initiatives will surely create winning and losing sectors and companies: This week’s note addresses the impact of policies and prices on several “green” investment themes.
Germany’s Energy Crunch Explained
The German government is currently prioritizing industries should they need to implement rationing later in the year according to the commercial, economic and social impact of any power cuts. Already, energy conservation is promoted in anticipation for winter peak energy demand. Since keeping the residential sector supplied with gas is the priority for the government, other sectors will be vulnerable to power cuts if energy flows into Germany stay at current levels. As energy supplies tighten in Germany and elsewhere in Europe, there is likely to be discrimination among company profitability based on their energy usage. In this context, industries who are large consumers of natural gas, such as chemicals, steel and fertilizers, appear the most vulnerable to energy rationing (see below for trading ideas on this theme).
The table below shows that for the Fertilizers sub-industry, Yara (Norway) is 2.7 times less energy intensive than its direct competitor OCI (Netherlands). Arcelor Mittal, a global steel giant with a large footprint in Europe, is 8 times less energy efficient than Sweden-based SSAB. In Chemicals, BASF appears more exposed to higher energy prices compared to its competitors. The same applies to Ferrari, which is two times less energy efficient than Mercedes Benz in the luxury automobile segment. As a result, we think a wedge could start appearing in the pricing of energy efficient and less energy efficient companies with thinning profit margins and growing energy costs.
Europe: Nuclear Energy
Nuclear energy is increasingly seen as a replacement energy source given Russia’s limited supply of gas to Europe (see our note “Back to the Future: A Nuclear Revival”, June 9 2022). To this end, countries such as Germany - which for the last generation sought to end nuclear energy on its territory - seems open to a change of tack on the matter. Last week, the German chancellor suggested that the country should extend the life of its nuclear reactors in order to relieve some pressure in domestic energy markets. In our view, we see this as supporting the global nuclear sector over the medium term, especially pure plays such as Cameco, one of the world’s largest producers of uranium.
Europe: Energy Efficiency or “Negawatts”
Last week’s note (see “Some Like it Cold”, August 4, 2022) underlined the growing appetite for the “cold” chain. Moreover, for anyone paying energy bills on the European continent these days, the temptation to invest in solar panels, better insulation for houses and industrial buildings and heat pumps has never been greater. About 40% of European firms were investing in energy efficiency measures in 2021 according to a recent survey from the European Investment Bank, a figure that will surely increase substantially in the coming months and years in Europe and globally. To this end, each of the European, US and Australian climate plans calls for greater energy efficiency.
EU Carbon Markets: A Tribute to EU Policymakers’ Resolve
European carbon markets have been surprisingly resilient to current economic conditions on the continent. So far, the European Commission has resisted calls to increase the quantity of carbon allowances (EUA) on the market despite the pressure coming from higher gas prices – which in turn have forced many coal utilities to resume production – leading to more scarcity in the regulated carbon emissions market. That said, given a rather gloomy economic outlook in Europe, we do not view EUA emission rights as a lucrative investment at this point. However, the EU carbon market shows yet again the EU leaders’ determination in using carbon markets as a tool to accelerate energy transition and lower emissions over the longer term. Alas, this is one of the key points– as well as carbon taxes – still missing in the U.S. climate plan.
Trading Ideas
We see several investment opportunities stemming from the recent climate legislation in a high energy price environment. First, our basket of green-themed stocks remains attractive for those looking to increase their long exposure to the energy efficiency theme.
Second, we see two industries of the Eurostoxx 600 being affected by persistently high energy prices. These should yield interesting ideas for investment pairs: Steel, Fertilizers and to a lesser extent Chemicals. In the steel industry, a long position on energy-efficient SSAB and a short on Arcelor Mittal could make sense.
Third, fertilizer makers typically use a very large quantity of fossil fuels such as natural gas to produce the methane from which the fertilizer is derived. As a result, we expect their profit margins to compress substantially in the coming months, especially for companies with a lower energy efficiency per MM of revenue such as OCI. Hence, a long position on more energy efficient fertilizer maker such as Yara and a short on OCI could make sense in the current environment.
One of the greatest contributors to improved living standards – and one that, most of us, take for granted – is the ability to have uniform indoor temperatures from central heating and air conditioning. As climate records continue to be broken in the U.S., U.K., Europe, and Asia, the ability to manage temperatures, not only for human health and comfort, but also for transportation (the U.K.’s halted train system last month is just one example of infrastructure challenges in high heat), food chains and a myriad of other applications, will be vital to maintain current lifestyles.
Today’s note explores the increasing challenges of controlling temperature amidst climate change in two basic areas of modern life: food and shelter. We highlight a handful of companies that are particularly well positioned to provide energy efficient temperature solutions in a world where energy conservation will become increasingly critical.
Food & Shelter: The Temperature Challenge
Scientists predict that unless dramatic action is taken, by 2070, one third of the world population could be living in conditions that are outside humanity’s comfort zone. As the globe heats up, more effort will be needed to maintain the “artificial” temperatures that we have become accustomed to. Nowhere will this be more important than in relation to our most basic needs of food and shelter. However, these areas are also responsible for over 10% of total GHG emissions.
In terms of shelter, according to the IEA, the use of air conditioners and electric fans to stay cool accounts for nearly 20% of the total electricity that is used in buildings around the world today. This number is steadily rising: the two charts below show that cooling unit sales are especially strong in the U.S. and China and critically, the use of energy for space cooling is growing faster than for any other end use in buildings, more than tripling between 1990 and 2016. The rising demand for space cooling is also putting enormous strain on electricity systems in many countries.
Absent major gains in energy efficiency, these strains are likely to only get worse, since – according to the IEA - the rate of growth of cooling systems is expected to explode higher in the coming decades, with the bulk of the expansion occurring in the U.S., China and India.
As for food, we have already detailed some of the challenges that climate change poses to agriculture (Finding True North to Feed the World, May 5, 2022). Artificial cooling will not help us grow more food, but it can help us do a better job with what we already produce: a cold chain is a temperature-controlled supply chain that includes continuous refrigeration from production to transportation, handling, storage, and delivery.
Cold chains are essential to preserve and maintain the suitability of foods such as fruits, vegetables, frozen foods, dairy, etc. According to recent data by the FAO, 46% of all food produced globally would benefit from refrigeration. Yet only about half of that amount is actually refrigerated; the result is that roughly 13% of total food production is wasted through spoilage. In terms of volume, this food waste equates to approximately 475 million tonnes of lost food annually that could theoretically feed 950 million people a year if access to refrigeration was possible.
Unlike air conditioning and climate change that is caught in a vicious circle, refrigeration may reduce overall GHG emissions. Not only is food waste a huge lost opportunity to feed more people, but it is also a significant contributor to GHG emissions and overall environmental degradation. The EPA estimates that each year, in the U.S. alone, food loss and waste equals the annual CO2 emissions of 42 coal-fired power plants. This does not include the significant methane emissions from food waste rotting in landfills (methane is 25 times more potent than carbon dioxide).
To solve the problem, as the diagram below highlights, cold solutions are necessary at all of the links in the food logistics supply chain.

The bottom line is that as the planet heats up, the desire and necessity to artificially bring down temperatures for food and shelter will inevitably grow. These extra demands on electricity supply imply that companies providing energy efficient cooling systems in the food and building sectors stand to be long-term winners.
Clean, Cold Solutions
Examples of companies that are leading the way in energy efficient cooling solutions are Carrier Global and NIBE Group.
- Carrier is an American based company with over half of its revenues generated in the U.S. They operate in three segments: HVAC equipment, refrigeration and security. The HVAC segment (53% of revenue in 2020) serves heating and cooling needs in residential and commercial properties, while refrigeration products (19% of revenues in 2020) support the middle sections of the cold chain (trucks, trailers, food retail and warehouses). Importantly, Carrier was the first company in the industry to phase out ozone-depleting refrigerants and has routinely won innovation awards related to its refrigeration business: the company has over 8,000 active patents. In terms of HVAC, Carrier products are up to 85% more efficient than industry standard models, making them a leader in heating and cooling energy efficiency.
- NIBE Group is a Swedish company specializing in climate solutions (representing 74% of the company’s profits in 2020). Their main product segment is heat pumps. Recall that heat pumps – unlike air conditioners and furnaces - transfer heat and cold rather than generating it. During the hotter seasons, heat pumps move heat from a building into the outdoors. Nibe heat pumps emit 10 times less emissions than traditional heating and cooling building methods; their products are sold worldwide. We expect that NIBE is particularly primed to reap the benefits of the ongoing push in Europe toward energy efficiency, intensified in the aftermath of Russian oil and gas supply reductions. In May, the European Commission released its RePowerEU plan; which has objectives to rapidly reduce reliance on Russian energy and accelerate the green energy transition. The plan calls for member states to double their deployment of heat pump installation - resulting in a cumulative 10 million units over the next 5 years. To achieve this, the EU intends to, along with member states, enhance the regulatory environment, facilitate access to financing heat pump manufacture and installation, and reduce VAT rates for high efficiency systems. Clearly, NIBE is extremely well placed to benefit from the RePowerEU plan.
These are two examples of companies that are well placed to benefit from both the immediate and long-term demand for cooling solutions. Other companies in this space that have innovative products include Trane, Johnson Controls, Emerson, Lennox and Daikin Industries. This equity sector is currently not particularly cheap relative to global benchmarks (e.g. MSCI world), however, long-term investors with high conviction in the necessity of energy efficiency solutions could be well served by owning a well diversified basket of companies offering sustainable cooling.
Water risks are increasingly discussed among the investment community amidst warming weather patterns and the growing frequency of droughts and water shortages. Most of these risks are directly material to almost any investment’s bottom line.
These risks are the usual suspects of climate change: increased severity of droughts, floods, wildfires, storms, sea-level rise and loss of freshwater reserves. They all imply either an excess or lack of water in any given place, affecting the water supply in local economies. Moreover, while carbon emissions are only material through regulatory and reputational mechanisms, water risks are physically material to the bottom line of almost all industries. The following materiality matrix from the World Resources Institute shows precisely how the 13 water risks it measures are relevant to all sectors of the economy in one way or another (on scale of 0 to 4, see the table below).

This is not difficult to grasp once one realises that all industries are using water as one of their main factors of production; most of them not even knowing it. Indeed, one needs water to grow food, produce cement, clothes, medicine, mining metals and to produce any kind of energy. All of these industries have developed business models that implicitly rely on a steady, secure and free supply of water.
The abundant supply of water is now being challenged by climate change and is creating various financial risks for businesses and their supply chains that investors need to understand:
Operational Risks: The most straightforward type of climate/water risk is simply if a business no longer has the necessary water to generate its own production. This is for example the case for a hydropower plant in California serving 750,000 homes that had to be shut down because there was no longer enough water in the river to run its turbines, following the aridification of the Californian landscape. The same applies this year to the Hoover Dam and Lake Mead with its historically low water levels.
Profitability Risks: Another straightforward risk businesses face from climate change are the increasing costs for adapting to abrupt changes in local water supply. This was, for example, the case for Taiwan Semi-Conductor Manufacturers whose water allowance was reduced by 15% by the government following an historic drought in the island. The company had to resort to shipping water by trucks every day from the other side of the island, a very costly solution. The change in the water supply and its costs inevitably affect business models and their economics through their margins and profitability.
Competitive or Transition Risks: Indirect but consequent types of risk due to climate change are Competitive or Transition Risks. These are the risks derived from failing to make the investments necessary to adapt. For example, businesses that have invested in resilient infrastructure to face increasing natural risks will be better prepared than those that did not. The same logic goes for companies that have invested in circular water management solutions for their factories and will therefore be less sensitive to change in the local water supply; as well as having reduced operational costs and improved margins. These companies will have a strong competitive edge, which will also be reinforced by market mechanisms and increasing green regulations. Financial markets participants will create the same discriminatory effect by screening between the companies that are fit enough to survive climate change.
Systemic Risks: A good example to illustrate systemic risk is the collapse of the energy and water systems in Texas during the last deep freeze in February 2021. Because of an ailing jet stream that could no longer contain arctic weather in the arctic, the state of Texas faced some polar weather for a month which froze most of its gas and water infrastructure. This left some parts of the state without running water and electricity for weeks and cost the Texan economy between $80-130 billion in direct and indirect economic losses. This included damage to homes and businesses, cleaning costs for contaminated water and foregone economic activity. This example shows how modern economies are dependent on a secured supply of water, and when threatened, creates systemic risks across the economy.
Inflation Risks: Little discussed is the inflation risk water scarcity is likely to bring. Water scarcity in many regions of the world will inevitably lead to an increase in its price. This has the potential to spread throughout supply chains and to consumers, and lead to sustained inflation throughout the economy. This is also valid for the other side of the water quantity spectrum, where too much water in the forms of floods, storms and intense rainfalls will increase asset erosion and repair costs. These are likely to be new structural pricing effects in the economy that will become new long-term risks for investors.
As the examples above show, many of these risks have already started to materialise in the economy and the probability is rising that water problems become greater over time. That said, hedging portfolios against the growing water risks remains a difficult task. While several ETFs and water “indices” have been created, we feel that they still poorly capture the true “water risk” embedded in the corporate world. To this end, we see three ways to measure water risks for investors.
The first way to evaluate this risk is to look at water usage per million dollars of revenue for companies in each sector, which points us to some of the companies with the highest “water hazard” embedded in their business models.
Second, the WWF Water Risk Filter gives a comprehensive water risks assessment of any global asset that is entered into its database. This tool can then be used as part of an engagement strategy whereby investors can request water-vulnerable companies to take a water-risk assessment, monitor their water vulnerability and eventually incentivize companies to invest in new water innovations to hedge against these risks.
Third, CDP is also emerging as one of the leading data providers for water metrics. It has designed an extensive questionnaire for 10 years on water awareness, exposure, management and stewardship of companies. This effectively evaluates the level of water responsibility for all companies globally and their readiness to face new climate risks. CDP Water ratings (A-F) can therefore be used to screen water risks across portfolios, for example, by only retaining water leaders that have scored an “A”. This water screen can be added to a carbon screening methodology to add adaptation risks to an existing sustainable investment strategy or risk management strategy.
The 1% has the potential to change from being the greatest climate change offenders to the leaders; these wealthy individuals have disproportionate climate influence via their roles as consumers, investors and by leveraging their social networks. It is promising that younger members of the 1% are beginning to act in favor of improved environmental outcomes.
Much of the attention about inequality is focused on income and wealth. However, inextricably tied to wealth and income disparity is carbon emissions, both in terms of those who emit (the wealthy) and those who suffer (the poor). The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the UN group responsible for evaluating climate change related matters, has issued a series of science-based reports documenting the impact of climate change on the planet and its inhabitants. Its analysis of how GHG emissions have and will disproportionately hurt the poor is a reminder of inequality in the world, and the responsibility that the richest have for the living conditions of the poorest.
In this note, we provide an overview of the current situation, what systemic approaches can be utilized to improve outcomes and perhaps, most importantly, what investment tools are at the disposal of wealthy individuals to rectify their current carbon footprint.
State of the World Today: In the Eye of the Storm
Just as the top 1% captured 38% of all additional wealth accumulated since the mid-1990s, the production of GHG emissions is also extremely concentrated among a small share of the population: the charts below show that the top 10 per cent of income earners is responsible for close to half of all emissions, whereas the lowest 50 per cent of income earners account for around 7–15 per cent of all emissions. In terms of volume, each member of the 1% on average is responsible for 110 tonnes of CO2 equivalent emissions, compared to only 6.6 tonnes for the median wage earner.
Perhaps even more dramatic, in many rich countries, per capita emissions among the bottom half of emitters have declined since 1990: their current emission levels are close to the 2030 per capita climate targets set by the US, the UK, Germany and France. In contrast, highest emitters continue to do so at ever increasing rates.

Looking forward, if the world is to comply with the Paris agreement to limit warming to 1. 5°C, the wealthiest 1% will need to reduce their current emissions by 97% by 2030. In other words, all emission reductions efforts “should” be made by citizens in the top half of wealth distribution. The climate crisis shows how rich people blow through their “fair share” of carbon emissions.
These statistics underscore that it is overwhelmingly a wealthy minority that is fuelling the climate crisis. But what is it precisely about wealthy individuals that makes their carbon footprint so drastically different? The main culprit is their choices regarding transportation and leisure, and to a lesser extent, their choice of residence(s). The chart below shows the environmental footprint of several high-profile billionaires: although transportation in private jets, helicopters and luxury cars are a well known high-emitting pleasure of the super-rich, yachts are actually the biggest contribution to their mammoth carbon footprint.
Toward a more equal outcome: Policy, People, and Portfolio Impacts
Policy makers are traditionally focused on reducing income inequality, yet for the future of the Earth to be secured, they must shift the focus to addressing carbon inequality.
Carbon inequality differs from income and wealth inequality in that in the case of the latter, the aim of policymakers is generally to increase the income and wealth outcomes of those in the bottom half, without negatively impacting the level of income and wealth of those that are better off. In other words, the goal is to “increase the pie,” and improve the quality of life – as measured in financial terms – for everyone.
Unfortunately, unless consumer preferences change naturally, or unless policymakers devise an improved set of policy tools to impact consumer preferences, increasing the pie for everyone would tragically mean increasing GHG emissions per capita.
Since the bottom half of the population is responsible for only a very small share of carbon emissions, it follows then that in order to be successful, policies must focus on the largest emitters, i.e., wealthier nations and wealthier individuals. Possible solutions include:
Carbon wealth tax: A carbon wealth tax involves applying a supplemental tax to high earners and spending the proceeds on green energy investments and/or other tools that redistribute in favor of lower carbon emitters.
Policy and Consumer Preferences: COVID-19 has shown how rapid lifestyle changes can be brought about by governments, through lockdown periods establishing new routines. While lockdowns are draconian, they highlight that spending patterns can shift meaningfully in the near term when there is a strong government action, or exogenous shock (COVID). Consumer preferences can be shifted by government policies, and this shift is a critical part of addressing the climate crisis. One approach, called Choice Editing, refers to the active process of controlling or limiting the choices available to consumers end goal, specifically by banning or imposing punitive taxation on certain products and services. In the case of forcing habit changes of the super-rich, authorities can restrict carbon-intensive products (like private jets or mega yachts) from coming to the market in the first place, or by taxing specific products so that lower-carbon options are favored. Tax incentives for modifying consumer behavior are a long established part of the policy took kit. For example, in the U.S., there are significant tax incentives for individuals to purchase municipals bonds to help finance local and state governments - these incentives largely help the wealthy and encourage them to direct their wealth to public infrastructure projects and financing the activities of municipalities. It would be reasonable to provide both taxes and tax incentives to shift the consumer preferences of the richest to save the planet.
In theory, both of the above approaches are straightforward. But in practice, both can be difficult to implement and in the case of taxation, difficult to assess the impact. Wealthy individuals not only have outsized financial resources but they also tend to have substantial social resources, meaning that their ability to lobby and influence regulatory incomes is high relative to other socioeconomic groups. Therefore, the likelihood that choice editing would occur in a way that would crimp the lifestyles of the rich and famous is lowered. In any case, there are currently few such restrictive measures in place. A lone exception is the UK labour party’s proposal to ban private jets from airports beginning in 2025. Meanwhile, carbon taxes have, historically, had little impact on the consumption of high-income households since demand inelasticity is greatest among this group.
A third approach in curbing carbon emissions by wealthier households is by targeting non-financial factors of decision-making. Much of consumer behaviour is influenced not only by rational choice regarding prices, but also by other factors including routines, normative influences, and heuristics and biases. Nudge theory is a concept in behavioral economics that proposes positive reinforcement and indirect suggestions as ways to influence the behavior and decision-making of groups or individuals. In other words, it attempts to alter people’s behavior in a predictable way without forbidding any options or significantly changing their economic incentives.
Nudging has been recognised as an effective policy tool to align intention and action in facilitating behavioural change with regard to environmental outcomes, especially in the areas of waste management, energy conservation and sustainable travel. Since high-income individuals are often viewed as role models (influencers) and set the tone to which others aspire, they could play an important positive role in changing consumer behavior at large in favor of “greener lifestyles”.
Generational Shifts: All Hands on Deck
An expected $68 trillion will change hands over the next two decades as part of the “Great Wealth Transfer” from the baby boomer generation (born 1946 - 1964) to millennials (born 1981 - 1996) and Gen Z (born 1997-2012). As the survey data in the Chart below highlights, the latter generations place a stronger importance on environmental issues, suggesting that as this wealth transfer occurs, the likelihood that behavior is more aligned with sustainable consumption will increase.
Moreover, a Deloitte survey shows that millennials and Gen Zs are willing to align their spending with their values: 90% of millennials and Gen Zs are taking action to limit environmental impact and are willing to pay a premium for more sustainable products.
This finding is especially true for the wealthiest of these generations. A 2020 report by Wealth-X exploring global luxury highlights that younger members of the ultra wealthy (defined as those having wealth over $30 M) do not have the same affinity for luxury items as those over 50 years old. They are less likely to own a yacht, private jet, art collection or other asset collection (real estate, cars, watches and jewelry, sports team, etc.) of significant value.
Further impact can be achieved through philanthropic activity. There is approximately US$1.5 trillion dedicated to all philanthropic assets and endowments around the world, but less than 1% was spent on curbing climate change in 2020. Philanthropic spending tends to be centred on health, public safety, community development and education, but since millennials tend to prioritize environmental projects, one can expect that giving to environmental causes will skew favourably in the future.
Finally, millennials are likely to invest in portfolios that are different than their parents and grandparents, by placing greater emphasis on environmental impact relative to financial metrics. This is good news since investments in stocks, bonds, businesses and real estate are disproportionately made by those in the top 1% of income and wealth. Through shifting investments to low-emissions companies and mutual funds, the 1% can push companies to lower GHG emissions and thereby drive structural change. By contrast, investments that favour continuing fossil fuel use will delay emissions reductions.
As Big Oil companies are raking in some of the fattest profits on record, one can think about how those companies’ recent commitments to become Net-zero by 2050 will fare against the easier, business-as-usual practices of making profits money when the commodity cycle favors them.
Interestingly, about all oil majors have announced their intention to become Net-zero players – mostly by 2050. These announcements have been met with severe criticism – if not cynicism – by many market players.
That said, for ESG-conscious investors who still buy into the industry’s Net-zero narrative and who expect to remain invested while companies transition out of fossil fuels, a recent report from Oil Change international, an NGO, suggests that those companies are still far from being able to reduce their GHG emissions, despite their Net-zero commitments. What’s more, many, if not most of these commitments, are still based on non-existing carbon removal technologies, some of which include buying carbon offsets (which is itself an already incredibly messy market), selling assets and scaling up carbon capture technologies. We view that it is highly unlikely that Big Oil will reach its Net-zero commitments with such policies.
Assessing the Oil Majors’ Climate Plans

Source: Oil Change International
The good news is that this year’s fat profits should help those companies increasingly invest into their transition towards renewables. This is at least the bet taken by that many ESG-minded investors who have not yet divested out of oil. In our view, this view is too optimistic given the industry’s past performance with regard to capital expenditure. First, there has been some considerable “underinvestment” in the industry in the past decade, which partly explains why the global oil market was stretched earlier this year.
Second, most oil majors have yet to embark on their massive transition program: one which will require more than USD 4 trillion of investment per year over the next 30 years according to the IEA for the world to reach net zero by 2050. Looking at current trends of capex/total assets ratios and forward-looking capex, it does not seem that a “re-investment” culture has been re-instilled in the oil industry just yet. By many accounts, even European oil companies, which remain ahead of their North American peers with regard to Energy Transition, are still way behind the required “investment” schedule.
Third, the sector’s unwillingness to live up to its commitments also manifests itself in the way these companies are currently using their decade-high profits. Looking at those companies’ short-term spending priorities one can see that investing some capex into transition-related projects is not on top of mind of Energy sector executives and board members just yet.
For a company like Exxon, we’ve yet to see the company’s senior management change the course of action as they still value more buybacks and dividend payouts than investment into transition-oriented projects. In fact, the company even announced early this year its intention that it would buy back USD 30 billion worth of its own shares before the end of next year, which is somewhat counterintuitive for a company to take climate change more seriously following its activist “takeover” by Engine No.1 last year.
Finally, with the global oil market now being under a bit less stress than earlier this year, one could think that oil prices “path of least resistance” would be downward given growing recession fears. In fact, the oil market is currently oversupplied – which could also begin to alleviate high oil prices.
Moreover, with the economic cycle entering extended time, we are also seeing that the oil market is now in backwardation over for the next year.
Central bankers in developed economies have finally woken up to the reality of high and sticky inflation. The Federal Reserve is leading the charge to quell inflation, while the Swiss National Bank and the European Central Bank are projecting an exit from negative interest rates. The Bank of Japan remains on its own course by keeping its yield curve control.
Until May, higher interest rates were mainly affecting high-growth companies but, since then, higher financing and energy costs are slowing the economy and it is progressively being reflected across all sectors and financial markets.
At the end of the first quarter, we published our revised outlook for the year (ESG Meets Macro Shifts: The Outlook for Q2 and Beyond). In today’s note, we are updating our calls, as summarized in the tables at the end of the note.
We see four key developments that will drive equity movements for the next twelve months.
1. Higher interest rates slowing the economy.
After qualifying it as transitory in 2021, central banks are doing their best to regain control of inflation by increasing their overnight rate and projecting future increases along with quantitative tightening. As a result, interest rates of all maturities have risen fast in 2022. Higher interest rates act with a lag on the economy but their impact has been immediately felt on housing and auto sales, sectors heavily dependent on financing.
We still believe that the inflation genie is out of the bottle and that it will average closer to 4% than 2% over the next decade. Contrary to the previous 20 years, higher prices are animating public discourse and the recent increases are shaping consumer behaviour. The record profit margins observed in recent years are under pressure; producer price indices are growing much faster than consumer price indices as can be seen from the graph below. These circumstances generally lead to lower profit margins that pressure companies to slow down new expenses.
In a slowing economy, defensive sectors that have low variability in revenues and earnings like health care and consumer staples tend to shine compared to other segments of the equity market. As financial markets reflect a greater probability of recession, we favor the low growth portion of the graphic below.
Health care has performed exceptionally well in previous bear markets, not just the pandemic-related bear market. In our note of June 2, 2022, “High Impact: Surviving a Recession with Care”, we included the chart below that shows the performance of the health care sector during the previous four bear markets; positive performance in all cases.
2. Stubborn cost pressures from commodities and other factors
The previous decade saw commodity prices fall. Exploration investments followed in the same direction and, as is typical for commodities after such a period, we find ourselves in an uncomfortable supply and demand position where forecasted demand outstrips projected supply. The transformation of industrial processes towards a greener world will also contribute to commodity demand, especially for transition commodities.
Even though a recession may be near, we expect commodity prices to remain elevated. They may fall as we experience a slowdown but any sign of recovery will soon reflect underlying supply issues. Moreover, the relative isolation of Russia from the global economy will continue to menace supply.
Higher commodity prices, continuing supply shocks for goods and tighter labour markets with the retirement of baby-boomers will continue to exert input cost pressures on companies. In our note on May 12, 2022, “Inflation Protecting your ESG Equity Portfolio”, we examined companies that have shown the ability to increase profit margins in a rising cost environment. The table below shows the ESG leaders able to do so.
3. Return on Capital ≤Cost of Capital
The financial system starts to have hiccups when the expected return on capital falls below the cost of capital. Over the last quarter century, we witnessed such an event during the bear market of 2000-2003 for a portion of the economy: high growth companies that could not meet excessive growth expectations. Central banks came to the rescue with interest rate cuts that reduced the cost of capital and re-established confidence that the return on capital of the economy was greater than the cost of capital. We lived through a more dangerous episode from 2007-2009 that started with real estate but propagated to the financial system and the rest of the economy. In this case, a combination of interest rate cuts and asset purchases from central banks and fiscal stimulus to recapitalize the banking system were necessary to re-establish confidence.
The current financial situation has more similarities with the 2000-2003 period where growth expectations for a portion of the economy are unlikely to be met. The banking system is not currently under pressure. The risk lies to the cost of capital part of the equation because, contrary to the previous episodes, inflation is out of control and it is unknown if central banks will have the ability to reduce the cost of capital once the expected return on capital falls below the cost of capital.
Under these circumstances, growth companies should continue to underperform value companies and most forms of private equity (venture capital, growth equity and leveraged buy-outs) should experience much tougher times than the benign conditions of the past decade.
4. Unsustainable Business Model Crash
With financial markets dropping precipitously so far in 2022, business models that rely on cheap access to capital to fund their operations and/or stock options to retain employees as in our note from February 17, 2022, “Buying the dream – Tech Sector stock options at a time of high volatility” are at risk. The graph below shows a list of companies that have aggressive option compensation practices.
Similar to 2000-2003 when the dotcom bubble imploded and financing became more complicated, we expect the situation for companies with financing needs and aggressive compensation approaches to deteriorate further.
As the consequences of climate change become more evident – drought, flooding, fires, hurricanes, etc. – the rallying call is growing louder to not only protect nature and natural ecosystems, but also to collaborate with nature. From an investment perspective, there is still plenty of room on this bandwagon; according to some calculations, the financing gap for nature is estimated at USD 700 billion.
In today’s Note, we provide a brief overview of the nomenclature of solutions stemming from nature, we pinpoint the most promising, and characterize the state of investment in these opportunities.
Nature and Its Solutions: The Landscape
Nature-based solutions (NbS) – the notion of working with nature to address societal challenges – has recently gained momentum as an integrated approach that could address the twin crises of climate change and biodiversity loss. Even with this definition in hand though, it is often unclear what the potential investment opportunities are. To start, we provide definitions of key terms in the table below to help guide investors.
Nature derived solutions are already well understood by investors; renewable energy has existed for decades and is already an important share of the total global energy mix. Meanwhile, nature inspired solutions, such as artificially synthesized spider silk as a textile, or harvesting wave energy with kelp motion, do not necessarily tackle climate change and biodiversity loss. Therefore, this report focuses on Nature-based Solutions and the opportunities for investors.
Nature-based Solutions
A defining feature of NbS is that this approach to addressing climate change and biodiversity loss relies on functioning ecosystems. Thus, the goal is to protect and restore natural capital so that nature can function properly and provide the ecosystem services that people and businesses depend on.
Investing in Nature-based Solutions is only in its infancy and the chart below shows just how underfunded nature is: although $44 trillion (over half of the world’s GDP) of value is generated in industries that depend highly (US$13 trillion) or moderately (US$31 trillion) on nature and its services, there is a major financing gap for conservation activities.
Moreover, investors have largely ignored NbS as an investment opportunity. As the chart below highlights, of the total financial flows that go toward biodiversity conservation, only 1% are considered NbS.
The private sector has been particularly slow to acknowledge nature’s solutions: as the chart illustrates, not only do NbS attract a far smaller dollar amount of funding relative to climate finance, but the private sector hardly participates. Indeed, the majority of funding for climate change originates with the private sector, whereas funding for Nature-based Solutions is almost exclusively done by the public sector. The scaling up of private capital for nature-based solutions is widely viewed as a central challenge to being on a path to sustainable economic growth.
For investors seeking direct opportunities in NbS, we see two broad categories where impact is highest: forestry and sustainable cities.
Forestry:
Protecting, managing and restoring forests offers roughly two-thirds of the total mitigation potential of all nature-based solutions. Not only are trees, plants and healthy soil an abundant and cost-effective means of removing and storing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, they are also home to insects, birds, animals and a world of microscopic organisms that help to underpin human life. We have previously articulated our top picks for publicly traded forestry companies (please see, Knock on Wood, May 20, 2021 and Investment Trends in 2022: Don’t Put Your ESG In One Basket, January 5, 2022). Beyond investing directly in forestry companies that have superior biodiversity records and goals, one of the other (few) options for investors looking to gain access to NbS in forestry is via carbon credits.
Recall that carbon credit markets function when sellers in the carbon market create carbon credits by reducing their emissions (e.g. a farmer who adopts sustainable land-use practices). Buyers, often corporations or governments, buy the credit and thus “gain” the right to emit a set amount of carbon dioxide. For more information, please see our Note, Heros and Zeros: What Investors Need to Know About Carbon Pledging, December 2, 2021.
Although carbon offsets are created and traded based on their climate benefits, many offset projects have positive collateral effects, or “co-benefits,” that may include the protection of forests and biodiversity. The co-benefits associated with forest carbon projects can include protecting watershed areas that supply clean water, safeguarding critical habitat for biodiversity, and providing important social benefits.
For now, most carbon offsets are largely focused on the accounting for greenhouse gas reductions or carbon sequestration and do not consider measures for protecting biodiversity. However, last month the NYSE launched the first Nature-Based Solutions carbon credit futures contract. This follows the launch of a similar product by the CME last year. We view this as solid evidence that there is at least tentative buy-in by financial actors of the role of nature-based solutions; tracking this market for liquidity and volume will provide an important bellwether regarding investor interest in nature-based solutions.
Sustainable Cities:
Urban resilience challenges are going to multiply as climate change will increase the frequency and intensity of natural hazards. In the past, structural interventions to reduce disaster risk and build climate resilience in urban settings have largely focused on gray infrastructure. Gray infrastructure refers to built structures and mechanical equipment, such as reservoirs, embankments, pipes, pumps, water treatment plants, canals, etc. The problem with these engineered solutions is that they are often less suitable to withstand more frequent and intense weather events, i.e. are less effective and resilient against extreme weather.
The figure below gives examples of Nature-based Solutions in an urban context.
Diversity of Nature-based Solutions for Urban Application
Source: Global Program on Nature-based Solutions for Climate Resilience
Equity investors can gain access to some of these solutions by being on the lookout for building and/or engineering companies that specialize in nature-based solutions. For example, we have highlighted in past research Arcadis (ARCAD NA), which is a Dutch firm that designs “sponge cities”, which are cities that are designed with sustainable features such as permeable pavements, small water storage facilities, public green spaces that absorb storm water, etc.
Another urban solution is green & cool roofs, whereby soil and vegetation function as living insulation, which moderates building temperatures year-round and reduces the need for energy used in heating and air-conditioning. The global green roof market size was valued at USD 1.1 billion in 2019 and is expected to grow at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 17% from 2020 to 2027. No wonder there is an increasing number of companies specializing in the design and installation of green roofs. ZinCo GmbH, Bauder Ltd., Green Roof Blocks, SOPREMA Group, XeroFlor, Bender GmbH & Co. KG, Green Roof Technology, Sempergreen, Axter Limited, and Optigreen International AG are among the larger players, although none have yet to go public.
Finally, companies that specialize in coastal remediation and protection stabilize shorelines by reducing wave intensity and to protect coasts from erosion. In contrast to concrete-based solutions, NbS can grow with sea-level rise or, if necessary, can be more easily adapted. Great Lakes Dredge & Dock (GLDD US) is an American-based company that undertakes projects all over the world, with 100% of revenue derived from dredging, coastal remediation, and marine construction.
Climate change is top of mind and the world is looking to reduce fossil fuels as the main source of greenhouse gas emissions. Nuclear energy is gaining new disciples because it is GHG-free.
On the other hand, nuclear energy has lost its glitter over the years and its naysayers argue that nuclear is not part of the solution for a greener world. The table below highlights the negative aspects of nuclear.
Over the rest of the note, we will examine these six issues in greater detail.
Not Significant
The following graph displays the evolution of electricity production through time. Fossil fuels have been the main source of electricity for decades, followed by hydro. From the 1970s, nuclear energy grew from a very low level to more than 15% in the 1980s, peaked in the early 2000s and has been falling since on a relative basis. Meanwhile, renewables have grown from a negligible amount in the early 2000s to near 10%, rivaling the level of nuclear. With focus, a global grid with 50% or less fossil fuels could be reached by 2030. The most reasonable path is that hydro maintains its current proportion, renewables double and nuclear gets back to its 2001 share of global electricity output.
If we want to reduce our dependence on fossil fuels for electricity production, we will need increases from other energy sources. Since large hydro projects are harder to find (big rivers already have hydro projects) and have steep environmental impact on biodiversity for example. The potential for hydro to make a big comeback to replace fossil fuels is low. Renewables should continue to grow rapidly but they have constraints, such as weather and geographical limitations, low output and storage difficulties and aside for large hydro, can hardly provide a base power grid solution. As discussed previously, nuclear has disadvantages but its advantages are very complementary to renewables. Nuclear energy production is not affected by weather or geography (other than earthquakes), has high output and no energy storage issues (storage of nuclear waste is another matter).
From a GHG emissions standpoint, we can see from the graph below that nuclear, wind and solar are leaps and bounds better compared to coal, oil and natural gas.
Dangerous
The graph below looks at the number of deaths to generate electricity according to the World Health Organization. It includes workplace deaths and the effects of pollution. Air pollution is one of the greatest environmental risks to health and fossil fuels are a major contributor. While nuclear material is extremely dangerous, safety has been a critical factor in the development of its industry, unlike the coal industry.
Too Expensive
The economics of nuclear power are very complex. There are three main factors driving the relative price competitiveness of nuclear:
- The relative cost of other energy sources. This has the greatest impact for fossil fuels as they are a large component of the overall cost. Nuclear fuel cost represents a smaller share of costs and for wind, solar and hydro, the inputs are free.
Over the last couple of years, the price of oil has been very volatile; temporarily negative in 2020 and more than $120 per barrel, recently. The prices of natural gas have also increased to all-time records recently in Europe and Asia. These high prices make nuclear competitive yet by considering the long-term nature of nuclear plants, the high volatility is a detriment.
- The relative investment cost which includes the engineering, construction, land, raw materials and financing costs for the required capital investment. This has the greatest impact for renewables and hydro and the least impact for fossil fuels. The interest rate is a very important factor for the financing cost.
With inflation rising, the cost of labor, raw materials and financing are increasing fast. On a positive note for nuclear, among the low GHG emitters, it requires the least raw materials.
- The external costs are permitting, taxes (including carbon taxes) and intermittency costs. When intermittent renewables represent a high proportion of the grid, incentives for low intermittency will have to be put in place.
There are more and tougher carbon taxes being introduced that should favor nuclear and renewables. A lot of promising energy storage projects are being financed but, so far, no storage holy grail has been found, therefore a high base load (minimum level of electricity demand) is very attractive and should be incentivized as we move towards a cleaner electricity grid. This is positive for nuclear energy and the nuclear industry.
Too Slow
The average time to completion for a nuclear plant is between 5 and 10 years. Recently, we have seen decommissioning plans get reversed as it becomes more economical and population views turn positive on nuclear as a “sustainable” source of energy.
Small modular reactors could be game changers in terms of time and cost as they are expected to take 3 to 5 years to build at much lower price tags.
Too Much Waste
Nuclear waste requires very careful handling. As reactors are reaching the end of their useful life, dealing with waste has become more critical. Recycling is not yet cost efficient and most countries in Europe (other than Finland) have not come up with a definitive solution. On the positive side, from a historical standpoint, nuclear waste has been safely handled.
Industry Always Disappoints
The historical failure of nuclear economics comes from the severe threats to public safety posed by radiation and the accompanying demands for safety improvements. This has meant long lead times and large sunk costs. The technology has not benefitted from economies of scale and witnessed cost escalation compared to other electricity producing industries. In order to be successful, it needs sustained high energy prices and government support. The past 40 years have been hard for nuclear, but things may be changing as climate change is reducing incentives for fossil fuel investments, pushing the price of energy higher. Furthermore, intermittency issues for renewables is making governments think twice about decommissioning nuclear plants. Lastly, the supply of nuclear energy has increased in China because its government is supportive.
The Outlook
Sustainable Market Strategies discussed the potential for nuclear versus solar and wind while hype was at its peak in a note last year “A Radioactive Topic for ESG-Minded Investors”, January 21, 2021. The timing of the note was prescient. Since then, we have seen some uranium enthusiasm while solar and wind have dropped quite a bit.
We believe that nuclear energy is part of the solution for many national grids to become Net Zero by 2050. The economic and geopolitical conditions for a revival of nuclear are more attractive than they have been in the last 30 years; a transition to a cleaner grid has become consensus, the price of energy remains close to all-time high while the price of materials is increasing fast as most countries would like to be as energy-independent as possible.
There are a few ways to invest in nuclear: small modular reactor providers and uranium miners are the most interesting to us.
For small modular reactors, Nuscale, Westinghouse (now part of Brookfield), GE-Hitachi (co-owned by GE and Hitachi) and Rolls Royce are the leading providers of small modular reactors. This segment will probably be the best risk-reward opportunity once momentum gathers towards new nuclear facilities. Nuscale is the purest play as the other companies mentioned are conglomerates. For GE and Rolls Royce, their aviation business is currently a more significant segment but that could change; they both share the characteristics of having too much leverage in an increasing rate environment.
For uranium miners, KazatomProm and Cameco are the largest pure plays. BHP is also a big uranium producer. Currently, the most attractive position for uranium for ESG-conscious investors is Cameco because it is a pure play that operates in Canada; a safer country compared to Kazakhstan.