In every economic cycle, rising interest rates shake out the weakest links first. In the U.K. last autumn, it was the pension system that came under pressure as U.K. rates spiked. Last week in the U.S., it was Silicon Valley Bank. Today’s note discusses the implications of the bank failure for sustainability investors, as well as two other brewing issues that have been temporarily sidelined during the bank meltdown: worsening China-U.S. trade relations and growing investment momentum related to U.S. and European green fiscal tailwinds.
Below, we detail how these three factors – SVB bank, global trade tensions and fiscal policy – are likely to play out for sustainability investors in the months ahead.
SVB: Implications For Sustainability Investors
In any given year – especially in periods where interest rates are rising – a handful of U.S. banks go bankrupt. From 2010- 2022, a total of 371 U.S. banks have gone bankrupt. What makes Silicon Valley Bank’s misfortunes newsworthy is its size and concentration. At $209 billion assets, it is among the largest banks to fail in recent history (the average inflation-adjusted bank failure is $6 billion). The bank’s customers were highly concentrated in tech innovation; as is now well known, the bank had few retail investors and catered almost exclusively to venture capital funds.
For sustainability investors, we see two main questions to be tackled: what is the overall macroeconomic implication of the bank failure, i.e. will SVB trigger a more significant risk-off phase for investors and 2) how does the SVB failure impact various sustainability-linked themes (e.g. climate tech) that are dependent on early stage financing?
In terms of the overall macro picture, the SVB debacle does little to change our business cycle view. As interest rates rise, the cost and availability of capital tightens, which tends to shake out the weakest hands. Banks that do not appropriately handle rate risk (SVB did not have a Chief Risk Officer!) are vulnerable.
At Sustainable Market Strategies, our view for some time has been that a prolonged higher inflationary environment would oblige the Fed to keep tightening rates “higher for longer” to force a decrease in the supply of cheap funding (i.e. slow the economy). The failure of SVB is testimony that this process is at work. The Fed’s mandate continues to be to bring inflation down to about 2%; until monetary policymakers are successful, rates will rise and growth is likely to weaken. We continue to advocate for investors to maintain defensive portfolio positions – the downfall of SVB simply means that credit conditions will tighten more quickly as remaining banks become more prudent (either by regulators imposing stricter rules or by choice) and that real economic activity will slow down another notch.
In the short-term, the Fed will be focused on its mandate of financial market stability, but the rate cycle will only reverse when the inflation is in sight.
For sustainability-themed investments, a loss of funding and/or a reticence to take risk at early financing stages means that the potential for innovative solutions (carbon capture, vertical farming, non-animal protein, etc.) to some of the world’s largest problems (climate change, soil degradation, deforestation) will likely slow. Given that SVB was known for backing startups, the failure of the bank may leave a hole that other banks will be weary to fill in. Two themes are particularly vulnerable: health care and climate. Many of SVB’s clients are innovators in the health sector that are trying to find novel solutions to improve outcomes for patients with a range of diseases.
In terms of climate change – a particularly urgent sustainability theme – Silicon Valley is only at the beginning of a long-term investment cycle. SVB appeared to be well entrenched in the climate-tech ecosystem; the bank reportedly had relationships with more than 1,500 companies working on technologies aimed at curbing global warming. In 2022, climate tech raised US$82 billion globally; an all-time high for funding despite a tough year for venture capital. From a geographic perspective, the U.S. – of which Silicon Valley is a major contributor – is accountable for roughly half of that funding.
To the extent that a global risk-off environment takes hold in the face of perceived or real financial stresses, funding to climate ventures will become more restrained. However, as we discuss below, fiscal policy is acting as a substantial positive tailwind. In other words, we expect that industrial policies targeting climate change will partially offset lower risk-taking in the private sector.
Geopolitical Risk Premium Rising
The collapse of SVB has temporarily taken investor focus away from another brewing risk for equity markets: international trade relations. One of the primary secular drivers of our investment research is the notion that globalization has peaked, with important consequences for global supply chains, sector-level investment returns as well as the overall pricing of risk assets.
Recent rhetoric from China, the U.S. and Europe all give credence to this view. China’s appointment this week of a defense minister under U.S. sanctions will surely make any dialogue between China and the U.S. even more challenging. Note that the appointment follows the foreign ministers’ comments last week that there “will surely be conflict” unless Washington changes its stance on several issues.
We believe that there are both macro and industry-level consequences of the mounting international trade tensions.
- Macro: it is challenging to isolate a geopolitical risk premium from other confounding factors. Nonetheless, it is intuitive that as the cost and risks of doing international business (tariffs, financing, regulation) rise, the premium required on risky assets reliant on global trade also rises. We believe we have entered a period where investors will need to be compensated for taking on these extra risks relative to the risk-free rate of return; a premium will be paid for the equity of companies that are showing success at reorienting supply chains away from China.
- Industry-level: we have repeatedly written in recent months about the global impetus to rebuild supply chains to be more regional. This theme is now well underway, beginning first with industries that are considered national security issues for various governments. Renewable energy solutions (solar power, batteries), semiconductors, pharmaceuticals are all industries that are ripe for transition. Indeed, many of these areas have already benefitted – and will continue to benefit – from aggressive industrial policy (see below).
Fiscal Tailwind Is the Best Game in Town
Very much tied to the geopolitical headwinds described above, currently the only major offset to a tightening in financial conditions (both credit and monetary) is the sizeable fiscal tailwind from the U.S. Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) as well as Europe’s response to it, the European Commission’s Green Deal Industrial Plan (GDIP). There are already multiple signs that policies aimed to spur investment in clean energy and other key environmental areas are impacting business decisions. For example, Volkswagen recently announced plans to set up battery plants in the U.S. and Canada instead of Europe due to generous conditions. The sectors that are natural “hiding places” from geopolitical strains are the same sectors that are benefitting from U.S. and European industrial and fiscal policy. Energy efficiency and sustainable building companies that are demonstrating weak ties to China will do especially well.
According to the International Energy Agency, if the world is going to reach its renewable energy goals in 2030, the decade will bring a gargantuan buildup of solar energy power. Currently, solar accounts for about 13% of total renewable energy, but is expected to account for one-third in 2030. Overall, to stay on a path to reach 2050 target emissions of net zero, solar power capacity will need to multiply by seven in the next seven years!
This is an extremely ambitious global goal that will require significant global cooperation. Unfortunately, this is not currently the case, as the industry appears to be confronted with a version of the irresistible force paradox.
An irresistible force paradox is commonly summed up in the phrase “unstoppable force meets immovable object”. When analyzing the solar power industry, China appears to be the unstoppable force that is about to meet its immovable object: deglobalization.
Solar Manufacturing Domination
China is a leader in solar power, both in domestic production of electricity, but also in the manufacture of solar panels; the Chinese solar panel industry is what allows other nations to claim solar as a renewable power source. Indeed, the country is both the largest producer and consumer at all stages of the solar power supply chain, including polysilicon, wafers, cells and completed modules.
Based on manufacturing capacity under construction, China’s share of global polysilicon and wafer production will soon reach almost 95% of total production. But even more alarming is that according to the IEA, one single province in China - Xinjiang - accounts for 40% of global polysilicon manufacturing; one out of every seven panels produced worldwide is manufactured by a single facility in China.
Note that Xinjiang province, referred to by China as the Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region (XUAR), has drawn worldwide attention for human rights abuses; the United Nations Human Rights Commissioner determined in 2022 that “allegations of patterns of torture, or ill-treatment, including forced medical treatment and adverse conditions of detention, are credible”. Investors with interests in the region -need to understand the risks involved, even with passive portfolios.
U.S. Policy to the Rescue?
Of course, this almost total domination of the solar power industry has not gone unnoticed. In 2021, U.S. President Biden emitted an executive order to review America’s supply chains. The “energy sector industrial base” was one of six key industries identified for further assessment. In the subsequent 2022 study by the U.S. Energy Department, a section is dedicated to “Building a Solar Power Chain Not Dependent on China”.
Since then, the U.S. government has taken several actions that have impacted the solar manufacturing industry. The Inflation Reduction Act’s (IRA) aggressive tax credits: The Advanced Manufacturing Production Tax Credit provides tax credits for each clean energy component domestically produced across the solar PV supply chain, while the Advanced Energy Project Credit provides a tax credit for building and commissioning a facility for clean-energy component manufacturing.
In addition, in February 2022, the U.S. extended tariffs on solar products containing crystalline silicon coming from China. Finally, the federal government enacted the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act in June 2022, which bans products including solar components from China’s Xinjiang region. Granted, it is unclear as how successful the ban has been, since there are myriad ways to circumvent this law.
China has not stood still in the face of U.S. promotion of a domestic solar industry. The Chinese government is reportedly looking to add raw materials used in solar panels to a list of items that could be restricted for export in order to ‘help safeguard national security’. These materials would require special permission for export and if enacted aggressively, could effectively strangle the global solar power industry.
How to Invest
From an investor perspective, the complex geopolitics of the solar power industry mean that what should be a relatively straightforward bull case for solar power stocks is in reality, highly muddled and potentially quite risky. Of course, there is the ethical question of investing in an energy transition built on the back of human rights abuses. At a very minimum, the potential for reputational and regulatory challenges associated with solar companies requires that investors embed a significant risk premium on equity in the solar industry.
As we have articulated in previous notes (for example, see Chinese Capitalism’s Long March, September 30, 2021), we believe that China is not investable at the current juncture. For investors desiring to gain exposure to the solar industry, this means that there are few options. After all, Chinese solar manufacturing companies have incredibly strong economic moats and it is far from clear that the U.S. (and other countries) will be able to (re-)establish a solar power manufacturing industry. As the IEA notes, “China is the most cost-competitive location to manufacture all components of the solar PV supply chain. Costs in China are 10% lower than in India, 20% lower than in the United States, and 35% lower than in Europe. Large variations in energy, labour, investment and overhead costs explain these differences. Still, in the absence of financial incentives and manufacturing support, the bankability of manufacturing projects outside of panel assembly remains limited outside of China and few countries in Southeast Asia.”
Currently, the vast majority of public solar power manufacturing companies – irrespective of where they are listed - have strong ties to China and the Xinjiang province and many have already been caught in scandal. The table below highlights features of publicly listed solar power players.
For investors that want to steer clear of trade regulation risks and human rights violations, gaining exposure to the solar manufacturing industry is tricky. Only six companies pass the above preliminary screening: Meyer Burger, Sun Power, First Solar, Maxeon, Wacker Chemie and Tokuyama. The two names that are considered pure plays and have severed any ties with Chinese solar suppliers are Meyer Burger and First Solar.
Note that these companies have already benefitted from being relatively unattached to the Chinese solar panel supply chain, as is reflected in their stock valuations and price performance. Meyer Burger is trading at a P/E of 56, while Sun Power and First Solar are valued at 28 times earnings. Only Wacker Chemi and Tokuyama have closer to fair valuations (14 and 8 respectively), although both of these companies are diversified chemical companies and are thus not pure plays on the solar industry.
We believe that a company like Maxeon Solar provides a good example of the risk associated with investing in solar power manufacturers within the current geopolitical context. Maxeon Solar Technologies was originally the manufacturing arm of SunPower and is now a separate company. Maxeon continues to supply SunPower with solar panels along with other international customers. Maxeon has a joint venture with a module manufacturer in China to produce panels; although the Chinese manufacturer is not in Xinjiang province, it is expected that this company could soon be a target for U.S. trade regulators and by extension, create business risks for Maxeon. Both Maxeon and SunPower stock prices have struggled since China’s human rights violations have come into investors’ focus.
The Mineral Demand Story
We highlight three main structural forces that will keep demand for minerals very buoyant for years to come:
1. Industrial Transformation to Fight Climate Change
Almost all developed countries have fairly aggressive emissions targets. To achieve those targets, a more carbon-efficient industrial complex is required. The table below highlights some of the solutions for the energy transition.
These solutions will require more industrial commodities like copper which is used in electric vehicles and renewable energy technologies, lithium, nickel, cobalt and manganese for batteries, graphite for energy storage, rare earth elements for renewable energy technologies, aluminum for electric vehicles and renewable energy technologies, iron for energy storage technologies and electric vehicles and tungsten for renewable energy technologies.
The chart below shows where each of those critical minerals was sourced from in 2021. China is a leading producer of many critical minerals. This makes sense since China enjoyed rapid growth after their accession to the World Trade Organization and developed local mineral companies to do so.
2. Invasion Leads to Depletion and More Defense
The defense industry is very demanding on critical minerals accounting for close to 10% of global annual output, as can be seen from the chart below. Over the next 5 years, it is reasonable to assume a 30-50% increase in defense spending (countries going from 1-1.5% of GDP to 1.5-2% of GDP on defense). This could translate into 2-5% more demand for minerals.
The US Department of Defense estimated that Tomahawk cruise missiles and Javelin missiles contain approximately 45% of critical materials, including steel, aluminum, copper. Those are the same minerals required for the industrial transformation.
3) India Replaces China
India is the likely replacement for China and its previous insatiable and growing demand for industrial commodities. India’s population is still growing, and its birth rate is at replacement level with around 2 children per woman. The estimated average age of the Indian population in 2022 is 28.5 years old (compared to, 39.3 in China and 39.4 in the United States). The Indian economy is expected to experience 7% real growth over the next five years and infrastructure investments are expected to grow by more than 8% over the same period.
One dampening factor for strong mineral demand in the future is China. The government has heavily subsidized infrastructure investments since the beginning of the century as China’s substantial industrial output outpaced all other countries. More recently, the country’s debt has grown much faster than the size of the overall economy with infrastructure investment representing a much larger part than anywhere else in the world. Debt growing faster than GDP is a clear sign that China has overinvested, and growth will slow on a structural horizon. Moreover, its population is aging and its size will fall rapidly with a birth rate far below the replacement rate, at close to 1 per woman. It has already built empty cities, but infrastructure investments are a quick way to get an economy going (a trick used aggressively during the 2008 and 2016 downturns); expect the long-term trend in commodity demand from China to slow with boom and bust episodes.
The Mineral Supply Story
On the supply side, we are looking at the geography of mining and the complexity to build new mines with a specific focus on copper.
1) Reserve Locations Lead to New Geopolitical Considerations
Chile, Peru and the Democratic Republic of Congo could replace Saudi Arabia as the most courted countries in the world, due to their vast reserve of “in-demand” transition minerals. The list of countries with abundant critical mineral reserves is very different from fossil fuel reserve maps. Vast countries like Russia, Canada, the United States and Brazil have both critical minerals and fossil fuels but smaller countries in South America and Africa are the place to be for minerals as can be seen from the chart below.
2) Copper in the Middle
Since copper is irreplaceable and critical to electrification, its availability will determine the pace of the energy transition. We will concentrate on copper for the remainder of the note.
The demand for copper is likely to increase rapidly from 20-25 million tonnes currently to 30-35 million tonnes in 10 years. There should be a persistent imbalance between supply and demand. We should witness a temporary reprieve over the next two years with a cluster of projects coming into production but the longer-term picture remains favorable to higher copper prices according to BHP’s 2023 Economic and Commodity Report.
Following the difficulties they suffered after overinvesting during the previous commodity cycle that started in 2000, commodity producers remain wary of new mine development even if they believe the strong consensus that there will not be enough copper after 2024. Building a new copper mine is difficult due to increasing costs and environmental regulations. Copper is becoming increasingly scarce. Also, the cost of mining operations have been increasing due to rising labor, energy, and transportation costs. The complexity of the mining process and the environmental impact of mining operations also presents a challenge for mining companies.
3) The Production Challenge
Africa has become more attractive for miners with the recent Lumwana Mine in Zambia, owned by Freeport McMorran, that is estimated to produce approximately 500,000 metric tonnes of copper annually and the Tenke Fungurume Mine in the Democratic Republic of Congo which is estimated to produce approximately 200,000 metric tonnes annually and is owned by Barrick Gold.
The graph below highlights that recent production has mainly come from Latin America where the political landscape is getting more difficult for existing mine operators and those looking to start new mines.
Looking at the companies with the biggest copper production and recognizing their positive optionality on higher copper prices and volume, the graphic below displays the sustainability scores from CSRHub to ascertain which companies have reduced downside risks. If a company is a good citizen from a community, employee and environmental standpoint, the risks to its operations should be reduced allowing it to benefit fully from higher prices and volume.
4) Recycling to the Rescue
Recycling accounts for approximately 25% of annual copper demand (5-7 million tonnes of recycling compared to 20-25 million tonnes of demand). The biggest copper recyclers in the world are China, the United States, and Japan. Together, these three countries account for approximately 60% of global copper recycling. China is the largest copper recycler, accounting for around 37% of global copper recycling. The United States is the second-largest, accounting for around 14% of global copper recycling, while Japan is the third-largest, accounting for around 9% of globally recycled copper.
Considering the difficulties in operating and building new mines that we addressed in the previous section, copper recyclers benefit from the same optionality in price and potentially less operational risks.
Looking at the biggest recyclers, the graph below highlights the sustainability scores from CSRHub to ascertain which companies have the best operations.
Almost all developed countries have fairly aggressive zero-emission vehicles targets for 2030 -2040. Shockingly, some of these targets could actually be met (government targets have a tendency to be missed)! Recent data has shown that the adoption of electric vehicles has been much faster than the projections made a few years ago and the trend seems to be accelerating. According to the International Energy Agency, the number of new electric cars sold worldwide has risen from just 200 000 in 2013 to 10.5 million in 2022. In terms of market share, 13% of new cars sold worldwide are EVs (in Norway it is 79%, China 27%, Europe 21% and USA 7%).
Looking at these numbers, we could conclude that we are well on our way to meeting the 2030 target of 60% of new cars sold being electric and that we should move on to a more difficult challenge. Hold your horses! As Stanley Druckenmiller once said, “trends work until they don’t”. We will soon be running out of rich Norwegians willing to go electric. When we get to the middle-class Indian farmer, living hundreds of kilometers from a reliably-functioning EV charging station, we might have a harder time to convince him of buying an EV over a conventional ICE car.
In this week’s note, we tackle the automotive transition dichotomy between developed and emerging markets and propose an investment thesis that is currently overshadowed by the EV hype: being bullish on catalytic converters!
As mentioned above and shown in the table below, most developed countries have aggressive zero-emission vehicle targets, but targets are weaker in some of the biggest emerging countries.
Another important factor to consider when looking at the rate of penetration of electric vehicles is the accessibility to EV charging stations and access to reliable electricity to power them. According to the Indian government, there are only 934 charging stations in the entire country – about the same numbers you can find in Oslo! Also, according to the Energy for Growth Hub, about 3.5 billion people, or about 45% of the world’s population, live without reliable power.
The utopia whereby in 2030 everyone drives an EV while drinking their oat milk latte is a very Western-centric vision. In reality, millions of new cars with internal combustion engines (ICE) will continue to be sold in countries with an increasingly large middle-class population that dreams to buy what is often viewed as a symbol of freedom and economic success: a car.
The demographic and economic cleavages between EMs and DMs are such that the vast majority of the growth in new car sales will be coming from EMs for the foreseeable future. Considering that, as discussed above, EMs will be neither here nor there in terms of EV sales by 2030, we can expect close to 100 million new conventional Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) cars to be built and sold worldwide by the end of the decade.
The good news is that while EV sales in EMs will likely remain low (except in China), most EMs are getting better at regulating the tailpipe emissions that are causing so much pollution and health problems around the world. Take India for instance. The Bharat Stage (BS) emission standards have been in place since 2000. The country has since moved from the initial BS-I standard to the current BS-VI standard adopted in 2020, which is equivalent to the Euro 6 standard used in Europe. The BS-VI standard mandates a reduction in sulfur content in fuels from 50 parts per million (ppm) to 10 ppm, and a reduction in nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions from diesel cars by 70% and from petrol cars by 25%. India is also in the process of implementing the Bharat Stage-VII (BS-VII) standards, which will come into effect in April 2025 and will be even stricter than the current standards. A similar regulatory process is happening in Brazil, with the PROCONVE (Programa de Controle de Poluição do Ar por Veículos Automotores).
These stricter emission controls for the automotive sector in EMs will act as a massive tailwind for catalytic converters (and their components). Catalytic converters are devices that are installed in the exhaust system of cars to reduce emissions of harmful gases. The converter contains a honeycomb-like structure coated with a catalyst such as platinum, palladium or rhodium. As exhaust gases pass through the converter, they come into contact with the catalyst, which triggers a chemical reaction that breaks down the toxic pollutants. The stricter the tailpipe pollution controls are, the more platinum, palladium and rhodium a catalytic converter needs.
There are two main strategies to benefit from the tailwind in tailpipe emission controls. First is to look at the main catalytic converter manufacturers. There are no real pure plays in the publicly traded markets but three companies are perceived as the leaders in this space (Umicore [UMI BB], BASF SE [BAS GY] and Johnson Matthey Plc [JMAT LN]), each of them deriving about 30% of their revenues from manufacturing catalytic converters.
As manufacturers, their costs exploded when commodity prices went up beginning at the end of 2021, so these companies have not been an attractive investment in the last few years. They are also exposed to a number of other markets beyond catalytic converters so it’s difficult to determine how that segment fared relative to the other sources of revenues of these companies. Of the three companies mentioned, Umicore and Johnson Matthey have the best sustainability-adjusted upside in our view due to their contribution to the transition to a circular economy (they are both heavily involved in the recycling of transition metals – see “Transition Metals: Wicked Problem, Smart Solutions”, October 14, 2021). Investors should avoid BASF due to their role in the genetically modified seed cartel alongside Corteva, Bayer, and ChemChina (see our note “Agriculture’s Addiction Problem: Pursuing a High(er Crop Yield)”, September 22, 2022).
The other way to ride the catalytic converter wave is to go straight at the source: by investing in companies involved in mining the platinum, palladium and rhodium necessary to build these magical devices (Impala Platinum [IMP SJ], Royal Bafokeng Platinum [RBP SJ], Anglo American Platinum [AMS SJ] and Sibanye Stillwater [SSW SJ]).
These companies, all listed on the Johannesburg stock exchange, derive the majority of their revenues from the mining and processing of the three metals of interest. They have had quite a ride, and are all getting close, or even have surpassed, their historical peak. The latter occurred days after the invasion of Ukraine when Russian company Norilsk Nickel, one of the major miners of these metals worldwide, was barred from trading internationally. Despite the phenomenal performance of these stocks, their valuation remains very palatable.
From a sustainability perspective, mining companies are known to have all kinds of ESG problems but almost surprisingly, these companies all fared very well in our analysis, opening the door for sustainability-minded investors to consider them as impactful investment opportunities.
Use of synthetic fertilizers is yet another wicked problem facing society (see also “Transition Metals: Wicked Problem, Smart Solutions”, October 14, 2021). Renowned for facilitating higher yields on less land, the use of synthetic fertilizer also has devastating effects on the environment and the Earth’s natural nitrogen cycle. This is a challenging landscape for sustainable investors looking to support solutions to food security. To help investors navigate this industry, this note discusses the role of fertilizers in food production and its associated challenges followed by a review of the best opportunities for a positive impact.
Apply More Fertilizer to Feed the World
As the global population marches toward its expected 10.4 billion peak in the 2080’s, food production will need to be scaled accordingly. Fertilizer’s role in crop production is to provide the nutrients necessary for plant health. These nutrients (nitrogen, potassium and phosphorous) are naturally occurring and can be found in healthy soil or from sources like manure, but they are absorbed more efficiently from the application of synthetic fertilizers. This efficiency also serves to limit the land area used for cultivating crops. In the face of growing demand for fertilizer, the early 1900s saw the creation of the Haber-Bosch process which enabled mass production of synthetic nitrogen fertilizers; an agriculture productivity boom that supported the rapid global population growth of the last century. It is estimated that up to 50% of crop yields come from the use of synthetic nitrogen fertilizers. Accordingly, synthetic fertilizer is fundamental to sustaining the global population and access to it has important implications for food security. Also of note, is that there appears to be little productivity improvement in fertilizers; since 1990, the amount of fertilizers consumed per person (see chart below) has remained stable. The implication is that as the global population continues to grow, it will require a proportionate increase in kilos of fertilizer. This has important consequences for planet Earth.
Apply Less Fertilizer to Save the Planet
Though this abundance of fertilizer improved quality of life for many historically, it has resulted in negative environmental outcomes. For one, it is a GHG intensive process; fertilizer production accounts for about 2% of GHG emissions and much like the use of other agri-chemicals (see note “Agriculture’s Addiction Problem”, September 29, 2022), over-application of fertilizer is having harmful effects on biodiversity. This overuse is especially harmful to waterways. As excess nutrients leach off fields into the water supply, they cause disproportionate algae growth creating dead zones. Furthermore, fertilizer is the subject of one of the breached planetary boundaries: biogeochemical cycles; this breach indicates that human activity has become the dominant force affecting the Earth’s nitrogen and phosphorous cycles. This poses a crucial conundrum: feed the people, or preserve the planet? Given the need for food production to keep pace with population growth, a transition to more sustainable solutions is urgently needed.
Adopt a Fertilizer Transition Plan
In addition to environmental issues, recent geopolitical events have countries reassessing their relationships with synthetic fertilizers. Natural gas is a key input in the production of nitrogen fertilizers, and the resultant price volatility of fertilizer over the past two years has been challenging for farmers. Prices first rose in 2021 with the economic recovery from COVID. The subsequent 2022 price hike following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine even led some fertilizer companies to halt production during 2022 as it was no longer cost-effective.
Restricted supply was not only due to higher energy prices. Chinese policymakers implemented an export ban on fertilizers in 2021, prioritizing access for its farmers. Sanctions on Belarus have limited access to Potash fertilizer and although Russian fertilizer was exempt from sanctions in the name of food security, many are reluctant to purchase from the country. These geopolitical events have added to price volatility as fertilizers are sourced from a limited set of countries that includes China, Belarus and Russia among top suppliers.
In the face of rising prices in 2021, Sri Lanka placed a ban on imports of synthetic fertilizers and pesticides. Unfortunately, rather than serve as a model for success, this decision showed just how much our food systems depend on these inputs and the necessity of a transition period. The sudden halt in the use of synthetic fertilizers led to a 20% decline in rice yields and 18% in tea yields, two important crops for Sri Lanka’s economy. Though the ban was reversed within a year, it was enough to contribute to runaway inflation rates and an economic crisis that culminated with the President’s resignation.
Strategies undertaken by the U.S. and Europe, take a slow but firm approach. The U.S. has made $500 million in grants available through its Fertilizer Production Expansion Program. The program seeks to expand domestic fertilizer production to reduce reliance on foreign suppliers, prioritizing alternatives that are more sustainable. The European commission is also tackling fertilizer challenges by encouraging green fertilizers (produced from clean energy), and sustainable agriculture methods (including precision farming) on top of an existing goal of organic farming on 25% of agricultural land under organic farming by 2030 - part of its Farm to Fork strategy.
Invest in the Future of Fertilizer
We see investing in fertilizer companies as a transition solution. For the time being, synthetic fertilizer will remain a considerable input to the global food system as it is a key input in maintaining sufficient food supply. Over the longer term, as countries focus on limiting environmental impacts and seek to reduce their dependence on volatile agricultural inputs, the role of synthetic fertilizers will become less significant. This has two implications for investors: 1) choosing companies with best-in-class environmental standards will help to limit effects of this otherwise regrettable necessity. Additionally, the companies operating in countries subject to higher environmental standards will also see their market share increase as they fill export gaps left by sanctioned countries and China’s export ban. North American producers also benefit from greater stability in natural gas prices. 2) Companies with diversified revenues will be best positioned to weather the transition away from synthetic fertilizers.
We find four suitable companies for these criteria: CF Industries, Nutrien, Sociedad Quimica Y Minera de Chile (SQM) and Yara. Each of these has an overall ESG rank above the 80th percentile in CSRHub, but of these four, Yara and Nutrien are the environmental leaders. Both have initiatives aligned with best environmental practices, strong disclosure on material topics and each has limited water withdrawal (~2%) from high stress areas. Nutrien is a significant supplier of the world’s Potash fertilizer and the company’s nitrogen production capacities are concentrated in North and South America, areas which have greater independence for natural gas supplies. The same goes for CF Industries with over 90% of their nitrogen production capacity in North America.
Looking for diversified revenues, SQM is a company with transition experience. Aside from fertilizers, SQM draws 32% of its revenues from lithium manufacturing, a metal used for batteries which are key to the energy transition. Yara is expanding its organic fertilizer offerings with a goal of $1.5 billion in revenue from this segment in 2022 (~10% of 2021 revenue values) and the company also sells precision agriculture tools, two products that are key in the next phase of agriculture production. Yara is also a leader in clean ammonia for use as a fuel selling 4.1 million tons in 2021; Nutrien (1 million ton capacity) and CF Industries also have ambitions in this space.
In 2022, each of these companies’ stock price outperformed the MSCI global equity benchmark, and we anticipate similar performance this year as farmers will once again rely more on the West for their supply of fertilizer.
For all investors, staying on top of the regulatory framework, best practices and political landscape is necessary to generate positive returns. But for investors focused on sustainability, the challenge is even greater; definitions and approaches to sustainability investing in many jurisdictions remain nebulous.
In Today’s note, we address our readers’ top questions regarding the regulatory and political landscape, to clarify and anticipate how the sustainability rules of the game may affect participants.
Question 1: Let’s start in Europe. What is going on with SFDRs? Why are so many funds being downgraded from Article 9 to Article 8?
There has been a lot of media attention about recent downgrades of European funds from “Article 9 to Article 8”. Recall that under European financial regulation, all investment funds must now be classified as either Article 6, 8 or 9; the higher the number, the more sustainable: for example, an Article 8 fund is defined as promoting environmental or social characteristics (light green funds) while an Article 9 must have a sustainable investment objective (dark green funds).
Asset managers have been required to classify their funds since March 2021, but earlier this month, tighter compliance around the classification has been applied. In anticipation of this, many asset managers downgraded their funds from Article 9 to Article 8 late last year; under the realization that their funds would not qualify for Article 9.
To be sure, this is causing frustration among investors who believed they were purchasing an investment product with a particular goal in mind. It could also shake the credibility of Europe’s approach to sustainability via the SFDR.
However, recent data suggests the opposite. Despite these high-profile downgrades, there is heightened demand for the greenest of investment products: according to Morningstar data, while non-sustainable (Article 6) funds saw marked outflows in the latter part of 2022, there were net inflows into Article 9 funds as well as far less outflows from Article 8 funds. This underscores that there is a strong and growing market for high-grade sustainable investment products.
In our view, the downgrading of certain funds suggests that EU taxonomy is “working”; asset managers believe the consequences from mislabelling their products are high enough that they are taking corrective action.
Question 2: What does all this mean for the next leg of EU disclosure rules, is “social” still on the table?
At the outset, the European commission had set a goal of sustainability taxonomy and disclosures for both environmental and social issues. The goal of the social taxonomy is to classify economic activities that contribute to the EU’s social goals and provide guidelines for investors, businesses and regulators. In early 2002, a social taxonomy proposal was published by the EU, but since then, work has stalled. Unlike for the environmental taxonomy, there is no formal timeline set out for social taxonomy and according to some sources, there is little likelihood of progress until 2024 or beyond.
Question 3: What about in the U.S.? It seems like there are forever delays in improving financial disclosure around climate.
There are two positive developments in the U.S. that we view of interest for investors concerned with climate change risks and opportunities.
First, the U.S. SEC is getting closer to instituting a new rule will require audited emissions data to be included in corporate financial reports. After a notable rise in greenwashing lawsuits (see chart below), the SEC plans to enact the new regulation before May 2023. Companies will need to describe in their annual 10-Ks (i.e. detailed financial report) their strategy toward climate risk, data on Scope 1 and 2 greenhouse gas emissions and obtain independent attestation of the data.
Second, the three main U.S. banking regulators (Federal Reserve, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp) released draft guidance on how they want large U.S. banks to manage exposure to climate change; final guidance is expected later this year. In addition, beginning in 2023, the Federal Reserve, now requires the country’s six largest banks to undergo “pilot” climate scenario analysis, aimed at providing clarity on how lenders are thinking about climate risks.
Together, the SEC proposal and the monitoring of systemically important banks regarding climate change will help investors have a clearer view of the risks and opportunities in their portfolio.
Question 4: What about other countries? Is there anything we need to know?
Investors in the U.K. have also started grappling with new regulation in regard to sustainability. The U.K.’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has issued its proposal for sustainability disclosure requirements (SDRs), which is largely the U.K. equivalent of Europe’s SFDRs. The consultation period ends this week and according to the preliminary timeline, the final rules will be published this June and enforced starting in June 2024.
The main difference between the EU’s SFDR and the U.K.’s SDR proposal is that the latter is a labelling regime, not a disclosure regime. If products do not meet the qualifying criteria under the FCA's proposals, they will not be able to use any of the regulator's sustainable investment labels, which are: “sustainable focus”, “sustainable transitioning” and “sustainable impact”. The flow chart below highlights how the UK labels correspond to the EU’s Articles 6, 8 and 9.

Ultimately, we continue to believe that disclosure and regulation around labelling will help investors and market participants avoid greenwashing. The main challenge is for investors and industry participants that sell products in multiple markets: complying to multiple national frameworks is complex and burdensome. There are various initiatives at work to harmonize various standards, such as the Global Reporting Initiative and International Sustainability Standards Board collaboration, but it is unlikely that concrete steps will be taken in 2023.
Question 5: What about voluntary carbon offsets? Isn’t it high time these are standardized and regulated?
Voluntary carbon offset programs have been around for close to twenty years but have recently grown exponentially, given the number of institutions that will need to use offsets to reach their net zero goals.
The voluntary offset market includes a wide range of programs, entities, standards, and protocols. However, the lack of standardized quality criteria, has generated plenty of concern that voluntary offsets are, at best, unproductive and at worst, fraudulent. A case in points: a recent article in The Guardian uncovered that Verra, one of the most commonly used carbon offset providers in the world uses projects whereby more than 90% of their rainforest offset credits are likely to be “phantom credits” and do not represent genuine carbon reductions.
Clearly, efforts to regulate the voluntary offset market have been wholly insufficient so far, but there are two international groups trying to address the issue by establishing new guardrails for offsets. The Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market (ICVCM) and the Voluntary Carbon Markets Integrity Initiative (VCMI) — were created in 2021, and include representatives from governments, businesses, non-profits, etc. ICVCM focuses on the characteristics that would render a particular carbon offset project legitimate, while VCMI is attempting to establish how companies should be permitted to use offsets. The supposition is that once international guidelines are in place, offsets that adhere to the guidelines will be more credible and therefore help institutions make better quality offset choices. ICVCM’s current plan is to release a first set of requirements in March.
Question 6: What else is on your radar?
We expect that the top two issues that could change the investment landscape specific to sustainability are the political sentiment surrounding ESG in the U.S. and the “climate incentive war” between the U.S. and Europe. We view both as positive developments for sustainability.
As is now well known, in 2022, “ESG” backlash resulted in some U.S. states enacting legislation preventing them from contracting with banks and asset managers with ESG policies, removed state funding from these firms, or reinvested state pension policies. But as Larry Fink (CEO, Blackrock) adroitly pointed out, the $4B withdrawn by Republican states was more than offset by $230B in US inflows last year. This underscores the notion that the global demand for sustainability investment products is growing much faster than the support for Republican “anti-ESG” ideas.
Nonetheless, Republicans are continuing their work from last year, and Republican state-attorneys general have begun 2023 by accusing ISS and Glass Lewis – the two companies that control about 97% of the market share for voting advice – of running afoul of laws and contractual obligations for state investments by prioritizing environmental and social concerns. Our base case is that these actions coming from Republican states will have little consequence over the next two years, i.e. while Joe Biden remains U.S. president, but this could change thereafter. We view all of this media attention as positive and contributing toward the legitimization of sustainability as a conventional and worthy investment approach.
A second issue is the current green stimulus battle between the U.S. and Europe, which could end up as the most beneficial “trade war” of our lifetime!
The U.S. Inflation Reduction Act, which includes significant tax breaks and subsidies amounting to a boost for US production of electric vehicles, solar panels, batteries, etc. has been widely lauded as a significant win for slowing climate change. However, the EU regards these subsidies as contrary to fair competition.
European policymakers, it appears, will be forced to initiate their own subsidy packages for climate investment to level the playing field. Europe’s response could take shape as early as next month at the extraordinary summit of the leaders of the EU (where the main topics will be migration and the EU’s global competitiveness).
All in all, the major likely developments in 2023 are pointing in the same direction: increasing legitimacy and clarity around sustainability investing.
The approximately 400 private planes landing in Davos for the World Economic Forum this week led us to reflect on how the richest have the potential to change from being the greatest climate change offenders to being leaders (as previously mentioned in a note from summer 2022: Lifestyles of the Rich and the Famous and the future of Global Warming, July 7, 2022). Moreover with the luxury hype surrounding China’s reopening, we thought it would be appropriate to cover the luxury goods sector this week. Companies in this space produce high-end products sold at a premium price and generally claim to be sustainable. Do not be fooled, these companies have great marketing machines, as the following chart of Louis Vuitton’s marketing expenses since 2010, shows.
The main factor that makes luxury goods unsustainable is the focus on consumerism. Luxury companies create obsolescence for profits by releasing new products and collections. This contributes to a culture of excess and waste, as people feel pressure to keep up and purchase new products to maintain their status. Depletion of natural resources from the rising demand of materials leads to negative environmental and social impacts. For example, many luxury goods are made from materials such as leather and exotic skins that are resource-intensive to produce and contribute to environmental degradation. Additionally, the manufacturing process for luxury goods generates significant waste and carbon emissions. Overall, while luxury goods companies may produce high-quality products and support the creative craftsmanship of artisans, they are not sustainable due to their resource-intensive production processes, consumerism, excess packaging, and high price point.
Luxury companies charge premium prices due to the perception of exclusivity and prestige associated with their brands. These companies rely on strong marketing and advertising strategies to create brand loyalty resulting in a loyal customer base that is willing to pay higher prices for the luxury goods and services that they offer. It is important to stay ahead of trends and understand customer preferences to remain competitive in the luxury market. To protect luxury company profits, high-quality products and services must be offered along with strong brand image to ensure repeat customers. Companies recently realized that sustainability is taking precedence in the customer’s mind as an attractive feature. To that end, we can see that ESG scores for most luxury companies are very high, as the table below shows. Similar to tobacco companies, luxury companies with huge profit margins and large marketing budgets are putting all the right policies in place to appeal to sustainable consumers. For example, there are only twelve firms that have received AAA from CDP for climate, water and forests. Philip Morris is one ; Firmenich, a private fragrance and taste company Beiersdorf, a closely held skin care company and Louis Vuitton, which we analyze in this note are three others in the luxury space.
It is great that these companies have policies and practices in place to optimize their operations from a sustainability standpoint. The problem is their product and the overconsumption and excess packaging it comes with.
To illustrate, according to Eikon, the 17 companies listed in the table above have a policy on resource reduction in production (including reduction in the use of water and energy, and raw materials) but less than half have any associated reduction targets. Reporting from luxury companies can sometimes be misleading. For example, Kering states in its latest sustainability report that it “sourced in the most responsible and sustainable manner”. This leaves a lot of room for interpretation!
Luxury companies have done so well since the Global Financial Crisis (2007-2008) that many investors believe that they are immune to risk because the rich are not affected by inflation as much as others. The two charts below highlight the historical performance of luxury compared to the market. The first chart starts with the launch of the S&P Global Luxury Index in 2005 and compares it to a global index. The second chart illustrates the behavior of a subset of French luxury brands compared to the French index during the dot-com era which was prior to the existence of the luxury index. As we can see in both charts, when the overall market falls, luxury tends to fall more. One fundamental justification for this behavior is that when wealth suffers from falling asset prices, even the rich are worried and become thrifty and those that pretended to be rich, prefer to eat.
In the current market environment of higher interest rates, we expect excess spending to be further curtailed from the negative wealth effect - investors have not only lost on their equity portfolio, but their fixed-income portfolio has also suffered in 2022 and private assets are likely to follow suit in 2023. Moreover, we anticipate labor shortages to be part of the economic equation for the next decade as baby boomers retire and are replaced with a smaller generation Z. After a very long period where capital has been handsomely rewarded compared to labor, we believe that inequalities will decline naturally as workers get a bigger slice of the pie. This should lead to less demand for luxury as profits (which is the major source of wealth for the well-to-do) decline as a percentage of the economy.
When we examine the specific financial characteristics of our luxury company subset, as shown in the tables below, we see that these companies are highly sensitive to market movements, have good margins and decent growth but trade at very high valuation.
In this first table we see that most luxury companies have a Beta greater than 1.
This second table shows their high profitability (over 10% net margin, for most) and decent growth which was very strong last year compared to previous years that were affected by the pandemic.
The final table highlights the high valuation of luxury companies (many have a forward P/E over 20), especially when one accounts for the rise in interest rates. There are a few companies with leverage issues (like Nordstrom), but it is not a major problem for the segment as a whole.
If our 2022 investment outlook note could be reduced to one investment adage – “power of diversification” – then SMS’ outlook theme for 2023 takes a page from Warren Buffett and focuses on “knowing the difference between price and value”. We believe that the bear market in stocks that got underway in 2022 is not yet over, but that 2023 will nonetheless offer opportunity for bargains in high-quality sustainable companies that are positioned for a low-carbon, high-care economy.
From a macro perspective, we expect there will be less surprises about inflation in 2023 (trending lower, but still above 2%) but ongoing uncertainty about the timing of recession. The chart below shows the evolution of our expectations about different macro investment scenarios; we expect recessionary conditions to linger for most of the year leading broad equity indices to trend lower until there is early evidence of a positive inflection point in the economic cycle. Equity markets have priced in the higher interest rate environment but not the fall in profitability. For now, a soft landing with no recession seems to be priced in markets.
Against this backdrop, and with our approach to investing that is focused on finding tradeable sustainability themes and the best companies that embody them, it is no surprise that we enter the year with a defensive tilt that offers downside protection. As the second half of the bear market unfolds, we will intensify our focus to find beaten-down names that offer superior value. A catalyst for the latter will be once forward earnings expectations turn firmly negative, which should serve as a sign that investor sentiment reflects economic reality.
We therefore kick off 2023 with a list of our high conviction investment ideas, with an eye on value: In the very short term, we look to protect capital in defensive areas of the stock market until a recession is well advanced. Looking further out into 2023, we expect conditions to be in place to be able to shift capital to select higher beta companies once the Fed reaches the end of its tightening campaign.
Idea #1: Long Energy Efficiency
Within the energy sector, we expect energy efficiency plays to outperform in 2023. Oil prices will be volatile, while companies involved in renewable energy production are often growth-oriented and highly sensitive to the interest rate backdrop, which we expect will continue to be a headwind for now. In contrast, many energy efficiency companies, e.g. companies that manufacture and/or provide solutions such as heat pumps, HVACs, and smart metering, tend to have low P/Es and trade as value stocks.
Energy efficiency is one of only a few areas that are well-supported by fiscal policy in 2023. According to the IEA, over half of OECD countries have generous subsidies for heat pumps and other energy-conserving products, with the RePower EU plan among the most ambitious; the EU must double the current roll-out rate in the next five years if its heat pump targets are to be achieved. In the U.S., the Inflation Reduction Act also provides significant support for heat pumps, offering subsidies up to $14, 000 per household.
The following companies have strong sustainability characteristics on an operational basis (i.e. ESG), provide excellent energy efficiency solutions, and are in good financial health: Carrier, Johnson Controls, Nibe, and Trane Technologies.
Idea #2 An ESG Comeback: Short Greenwashers
Events in 2022 sparked a necessary shakeout for “ESG” and responsible investment. Although recent focus has been on the asset management industry, these debates have been helpful at shining a spotlight on all false claims whether they be at the investment or corporate level.
Companies that embellish their sustainability credentials risk being punished in this environment, since reputational risk affects stock price performance.
We suggest two trades for 2023, based on the concept of “go long sustainability” and “short greenwashing”. Incidentally, in both cases, our short candidates are not only viewed as potential sustainability fraudsters, but their dubious use of financial engineering is also a major investment risk:
- Short Enviva/Long Svenska Cellulosa: The world’s largest producer of wood pellets, which are considered a renewable energy source, is Enviva. But Enviva is also the producer most shrouded in controversy. As early as 2013, a report was delivered to the SEC regarding omissions and misrepresentations by Enviva; the company has been regularly cited since for giving false information about greenhouse gas emissions in this industry. There is currently a class action lawsuit against Enviva for making materially false and misleading statements regarding the company's business, operations, and compliance policies. According to the suit, Enviva has misrepresented the environmental sustainability of its wood pellet production and procurement and has also overstated the true measure of cash flow generated (the company has not had a positive net income over the past 3 years and has been issuing more debt and selling shares to support increases in their dividend payment).
On the opposite end of the spectrum, Svenska Cellulosa merits its reputation as one of the most sustainably managed forest companies in Europe. As an integrated industrial business, they aim to maximize the possible value in the forest and from the forest; wood pellets are a by-product from production of other wood products, helping the company achieve a recycled waste-total waste ratio of 96% (!) and underscoring the company’s effectiveness at maximizing the value of the entire forest.
- Short Credit Acceptance Corp: a self-described socially responsible company, Credit Acceptance Corp claims to help indebted individuals purchase automobiles by offering loans to consumers with “Bad & No Credit”. SMS and the U.S Financial Protection Bureau see things differently. The latter (along with the New York Attorney General) recently announced a lawsuit against Credit Acceptance Corp for predatory lending practices- practices that ultimately yielded profits for the company. We first mentioned Credit Acceptance Corp in our “The Greed Without the Green” Note (October 6, 2022) questioning the conduct of consumer finance companies and spotting an opportunity to short in the context of rising interest rates. As we anticipate this economic context to carry over to 2023, more defaults should be expected; the January lawsuit announcement may be just the beginning of bad news for CACC. In addition, the company has used virtually all cashflow from the past three years for the repurchase of shares at inflated prices (2-year average weighted price 30% higher than current market prices). This is destroying shareholder value, rather than adding to it.
Idea #3: Switch from Illiquid Alternatives to Liquid Alternatives
Money poured into the illiquid alternative space over the past decade. However, investors should never forget that liquidity has a price and you pay for it with a premium over publicly traded investments.
While the rise in interest rates last year created havoc in bonds and public equities, many illiquid alternative funds (PE, real estate, infrastructure, etc.) actually reported gains for the year, despite many of the underlying assets being highly interest rate sensitive. The best example is private real estate funds compared to publicly traded real estate investment trusts: both essentially hold the same assets, yet private real estate funds were up 5-10% while real estate investment trusts were down 20-25%. Unless bonds and stocks recover quickly, this is an unsustainable practice: smoothing out returns and locking in clients by limiting redemptions is a recipe for disaster.
We look at private assets under one of our investable sustainability themes: Building Better Markets. The opacity of private asset investment vehicles and, in many cases, the way they have been sold to investors is a dangerous practice.
We believe poor returns are in store for private investments since these products will need to be marked down over the next three years to progressively absorb the new valuation reality. If it is possible to redeem, investors would be better served by 3-year certificate of deposits yielding close to 5% or liquid alternatives like hedge funds that are marked to market, have attractive investment opportunities in a changing investment landscape and can benefit from a higher volatility regime that is likely to persist for the next 3 years.
Idea #4: Build Back Better With Industrial Automation
In the latter half of 2023, if recession risks wain and signs of a new bull market appear, we will advocate for beginning to reallocate to growth opportunities, starting with the industrial sector. Especially in the U.S., bipartisan support for recapturing manufacturing prowess will provide a favorable backdrop for upgrades to existing factories and the construction of new ones. Given the combination of reshoring and a structural labor shortage, we anticipate a boon in industrial automation. The benefits of automation include improved resource efficiency (optimized water, waste and energy management) and better safety. Two names on our radar are: Rockwell Automation and Emerson Electric.
Rockwell is the largest pure play in industrial automation and is also recognized as a leader in sustainability (CSRHub overall rank of 94 and listed on Barron’s 100 Most Sustainable Companies). In 2021, Rockwell’s energy efficiency related products were responsible for over one quarter of revenues. Emerson Electric also counts energy efficiency among its solutions. The company serves industries (such as energy, life sciences and food and beverage) that are key to a low-carbon, high-care economy and is diversified across both automation and commercial HVAC solutions. We find this especially beneficial from an investment perspective, given that the company is the intersection between two highly investable 2023 themes: energy efficiency (see idea #1) and automation. Though currently expensive, investors should look for buying opportunities later in the year.
Idea #5: Opportunities in EM
Similar to Idea #4, we expect that later in 2023, there will be scope for a change in leadership between EM and DM. Historically, the U.S. business cycle leads the rest of the world by about six months, since U.S. consumption is a major source of demand for much of the world's export.
It is therefore premature to expect emerging markets stock outperformance in the near term. We have articulated in prior research why we are hesitant investors in China (for example, please see Chinese Capitalism’s Long March, September 29, 2021; we continue to believe that the country is extremely challenging for international investors that focus on sustainability, given an unpredictable regulatory backdrop and overall opacity in the country. That said, many emerging markets – as well as the companies that make up their stock markets – have historically healthy debt profiles and excellent growth prospects, yet are still trading at crisis-level valuations. Some tailwinds that may develop in 2023 include manufacturing revivals in some markets from “China plus one” strategies related to supply chains, exposure to the commodity cycle, as well as favorable political cycles in some pockets. Opportunities in EM for sustainability-minded investors are a key topic that we intend to explore further in 2023, stay tuned.
Idea #6: Structural Long in Transition Metals
Long-time readers of our work will note that we have been recommending positions in transition metals for quite some time and believe that an overweight allocation to these metals will be profitable on a structural basis. To be sure, higher metal prices are incongruent with our forecast for recession and we would not be surprised to see prices soften in the short-to-intermediate term. However, the long-term outlook for transition materials and metals is extremely bullish. Our preferred investments focus on sustainable miners and high-tech recyclers such as Umicore and Boliden. We believe that resource scarcity, the regulatory backdrop, as well as national energy and security policies of various nations will largely benefit these companies.
2022 was a challenging year for investors in general, and for sustainability-minded investors in particular.
First, an unprecedented war following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine jolted global energy markets – especially oil, gas and coal sectors – which are often excluded from sustainability-themed strategies given their direct connection to fossil fuels. Second, a war of ideas broke out, affecting sustainable investors as U.S. politics hit the “ESG fan”, forcing the investment industry to “choose camps”. Furthermore, European financial regulators prompted several asset managers to “rebrand” their strategies in an effort to quell greenwashing. With all of this, one could conclude that sustainable investing is going through some sort of a midlife crisis. Finally, Central Banks’ lateness in recognizing the “inflation issue” provoked an abrupt turnaround in markets in mid-2022 (see our note “Beware Drunken Sailors, the Tide is Turning”, January 20th), which further crushed ESG investment strategies which are typically long Tech and short Energy. In this context, the outperformance of the global Energy sector combined with the rout in Tech stocks formed a “perfect storm” for many ESG investors.
Despite this adverse environment, SMS researchers have several investable themes to draw from and continued to produce investment ideas to 1) provoke real word change through financial markets solutions and 2) generate value for their stakeholders by moving capital away from destructive themes and companies and into more constructive ones.
Though SMS lagged in recognizing the turnaround in oil prices, we were able to benefit from rising commodity prices under our transition materials subtheme and identify opportunities that would benefit from the new macro backdrop. To this end, our top-down, macro/sustainability theme-based research process managed to yield quite a few long/short investment ideas which, on an average basis since our notes were published, returned -1.5%, compared to -20% for the S&P 500 (our sister company Nordis Capital L/S Global equity strategy returned about +3% YTD in USD). In all, our governance theme “Building Better Markets” was the top-performing theme as it included some recommendations to short tech and crypto-based business models – mostly on governance grounds. Conversely, our “Supply Chains” theme was the worst performing one as we suggested short-selling dollar-store business models which had a strong exposure to supply chain bottlenecks. In retrospect, these companies actually profited from the rising cost of living during the year and the valuation followed suit.

With this in mind, today’s note looks at some of our big investment calls of 2022 (see our note “Investment Trends in 2022: Don’t Put Your ESG All in One Basket” January 12th for our initial calls) and explores what we got right and wrong during the year.
Idea #1: Transition Metals: Long Recyclers and Strong ESG-minded Miners
Elevated commodity prices – those of transition metals in particular – amid a shortage of chips and battery materials led us to favor companies with the ability to “mine” those metals in the most sustainable fashion, i.e. from recycled sources (to the extent possible). To this end, we wrote a note (see “Circular Economy When Going Around in Circles is the Right Thing to Do”, April 14th) suggesting long opportunities in companies that are active in the circular economy theme. To this end, our circular economy theme has performed “on par” with the market so far this year.
Idea #2: A Mighty Link in the Supply Chain: Long distribution warehouses
We were bullish on logistics at the outset of the year in the context of still-present shortages, reshoring and growing political tensions around the world - and now de-globalization. That being said, our Supply Chains theme under performed the S&P 500 and even the overall REIT sector these past few months. In fact, this sector even suffered a “double blow” from rising rates (especially REITs) and cyclical recessionary headwinds, which made it one of our worst investment calls of the year.
Idea #3: Seeing the Forest and the Trees
Given the mostly defensive nature of our 2022 calls, it is not surprising to see that we were bullish on forestry and timber companies under our “Natural Capital” theme. This has proven quite valid given the outperformance of the sector these past few months - even if lumber prices currently are pricing in a recession after being jolted during the pandemic months.
Idea #4: Emerging Asset Class and Diversifier: Long Carbon
One interesting turnaround this year can be found in the price of carbon. While we were initially bullish on the carbon market in the EU in particular - which was one of our best-performing investment ideas of the past two years - we turned bearish following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the resulting burst in EU energy prices. We perceived risk that these higher energy prices could in fact provoke a recession in Europe, and with it the fall in carbon prices.
Moreover, we had originally thought that EU authorities would relax some of the constraints in the domestic carbon trading market – such as temporarily increasing emission allowances for 2022 and 2023 in industries covered under the EU Emission Trading Scheme (ETS). Not only were we wrong on this aspect, but we also underestimated the impact that the restarting of coal reactors could have on the demand for carbon emissions. This helps explain the resilience and as well as recent increase in prices of carbon allowances in the EU market.
Idea #5: Spotting Charlatans
We were short Tech for most of the year on governance and macro grounds under our “Building Better Markets” theme. Now that the crypto world faces its first “reckoning moment” with the indictment of SBF, we expect more news of this kind to surface in the coming months and also that companies like MicroStrategy – which part of the business model is a levered play over cryptos - to commence their own “race to zero”. META, another favorite short of the team throughout the year, continued its downfall with dubious data practices and anti-trust enquiries out of Europe. Another team favorite in the shorts department was Robin Hood, a business model which is currently suffering from the current “trust crisis” in the market coming from the demise of crypto and meme stock trading. Finally, we continue to anticipate that companies with poor governance structures such as Softbank - and which took undue risks on tech/crypto plays during the past year - will suffer from the current “return to sanity” of investors.
Following up on our quest for defensive companies in anticipation of an economic recession, this week’s note expands on previous notes on defensive sectors. Over the past few months, we have written on healthcare (“High Impact: Surviving a Recession with Care”, June 02, 2022), and utilities (“Improving Utility with Water and Power”, October 20, 2022). This time, we focus on grocery stores. Demand for consumer staples generally remains stable during recessions, as people continue to buy food, household goods and hygiene products. Consumer staples have outperformed the reference index in all recessions since 2000. This story holds so far this year, as the performance of consumer staples remained positive while the rest of the market fell.
In an environment of rising inflation, grocery stores, as a subset of consumer staples, benefit from a simple thesis: people tend to stay home and cook instead of going to restaurants when prices increase (backed by the fact that inflation for food away from home has been higher than inflation for food at home in the U.S. over the past twelve months). As a non-discretionary budget item, food spending is far more stable than other parts of consumer budgets. Budget constraints can be due either to a surge in inflation or from a weakening economy (i.e. recessions). After 40 years of declining inflation, on average, and particularly, the past two decades of inflation mostly under 2% in developed economies, the recent eruption in inflation has been an adjustment for consumers in most income brackets. Although prices have risen across most categories, grocery prices have skyrocketed, and consumers are trying to find ways to eat without jeopardizing their finances. Supply chain issues, tough weather conditions and the higher cost of fertilizers from the war in Ukraine have all contributed to food price increases. In many countries, like Canada, controversies are developing around egregious profits from grocery stores.
The chart below shows the price evolution of important grocery items over the past year in Canada. These increases are similar in many countries.
“Greedflation” is a new word to reflect taking advantage of inflation to raise prices. Grocery stores are facing increased scrutiny with regards to this. For example, a recent survey showed that more than half of Canadians say they can't keep up with the rising cost of living, and 78% blame grocers for soaring food prices. At the same time, large corporations are reporting record earnings, Loblaw's first-quarter profits this year were up nearly 40% from last year, which adds fuel to the fire: Are grocery stores greedy? To answer the question, we looked at the 2022 quarterly profit margins of 20 of the largest grocery chains worldwide to see if companies increased their margins to generate those higher profits.
We looked at the profit margins of the following companies:
The charts below show that margins have decreased over the past decade and remained steady throughout 2022, refuting the price gouging theory.
Given the above analysis on profit margins, it seems clear that the rise in profits is due to the volume of groceries sold, i.e. greater demand for groceries both during COVID when consumers were constrained from eating elsewhere and more recently, by generalized inflation that is curbing discretionary spending budgets.
We expect that high inflation will persist for several more months. In this context, the outlook for defensive companies with pricing power will stay positive. To untangle the best sustainable companies to invest in the sector, we looked at their relevant sustainability practices and financial outlook of prospect companies.
We used the SASB materiality index for food retailers & distributors to find the most material sustainability topics for the sector, which include energy management, food waste management, product health & nutrition and labor practices. We examined several indicators to assess the sustainable performance of the companies and highlighted those with best practices in the table below:
Next, we analyzed the financial characteristics of grocers:
The eight grocery stores listed above pass our sustainability test as well as offers investors positive financial features, in particular attractive valuations.