In the last couple of months, insurance behemoths Allstate, State Farm and AIG all announced they would no longer write new homeowners’ insurance policies in California. All three cited the rising risk of wildfires as the main reason for their decision. These announcements followed other statements from private insurers that have almost completely withdrawn from parts of Florida – where storm coverage is becoming increasingly difficult to find – and other environmental-disaster-prone areas such as Louisiana and Kentucky where flood insurance has also recently been removed. As an industry that doesn’t like surprises, the insurance sector looks to be rapidly approaching a pivotal realization that climate risks are financial risks.

Though increased news coverage sometimes gives the false impression that something is happening more often than it is in reality (a phenomenon called the illusory truth effect, exemplified in the perception that crime levels are on the rise when they actually are not), in this instance, you would be right to believe that climate-related natural catastrophes are truly happening more frequently. Unfortunately, they are not only growing in frequency, but also in intensity. According to the World Meteorological Organization (WMO), the number of 1 in 100 years occurrences has increased five-fold over the past 50 years, which aligns with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)’s data specific to the USA.

As mentioned in our June 15, 2023, note “Macro Meets Sustainability: Outlook for Q3 and Beyond”, climate adaptation is climate mitigation’s poor little brother, as 93% of total climate funding going towards reducing greenhouse gas emissions instead of building resilient infrastructure.

But this unbalance is unsustainable. A study by McKinsey found that even if the global temperature warms only by 1.5°C by 2030 – which is an increasingly elusive target as we drag our feet when it comes to concrete actions – almost half of the world's population will still be exposed to climate hazards, such as heat stress, drought and floods. Most reasonable observers would then conclude that we should probably accelerate the pace of adaptation investments instead of praying to the hydrogen God to save us, or even crazier, to seriously consider geoengineering techniques such as stratospheric aerosol injection to reflect the sun rays (currently proposed for discussion by the European Commission!)

Historically, it has been very hard to find relevant publicly listed companies in the adaptation space as most of the capital was flowing between government departments, multilateral development banks, municipal governments, academics, and NGOs.

As projects became more sophisticated and larger in scale, some businesses developed an expertise in adaptation-related fields. So, while mainstream investors are still stuck in the carbon mitigation tunnel, sustainability-minded investors should be looking for opportunities beyond mitigation as the inevitable tailwinds that should benefit climate adaptation solutions are not yet priced in our opinion.

Although climate adaptation opportunities cut across industries such as resilient agriculture, irrigation, and water management –covered by other investment themes in our proprietary SMS sustainable thematic mapping – we will focus on three subsectors for the purpose of this note: insurance, advanced data, and resilient infrastructure.

In a 2019 note (“Some Unreassuring Thoughts”, June 20, 2019), we discussed the fact that at some point, insurance companies that fail to account for increased climate physical risks in their policies would eventually pay the price. This situation is unfolding now. According to a January 2023 report by the Swiss Re Institute, the global cost of climate-related insurance claims has increased by more than 50% in the last five years. The report also found that the number of climate-related insurance claims has increased by 30% in the same period. The three major companies who pulled out from the California market were clearly ill-prepared for this situation and have paid the price of increased claims. Other insurance companies have seen these climate risks coming and have built-in new risk models in the insurance policies. For instance, Markel Group (MKL US) acquired Nephila Holdings in 2018. Over the years, Nephila developed a strong expertise in natural disaster risk and has launched a number of innovative products to help manage their exposure to these risks (catastrophe bonds, insurance-linked securities, weather derivatives, etc.). These cutting-edge products have generated a new revenue stream for Markel, which helped them outperforming their peers.

One way insurance companies, as well as other industries, can better prepare for the physical climate risks coming their way is by modeling these impacts. An entire industry of data providers and data analytics companies is starting to emerge, and their future looks bright as the insurance and risk management industry will (eventually) embrace AI and other advanced data analysis techniques. For instance, Verisk Analytics (VRSK US) offers data, statistical and actuarial services to the insurance industry, with an increased focused on natural disasters. They have an entire unit (Verisk Climate Division) focused on providing their clients tools such as wildfire or flood risk analyses. Same with Willis Tower Watson (WTW US) which also serves the insurance industry with risk management consulting services, including through their Climate and Resilience Hub which grew to more than 130 climate risk professionals. Other data companies such as Fugro NV, Hexagon AB and Vaisala Oyj are also well positioned to benefit from the climate adaptation tailwinds as they provide data and technology that can help insurers assess and manage climate-related risks.

These companies have generally performed well over the past couple of years, with valuations (price to earnings ratio) hovering from a relatively cheap 10.8x for Fugro NV and 14.9x for Willis Tower Watson, to a more expensive 37.4x for Verisk Analytics.

Adapting to climate change also means building more resilient infrastructure. A few companies have shown leadership in this domain and are worth looking into for a sustainability-minded investor. First is Arcadis NV (ARCAD NA). Being based in the Netherlands with its low-lying geography and extensive coastlines, Arcadis has developed an expertise in water management infrastructure, and has now become a leader in the field of climate adaptation engineering. Most of what they do falls in the adaptation category: designing and constructing flood defenses, developing water management plans, assessing the vulnerability of infrastructure to climate change, and providing training and education on climate adaptation. NV5 Global (NVEE US) is another engineering firm with a growing portfolio of climate adaptation solutions for their clients. Software company Bentley Systems (BSY US) provides products and services that help engineers, architects, and other professionals design, build, and operate infrastructure that is more resilient to the impacts of climate change. Some of their most recent projects include working with the US Army Corps of Engineers to design and construct a new levee system to protect the city of New Orleans from flooding, and working with the State of Florida to manage and operate the state's stormwater management system. Finally, Great Lakes Dredge & Dock Corp (GLDD US) provides dredging services, which are used to maintain and improve waterways. As climate change causes sea levels to rise and storms to become more severe, the demand for dredging services is likely to increase.

While these company examples show how broad climate change adaptation as a theme is, what they all have in common is the potential to greatly benefit from the wall of money that is about to flood – pun intended – the adaptation-related industries.

Since our last quarterly macro meets sustainability update – published March 15, 2023 – financial risks have significantly diminished. Less than three months ago, the fall of SVB bank triggered a mini-banking crisis, but since then, U.S. and global bank CDS spreads have collapsed, the VIX is below 15, and the NASDAQ index has rallied significantly. Crisis averted – at least for now.

Although the likelihood of a banking crisis is now severely diminished, the outlook for risky assets remains gloomy in our view.

To be sure, the AI fuelled rally in tech stocks may have some juice left, but the threat of further central bank hawkishness means that the risk/reward trade-off of betting on further gains is deteriorating. After all, the policy hikes last week and accompanying hawkish tone were enough to send a negative jolt to global interest rate sensitive stocks.

In the U.S. and elsewhere, we expect upcoming inflation prints to be relatively benign, given year-over-year comparisons with last year’s May and June surging inflation rates. However, this will not be enough to end the Fed hiking campaign; inflation is still outside of acceptable range for policymakers with core CPI still above the overnight rate.

Meanwhile, although consumers in most advanced economies are still spending, thanks both to lingering savings built up during the pandemic as well as ongoing tightness in the job market, industrial activity is less buoyant. Manufacturing surveys in the U.S. and elsewhere show that current levels of pessimism typically coincided with economy-wide recession. We expect that consumers will also become increasingly downbeat as higher interest rates and tighter lending conditions begin to bite more substantially. With this backdrop, we continue to advise investors to overweight high impact, defensive sectors like health care and grocery stores. Despite a manufacturing slowdown, there remain select opportunities in industrial stocks that are best positioned for the energy transition and ongoing fiscal stimulus. Indeed, the chart below highlights that constructors of manufacturing facilities are already enjoying a massive boom thanks to the Inflation Reduction Act.

Finally, we reiterate our bullish conviction toward sustainability plays in Japan.

Macro Is Supporting Innately Sustainable Japan

Japanese stocks have been among the best performing risk assets year to date, a trend that we believe can continue in the months ahead. Weakness in the Japanese yen (which is typically bullish for Japanese equities) is unlikely to reverse anytime soon, given that the Bank of Japan appears in no rush to join its peers and tighten monetary policy. Furthermore, an important tailwind is coming from foreign investors who have recently increased allocations to this country, attracted by relatively cheap equity valuations.

As we highlighted in a recent note (“Sustainability Is Big in Japan”, December 1, 2022), Japanese companies are often highly aligned with sustainability principles, given cultural and geographic characteristics of the country. Indeed, within the Sustainable Market Strategies investment universe, Japanese companies have, on average, higher sustainability rankings than the rest of our universe. Among the companies that we believe will perform well based on the macro and sustainability backdrop are: Asahi Holdings, Denso, Kubota, Kurita, Marubeni and Oji Holdings.

H1 Climate Disasters Bring Adaptation Into Focus

Beyond the monetary and growth conditions highlighted above, a second major sustainability trend that should not catch any investor off-guard is the proliferation of climate disasters this year. The number of costly and frequent climate disasters has been rising for the past decade, and 2023 will not be an exception to this trend.

Some climate disasters are direct forces of nature, while others are clear, direct acts by humans.

War is never good for environmental health and the ongoing Russian invasion of Ukraine is no exception. Last week’s Nova Kakhovka dam burst is being considered “ecocide” by environmentalists and politicians alike. At least 150 tons of oil has been taken by the current to the Black Sea so far and unpredictable amounts of chemicals, fertilizers and oil products that were stored in the flooded areas will end up in the rivers and sea.

Meanwhile, Quebec wildfires made headlines last week, not in small part because winds blew smoke and particles to the south, briefly New York City one of the worst air quality scores in the world. The delocalization of the inhabitants of several towns has (finally) sparked a larger conversation about the necessity to fund climate adaptation. Our expectation is that as more and more climate disasters occur, there will be increasing realization of the need to invest in our ability to adapt to be resilient to climate change. Of course, adaptation will not be uniform and will range from building flood defences, setting up early warning systems for cyclones, switching to drought-resistant crops, and so on.

There is room for the private sector to provide adaptation solutions (this will be the subject of an upcoming research note) but much of the funding and programs associated with climate adaptation will need to come from the public sector. This is because the benefits of climate adaptation infrastructure are often difficult to quantify and monetize in a way that creates the cash flows required for the private sector to invest.

So far, most experts agree that adaptation is massively underfunded. For example, in a recent report from the UN, Adaptation Gap Report 2022, it was estimated that worldwide annual adaptation needs will be between $160 billion to $340 billion by the end of the decade, and up to $565 billion by 2050.

As SMS readers know, one of our major structural investment theses is that fiscal policy will become an ever-greater force in financial markets and the economy at large. This is because monetary policy is a less effective tool in solving the major environmental and social challenges of our time. Financing climate adaptation will, on the margin, put extra pressure on government budgets.

Pollution and : Unveiling the Dynamic Duo’s Destructive Alliance

In recent years, the global community has rightfully placed immense focus on mitigating the impacts of climate change, recognizing the urgent need for collective action. However, amidst this vital effort, another pressing environmental challenge has often been relegated to the background: air pollution. While climate change is undeniably crucial, it is essential to acknowledge that it is just one component of a broader set of planetary boundaries, which include other key environmental challenges such as the biosphere integrity, freshwater use, and atmospheric aerosol pollution. In fact, we were reminded just this week that scientists now estimate that seven out of the eight quantifiable planetary boundaries have already been surpassed by humans, according to an update published in Nature (only stratospheric ozone depletion is under control).

Air pollution is a multifaceted problem that poses severe risks to human health, ecosystems, and the global economy. The adverse impacts of polluted air on respiratory and cardiovascular health are well-documented, contributing to increased mortality rates and a significant burden on healthcare systems. Additionally, air pollution’s destructive influence on ecosystems, including crop yields and biodiversity, further jeopardizes our planet’s delicate balance.

To make matters worse, global warming can exacerbate certain forms of pollution through feedback loops. For example, as temperatures rise, air pollution can intensify due to the increased formation of ground-level ozone, a harmful pollutant. Industrial processes, deforestation, agricultural practices, and the burning of fossil fuels release significant amounts of methane and nitrous oxide into the atmosphere, trapping heat and leading to a rise in global temperatures.

In order to foster a sustainable future, investors and policymakers must broaden their scope to include air pollution as a priority. By doing so, we not only fulfill our moral duty to safeguard the planet but also capitalize on the compelling business case presented by the increasing demand for air pollution solutions worldwide.

In this week’s note, we will focus our analysis on pollution from methane, nitrous oxide, sulfur dioxide, and volatile organic compounds, all of which are affecting the ability of the planet to rehabilitate naturally. Building upon our previous discussions regarding the planetary boundaries, most recently explored in “Hold Your Nose – A Sustainable Investor’s Guide to Fertilizers” on March 2, 2023, we now delve deeper into the pollution control for these specific compounds.

 

The Pollution Puzzle: Identifying the Sources

The table below neatly condenses the main sources of pollution and highlights the need for transversal regulation.

 

 

Pollution Patrol: Unveiling the Rules for a Cleaner Future

Taking an optimistic view on the power of regulation and innovation; we believe in the Porter Hypothesis where strict environmental regulations can trigger/instigate efficiency gains and encourage innovations that improve competitiveness. Our optimism is fueled by two major historical successes: elimination of acid rain and the halt of ozone depletion. In the 1980’s, acid rain in North America was a major issue and the environment movement won the acid rain fight. In 2000, the ozone hole reached its peak but the Earth’s ozone layer is on track to recover following the Montreal Protocol. Those two success stories give us hope that smart regulation brings focus, investments and innovation.

In the past decade, the world has witnessed a remarkable surge in the implementation of air pollution regulations, reflecting the growing recognition of the urgent need to address this critical issue. The table presented herein encapsulates the culmination of these endeavors, illustrating a comprehensive overview of air pollution policies worldwide.

The increase in regulatory measures targeting air pollution signifies a profound shift in public perception and understanding of the detrimental consequences associated with poor air quality. Recognizing the far-reaching implications on human health, ecosystems, and climate change, policymakers have taken proactive steps to prioritize this challenge.

As policies set the stage for environmental change, it is through innovative solutions offered by companies that the tangible implementation and transformation of these policies into practical measures happens.

 

From Problem to Solution: Companies Leading Against Pollution

Fortunately, there are several companies spearheading the battle against pollution; we explore their innovative solutions for effective air pollution control.

 

The anticipated surge in demand for batteries is garnering a lot of attention. China has managed to carve out a dominant position all along the battery supply chain (see also A Matter of National Security, November 3, 2022). With ambitious targets for EV adoption and as home to some of the world’s largest automakers, the U.S. and Europe are in a scramble to secure their battery supply chain. This geopolitically charged backdrop is difficult to navigate for investors as it is hard to know whether supportive policy will one day materialize into fruitful domestic production. In this note, we assess investment opportunities in three segments relating to the battery industry: materials mining, recycling, and production.

The Miners

Lithium-ion is the dominant battery type, accounting for 85% of battery capacity sold in 2021. These batteries are characterized by a cathode composed of slightly varying quantities of cobalt, nickel, manganese and lithium. Investing in the mining of these materials remains challenging from a sustainability perspective (see Transition Metals: Wicked Problem, Smart Solutions, October 14, 2021).

Cobalt is shrouded in human rights controversies; 70% of the cobalt produced comes from the Democratic Republic of Congo which holds a significant majority of the world’s reserves. Moreover, 41% of global cobalt mines are controlled by China. Neither of these countries has a strong track record on the environment or human rights.

Nickel and manganese are more abundantly available but, as a result, are predominantly sourced by large mining companies that also extract other resources, making them a controversial choice for sustainability-minded investors.

This leaves lithium. It should come as no surprise that China controls a significant portion of lithium mining as well (28%). However, it is Chile that holds the most lithium reserves globally and two non-Chinese miners with a focus on the energy transition mineral are already established there: Sociedad Quimica y Minera (SQM) and Albemarle (though it should be noted that China’s Tianqi Lithium Corp owns a 20% stake in SQM). As two of the biggest lithium miners, the future looked promising for Albemarle and SQM given the West’s objective of lowering reliance on China; but an announcement in April by Chilean president Gabriel Boric to nationalize lithium operations has brought the prospects for mining in Chile into question. Both Albemarle and SQM stocks slumped on the news but have rebounded since.

This could be seen as a win from an ESG perspective (part of the reasoning behind nationalization is to protect the environment and local communities), but how it will affect Chile’s competitiveness remains to be seen. If countries with good environmental and social standards, such as Australia, the U.S. and Canada, areincrease mining production in time to meet soaring battery demand, Chile will face intense competition. Investors should watch closely how nationalization proceeds in Chile and the pace of production at new geographic sites.

Lastly, miners also face the risk of disruption from alternative battery types. In 2022, rising material costs favoured lithium iron phosphate (LFP) battery chemistries, despite their weaker energy density (which translates to lower range for an EV). Moreover, with lithium being the most expensive mineral, China has recently made significant progress on lithium free chemistries such as sodium-ion. These two alternative battery types (LFP and na-ion) offer lower costs but are less efficient in terms of energy density; meaning there are still gains to be made in optimizing EV range. A breakthrough could cause a sudden drop in demand for certain battery materials.

The Recyclers

In contrast to mining, battery recycling is something sustainability-minded investors can certainly get behind. However, the risks facing this segment of the battery industry overlap with those in the mining segment, though stock prices of recycling companies like Umicore (UMI BB) and Li-cycle (LICY US) did not rally along with the 2022 boom in prices for battery materials (see chart below).

A shortage in supply would offer a huge tailwind for recycling, but there is contention on this subject. U.S. geological survey results (see table below) show the estimated amount of lithium reserves has doubled in the last decade. While the IEA projects a shortage of lithium, others like McKinsey see things differently. Cobalt is also looking more abundant than once thought. This has implications for both miners and recyclers who may have to cope with a ceiling on prices resulting from wider availability.

One thing favouring recycling in this context is the European Critical Raw Materials Act. While pressure to appropriately dispose of batteries at the end of their lifecycle will likely come from an increasingly environmentally conscious public, the Critical Raw Materials Act (which applies to battery minerals) has set a target that by 2030, a minimum of 15% of EU critical raw materials must come from domestic recycling sources. Action items include financial support and faster permit processing, but these may do little to help with the supply issue facing battery recyclers: a lack of batteries.

Even though EV sales are growing each year, it takes about seven years (and closer to ten years for more recent models) before the batteries are available for recycling. Hence, the recycling facilities in existence today are competing over battery scrap from the number of electric cars sold in 2016! With Europe speeding up permit processing and offering financial support, the result is a fragmented market where consolidation is likely. The few publicly traded companies that exist are small and face competition from conglomerates like BASF looking to enter the market. One company to watch is Umicore; an established metals recycler that is already known in the automotive industry, it is well suited for EV battery recycling. Umicore inaugurated Europe’s first battery factory last year and signed a contract with Canada to do the same, the company also entered a partnership with Volkswagen to support its battery needs.

The Producers

On the road to success, established battery makers appear to have the path of least resistance. The demand for ready-made batteries is not a question of “if”, but “when”. The threat of alternative batteries is somewhat mitigated since it is the composite materials rather than the battery structure (anode, cathode, electrolyte, and separator) that are most vulnerable to innovation, and this can be further offset by sufficient R&D. South Korean companies LG Energy Solutions, SK Innovation and Samsung SDI as well as Japan’s Panasonic could grab some of China’s market share (ruled by CATL and BYD) by benefitting from anti-China policies. South Korean companies could be further bolstered by their own government’s plans to support domestic battery makers.

Though a strong contender with 7% of global battery market share, SK Innovation still earns the majority of its revenues from fossil fuels. The more pure-play battery makers are found in LG (100% of revenues from batteries) and Samsung (87%) and come at higher valuations, FWD PE of 54 and 21 respectively. For staying on top of innovations, Samsung’s R&D investment of 5.3% of revenues is comparable to its Chinese counterparts CATL and BYD.  LG lags with R&D at 0.1% of sales though it is a recent subsidiary of the larger LG Chem, carved out in December 2020.   

With economic activity slowing down in many advanced economies amid still-rising interest rates, some EMs are showing signs of strength. This is not yet reflected in relative company-level stock performance, providing a potential opportunity for investors. In today’s note, we explore sustainable plays within EM markets.

Macro Perspective

A first consideration is that the EM economic surprises index (growth, inflation, economic activity, etc) has diverged in the past two months from that of G10 economies despite China’s underwhelming growth.

Second, with the value of USD likely reaching a peak on a trade-weighted basis, the impact of rising rates in the U.S. may now be priced into a number of EM stocks already. Risk of a U.S. recession later in the year could reverse this course but for now, we see that the path of less resistance for EM currencies is to start appreciating against the USD over the medium term.

A case in point is Airtel Africa, a mobile phone service provider and payments facilitator that operates in several African countries, which suffered a blow to its earnings FX hedging issues when they reported their 2023Q1 earnings last month. With many such companies adjusting to a weaker exchange rate against the USD, foreign investors can go bargain hunting in EMs and, potentially, frontier markets (FMs) at this juncture. Afterall, the J.P Morgan EM currency index is currently at a 4-year low, suggesting that many EM currencies could actually start rebounding in the coming months as the interest rate differential between DMs and EMs/FMs starts to decrease. In that, sustainable plays in EMs and FMs represent an interesting tactical play before EM currency appreciation against the USD starts to impact companies bottom line negatively.

Furthermore, EM companies remain about 30% cheaper on a forward P/E basis compared to their MSCI and FM companies are even cheaper than their historical discount would suggest.

Sustainable Opportunities In EM

Although the macro context is brightening for EMs and FMs, investing for sustainability remains a difficult task in those regions given 1) the scarcity of listings in general and those related to sustainability themes in particular, 2) questionable sustainability features of some FM and EM companies, especially in regard to governance and 3) underwhelming country-level regulatory frameworks.

Despite these difficulties, “Long” opportunities in SMS’ EM investment universe include companies such as Bajaj Auto and Hero Motorcorp, two transportation companies with good electrification potential with a strong exposure to India’s secular growth story which score well on SMS’ proprietary financial investment attractiveness score based on value, momentum and technical analysis (ranging from -100 to 100). Furthermore, with lumber, pulp and paper prices close to a cyclical bottom, Brazilian companies such as Suzano and Klabin – two pulp and paper companies using Brazilian eucalyptus forests in a renewable fashion - offer attractive valuation. Finally, for those willing to see through South Africa’s current macro and energy wobbles, opportunities to gain exposure to palladium producers (see our note “A Two-Speed Transition: Why it’s Time to Park the EV Frenzy in EMs”, February 16, 2023) abound in a context where demand for palladium should continue to grow at a double-digit rate in the coming decade.

Conversely, looking at SMS’ EM short side, Gaotu – an Edtech firm – fares poorly against our proprietary investment attractiveness score (ranging from -100 to 100). After all, China’s government crackdown against private education, its firm grip over curriculum and its relatively unattractive investment environment could sink firms such as Gaotu even further over the next few months. Another potential short idea includes Petrobras, for which the combination of 1) the outlook of Brazilian politics, 2) enduring poor internal governance standards and 3) oil prices increasingly vulnerable to an economic slowdown also makes it an interesting candidate on the short side.

While our names in India (Bajaj Auto and Hero Motorcorp) appear to have rebounded lately, Suzano and Klabin in Brazil look particularly attractive from a momentum perspective.

Finally, from a valuation perspective, Klabin remains attractive, and scores above its industry peers with regard to sustainability according to CSRHub’s overall percentile rankings – including on environmental grounds.

 

The world is undergoing a major transformation as the transition to a low-carbon economy gains momentum. This shift is being driven by a range of factors, from climate change and growing public awareness of its impacts, to technological advancements and shifting economic and regulatory landscapes. As the transition progresses, it is becoming increasingly clear that the energy sector will play a critical role in shaping the future of the global economy. In this note, we review the main structural growth drivers and their anticipated effects on the energy transition as an investment theme.

 

Demographic Shifts Are Reshaping the Energy Landscape

The UN projects the world population to reach 9.7 billion people by 2050. This rise in population will mostly come from the middle class, which is expected to grow by 1.7 billion to reach 5.3 billion by 2030 from 2020 levels and especially in Asia – which will represent almost 9 in 10 of the next billion middle-class consumers – (spread out between China, India, and South and Southeast Asia). As the global population continues to grow, the demand for energy is expected to surge significantly, especially since the rate of increase in energy intensity is outpacing the rate of population growth. As the chart below shows, there is a critical need for an increase in energy supply to meet rising demand.

Note that the increase in demand for energy services is largely driven by middle-income countries that are experiencing both population growth and a rise in the middle-class, which is being fueled by a fast rate of wage increase. This growing middle class tends to adopt more energy-intensive behaviors, as reflected in the graph below.

Space cooling accounts for a large share of the increase in energy demand, as it requires a significant amount of electricity. There is some irony here that need for more air conditioning will make it hotter if we fail to transition from GHG energy sources. It is projected that an additional 2,800 terawatt-hours of electricity will be needed globally by 2050 to meet this demand. If we don’t transition rapidly to clean energy production, this will create a negative feedback loop, wherein the more we rely on fossil fuels to generate energy for cooling, the more we contribute to the vicious circle we find ourselves in. Furthermore, the transport sector is also expected to more than double by 2050, propelled by the rising mobility needs in developing countries, where the transition to electric vehicles is far from guaranteed (see “A Two-Speed Transition: Why it's Time to Park the EV Frenzy in EMs”, February 16, 2023). Additionally, the trend towards urbanization, improvements in health and living conditions, and increasing life expectancy are among the many factors that have significant implications for the patterns of energy use.

 

The Rise of the Green Regulators

The scale of action required to achieve a successful energy transition should not be underestimated. It entails a comprehensive overhaul of all sectors, including energy, manufacturing, transport, infrastructure, agriculture, forestry, and land use. Governments need to increase their efforts and scale up interventions to meet the requirements for transitioning to green energy. With more than 70 countries, including major polluters such as China, the United States, and the European Union, committing to a net-zero target, there is expected to be a surge in clean energy demand. In this context, electrification and a shift away from fossil fuels are essential for achieving a net-zero emissions system. The table below illustrates how governments are taking action to promote this transition.

As previously stated ("Macro goes ESG", July 8, 2021), the realm of sustainability issues is increasingly intertwined with politics, leading governments to prioritize climate considerations in their industrial and economic policies. The key takeaway is that the regulatory backdrop around the world is now pushing in one direction: to limit higher intensity GHG emissions products. This means that, relative to previous decades, the ability to ramp up energy production to meet increased demand will be constrained.

 

Technological Solutions Exist but Costs Need to Come Down

Should population growth and energy intensity forecasts to 2050, as mentioned above, be accurate, we will require much more energy than we currently have. If we are to achieve climate goals, the need to lower the emission intensity of energy is obvious.

Solar panels and wind turbines have advanced significantly in recent years, becoming more efficient and cost-effective. The table below shows the relative cost of producing electricity from different sources as of 2021. These costs can vary depending on several factors, such as the location of the power plant, the availability of resources, and the efficiency of the technology used. The low level of GHG emissions emanating from renewable energy relative to traditional fuel sources highlights the need to produce more energy from wind, hydro, nuclear, geothermal, and solar and less energy from coal, oil, and natural gas in order to reach net zero goals.

An ongoing challenge for the energy transition is storage, especially considering the intermittent nature of wind and solar. Energy storage technologies, such as batteries and pumped hydro storage, allow excess energy to be stored and used when demand is high, ensuring a reliable and stable energy supply. The cost is still high but the prize for success in improving the efficiency and cost is also high.

Electrification is another necessary ingredient of the energy transition and one where technology will play an important role. Electricity is a highly efficient form of energy, and electrifying various systems and processes can lead to significant improvements in energy efficiency. For example, electric motors are typically more efficient than internal combustion engines, and electric heating systems can be more efficient than gas heating systems.

Smart grid technologies will be needed to optimize the distribution and management of electricity across the grid. These technologies enable better monitoring, control, and coordination of energy resources, and can help to increase the efficiency and reliability of the grid. Grid modernization technologies include sensors, communication networks, and advanced analytics that enable the grid to operate more efficiently and effectively.

While electrification offers many benefits, there are also several challenges that must be addressed to increase its adoption. Some of the main challenges include cost, resilience and grid integration.

The upfront cost of new electric vehicles, appliances, and infrastructure. The performance and cost of battery technology is a key factor in the adoption of electric vehicles and other electrified systems. While battery technology has improved significantly in recent years, further advancements will be necessary to improve the range, charging time, and durability of batteries. Electric vehicles and appliances may be more efficient and cost-effective over the long-term, but the initial investment can be a significant obstacle for many consumers and businesses.

Meanwhile, the integration of renewable energy sources like wind and solar can also present challenges for electricity grids, as these sources are intermittent and can be difficult to predict. Energy storage technologies like batteries and pumped hydro storage will be critical to balancing supply and demand on the grid.

The graph below highlights the mid-point of global investments required to achieve the energy transition. The size of the needed investments is so large that we can expect tremendous activity for the energy transition for years to come.

Tougher Relationships

Deglobalization refers to the process of reducing the interconnectedness and interdependence of economies across the world. The effects of deglobalization on the energy transition can be both positive and negative, depending on the extent of deglobalization, the policies and regulations implemented, and the availability of alternative energy sources.

On the positive side, deglobalization may lead to a reduction in global energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions, as trade and transportation activities decrease through the promotion of local production and consumption of goods and services, reduction in long-distance commuting, and energy efficiency in buildings and transportation. Additionally, deglobalization may increase the resilience of local energy systems, as countries focus on developing their own energy sources and reducing their dependence on imported fossil fuels.

However, there are also potential negative effects of deglobalization on the energy transition. Some countries may choose to prioritize their own economic interests over environmental concerns. While, global collaboration and knowledge-sharing are crucial for accelerating the development and deployment of renewable energy technologies, deglobalization may slow down the pace of innovation and limit the availability of renewable energy technologies, as countries become more isolated and less willing to share knowledge and resources.

Overall, the effect of deglobalization on the energy transition is complex and multifaceted. While it may provide some benefits in terms of reducing emissions and increasing energy resilience, it also poses significant risks to the pace and scale of the transition to a low-carbon economy.

As the graph below shows, the growth in global trade has been slowing since the Great Financial Crisis.

The Russian invasion of Ukraine and the deteriorating relationship between the United States and China are recent indications of greater geopolitical tensions that can have significant impacts on the energy transition, affecting the production, distribution, and consumption of energy resources in various ways. Geopolitical tensions can disrupt global supply chains, leading to shortages and price spikes in critical components needed for renewable energy technologies. For example, conflict or sanctions on countries that produce key minerals such as lithium and cobalt, which are essential for manufacturing batteries, can impact the availability and cost of these materials.

Geopolitical tensions can lead to an increase in fossil fuel prices due to supply disruptions and production cuts. This may incentivize a shift to renewable energy sources that are less affected by geopolitical tensions but may also slow down the transition if renewable energy prices remain higher than fossil fuel prices. Geopolitical tensions can also lead to changes in government policies and regulations, affecting the development and adoption of renewable energy technologies. For example, sanctions or trade barriers can limit the export and import of renewable energy products, while subsidies and incentives for fossil fuels can slow down the transition to renewable energy. Barriers create uncertainty and risks for investors, leading to a reduction in investment in the renewable energy sector which can slow down the pace of innovation and deployment of renewable energy technologies, critical for achieving the energy transition.

Since its launch in November, ChatGPT has become hugely popular and has already been integrated in a myriad of software by companies like Duolingo, Snapchat, Salesforce and others. It’s no wonder companies and individuals have been quick to adopt ChatGPT – for most humans, it is more than just another tool that improves productivity. In terms of raw intelligence, ChatGPT can do things that many humans can’t: AI experts estimate that ChatGPT displays an IQ of above 120, placing it among the top 10% of humans. OpenAI researchers estimate that around 80% of the U.S. workforce could have at least 10% of their work tasks affected by the introduction of large language models (like ChatGPT), while approximately 19% of workers may see at least 50% of their tasks impacted. This is quite the progress, given that less than a decade ago, researchers ranked Google’s AI IQ at 47, just shy of the average IQ (55) of a human 6-year-old.

This massive rise of machine intelligence has given way to an important debate about the ethical nature of AI and possible paths for humans once computers surpass us in both verbal and social intelligence. This is a topic that will increasingly concern investors of all stripes and one that we will tackle within a sustainability framework in a future note.

In the meantime, with labor shortages persisting in most developed countries and an ever-increasing need to make better use of physical resources, today’s note explores seventeen companies that are well positioned to leverage the progress in AI in order to address these challenges (and accelerate what is sometimes referred to as the fourth industrial revolution). The companies we’ve identified provide technological solutions that support decarbonization, optimized resource use and improved safety and they tend to serve high impact industries like energy, food and health care.

 

A. Defining a Frontier Technology Sustainability Enabler

The companies best positioned to leverage AI advances for purposeful application are those with products and services already integrating machine learning. Computer-assisted manufacturing (CAM) and computer-assisted design (CAD) are two such areas.

CAM relies on the combination of software and hardware; this includes automation, robotics and Internet of Things (IoT) devices. Each of these technologies can improve resource efficiency and worker safety. Enhanced with stronger AI, this hardware will be better able to communicate and interpret data in real time and rapidly adapt to the situation at hand having implications for reducing safety risks and the waste of resources.

CAD, on the other hand, supports effective decision-making at the design phase of a new process or new factory. Things like digital twinning software replace physical mock-ups and facilitate testing of various scenarios. As AI evolves, the capabilities of CAD will improve at assessing inputs and constraints to make relevant recommendations for optimized design.

To identify companies that we believe are frontier technology sustainability enablers, we follow three steps:

  1. We screen for companies with at least 20% of revenue from factory automation, control sensors or computer-assisted design software. To do this, we use Factset’s RBICS Industry classification and we include companies within the following RBICS sub-industry groups: Industrial Robots and Robotic Assembly Line Makers, General Factory Automation Makers, Other Automation Support Product Manufacturing, Monitoring and Control Sensor/Instrument Products, and Computer Assisted Design software.
  2. We then identify those companies that are serving high impact areas: health care, energy and food.
  3. Finally, we assess whether the companies are operational leaders in terms of ESG by observing their CSRHub ESG rankings.

The table below highlights companies with a market cap of $10 billion or greater that satisfy all three of the above criteria for “frontier technology sustainability enablers”.

 

B. Macro Considerations

Many of the companies in the above table have seen the performance of their stock prices appreciate meaningfully in the past few months. The leaders are ANSYS and Yaskawa which have returned 49.5% and 35.0% respectively over the last six months. Automation companies have faired the strongest with all but one outperforming the SP500 (6 out of 8 outperforming the Nasdaq YTD). To be sure, these companies have benefitted from positive media mentions about the recent leap forward in artificial intelligence, as described above.

Going forward, there are a number of crosscurrents for investors to consider.

The bearish news:

The bullish news:

In 1997, while sailing home to Southern California after finishing the Transpacific Yacht Race, oceanographer Charles Moore sailed into a massive swirling mass of plastic debris in the middle of the North Pacific Ocean. The discovery of the “Great Pacific Garbage Patch”, as it became known, acted as a wake-up call to the global community that our addiction to plastics and our inability to manage its disposal had to stop. Or has it?

Since the discovery of what has been called the “seventh continent”, the global production of plastics worldwide has more than doubled.

How is it possible that our collective outrage hasn’t yielded more concrete results? The problem is that we are addicted to plastics for the same reasons we must get rid of them: plastics are ultra durable (a great material characteristic, but not so great when it ends up in nature) and inexpensive to produce (which makes managing the end of its useful life more expensive than using new plastics). Moreover, plastics are super lightweight, making transportation of goods easier and less emission-intensive, and can dramatically improve food preservation, elongating shelf lives of certain foods by as much as 4.5 times. And of course, the hygienic characteristics of plastic can come in handy during a global pandemic. No wonder its use is ubiquitous and our addiction is so hard to break.

Another thing we are addicted to is making commitments without proper follow-through. Earlier this week, G7 members committed to ending plastic pollution by 2040. This commitment sets the stage for a new round of intergovernmental negotiations on the future international treaty against plastic pollution, which is scheduled for the end of May in Paris. Talk is like plastic – cheap! For those who prefer practical solutions, this note shows how investors can position themselves to tackle the plastics problem.

In short, the environmental issues linked to plastics come from three different parts of the supply chain which are also the three elements of the linear economy: Take (feedstocks) – Make (production) – Waste (disposal). An obvious part of the plastic solution is the reduction of plastic use altogether, but this is hardly investible and we know it won’t be enough to entirely eliminate the problem.

Upstream: The Feedstock Conundrum

Let’s start upstream and discuss the feedstocks necessary for making all this plastic. For approximately 70 years, plastic has been made from a range of petrochemical products that are derived from crude oil. It was an economical way to produce plastic as there was an excess of oil by-products that were well adapted for its production. Now, however, about a tenth of global oil production is attributed to the petrochemical industry, and it is projected to represent a fifth of oil production by 2050; we can hardly talk about plastics as an oil by-product anymore. Considering that the current feedstock is almost exclusively fossil fuel-based, the main issue at the upstream level is the carbon emissions released, which represent globally about 4% of all emissions.

Solving this issue requires changing the feedstock to something less emission intensive than petrochemicals. Luckily for us, plastics can be made from a variety of renewable sources, including plants, algae, and even bacteria, to create bioplastics. It can also be produced using recycled plastic as feedstock.

Bioplastics are made from organic materials rather than petrochemicals and it is the feedstock source that saw the largest relative growth since 2018 (+69%). Bioplastics CAN BE biodegradable and compostable, but this is not always the case. Currently, only about half of bioplastics are biodegradable. The rest needs to be responsibly disposed, just like all other fossil-based plastics. Also, because bioplastics predominantly use food commodities as feedstock (i.e. corn and potatoes), there is a concern that they could compete with food production and potentially drive up food prices. Fortunately, some companies are developing advanced bioplastics technologies made from algae or bacteria, which is a more sustainable avenue. For instance, Origin Materials (ORGN US), Green Earth Institute (9212 JT), Corbion (CRBN NA), and Danimer (DNMR US) are all companies that are working to develop sustainable alternatives to traditional plastics. They are all using different methods to achieve this goal, but they share the same goal of reducing the environmental impact of plastic pollution. While Origin Materials is developing a process to convert plant-based materials into high-performance plastics, Green Earth Institute is developing a process to convert agricultural waste into plastics. For their part, Corbion is developing a process to convert sugar into plastics and Danimer is developing a similar process using algae.

All of these companies are still in the early stages of development, but they have the potential to make a significant impact on the fight against plastic pollution. If they are successful, they could help reduce the amount of plastic that ends up in our oceans and landfills.

Using recycled materials to make new plastics also sounds like a good idea, but as shown in the previous table, it represents less than 10% of the plastic production feedstock and has been at that level for many years. This is in part due to the premium that producers need to pay for the recycled PET pellets. It is usually more economical for plastic manufacturers to use Virgin PET (and pay the Plastic Tax, which in the UK for instance is at £200 per tonne), rather than to pay the €700 premium for recycled pellets!

Midstream: Being the Best at Making Plastics

Having dealt with the feedstock issue, other production considerations can make a plastic manufacturer more attractive for sustainability-minded investors. Below is a table with 12 listed companies producing the most single-use plastics (SUP) along with their SBTi status and their CSRHub Environmental Scores. Only three companies have developed a credible, SBTi-aligned target: Indorama Ventures (IVL TB), LyondellBasell (LYB US), and Alpek SA de CV (ALPEKA MM). Of them, only Alpek SA de CV ‘s targets have been set and approved by the SBTi – a more rigorous process than the initial commitment that Indorama and LyondellBasell have made.

As producers of SUP, these companies can play a pivotal role in helping solve the environmental problems of plastics. Some are clearly not interested in participating in the transition, while others take the necessary step to work on a SBTi target and getting it approved, which demonstrates a certain level of commitment.

Downstream: Managing Plastic Disposal Responsibly

Recycling comes at the very end of the “R” hierarchy but it would be irresponsible to think that it is not an important part of waste management, especially for plastics. With current plastic recycling rates in the low double digits, there is a lot of room for improvement. Traditional mechanical recycling techniques are not very well adapted for the plastic industry as the contamination levels are sky high, especially in the food packaging sector.

A number of companies are developing advanced recycling techniques, such as Eastman Chemicals (EMN US), PureCycle Technologies (PCT US), and Agilyx (AGLX NO) who are all working on recycling specific types of plastic using mostly chemical recycling techniques, while Carbios (ALCRB FP) and Pyrum Innovations (PYROM NO) are working on recycling mixed plastic waste using enzymes.

Of these companies, only Eastman Chemicals has produced positive earnings and its P/E ratio hovers around 10, making it an attractive investment idea. From a technological standpoint, Agilyx offers an interesting proposition with its Advanced Recycling Technology.

With billions of tons of cargo transported around the world each year by trucks, planes, ships, and trains, freight transportation is a critical component of the global economy. While freight transportation supports economic growth and helps to improve the standard of living, it is also a big contributor to GHG emissions. The International Transport Forum (ITF) estimates that international trade-related freight transport currently accounts for around 30% of all transport-related CO2 emissions from fuel combustion, and more than 7% of global emissions. Moreover, emissions from global freight transport are expected to increase fourfold from 2010 levels, and are, at this pace, incompatible with a net-zero scenario.  

Although ships transport the majority of the world's cargo (75%), trucks and vans are responsible for emitting 65% of the freight's total emissions. This is because ships are more efficient, meaning they can carry a large amount of cargo while emitting a relatively low level of emissions. On the other hand, trucks emit more pollutants than ships when transporting the same amount of freight over the same distance. A look at the U.S. alone shows the predominance of trucks within freight transportation:

Freight movement is expected to increase by nearly 50% by 2050 in volume (compared to 2019 levels), and trucks are following the same trend line due to their cheap costs. With logistics trends such as digitization, faster innovation cycles and local production, there is an increased pressure on prices, which made trucking boom over the past years (see our note Keep on Trucking: How Driver Retention Can Reinforce Supply Chains, April 28, 2022). However, in order to reach net-zero goals, trains seem to be the best alternative option to trucks, as they emit 4 times less on average than trucks and can help avoid traffic congestion and health problems linked to pollution.

Putting Trains Back on the Right Track

Trains have the possibility to carry freight for long distances while greatly reducing CO2 emissions. In addition, clean electric rail’s energy efficiency and proven safety systems can translate into six-times lower external costs (noise, climate change, pollution, accidents) of freight rail versus road freight. However, in many developed countries, the majority of trains are still powered by diesel: as of 2019, 64% of locomotives in the U.S. freight rail fleet were powered by diesel, and this number is even at 91% in Canada. Europe is more electrified with 52% of electric freight trains. Japan is the most advanced, with 82% of electric trains in its freight rail transport.

Massive investments are therefore necessary to electrify the sector with clean energy. However, in rail, asset replacement cycles are up to 10 times longer than for roads, which naturally limits the rate of innovation uptake of companies. Government investments are critical for countries wanting their trains to compete with trucks if they want to achieve their climate goals. The table below presents the most recent programs in key countries regarding investment in rails:

These plans mostly concern passenger transportation, and the ambitious 30 by 2030 program envisioned by the European Freight Rail Association is facing a number of limitations. The growth of goods with rail affinity (like coal, metal, ores or wood) is expected to decline, compared to a strong growth of goods with low rail affinity (such as food, textile and machinery, which require shorter transport times, smaller shipment size and demand higher reliability), putting a brake on the development of freight railroads. In an effort to stay competitive, rail companies have cut costs, mostly on maintenance, safety and labour. This led to negative outcomes like the Norfolk Southern’s Train Derailment in Ohio in February 2023, shining a spotlight on the deficiencies of an often overlooked industry. 

Derailing Expectations

Numerous articles point out that the train derailment and chemical spill in Ohio was the culmination of a long trend of cost-cutting in the rail industry. Rail workers, government officials, and industry analysts have long warned that such disasters are an expected consequence.

While the number of train derailments in the U.S. has decreased over time, with over 1,000 still occurring each year as shown in the chart below, a closer examination reveals an increase in the derailment rate. This is likely due to the trend of longer and heavier trains, which have enabled railroads to reduce the number of miles travelled. As a result, even though there are fewer accidents overall, the rate of derailments has increased in five out of the last seven years when compared to the miles travelled.

Most derailments are caused by a lack of investment in tracks and human error:

The primary cause of derailment is often attributed to track issues, such as broken sections of the track that have been repeatedly pounded by passing trains due to lack of maintenance. Maintenance and inspections are critical to safe operations. The Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) regulations do require railroads to maintain track inspection records and make them available to FRA or state inspectors on request, but freight rail carriers are not required to report publicly on freight track conditions. Universal track condition reports are therefore unavailable.

Operational cost cutting also has social implications. As shown in the chart below, the rail industry has seen declining levels of employee compensation and benefits for rail workers (Norfolk Southern ranking the worst among the five), leaving employees discontented, but not without reaction.

In December 2022, President Biden signed legislation to impose a labour agreement between rail companies and workers who had been locked in a bitter dispute over paid sick leave, averting a strike that could have upended the economy just before the holiday season. In February 2023, the Union Pacific CEO announced its departure after an activist shareholder accused the company of providing the worst service among the major railroads and blaming the CEO.

Freight Rail Investing: Proceed With Caution

This is a challenging context for sustainability minded investors. In the absence of government support, there seem to be few tailwinds for increased transport by rail. In North America, where nearly all freight rail relies on diesel locomotives, the top five publicly traded railway companies (Union Pacific, Canadian Pacific, Canadian National, CSX and Norfolk Southern) have been working to improve their environmental standing; moving from around the 50th percentile closer to the 90th percentile over the past ten years. Though electrification in this region seems unlikely, there are other ways trains can reduce their emissions and environmental impact (such as the use of cleaner fuels, efficiency and energy-saving measures). We expect rail operators to invest in these environmental solutions as well as safety improvements as these elements take on increasing importance when it comes to being selected as a supply chain partner. We consider three rail equipment companies that are providers of these solutions: Alstom, Wabtec and Knorr-Bremse.

Alstom and Wabtec have similar product offerings but serve different regions; Alstom’s revenues are more concentrated in Europe (62%) and Wabtec in North America (50%). In addition to producing new locomotives, both companies contribute to the circular economy through the sale of remanufactured trains. Trains can be retrofitted to operate more efficiently, helping to lower emissions. Both companies are also looking into researching alternatives to diesel trains including battery locomotives, hydrogen and other alternative fuels (Alstom is hoping to expand in the U.S. market with these solutions). Smart digital solutions that help to optimize processes and improve safety are also on offer. In 2021, 22% of Wabtec’s revenues were from products that support environmental efficiency, an important consideration given the market it serves most. A distinguishing factor for Alstom is that it does have more passenger rail clients than Wabtec and produces more electric locomotives which is also related to the region it serves. This could be to its advantage as passenger rail appears to be a higher governmental priority.

Knorr-Bremse is a provider of smart solutions for the rail industry. These services aim to enhance safety, limit air pollutants and optimize HVAC systems among other efficiency gains. The company’s Digital Freight Train product offering supports objectives of standardizing processes across the European rail network. This is more of a supply chain optimization than emissions reducing but it will be advantageous in encouraging more freight transport by rail.

Compared to the five large publicly traded freight rail companies (Union Pacific, Canadian Pacific, Canadian National, CSX and Norfolk Southern), these three equipment companies have more attractive valuations, less debt and better growth prospects.

Water stress or scarcity occurs when demand for safe, usable water in a given area exceeds the supply. Historically, most water shortages were considered broadly as an economic scarcity: inadequate water infrastructure to meet the needs of communities.

More and more however, water scarcity is due to physical scarcity: we are consuming more water than the natural world can supply. It is predicted that by 2030, the demand for fresh water will outstrip supply. That is in less than seven years!

It is therefore appropriate that, for the first time since 1977, the UN Water Conference was held in New York last week. The aim is to raise awareness about water scarcity. The event is way overdue since it has been long known that many industrialized economies, like the U.S., under the status quo, would run low on water.

To be clear, water risks are broader than “just” water scarcity. Other threats include water contamination, plastic pollution, diversion and transfer of water, and eutrophication. All of these risks have financial implications that include reduced company revenue, increased operating costs, and an impairment to business viability.

As the table below shows, eutrophication and groundwater depletion (water scarcity) threats are deemed the most severe from an industrial/economic perspective. We have written in past notes on fertilizers’ detrimental impacts on the environment, including eutrophication. Therefore, today’s note focuses on the other most critical water risk - groundwater depletion - and on opportunities inherent in companies that are mitigating this risk.

Risky Business - Industries most at risk from water scarcity

Water, like many resources, is often taken for granted. This is in large part because in most regions, the cost of water is severely underpriced (in most countries, only the cost of service is paid, not the commodity price of water). Despite growing media attention, World Water Days are critical to raise awareness about water scarcity because most economic actors continue to underprice both water as an asset as well as the risks associated with water scarcity. The problem is perhaps even worse among investors: a 2022 report by CDP showed that water reporting is increasing (although severely lags climate change reporting) but there are still one third of listed financial institutions that are not yet assessing exposure of financial activities to water risks.

For investors, water scarcity risks run right through any diversified portfolio: virtually all S&P 500 GICS sectors have some exposure to risks associated with groundwater depletion. That said, some sectors are far more exposed to water scarcity risks than others. According to The Global Institute For Water Security, the industry that is both the biggest threat and most at risk from water scarcity is the Consumer Staples sector, including food, beverage, and livestock production. Specific industries within the Consumer Discretionary sector – apparel, textiles and luxury goods – are also major contributors and are at major risk, mostly due to thirsty cotton production, in India, Brazil, Central Asia, and parts of the U.S. The Metals and Mining industry and Oil and Gas industry, especially from hydraulic fracturing and oil sands extraction, are also causing severe groundwater depletion and pollution.

Only a handful of companies like Diageo and Nestlé, have made efforts to quantify the impact of water scarcity on their businesses.

 

 

 

Keep it Flowing - Companies providing water reuse and recycling solutions

In the face of these risks, it is imperative that companies reuse, or at the very least, recycle their water. Recycling consists of treating wastewater so it can be safely discharged back into the environment, relieving some of the strain on regional water supply. Companies can optimize their own water supply by reusing water in as many processes as possible before recycling it. Even better is water management within a closed loop system (Zero Liquid Discharge) where water is treated and reused without being discharged from the facility. Factories able to implement this will have the best chance at mitigating water scarcity issues.

The key to water recycling and reuse is water treatment. Veolia, Ecolab and Kurita Water Industries are three companies that offer water treatment solutions to industrial clients (including tools dedicated to closed-loop systems).

Veolia Water Technologies has solutions in place for major clients in several water-intensive industries: food production (Nestle), mining, automobile (General Motors) and pharmaceuticals (Pfizer). Ecolab is recognized as a sustainability leader and has a 2030 objective to contribute to the conservation of 300 billion gallons of water annually, equivalent to the drinking water needs of 1 billion people.

Both Veolia and Ecolab operate in business segments other than water. Veolia also offers waste management solutions and energy management services and Ecolab is a chemicals company with products supporting healthier food and quality hygiene. These other segments support environmental and social objectives, and we expect them to benefit from the growing focus on sustainability.

Finally, Kurita operates exclusively in the water treatment business, providing purifying chemicals and filters. Included in its offerings is a five-phase approach to Zero Liquid Discharge systems.

Xylem is another pure play in water. The company earns the majority of its revenues from water infrastructure and only about 8% from water treatment products. However, this is about to change as Xylem is in the process of acquiring Evoqua (100% of revenue from water treatment). Expansion in this segment will be complementary to the company's existing products which also support water conservation. Following announcement of the acquisition in January, Xylem’s stock price has come in, creating a potential buying opportunity.  

In the past year, Veolia, Kurita and Xylem stock prices have outperformed global equities; Ecolab’s performance was aligned. While the valuations of these companies look expensive (see chart below), we believe the growing recognition of water scarcity and the ensuing water conservation goals will provide tailwinds that outweigh expensive valuations.