More Money Going Out than Coming In

Budget deficits have been growing since the beginning of the century. An older population with large entitlements has driven to the deterioration of government finances. The chart below shows deficits as a % of GDP for G20 countries plus Singapore and Ireland (the latter two are especially relevant to the topic of corporate taxes). Out of the 22 countries, 16 experienced a deterioration (higher deficit as a % of GDP) since 2003, four have improved and two have stayed the same.

We Want More but Are Starved for Cash

Governments have spent more and taxed less - and yet opinion surveys show that respondents are not happy with the leadership of their countries. The chart below shows that on average, respondents think that their society is broken and their country is in decline, and that elites act for their own good more than for the public good. They want to increase spending on infrastructure, health care and education – all this without increasing taxes. Even Sweden, a Nordic country and often the poster child of an egalitarian approach - fares very poorly. A surprising fact is that the Sweden surveys have significantly deteriorated since the onset in 2016 whereas the average of countries has remained at about the same disgruntled level.  On the other hand, Singaporeans do not believe their country is in decline or that their society is broken. They also have a more favorable view of elites.

What Are Potential Solutions for Smaller Deficits?

Considering the high likelihood that government expenses keep on growing with a greying population, more revenues will be needed to keep the current level of services. In this context, the solution probably lies on the revenue side of the equation. The table below highlights many of the options available for government to increase their revenues. In a world of high-income inequality, we have highlighted the first row because those options seem more likely to be chosen because they disproportionately affect the rich.

Profits Rise, Workers Left Behind

The current economic landscape is marked by corporate profits reaching historical highs as a percentage of GDP. This phenomenon reflects a significant shift in the distribution of economic gains, where corporations have managed to increase efficiency, reduce costs, and leverage technology to boost profitability. However, this trend raises concerns about the broader economic implications, particularly in terms of income inequality and wage stagnation. As profits surge, workers' share of economic output has not kept pace, leading to growing disparities. This situation underscores the need for policy discussions around tax reform, corporate responsibility, and labor rights to ensure a more equitable distribution of economic prosperity.

The charts below show the effective tax rate for the largest public companies in the world from 2008 to 2023; most of the lines are downward sloping, indicating that the largest companies are paying less as a % of their profits. Reverting to the 2008 effective tax rate would bring in substantial revenue for governments and we believe they have their eye on it. Only Exxon Mobile and Costco have an effective tax rate significantly over 20%.

Maximum Profits, Minimum Taxes

To reduce their tax burden, companies are willing to use complex structures to hide their true economic reality from the taxmen. The table below highlights some of the tricks of the trade and their weird names.

Strait Success-Luck of the Irish

The economies of Ireland and Singapore have performed exceptionally well since the beginning of the century, in large part, because of their low tax regime. The chart below shows the importance of corporate taxes in Singapore and Ireland compared with the United States and a middle of the road country like Sweden. Even with a very low effective tax rate, Ireland and Singapore have a much larger contribution of corporate taxes compared to their overall taxes. It is obvious that multinational companies are moving profits to be taxed at a lower rate.

Stocks Soar, Will Taxes Roar?

The charts below highlight the stock performance of the largest corporations in the world. These companies have enjoyed amazing growth in profitability. The median performer is Eli Lilly: if you had invested 1,000$ in 2008 in its stock, it would be worth close to 20,000$ excluding the dividends you have received.

Most of these companies have been arbitraging corporate taxes on a global basis. Spanning our list of the largest companies with effective tax rates much below 15%, Apple and Alphabet have used the Double Irish with a Dutch Sandwich strategy to shift profits to Ireland, while Nvidia, Broadcom and Johnson & Johnson have also shifted some of their profits to lower tax jurisdictions. but Tesla has been less active on the tax front, benefitting from EV subsidies, instead. For companies with an effective rate closer to 20%, Microsoft, Amazon, Eli Lilly and Meta have large Irish operations.

What Comes Next?

In the first year of the Biden administration, Democrats recognized the big revenue opportunity regarding corporate taxes and the problem of tax optimization; Janet Yellen led an effort to apply a 15%  global minimum tax. However, implementation has been slow: members of the European Union are in the process of incorporating the minimum tax in their national laws, the United States are committed to the minimum tax but face ongoing legislative challenges and other countries like Australia, Canada and Japan are working on its implementation. These initiatives are moving slowly against the will of big corporate lobbies, but they are moving. Moreover, a similar initiative for billionaires is being considered.

We believe that current beneficiaries of tax management (large multinational corporations, billionaires and tax havens) will be under more scrutiny and will bear the brunt of upcoming adjustments. The timing and the specific groups targeted are somewhat unclear but the driving factors for higher corporate tax rates are all in place: income inequality is persisting or increasing, public sentiment toward the elites and governments is very poor and some politicians have espoused economic fairness and redistribution as their calling card.

With U.S. interest rates now on a downward trajectory – approximately 200 basis points of cuts are anticipated over the next 24 months – and electoral polls indicating a tight race between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris, today’s note revisits the performance of our sustainability themes during electoral periods. We also assess the economic and policy differences between the 2020 context and today and explore opportunities for re-entry into some of our favorite investment themes.

First, we examine the performance of seventeen of SMS’ sustainable investment themes three months before, and three months after the 2020 election. Recall that interest rates were near zero during this period due to COVID-19. Some themes, such as Human Capital (which includes edtech, up 68%), Tech Infrastructure, and Transition Materials (up 45%), performed exceptionally well, while others, like Alternative Energy, somewhat underperformed (up 5%) post-election – especially we consider that the S&P 500 was up by some 10 percentage points in the three months following the election. In our view, the performance of many of our themes was driven more by market momentum and close-to-zero interest rates than by any government policies discussed during the 2020 election.

As such, there was a clear rotation in and out of several sustainable investment themes following the 2020 election. This time around, investors should also be prepared for another election-based market shift – especially if we consider that market participants already penciled in a Trump victory - and discounted several sustainability plays. Now that a Harris victory is the cards, investors could re-ignite the kind of hype in themes such as renewables and energy transition we last witnessed in 2019-20.

A second consideration is to explore how the election could alter the fundamental trajectory of U.S. policymaking, which could also impact several of our investment themes. The table below outlines our expectations for what could stay the same versus what could change following the election - and identifies potential areas for surprise.

Given the table above, we suggest four sustainable investment ideas that take into account the current U.S. political and monetary backdrop: Shorting prisons, going long on carbon, engineering firms, and renewable energy.

Short Prisons

Private prisons remain a contentious theme in the U.S., with equity prices in the sector closely tracking electoral polls. While Kamala Harris would likely aim to shut down private prisons and prolong Biden’s policy on the matter, Donald Trump would probably expand their role in the U.S. carceral system. As Harris is currently leading Trump in the polls, prison stock prices have already receded. Companies such as GEO Group (GEO US) have already profited from stricter immigration control policies, including electronic surveillance through apps, which have boosted revenues for companies in the sector. One could expect such controls to be less infringing on immigrant rights should Harris win, likely capping prison stock prices.

From a valuation perspective, prison stock prices also seem stretched when considering their 12-month trailing P/E ratios – they are trading at a 50 percent premium compared to their 2020 levels. That said, as immigration remains an important electoral theme – and in a context where private prisons increasingly rely on immigration flows as a source of revenue - we recommend taking a smaller short position on this theme while continuing to monitor polls closely.

Long Carbon

One of the starkest wedge issues between Kamala Harris and Donald Trump is their stance on the environment and carbon. Kamala Harris, known for her prosecutorial background, did not hesitate to take on Big Oil and win a settlement for the people of California over environmental damage from climate-warming fossil fuel emissions. In contrast, Donald Trump advocates for minimal, if any, environmental regulations.

This divergence in views is evident in North American regulated carbon markets. December 2024 carbon futures have recently plummeted due to 1) the prospect of Trump winning the election (especially when he was leading in polls), 2) the politicization of carbon markets (the State of Washington has put the termination of its newly created carbon market on the November 5th ballot), and 3) retail investors feeling the pressure and cashing out of their positions.

That being said, current North American carbon auction pricing dynamics are approaching the government-set floor price of $24.04, which is 25% lower than the most recent auction price of $30.24. As a reminder, the floor price is set by WCI member governments to increase by 5% plus inflation every year. For an investor with a six-year time horizon, the floor price will be equivalent to the current price in 2030, even if inflation is 0% between now and then. Investors now have the chance to buy the equivalent of a convertible bond that will pay inflation between now and 2030 with a conversion price equivalent to the current price. If the price of carbon credits rises to last spring’s peak of $44, a return of almost 50% could be achieved. For public market access to this play, investors can purchase the KCCA ETF, which has dropped by about 25 percentage points since its February 2024 peak.

Furthermore, the foundations of the North American carbon market remain strong. New York State is contemplating the creation of its own market, which could potentially merge with the Western Climate Initiative, which include the main players in the market such as California and Québec. Additionally, current electricity demand trends in North America, particularly in California, suggest that the scarcity of emission rights could return soon amid a growth in production – including from non-renewable sources. This is currently our strongest conviction for a “Kamala trade.”


Long Renewable Energy

In a recent note, we recommended re-entering the renewables sector when and if interest rates began to decline (see our note “A Second Wind: What Peak Interest Rates Mean for Renewables” March 21, 2024). Now that approximately 200 basis points of rate cuts are priced in over the next 24 months, we are somewhat surprised that the sector hasn’t yet rebounded, especially in light of recent trends in energy demand in the U.S. In that, we think that the time to re-enter the renewables space is now.

While we don’t anticipate additional government funding à la Biden IRA for the sector just yet, overweighting the sector could makes sense if you think that Kamala will make it to the White House. Companies - developers and operators - that have demonstrated strong revenue growth these past years amid higher interest rates – such as Acciona and Hannon Armstrong – could strongly reprice positively in the coming months, even if they are already trading at high P/E ratios.

Long Engineering & Construction

Given that infrastructure spending is likely to persist regardless of who wins the White House, the Engineering Services sector looks promising, especially for companies with a strong presence in the United States. We place particular emphasis on those that have developed leading sustainability practices. Many of the companies listed below have integrated sustainability as a key feature of their practice, making them a natural fit for sustainability-focused portfolios as they are the builders of infrastructure of the future.

The sector has substantially outperformed the rest of the stock market since November 2020 and, to much surprise, has even proved resilient to the current higher interest rate environment. To this end, SMS’s Green Engineering Leaders Equal-Weighted Index has outperformed both the S&P and Nasdaq by nearly 100 percentage points since Biden was elected to the White House in 2020. Given both parties’ interest in improving infrastructure, we believe this trend will continue for the foreseeable future. Companies like Stantec and Arcadis stand out in this group for their sustainability features and relatively attractive valuations.

 

Macro: “A Tall Order for Restaurants”

At the start of the month, U.S. Employment data sent a shock wave through financial markets. There were fewer jobs created than was expected and the unemployment rate increased to its highest level since October 2021. And just yesterday, a significant downward revision of the number of jobs created in the 12 months leading up to March 2024 was announced. This trend does not bode well for discretionary spending like restaurants, especially when interest rates remain elevated.

Although subsequent data struck a more “goldilocks” tone, we still see reasons to believe that households will curtail spending at restaurants:

  1. Although overall inflation fell below the 3% mark for the first time in over three years, for food prices, the cost of dining out is significantly outpacing the cost of eating at home. To be sure, restaurant food inflation can be taken as a sign that restaurants have been able to pass on higher input costs to consumer. However, as the relative cost of dining out vs dining in become stretched, we expect that more consumers will turn budget-conscious and opt for eating at home.

  2. The latest retail sales may have surprised to the upside, but a closer look at spend on bar and restaurants shows that spending on food away from home is starting to plateau since its post-pandemic boom (see chart below). On a monthly basis, food services and bar sales increased 0.3% while grocery store sales rose by 1% reflecting the swap to dining in as mentioned above. These observations are especially noteworthy given that retail sales data does not adjust for inflation which remains elevated for dining out. Furthermore, sales data for other discretionary areas, like leisure and apparel, were weaker compared to the previous month.

At Sustainable Market Strategies, we are more inclined to short the restaurant industry concerns over nutritional content and quality of employment. This is fitting for the current economic backdrop. However, we also remain vigilant for potential buying opportunities if value has been created. The remainder of today’s note focuses on American publicly traded restaurant companies, as there are virtually no comparable European listed options, and companies listed in Asia are further removed from U.S. economic and consumer data.

Corporate Responsibility in Restaurants: The Long and Short of It

 The biggest issue with the restaurant industry is the poor nutritional value offered to customers. In our list of publicly traded American restaurant companies with over 1 billion USD in market cap, most fall into the fast-food category, also known as limited-service restaurants. Sure, everyone loves a treat and the convenience of take out, but the widespread availability of cheap, high calorie meals is problematic: the expansion of fast-food chains has long been associated with rising obesity.

Unfortunately, full-services restaurants, offering sit down meals served by wait staff, don’t fare much better on the nutrition front. Two studies from 2018 showed that meals at full-service restaurants often contain even more calories than the meals at fast-food chains. None of the companies in these two segments (limited and full service) stand out as having a more health-focused brand, we therefore do not consider them for long positions.

The last two decades saw the emergence of a third restaurant category: Fast casual. These restaurants offer the same quick convenience, often in a more upscale dining experience. Fast casual restaurants tend to have more limited menus with basic ingredients, benefitting from simplified supply chains. This category is where we see the greatest potential for long candidates. Not all fast casuals are created equal: some, but by no means all, emphasize healthier menus. We consider what they serve, average calorie content and branding (self-proclaimed mission or menu description). Our analysis identifies Sweetgreen, Chipotle and Cava as candidates for long positions given their lower in calorie and higher in vegetables menus.

According to the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), another material consideration for the restaurant industry is their role as employers. Restaurants are major employers in the U.S., but these jobs tend to offer low pay, few benefits and poor working conditions. None of the companies we reviewed had a CSRHub Employment Score rank within the top 20%. Though none qualify as high-quality employers, we deem companies with scores below the 40th percentile as particularly underperforming. The companies are ordered by their Employment score rank in the table below.

Finally, we assess energy, waste and water metrics (also key topics identified by SASB). The extensive number of restaurant locations makes for a significant environmental footprint. Food safety and Supply Chain Management are also flagged as key issues by SASB. Food safety is difficult to assess beyond health records and past controversies. For supply chain management, we give a leg up to the fast casual restaurants given their simplified menus. The table below presents our findings on the three categories of restaurants.

For the fast casual segment, we retain only Chipotle on the long side. Despite better nutrition in their menus, Cava Group and Sweetgreen (whose labor score is notable) do not have sufficient disclosures to retain as long opportunities. Wingstop is kept as a short candidate given its weaker labor score and lack of reporting on environmental factors. Recall that limited and full-service restaurants are only considered from the short angle given their poor nutritional value. Three shorts are identified in the full-service segment: Darden Restaurants, Texas Roadhouse and Bloomin Brands; and two in the limited-service segment: Domino’s Pizza and Krispy Kreme. These companies are identified as short candidates due to their poor labor scores and weak disclosures.

Various Business Models Drive Diverging Stock Results

Since the pandemic reopening, fast casual restaurants stock prices are the only segment that have outperformed the SP500. The performance or full-service restaurants is relatively flat and limited-service restaurants have seen price declines.

This can be attributed to the different business model characteristics of each of the restaurant segments. Fast casual and full-service restaurants have higher price points and therefore tend to have higher-income patrons that are better able to weather the rising inflation over this period. Up until 2024, the performance of these two segments was mostly aligned. But fast casual has two advantages over full service: health (higher quality menus) and convenience. Customers of these restaurants are seeking the convenience of a fast-food place but willing to pay more for a better quality or more specialized menu.

Most of the short candidates we identified have seen sales growth decline in the first half of 2024 compared to last year. Full-service restaurants have seen sales growth reduce the most (see chart below). Wingstop, in the fast casual segment, has also had waning sales growth, but still remains well above restaurants in the other categories (though this cannot be attributed to customers seeking healthier options and is likelier more the result of expansion). Domino’s is the exception, and may be explained by consumers trading down from fast casual or other more expensive pizza chains. Within the fast-food category, the last two quarters saw sales growth decline for both Starbucks (-0.6%) and Papa John’s (-1.3%) while it remained positive - around 7% - for Krispy Kreme and Domino’s.

In the limited-service (fast food) category, restaurants that are able to offer the best deals will be favored by consumers. With their higher margins, fast food giants like McDonald’s (33% net margin) and Yum! (owner of Taco Bell, KFC and Pizza Hut, net margin of 23%) will have the greatest capacity to offer discounts, cutting prices on some items while maintaining positive margins.

Still, if rates remain elevated and unemployment continues to rise, we expect a further decline across the board for restaurants. It is noteworthy that Krispy Kreme, Domino’s and Wingstop have the highest betas. Chipotle, a long candidate (though too richly valued today), also has a relatively higher beta.

In a world shrouded in uncertainty—marked by elections, climate change, and the specter of new conflicts—there is a clear consensus: deglobalization is taking hold. Consider the upcoming U.S. elections. Although Kamala Harris has yet to reveal her economic platform, her predecessor Joe Biden shared one crucial stance with Donald Trump: a focus on strengthening the national economic base, even at the expense of deepening international ties. These developments matter for all investors and in particular have ramifications for investors concerned with sustainability: moving production from jurisdictions that have varying degrees of control and/or oversight regarding environmental and social considerations will change the course of progress in these areas. In today’s note, we evaluate how strong the deglobalization trend really is and what this means for investors.

Has Deglobalization Really Increased Since COVID-19?

Global trade expanded rapidly in the 1990s and 2000s, driven by advancements in technology, China’s entrance into the World Trade Organization and the resultant rise of multinational corporations. The idea of deglobalization, however, started gaining momentum during the global financial crisis in 2008. Some governments, in an attempt to boost domestic production and employment, began prioritizing protectionist measures, imposing restrictions on the free movement of trade and investment across borders. Since then, global trade patterns have shifted. Overall, the growth of global imports as a percentage of GDP, which had steadily increased for decades, began to plateau around 2008 and has stalled ever since (see the chart below). In other words, global trade is no longer growing.  

Following the 2008 crisis, the COVID-19 pandemic served to expose weak links in global supply chains. The urgent need for critical supplies at that time, such as masks and medical equipment, revealed the risks of over-reliance on distant suppliers, particularly from China. In the U.S. and elsewhere, the episode created popular support for inward-looking policies. For example, the U.S.’ Biden administration has pushed for reshoring through initiatives like the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) and CHIPS Act.

However, true deglobalization, when trade as a share of total economic activity begins to shrink, is not yet occurring; imports as a share of GDP have stalled but are not yet falling. It is true that the underlying conditions for sustaining openness - domestic social consensus in its favor and a convergence of global monetary, legal and regulatory regimes- are becoming increasingly fragile (please see our note “Global Supply and Its Chains: From Efficient Bounty to Complex Scarcity?”, March 3, 2022). But instead of driving a decline in overall trade, dramatic shifts in trading partners (i.e. import source) are occurring. In other words, it is not the level of trade that has fallen since COVID-19, but rather who-trades-with-who that has changed.

The following chart illustrates these changes from a U.S. perspective. From 2016 to 2023, Mexico, Vietnam, and India have gained more of the U.S. import share, while China's share has dropped. Similar patterns are no doubt occurring in the euro area and elsewhere, as various government policies and incentives drive businesses to diversify their supply chains and reduce their reliance on any single nation. Importantly for investors, these shifts have the potential to create opportunities in companies that are benefiting either from a diversification of supply chains and near-shoring or greater re-shoring.

Supply Chain Diversification and Near-Shoring: Opportunities in Mexico, Vietnam and India

As the chart above highlights, Mexico, Vietnam and India have already become the benefactors of U.S. trade policy aimed at boosting supply chain resilience and reduced dependency on China:   

This year, the U.S. introduced the Biosecure Act to reduce dependency on Chinese pharmaceutical imports, and as a result, India's contract manufacturing sector is expected to double in the next three years, further solidifying its position as a key player. In terms of headwinds, safety concerns have prompted increased FDA inspections and scrutiny over the quality of India’s drug manufacturing. Ergo, investors must be vigilant about the sustainability practices when considering Indian pharmaceutical companies, as some have faced recalls and quality control issues in the past.

The following charts highlight the characteristics of select Indian pharmaceutical firms, each with the majority of their revenue derived from Europe and North America, and having no major controversies linked to their products. These companies are poised to benefit from further nearshoring trends. Of the four companies highlighted, Neuland is the most likely to benefit from the U.S. Biosecure Act due to the company’s role in supporting biotechnology and pharmaceutical companies. The stock has already enjoyed a massive recent run-up, so timing an entry will be key.

Re-shoring Winners: Select U.S. Industrials in the Pole Position

Although deglobalization so far has been mostly about shifting the country of origin of supplies rather than repatriating production, there is nonetheless some evidence that manufacturing is returning to some countries like the U.S. Sustainable Market Strategies’ readers should be familiar with the chart below that shows construction of manufacturing facilities in the U.S. is in a multi-decade breakout.

It is no surprise that the breakout in construction spending on manufacturing corresponds to a significant outperformance phase for companies that are benefiting from this demand. Indeed, the chart below shows that the SMS U.S. deglobe industrial index, when compared to the overall U.S. and global industrial indices, has outperformed. Our index is a sub-selection of U.S. industrial companies that generate most of their revenues domestically.

To be sure, industrial companies tend to be pro-cyclical plays, i.e. higher beta, outperforming when economic activity is in an upswing, and underperforming when a recession is in play. Interestingly, we can rule out choosing higher beta names as the reason for the outperformance of our U.S.equal-weighted deglobe universe: since the average beta in our index is about the same as the beta of both overall global and U.S. industrial benchmarks.

In other words, industrial companies that are most likely involved in the buildout of factories and facilities needed in reshoring are seeing their stock price react positively to deglobalization tailwinds. This is particularly reassuring given that the market consensus is now building in higher odds of a recession over the next twelve months.

Interestingly, this phenomenon – the outperformance of industrial companies most exposed to the building out of domestic manufacturing facilities – is only occurring in the U.S. We repeat the exercise for European companies and note that there is no stock price discrepancy between “deglobe exposed” and broader baskets of euro area industrial companies.

The investment community usually has strong views about its role in solving environmental and social issues. Ask any investment professional how they approach the climate crisis, and they will enthusiastically discuss their investments in renewables and other clean technology disruptive strategies. Now ask them about their strategy to address the opioid crisis. In our experience, the opioid epidemic is one of the most critical societal issues that remains largely ignored by the financial community.

Healthcare is often perceived as a straightforward sustainability or impact investment due to its inherent focus on improving lives and promoting well-being. However, the sector is not devoid of controversies and egregious behaviors that can undermine its positive impact. Our previous research on insulin prices (see Basic Instinct: The Insulin Profit Machine, September 22, 2022) highlighted significant ethical concerns, demonstrating how certain practices can lead to affordability issues and hinder access to essential medications. For investors, it is crucial to go beyond the surface and conduct thorough due diligence to identify and mitigate such risks.

In this week’s note, we will explore the financial implications of the opioid crisis affecting millions in the United States and beyond.

 

The Context of a Crisis

While the opioid crisis is a global issue, the United States is particularly affected by this epidemic.

Unfortunately, the opioid crisis in the United States continues to escalate, with the number of deaths increasing year after year. Despite ongoing efforts to combat the epidemic, the situation remains dire and shows no signs of improvement.

Opioids have been the leading cause of death for individuals aged 18 to 45 since 2019, claiming 200 American lives daily. This epidemic severely impacts the American economy, with estimates suggesting it accounts for 43% of the decline in men’s labor force participation and 25% for women. States with lower median incomes and higher unemployment rates, such as West Virginia, Kentucky, and Alabama, have the highest opioid dispensing rates, highlighting a strong link between economic despair and opioid dependency.

US politicians on both sides have shown a desire to connect more closely with rural America, so it is not surprising to see “opioid epidemic” being increasingly mentioned in their respective speeches.

In late 2022, a significant demonstration of bipartisanship occurred when congressmen from both parties approved the NOPAIN Act (Non-Opioids Prevent Addiction in the Nation Act). This legislation aims to reduce reliance on opioid prescriptions by expanding access to non-opioid pain management treatments. Starting in 2025 separate Medicare reimbursement for FDA-approved non-opioid therapies will be provided, particularly in outpatient surgical settings. This legislative effort underscores a broader recognition that addressing the opioid crisis requires comprehensive strategies, including holding various sectors accountable.

The Offenders

Although a large part of the blame must go to pharmaceutical companies that designed, manufactured, and promoted these products, other parts of the healthcare sector, such as distributors, retailers, pharmacies, and insurers, also share in the responsibility. The legal troubles for a suite of healthcare companies began a decade ago when state and municipal governments across the United States launched thousands of investigations. The specific crimes and subsequent settlement amounts varied depending on their roles in the opioid crisis.

For many, the most notorious offender in the opioid crisis is Purdue Pharma and its owners, the Sackler family. They will forever be remembered as the creators of OxyContin, a drug that was deceptively marketed as having a low risk of addiction despite its potent similarity to heroin. Purdue Pharma ultimately declared bankruptcy but initially agreed to pay $6 billion for its pivotal role in igniting the opioid epidemic. Originally, the settlement shielded the Sackler family from future civil claims though they had withdrawn billions from the company before the bankruptcy. However, in a surprising turn of events last month, the Supreme Court rejected this part of the settlement, potentially reopening the door to thousands of lawsuits against the Sackler family.

More pertinent for current equity investors is what role publicly-listed healthcare companies played and how they responded to accusations. Investors' decisions to include or exclude these companies from their portfolios will vary based on individual tolerance and justification.

The Opioid Cartel: Who is Responsible for What

For sustainability-minded investors, it is crucial to seek assurance that companies will behave differently if a similar situation arises. The opioid crisis highlighted failures across the entire healthcare supply chain:

The failures on multiple levels underscore the importance of having accountability and robust ethical practices within the healthcare industry to prevent future crises.

The "Responsible Investment Theory" suggests that companies engaged in controversial behaviors should suffer financial or reputational damage. However, with a few exceptions such as the bankruptcies of Purdue Pharma, Insys Therapeutics, and Mallinckrodt, many larger players have largely weathered the storm. Companies like Johnson & Johnson and CVS have faced the opioid settlements as one of many challenges in recent years, indicating that the impact on their financial health and reputations has been somewhat limited compared to their overall market presence and diversified operations.

Looking ahead: the investment opportunity

The upcoming implementation of the NOPAIN Act could mark a significant inflection point for investors seeking to address the opioid crisis through strategic capital allocation. By boosting non-opioid alternatives, the Act opens new investment avenues for impact-minded investors.

The investment opportunity falls into two main categories: companies providing pharmaceutical solutions to current opioid dependence, and companies developing non-opioid alternatives for pain management.

For the first category, we focus on companies offering overdose reversal medications like naloxone hydrochloride nasal sprays, and other treatments to prevent relapse in opioid-dependent patients:

In the realm of developing alternative non-opioid pain management medications, one might expect a crowded field given the significant market potential for effective pain relief that avoids addiction risks. However, pain management research is notoriously challenging and often leads to dead ends. After years of arduous clinical trials and numerous unsuccessful attempts by Big Pharma to discover new mechanisms for pain treatment, there is finally a glimmer of hope.

In late July, the FDA granted Vertex Pharmaceuticals (VRTX US) Priority Review for its New Drug Application for suzetrigine, an investigational oral non-opioid treatment for moderate to severe acute pain. The FDA’s decision is expected by January 30, 2025. If approved, suzetrigine could become the first new class of drug approved for acute pain in over 20 years! Unlike opioid-based painkillers, suzetrigine treats pain without entering the brain, thus avoiding the addiction potential that opioids present. This new class of medication will undoubtedly be more expensive than traditional opioid drugs, but the NOPAIN Act addresses this issue by providing higher reimbursement rates for non-opioid drugs.

Another company poised to benefit significantly from the implementation of the NOPAIN Act is Pacira BioSciences (PCRX US). Pacira produces EXPAREL®, a non-opioid local analgesic used for postsurgical pain management. The NOPAIN Act's reimbursement changes are expected to significantly increase the utilization of EXPAREL® in surgical settings, enhancing its market penetration and impact.

These developments underscore the recent breakthroughs creating promising opportunities in non-opioid pain management. These drugs present substantial potential for positive impacts on both public health and investment returns. Screening for valuation and market capitalization, a strategic combination of Vertex Pharmaceuticals (VRTX US), Pacira BioSciences (PCRX US), and Indivior (INDV LN) looks like an attractive investment approach to capitalize on the implementation of the NOPAIN Act in 2025.

Investing in these companies not only aligns with emerging healthcare trends but also supports the transition towards safer, non-addictive pain management solutions.

 

The Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) is a policy tool in the European Union designed to address carbon leakage – when companies relocate their production to countries with less stringent climate regulations to avoid carbon costs – and to promote carbon neutrality by imposing a carbon price on imports of certain goods from countries with less stringent climate policies.

By putting a carbon price (tax) on imports to the EU, CBAM aims to ensure a more level playing field between domestic products and imports. In addition, while not the stated goal, a carbon border adjustment tax is a sign of the times in terms of deglobalization; countries that are currently exporting emission-intensive products view CBAM as thinly veiled trade barrier and have threatened taking complaints to the WTO.

CBAM has been in a “transitional phase” since end-2023 when importers of steel & iron, aluminum, fertilizers, cement, electricity and hydrogen became required to report carbon emissions. Beginning in 2026, importers of these goods will also need to buy CBAM certificates that correspond to the number of embedded emissions in their goods at a certificate price determined by the European carbon price (i.e. the weekly auction emission trading price).

In a nutshell, the CBAM will erode any competitive advantage for companies that are not currently subject to paying a carbon price on par or above the cost of carbon in the EU.

Notably, much of the sell-side investment research published about the implications of CBAM focuses on country-level trade implications. But it is the companies that produce these goods that are directly subject to the policy, creating the potential for equity winners and losers.

In today’s note, we highlight the companies that stand to gain or lose in four of the six industries targeted by CBAM – fertilizers, cement, aluminum, and steel & iron. We exclude electricity and hydrogen because these markets are currently supplied primarily within the European market. To identify companies, we follow a simple procedure:

We discuss our findings for each of the industries below.

Cement: Largely Irrelevant for Equity Investors  

It is unlikely that CBAM will have a significant impact on competitivity of the global cement industry. Europe barely imports any cement and indeed, all over the world cement and concrete are typically manufactured locally because raw materials are available, and transportation is relatively expensive due to the low density value of cement. According to the European Cement Bureau, the value of imports of cement in 2023 was USD 443 million for the euro area, or roughly 9 million tonnes of cement. This accounts for a puny 3% of the annual cement needs in the region.

The chart below shows European imported cement by country of origin. Together, Turkey, Tunisia, Algeria, and Ukraine make up 75% of all imported cement. Investment opportunities in these countries are scarce since, in Algeria and Tunisia the major cement manufacturers are not publicly listed. In Ukraine, the major cement exporter is a subsidiary of CRH, an Irish company listed in the U.S.

Of the approximately 40 publicly traded cement companies we found, only eight report generating more than 10% of revenues in Europe. Moreover, with the exception of two, all of these companies are headquartered within the euro area or in a country that is exempt from CBAM (EEA countries and Switzerland).

Cemex (Mexico) and Nuh Cimento Sanayi AS (Turkey) are the only companies with any real exposure to the CBAM risk. Nuh Cimento Sanayi AS ranks among the very worst carbon emitters per revenue dollar, while Cemex is among the companies with the lowest emissions. The implication is that only Nuh Cimento Sanayi AS is a potential short based on the likelihood of a margin squeeze induced by CBAM.

 

Fertilizers

Contrary to cement, the EU is largely dependent on imports for most fertilizers and has traditionally sourced its mineral fertilizers from a select group of suppliers, primarily Russia, Egypt, Algeria, Morocco, and Belarus.

Looking at the ten largest publicly traded fertilizer companies, only three are located in the euro area or in countries that are excluded from CBAM. This implies that the majority of fertilizer will be newly subjected to integrating the cost of its carbon emissions into the price of production.

The table below highlights total emissions/ million USD in revenue for each company. CF Industries and SABIC are among the most carbon intensive fertilizer manufacturers and are most likely to see the greatest margin compression once CBAM is enforced.

 

 

Iron & Steel

In the iron & steel market, an examination of emissions intensity uncovers that the CBAM may create opportunities for some low-intensity steel producers outside of the euro area. In the steel industry, a major factor in emissions is the type of energy used in furnaces to make steel. Electric arc furnaces (EAFs) generate a mere fraction of the carbon emissions by traditional blast furnace steelmaking. In the U.S., the vast majority of steelmaking plants use EAFs, which explains why U.S. steelmaking companies generally have low emissions intensity versus companies elsewhere in the world. In India for example, less than 10% of plants use EAFs. Given that neither of these countries currently have nationwide carbon schemes in place, there is a significant cost advantage to U.S. producers should they desire to compete in the European market.

As it stands, many high-emitting steel companies are currently exporting to the euro area, while many lower emitting companies (using primarily electric arc furnaces) mostly serve their domestic markets and have not competed in the euro area. The steel industry is highly political and the ability to export goes far beyond the cost of carbon. That said, of all of the industries addressed by CBAM, our analysis suggests that it is the steel industry that has the greatest potential for change. Companies with low carbon intensity that have already had some success at entering the European market, such as Sims Metals, are non-EU candidates that stand to benefit from a levelling of the carbon playing field.



Aluminum

In the aluminum industry, for now CBAM only covers direct-process related emissions. However, it is the indirect emissions that account for most (80%) of total emissions in the primary aluminum process – which is mostly related to the production of electricity that is subsequently consumed in the smelting process.

In the sixth column of the table below, we show Scope 1 emissions per revenue for the major publicly traded aluminum companies.

Of the companies that have a significant share of exports to the euro area, Hindalco Industries, Alcoa and Aluminum Bahrain are the three with the higher scope 1 emissions intensity; they are at the highest risk of observing a margin squeeze when the euro area price of carbon is applied.

 

 

 

You probably remember Miss Materiality from our December 2022 note: Miss Materiality’s Night Out: A Lesson in Consumer Choice and our August 2023 note: Miss Materiality’s Summer Vacation. She is back for a third year, this time, at the grocery store. In 2022, right after the pandemic, she just wanted to go out. Last year, she wanted to get away. This year, she is concerned about meeting her basic needs because the reality of higher and more volatile food prices is becoming a greater preoccupation for her.

Miss Materiality has become more cost-conscious this year and this is translating to how she spends on food she cooks at home.

On her list, she has the basics that are difficult to replace, things like olive oil, milk and sugar. She needs protein: salmon, eggs, tofu and some meat and she cannot live without coffee, orange juice, bananas and chocolate. Recent sticker shock for some of these items leaves her curious about the evolution of prices over the past five years.

As can be seen from the graph below, the overall cost of her basic foodstuffs has increased, with olive oil leading the way higher, albeit milk has reverted to pre-pandemic price levels.

 

Researching the salient points for each food item (see table below), Miss Materiality notices a common theme: the impact of the weather. Olive oil and sugar price inflation is the result of supply disruptions from droughts.

For proteins, the trend toward higher prices has been volatile and she was happy to see recent price drops after massive run-ups in basic ingredients like eggs.

Traditional supply and demand factors have been at play in proteins; except for eggs where the H5N1 disease created a shortage in 2023 that is still not completely resolved.

 

Miss Materiality noticed large price moves for the things she loves most. The cost of cocoa is a relatively small portion of the price of chocolate bars but with cocoa price shooting up in recent years, chocolate bars have followed suit with, higher prices per gram.

From a nutrients and calorie perspective, her other favorite snack, bananas, are cheaper than other fruits and have remained so for many years. Miss Materiality was wondering why and she found that bananas are produced in many countries. India, China and Indonesia are the top 3 producers but they have large populations to feed. The top exporters are in Latin America: Ecuador, Costa Rica, Colombia and Guatemala. Other reasons for the low prices of bananas are the fact they are picked green and ripen during their transportation, the trees are perennials and there is a strong global system for bananas. In other words, diverse geographic crop location and ease of transport makes bananas one crop that is relatively insulated from many of the major threats of global food supply disruption. That’s a good thing for Miss Materiality!

Just like for the basics, Miss Materiality realized that the weather played a significant role in the prices of indulgence items. For some of her other favorites like coffee and orange juice, weather and diseases – both directly linked to climate change – are creating episodic shortages that drive prices higher.

 

These price surges underscore that concentration of production is a major consideration in food supply chains. Theoretically, food items that are produced in only a few countries are at greater risk of supply disruption from the weather, local diseases or internal politics leading to export bans. In the chart below, Miss Materiality shows the share of global production of her grocery items by the top 5 and top 10 producing countries. She posits that those with the lowest concentration have a reduced risk of supply shortages. This is consistent with preceding charts, where the price of bananas and milk are the only prices that fell during the period (both have among the lowest concentration of production). Eggs are the exception to the assertion that low concentration reduces the risk of shortages which is explained by the effects of H5N1, a global disease.

 

Since Miss Materiality is doing as much as she can to adapt to higher food prices, she wonders if her investments could compensate for those higher costs. The map below shows the publicly-listed companies with strong sustainability practices that she could potentially invest in. For salmon, Mowi has strong sustainability practices and is a relatively low-cost producer. For soybeans which get transformed into tofu, House Group Food fits the bill. Adecoagro scores highly for a sugar producer, while JDE Peets is a positive standout for coffee and tea that is on pace to have 100% of its tea and coffee certified as responsible this year. For orange juice and olive oil, she did not find interesting candidates. For cocoa and meat, she cannot find attractive long candidates; she has a negative view on Mondelez, Tyson Foods and JBS. For eggs and bananas, she found four companies: Vital Farms, Cal Maine, Dole and Fresh Del Monte.

 

From an investment perspective, we agree with Miss Materiality that it is better to own low-cost producers in a concentrated industry where one can benefit from shortages. From that standpoint, MOWI, House Food Group, JDE Peets and Adecoagro are companies that are likely to benefit should a shortage occur in a related foodstuff. The chart below shows financial ratios for the companies mentioned above, with Cal-Maine and Adecoagro having the most attractive historical financial ratios. Miss Materiality is not surprised to see a company from an emerging market country, Adecoagro, in a concentrated industry with attractive financial ratios. Emerging markets have lagged developed markets over the last 15 years.

In terms of helping farmers and finding solutions that mitigate climate change risks with the view to stabilize prices, Miss Materiality found four leading irrigation companies with the greatest irrigation revenues as shown on the map below. Irrigation is key because droughts and excess heat can ravage crops. Miss Materiality could not believe that both, Valmont Industries and Lindsay Corporation are based in the home of Warren Buffett, Omaha, Nebraska.

Companies heavily involved in irrigation have comparable financial ratios, with the exception of Orbia Advance Corporation from Mexico, another company that operates in an emerging market. Note also that Orbia has a smaller exposure to irrigation compared to other companies in the chart. Beyond irrigation, Orbia is involved in other aspects of the chemical product industries.

 

This week saw yet more bad news for proponents of the famous Hydrogen Economy. One of the Biden administration’s flagship projects to derive energy from hydrogen, the $6bn Appalachian Regional Clean Hydrogen Hub (ARCH2), is in jeopardy due to unrealistic project economics and strong community opposition, as well as another minor obstacle: fundamental physics.

The demise of a variety of hydrogen projects is becoming increasingly common. There are example in the transportation, industrial, energy, and heating sectors.

In this week’s note, let’s bust some myths around the hydrogen economy.

 

How Did We Get Here?

The Climate Crisis is often described as a wicked problem which involves numerous interconnected factors, including economic, environmental, political, and social elements, with no straightforward solutions, and each intervention often leads to unforeseen consequences and trade-offs. So when a visibly simple solution is presented, like 'transitioning to the hydrogen economy,' people want to believe it and jump on the bandwagon.

These promises are then being amplified by powerful people with large audiences: politicians and Big Oil. For both groups, the idyllic image of a hydrogen economy allows them to delay any real and difficult transition decisions. By dangling this shiny catch-all technological solution that will solve (almost) all our climate problems, they can continue their business as usual: producing fossil fuels. And they are putting their money where their mouth is: fossil fuel companies rank among the top lobbying firms for hydrogen and outnumber companies from every other industry, including the renewable energy sector!

In fact, hydrogen lobbying efforts by all industries seriously took off with the inauguration of Joe Biden in 2021, in anticipation of a massive environmental Bill which the industry hoped would include generous subsidies for several technological solutions, including hydrogen. In August 2022, that Bill took form as the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) and indeed included the largest and most generous hydrogen subsidies in the world, known as the 45V credit for hydrogen. The lobbying efforts seems to have paid off as blue hydrogen, the kind that is produced by fossil fuels assisted by some CO2 capture technology, does qualify for the tax credit.

The situation in Europe is very similar. A 2023 study by LobbyFacts showed that more than €75 million a year is spent on lobbying efforts by the EU hydrogen promoters, among which the top players are Shell, ExxonMobil, Dow, BASF, TotalEnergies, Equinor, BP and Siemens Energy.

 

“It’s physics, stupid”

The fact that Oil & Gas majors are aggressively promoting a technology does not automatically disqualify it, although it should raise flags and call for more scrutiny. The main disqualification for hydrogen is much more clear-cut: thermodynamics.

Without going into the details of hydrogen’s physical properties, there are a few killer facts that demonstrate that betting the climate farm on the hydrogen economy is a dead end.

First things first: hydrogen is not an energy source. It’s an energy vector. Since hydrogen can’t be found – in sufficient quantities – in its natural form, it needs to be extracted from compounds like water (H2O) or hydrocarbons (e.g., methane, CH4). Producing hydrogen requires energy, typically through processes like electrolysis (the green-ish way, by splitting water using electricity which itself may or may not be green) or via steam methane reforming (SMR), the gray or black way, which involves reacting methane with steam (which emits a lot of CO2 as a by-product). In this sense, hydrogen serves as a medium to store, transport, and utilize the energy that originated from those primary sources.

How efficient is this whole process? Not very, unfortunately. When considering the entire hydrogen value chain – from production to end-use – the overall efficiency, expressed as the resulting energy as a share of initial energy input, is quite low. For example, starting with electricity from a renewable source to produce hydrogen via electrolysis (70% efficiency), then compress it for storage (90% efficiency), transport it (95% efficiency), and finally use it in a fuel cell (60% efficiency), the overall efficiency would be:

0.70 (electrolysis) * 0.90 (compression) * 0.95 (transport) * 0.60 (fuel cell) = 0.36 or 36%

This means that only 36% of the original energy input is converted into usable energy at the endpoint, with 64% lost along the way! Of course, the industry would like us to believe that they can improve these efficiencies with a few additional billions in subsidies, but if there is one thing that money can’t change, it is the Second Law of Thermodynamics (i.e. energy transformations are inherently irreversible and always generate some amount of waste heat, leading to inefficiencies).

 

“Ok, so the hydrogen space is uninvestible?”-  Not so fast…

There’s physics, and then there’s politics. The reality is that there is so much public money being poured on this issue that not every project will be kiboshed. It won’t be the first time, nor the last, that governments go ahead with the most expensive option possible to accomplish something. However, our expectation is that the vast majority of the hydrogen applications that are being discussed right now will not go ahead. For example, hydrogen as a transportation solution is a hard sell, even for trucks, trains and planes (biofuels make more sense for economics and logistical reasons). What about hydrogen as a heating source? Why would we use electricity to inefficiently convert it to hydrogen to inefficiently transport it to ultimately inefficiently re-convert it to an energy source? By cutting out the molecular middleman, one saves energy and capital. Other applications like energy storage face the same inefficiencies. Furthermore, competition with other energy storage technologies is strong (batteries, pumped hydro, and compressed air energy storage (CAES) are more efficient for large-scale energy storage and have established infrastructure).

From an investment perspective, this suggests that investors should stay away from unprofitable, unproven-at-commercial-scale, single-technology-dependent, narrow-focused hydrogen companies like Plug Power (PLUG US), FuelCell (FCEL US), Ballard Power Systems (BLDP CN), NEL ASA (NEL NO), Bloom Energy (BE US), and ITM Power Systems (ITM LN). For reference, these companies lost between 55% and 92% of their market capitalisation since Joe Biden took office, promising to make the hydrogen economy a reality.

The remaining opportunity for a sustainability-minded investor to play the hydrogen theme lies in the transition from dirty to clean hydrogen production. Global hydrogen production currently stands at around 100-125 million tonnes per year, with approximately 60% used in oil refining (hydrocracking and desulfurization), 30% in ammonia production (a key ingredient in fertilizers), and about 10% in methanol production (used as a feedstock for chemicals). Presently, almost all (99%) of this hydrogen is produced from fossil fuel sources—50% from natural gas, 20% from coal, 22% from oil, and only about 1% from electrolysis powered by clean electricity.

Only a handful of companies produce the vast majority of this hydrogen. First Principles Thinking suggests that market incumbents have competitive, technological, economic, and reputational advantages over the numerous narrow-focus start-ups that must fight an uphill battle to gain any market share. This advantage is due to the incumbents' established infrastructure, experience, and resources, which position them better to transition to cleaner hydrogen production methods.

The four major incumbents are Air Liquide SA (AI FP), Air Products and Chemicals Inc (APD US), and Linde PLC (LIN US) for the industrial segment, and Yara International ASA (YAR NO) for the fertilizer segment. Any of these companies would make a justifiable investment in the greening of hydrogen production, as they all have major projects underway. Moreover, despite being at the center of the green hydrogen theme, their valuations are very reasonable, with price-to-earnings ratios between 20 and 27 for the industrial names and 12 for Yara. These investment options make more economic and scientific sense compared to the small-cap, unprofitable names mentioned above.

Heightened awareness of the environmental and social issues associated with global economic activities is driving demand for greater transparency and prompting governments to take regulatory action. Greater consumer scrutiny and a more stringent regulatory backdrop add to reputational risks that investors must consider, but also create opportunities: companies that provide the testing and certifications needed to comply with these evolving standards will benefit from increased demand. In this note, we explore investment opportunities in the testing, inspection and certification (TIC) market.

The Growing Testing, Inspection and Certification Market

Despite recent backlash on ESG, companies appear to recognize its merits. The need to comply with government regulations and meet expectations of various stakeholders (customers, board, senior management, and shareholders) were identified among the top (“very significant”) reasons for having a sustainability strategy in a recent Morgan Stanley survey where 85% of respondents see sustainability as a value creation opportunity. Both factors translate to greater demand for testing and certification. The market is expected to achieve a cumulative annual growth rate of 4.5% over the next decade.

1) Government Regulations

Over the past two decades, there has been a notable tightening of environmental policies globally (see chart below). Though data for the Environmental Policy Stringency index is only available up to 2020, the trend continues as protection of the environment protection remains a key public issue.

For example, in the U.S., the Biden Administration has sought to pass a slew of environmental policies. The EPA has published new standards addressing vehicle tail-pipe emissions, acceptable air, water and waste levels from fossil-fuel power plants, mandatory independent audits for chemical plants and utilities’ responsibility in monitoring and treating PFAs in the water supply. Efforts have been made to try and safeguard these laws from a change in administration. Though a Trump presidency creates a more challenging context for passing environmental policy, reversing pollution controls (like tracking PFAs in water) could be unpopular with the public. This suggests that more stringent standards are likely to continue as public awareness of environmental health risks grows.

Europe is recognized as the leader when it comes to environmental policy, and the EU continues to introduce new policies, most recently the ecodesign regulation that sets sustainability requirements for a broad array of goods sold in the EU.

While new, more stringent environmental regulations are found mostly in richer countries, the environmental standards in developing nations are likely to tighten as these countries attain greater economic wealth. We can see this in the progress of both China and India’s Environmental Policy Stringency numbers in the past ten years, shown in the chart. As developing countries continue to improve environmental policy, the demand for testing and certification will also increase in these regions.

 

2) Green Credibility

In addition to adhering to new laws and regulations, companies are also striving to live up to consumers’ higher standards. Environmental criteria are growing in importance in purchasing decisions. Although this trend has given rise to the issue of greenwashing - where companies make misleading claims about environmental benefits of their products with the hopes of capitalizing on demand - growing awareness is driving a push for standardized metrics and disclosures. Companies can gain credibility by providing specific environmental data points and disclosures and obtaining third-party verifications. Moreover, the pressure for companies to disclose on a growing number of data points including water usage, biodiversity impacts, worker and product safety and supply chain traceability will broaden the testing, measuring and certification needed to meet higher standards.

 

The Testing, Inspection and Certification Companies

The TIC market is involved in a wide variety of industries ranging from health care and food to mining and automotive. There are a few exceptions like Eurofins Scientific, that focus almost exclusively on bio-analytical testing. In today’s note, we focus on the companies that are most highly levered to the trends described above, i.e. increasing regulation and sustainability adherence, and that are exposed to a wide array of industries.  

The TIC market is considered to be highly fragmented, with only a few large global players competing against many highly specialized local entities. To this end, it is an industry that is ripe for M&A activity.  The large, publicly traded TIC companies tend to be long-standing, established companies with entrenched relationships. It should not be a surprise that companies operating in the quality assurance and certification space have impeccable ESG records; after all, they are paid to ensure the quality of others! All five of the names that we have identified rank above the 90th percentile for ESG practices, according to CSRHub scores. They are also all headquartered in Europe, except for ALS in Australia.

The stock prices of the five companies we analysed – Intertek, Bureau Veritas, Applus, ALS, and SGS – tend to be highly correlated and have a beta to the global equity market of well under one. This is no doubt because many of the companies derive significant revenue from the public sector and because it is difficult to reduce expenditure on testing and assurance, even during economic downturns. All of the companies’ annual reports cite the importance of the two megatrends we described above – sustainability and regulation. Note that we include Applus in our analysis in order to have a larger company sample size, despite the fact that the company will (finally) be taken private: last month Spanish regulators approved the takeover by two private equity firms, making it no longer investable for public equity participants.

The chemical industry is low on the list of what comes to mind for sustainable investors. It is generally considered to be among the largest sources of industrial greenhouse gas emissions, with steel and cement being the other major contributors. The chemical industry is complex, covering a wide variety of processes and applications that are present in nearly 95% of manufactured products. As an industry with a tight regulatory framework and large emissions, it is devoting significant efforts to reduce its carbon footprint.

The industry is divided into four major categories: commodity chemicals, fertilizers, industrial gases, and specialty chemicals. In this note, we start at the base and focus on commodity chemicals which encompass petrochemicals and inorganic commodities.

 

Chemicals Outlook

The overall outlook for the chemical industry is one that is intimately tied to the state of global manufacturing. The chart below shows that global manufacturing is starting to recover after more than a year of slow manufacturing activity.

To identify investment ideas, we focused more on the operational performance of companies than their products. The list of end-products produced from chemicals is vast, making it difficult to narrow down a company to a single product. The purpose of this note is to guide sustainability-minded investors through this sector to make more informed investment decisions mainly based on operational performance.

 

Commodity Chemicals

 Commodity chemicals remain at the bottom of the chemical product value chain. Compared to more complex sectors of the chemical industry like industrial gases and specialty gases, technical barriers to entry are low and differentiating factors are smaller.

There are two types of commodity chemicals: petrochemicals and inorganic chemicals. Polyvinyl chloride (PVC) is a combination of the two. In our search for companies, we included PVC in the petrochemical segment.

Petrochemicals are obtained through the process of refining oil, they are fossil fuel-based products.  Their most common use is as plastic in packaging and containers. Though plastic packaging can draw the ire from environmentalists, a lack of good alternatives means they do have a role to play in preserving food, among other uses (see notes A Reality Check about Plastic Fantasies, April 21, 2023 and Good Things Come in Minimal Packaging, May 16, 2024).

Inorganic commodities are co-products from the chlor-alkali process. This process is very energy-intensive, accounting for about 40 to 50% of manufacturing costs. There are two main products: chlorine and sodium hydroxide. Chlorine is a disinfectant, a solvent and is used in solar panels and PVC. Sodium hydroxide, also known as caustic soda, is a cleaning agent commonly found in soaps and detergents, used as a water treatment product and in aluminum production to break down bauxite. These products have very useful applications where alternatives are limited.

 

Commodity Chemicals Outlook

 The short-term outlook for ethylene depends on the resolution path of the current oversupply; improved demand and/or shutdown of capacity. Improved demand prospects for the Chinese economy and recent capacity reduction have resulted in a recent increase in prices.

The short-term outlook for PVC is slightly better than ethylene because oversupply is not as pronounced. Just like ethylene, the recent price increases reflect improved prospects from China.

The caustic soda market is in better balance between supply and demand. This market is not as economically sensitive as ethylene which explains the less dramatic price increases observed recently.

Just like the United States, which used to be the biggest importer of energy and is now a net exporter, China was the world's largest importer of chemicals but has now become a net exporter. The significant growth in supply from China across the chemical industry is transforming the landscape.

The price and proximity of energy determines where commodity chemicals are produced. The shale revolution and the war in Ukraine have put significant pressure on European plants. The shale revolution improved access to petroleum in the United States with very cheap prices relative to other jurisdiction for natural gas. The war in Ukraine deteriorated access to cheap Russian energy for European chemicals company. As a result, many chemical producers are curtailing their operations in Europe. Higher cost of production and lower prospects for increasing demand from Europe are the driving force behind those shutdowns.

 

Petrochemical Companies

To find the most attractive companies within ethylene and PVC from a long and short perspective, we constrained our analysis to a minimum market capitalization of 1B$ and at least 30% of revenues from plastic resins and materials manufacturing industry. We use the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) materiality framework to identify key issues such as GHG emissions, hazardous waste management, and safety & environmental stewardship of chemicals. To rank the companies within the industry we referred to their CSRhub scores for energy and climate change, and resources management and evaluated the number and importance of recent safety controversies to assess safety aspects.

The following table provides a ranking of petrochemical producers based on their percentile score in energy and climate change, resource management, and safety controversies.

Despite its top ranking, we decided to exclude Daicel Corp from long opportunities as it is also the leading Japanese producer of materials used in cigarette filters, as we try to avoid exposure to the tobacco industry.

We also excluded Alfa SAB de CV from short opportunities despite its bottom ranking because of conflicting signals: Alfa operates in the petrochemical and synthetic fibers industry (polyester, plastics, and chemicals), its petrochemical segment – Alpek - was spun off and is now a public company. Alpek has high CSRHub rankings and still represents 40% of the market capitalization of Alfa.

The two long opportunities derived from our analysis are Shin-Etsu Chemical and Covestro given their strong operational scores in high materiality elements of the business. Westlake and EMS-Chemie are short opportunities, especially given their poor operational scores, but also because of the concerns raised about Westlake's safety practices following the plant explosion at their Louisiana facility.

Inorganic Companies

To select companies in the inorganic chemical industry, we used the same methodology as for petrochemicals.

Based on our analysis, we identified 2 long opportunities, Tata Chemicals and Tokai Carbon, and 2 short opportunities, Genesis Energy and Olin Corp.

Finally, we looked at financial ratios to determine the most attractive long and short for each of petrochemicals and inorganics. From the graph below, we see that Shin-Etsu has good margins, strong growth, decent valuation and no debt whereas EMS-Chemie has similar margins with no debt but much lower growth and much higher valuation. For inorganics, Tokai Carbon has high margins, strong growth, decent valuation and no debt whereas Genesis has low margins, low growth, high valuation and a high debt load.