As the holiday season approaches, we expect a familiar topic to come up around dinner tables: the value of learning an in-demand trade as a path to a successful—and resilient—career in the decade ahead. Families who once urged the next generation to pursue a four-year degree (and maybe even learn Mandarin) in computer science may soon be encouraging something different: enroll in technical school and become an electrician, HVAC technician, or a plumber.

Why the shift? As AI and automation make knowledge and many service-sector tasks easier to access and less scarce, the economy is placing a premium on work that still has to be done by someone in the real world. For this, we urgently need more skilled tradespeople to install, maintain, and repair the physical systems that allow all these powerful tools to show up in our day-to-day workflows.

Investors are also increasingly putting a premium on the physical inputs to our automated world. Whereas in the past several decades, business strategies of developed economies have increasingly favored capital-light models – ones that prioritize intellectual assets, technology, branding, and nimble operations over the ownership of heavy physical infrastructure or large inventories – it seems that the world is going back into the heavy stuff.

This Time is Different – Investing in Hard Stuff

Key strategies underpinning capital-light models have included outsourcing with manufacturing contracts to partners, franchising, licensing, and shared platforms. As SaaS and third-party data storage displaced on-premise hardware, even IT operations trended towards asset-light models. The chart below shows the vertiginous fall of tangible assets for S&P 500 companies over the last fifty years.

The Return of Asset-Heavy Ambitions

As governments intensify their focus on building economic autonomy and national security, scarcity assets have become a central theme. This type of assets is one where goods and services tend to hold (or gain) value because they are limited in supply and hard to create. For investors, these assets, which are often physical in nature, are increasingly perceived as natural hedges against inflation. Scarcity assets can be natural resources (fertile soil, copper, etc.), critical infrastructure (ports, rail, power grids, data centres), but also regulatory-based (e.g. taxi medallions) or cultural (fine art, collectibles).

Importantly, while financial assets can be diluted through monetary expansion or leverage, scarcity assets have a relatively fixed quantity and makes them a crucial store of purchasing power across business cycles.

These also include capital-heavy industries like energy, mining, utilities, telecom, airlines, manufacturing and data-center infrastructure (including compute) require large upfront investment in fixed assets that produce long-term cash flows and tend to be considered scarcity assets as they are costly and take a long time to build. The trade-off is that returns are extremely sensitive to capacity utilization, commodity or service price and financing cost, creating boom-bust return cycles. The table below highlights the differences between capital light and capital heavy industries.

Identifying Scarcity Assets Opportunities

The shift to clean energy has deepened dependence on scarce natural inputs. Critical minerals such as lithium, nickel, and rare earths are finite and geographically concentrated. Meanwhile, water, sand and arable land once believed to be extraordinarily abundant – are not anymore. Finally, electricity infrastructure and semiconductor chips – the key inputs to computing power – are rapidly becoming the new “hard assets” of this century.

To be sure, investing today in semiconductors would be a late move – after all, Nvidia stocks have 5x in the past three years and is already among the most valuable global companies due to the tremendous pricing power its chips have in this AI build-out phase. However, we expect that the electricity infrastructure underpinning those chips – the second hard asset input to computing power – still has some upside. The table below outlines a few of the scarcest plays in the tech commodities nexus. One column shows the number of years for which we expect the current level of undersupply to perdure. The other gives a financial score to that play based on price momentum and value.

In this context, the Tech theme seems to be already fully valued. That said, with the hype in chips maybe mostly behind us, we think we may still be at the early innings of a grid transition Supercycle. We have written about this theme in several past notes, (please see our October 23, 2025 note “Power Hungry: The Real Cost of a Digital Future”) have highlighted several electrical equipment companies that will benefit from rising demand for their services.

Additionally, investors can gain exposure to chips and electricity themes by investing in the associated natural resources that they rely on – ones where prices may not yet be accurately reflecting their status as scarcity assets. Two such areas are water (high usage in chips production) and copper (input to the grid buildout). Although both equity plays associated with water and copper have performed positively this year, returns have nonetheless lagged that of chips and grid names (see the chart and table below). Should our thesis – one where these resources will increasingly be viewed as scarcity assets – pan out, more upside for water and copper themes lies ahead.

Looking at some specific plays, we still like grid and copper plays as we feel that the market underappreciates the scarcity in these areas. We also like nuclear plays as the path of least resistance to grow grid capacity over the next decade. Looking at copper (see our July 15 note “Dig, Squeeze and Recycle: Rewiring the Copper Market“, the recent announcement of the merger between Teck Resources and Anglo American, we also think that it remain underinvested.

Investors looking to gain commodity exposure related to the energy transition theme often look no further than copper. After all, copper is considered the backbone of electrification as wiring, motors, grids, and charging networks require huge amounts of the metal. But other materials are arguably just as important and are somewhat neglected by investors: aluminum, a key material for lightweighting,  has several tailwinds that make aluminum producers – both primary and secondary (scrap) – an interesting investment proposal.

Aluminum: What is it?

Unlike copper or gold, aluminum never appears as a pure metal, it is bound up mostly in bauxite, a rock found on the earth’s surface, primarily in Guinea, Australia and China. To make aluminum, alumina is extracted from the bauxite (rock) using caustic soda. Alumina is then turned into aluminum in liquid form using electrolysis, which is hugely electricity intensive. Indeed, aluminum has often been called electricity in a solid form because it takes a huge amount of electricity to produce it.

Because bauxite and alumina are relatively common, aluminum is an abundant material that is used in a myriad of applications and across economic sectors (see chart below).

Importantly, unlike fossil fuels and some other industrial inputs, aluminum intensity is increasing in the global economy. The charts below show the trajectory of oil and aluminum per unit of GDP. Fossil fuel intensity in the global economy has been dropping for several decades. Conversely, aluminum and copper intensity of GDP stabilized around 2010 and is widely forecast to increase in the years ahead.

The largest increase in aluminum demand – both now and for the next several years- is in the transportation sector, which is already the single largest consumer of aluminum, accounting for almost 30% of global demand.  Lightweight vehicles and aircraft, designed for fuel efficiency and lower emissions, rely heavily on aluminum components. This trend will increase as automakers continue to adopt aluminum for lightweighting, especially in electric vehicles whereby manufacturers look for ways to offset the weight of batteries, and to comply with emissions standards.

Outside of transportation, other tailwinds for aluminum demand include:

On the supply side, bauxite is considered a plentiful resource that is relatively easy to access given that it is found near the earth’s surface. The chart below shows how aluminum compares to other metals – aluminum production is relatively resource efficient in that it takes only 7 kg of rock (bauxite) to produce 1 kg of aluminum. This ratio has held fairly steady over the past several decades.  

Although there are no physical constraints to aluminum supply, most forecasters expect aluminum supply to tighten relative to demand beyond the next three years.

Most notable is that China, currently responsible for about 60% of global aluminum production, has implemented a national ceiling of 45 million tons per year on primary aluminum production. The cap was established in 2017 to address overcapacity and environmental concerns. 2024 was the first year that the cap appeared to be binding (Chinese aluminum output was about 45 mt in 2024) and it is very likely that it is binding again this year.

In March 2025 the Chinese government issued a formal plan: “Aluminum Industry High‑Quality Development Implementation Plan (2025–2027)”, in which supply-side controls on primary aluminum capacity and output were reaffirmed. The implication is that Chinese supply is unlikely to meet rising global aluminum demand.  

The second supply-side risk is electricity constraints. Given the quantity of electricity necessary to produce aluminum, the economics of aluminum are essentially the economics of power. It’s no wonder that smelting capacity is clustered where electricity is relatively cheap (e.g. Norway, Canada and increasingly in the Middle East).

Green Aluminum Plays

Since electricity is such a major input to aluminum production, competitive advantages are available for producers that can either reduce the cost or the volume of the electric input. Enter recycling.

One of the defining features of aluminum is its ability to be recycled infinitely without losing its original properties. Moreover, making recycled aluminum only takes around 5% of the energy needed to make new aluminum. Therefore, there is a strong economic incentive to recycle: about 75%  of all aluminum ever produced is still in use today.

Given the supply risks mentioned above (limited Chinese output of primary aluminum and a potential shortfall of electric power), there are strong incentives to improve aluminum recycling rates. In this context, it should be no surprise that we favor non-Chinese companies with the technology and capacity to produce with high recycled content, especially those with access to low-emissions electricity like hydropower.

In the table below, we show GHG emissions for large cap aluminum producers as a share of revenue.  Note that emissions are particularly important to monitor for aluminum companies, since the vast majority of emissions are related to the source of energy used in producing electricity used smelting. What sets the low-emissions companies apart from their peers is that they all have sizeable recycling operations.

Apart from a comparatively low carbon footprint, aluminum recycling companies have also distinguished themselves from their peers by their stock market performance, both over the past three years and especially in 2025.

As we have written in past notes, since recycling is geographically agnostic, it bypasses many geopolitical and trade issues – one can build a recycling plant anywhere so long as there is access to reliable energy and labor. Importantly, input feed (scrap aluminum) generally trades at a discount to the index price of aluminum, but a significant risk is the availability of scrap. Several countries, but most notably the EU, are set to place export bans on aluminum scrap, precisely because they view it as a national security issue, just like access to copper and rare earth metals. So far in 2025, the price margin between scrap and primary aluminum prices is worth monitoring even if it has remained stable up to now.

Overall, in a world that risks becoming increasingly energy constrained, we expect that aluminum producers most exposed to recycling will outperform and should command a premium over those companies that compete for (higher priced) electricity inputs.

Interestingly, there is currently little valuation discrepancy between the companies in our recycling leaders and laggards baskets (see the chart below).  

Earlier this year, we published a note explaining why only three publicly traded companies were poised to reap the gains of a bull market in rare earth metals in 2025. Since our note (“Critical Minerals, Critical Moves: The Scramble for Rare Earth Metals”, May 7, 2025) an equally weighted basket of MP Materials, Lynas Rare Earths and Neo Performance Materials has gained almost 100%.

Rare earth metals are the lifeblood of most new technologies, both military and civilian (many of which sit squarely within the energy transition theme).

We were compelled to write our previous note due to the geopolitical context of procuring rare earth metals. Recall that in April, China implemented export restrictions on seven rare earths in retaliation to tariffs imposed by the U.S. Trump administration. Then in October, China further restricted supply by adding wide-ranging controls on several rare earths, as well as on battery precursors and superhard materials. At the end of October, U.S. and China leaders reached a trade truce, whereby the most recent restrictions have been temporarily suspended. History suggests, however, that Chinese export restrictions are far from over.

In our last note, we focused on recycling as a possible means to improve rare earth elements (REE) supply. After all, recycling can be geographically agnostic and would lessen the ecological footprint of extremely dirty mining activity. We stand by our previous conclusions: recycling offers a path to increased REE autonomy. However, with recycling rates of REEs currently under 1% and very few operations commercially viable, even an aggressive ramp up in recycling will not be a significant solution to diversify REE supply over the next five years.

In today’s note, we explore whether there are other means to avoid sleepwalking into an REE crisis and how investors should position within this sector.

REE Substitution?

It is not hard to understand that the motivation to find substitutes to REE use is high and rising. After all, companies that use REEs as an input to production are currently held hostage by a tightly controlled supply chain. Moreover, mining and processing REEs creates massive environmental degradation and human health risks. And the costs to procure REEs are forecast to rise sharply as demand swamps available supply.

Unfortunately, however, it seems that REE mining is here to stay for some time. Of the major industries that rely on REEs (defense, renewable energy, consumer electronics), we could only find evidence in the electric vehicle industry for a potential pathway to significantly reduce REE use.

Currently, most electric vehicles run on permanent-magnet motors that are comprised of REEs (Nd, Pr, Dy, Tb). However, alternatives exist. For example, BMW produces electric SUVs with motors that contain no rare earth metals; the development of these motors began in reaction to the 2011 neodymium price spike triggered by Chinese policy. These vehicles will be available for sale in North America in 2026 and may offer a pathway for larger adoption of REE-free electric vehicles.

Conversely, catalytic converters that are used in the exhaust systems of non-EV vehicles are still entirely reliant on REEs such as cerium oxide. While this is not the prime reason, the potential divergence in REE dependence adds more credence to our view that the combination of technological developments and scale are making wider EV adoption the path of least resistance (please see our recent note, “Charging Up on Cheap EV Stocks”, November 13, 2025).

Nonetheless, the likelihood of a widespread conversion across industries away from rare earth metals is unlikely. A “simple” swapping out materials often requires a costly redesign of components, systems, or supply chains. Many substitutions and alternative‐material efforts are still at the research or pilot stage and are far from economically viable.

Follow The Money?

In the absence of private sector capabilities to re-orient away from REEs, governments are increasingly throwing money at the problem. While there are newly announced programs to jumpstart R&D for substitute materials, the bulk of government attention so far has been allocated to building national champions with the aim to re-build global supply chains. The table below highlights various government investments and interventions in 2025 alone:

There are several potential drawbacks for investors when governments intervene in public corporations (reduced operational efficiency, deprioritizing shareholder returns, distorted market signals, etc.) but in the case of rare earth metals, we expect that the advantages outweigh any problems. Since rare earth metal mining is inherently a risky business, governments as stakeholders tend to lower the overall risk for other shareholders and improve financing conditions (i.e. cost and access to capital). Additionally, from a sustainability perspective, there is some evidence that environmental standards tend to be higher when governments take stakes, which is especially significant in the mining sector.

In the U.S., MP Materials has become the government REE “darling”. Earlier this year, the Department of War created a Public Private Partnership (PPA) with the company that established a 10-year price floor of $110 per kg (roughly $40/kg above the current market price) for NdPr. The government will purchase 100% of the magnets produced for defense and commercial use for a decade following commissioning. Needless to say, these actions materially stabilize the near-term earnings outlook and helps support the stock price, irrespective of China’s next moves.

Meanwhile, smaller REE companies (miners) have failed to keep up. With no deal from Uncle Sam, these companies trade similar to junior miners of other commodities (gold, copper, nickel).

Investment Strategy

Given our analysis above, there are three crucial points that investors looking to play the rare earth metals theme need to keep in mind:

Taken this information together, we believe investing in rare earth elements should be framed as such:

For decades, logistics was the invisible infrastructure of globalization – cheap, frictionless, and engineered for cost minimization rather than resiliency. COVID exposed those assumptions, and the system never fully recovered. As manufacturing re-shores to North America and Europe, trade policy becomes more protectionist, and corporates confront the limits of net-zero commitments, logistics has shifted from a background function to a material sustainability and financial risk factor.

When production sat in low-cost geographies, moving goods thousands of miles was still cheaper than manufacturing locally – making inefficiencies tolerable. Re-shoring changes the equation. The two charts below make the re-shoring trend unmistakable: manufacturing construction spending and re-shoring job announcements have both accelerated dramatically since COVID. If one assumes that the proposed Trump-era tariff regime materializes (a big IF), the next few years could see further re-shoring as firms hedge against heightened trade friction.

 

More volume must now be processed closer to end markets, last-mile and returns networks must tighten, and transportation costs re-enter the foreground. This is not “sustainability as virtue signaling”: for many companies, improving logistics efficiency is simply good business.

From a regulatory perspective, Europe’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) is reshaping cross-border cost structures by attaching carbon pricing to imports. At the same time, mandatory disclosure frameworks – most notably the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) – require companies to measure and report Scope 3 emissions across their full value chain, placing scrutiny on the largest share of their footprint. With most corporates having already captured the low-hanging Scope 1 and 2 reductions, the decarbonization frontier has shifted upstream and downstream to suppliers.

The chart below shows how sharply the emissions profile has tilted. Operational emissions (Scopes 1 and 2) have fallen by roughly 15% from their 2019 peak, but this progress has driven Scope 3 to more than 90% of total emissions among the world’s 500 largest companies – up from about 75% in 2014.

The final catalyst is that logistics networks built for 2010 demand patterns are misaligned with 2025 realities. E-commerce growth, SKU proliferation, labor shortages, congested ports, and high empties (nearly 33% of U.S. truck miles still run unloaded) are pushing the system to its limits. At the same time, cutting-edge technologies like automation, robotics, AI-driven routing, and end-to-end visibility platforms are finally mature enough to produce step-change efficiency gains. The timing is consequential: structural stress is colliding with tools capable of materially reducing it.

 

Three Pillars of the Sustainable Logistics Investment Theme

The structural pressures reshaping global supply chains create an investment landscape that echoes past infrastructure transitions: a system operating at its physical limits, a new cohort of technologies capable of relieving those constraints, and a geopolitical alignment where countries are focusing more on themselves. But the logistics transformation is fundamentally distributed. It unfolds simultaneously in buildings, transport networks, and the digital orchestration layer that stitches everything together.

Sustainable logistics is therefore best understood as a multi-sector theme with heterogeneous business models and risk profiles. On one end sit the Logistics Real Estate Companies, providing the physical backbone where goods are stored, sorted, and processed. In the middle are the Transportation & Logistics Operators, the firms that actually move products across increasingly complex global and regional networks. Layered above both is the fast-growing class of Software & System Optimizers, the digital infrastructure orchestrating flows, improving asset utilization, and maximizing emissions efficiency across the entire “supply chain of supply chains.”

This week’s note will highlight the leading companies in each subsector for investors seeking exposure to the ongoing transformation of sustainable logistics.

I. Logistics Real Estate: Warehousing as Critical Infrastructure

Warehousing has become one of the most structurally constrained components of the global economy. Despite intermittent recession fears, U.S. industrial vacancy remains near 4%, well below historical averages. European markets are even tighter, with modern logistics space in the Netherlands and Germany at sub-3% vacancy. When space is available, much of the global stock is outdated – not designed for automation, electrification, or high-velocity returns. The result: lower storage density, inefficient material flows, and higher energy use per pallet.

As throughput requirements surge and tenants electrify fleets, grid capacity, rooftop solar, EV-charging yards, and digital backbones have become mission-critical. This is pushing logistics real estate owners into the role of modernization utilities – enabling tenants to meet operational, emissions, and resilience requirements that legacy warehouses simply cannot support.

Within the subsector, Prologis stands out as the most advanced on sustainability investment, supported by green-financing programs, integrated climate governance, and large-scale infrastructure upgrades across its portfolio. Segro plc is a close second followed by Goodman Group with credible long-term decarbonization strategies and capex commitments.

II. The Transportation & Logistics Operators: Fixing the Network Itself

If logistics real estate companies control the physical nodes, transportation and logistics operators manage the edges – the links that move goods between every point in the system. Those links remain structurally inefficient. U.S. trucking networks still operate with about a third of empty miles, and global road-freight emissions reached a record 2.2 Gt CO₂ in 2023. Inefficiency is both a cost burden and an emissions problem.

Operators such as C.H. Robinson, DSV, SG Holdings, and Brambles are increasingly closing these gaps with software-driven, data-coordinated transport networks. Freight brokerage has become algorithmic; consolidation and routing decisions are automated; and real-time emissions data is shaping modal-shift decisions. Asset-sharing systems – most notably Brambles’ CHEP pallet-pooling model – reduce waste, improve reuse rates, and drive circularity at global scale.

Within this subsector, Brambles stands out as the sustainability benchmark due to the inherent circularity of its CHEP model and its progress against science-based targets. DSV ranks as the strongest of the global Third-Party Logistics companies (3PLs), supported by robust absolute emissions-reduction commitments and leading disclosure. SG Holdings has quietly built a high-quality sustainability profile. C.H. Robinson is making credible improvements and launching customer-facing tools, but its transitions appear more incremental relative to the leaders.

III. Software & System Optimizers: The Intelligence Layer

The third pillar – and the highest-growth, highest-margin segment – is the software and data infrastructure that orchestrates modern logistics. This includes warehouse management systems (WMS), transportation management systems (TMS), real-time visibility platforms, RFID ecosystems, and automation-control engines. As regulatory scrutiny tightens and operational complexity scales, the digital layer offers the fastest, most capital-efficient path to emissions reductions and productivity gains.

Several technology vectors are now converging. RFID adoption has finally passed its inflection point: global shipments exceeded 30 billion tags in 2023, up 25% year-over-year. Persistent labour shortages are accelerating warehouse automation capex, which is expanding 10–12% annually. And visibility tools that were niche pre-COVID are now mainstream, with 70% of Fortune 500 shippers deploying real-time tracking, exception management, and digital documentation.

Companies such as Zebra Technologies, Descartes, and WiseTech Global increasingly run the critical logic of logistics. Their platforms determine pallet routing, slotting optimization, picking sequences, carrier selection, and customs compliance. The impact is measurable: shrinkage reductions of up to 30%, stockout improvements of 10–20%, and materially higher asset-utilization rates across fleets, containers, and warehouse equipment.

Within this subsector, Zebra Technologies and WiseTech Global emerge as the clearest sustainability leaders, integrating emissions-aware tools and efficiency metrics directly into their solutions. Descartes remains an essential enabler of efficient logistics flows with solid ESG reporting, though it communicates its sustainability positioning more quietly than peers.

 

Sustainability x Financial Analysis

Building on the investment theses for each subsector, we evaluate the selected companies through a dual lens of sustainability and financial performance. The names highlighted in yellow represent our top picks, offering the most compelling intersection of ESG impact and valuation.

Ultimately, this theme offers a distinct advantage for portfolio construction: it provides natural diversification across asset classes and business models. Logistics Real Estate Companies provide defensive ballast through real-asset duration, inflation-linked income, and structurally tight markets. Transportation & Logistics Operators add cyclical torque, outperforming when global trade accelerates and capacity tightens. Software & System Optimizers supply the long-duration growth engine, driven by automation, digitization, and the rising value of real-time data. Combined, these segments create a tunable mix of quality, growth, and cyclicality depending on an investor’s risk posture.

Taken together, these three pillars form an ecosystem undergoing simultaneous modernization. Buildings are being retrofitted, networks are being re-optimized, and software is finally coordinating the whole system with real-time data. It is rare to find a theme where physical infrastructure, operational networks, and digital layers are all experiencing multi-year investment cycles in parallel – and rarer still when the economics and decarbonization objectives align this cleanly.

The rumours of the death of the EV have been greatly exaggerated. While Donald Trump applied the brakes on the whole EV industry – except for a brief “Broment” with Elon Musk when he turned the White House into a “pop-up” Tesla dealership, it seems that he is doing his best to prolong the life of the internal combustion engine (ICE) – at least in America. It is true that the President is setting back the overall energy transition a few years back, but the transition is still happening fast in the automotive sector.

Moreover, while the political crowd is busy rolling back environmental legislation in many countries– it seems that technological developments are still accelerating to a point where, according to the American Automobile Association (AAA), EVs are now cheaper to buy, own and operate than their equivalent ICE cars. Additionally, the price of traditional gas-powered cars are rising more quickly than EV prices. This suggests that despite the politics, the combination of technological developments and scale are making EVs the path of least resistance.

While global EV sales growth is decelerating, some sources suggest that sales are still expanding at a robust pace 3As a result, EVs are rapidly becoming the default mode of transportation in many parts of the world – even across emerging markets, where electrification and grid infrastructure still lag developed economies.

 

 

China is leading the way in building the next generation of EVs and batteries. Conversely, one could think that the stance of the current U.S. administration will likely decrease the odds of the U.S. automobile industry ability to catch up with China’s dominance in the sector. To this end, some recent comments from Ford’s CEO Jim Earley suggesting that Chinese cars have “far superior technology, lower costs and great quality” compared to their U.S. counterparts should be worrisome for U.S. automakers. In fact, the very idea that the U.S. auto industry may become obsolete vis-à-vis its competitors is an increasingly plausible scenario. While China is “stepping on the gas” and propping EV factories, most U.S. makers are slowing down their EV roll-out – and in some cases even considering to cease production.

In this context, the global tariff standoff is also acting as an artificial protection for U.S. automakers and delaying their adaption to an EV world led by Chinese automakers.

Did Trump Really Boost the Global EV Industry?

Like many other transition-focused investment themes (see our note “Contrarians in the Green”, September 18, 2025), EVs and batteries have been a hot topic this year. That also true on a 2-year basis – a period during which the equity price of companies such as Tesla and BYD have almost doubled and solidly outperformed global indices. Interestingly, GM outperformed EV automakers despite being still mostly focused on ICE vehicles as its performance of late was supported by Trump tariffs and, more recently, some positive analyst revisions. Looking three to five years ahead, we would prefer to be long EV makers (BYD, TSLA) and short legacy U.S. automakers (F, GM).

 

Furthermore, for those looking to capture the up-and-coming EV automakers with some exposure to ICE technology, Korean automakers are interesting (and cheap).

An EV Corollary: The Battery Play

Despite all the negative press over EVs and overcapacity in the industry, it seems that battery makers are still well-liked by the market. After hitting a floor in 2024, their price has rebounded recently.

Finally, while batteries are mostly made in China, they remain an expensive play compared to EVs (especially Korean ones). However, if one were to take a longer view on the theme considering that the future to the global automotive industry is still one which is closely tied to electrification, it could still make sense to re-enter the play at this stage. Furthermore, if tariffs on China EVs exports to the EU, U.S. and Canada were to abate amid a possible rapprochement between China and G7 economies (ex-U.S.), then we could expect the rebound in EV and battery prices to be prolonged.

 

Precious and Unique

Precious metals are called precious because they embody a rare combination of scarcity, durability, and enduring value that few materials can match. Elements like gold, silver, and the platinum group metals do not rust, tarnish, or corrode easily, allowing them to preserve their function over centuries. This durability translates into intrinsic value retention, making them timeless stores of wealth. Their importance has expanded beyond ornament or currency because of properties like conductivity, catalytic efficiency, and chemical inertness which have made them indispensable to advanced industry, from renewable energy and electronics to medicine and clean transportation.

The table below highlights some precious metal’s unique characteristics.

Higher Prices

Over the past decade, the average price of precious metals has roughly quadrupled, reflecting a convergence of structural and cyclical forces. Early gains were driven by monetary stimulus, low real interest rates, and diversification flows seeking refuge. More recently, the rally has broadened, as industrial demand has become a second growth engine with silver, platinum, and palladium increasingly critical to clean-energy technologies, electronics, and automotive catalysts. On the supply side, mine depletion, geopolitical risk, and limited recycling capacity have constrained availability just as global demand diversified beyond investors. In 2025, these pressures appear to be intensifying: gold, silver, and the entire platinum-group complex have entered a synchronized upswing.

Many of the precious metals are part of critical minerals list that many developed countries have identified. Canada, in its latest budget, has earmarked 214 million over 5 years to support critical mineral projects.

The chart below shows the price evolution of each precious metal.

More than a Store of Value

The table below underscores how precious metals have evolved as enablers of modern industry, bridging technology, sustainability and performance in sectors ranging from electronics to medicine and renewable energy.

Recycling Opportunity

Precious metals mining remains controversial because they are among the most resource-intensive materials to extract, yet once in circulation, they are remarkably efficient to recover and reuse. The same properties that make them rare (i.e.   density, chemical stability, and resistance to corrosion) also make them highly recoverable from industrial scrap and end-of-life products. Whether reclaimed from catalytic converters, electronics, or jewelry, precious metals can be recycled indefinitely without loss of quality. This creates a powerful sustainability dynamic: while supply from mining remains constrained and environmentally costly, recycling offers a low-impact, circular source of value, reinforcing the long-term appeal of precious metals as both strategic resources and renewable stores of wealth.

The current mining environment is increasingly challenging and marked by declining ore grades, high extraction costs and growing environmental constraints. Therefore, precious metals recyclers occupy an increasingly strategic position. As the prices of gold, silver, and platinum-group metals have increased, recyclers have benefited from expanding margins without the heavy capital intensity or ecological footprint associated with new mining projects. After all, their business model converts waste into high-value feedstock that can be refined and resold with far lower energy use. This aligns with circular resource management but also provides pricing leverage in a market where primary supply is tightening. In effect, precious metals recyclers could become the low-carbon miners of the modern era, turning scarcity, regulation, and volatility into opportunity while improving their profit margin by participating directly in the upside of rising metal prices.

The table below highlights publicly-traded companies with activities in precious metals recycling.  It is encouraging to see that investors have several options to play into this theme.

Recycling Stocks Are Starting to Perk Up

The chart below illustrates the five-year price performance of the nine recycling companies we selected based on their overall business alignment with sustainability. While returns have varied widely across the group, all have benefited from the recent rally in precious metals, reflecting renewed investor interest and stronger fundamentals. Recyclers have less leverage to the price of precious metals than miners because they have to pay market price for their input (residues, e-scrap, etc.) but they still benefit from price increases.

Still Some Catching Up to Do

The chart below compares the five-year average price performance of the SMS Precious Recyclers group with the S&P 500 (SPY) and the Gold Miners ETF (GDX). While gold miners have recently closed the gap with the broader equity market, helped by their operational leverage to rising gold prices, recyclers have only begun to recover.

Precious But Not Prized

The table below highlights that precious metals recyclers continue to trade at a significant valuation discount to the broader equity market. Most companies in the group exhibit price-to-earnings ratios between 8x and 20x, well below the S&P 500 average of 27x, and similarly modest price-to-tangible book multiples that are generally under 2x, versus 4.6x for the S&P. This reflects lingering caution and the absence of AI buzz toward the sector; it also underscores meaningful re-rating potential as earnings visibility improves. Net margins should recover, supported by higher metal prices. Taken together, the group appears undervalued relative to its strategic position with scope for further improvement as pricing power continues to expand.

It is difficult for sustainability-oriented investors to gain exposure to precious metals through mining because of the environmental degradation it causes. It is also very energy and resource intensive: the extraction of a single ounce of gold can require processing tons of ore, using cyanide and mercury. Moreover, artisanal mining, which produces 20% of annual gold production generally occurs in unsafe working conditions. Recycling is an alternative way to gain exposure to precious metals.

Although over two thirds of the Earth’s surface is water-covered, 99.7 percent of all water on earth is either salted in the oceans, trapped in soils and icecaps, or floating in the atmosphere. Of the 0.3% of the earth’s water that is theoretically useable, much of it is either unattainable or polluted beyond sanitary use.

Freshwater is a finite resource, meaning that it is in our collective interest to both conserve and protect the sources that we have, or find substitutes for freshwater withdrawals.  

In a recent note (Not So Salty Anymore: The Investment Case for Desalination July 3, 2025), we discussed the prospects – and investment opportunities – of growing the freshwater supply via desalination, i.e., finding substitutes for freshwater resources. While desalination is an increasingly promising solution for coastal regions (since salt water is vastly abundant) and offers enticing investment prospects, it is unlikely to replace the need for freshwater resources on even very long investment horizons. In other words, the supply of water is relatively fixed – save for additions from desalination – so establishing economic incentives to constrain demand and allocating capital to encourage water efficiency is urgently needed.

Economic Incentives for Water Conservation: Finding a Price

One of the challenges in gauging our vulnerability to water scarcity is that, since using water resources is considered a basic human right, the cost of water, and indeed the very notion of paying for water, is not well accepted. Indeed, of all environmental resources, governments tend to shy away most from taxing water. The chart below shows that around the world, revenues raised through the taxation of environmental assets represents a very small share of total tax revenues (the OECD average is less than 5%). Water is the least taxed of all.

Importantly, water demand has been long-considered inelastic, meaning that changes in its price do not significantly affect quantities demanded. Recent studies suggest that the reality is somewhat more nuanced; there are vast discrepancies in water demand elasticities both within and across economic sectors. This means that water pricing can be an effective tool in some situations. For example, in China, it was found that water rights’ trading, i.e. permissions that enable entities to extract or use water from sources like rivers, lakes, or underground aquifers., has significantly improved efficiency with a net effect of reducing water consumption per unit of agricultural output by almost 5%. As such, water pricing schemes in the agriculture sector are often the most efficient mean to curb water demand, which is an encouraging outcome since agriculture accounts for over 70% of all freshwater withdrawals globally.

It is worth noting that water demand is considerably less sensitive to prices than carbon. One of the reasons that regulated carbon markets are considered successful is because economic theory has been borne out in practice. Simply put, researchers can show that introducing a carbon price has yielded immediate and substantial emission reductions for the vast majority of carbon price policies, “despite the low level of prices in most instances”. Given that water demand does not display the same price elasticity as carbon, it’s unlikely that water pricing can – or should – be considered as a universal tool to tackle water scarcity.

 

Investing For Efficiency

The lack of strong price signals does not mean that improving water supply – and slowing the rate of freshwater withdrawals – is impossible. However, our observation is that water conservation, via improved efficiencies, tend to only occur once serious water scarcity episodes have been experienced.

As an example, the state of California has been hit with several major droughts beginning in the 1970s; each drought episode has triggered increasingly strict water management regulation. The 2007-2009 drought induced the Water Conservation Act in 2009 which mandated that water suppliers increase their water-use efficiency, targeting a 20% reduction in residential gallons per capita per day by 2020. More recently, the California State Water Resources Control requires that all urban water suppliers set Water Use Objectives (WUO), and annual water budgets that are reduced at least every 5 years through 2040. The culmination of stricter regulation means that per capita residential water consumption (gallons per capita per day) in California fell dramatically in the past three decades.

If California’s experience is regulating water usage can be considered a road map for other jurisdictions, then the bad news is that it is likely that communities will suffer water scarcity before significant regulation is adopted to force conservation.

On the flip side, once regulation (and enforcement) kicks in, there are easy conservation gains to be made, at least in North America.

For one thing, the continent’s water infrastructure is in very poor shape. Each year, drinking water systems in the U.S. and Canada experience about 260,000 water main breaks. Nearly 20% of installed water mains in the U.S. and Canada are beyond their useful lives and estimates of associate drinking water losses are in the trillions of gallons per year.

The American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) National Infrastructure Report Card is a critical benchmark for the condition and performance of 18 key infrastructure sectors. The 2025 report card (shown below) states water-related infrastructures scored below the national average, confirming that the sector is in acute need of an upgrade.

The good news is that upgrade appears to finally be underway. Since 2022, total U.S. construction spending on water supply has outpaced overall (public and private) construction spending. Water suppliers have especially rushed to keep up with water demand from data centres that require ongoing cooling needs. Indeed, according to a Bank of America study last year, data centres are now the data centres are now the tenth largest industry for water consumption (see our recent note “Hot Picks for the Heat Economy”, August 7, 2025) for how to invest in cooling solutions for data centres.  

We expect the water infra boom to persist. After all, the projected funding required to upkeep the U.S.’ water system over the next decade is enormous relative to the current situation.

Water Equity Portfolio Considerations

Over the past several years, we have published several notes exploring different opportunities of water equity investing. The water theme, like many other sustainability topics, offers exposure to companies with extremely diverse financial characteristics. For example, “water tech” can just as easily get caught up in hype cycles alongside other tech innovation companies.

Conversely, water utilities typically offer low beta and can enhance portfolio downside protection during bear markets. Particular to the U.S., the water utilities sector is making headlines due to a wave of M&A activity. As discussed earlier this year (please see Liquid Gold: Water as a Safe Haven for Sustainability Investors, March 27, 2025), the American water utilities market is very fragmented with many operators in regional monopolies. American Water Works has been the standout for its M&A activity and has been aggressively pursuing acquisitions over the past five years. The merger announcement earlier this week between American Water Works and Essential Utilities is unlikely to be the last in this industry.

Over the past three years, water-related equity stocks have aptly reflected economic conditions, with utility companies underperforming broad stock indexes, and higher beta sectors like water tech and those tied to the construction cycle (parts and valves) continuing to coast.

With interest rates unlikely to induce recessionary conditions anytime soon, we expect that infra and tech water plays will continue to ride the wave.

Even if artificial intelligence and hyperscale data centers fail to expand as aggressively as expected, global electricity demand is set to rise steeply over the coming decade. This acceleration will be driven by industrial revitalization, transportation electrification, manufacturing expansion in emerging economies, and population growth.

Across major regions, the new appetite for power stems from still-strong electric vehicle (EV) adoption, battery and semiconductor manufacturing, and a wave of industrial reconfiguration aimed at energy security and supply chain resilience. Electrification of heating, logistics, and public transport has rapidly replaced fossil fuel demand for electricity.

The chart below highlights two periods of high electricity demand compared to average growth of 3.3% since 1980. The first is the late 1980’s whereby Southeast Asia industrialized quickly, and electrification accelerated after the oil shock. The second is the current period, beginning in 2020 for all the reasons mentioned above.

Electricity demand is having its comeback moment in the United States; the chart looks like a voltage spike. Indeed, after years of grid complacency, power demand is set to post its fastest sustained growth in a generation. Blame (or thank) data centers, electrified factories, and all the stuff we promised that would be “digital”. The cleaner, smarter, more efficient future turns out to be wildly power-hungry.

Identifying Bottlenecks: Paperwork Not Construction

Under most circumstances (except this time with the rapid data center build-out), electricity consumption growth has been relatively predictable, but the infrastructure build out to meet demand tends to lag far behind. Currently, the greatest bottleneck lies not in generation but in permitting and transmission capacity. Across all continents, thousands of gigawatts of renewable and storage projects are stuck in interconnection queues or awaiting regulatory approval. In many markets, large-scale power projects can take five to ten years to permit and build, compared with only two years for new industrial or data center construction. The table below shows the typical timeframe to add power to the grid; from planning to commissioning. The bolded rows highlight when significant expenses (revenues for the companies delivering the product or service) start to materialize.

This regulatory friction is a big clash with the technology sector, which thrives on “moving fast and breaking things,” while electricity generation is governed by the opposite imperative: “move carefully, ensure nothing breaks.” With data centers seen as a chokepoint for artificial intelligence (AI), developers accustomed to timelines measured in months now confront energy timelines measured in multiple years.

Even under conservative assumptions, the world’s electricity infrastructure will require massive capital mobilization over the next decade to accommodate industrial electrification and digitalization. The central challenge is not how to produce enough electrons, but how to deliver them swiftly, safely, and economically within a system that is unaccustomed to “move fast and break things.”

 

Investment Opportunities

From an investment standpoint, the demand for electricity infrastructure equipment and services across the entire supply chain is expected to remain robust. This ongoing build-out will likely face periods of scarcity because suppliers operate in a capital-intensive industry accustomed to the traditionally slow pace of the electricity sector. However, this sector is now under pressure to accelerate, driven by deep-pocketed, power-hungry companies like Alphabet, Meta, and Microsoft, who want to move fast and scale quickly.

The table below highlights 20 sustainable companies and illustrates how their products and services fit within the electrification ecosystem. We divided this ecosystem into eight segments that generate revenue across the post approval project lifecycle, from engineering and procurement to construction, commissioning, maintenance, and grid optimization.

The chart below highlights the stock performance of the same companies over the last five years. From the company that has performed best, Vertiv, which concentrates its efforts in critical digital infrastructure and has benefitted from the data center build-out and hype, to the company that has performed worst, Daikin Industries, which is the world’s largest Heating, Ventilation and Air-Conditioning (HVAC) manufacturer with a growing portion in smart, grid-responsive HVAC.

One noticeable aspect of the performance charts is that companies strictly involved in automation and monitoring and cooling are at the bottom of the list. This makes sense considering that optimization and maintenance happen after the build-out phase, therefore those companies have not yet seen strong and rising demand for their services, like the ones at the top of the schedule Note that all of these companies have strong sustainability credentials, as the chart below highlights.

However, from a financial perspective, these companies have not yet caught the attention of investors. Sales growth has been generally weak because their grid-related revenues will come later in the electrification cycle, among other things. They will gain more revenues in the maintenance and optimization phase of the electric grid expansion. The aggressive expansion of the electric grid is an early part of a long-term trend toward electrification; these companies offer good risk vs. reward at current valuations.

The key law of economics is that of supply and demand. When demand exceeds supply, prices tend to rise. When supply exceeds demand, prices generally fall.

But there are some goods and services that defy the law of supply and demand: many environmental assets have not re-priced in times of scarcity or are simply not priced at all!

Indeed, a growing number of environmental assets — both physical materials and ecological systems — are reaching depletion thresholds. These shortages pose cross-sectoral risks to growth, food security, and climate stability. Carbon sinks can be thought of as the greatest environmental asset in short supply; we simply are not “capturing” enough of the carbon that humans currently produce.

We have written several notes on the shortage of carbon sinks (for example, please see Trump, Tariffs and Trees: Opportunities in North American Forestry, April 17, 2025). Today’s note sheds light on two other environmental assets – sand and soil – that face structural supply issues.

 

(Construction-Grade) Natural Sand: At the Bottom of the Pit

Construction grade sand is the foundation of urbanization and is found in a multitude of building products like concrete, glass, and asphalt. It is considered the most-consumed natural resource on the planet besides water. Over 50 billion tonnes of sand and gravel is used every year.

Most laypersons could be mistaken for believing that sand is a plentiful resource, never to be in short supply. But all sand is not created equal. Desert sand is extremely abundant but is rarely used in building materials since its grains (smooth, round, created by erosion from wind) do not bind easily to form stable concrete. Conversely, sand found in riverbeds, lakes and seashores (i.e. created from water erosion) is compiled of grains that are angular and thus bind together.

The problem is that river and coastal sand is being depleted faster than it can regenerate. On top of that, coastal sands are being used in increasing quantities to shore up beaches of coastal communities, that are facing unprecedented rates of erosion.

In sum, cheap, ready-to-use building sand is becoming harder to come by. This has only started to show up in North American prices in the last couple of years. The Chart below shows a price index of construction sand, gravel and crushed stone in comparison to an all-commodity price index. Inflation in the former has far outpaced other commodities and incredibly, unlike other commodities, the inflation rate has never contracted – or even dipped below 3% – during recessions.  Sand prices are currently growing at 6% per year.

Encouragingly, there are substitutes to natural sand. Artificial or manufactured sand is essentially large stones crushed into small stones. Currently, the cost to produce manufactured sand remains higher in many regions than extracting it from nature. The exceptions are where scarcity and/or strict environmental regulations limit the extraction of natural sand; in China and India, leaders in this industry – it is estimated that 80% of construction now uses manufactured sand. We expect that the shift to manufactured sand will accelerate in other regions as global sand scarcity accelerates and the price differential between manufactured and natural sand diminishes.

Manufactured sand is considered an environmentally superior option to natural sand. Despite the additional energy required to crush rock, manufactured sand has the following environmental advantages:

The shift to manufactured sand can be played either by investing in companies that provide the equipment and technology to manufacture sand or by investing in building companies that producing manufactured sand. The table below highlights the main companies in each of these investment plays.

Performance of these stocks have generally been excellent over the past five years. The chart below shows the five-year price returns, in local currency terms, of companies involved in the manufactured sand industry that have the highest CSRhub sustainability scores. All of them matched or beat the S&P500.

Soil: Fertile Returns Beneath Our Feet

The United Nations recently declared soil as finite, and predicted catastrophic loss: the magnitude of soil loss has the potential to create $23 trillion in losses of food, ecosystem services and income worldwide in the next 25 years. The leading cause of soil loss is erosion (due to monocropping and chemical overuse) and the global erosion rate is estimated at about 20 – 30 times faster than the new soil formation rate.

There is no global tradeable soil price, since soil is a strictly domestic product: no country in the world allows for the bulk import of topsoil. And unlike our discussion of sand above, there is no manufactured/man-made substitute for soil; regenerative agriculture, however, can restore soil quality although progress is usually measured in years or even decades.

Despite the inexistence of a “soil price”, it is somewhat straightforward to infer one via the price of agricultural land. To be sure, there are a myriad of factors that drive the price of ag real estate, including proximity to markets and roads, water availability, tillability, macro drivers like interest rates and commodity prices and, of course, soil productivity. Soil productivity is logically positively correlated with agricultural land prices and is observable. For instance, in Iowa America, the state uses a Corn Suitability Rating (CSR2) to measure soil productivity in the state (a higher rating means more productive land). Land with higher ratings command higher per-acre values.

Interestingly, there is some evidence that the premium paid for land with more productive soil is growing. The chart below shows the annual percent change in Iowa land prices as measured by USD/acre compared to quality adjusted land prices ($/acre/suitability rating). While land prices have increased 33% since 2020, the price for quality has increased by over 50%.

Indeed, there is emerging evidence that investing in soil health is increasingly reflected in land prices. A recent study of Brazil agriculture also showed that a premium is building for land with healthy soil. Researchers compared conventional farming practices to no-tillage, crop rotation, contour farming; the latter practices are known to protect soil quality. They found a premium on no-tillage land of between 10 and 22%.

It appears that investors are seeking metrics to account for soil health in prospective agriculture assets as well. Farmland Partners (FPI US), the largest farmland REIT in North America, screens for soil health and only considers investments that have a better than average soil quality index. The company states 94% of tenants practice some of form of no or low-tillage technique and over 40% use cover crops (the national average is below 10%). FPI’s basic investment thesis is that as the population expands and the supply of farmland shrinks, there will be a premium on high (soil) quality assets.

Agricultural land REITs performance, compared to broad indexes like the S&P 500, have not been particularly stellar. However, compared to other real estate trust segments, ag land has a wide lead over the past five years (please see the chart below).

Over the last month, political and security turbulence has escalated on multiple fronts. The shooting of conservative commentator Charlie Kirk dominated headlines, amplifying the discourse around political violence. Donald Trump made waves by renaming the Department of Defense to the Department of War. Against this backdrop, Pete Hegseth has convened a special meeting of Department of War leaders this week. Across the Atlantic, a series of Russian drone incursions into allied airspace highlighted the fragility of European security.

In our previous note, “The European Defense Offensive: From Peace Dividend to War Premium”, March 6, 2025, we discussed how guns and drones can help to achieve security and how drones are reshaping entire civilian sectors. The central task for policymakers and investors is to channel these tools toward stability, innovation, and resilience.

 

Back to the Battlefield: The Resurgence of Geopolitics

Since 1980, we experienced a relative period of geopolitical calm, shaped by the end of the Cold War, expanding globalization, and the absence of direct large-scale conflict between major powers. However, this environment has been progressively shifting toward conflicts, with renewed great-power rivalries, regional wars, trade tensions, and escalating competition over resources and technology.

The table below shows the most important conflicts since the beginning of the century. The same conflicts are repeated as they generally remain unresolved as more are added to the list. The projected increases in defense spending for most countries in the world tend to confirm our assessment that tensions are accelerating globally.

The Drone Disruption: From Battlefields to Boardrooms

The Russian invasion of Ukraine has brought the extensive use of drone for reconnaissance and direct attacks into focus and shows how innovation changes the nature of wars. Twenty-five years ago, in Iraq and Afghanistan, insurgents relied on classic guerilla tactics of ambushes and mobility to counter Western military strength. In Ukraine however, drones now serve a similar role. Cheap, nimble, and precise, they harass supply lines and equipment much like guerilla fighters once did.

The chart below shows the exponential rise in demand for drones over the past five years as well as the  continued exponential growth expected to occur in future years. As described above, military use is growing due to larger defense budgets and the transformation of armed forces towards more drone usage. In the civilian sector there are increasing commercial and societal uses.

From an investment perspective, the combination of military and non-military uses is appealing since it amounts to a certain diversification in demand; military spending does not tend to follow the economic cycle, whereas drone demand from non-military sources tends to more cyclical.

Indeed, for sustainable investors, drones are increasingly being deployed in ways that deliver tangible benefits for society:

Importantly, this civilian transformation of drone technology echoes a broader historical pattern: many advances that originated in military research such as GPS, the internet, and satellite imaging eventually delivered immense benefits for public use. In the same way, drones are now transitioning from instruments of conflict to powerful tools for society where demand is growing.

 

The Gun Market’s Surprising Stall

Surprisingly even with greater polarization, gun demand in the U.S. has plateaued following the post-COVID surge. Several forces explain this: many households already own multiple guns, crisis fatigue has diminished the urgency to arm, and inflation has constrained discretionary spending.

The chart below shows two indicators highlighting the COVID peak in gun demand and the recent plateauing in the United States; the largest market in the world. Background checks from the National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NCIS) are a good leading indicator of new gun demand in the United States whereas firearms manufacturing from the Annual Firearms Manufacturing and Export Report (AFMER) is a coincident to lagging indicator because manufacturers respond to current demand.

Despite persistently high homicide rates in the U.S., the political landscape leaves little room for meaningful gun legislation, and this affects the firearms market. Paradoxically, in the past, fears of tighter regulation have triggered surges in gun sales, i.e. people purchase guns in anticipation of not being able to in the future. However, with a Supreme Court broadly supportive of expansive Second Amendment rights, the likelihood of new restrictions is low, which removes the urgency to purchase additional firearms.

The map below shows that the U.S., Mexico and Brazil have among the highest firearms homicide rates and yet stronger gun control legislation is unlikely in the near future. In the United States, the current administration does not favor stricter rules. In Mexico, civilian ownership is tightly regulated but illicit firearms traficking is a powerful source of demand. In Brazil, Bolsanaro loosened gun laws when he was president while Lula has issued executive orders to tighten gun control because the Brazilian Congress is ambivalent to enact stronger regulation.

The Promise of Drones (Go Long) vs. the Limits of Guns (Be Short)

Unlike drones, which have evolved from military origins to offer wide-ranging civilian and environmental benefits, guns and munitions lack such positive spillover potential for society. Firearms are designed with a single purpose: to wound or kill, and their civilian proliferation is more often linked to rising homicide rates, accidents, and social costs rather than broad social gains.

The table below shows drone and drone-adjacent companies that offer societal benefits and positive financial attributes and gun companies to avoid from a sustainable investment standpoint.

The chart below shows market capitalization, sustainability scores, growth in sales and price to sales for companies in our targeted long and short sectors There are not yet many large companies considered to be specializing in drones; the larger companies like Nokia, Honeywell and Leonardo manufacture components used in drones as part of their much larger organization. The same can be said for gun manufacturers as they remain small capitalization. As expected from our sectoral analysis above, drone companies are experiencing strong growth: for example, Red Cat has had exceptional growth in the last five years (78% growth in sales), it is also expected to continue as its price-to-sales of 128 highlights. On the other hand, gun companies have had close to zero growth in sales and trade at depressed price-to-sales. We expect this trend to continue: high valuation in the growth segment of drones and low valuation in the stagnating gun segment.