As the reflation trade continues, ESG-minded investors – and indeed other fossil fuel sector bears – remain skeptical about the recent oil price hike to USD 70+/bbl. Oil prices are up about 40% in the last 12-month amid recent Middle East tensions, attacks against Saudi assets and OPEC+ limitation on supply.

As we view these elements being transitory in a context where stimulus money will continue to flow into the global economy (and in the U.S. in particular), one can wonder for how long the global oil market can remain at levels worthy of its glorious days. Like a growing number of Big Oil executives, we are of the view that global demand for oil will probably have topped with the COVID crisis and that going forward, the commodity’s future looks down more than up.

Interestingly, despite the recent rise in oil prices, it seems that drilling activity remains subdued, which suggests that drillers have taken a cautious approach to the recent rebound in prices.

That said, rising oil prices have provided a breather for the suffocating North American oil industry these past few months. While we are seeing some resurgence in High Yield Energy bond prices, we think that the market has somewhat been getting ahead of itself given the sector’s underlying weaknesses.

This is perhaps due to the fact that unconventional Oil & Gas debt levels have increased substantially since the COVID crisis (six percentage points in fact) and, in a context of rising interest rates, the increased debt load (and its associated debt service) could prove detrimental to free cash flow levels of the industry. In this context, drillers should consider taking advantage of the current hike in prices to transition towards more financially sustainable business models.

Moreover, it seems the sector also has been shedding assets following depressed oil prices of the past few years (and 2020 in particular) which are now at their 5-year low point. In that, we expect that the crisis will have accelerated the amount of stranded assets in sector.

Pre-COVID, some were already worrying about the financing difficulties of North American oil producers given their deteriorating financial structure. Interestingly, this does not seem to worry HY Energy investors as bond prices in the sector have also increased by about 25 percentage points over the last 12 months – almost as much as the commodity itself.

Looking at how the market perceives risks in HY Energy assets these days, one sees that the Markit CDX HY Index is back to normal. Knowing that this index is comprised of CDS of several junk-graded debt securities from unconventional energy producers in North America, one could think that CDS spreads in HY will only go up over the coming months, especially those in HY Energy unless the price of oil stays elevated.

The sector’s resurgence is also visible in equities – especially those of shale oil in the U.S. and oil sands in Canada. Here again, the unconventional sector, represented by the FRAK ETF in the chart, rebounded as much as the commodity itself these past few months. Given the operational leverage in the Oil & Gas industry, we would have expected an even stronger rebound in the FRAK if things would be as rosy as the market currently prices for the industry – especially in HY. It is as if equity investors into Unconventional Oil & Gas are becoming more doubtful about the sector’s overall financial sustainability – which is now affecting equities’ valuation in the sector. We expect this trend to continue and accelerate going forward.

Furthermore, a look at the most important components of the MVIS Unconventional Oil & Gas Index shows us that the industry’s fundamentals are still far from appealing. More specifically, financial ratios of the largest holdings of the FRAK ETF show that despite bond spreads coming back to their pre-covid levels, most key financial ratios have continued to deteriorate this past quarter. A case in point is Cenovus Energy, a Canadian oil sands company, which saw an increase in its financing cost (WACC) this past quarter amid difficulties and growing reputational risks associated to the financing of Alberta’s Oil & Gas activities.

Finally, some companies in the sector are trying to burnish their reputations by launching experimental GHG-reducing initiatives such as Occidental Petroleum – but these are still mostly window-dressing for companies whose operations remain firmly anchored in oil drilling. We don’t’ think that drillers will derive a significant part of their revenues from carbon capture anytime soon.

Electric vehicles companies have had a rough start of 2021. The sector is in “bear market” territory, having corrected more than 20% since its peak mid-January. After the incredible year EV stocks had in 2020, it was bound to happen. To put the correction in context, an investor who would have bought NIO (NIO US) in January 2020 would still be up more than 1,000% as of today.

Not all EV stocks are nosediving, though. Volkswagen (VOW GR) was upgraded this week by some analysts who saw the full potential of VW’s new EV lines, ID.3 and ID.4, resulting in the stock being up 24% on the year. Long-time readers of ours know how bullish we are on VW precisely for its EV growth potential. If Tesla is the Apple of EVs, Volkswagen is its Samsung – cheaper, bigger total addressable market, and still a very high-quality product.

But what will determine who wins or loses the race to become the next Tesla will entirely depend on who comes on top in the Chinese market. By far, China is and will be the most important market for electric vehicles due to a few reasons. First of all, China already accounts for more than 40% of global EV sales (1.3M EVs sold in China in 2020 out of 3.2M globally) and the sheer size of the automotive market in China means that a company with any significant market share of the Chinese market is automatically a global leader.

 

Secondly, China imports two thirds of the oil they consume, and they hate it. There is only one path to energy independence for China and it heavily relies on the fast dissemination of EVs. Thirdly, the air pollution is still a problem that they need to address as it has important health and economic consequences. To promote EVs, the Chinese government offers license plates for free in a country where it can take months, if not years, to obtain the right for a license plate for a regular car. Finally, Beijing set aggressive targets for itself regarding EVs (one in every five new cars hitting the country’s roads to be either purely electric, hybrid or fuel-cell powered by 2025) and carbon neutrality (net-zero commitment by 2060) – and so far they seem serious about achieving them.

Objectively speaking, Tesla (TSLA US) has everything going in its favor to remain market leader in China. After all, they are currently selling the most EVs (premium segment), its gigafactory in Shanghai is operating at full capacity, and the company’s finances are solid and able to withstand greater market swings than local competitors. However, Tesla is the only foreign-owned manufacturing company in China without a local joint venture partner. Historically, China favored the JV model, especially when it comes to foreign companies in the tech sector – which is arguably the case for Tesla. Notably, Tesla generates loads of data that feeds its AI algorithm and China is known to be protective of any data on its citizen. If past behavior is indicative of future behavior, Tesla could be slowed down in their growth in China either through regulations, or even consumer preferences once the local competition is up to par. In fact, signs of interference may have already started to appear. Last month, five Chinese regulators summoned Tesla over quality and safety issues at its plant – a measure that seemed excessive to industry observers.

Volkswagen took the more traditional way to enter the Chinese EV market by investing €2 billion in two separate deals – one with JAC Motors and the other with Guoxuan High-tech Co Ltd, a maker of electric vehicle batteries. The VW approach might be the less risky strategy in the circumstances.

In terms of domestic Chinese pure play companies, four companies stand out for their unique strategies.

In the past year, the Chinese EV market has already seen a significant consolidation, with hundreds of start-ups having either been acquired or disappeared. Li Auto and Xpeng are the most vulnerable of the remaining “Big Four” having a more fragile cash position but the anticipated growth and strong financial backers should help during the transition to profitability.

The fact that Xpeng is more advanced when it comes to autonomous driving is a considerable advantage considering the anticipated growth in that market. Xpeng will release a model in 2021 that will be equipped with LiDAR, which is a technology that significantly improves the vehicle’s high-precision object recognition performance. Li Auto and NIO’s strategy to overcome the lack of charging infrastructure by either providing a battery swap service (NIO) or a gas engine that can generate additional power (Li Auto) seems overkill for what is likely to be a temporary problem, considering the infrastructure investments the Chinese government is currently doing in the electrification space (82% of all publicly accessible fast chargers in the world are already in China).

Morgan Stanley released a report last week to help investors properly value environmentally themed stocks. It revealed that the most common question it has received over the past month is whether a ‘green bubble’ has formed.

This past year was all about the color green. From renewable energy to EVs, all 50 shades of green saw a massive hike in valuations. In fact, according to Morgan Stanley’s report, a basket of green stocks saw their price-to-earnings ratios increase by an average of 24 points over 2020, compared with two points for sector peers.

In our note “ESG discounts in emerging markets” (October 29, 2020), we suggested to investors who thought that green investments in DMs were too “bubbly” to look down south for green opportunities in EMs. This week, we suggest an alternative approach: changing your color palette from green to blue.

From the graph above, one can see that the decoupling between the performance of green, blue and the general market indicators happened since the rebound following the COVID flash crash. The very nascent correction observed in the green sectors these past couple of weeks has also not been observed in the Blue Economy sectors. In our opinion, this is the perfect time to for ESG-minded investors to reallocate some of the profits from green investments towards blue ones.

But first, let us define what we mean by Blue Economy, as its definition can be as wide and deep as the oceans themselves. The Asian Development Bank’s taxonomy for the sector is probably one of the most complete out there.

The segments represent different investable industries related to the oceans and the services they provide.

According to the OECD, the ocean economy is projected to double and reach USD 3 trillion by 2030. Moreover, the required investments to make the Blue Economy more sustainable are even greater than the land-based ones, as of the 17 UN Sustainable Development Goals, SDG14 on the conservation and sustainable use of the ocean and its resources attracts the lowest share of investment (3.5%). With the increased realization that more needs to be done to ensure the sustainability of the water resource in particular and the oceans in general, the growth opportunities for ESG-minded investors are extremely attractive.

A few segments are particularly attractive right now. Aquaculture, and its corollary Seafood Processing, is definitely the hottest theme of the space as it drives on demographic drivers to feed a growing population. The WWF estimates that more than USD 3 billion people depend on seafood as their main source of protein. As the state of global fisheries is very dire, all hopes are focused on aquaculture to feed this large part of the human population. Listed companies like Mowi (MOWI NO), the leader in the space with 25 to 30% of the trout and salmon markets, is often touted to be a sustainable leader in this space. Aquaculture is, however, not without its challenges as it suffers from the same issues as industrial farming, namely overcapacity, animal welfare, and over-reliance on chemicals to combat diseases – in this case sea lice. Moreover, environmentalists often criticized aquaculture to be detrimental to local ecosystems with fish excrement concentration as well as inducing genetic degeneration in wild populations when farmed fish escape. Another Norwegian company, Atlantic Sapphire (ASA NO) is one of the few listed companies working on recirculating aquaculture systems (RAS), which offers a way to do land-based fish farming – a more sustainable method as fish are farmed closer to centers of demand, reducing the incidence of sea lice and contamination with wild populations. Aquaculture is definitely an attractive opportunity for investors as the market is expected to grow to USD 245 billion by 2027, but they should proceed with care as this space is not free from potentially large environmental risks.

Algaculture, or seaweed farming, is the next big thing in the Blue Economy, if not destined to be the top. The global Seaweed market has been estimated at USD 13 billion in 2019 and expected to grow to USD 23 billion by 2027. Final use is the most important aspect as seaweed has the potential to be a strong sustainable substitute to many existing industrial processes in consumer staples to create more eco-friendly products. This is especially relevant for direct substitute in Agriculture Fertilizers, Animals Feeds, and Bioplastics, whilst Cosmetics and Pharmaceuticals have their own direct needs for seaweed properties. Furthermore, seaweed farms are carbon negative as seaweed acts as a carbon sink. The space is mostly now in a Private Equity / Start-up stage although DuPont (DD US) has a seaweed businessv that can be a listed equity play. The space should, however, stay on any ESG investor’s radar because of its strong economic and environmental potential.

Offshore Wind is one of the big investment opportunities as it has its part to play in the energy transition, expecting to deliver 61 GW of energy by 2025. Moreover, it also has a lot of geopolitical strategical importance as it can help coastal countries strive towards energy independence. Germany, China and the UK are some of the leading country in the matter whilst South Korea just announced the Biggest Offshore Wind Infrastructure plans estimated at USD 43 bn. Ørsted (ORSTED DC) is the poster child in the theme and for the energy transition, having almost completely shifted its oil business to renewables. Vestas Wind (VWS DC) is a second play whilst BP (BP/ LN) just got in the game with a 3 GW project in the Irish Sea.

From an investment universe perspective, and beyond the deep value potential we just covered, Ocean Equities are an investment universe already composed of profitable and rewarding companies.

On a portfolio construction perspective, these different segments and stocks can make a diversified stand-alone allocation with its own risk-return characteristics. The SMS Basket of 29 Ocean Equity Stocks achieved an annualized over-performance of 3.7% to the MSCI World over 5 years, a reduction in annualized volatility of 1.8% and a negative correlation of -2.89%. The space has therefore the potential to deliver performance and diversification to any kind of portfolio when considered together.

 

Municipal bonds in the United States are typically non-taxable. The economic logic for exemption is that it encourages investments in projects that benefit the collectivity. There is an ongoing debate as to the usefulness of the tax-exempt status of municipal bonds. Detractors argue that most of the benefits associated to tax-exempt muni bond issues go to the rich living in high income tax states with little left to the issuer.

As the global consensus evolves towards fighting climate change aggressively and the need for greater community-level involvement, many countries could get inspiration from the municipal bond market in the United States. For now, ESG investors looking to support impact projects can easily build a diversified portfolio in line with their desired credit and duration characteristics.

The table below details this week’s list of issuers with more than 100 million to finance. Most of the bonds issued have maturities that span the next 20 years making portfolio construction flexible.

To establish if investments have a positive impact, we have found the Impact Management Project methodology very useful and intuitive. The Impact Management Project is a forum for building global consensus on how to measure and manage impact and has contributors across the spectrum of the ESG community. It proposes an approach that focuses on the 17 Sustainable Development Goal of the United Nations and their 169 targets for 2030.

The first step of the methodolgy is to identify the impact and determining if it is important (What). The second step is to determine if the recipient is underserved (Who) then the goal is to measure the size of the effect and the duration (How much) and finally to see if the effect would have happened anyway (Contribution) and the risk if it does not happen (Risk).

The next step is to determine the degree to which there is an impact.

Using this approach, we have developped a star-system with the most impactful investments receiving 5 stars and the least impactful receiving no star.

We have applied this system to the largest non-taxable issuers for this week and have found that 7 of 13 received 5 stars meaning they have a significant impact and another 3 received 4 stars.

For example, our analysis shows that Regional Transportation District of Colorado – which is issuing USD 298 millions worth of green bonds (climate bond certified) merits the 5-star classification from our rating system. Its issuance supports SDG 11.2 that aims to provide access to safe, affordable, accessible and sustainable transport for all and improve road safety. Here again, the issuer’s operations have a positive  impact on SDG 7.2 which seeks to increase substantially the share of renewable energy in the global energy mix with the Electric Free Mall Ride Shuttles that uses batteries and regenerative braking. Finally, the issuer’s activities also impacts 6.3 which pertains to the improvement of water quality by reducing pollution and reducing untreated wastewater with its stormwater management program.

For the sake of simplicity, we have concentrated our analysis on one week of issuance using the largest non-taxable issuers. We have found that a portfolio using only 4-stars and 5-stars issuers covers 6 of the 17 SDG and can meet the needs of most investors with advantageous tax treatment. With that in mind, a US taxable ESG investor can build a truly diversified portfolio simply by participating in the most impactful municipal issuances.

Interestingly, while we often hear that the United States is behind the curve in terms of ESG compared to Europe, the tax-exempt muni market provides an interesting opportunity for taxable investors. As a result, when it comes to fixed income for taxable individuals, the U.S. muni market has a variety of solutions that do not exist elsewhere for ESG-minded investors.

With the Biden administration looking to pass its large stimulus plan that would shore up the finance of states and the administration intent on fighting climate change, we expect to see significant issuance with positive impact characteristics.

For those looking to achieve impact and earn extra return, allocating a greater share of their fixed income (FI) portfolio to supranational paper could make sense. As it happens, the fallout of the global COVID crisis will likely generate massive lending from supranational institutions such as the IBRD (World Bank), EBRD (European Bank for Reconstruction and Development), IDB (InterAmerican Development Bank), and other International Financial Institutions (IFIs) – which also happen to specialize in impact lending for developing countries.

As a reminder, these institutions typically attach strings to the loans they make to governments enticing their sovereign clients to make progress in areas such as health care, education, and climate change. As a result, supranational bonds offer an interesting way of leveraging IFI impact frameworks towards measurable results while improving and diversifying your overall bond portfolio. More importantly, as the COVID crisis will likely linger in several of the world’s poorest nations, financial lifelines from IFIs will become even more important to sustain the fight against the virus and its economic repercussions.

One interesting class of bonds we have identified back in 2018 (see our note “World Bank bonds: A “macro” impact Opportunity”, October 10th, 2018) were IBRD (World Bank) bonds. Overall, the Bloomberg Barclays World Bank Global Aggregate Index has outperformed USTs since 2012, with 300+ bps of outperformance on an aggregate, total return basis. With 10-year USTs trading below 1% amid aggressive QE operations from the Fed, such an outperformance could continue to benefit even the most conservative bond portfolios.

Looking at duration, World Bank bonds started to display a lower duration than their USTs equivalents before the COVID crisis. When the Fed starts to normalize its policy, one can expect WB bonds to become interesting once again from a duration perspective.

Interestingly, the spread between both indices compressed substantially until March 2020, time at which the Fed reignited its QE purchases. While the spread increased significantly these past few months, we would expect it to resume its path towards zero as an increasing amount of impact and search-for-yield investors increase their allocation to IBRD paper in the coming months and years and the Fed starts to reduce its monthly purchases of USTs.

Impact investors’ effect on the IBRD yield curve and spreads against USTs is especially visible if one considers the change in IBRD/UST spreads at every maturity. One could also expect that the IBRD yield curve spread will continue to compress given the relative health of the IBRD’s credit outlook versus that of the U.S. Treasury – which has not yet finished to pick up the US fiscal AND COVID policy messes. To this end, IBRD paper is rated at lesser credit risk (AAA) than the USTs (AA+) while the institution’s balance sheet is solidly diversified and backstopped by the Banks’s contributing members.

Many market participants have entered the IBRD Green bond market. The institution increased its green bond issuance program these past few years and we expect those trends to continue in 2021. While many Green bonds displayed even more spread compression against their comparable non-green issues given strong demand and limited offer, the “greenium” mostly disappeared in FI markets these past few months.

Looking ahead, we expect the liquidity on IBRD benchmark bonds to increase as the World Bank increases its own lending to its developing country clients post-COVID. Moreover, an increasing number of search-for-yield and impact investors will continue to enter the supranational market, which should help reduce bid-ask spreads of IBRD paper and make IBRD bonds a staple holding within diversified portfolios. Finally, the recent reflation trade and growing inflation expectations in the U.S. should also signal that U.S. bond yield have perhaps touched the bottom these past few weeks.