It is becoming increasingly well known that if we are to limit global warming, significant reform of the agriculture industry is necessary.
Much of the focus on food reform is about animal-sourced protein, since the rearing of livestock generates 14 per cent of all greenhouse gas emissions, similar to the amount generated by all cars and trucks worldwide.
It is easy to understand the problem of meat: it is an environmentally expensive food since large animals are inefficient at converting feed to muscle, meaning they make large demands for cropland, water, and fertilizers. An improvement in agricultural practices could help, but the enormity of the problem – meat and dairy provide just 18% of calories consumed but use 83% of global farmland and make 60% of agriculture’s greenhouse gas emissions – mean that simply tweaking current processes will not be enough.
The solution – to eat less meat – also seems relatively simple. Unfortunately, as with many climate change problems, humans’ hardwiring makes it complex in practice. Human psychological biases and behavioral tendencies – such as preferring things stay the same (continuing to frequent the same stores and restaurants), avoiding things that are difficult (learning to cook with new ingredients), and discounting the future (giving up something today for a better future tomorrow) – mean that convincing people to reduce animal consumption is difficult.
For all the above reasons, we expect that the transition to a lower meat diet, although necessary, will take time. After all, those that are trying to reduce meat consumption are overwhelmingly driven by personal reasons (e.g. health and financial savings) rather than the environment.
A wholesale turn-away from meat is likely to occur only once meat-like alternatives become tastefully acceptable; environmental factors won’t trigger a significant shift toward vegetarianism. On this basis, the quest for a lower environmental footprint protein can be divided into three distinct groups: ‘Meat Is Meat’, ‘Vegetables As Protein’ and ‘Plant-based Meat Substitutes’.
‘Meat is Meat’
Meat lovers have the greatest resistance to lowering their steak intake: substituting a non-animal protein will only happen if high sensory standards were met on taste, look and texture. To achieve the meaty taste without the animal requires significant R&D. Many companies therefore look more like tech start-ups than food companies as they use AI, 3D Printing and biotechnology to develop their products. AI can be leveraged to find flavour combinations and plant proteins to replicate the taste; 3D printing can help achieve the look, but cell-based production will be the closest to the real deal.
Lab-grown meat is cultivated from cells taken from an animal and then grown into the fat or muscle people like to eat. The result is a product composed of the same proteins and cells as the animal of origin but requiring significantly less resources to grow it. While there are many companies exploring these technologies, the majority are privately owned, a testament to the remaining challenges of scalability and cost. Small-cap players like Agronomics, MeaTech 3D and Bio Meat Foodtech are publicly traded. As the chart shows, the first two names have not seen any price appreciation in their stock while Bio Meat has had a fantastic post IPO run-up but appears about to return to earth. A larger name to watch is Amyris Inc.: while not a pure food play, the biotech company has recently signed a joint venture with Minerva Foods to explore more sustainable protein sources.
‘Vegetables As Protein’
At the other end of the spectrum are steadfast vegetarians and vegans. These dietary movements were around long before alt-meat and self-identified vegetarians do not necessarily require protein to resemble meat; unprocessed peas, beans, lentils, quinoa, tempeh, tofu, etc. are acceptable alternatives. Vegans and vegetarians also tend to have more produce in their diets. The denser texture of mushrooms, avocados and eggplants act as substitutes and Calavo Growers, Mission Produce and Yukiguni Maitake Co Ltd are recognized to fill this market.
However, it is challenging to find a strictly vegetarian investment opportunity: many of the companies growing produce and crops are small or private. There is often a direct link to the traditional meat industry since a significant portion of their yield is also sold as feed for livestock.
Demand for unprocessed vegetarian staple foods is expected to continue to grow somewhat as people try to lower their consumption of animal products. However, the greatest potential for demand increase will be from alternative meat producers using these plant-based proteins as ingredients in their products.
‘Plant-based Meat Substitutes (Flexitarians)’
Despite the relatively static share of strict vegetarians and vegans, it is an undeniable question that consumers seek alternatives to meat. They want simple changes to their diet that can be easily substituted in their existing recipe repertoire and restaurant options. Companies – whether it be food producers or restaurants – that can offer products that are healthier with little friction to the consumer will have a winning formula.
The leaders in plant-based meat substitutes – Beyond Meat and Impossible Foods – are young companies in a fledgling industry. Beyond Meat IPO’d in May 2019, while Impossible Foods is expected to go public later this year.
There has been a lot of hype around plant-based substitutes (Bill Gates is a major promoter and investor in the industry). The health benefits of eating green and the major environmental problems that need to be overcome in the agricultural industry are well known and these companies offer a solution to both. However, sales of plant-based products have not fulfilled expectations of late. U.S. retail sales of plant-based meats in 2021 Q3 were 3% lower than in Q3 2020, which is a worrisome sign for an industry that should be in a high-growth phase (sales of conventional meat increased by 4% over the same period).
Despite recent disappointing sales, we do agree with Bill Gates that plant-based substitutes are an important innovation and will be part of the solution to replace environmentally inefficient protein sources (conventional meat). However, investing in this sector is not for the faint-hearted. We note several risks that make it difficult to decipher which companies will be long-term winners in this sector:
- Competition from incumbents: Realizing the growing demand for plant-based products, several traditional food conglomerates and meat producers are making their own alternatives. Kellogg’s, Maple Leaf Farms, Nestle, Tyson, Smithfield, Perdue and Hormel have all rolled out meat alternatives over the past few years and already have well-established distribution channels compared to the start-ups in the industry.
- The commoditization of plant-based meat substitutes might be inevitable: plant-based meat is a basic consumer good. They are made of basic, low-priced ingredients and are likely to be replicable. Already, restaurants like Chipotle are producing in-house products rather than relying on third-party brands like Beyond Meat and Impossible Foods.
- Complex choice matrix for restaurant-goers: Both Impossible Food and Beyond Meat have teamed up with restaurant chains to help consumers become familiar with their products. While this may help consumers try new foods in the short term, it complexifies choices. Consumers looking for meat substitutes must choose a restaurant brand AND choose an alternative meat brand. This reinforces the argument that restaurants are likely to develop in-house meat substitutes.
- Confounding plant-based and healthy: The majority of people that are giving up meat do it for health reasons (see chart above), so it is crucial that the industry lives up to its claim that plant-based meat substitutes are a healthier option. These substitutes, which are known to be highly processed and by design do not resemble their underlying ingredients, compete with other food fads like the desire for wholesome, natural products.
- Adoption is slow: The early buzz created by the launch of products in 2019 certainly drew curiosity and first-time experiences with meat substitutes. However, earnings expectations for companies like Beyond Meat appear to be constructed by simply extrapolating the torrid growth trends of the industry’s initial years (sales of plant-based meat grew by 72% from 2018 to 2020). Indeed, there is an expectation that plant-based meat market will follow the growth experience of plant-based milks. The latter currently accounts for 15% of all sales of U.S. milk. Should plant-based meats reach the same level of market share, this opportunity is worth $14 billion. In 2022, a major issue for investors will be understanding prospects for plant-based substitutes to become a regular part of household diets.
There is no doubt that Omicron is different from its earlier COVID cousins (more transmissible, more resilient to current vaccines). Yet to the untrained eye, an atom of Omicron or Delta is completely indistinguishable. In a similar fashion, although outcomes will surely be different, the investment outlook for 2022 has a lot in common with 2021! After all, many of the major drivers that were in place are relatively unchanged:
- The majority of developed market monetary policymakers around the globe are (still) contemplating the date of a first rate hike, and markets will have to contend with the risk of rising bond yields. Meanwhile in emerging markets, most have already started the process to address inflation.
- Although parts of the U.S. government’s build back better plan have been passed, the Build Back Better Act, which focuses on funding for care and climate change, is (still) stuck.
- Supply chain bottlenecks in various industries are still slowing down the delivery times of various products and services.
- Labor shortages in developed markets are (still) acute in some industries.
- Climate scientists are (still) sounding the alarm on global warming.
All of this means that many of the investment themes identified at Sustainable Market Strategies in 2021 will still be very much in play in 2022.
Most notably, the need to strengthen supply chains in a world where inflation surprises will continue to be to the upside will remain top of mind for investors (please see our Note on November 25, 2021, Inflation Is An ESG Phenomenon).
Reducing carbon emissions remains as critical as ever, but one theme that we expect will become more prominent in 2022 is biodiversity and the need to protect (and invest) in natural capital. The UN COP Biodiversity is scheduled to be held in person in April 2022 with the stated aim of elevating the protection of biodiversity to the same level of importance as climate. Additionally, while you may have heard of the Taskforce on Climate Change Disclosure (TCFD), the Taskforce for Nature Disclosure (TNFD) was launched this June with the goal of encouraging global financial flows toward nature-positive outcomes. We anticipate that these developments will help to sharpen investors’ focus around environmental risks and opportunities and that investment diversification beyond the “energy transition” will intensify in the coming months.
We kick off 2022 with a list of our high conviction investment ideas, with a particular eye on investments that deliver diversification benefits and can offer a hedge against inflation. Many of our recommendations are environment-based as there is a greater likelihood that capital will be allocated to the sector in coming months. However, no ESG investment list would be complete without addressing “washing”, i.e. paying lip-service to a cause with no discernable positive impact. Our top 2022 short ideas emanate from companies that have run afowl to this practice.
Idea #1: Transition Metals: Long Recyclers and Strong ESG-minded Miners
Long-time readers of our work will note that we have been recommending positions in transition metals for quite some time but our conviction that a structural overweight allocation to these metals will be profitable is too high to ignore on our list for 2022. Our view was even reinforced late last year by recent IMF research that showed copper, nickel, cobalt and lithium prices could rise several hundred percent (!) compared to their average 2020 levels in a net-zero emissions scenario.
After an impressive price run-up in the past year among some battery materials, the consensus is for flat to weaker prices in 2022 on account of additional supply that is forecasted to come on-line for copper and nickel: miners are expected to ramp up production. That said, bottlenecks are ongoing and even after the impressive increase in 2021, both copper and nickel prices are still below their ten-year peak (established well before the EV market was really born). Any pull back in these commodity prices should serve as an entry point to structural long positions.
Commodities are well known to be an effective inflation hedge. Of course, the relationship between oil prices and inflation will be challenged as the energy transition progresses, but the high correlation between industrial metals – especially those that are also considered transition metals (e.g. copper, nickel) and inflation is likely to stay in place. For investors concerned about upside inflation surprises, an overweight position to transition metals should be especially appealing.
At this stage, investing in other battery materials still broadly requires investing in the companies that mine and/or recycle them. Cobalt and lithium contracts have been introduced to both the LME and CME metal exchanges – the former enforces responsible sourcing requirements – but volumes are still low (albeit rising, see Chart) and are dominated by industrial players that are hedging their physical needs. Investors might rightly worry about the nefarious environmental and social impact of extracting these metals: our analysis identified indicators to help discriminate among mining companies (please see our note ‘Transition Metals: Wicked Problems, Smart Solutions’ on October 14, 2021). Our favourite transition metal plays are Umicore, Boliden and increasingly, Rio Tinto.
Idea #2: A Mighty Link In the Supply Chain: Long distribution warehouses (Prologis, Duke, STAG)
Real Estate investments are often seen as a go to for investors seeking inflation protection, given their reputation for high dividend yields and the capacity to increase rent in accordance with generalized price rises. However, desirable options in the REITs space are increasingly limited: the future of retail was already under question even before the pandemic tailwinds for e-commerce arrived and REITs in the hotel and office industries look less attractive. Competing strongly for hotel’s market share prior to 2020, private property rentals via Airbnb and Vrbo were the preferred accommodation for pandemic travellers seeking socially distanced time off. Office real estate is unlikely to fully recover as some offices will become obsolete and many are likely to downsize their current spaces as employees have adapted to working from home.
Opportunities in the industrial REITs sector via warehouses and distribution centers can offer the benefits of inflation protection while also helping improve supply chain resiliency, one of our six investable ESG themes at SMS. Investors interested in this sector should look for REITs that focus on warehouses and distribution centers that are efficient in their internal operations and also lower the distance goods travel from warehouse to consumer, therefore reducing the carbon footprint of delivery.
We recommend three names that fit these criteria: Prologis, Duke Realty and STAG Industrial. Prologis is the largest, operating in 19 countries with 4675 facilities. Duke Realty and STAG Industrial are U.S.-based but are well diversified with over 500 buildings each. Each of these three REITs ranks above their peers in CSRHub consensus ESG ratings, with Prologis having the strongest showing. This suggests they are already well placed for the transition to a high care, low carbon economy.
As supply chain issues continue in early 2022 due to the Omicron variant, we expect these companies, with their diversified locations, to be better positioned to face these challenges. Regardless of the next chapter in the pandemic chronicles, these REITs can be expected to benefit from consumers’ continued enthusiasm for at-home delivery.
Idea #3: Seeing the Forest and The Trees: Long Holmen, SCA and Weyerhaeuser
As mentioned above, we anticipate that investable opportunities for the environment will go beyond the energy transition in 2022. In a Note last year (Knock on wood, May 20, 2021), we concluded that while higher lumber prices were giving a boost to some lumber companies, the forest was the real asset: “If we look at the forest instead of the trees, the recent rise in lumber is a short-term boost to profitability for companies that produce lumber, but the long-term value will be derived in forestry and the ownership of trees”. The importance that Holmen and SCA (Svenska Cellulosa Aktibolaget) and Weherhaueser place on their forests is the reason they are included in our top ideas for 2022.
SCA is Europe’s largest private forest owner, with 2.6 million hectares of woods. Holmen counts 1.2 million hectares. Both Swedish companies, Holmen and SCA are committed to managing their forests in a sustainable manner with biodiversity as an important element in their processes. Both companies boast environmentally certified forests and have dedicated conservation areas - more than 20% for Holmen and 10% for SCA. Maximizing the use of resources by using every component of the trees that are harvested is another commitment common to both. Weyerhaueser operates on a similar basis in North America.
Aside from their sustainable approaches to forestry management, the increasing demand for more nature-based solutions also makes this an appealing investment. Trees offer eco-friendly building materials, emitting less carbon than cement or steel; and despite the fading print industry, paper is reinventing itself in sustainable packaging.
One caveat is the potential for regulation in Europe. In July 2021, the EU announced its revised forest strategy, with the aim to increase “the quantity and quality of forests” and “increase carbon sequestration through enhanced sinks and stocks”. For companies like SCA and Holmen that are both built on the thesis that healthy forests are ones that are actively managed, any new regulations that go against this principle could temper their operations. Overall, we expect the financial value of standing tree forests to increase over time and SCA and Holmen are particularly well suited to capitalize on this trend, given their long history in sustainable forestry management.
Idea #4: Emerging Asset Class and Diversifier: Long Carbon ETF (KRBN)
Well-functioning carbon markets are widely considered as essential to reach the globally agreed upon target of limiting the earth’s temperature rise to 1.5 °C. It has been well over a decade since the inception of the first carbon markets, but the concept of buying and selling emission credits has finally taken off: the traded value of the three major programmes exceeds $250 billion.
Now that carbon has proven itself as a liquid and investable asset class (over $1 billion per day is traded across physical carbon, futures and options), we expect investors to be increasingly attracted to this emerging asset class for two main reasons:
- Diversification: Carbon has exhibited low correlation with other asset classes. Most interestingly, carbon has a low correlation with other commodities.
- Potential returns: Although the price of carbon increased considerably on all the major emissions exchanges, carbon prices still remain significantly below what is considered consistent with Paris Agreement goals. As such, carbon prices will likely rise significantly. Academics at Carbon Cap estimate a prospective risk premium of 6% to 12%, based on a 2% risk-free rate.
The Kraneshare Global Carbon ETF (KRBN) tracks the most traded carbon credit futures contracts and covers the major European and North American cap-and-trade programs: European Union Allowances (EUA), California Carbon Allowances (CCA) and the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative. Long positions in this ETF or similar product should be a core holding in a diversified portfolio.
2021 was another bumper year for investors (S&P 500 up 25%) following never seen before stimulus from central banks and fiscal purses. In this context, it was hard for active investors to beat the market. As a result, ESG-minded investors – who got a great ride post-COVID by investing in emerging themes such as EVs and clean energy in 2020 – found it much harder to achieve high returns again this year. Indeed, some could say that some investors were forced into “unknown territory” by looking for investment ideas in a wider array of ESG themes.
This year, our short calls demonstrated that one can indeed generate returns not only by taking long positions in ESG megatrends, but also by shorting themes, sectors and names that will fall out of favor given the changing global investing landscape. In this context, we’ve managed to articulate several short ideas which in all represented about 1/3 of our calls this past year.
Show me your themes: SMS goes thematic
Furthermore, one key development at our firm this past year was the creation of our proprietary thematic research structure. For this, we’ve mapped our investment universe according to global, top down, ESG megatrends. These are also the themes that we are seeing being implemented by some of the world’s most advanced and innovative ESG investors.

In this context, it is worthwhile to measure the performance of our research against this thematic architecture. For starters, our overall average of long/short calls yielded 5.6% (on average) this year, a relatively modest performance compared to the overall market. That being said, SMS’ strives to inform its clients on both “long” and “short” opportunities in companies, sectors, and commodities according to their alignment with ESG megatrends – which we see as being one of the key differentiators of our research offering.
Interestingly, even our short positions displayed some positive price performance (4.7%, on average) amid a market that has tested the nerves of short sellers like never before. However, given the outperformance of the global Energy sector – in particular that of oil and coal companies’ stocks - our short calls under the Energy Transition theme have suffered from rapidly growing post-COVID demand for energy.
Looking at our performance in a more granular fashion using SMS’ Level 2 themes, one sees that our long/short performance is in the red under a few of our subthemes - including water management. The latter can be explained by our long position in Autodesk – a firm which is producing water management software (among other things) – which got hard hit by markets when it reported disappointing earnings last month.
Digging deeper, some of our short calls were right but their timing proved quite difficult, which is often the case when shorting – especially on ESG-related concerns. A case in point is our short call on the generic front-month lumber contract (See our note, “Knock on Wood,” June 20, 2021), for which the price doubled in the past six months, suggesting that we had prematurely called the top in wood prices earlier this year.
Top themes of the year: Labor Fairness and Energy Transition
Labor fairness: Among our most out-of-the-box calls of the year is our short position on food delivery companies (see our note, “Working Class Hero,” April 4, 2021) – DoorDash, Deliveroo, Uber, and others. Our recommendation to short these companies is motivated by the idea that they actually “make money” (although none has profits yet) by underpaying staff – mostly for-hire delivery people with zero social protection – to use their own bikes and e-bikes to criss-cross cities around the world and put themselves (and others) at a high risk of injury on the job. We view such business models as being unsustainable in the medium term – hence our short on the sector.
That said, we were not surprised earlier this week when the EU commission mentioned that it was looking to regulate the delivery industry in an effort to formalize workers’ contracts - forcing those companies to consider them as employees as opposed to contractors. Stock prices in the sector fell subsequently, further pushing our short call into profit territory and with it our investment thesis.
Energy Transition: Within our Energy transition theme, the most interesting calls of the year were on the Carbon ETF (KRBN) and Cameco (CCO CN, uranium) on the long side, and Peabody Energy (BTU), a pure-play coal producer, on the short side.
Carbon has been one of the best-performing commodities again this year. Adding fuel to the fire was the announcement last week that Germany’s incoming government would not let the EU carbon emission right fall below EUR 60 per tonne. This sent benchmark EU carbon contracts trading at above EUR 80 per tonne briefly last week. We view carbon emission rights as a play which will only increase in value through time (actually it is the only way the carbon market can work, i.e., higher price to pollute for emitters!) and one where the energy transition can be accelerated by increasing carbon emission prices.
Our call that uranium producers, nuclear power servicers and utilities could benefit from another leg up in the need for clean energy ahead of COP26 in Glascow was the right one (see our note “An ESG Investor’s Dilemma: Divesting from fossil fuels in times of high prices,” October 28, 2021). Indeed, while nuclear and related industries were seen with a negative eye in the 1980s and after the Fukushima nuclear disaster due to the risk of large-scale accidents, sentiment has turned and it is increasingly understood that the world has little choice but to rely on the nuclear industry more heavily to accelerate the clean-up of energy grids in Europe, Japan and the U.S. For this, we believe the sector will continue to benefit from tailwinds from both governments and consumer appetite for cleaner energy systems over the medium term.
This year we also witnessed the global resurgence of coal prices (see our note “Coal’s last dance,” July 29, 2021) – but not the coal industry. This was mostly due to a diplomatic feud between China and Australia – the biggest players in the global coal trade – and a particularly hot summer in the U.S. which forced a greater use of coal to power the national grid.
Here, SMS suggested to short coal a bit too early in late August only to see its position being crushed by the market in the following three months due to the energy demand shock. That said, we think that coal’s death has not been overexaggerated and that the industry will fade at an accelerated pace, at least as a source of power in developed economies.
Finally, again within the Energy transition theme, our favorite transition pair fared poorly as oil prices doubled this past year. That said, we would expect Total Énergies to outperform Exxon over the longer run when oil prices start resuming to a lower level.
Who hasn’t wondered at least once about the pricing mystery of dollar stores? The news last month that the inevitable has finally occurred: the last of the discount chain stores, Dollar Tree, has announced raising prices above $1. This shouldn’t come as a surprise in the current inflationary backdrop. However, it should have investors wondering how these companies can continually deliver above-average returns to shareholders while maintaining bargain basement prices. This week’s report analyzes the discount store model, with particular focus on the major North American dollar store chains: Dollarama, Dollar General, Dollar Tree and Family Dollar (acquired by Dollar Tree in 2015). We resolutely come out in disfavour of these stores on account of several alarming E, S and G behaviours. From a stock price perspective, macroeconomic forces will move from being a strong tailwind to being a slight headwind to this group of companies in the months ahead.
Socioeconomics and Dollar Stores
Households who have seen their financial situation become increasingly precarious during the pandemic have been a windfall for dollar stores. Close to 60% of the customer base at dollar stores is made up of families with household income under $50,000; since the economic hardship of the past two pandemic years was borne primarily by lower income families, shopping at dollar stores has ballooned.
Indeed, this has been reflected in the equity prices of North American dollar store companies, which have had a strong run-up in the past two years.
Although dollar stores have become a near-term fix for many, from a long-term investment, they leave much to be desired. First, dollar stores have become highly concentrated in many geographic areas causing detriment to communities and calling into question the potential for further growth. Second, the quality and toxicity of certain products have created significant reputational risk given the potential harm to human life. Finally, poor labour conditions imply that in a tight labour market, staffing will become a major problem to the business model.
New Store Openings: Expansion Meets Regulation
Dollar stores are everywhere in North America. As of August 2021, there were more than 34,000 dollar stores in the U.S. alone, which is more than the number of Walmart, Starbucks, and McDonald’s combined. According to a recent survey, 75% of Americans live within 5 miles of a Dollar General store, whereas only 60% live at the same distance from a hospital. In rural communities, where access to goods and services is often limited, dollar stores sometimes represent the sole choice for consumers. Dollar stores’ proliferation in small towns and rural areas is in part because these stores are smaller and relatively inexpensive to put in place compared to other supermarkets and retail chains. They tend to have lower operating costs than grocery stores and are run with far fewer staff - all of which helps to keep prices below those of competing stores. Indeed, studies show that once a dollar store opens in low-income communities, sales in nearby grocery stores drop drastically, leading to closures of traditional supermarkets and stores.
As regular grocery stores are deterred from opening, and existing ones are pushed out, it creates communities with limited access to affordable and nutritious food – these are known as “food deserts,” but communities are beginning to act. Recent legislation has been passed in some municipalities to restrict the opening of new discount stores. While these mandates are only in a few geographic pockets in the U.S. so far, the threat and potential for tighter regulations could become a significant restraint on the hectic pace of store openings. In other words, investors expecting a continued increase in market share may be disappointed.
Product Quality: You Get What You Pay For
As describe above, when dollar stores move in, grocers often move out. This means that dollar stores become the de facto supermarket for households, with limited options and access to other stores. However, food offered at dollar stores is notoriously highly processed, having low nutritional quality and toxic chemicals in their packaging. Facing severe criticism, some dollar store chains, like Dollar General, have started to offer fruits and vegetables, albeit as of October 2021, in only 3% of their stores. Here too, regulation is catching up: in Oklahoma City’s Ward 7, discount stores are now required by law to sell fresh foods alongside other fare.
Food quality is not the only problem. Other products from dollar stores can sometimes be counterfeited or defective. Many of the plastic products found in dollar stores contain chemicals that adversely affect health. A report from earlier this year, showed that 60% of products tested from Dollar Tree stores in the U.S. and in Canada contained chemicals like BPA, PFAS, phthalates and lead. Shamefully, it was only after the release of the report that management began taking action to remove some of these harmful products from shelves. It is noteworthy that these problems are far more common in dollar stores than other discount stores and retailers. As shown in the chart below, according to CSRHub product scores, all the major dollar store chains rank below the 50th percentile on product quality compared to retailing peers. Ultimately, the pricing at dollar stores reflects the quality of the goods: nowhere else can shoppers pay so little for household items … and nowhere else in retail is the hazard to human health from products as high.
Labour Conditions: Hardly Enticing
It is perhaps not surprising that dollar store pricing strategies do not leave much room for maneuver in terms of salaries and benefits. Once again, CSRHub scores reveal dollar stores rank very poorly among peers when it comes to compensation. In Canada, since the beginning of the pandemic, workers at Dollarama warehouses have criticized the use of temporary employment agencies. Meanwhile, in the U.S., in response to pressure from workers regarding overtime, Dollar General recently announced intentions to hire 50,000 more workers. However, in the context of the current widespread labour shortage, it is highly dubious whether these stores can recruit, let alone retain, new employees.
Finally, dollar stores are far from immune to the supply chain challenges that the retail sector is facing. In our November 4th Note on retailers, we highlighted that generalist giants like Walmart, Amazon, Target and Costco have superior pricing power throughout the supply chain and are best positioned to negotiate supply chain hurdles. Indeed, on a recent call, Mike Witynski, Dollar Tree’s CEO, admitted that his company’s near-term outlook was particularly sensitive to freight costs and its ability to keep shelves stocked.
It'll Cost More Than a Quarter
Given the above factors, there is perhaps not much of a “pricing mystery” at dollar stores after all. These stores can maintain bargain basement pricing because they aim to operate in monopolistic environments, offer subpar quality products and provide inferior compensation to their workers. No wonder then that even with most items still priced near $1, dollar stores have managed to keep gross profit margins higher than big-box retailers like Walmart and Target, where longer-term strategies include improving employee conditions to retain workers and continued investment in the supply chain.
The U.S. Healthcare System is Massive and so are its Problems
According to the World Health Organization (WHO), the three fundamental objectives of a healthcare system are:
(1) Improve the health of the population it serves
(2) Ensure financial protection against the cost of disease
(3) Respond to people’s expectations (i.e., respect people’s dignity, autonomy, and confidentiality)
Implicit in the first two objectives is a fourth one: equity. Moreover, the 17 Sustainable Development Goals of the United Nations, designed in 2015 to achieve a better and more sustainable future for all, and for which the United States had an important role in the negotiation process, contrasts broadly with the functioning of the U.S. system on the 3rd goal. This goal has the objective of ensuring healthy lives and promoting well-being for all (at all ages) and can hardly be reached without scaling up investment in universal health coverage and providing fair access to all. Therefore, improving the health of the population (i.e., maximizing patient outcomes), while also providing financial protection, means minimizing differences in care among individuals or groups. However, this is not the case at for-profit hospitals. Efforts to provide equitable access to care at these institutions are virtually non-existent. The situation worsened with COVID due to dramatic decreases in healthcare spending as elective procedures got delayed. This impacted disproportionally smaller public providers, already in worse financial shape, further amplifying long-standing inequities in healthcare between private and public hospitals. Such disparities are most common among low-income, working-class communities which tend to also be underinsured or uninsured.
Accounting for over 31% of total health spending and nearly 5.6% of GDP, hospitals are one of the largest industries in the entire U.S. economy. Private hospitals (for-profit and not-for-profit) make up about 81% of this. They are also hugely influential price setters, as well as some of the biggest contributors to healthcare inequality.
At the very heart of the matter is the fact that from a taxation standpoint, health benefits are considered part of compensation, but they do not count as income. This means that both workers and employers do not pay tax on these benefits. As a result, employers are incentivized to provide additional compensation in the form of health benefits in lieu of wage increases. Much of the inefficiencies and waste in U.S. healthcare today are a direct consequence of the tax incentives provided to employers. With employees receiving increasingly greater and more generous health benefits, seemingly for free, they are more inclined to overuse health services, while putting providers in a position to overcharge: the U.S. healthcare system is designed to be wasteful and inequitable.
In addition, to cushion the financial blow of Covid, the federal government poured billions of dollars into hospitals using the Provider Relief Fund, a package of $175 billion. Ironically, this contributed to further consolidation; the funding was disproportionately dispersed, going mostly to the largest and most well-funded hospitals, some of which then used the money to scoop up weakened competitors, including smaller physician practices. For example, Tenet Healthcare, a for-profit provider group which received $500 million in federal aid, announced a $1 billion acquisition of 45 ambulatory surgery centres. Providence, a network of over 50 hospitals, received $1 billion in federal aid and bought two small public hospitals in Northern California in 2020. Frustratingly, industry experts and major employers had both warned that without oversight, bailouts to the healthcare industry, could spur additional consolidation and lead to even higher prices for employers, individuals, and insurers.
Hospital Consolidation
Hospital consolidation is hurting American patients. In the past 20 years, there have been over 1,800 mergers and the share of for-profit hospitals has risen to 24% in 2019, up from 15% in 2000. Additionally, the number of individual hospitals that are now part of a larger hospital system has also risen steadily. The result is that many local communities are now dominated by one large, powerful healthcare provider, operating in a monopolistic environment. In recent years, private equity has started to play a key role in this consolidation. Between 2010 and 2020, the number of deals has increased from 352 to over 900 and they have been worth approximately $750 billion. This is expected to increase sizeably in coming years. The private equity business model, however, is incompatible with an equitable distribution of healthcare; private equity funds are focused on short-term revenue gains, cost-cutting, and profitability, which leads to prioritizing financial gains over quality of care.

Against such a backdrop of rapid consolidation, prices have risen with no commensurate improvement in quality. Access for entire communities has been reduced, especially in cases where hospitals are shut or relocated. Numerous studies have found evidence of higher prices and with no measurable improvement in quality. A 2020 study by MedPAC (The Medicare Payment Advisory Commission) found that mergers between rival hospitals are likely to raise the cost of care and that these effects are larger in super-concentrated markets (markets with one dominant health system). From 2003 to 2017, the share of hospital markets that were highly concentrated increased from 47% to 57%. Additionally, concentrated markets are frequently in poorer communities that have a lower number of physicians per capita.
Consolidation also risks fuelling anti-competitive market practices. As hospitals get larger and acquire further market power, there is an incentive to acquire more market power. For example, there are extensive reports of data blocking (Savage et al., 2019). Data blocking refers to a practice by which large hospitals obstruct the flow of a patients’ medical information to providers outside their network, making it less likely for patients to switch providers since their information doesn’t follow them. With many communities now dominated by one large hospital or health system, there is considerable potential for this type of activity to become pervasive.
Private Insurance Hurts
Hospital consolidation is also linked to insurance premiums that are on average 5% higher than those in less concentrated areas. In places that lacked competitors within a 15-mile radius, prices for employer-sponsored health insurance were 12% higher than markets with four or more competing hospitals. Although health plans may try to keep hospital prices low, health plans’ ability is limited in areas where hospitals have greater market power. Interestingly, studies have also found that these results hold even when looking specifically at non-profit hospitals.
The incentives of private hospitals are straightforward. Private insurers pay more than Medicare and Medicaid, and the gap has been growing. Fifteen years ago, private insurance paid $1.50 for every $1 Medicare paid. In 2018, private insurance was paying almost $2.50 for every $1 that Medicare paid. This is the key driver behind consolidation, and it has helped propel profits and revenue at for-profit hospitals to record levels. In other words, hospitals that cater to more privately insured patients (who are typically healthier and richer) do better financially. This disparity will continue as long as the government continues to underpay for healthcare for the poor, or more likely, until investors force the industry to change.
Unsurprisingly, while smaller facilities struggled financially, the largest for-profit hospital chains like HCA or Tenet had banner years. As we look forward, we know uncontrolled healthcare spending is unsustainable. In addition, social components of responsible investing are turning increasingly relevant for investors. For-profit hospitals have displayed little incentive to contribute to the social ethic of equitable access to healthcare or limiting financial hardship. These businesses continue to contribute massively to an unequal distribution of healthcare in the U.S. We believe this will weigh on for-profit hospitals over the long-term. Although these large hospitals have had a great stock price run-up in recent months and are ripe for a correction, a trigger for a longer-term bear market is currently lacking, making the timing for an outright short in this industry a risky proposition. We recommend that investors stay on the sidelines in U.S. hospitals: the current run-up in prices and profit surge is likely behind us and from a fundamental position, the industry is ripe for an overhaul that will eventually have significant negative consequences for large for-profit hospitals.
As the global population keeps growing and planetary boundaries are being tested, the creation of tools that enhance our well-being is being observed across a spectrum of sectors. Many of these tools rely on the application of new and existing technologies to improve productivity. This week’s note concentrates on how we can assess technologies for productivity enhancement with positive and purposeful intent and highlights which technological applications to avoid.
Productivity enhancing tools will play an important role in transitioning to a low carbon, high care global economy. Alongside the thematic of Productivity with Purpose, we have identified four sub-themes: Data Analytics that includes artificial intelligence and the Internet of Things, Information Sharing that includes the Blockchain and social media, Physical Structure Enhancements that cover 3D printing and industrial robots and lastly, Technology Infrastructure that spans data servers, microchips, 5G-6G and quantum computing. Each of these four areas of technological innovation has the potential to improve our world for the better, if adopted with the right goals in mind.
Our analytical process examines various technological applications and maps them along two dimensions: innovation and purpose. On the innovation axis, we ascertain the extent to which an application is an adaptation of an existing process or whether it is a pure innovation that can revolutionize the way things are currently done. On the purpose axis, we establish the extent to which an application is motivated by profit or by purpose. Technologies – and the companies that champion them – that have high scores on both innovation and purpose should provide for lasting impactful success. The results of our mapping are described below.
In terms of data analytics:
(1) Visualization is the most innovative and can have very purposeful applications in training and performing tasks from a distance. However, there is often a greater focus on addictiveness of gaming as a downside.
(2) AI unsurprisingly ranks highly on innovation and can improve our livelihood by improving decision-making, among other things. On the negative side, AI has been used aggressively for profit in social media with clustering opinion as a side effect.
(3) The Internet of Things has a lot of purposeful endeavour and is somewhat innovative.
(4) Finally, surveillance is not a new idea, placing it lower on the innovation scale and its increased pervasion is generally not well intentioned.
For information sharing, we note the following:
(1) Blockchain to track inputs is the most innovative and very purposeful; as it becomes more widely used, it is a good opportunity. While Cryptocurrencies are equally innovative, their energy consumption and use as a ransomware tool currently make them much more profit-driven than purpose driven.
(2) The same applies to novel payment systems that seem more interested in replacing financial firms with the same focus on profits instead of expanding access to finance.
(3) There is still some innovation in social media, but the monetization objective of most platforms will affect their long-term viability under the current construct. Cybersecurity is not very innovative but largely purpose driven.
We find that in our physical structure enhancements, sub-theme, all of the technologies rank highly on innovation:
(1) 3D printing and industrial robots both have the potential to improve working conditions, reduce waste and shrink the complexity of supply chains. On the other hand, drone innovation can be useful in transport and remote servicing but recreational use mainly targets profits and it has also been applied as a warring tool.
Finally, in our technology infrastructure category:
(1) Quantum computing has the potential to revolutionize computing power that can be put to good use. We are eagerly awaiting convincing commercial proof of concept in quantum computing.
(2) 5G, and eventually 6G, will improve the availability of information, while older technologies like servers and microchips are improving in capabilities with optimization and are continuing to be better utilized to improve lives. Although servers and chips require a lot of energy and material to create and operate, their ultimate uses are increasingly essential to supporting data needs (see our note: “Chips Ahoy, Let’s Make semis at Home”, October 21, 2021).
Looking at the big picture, we view AI, Blockchain, Quantum computing and 3D Printing as the most promising technologies in each of our subthemes that have the greatest potential for applications aimed at improving productivity with a purpose. Think transparency, waste reduction, access to information and healthcare. We are less optimistic about social media, Cryptocurrency and Surveillance which tend to be more profit-driven than ESG-minded.

Since the launch of our research services in 2018, we have touched upon many of the sub-themes identified in this note from various angles as can be seen from the table below. Future research will put greater emphasis on productivity with purpose as we strongly believe that the challenges facing society require a concerted effort: companies that can find novel applications of these technologies that help tackle these challenges will be rewarded.
Consumers around the world are beginning to have sustained confidence in the economic outlook. The Covid ‘4th wave’ is peaking but more importantly, employment prospects are good and consumers are flush with cash. True, gasoline prices have risen in recent months – which acts as a tax on consumers – but they nonetheless remain below the peaks achieved in the past decade. It remains an exceptionally strong backdrop for consumer spending and indeed, consumer confidence is running high, both in North America and Europe.
Admittedly, there are headwinds as well. In this report, we attempt to unravel the various cross-currents that are currently at work in the retail industry. First, we describe three major trends in the retailing sector (supply chain challenges, micro-moment shopping and buy now, pay later) and identify a basket of companies that are likely to be stock market winners from these trends. Second, we shine a spotlight on a fourth, particularly important, trend at work among consumers: the growing preference for brands that have demonstratable sustainability qualities. Here as well, we identify publicly traded companies that stand out for their ESG reputation. Finally, we identify those companies that overlap in the two analyses: i.e. retailing companies that are strong candidates to capitalize on multiple trends, both ESG and non-ESG related.
Retail Trend #1: Supply Chain Angst
Global supply chains have been disrupted on many fronts; the list of challenges that we published in our Note on September 16th (see “Supply Chain Resiliency Ensuring A Full Plate, September 16th, 2021) has not shrunk and a growing number of pundits believe these issues cannot be resolved until the second half of 2022 or even later.
One of our long-term investable ESG themes is building resilience into supply chains. We believe that retailers with strong supply chains will distinguish themselves as winning equity choices and will be rewarded.
However, in the immediate term, the ability to get sufficient products onto shelves in the coming weeks will be critical, since for many retailers, roughly a third of annual sales are generated during the winter holiday season.
One short term investment implication of this theme is that generalist giants (e.g. Walmart, Amazon, Target, Costco) will likely have greater tailwinds than specialty stores. The generalists have comparably large cash and capital resources, which help them maintain superior pricing power all along the supply chain.
Retail Trend #2: Shopping in Micro Moments
The ubiquitous use of smartphones means that consumers are researching and making purchases virtually anywhere and anytime. These shopping experiences last only a few minutes and are vastly different than the shopping ‘outings’ that used to occur. Micro-moment shopping is certainly not new, as this tendency has been underway for at least the past five years. Nonetheless, some retailers stand out and are recognized as having superior on-line shopping platforms.
Retail Trend #3: Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL)
Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) is an emerging trend that allows shoppers to defer or stagger payment of a purchase and repay the provider with interest-free payments. Although offering loans at the check-out are not new, the current BNPL, in digital form, is especially useful for on-line shoppers. BNPL providers platforms that are independent of retail merchants. According to a recent Bain & Company study, one implication is that BNPL solutions at checkout lends credibility and makes shoppers more likely to trust smaller merchants online. A second known advantage is that BNPL allows consumers to try products and return them if not satisfied without out-of-pocket outlays. Several BNPL companies exist, but the main BNPL players include Quadpay, Afterpay, Affirm and Klarna. Retailers that are most advanced at providing BNPL options to shoppers will have multiple BNPL platforms available to consumers.
Retailers For The Future
2020 was a turning point for consumers and their desire to purchase goods and services that are more closely aligned with their values. Indeed, in a recent IBM survey, 80% of respondents cited ‘sustainability’ as important to them and were willing to pay a premium for products and services that they felt aligned with their values.
But what specifically are shoppers concerned with and what do retailers need to do to distinguish themselves as ‘sustainable’?
In the retail sector, the desire for consumers to align their purchases with their values translates primarily into concerns about the environment, employee treatment and product quality.
Indeed, according to the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), the most material risks for companies operating in the consumer goods sectors re:
(1) Energy & wastewater management: consumers want to understand how key natural resources are used in the production of their products and will favour companies that report clearly on these topics and have a reputation for superior practices relative to their peers.
(2) Consumer privacy & data security: shoppers want assurance that any data collected both at time of purchase and throughout the product life are not being used unwittingly and that all personal information is not at risk of breach.
(3) Product quality & safety: consumers are concerned more than ever about health and wellness. This translates into purchases of healthier products as well as higher awareness about the potential environmental dangers of certain products.
(4) Product & design & lifecycle management: For some goods, understanding what happens at the end of the product’s life is important to consumers. This is particularly relevant for electronic goods and household appliances.
(5) Supply chain management & sourcing: Understanding where products (and services) are sourced and produced as well as under what conditions has become an important concern for consumers, given the digital tools that now exist to trace items throughout the supply chain.
(6) Employee engagement, diversity, equity and inclusion: Consumers increasingly view employees as significant stakeholders in retail companies and will more frequently avoid companies with controversies related to treatment of workers.
Companies that can demonstrate a superior commitment to these values should, over time, be favorably rewarded with better sales growth relative to their peers.
Below, we present two tables. The first shows publicly traded companies across retail spending categories that will potentially benefit from Retail Trends #1, #2, or #3, while the second table lists the publicly listed companies that rank highly on the material ESG issues that consumers consider when shopping at retailers. For the latter table, we use rankings available from the score aggregator CSRHub, but focus exclusively on the ratings components that reflect the six issues highlighted above. We display the top companies per retailing sub-industry; investors that are looking for companies that have potential to benefit from consumers’ desires to align their sustainability values with their purchases could explore these businesses. Note that a handful of companies appear in both tables and are stressed in bold in the second table: this shortlist of names are companies that appear set to benefit from both the major trends in the retail space. Indeed the final chart shows that this group of companies has outperformed the benchmark index since the beginning of the year and we expect the streak to continue well into 2022.
There has been quite a bit of discussion around the idea that ESG investors have left an important chunk of the stock market uninvested these past years – all things fossil fuel-related. This proved a boon to lesser-principled investors who have feasted on cheaply priced stocks in recent months as commodity prices rose to five-year highs. To the latter’s credit, it is generally a smart idea to invest in disregarded stocks with fat profit margins – especially if these underlying companies offer a source of strong and stable profits.
To this end, the recent increase in fossil fuel prices – be it oil, natural gas or even coal – has been a great source of returns this past year. From an ESG-minded investor perspective who is in for the long run, the financial attractiveness of fossil fuels should not be a good enough reason to allocate a greater part of their portfolios in these industries. After all, fossil fuels remain technologically surpassed and increasingly economically unviable if compared to renewables.
Interestingly, the pace at which large institutional investors have been divesting from fossil fuels has not slowed during this last fossil fuel price rally. Behemoths such as ABP (The Netherlands) and CDPQ (Canada) have added to the chorus of voices that are selling their fossil fuel-related holdings. Going forward, this will likely prove smart amid decade-high prices when fossil fuel return to more normal price levels over the next 24-36 months.
Recent commitments to divest out of fossil fuels are rather timely: many policymakers and ESG investors are gathering nest week at the COP 26 summit in Glasgow, where the subject of the speed at which the world is transitioning toward a renewable future will be top of mind.
But there remains reasons to be worried: the International Energy Agency, a division of the OECD, recently articulated in its World Energy Outlook report that the current level and speed of investment in renewables remains vastly insufficient in light of commitments towards a Net Zero future. The IEA still foresees a need to invest as much as USD 4 trillion per year between 2030 and 2050 year to modernize the world’s energy infrastructure for the world to become net zero. As a reference, this figure is equivalent to the combined market capitalizations of the MSCI World Energy AND that of the MSCI World Utilities indices.
To explain the underinvestment, many media pundits have suggested that 1) the divestment operations of ESG-principled divestors of the past few years have increased the cost of capital of fossil fuel companies and 2) that fossil fuels are increasingly being phased out by the entire financial system (banks), which is also increasing the cost of capital (if even available at all). According to their arguments, banks and asset managers getting out of fossil fuels has caused some supply bottlenecks in the production of fossil fuels - which could explain the recent increase in prices amid the growing post-covid demand for energy. For our part, we don’t think these channels are to blame, especially for 2) as most banks have yet to substantially reduce their fossil fuel financing and that the cost of capital of these companies has not materially increased just yet.
To this end, capex levels in the two most important sectors relevant to the Energy Transition - Energy and Utilities - remain depressed. They have yet to recover from the COVID-related episode of negative oil prices and lower energy demand and re-adjust to a booming economy.
What to do if you can’t invest in fossil fuels? Time for carbon and uranium
Investors that have divested from fossil fuels and are at risk of underperforming as energy prices rise can implement tactical hedging strategies. This could be especially relevant for investors superposing fossil-free strategies atop other portfolios. In previous Notes, we have written about the strong diversifying and positive return potential of carbon (see our note “Carbon as an emerging asset class”, December 10th, 2020).
Indeed, global fossil fuel underinvestment, allied to short-term demand pressures, should support oil prices in the short term. Conversely, carbon prices in Europe and more globally should also be lifted by the need to decarbonize at a much faster rate which should created additional rarity on EU and other emission rights – at least more than what we’ve seen so far. To this end, outcomes of the COP 26 summit should provide clues to the future trend of carbon prices; a long position in carbon could replace one in oil.
A second hedging idea is to take a second look at nuclear options. Since weaning ourselves off fossil fuels takes time and there is still a current need for a reliable, low carbon power infrastructure, a resurgence in the demand for nuclear power (and all-things related) is likely. This is especially true for countries and utilities looking to phase out fossil fuel-based power grids in a context of higher fossil fuel prices. As a result, demand for nuclear – uranium miners and nuclear servicers alike – should increase substantially, and given the complexity and the limited supply in this industry, uranium prices and those of companies in the nuclear sector could also increase.
Finally, a favorite long/short pair in the Energy Transition theme is energy transition leaders versus laggards. Exxon, is a fossil fuel pure-play lagging in the global transition game, while TotalEnergies is rapidly establishing itself as a leader in changing its fossil fuel base to a more renewable production mix. Contrary to expectations, these two companies have shared similar price patterns over the past six months as oil prices doubled. One would have expected Exxon stock to rise more than Total given 1) the level of divestment done by ESG-minded investors over Exxon, 2) the pure-play nature of Exxon with regard to oil exploration and production, and 3) the rapidly improving bottom of Exxon line compared to Total amid higher oil prices. With this in mind, it seems that Total’s investor likability proved relatively resilient during the recent doubling of oil prices. We expect this trend to continue going forward.
Chips Everywhere
We need chips for everything: phones, cars and fridges. It has become critical to our daily lives. As we transition to a high care, low-carbon economy, a significant amount of infrastructure investment will be needed. This should provide demand support for semiconductors in the foreseeable future.
At SMS, we have been highlighting six investment themes that should play out for investors over the next decade and each of them will require an increasing use of technology in which semiconductors are critical.

Another Wicked Problem
Just like last week’s note (“Transition Metals: Wicked Problem, Smart Solutions”, October 14, 2021), we find that access to the necessary inputs to achieve the energy transition and improve collective standards of living like semiconductors have negative side effects on the environment. Moreover, just like many critical physical commodities, semis can only be sourced from a limited number of places. On the environmental side, water use, energy requirements and gas pollution from the specialized industrial gases used in semiconductor processes are the three main problems. In terms of geographical challenges, although the concentration of semiconductor manufacturing operations improves economic efficiency, it reduces supply chain resiliency as we are experiencing these days. Covid-related delays, lower precipitations in Taiwan and dry weather in the Southwest of the United States that reduced output have all contributed to the creation of bottlenecks in the semiconductor supply chain. In the past, earthquakes, explosions and even polar vortexes created similar issues that were resolved faster than the current episode.
With climate change affecting weather patterns for the long run, we can expect more similar weather-related interruptions going forward. Moreover, Taiwan and South Korea, which are currently the only countries producing the most advanced chips, are located in an increasingly hot geopolitical zone.
An important goal of the United States, 15 years ago, was to become energy independent. High oil prices, large investments and shale oil technology allowed the US to reach its goal. In the same vein, one could expect the United States, or even Europe, to target semiconductor independence. China has already invested massively in this field and is in position to become self-sufficient in the next 10 years.
Made in Asia
As the chart below shows, the U.S., China and Europe all use more than 20% of the chips manufactured but produce a lot less. On the other hand, Taiwan, South Korea and even Japan, manufacture a lot more than they use. In a world where globalization is stagnating and national? industrial policies are gaining popularity, we should expect a reshoring even if the three large producing countries are close allies to the United States.
The graph below looks at global semiconductor producers’ revenue growth on an annual basis compared to global GDP growth on the same basis. As we can see, there are large variations in chip revenues. This helps explain why manufacturing has concentrated in jurisdictions where local governments instituted aggressive semiconductor industrial policies. Building semiconductor fabs require large initial investments and companies go where they are best supported.
Efficiency or Effectiveness
The chart below shows that the United States are leaders in the overall semiconductor value chain because they dominate the design of chips, which requires talent but significantly less initial capital outlays compared to manufacturing. Manufacturing leadership was left to Asia in order to improve efficiency and optimize capital allocation.
In a previous note (“Supply Chain Resiliency: Ensuring A Full Plate”, September 16, 2021), we looked at resiliency of supply chains compared to their efficiency in the restaurant industry. The conclusion was that employee loyalty, simplicity and proximity are strong assets for restaurant chains. A similar conclusion probably applies for chips, an industry which could also be “re-shored” in the coming years closer to final production centres.
Dirty Chips
Semiconductor manufacturers use a variety of high global warming potential (GWP) gases to create circuitry patterns and clean chemical vapor chambers. The continued availability of these gases is critical to the success of the industry. It is now known that anywhere between 10 to 80 percent of the fluorinated greenhouse gases (GHG) pass through manufacturing unreacted and are released in the air.
Pure water is a necessary ingredient for chips and wastewater is a negative aspect of the production process. This article highlights the need for continuous water availability for manufacturers which supports having geographical diversification.
That said, many companies in the semiconductor manufacturing industry have successfully identified, evaluated, and implemented a variety of technologies that protect the climate and improve production efficiencies, including reutilization of water. Recent research shows the opportunities to improve water recycling and the interrelationship between water and the energy requirements to treat water.
Energy use is also a key ingredient in the production of semiconductors and it typically represents up to a quarter of the total operating cost of a manufacturing facility. Large manufacturers have committed to increase their non-emitting sources of electricity in the future. To this end, Intel (2030) and TSMC (2050) have both committed to completely green sources of power.
Where to build?
Proximity to talent, adequate rainfall and, now, the availability of green energy are becoming key criteria in determining where semiconductor fabs will be set up. Considering the enormous initial capital requirements to build from scratch, country and local enticements are even more critical to determine the location of a new manufacturing facility. For example, the United States has passed the Chips Act to support the industry and Europe anticipates legislating its own European Chips Act.
The table below looks at the location of the leading chips manufacturer plants. Most production takes place in Asia and the Western United States. Water is typically less of an issue in Asia even though it was, this year, in Taiwan. On the other hand, it will likely be a recurring problem in Arizona. Maybe, moving further north in the United States or to the East Coast would make more sense than building more in the desert – as long as talent follows.
Who will win?
Samsung and TSMC are the only producers of high-performance chips. From that standpoint, Intel, Micron and STM seem like natural beneficiaries to upgrade their manufacturing platform with some help from governments in the US and Europe to catch up with the two current leaders.
Moreover, semiconductors should see increasing demand in the future since we use chips everywhere and market penetration should deepen. However, it is still a very cyclical business with large swings in demand. As governments step up their incentives to companies to ensure more resilient supply and mitigate geopolitical risks, overcapacity could surface in a few years.
By now, it is widely understood that the energy transition is underway and will eventually allow us to pivot away from fossil fuel energy…and that it will require an enormous amount of ‘other’ natural resources.
Indeed, according to the International Energy Association (IEA), the energy transition is already the major driving force for total demand growth for certain metals and minerals, “since 2015, EVs and battery storage have surpassed consumer electronics to become the largest consumers of lithium, together accounting for 30% of total current demand”. Minerals and metals that are forecast to experience massive new demand from the energy transition include copper, nickel, cobalt, and certain ‘rare earth metals’.
On this basis, it is enticing to be a long-term metal bull. In this report, we review the main challenges to the transition metals mining sector; outline appropriate investment strategies in face of these challenges, and then review select investment opportunities.
Metals Mining: A ‘Wicked Problem’
The term ‘wicked problem’ emerged in the 1970s to describe situations whereby multiple risks and uncertainties combine with sharply divergent public values to generate stalemates. In the environmental arena, these problems usually arise from entrenched conflicts over natural resource management and over the prioritization of economic and conservation goals. Metals mining fits the description on several fronts:
(1) The end-use of many products that contain metals serve the mission of reducing our dependence on fossil fuels and therefore decreasing global carbon emissions. However, the extraction process of these ‘critical’ metals is itself environmentally noxious.
(2) What is more, due to declining resource quality, the production and processing of energy transition minerals are energy-intensive and water intensive, involving ever higher emissions and water depletion to produce the same quantity of product; it creates a vicious circle of costs and negative externalities.
(3) The end-use of many products that contain metals offer major improvements in quality of life and are strong enablers of social progress. And yet, mining continues to be a relatively dangerous activity, rife with negative social impacts (i.e. human rights abuses) often stemming from corruption.
A final (significant) challenge associated with procuring metals and minerals necessary for the energy transition is that the supply chains for clean energy technologies are complex and their raw materials are often more geographically concentrated than conventional fossil fuel energy. Moreover, these geographic concentrations (see the Table below) are often in countries with loose regulatory backdrops and high rates of corruption; the likelihood that strict environmental and social protection is enforced is low.
For investors attuned to this wicked problem, there are several courses of action. The first is to choose to ignore; these investors acknowledge that the business of mining is complex and contentious but choose to invest anyway since the long-term demand and supply fundamentals warrant having significant exposure to the mining industry. Generally, this approach has little regard for ESG issues. The second is refusal to participate; by divestment or by exclusion, investors can dissociate themselves from potential negative aspects of an investment or sector. While this strategy absolves the investor, it does nothing to mitigate/reduce problems at a systemic level. The third is to participate and influence; investors acknowledge that the economic activity being funded is useful and important, and therefore attempts to support and influence outcomes in a positive way.
Divestment, exclusion and outright short selling are wholly appropriate strategies for dealing with economic sectors or business models that are unproductive and/or have little social value. However, when it comes to vital economic activities with wicked problems such as metals mining, investors have an important role to positively influence outcomes.
Smart Solution #1: Best-in-Class Investing
The first investment strategy to help ensure that vital economic activity affected by wicked problems is carried out in an optimal way is to choose best-in-class companies, i.e. companies with superior ESG characteristics. A best-in-class approach is effective because it can stimulate competition among companies for inclusion in specific indices and therefore lifting standards across an industry. Moreover, return on equity tends to be higher for companies with better ESG scores, while the cost of capital for these companies tends to be lower (please see our Note “Keep digging for sustainable mining”, November 21, 2019).
How to choose best-in-class in the transition metals and minerals mining industry?
Like all industries, mining is not immune to greenwashing. Indeed, it is not rare in the industry to observe companies battle with environmental and social controversy, while simultaneously taking top ranks in ESG ratings. For this reason, to choose best-in-class companies, we propose a process that takes into consideration both ESG commitments as well as the likely profitability of the firm: after all, only companies that are in a sufficiently strong financial position to weather the volatility of commodity markets are likely to be able to make lasting commitments to environmental and social goals.
In mining, the metric of profitability considered most useful is the ‘all-in sustaining cost’ (AISC). The AISC includes not only direct mining and processing costs (labor, energy, etc.) and royalties but also other expenses like site rehabilitation at the end of the mine life. Companies with a lower AISC are generally most profitable.
Below, we use the copper industry as an illustrative example. The first table shows ESG scores for large copper producers, while the second table shows the top ten copper mines with all-in sustaining costs significantly below the average copper price (i.e. the table showcases copper companies that are most likely to have positive, long-term profitability).
Putting the information from the two tables together, BHP, Teck, Freeport McMoRan and Anglo American all have the desired combination of low AISC and high ESG scores – which would make them potentially ‘best-in-class’ companies within copper markets. Investors looking to participate in the energy transition by owning companies that will supply critical copper resources could start by analysing this group of companies.
Smart Solution #2: The Intersection of Recycling and Tech
The above strategy is helpful in ensuring that any new (virgin) metal that is extracted from the ground is done in the most environmentally and socially positive way possible. However, as mentioned above, geographical concentration of key resources mean that the geopolitical risks associated with mining are ever-present. In contrast, metal recycling companies have no geographic constraints and they also relieve pressure on primary supply (i.e. helps to leave more metals in the ground).
In theory, metals and minerals can be re-used infinitely. In practice, current recycling rates range from almost 0% (lithium) to upwards of 80% (gold). The variation in recycling rates is a function of several factors, but most notable are underlying commodity price (higher priced, precious metals experience higher recycling rates) and technology.
In terms of technology, recycling can range from very low-tech ( e.g. hand sorting of materials) to extremely high-tech (e.g. laser object detection, MRI scanning, artificial intelligence and hydrometallurgy).
Many of the ‘transition metals’ that are used in batteries are excellent candidates for progress in recycling. For example, there is a strong desire among battery manufacturers to diversify cobalt sourcing away from the Democratic Republic of the Congo. Currently, battery recycling remains in the early stages, but there are a handful of companies that are making great strides. For example, to date there is no operating facility in North America that can recover nickel, cobalt, copper, lithium, graphite and manganese from battery ‘black mass’ on a large scale. First Cobalt, a Canadian-based company (FCC CN) recently announced plans to do so and if successful, will be an early entrant in this industry. In Europe, where metals recycling is further advanced, Umicore (UMI BB) is the established leader.
Interestingly, First Cobalt equity prices currently trade in unison with cobalt prices, suggesting that, so far, the company continues to be viewed solely as a producer of cobalt. An important signal that the company’s ability to recycle batteries becomes more advanced will be a weakening in this relationship.