With economic activity slowing down in many advanced economies amid still-rising interest rates, some EMs are showing signs of strength. This is not yet reflected in relative company-level stock performance, providing a potential opportunity for investors. In today’s note, we explore sustainable plays within EM markets.
Macro Perspective
A first consideration is that the EM economic surprises index (growth, inflation, economic activity, etc) has diverged in the past two months from that of G10 economies despite China’s underwhelming growth.
Second, with the value of USD likely reaching a peak on a trade-weighted basis, the impact of rising rates in the U.S. may now be priced into a number of EM stocks already. Risk of a U.S. recession later in the year could reverse this course but for now, we see that the path of less resistance for EM currencies is to start appreciating against the USD over the medium term.
A case in point is Airtel Africa, a mobile phone service provider and payments facilitator that operates in several African countries, which suffered a blow to its earnings FX hedging issues when they reported their 2023Q1 earnings last month. With many such companies adjusting to a weaker exchange rate against the USD, foreign investors can go bargain hunting in EMs and, potentially, frontier markets (FMs) at this juncture. Afterall, the J.P Morgan EM currency index is currently at a 4-year low, suggesting that many EM currencies could actually start rebounding in the coming months as the interest rate differential between DMs and EMs/FMs starts to decrease. In that, sustainable plays in EMs and FMs represent an interesting tactical play before EM currency appreciation against the USD starts to impact companies bottom line negatively.
Furthermore, EM companies remain about 30% cheaper on a forward P/E basis compared to their MSCI and FM companies are even cheaper than their historical discount would suggest.
Sustainable Opportunities In EM
Although the macro context is brightening for EMs and FMs, investing for sustainability remains a difficult task in those regions given 1) the scarcity of listings in general and those related to sustainability themes in particular, 2) questionable sustainability features of some FM and EM companies, especially in regard to governance and 3) underwhelming country-level regulatory frameworks.
Despite these difficulties, “Long” opportunities in SMS’ EM investment universe include companies such as Bajaj Auto and Hero Motorcorp, two transportation companies with good electrification potential with a strong exposure to India’s secular growth story which score well on SMS’ proprietary financial investment attractiveness score based on value, momentum and technical analysis (ranging from -100 to 100). Furthermore, with lumber, pulp and paper prices close to a cyclical bottom, Brazilian companies such as Suzano and Klabin – two pulp and paper companies using Brazilian eucalyptus forests in a renewable fashion - offer attractive valuation. Finally, for those willing to see through South Africa’s current macro and energy wobbles, opportunities to gain exposure to palladium producers (see our note “A Two-Speed Transition: Why it’s Time to Park the EV Frenzy in EMs”, February 16, 2023) abound in a context where demand for palladium should continue to grow at a double-digit rate in the coming decade.
Conversely, looking at SMS’ EM short side, Gaotu – an Edtech firm – fares poorly against our proprietary investment attractiveness score (ranging from -100 to 100). After all, China’s government crackdown against private education, its firm grip over curriculum and its relatively unattractive investment environment could sink firms such as Gaotu even further over the next few months. Another potential short idea includes Petrobras, for which the combination of 1) the outlook of Brazilian politics, 2) enduring poor internal governance standards and 3) oil prices increasingly vulnerable to an economic slowdown also makes it an interesting candidate on the short side.
While our names in India (Bajaj Auto and Hero Motorcorp) appear to have rebounded lately, Suzano and Klabin in Brazil look particularly attractive from a momentum perspective.
Finally, from a valuation perspective, Klabin remains attractive, and scores above its industry peers with regard to sustainability according to CSRHub’s overall percentile rankings – including on environmental grounds.
Up until February 2022, the defense and military sector’s stock performance had pretty much stagnated for half a decade as budgets were being cut and the world was enjoying a quasi-conflict-free phase. This period also coincided with the rise of ESG investing which came with its suite of sectoral exclusions. Defense stocks were rapidly labelled as “sin stocks” along with tobacco, coal, gambling, and alcohol. In fact, controversial weapons are, to this day, the most excluded activity with over 70% of European funds excluding them, while about 50% exclude civilian firearms and 35% exclude conventional military equipment and services. Prior to February 2022, the reasoning was flawless: Defense companies make products that kill people, and are often sold to bad actors – for instance to Saudi Arabia, even despite Jamal Khashoggi’s murder in 2018.
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine on February 24, 2022 changed a lot of things – including how some ESG-minded investors are looking at the defense sector.
The consensus before the invasion was that it was just flexing and positioning on Putin’s part. We were all wrong. Then we were certain that Ukraine would surrender in a matter of days. Wrong again. These days, we like to think that China would never do the unthinkable and make a move for Taiwan. However, we may have to face the fact that we live in an increasingly uncertain world with a greater likelihood of major geopolitical moves making lasting impacts on our lives and our investments. One of these impacts for investors is the subject of this week’s note: Can defense stocks be considered in an ESG portfolio?
For the first time since the creation of the Munich Security Index (a global risk perception survey conducted by the Munich Security Conference) in 2014, security has replaced climate change as the top concern among the 12,000 respondents.
Governments too are concerned about security, and defense budgets are shooting up to historically high levels.
In and of itself, an increased interest from investors and bigger budgets should not influence whether defense stocks belong in and ESG portfolio or not. The change in mindset came from the Ukraine invasion and the West’s response of sending military equipment to support the Ukrainian resistance. After all, security is a human right enshrined in human rights treaties and most would agree that the right to defend oneself and preserve sovereignty does not go against any ESG principles. This is one element that separates defense-related activities from tobacco or gambling for instance, where it is legitimately difficult to see any wider social good from those activities.
Defense hawks might even argue that there is a social benefit to consider too: well-equipped military can act as “armed deterrence”, preventing conflict and maintaining stability in the international system. By having a powerful military, they argue, potential adversaries will be deterred from aggressive actions, thereby reducing the likelihood of conflict and promoting a safer world. As the saying goes: “weapons are harmful – but they are even more harmful if those who threaten you have them and you do not”.
The conundrum is, however, that defensive weapons are indistinguishable from offensive weapons – it’s a matter of perspective – and the pendulum between global good and evil can rapidly swing.
Nonetheless, this is a bet that some asset managers are willing to take in light of the Russian invasion. For instance, Swedish financial group SEB announced in March 2022 that it would start permitting some of its funds to buy shares of weapons makers and defense companies, reversing a position it adopted a year prior as part of its ESG commitments. SEB justified the change of tack by claiming the war in Ukraine had softened some of its clients’ view on the defense sector.
Defense No-Go Zones: Controversial Weapons and Weak Governance
Relaxing ESG exclusions for the defense sector should not be unbridled, however. There are good ‘S’ and ‘G’ reasons to continue to exclude large swaths of the sector. For instance, “controversial weapons” are unjustifiable in an ESG portfolio because these weapons – which include biological, chemical and incendiary weapons, white phosphorus, landmines, cluster bombs, depleted uranium and nuclear weapons outside of the international non-proliferation treaty – are often used in ways that violate human rights. For example, landmines and cluster munitions have been used over and over to kill civilians, whether intentionally or not. Although there is some debate over what should be considered a controversial weapon or not, a good starting point is to stick to the definitions in international treaties (Convention on Cluster Munitions, Ottawa Convention on the Prohibition of Anti-Personal Mines, Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, Chemicals Weapon Convention, and the Biological Weapons Convention).
Another exclusionary filter that should be applied relates to Governance. The defense sector is notorious for operating behind closed doors and entertaining an incestuous relationship with the government. It was recently revealed that as of 2021, 672 former Pentagon, Congress and other Government Agencies’ officials were working for the top 20 defense contractors, with the vast majority – 91 percent – effectively lobbying the very government they formerly worked for. This revolving door between the military-industrial complex and government agencies is perfectly correlated with the government contracts these companies receive. In 2021 and 2022, Lockheed Martin, Boeing, Raytheon, General Dynamics, and Northrop Grumman – also known as the “Defense Primes” – were the top 5 federal defense contractors in the U.S. and they also had some of the highest numbers of “revolving door hires” out of the top 20 contractors. Between the five of them, they provided 60% of the total lobbying money spent by more than 200 companies in the defense industry in 2022.
This defense oligopoly is a problem for ESG investors. Half a century ago, the U.S. relied on 50 major arms contractors, but a massive consolidation has brought that number down to five – the Defense Primes. This concentration of defense technology expertise only gives the Pentagon few choices of where to go for the production of major weapons systems, raising the risk of price hikes and irresponsible behavior when it comes to delivering weapons that can perform as advertised (e.g. Lockheed Martin’s F-35 saga).
Now that we have determined that ESG-minded investors should probably avoid the Defense Primes altogether, what criteria should be considered to gain exposure to the sector while respecting basic responsible investment principles?
First, controversial weapons should be avoided at all costs. Second, companies working with both civilian and government clients are better protected in case of massive government policy changes following an election or even a severe austerity plan. Finally, according to SASB, the material ESG elements for the Aerospace & Defense Industry are: Energy Management, Hazardous Waste Management, Data Security, Product Safety, Fuel Economy & Emissions in Use-phase, Materials Sourcing, and Business Ethics. Companies which score well in these categories could therefore be interesting candidates for inclusion in ESG portfolios.
These five companies – the SMS Secondary Defense Contractors – all happen to be Europeans. Due to the level of ESG maturity in Europe, this should not come as a surprise. American companies in the defense industry are more likely to be involved in controversial weapons and suffering from a low score with regard to business ethics and transparency.
From a stock performance perspective, the SMS Secondary Defense Contractors basket underperformed the S&P 500 and the Defense Primes for most of the last 5 years but outperformed massively since the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Although some macro factors partially explain why the European names contained in the Secondary Defense Contractors basket did so well since October 2022 (e.g. optimistic easing calendar, consistently strong earnings, etc.) these companies are also more directly involved in the global efforts to supply Ukraine with state-of-the-art military equipment.
With Price to earnings ratios in-line with the general market – the S&P 500 P/E is about 19 – but a growth perspective more attractive than the rest of the market thanks in part to the defense spending having been increased. Timing could therefore still be on the side of an ESG investors wanting to add some defense-exposed companies to her portfolio. Leonardo S.p.a. and Rheinmetall AG could be particularly interesting due to their valuation and contract pipelines.
Since its launch in November, ChatGPT has become hugely popular and has already been integrated in a myriad of software by companies like Duolingo, Snapchat, Salesforce and others. It’s no wonder companies and individuals have been quick to adopt ChatGPT – for most humans, it is more than just another tool that improves productivity. In terms of raw intelligence, ChatGPT can do things that many humans can’t: AI experts estimate that ChatGPT displays an IQ of above 120, placing it among the top 10% of humans. OpenAI researchers estimate that around 80% of the U.S. workforce could have at least 10% of their work tasks affected by the introduction of large language models (like ChatGPT), while approximately 19% of workers may see at least 50% of their tasks impacted. This is quite the progress, given that less than a decade ago, researchers ranked Google’s AI IQ at 47, just shy of the average IQ (55) of a human 6-year-old.
This massive rise of machine intelligence has given way to an important debate about the ethical nature of AI and possible paths for humans once computers surpass us in both verbal and social intelligence. This is a topic that will increasingly concern investors of all stripes and one that we will tackle within a sustainability framework in a future note.
In the meantime, with labor shortages persisting in most developed countries and an ever-increasing need to make better use of physical resources, today’s note explores seventeen companies that are well positioned to leverage the progress in AI in order to address these challenges (and accelerate what is sometimes referred to as the fourth industrial revolution). The companies we’ve identified provide technological solutions that support decarbonization, optimized resource use and improved safety and they tend to serve high impact industries like energy, food and health care.
A. Defining a Frontier Technology Sustainability Enabler
The companies best positioned to leverage AI advances for purposeful application are those with products and services already integrating machine learning. Computer-assisted manufacturing (CAM) and computer-assisted design (CAD) are two such areas.
CAM relies on the combination of software and hardware; this includes automation, robotics and Internet of Things (IoT) devices. Each of these technologies can improve resource efficiency and worker safety. Enhanced with stronger AI, this hardware will be better able to communicate and interpret data in real time and rapidly adapt to the situation at hand having implications for reducing safety risks and the waste of resources.
CAD, on the other hand, supports effective decision-making at the design phase of a new process or new factory. Things like digital twinning software replace physical mock-ups and facilitate testing of various scenarios. As AI evolves, the capabilities of CAD will improve at assessing inputs and constraints to make relevant recommendations for optimized design.
To identify companies that we believe are frontier technology sustainability enablers, we follow three steps:
- We screen for companies with at least 20% of revenue from factory automation, control sensors or computer-assisted design software. To do this, we use Factset’s RBICS Industry classification and we include companies within the following RBICS sub-industry groups: Industrial Robots and Robotic Assembly Line Makers, General Factory Automation Makers, Other Automation Support Product Manufacturing, Monitoring and Control Sensor/Instrument Products, and Computer Assisted Design software.
- We then identify those companies that are serving high impact areas: health care, energy and food.
- Finally, we assess whether the companies are operational leaders in terms of ESG by observing their CSRHub ESG rankings.
The table below highlights companies with a market cap of $10 billion or greater that satisfy all three of the above criteria for “frontier technology sustainability enablers”.
B. Macro Considerations
Many of the companies in the above table have seen the performance of their stock prices appreciate meaningfully in the past few months. The leaders are ANSYS and Yaskawa which have returned 49.5% and 35.0% respectively over the last six months. Automation companies have faired the strongest with all but one outperforming the SP500 (6 out of 8 outperforming the Nasdaq YTD). To be sure, these companies have benefitted from positive media mentions about the recent leap forward in artificial intelligence, as described above.
Going forward, there are a number of crosscurrents for investors to consider.
The bearish news:
- Automation and digital design companies, especially those with the sustainability and ESG characteristics that we favor, continue to have very lofty valuations. In our basket of companies, the trailing p/e ranges from 13.5 to 57.0, with the median company trailing p/e of 27.1. On a twelve-month forward basis, the range in p/e is 15.9 to 41.5, with a median company forward p/e of 23.4. The Digital Design category exhibits the highest valuation, likely attributable to the ease of adoption of new AI technologies in this segment. For both automation and IoT applications, upgrading software with the latest AI may also necessitate changes to hardware. The implication is that it is currently challenging to find bargains in this sector.
- The stock prices of the companies highlighted above typically behave as growth stocks: they tend to outperform broad equity benchmarks at early and mid stages of economic cycles (i.e. when interest rates are accommodative and economic growth is accelerating) and underperform during late business cycle stages (when interest rates become restrictive and economic growth is slowing and/or contracting). Although interest rate expectations have peeled back in recent weeks, SMS’ view is that we remain in an economic slowdown phase, with recession risks greater than 50%. In this context, we would expect automation and digital design companies’ stock prices to be held back in this environment.

The bullish news:
- We anticipate that the recent U.S. fiscal stimulus will be an important tailwind for these companies for the next several years. There are over 40 new semiconductor ecosystem projects that have been announced across the U.S. since May 2020 valued at nearly US $200B in private investment. Some projects have already broken ground and virtually all require industrial automation, digital transformation and workforce enablement solutions.
- With unemployment rates hovering at historic lows in many developed economies, the cost of labor is increasing and the ability to find skilled labor is challenging. In this context, companies will continue to be incentivized to invest in automation and robotization solutions rather than labor, especially as countries are looking to re-shore critical industries.
In 1997, while sailing home to Southern California after finishing the Transpacific Yacht Race, oceanographer Charles Moore sailed into a massive swirling mass of plastic debris in the middle of the North Pacific Ocean. The discovery of the “Great Pacific Garbage Patch”, as it became known, acted as a wake-up call to the global community that our addiction to plastics and our inability to manage its disposal had to stop. Or has it?
Since the discovery of what has been called the “seventh continent”, the global production of plastics worldwide has more than doubled.
How is it possible that our collective outrage hasn’t yielded more concrete results? The problem is that we are addicted to plastics for the same reasons we must get rid of them: plastics are ultra durable (a great material characteristic, but not so great when it ends up in nature) and inexpensive to produce (which makes managing the end of its useful life more expensive than using new plastics). Moreover, plastics are super lightweight, making transportation of goods easier and less emission-intensive, and can dramatically improve food preservation, elongating shelf lives of certain foods by as much as 4.5 times. And of course, the hygienic characteristics of plastic can come in handy during a global pandemic. No wonder its use is ubiquitous and our addiction is so hard to break.
Another thing we are addicted to is making commitments without proper follow-through. Earlier this week, G7 members committed to ending plastic pollution by 2040. This commitment sets the stage for a new round of intergovernmental negotiations on the future international treaty against plastic pollution, which is scheduled for the end of May in Paris. Talk is like plastic – cheap! For those who prefer practical solutions, this note shows how investors can position themselves to tackle the plastics problem.
In short, the environmental issues linked to plastics come from three different parts of the supply chain which are also the three elements of the linear economy: Take (feedstocks) – Make (production) – Waste (disposal). An obvious part of the plastic solution is the reduction of plastic use altogether, but this is hardly investible and we know it won’t be enough to entirely eliminate the problem.
Upstream: The Feedstock Conundrum
Let’s start upstream and discuss the feedstocks necessary for making all this plastic. For approximately 70 years, plastic has been made from a range of petrochemical products that are derived from crude oil. It was an economical way to produce plastic as there was an excess of oil by-products that were well adapted for its production. Now, however, about a tenth of global oil production is attributed to the petrochemical industry, and it is projected to represent a fifth of oil production by 2050; we can hardly talk about plastics as an oil by-product anymore. Considering that the current feedstock is almost exclusively fossil fuel-based, the main issue at the upstream level is the carbon emissions released, which represent globally about 4% of all emissions.
Solving this issue requires changing the feedstock to something less emission intensive than petrochemicals. Luckily for us, plastics can be made from a variety of renewable sources, including plants, algae, and even bacteria, to create bioplastics. It can also be produced using recycled plastic as feedstock.
Bioplastics are made from organic materials rather than petrochemicals and it is the feedstock source that saw the largest relative growth since 2018 (+69%). Bioplastics CAN BE biodegradable and compostable, but this is not always the case. Currently, only about half of bioplastics are biodegradable. The rest needs to be responsibly disposed, just like all other fossil-based plastics. Also, because bioplastics predominantly use food commodities as feedstock (i.e. corn and potatoes), there is a concern that they could compete with food production and potentially drive up food prices. Fortunately, some companies are developing advanced bioplastics technologies made from algae or bacteria, which is a more sustainable avenue. For instance, Origin Materials (ORGN US), Green Earth Institute (9212 JT), Corbion (CRBN NA), and Danimer (DNMR US) are all companies that are working to develop sustainable alternatives to traditional plastics. They are all using different methods to achieve this goal, but they share the same goal of reducing the environmental impact of plastic pollution. While Origin Materials is developing a process to convert plant-based materials into high-performance plastics, Green Earth Institute is developing a process to convert agricultural waste into plastics. For their part, Corbion is developing a process to convert sugar into plastics and Danimer is developing a similar process using algae.
All of these companies are still in the early stages of development, but they have the potential to make a significant impact on the fight against plastic pollution. If they are successful, they could help reduce the amount of plastic that ends up in our oceans and landfills.
Using recycled materials to make new plastics also sounds like a good idea, but as shown in the previous table, it represents less than 10% of the plastic production feedstock and has been at that level for many years. This is in part due to the premium that producers need to pay for the recycled PET pellets. It is usually more economical for plastic manufacturers to use Virgin PET (and pay the Plastic Tax, which in the UK for instance is at £200 per tonne), rather than to pay the €700 premium for recycled pellets!
Midstream: Being the Best at Making Plastics
Having dealt with the feedstock issue, other production considerations can make a plastic manufacturer more attractive for sustainability-minded investors. Below is a table with 12 listed companies producing the most single-use plastics (SUP) along with their SBTi status and their CSRHub Environmental Scores. Only three companies have developed a credible, SBTi-aligned target: Indorama Ventures (IVL TB), LyondellBasell (LYB US), and Alpek SA de CV (ALPEKA MM). Of them, only Alpek SA de CV ‘s targets have been set and approved by the SBTi – a more rigorous process than the initial commitment that Indorama and LyondellBasell have made.
As producers of SUP, these companies can play a pivotal role in helping solve the environmental problems of plastics. Some are clearly not interested in participating in the transition, while others take the necessary step to work on a SBTi target and getting it approved, which demonstrates a certain level of commitment.
Downstream: Managing Plastic Disposal Responsibly
Recycling comes at the very end of the “R” hierarchy but it would be irresponsible to think that it is not an important part of waste management, especially for plastics. With current plastic recycling rates in the low double digits, there is a lot of room for improvement. Traditional mechanical recycling techniques are not very well adapted for the plastic industry as the contamination levels are sky high, especially in the food packaging sector.
A number of companies are developing advanced recycling techniques, such as Eastman Chemicals (EMN US), PureCycle Technologies (PCT US), and Agilyx (AGLX NO) who are all working on recycling specific types of plastic using mostly chemical recycling techniques, while Carbios (ALCRB FP) and Pyrum Innovations (PYROM NO) are working on recycling mixed plastic waste using enzymes.
Of these companies, only Eastman Chemicals has produced positive earnings and its P/E ratio hovers around 10, making it an attractive investment idea. From a technological standpoint, Agilyx offers an interesting proposition with its Advanced Recycling Technology.
With billions of tons of cargo transported around the world each year by trucks, planes, ships, and trains, freight transportation is a critical component of the global economy. While freight transportation supports economic growth and helps to improve the standard of living, it is also a big contributor to GHG emissions. The International Transport Forum (ITF) estimates that international trade-related freight transport currently accounts for around 30% of all transport-related CO2 emissions from fuel combustion, and more than 7% of global emissions. Moreover, emissions from global freight transport are expected to increase fourfold from 2010 levels, and are, at this pace, incompatible with a net-zero scenario.
Although ships transport the majority of the world's cargo (75%), trucks and vans are responsible for emitting 65% of the freight's total emissions. This is because ships are more efficient, meaning they can carry a large amount of cargo while emitting a relatively low level of emissions. On the other hand, trucks emit more pollutants than ships when transporting the same amount of freight over the same distance. A look at the U.S. alone shows the predominance of trucks within freight transportation:
Freight movement is expected to increase by nearly 50% by 2050 in volume (compared to 2019 levels), and trucks are following the same trend line due to their cheap costs. With logistics trends such as digitization, faster innovation cycles and local production, there is an increased pressure on prices, which made trucking boom over the past years (see our note Keep on Trucking: How Driver Retention Can Reinforce Supply Chains, April 28, 2022). However, in order to reach net-zero goals, trains seem to be the best alternative option to trucks, as they emit 4 times less on average than trucks and can help avoid traffic congestion and health problems linked to pollution.
Putting Trains Back on the Right Track
Trains have the possibility to carry freight for long distances while greatly reducing CO2 emissions. In addition, clean electric rail’s energy efficiency and proven safety systems can translate into six-times lower external costs (noise, climate change, pollution, accidents) of freight rail versus road freight. However, in many developed countries, the majority of trains are still powered by diesel: as of 2019, 64% of locomotives in the U.S. freight rail fleet were powered by diesel, and this number is even at 91% in Canada. Europe is more electrified with 52% of electric freight trains. Japan is the most advanced, with 82% of electric trains in its freight rail transport.
Massive investments are therefore necessary to electrify the sector with clean energy. However, in rail, asset replacement cycles are up to 10 times longer than for roads, which naturally limits the rate of innovation uptake of companies. Government investments are critical for countries wanting their trains to compete with trucks if they want to achieve their climate goals. The table below presents the most recent programs in key countries regarding investment in rails:
These plans mostly concern passenger transportation, and the ambitious 30 by 2030 program envisioned by the European Freight Rail Association is facing a number of limitations. The growth of goods with rail affinity (like coal, metal, ores or wood) is expected to decline, compared to a strong growth of goods with low rail affinity (such as food, textile and machinery, which require shorter transport times, smaller shipment size and demand higher reliability), putting a brake on the development of freight railroads. In an effort to stay competitive, rail companies have cut costs, mostly on maintenance, safety and labour. This led to negative outcomes like the Norfolk Southern’s Train Derailment in Ohio in February 2023, shining a spotlight on the deficiencies of an often overlooked industry.
Derailing Expectations
Numerous articles point out that the train derailment and chemical spill in Ohio was the culmination of a long trend of cost-cutting in the rail industry. Rail workers, government officials, and industry analysts have long warned that such disasters are an expected consequence.
While the number of train derailments in the U.S. has decreased over time, with over 1,000 still occurring each year as shown in the chart below, a closer examination reveals an increase in the derailment rate. This is likely due to the trend of longer and heavier trains, which have enabled railroads to reduce the number of miles travelled. As a result, even though there are fewer accidents overall, the rate of derailments has increased in five out of the last seven years when compared to the miles travelled.
Most derailments are caused by a lack of investment in tracks and human error:
The primary cause of derailment is often attributed to track issues, such as broken sections of the track that have been repeatedly pounded by passing trains due to lack of maintenance. Maintenance and inspections are critical to safe operations. The Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) regulations do require railroads to maintain track inspection records and make them available to FRA or state inspectors on request, but freight rail carriers are not required to report publicly on freight track conditions. Universal track condition reports are therefore unavailable.
Operational cost cutting also has social implications. As shown in the chart below, the rail industry has seen declining levels of employee compensation and benefits for rail workers (Norfolk Southern ranking the worst among the five), leaving employees discontented, but not without reaction.
In December 2022, President Biden signed legislation to impose a labour agreement between rail companies and workers who had been locked in a bitter dispute over paid sick leave, averting a strike that could have upended the economy just before the holiday season. In February 2023, the Union Pacific CEO announced its departure after an activist shareholder accused the company of providing the worst service among the major railroads and blaming the CEO.
Freight Rail Investing: Proceed With Caution
This is a challenging context for sustainability minded investors. In the absence of government support, there seem to be few tailwinds for increased transport by rail. In North America, where nearly all freight rail relies on diesel locomotives, the top five publicly traded railway companies (Union Pacific, Canadian Pacific, Canadian National, CSX and Norfolk Southern) have been working to improve their environmental standing; moving from around the 50th percentile closer to the 90th percentile over the past ten years. Though electrification in this region seems unlikely, there are other ways trains can reduce their emissions and environmental impact (such as the use of cleaner fuels, efficiency and energy-saving measures). We expect rail operators to invest in these environmental solutions as well as safety improvements as these elements take on increasing importance when it comes to being selected as a supply chain partner. We consider three rail equipment companies that are providers of these solutions: Alstom, Wabtec and Knorr-Bremse.
Alstom and Wabtec have similar product offerings but serve different regions; Alstom’s revenues are more concentrated in Europe (62%) and Wabtec in North America (50%). In addition to producing new locomotives, both companies contribute to the circular economy through the sale of remanufactured trains. Trains can be retrofitted to operate more efficiently, helping to lower emissions. Both companies are also looking into researching alternatives to diesel trains including battery locomotives, hydrogen and other alternative fuels (Alstom is hoping to expand in the U.S. market with these solutions). Smart digital solutions that help to optimize processes and improve safety are also on offer. In 2021, 22% of Wabtec’s revenues were from products that support environmental efficiency, an important consideration given the market it serves most. A distinguishing factor for Alstom is that it does have more passenger rail clients than Wabtec and produces more electric locomotives which is also related to the region it serves. This could be to its advantage as passenger rail appears to be a higher governmental priority.
Knorr-Bremse is a provider of smart solutions for the rail industry. These services aim to enhance safety, limit air pollutants and optimize HVAC systems among other efficiency gains. The company’s Digital Freight Train product offering supports objectives of standardizing processes across the European rail network. This is more of a supply chain optimization than emissions reducing but it will be advantageous in encouraging more freight transport by rail.
Compared to the five large publicly traded freight rail companies (Union Pacific, Canadian Pacific, Canadian National, CSX and Norfolk Southern), these three equipment companies have more attractive valuations, less debt and better growth prospects.
Water stress or scarcity occurs when demand for safe, usable water in a given area exceeds the supply. Historically, most water shortages were considered broadly as an economic scarcity: inadequate water infrastructure to meet the needs of communities.
More and more however, water scarcity is due to physical scarcity: we are consuming more water than the natural world can supply. It is predicted that by 2030, the demand for fresh water will outstrip supply. That is in less than seven years!
It is therefore appropriate that, for the first time since 1977, the UN Water Conference was held in New York last week. The aim is to raise awareness about water scarcity. The event is way overdue since it has been long known that many industrialized economies, like the U.S., under the status quo, would run low on water.
To be clear, water risks are broader than “just” water scarcity. Other threats include water contamination, plastic pollution, diversion and transfer of water, and eutrophication. All of these risks have financial implications that include reduced company revenue, increased operating costs, and an impairment to business viability.
As the table below shows, eutrophication and groundwater depletion (water scarcity) threats are deemed the most severe from an industrial/economic perspective. We have written in past notes on fertilizers’ detrimental impacts on the environment, including eutrophication. Therefore, today’s note focuses on the other most critical water risk - groundwater depletion - and on opportunities inherent in companies that are mitigating this risk.
Risky Business - Industries most at risk from water scarcity
Water, like many resources, is often taken for granted. This is in large part because in most regions, the cost of water is severely underpriced (in most countries, only the cost of service is paid, not the commodity price of water). Despite growing media attention, World Water Days are critical to raise awareness about water scarcity because most economic actors continue to underprice both water as an asset as well as the risks associated with water scarcity. The problem is perhaps even worse among investors: a 2022 report by CDP showed that water reporting is increasing (although severely lags climate change reporting) but there are still one third of listed financial institutions that are not yet assessing exposure of financial activities to water risks.
For investors, water scarcity risks run right through any diversified portfolio: virtually all S&P 500 GICS sectors have some exposure to risks associated with groundwater depletion. That said, some sectors are far more exposed to water scarcity risks than others. According to The Global Institute For Water Security, the industry that is both the biggest threat and most at risk from water scarcity is the Consumer Staples sector, including food, beverage, and livestock production. Specific industries within the Consumer Discretionary sector – apparel, textiles and luxury goods – are also major contributors and are at major risk, mostly due to thirsty cotton production, in India, Brazil, Central Asia, and parts of the U.S. The Metals and Mining industry and Oil and Gas industry, especially from hydraulic fracturing and oil sands extraction, are also causing severe groundwater depletion and pollution.
- Consumer Staples: The consumer staples sector which includes food, ingredients, agribusiness, meat, beverages, tobacco, and household and personal care, sources the lion’s share of agricultural produce, which accounts for more than two thirds of global water withdrawals. According to a recent Barclay’s report, average, 19-27% of the industry’s withdrawals are from areas of high or extremely highwater risk and if a high true cost of water were applied across the industry, the profitability of some companies could be theoretically wiped out.
Only a handful of companies like Diageo and Nestlé, have made efforts to quantify the impact of water scarcity on their businesses.
- Consumer Discretionary: The Textiles, Apparel, and Luxury Goods industries use large volumes of water for growing natural fibers and industrial manufacturing processes. Based on the life cycle analysis, on-farm cotton production is the largest consumer of freshwater for many apparel companies. Among the top ten largest cotton producers, only Olam Group (OLG) in Singapore is publicly listed. According to a recent CDP report, the majority of apparel and textile companies do not demonstrate a comprehensive awareness or understanding of potential water risks that exist across their value chains; companies are underreporting and underestimating their risk exposure and are thus poorly positioned to manage that exposure.
- Energy: Within the energy sector, fracking is the most problematic from a water scarcity perspective. According to a Ceres report, more than half of U.S. wells that were hydraulically fractured in recent years were in regions with high or extremely high water stress. In terms of worst offenders, Chesapeake (CHK) had the largest amount of water use reported, followed by EOG Resources (EOG), XTO Energy (owned by Exxon, XOM) and Anadarko Petroleum (APC).
- Metals and Mining: Access to water and the ability to store and discharge it, are critical factors in all areas of mining developments and operations. Mining activities are causing a decrease in surface and groundwater availability in many parts of the world, with severe impacts in water-stressed regions like western Australia, South Africa, and Peru. According to a 2019 CDP survey of the world’s largest mining companies, just under one third of all mining production will be exposed to high levels of water stress risk by 2030. BHP Billiton and Rio Tinto, are exposed to lower than average physical water risks while Coal India, Grupo Mexico and China Shenhua Energy are the most exposed, according to WWF.
Keep it Flowing - Companies providing water reuse and recycling solutions
In the face of these risks, it is imperative that companies reuse, or at the very least, recycle their water. Recycling consists of treating wastewater so it can be safely discharged back into the environment, relieving some of the strain on regional water supply. Companies can optimize their own water supply by reusing water in as many processes as possible before recycling it. Even better is water management within a closed loop system (Zero Liquid Discharge) where water is treated and reused without being discharged from the facility. Factories able to implement this will have the best chance at mitigating water scarcity issues.
The key to water recycling and reuse is water treatment. Veolia, Ecolab and Kurita Water Industries are three companies that offer water treatment solutions to industrial clients (including tools dedicated to closed-loop systems).
Veolia Water Technologies has solutions in place for major clients in several water-intensive industries: food production (Nestle), mining, automobile (General Motors) and pharmaceuticals (Pfizer). Ecolab is recognized as a sustainability leader and has a 2030 objective to contribute to the conservation of 300 billion gallons of water annually, equivalent to the drinking water needs of 1 billion people.
Both Veolia and Ecolab operate in business segments other than water. Veolia also offers waste management solutions and energy management services and Ecolab is a chemicals company with products supporting healthier food and quality hygiene. These other segments support environmental and social objectives, and we expect them to benefit from the growing focus on sustainability.
Finally, Kurita operates exclusively in the water treatment business, providing purifying chemicals and filters. Included in its offerings is a five-phase approach to Zero Liquid Discharge systems.
Xylem is another pure play in water. The company earns the majority of its revenues from water infrastructure and only about 8% from water treatment products. However, this is about to change as Xylem is in the process of acquiring Evoqua (100% of revenue from water treatment). Expansion in this segment will be complementary to the company's existing products which also support water conservation. Following announcement of the acquisition in January, Xylem’s stock price has come in, creating a potential buying opportunity.
In the past year, Veolia, Kurita and Xylem stock prices have outperformed global equities; Ecolab’s performance was aligned. While the valuations of these companies look expensive (see chart below), we believe the growing recognition of water scarcity and the ensuing water conservation goals will provide tailwinds that outweigh expensive valuations.
The rise of private assets in institutional portfolios is one of the great investment stories of the last decade. Indeed, the GFC prompted many investors to reduce their exposure to publicly listed assets to shelter their portfolios against market volatility and diversify sources of returns. Furthermore, private asset investors were also blessed with a 15-year-long monetary détente which acted as a major tailwind to the PE industry. With inflation roaring back last year and Central Banks “normalizing” monetary policy, PE allocations became especially relevant and convenient in preserving returns amid the market rout. Many institutional pension funds reported positive returns in their PE portfolios despite negative returns for other asset classes. While PE investments are normally marked-to-market, their “resilient” paper returns continue to amaze many market participants – including this research service.
In the buoyant investment context of the past decade, listed private equity firms such as KKR, Blackstone, TPG, The Carlyle Group and EQT have made their PE investment models available to retail investors by listing publicly. These investors were not immune to the changing tide of the past few months – PE firms have underperformed the MSCI World Financials index by about 15 percentage points on an equal-weighted basis. To this end, the demise of SVB as well as the response from the U.S. Treasury to offer yet another bail out to the financial sector – which suggests a significant financial stress – puts further pressure on the even riskier PE sector. With the perfect storm of tighter financial conditions, the repricing of growth/PE/VC type investments, lesser amounts of carried interest and slower prospects for fund-raising, it is not surprising that listed-PE firms have underperformed the overall financial sector over the past year.
Looking at sector exposure of listed private equity firms, one sees that some firms are now forced to navigate a perfect storm in Real estate, Tech and Financial Services. Unsurprisingly, listed-PE firms with a higher exposure to tech and growth companies underperformed those with a relatively higher exposure to energy sectors (Carlyle Group and TPG are in the latter group).
While EQT has re-repriced considerably in the past 18 months, firms such as KKR and Blackstone have yet to fully price-in current monetary conditions. From a valuation perspective, Blackstone appears especially vulnerable to the “gravity pull” of a serious repricing of its real estate, financial and tech portfolios in the coming months. Moreover, for PE fund managers to preserve their own financial stability, we expect an increasing number of investors with little exposure to PE to enter the asset class at very favorable terms - akin to the recent deal between the Regents of the University of California and Blackstone which granted advantageous terms for the U of C. In that, we view that the current liquidity crunch and its impact on listed-PE firms’ revenue and profit outlook puts further pressure on listed-PE firms’ stock prices.
Furthermore, publicly listed-PE fund managers are often criticized for their opaque structure – which typically gets even more opaque when valuations start sinking as they have done since last year. In fact, it is hard to truly assess the value of listed-PE fund managers as they are mostly a “pass through” of the underlying companies they hold. In short, the number of subsidiaries and varying valuation methodologies make it hard to put a price on listed-PE firms, especially in a context of receding financial liquidity and rising interest rates.
We see several reasons why investing in listed private equity asset managers could be problematic for investors with a concern for governance:
Hidden Fees: investors in listed public equity firms don’t really know the true level of fees they are paying on the deals that make it into the holding firm’s portfolio.
Upper Hands: investors don’t really know the extent to which each deal also encompasses “side deals” whereby partners or other entities gravitating around deals can access better terms than listed-PE firm investors. Furthermore, it’s hard to understand who between 1) listed-PE company shareholders, 2) listed-PE company partners or 3) PE investee company founders - or for that matter any other party - really gets the better deal when transactions are brought to the table. After all, whatever happens in terms of side deals may remain forever secret to many listed-PE stakeholders and shareholders.
Successor Funds and Illiquidity: when liquidity becomes scarce, successor funds often buy out earlier vintages in a way that gives a false sense of price and liquidity to the market.
Taxes Paid: the number of entities controlled by listed-PE firms suggests a great use of tax havens and tax avoidance practices which makes it likely that listed-PE firms true tax effort remains below average. In fact, one can see that 1) US-based listed-PE firms pay less taxes than their European peers and 2) listed-PE firms also pay less effective taxes than the overall financial sector.
As a result, investors looking for a maximum level of transparency in investments they make in publicly listed companies must learn to “look through” governance practices of listed-PE firms. Indeed, most ESG rating agencies rate listed private equity firms with poor governance score, with the bigger ones just above the passing grade with a less than stellar “D-”.
Finally, less than optimal transparency and governance structures of many listed-PE firms’ investee companies does not necessarily mean that they do not invest in innovative solutions in sustainability-themed sectors such as housing, energy efficiency and climate tech. While sustainability-inclined investors are typically also interested in governance aspects of their investments, the relatively low level of transparency of listed-PE firms could make them think twice about such an idea. It’s just that the level of murkiness of these firms - especially in times of financial stress - could become increasingly problematic for investors looking for transparency.
According to the International Energy Agency, if the world is going to reach its renewable energy goals in 2030, the decade will bring a gargantuan buildup of solar energy power. Currently, solar accounts for about 13% of total renewable energy, but is expected to account for one-third in 2030. Overall, to stay on a path to reach 2050 target emissions of net zero, solar power capacity will need to multiply by seven in the next seven years!
This is an extremely ambitious global goal that will require significant global cooperation. Unfortunately, this is not currently the case, as the industry appears to be confronted with a version of the irresistible force paradox.
An irresistible force paradox is commonly summed up in the phrase “unstoppable force meets immovable object”. When analyzing the solar power industry, China appears to be the unstoppable force that is about to meet its immovable object: deglobalization.
Solar Manufacturing Domination
China is a leader in solar power, both in domestic production of electricity, but also in the manufacture of solar panels; the Chinese solar panel industry is what allows other nations to claim solar as a renewable power source. Indeed, the country is both the largest producer and consumer at all stages of the solar power supply chain, including polysilicon, wafers, cells and completed modules.
Based on manufacturing capacity under construction, China’s share of global polysilicon and wafer production will soon reach almost 95% of total production. But even more alarming is that according to the IEA, one single province in China - Xinjiang - accounts for 40% of global polysilicon manufacturing; one out of every seven panels produced worldwide is manufactured by a single facility in China.
Note that Xinjiang province, referred to by China as the Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region (XUAR), has drawn worldwide attention for human rights abuses; the United Nations Human Rights Commissioner determined in 2022 that “allegations of patterns of torture, or ill-treatment, including forced medical treatment and adverse conditions of detention, are credible”. Investors with interests in the region -need to understand the risks involved, even with passive portfolios.
U.S. Policy to the Rescue?
Of course, this almost total domination of the solar power industry has not gone unnoticed. In 2021, U.S. President Biden emitted an executive order to review America’s supply chains. The “energy sector industrial base” was one of six key industries identified for further assessment. In the subsequent 2022 study by the U.S. Energy Department, a section is dedicated to “Building a Solar Power Chain Not Dependent on China”.
Since then, the U.S. government has taken several actions that have impacted the solar manufacturing industry. The Inflation Reduction Act’s (IRA) aggressive tax credits: The Advanced Manufacturing Production Tax Credit provides tax credits for each clean energy component domestically produced across the solar PV supply chain, while the Advanced Energy Project Credit provides a tax credit for building and commissioning a facility for clean-energy component manufacturing.
In addition, in February 2022, the U.S. extended tariffs on solar products containing crystalline silicon coming from China. Finally, the federal government enacted the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act in June 2022, which bans products including solar components from China’s Xinjiang region. Granted, it is unclear as how successful the ban has been, since there are myriad ways to circumvent this law.
China has not stood still in the face of U.S. promotion of a domestic solar industry. The Chinese government is reportedly looking to add raw materials used in solar panels to a list of items that could be restricted for export in order to ‘help safeguard national security’. These materials would require special permission for export and if enacted aggressively, could effectively strangle the global solar power industry.
How to Invest
From an investor perspective, the complex geopolitics of the solar power industry mean that what should be a relatively straightforward bull case for solar power stocks is in reality, highly muddled and potentially quite risky. Of course, there is the ethical question of investing in an energy transition built on the back of human rights abuses. At a very minimum, the potential for reputational and regulatory challenges associated with solar companies requires that investors embed a significant risk premium on equity in the solar industry.
As we have articulated in previous notes (for example, see Chinese Capitalism’s Long March, September 30, 2021), we believe that China is not investable at the current juncture. For investors desiring to gain exposure to the solar industry, this means that there are few options. After all, Chinese solar manufacturing companies have incredibly strong economic moats and it is far from clear that the U.S. (and other countries) will be able to (re-)establish a solar power manufacturing industry. As the IEA notes, “China is the most cost-competitive location to manufacture all components of the solar PV supply chain. Costs in China are 10% lower than in India, 20% lower than in the United States, and 35% lower than in Europe. Large variations in energy, labour, investment and overhead costs explain these differences. Still, in the absence of financial incentives and manufacturing support, the bankability of manufacturing projects outside of panel assembly remains limited outside of China and few countries in Southeast Asia.”
Currently, the vast majority of public solar power manufacturing companies – irrespective of where they are listed - have strong ties to China and the Xinjiang province and many have already been caught in scandal. The table below highlights features of publicly listed solar power players.
For investors that want to steer clear of trade regulation risks and human rights violations, gaining exposure to the solar manufacturing industry is tricky. Only six companies pass the above preliminary screening: Meyer Burger, Sun Power, First Solar, Maxeon, Wacker Chemie and Tokuyama. The two names that are considered pure plays and have severed any ties with Chinese solar suppliers are Meyer Burger and First Solar.
Note that these companies have already benefitted from being relatively unattached to the Chinese solar panel supply chain, as is reflected in their stock valuations and price performance. Meyer Burger is trading at a P/E of 56, while Sun Power and First Solar are valued at 28 times earnings. Only Wacker Chemi and Tokuyama have closer to fair valuations (14 and 8 respectively), although both of these companies are diversified chemical companies and are thus not pure plays on the solar industry.
We believe that a company like Maxeon Solar provides a good example of the risk associated with investing in solar power manufacturers within the current geopolitical context. Maxeon Solar Technologies was originally the manufacturing arm of SunPower and is now a separate company. Maxeon continues to supply SunPower with solar panels along with other international customers. Maxeon has a joint venture with a module manufacturer in China to produce panels; although the Chinese manufacturer is not in Xinjiang province, it is expected that this company could soon be a target for U.S. trade regulators and by extension, create business risks for Maxeon. Both Maxeon and SunPower stock prices have struggled since China’s human rights violations have come into investors’ focus.
The Mineral Demand Story
We highlight three main structural forces that will keep demand for minerals very buoyant for years to come:
1. Industrial Transformation to Fight Climate Change
Almost all developed countries have fairly aggressive emissions targets. To achieve those targets, a more carbon-efficient industrial complex is required. The table below highlights some of the solutions for the energy transition.
These solutions will require more industrial commodities like copper which is used in electric vehicles and renewable energy technologies, lithium, nickel, cobalt and manganese for batteries, graphite for energy storage, rare earth elements for renewable energy technologies, aluminum for electric vehicles and renewable energy technologies, iron for energy storage technologies and electric vehicles and tungsten for renewable energy technologies.
The chart below shows where each of those critical minerals was sourced from in 2021. China is a leading producer of many critical minerals. This makes sense since China enjoyed rapid growth after their accession to the World Trade Organization and developed local mineral companies to do so.
2. Invasion Leads to Depletion and More Defense
The defense industry is very demanding on critical minerals accounting for close to 10% of global annual output, as can be seen from the chart below. Over the next 5 years, it is reasonable to assume a 30-50% increase in defense spending (countries going from 1-1.5% of GDP to 1.5-2% of GDP on defense). This could translate into 2-5% more demand for minerals.
The US Department of Defense estimated that Tomahawk cruise missiles and Javelin missiles contain approximately 45% of critical materials, including steel, aluminum, copper. Those are the same minerals required for the industrial transformation.
3) India Replaces China
India is the likely replacement for China and its previous insatiable and growing demand for industrial commodities. India’s population is still growing, and its birth rate is at replacement level with around 2 children per woman. The estimated average age of the Indian population in 2022 is 28.5 years old (compared to, 39.3 in China and 39.4 in the United States). The Indian economy is expected to experience 7% real growth over the next five years and infrastructure investments are expected to grow by more than 8% over the same period.
One dampening factor for strong mineral demand in the future is China. The government has heavily subsidized infrastructure investments since the beginning of the century as China’s substantial industrial output outpaced all other countries. More recently, the country’s debt has grown much faster than the size of the overall economy with infrastructure investment representing a much larger part than anywhere else in the world. Debt growing faster than GDP is a clear sign that China has overinvested, and growth will slow on a structural horizon. Moreover, its population is aging and its size will fall rapidly with a birth rate far below the replacement rate, at close to 1 per woman. It has already built empty cities, but infrastructure investments are a quick way to get an economy going (a trick used aggressively during the 2008 and 2016 downturns); expect the long-term trend in commodity demand from China to slow with boom and bust episodes.
The Mineral Supply Story
On the supply side, we are looking at the geography of mining and the complexity to build new mines with a specific focus on copper.
1) Reserve Locations Lead to New Geopolitical Considerations
Chile, Peru and the Democratic Republic of Congo could replace Saudi Arabia as the most courted countries in the world, due to their vast reserve of “in-demand” transition minerals. The list of countries with abundant critical mineral reserves is very different from fossil fuel reserve maps. Vast countries like Russia, Canada, the United States and Brazil have both critical minerals and fossil fuels but smaller countries in South America and Africa are the place to be for minerals as can be seen from the chart below.
2) Copper in the Middle
Since copper is irreplaceable and critical to electrification, its availability will determine the pace of the energy transition. We will concentrate on copper for the remainder of the note.
The demand for copper is likely to increase rapidly from 20-25 million tonnes currently to 30-35 million tonnes in 10 years. There should be a persistent imbalance between supply and demand. We should witness a temporary reprieve over the next two years with a cluster of projects coming into production but the longer-term picture remains favorable to higher copper prices according to BHP’s 2023 Economic and Commodity Report.
Following the difficulties they suffered after overinvesting during the previous commodity cycle that started in 2000, commodity producers remain wary of new mine development even if they believe the strong consensus that there will not be enough copper after 2024. Building a new copper mine is difficult due to increasing costs and environmental regulations. Copper is becoming increasingly scarce. Also, the cost of mining operations have been increasing due to rising labor, energy, and transportation costs. The complexity of the mining process and the environmental impact of mining operations also presents a challenge for mining companies.
3) The Production Challenge
Africa has become more attractive for miners with the recent Lumwana Mine in Zambia, owned by Freeport McMorran, that is estimated to produce approximately 500,000 metric tonnes of copper annually and the Tenke Fungurume Mine in the Democratic Republic of Congo which is estimated to produce approximately 200,000 metric tonnes annually and is owned by Barrick Gold.
The graph below highlights that recent production has mainly come from Latin America where the political landscape is getting more difficult for existing mine operators and those looking to start new mines.
Looking at the companies with the biggest copper production and recognizing their positive optionality on higher copper prices and volume, the graphic below displays the sustainability scores from CSRHub to ascertain which companies have reduced downside risks. If a company is a good citizen from a community, employee and environmental standpoint, the risks to its operations should be reduced allowing it to benefit fully from higher prices and volume.
4) Recycling to the Rescue
Recycling accounts for approximately 25% of annual copper demand (5-7 million tonnes of recycling compared to 20-25 million tonnes of demand). The biggest copper recyclers in the world are China, the United States, and Japan. Together, these three countries account for approximately 60% of global copper recycling. China is the largest copper recycler, accounting for around 37% of global copper recycling. The United States is the second-largest, accounting for around 14% of global copper recycling, while Japan is the third-largest, accounting for around 9% of globally recycled copper.
Considering the difficulties in operating and building new mines that we addressed in the previous section, copper recyclers benefit from the same optionality in price and potentially less operational risks.
Looking at the biggest recyclers, the graph below highlights the sustainability scores from CSRHub to ascertain which companies have the best operations.
Regardless of socioeconomic status, housing is a basic need. In recent years, the cost – whether homeownership or rent – has become increasingly burdensome.
In the U.S., home ownership is seen as a national purpose and a hallmark of the American dream. Since World War II, it has been encouraged by policymakers. Most notably in 1997, when Democratic President Clinton passed an act to force mortgage lenders to relax the conditions on loans for low-income households, followed by tax breaks on housing capital gains in 1998. Despite these aggressive policies promoting home ownership, 34% of households were renters in 2022, the mid-range of historical homeownership rates. Moreover, housing affordability is becoming a growing concern in many regions as the cost of housing continues to outpace the growth in household incomes and both renters and homeowners are facing a housing affordability crisis that threatens to deepen economic inequality and exacerbate social problems.
In today’s note, we focus on the state of the U.S. housing market, and the role for investors in broadening access to affordable housing.
Access to Affordable Shelter: The Current State
Shelter expenses have risen dramatically. According to the CPI index, the median rent has risen nearly 20% in the past five years. Meanwhile, housing affordability (both rent and ownership) has also deteriorated (see the chart below). The cost of shelter has increased due to multiple factors. There is a chronic undersupply (limited inventory) of affordable housing. Many who would like to build are pushed out/unable due to higher labor and material costs and the effects of the pandemic are pushing housing prices higher in areas that were previously more affordable. For decades, housing supply has fallen short of what is needed to keep housing affordable. After the Great Recession, new home construction cratered; fewer new homes were built in the decade following 2008 than in any decade since the 1960s. This is only partly explained by slowing population growth, meaning that U.S. housing supply is historically extremely tight; by some estimates, the shortage of housing units for sale or rent is around 3.8 million.
In addition, the rise in interest rates has negatively affected homeownership affordability.
These factors have made it challenging for many people to afford suitable housing. Nearly 50% of U.S. renters are dedicating over 30% of their gross income to housing costs and are considered rent-burdened.
“Rent burden” is a challenge that particularly affects low-income individuals and families. As seen in the graph below, 80% of households with an income under US$ 15,000 were rent-burdened, and households with income under US$30,000 are approaching that ratio as well.
Families in the lowest income bracket have a monthly income that is barely sufficient to cover shelter costs leaving them with less than $500 to spend on basic necessities like food, clothing, healthcare, and transportation. Any unexpected reduction in income could easily result in eviction, further exacerbating their financial struggles.
Even with the recent slowdown of home price growth and the reduction in demand caused by higher interest rates, the run-up in rents and home prices since 2019 has been catastrophic for working families. And with wage growth failing to keep up with the pace of inflation over the past year, many households feel increasingly burdened paying for necessities such as gas, food, medical bills, and housing payments.
Levers to Improve Affordability
Fortunately, several strategies, at both a regional and national level, exist to tackle the challenge of housing affordability:
A. Build More and Build Efficiently
The path to build efficient housing was laid out during the last major affordable housing shortage, which occurred directly after World War II. At that time, innovative builders such as William Levitt, alleviated the national housing crisis by focusing on four principles: building smaller homes, improvements in manufacturing processes, mass production and government-backed mortgage funding. In the final section of today’s note, we show how Levitt’s principles can be applied to the private sector today.
B. Greater Government Support
In order to improve access to affordable housing, some jurisdictions have relied on progressive taxation on residential housing. For example, in California, taxes are collected from richer neighbourhoods to fund construction of parks/schools in poorer areas. At the national level, the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC – enacted in 1986), encourages private investment in the creation of affordable housing. Under the program, developers receive tax credits for a portion of the costs of constructing or rehabilitating affordable rental housing. These credits can then be sold to investors to help raise capital for the project. Since its creation, the LIHTC program has helped finance the construction or rehabilitation of over 3 million units of affordable housing across the United States.
More recently, the Biden administration has proposed a first-time homebuyer credit focused on accessibility to help new homeowners with down payment. The administration also announced the Housing Supply Action Plan in May 2022 with the objective of building and/or rehabilitating 100,000 homes over the next three years.
According to a recent study of Fannie Mae, addressing housing supply shortages will require different, highly localized strategies. The socioeconomic problems underpinning shortages of affordable housing are complex and difficult to entangle. For this reason, unique solutions are often required for each neighborhood. Municipal governments are typically best positioned to design programs aimed at social and affordable housing.
What Can Investors Do?
The background provided above underscores that improving access to affordable housing has several challenges and solutions require both the private and public sectors. From an investment standpoint, since affordable housing projects tend to have lower profit margins, they are often less attractive from a purely financial perspective. However, the potential for impact is significant and offers an opportunity for impact investors. Some ideas/opportunities for investors looking to make a difference in affordable housing are:
A. Social Purpose REITS: Social purpose REITs are similar to traditional REITs in that they own and manage a portfolio of real estate properties, and generate income from rents, leasing, and property appreciation, but with a focus on investing in properties that have a positive social impact, such as affordable housing, healthcare facilities, and education properties.
The social purpose REIT market is still relatively small, but there are some funds that have been very successful. One of the most well known is Housing Partnership Equity Trust (HPET), which was created by non-profit housing providers who recognized it as a gamechanger to tap into private capital to alleviate the housing crisis. HPET acquires properties with for-profit and non-profit partners, the latter of which can take advantage of state and local tax abatements to help reduce operating costs.
B. Manufactured homes: manufactured homes, also known as mobile homes or prefabricated homes, can be part of the solution to creating more affordable housing.
Unfortunately, this type of housing has long been stigmatized and associated with negative stereotypes. Some of the reasons for this stigma include historically poor-quality build, poor aesthetics and perception of value (i.e. mobile homes are viewed as a depreciating asset rather than a long-term investment like a traditional site-built home).
However, as William Levitt recognized in the 1950s, manufactured homes are probably the best value proposition for affordable housing. The lower barrier to entry - average new home sale prices are often well under $150,000—along with lower taxes makes housing attainable. In addition, the environmental footprint of manufactured homes, particularly recent builds, is far smaller than traditional homes. This is by virtue of being built in a factory setting, which results in less waste and more efficient use of materials.
Like with all investing, manufactured housing companies are not all created equally from an ESG perspective. One company that shows good potential is Sun Communities (NYSE: SUI). SUI provides real estate management services, with about half its revenue generated from owning, operating, and developing manufactured housing communities to provide housing solutions. The company has implemented a number of energy efficiency measures in its communities, including upgrading lighting systems, installing energy-efficient HVAC systems, and conducting energy audits. The company has received recognition for its sustainability efforts, including being named a 2020 Green Lease Leader by the Institute for Market Transformation and is included in the Dow Jones Sustainability North America Index.
C. Traditional Homebuilders With a Social Conscience
With housing shortages existing for years, big firms have taken advantage of a real estate market that had become very profitable, but not without controversy. BlackRock (NYSE: BLK) was accused in 2021 with contributing to the U.S. housing crisis by engaging in large-scale buying of single-family homes. The controversy arose because BlackRock and other institutional investors had been buying single-family homes in large numbers, which was driving up home prices. BlackRock is not an exception; the biggest real estate residential companies have faced criticism in recent years over their practices. Among them, Equity Residential (NYSE: EQR), Mid-America Apartment Communities (NYSE: MAA), and AvalonBay Communities (NYSE: AVB), have all been accused of gentrification, rent increases and eviction of long-term tenants.
The complexity of the real estate sector makes it difficult to find socially conscious investment plays. Nonetheless, one name to consider is Bridge Investment Group (NYSE: BRDG - listed since 2021). The US-based real estate investment trust focuses on affordable and senior housing. The company notably owns 11,500 seniors’ units, and 18,100 “Workforce & Affordable Home” units where at least 51% of units are occupied by families earning less than 80% of the area’s median income.