The Elusive ESG Rating Consensus

July 21, 2021
You must provide your professional email address to view this content.

One might think that continuously improving ESG data would lead to less dispersion in ESG ratings. In fact, the opposite has happened: the more a firm reports on ESG (stronger ESG disclosure), the more variation appears in its ESG ratings from different data providers. These findings are robust among global stocks controlling for firm and sector effects, as well as key fundamentals. Stocks with low ESG ratings are particularly prone to higher ratings disagreements when they disclose more ESG data, so investors looking to invest in stocks with improving ESG prospects should be especially careful about the ratings they use. Environmental disclosures contribute most to ESG disagreement, despite often being perceived as more objective than other ESG pillars. Objective ESG data will remain elusive, so investors should aggregate various ratings or find the rating approaches that best match their preferences.

Disclaimer / Securities Disclosure

SECURITIES DISCLOSURE
The author(s) of this research note does (do) not personally hold any position in any of the above-mentioned securities. Sustainable Market Strategies does not hold any of the above-mentioned securities in its ESG Funds.

DISCLAIMER
© Sustainable Market Strategies, a division of SMS Financial Technologies inc. Redistribution prohibited without prior consent. This report has been prepared by Sustainable Market Strategies mainly for distribution to market professionals and institutional investors. It should not be considered as investment advice or a recommendation to purchase any particular security, strategy, or investment product. References to specific securities and issuers are not intended to be, and should not be interpreted as, recommendations to purchase or sell such securities. Information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but not guaranteed.