ESG Performance Under the Microscope

May 13, 2021
You must provide your professional email address to view this content.
ESG detractors like to point out that ESG performance has been driven by flows and inflated P/Es rather than strong fundamentals. We find this claim to be untrue for global stocks since 2020. In 2018 and 2019, global stocks with higher ESG scores (aggregating ratings from different providers) did enjoy higher returns due to P/E ratios falling slower than average. This movement stopped when COVID-19 hit, and highly-rated ESG stocks have benefited from more robust earnings than broader benchmarks. By decomposing total returns since 2020, we identify pockets of cyclical ESG opportunities in US industrials and European consumer discretionary stocks. In these two segments, securities with good ESG ratings have trailed their sectors due to valuations rather than earnings, despite a favorable macro backdrop.   There has been no widespread ESG bubble in global equities. Since COVID-19 hit in early 2020, global stocks with higher ESG scores have had their returns rely more on EPS growth than P/E expansion when compared to the broader market. In 2018-2019, well-rated ESG stocks had a valuation advantage but it was only relative: their P/Es fell at a slower rate than the total market average. Currently, we believe two segments show interesting return profiles: the top ESG tiers of the US industrials and European consumer discretionary stocks. Both have largely trailed their sector based on valuations rather than earnings and will respectively benefit from a robust global industrial cycle and long-awaited consumer spending in Europe.

Disclaimer / Securities Disclosure

The author(s) of this research note does (do) not personally hold any position in any of the above-mentioned securities. Sustainable Market Strategies does not hold any of the above-mentioned securities in its ESG Funds. © Sustainable Market Strategies, a division of SMS Financial Technologies inc. Redistribution prohibited without prior consent. This report has been prepared by Sustainable Market Strategies mainly for distribution to market professionals and institutional investors. It should not be considered as investment advice or a recommendation to purchase any particular security, strategy, or investment product. References to specific securities and issuers are not intended to be, and should not be interpreted as, recommendations to purchase or sell such securities. Information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but not guaranteed.